Putting the “ME” in DIFM: Insights from Behavioral Economics Paul Whitmore Sas Jan 12, 2010
Putting the “ME” in DIFM: Insights from Behavioral Economics
Paul Whitmore Sas
Jan 12, 2010
2
Automating Choice
Subscription to reduce friction of decision-making
Theater tickets / Gym membership
Amazon: 2 ways – PRIME & 15% off if a purchase is transformed from a one-off purchase to a subscription
Medical insurance –Seems irrational to choose high premium, low deductible, yet many don’t want to make repeated calculations about trade offs
3
What can an algorithm do that leaves me feeling as if I myself had done it?
Algorithm does the work, but the self gets to take the credit for it.
Good spam filtering
4
“Framing” Links Psychology to Behavioral Economics
Contextual cues, situational aspects, environmental associations shape/structure perception
5
Prospect Theory is the most powerful theory of Framing
Avoid a loss Collecting a gain>
6
Behavioral economists view Designers/Product Managers as CHOICE ARCHITECTS
“Many features, noticed and unnoticed, can influence decisions. The person who creates that environment is, in our terminology, a choice architect.” (Thaler & Sunstein)
Option A
Option B
7
Endowment Effect explains one way subscriptions change framing
Mug Experiment at Cornell in 1985
Every other MBA class was given a $6 mug
Buyer reserve price $2.50 ; Seller reserve $5.25
Expected trades 11; actual number below 2.
Random distribution should not have guessed which people preferred $ to a Cornell mug.
8
How do subscriptions change the framing?
How does endowment effect show up in subscription momentum?
Once something is part of ME, letting go of it feels like a loss, even if offered a compensatory gain
I lose part of me, and gain mere $ back.
9
Subscriptions can support behavioral change
Set up a policy where I am guaranteed not to have to make a sequence of choices
Don’t Make Me Think
Create a climate of “us” where trust is supported
10
Implication for Intuit
Many people set up budget in Mint
Add one extra ingredient: A programmatic reminder to re-direct savings
Once a month prompt: Would you like to take the $75 you’ve not spent on restaurants & save/invest it?
Mint w/ FinanceWorks can facilitate investing/saving
11
Watch out for the Sorcerer’s Apprentice
Sorcerer’s Apprentice is the relevant metaphor for computers going wild assisting us.
Example: early Iphone bills
Hegel’s master/slave dialectic
12
Understanding Preferences
Building a better Eliza (1966 computer program)
ELIZA mimicked a therapist by returning whatever user typed with a question
> How does that make you feel?
> Tell me more about …
Next week I will want things that are good for me…
Choosing for tonight Choosing for next Thursday
Choosing for second Thursday
People are not adept at knowing what they want
Asking people about their goals is tricky
When asked to describe personal
priorities, people provide more
articulate & explicit goals for lower
priorities
Delmore Effect - http://www-psych.stanford.edu/~wit/PhDraft.pdf
15
Eliciting Goals that Matter
Recalling past successes just
makes it worse
Distracting people by asking them
to think about irrelevant topics
doesn’t help either
16
To recall a success, not connected to most important goal, can help
Relevance to Intuit for DIFM:
1- Make it possible to accumulate info without deliberate action
2- Enable answers to “quiz” like questions to create small successes to build greater engagement w/o triggering anxiety
17
How to get people to talk about themselves?
Hunch is exemplary at playing
“the question
game”
18
Illusion of Control (Langer 1975)
Chance can be overcome by Choice
Lottery staged one week before Superbowl
Tickets were 4 x 2 inch football cards Odds were 1:227
Asked to sell card back to someone else:
No choice: $1.96 Choice: $8.67
Knowing more about a person means that the interaction can be more nuanced.
Transition from a modal best guess to a dialog that enables nuance and tuning
Transitional object “My me”
19
Elicited versus Explicit Preferences
20
Beware that Q&A can just be pesky
Eliza tricked people into thinking that we are talking about me
Microsoft “Clippy” had much more computational intelligence, but it
only directed more attention to Clippy
21
Making it fun / addictive
Zynga games appear deliberately designed to incarnate the absinthe/crack cocaine elements of motivation and engagement inside FaceBook.
84.2 Million Cityville players this January outstripped Farmville’s maximum by over 500K
Achievement Orientation as Motivator
Psychophysical Curve of Response to Increase Stimulus
22
Diminishing Returns (Weber-Fechner Law)
Response starts big
Each additional increment gives less & less bang
Move from framing where response is flat into framing where the payoff is still increasing.
Games do this by slicing infinite horizon into smaller intervals
The reverse occurs with Subscription, and explains how friction reduces: Move many short, sharp shocks toward one smooth flat perspective.
Behavioral Economics can explain one way that games hook into motivation
24
Sources for followup
Best Review book on the subject
Priceless: The Myth of Fair Value (and How to Take Advantage of It) Poundstone (2010)
Delmore Effect (Paul Whitmore Sas)http://www-psych.stanford.edu/~wit/PhDraft.pdf
Daniel Kahnemanhttp://www.nobel.se/economics/laureates/2002/kahneman-lecture.html
Dan Arielyhttp://danariely.com/the-books/
Sheena Iyengarhttp://www.columbia.edu/~ss957/articles.html
Also see http://longnow.org/seminars/02010/jul/27/visions-gamepocalypse/
Additional ideas and resources
25
26
Paradoxes of Hedonics (the study of experience)
Experienced vs. Remembered Utility
Certain dimensions are easy to evaluate:Most intense moment
Last moment
Other dimensions are nearly impossible to guess:
Average height on a roller coaster ride
Average rate of return within a sector, or by a particular trade strategy, or in the past 20 days
Peak and End Rule (Kahneman)
Experienced vs. Remembered Utility
Our mind does not make movies; it takes snapshots
Rather than guess the total amount of suffering, people recall the worst instant, and the last instant.
If you increase the amount of suffering, but arrange for the last minutes to be less intense, people report a longer period as less painful
28
Peak and End Rule -- Pictograph
Peak and End Rule for User Design
The last moment of contact makes an inordinate difference to the recalled value of experience
Jared Spool's "Truth About Download Time"
Nielsen concluded that users will be annoyed … by pages that take any longer than about 10 seconds to load. (Since most popular sites take 8 secs, and less popular take an avg of 19 secs to download)
No correlation between download times and perceived speeds. Amazon.com, rated one of fastest, really one of the slowest
Strong correlation between perceived download time and whether successfully completed task on a site
30
More choice causes less purchasing (Iyengar)
Every other hour, a set of 24 jams/jellies to sample. On odd hours, only 6 jams available.
Choice of sampling any of 24 jams: 3% redeemed coupon.
Choice of sampling any of 6 jams
31
More choice causes less purchasing (Iyengar)
Every other hour, a set of 24 jams/jellies to sample. On odd hours, only 6 jams available.
Choice of sampling any of 24 jams: 3% redeemed coupon.
Choice of sampling any of 6 jams: 30% redeemed coupon.
Choice Overload shown in 401K participation
32
Relevance to Designers
Ruthlessly simplify: Every choice is a pain point
If it’s a brochure-ware feature, “provide but hide”
“The great thing about [Apple] omitting a feature that people want is that then they start clamoring for it. When you give it to them in the next version, they're even happier somehow.” -Glenn Reid, creator of iMovie
33
Power of Defaults A study of 401K participation, 3 different conditions: Opt-in,
Suggestion, and Automatic enroll
Fact 1. Most investors follow Default Plan
Changes participation
Also contribution level
Fact 2. ‘Suggested choice’ not very attractive unless default
Can education/training overcome default?
35
In a word, No
Notice: People said
they were 100% likely
to enroll, yet only
14% actually did
Relevance to Designers
Assume that 90+% will use the default set up, so don’t rely on “customization” to solve problems
Wherever possible, inherit behaviors that people exhibit, so that their slight modifications can carve a path that fits their needs
Suggest fill-ins for many choices, so that if a customer is “lazy” they can have the calculator guess what would fit their profile
36
How to manage tendency to procrastinate
People make “bold forecasts” but “timid choices”
Dan Ariely’s Procrastinator app. If you can’t make a choice by the deadline, it chooses for you.
Analogy for portfolio re-allocation:
Although we can’t re-allocate, we could show customers who bail/pause what returns they could have seen if they had done a re-allocation
37
38
Descriptive Choice: Prospect Theory
Some consequences of loss aversion
Extreme risk aversion
Status quo bias (connected to power of defaults)
Disads of change weighted more than the advantages
Reluctance to trade goods held for use
Losses>>opportunity costs (foregone gains)
Customers would be far more motivated if we show them what they’re losing out on, rather than offer them a chance to gain additional benefits
“Fear is your best friend or your worst enemy. It's like fire. If you can control it, it can cook for you; it can heat your house. If you can't control it, it will burn everything around you and destroy you.” Mike Tyson
iNcentives
Understand mappings
Defaults
Give feedback
Expect error
Structure complex choices
Bend of the payoff curve, both for gains & losses
40
Designers as Choice Architects have the following techniques available to “nudge” decisions
Which mental account? A Peak or an End?
The road most taken
Support needs to know
Fallible predicting future self
Streamline, hold hands, createmeans to feel on track
Goals in Prospect Theory
Goals divide outcomes into
gains or losses
People approach losses differently
Failure is more painful than success is satisfying,
More motivating than achieving a
success
42
Less is More (Hsee)
Music Dictionary A
10,000 entries
condition is like new
Music dictionary B
20,000 entries
cover is torn
When evaluated separately: A $24 B $20
When evaluated jointly: A $19 B $27
43
Less is More, again
You are considering one year jobs at two different magazines
At magazine A you are offered a job paying $35K. However, the other workers who have the same training and experience as you do are making 38K
At Magazine B you are offered a job paying $33K, however the other workers have the same training and experience as you do are making $30K
Choice: A > B
Happiness B > A
44
Separate v Joint Evaluation (JE)
SE: analogous to purchasing one item from an auction, w/o comparative shopping
JE: Occurs when choosing from a range of items
Lay rationalism: a tendency to overweight attributes that appear rationalistic, such quantity and economic value, and downplay attributes that appear subjective
Features that trigger clear sentiments in separate evaluation sometimes lose their appeal in comparative settings
Features that are hard to assess in separate evaluations are sometimes easier to evaluate in comparative settings
45
Primed to feel or Primed to Calculate(Rottenstreich)
Box of Madonna CDs
If evaluated from an affective/emotional valence, then quantity is irrelevant
If viewed as tokens with exchange value, then more equals more
Primed to feel: No more price for box of 10 CDs than for 5 CDs
Primed to calculate: Box of 10 CDs has receives higher valuation than 5
46
What does this tell Designers?
Tables of comparative features drive people into Joint Evaluation mind-set, even when they may not value all features in the comparison
Aim to move people toward an emotionally valent sphere where there is no longer simple linear comparisons
Apple is superb at transcending the commodity space of price