Department of Natural Resources and Mines Resources Registered Training Organisation Association Conference “Issues Relating to Harmonisation” Stewart Bell Commissioner for Mine Safety and Health October 2012
Department of Natural Resources and Mines
Resources Registered Training Organisation Association Conference
“Issues Relating to Harmonisation”
Stewart BellCommissioner for Mine Safety and Health
October 2012
2© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
3© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Introduction
• Training is integral to mine safety
• The inspectorate has concerns about whats happening in the training arena
• We are disturbed by the range of HPIs which have rippled through the industry over the past 6 months
4© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
OrganisationCOMMISSIONER FOR MINE SAFETY AND HEALTH
DEPUTY DIRECTOR-GENERALStewart Bell
PETROLEUM & GAS
INSPECTORATE
EXPLOSIVESINSPECTORATE
MINES INSPECTORATE
HEALTHSURVEILLANCE
UNIT
SIMTARSABANDONED MINING
LAND PROJECT
Chief InspectorStephen Matheson
Chief InspectorGeoff Downs
Chief Inspector ofCoal Mines
Gavin Taylor
Chief Inspector of Metalliferous Mines
Rob O’Sullivan
Executive DirectorPaul Harrison
AMLP CoordinatorOskar Kadletz
ManagerMaura Thompson
Executive DirectorGrahame Wise
Principal Project Officer
Principal Advisor- Policy & CoordinationMick O’Donoghue
Executive OfficerSue Cosgrove
Organisational Structure – DNRM Safety & Health Division
5© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Inspectorate concerns
• For some time we have experienced a growing disquiet.
• The seriousness of some HPIs is most disconcerting and they are growing in number rather than decreasing.
• We seriously question the culture that is generating these incidents and we point out it is no one company or one sector – it is across the board.
6© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Our view
• Inadequate and inappropriate training across all classifications
• Supervisors who can not identify hazards.
• Supervisors and managers appointed to positions outside their level of experience or expertise.
• Fundamental lack of legislative knowledge and awareness of the local Safety and Health Management System.
• Poor safety culture
7© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
The evidence - underground
• Non authorised personnel issued with methanometer keys and using them to bypass gas monitors on equipment in gassy environments.
• Deputies not carrying out inspections before repowering districts or starting auxiliary fans.
• Numerous diesels discovered with methanometers bypassed
• Electrician opening FLP enclosure and working on live equipment in an ERZ zone
• A contractor caught smoking underground
• A deputy running and attempting to start a vehicle in a return when the gas concentration was over the prescribed level.
8© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
The evidence - underground
• Numerous frictional ignitions through mismanagement – non compliance with the SHMS.
• Non technically qualified personnel involved in risk assessments leading to a battery being changed on a ram car in an ERZ
• Contract tunneling company now working in coal found to have three times the silica limit when personnel monitors were fitted.
• Electrician repowered panel before deputy had inspected the panel.
• Emergency stop defeated on a continuous miner
9© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
The evidence – surface mines
• Surface structure being dismantled – shotfirer used was not licensed in Qld. Job failed and persons lucky not to be seriously injured.
• OCE overruled on legislative issue by incorrectly appointed supervisor/manager. SSE also unaware of legislation.
• Gas flare and no persons with knowledge or experience to deal with same (same mine someone lit a gas blower with a cigarette and even though directive issued to address gas problem – nothing done).
• Young apprentice assigned to drive a 4WD towing a noncompliant trailer which was over the capacity of the 4WD. 4WD rolled and apprentice lucky to escape with minor injuries.
10© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
The evidence – surface mines• Continued non-reporting of HPIs although there has been some
improvement.
• Dozer destroyed when parked too close to a blast
• Incorrect fitment of after sales equipment leading to ergonomic issues and injury – some serious.
• Trucks bursting through tip bunds.
• Numerous vehicle interfaces with some exceptionally high potential.
• Continual loss of control of heavy and light vehicles where roads and ramps have been overwatered.
• Vehicles not meeting corporate standards.
11© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Catastrophe avoidance
• In the increasingly complex operating environment, to sustain business vitality and performance excellence, an organisation must be able to manage unexpected events and lessen the threat from those low-frequency/high-consequence events. The four elements discussed above – risk sensitivity, decision-making capability, enabling culture, and operating discipline – are interdependent components that collectively build an organisation’s operating dexterity and allow it to navigate through uncharted territories with great speed and accuracy.
Dr Mei-Li Lin Director of Research and Development,
Dupont Sustainable Solutions
12© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Comments from an experienced miner
• I have got to admit I’ve found it very hard here with the young men. They seem to have too much self-confidence, too quick. They’ve been underground maybe six months and they are a miner. But they can’t have in those six months appreciated the dangers down there. … Some of these young men have called me some serious names while I’ve been here …. I said, ‘Look, I don’t care. I’ve been in this game all my life and I’m not going to die here just because you don’t understand where you are working.’ And that’s why I jacked it in ….
Albert Houlden
13© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
14© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
15© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Unreported Incident
16© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
17© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
18© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Can you see the cable handling tractor?Neither could the dragline operator
19© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Escaped on foot
20© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Short cut
21© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
22© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
23© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
24© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
25© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
26© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
27© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
28© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Emergency stop&
Fire suppression
After market items mounted in cab at head height
29© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
National Mine Safety Framework & COAG reforms
• NMSF started in 2002 - compatibility of all states’ legislation with the United Nations’ International Labour Organisation Convention 176
• The idea was to get consistent legislation
• Handled by Chief Inspectors of Mines – 100% people directly linked to mine safety
• 2005 – NMSF taken over by Ministerial Council – C’wealth + states + territories – now only 40%
30© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
NMSF Genesis
• 2007 – COAG’s 27 regulatory reforms includes NMSF, OHS, rail, marine – now only 20%
• 2008 (Feb.) Workplace Relations Ministers - harmonise OHS laws – now 15%
• 2008 (Jul.) COAG IGA OHS for all workers
• 2009 (May) Workplace Relations Ministers – no industry specific OHS unless justified [decision made by people with no direct link to mining]
31© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
National Mine Safety Framework & COAG reforms
• Series of endorsements and approvals - committees with tenuous links to mining.
• Decisions were made on the vote - Three jurisdictions with 90% of the mining activity were outvoted by six (C’wealth, states and territories with the remaining 10%) - now 10 %
• Business Regulation and Competition Working Group (BRCWG) –chaired by Minister for Finance and Deregulation and the Minister Assisting – now 7.5 %
32© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Genesis
• Strategic Issues Group on Occupational Health and Safety (SIG-OHS) formed by Safe Work Australia to develop model WHS Regulations 5%
• Reward payments / Audits by COAG Reform Council (CRC) 4%
• Arresting the ‘drift into failure*’ - Qld, NSW and WA formed ‘non-core’ to achieve greater consistency.
• Queensland’s position: existing safety standards maintained and no significant increase in cost.
• *with apologies to Professor Sidney Dekker of Griffith University author of “Drift Into Failure”
33© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Changes for Qld
– Statutory positions requiring BOE practicing certificates increases from 5 to 16
– Notification of high risk activity
– Stone dust bags in underground coal mines
– Tri-state Advisory Committee on Competencies• Advice on competencies for mining
• Member from 3 states
• Tripartite membership is being considered.
34© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Next step – Regulatory Impact Statement (RIS)
• New government established Office of Best Practice Regulation under the Qld Competition Authority
• RIS - A fundamental step is establishing a case to act – determining that regulation is necessary - Identification of the problem and the issue that needs addressing
• ensure that legislation should not restrict competition unless it can be demonstrated that:– the benefits of the restrictions to the community as a whole
outweigh the costs (a cost benefit analysis must be undertaken).
– ensuring that regulation remains relevant and effective over time
– consulting effectively with affected key stakeholders at all stages of the regulatory cycle
– ensuring that government action is effective and proportional to the issue being addressed.
35© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Indicative timelines
• RIS release target mid-November 2012
• RIS to be published on the internet for a minimum of 28 days
• Road shows in regional mining centres – November - December 2012.
• Analysis of the feedback from the RIS - second half of February 2012.
• Seek approval to introduce a Bill into Parliament - March 2012
• Referral to Parliamentary Agriculture, Resources and Environment Committee – submissions & hearings
• It will be law mid 2013
36© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
What it means for RTOs
• Mines Inspectors will be involved in technical audits of RTOs
• RTOs and the training industry face the challenge of providing quality training vs. time and cost pressures
• Mineworkers need to understand and identify risk
• We need to better understand the challenges of training greenskins
• Training quality needs to improve and be better focussed
• Supervisor training needs to better developed
37© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Audits
• Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) may require technical experts from the Mines Inspectorate involved in quality audits of RTOs
• An MOU is being discussed with ASQA to cover possible audits
38© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Authorised work / Competency
• WHS laws – certain work must be done by authorised (licensed) persons e.g. crane and hoist operation, forklifts
• Qld Mine Safety laws – SSE must – train coal mine workers so that they are competent to perform
their duties;
– not assign the tasks of a supervisor to a person unless the person
• is competent to perform the task assigned • has the relevant competency if recognised by the advisory
committee
39© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Where to from here?
• How far are we away from a catastrophe?
• What are we going to do about it?
• The inspectorate can assist but the ultimate responsibility rests with you
• We need to work together
• If we don’t address these issues we are failing in our responsibility to our employees
40© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Finally
Every miner home safe and healthy Every miner home safe and healthy every dayevery day
41© The State of Queensland, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, 2012
Decisions – in a nutshell
Decisions can be life taking
Decisions can be life giving
Its your call…