Top Banner
Medical Imaging Seminar Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts assessment and correction A. Coste, S. Gouttard, C. Vachet, G. Gerig
29

Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

Jun 03, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

Medical Imaging Seminar

Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts assessment and correction

A. Coste, S. Gouttard, C. Vachet, G. Gerig

Page 2: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 2

Overview

● Introduction

● DWI – DTI

● Artifact Assessment

● Artifact Consequences

● Artifact Detection

● Possible Correction

● Conclusion

Page 3: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 3

Introduction

● DTI is a powerful technique giving insights into white matter organization

● Allows Tractography

● Increased Artifacts

● Reduced Signal to Noise Ratio

● Need of Quality Control

● Need of new processing methods to process DTI due to new kind of artifacts

Page 4: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 4

Diffusion Weighted Imaging

● Acquisition of multiple set of MRI with several values of the exciting magnetic field and with different orientation.

● In our protocol we use 25 different directions

direction

b value

Page 5: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 5

Diffusion Tensor Imaging

● DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set.

● Each voxel contains a second order diffusion Tensor :

● D is symmetric and positive definite

● To visualize the tensor we use Eigen decomposition to get the local diffusion characteristics

Page 6: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 6

DTI Visualization

● Ellipsoid parametrization with eigen vectors and eigenvalues

● Interpretation of diffusion properties

Page 7: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 7

DTI Visualization

Page 8: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 8

Fractional Anisotropy

● Fractional Anisotropy (FA)

0 1

Page 9: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 9

Artifact Assessment

● Quantitative assessment

– Unexpected evolution of FA over time

– Diffusion evolution inconsistent● Qualitative assessment

– “blurry” FA images

– Red Color FA images

– “Red” Tensors

FA

age

Page 10: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 10

Artifact Assessment

● Quantitative assessment

– Unexpected evolution of FA over time

– Diffusion evolution inconsistent● Qualitative assessment

– “blurry” FA images

– Red Color FA images

– “Red” Tensors

Position on fiber

FA

Page 11: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 11

Artifact Assessment

● “blurry” FA images

Good case Bad case

Page 12: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 12

Artifact Assessment

● Red ColorFA images

Good case Bad case

Page 13: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 13

Artifact Assessment

“Red” Tensors

Good case Bad case

Page 14: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 14

Artifact Assessment

● Quantitative assessment

– Unexpected evolution of FA over time

– Diffusion evolution inconsistent● Qualitative assessment

– “blurry” FA images

– Red Color FA images

– “Red” Tensors

● ⇒ Something is wrong but what ?

– Processing

– Acquisition

Page 15: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 15

Artifact Consequences

● Wrong calculation of diffusion characteristics

● Poor quality tensors used in atlas building

● Unknown influence of it in atlas building

● Reliability of conclusions based on these data

Page 16: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 16

Statistical Assessment

● Our data set is composed of 1200+ DWI sets

● 4 acquisition sites across the US : ACE / IBIS Network

– University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

– University of Washington in Seattle

– Washington University in St. Louis

– Children Hospital of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia● Artifact ratio within the data set :

Page 17: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 17

Artifact Detection

● Visual QC

– ColorFA-OnlineQuickViewer

Page 18: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 18

Artifact Detection

● Visual Quality Control

Page 19: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 19

Artifact Detection

● Principal Direction Space

Principal Eigen Vector Field

Page 20: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 20

Artifact Detection

● Principal Direction Spherical Histogram

Entropy Based Diffusion Imaging Quality Control via Principal Orientation Distribution : M. Farzinfar et al

Page 21: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 21

Artifact Detection

● Entropy

case

Entropy

Page 22: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 22

Possible Correction

● The Leave One Out Method (LOO) on DWI set

Page 23: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 23

Possible Correction

● Leave One Out improved results :

Page 24: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 24

Possible Correction

● Analysis with Principle Direction Distribution

Page 25: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 25

Possible Correction

● Leave Multiple Out Method (LMO)

– LOO is not generalizable ● Ongoing research

– Combination of directions depending on patient position

– Influence of each gradient direction● Computation of spherical Voronoi Tessellation

Page 26: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 26

Conclusion

● Identify and characterize directional artifact

● Possible automated detection via entropy

● Possible correction with Leave One / Multiple Out

● Further investigation on acquisition

● Overall Objective: prevent the artifact occurrence

Page 27: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 27

Acknowledgment

● I would like to thank :

– Dr Guido Gerig

– Sylvain Gouttard

– Clement Vachet

– People in Utah, University of North Carolina and at the Montreal Neurological Institute

– Everyone for your attention

Page 28: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 28

Questions

Questions ?

Page 29: Diffusion Tensor Imaging quality control : artifacts ...€¦ · Diffusion Tensor Imaging DTI is computed with an overdetermined system based on all images of the DWI set. Each voxel

09/10/12 29

Tensor Estimation Method