Deloitte Consulting LLP August 2012 Positioning P3 for Success and Applications for Energy Sustainable Energy Workshop 2012
Mar 31, 2015
Deloitte Consulting LLP
August 2012
Positioning P3 for Success and Applications for EnergySustainable Energy Workshop 2012
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 2
About DeloitteDeloitte is a leading professional services firm with a commitment to energy and sustainability
FinancialServices
Manufacturing Energy & Resources
HealthCare
ConsumerBusiness
Transportation PublicSector
RealEstate
TMT
Audit and Enterprise Risk
• Finance Operations and Controls Transformation
• Financial Instrument Valuation & Securitization
• Governance, Regulatory & Risk Strategies
Financial Advisory
• Corporate Finance Advisory
• Capital Projects • Business Valuation
Consulting
• Strategy & Operations• Human Capital• Technology
Tax
• Global Business Tax Services
• Multistate Tax• Indirect Tax
Services
Industries
Sustainability
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited
Contents
- Definition of P3- A Case Study and Lessons Learned
- Strategic Considerations- P3 Execution Challenges- Solutions
Positioning P3 for Success
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 5
Definition of P3 IP3 enables an overall energy and sustainability strategy and the definitions are broad
A public-private partnership, or P3, refers to a contractual agreement formed between a government agency and a private sector entity that allows for greater private sector participation in the delivery of public projects. Compared with traditional procurement models, the private sector assumes a greater role in the planning, financing, design, construction, operation, and/or maintenance of public facilities.
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 6
Definition of P3 IIAt the Federal level, there are lesser-known tools in the P3 toolbox that can be used to great affect
Government | Commercial Partnership Description
Alliance Agreement Alliance Agreements are legal documents between one or more parties, for the purpose of competitive intelligence, drafting documents or to get information about transactions within a particular industry or sector.
Public-Private Ventures A special-purpose public/private venture refers to a business entity that is created by public and private parties for a single specified purpose and whose activities are predetermined by the contracts and other arrangements.
Enhanced Use Lease for R&D Test-bed
An EUL is a contract calling for the lessee (user) to pay the lesser (owner) for use of an asset.
Patent License Agreement A license to commercial companies to utilize patented government-developed technology commercially. The government retains the rights to use the technology for government purposes.
Government | Non-profit Partnership Description
Memorandum of Understanding (MOU)
A bilateral agreement between parties, indicating an intended coordination and collaboration between agencies, rather than a legal commitment.
Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) Document written between parties to cooperatively work together on an agreed upon project or meet an agreed objective (Can also be a legal document that is binding).
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 7
A Case Study and Lessons Learned IA successful P3 can come together through many different types of transacting mechanisms
Deloitte served as strategic advisors to the Government of Bulgaria on the long-term concession of Bulgaria’s Black Sea Coast airports. We performed an options
analysis in close consultation with the Government, proposed amendments to the enabling environment for P3, assisted the Government to create a core base of stakeholder support, managed interactions with strategic investors, assisted in the conduct of the competitive tender, and built the capacity of the Civil Aviation Authority to be a strong partner for this P3.
The Government received 4 proposals from leading airport development groups, and accepted the proposal from Fraport, the international arm of the Frankfurt International Airport, with an estimated total value in excess of $500M USD, while securing the long-term development of these strategic assets.
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 8
A Case Study and Lessons Learned IIEstablishing governance up-front helps to ensure a successful transaction and subsequent operate environment
Due Diligence: legal, environmental, technical and social
• Developed capital expenditure plan for 10-years
• Identified problem with Civil Aviation Act
Financial Analysis
• Developed traffic forecast and financial modeling
• Clear projections on key issues: future costs /returns to public sector and user charges
International Market Study
• At the macro-level by sector
• Detailed review of individual aviation projects
Options Analysis
• Public vs. private operation
• Issue: To bundle the airports to make more attractive
Project Development and Implementation: Pre-feasibility activities
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 9
A Case Study and Lessons Learned IIISelecting the optimal framework is a first step to a functioning governance model for the P3
Selecting a Model
Applications for Energy
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 11
Strategic Considerations IERCOT faces some difficult supply challenges in the near-term future
According to the most recent ERCOT capacity report, reserve margins are forecast at less than 10 percent by next year
Coal and natural gas make up the largest share of generating capacity in Texas with more reliance on gas expected in the future
ERCOT, May 2012
ERCOT, May 2012
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 12
Future Energy PricesDeveloping a strategic view of future prices is critical to success
ContractingThe federal government has an array of available tools but their use is complex
Raising CapitalNew funding sources require networked outreach to stakeholders
Above or Behind the MeterDirect interaction with the grid will be one of the larges and most tangible sources of value for the P3. The P3 should be structured to optimize the strategic objectives of both parties in the transaction.
Own or LeaseAsset ownership comes with risk and will greatly impact pricing considerations
Risk ManagementEstablishing a governance model that can last the duration of the lifecycle
$.05 per kwh price electric
$50M annual energy
cost
3% annual energy goal
1055 GWh annual energy consumption
727,485 metric tons of carbon emitted per year
Mandates versus ValueSelecting the optimal balance of mandates versus value will drive tactical considerations such as the type of contracting vehicle used.
P3 Execution Challenges IBreaking down barriers to P3 execution requires tenacious problem solving
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 13
According to NIST forecasts, electricity escalators are flat out to 2022, excluding general inflation
P3 Execution Challenges IINIST Supplemental 135 has serious analytical shortcomings, which can lead to faulty P3 pricing
Measures of future prices are based on census zone, which has little direct applicability to electric markets
South Region
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 14
Our analysis shows that TRE South could see significant price increases by 2030 with more than a doubling of prices from today’s level in nominal terms. With large generating capacity needed in the region, a number of pricing assumptions should be evaluated to determine future strategy.
P3 Solutions IIEven before considering spot prices and DR opportunities, long-term energy economics in Texas yield potential
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 15
P3 Solutions IIIAlthough energy prices are local, energy markets are integrated and have global reach
In today’s world, local decisions quickly bump up against international factors. Long-lived P3 assets will be impacted by these factors well into the future.
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 16
P3 Solutions IVInternational markets could be knocking at America’s door; what are the scenarios to consider?
Impact of LNG Exports on Average US Citygate Gas Prices
Price Impact by Region
A recent Deloitte analysis forecasts a marginal affect on domestic gas prices as a result of LNG imports. Despite varying worldviews, strategic flexibility enables strong organizations.
As compared to the NIST 135 census regions, local markets and regions are a key factor in forecasting future prices.
Source: Deloitte MarketPoint
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 17
Tried and true P3 tools for energy will be a major source of project funding with ARRA funds expended
P3 Solutions VWith a compelling and targeted value proposition, sources of capital reach beyond traditional buckets
While not typically a source of outsized returns, energy project financing can go a long way to solving the asset / liability mismatch facing the U.S. and other developed economies
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 18
Solutions VStructured processes help drive execution through the transaction phase and beyond
PPAPPA
Level 0Process
Steps
13
Selec
t Agen
t
Issu
e In
fo R
eques
t
Issu
e Qual
s Req
uest
Devel
op RFP
Issu
e RFP
Admin
iste
r RFP
Evalu
ate
Proposa
ls
Award
Desig
n Pro
ject
Constru
ct P
roje
ct
Comm
issi
on Sys
tem
M&V P
erfo
rman
ce
End Ove
rsig
ht
EULEUL
Level 0Process
Steps
12
Devel
op sco
pe
Notice
of Opp.
Issu
e Notic
e of O
pp.
Evalu
ate
Proposa
ls
Selec
t Contra
ctor
Lease
and M
gmt.
Plan
Issu
e Lea
se
Desig
n Pro
ject
Constru
ct P
roje
ct
Comm
issi
on Pro
ject
M&V P
roje
ct
End Ove
rsig
ht
Sample Level 0 Process Steps for PPA and EUL
Source: Federal Energy Management Program
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 19
ConclusionEnergy and sustainability strategy drives capital budgeting decisions and P3s support and enable execution
After designing a project that best meets an organization’s strategic goals and objectives there are many P3 options that can support successful implementation and operations.
Careful consideration is required to ensure that both parties achieve the maximum risk-adjusted value from the projects while ensuring the transaction gets done and service is maintained.
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited 20
Thank You
© 2010 Deloitte Global Services Limited
For more information
Alexander Kasuya
Manager, Deloitte [email protected]
www.deloitte.comwww.deloittemarketpoint.com