Deterring Speech: When Is It “McCarthyism”? When Is It Proper? !"#$%$ '()(*+, -. /012345620 107 5!'2!7 898. :;<<=> Table of Contents "#$%&'()$*&#++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ , "+ -&#'./#0$*&# &1 23&4. 53& 607 "#0'8.%$.#$97 :.9; $3. <#./7 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ = ""+ >%*80$. <)&#&/*) ?.$09*0$*&# @A0*#4$ B;.0C.%4 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ DD @+ <#$.%$0*#.%4 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ DD E+ -&//.#$0$&%4+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ DF -+ G$3.% 5&%C.%4+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ DH I+ >&44*J9. B&9($* +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ,H """+ B(J;&.#04 &1 "#1&%/0$*&# @J&($ >.&;9.K4 L*%4$ @/.#'/.#$ @)$*8*$*.4+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ MN -&#)9(4*&#O @ 23&(A3$ <P;.%*/.#$ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ MH -&;7%*A3$ Q ,NN= -09*1&%#*0 R0S ?.8*.ST "#)+ -09*1&%#*0 R0S ?.8*.ST "#)+ U-R?V *4 0 -09*1&%#*0 #&#;%&1*$ )&%;&%0$*&#+ -R? 0#' $3. 0($3&%4 0%. 4&9.97 %.4;*J9. 1&% $3. )&#$.#$ &1 $3.*% ;(J9*)0$*+ 23*4 >IL 1*9. *4 0 %.;%*#$.' 0#' %.;0A*#0$.' 8.%4*&# &1 $3. &%*A*#09 0%$*)9.+ W >%&1.44&% &1 R0ST X-R@ B)3&&9 &1 R0S U8&9&C3Y90S+()90+.'(V+ 60#7 $30#C4 $& R9&7' E*99*#A49.7T 50%' L0%#4S&%$3T Z*)$&% L9.*4)3.%T 60%C [9.*/0#T ?&J.%$ ?0)0#4C7T @#'7 B0J9T \�$30# ]049&11T 0#' @/7 ].A0%$ 1&% $3.*% 3.9;+ 230#C4 094& $& $3. &%A0#*^.%4 &1 $3. \&%'. B7/;&4*(/ 1&% *#8*$*#A /. $& )&//.#$ &# _.&11%.7 B$&#.K4 $3&(A3$1(9 0#' $3&(A3$`;%&8&C*#A ;0;.%T !"## %&##'( )* +(# ,-# ./ 0'12"+(34 , 125+).*2"3 627#a $3*4 <4407 *4 0 /()3`)30#A.' 8.%4*&# &1 $3&4. )&//.#$4+
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
!
Deterring Speech: When Is It “McCarthyism”? When Is It Proper?
!"#$%$&'()(*+,&
-.&/012345620&107&5!'2!7&898.&:;<<=>&
Table of Contents
"#$%&'()$*&#++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ,!"+! -&#'./#0$*&#!&1!23&4.!53&!607!"#0'8.%$.#$97!!
:.9;!$3.!<#./7+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ =!""+! >%*80$.!<)&#&/*)!?.$09*0$*&#!@A0*#4$!B;.0C.%4 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ DD!
@+! <#$.%$0*#.%4 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ DD!E+! -&//.#$0$&%4+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ DF!-+! G$3.%!5&%C.%4+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ DH!I+! >&44*J9.!B&9($* +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ,H!
"""+! B(J;&.#04!&1!"#1&%/0$*&#!@J&($!>.&;9.K4!L*%4$!!@/.#'/.#$!@)$*8*$*.4+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ MN!
-&#)9(4*&#O!@!23&(A3$!<P;.%*/.#$ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ MH!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -&;7%*A3$!Q!,NN=!-09*1&%#*0!R0S!?.8*.ST!"#)+!-09*1&%#*0!R0S!?.8*.ST!"#)+!U-R?V!*4!0!-09*1&%#*0!#&#;%&1*$!)&%;&%0$*&#+!-R?!0#'!$3.!0($3&%4!0%.!4&9.97!%.4;*J9.!1&%!$3.!)&#$.#$!&1!$3.*%!;(J9*)0$*+!!23*4!>IL!1*9.!*4!0!%.;%*#$.'!0#'!%.;0A*#0$.'!8.%4*&#!&1!$3.!&%*A*#09!0%$*)9.+!!! W! !>%&1.44&%! &1! R0ST! X-R@! B)3&&9! &1! R0S! U8&9&C3Y90S+()90+.'(V+! 60#7! $30#C4! $&! R9&7'!E*99*#A49.7T!50%'!L0%#4S&%$3T!Z*)$&%!L9.*4)3.%T!60%C![9.*/0#T!?&J.%$!?0)0#4C7T!@#'7!B0J9T!\�$30#!]049&11T! 0#'! @/7! ].A0%$! 1&%! $3.*%! 3.9;+! 230#C4! 094&! $&! $3.! &%A0#*^.%4! &1! $3.! \&%'.! B7/;&4*(/! 1&%!*#8*$*#A!/.!$&!)&//.#$!&#!_.&11%.7!B$&#.K4!$3&(A3$1(9!0#'!$3&(A3$`;%&8&C*#A!;0;.%T!!"##$%&##'($)*$+(#$,-#$./$0'12"+(34$,$125+).*2"3$627#a!$3*4!<4407!*4!0!/()3`)30#A.'!8.%4*&#!&1!$3&4.!)&//.#$4+!!
!
,! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!,!
Deterring Speech: When Is It “McCarthyism”? When Is It Proper?
<(A.#.!Z&9&C3!
Introduction
! 530$!/07!A&8.%#/.#$!&11*)*094!'&!$&!;%.8.#$!4;..)3!$30$!$3.7!$3*#C!*4!.8*9! 0#'! '0#A.%&(4d!530$! /07! J(4*#.44.4T! &%A0#*^0$*T! &%! *#'*8*'(094!'&d!B&/.!0)$*!0%.!)9.0%97!;.%/*$$.'T!.8.#! 90('0J9.O!>.%4(0'*#A!;.&;9.!$30$!$3.!4;..)3!*4!J0'!*4!$3.!&J8*&(4!.P0/;9.+!e.*$3.%!S.!#&%!$3.!A&8.%#`/.#$!#..'!4*$!*'9.!S3.#!.8*9!*'.04!0%.!4;%.0'+D!! "$K4!094&!f(*$.!;%&;.%!$&!/0C.!4(%.!$30$!&(%!*'.&9&A*)09!A%&(;4!0%.!#&$!$0C.#!&8.%!J7!.8*9!/&8./.#$4+!23.!Dc=N4!@-RXT!1&%!*#4$0#).T!%*A3$97!%.`g.)$.'!/./J.%4!S3&! 4(;;&%$.'! $&$09*$0%*0#! *'.&9&A*.4+,! 2&$09*$0%*0#*4/! *4!$3.!0#$*$3.4*4!&1!)*8*9!9*J.%$*.4O!@!)*8*9!9*J.%$0%*0#!&%A0#*^0$*&#!/07!%*A3$97!4(;;&%$!$&$09*$0%*0#4K!%*A3$!$&!4;.0CT!J($!*$!43&(9'!094&!S0#$!$&!08&*'!*#8&98`*#A! ;%&`$&$09*$0%*0#4! *#! *$4! '.)*4*&#! /0C*#A+M! R*C.S*4.T! A%&(;4! $30$! $0C.!)&#$%&8.%4*09!J($!S.99`/.0#*#A!4$0#'4!&#!%0)*09!*44(.4!/07!%*A3$97!S0#$!$&!.P)9('.! %0)*4$4! 1%&/! $3.*%! %0#C4T! 0#'! .4;.)*0997! 1%&/! $3.*%! 9.0'.%43*;+!230$K4!J&$3!A&&'!;&9*$*)4!0#'!A&&'!;&9*)7+!! @!$3*%'!0)).;$0J9.!&;$*&#!*4!$&!)%.0$.!4&)*09!#&%/4!$30$!)&#'./#!)&#`$./;$*J9.!8*.S4!0#'!$3.!;.&;9.!S3&!.P;%.44!$3./+!23.4.!#&%/4!/07!'.$.%!.8.#! $3&4.! 4;.0C.%4!S3&! 0%.#K$! ;.%4(0'.'! J7! $3./h(#9*C.! ;(%.! ;.%4(0`4*&#T! $3.! #&%/4! /07T! *#! 4&/.! 4.#4.T! J.! 4&)*0997! )&.%)*8.+! ?0)*4$4T! 1&%!!.P0/;9.T!&1$.#!1..9!%.9()$0#$!$&!.P;%.44!$3.*%!8*.S4!J.)0(4.!$3.7!1.0%!4&)*09!&;;%&J%*(/+! 23*4! *4! A.#.%0997! A&&'+! R*C.S*4.T! ;.&;9.! 0%.! 9.A0997! 1%..! $&!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! D+! %##! 53*$#.7! 8+! -09*1&%#*0T! ,HF! X+B+! M=HT! MH=! UDc,HV! UE%0#'.*4T! \+T! )&#)(%%*#A! *#! $3.!g('A/.#$V!Uib2j3.!1*$$*#A!%./.'7!1&%!.8*9!)&(#4.94!*4!A&&'!&#.4+kV+!! ,+! %##! ACLU, America’s Need: A New Birth of Freedom: 34th Annual Report! D,l!UDc=FV!Ui23.!@-RX!#..'4!0#'!S.9)&/.4!$3.!4(;;&%$!&1!099!$3&4.h0#'!a!$3&4.hS3&4.!'.8&$*&#!$&!)*8*9! 9*J.%$*.4! *4! #&$! f(09*1*.'! J7! 0'3.%.#).! $&! -&//(#*4$T! L04)*4$T! [[[T! &%! &$3.%! $&$09*$0%*0#!'&)$%*#.+kVa! @##$ 27@.! 60%7! 6)@(9*11.T! 6(#$ A.7)+)'@$ ./$ 1)B)7$ 8)C#"+)#@4$6(#$ ,D#")'2*$ 1)B)7$ 8)C#"+)#@$E*).*$F5")*-$+(#$0'12"+(3$G#2"@T!)*!The Specter: Original Essays on the Cold War and the Origins of McCarthyism! D=FT!D=F`=l! U?&J.%$!_%*11*#!m!e0$30#!23.&30%*4! .'4+T! DcHFV! U'*4)(44*#A!$3.!@-RXK4!;&9*)7!*#!/&%.!'.$0*9V+!23.!@-RX!/07!308.!J..#!;0%$97!)&#).%#.'!0J&($!'.19.)$*#A!;(J9*)!)%*$*)*4/T!J($!$30$K4!;.%1.)$97!4.#4*J9.O!"1!*$!S04!;%&;.%T!04!"!0%A(.T!1&%!)*8*9!9*J.%$*.4!0'8&)0$.4!$&!S0#$!#&$3*#A! $&! '&! S*$3! $3&4.! S3&! S&(9'! .P$*#A(*43! )*8*9! 9*J.%$*.4T! *$! S04! 094&! ;%&;.%! 1&%! )*8*9! 9*J.%$*.4!0'8&)0$.4!$&!/0C.!$3*4!'.4*%.!)9.0%!$&!$3.!;(J9*)+!! M+! "!$3(4!'*40A%..!S*$3!Geoffrey R. StoneT!Perilous Times: Free Speech in Wartime from The Sedition Act of 1798 to The War on Terrorism!F,N`,D!U,NNFVT!S3*)3!4074!$3*4!S04!0!4*A#!&1!i109$.%b*#Ajk! J7! 0#! i&%A0#*^0$*&#bj! .P;%.4497! '.'*)0$.'! $&! $3.! ;%&$.)$*&#! &1! )*8*9! 9*J.%$*.4Tk! 0#'!S*$3!6)@(9*11.T!@5&"2!#&$.!,T!S3*)3!$0C.4!0!4*/*90%!8*.S+!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! M$
! M!
;%0*4.!%0;.T!)3*9'!/&9.4$0$*&#T!&%!&$3.%!)%*/.4T!J($!$3.7!$.#'!$&!C..;!f(*.$!0J&($!4()3!8*.S4!*#!/&4$!)*%)9.4+!230$!094&!*4!A.#.%0997!A&&'+!! G1!)&(%4.T!4()3!#&%/!)%.0$*&#!*4!;%&;.%!a!*1!$3.!)&#'./#.'!8*.S4!0%.!*#'..'!)&#$./;$*J9.+!B&)*09!#&%/4!$30$!)&#'./#!$3&(A3$1(9!0#'!;&9*$.!)%*$*)*4/! &1! %0).`J04.'! 011*%/0$*8.! 0)$*&#T! @/.%*)0#! 1&%.*A#! ;&9*)7T! &%!80%*&(4! %.9*A*! 0%.! )&(#$.%;%&'()$*8.hJ.)0(4.! $3.7! 4$*19.! ;&$.#$*0997!.#9*A3$.#*#A! '.J0$.h0#'! (#10*%+! n.$! $3*4! /.%.97! )&(#4.94! )0($*&#! 0#'!$3&(A3$1(9#.44!*#!0'&;$*#A!0#'!0;;97*#A!4()3!#&%/4a!*$!'&.4#K$!(#'.%/*#.!$3.! 9.A*$*/0)7! &1! 0#$*`4;..)3! 4&)*09! #&%/4! 04! 4()3+!5.! 43&(9'! J.! ;&9*$.!0#'!S.9)&/*#A!$&!$3&4.!S3&!308.!(#&%$3&'&P!8*.S4!&#!4&)*09!4.)(%*$7!%.`1&%/+!5.! #..'#K$T! 3&S.8.%T! 0;;97! $3.! 40/.! 4&)*09! A%&(#'! %(9.4! $&! $3&4.!S3&!308.!$3.!(#&%$3&'&P!8*.S!$30$!).%$0*#!%0).4!0%.!4(J3(/0#+!! G$3.%!0)$*! $&!)&/J0$!.8*9!8*.S4!0%.!%*A3$97!1&%J*''.#!J7!$3.!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$h&1$.#!J7!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$!'&)$%*#.4! $30$! 4;%*#A! 1%&/!%.0)`$*! $&! $3.!6)-0%$37! .%0h&%! J7!S.99`0)).;$.'! 4&)*09! #&%/4+F! 23.! A&8`.%#/.#$! /07! #&$! $3%&S! ;.&;9.! *#! ;%*4&#! 1&%! $3.*%! J0'! *'.04T! S3.$3.%!-&//(#*4$T!%0)*4$T!&%!;%&`$.%%&%*4$+=!23.!A&8.%#/.#$!/07!#&$!J0#!;&9*$*)09!;0%$*.4! $30$! .P;%.44! $3&4.! 8*.S4+o! 23.! A&8.%#/.#$! 43&(9'#K$! J0%! ;.&;9.!1%&/!;%&1.44*!&%! 1%&/!(#*8.%4*$*.4TH! $3%.0$.#!)*8*9! 9*0J*9*$7Tl!&%!4$%*;!'*`8&%)*#A!;0%.#$4!&1!)3*9'!)(4$&'7!1&%!.P;%.44*#A!&%!$&9.%0$*#A!4()3!8*.S4+c!!! R*C.S*4.T! J&$3! A&8.%#/.#$09! )%*$*)4! 0#'! ;%*80$.! )%*$*)4! 43&(9'#K$! %.`4&%$!$&!9*.4!&%!(#1&(#'.'!0))(40$*+!23.7!43&(9'#K$!(4.!.P).44*8.!%3.$&%*)!$30$! 4/.0%4! ;.&;9.! S*$3! 90J.94! $30$! $3.7! '&#K$! '.4.%8.T! 4()3! 04! )099*#A!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! F+! "!$0C.!*$T!1&%!*#4$0#).T!$30$!)%*$*)4!&1!$3.!4$0$./.#$4!'*4)(44.'!*#!>0%$!"h4$0$./.#$4!$30$!044.%$!$30$!i&(%!0'8.%40%*.4K!4;..)3!*4!3.9;*#A!$3.!.#./7khS&(9'!(%A.!0!4&)*09!#&%/!$30$!4()3!4$0$./.#$4!J.!)&#'./#.'T!%0$3.%!$30#!0!9.A09!%(9.!;%&3*J*$*#A!$3.!4$0$./.#$4+!! =+! %##!E%0#'.#J(%A!8+!G3*&T!Mc=!X+B+!FFF!UDcocV+!! o+! %##!-&//(#*4$!>0%$7!&1!"#'+!8+!53*$)&/JT!FDF!X+B+!FFD!UDcHFV+!! H+! J5+$@##!9*$"#!:09.T!H,M!e+<+,'!,NoT!,No!U"99+!DcccV!U:.*;9.T!\+T!'*44.#$*#AV!U!i23.!)%(P!&1!$3.!b"99*#&*4!E0%!-&//*$$..!&#!-30%0)$.%!L*$#.44j!'.)*4*&#!$&!'.#7!;.$*$*&#.%K4!0;;9*)0$*&#!$&!;%0)$*).!90S!*4!;.$*$*&#.%K4!&;.#!0'8&)0)7!&1!%0)*0997!&J#&P*&(4!J.9*.14+!23.!"#f(*%7!>0#.9!1&(#'!$30$T!*#!%.A(90$*#A!$3.! )&#'()$! &1! 0$$&%#.74T! ).%$0*#! p1(#'0/.#$09! $%($34K! &1! .f(09*$7! 0#'! #&#'*4)%*/*#0$*&#! p/(4$! J.!;%.1.%%.'!&8.%!$3.!809(.4!1&(#'!*#!$3.!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$+KkV+&! l+! 1/K! <(A.#.! Z&9&C3T! !"##L.D$ ./$ %&##'(M$ 13C#"@&2'#M$ I2"2@@D#*+$ 82NM$ 2*L$ +(#$ 17)*+.*$,LD)*)@+"2+).*T!oM!L. & Contemp. Probs.!,cc!U,NNNV!U'.4)%*J*#A!3&S!3&4$*9.!.#8*%&#/.#$!30%044/.#$!90S!4(;;%.44.4!4;..)3!$30$!.P;%.44.4!4.P*4$T!%0)*4$T!0#'!%.9*A*&(497!&11.#4*8.!8*.S;&*#$4!*#!S&%C;90).4T!.'()0$*	! *#4$*$($*T! 0#'! ;90).4! &1! ;(J9*)! 0))&//&'0$*&#Va! <(A.#.! Z&9&C3T!=(2+$ %&##'($ F.#@$OI.@+)7#$ =."P$ >*B)".*D#*+Q$ I2"2@@D#*+$ 82N$ ;#@+")'+RT! l=!Geo. L.J.! o,H! UDccHV! U40/.T! *#! /&%.!'.$0*9! 0#'! a! 04! $&! S&%C;90).4Va! <(A.#.! Z&9&C3T! -&//.#$T! !"##L.D$ ./$ %&##'($ 2*L$ =."P&72'#$I2"2@@D#*+T!Mc!UCLA L. Rev.!DHcD!UDcc,V!U)%*$*)*^*#A!/0#7!04;.)$4!&1!3&4$*9.!S&%C!.#8*%&#/.#$!90S!&#! L*%4$! @/.#'/.#$! A%&(#'4VT! 2B2)72C7#$ 2+! 3$$;OqqSSSD+90S+()90+.'(qr8&9&C3q!30%044q4(J4$0#)+3$/!*#!(;'0$.'!1&%/+&! c+! %##!<(A.#.!Z&9&C3T!A2"#*+S1()7L$%&##'($2*L$1()7L$15@+.L3$%&##'($;#@+")'+).*@T!lN!N.Y.U. L. Rev.! U1&%$3)&/*#A!,NNoVT!2+!3$$;OqqSSSD+90S+()90+.'(qr8&9&C3q)(4$&'7+;'1!U#&$*#A!)04.4!1%&/!$3.!DcMN4!0#'!Dc=N4!*#!S3*)3!;0%.#$4K!-&//(#*4$!011*9*0$*!S.%.!)&(#$.'!0A0*#4$!$3./!*#!)3*9'!)(4$&'7!'.)*4*T! 0#'! )04.4! 1%&/! $3.! DcHN4! $&! $3.! ;%.4.#$! *#! S3*)3! ;0%.#$4K! %0)*4$! 0'8&)0)7! S04! )&(#$.'!0A0*#4$!$3./!*#!)3*9'!)(4$&'7!'.)*4*V+&
2010
F! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!F!
.8.%7&#.!&#!$3.!R.1$!ib-j&//(#*4$!47/;0$3*^.%4TkDN!&%!)099*#A!;.&;9.!%0)`*4$4!4*/;97!J.)0(4.!$3.7!&;;&4.!011*%/0$*8.!0)$*&#!&%!4(;;&%$!<#A9*43`a!*#4$%()$*&#+DD!! n.$! J.$S..#! $3.! .047! )04.4! &1! /.%.! ;.%4(04*&#! 0#'! )9.0%! L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$!8*&90$*&#!9*.!;%0)$*).4!$30$!0%.!%*A3$97!)&#$.4$.'+!607!A&8.%#`/.#$!&11*)*094! 0%A(.! $30$! $3.!A&8.%#/.#$K4!;&9*$*)09! &;;&#.#$4! 0%.!(#S*$`$*#A97!3.9;*#A!.8*9d!607!;%*80$.!;0%$*.4!;%&;.%97!(4.!$3.*%!.)&#&/*)!;&S.%!$&!%.$09*0$.!0A0*#4$!$3&4.!S3&4.!8*.S4!$3.7!)&#'./#d!607!$3.!A&8.%#/.#$!4(J;&.#0! 9*J%0%7! 0#'! J&&C4$&%.! %.)&%'4! $&! 3.9;! (#)&8.%! $3.! *'.#$*$*.4! &1!;&9*$*)09!)%*/*#094!&%!$.%%&%*4$4d!! B()3!;%0)$*).4! 4&/.$*/.4! $%*AA.%! )30%A.4!&1! i6)-0%$37*4/+k!-%*$*)4!)&%%.)$97! ;&*#$! &($! $30$! $3.4.! ;%0)$*).4! /07! '.$.%h.8.#! S*$3&($! 9.A0997!;%&3*J*$*#Ah).%$0*#!C*#'4!&1! 4;..)3+!B&/.!&1! $3.!;%0)$*).4!/07!.8.#!J.!*#$.#'.'!$&!'.$.%!4()3!4;..)3+!! n.$!04!$3.!.P0/;9.!&1!4&)*09!#&%/4!0A0*#4$!%0)*4$!4;..)3!43&S4T!4&/.!'.$.%%.#).!&1!J0'!4;..)3!*4!4&)*0997!0#'!9.A0997!;.%/*44*J9.+!23.!30%'!f(.4`$*&#T!S3*)3!$3*4!<4407!1&)(4.4!&#T!*4!S3.#!4()3!;%0)$*).4!%.0997!'.4.%8.!$&!J.!90J.9.'!i6)-0%$37*4/k!0#'!$&!J.!1&%J*''.#!J7!$3.!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$T!J7!4$0$($.T!&%!J7!4&)*09!#&%/+D,!"!%.A%.$!$30$!"!)0#K$!&11.%!0!A.#.%09!0#4S.%T!&%!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! DN+! %##M$ #K-KT! :.9.#! I.S0%T! ,$ H:A$ 12D&2)-*$ F.'5D#*+$ .*$ 0#+T#*C25D$ %+)"@$ !5"."U$V1.DD5*)@+$%3D&2+()T#"W$82C#7$=2@$A".&.@#LT!Wash. PostT!\(97!MNT!DclHT!0$!@D!U'*4)(44*#A!i0!4.)%.$!B.#0$.! ?.;(J9*)0#! )0/;0*A#! '&)(/.#$! (%A*#A! $30$! B.#+! :&S0%'! 6+! 6.$^.#J0(/! UI`G3*&V! J.!)30%0)$.%*^.'!04!0!pb-j&//(#*4$!47/;0$3*^.%Kk!&#!$3.!A%&(#'4!$30$!6.$^.#J0(/!30'!i40b*'j!$30$!p$3.!9&#A`%0#A.!4&9($*&#! 1&%!(#./;9&7/.#$! 9*.4! *#!)%.0$*#A!0!3.09$37!0$/&4;3.%.! 1&%! *#'(4$%*09!.P;0#4*&#K!0#'!+!+!+!'.)9*#b.'j!$&!%(9.!&($!p(4.!&1!5>@!0#'!\&J4!-&%;4!$.)3#*f(.4!04!0!;(/;!;%*/.%KkV+!&! DD+! %##M$#K-KT!B30%&#!E.%#4$.*#T!%+."D$;)@#@$.B#"$>XSY72*@D2*$2+$F#C2+#T!L.A. TimesT!B.;$+!DDT!DccoT!0$!@M!Ui>%&;&4*$*&#!,Nc!*4!%0)*4$T!b>0$%*)*0!<S*#AT!S3&!3.0'4!$3.!)0/;0*A#!$&!'.1.0$!>%&;&4*$*&#!,NcTj!40*'!+!+!+!+kV+!>%&;+!,Nc!*4!$3.!-09*1&%#*0!/.04(%.!$30$!J0%%.'!A&8.%#/.#$!&11*)*094!1%&/!(4*#A!%0).!0#'!4.P!;%.1.%.#).4!*#!./;9&7/.#$T!.'()0$*&#T!0#'!)&#$%0)$*#A+!9LKa!@##$27@.!_.&%A.!-&$3%0#!m!\&3#!6.)C9*#T!6(#$H")LT!S.F. Weekly!U607!,HT!DcclVT!2B2)72C7#$2+!3$$;OqqSSS+41S..C97+)&/q*44(.4qDccl`N=`,Hq#.S4q)&9(/#4s;%*#$+3$/9! Ui?&#! X#^T! $3.! 30$.1(9! )%..;! S3&! 4(;;&%$4! $3.! .9*/*#0$*&#! &1! 099!J*9*#A(09!.'()0$*&#!*#!$3.!4$0$.T!C#&S4!#&$3*#A!0J&($!.'()0$*&#!;&9*)7+!+!+!+!>%&;&4*#A!$&!30%/!)3*9'%.#!1&%!;&9*$*)09!%.04!*4!0!4;.)*09!$7;.!&1!4*#!$30$!43&(9'!.0%#!6%+!X#^!0!4;.)*09!;90).!*#!3.99+!E.1&%.!3.!A.$4! $3.%.T! A*8.! 3*/! 3*4! .0%$397! %.S0%'+! Z&$.! $&! '.1.0$! (A97T! %0)*4$! >%&;&4*$*&#! ,,H+kVa$_%.A! R()04T!J".N*$F#'")#@$A72*@$+.$>*L$,//)"D2+)B#$,'+).*T!S.F. Chron+T!L.J+!D=T!Dcc=T!0$!@DN!Ui@#!*/;044*&#.'!@44./J97! B;.0C.%! 5*99*.! E%&S#! 9043.'! &($! 7.4$.%'07! 0$! ;%&;&4094! $&! .#'! 011*%/0$*8.! 0)$*&#! *#!-09*1&%#*0T! J%0#'*#A! $3./! p;(%.T! (#0'(9$.%0$.'! .P;9&*$0$*&#! &1! %0)*4/+KkVa! [0%0! >90$&#*T!0.*#3M$ %#XM$2*L$A.7)+)'@T!Sacramento News & Rev.T!60%+!,oT!Dccl!Ui>%&;&4*$*&#!,,HT!S3*)3!S&(9'!'&!0S07!S*$3!J*9*#A(09!.'()0$*&#T!094&!)0/.!(#'.%!3.087!1*%.! b0$! $3.!-09*1&%#*0!I./&)%0$*)!>0%$7!-.#$*&#j!0#'!S04! %&(#'97! '.#&(#).'! J7! B$.8.! nJ0%%0T! -30*%/0#! &1! $3.! -3*)0#&qR0$*#&! -0()(4T! 04! p%0)*4$!$3(AA.%7+KkV+!1/K!\0)f(.4!B$.*#J.%AT$9*'"#2@#$)*$6#@+$%'."#@$1.5*+#"@$F)"#$!."#'2@+@$/."$J)7)*-527$J2*T!N.Y. TimesT!@(A+!,NT!,NNNT!t!DT!0$!D!Ui2S&!7.0%4!01$.%!-09*1&%#*0#4!8&$.'!$&!.#'!J*9*#A(09!.'()0$*&#!0#'! 1&%).! 0!/*99*&#!B;0#*43`4;.0C*#A! 4$('.#$4! $&! *//.%4.! $3./4.98.4! *#!<#A9*43! 04! *1! *$!S.%.! 0! )&9'!J0$3T! $3&4.! 4$('.#$4! 0%.! */;%&8*#A! *#! %.0'*#A! 0#'!&$3.%! 4(Jg.)$4! 0$! &1$.#! 4$%*C*#A! %0$.4T! 0))&%'*#A! $&!4$0#'0%'*^.'!$.4$!4)&%.4!%.9.04.'!$3*4!S..C+kV+!23*4!*4!;%.)*4.97!$3.!.11.)$!$30$!?&#!X#^!30'!;%.'*)$.'!0#'!S&%C.'!1&%+!! D,+! i6)-0%$37*4/Tk! 0))&%'*#A! $&! $3.! American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language!DNlF!UF$3!.'+!,NNNVT! *4!ib$j3.!;%0)$*).!&1!;(J9*)*^*#A!0))(40$*!&1!;&9*$*)09!'*49&709$7!&%!4(J8.%4*&#! S*$3! *#4(11*)*.#$! %.A0%'! $&! .8*'.#).k! &%& ib$j3.! (4.! &1! (#10*%! *#8.4$*A0$&%7! &%! 0))(40$&%7!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! =$
! =!
.8.#!'*4)(44!/&%.! $30#!0! 1.S!4()3!;%0)$*).4+!E($! *#! $3*4!<4407T!"!3&;.!$&!&11.%! 4&/.! $3&(A3$4! &#! $3.! 4(Jg.)$T! $3&(A3$4!S3*)3! 4(%.97! 0%.#K$! )&#)9(`4*8.T!J($!S3*)3!"!3&;.!S*99!J.!3.9;1(9+!
I Condemnation of Those Who May Inadvertently Help the Enemy
! i2&! $3&4.! S3&! 4)0%.! ;.0).`9&8*#A! ;.&;9.! S*$3! ;30#$&/4! &1! 9&4$!!9*J.%$7Tk!@$$&%#.7!_.#.%09!@43)%&1$!10/&(497!40*'!#&$!9&#A!01$.%!B.;$./J.%!DDT!i/7!/.440A.!*4!$3*4O!n&(%!$0)$*)4!a!0*'!$.%%&%*4$4T!1&%!$3.7!.%&'.!&(%!#0$*	! (#*$7! 0#'! '*/*#*43! &(%! %.4&98.+! 23.7! A*8.! 0//(#*$*&#! $&!!@/.%*)0K4!.#./*.4!+!+!+!+kDM!230$K4!6)-0%$37*4/T!4&/.!%.;9*.'+DF!! :.%.K4!0#&$3.%!f(&$.T!$3*4!&#.!1%&/!$3.!;%.4*'.#$O!iG(%!#0$*&#!304!1.9$!$3.!9043!&1!$.%%&%*4/+!+!+!+!5.!)0#K$!9.$!b0!).%$0*#!A%&(;j!$(%#!@/.%*)0!*#$&!0!401.3&(4.! 1&%! $.%%&%*4$4+! -&#A%.44! 43&(9'! A.$! J0)C! &#! $%0)C! 0#'! 4.#'!/.!$&(A3!9.A*490$*&#!$30$!)%0)C4!'&S#!&#!$.%%&%*4/+!"$!43&(9'!9*4$.#!$&!$3.!)%*.4!&1!$3.!8*)$*/4!0#'!$3.!3&;.4!&1!&(%!)3*9'%.#T!#&$!$3.!J0)C`099.7!S3*4;.%4!&1!$3.! bA%&(;j+k! 23.! ;%.4*'.#$!S04! E*99! -9*#$&#T! 0#'! $3.! A%&(;! $30$! 3.!S04!)&#'./#*#A!S04! $3.! iA(#! 9&JJ7Tk!S3*)3! &;;&4.'! 4&/.!A(#`)&#$%&9! ;%&`;&4094!$30$!-9*#$&#!108&%.'+D=!!! R*C.S*4.T! 1&99&S*#A! $3.!GC903&/0! -*$7! J&/J*#AT! >%.4*'.#$! -9*#$&#!0%A(.'!&#!#0$*	!$.9.8*4*&#!$30$!8*&9.#).!*4!)0(4.'!i#&$!g(4$!bJ7j!$3.!/&8`*.4!43&S*#A!8*&9.#).+!"$K4! $3.!S&%'4!4;&($*#A!8*&9.#).T!A*8*#A!40#)$*&#!$&!8*&9.#).T! $.99*#A! ;.&;9.! 3&S! $&! ;%0)$*).! 8*&9.#).! $30$! 0%.! 4S..;*#A! 099!0)%&44!$3.!)&(#$%7+!>.&;9.!43&(9'!.P0/*#.!$3.!).f(.#).4!&1!S30$!$3.7!407!0#'! $3.!C*#'!&1!./&$*! $3.7K%.! $%7*#A! $&! *#190/.+kDo!:.!/*A3$!308.!/.0#$! $&! )&#'./#! a! $3&4.!S3&! 0)$(0997! (%A.! 8*&9.#).T! 0#'! #&$! $3&4.!S3&! 4*/;97! iA*8b.j! 40#)$*&#! $&! 8*&9.#).k! J7! 30%4397! )%*$*)*^*#A! $3.! A&8`.%#/.#$+!E($!3*4!S&%'4!)&(9'!094&!308.!J..#! *#$.%;%.$.'!U0#'!S.%.! *#$.%`;%.$.'T!J7!0$!9.04$!&#.!47/;0$3.$*)!)&//.#$0$&%V!04!0!)%*$*)*4/!&1!4$%*'.#$!0#$*`A&8.%#/.#$!%3.$&%*)!/&%.!J%&0'97+DH!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!/.$3&'4! *#!&%'.%! $&! 4(;;%.44!&;;&4*$*&#ka! $3.!'.1*#*$*&#! "K8.!3.0%'!(4.'!/&4$!&1$.#! *4! $3.! 90$$.%!&#.T!S3*)3! "K/! (4*#A! 3.%.+!:.#).T! $&! '.)*'.!S3.$3.%! 4&/.! J.308*&%! *4! ;%&;.%97! )099.'! J7! $3.! ;.g&%0$*8.!90J.9!i6)-0%$37*4/Tk!S.!#..'!$&!04C!S3.$3.%!$3.!J.308*&%!*4!*#'..'!*/;%&;.%+!!! DM+! F#&2"+D#*+$ ./$ Z5@+)'#$ :B#"@)-(+4$A"#@#"B)*-$ :5"$ !"##L.D@$ =()7#$ F#/#*L)*-$ ,-2)*@+$
6#"".")@D4$I#2")*-@$J#/."#$+(#$%#*2+#$1.DDK$.*$+(#$Z5L)')2"3T!DNH$3!-&#A+!MDM!UI.)+!oT!,NNDV+!! DF+! %##M$ #K-KT! \&3#!5+! I.0#T! 8)C#"+)#@$ F)@2&")*-$ J#/."#$ :5"$ >3#@T! L.A. TimesT! B.;$+! ,DT!,NNMT!0$!?Ma!_.&11%.7!?+!B$&#.T!,D#")'2W@$<#N$0'12"+(3)@DT!Chi. Trib.T!G)$+!DHT!,NNFT!0$!-DD+!!! D=+! 5*99*0/!\+!-9*#$&#T!>%.4*'.#$!-9*#$&#K4!5..C97!?0'*&!@''%.44T!Dcco!Pub. Papers!FoMT!FoF!U60%+!DoT!DccoV+&&! Do+! 5*99*0/!\+!-9*#$&#T!"#$.%8*.S!&#!-EBK!ioN!6*#($.4kT!Dcc=!Pub. Papers!=HFT!=Hl!U@;%+!,MT!Dcc=V+!! DH+! <+\+!I*&##.!\%+T!,$6)D#$/."$A.7)+)')2*@$+.$8..P$=)+()*T!Wash. PostT!@;%+!,=T!Dcc=T!0$!@DH!Ui"$K4!S%&#A! $&! 4(AA.4$! $30$!3&#.4$!0'8&)0$.4!&1! 4/099.%!A&8.%#/.#$!308.!0#7$3*#A! *#! )&//&#!S*$3!C*99.%4!0#'!10#0$*)4+!+!+!+!bE($!/j0*#4$%.0/!;&9*$*)*0#4!+!+!+!308.!$&!044.44!S3.$3.%!$3.7!308.!4$&&'!4*9.#$97!04!b8*&9.#$j!0$$*$('.4!$&&C!3&9'!b0/&#A!10%`%*A3$!/*9*$*04jT!S3.$3.%!$3.7!.P;9&*$.'!$3./!0#'!S3.$3.%T!0$!$*/.4T! $3.7!/07! .8.#! 308.! .#)&(%0A.'! $3./+!+!+!+!@1$.%! $3.! 4(11.%*#A! *#!GC903&/0!-*$7T! $3.! )&(#$%7!
o! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!o!
! B*/*90%97T! )*'.%!5*#4$&#!-3(%)3*99K4! 90/.#$! $30$! 3*4! )%*$*)4K!S0%`$*/.!4$0$./.#$4!S.%.!U0/&#A!&$3.%!$3*#A4V!iS.0C.#b*#Aj!)*'.#).!*#!$3.!_&8.%#/.#$Tk! i/0Cb*#Aj! $3.!@%/7!'*4$%(4$! $3.!J0)C*#A! *$! *4!A.$$*#A! 1%&/!$3.! )*8*9! ;&S.%Tk! 0#'! i/0Cb*#Aj! $3.! S&%C/.#! 9&4.! )*'.#).! *#! $3.!!S.0;! $3.7!0%.!4$%*8*#A!4&!30%'! $&!/0C.Tk!099!i$&! $3.!'*4$%.44!&1!099!&(%!1%*.#'4!0#'!$&!$3.!'.9*A3$!&1!099!&(%!1&.4+kDl!@#'T!1*#0997T!)*'.%!$3*4!f(&$.!1%&/! _.&%A.! G%S.99! '(%*#A! 5&%9'! 50%! ""O!i>0)*1*4/! *4! &Jg.)$*8.97!!;%&`104)*4$+!23*4!*4!.9./.#$0%7!)&//&#!4.#4.+!"1!7&(!30/;.%!$3.!S0%!.11&%$!&#!&#.!4*'.T!7&(!0($&/0$*)0997!3.9;!&($!$30$!&1!$3.!&$3.%+kDc!G%S.99K4!/.4`40A.T! "! $0C.! *$T!S04! $3*4O!23.!;0)*1*4$4K! $0)$*)4!a!0*'! $3.!e0^*4T! 1&%! $3.7!.%&'.!$3.!@99*.4K!#0$*	!(#*$7!0#'!'*/*#*43!$3.*%!%.4&98.+!23.7!A*8.!0/`/(#*$*&#!$&!$3.!@99*.4K!.#./*.4+!! B()3!4$0$./.#$4!308.!4&/.!$3*#A4!*#!)&//&#+!23.7!0))(4.!;.&;9.!&1!'&*#A! $3*#A4! $30$! 3.9;! $3.! .#./7+! 23.! A%.0$!/0g&%*$7! &1! $3.! 0))(4.'! 0%.!;%&J0J97! '.).#$! ;.&;9.T!S3&! 308.! #&! '.4*%.! $&! 3.9;! $.%%&%*4$4! &%!e0^*4+,N!23.!4$0$./.#$4!/07!094&!'.$.%!'*44.#$.%4O!>.&;9.!'&#K$!9*C.!$&!J.!$&9'!$30$!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!#..'4!0#!.P$.#'.'!;.%*&'!*#!S3*)3!;&9*$*)09!%3.$&%*)!*4!$&#.'!'&S#T!S&%'4!0%.!/&%.!)0%.1(997!S.*A3.'!0#'T! 04! $3.! ;%.4*'.#$! 40*'! 7.4$.%'07T! p$3.! ;(%8.7&%4! &1! 30$%.'! 0#'! '*8*4*&#K! 0#'! p$3.! ;%&/&$.%4! &1!;0%0#&*0K! 0%.! %.4*4$.'! 0#'!)&#'./#.'+kV+!J5+$ '/K!Z*%A*#*0! "+!>&4$%.9T!F.#@$;#2L)*-$6()@$02P#$G.5$2$6#"".")@+RT! ReasonOnlineT! \(97! Dcc=T! 2+$ 3$$;Oqq%.04&#+)&/qc=NHqZ">.'*$+g(9+43$/9! U)%*$*)*^*#A!I*&##.K4!0%$*)9.V+!! Dl+! !
530$! 0! %./0%C0J9.! .P0/;9.! b$3.! '.J0$.j! 304! J..#! &1! $3.! (#J%*'9.'! 1%..'&/! &1! &(%!>0%9*0/.#$0%7!*#4$*$($*!*#!$*/.!&1!S0%u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
5*#4$&#!-3(%)3*99T!B;..)3!*#!$3.!:&(4.!&1!-&//!U\(97!,T!DcF,VT!)*!Never Give In!: The Best of Winston Churchill’s Speeches!MMc!U5*#4$&#!B+!-3(%)3*99!.'+T!,NNMV+&-3(%)3*99!4$%.44.'!$30$!3.!S04!i*#!108&(%!&1!$3*4!1%..'&/T!S3*)3!#&!&$3.%!)&(#$%7!S&(9'!(4.T!&%!'0%.!$&!(4.T!*#!$*/.4!&1!/&%$09!;.%*9!4()3! 04! $3&4.! $3%&(A3! S3*)3! S.! 0%.! ;044*#A+k! 9LK! E($! *$! S04! )9.0%! $30$! 3.! 40S! ).%$0*#! (4.4! &1! $3.!1%..'&/! 04! J.*#A! 3.9;1(9! $&! $3.! #0$*&#K4! .#./*.4+! %##$ 27@.! R.$$.%! 1%&/! 23&/04! \.11.%4&#! $&! $3.!?.;(J9*)0#!n&(#A!6.#!&1!e.S!R&#'&#T!UL.J+!,FT!DlNcV!)*!Do!The Writings of Thomas Jefferson!MMc! U@#'%.S! @+! R*;4)&/J! .'+T! DcNMV! Ui230$! *#! 0! 1%..! A&8.%#/.#$! $3.%.! 43&(9'! J.! '*11.%.#).4! &1!&;*#*&#!04!$&!;(J9*)!/.04(%.4!0#'!$3.!)&#'()$!&1!$3&4.!S3&!'*%.)$!$3./T!*4!$&!J.!.P;.)$.'+!"$!*4!/()3T!3&S.8.%T! $&! J.! 90/.#$.'T! $30$! $3.4.! '*11.%.#).4! 43&(9'! J.! *#'(9A.'! 0$! 0! )%*4*4! S3*)3! )0994! 1&%! $3.!(#'*8*'.'! )&(#4.94! 0#'! .#.%A*.4! &1! &(%! )&(#$%7!+!+!+!+kVa! R.$$.%! 1%&/! 23&/04! \.11.%4&#! 2&! :*4!<P).99.#)7!_&8.%#&%!I0#*.9!I+!2&/;C*#4T!UL.J+!,FT!DlNcVT!)L+!0$!MFD!Ui23.!$*/.4!'&!).%$0*#97!%.#'.%!*$!*#)(/J.#$!&#!099!A&&'!)*$*^.#4!0$$0)3.'!$&!$3.!%*A3$4!0#'!3&#&%!&1!$3.*%!)&(#$%7T!$&!J(%7!*#!&J9*8*&#!099!*#$.%#09!'*11.%.#).4!+!+!+!+!@99!0$$./;$4!$&!.#1..J9.!0#'!'.4$%&7!$3.!.P.%$*!&1!$3.!_.#.%09!_&8.%#/.#$!*#!8*#'*)0$*&#!&1!&(%!#0$*	!%*A3$4!+!+!+!/.%*$!$3.!'*4)&(#$.#0#).!&1!099+kV+!230#C4!$&!E&J!2(%#.%!0#'!$&!3$$;Oqq.$.P$+9*J+8*%A*#*0+.'(qg.11.%4&#qf(&$0$*q!1&%!;&*#$.%4!$&!$3.4.!\.11.%4&#!f(&$.4+!! Dc+! _.&%A.!G%S.99T!A2')/)@D$2*L$+(#$=2"T!Partisan Rev.T!B.;$+`G)$+!DcF,T!"#&")*+#L$)*!,!The Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell!,,o!UB&#*0!G%S.99!m!"0#!@#A(4!.'4+T!DcolV+!! ,N+! "1!$3.!4$0$./.#$4!)&#'./#.'!;.&;9.!S3&!'*'!4(;;&%$!$.%%&%*4$4!&%!e0^*4T!"!$0C.!*$!$3.7!S&(9'!J.!)9.0%97!;%&;.%+!
2010
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! H$
! H!
$3.7! 0%.!3.9;*#A! $3.!#0$*&#K4!/&%$09! .#./*.4T! .4;.)*0997!S3.#! $3.! )30%A.!)&/.4!1%&/!0#!&11*)*09!$&!S3&/!/*99*!9*4$.#+!<8.#!*1!$3.!0))(4.'!$3*#C!$3.!0))(40$*&#! *4!(#g(4$T! $3.7!/07!C..;!f(*.$T!&%! 0$! 9.04$! $&#.!'&S#! $3.*%!0%A(/.#$4T! $&! 08&*'! 4()3! 0$$0)C4! *#! $3.! 1($(%.+,D! 23.! 0))(4.%4! 9*C.97! *#`$.#'.'!$&!'.$.%!'*44.#$!J7!/0C*#A!;&$.#$*09!'*44.#$.%4!1..9!./J0%%044.'!$&!/0C.!).%$0*#!)%*$*)*4/4!$30$!$3.!0))(4.%4!$3&(A3$!J04.9.44!0#'!30%/1(9+,,&&! @#'! $3.! 0))(40$*!/07!094&! 308.!J..#! 10)$(0997! )&%%.)$+! >0)*1*4$4K!&;;&4*$*&#!$&!$3.!@99*.'!S0%!.11&%$!/07!308.!3.9;.'!$3.!e0^*4!04!/()3!04!;%&`e0^*! &;;&4*$*&#! S&(9'! 308.+! <P).44*8.! *#4*4$.#).! &#! A(#! &S#.%4K!%*A3$4!/*A3$! 9*C.S*4.!3.9;! $.%%&%*4$4+,M!B*/*90%97T!)%*$*)*4/4!&1! $3.!0'/*#*`4$%0$*&#K4!0)$*!/07!S.99!.%&'.!#0$*	!(#*$7T!'*/*#*43!#0$*	!%.4&98.T!A*8.!0//(#*$*&#!$&!&(%!.#./*.4T!0#'!0*'!$.%%&%*4$4+!23*4!*4!.4;.)*0997!$%(.!S3.#! $3.! )%*$*)*4/4! )&/.! 1%&/! 9.A*490$*8.! 9.0'.%4+!?.)099! $30$!@43)%&1$K4!4$0$./.#$!)0/.!0$!0!3.0%*#A!&%A0#*^.'!J7!B.#0$&%!>0$%*)C!R.037T!$3.#`)30*%!&1! $3.!I./&)%0$`%(#!B.#0$.!\('*)*0%7!-&//*$$..!0#'!0! 9.0'*#A!0'8.%40%7!&1!@43)%&1$+,F!23.!3.0%*#A!30'!0;;0%.#$97!J..#!)099.'!*#!;0%$!$&!)%*$*)*^.!$3.!0'/*#*4$%0$*&#K4! 0#$*$.%%&%*4/!;&9*)7!&#! )*8*9! 9*J.%$*.4!A%&(#'4+,=!<#./*.4!S3&!4..!&(%!;&9*$*)09!9.0'.%4!'*8*'.'!&#!$3.!S0%!&#!$.%%&%!/07!S.99!J.!./`J&9'.#.'T!0#'!1&%.*A#!#.($%094!/07!4..!(4!04! 9.44! 9*C.97! $&!;%.80*9! $30#!*1!S.! 4../.'! (#*$.'+! B()3! *#$.%#09! '*8*4*&#! /07! S.99! i'*4$%.44!+!+!+!099! &(%!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ,D+! B&/.! 308.! 0%A(.'! $30$!@43)%&1$K4! f(&$.!S04! ;0%$*)(90%97! $3%.0$.#*#A! J.)0(4.! 3.!/0'.! $3.!4$0$./.#$!04!$3.!#0$*&#K4!)3*.1!1.'.%09!90S!.#1&%)./.#$!&11*)*09+!23.!40/.!)&(9'!J.!40*'!0J&($!>%.4*'.#$!-9*#$&#K4!4$0$./.#$T!4*#).!;%.4*'.#$4!A*8.!&%'.%4!$&!1.'.%09!90S!.#1&%)./.#$+!E($!"!$3*#C!#.*$3.%!f(&$.!)0#!%.04�J97!J.! *#$.%;%.$.'!04!0#!0)$(09! $3%.0$! $&!;%&4.)($.! $3&4.!S3&!)%*$*)*^.! $3.!0'/*#*4$%0$*&#K4!;&9*)*.4!&#! 4&/.!0*'*#A`$3.`$.%%&%*4$4! $3.&%7+! "1! *$!S.%.! 0! $3%.0$T! *$!S&(9'!308.!J..#!0#!(#)&//a!./;$7! &#.h#.*$3.%! $3.! -9*#$&#! #&%! $3.! E(43! \(4$*).! I.;0%$/.#$4! .8.%! .#A0A.'! *#! 0#7! 4()3!;%&4.)($*T!.*$3.%!J.1&%.!$3.!4$0$./.#$4!&%!01$.%+!!! e&%!'*'!4()3!;%&4.)($*!4../!9*C.97!0$!$3.!$*/.+!G#97!(#(4(0997!1.0%1(9!'.1.#'.%4!&1!A(#!%*A3$4!&%! &1! &$3.%! )*8*9! 9*J.%$*.4! S&(9'! 308.! J..#! 4*9.#).'! J.)0(4.! $3.7! *#$.%;%.$.'! .*$3.%! 4$0$./.#$! 04!$3%.0$.#*#A!;%&4.)($*&#+!Ue&#)*$*^.#4!'*'!*#'..'!308.!/&%.!$&!1.0%!1%&/!$3.!\(4$*).!I.;0%$/.#$a!*1!$3.7!'%.S! $3.!A&8.%#/.#$K4!0$$.#$*&#T!0#'! $3.!A&8.%#/.#$! $3.#! 1&(#'! $30$! $3.!#&#)*$*^.#4!30'!)&//*$$.'!$.)3#*)09! *//*A%0$*&#! 8*&90$*T! $3.7! )&(9'! J.! '.;&%$.'+! %##! ?.#&! 8+! @/.%*)0#`@%0J! @#$*`I*4)%*/*#0$*&#!-&//+T!=,=!X+B+!FHDT!Fll`cD!UDcccV+!E($!@43)%&1$K4!'&/.4$*)!)*8*9`9*J.%$0%*0#!)%*$*)4!0$! $3.! $*/.T! $&!S3&/!3.!S04! %.4;&#'*#AT!S.%.!&8.%S3.9/*#A97! )*$*^.#4+V!E&$3!@43)%&1$! 0#'!-9*#$&#!9*C.97! '*'! S0#$! $&! '.$.%! ;.&;9.! 1%&/! .P;%.44*#A! ).%$0*#! 8*.S4hJ($! S*$3! $3.! $3%.0$! &1! 4&)*09!&;;%&J%*(/T!#&$!&1!)%*/*#09!;%&4.)($*&#+!! ,,+! G1!)&(%4.!@43)%&1$!0#'!-9*#$&#!094&!9*C.97!3&;.'!$30$!4&/.!)%*$*)4!S&(9'!J.!;.%4(0'.'!$30$!$3.*%!)%*$*)*4/4!S.%.!4*/;97!/*4$0C.#a! $3.%.!)0#!J.!9*$$9.!&Jg.)$*&#! $&!4()3!0#!&($)&/.+!E($!"!4(4;.)$!$3.7!%.09*^.'!$30$!/0#7!;.&;9.!S&(9'#K$!J.!;.%4(0'.'!&#!$3.!/.%*$4!J($!/*A3$T!#&#.$3.9.44!J.!'.$.%%.'!1%&/!4;.0C*#A!J7!$3.!%*4C!&1!;(J9*)!&;;%&J%*(/+!! ,M+! "!$3*#C!A(#!)&#$%&94!;%&J0J97!S&#K$!/0$.%*0997!*#$.%1.%.!S*$3!$.%%&%*4$4K!;90#4T!J($!%.04�J9.!/*#'4!/07!'*11.%+!! ,F+! %##$@5&"2$#&$.!DM+!! ,=+! %##!@J%030/!6)R0(A39*#!m!I0#$.!-3*##*T!,@('"./+$!)*2773$!2'#@$I)77$1")+)'@T!Christian Sci. MonitorT!I.)+!=T!,NNDT!0$!D!Ui@4!3.!4*$4!'&S#!J.1&%.!$3.!B.#0$.!\('*)*0%7!-&//*$$..!$&/&%%&ST!@$$&%#.7!_.#.%09!\&3#!@43)%&1$!)0#!.P;.)$!0!A%*99*#A!#&$!4..#!4*#).!3*4!B.#0$.!)*%/0$*&#!3.0%*#A+!23.!9*#.!&1!f(.4$*&#*#A!S*99!9*C.97!J&*9!'&S#!$&!&#.!*44(.O!S3.$3.%!3.!0#'!$3.!E(43!0'/*#*4$%0$*&#!308.!J..#!&8.%97!0($3&%*$0%*0#!*#!;%&4.)($*#A!$3.!S0%!&#!$.%%&%*4/!0#'!;%&$.)$*#A!$3.!;(J9*)+kV+!&
l! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!l!
1%*.#'4!0#'!+!+!+!'.9*A3$!099!&(%!1&.4+k,o!@#'!*1!B.#0$&%!R.037K4!0#'!&$3.%4K!)%*$*)*4/4!S.%.!*#'..'!(#1&(#'.'!&%!0$!9.04$!.P0AA.%0$.'!U0!3&$97!)&#$.4$.'!;&4*$*&#T!&1!)&(%4.T!J($!&#.!$30$!@43)%&1$!'.1.#'.'!&#!$3.!/.%*$4!*#!3*4!$.4`$*/VT! $3.#!@43)%&1$! )&(9'! 308.! %.04�J97! )&#)9('.'! $30$! $3.! )%*$*)4K!0)$*!S.%.!J&$3!(#g(4$*1*.'!0#'!'0#A.%&(4+!! _&&'!*#$.#$*!/07!4&/.$*/.4!7*.9'!J0'!%.4(9$4+!230$K4!$%(.!&1!S.99`*#$.#$*&#.'! 0'/*#*4$%0$*&#! 0)$*T! S3*)3! $3.! ;0%$7! &($! &1! ;&S.%! &1$.#!S0%#4!0J&($+!"$K4!094&!$%(.!&1!S.99`*#$.#$*&#.'!)%*$*)*4/4!&1!4()3!0)$*+!"1!4()3! J0'! %.4(9$4! 4../! 9*C.97T! $3.#! $3.! ;(J9*)! &(A3$! $&! J.!S0%#.'! &1! $3*4!'0#A.%T!$3&(A3!&1!)&(%4.!$3&4.!S3&!'*40A%..!43&(9'!9*C.S*4.!0%A(.!$30$!$3.!'0#A.%!*4!*$4.91!0!i;30#$&/+k!! @#'!A&8.%#/.#$!&11*)*094!0%.!04!.#$*$9.'!04!0#7&#.!.94.! $&!#&$.!4()3!'0#A.%4+!23.!0'/*#*4$%0$*&#T!S3*)3!*4!%.4;*J9.!1&%!C..;*#A!$3.!)&(#$%7!401.T!304!0!%.4;*J*9*$7!$&!S0%#!&1!0!S*'.!%0#A.!&1!'0#A.%4+!>.&;9.!S3&!*A#&%.!$3.!'0#A.%T! *1! $3.!'0#A.%!*4!%.09T!/07!S.99!'.4.%8.!$&!J.!)%*$*)*^.'+!@#'!S3.#!;&9*$*)09! 9.0'.%4!'.J0$.!f(.4$*!&1! 9*J.%$7!0#'!#0$*	! 4.)(`%*$7T! ;90(4*J9.! )90*/4! $30$! &#.! 4*'.K4! 0)$*!/07! g.&;0%'*^.! 9*J.%$7!/07!%.04�J97! J.! /.$! J7! ;90(4*J9.! )90*/4! $30$! $3.! &$3.%! 4*'.K4! 0)$*! /07!g.&;0%'*^.!4.)(%*$7+,H!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ,o+! -3(%)3*99T!@5&"2!#&$.!Dl+!! ,H+! "K8.!3.0%'!4&/.!04C!S37T!*1!$3*4!;&*#$!S04!$&!J.!/0'.T!@43)%&1$!S04!$3.!&#.!$&!/0C.!*$+!537!#&$!9.08.!*$!$&!4&/.!9.44!)&#$%&8.%4*09!0'/*#*4$%0$*&#!&11*)*09T!&%!.8.#!$&!;%*80$.!;0%$*.4d!2&!J.A*#!S*$3T!"! $3*#C! $30$! )&#$%&8.%4*09! 0$$&%#.74! A.#.%09! 308.! 04! /()3! %*A3$! $&! .P;%.44! $3.*%! 8*.S4! 04! '&! 9.44!)&#$%&8.%4*09! 1*A(%.4! *#! &$3.%! g&J4+! "$!/07! 4&/.$*/.4! J.!/&%.! ;&9*$*)! 1&%! 0#! 0'/*#*4$%0$*&#! $&! 9.08.!4&/.! 4$0$./.#$4! $&! 9.44! )&#$%&8.%4*09! &11*)*094T! J($! ;&9*$*)09! .11.)$*8.#.44! *4! 0! '*11.%.#$! /0$$.%! 1%&/!;%&;%*.$7+!!! E($! /&%.! */;&%$0#$97T! @43)%&1$! S04! %.4;&#'*#A! $&! )%*$*)*4/4! &1! ;%&;&4094! $30$! )0/.! 1%&/! 3*4!\(4$*).!I.;0%$/.#$T!$30$!S.%.!044&)*0$.'!S*$3!3*/!*#!$3.!;(J9*)!/*#'T!0#'!$30$!S.%.!&1$.#!$*.'!$&!3*/!J7!#0/.+!%##M$#K-KT!_0*9!_*J4&#T!,@('"./+$!257+#L$:B#"$1)B)7$8)C#"+)#@T!Balt. SunT!e&8+!,=T!,NNDT!0$!D@!U#&$*#A! $30$!0!i9*J.%09!0)$*8*4$k!)099.'!@43)%&1$!i$3.!/&4$!'0#A.%&(4! $3%.0$! $&!)*8*9! 9*J.%$*.4! *#! $3.!1.'.%09!A&8.%#/.#$kVa!I08*'!\0)C4&#T!J5@($F#/#*L@$1277$/."$0)7)+2"3$6")27@T!Dallas Morning NewsT!e&8+! MNT! ,NNDT! 0$! Dl@! Uie.P$!S..CT!6%+! R.037K4! )&//*$$..!S*99! 3.0%! 1%&/!@$$&%#.7!_.#.%09! \&3#!@43)%&1$T! S3&! *4! J.0%*#A! $3.! J%(#$! &1! )%*$*)*4/! 1%&/! )*8*9! 9*J.%$0%*0#4+kVa! \&3#! R0#)04$.%T!I#2")*-@$;#/7#'+$ %.D#$E*#2@#$=)+($ ,@('"./+W@$ 8#-27$ ,&&".2'(T!Wash. PostT! I.)+! ,T! ,NNDT! 0$!@,=! Ui@! 1.S!)%*$*)4T!9.'!J7!B.#+!>0$%*)C!\+!R.037!UI`Z$+VT!308.!J..#!8&)09!0J&($!S30$!$3.7!%.A0%'!04!&8.%%.0)3*#A!J7!$3.!.P.)($*8.!J%0#)3T!@$$&%#.7!_.#.%09!\&3#!I+!@43)%&1$!*#!;0%$*)(90%+kVa!6)R0(A39*#!m!-3*##*T!@5&"2!#&$.! ,=! Uib>j0%$*40#43*;! *4! %.4(%%.)$*#A! *$4.91! &#! -0;*$&9! :*99+! L(%$3.%/&%.T! @43)%&1$! 3*/4.91T! p304!J.)&/.!$3.!)9.0%!10).!&1!30%'`)&%.!).%80$*4/K!1&%!4&/.!I./&)%0$4T!p0#'!$30$!304!1(.9.'!&;;&4*$*&#!$&! 3*/! &#! )*8*9! 9*J.%$*.4! 0#'! &$3.%! *44(.4TK! 4074! b:('4&#! "#4$*$($.! )&#A%.44*	! 0#0974$! 60%43099j!5*$$/0##+!+!+!+!b?j.).#$97! &#! -0;*$&9! :*99! 90S/0C.%4! S3&! 308.! J..#! a! f(*.$97! )%*$*)*^*#A! $3.!0'/*#*4$%0$*&#!308.!A%&S#!J&9'.%+!+!+!+kV+&& @43)%&1$K4! ;&9*$*)09! 0'8.%40%*.4! )3099.#A.'! 3*/! 1&%! 099.A.'97! $3%.0$.#*#A! @/.%*)0#4K! 9*J.%$7+!@43)%&1$!%.4;&#'.'!J7!;&*#$*#A!&($!*#!4&/.!'.$0*9!S37!3.!$3&(A3$!$3.!)30%A.4!S.%.!A%&(#'9.44T!0#'!*#!$3.!;%&).44!3.!094&!40*'!$30$!4()3!)30%A.4!S.%.!#&$!a!(#1&(#'.'!J($!30%/1(9+&"$!/0C.4!4.#4.!$30$!0!;&9*$*)*0#!)%*$*)*^.'!J7!&$3.%!;&9*$*)*0#4!S&(9'!'.1.#'!3*/4.91T! %0$3.%! $30#!.P;.)$*#A!&$3.%4! $&!'.1.#'!3*/+!
2010
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! c$
! c!
! e&S!*$K4!$%(.T!04!/0#7!)%*$*)4!0%A(.T!$30$!4()3!0))(40$*!$%7!$&!/&8.!;.&;9.! $3%&(A3! 1.0%+,l! E($! $.%%&%*4$4! &(A3$! $&! J.! 1.0%.'+! 60#7! A%&(;4!%*A3$97!$%7!$&!*#19(.#).!8&$.%4!J7!/0C*#A!$3./!01%0*'!&1!.#8*%&#/.#$09!)0`$04$%&;3.T!)%*/.T!A(#!8*&9.#).T!$.%%&%*4/T!S0%T!4;.)*09!*#$.%.4$4T!&%!4(;;%.4`4*&#! &1! )*8*9! %*A3$4+!5.99`1&(#'.'! 1.0%! *4! J.$$.%! $30#! 1&&9*43! 1.0%9.44#.44+!B&/.!1.0%!*4!.P).44*8.!&%!.8.#!*%%0$*	T!J($!4&/.!*4!./*#.#$97!g(4$*1*.'T!&%!*4!0$!9.04$!0!%.04�J9.!%.4;.!$&!(#).%$0*#$7+,c!! "$K4!094&! $%(.! $30$!;&9*$*)*0#4!4&/.$*/.4!30%#.44! 1.0%! 1&%!;&9*$*)09!0'`80#$0A.+! 230$K4! S30$! $3.7K%.! 4(;;&4.'! $&! '&! *#! 0! './&)%0)7+!53.#! #0`$*	! 4.)(%*$7! *4! 0! J*A! ;0%$! &1! 0#! .9.)$*&#! )0/;0*A#T! .0)3! 4*'.! 9*C.97!J.9*.8.4! $30$! *$4!;%&A%0/!S*99!;%&$.)$! $3.!#0$*&#T!0#'! $3.!&$3.%!4*'.K4!S*99!U0$! 9.04$! )&/;0%0$*8.97V! .#'0#A.%! $3.! #0$*&#h0#'! .0)3! 4*'.! $3.#!304! $3.!%*A3$!0#'!.8.#!$3.!'($7!$&!/0C.!$3.4.!0%A(/.#$4!$&!$3.!8&$.%4+MN!! "#! ,NNF! I./&)%0$4! 4*#).%.97! J.9*.8.'! $30$! %.`.9.)$*#A! _.&%A.! 5+!E(43!S&(9'!.#'0#A.%!@/.%*)0T!J.)0(4.!$3.7!$3&(A3$!$30$!E(43K4!#0$*	!4.)(%*$7!;&9*)7!S04!'0#A.%&(4+!:&(4.!6*#&%*$7!R.0'.%!e0#)7!>.9&4*T! 1&%!*#4$0#).T!0%A(.'!$30$!i$3.!;%.4*'.#$!304!10*9.'!*#!3&S!3.!304!$%*.'!$&!;%&$.)$!@/.%*)0+!+!+!+!5.! 0%.! 9.44! 401.hS.! 0%.! 9.44! 401.! J.)0(4.! 3.! *4!!;%.4*'.#$!+!+!+!+kMD! ?.;(J9*)0#4! 4*#).%.97! J.9*.8.'! $3.! 40/.! &1! [.%%7T! 0#'!0%A(.'! 0))&%'*#A97+M,!G#.!/*A3$! 1*#'! &#.! 4*'.K4! )04.! $&! J.! .%%&#.&(4! &%!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ,l+! %##M$#K-KT!B$&#.T!@5&"2!#&$.!DF! U)&#'./#*#A!I*)C!-3.#.7K4!i044.%$*&#! $30$!0!8&$.! 1&%! \&3#
DN! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!DN!
.8.#!'*43&#.4$T!J($!/0C*#A!1.0%!&1! $.%%&%*4/!0#!i(#'.%97*#A!$3./.!&1!'&`/.4$*)! 0#'! 1&%.*A#! ;&9*)7kMM! *4! f(*$.! ;%&;.%! S3.#! $.%%&%*4$4! 0%.! '&*#A!1%*A3$.#*#A!$3*#A4+!! n.$!0$!$3.!40/.!$*/.T!;&*#$*#A!&($!U.8.#!*1!0))(%0$.97V!$30$!)%*$*)*4/!&1!$3.! 0'/*#*4$%0$*&#! *4! 3.9;*#A!@/.%*)0K4! 1&%.*A#! &%! '&/.4$*)! .#./*.4! 304!)&4$4+!2&!J.A*#!S*$3T!*$!)0#!'*4$%0)$!1%&/!$3.!9.A*$*/0$.!0%A(/.#$4!$30$!$3.!)%*$*)!*4!/0C*#A+!>.%30;4!;07*#A!/&%.!0$$.#$*&#!$&!)*8*9!9*J.%$*.4!S*99!0)$(`0997!3.9;!$3.!S0%!.11&%$!J7!43&S*#A!(4!$&!J.!0!3(/0#.!0#'!$&9.%0#$!#0$*&#!0#'!$3(4!/0C*#A!(4!/&%.!;&;(90%!$3%&(A3&($!$3.!S&%9'+!G%!/07J.!J%&0'97!;%&$.)$*#A!)*8*9! 9*J.%$*.4!S*99!3(%$! $3.!S0%!.11&%$T!J($!4&/.!)&4$! $&!$3.!S0%!.11&%$!*4!0!$&9.%0J9.!;%*).!$&!;07!1&%!;%.4.%8*#A!&(%!$%0'*$*	!%*A3$4+!! 6&%.&8.%T!0%A(*#A!$30$!)%*$*)4!&1!$3.!A&8.%#/.#$!0%.!3.9;*#A!&(%!.#.`/*.4!)0#!S%&#A97! $0%!;.&;9.!S*$3! $3.! */;9*)0$*&#!&1!J0'!;(%;&4.T!.8.#! *1!#&!4()3!)30%A.!*4!.P;9*)*$97!/0'.+!23*4!/07!J.!(#10*%+!"$!/07!J%..'!(##.)`.440%7!;&9*$*)09!3&4$*9*$7h#&$! g(4$!'*40A%../.#$!J($!)&#$./;$!&%!30$%.'h$30$! *4! *$4.91! 30%/1(9! $&! $3.! #0$*&#+! "$! )0#! &8.%`'.$.%! 4;..)3! J7! /0C*#A!4;.0C.%4! 01%0*'! $&! 9.8.9! .8.#! $3&4.! )%*$*)*4/4! $30$T! &#! J090#).T! 3.9;! $3.!)&(#$%7!/&%.!$30#!3(%$!*$+!@4!G%S.99!3*/4.91!S%&$.T!g(4$!$S&!7.0%4!01$.%!$3.!9*#.4!"!f(&$.!0J&8.T!
! 5.! 0%.! $&9'! $30$! *$! *4! a! ;.&;9.K4! &Jg.)$*8.! 0)$*! $30$!!/0$$.%T! 0#'! $3.*%! 4(Jg.)$*8.! 1..9*#A4! 0%.! &1! #&! */;&%$0#).+! 23(4!;0)*1*4$4T!J7!&J4$%()$*#A!$3.!S0%!.11&%$T!0%.!i&Jg.)$*8.97k!0*'*#A!$3.!e0^*4a!0#'!$3.%.1&%.!$3.!10)$!$30$!$3.7!/07!J.!;.%4ϥ!3&4$*9.!$&!L04)*4/!*4!*%%.9.80#$+!"!308.!J..#!A(*9$7!&1!407*#A!$3*4!/74.91!/&%.!$30#!&#).+!+!+!+!! +!+!+!+!! "#!/7!&;*#*&#!0!1.S!;0)*1*4$4!0%.!*#S0%'97!;%&`e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
! e&S!;.%30;4!G%S.99K4!)30#A.!&1!/*#'!S04!&))04*&#.'!J7!$3.!)30#A.!1%&/!$3.!'0%C!'074!&1!DcF,!$&!;&4$`I`'07T!;&4$`B$09*#A%0'!DcFF+!"$!*4!.04*.%!$&!J.!A.#.%&(4!$&!$3&4.!S3&T!*#!7&(%!8*.ST!3.9;.'!:*$9.%!U.8.#!(#*#$.#$*&#`0997V! S3.#! :*$9.%! *4! #.0%97! '.1.0$.'+! n.$! "! $3*#C! $30$! G%S.99K4! 4.)&#'!$3&(A3$4T!S30$.8.%!$3.*%!%.04&#T!S.%.!&Jg.)$*8.97!$3.!%*A3$!&#.4+!<P;90*#*#A!S37!7&(%!0'8.%40%*.4K!0%A(/.#$4!(#*#$.#$*ϥ!3.9;!$3.!.#./7!*4!9.A*$*`/0$.+!E($!.P;%.4497!0)C#&S9.'A*#A!$30$!$3*4!.11.)$!*4!9*C.97!(#*#$.#$*	h!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! MM+! %##!B$&#.T!@5&"2!#&$.!DF!Uf(&$*#A!\0/.4!_&&'J7V+!! MF+! _.&%A.!G%S.99T!,@$9$A7#2@#T!TribuneT!I.)+!lT!DcFFT!"#&")*+#L$)*$M!The Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell!,ll`lc!UB&#*0!G%S.99!m!"0#!@#A(4!.'4+T!DcolV+!
2010
2010
2010
2010
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! DD$
! DD!
.8.#!S3.#!7&(K%.! $(449*#A!S*$3! 0! 4.#0$&%!S3&!7&(! $3*#C! 304! (#10*%97! 0$`$0)C.'!7&(h*4!10*%.%T!9.44!;&9*$*)0997!'*8*4*8.T!0#'!&1$.#!/&%.!%3.$&%*)0997!.11.)$*8.+!"!4(4;.)$!\&3#!@43)%&1$K4!f(&$.!09*.#0$.'!/&%.!@/.%*)0#4!$30#!*$!;.%4(0'.'+!R*C.S*4.T! $3.! 8*$%*&9*)!E(43`$3.`e0^*! 0$$0)C4! 1%&/! 4&/.!;0%$4!&1!$3.!R.1$!;%&J0J97T!&#!J090#).T!3.9;.'!E(43!*#!$3.!,NNF!.9.)$*&#+!! B&!*$!4../4!$&!/.!$30$T! 1*%4$T! $3.!f(&$.4!S*$3!S3*)3!"!J.A0#!$3*4!>0%$!)&(9'! 308.! J..#! ;($! J.$$.%+! B.)&#'T! J.)0(4.! ;.&;9.! $.#'! $&! &8.%.4$*/0$.!$3.!J0'! .11.)$4!&1! $3.*%! 0'8.%40%*.4K! 4;..)3T!S.! 43&(9'!&1$.#!J.! 4C.;$*)09!0J&($!099.A0$*!&1!4()3!J0'!.11.)$4+!@#'!$3*%'T!4()3!099.A0$*!;%&8*'.!0!).#*.#$!S07! $&! .80'.! U'.9*J.%0$.97! &%! 4(J))*&(497V! $3.! 4(J4$0#$*8.!)%*$*)*4/4!9.8.9.'!J7!$3.!0'8.%40%*.4K!4;..)3+&&! e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i6)-0%$37*4/k!*4!9*C.97!$&!'*4$%0)$!9*4$.#.%4!/&%.!$30#!*$!3.9;4!$3./!044.44!S3*)3!099.A0$*!0%.!4&(#'!0#'!S3*)3!0%.#K$+&
II Private Economic Retaliation Against Speakers
,K$ >*+#"+2)*#"@$
! 23.!J90)C9*4$!*4!J0)CT!S.!0%.!$&9'+!@1$.%!e0$09*.!60*#.4T!9.0'!4*#A.%!&1!$3.!)&(#$%7!/(4*)!J0#'!$3.!I*P*.!-3*)C4T! $&9'!10#4!'(%*#A!0!R&#'&#!)&#`).%$T!ib5j.K%.!0430/.'!$3.!>%.4*'.#$!&1!$3.!X#*$.'!B$0$.4!*4!1%&/!2.P04Tk!/0#7!4$0$*!4$&;;.'!;907*#A!3.%!/(4*)T!0#'!4&/.!4$0$*!&%A0#*^.'!%09`9*.4!0$!S3*)3!I*P*.!-3*)C4!-I4!S.%.!)%(43.'!J7!J(99'&^.%4+M=!6-"!4$&;;.'!(4*#A!0)$&%!I0##7!_9&8.%!*#!*$4!)&//.%)*094T!0;;0%.#$97!J.)0(4.!3.!4*A#.'!80%*&(4! 4$0$./.#$4! $30$! 30%4397! &;;&4.'! $3.! "%0f!S0%! 0#'! '.1.#'.'!L*'.9!-04$%&+Mo!B(40#!B0%0#'&#!0#'!2*/!?&JJ*#4!S.%.!'*4*#8*$.'!1%&/!4;.0C*#A!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! M=+! Ted MorganT! Reds: McCarthyism in Twentieth-Century America! =cc! U,NNMV!U)30%0)$.%*^*#A!4&/.!%0'*&!4$0$*K!%.1(409!$&!)0%%7!$3.!I*P*.!-3*)C4!04!iJ90)C9*4$b*#AjTk!0#'!;0%$!&1!0!i)9*/0$.! %./*#*4).#$! &1! $3.! bDc=N4j! J90)C9*4$kVa! @##$ 27@.$ \0%.$! B.*J.%AT!F)X)#$ 1()'P@$ 6")&$E&$ ;2L).$6)+2*@T!Daily DealT! \(97!cT!,NNM! Ui23.!'.)*4*&#!J7!-(/(9(4! 0#'!-&P!?0'*&! "#)+! $&!;(99! $3.!I*P*.!-3*)C4K! /(4*)! 1%&/! $3.*%! ;9079*4$4! S04! %./*#*4).#$! &1! $3.! 6)-0%$37! 3.0%*#A4! 1%&/! $3.! Dc=N4! $30$!%.4(9$.'! *#!0)$&%4!J.*#A!J90)C9*4$.'! *#!:&997S&&'!&%! $3.!e0^*4!J(%#*#A!J&&C4! *#!DcMN4`.%0!_.%/0#7T!40*'!B.#+!E0%J0%0!E&P.%T!I`-09*1+kV+!!! Mo+! R0%0!5.J.%!m!6*)30.9!6&%A0#T!;#2'+).*$ +.$=2"$1.DD#*+@$F)D@$%+2"$A.N#"T!Chi. Trib.T!607!,DT!,NNMT!0$!=c!Ui@!$3%.0$.#.'!J&7)&$$!4..C4!$&!1&%).!6-"!$&!'(/;!_9&8.%!04!*$4!;*$)3/0#!J.)0(4.!&1!8*.S4!3.!.P;%.44.'!0J&($!-(J0!0#'!0A0*#4$!$3.!"%0f!S0%+!+!+!+!_9&8.%!40*'!$3*4!)3*99!)&/.4!1%&/!%*A3$`S*#A! 10)$*! $30$! 3.! '.#&(#).'! 04! 4.91`0;;&*#$.'! $3&(A3$! ;&9*).+kV+! G#.! ;0%$*)(90%! 4$0$./.#$! $30$!$%&(J9.'!4&/.!;.&;9.!S04!90J.9.'!i23.!-)*.#).!&1!$3.!5&%9'Tk!S3*)3!I0##7!_9&8.%T!0/&#A!&$3.%4T!4*A#.'+!9LK!23.!4$0$./.#$!.P;%.4497!)&#'./#.'!@/.%*)0!1&%!i8*&90$b*#Ajk!$3.!i*#$.%#0$*	!&%'.%k!0#'!
2010
2010
2010
D,! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!D,!
.#A0A./.#$4!J.)0(4.!&1!$3.*%!&;;&4*$*&#!$&!$3.!S0%!*#!"%0fa!B.0#!>.##!0;`;0%.#$97!9&4$!0#!0)$*#A!%&9.!1&%!$3.!40/.!%.04&#+MH!! :&S! 43&(9'! S.! %.0)$! S3.#! ;%*80$.! .#$*$*.4! .)&#&/*)0997! %.$09*0$.!0A0*#4$!;.&;9.!J04.'!&#! $3.*%! 4;..)3T!&%!)*$*^.#4!(%A.! $3&4.!.#$*$*.4! $&!'&!$3*4d!23.!%.$09*0$*&#!*4!A.#.%0997!9.A09+!23&(A3!4&/.!4$0$.!90S4!%.4$%*)$!./`;9&7.%4K!;&S.%!$&!%.$09*0$.!0A0*#4$!./;9&7..4!1&%!$3.*%!;&9*$*)09!4;..)3TMl!"!C#&S!&1! #&! 90S4! $30$! %.4$%*)$! )&/;0#*.4K! ;&S.%! $&! %.$09*0$.! 0A0*#4$! $%(97!*#'.;.#'.#$!)&#$%0)$&%4+!6&%.&8.%T!/.'*0!&%A0#*^0$*!/07!308.!0!)&#`4$*$($*	! %*A3$! $&! 1*%.! $3.*%! ./;9&7..4! 1&%! $3.*%! ;&9*$*)09! 8*.S4T! .8.#! *1!4$0$.!90S!;%&3*J*$4!4()3!1*%*#A4+Mc!-0994!1&%!4()3!%.$09*0$*&#!J7!$3.!;(J9*)!0%.!9*C.S*4.!)$*$($*ϥ!;%&$.)$.'+!E($!0%.!.)&#&/*)! %.$09*0$*&#!0#'!)0994!1&%! %.$09*0$*&#! ;%&;.%T! &%! 43&(9'! S.! '.8.9&;! 4&)*09! #&%/4! 0A0*#4$! $3./d!23*4T! *$! 4../4! $&!/.T! *4! 0! 30%'! f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`9*C.'!/&8*.!4$0%!B(40#!B0%0#'&#T!#&$!J.)0(4.!B0%0#'&#! *4!0!#0$*	!.P;.%$!&#!S&/.#!*#!8&9(#`$..%*4/+!>.&;9.!A&!$&!/&8*.4!90%A.97!J.)0(4.!$3.7!9*C.!$3.!4$0%4K!S&%CT!J($!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!i*#19*)$*#A!A%08.!'0/0A.! $&! $3.!#&%/4!&1!(#'.%4$0#'*#AT!'.J0$.!0#'!/.'*0$*&#!0/&#A4$!)&(#$%*.4ka! *$!094&! )&#'./#.'! i30%044/.#$! 0A0*#4$! -(J0Tk! S3*)3! 4(;;&4.'97! i)&(9'! 4.%8.! 04! 0! ;%.$.P$! 1&%! 0#!*#804*&#+k!%##!3$$;OqqSSS+^/0A+&%Aq)&#$.#$q;%*#$s0%$*)9.+)1/d*$./"IwM==om4.)$*&#"Iw=F+!! MH+! \.##*1.%!:0%;.%T!A#**$12*$%5#$/."$8.@@$./$!)7D$;.7#$F5#$+.$?)#N@T!Wash. TimesT!607!DDT!,NNMT!0$!@D!U'*4)(44*#A!B.0#!>.##K4!90S4(*$!0A0*#4$!;%&'().%!B$.;3.#!E*#AT!0#'!E*#AK4!0%A(/.#$4!$30$!i>.##! )%&44.4! &8.%! 0! J%*A3$! 9*#.! *#$&! (#;%&$.)$.'! 4;..)3! S3.#! 3.! ;(J9*)97! 0'8&)0$.'! $3.! 8*&9.#$!&8.%$3%&S!&1!$3.!X+B+!A&8.%#/.#$k!0#'!$30$!i6%+!>.##!$%043.'!p0#7!4$0#'0%'!&1!'.).#)7K!J7!;&4*#A!1&%!;3&$&A%0;34!(#'.%!0!;&%$%0*$!&1!"%0f*!'*)$0$&%!B0''0/!:(44.*#!0#'!/..$*#A!S*$3!%.A*/.!&11*)*094!'(%*#A!3*4! 8*4*$! $&! E0A3'0'kVa! R.&#&%0! R0>.$.%T!1(2")+3$ 1277@$ .//$ >B#*+$ N)+($ %2"2*L.*T! St. Petersburg TimesT!60%+!,HT!,NNMT!0$!DE!Ui23.!X#*$.'!507!&1!20/;0!E07!)0#).9.'!0#!(;)&/*#A!.8.#$!1.0$(%*#A!B(40#! B0%0#'&#! 01$.%! A.$$*#A! $3%..! '&^.#! )&/;90*#$4! 1%&/! '&#&%4! 0#'! &$3.%4! 0J&($! $3.! 0)$&%K4!&;;&4*$*&#! $&! $3.! X+B+`9.'! S0%! *#! "%0f+!+!+!23.! &%A0#*^0$*&#! '.)*'.'! $3.! .8.#$! 30'! $3.! ;&$.#$*09! $&!J.)&/.!p'*8*4*8.K!+!+!+!+!p23.!1&)(4!&1!&(%!S3&9.!/..$*#A!30'!43*1$.'!$&!S3.$3.%!&%!#&$!S.!S.%.!)%.0$*#A!0! ;&9*$*)09! ;90$1&%/! 1&%! B(40#! B0%0#'&#TK! b0! X#*$.'! 507! 4;&C.4S&/0#j! 40*'!+!+!+!+kVa! 60$$3.S!?&$34)3*9'T! >*/."'#L$ 1.*/."D)+3T! ProgressiveT! \(97! DT! ,NNMT! 0$! Dc! UA*8*#A! $3.! _9&8.%T! B0%0#'&#T!?&JJ*#4T! 0#'!>.##! *#)*'.#$4! 04! .P0/;9.4!&1! i$3.!A&&#! 4f(0'! 4$79.Tk! 0#'!0;;0%.#$97! 0#09&A*^*#A! $3*4!4$79.! $&! i#.&`6)-0%$37*4/kV+! 1/K! I0#! :&S9.7T! J2@#C277$ %(")*#$ 6#77@$ ,'+."@M$ G.5W"#$ :5+[T! Times Union! U@9J0#7VT! @;%+! DDT! ,NNMT! 0$! @D! Ui23.! e0$*	! E04.J099! :099! &1! L0/.! 0#'! 6(4.(/! 304!)0#).9.'!0!D=$3`0##*8.%40%7!).9.J%0$*&#!&1! $3.!)9044*)!J04.J099!/&8*.!pE(99!I(%30/K!J.)0(4.!&1!0#$*`S0%! 8*.S4! 8&*).'! J7! /&8*.! )&`4$0%4! 2*/! ?&JJ*#4! 0#'! B(40#! B0%0#'&#+!+!+!+!:099! ;%.4*'.#$! I09.!>.$%&4C.7! 0'/&#*43.'! b?&JJ*#4j! 1&%! (#'.%/*#*#A! X+B+! /*9*$0%7! 0)$*&#! *#! "%0f!+!+!+!+kV+! 23.! :099!;%.4*'.#$K4!'.)*4*&#!/07!J.!)%*$*)*^.'!&#!$3.!A%&(#'4!$30$!3.!S04#K$!J.*#A!0!10*$31(9!4.%80#$!&1!$3.!:099T!A*8.#!$30$!3.!4../*#A97!(4.'!3*4!;&4*$*&#!$&!1(%$3.%!3*4!&S#!;&9*$*)09!8*.S4T!%0$3.%!$30#!$&!;%&/&$.!$3.!:099K4!*#$.%.4$4+!230$T!$3&(A3T!*4!0!4.;0%0$.!f(.4$*&#!1%&/!S3.$3.%!$3.!'.)*4*&#!S04!(#10*%!$&!B0%0#'&#!0#'!?&JJ*#4T!&%!30%/1(9!$&!;(J9*)!'.J0$.+!! Ml+! %##M$#K-KT!Cal. Labor Code!t!DDND!U5.4$!,NNMVa!Wash. Rev. Code t!F,+DH+olNU,V!U,NNFV+!! Mc+! %##!e.94&#!8+!6)-90$)37!e.S4;0;.%4T!"#)+T!cMo!>+,'!DD,M!U5043+!DccHV+!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! DM$
! DM!
094&!J.)0(4.!$3.7!9*C.!$3.!4$0%4!&%!0$!9.04$!9*C.!$3.!*/0A.!$30$!$3.!4$0%4!;%&`g.)$a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g.)$4!$3.7!4(;;&%$T!&%!044&)*0$*&#!S*$3!)0(4.4!$3.7!'*49*C.+!2&9.%0#).!'./0#'4!$30$!;.&;9.!#.*`$3.%! J.0$! 7&(! (;! 1&%! 7&(%! 8*.S4! #&%! $3%&S! 7&(! *#! g0*9! 1&%! $3./+! E($! *$!'&.4#K$! './0#'! $30$! ;.&;9.! )&#$*#(.! $&! 9*C.! 7&(h0#'! *1! $3.7! '&#K$! 9*C.!7&(T!$3.#!7&(!S&#K$!J.!04!.11.)$*8.!0!;%&/&$.%+!! e0$(%0997! $3*4!/07! 9.0'!.#$.%$0*#.%4! $&! $3*#C! $S*).!J.1&%.!.P;%.44*#A!)&#$%&8.%4*09! 8*.S4+! 23.! J&7)&$$! 0A0*#4$! L9&%*'0! &%0#A.! g(*).! J.)0(4.! &1!4;&C.4S&/0#!@#*$0!E%70#$K4!0#$*`A07!4$0#'!4(%.97!$0(A3$!/0#7!.#$.%$0*#`.%4! $30$+F,!E($! *1! 7&(%! 9*8.9*3&&'! $(%#4!&#!;.&;9.K4! 011.)$*&#! 1&%!7&(T!7&(!)0#K$! ;%&$.)$! $30$! 011.)$*&#!S3*9.! 407*#A! $3*#A4! $30$! $(%#! ;.&;9.! &11+!@#'!$&9.%0#).!'&.4#K$!%.f(*%.!$30$!;.&;9.!J(7!;%&'()$4!;%&/&$.'!J7!).9.J%*$*.4!S3&/!$3.7K8.!)&/.!$&!'*4$%(4$T!3.0%!4&#A4!J7!4*#A.%4!S3&/!$3.7!#&!9&#A.%!.#g&7T! &%! 9*4$.#! $&! 4;..)3.4! J7! .#$.%$0*#.%4! S3&! $3.7K8.! )&#)9('.'! 0%.!1&&94+!! @#'!g(4$!04!.#$.%$0*#.%4!'.%*8.!/()3!&1!$3.*%!*#)&/.!1%&/!$3.!;(J9*)K4!011.)$*&#!1&%!$3./T!$3.7!094&!'.%*8.!/()3!&1!$3.*%!;&9*$*)09!)9&($!1%&/!4()3!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FN+! 1/K$I08.!_&9'*#.%T!J2LS62@+#$F)-@$2+$=$F5")*-$F#D$H272$1.@+$J)-$!2+$H)-T!e+n+!Daily NewsT!\(97!D=T!,NNFT!0$!=!Ui53&&;*!_&9'J.%A!S04!+!+!+!)0##.'!b7.4$.%'07j!J7!$3.!/0C.%4!&1!B9*/L04$!&8.%!3.%!x`%0$.'!J0%J4!0J&($!$3.!>%.4*'.#$+!_&9'J.%A!4$&C.'!&($%0A.!904$!S..C!S*$3!0#!.P$.#'.'!1*9$37!%0#$! b*#8&98*#A! g&C.4! J04.'! &#! $3.! 4.P(09! )&##&$0$*! &1! >%.4*'.#$! E(43K4! 904$! #0/.! 0#'! Z*).!>%.4*'.#$!-3.#.7K4!1*%4$!#0/.jT!S3*)3!'.9*A3$.'!$3.!;0%$*40#!)%&S'!$30$!;0)C.'!0!+!+!+!I./&)%0$*)!1(#'`%0*4.%!+!+!+!+kVa! I.J&%03! G%*#T! H:A#"@$ =2*+$ =(..&)W@$ V!2@+W$ >X)+T! e+n+! PostT! \(97! DMT! ,NNFT! 0$! o!UiB&/.! ?.;(J9*)0#! 0)$*8*4$4! 0%.! 90(#)3*#A! 0! J&7)&$$! &1! B9*/L04$! '*.$! ;%&'()$4! $&! ;%&$.4$! B9*/L04$!4;&C.4S&/0#!53&&;*!_&9'J.%AK4!x`%0$.'!%0#$!0A0*#4$!>%.4*'.#$!E(43!0$!0!e.S!n&%C!1(#'`%0*4.%!1&%!I./&)%0$!\&3#
DF! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!DF!
011.)$*&#! 0#'! 1%&/! $3.*%! 4()).44.4! *#! 1*.9'4! f(*$.! (#%.90$.'! $&! ;&9*$*)4+!I0##7!_9&8.%K4!4*A#0$(%.!&#!$3.!0#$*`"%0f`S0%!9.$$.%!S04!809(0J9.!J.)0(4.!3.! S04! 0! /&8*.! 4$0%T! #&$! J.)0(4.! 3.! S04! 9.0%#.'! &#! *#$.%#0$*	! 90S+!!e0$09*.!60*#.4! 30'! 0! 90%A.! 0('*.#).! 1&%! 3.%! .P;%.44*&#! &1! )&#$./;$! 1&%!>%.4*'.#$!E(43!J.)0(4.! 43.!S04! *#8*$.'! $&! 4*#AT! #&$! J.)0(4.! 43.!S04! *#`8*$.'!$&!'.9*8.%!0!;&9*$*)09!9.)$(%.+!! -(/.%4! C#&S! $30$! J7! 4(;;&%$*#A! e0$09*.! 60*#.4T! $3.7! 0%.! *#'*`%.)$97!3.9;*#A!4(;;&%$!60*#.4K!;&9*$*)09!/.440A.T! g(4$!04!)(/.%4!C#&S!$30$!J7!4(;;&%$*#A!0!J(4*#.44T! $3.7!0%.!*#'*%.)$97!3.9;*#A!4(;;&%$! $3.!;%&`g.)$4!$30$!$3.!J(4*#.44!&%!*$4!&S#.%!1(#'4+!"$!4../4!f(*$.!9.A*$*/0$.!1&%!)&#`4(/.%4!$&!S*$3'%0S!$3.*%!4(;;&%$!&1!.#$.%$0*#.%4!0#'!$&!(4.!$3.*%!.)&#&/*)!;&S.%!$&!;%.44(%.!&$3.%4!$&!S*$3'%0S!$3.*%!4(;;&%$+!_%&(;4!308.!&%A0#*^.'!)(/.%! J&7)&$$4! &1! J(4*#.44.4! $30$! )&#$%*J($.! $&! G;.%0$*&#! ?.4)(.T! $&!;%&`9*1.!)0#'*'0$.4!0#'!J099&$!/.04(%.4T!0#'!$&!>90##.'!>0%.#$3&&'aFM!&$3`.%4!308.!;%.44(%.'!J(4*#.44.4! $&!4$&;!0'8.%$*4*#A!&#!).%80$*8.!B*#)90*%!E%&0')04$*#A+FF! -(/.%! %.$09*0$*&#! 0A0*#4$! .#$.%$0*#.%4! 4../4! .f(0997!9.A*$*/0$.!S3.#!0!).9.J%*$7!4(;;&%$4!0!)0(4.!J7!(4*#A!3.%!10/.T!%0$3.%!$30#!0!J(4*#.44!4(;;&%$*#A!0!)0(4.!J7!(4*#A!*$4!/&#.7+!
JK$ 1.DD#*+2+."@$
! B*P!'074!01$.%! $3.!B.;$./J.%!DD!0$$0)C4T!E*99!603.%T!3&4$!&1! $3.!2Z!43&S!A.7)+)'2773$ 9*'.""#'+T!S04!'*4)(44*#A! $3.!&1$`%.;.0$.'! )90*/! $30$! $3.!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FM+! %##! ?.#..! _%030/T! 6(#$ 9@@5#$ /."$ <:=, Boston GlobeT! 607! oT! DclcT! 0$! DH! Ui@4! $3.!0J&%$*&#! 0%A(/.#$! *#$.#4*1*.4T! eG5! &11*)*094! 308.! 0''.'! 0! #.S! $0)$*)! $&! $3.! ;%&)3&*).! 1*A3$hJ&7)&$$*#A!J(4*#.44.4!$30$!4(;;&%$!$3.!0#$*0J&%$*&#!/&8./.#$+!I&/*#&K4!>*^^0!+!+!+!0#'!$3.!20%0!3&$.94!+!+!+!308.!J..#!)*$.'!J7!eG5!04!$3.!1*%4$!$S&!J(4*#.44.4!$0%A.$.'!1&%!J&7)&$$4+!p>.&;9.!308.!0!%*A3$!$&!C#&S!S3.%.! $3.*%! /&#.7! *4! A&*#ATK! b$3.! ;%.4*'.#$! &1! $3.! E&4$&#! eG5! )30;$.%j! 40*'+kVa! -30%9.4! Z+!].3%.#T!125-(+$ )*$ ,C."+).*$ 1".@@/)"#U$ J.+($ %)L#@$ A"#@@5"#$ !)"D@T!NewsdayT! @(A+! DMT! DclcT! 0$! o!U#&$*#A! $30$!20%0!:&$.94!S04!0;;0%.#$97!J&7)&$$.'!J.)0(4.! *$4!-<G!i)&#$%*J($b.'j! $&!J0)C.%4!&1!4$0$.!0#$*`0J&%$*&#!%.1.%.#'(/4!0#'!0#$*`0J&%$*&#!9.A*490$*8.!)0#'*'0$.4Tk!0#'!$30$!;%&`9*1.!A%&(;4!308.!094&!J&7)&$$.'!)&/;0#*.4!$30$!308.!)&#$%*J($.'!$&!>90##.'!>0%.#$3&&'V+$! FF+! "$K4! #&$! )9.0%! S3.$3.%! $3.! ;%.44(%.! 4())..'.'+! 1.D&2"#$ L%0#C! @3%.#4T! %+2&7#@$ A577@$,LB#"+)@)*-$ !".D$ %)*'72)"T!Wash. PostT! \0#+! =T! ,NN=T! 0$! <D& UiG11*).`4(;;97! %.$0*9.%! B$0;9.4! "#)+! *4!;(99*#A! *$4! 0'8.%$*4*#A! 1%&/!#.S4! ;%&A%0//*#A! &#!B*#)90*%!E%&0')04$!_%&(;! "#)+! $.9.8*4*&#! 4$0$*T!407*#A!$3.!'.)*4*&#!S04!1(.9.'!*#!;0%$!J7!.`/0*94!1%&/!)(4$&/.%4!0#A%7!0$!S30$!$3.7!)*'.%!$&!J.!$3.!J%&0')04$.%K4!%*A3$`S*#A!J*04!*#!#.S4!0#'!)&//.#$0%7+!+!+!+!B*#).!I.)./J.%T!B*#)90*%!304!J..#!$0%A.$.'!J7!6.'*0!60$$.%4! 1&%!@/.%*)0T! 0! 9*J.%09!/.'*0! A%&(;T!S3*)3! )90*/.'! $3.! )&/;0#7!S04! 0J(4*#A! $3.!;(J9*)! 0*%S08.4! $&! ;%&/&$.! 0! ).%80$*8.! 0A.#'0! 0#'! #&$! &11.%*#A! ;&9*$*)0997! J090#).'! #.S4bT! 0#'!S3*)3! .#)&(%0A.'! )(/.%4! $&! )&/;90*#! $&! B*#)90*%K4! 0'8.%$*4.%4j+kVT! N)+(! _%.A! _0$9*#T! %+2&7#@$17)&&#L$C3$A.7)+)'27$!)-(+T!Boston HeraldT!\0#+!lT!,NN=T!0$!Dc!UiB$0;9.4!*#*$*0997!40*'h*#!#(/.%&(4!*#$.%8*.S4! 0#'! *#! 0! #.S4! %.9.04.! *44(.'!J7!6.'*0!60$$.%4h$30$! *$4! '.)*4*&#! $&! 4$&;! 0'8.%$*4*#A!S04!J04.'!*#!;0%$!&#!)&/;90*#$4!1%&/!B$0;9.4!)(4$&/.%4!&8.%!$3.!#.S4)04$4K!).%80$*8.!J.#$+!E($!B$0;9.4!90$.%!J0)C;.'09.'T!407*#A!*$!S04!p/*4%.;%.4.#$.'K!J7!6.'*0!60$$.%4+kV+!E($!*#!0#7!.8.#$T!6.'*0!60$$.%4!'*'! $%7! $&! .P.%$! ;%.44(%.+! %##$ -#*#"2773! 60%8*#! @//&%*T! %(2L.N$ H.B#"*D#*+4$A")B2+#$ ;#-572+).*M$!"##$ %&##'(M$ 2*L$ 8#@@.*@$ /".D$ +(#$ %)*'72)"$ J7.-@+."D DM`D=! US&%C*#A! ;0;.%V! UI.)+! ,lT! ,NNFVT! 2+!3$$;Oqq44%#+)&/q0J4$%0)$woFNcF,!U'*4)(44*#A!$3.!J&7)&$$!0#'!J%&0'.%!0$$./;$4!$&!;%.44(%.!B*#)90*%!*#$&!)30#A*#A!*$4!;%&A%0//*#A!'.)*4*V+!!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! D=$
! D=!
$.%%&%*4$4! S.%.! )&S0%'4+! e&$! 4&T! 603.%! 40*'T! 0A%..*#A! S*$3! &#.! &1! 3*4!A(.4$4T!).%80$*8.!)&//.#$0$&%!I*#.43!IKB&(^0+!603.%!S.#$!&#O!
E($! 094&T! S.! 43&(9'hS.! 308.! J..#! $3.! )&S0%'4! 9&JJ*#A! )%(*4.!/*44*9.4! 1%&/! ,TNNN!/*9.4! 0S07+! 230$K4! )&S0%'97+! B$07*#A! *#! $3.!0*%;90#.!S3.#!*$!3*$4!$3.!J(*9'*#AT!407!S30$!7&(!S0#$!0J&($!*$T!*$K4!#&$!)&S0%'97+!n&(K%.!%*A3$+F=!
23*4!S&#!603.%!#&!1%*.#'4+!B.8.%09!4$0$*!;(99.'!3*4!43&S!J%*.197+Fo!e*#.!/&#$34!90$.%T! $3.!43&S!S04!)0#).9.'T!;&44*J97!;0%$97!J.)0(4.!&1!$3*4! *#)*`'.#$+FH!@#'! %.4;&#'*#A! $&! $3.!603.%! *#)*'.#$T! $3.#`53*$.!:&(4.! 4;&C.4`/0#! @%*! L9.*4)3.%! 10/&(497! 40*'! $30$! i099! @/.%*)0#4!+!+!+!#..'! $&! S0$)3!S30$! $3.7! 407T! S0$)3! S30$! $3.7! '&+kFl! L9.*4)3.%! 09/&4$! ).%$0*#97! S04#K$!$3%.0$.#*#A! 9.A09! %.$09*0$*&#! 0A0*#4$! 603.%hJ($! "! 4(4;.)$! $30$! 3.! S.9`)&/.'! $3.! &($)%7! 0A0*#4$!603.%K4! %./0%C4! 0#'! $3.! #&#A&8.%#/.#$09! %.`$09*0$*&#!$30$!603.%!10).'+!! n.$! &1! )&(%4.! )&//.#$0$&%4! 308.! 9&#A! C#&S#! $30$! $3.7! i#..'! $&!S0$)3!S30$! $3.7!407k!&#!$.9.8*4*&#!&%! *#!;%*#$+!23.*%!./;9&7.%4T!01$.%!099T!0%.!S0$)3*#A!S30$! $3.! )&//.#$0$&%4! 407+! 23.! ./;9&7.%4! %*A3$97!S0#$! $&!08&*'!(4*#A!$3.*%!#.$S&%C4!0#'!$3.*%!#.S4;0;.%4! $&!4;%.0'!*'.04! $30$! $3.7!4$%&#A97!'*40;;%&8.!&1+!! 23.! ./;9&7.%4!/07!J.!f(*$.!S*99*#A! $&! )0%%7! 4&/.!8*.S4! $30$! '*11.%!1%&/!$3.*%!&S#a!.8.#!#.S4;0;.%4!S*$3!)9.0%!.'*$&%*09!;&9*)*.4!/07!S0#$!$&!308.!0!/*P!&1!8*.S4!&#!$3.*%!&;`.'!;0A.+!E($!4&/.!8*.S4!'&.4#K$!.f(09!099!8*.S4+!L.S!/.'*0!&($9.$4!S0#$! $&!)0%%7h0#'!;90).! $3.*%!&S#!*/;%*/0$(%!&#h099! ;&44*J9.! 8*.S4T! #&! /0$$.%! 3&S! %('.T! '.4;*)0J9.T! &%! 1&&9*43! $3.!8*.S4!/07!J.+!@#'!&1!)&(%4.!$3.!;(J9*)!094&!S0$)3.4!S30$!)&//.#$0$&%4!407T!0#'!$3.!./;9&7.%4!S0$)3!S30$!$3.!;(J9*)!$3*#C4+&! -.%$0*#97! $3.!.P;.%*.#).!&1!\*//7!i$3.!_%..Ck!B#7'.%T!0!-EB!)&/`/.#$0$&%!1*%.'!1&%!/0C*#A!%0)*0997!&11.#4*8.!4$0$./.#$4!*#!0!2Z!*#$.%8*.ST!/0'.! $3*4! )9.0%+Fc! UB#7'.%K4! )&//.#$4! S.%.#K$! .P;9*)*$97! 0#$*`J90)Ch3.!)&#'./#.'!S3*$.!0$39.$.4T!#&$!J90)C!&#.4hJ($!$3.7!S.%.!4..#!04!&11.#4*8.!)3*.197!J.)0(4.!$3.7!044.%$.'!$30$!J90)C4K!0$39.$*)!0J*9*$7!19&S4!90%A.97!1%&/!4908.%7`.%0! J%..'*#A! ;%0)$*).4+V! 23&4.! S3&! #..'.'! /&%.! .8*'.#).! $30$!)&//.#$0$&%4!i#..'!$&!S0$)3!S30$!$3.7!407k!A&$!*$!S3.#!-EB!e.S4!4(4`;.#'.'!@#'7!?&&#.7!1&%!099.A.'97!%./0%C*#A!*#!0!/0A0^*#.!*#$.%8*.S!$30$!i/&4$! ;.&;9.! 0%.! J&%#! S*$3! .f(09! *#$.99*A.#).T! J($! J90)C4! 308.! S0$.%.'!'&S#!$3.*%!A.#.4!J.)0(4.!$3.!9.44!*#$.99*A.#$!&#.4!0%.!$3.!&#.4!$30$!308.!$3.!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! F=+! A.7)+)'2773$9*'.""#'+!U@E-!$.9.8*4*&#!J%&0')04$T!B.;$+!DHT!,NNDV+!&! Fo+! %##!>0(9!L0%3*T!=Z8,W@$1.""#'+).*4$A577$02(#"T!Wash. PostT!B.;$+!,,T!,NNDT!0$!-Ha!R*40!'.!6&%0.4T!=Z8,$A577@$VA9W$2$%#'.*L$6)D#T!Wash. PostT!B.;$+!,lT!,NNDT!0$!-H+!! FH+! %##$>0(9!E%&S#1*.9'T!VA.7)+)'2773$9*'.""#'+W$12*'#7#LT!L.A. TimesT!607!D=T!,NN,T!0$!LM+!! Fl+! >%.44! E%*.1*#A! J7! @%*! L9.*4)3.%! UB.;$+! ,oT! ,NNDVT! 2B2)72C7#$ 2+$
3$$;OqqSSS+S3*$.3&(4.+A&8q#.S4q%.9.04.4q,NNDqNcq,NNDNc,o`=+3$/9+!!! Fc+! %##! I08.!@#'.%4&#T!%&."+@$ ./$ +(#$ 6)D#@4$VH"##PW$ 8.@#@$ 2*$:5+$ J#+T!N.Y. TimesT! \0#+! DHT!DcllT!t!=T!0$!D+$
Do! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!Do!
/&4$!)3*9'%.#+!23.7!'%&;!&($!&1!4)3&&9!.0%97T!'&!'%(A4!0#'!A.$!;%.A#0#$+k=N!-EB!%*A3$97!'*'#K$!S0#$!$&!J.!4..#!04!0;;%&8*#A!4()3!8*.S4T!0#'!$3(4!$3.!#.$S&%C!$&&C!4$.;4!$&!'*44&)*0$.!*$4.91!1%&/!$3&4.!S3&!;%&/&$.'!$3./+!! @%*!L9.*4)3.%K4!%./0%C4T!*#!10)$T!)%*$*)*^.'!.$3#*)!;%.g('*).!04!S.99!04!;.%).*8.'! )&#$./;$! 1&%! &(%! 4&9'*.%4+! G#! B.;$./J.%! DHT! ,NNDT!!?.;%.4.#$0$*8.!\&3#!-&&C4.7!40*'! *#!0!%0'*&! *#$.%8*.ST!i"1!"!4..!4&/.&#.!$30$! )&/.4! b*#$&! 0#! 0*%;&%$j! $30$! 304! 0! '*0;.%! &#! 3*4! 3.0'! 0#'! 0! 10#! J.9$!S%0;;.'!0%&(#'! $3.!'*0;.%!&#!3*4!3.0'T! $30$!A(7!#..'4! $&!J.!;(99.'!&8.%!0#'!)3.)C.'+k=D!@$!0!J%*.1*#A!0!S..C!90$.%T!0!g&(%#09*4$!f(.4$*&#.'!L9.*4)3.%!0J&($!-&&C4.7K4!4$0$./.#$T!04C*#A!S3.$3.%!$3.!;%.4*'.#$!30'!0!/.440A.!1&%!i/./J.%4!&1!3*4!;0%$7!+!+!+!0J&($!$3*4!*44(.k!&1!0#$*`@%0J!4;..)3+=,!L9.*4)3.%!40*'! $30$! $3.! ;%.4*'.#$!S04! '*4$(%J.'! J7! -&&C4.7K4! %./0%C4a! 0#'! $3.#T! 0!1.S!f(.4$*!90$.%T!L9.*4)3.%!0A0*#!)&#'./#.'!-&&C4.7T!0$!$3.!40/.!$*/.!04!3.!)&#'./#.'!603.%O&
bvX<B2"GeOj!@4!-&//0#'.%`*#`-3*.1T!S30$!S04! $3.!>%.4*'.#$K4!%.0)$*&#! $&! $.9.8*4*&#K4! E*99! 603.%T! *#! 3*4! 0##&(#)./.#$! $30$!!/./J.%4!&1!&(%!0%/.'!1&%).4!S3&!'.09!S*$3!/*44*9.4!0%.!)&S0%'4T!S3*9.! $3.! 0%/.'! $.%%&%*4$4! S3&! C*99.'! oTNNN! (#0%/.'! 0%.! #&$!!)&S0%'4T! 1&%! S3*)3! 603.%! S04! J%*.197! /&8.'! &11! 0!5043*#A$&#!$.9.8*4*&#!4$0$*&#d!!+!+!+!+!6?+! LR<"B-:<?O!"K/! 0S0%.! &1! $3.! ;%.44! %.;&%$4! 0J&($!S30$! 3.!40*'+! "! 308.! #&$! 4..#! $3.! 0)$(09! $%0#4)%*;$! &1! $3.! 43&S! *$4.91+! E($!!044(/*#A!$3.!;%.44!%.;&%$4!0%.!%*A3$T!*$K4!0!$.%%*J9.!$3*#A!$&!407T!0#'!b*$K4j! (#1&%$(#0$.+! @#'! $30$K4!S37h$3.%.!S04! 0#! .0%9*.%! f(.4$*&#!0J&($!304!$3.!>%.4*'.#$!40*'!0#7$3*#A!$&!;.&;9.!*#!3*4!&S#!;0%$7h$3.7K%.! %./*#'.%4! $&! 099!@/.%*)0#4! $30$! $3.7! #..'! $&!S0$)3!S30$!$3.7!407T!S0$)3!S30$! $3.7!'&+!23*4! *4!#&$!0! $*/.! 1&%! %./0%C4! 9*C.!$30$a!$3.%.!#.8.%!*4+=M!
! e&S!04! *$!30;;.#4T!L9.*4)3.%!/07!308.!.%%.'! *#! %.97*#A!&#!;%.44! %.`;&%$4T!*1!$3&4.!%.;&%$4!$%0)C.'!$3.!f(.4$*&#.%K4!)30%0)$.%*^0$*&#!&1!603.%K4!4$0$./.#$+!603.%!'*'#K$!)&#'./#!$3.!i/./J.%4!&1!&(%!0%/.'!1&%).4!S3&!'.09!S*$3!/*44*9.4k!04!)&S0%'4+!:.!40*'!$30$!N#$0%.!)&S0%'4T!0#'T!*#!)&#`$.P$T!*$!4../4!9*C.9*.%!$30$!3.!S04!)&#'./#*#A!&(%!$3.#`.P*4$*#A!;%0)$*).h*+.+T!$3.!)&(#$%7K4!;%0)$*).h&1!1*A3$*#A!$.%%&%*4$4!(4*#A!/*44*9.4!%0$3.%!$30#!A%&(#'!$%&&;4+=F!603.%T!"!$3*#CT!A&$!0!J(/!%0;!1&%!S30$!3.!40*'a!*#!$3.!$.#4.!0#'!./&$*	!$*/.!1&99&S*#A!$3.!0$$0)C4T!3*4!%./0%C4!S.%.!/*4*#$.%;%.$.'+!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =N+! 1J%$H)B#@$;..*#3$2$\S0.*+($%5@&#*@).*$/."$;#D2"P@T!N.Y. TimesT!L.J+!cT!DccNT!0$!-MN+!!! =D+! @30#
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! DH$
! DH!
! E($!&$3.%!;.&;9.!'*'!#&$!A.$!0!J(/!%0;+!<#N$G."P$6)D#@$.'*$&%*09!)0%`$&&#*4$!2.'!?099!S04!%*A3$97!)&#'./#.'!1&%!0!)0%$&&#!$30$!)%(.997!/&)C.'!$3.!S*'&S4!&1!$3&4.!C*99.'!&#!B.;$./J.%!DD!0#'!$3.!S*'&S!&1!I0#*.9!>.0%9T!$3.! /(%'.%.'!=277$ %+"##+$ Z.5"*27! %.;&%$.%+! 23.! 6)D#@$ 0#'! &$3.%! ;0;.%4!;(99.'! $30$! ;0%$*)(90%! )0%$&&#T! 0#'! ;%&;.%97! 4&+==! "1! "! S.%.! 0#! .'*$&%T! "!S&(9'#K$!%(#!?099K4!)0%$&!0$!099T!A*8.#!$3.!#04$*#.44!3.!304!;%&8.'!3*/`4.91! )0;0J9.! &1+! 23*4! .'*$&%*09! '.)*4*&#! *4! #&! /&%.! %./*#*4).#$! &1! $3.!i:&(4.!X#`@/.%*)0#!@)$*8*$*.4!-&//*$$..k=o!$30#!*4!$3.!1*%*#A!&1!B#7'.%+!e.S4;0;.%4!0#'!2Z!#.$S&%C4!0%.!.#$*$9.'!#&$!$&!)0%%7!8*.S4!0#'!4;.0C.%4!$30$!$3.7!1*#'!)&#$./;$*J9.+=H!! @! 7.0%! 90$.%T! 6BeE-! $09C`43&S! 3&4$! 6*)30.9! B080A.! A&$! S30$! 3.!'.4.%8.'T!$&&+!?.4;&#'*#A!$&!0#!*#4(9$!1%&/!0!)099.%T!3.!04C.'!S3.$3.%!$3.!)099.%!S04!i&#.!&1!$3&4.!4&'&/*4$4ka!S3.#!$3.!/0#!40*'!7.4T!B080A.!40*'T!in&(! 43&(9'! a! A.$! @"IB! 0#'! '*.T! 7&(! ;*A+k!6BeE-! ;%&/;$97! 1*%.'!3*/T! 0#'! %*A3$97! 4&+=l! I&! 4()3! 1*%*#A4! /0C.! )&//.#$0$&%4! iS0$)3! S30$!$3.7! 407kd!n&(! J.$+! n.$! /.'*0! &($9.$4! 4()3! 04!6BeE-! 0%.! #&#.$3.9.44!.#$*$9.'!$&!%.1(4.!$&!)0%%7!4;..)3!$30$!$3.7!1*#'!%.;(A#0#$+!!
1K$ :+(#"$=."P#"@$
! 23.! $&(A3.%! f(.4$*! 0%*4.! S3.#! S.! A&! J.7&#'! .#$.%$0*#.%4! 0#'!)&//.#$0$&%4! 0#'! )*'.%! $3.! %./0*#*#A! c=y! &%! /&%.! &1! $3.! S&%C*#A!;(J9*)+! 23.4.! ;.&;9.! '&#K$! 4.99! $3.*%! ;(J9*)! 0;;.09! &%! $3.*%! 8*.S;&*#$4+!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!308.!"!.8.%!$3&(A3$T!$30$!$3.!/.#!0#'!S&/.#!S3&!'.1.#'!&(%!#0$*&#!*#!(#*1&%/!0%.!0#7$3*#A!J($!)&(%0A.&(4!0#'!809*0#$!+!+!+!+!67!)%*$*)*4/!S04!/.0#$!1&%!;&9*$*)*0#4!S3&T!1.0%*#A!;(J9*)!%.0)$*&#T!308.!#&$!099&S.'!&(%!/*9*$0%7! $&!'&! $3.! g&J! $3.7!0%.!&J8*&(497! %.0'7T!S*99*#A!0#'!0J9.!$&!'&+!
I.!6&%0.4T! @5&"2! #&$.! Fo+!67! 4.#4.! 1%&/! %.0'*#A! 0! $%0#4)%*;$! &1! $3.! ;%&A%0/! *4! $30$!603.%K4! 90$.%!)30%0)$.%*^0$*&#!&1!3*4!&%*A*#09!;(%;&4.!S04!*#'..'!)0#'*'O!603.%K4!S&%'4!S.%.!f(*$.!)*4$.#$!S*$3!3*4!90$.%!.P;90#0$*&#T!0#'!*#!)&#$.P$!/&%.!)*4$.#$!S*$3!$3.!J90/*#A`$3.`X+B+`;&9*)7!$3.&%7!$30#!S*$3!$3.!J90/*#A`$3.`4&9'*.%4!$3.&%7+!! ==+! %##$I08.! _&9'*#.%T!=61$ 12"+..*$ ;)&&#L4$0.'P@$ ?)'+)D@W$ !2D)7)#@$ 2@$ %(277.NM$ H"##L3T!N.Y. Daily NewsT!60%+!oT!,NN,T!0$!,a!E*99!B0#'.%4&#T!6)D#@W$]^__$12"+..*$%&#N@$,77$+(#$?)#N@$!)+$6.$://#*LT!N.Y. PostT!60%+!oT!,NN,T!0$!M+!!! =o+! <%*)!@9$.%/0#T!%577)B2*W@$6"2B2)7@T!NationT!@;%+!lT!,NN,T!0$!DN!Uib@#'%.Sj!B(99*80#!304!4.$!3*/4.91! (;! 04! 0! &#.`/0#!:&(4.! X#`@/.%*)0#! @)$*8*$*.4! -&//*$$..+! 20C.T! 1&%! *#4$0#).T! 2.'! ?099K4!#04$7T! &11.#4*8.! )0%$&&#! %*'*)(9*#A! 60%*0##.! >.0%9! 0#'! cqDD! S*'&S4! 04! /&#.7`A%(JJ*#A! 0$$.#$*&#!A%0JJ.%4+!+!+!+!b2j3.! )&//*440%K4! '.)%..O!pe&! ;0;.%! 43&(9'! .8.%! %(#! ?099! 0A0*#+K!+!+!+!b2j3.! S*99! $&!).#4&%43*;!$30$!(#'.%9*.4!B(99*80#K4!%0#$4!*4!'0#A.%&(4+kV+!B(99*80#!S04!0!g&(%#09*4$!0#'!;(J9*43.%!&1!0!;&;(90%!S.J9&A+!&! =H+! G#.! )&(9'! $%7! $&! '*4$*#A(*43! 0! #.$S&%CK4! &%! 0! #.S4;0;.%K4! '.)*4*&#! #&$! $&! %(#! 0! ).%$0*#!4$0$./.#$h$3.! .P)9(4*&#! &1! 0! )&/*)! 4$%*;! &%! 0! )&9(/#h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l+! \*/!?($.#J.%AT!6?$A".-"2D$12*'#7#L$:B#"$;#D2"P@$.*$H23@T!N.Y. TimesT!\(97!lT!,NNMT!0$!-F+!
Dl! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!Dl!
23.7!'&!$3.*%! g&J4T!0#'!*$K4!0;;.09*#A!$&!407!$30$! *1! $3.7!'&!$3.!g&J4!S.99T!./;9&7.%4T! )&`S&%C.%4T! 0#'! )(4$&/.%4! 43&(9'! *A#&%.! $3.! ./;9&7..4K! &11`$3.`g&J!;&9*$*)09!8*.S4+!!! @#'!*#!10)$T!$3.%.!4../4!$&!J.!0!%&J(4$!4&)*09!#&%/!0A0*#4$!'*4)*;9*#`*#A! S&%C.%4! J04.'! &#! $3.*%! *'.&9&A7+! ?.1(4*#A! $&! 3*%.! ?.;(J9*)0#4T!!I./&)%0$4T!;%&`9*1.!8&$.%4T!&%!;%&`)3&*).!8&$.%4!*4!A.#.%0997!4..#!04!*#$&9`.%0#$T!0#'!*$!)0#!9.0'!$&!;(J9*)!)%*$*)*4/!$30$!$%0#490$.4!*#$&!./J0%%044/.#$!0#'! 9&4$! J(4*#.44+=c!23*4! *4#K$! $%(.! 1&%! ./;9&7..4!S3&4.! g&J4! *#8&98.! .P`;%.44*#A! $3.! ./;9&7..4K! 8*.S4! &%! $%0'*#A! &#! $3.! ./;9&7..4K! A&&'`S*99O!G;*#*&#! /0A0^*#.4! 0%.#K$! )&#'./#.'! 1&%! ;%.1.%%*#A! )&9(/#*4$4!S3&4.!8*.S4!$3.!.'*$&%4!.#'&%4.T!0#'!0'8.%$*4.%4!0%.!%0%.97!)&#'./#.'!1&%!08&*'*#A!4;&C.4;.&;9.!S3&4.!;&9*$*)4!308.!)0(4.'!)&#$%&8.%47+!E($!S3.#!&$3.%!C*#'4!&1!./;9&7..4!0%.!1*%.'!J.)0(4.!$3.7!308.!$3.!S%&#A!&11`$3.`g&J!8*.S4!&#!A07!%*A3$4T!.#8*%&#/.#$09*4/T!&%!80%*&(4!&$3.%!*44(.4T!$3.!;(J9*)!*4!/&%.!9*C.97!$&!'*40;;%&8.+!23*4!3.9;4!.P;90*#!S37!$3.%.!308.!J..#!1.S!1*%*#A4! &1! &%'*#0%7! S&%C.%4! 1&%! &11`$3.`g&J! 4;..)3! )%*$*)*^*#A! $3.! S0%T! &%!10(9$*#A!>%.4*'.#$!E(43!&%!B.#0$&%
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! Dc$
! Dc!
Dc=N4T!*$!'*'#K$!.P$.#'!$&!-&//(#*4/+!2&'07T!*$!;%&J0J97!S&(9'#K$!.P$.#'!$&!30%'`)&%.!%0)*4/T!&%!$&!;%0*4.!&1!)&#'()$!$30$K4!4..#!04!4.%*&(497!*99.A09!&%! *//&%09h%0;.T! /044! /(%'.%T! ;.'&;3*9*0T! 0#'! $3.! 9*C.O!"! 4(4;.)$! $30$!/0#7! ./;9&7.%4!S&(9'! 1*%.! ./;9&7..4! 1&%! 4()3! 4;..)3T! 0#'!/&%.!S&(9'!%.1(4.! $&!3*%.! $3./+!<8.#! $&'07T!./;9&7..4!S3&!;%0*4.!09!v0.'0!0#'!407!$30$! *$K4! A&&'! $30$! MTNNN!@/.%*)0#4! S.%.! C*99.'! &#! B.;$./J.%! DD!/*A3$!S.99!A.$!1*%.'T!04!S&(9'!./;9&7..4!S3&!;%0*4.!$3.
,N! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!,N!
S3&!0%.!&11.#'.'!J7!$3.!4;..)3+!"$!)0#!09*.#0$.!)(4$&/.%4!0#'!)&`S&%C.%4!S3&!4..! $3.!4;..)3!04!.8*'.#).! $30$! $3.!4;.0C.%!S*99!'&!J0'! $3*#A4hS*99!/*4$%.0$! $3./!&%!S*99!)&//*$!)%*/.4!0A0*#4$! $3./+&@#'! *$!)0#!J.!(4.'!04!.8*'.#).! *#!)&(%$T! *1! 0#!./;9&7.%! *4! 4(.'! 1&%! )%*/.4!&%! $&%$4! $30$! $3.!./`;9&7..!)&//*$4+!&! -*'.%! $3.! S*'.4;%.0'! *#$&9.%0#).! 1&%! %0)*4$! 4;..)3T! 0#'T! 4&/.`$*/.4T! 1&%! &$3.%! J*A&$.'! 4;..)3+!@$90#$0!E%08.4! ;*$)3.%! \&3#!?&)C.%T! 1&%!*#4$0#).T!S04! 4(4;.#'.'!0#'! 1*#.'! *#!,NNN!J7! $3.!J04.J099! )&//*44*&#.%!1&%!3*4!0#$*`1&%.*A#.%T!0#$*`A07T!0#'!;&44*J97!%0)*4$!)&//.#$4+oM!-*#)*##0$*!?.'4!&S#.%!60%A.!B)3&$$!S04!4(4;.#'.'!1&%!3.%!%0)*4$!%./0%C4+oF!\('*)*09!.$3*)4!%(9.4!J0%! g('A.4!1%&/!J.9&#A*#A!$&!i0#7!&%A0#*^0$*&#!$30$!;%0)$*).4!*#8*'*&(4!'*4)%*/*#0$*&#!&#!$3.!J04*4!&1!%0).T!4.PT!%.9*A*&#!&%!#0$*	!&%*`A*#Tko=! .8.#! S3.#! $3.! &%A0#*^0$*&#K4! '*4)%*/*#0$&%7! %(9.4! 0%.! 9.A09! 0#'!)$*$($*ϥ!;%&$.)$.'!J7!$3.!&%A0#*^0$*&#K4!%*A3$!&1!.P;%.44*8.!044&)*0`$*&#+oo!@#'!"!4(4;.)$!$30$!/0#7!./;9&7.%4!0%.!%.9()$0#$!$&!3*%.!/0#0A.%4!&%!.8.#! 9*#.! ./;9&7..4! S3&! 0%.! C#&S#! $&! J.! %0)*4$+oH! "#! $3.! S&%'4! &1! $3.!;%.4*'.#$!&1!0#!e@@->!)30;$.%!*#!_.&%A*0T!S3&!S04!)%*$*)*^*#A!0!4$('.#$K4!099.A.'97!%0)*4$!)&9(/#!*#!0!)&99.A.!#.S4;0;.%O!
@/.%*)0!*4!#&S!*#!0#!.%0!&1!9*$*A0$*&#T!0#'!)&%;&%0$*!S3*)3!3*%.!%0)*4$4!0#'!0'&;$!%0)*4$!;%0)$*).4!0%.!1*#'*#A!$30$!1.'.%09!)&(%$4!0%.!S*99*#A! $&! 490;! $3./! S*$3! /(9$*`/*99*&#! '&990%! g('A/.#$4!!90S4(*$4+!+!+!+!23.! e@@->! )&99.)$4! .8*'.#).! &1! %0)*0997!!'*4)%*/*#0$&%7!;%0)$*).4!S*$3*#!)&%;&%0$*!0#'!;(J9*)!*#4$*$($*+!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! oM+! 6(%%07!-3044T!J2@#C277$%5@&#*L@$;.'P#"!6)77$023$/."$1.DD#*+@T!N.Y. TimesT!L.J+!DT!,NNNT!0$!@D!U#&$*#A!$30$!?&)C.%K4!%./0%C4!/07!308.!09*.#0$.'!J&$3!10#4!0#'!1.99&S!;907.%4Va!@##$27@.!@90#!6+!I.%43&S*$^T! J2@#C277W@$ %&##'($ A.7)'#T! N.Y. TimesT! L.J+! ,T! ,NNNT! 0$! @,D! U)%*$*)*^*#A! $3.!)&//*44*&#.%K4! '.)*4*&#! 04! 0#! */;%&;.%! ;%*80$.! %.4$%0*#$! &#! 4;..)3V+! 23.! J04.J099! )&//*44*&#.%K4!%.90$*+*;!S*$3!;907.%4!0#'!&S#.%4!*4!#&$!$3.!4$0#'0%'!./;9&7.%`./;9&7..!%.90$*+*;T!J($!*$!*4!)9&4.!.#&(A3!1&%!&(%!;(%;&4.4+!! oF+! B)3&$$!S04!4(4;.#'.'!*#!DccM!1&%!/0C*#A!%0)*09!0#'!.$3#*)!49(%4+!"#!DccoT!43.!0A%..'!$&!A*8.!(;! )&#$%&9! &1! $3.!-*#)*##0$*! ?.'4! 1&%! $S&! 0#'! 0! 3091! 4.04! 01$.%!60g&%! R.0A(.! E04.J099! &11*)*094!$3%.0$.#.'!$&!4(4;.#'!3.%!0A0*#T!$3*4!$*/.!1&%!407*#A!$30$!:*$9.%!iS04!A&&'!0$!$3.!J.A*##*#Ak!J($!iS.#$!$&&! 10%+k! %##! 60%C!604C.T!:N*#"$ %'(.++$ %5""#*L#"@$ ;#L@W$ ;#)*@U$ %)L#7)*#L$ `$ _^`$ %#2@.*@$ F5#$ +.$V9*@#*@)+)B)+3WT!Wash. PostT!\(#.!DMT!DccoT!0$!@D+!! o=+! Model Code of Jud. Conduct!-0#&#!,T!t!-!UDcccV+!! oo+! %##!E&7!B)&($4!&1!@/+!8+!I09.T!=MN!X+B+!oFN!U,NNNV!U3&9'*#A!$30$!$3.!B)&($4!30'!0!%*A3$!$&!'*4)%*/*#0$.!J04.'!&#!4.P(09!&%*.#$0$*&#!*#!)3&&4*#A!$3.*%!/./J.%4V+!"!$3*#C!*$4!9&A*)!0;;9*.4!.f(0997!$&!'*4)%*/*#0$*&#!J04.'!&#!10)$&%4!&$3.%!$30#!4.P(09!&%*.#$0$*&#+!! oH+! L&%!*#4$0#).T!$3.%.!0%.!/0#7!)04.4!*#8&98*#A!1*%*#A!&1!;&9*).!&11*).%4h&%!.8.#!)9.%*)09!;&9*).!./;9&7..4h1&%!$3.*%!&11`'($7!%0)*4$!&%!099.A.'97!%0)*4$!4;..)3+!%##M$#K-KT!2*#'9.!8+!-0('.99T!=o!L+M'!coo!Ul$3! -*%+! Dcc=Va!6)6(99.#! 8+! -0%4&#T! H=F! L+,'! cMo! UDD$3! -*%+! Dcl=Va! G%'.%! *#! _07! 8+!5*99*0/4&#!-&(#$7T! )04.! #&+!@`N,`-0`oM=`BBT! 0$! DD`D,! U5+I+!2.P+!@(A+! DcT! ,NNMVa! >0;;04! 8+!_*(9*0#*T! DDl! L+!B(;;+!,'!FMM!UB+I+e+n+!,NNNVa!5.*)3.%'*#A!8+!?*.A.9T!clD!L+!B(;;+!DDFM!U-+I+!"99+!DccHVa!R0S%.#^!8+!\0/.4T!l=,!L+!B(;;+!clo! U6+I+!L90+! DccFVa!>%(*$$!8+!:&S0%'!-&(#$7!B3.%*11K4!I.;K$+T! o,M!@+,'!oco!UDccMV+!23.!;&9*).!'.;0%$/.#$4K!$3.&%7!*4!A.#.%0997!$30$!%0)*4$!./;9&7..4!/07!.#1&%).!$3.!90S!*#!%0)*4$!S074T!0#'!$30$! $3.!;(J9*)!/07!*#!0#7!.8.#$!J.!%.04�J97!S&%%*.'!0J&($!$3.!;&44*J*9*$7!&1!4()3!%0)*4$!0)$*&#+!%##M$#K-KT!0'0577#*T!H=F!L+,'!0$!cMl`Mc+!230$!0%A(/.#$!)&(9'!&1!)&(%4.!0;;97!$&!0!S*'.!%0#A.!&1!g&J4T!0#'!#&$!g(4$!90S!.#1&%)./.#$+!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! ,D$
! ,D!
B3&(9'! b$3.! 4$('.#$j! .8.%! J.)&/.! 0#! ./;9&7..! &1! 0! )&%;&%0$*&#!4)%($*#*^.'!J7!)*8*9! %*A3$4!S0$)3'&A!A%&(;4T!3.!S&(9'!J.!0!/0g&%!9*0J*9*$7+!6&4$! )&%;&%0$*! '&#K$! 3*%.! ;.&;9.!S3&! ;(J9*)97! 0'&;$!f(04*`[[[! &%! #.&`e0^*! *'.&9&A*.4! J.)0(4.! $3.7! 0%.! 0! ;(J9*)!!%.90$*! ./J0%%044/.#$! 0#'! 0! 9*0J*9*$7! *#! $3.! .8.#$! &1! <<G-!!*#8.4$*A0$*!&%!)*8*9!%*A3$4!90S4(*$4+!:&S!40'!$30$!b$3.!4$('.#$j!9.$!3*4! %0)*4$! *'.&9&A7! J.)&/.! ;0%$! &1! $3.! ;(J9*)! %.)&%'! b0#'! $3(4T!0/&#A!&$3.%!$3*#A4Tj!+!+!+!'0/0A.'!3*4!&S#!)0%..%!;%&4;.)$4!+!+!+!+ol!
"!'&(J$T!$3&(A3T!$30$!*#$&9.%0#).!$&S0%'!A.#(*#.!%0)*4/!43&(9'!J.!)*'`.%.'!6)-0%$37*4/!&%!&$3.%S*4.!10(9$.'!J7!'.).#$!;.&;9.+!@#'!.8.#!*1!$3.%.!*4!10(9$!3.%.T!*$!43&(9'!J.!;90).'!&#!$3.!J(7*#A!;(J9*)!0#'!&#!$3.!9.A09!474`$./!%0$3.%!$30#!&#!./;9&7.%4+!! 23.!J04.J099!)&//*44*&#.%!S04!(#'.%4$0#'0J97!S&%%*.'!$30$!B)3&$$K4!0#'! ?&)C.%K4! )&//.#$4! S&(9'! 09*.#0$.! 10#4a! 0#'! $3&(A3! B)3&$$! 0#'!?&)C.%!S.%.!%.90$*8.97!10/&(4!;.&;9.Toc!./;9&7.%4!)0#!308.!4*/*90%!S&%`%*.4!.8.#!0J&($!/()3!9.44!;%&/*#.#$!./;9&7..4+!-(4$&/.%4!&1$.#!1%.f(.#$!;90).4!J.)0(4.!$3.7!9*C.!$3.!;.&;9.!$3.%.T!0#'!J.)0(4.!$3.7!1..9!S.9)&/.'!$3.%.+! ?&)C.%T! B)3&$$T! 0#'! &$3.%4! S3&! .P;%.44! J*A&$.'! 8*.S4h&%! &$3.%!8*.S4! $30$! $3.! ;(J9*)! 4..4! 04! )&#$./;$*J9.h/0C.! )(4$&/.%4! %.9()$0#$! $&!8*4*$+!5&(9'!J90)C4!&%!\.S4!J.!.0A.%!$&!;0$%&#*^.!0!J(4*#.44!S3.%.!$3.7K99!308.!$&!'.09!S*$3!4&/.&#.!S3&/!$3.7!C#&S!$&!J.!0
,,! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!,,!
;(J9*)!/07!S&%%7!$30$!0#!./;9&7..!S*99!$%.0$!$3./!(#10*%97T!0#'!$3*4!/07!(#'.%/*#.!$3.!./;9&7.%K4!%.90$*!S*$3!$3.!;(J9*)+H,!! !! 530$! *4! .8*'.#).! *#! $3.! .7.4! &1! $3.! ./;9&7.%T! ./;9&7..4T! 0#'! )(4`$&/.%4!/07!094&!J.!.8*'.#).!*#!$3.!.7.4!&1!g(%&%4!S3&!0%.!'.)*'*#A!)04.4!J%&(A3$! 0A0*#4$! 0#! ./;9&7.%!J04.'!&#! 0#! ./;9&7..K4! 0)$*!&%!/&$*8.4+!L*%4$T! *#! 0!'*4)%*/*#0$*&#! 90S4(*$T! 0!/0#0A.%K4! 4;..)3!)0#!J.!.8*'.#).!&1!3*4!J*04.'!/&$*8.+!"$!S&(9'#K$!J.!)&#)9(4*8.!.8*'.#).T!J($!;.%30;4!.#&(A3!$&!4S07!$3.!g(%7T!$&A.$3.%!S*$3!&$3.%!.8*'.#).!$30$!/*A3$!#&$!308.!4(11*).'!&#! *$4! &S#+HM! B&! *1! 0#! ./;9&7.%! C#&S4! $30$! 4&/.! /0#0A.%! $3*#C4! $30$!J90)C4!0%.!*#1.%*&%T!&%!$30$!1(#'0/.#$09*4$!-3%*4$*0#4!0%.!*%%0$*	!1&&94T!$3.!./;9&7.%!/07!J.!S*4.!#&$!$&!3*%.T!;%&/&$.T!&%!C..;!3*/+!@#'!J.)0(4.!./`;9&7.%4! 0%.! 4$%*)$97! 9*0J9.! 1&%! '*4)%*/*#0$&%7! ./;9&7/.#$! 0)$*! J7! $3.*%!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! H,+! %##!0'0577#*T!H=F!L+,'!0$!cMo! U3&9'*#A! $30$!0! 43.%*11K4!'.;0%$/.#$!)&(9'! 1*%.!0!)9.%C!S3&!S04! 0! C#&S#! [90#! %.)%(*$.%T! /&4$97! J.)0(4.! $3.! 0%.0K4! iJ90)C! )&//(#*$7! *#! 90%A.! ;0%$! S&(9'!)0$.A&%*)0997! '*4$%(4$! $3.! B3.%*11K4! &11*).! *1! 0! C#&S#
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! ,M$
! ,M!
0A.#$4THF!$3.!./;9&7.%!/*A3$!S0#$!$&!*#8.4$*A0$.!0!J*$!J.1&%.!3*%*#A!0#!0;`;9*)0#$O!"$!/*A3$!04C!0#!0;;9*)0#$K4!%.1.%.#).4!0J&($!S3.$3.%!$3.!0;;9*)0#$!304!8*.S4!$30$!/*A3$!%.'&(#'!$&!$3.!)&/;0#7K4!30%/T!&%!*$!/*A3$!.8.#!'&!0!J*$!&1!_&&A9*#A!$&!4..!S30$!;(J9*)!4$0$./.#$4!0#!0;;9*)0#$!304!/0'.+!"1!$3.!0;;9*)0#$!%(#4!0!i53*$.!>&S.%k!S.J9&AT! $3.!./;9&7.%!/*A3$!S0#$! $&!3*%.!4&/.&#.!.94.+H=!! B.)&#'T!./;9&7..!4;..)3!0#'!044&)*0$*&#!)&(9'!J.!(4.'!*#!0!#.A9*A.#$!3*%*#A! &%! #.A9*A.#$! %.$.#$*&#! 90S4(*$! 0A0*#4$! $3.! ./;9&7.%+! 23.! $3.&%7! *#!4()3!90S4(*$4!*4!$30$!0#!./;9&7.%!C#.S!&%!43&(9'!308.!C#&S#!$30$!0#!./`;9&7..!30'!0!;%&;.#4*$7!$&S0%'!30%/1(9!)&#'()$T!0#'!$3.!./;9&7.%!43&(9'!$3.%.1&%.! J.! 3.9'! 9*0J9.! 1&%! $30$! ./;9&7..K4! 1&%.4..0J9.! J.308*&%+Ho! 23.!)9044*)!.P0/;9.!*4!0#!./;9&7.%K4!3*%*#A!0!S&%C.%!C#&S*#A!$30$!$3.!S&%C.%!304!0!%.)&%'!&1!4.P!)%*/.4!U&%!#&$!308*#A!)3.)C.'!$&!1*#'!4()3!0!%.)&%'V+&"1!$3.!S&%C.%K4!g&J!4.#'4!3*/!*#$&!)(4$&/.%4K!3&/.4T!0#'!$3.!S&%C.%!(4.4!$3.!g&J! $&! %0;.! 0! )(4$&/.%T! $3.! ./;9&7.%! *4! #&$! 9*0J9.! (#'.%! %.4;&#'.0$!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HF+! E(%9*#A$&#!"#'(4+!8+!<99.%$3T!=,F!X+B+!HF,T!Ho,`oM!UDcclV!Uib@j!$0#A*J9.!./;9&7/.#$!0)$*&#!$0C.#!J7! $3.!4(;.%8*4&%!J.)&/.4!1&%!2*$9.!Z""!;(%;&4.4! $3.!0)$!&1! $3.!./;9&7.%Tk!0#'!0#!./;9&7.%! *4!9*0J9.!1&%!4()3!0#!0)$+V+!R*0J*9*$7!1&%!3&4$*9.!.#8*%&#/.#$!30%044/.#$!*4!#&$!#.).440%*97!4$%*)$T!@##$)L+T!J($!9*0J*9*$7!1&%!'*4)%*/*#0$&%7!1*%*#A!&%!3*%*#A!*4+!! H=+! e&%! )0#! $3.! ./;9&7.%! 044(/.! $30$! 0! /&%.! $&9.%0#$! 0;;%&0)3h3*%*#A! 4&/.&#.! '.4;*$.! 3*4!4$0$.'!8*.S4!0#'!3&;*#A!3.!S*99!9.08.!$3&4.!8*.S4!0$!$3.!&11*).!'&&%hS*99!J.!;%&$.)$.'!J7!)(%%.#$!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$! '&)$%*#.+! >.&;9.K4! 4;..)3! *4! %&($*#.97! 0'/*44*J9.! 04! .8*'.#).! &1! $3.*%! /&$*8.4+! L&%!*#4$0#).T!*#!0!30$.`)%*/.!;%&4.)($*&#T!S3.%.!$3.!;%&4.)($&%4!/(4$!43&S!$30$!$3.!'.1.#'0#$K4!0$$0)C!S04!%0)*0997!/&$*80$.'T!)&(%$4!%&($*#.97!0'/*$!$3.!'.1.#'0#$K4!;04$!%0)*4$!4$0$./.#$4T!.8.#!*1!$3.!4$0$./.#$4!S.%.!&$3.%S*4.!(#%.90$.'!$&!$3.!)%*/.+!%##M$#K-KT!X#*$.'!B$0$.4!8+!I(##0S07T!ll!L+M'!oDHT!oDc!Ul$3!-*%+!DccoV! U3&9'*#A! $30$! $3.! '.1.#'0#$K4! ;04$! 4$0$./.#$4! $30$! 3.! i'*'! #&$! 9*C.! J90)C! ;.&;9.k! 0#'! $30$! 3.!iJ.9*.8.'!*#$.%%0)*09!%.90$*+*;4!S.%.!S%&#Ak!S.%.!0'/*44*J9.!04!.8*'.#).!$30$!3*4!)%*/.!S04!%0)*0997!/&$*80$.'Va!X#*$.'!B$0$.4!8+!@99.#T!MFD!L+M'!lHNT!ll=`lo!Uc$3!-*%+!,NNMV!U3&9'*#A!$30$!*$!S04!;%&;.%!1&%!$3.! ;%&4.)($*&#! $&! *#$%&'().! i;3&$&A%0;34! &1! b$3.! '.1.#'0#$4Kj! $0$$&&4! U.+A+T! 4S04$*C04! 0#'! &$3.%!47/J&94! &1! S3*$.! 4(;%./0)7VT! e0^*`%.90$.'! 9*$.%0$(%.T! A%&(;! ;3&$&A%0;34! *#)9('*#A! 4&/.! &1! $3.!'.1.#'0#$4!U.+A+T!*#!p:.*9!:*$9.%K!;&4.4!0#'!4$0#'*#A!J.1&%.!0!90%A.!4S04$*C0!$30$!$3.7!90$.%!4.$!&#!1*%.VT!0#'!4C*#3.0'!;0%0;3.%#09*0!U.+A+T!)&/J0$!J&&$4T!0%/`J0#'4!S*$3!4S04$*C04T!0#'!0!%.A*4$%0$*&#!1&%/!1&%!$3.!@%70#!e0$*!5&%9'!-&#A%.44VkVa!X#*$.'!B$0$.4!8+!5&&'9..T!DMo!L+M'!DMccT!DFDN!UDN$3!-*%+!DcclV!U9*C.S*4.!099&S*#A!0'/*44*&#!&1!.8*'.#).!$30$!ib'.1.#'0#$j!;90##.'!$&!0))&/;0#7!4&/.!1%*.#'4!&#!0#!&($*#A! J($T! S3.#! b3.j! 9.0%#.'! 0! S&/0#! &1! p/*P.'! %0).K! S&(9'! 094&! 0$$.#'T! 3.! %.1(4.'! $&! A&Tk! 0#'!4$0$*#A!$30$!ib.j8*'.#).!&1!;04$!%0)*09!0#*/&4*$7!*4!%.9.80#$!$&!.4$0J9*43k!%0)*4$!*#$.#$Va!>.&;9.!8+!B908*#T!lNH!e+<+,'!,=c!Ue+n+!,NNFV!U9*C.S*4.!099&S*#A!0'/*44*&#!&1!%0)*4$!$0$$&&4V+!!! B()3!4$0$./.#$4!0%.#K$!;(#*430J9.!$3./4.98.4T!J($!$3.7!)0#!J.!.8*'.#).!&1!0!%0)*4$!*#$.#$!*#!0!30$.`)%*/.!)04.!0#'T!$3(4T!/07!'%0/0$*)0997!*#)%.04.!$3.!'.1.#'0#$K4!4.#$.#).+!23.!40/.!*4!$%(.!*#!2*$9.!Z""!)04.4! 0#'!&$3.%! )04.4+!%##M$ #K-KT!5*4)*#!8+!6*$)3.99T! =Nl!X+B+!FHoT!Flc`cN! UDccMVa!B$%..$!8+!e.S!n&%CT!McF!X+B+!=HoT!=cF!UDcocVa!:0(;$!8+!X#*$.'!B$0$.4T!MMN!X+B+!oMD!UDcFHV+!@#'!4()3!4;..)3!9*C.97!S&(9'!J.!0'/*44*J9.!(#'.%!$3.!%(9.4!&1!.8*'.#).+!"#!$3.!1.'.%09!474$./T!1&%!*#4$0#).T!?(9.!FNF!J0%4!$3.!(4.! &1! 4&/.! )30%0)$.%! .8*'.#).T! J($! 4;.)*1*)0997! 099&S4! ;%*&%! J0'! 0)$4h*#)9('*#A! ;%*&%! J0'!4$0$./.#$4h$&! J.! (4.'! 04! .8*'.#).! &1! 0! 4;.0C.%K4! *#$.#$*! &%!/&$*8.4+!%##!Fed. R. Evid.! FNFUJV+!?(9.! FNM! J0%4! .8*'.#).! S3.#! *$4! ;%.g('*)*09! .11.)$! 4(J4$0#$*0997! &($S.*A34! *$4! ;%&J0$*8.! 809(.a! J($!;.&;9.K4!;04$!;&9*$*)09!4$0$./.#$4!0#'!.8.#!;&9*$*)09!044&)*0$*!0%.!&1$.#!f(*$.!;%&J0$*8.!&1!$3.*%!90$.%!0)$*!0#'!/&$*80$*+!%##!Fed. R. Evid.!FNM+!!! 23.!)&%%.90$*&#!J.$S..#!J.9*.1!0#'!0)$*&#!*4!&1!)&(%4.!10%!1%&/!;.%1.)$+!E($!$&!S*#!0$!$%*09T!0!;0%$7!/07! #&$! #..'! 0! 4*#A9.! '*4;&4*$*8.! ;*.).! &1! .8*'.#).h$3.! 0AA%.A0$.! &1!/0#7! ;%&J0$*8.! ;*.).4T! .0)3!*/;.%1.)$!&#!*$4!&S#!J($!;.%4(04*8.!S3.#!;($!$&A.$3.%T!/07!4(11*).+!! Ho+! %##$Restatement (Second) of Agency!t!,DM!)/$+!'!UDc=lV+!
2010
,F! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!,F!
4(;.%*&%T!4*#).!$3.!S&%C.%K4!)&#'()$!S04!&($4*'.!$3.!4)&;.!&1!3*4!./;9&7`/.#$+HH!E($!$3.!./;9&7.%!S&(9'!J.!9*0J9.!(#'.%!0!#.A9*A.#$!3*%*#A!$3.&%7T!4*#).! $3.!)%*/.!S04!1&%.4..0J9.!A*8.#!S30$! $3.!./;9&7.%!C#.S!&%!43&(9'!308.!C#&S#!0J&($!$3.!S&%C.%K4!;%&;.#4*$*.4+Hl!! @#'! $3.4.! ;%&;.#4*$*.4! )0#! J.! 43&S#! $3%&(A3! $3.! ./;9&7..K4! ;04$!4$0$./.#$4T! #&$! g(4$! 3*4! ;04$! 0)$*+! 23(4T! *#!0)LL7#C"..P@$ BK$ I)77'"#@+$!..L@M$9*'KT!$3.!<9.8.#$3!-*%)(*$!3.9'!$30$!0!%.4$0(%0#$!)&(9'!J.!3.9'!9*0J9.!1&%!#.A9*A.#$97!3*%*#A!0!)&&C!S3&!*#4(9$.'!J90)C!;0$%!0#'!30'!$3./!%.`/&8.'!1%&/!$3.!%.4$0(%0#$!J.)0(4.!&1!$3.*%!%0).+!>0%$!&1!$3.!.8*'.#).!S04!$30$! 0!/0#0A.%&i$.4$*1*.'! $30$! *$!S&(9'!#&$! 4(%;%*4.!3*/! $&! 9.0%#! $30$! b$3.!)&&Cj!S&(9'!(4.!;%&10#*$7!&%!/0C.! %0)*4$! %./0%C4T!09$3&(A3!3.!S&(9'!J.!4(%;%*4.'! $30$! b$3.! )&&Cj! (4.'! $3*4! 90#A(0A.! *#! 1%&#$! &1! )(4$&/.%4+kHc!!R*C.S*4.T! *#!1."C2773$ BK$ %)P"2@$ ;#27+3$ 1.KT! 0! e.S!n&%C! 0;;.990$.! )&(%$!3.9'!$30$!0#!./;9&7.%!/07!308.!J..#!#.A9*A.#$!*#!3*%*#A!0#'!%.$0*#*#A!0#!./;9&7..!S3&!90$.%!0440(9$.'!$3.!;90*#$*11T!J.)0(4.!$3.!./;9&7..K4!0J(4*8.!;%&;.#4*$*.4!S.%.!43&S#!J7T!0/&#A!&$3.%!$3*#A4T!0#!i0;;0%.#$!011*#*$7!1&%!e0^*!/./&%0J*9*0+klN!! e0$(%0997T! 4()3! )90*/4! 0%.! 30%'97! 4(%.! S*##.%4+! 23.! ./;9&7.%! /07!0%A(.!$30$!$3.!./;9&7..K4!4;..)3!S04#K$!.#&(A3!$&!/0C.!$3.!./;9&7.%!%.`09*^.!$30$!$3.!./;9&7..!30'!0!'0#A.%&(4!;%&;.#4*$7+!23.!g(%&%4!/07!0A%..T!;.%30;4!J.)0(4.!$3.7!S0#$!$&!)($!$&9.%0#$!./;9&7.%4!4&/.!490)CT!0#'!$3.7!'&#K$! S0#$! $&! .#)&(%0A.! ./;9&7.%4! $&! 1*%.! ./;9&7..4! J.)0(4.! &1! $3.*%!4;..)3+!! G%! $3.! g(%&%4! /07! '*40A%..T! 0#'! 1*#'! $30$! $3.! )&/;0#7! S04! *#'..'!#.A9*A.#$!1&%!'*4%.A0%'*#A!4()3!;&S.%1(9!.8*'.#).!&1!$3.!./;9&7..K4!1($(%.!'0#A.%&(4#.44+! U@1$.%! 099T! $3.! ./;9&7..! .#'.'! (;! J.*#A! '0#A.%&(4T! 0#'!g(%&%4!0%.!09%.0'7!$./;$.'!$&!*#1.%!$30$!.8.#$4!S3*)3!30;;.#.'!S.%.!1&%.`4..0J9.+lDV!@#'!$3.!/&%.!(#;&;(90%!$3.!./;9&7..K4!4;..)3T!$3.!/&%.!9*C.97!0! g(%7! *4! $&!4&!'.)*'.+!60#7!0! g(%&%!S*99!044(/.!$3.!S&%4$!&1!;.&;9.!S3&!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HH+! %##M$#K-KT!e+x+!8+!-0J%*#*!6.'+!-$%+T!Ho=!e+<+,'!lFF!Ue+n+!,NN,V+!! Hl+! %##$Restatement (Third) of Torts: Liability for Physical Harm!t!Dc!U2.#$0$*8.!I%01$!e&+!DT!,NNDVa!Restatement (Second) of Torts!t!MNH!UDco=V+!!! Hc+! ,=o! L+M'! D,FDT! D,FH! UDD$3! -*%+! ,NNDV! U%.g.)$*#A! $3.! '*44.#$*#A! g('A.K4! 0%A(/.#$! $30$! $3*4!.8*'.#).!S04!*#4(11*)*.#$V+!!! lN+! ==F!e+n+B+,'!lMcT!lMc`FN!U@;;+!I*8+!DccNVa!@##$27@.!L*43.%!8+!@+5+!2./;9.T!"#)+T!e&+!RR`lHNT!,NNN!5R!D=ololFT!0$!zF!UZ0+!-*%+!-$+!@(A+!FT!,NNNV!U'*4)(44*#A!0!#.A9*A.#$!3*%*#A!)90*/!J04.'!*#!;0%$!&#!$3.!'.1.#'0#$!./;9&7.%K4!C#&S9.'A.!$30$!0#!./;9&7..!S3&!0440(9$.'!$3.!;90*#$*11!S04!0
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! ,=$
! ,=!
308.!)&#$./;$*J9.!8*.S4T!0#'!S*99!044(/.!$30$!4()3!;.&;9.!S.%.!'0#A.%&(4!04! S.99! 04! S%&#A`$3*#C*#A+! B()3! g(%&%4! /07! 308.! 9*$$9.! 47/;0$37! 1&%! 0!)&/;0#7! $30$! 4../4! $&! 308.! )&''9.'! $3&4.! J0'! ;.&;9.! 0#'! '*4%.A0%'.'!$3.*%!.8*9!;%&;.#4*$*.4+!! 6&%.&8.%T! $3.! )&/;0#7!304! $&!/0C.! *$4! '.)*4*&#!(;! 1%&#$O!B3&(9'! *$!3*%.!&%!C..;!4&/.&#.!S3&4.!4$0$./.#$4!/*A3$!&;.#!*$!$&!9*0J*9*$7!*#!$3.!1(`$(%.dl,! G%! 43&(9'! *$! ;907! *$! 401.! 0#'! A&! S*$3! 4&/.&#.! .94.d! </;9&7.%4!10).'!S*$3!0#!&1$.#!(#;%.'*)$0J9.!9.A09!474$./!/07!S.99!S0#$!$&!.%%!&#!$3.!4*'.!&1!)0($*&#+!@#'!*$K4!S%&#AT!"!$3*#CT!$&!)&#'./#!0!)&/;0#7K4!0)$*!04!6)-0%$37*4/!S3.#! $3.! 0)$*! 0%.! #..'.'! $&!/*#*/*^.! $3.! %*4C! &1! 9.A09!9*0J*9*$7+!! B*/*90%!1&%).4!/07!9.0'!./;9&7.%4!$&!1*%.!;.&;9.!S3&!;%0*4.!&%!'.1.#'!*99.A09T! 30%/1(9! J.308*&%+!0#7T#"$ BK$ J.2"L$ ./$ >L5'2+).*! *4! 0! )9044*)! 4).`#0%*&+!6.9^.%T!0;;0%.#$97!0!A&&'!3*A3!4)3&&9!$.0)3.%!*#!/&4$!S074T!$(%#.'!&($! $&! J.! .'*$*#A! 0! #.S49.$$.%! 1&%! $3.! e&%$3! @/.%*)0#! 60#qE&7! R&8.!!@44&)*0$*&#!Ue@6ER@V+lM!>0%.#$4!)&/;90*#.'T!1.0%*#A!$30$!3.!/*A3$!;%0)`$*).!S30$!3.!;%.0)3.'T!$3&(A3!$3.%.!S04!#&!.8*'.#).!$30$!3.!30'!'&#.!$3*4!*#!$3.!;04$+lF!! "/0A*#.!0!;%*80$.!g(#*&%!3*A3!4)3&&9!/0C*#A!0!4*/*90%!'*4)&8.%7!0J&($!&#.!&1!*$4!$.0)3.%4+l=!5&(9'!/&4$!;0%.#$4!J.!)&/1&%$0J9.!4.#'*#A!$3.*%!C*'4!$&!4()3!0!4)3&&9T!.8.#!*1!$3.!$.0)3.%!304!0!4../*#A97!)9.0#!%.)&%'!U$3&(A3!S3&! )0#! $.99! 1&%! 4(%.dVT! 0#'! .8.#! *1! $3.! $.0)3.%! 044(%.'! ;.&;9.! $30$! 3.!S&(9'!#.8.%!0)$!&#!3*4!8*.S4d!5&(9'!7&(! 1..9!)&/1&%$0J9.! 4.#'*#A!7&(%!)3*9'!$&!$30$!4)3&&9d!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! l,+! E&$3!*#!'*4)%*/*#0$*&#!)04.4!0#'!#.A9*A.#$!3*%*#A!)04.4T!0!)&/;0#7!S*99!%0%.97!J.!3.9'!9*0J9.!J04.'[email protected]#73!&#!.8*'.#).!&1!./;9&7..4K!4;..)3+!23.!;90*#$*11!S*99!J%*#A!*#!04!/()3!.8*'.#).!04!3.!)0#a!.0)3!*$./!4.9'&/!S*99!J.!'*4;&4*$*8.T!0#'!4&/.!/*A3$!#&$!.8.#!J.!J.9*.8.'!J7!$3.!g(%7T!J($!$3.!;90*#$*11!S*99!3&;.!$30$!$3.!0AA%.A0$.!&1!099!$3.!*$./4h$3.!.8*'.#).!&1!4;..)3!04!S.99!04!$3.!.8*'.#).!&1!&$3.%!)&#'()$hS*99!4(11*).+!!! -.%4.97T! $3.! ./;9&7.%T! $&! 08&*'! 9*0J*9*$7T!S*99!S0#$! $&!/*#*/*^.! $3.! 4;..)3! 0#'! )&#'()$! $30$!1($(%.!;90*#$*114! )&(9'!;&*#$! $&+!23.!./;9&7.%!S&(9'T!&1! )&(%4.T!308.!0#! *#).#$*8.! $&! 1*%.!&%!#&$!3*%.!./;9&7..4!S3&!)&//*$!)%*/.4T!&%!.8.#!S3&!'&!$3*#A4!$30$!0%.#K$!)%*/*#09!J($!/*A3$!4../!4(4;*)*&(4+!U"#!1."C2773T!1&%!*#4$0#).T!$3.!)&(%$!3.9'!$30$!0#!./;9&7..K4!C#*1.!)&99.)$*&#hf(*$.!9*C.97!0!;.%1.)$97!9.A09!)&99.)$*&#h)&(9'!J.!4..#!04!.8*'.#).!&1!0!;%&;.#4*$7!1&%!8*&9.#).!$30$!$3.!./;9&7.%!C#.S!0J&($+!==F!e+n+B+,'!0$!lFN+V!E($!$3.!./;9&7.%!S&(9'!094&!308.!0#!*#).#$*8.!$&!1*%.!&%!#&$!3*%.!./;9&7..4!S3&!/0C.! 4$0$./.#$4! $30$! 1($(%.! g(%*.4! )&(9'! *#$.%;%.$! 04! .8*'.#).! &1! 0! /&$*8.! $&! '*4)%*/*#0$.! &%! 0!;%&;.#4*$7!1&%!*99.A09!)&#'()$+!! lM+! MMo!L+M'!Dl=T!Dll`lc!U,'!-*%+!,NNMV+!! lF+! 9LK!0$!DlcT!DcD+!E.)0(4.!0#7T#"!*#8&98.'!0!;(J9*)!4)3&&9T!$3.%.!S.%.!4&/.!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$!)$%0*#$4!&#!$3.!./;9&7.%T!J($!6.9^.%K4!1*%*#A!S04!(9$*/0$.97!(;3.9'!(#'.%!$3.!A)'P#")*-$J090#)*#A!$.4$+!9LK!0$!Dc=+!! l=+! >%*80$.! 4)3&&94! /07! J.! .4;.)*0997! 9*C.97! $&! 1*%.! $.0)3.%4! S3&! ;0%$*)*;0$.! *#! ;%&`;.'&;3*9.!;&9*$*)4O!@/&#A! &$3.%! $3*#A4T!!UDV!!;%*80$.`4)3&&9! ;0%.#$4! 0%.! ;%&J0J97! /&%.! 0J9.! $30#! /&4$! ;(J9*)`4)3&&9!;0%.#$4!$&!4.#'!$3.*%!)3*9'%.#!$&!&$3.%!4)3&&94T!!U,V!!0#!.P&'(4!1%&/!0!;%*80$.!4)3&&9!U(#9*C.!&#.!1%&/! 0! ;(J9*)! 4)3&&9V! '*%.)$97! g.&;0%'*^.4! $3.! 4)3&&9K4! 4&98.#)7! 0#'! $3.! 4)3&&9! &11*)*094K! g&J4T!0#'!!UMV!!;%*80$.! 4)3&&94! 308.! 9.44! #..'! $30#! ;(J9*)! 4)3&&94! $&! S&%%7! 0J&($! 0#7! L*%4$! @/.#'/.#$!90S4(*$4!J04.'!&#!4()3!1*%*#A4h90S4(*$4!$30$!/07!;%&8.!.P;.#4*8.!0#'!J(%'.#4&/.!.8.#!*1!$3.!4)3&&9!S*#4!$3./hJ.)0(4.!;%*80$.!4)3&&94!0%.#K$!4$0$.!0)$&%4!0#'!$3(4!0%.#K$!J&(#'!J7!$3.!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$+&
,o! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!,o!
! G%!407! $3.! $.0)3.%!/&9.4$.'!0!)3*9'T!0#'!$3.!)3*9'K4!;0%.#$4!4(.'!$3.!4)3&&9! 1&%! #.A9*A.#$! 3*%*#A! &%! %.$.#$*&#T! 0%A(*#A! $&! $3.! g(%7T! i23.! 4)3&&9!C#.S!$3*4!$.0)3.%!$3&(A3$!/0#`J&7!4.P!S04!1*#.a!$3.!$.0)3.%!30'!4.P!S*$3!$3*4!J&7a!$3.!4)3&&9!/(4$!308.!1&%.4..#!$30$!$3*4!S&(9'!30;;.#T!7.$!$3.7!9.$!$3.! $.0)3.%! 308.! 0)).44! $&! 3(#'%.'4! &1! J&74+k!23.! 4)3&&9! )0#! *#'..'! %.`4;&#'!J7!;&*#$*#A!&($! $30$! #&$! 099! ;.&;9.! 0)$! &#! $3.*%! *'.&9&A*)09! J.9*.14T!.4;.)*0997!S3.#! $3.! 0)$*! 0%.! *99.A09+! 23.! 4)3&&9! )0#! 0%A(.! $30$! *$! 30'!A&&'! .P;.%*.#).4! S*$3! $3.! $.0)3.%! J.1&%.T! 0#'! $30$! *$! 4(;.%8*4.'! 3*/! 04!)9&4.97!04!$.0)3.%4!0%.!#&%/0997!4(;.%8*4.'+!E($!)0#!S.!)*'.#$97!;%.'*)$!$30$!$3.!g(%7!S&(9'!%.g.)$!$3.!;90*#$*11K4!0%A(/.#$d!! B&! 0! %.04�J9.! 4)3&&9! $30$K4! *#$.%.4$.'! *#! ;%&$.)$*#A! *$4! 4$('.#$4T!C..;*#A!$3./!.#%&99.'T!0#'!08&*'*#A!%(*#&(4!9*0J*9*$7!S*99!308.!$&!1*%.!$3.!$.0)3.%+! @#'! $3.! 40/.! *4! $%(.! 1&%! &$3.%! ./;9&7.%4! U0#'! $3.%.! 0%.! /0#7V!$3%&(A3!S3*)3!0#!./;9&7..!/07!J.)&/.!0)f(0*#$.'!S*$3!)3*9'%.#T! .4;.`)*0997! 4*#).! $3.! ./;9&7.%!/07!J.!3.9'! 9*0J9.! .8.#! *1! $3.! $&%$*&(4!)&#'()$!30;;.#.'!&($4*'.!$3.!S&%C;90).T!4&!9&#A!04!$3.!./;9&7..K4!g&J!3.9;.'!3*/!.#A0A.!*#!$3.!)&#'()$+lo&! e&%!0%.!4()3!*#).#$*8.4!$&!1*%.!./;9&7..4!J04.'!&#!$3.*%!8*.S4!9*/*$.'!$&!/./J.%4!&1! $3.!J%&0'97! 9&0$3.'!e@6ER@!&%! $&! %0)*4$4+! "1!7&(! %0#!0#!0J&%$*&#!)9*#*)T!7&(!/*A3$!S0#$!$&!%.;90).!0!4.)(%*$7!A(0%'!*1!7&(!9.0%#!$30$!3.!$3*#C4!&1!0#$*`0J&%$*&#!$.%%&%*4$4!04!1%..'&/!1*A3$.%4+!"1!7&(!%0#!0!4.)(`%*$7`A(0%'!)&/;0#7T!7&(!/*A3$! 9*C.S*4.!S0#$! $&! %.;90).!0!A(0%'!S3&!J.`9*.8.4! $30$! 099! ;%&;.%$7! *4! $3.1$T! 0#'! $30$! 43&;9*1$.%4! 0%.! g(4$! &;;%.44.'!J7!.8*9!4$&%.!&S#.%4+lH&! ?*A3$! #&ST! '*4)%*/*#0$*&#! 0A0*#4$! ;.&;9.! S3&! 3&9'! 4()3! 8*.S4! *4!9*C.97!$&!J.!9*/*$.'!$&!a!0!1.S!g&J!)0$.A&%*.4+!E($!*1!;&9*$*)0997!/&$*80$.'!$.%%&%*4/!&%!40J&$0A.!J.)&/.4!/&%.!)&//&#!0#'!/&%.!J%&0'`A0(A.'h1&%!*#4$0#).T! *1! %0'*)09! 0#$*`0J&%$*&#T! 0#$*`A9&J09*^0$*&#T! 0#$*`A&8.%#/.#$T! &%!.#8*%&#/.#$09*4$! $.%%&%*4$4! 4$0%$! 0$$0)C*#A! &%! $3%.0$.#*#A! $&! 0$$0)C! 0! S*'.!%0#A.!&1!'&/.4$*)! $0%A.$4h./;9&7.%4!/07!J.)&/.!(#'.%4$0#'0J97! %.9()`$0#$!$&!3*%.!0#7&#.!S3&!*4!1&(#'!$&!47/;0$3*^.!S*$3!4()3!8*.S4+!! e0$(%0997T! $3.! 30%'`)&%.! $.%%&%*4$4! (4(0997!S&#K$! 0##&(#).! $3.*%! *'.`&9&A*.4a!J($!$&!4())..'T!$3.7!/07!&1$.#!308.!$&!%.97!&#!47/;0$3*^.%4!S3&!)0#!J.!;.%4(0'.'!$&!3.9;!$3./+!B07!0#!0#$*`0J&%$*&#!$.%%&%*4$!4$%*C.4!0!9&)09!$0%A.$T! 0#'! *$! $(%#4!&($! $30$! 4&/.!C#&S#! $.%%&%*4$! 47/;0$3*^.%4!(4.'! $3.*%!g&J4! $&! 3.9;! 3*/h1&%! *#4$0#).T! $3.7! 3.9;.'! 3*/! *99.A0997! J(7! .P;9&4*8.4!*#A%.'*.#$4T!S*991(997!*A#&%.'!3*4!(4*#A!0!4$%0S!;(%)304.%!$&!J(7!0!A(#T!&%!'*'#K$!%.;&%$!4&/.!4(4;*)*&(4! $%0#40)$*&#!$30$! $3.7!30'!0! 9.A09!'($7! $&!%.`
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lo+! %##$@5&"2!#&$.4!HD`HM!0#'!0))&/;0#7*#A!$.P$+&!! lH+! e.A9*A.#$!3*%*#A!0#'!%.$.#$*&#!)90*/4!)0#!J.!/0'.!*#!4&/.!g(%*4'*)$*!.8.#!S3.#!$3.!a!30%/!S04! $&!;%&;.%$7+!1.D&2"#$5.943!61A+!8+!>*#C.%$&#K4! "#)+T!FHF!@+,'!FMo!U?+"+!DclFV! U099&S*#A!4()3! 0! )90*/VT!N)+(! R.*'*A! 8+!:&#.7S.99T! "#)+T! l=N! L+! B(;;+! Hco! UI+!6*##+! DccFV! U%.g.)$*#A! 4()3! 0!)90*/V+!!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! ,H$
! ,H!
;&%$+!5&(9'!7&(!S0#$!$&!J.!$3.!./;9&7.%!S3&!3*%.'!&%!%.$0*#.'!$3.!$.%%&%*4$!47/;0$3*^.%4T!C#&S*#A!$3.!./;9&7..4K!8*.S4d!I&!7&(!$3*#C!7&(!S&(9'!J.!.04*97! 1&%A*8.#! $3*4! J7! )(4$&/.%4T! &%! J7! g(%&%4! *#! 0! #.A9*A.#$! 3*%*#A! 90S`4(*$d!
FK$ A.@@)C7#$%.75+).*@$
! B&!S30$! $3.#! *4! $&! J.! '&#.d! B&/.!/*A3$! 0%A(.! 1&%! 4&)*09! #&%/4! &%!.8.#!90S4!$30$!$%.0$!;&9*$*)09!8*.S4!$3.!40/.!S07!$30$!%0).T!4.PT!0#'!%.9*A`*&#!0%.! $%.0$.'+!</;9&7.%4!0%.!#&$!099&S.'! $&!'*4)%*/*#0$.!J04.'!&#! %0).T!4.PT! 0#'! %.9*A*&#! .8.#! *1! 3*%*#A! U407V! 0! J90)C! &%! 0$3.*4$! ./;9&7..! /*A3$!'%*8.!0S07!)(4$&/.%4T!&%!.8.#!*1!$3.!./;9&7.%!0#'!*$4!)(4$&/.%4!$3*#C!$30$!0! J90)C! ./;9&7..! &%! 0! /09.! ./;9&7..! *4! /&%.! 9*C.97! $&! )&//*$! )%*/.4+!R*C.S*4.T! $3.! 0%A(/.#$! S&(9'! A&T! ./;9&7.%4! /(4$! 3*%.! $3.! [90#4/.#T!e@6ER@!/./J.%4T! 0#'! $3.! 9*C.+! "1! $3.7! /*4J.308.T! $3.#! 7&(! )0#! 1*%.!$3./+!E($!(#$*9!$30$!30;;.#4T!7&(!)0#K$!J&S!$&!;(J9*)!;%.44(%.T!.8.#!*1!7&(%!./;9&7..4! f(*$! $&! 08&*'! S&%C*#A! S*$3! 0! [[[! /./J.%T! &%! ;0%.#$4! 4$&;!4.#'*#A!$3.*%!)3*9'%.#!$&!7&(%!4)3&&9+ll!! E($!"!'&#K$!$3*#C!$30$K4!%*A3$+!23.!;%./*4.!&1!/&4$!0#$*'*4)%*/*#0$*&#!90S4!0#'!4&)*09!#&%/4!*4!$30$!*$K4!S%&#A!0#'!A.#.%0997!*%%0$*	!$&!'*49*C.!;.&;9.!J.)0(4.!&1!$3.*%!%0).T!4.PT!&%!$3.&9&A*)09!J.9*.14+!5.!3&;.!$30$!)&#`'./#*#A!4()3!'*4)%*/*#0$*&#!S*99!.8.#$(0997!;.%4(0'.!)(4$&/.%4!0#'!./`;9&7..4!$&!J.!/&%.!$&9.%0#$T!.4;.)*0997!4*#).!$&9.%0#).!*4!$3.!/&%.!%0$*	!0#'!;%0)$*)09!0)$*&#!1&%!$3.!)(4$&/.%4!0#'!./;9&7..4+!23.!J(%'.#!&#!./`;9&7.%4! &1! 308*#A! $&! 3*%.! ;.&;9.! S3&/! &$3.%4! '*49*C.! S*99! $3.%.1&%.! '.`)%.04.!&8.%!$*/.+!@#'!S.!044(/.!$30$!$3.!)&%%.90$*&#!J.$S..#!J.308*&%!0#'!%0).T!4.PT!&%!$3.&9&A*)09!J.9*.1!S*99!J.!f(*$.!S.0C+lc!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ll+! e&%!)&(9'!4()3!'*4)%*/*#0$&%7!3*%*#A!'.)*4*!J.!'.1.#'.'!(#'.%!0!iJ�!1*'.!&))(;0$*	!f(09*1*)0$*&#k!UELGvV!.P).;$*&#!$&!$3.!37;&$3.$*)09!0#$*'*4)%*/*#0$*&#!90S+!-&#).%#!0J&($!)&`S&%C.%!&%! )(4$&/.%! %.0)$*&#! *4! A.#.%0997! #&$! .#&(A3! $&! g(4$*17! '*4)%*/*#0$*&#! (#'.%! $3.! ELGv! .P).;$*&#T!.P).;$!*#!%0%.!)04.4+!%##!<(A.#.!Z&9&C3T!6(#$127)/."*)2$1)B)7$;)-(+@$9*)+)2+)B#4$,*$9*+#"&"#+)B#$H5)L#T!FF!UCLA L. Rev.!DMM=T!DMHN!m!#+DDM!UDccHV!U'*4)(44*#A!$3.!ELGv!.P).;$*&#V+!R*C.S*4.T!;%.'*)$*!$30$! ;.&;9.!S3&!308.! 0! ).%$0*#! 0$$%*J($.!S*99! J.308.! *99.A0997! &%! 30%/1(997! 0%.#K$! 0)).;$.'!(#'.%! $3.!ELGv!.P).;$*&#+!9LK!0$!DMoc+!!! L&%!0#!0%A(/.#$!$30$!./;9&7.%4!/07!308.!0!)$*$($*	!%*A3$!$&!%.1(4.!$&!3*%.!;.&;9.!J04.'!&#!$3.*%!;&9*$*)09!J.9*.14T!4..!60%$*#!?.'*43!m!-3%*4$&;3.%!?+!6)L0''.#T!IE,1M$+(#$I.773N..L$6#*M$2*L$+(#$!)"@+$,D#*LD#*+$;)-(+$./$<.*S,@@.')2+).*T!l=!Minn. L. Rev+!DoocT!DHNM`Dc!U,NNDV+$! lc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g.)$4h1&%! *#4$0#).T! S3.$3.%!0J&%$*&#! ;%&8*'.%4! 0%.!/(%'.%.%4T!S3.$3.%! J90)C4! 0%.! *#1.%*&%! $&!S3*$.4T! 0#'! 4&! &#h0#'! J.308*&%! *4!4$%&#A.%+!E($! %.9*A*&(4! '*4)%*/*#0$*&#! 90S4! A.#.%0997! 9.$! ./;9&7.%4! '*4)%*/*#0$.! J04.'! &#! 0! ;.%4&#K4!&;*#*!&#!4.)(90%!4(Jg.)$4+!%##M$#K-KT!>.$.%4&#!8+!:.S9.$$`>0)C0%'!-&+T!M=l!L+M'!=ccT!oNF`N=!Uc$3!-*%+!,NNFV! U3&9'*#A! $30$! 1*%*#A! 0#! ./;9&7..! J04.'! &#! 3*4! %.9*A*&(497! /&$*80$.'! 0#$*`A07! 4;..)3! S04#K$!
,l! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!,l!
! G#!$3.!&$3.%!30#'T!'*49*C*#A!;.&;9.!S3&!308.!.8*9!8*.S4!*4!f(*$.!%.0`4�J9.+cN!5.! )0#K$! ;.%4(0'.! ;.&;9.! $&! 9*C.
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! ,c$
! ,c!
10)$1*#'*#A!$30$! *$!)0#K$!J.!'*4;90).'!.04*97+!E($!./;9&7.%4K!C#&S9.'A.!&1!$3.*%! ./;9&7..4K! ;&9*$*)09! ;&4*$*h.8.#! g(4$97! (#;&;(90%! &#.4h43&(9'#K$! J.! 0'/*44*J9.! 04! .8*'.#).! &1! ./;9&7.%! #.A9*A.#).+c=! -&(%$4!43&(9'!)&#)9('.!$30$T!04!0!/0$$.%!&1!90ST!*$K4!%.04�J9.!1&%!0#!./;9&7.%!$&!$&9.%0$.!*$4!./;9&7..4K!;&9*$*)09!8*.S4+!!! <8.#! *1! .8*'.#).!&1! 0#!./;9&7.%K4!C#&S9.'A.!&1! 0#!./;9&7..K4!;&`9*$*)09! 8*.S4! *4!/0'.! *#0'/*44*J9.T! ./;9&7.%4!S*99! 4$*99! 308.! 4&/.! *#).#`$*8.4! $&! 1*%.! ./;9&7..4!S3&4.!S.99`C#&S#! 8*.S4!/07! 1&%.430'&S! 1($(%.!/*4)&#'()$+!L&%!.P0/;9.T!0#!0J&%$*&#!)9*#*)!/07!%.1(4.!$&!3*%.!0!/*9*$0#$97!;%&`9*1.! 4.)(%*$7! A(0%'! .8.#! *1! *$K4! *//(#.! 1%&/! 0! #.A9*A.#$! 3*%*#A! 90S`4(*$h4()3!0!A(0%'!)0#!30%/!$3.!)9*#*)!/()3!/&%.!'*%.)$97!$30#!g(4$!J7!.P`;&4*#A!*$! $&!;&44*J9.!9*0J*9*$7+!E($!0$!9.04$!;%.8.#$*#A!$3.!A(0%'K4!*'.&9&A7!1%&/! 9.0'*#A! $&! #.A9*A.#$! 3*%*#A! 9*0J*9*$7! S*99! .9*/*#0$.! 0! A&8.%#/.#$`*/;&4.'!'.$.%%.#$!$&!1%..!4;..)3T!0!'.$.%%.#$!$30$!*#8&98.4!A&8.%#/.#$!0)`$&%4!Ug('A.4!0#'!g(%&%4V!;044*#A!g('A/.#$!&#!$3.!'0#A.%&(4#.44!&1!80%*&(4!8*.S4+co!! B.)&#'T!S.!)&(9'!1(%$3.%!4(;;&%$!$3.!.P*4$*#A!4&)*09!#&%/4!$30$!;%.4`4(%.!./;9&7.%4!$&!$&9.%0$.!%.04�J9.T!'.).#$!8*.S;&*#$4T!.8.#!*1!$3.7!'*4`0A%..!S*$3!$3&4.!8*.S;&*#$4+!"1!0#!./;9&7.%!1*%.4!0#!./;9&7..!J.)0(4.!$3.!./;9&7..!304!0!I./&)%0$*)!J(/;.%!4$*)C.%!&#!3.%!)0%h.8.#!S3.#!$3.!)0%!*4!;0%C.'!*#!0!)&/;0#7!;0%C*#A!9&$h$3.!./;9&7.%!'.4.%8.4!)&#'./#0$*&#+!23.!./;9&7.%!43&(9'!#&$!J.!7#-2773!J0%%.'!1%&/!0)$*#A!$3*4!S07+!E($!4()3!0)$*!%.19.)$!0#!*#$&9.%0#$!0$$*$('.T!0%.!(#10*%! $&!./;9&7..4T!0#'!%*4C!'.`$.%%*#A!;.&;9.K4!;&9*$*)09!0)$*8*$7!1&%!#&!%.09!J.#.1*$+!23.!0)$*!'.4.%8.!$&!J.!/&)C.'T! 4&! $30$! 1($(%.! ./;9&7.%4!/07! $3./4.98.4! J.! '.$.%%.'! J7! $3.!4&)*09!0#'!;.%30;4!.)&#&/*)!)&4$4!&1!$3.*%!0)$*+cH!! 23*%'T!S.!)&(9'!4(;;&%$!4&)*09!#&%/4!$30$!'*4)&(%0A.!./;9&7.%4!1%&/!&8.%%.0)$*#A+! B&/.$*/.4T! )&`S&%C.%4! &%! ;0$%! A.$! (;4.$! #&$! J7! %.09! *#`4(9$4!J($!J7!;.%).*8.'!&#.4+!23.!#&$&%*&(4!)04.!&1!$3.!./;9&7..!S3&!S04!1*%.'!1&%!(4*#A!$3.!S&%'!i#*AA0%'97Tk!S3*)3!4&/.!&1!3*4!9*4$.#.%4!S%&#A97!;.%).*8.'!04!%0)*4$T!*4!$3.!)9044*)!.P0/;9.acl!$3.!E*99!603.%!*#)*'.#$!/07!J.!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! c=+! 2&!/0C.! $3*4!S&%CT! $3.! )&(%$4!S&(9'!308.! $&! 407! $30$! $3.! #.A9*A.#).! )90*/! )0#K$! J.! J04.'!.8.#!*#!;0%$!&#!$3.!./;9&7.%4K!*A#&%*#A!$3.!4;..)3+!%##!@5&"2!#&$.!lD+!! co+! %##$ -#*#"2773! <(A.#.! Z&9&C3T! %&##'($ 2@$ 1.*L5'+4$H#*#"2773$ ,&&7)'2C7#$ 82N@M$ 977#-27$1.5"@#@$./$1.*L5'+M$O%)+52+).*S,7+#")*-$E++#"2*'#@MQ$2*L$+(#$E*'(2"+#L$a.*#@T!cN!Cornell L. Rev.!D,HH! U,NN=V! U0%A(*#A! $30$! .8.#! A.#.%0997! 0;;9*)0J9.! 90S4! /(4$! J.! $%.0$.'! 04! )&#$.#$`J04.'! 4;..)3!%.4$%*)$*!S3.#!$3.7!0%.!0;;9*.'!$&!*/;&4.!9*0J*9*$7!J04.'!&#!$3.!)&#$.#$!&1!4;..)3V+$! cH+! L&%!$3.!%.04!A*8.#!*#!>0%$4!""+@!0#'!""+ET!"!$3*#C!$30$!)&/;0#*.4!308.!A&&'!%.04&#!$&!'%&;!).9.J%*$7!.#'&%4.%4!&%!)&//.#$0$&%4!J04.'!&#!$3.!).9.J%*$*.4K!&%!)&//.#$0$&%4K!8*.S;&*#$4T!.8.#!*1!$3.!8*.S;&*#$4! 0%.! S*$3*#! $3.! /0*#4$%.0/+! @! )&/;0#7! /07! ;%&;.%97! #&$! S0#$! *$4! ;(J9*)! 10).! $&! J.!044&)*0$.'!S*$3!0!).%$0*#!8*.ST!0#'!0!/.'*0!&($9.$!/07!#&$!S0#$!$&!3.9;!;%&/&$.!$30$!8*.S+!23.!;&*#$!"!/0C.!3.%.!*4!9*/*$.'!$&!i&%'*#0%7!./;9&7..4+k!! cl+! %##! 6.9*#'0! :.##.J.%A.%T! ;2'#$ 0)XSE&$ ;2)@#@$ I2B.'$ /."$ 12&)+27T!N.Y. TimesT! \0#+! ,cT!DcccT!0$!@DN+!
MN! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!MN!
0#&$3.%+cc! "#! 4()3! )04.4T! 4&/.! ./;9&7.%4!/07! &;$! 1&%! 1*%*#A! $3.! 4;.0C.%T!%0$3.%! $30#! $%7*#A! $&! .P;90*#! $3.!/*4(#'.%4$0#'*#A! $&! $3.!;(J9*)+!>(J9*)97!)%*$*)*^*#A!$3.!./;9&7.%!1&%!$3*4T!0#'!;&*#$*#A!&($!$3.!30%/4!$30$!4()3!&8.%`%.0)$*!)0#!)0(4.h30%/!$&!;.&;9.K4!)0%..%4T!$&!$3.!.04.!0#'!4;&#$0#.*$7!&1!;.&;9.K4! 4;..)3T! 0#'T! *#! $3.! i#*AA0%'97k! )04.T! $&! $3.! 1*A3$! 0A0*#4$! %.09!%0)*4/h)0#!/0C.! $3.!&8.%%.0)$*!/&%.! .P;.#4*8.+!@4! )%*$*)*4/!/0C.4!4()3!1*%*#A4!/&%.!.P;.#4*8.T!$3.!1*%*#A4!4$&;!J.*#A!$3.!)3.0;!S07!&($+!! "#'..'T! $3.4.! 0%.! a! /&'.4$! 4$.;4+! 23.7! /07! 3.9;! ;%&$.)$! /0*#`4$%.0/!4;..)3!1%&/!&))04*	!4(;;%.44*&#T!J($!$3.7!S*99!'&!9*$$9.!$&!;%&$.)$!1%&/!;%*80$.!%.$09*0$*&#!$3.!4;..)3!$30$!/&4$!;.&;9.!$3*#C!*4!)&#$./;$*J9.+!23.7!S&(9'!308.!'&#.!9*$$9.!$&!4$&;!J90)C9*4$4!&1!A.#(*#.!-&//(#*4$4T!0#'!$3.7!S*99!'&!9*$$9.!$&!/0C.!%0)*4$4!&%!e@6ER@!/./J.%4!1..9!1%..!$&!4;.0C!$3.*%!/*#'4!S*$3&($!1.0%!&1!9&4*#A!$3.*%!g&J4+!! E($!"!'&#K$!$3*#C!$3*4!*4!;0%$*)(90%97!J0'+!>.&;9.!S3&4.!*'.&9&A*.4!0%.!%*A3$97!)&#'./#.'!$.#'!$&!J.!)&4$97!./;9&7..4!04!S.99!04!J0'!;.&;9.+!@#'!./;9&7.%4!43&(9'!J.!1%..!$&!4$&;!;07*#A!0!4090%7!$&!;.&;9.!S3&4.!)&4$4!$&!$3.!./;9&7.%!.P)..'!$3.*%!J.#.1*$4+!
III Subpoenas of Information About People’s First Amendment
Activities
! ib?0JJ*! 60Pj! 5099! *4! '*4$%.44.'! 0$! $3.! .)3&.4! &1! 6)-0%$37*4/! 3.!3.0%4! $&'07+! 23.! XB@! >0$%*&$! @)$T! b0/&#A! &$3.%! $3*#A4j!+!+!+!099&S4!!*#8.4$*A0$&%4! $&! *#4;.)$! 9*J%0%7! %.)&%'4+! p"$! J&$3.%4!/.! 8.%7!/()3TK!5099!40*'+! \(4$! 04! 3.!S04! J&$3.%.'! =N! 7.0%4! 0A&! J7! b6)-0%$37*4/j+kDNN!X#'.%!$3*4! ie.S! 6)-0%$37*4/Tk! 0#&$3.%! )&//.#$0$&%! S%*$.4T! ib7j&(! 0%.! #&!9&#A.%! 1%..! $&! ;0$%&#*^.! 0! J&&C4$&%.! S*$3&($! 1.0%! &1! A&8.%#/.#$!!4)%($*#7+kDND!! @4! *$!30;;.#4T! $3.!>0$%*&$!@)$!304!#&!4;.)*09!;%&8*4*!%.A0%'*#A!9*`J%0%7! 4(J;&.#04T! 0#'! *$4! A.#.%09! 4(J;&.#0! ;%&8*4*&#h4.)$*&#! ,D=! &1! $3.!@)$h*4#K$!;0%$*)(90%97!#&8.9O!23.!A&8.%#/.#$!304! 9&#A!30'! $3.!;&S.%! $&!4(J;&.#0! 9&$4! &1! %.)&%'4T! *#)9('*#A! 9*J%0%7! %.)&%'4T! 4*/;97! J7! (4*#A! $3.!#&%/09! A%0#'! g(%7! 4(J;&.#0+DN,! B$*99T! S3*9.! $3.! >0$%*&$! @)$! *4#K$! 0$! 10(9$!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! cc+! %##$@5&"2!>0%$!""+E+!E&$3!)04.4!*#8&98.'!&#`$3.`g&J!4;..)3a!1*%*#A4!J04.'!&#!4*/*90%!&11`$3.`g&J!4;..)3!S&(9'!.8.#!/&%.!)9.0%97!J.!&8.%%.0)$*&#+!!! DNN+! E%.#$!:099.#J.)CT!=(#*$0'12"+(3)@D$I)+$?#"D.*+T!Burlington Free PressT!B.;$+!HT!,NNMT!0$!D@+!%##[email protected]!#K-KT!E.447!?.7#0T!A.#+$E@#@$I#"$,"+$+.$!)-(+$%.')27$9*b5@+)'#T!Hartford CourantT!@;%+!,NT!,NNMT!0$!_D+!! DND+! 60$$3.S!?&$34)3*9'T!6(#$<#N$0'12"+(3)@DT!ProgressiveT!\0#+!DT!,NN,T!0$!,N+!! DN,+! L&%!0!4$0$.!)04.!*#8&98*#A!0!#&%/09!4(J;&.#0!4.%8.'!0A0*#4$!0!9*J%0%7T!4..!E%&S#!8+!\&3#4$&#T!M,l!e+5+,'!=DNT!=D,!U"&S0!DclMV+!!! "!308.!10(9$.'!4.)$*&#!,D=!1&%!099&S*#A!$3.!A&8.%#/.#$!$&!4(J;&.#0!%.)&%'4!0#'!0$!$3.!40/.!$*/.!&%'.%! $3.! 4(J;&.#0! %.)*;*.#$4! #&$! $&! '*4)9&4.! $3.! 4(J;&.#0K4! .P*4$.#).+! 23*4! ;%&8*4*&#! 0#'! 4*/*90%!;%&8*4*!$30$!308.!9&#A!.P*4$.'!*#!&$3.%!4(J;&.#0T!4.0%)3T!&%!S*%.$0;!4$0$($.4!0%.!4;..)3!%.4$%*)$*h$3.7! J0%! ;.&;9.! 1%&/! %.8.09*#A! ).%$0*#! *#1&%/0$*&#! $30$! /07! J.! %.9.80#$! $&! ;(J9*)! '.J0$.! 0J&($! $3.!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! MD$
! MD!
3.%.T! $3.%.! 4(%.97! *4! 0! ;90(4*J9.! 0%A(/.#$! 0A0*#4$! 9*J%0%7! 0#'! J&&C4$&%.!4(J;&.#04O!
UDV! ?.0'*#A!J&&C4!*4!)$*$($*ϥ!;%&$.)$.'!0)$*8*$7+!U,V! ?.0'*#A! ).%$0*#! J&&C4! )0#!/0C.! $3.! ;&9*).! 4(4;.)$! $30$! 7&(K%.!
;%&#.! $&! '&! *99.A09! $3*#A4! 0#'! )0#!/0C.! g(%*.4! $3*#C!7&(K%.! $3.!&#.!S3&! '*'! 4&/.! 0)$! 4(AA.4$.'! J7! $3&4.! J&&C4+! 23*4!/07! J.!$%(.! &1! J&/J/0C*#A! /0#(094T! ;%&`-&//(#*4$! ;%&;0A0#'0T! &%!%0)*4$! $%0)$4+! "$! /07! 094&! J.! $%(.! &1! )3./*4$%7! $.P$J&&C4! $30$!!'*4)(44! .P;9&4*8.4T! J&&C4! $30$! 30%4397! )&#'./#! A&8.%#/.#$!;&9*)*.4T! &%! 4)3&90%97! 8&9(/.4! &#! 4(;;&4.'! A.#.$*)! '*11.%.#).4!0/&#A!$3.!%0).4+!e0$(%0997T!#&$!.8.%7&#.!S3&!%.0'4!4()3!J&&C4!S*99! 0$$%0)$! ;&9*).! 0$$.#$*&#+!E($! *1! $3.! ;&9*).! 0%.! $%7*#A! $&! 1*#'!&($!S3&K4!*#8&98.'!*#!4&/.!J&/J!;9&$T!4(J8.%4*8.!)*%0)7T!&%!30$.! )%*/.T! $3.7! /*A3$! $%7! $&! (4.! %.0'*#A! %.)&%'4! $&! *'.#$*17!!;&$.#$*09!4(4;.)$4+!
UMV! "1! $3.! ;&9*).! )0#! .04*97! 9.0%#! S3&! J&(A3$! &%! J&%%&S.'! ).%$0*#!J&&C4T! $3.#! 4&/.! ;.&;9.! /07! J.! '.$.%%.'! 1%&/! %.0'*#A!!4(4;*)*&(4!J&&C4+!
UFV! 23.%.1&%.T! S.! 43&(9'! *#$.%;%.$! $3.! L*%4$! @/.#'/.#$! 04!!;%&3*J*$*#AT!&%!0$!9.04$!430%;97!9*/*$*#AT!4(J;&.#04!1&%!J&&C4$&%.!&%!9*J%0%7!%.)&%'4+!
! "#!,NN,T!$3.!-&9&%0'&!B(;%./.!-&(%$!0)).;$.'!$3*4!8.%7!0%A(/.#$!*#!3&9'*#A! $30$! $3.! -&9&%0'&! -$*$($*&#! J0%%.'! 4(J;&.#04! &%! 4.0%)3.4! &1!J&&C4$&%.! %.)&%'4! (#9.44! ;%&4.)($&%4! )&(9'! i'./$%0$.! 0! 4(11*)*.#$97!)&/;.99*#A!#..'!1&%!$3.!4;.)*1*)!)(4$&/.%!;(%)304.!%.)&%'k!0#'!*#!;0%$*)(`90%! $30$! $3.%.! 0%.! #&! i%.04�J9.! 09$.%#0$.! S074! &1! )&#'()$*#A! 0#!!*#8.4$*A0$*&#!&$3.%!$30#!J7!4.*^*#A!0!)(4$&/.%K4!J&&C!;(%)304.!%.)&%'+kDNM!23*4!*4!0!'.9*J.%0$.97!'./0#'*#A!4$0#'0%'T!/()3!3*A3.%!$30#!$3.!(4(09!4$0#`'0%'! 1&%! 4(J;&.#04! U$30$! $3.%.K4! 0! i%.04�J9.! ;&44*J*9*$7! b$30$! $3.!!4(J;&.#0j!+!+!+!S*99!;%&'().! *#1&%/0$*&#! %.9.80#$! $&! $3.! b*#8.4$*A0$*&#jkDNFV!&%! .8.#! $3.! ;%&J0J9.! )0(4.! 4$0#'0%'! 1&%! 4.0%)3.4+! 23*4! 9&A*)! 43&(9'! 094&!0;;97!$&!9*J%0%7!%.)&%'4+!! @#'!$3.%.!*4!;%.).'.#$!1&%!$3*4!4&%$!&1!%.4$%*)$*&#!&#!$3.!A&8.%#/.#$K4!*#8.4$*A0$*8.!;&S.%4O!23.!-&(%$!304!9&#A!%.4$%*)$.'!$3.!A&8.%#/.#$K4!0J*9`*$7!$&!1&%)*J97!'*4)&8.%!S3&!J.9&#A4!$&!&%!)&#$%*J($.4!$&!.P;%.44*8.!044&)*0`$*T! ;%.)*4.97! J.)0(4.! A&8.%#/.#$! 4)%($*#7! /07! '.$.%! ;.&;9.! 1%&/!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!A&8.%#/.#$K4!*#8.4$*A0$*8.!;%0)$*).4h0#'!"!$3*#C!$3.7!0%.!(#)$*$($*	T!$3&(A3!(#'.%4$0#'0J9.+!%##!<(A.#.!Z&9&C3T!1")D#S!2')7)+2+)*-$%&##'(T!=H!Stan. L. Rev.!DNc=T!.4;.)*0997!DDNN!#+,c!U,NN=V+!E($!S3.$3.%!;.&;9.!/07!J.!&%'.%.'!$&!%./0*#!f(*.$!0J&($!$3.!4(J;&.#04!*4!0!4.;0%0$.!*44(.!1%&/!S3.$3.%!$3.!4(J;&.#04!43&(9'!J.!;.%/*44*J9.!*#!$3.!1*%4$!;90).+!! DNM+! 20$$.%.'!-&8.%T! "#)+! 8+!-*$7! &1!23&%#$&#T! FF!>+M'!DNFFT! DN=c! U-&9&+! ,NN,Va! @##$ 27@.$ 9*$ "#$_%0#'! \(%7! B(J;&.#0! $&! [%0/.%J&&C4! m! @1$.%S&%'4T! "#)+T! ,o! 6.'+! R+! ?;$%+! D=cc! UI+I+-+! DcclV!U%.0)3*#A!0!4*/*90%!%.4(9$V+!!! DNF+! X#*$.'!B$0$.4!8+!?+!<#$.%4+T!Fcl!X+B+!,c,T!MND!UDccDV+!
M,! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!M,!
;0%$*)*;0$*#A! *#! 4()3! A%&(;4+DN=!R*C.S*4.T!/0#7! )*%)(*$! )&(%$4! 308.! %.9*.'!&#!$3*4!0%A(/.#$!*#!A%0#$*#A!g&(%#09*4$4!0!f(09*1*.'!;%*8*9.A.!#&$!$&!%.8.09!$3.!*'.#$*$*.4!&1!)*'.#$*09!4&(%).4+DNo!! n.$!0;;.09*#A!04!$3*4!0%A(/.#$!/*A3$!4../T!)*'.%!*$4!)9&4.!0#09&AO!
UDV! B;.0C*#A!&%!4.#'*#A!./0*9!*4!)$*$($*ϥ!;%&$.)$.'!0)$*8*$7+!U,V! B07*#A!&%!S%*$*#A!).%$0*#!$3*#A4!)0#!/0C.!$3.!;&9*).!4(4;.)$!7&(!
&1!80%*&(4!*99.A09!)&#'()$!0#'!)0#!/0C.!g(%*.4!$3*#C!7&(K%.!A(*9$7!&1! 4()3! )&#'()$+! 23*4! /07! J.! $%(.! &1! ;%&`$.%%&%*4$T!!;%&`-&//(#*4$T! &%! %0)*4$! 4$0$./.#$4T! 04!S.99! 04! 4$0$./.#$4! $30$!0%.! S.99`*#$.#$*&#.'! J($! /*A3$! J.! *#$.%;%.$.'! 04! ;%&`$.%%&%*4$T!;%&`-&//(#*4$T!&%!%0)*4$+!
UMV! "1! $3.! ;&9*).! U&%! )*8*9! 9*$*A0#$4V! )0#! .04*97! 9.0%#!S3&! 40*'!S30$T!$3.#! 4&/.! ;.&;9.! /07! J.! '.$.%%.'! 1%&/! 407*#A! &%! S%*$*#A!!4(4;*)*&(4!$3*#A4+!
UFV! 23.%.1&%.T! S.! 43&(9'! *#$.%;%.$! $3.! L*%4$! @/.#'/.#$! 04!!;%&3*J*$*#AT! &%! 0$! 9.04$! 430%;97! 9*/*$*#AT! 4(J;&.#04! './0#'*#A!$30$!;.&;9.!$.4$*17!0J&($!S30$!4&/.&#.!40*'!&%!S%&$.+!
! 23.! $S&! 0%A(/.#$4! 0%.! 4*/*90%h7.$! $3.! 90$$.%! 0%A(/.#$! *4! f(*$.!(#9*C.97! $&!;%.80*9+!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$! 90S!'&.4#K$!J0%! $3.!;&9*).! 1%&/! *#`8.4$*A0$*#A!S30$!4(4;.)$4!308.!40*'!&%!S%*$$.#!$&!0)f(0*#$0#).4T!&%!S3&!304!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! DN=+! %##!e@@->!8+!@90J0/0!#X$ "#7K!>0$$.%4&#T!M=H!X+B+!FFcT!Fo,`oM! UDc=lV+!J5'P7#3$ BK$?27#.T!F,F! X+B+! D! UDcHoVT! (;3.9'! 0! %.f(*%./.#$! $30$! ;.&;9.K4! ;&9*$*)09! )&#$%*J($*! 0#'! .P;.#'*$(%.4! J.!'*4)9&4.'T!'.4;*$.!$3.!;&$.#$*09!'.$.%%.#$!.11.)$!&#!4()3!J.308*&%+!E($!J".N*$BK$%.')27)@+$=."P#"@$Vcd$12D&2)-*$1.DDKT!F=c!X+B+!lH!UDcl,VT!3.9'!$30$!.8.#!$3*4!%.f(*%./.#$!/(4$!J.!S0*8.'!S3.#!0!/*#&%!;0%$7! $&!S3*)3! $3.! )&#$%*J($*&#! *4!/0'.! *4! (#;&;(90%! .#&(A3! $30$! $3.! '.$.%%.#$! .11.)$! *4! 9*C.97! $&! J.!.4;.)*0997!4.8.%.+!&& 23.!-&(%$! 304! 094&! A.#.%0997! 4$%()C! '&S#! %.f(*%./.#$4! $30$! ;.&;9.! *'.#$*17! $3./4.98.4! *#! $3.*%!;(J9*)0$*+! %##M$ #K-KT$ 6)"#$7%.! 8+! G3*&! <9.)$*! -&//K#T! =DF! X+B+! MMFT! M=H! UDcc=V+! B()3!%.f(*%./.#$4T! $3&(A3T!#&$!a!'.$.%! ).%$0*#!C*#'4!&1! 4;..)3T!J($! 094&! 1&%)*J97! )30#A.! $3.! )&#$.#$!&1!4;..)3O!23.7!J0%!4;..)3!&1!0!).%$0*#!)&#$.#$!U(#4*A#.'!/0$.%*09V!0#'!/0#'0$.!$3.!*#)9(4*&#!&1!)&#$.#$!U$3.! 0($3&%K4! #0/.V! $30$! $3.! 0($3&%! /*A3$! S0#$! $&! 08&*'+! 23.! -&(%$! $3(4! 3.9'! $3.! *'.#$*1*)0$*&#!%.f(*%./.#$4! $&! J.! (#)$*$($*	! ;0%$97! J.)0(4.! $3.7! 0%.! i0! '*%.)$! %.A(90$*&#! &1! $3.! )&#$.#$! &1!4;..)3Tk!)LK!0$!MF=T!0!g(4$*1*)0$*&#!$30$!'&.4#K$!0;;97!.f(0997!$&!#&%/09!'*4)&8.%7!%.f(.4$4T!S3*)3!'&#K$!'*%.)$97!%.A(90$.!$3.!)&#$.#$!&1!0!;(J9*)0$*&#+!! DNo+! %##M$#K-KT!2*$0#!B;&%$4T!"#)+!8+!2(%#.%!E%&0'+!B74+!U9*$"#!60''.#VT!D=D!L+M'!D,=T!D,l`,c!UM'!-*%+!DcclVa!X#*$.'!B$0$.4!8+!B/*$3T!DM=!L+M'!coMT!cHD!U=$3!-*%+!DcclVa!B3&.#!8+!B3&.#T!=!L+M'!D,lcT!D,c,`cM!Uc$3!-*%+!DccMVa!X#*$.'!B$0$.4!8+!R&#A!U9*$"#!B30*#VT!cHl!L+,'!l=NT!l=,!UF$3!-*%+!Dcc,Va!X#*$.'!B$0$.4!8+!R0?&()3.!-0/;0*A#T!lFD!L+,'!DDHoT!DDlD`l,!UD4$!-*%+!DcllVa!Z&#!E(9&S!8+!Z&#!E(9&ST!lDD!L+,'!DMoT!DF,!U,'!-*%+!DclHVa!X#*$.'!B$0$.4!8+!-0;&%09.T!lNo!L+,'!DFlHT!D=NF!UDD$3!-*%+!DcloVa!].%*99*!8+!B/*$3T!o=o!L+,'!HN=T!HDF!UI+-+!-*%+!DclDVa!B*9CS&&'!8+
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! MM$
! MM!
40*'!&%!S%*$$.#!4&/.$3*#A!$30$!/*A3$!/0C.!3*/!0!4(4;.)$+DNH!e&%!'&.4!*$!J0%!;%&4.)($&%4! 1%&/! (4*#A! 4(J;&.#04! &%! &$3.%! $.)3#*f(.4! $&! )&.%).! $3.! 4(4`;.)$K4!0)f(0*#$0#).4!*#$&!$.4$*17*#A!0J&($!4()3!$3*#A4+DNl!B07!$3.!;&9*).!0%.!*#8.4$*A0$*#A!$3.!C*99*#A!&1!0#!0J&%$*&#!;%&8*'.%T! $3.!J&/J*#A!&1!0!1.'.%09!J(*9'*#AT! &%! $3.! J(%#*#A! &1! 0! J90)C! )3(%)3+! B(%.97! $3.7! S&(9'! 04C!0%&(#'O!53&! 304! J..#! 407*#A! $3*#A4! $30$! %.8.09! 0#! *'.&9&A*)09!/&$*8.! $&!)&//*$! $3.! )%*/.d!:04! $3*4!;0%$*)(90%! ;.%4&#! 4.#$!7&(!0#7!./0*9! $30$! %.`8.09.'!4()3!0!/&$*8.dDNc!23.4.!0%.!9.A*$*/0$.!0#'!809(0J9.!f(.4$*+DDN!! "1!#..'!J.T!$3.!;&9*).!/*A3$!$%7!$&!;%.44(%.!;.&;9.!$&!$09CT!&%!4(J;&.#0!$3./!$&!$.4$*17!J.1&%.!0!A%0#'!g(%7!&%!0$!$%*09+!53.#!$3.7!1*#'!0!4(4;.)$T!0#'!308.!;%&J0J9.!)0(4.!$&!J.9*.8.!$30$!3*4!)&/;($.%!)&#$0*#4!*#1&%/0$*&#!$30$!/*A3$!%.8.09!U0/&#A!&$3.%!$3*#A4V!0!/&$*8.T!$3.7!)0#!4.0%)3!$3.!4(4;.)$K4!1*9.4+! 23.7!/07! 4(J;&.#0! $3.! 4(4;.)$K4! "#$.%#.$! 4.%8*).! ;%&8*'.%! 1&%! %.`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a!2$/."+).")T!*$!'&.4#K$!J0%!*#f(*%*.4!0J&($!4()3!4$0$./.#$4+!! DNl+! %##M$ #K-KT! X#*8+! &1! >0+! 8+! <<G-T! FcM! X+B+! Dl,! UDccNV! U3&9'*#A! $30$! $3.%.! *4! #&! L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$!J0%!$&!4(J;&.#04!1&%!.8*'.#).!&1!S30$!;.&;9.!40*'!*#!$.#(%.!%.8*.S4Va!:.%J.%$!8+!R0#'&T!FFD!X+B+!D=M!UDcHcV!U9*C.S*4.!04!$&!S30$!;.&;9.!40*'!*#!.'*$&%*09`%&&/!).%.#).4V+!! DNc+! 23*4! 4;..)3! *4! 9*C.97! $&! J.! g(4$! 0/&#A! 1%*.#'4T! 0#'! #&$! *#$.#'.'! 1&%! ;(J9*)0$*&#a! J($! 4()3!4;..)3! *4! 0#! */;&%$0#$! ;0%$! &1! ;&9*$*)09! '.J0$.O!60#7! ;.&;9.! 0%.! /&%.! ;.%4(0'.'! J7! ;&9*$*)09!'*4)(44*! S*$3! 1%*.#'4! $3.7! $%(4$! $30#! J7! ;(J9*)! 4;..)3! $30$! )&/.4! 1%&/! 4$%0#A.%4+! %##! L%.'.%*)C!B)30(.%T!OA")B2+#Q$%&##'($2*L$ +(#$OA")B2+#Q$!."5D4$_*830#!8+!5.4$.%#!R*#.!B)3&&9!I*4$%*)$T!DcHc!Sup. Ct. Rev.!,DH!UDcHcV+!! DDN+! G#.! '*11.%.#).! J.$S..#! *#8.4$*A0$*#A! S30$! 4&/.&#.! 40*'! 0#'! S30$! 3.! %.0'! *4! $30$! S30$!;.&;9.!%.0'!*4!(4(0997!9.44!$.99*#A!$30#!S30$!$3.7!407+!"/0A*#.!$30$!$3.!;&9*).!&%!g(%&%4!0%.!$%7*#A!$&!1*#'!&($!S3.$3.%!0!;.%4&#!)&//*$$.'! 4&/.!30$.!)%*/.T!&%!S3.$3.%! $3.! )%*/.!3.!099.A.'97!)&//*$$.'!S04!*#'..'!/&$*80$.'!J7!%0)*09!3&4$*9*$7+!<8*'.#).!$30$!$3.!4(4;.)$!%.0'!0!4(;;&4.'97!%0)*4$!J&&C!S&#K$!J.!04! ;%&J0$*8.! &1! 3*4! 0)$*! &%! *#$.#$*! 04! .8*'.#).! $30$! 3.! .P;%.44.'! 4(;;&4.'97! %0)*4$! 8*.S4+!23.%.1&%.T!$3.!0%A(/.#$!/*A3$!A&T!$3.!;&9*).!308.!9.44!#..'!$&!'*4)&8.%!$3.!;.%4&#K4!%.0'*#A!30J*$4!$30#!$&!'*4)&8.%!3*4!;04$!4$0$./.#$4+!!! E($!1&%!$3*4!8.%7!%.04&#T!$3.!$3%.0$!&1!'*4)&8.%7!*4!9.44!9*C.97!$&!'.$.%!0!;.%4&#!1%&/!%.0'*#A!0!J&&C!$30#!1%&/!/0C*#A!0!4$0$./.#$+!"1!$3.!;.%4&#!*4!)&#$./;90$*#A!%.0'*#A!0!%0)*4$!J&&CT!3.!C#&S4!$30$!3.!)0#! 9*C.97!A*8.!0!;90(4*J9.! *##&).#$!.P;90#0$*&#O!:.!S04! g(4$! )(%*&(4!0J&($!S30$! $3*4!#&$&%*&(4!J&&C!%.0997! 40*'a! 3.! '&.4#K$! 0A%..! S*$3! $3.! J&&CK4! 8*.S4! J($! S0#$.'! $&! C#&S! S30$! $3.! &$3.%! 4*'.! S04!0%A(*#Aa!3.!40S!4&/.$3*#A!	*#.!;%0*4*#A! $3.!J&&C!0#'!;*)C.'! *$!(;!S*$3&($! %.0997!C#&S*#A!S30$! *$!)&#$0*#.'+!E($!*1!$3.!;.%4&#!*4!)&#$./;90$*#A!S%*$*#A!0!%0)*4$!./0*9T!3.!C#&S4!$30$!$3.!./0*9hS.%.!*$!$&!)&/.!$&!9*A3$hS&(9'!9*C.97!J.!/()3!/&%.!*#)%*/*#0$*#A+!! DDD+! %##M$ #K-KT! _.&%A.! E%0#'&#T!=."P#"@W$ =#C$ E@#$ 2$ H".N)*-$ 1.*'#"*$ /."$ 0."#$ >D&7.3#"@T!Kiplinger Bus. ForecastsT!L.J+!,DT!,NN=! Ui>90*#$*11! 0$$&%#.74! %&($*#.97! 4(J;&.#0!.`/0*9! %.)&%'4! *#!4.P(09! 30%044/.#$T! %0)*09! '*4)%*/*#0$*&#! 0#'! 3&4$*9.! S&%C! .#8*%&#/.#$! )04.4T! 4074! \.##*1.%! E%&S#!B30ST!0!;0%$#.%! *#! $3.!B0)%0/.#$&!&11*).!&1!./;9&7/.#$! 90S!1*%/!\0)C4&#!R.S*4+!@#'!S3.#!.`/0*94!S*$3! 4.P(0997! .P;9*)*$! &%! &$3.%! *#0;;%&;%*0$.! )&#$.#$! 0%.! *#$%&'().'! 04! .8*'.#).! *#! S&%C;90).!30%044/.#$! 90S4(*$4T! p$3.! f(.4$*&#! $30$! S*99! *#.8*$0J97! )&/.! (;! *4! S37! $3.! ./;9&7.%! '*'#K$! C#&STK!B30S!0''4+kVa!E*99!@$C*#4&#!m!B$0).7!:*%43T!_$>SD2)7K$02*3$8)B#@T!Balt. SunT!G)$+!DNT!,NNFT!0$!D-!Uip-30#).4!0%.!J*A!J%&$3.%!*4!%.0'*#A!&8.%!7&(%!.9.)$%&#*)!43&(9'.%+!"1!7&(!0%.!*#8&98.'!*#!0!S&%C;90).!
MF! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!MF!
! 23*4! #.).440%*97! 304! 0! '.$.%%.#$! .11.)$! &#! 4;.0C.%4+!<8.#! #*&9.#$!;.&;9.!S3&!3&9'!;%&`9*1.T! 0#$*`A&8.%#/.#$T!&%! %0)*4$!8*.S4!/*A3$!J.)&/.!%.9()$0#$! $&! .P;%.44! $3.4.! 8*.S4! $&! 0)f(0*#$0#).4T! .4;.)*0997! *#! S%*$*#A!U4()3! 04! ./0*9V+! "$K4! $%(.! $30$! J.)0(4.! J&&C4$&%.! %.)&%'4! )0#! J.! 4(J;&.`#0.'T!7&(!0%.#K$!i1%..!$&!;0$%&#*^.!0!J&&C4$&%.!S*$3&($!1.0%!&1!A&8.%#/.#$!4)%($*#7k!&1!S30$!7&(!%.0'+!E($!7&(!308.!#.8.%!J..#!1%..!$&!4;.0C!&%!./0*9!S*$3&($!1.0%!&1!4*/*90%!A&8.%#/.#$!4)%($*#7!&1!S30$!7&(!407!&%!S%*$.h7.$!$3*4! '.$.%%.#$! .11.)$! 304! #&$! ;%.8.#$.'! A&8.%#/.#$! *#8.4$*A0$*! &1!S3&!40*'!S30$+!-&(%$4!'&#K$!.8.#! %.f(*%.!;&9*).! $&!43&S!0!i)&/;.99*#A!#..'k!1&%! .0)3! ;*.).! &1! 4;..)3`%.90$.'! .8*'.#).! 1&%! S3*)3! $3.7! 4(J;&.#0! &%!4.0%)3+DD,&! 5.!4..T!$3.#T!0!$.#4*&#!*#!$3.!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$!90S!%.90$.'!$&!;&$.#`$*0997!4;..)3`'.$.%%*#A!A&8.%#/.#$!*#f(*%*.4+!G#!$3.!&#.!30#'T!$3.!90S!%.`4$%*)$4! )&.%)*8.! '*4)&8.%7! &1! S3&! J.9&#A4! $&! 0! A%&(;T! &%T! *#! 4&/.!g(%*4'*)$*T!S3&!40*'!4&/.$3*#A!$&!0!g&(%#09*4$+!G#!$3.!&$3.%!30#'T!*$!'&.4!#&$!%.4$%*)$!$3.!'*4)&8.%7!&1!S30$!0!4(4;.)$!40*'T!'*4)&8.%7!&1!S30$!(#*8.%`4*$7!;%&1.44&%4!40*'!*#!$.#(%.!%.8*.S4TDDM!&%!S30$!%.;&%$.%4!40*'!*#!.'*$&%*09!'*4)(44*!0J&($!0#!099.A.'97!9*J.9&(4!4$&%7TDDF!$3&(A3!4()3!'*4)&8.%7!)0#!'.$.%! ;.&;9.! 1%&/! 4;.0C*#A! )0#'*'97+DD=! @#'! #&$S*$34$0#'*#A! S30$! 4&/.!9&S.%!)&(%$4!308.!'&#.T!$3.!-&(%$K4!J"2*TC5"-$BK$I23#@!&;*#*&#!3.9'h0#'!$3.!-&(%$!90$.%!%.011*%/.'h$30$!;%&4.)($&%4!)0#!*#'..'!'*4)&8.%!$3.!#0/.4!&1!0!g&(%#09*4$K4!)*'.#$*09!4&(%).4+DDo$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!90S4(*$T! S3.$3.%! *$! *4! 4.P(09! 30%044/.#$T! %0)*09! '*4)%*/*#0$*&#T! S%&#A1(9! $.%/*#0$*&#T! 3&4$*9.! S&%C!.#8*%&#/.#$T!7&(!)0#!$0C.!*$!$&!$3.!J0#C!+!+!+!$30$!.`/0*9!*4!A&*#A!$&!J.!4(J;&.#0.'!0#'!(4.'!04!.8*'.#).!1&%!&%!0A0*#4$!7&(%!)04.+KkV!Uf(&$*#A!e0#)7!L97##T!i0($3&%!&1!4.8.%09!J&&C4!&#!.`/0*9kV+!! DD,+! %##$X#*$.'!B$0$.4!8+!?+!<#$.%4+T!Fcl!X+B+!,c,T!MND!UDccDV+!! DDM+! E*)BK$./$A2KT!FcM!X+B+!0$!Dl,+!G1!)&(%4.T!9*C.!099!4(J;&.#04T!4()3!4(J;&.#04!)&(9'!4..C!a!%.9.80#$!.8*'.#).T!J($!$30$K4!0#!.047!4$0#'0%'!$&!/..$+!! DDF+! :.%J.%$!8+!R0#'&T!FFD!X+B+!D=M!UDcHcV+!! DD=+! @4!<#N$G."P$6)D#@$1.K$BK$%577)B2*T!MHo!X+B+!,=FT!,HH!UDcoFVT!;&*#$.'!&($T!$3.!i1.0%!&1!b)*8*9j!'0/0A.!0S0%'4k!)0#!J.!0$!9.04$!04!i*#3*J*$*#A!b04j!1.0%!&1!;%&4.)($*&#+k!!! DDo+! -&3.#! 8+!-&S9.4!6.'*0!-&+T! =ND!X+B+! ooMT! ooc! UDccDV! U4$0$*#A! $30$! iA.#.%0997! 0;;9*)0J9.!90S4! '&! #&$! &11.#'! $3.! L*%4$! @/.#'/.#$! 4*/;97! J.)0(4.! $3.*%! .#1&%)./.#$! 0A0*#4$! $3.! ;%.44! 304!*#)*'.#$09!.11.)$4!&#!*$4!0J*9*$7!$&!A0$3.%!0#'!%.;&%$!$3.!#.S4Tk!0#'!#&$*#A!04!0#!.P0/;9.!$30$!i$3.!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$!b'&.4!#&$j!%.9*.8.!0!#.S4;0;.%!%.;&%$.%!&1!$3.!&J9*A0$*&#!430%.'!J7!099!)*$*^.#4!$&!%.4;&#'!$&! 0! A%0#'! g(%7! 4(J;&.#0! 0#'! 0#4S.%! f(.4$*! %.9.80#$! $&! 0! )%*/*#09! *#8.4$*A0$*&#T! .8.#! $3&(A3! $3.!%.;&%$.%!/*A3$!J.!%.f(*%.'!$&!%.8.09!0!)*'.#$*09!4&(%).kV!U)*$0$*&#!&/*$$.'Va!E*)BK$./$A2KT!FcM!X+B+!0$!,ND! U0#09&A*^*#A! $3.! )04.T! *#!S3*)3! $3.!-&(%$! %.g.)$.'! 0! ;%*8*9.A.T! $&!J"2*TC5"-T! 0#'! )30%0)$.%*^*#A!J"2*TC5"-$04!i%.g.)$b*#Aj!$3.!#&$*&#!$30$!(#'.%!$3.!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$!0!%.;&%$.%!)&(9'!#&$!J.!%.f(*%.'!$&!0;;.0%! &%! $&! $.4$*17! 04! $&! *#1&%/0$*&#! &J$0*#.'! *#! )*'.#).! S*$3&($! 0! 4;.)*09! 43&S*#A! $30$! $3.!%.;&%$.%K4! $.4$*/! S04! #.).440%7kVa! U>&S.99T! \+T! )&#)(%%*#AV! Ug&*#*#A! $3.! /0g&%*$7! &;*#*&#! 0#'!4;.)*1*)0997! %.g.)$*#A! $3.! f(09*1*.'! ;%*8*9.A.! ;%&;&4.'! J7! $3.! '*44.#$T! $3&(A3! .90J&%0$*#A! $30$!i30%044/.#$k! &1! g&(%#09*4$4! S*$3&($! i9.A*$*/0$.! #..'k! S&(9'! #&$! J.! 099&S.'! (#'.%! $3.! /0g&%*$7K4!&;*#*&#V+!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! M=$
! M=!
! 23.!4.0%)3!1&%!$%($3!*#!$3.!)&(%$%&&/T!9*C.!$3.!4.0%)3!1&%!$%($3!*#!;(J`9*)! '.J0$.T! (4(0997! J.#.1*$4! 1%&/! /&%.! *#1&%/0$*&#+DDH! 23.! L*%4$!!@/.#'/.#$!J0%4! $3.!A&8.%#/.#$! 1%&/!&($90S*#A!).%$0*#!4;..)3T!&%!/0C`*#A! *$! 4(Jg.)$! $&!)*8*9! 9*0J*9*$7+!E($! $3.! 9.A09! 474$./K4! *#8.4$*A0$*8.!;&S.%!/07!&1$.#!;%&;.%97!J.!(4.'! $&!(#)&8.%! %.9.80#$! .8*'.#).!.8.#!S3.#! $30$!'*4)&8.%7!/07!'.$.%!809(0J9.!4;..)3+!! 530$T! *1! 0#7$3*#AT! )0#! J.! '&#.! 0J&($! $3.4.! '.$.%%.#$! .11.)$4d! L*%4$T!)&(%$4! &%! 9.A*490$(%.4! )&(9'! *#'..'! */;&4.! './0#'*#A! 4$0#'0%'4! 1&%! 4(J`;&.#0*#A!&%!4.0%)3*#A!9*J%0%7!&%!J&&C4$&%.!%.)&%'4T!$3&(A3!#&$!1&%!'*4)&8`.%7!&1!S30$!;.&;9.!308.!40*'!&%!S%*$$.#+!23.!$3.&%7!S&(9'!J.!$30$!;.&;9.K4!%.0'*#A!30J*$4!U04!&;;&4.'!$&!;.&;9.K4!4$0$./.#$4V!0%.!*/;&%$0#$!.8*'.#).!*#!a!0! 1.S!)04.4T!4&! $3.! 9.A09!474$./!)0#!&;.%0$.!S.99!.#&(A3!S*$3&($!4()3!.8*'.#).+DDl!! n.$!%.0'*#A!30J*$4!0%.!;&$.#$*0997!%.9.80#$+!"#!$3.!X#0J&/J.%!)04.T!$3.!LE"!)&/J.'!9*J%0%7!%.)&%'4!1&%!;.&;9.!S3&!/*A3$!308.!J&%%&S.'!$S&!&J`4)(%.! U0#'! J7! $3./4.98.4! *##&).#$V! J&&C4! $30$! $3.! J&/J.%! f(&$.'! *#! 3*4!/0#*1.4$&a! (#1&%$(#0$.97T! $3.! LE"! )&(9'! 9&&C! a! *#! $3.! 1.S! A.&A%0;3*)!0%.04!$&!S3*)3!$3.7!30'!9*#C.'!$3.!J&/J.%T!4&!$3.!4.0%)3.4!'*'#K$!3.9;+DDc!>&9*).!$%0)C*#A!$3.!]&'*0)!4.%*09!C*99.%!#&$*).'!$30$!$3.!C*99.%K4!/&'(4!&;.%`0#'*!4../.'!$&!J.!*#4;*%.'!J7!0!B)&$$*43!/74$*)K4!J&&C4!US3*)3!S.%.!0A0*#!J7! $3./4.98.4! *##&).#$VT! 0#'! $3.! ;&9*).! $3(4! 4(J;&.#0.'! $3.! %.)&%'4! &1!;.&;9.!S3&! 30'! J&%%&S.'! $3.! J&&C4! 1%&/! 9&)09! 9*J%0%*.4+D,N!@! '*4)9&4(%.!%(9.!$30$K4!'./0#'*#A!.#&(A3!$&!'*/*#*43!%.0'.%4K!1.0%4!$30$!$3.!;&9*).!)0#!9.0%#! S30$! $3.7K%.! %.0'*#A! S*99! 094&! 4(J4$0#$*0997! *#$.%1.%.! S*$3! $3.4.!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! DDH+! %##M$ #K-KT!X#*$.'!B$0$.4!8+!e*P&#T!FDl!X+B+!olMT!HNc`DN! UDcHFV+!e0$(%0997T! $3.! 0#09&A7!)0#!a!A&!4&!10%O!2*/.!)$%0*#$4T!1&%!*#4$0#).T!#.).440%*97!%.f(*%.!4&/.!$%($31(9!.8*'.#).!$&!J.!.P)9('.'!04!'(;9*)0$*8.!&%!$&&!$0#A.#$*09+!! DDl+! %##$27@.$@5&"2$#&$.!DDN!U%.4;&#'*#A!$&!0#&$3.%!8.%4*&#!&1!$3*4!0%A(/.#$V+!! DDc+! %##!R0#).!_07T!%5@&#'+$!)+$A"./)7#$C5+$=#*+$E**.+)'#LT$Plain DealerT!@;%+!oT!DccoT!0$!H@!U#&$*#A!$30$!$3.!;&9*).!4.0%)3.'!%.)&%'4!*#!$3.!B0#!L%0#)*4)&!0%.0!0#'!$3.!-3*)0A&!0%.0Va!_0%7!60%P!m!>.$.%
Mo! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!Mo!
*#8.4$*A0$*+D,D! @#'! 1&)(4*#A! &#! $3.! %0%.! 4(J;&.#04! $30$! '.$.%! %.0'*#A!S*$3&($!'&*#A!0#7$3*#A!0J&($! $3.!/&%.!)&//&#!4(J;&.#04! $30$!'.$.%!0)`$(09!4;..)3!U&%!S%*$*#AV!/07!J.!0!90%A.97!./;$7!4$.;+!! B.)&#'T! )&(%$4! &%! 9.A*490$(%.4! )&(9'! */;&4.! 0! 3*A3.%! $3%.43&9'! 1&%!J&&C4$&%.!0#'!9*J%0%7!4(J;&.#04!$30#!&#!#&%/09!4(J;&.#04T!J($!#&$!0!/()3!3*A3.%!4$0#'0%'+!23*4!S&(9'!*#$.%1.%.!9.44!S*$3!A&8.%#/.#$!*#8.4$*A0$*T!J($! *$! S*99! 094&! '&! 9*$$9.! $&! 40$*417! %.0'.%4K! )&#).%#4! 0J&($! 0! )3*99*#A! .1`1.)$+D,,!5.K99!4$*99!J.!(#0J9.!$&!;0$%&#*^.!0!9*J%0%7!&%!J&&C4$&%.!S*$3&($!1.0%!&1!A&8.%#/.#$!4)%($*#7T!.8.#!$3&(A3!$3.!4)%($*#7!/*A3$!%.f(*%.!0!J*$!/&%.!g(4$*1*)0$*&#!&#!$3.!A&8.%#/.#$K4!;0%$+!! 23*%'T!)&(%$4!&%!9.A*490$(%.4!)&(9'!)$%0*#!'*4)&8.%7!&1!0#7!*#1&%/0`$*&#!%.90$.'!$&!0#7!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$`;%&$.)$.'!0)$*8*$*.4+!L&%!.P0/;9.T!S.!)&(9'!%.f(*%.!$3.!;&9*).!$&!;044!0!3*A3!$3%.43&9'!J.1&%.!$3.7!)&(9'!*#8.4$*`A0$.!S30$! ;.&;9.! 40*'! &%!S%&$.T! 0$! 9.04$!S3.#! $3.! 4;..)3!304! 4&/.! *'.&`9&A*)09! )&/;&#.#$+! G%! ;.%30;4! S.! )&(9'! './0#'! $3*4! $3%.43&9'!%.f(*%./.#$! a! 1&%! )&.%)*8.! *#8.4$*A0$*! U(4*#A! 4(J;&.#04! &%! 4.0%)3!S0%%0#$4VT! 0#'! #&$! 4*/;9.! f(.4$*&#*#A+D,M! 23.! 40/.! %(9.!/07! 094&! J.! 0;`;9*.'! $&! 4(J;&.#04! *#! )*8*9! )04.4T! $3(4! %.8.%4*#A!I#"C#"+$ BK$ 82*L.! 0#'!!E*)B#"@)+3$./$A#**@37B2*)2$BK$>>:1+!n.$!$3*4!S&(9'!'%0/0$*)0997!*#$.%1.%.!S*$3!$3.!*#8.4$*A0$*&#!&1!/0#7!)%*/.4!0#'!$&%$4T!.4;.)*0997!$3&4.!$30$!308.!0#!*'.&9&A*)09!/&$*8.+!! G%T! 1&(%$3T! )&(%$4! 0#'! 9.A*490$(%.4! )&(9'! )&#)9('.! $30$! $3.! '.$.%%.#$!.11.)$4!&1!4(J;&.#04!1&%!9*J%0%7!&%!J&&C4$&%.!%.)&%'4!0%.!0)).;$0J9.T!g(4$!04!$3.! '.$.%%.#$! .11.)$4! &1! 4(J;&.#04! 1&%! $.4$*/! 0J&($! 0! ;.%4&#K4! 4$0$.`/.#$4!0%.!0)).;$0J9.+!"#!$3*4T!$3.7!S&(9'!4*/;97!J.!1&99&S*#A!$3.!9&A*)!&1!J"2*TC5"-T!I#"C#"+T!0#'!E*)B#"@)+3$./$A#**@37B2*)2+!! E($!*#!0#7!.8.#$T!*$K4!0!/*4$0C.!$&!8*.S!4(J;&.#04!&1!9*J%0%7!&%!J&&C`4$&%.! %.)&%'4! 04! 0! %0'*)09! *##&80$*&#+! 23.7! 0%.! 4*/;97! 4;.)*09! )04.4! &1! 0!/&%.!A.#.%09!0#'!S.99`.4$0J9*43.'!;3.#&/.#&#T!4(J;&.#04!&1!*#1&%/0$*&#!%.90$.'! $&!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$!0)$*8*$*.4+!B&/.!4()3!4(J;&.#04T! 1&%! *#4$0#).!4(J;&.#04!&1!/./J.%43*;!%.)&%'4T!0%.!;%.4(/;$*8.97!1&%J*''.#+!n.$!&$3.%4!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! D,D+! %##!E*)BK$ ./$ A2KT$ FcM! X+B+! 0$! DcF! UDccNV! Ui6&%.&8.%T! S.! 0A%..! S*$3! $3.! <<G-! $30$! $3.!0'&;$*&#! &1! 0! %.f(*%./.#$! $30$! $3.! -&//*44*&#! './$%0$.! 0! p4;.)*1*)! %.04&#! 1&%!'*4)9&4(%.K!+!+!+!J.7&#'!0!43&S*#A!&1!%.9.80#).T!S&(9'!;90).!0!4(J4$0#$*09!9*$*A0$*&#`;%&'()*#A!&J4$0)9.!*#! $3.!S07! &1! $3.!-&//*44*&#K4! .11&%$4! $&! *#8.4$*A0$.! 0#'! %./.'7! 099.A.'! '*4)%*/*#0$*&#+kV! U)*$0$*&#!&/*$$.'V+!! D,,+! %##! )LK! 0$! ,NN! Ui6&%.&8.%T! 4&/.! '*4)9&4(%.! &1! ;..%! .809(0$*! S&(9'! $0C.! ;90).! .8.#! *1!;.$*$*&#.%K4!p4;.)*09!#.).44*$7K!$.4$!S.%.!0'&;$.'+!23(4T!$3.!p)3*99*#A!.11.)$K!;.$*$*&#.%!1.0%4!*4!0$!/&4$!a!*#)%./.#$0997!S&%4.#.'!J7!$3.!0J4.#).!&1!0!;%*8*9.A.+kV+!! D,M+! E(9C! 4.*^(%.4! &1! /0#7! )&;*.4! &1! J&&C4! 0#'! 1*9/4! 0%.! 4(Jg.)$! $&! 4;.)*09! L*%4$! 0#'! L&(%$3!@/.#'/.#$! %.4$%*)$*T! J.)0(4.! $3.%.! *4! 0! %*4C! $30$! 4()3! 0! 4.*^(%.!S&(9'! ;374*)0997! ;%.8.#$! ;.&;9.!1%&/! J(7*#AT! %.0'*#AT! &%! S0$)3*#A! )$*$($*ϥ! ;%&$.)$.'! /0$.%*09+! L&%$! 507#.! E&&C4T! "#)+! 8+!"#'*0#0T! Flc! X+B+! FoT! o,`oF! UDclcV+! E($! 4.*^(%.4! &1! *#'*8*'(09! *$./4! $&! J.! (4.'! 04! .8*'.#).! 0%.!A.#.%0997! ;.%/*44*J9.! (#'.%! $3.! #&%/09! ;%&J0J9.! )0(4.! 4$0#'0%'T! 4(Jg.)$! a! $&! 49*A3$97! *#)%.04.'!;%&).'(%09!%.f(*%./.#$4+!:.99.%!8+!e.S!n&%CT!FDM!X+B+!FlMT!Fc,`cM!UDcHMV+!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! MH$
! MH!
0%.! A.#.%0997! 099&S.'! .8.#! S3.#! $3.7! /07! '.$.%! ;.&;9.! 1%&/! 407*#A! &%!S%*$*#A!4(4;*)*&(4`4../*#A!$3*#A4+!! >.%30;4! $3.!L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$! $.4$! 43&(9'!J.!'*11.%.#$! 1&%! 4(J;&.#04!0J&($!%.0'*#A!$30#!1&%!4(J;&.#04!0J&($!4;.0C*#A!&%!S%*$*#AhJ($!$30$!)&#`)9(4*&#!*4!10%!1%&/!&J8*&(4+!@#'!*$!30%'97!4../4!6)-0%$37*$.!$&!$%.0$!4(J`;&.#04! &1! J&&C4$&%.! 0#'! 9*J%0%7! %.)&%'4! 9*C.! $3.! 4(J;&.#04! 1&%! 4;..)3`%.90$.'!*#1&%/0$*&#!$30$!$3.!)&(%$4!308.!%&($*#.97!(;3.9'+!
Conclusion: A Thought Experiment
! L*%4$!@/.#'/.#$!90S!%*A3$97!%.)&A#*^.4!$30$!90S4!)0#!308.!0!i)3*99*#A!.11.)$+k!R*J.9!90S4!/07T!&#!$3.*%!10).T!;%&3*J*$!a!1094.!4;..)3T!J($!$3.7!/07!094&!'.$.%! $%(.!4;..)3+D,F!Z0A(.! 90S4!/07!)0(4.!;.&;9.! $&!i4$..%! 10%!S*'.%! &1! $3.! (#90S1(9! ^&#.k! $30#! )9.0%! 90S4T! 0#'! /07! $3(4! '.$.%! /&%.!4;..)3!$30#!$3.7!(9$*/0$.97!;(#*43+D,=!!! E($!#&$!099!0)$*!$30$!'.$.%!4;..)3!0%.!(#)$*$($*	!&%!.8.#!*/`;%&;.%+!B&/.!4;..)3!43&(9'!J.!'.$.%%.'+!G#.!%.04&#!$30$!.8*9!0#'!&11.#4*8.!4;..)3! )0#! %./0*#! )$*$($*ϥ! (#;(#*43.'! *4! $30$! *$! *4! C.;$! *#! )3.)C!$3%&(A3!4&)*09!#&%/4!0#'!.)&#&/*)!%.$09*0$*&#+D,o!! ?0)*4$!4;..)3!*4!0!)9044*)!.P0/;9.O!60#7!;.&;9.T!*#)9('*#A!$3&4.!S3&!308.!4&/.!%0)*4$!8*.S4T!0%.!9*C.97!%.9()$0#$!$&!407!%0)*4$!$3*#A4!1&%!1.0%!&1!4&)*09! &;;%&J%*(/+! 6.'*0! &($9.$4! A.#.%0997! %.1(4.! $&! )0%%7! %0)*4$! ;%&;0`A0#'0+!G($9.$4!$30$!'&!)0%%7!%0)*4$!/0$.%*09!/07!10).!.)&#&/*)!%.$09*0$*&#+!! @$!$*/.4T!$3*4!304!9.'!$&!$&&!/()3!4;..)3!J.*#A!'.$.%%.'+!E($T!&#!J09`0#).T!)3.)C*#A!%0)*4$!4;..)3!$3%&(A3!4&)*09!0#'!/0%C.$!;%.44(%.4h04!S.99!04!$3%&(A3!;.%4(04*&#h*4!0!A&&'!4&9($*&#+!"$K4!J.$$.%!$30#!4(;;%.44*#A!%0)`*4$!4;..)3!$3%&(A3!9.A09!40#)$*+!@#'!*$K4!J.$$.%!$30#!#&$!$%7*#A!$&!'.$.%!*$!0$!099T!&%!)*#*#A!&(%4.98.4!$&!;&9*$.!;.%4(04*&#T!/()3!04!S.!'&!1&%!.%%&`#.&(4!8*.S4!0J&($!$0P!;&9*)7!&%!3*A3S07`)$%()$*&#!1(#'4+!! e0$(%0997T!S3*)3!'.$.%%.#$4!0%.!;%&;.%!0#'!S3*)3!0%.#K$! *4!0!'*11*)(9$!f(.4$*&#+!@4!0!A.#.%09!/0$$.%T!'.$.%%.#).!$3%&(A3!10)$(0997!0))(%0$.!'.#(#`)*0$*&#! 0#'! 4&)*09! &;;%&J%*(/! U>0%$! "V! *4! 9*C.97! $3.! 9.04$! $%&(J9.4&/.+!!I.$.%%.#).!$3%&(A3!;%*80$.!.)&#&/*)!;%.44(%.!U>0%$!""V!*4!;&$.#$*0997!$%&(`J9.4&/.T!J($!4$*99!&1$.#!0)).;$0J9.+!I.$.%%.#).!04!0#!.11.)$!&1! $3.!A&8.%#`/.#$K4! )&.%)*8.! *#8.4$*A0$*8.! $&&94T! 4()3! 04! 4(J;&.#04! U>0%$! """VT! *4!;&$.#$*0997!/&%.!$%&(J9.4&/.T!J($!;%&J0J97!*#.8*$0J9.!0#'!;%&;.%!*#!0$!9.04$!4&/.! 4*$(0$*+!E($! "K/! 4(%.! $30$! $3.%.! 0%.! .P).;$*! $&!/0#7! &1! $3.4.!A.#.%09*$*.4+!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! D,F+! e.S!n&%C!2*/.4!-&+!8+!B(99*80#T!MHo!X+B+!,=F!UDcoFV+!! D,=+! _%07#.'!8+!-*$7!&1!?&)C1&%'T!FNl!X+B+!DNFT!DNc!UDcH,V+!! D,o+! 1/K!I.##*4! 8+!X#*$.'!B$0$.4T! MFD!X+B+! FcFT! =lc! UDc=DV! UI&(A904T! \+T! '*44.#$*#AV! U%.04&#*#A!$30$!-&//(#*4$!0'8&)0)7!&(A3$!#&$!J.!)%*/*#09*^0J9.!;0%$97!J.)0(4.!$3.!-&//(#*4$4!30'!09%.0'7!J..#!%.#'.%.'!30%/9.44!J7!&$3.%!/.0#4T!*#)9('*#A!4(%8.*990#).!J7!$3.!LE"!0#'!i$3.!0)$*8*$*.4!*#!%.).#$!7.0%4!&1! )&//*$$..4! &1! -&#A%.44T! &1! $3.! @$$&%#.7! _.#.%09T! &1! 90J&%! (#*T! &1! 4$0$.! 9.A*490$(%.4T! 0#'! &1!R&709$7!E&0%'4kV+!
Ml! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!Ml!
! 23*4!'*4)(44*&#!094&!304#K$!'.09$!S*$3!/0#7!&$3.%!'.$.%%.#$4! $30$!0%.!4&/.$*/.4! 90J.9.'! i6)-0%$37*4/k!J($! $30$! )0#K$! 09S074! J.! '*4/*44.'! 4&!.04*97O!*#1*9$%0$*&#!&1!099.A.'97!'0#A.%&(4!;&9*$*)09!&%! %.9*A*&(4!A%&(;4a! *#`1*9$%0$*&#! &1! A%&(;4! $30$! 0%.! #&$! $3./4.98.4! '0#A.%&(4T! J($! $30$! /07! J.!/..$*#A! ;90).4! 1&%! ;&$.#$*09! $.%%&%*4$4! &%! 40J&$.(%4a! 1*%*#A! &1! A&8.%#/.#$!./;9&7..4!S3&!.P;%.44!).%$0*#!8*.S4!&%!J.9&#A!$&!).%$0*#!A%&(;4a!9.A*490`$*8.! *#8.4$*A0$*&#! &1! 099.A.'! 0$$./;$4! $&! 4(J8.%$! 80%*&(4! &%A0#*^0$*! $&!.8*9! .#'4a! 0#'! /&%.+! "! 308.! #&! A&&'! 4&9($*! $&! $3&4.! ;%&J9./4T! J($! "!$3&(A3$!"!S&(9'!)9&4.!$3*4!<4407!S*$3!0!37;&$3.$*)09!4).#0%*&!$30$!S.!/*A3$!(4.! $&! $3*#C!$3%&(A3!$3./+!"!3&;.!$3*4!4).#0%*&!S&#K$!)&/.!$&!;044T!J($!"!0/!01%0*'!*$K4!#&$!*/;90(4*J9.+!! 23.! 7.0%! ,N,,! *4! 0! '0#A.%&(4! &#.! 1&%! @/.%*)0+! 23.!53*$.! ?*A3$4!6&8./.#$! U49&A0#O!i1&%! $3.! %0).T! .8.%7$3*#Aa! 1&%! $3&4.! &($4*'.! $3.! %0).T!#&$3*#AkVT! 304! J..#! &#! $3.! %*4.+!53*9.! $3.!53*$.! ?*A3$4! >0%$7! *$4.91! 304!a!0!)&(;9.!&1!3(#'%.'! $3&(40#'!/./J.%4T!)*8*9! %*A3$4!0)$*8*4$4!4(4;.)$!$30$!*$!304!/*99*!&1!47/;0$3*^.%4+!! 23.! >0%$7! 304! (%A.'! *$4! /./J.%4! $&! g&*#! &$3.%! A%&(;4! 0#'! )&8.%$97!$0C.!$3./!&8.%T!4&!$30$!$3.7!4../!$&!J.!*#'.;.#'.#$!8&*).4!J($!0%.!0)$(0997!09*A#.'!S*$3!$3.!>0%$7K4!;&9*$*)09!;90#4+!60#7!)*8*9!%*A3$4!9.0'.%4!)90*/!$30$!/0#7!A%&(;4h*#)9('*#A!*/;&%$0#$!;&9*$*)09!0#'!4&)*09!&%A0#*^0$*!1%&/!$3.!e0$*	!?*19.!@44&)*0$*&#!$&!/0#7!)30;$.%4!&1!$3.!\07)..4h308.!J..#!$0C.#!&8.%!J7!>0%$7!10*$31(9+!23.!9.0'.%4!&1!$3.!A%&(;4T!0#'!$3.!>0%$7!*$4.91T!'.#7!$3*4+!! 530$!.P0)$97!*4!$3.!>0%$7K4!0A.#'0d!230$!$&&!*4!3&$97!'*4;($.'+!B&/.!&1!$3.!>0%$7K4!*'.&9&A*)09!'&)(/.#$4!4(AA.4$!0!'.4*%.!$&!$0C.!&8.%!$3.!A&8`.%#/.#$T!J7!8*&9.#$!/.0#4!*1!#.).440%7T!0#'!$3.#!*#4$*$($.!0!/044*8.!)0/`;0*A#! &1! A&8.%#/.#$09! '*4)%*/*#0$*&#! 0A0*#4$! #&#`S3*$.4O!9*/*$4! &#! #&#`S3*$.! *//*A%0$*&#T! .P)9(4*&#! &1! #&#`S3*$.4! 1%&/! C.7! A&8.%#/.#$! g&J4T!'.#*09! &1! $3.! 1%0#)3*4.T! 0#'! .8.#$(0997! 1&%)*J9.! .P;(94*&#+! B*/*90%!/&8.`/.#$4!*#!0!1.S!<(%&;.0#!)&(#$%*.4T!S3*)3!30'!9&#A!J..#!%0)C.'!J7!%0)*09!3&4$*9*$7!0A0*#4$!6*''9.!<04$.%#.%4T!308.!*/;9./.#$.'!4()3!0!;%&A%0/+!! E($!$3.!>0%$7!9.0'.%43*;!'*4/*44.4!$3.4.!'&)(/.#$4!04!/.%.!$3.&%.$*`)09! 4;.)(90$*&#+!53.#! 04C.'T! ;0%$7! 9.0'.%4! 407! $30$! $3.! >0%$7K4! A&094! &1!i;%&$.)$*#A!$3.!%0).k!)0#!J.!0))&/;9*43.'!$3%&(A3!;.0).1(9!)30#A.!*#!4&`)*09!0$$*$('.4T!4()3!04!8&9(#$0%7!4.91`4.A%.A0$*&#!J7!099!%0)*09!A%&(;4+!"1!$30$!*4!'&#.T!>0%$7!9.0'.%4!;&*#$!&($T!$3.%.K99!J.!#&!#..'!1&%!0#7!30%43.%!0)$*&#+!! "#! 0#7! .8.#$T!S3.#! $3.7! 308.! $3.! )3&*).T! >0%$7!/./J.%4! '&#K$! $09C!$3.&%7!/()3T!0$!9.04$!$&!$3.!;(J9*)+!?0$3.%T!$3.7!4$%.44!0!S*'.!%0#A.!&1!4;.`)*1*)! ;&9*)7! ;%&;&4094T! /0#7! f(*$.! /0*#4$%.0/O!30%43.%! ;%*4&#! 4.#$.#).4!0#'!J%&0'.%!'.0$3!;.#09$7!;%&8*4*!1&%!8*&9.#$!)%*/*#094! US3&!4$*99!30;`;.#!$&!J.!'*4;%&;&%$*�$.97!J90)C!0#'!:*4;0#*)T!.8.#!*#!,N,,Va!%.4$%*)$*!&#!*//*A%0$*&#a!%.;.09!&1!011*%/0$*8.!0)$*&#!;%&A%0/4T!/0#7!&1!S3*)3!0%.!4$*99!*#!.11.)$a!0#!.#'!$&!S.910%.a!0#'!4&!&#+!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! Mc$
! Mc!
! E.)0(4.!$3.4.!;%&;&4094!308.!J%&0'!;(J9*)!4(;;&%$T!0#'!J.)0(4.!/0#7!;.&;9.! $3*#C!$30$!/0g&%!;0%$7!;&9*$*)*0#4!308.!4&1$`;.'09.'!$3.4.! *44(.4! *#!$3.!,NDN4!0#'!.0%97!,N,N4T!$3.!>0%$7!304!0$$%0)$.'!4(J4$0#$*09!4(;;&%$!1%&/!4&/.! #&#/./J.%4T! '.4;*$.! *$4! %0)*4$! $3.&%*.4+! i5.! '&#K$! J(7! 0#7! &1! $3.!>0%$7K4! %0)*4$! #.#4.Tk! ;.&;9.! 308.!J..#!3.0%'! $&! 407T! iJ($! $3.7K%.! $3.!a!&#.4!S3&!0%.!$0C*#A!4.%*&(497!$3.!)&(#$%7K4!%.09!;%&J9./4+k!! -*8*9!%*A3$4!0)$*8*4$4T!0#'!'.).#$!@/.%*)0#4!/&%.!A.#.%0997T!0%.!#0$(`%0997!0;;099.'+!L*#0997T!/&%.! $30#!1*1$7!7.0%4!01$.%! $3.!-*8*9!?*A3$4!@)$!&1!DcoFT! *$! 9&&C.'! 9*C.! $3.! J0$$9.! 1&%! %0)*09! $&9.%0#).! S04! #.0%97! S&#h0#'!#&S!*$!9&&C4!9*C.!$3&4.!A0*#4!/*A3$!J.!%.8.%4.'+!! B.%*&(4!&J4.%8.%4!'&#K$T!&1!)&(%4.T!S&%%7!$30$!$3.!>0%$7!S*99!$0C.!&8.%!$3.!A&8.%#/.#$!0#7$*/.!4&&#+!@J&($!FNy!&1! $3.!;&;(90$*&#! *#!#&S!#&#`S3*$.T! 0#'T! .8.#! 0/&#A!S3*$.4T! a! DNy! $.99! ;&994$.%4! $30$! $3.7! 308.! 0!108&%0J9.!8*.S!&1!$3.!>0%$7!U$3&(A3!4&/.!%.4;&#'.#$4!/*A3$!J.!)&#).09*#A!$3.*%!$%(.!1..9*#A4V+!23.!>0%$7!304!#.8.%!A&$$.#!/&%.!$30#!0!1.S!;.%).#$!&1!$3.! 8&$.! *#! 0#7! .9.)$*&#+!6&4$! @/.%*)0#4! $3*#C! %0)*4/! *4! '&S#%*A3$! (#`@/.%*)0#+!! E($! $3.!>0%$7!0#'! *$4!/.440A.!0%.!'0#A.%&(4!.8.#! *1! $3.!>0%$7!#.8.%!S*#4!0#!.9.)$*&#+!L*%4$T!/0#7!;.&;9.!4(4;.)$!$30$!>0%$7!/./J.%4!0#'!47/`;0$3*^.%4!S*99!'*4)%*/*#0$.!0A0*#4$!#&#S3*$.4!.8.%7!)30#).!$3.7!A.$O!*#!./`;9&7/.#$T!*#!A%0'*#A!*#!4)3&&94!0#'!(#*8.%4*$*.4T!*#!0S0%'*#A!)&#$%0)$4T!*#!90S!.#1&%)./.#$T!*#!;&9*$*)09!'.)*4*&#/0C*#AT!*#!g('*)*09!'.)*4*T!*#!g(%7!8.%'*)$4T! 0#'! 4&!&#+!23.%.!308.!J..#!;9.#$7!&1!'*4)%*/*#0$*&#! 90S4(*$4! *#!S3*)3! $3.! ;90*#$*114! 308.! 4&/.3&S! '*4)&8.%.'! $30$! $3.! ;.%4&#!S3&! 1*%.'!$3./!&%!0%%.4$.'! $3./!S04!0!>0%$7!/./J.%a!0#'!S3*9.! $3.!/./J.%4!308.!09S074! )90*/.'! $30$! $3.*%! %.09! %.04! 1&%! $3.! '.)*4*! S.%.! #&#%0)*09T!#0$(%0997!1.S!;.&;9.!308.!J.9*.8.'!$3./+!! 530$K4!/&%.T!/0#7!;.&;9.!4(4;.)$!$30$!$3.%.K4!0!9&$!/&%.!%0)*4/!$30#!*4!8*4*J9.+!I*4)%*/*#0$*&#!*4!30%'!$&!'.$.)$+!53.#!0!#&#S3*$.!@/.%*)0#!*4!0%%.4$.'!&%!1*%.'!J7!0!S3*$.T!$3.!$3&(A3$!&1$.#!)%&44.4!3*4!/*#'O!504!$3*4!0!53*$.!?*A3$4! $3*#Ad!23*4!1.0%! *4!#&$3*#A!#.ST!0#'!J7!099!0))&(#$4!$3.%.K4!9.44!'*4)%*/*#0$*&#! *#!,N,,! $30#! $3.%.!S04! *#!Dcl,!&%!.8.#!,NN,+!E($! $3.!53*$.!?*A3$4!/&8./.#$!304!3.*A3$.#.'!;.&;9.K4!0S0%.#.44!&1! $3.!;.%4*4`$.#).! &1! %0)*4/+!@#'! 4&/.! )&#$%&8.%4*09! '0$0! 4(AA.4$! $3.!/&8./.#$! 304!*#'..'!9.'!$&!0#!*#)%.04.!*#!'*4)%*/*#0$*&#!1%&/!$3.!9&S4!4..#!*#!$3.!/*'`,NDN4+!! B&!#&#S3*$.4!0%.!4(11.%*#A+!"#4$*$($*T!;%*80$.!0#'!;(J9*)T!0%.!4(11.%`*#AT! $&&T! J.)0(4.! #&#S3*$.4K! %.04�J9.! 1.0%! &1! '*4)%*/*#0$*&#! '.)%.04.4!$3.!*#4$*$($*K!)%.'*J*9*$7+!>&9*).!'.;0%$/.#$4!308.!S&%C.'!30%'!$&!J(*9'!$%(4$! 0/&#A! /*#&%*$7! )&//(#*$*.4T! J($! $30$! $%(4$! *4! #&S! '*40;;.0%*#A+!R*C.S*4.! 1&%! (#*8.%4*$*.4T! J0#C4T! 0#'! J*A! )&%;&%0$*+!@#'!/0#7!S3*$.4!0%.!4(11.%*#AT!$&&O!23.7!094&!30$.!%0)*4/T!0#'!$3.7K%.!$%&(J9.'!J7!$3.!4&)*09!
FN! ! 1,89!:;<9,$8,=$;>?9>=! bZ&9+!cMODFDM$
!FN!
30%/! )0(4.'! J7! $3*4! *#)%.04.'! '*4)%*/*#0$*&#! 0#'! %.04�J9.! 1.0%! &1! '*4`)%*/*#0$*&#+!! B.)&#'T! ;.&;9.! 0%.! S&%%*.'! 0J&($! S30$! S*99! 30;;.#! $.#! &%! $S.#$7!7.0%4!1%&/!#&S+!L&%!$3.!1*%4$! $*/.!*#!/0#7!'.)0'.4T!(#*8.%4*$7!;%&1.44&%4!0%.!&;.#97!$.0)3*#A!)9044.4!&#!4(;;&4.'!%0)*09!'*11.%.#).4!*#!*#$.99*A.#).!&%!&#!$3.!/&%09!809(.!&1!%0)*09!;(%*$7!0#'!%0)*09!4.A%.A0$*&#+!! 23.!;%&1.44&%4!0%A(.!$30$!$3.7K%.!g(4$!$%7*#A!$&!;%.4.#$!0!J090#).'!;.%`4;.)$*8.!&#!*/;&%$0#$!*44(.4T!J($!*#!/0#7!*#4$0#).4T!$3.!;%&1.44&%4!4../!$&!J.!47/;0$3*^*#A!S*$3!$3.!53*$.!?*A3$4!9*#.+!@#'!$3.!/&&'!0/&#A!4$('.#$4!304!43*1$.'T!$&&O!53*9.!$3.!/0g&%*$7!4$%&#A97!'*40A%..4!S*$3!$3.!;%&`53*$.`?*A3$4! ;%&1.44&%4T! 0! 8&)09! /*#&%*$7! 4$%*'.#$97! U0#'! 4&/.$*/.4! 8*&9.#$97V!%.4*4$4!0#7!0$$./;$4!$&!)%*$*)*^.!$3.!53*$.!?*A3$4!8*.S+!-*8*9!%*A3$4!0)$*8*4$4!1.0%! $30$! $3.! 4$('.#$4! &#! $3.*%! 4*'.! 308.! J.)&/.! )&/;90).#$! 01$.%! /0#7!'.)0'.4!'(%*#A!S3*)3!%0)*09!.f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d!"#!<(%&;.T!$3.!%0)*4$4!308.!/0'.!$3.*%!/0*#!*#%&0'4!*#!$*/.4!&1!.)&#&/*)!$%&(J9.+!23.!@/.%*)0#!.)&#&/7!*4!49&S*#A!$&&T!0#'!4&/.!;.&;9.!0%.!;%.'*)$*#A!0!4.%*`&(4!%.).44*&#+!! 530$!S*99!30;;.#!$3.#T!&%!;.%30;4!$3.!#.P$!$*/.T!.4;.)*0997!*1!$3.!%.`).44*&#! *4!J90/.'!&#!)&/;.$*$*&#!1%&/!23*%'!5&%9'!#0$*d!@#!&($%*A3$!%0)*4$! %.8&9($*&#T! .8.#! 0#!(#4()).441(9! &#.T! *4! (#9*C.97T! J($!S*99! $3.%.! J.!%0)*4$! %*&$4d! 5*99! )&8.%$! >0%$7! /./J.%4! *#! $3.! ;&9*).! 0#'! $3.! e0$*	!_(0%'!3.9;! $3.! %*&$.%4T! &%! 0$! 9.04$! J.!'.9*J.%0$.97! 49&S! *#! 4$&;;*#A! $3./d!5*99!S.!'*4)&8.%!$30$!$3.!>0%$7K4!;%&4.97$*^*#A!304!)%.0$.'!/*99*!&1!%0)`*4$!S3*$.! $..#0A.%4! 0#'! $S.#$7`4&/.$3*#A4T! 4&/.! &1!S3&/!S*99! J.! 0#A%7!.#&(A3!0#'!/*4A(*'.'!.#&(A3!$&!A.$!8*&9.#$d!5*99!J90)C!@/.%*)0#4!0A0*#!J.!01%0*'!$&!S09C!*#!S3*$.!;0%$4!&1!$&S#!&%!J.!4..#!S*$3!S3*$.!S&/.#d!! 60#7! 9.0'.%4T! *#)9('*#A! %.4;.)$.'T! $3&(A3$1(9T! 0#'! S.99`*#$.#$*&#.'!;&9*$*)*0#4T! )*8*)! 9.0'.%4T! 0#'! *#$.99.)$(094T! './0#'! 0)$*&#+!53.#! 10(9$.'!1&%!4..C*#A!iS*$)3!3(#$4Tk!$3.7!%.4;&#'T!i5*$)3!3(#$4!0%.!J0'!J.)0(4.!S.!C#&S!$3.%.!0%.!#&!S*$)3.4+!23.%.!0%.!%0)*4$4T!0#'!$3.7!)0#!)0(4.!%.09!30%/+!e&$3*#A!#..'4!$&!J.!'&#.!0J&($!S*$)3.4+!B&/.$3*#A!#..'4!$&!J.!'&#.!0J&($!90%A.!#0$*&#S*'.!%0)*4$!)*%0)*.4+k!
,NN=j! F>6>;;9<H$%A>>1I! FD$
! FD!
! 23*4!4).#0%*&!*4T!&1!)&(%4.T!#&$!*'.#$*)09!$&!-&//(#*4$!)*%0)*.4!&1!$3.!Dc=N4+!?0)*4$4!g.&;0%'*^.!.f(09*$7a!-&//(#*4$4!g.&;0%'*^.'!'./&)%0)7!0#'! 1%..'&/+!>.&;9.!S.%.!S&%%*.'! 0J&($!-&//(#*4$4! ;0%$97! J.)0(4.! &(%!.#./*.4!0J%&0'!S.%.!-&//(#*4$a! $30$!'&.4#K$!0;;.0%!*#!/7!37;&$3.$*)09+!B0J&$0A.!0#'!.4;*�A.!0%.! %0%.%! $30#!'*4)%*/*#0$*&#T! $3&(A3!.0)3! 4*#A9.!*#4$0#).!&1!40J&$0A.!0#'!.4;*�A.!/*A3$!J.!/&%.!30%/1(9!$30#!.0)3!4*#A9.!*#4$0#).!&1!'*4)%*/*#0$*&#+!! E($! "! '&#K$! $3*#C! $3.4.! '*11.%.#).4! /0$$.%! $30$! /()3+! 2&/&%%&SK4!;%&J9./4! S&#K$! J.! *'.#$*)09! $&! 7.4$.%'07K4T! J($! $3.7! /07! J.! 4*/*90%!.#&(A3+!i:*4$&%7!'&.4#K$!%.;.0$!*$4.91T!J($!*$!%37/.4+kD,H!! B&/.'07!S.!S*99! 0A0*#! 10).! 0#! *'.&9&A*)09!/&8./.#$! $30$! 4..C4! $&!(#'.%/*#.!1(#'0/.#$09!@/.%*)0#!809(.4!0#'!(4.4!4;..)3!#&$!g(4$!$&!0'8&`)0$.! 1&%! 90S1(9! UJ($! .8*9V! ;&9*$*)09! )30#A.T! J($! 094&! $&! ;%&/&$.! *99.A09T! &%!.8.#!8*&9.#$T!J.308*&%+!"!A*8.!&#.!;&44*J9.!.P0/;9.T!J($!$3.%.!0%.!&$3.%4+!! :&S!43&(9'!&(%!A&8.%#/.#$!0#'!&(%!4&)*.$7!1*A3$!J0)Cd!53.#!4;..)3!)0#!A.#(*#.97!)0(4.!30%/h0#'!S3.#!S.!308.!%*A3$97!1&%4S&%#!$3.!0J*9*$7!$&!4*/;97! 9&)C!(;! $3.!4;.0C.%4!&%!J0#C%(;$! $3./!S*$3!'0/0A.4!0S0%'4hS30$! $&&94!'&!S.!308.! 9.1$! $&! 1*A3$! $3.!30%/d!530$!)0#!S.!'&! $&!;%&$.)$!9*J.%$7T!S3*9.!094&!.11.)$*8.97!1*A3$*#A!0!/&8./.#$!$30$!*$4.91!$3%.0$.#4!9*J`.%$7d!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! D,H+! G1$.#!0$$%*J($.'!$&!60%C!2S0*#+!
Related Documents
