'Debt Restructuring a Good Concept in India' _ Business Standard

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 1/13

E-Paper

|Today's Paper

|SmartInvestor.in

|BS Hindi

|BS Motoring

|

BS Books|B2B Connect

|Apps

Sign in

|

Register

Saturday, April 19, 2014 | 03:58 PM IST

News Stock Quote Authors

Advanced Search

Finance » Banking Annual » 2013

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 2/13

Tweet 0 0 0Share

'Debt restructuring a good concept in India'

Shyamal Majumdar | Mumbai February 11, 2014 Last Updated at 21:45 IST

CFP Certification @ ICICI

A useful qualification for banking, investment & many more industries! www.icicidirect.com/CFP

Ads by Google

Add to My Page

Read more on: Gdp | Rbi | Debt Restructuring | Banking Annual | Round Table | Pramit Jhaveri | Debabrata Sarkar |Stuart Milne | Aditya Puri | Chanda Kochhar | Shikha Sharma.

Related News

RBI to unveil Monetary Policy for 2013-14 on May 3

Why there is a need to put an end to 'Banana Banking'FSLRC and consumer protection

Credit Card: Apply Online

Discounts, EMI Offers, Loan on Card

Bonus Points, Cashbacks* & More!

apply.standardchartered.co.in

HDFC™ Instant Home Loans

Lowest EMI @ 10.25%* Apply Now.

Quotes In 2 Min.Instant Call Back.

hdfcinstanthomeloans.com/30+Year

Ads by Google

Six of the country's leading bankers say that while green shoots are visible, the pace of recovery will be slow. The

following are edited excerpts from the Round Table, which was moderated by Shyamal Majumdar

Moderator: There has been a lot of talk about a change in mood - is the worst really over?

Chanda Kochhar: There are definitely some positive signs. It's clear that agriculture will play a more positive role in the

country's GDP growth and could bring back the momentum in the GDP numbers. Secondly, the entire set of measures

that have brought about some amount of stability on the currency. The third is the improvements in exports. Finally,some approvals around some projects have started to come in.

But I must add that the pace of the appearance of these green shoots is pretty slow. So, while I do think that we have

hit the bottom and from here on, there will be improvement, the pace will be slow and gradual.

Pramit Jhaveri: In general there is no doubt that sentiments have improved. That's not to say that the issues around the

Fed tapering have disappeared. As the US economy grows stronger, tapering is inevitable. But now RBI is in a much

stronger position to deal with that.

From the internal point of view, if you take consensus GDP expectation, you will come to something between 4.5 per

cent and 5 per cent in FY14. In FY15, the consensus is that it will be higher than that. There are some early signs of

0Like

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 3/13

recovery, but I think it's still early days and investment cycle needs to come back.

Moderator: But there is a view that the measures that we have taken for currency stability are just quickfixes and not sustainable.

Aditya Puri: There has to be both quick fixes and long-term solutions. There is no magic wand. Our current account

deficit and its financing is less of a problem now. I think we are moving in the right direction. With good growthexpected in agriculture, exports picking up and some stalled projects re-starting, we will see better GDP growth in the

last two quarters of the current financial year. While 5 per cent GDP growth is possible in the fourth quarter, to attain 7

per cent growth may take 18 months.

Moderator: One worry is that the fresh project pipeline is completely dry. Do you share the concern?

Shikha Sharma: Actually, there are a lot of investments that are stuck in stalled projects, mainly power and some road

projects. It makes sense to get these projects going before more money is pumped into these projects. What isimportant in the next 12-18 months is that these projects become operational after solving bottlenecks like fuel linkages.

Fresh investment will come in only after these issues get resolved.

We will continue to see consumption grow, driven by agriculture, rural markets and service-based delivery. But for thatto continue, we will need a benign interest rate environment.

Moderator: But going by the Reserve Bank of India's stance, that seems a long way off.

Sharma: I think that's for the RBI to decide. But I don't think standard economics has all the answers to the problems

in a fast-evolving world. I am sure the RBI will look at data and based on that, they will decide what the right action is.

Kochhar: High interest rates are required because they are a tool to control inflation. But if you ask if it is desirable tobring down interest rates, it is indeed desirable.

Puri: Inflation is a problem and has to be controlled; otherwise it will affect long-term growth. RBI has said that it

cannot control it wholly through monetary policy and there has to be control on the fiscal side as well. The fact of thematter is that you cannot bring the interest rates down till you solve the infrastructure around it.

With monsoon coming in, let us hope that food inflation is down and RBI gets inflation numbers that allow it to act

positively. If we create the appropriate structure and in that we infuse liquidity, the valid rate will become the repo rate.At this point, due to inadequate liquidity, the operational rate is the marginal standing facility rate.

Debabrata Sarkar: We have compulsions. Banks are not getting deposits at the desired levels. Therefore, we areunable to reduce the cost of deposits. I do feel that interest rates are at a higher level. There is no credit demand as the

players feel that at this level of interest rates, sustainability and profitability of projects is a big question mark.

Stuart Milne: While we all would like interest rates to come down, the fact is that they can't unless inflation numbers

come down. A lot of concrete measures have been taken, especially after the new governor took over.

Sharma: We are trying to spur investment, ensure consumption at right levels and trying to make sure that savings find

interest rates attractive. If we are saying that this is an economy in transition which is deliberately trying to contain some

of its risk by reducing fuel subsidy, we are doing some social objectives in transfer of incomes to rural poor and that is

resulting in food inflation, then you have two big macro themes here. One which is going to continue with food inflation

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 4/13

since we are doing transfer of money from urban to rural markets; and second is since we are reducing fuel subsidy, it

will have an impact on fuel prices and consequently impact inflation. Those are macro choices we have chosen to make,

since those will be an appropriate development model for India.

If that is the case, inflation is going to take its hand to control. Should inflation be the only factor to determine interestrates? This needs to be debated.

Moderator: At the round table last year, there was a view that cash-rich PSUs should kick start investment.

But nothing much has happened. What do you think is the problem?

Sarkar: Companies are apprehensive whether the time is right for making investments. Another issue is lack of

clearances. The other apprehension is over getting the return on investments or capital.

Moderator: With economic indicators offering no signs of relief, don't you think asset quality issues will only

get worse?

Milne: There is definitely more concentration of risk in the corporate world today. If you take non-performing

advances and add in the assets under restructuring, you are getting up to high teens in terms of percentage of portfolio

across systems which are stressed. The interest cover ratios, the quantum of equity versus debt; these are all indicators

that they are not behind us. We are going to still see more assets to come under restructuring, especially construction

and engineering, textiles and trading.

Moderator: A lot of promoters appear to have misused the corporate debt restructuring forum (CDR) and

have rushed to get laxer terms in order to avoid admitting they are bust - ably assisted by their bankers?

What's your assessment?

Kochhar: When you have an economy which was growing at 9 per cent per annum eight quarters ago and is now at

half of that, everything slows down. Every investment that was geared at a 9 per cent rate is now geared for 4.5 per

cent rate. These are the reasons that led to restructuring. This does not deny the basic viability of the project, but justmeans that they will need a little longer time to repay the loan. In a growth economy like ours, most projects need

handholding. Restructuring is a good concept for a growth economy like India.

On the concerns you raised, banks need to take a very calculated call to say if this project indeed needs two years to

come out, let us provide the handholding. But, banks as well as promoters have a responsibility to meet their obligations.

You will still see some more assets getting added to the restructured base. For us, the flow of restructured assets into

NPA is 10 per cent. This is not very high, but is higher than what it used to be in the past, that is 5 per cent.

Sharma: We have a lot of concerns around restructuring and we call restructured assets stressed assets. In that

context, if you look at markets across the world, restructuring gets done by banks. We have more detailed disclosures

than many other parts of the world and that could be causing confusion on the nature of the asset. We have been

indicating since 2009 that 25 per cent of restructured loans will turn into NPAs. So, in a much more stressed economy,

it is not a surprising number. But 25 per cent is not 100 per cent. Restructured should not be seen as NPA. In a difficult

marketplace, it is a legitimate thing to allow restructuring.

Moderator: RBI recently issued norms regarding foreign banks' subsidiarisation. But foreign banks stillseem to have a lot of concerns .

Milne: Whether foreign banks operate as a branch or as a subsidiary, it is not really a driver of our strategy in India. If

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 5/13

you look at our own business around Asia, we have subsidiarised operations in China, Vietnam, Taiwan, Malaysia and

Australia. The regulations have encouraged us to do so. In return, we have a level playing field with other banks in those

countries.

We are closely looking at the subsidiary guidelines. Whether we operate as a branch or as a subsidiary, we still have to

do what we are good at, and in this market that's connecting customers to international markets and financing trade andinvestment flows from outside India into India and from India to the global market place. We can do that either way,

through a branch structure or a subsidiary.

Moderator: Will Citibank take the subsidiary route, going forward?

Jhaveri: I don't think we are going to be able to take a decision in a few weeks. As with everything, the devil is in the

detail. I don't think our strategy, even if we were given unfettered access to branches, is ever going to be to try and

compete with our friends on the table. At the end of the day, they have 3,000 to 4,000 branches, and I don't think thatfor a bank like Citi over the next five to ten years, we are looking at several hundred or thousand branches.

Moderator: We will also have new banks probably backed by big corporate houses coming in.

RBI is also talking about differentiated bank licences. So how do you see competition changing the existing banking

landscape?

Sharma: Competition is always good. It can spur new ideas and innovation and ultimately expansion of the market. Inthe short term, if there are a lot of new licences given out, there will be a scramble for talent, so that's the place I see

some confusion happening.

Moderator: Indian companies hold about $225bn of US dollar-denominated debt and as much as half of that

is estimated to be unhedged. Isn't that a serious concern?

Jhaveri: There are certainly some areas where there has been excessive dollarisation of balance sheets. RBI has been

talking to us as an industry for being cautious on that front. Companies that have this excessive indebtedness will be introuble.

Kochhar: Corporates took dollar loans because they were cheaper compared to rupee loans, as far as basic interest

rates are concerned. Of course, no one planned for such an unprecedented change in the exchange rate, and clearly that

has hit the corporate sector. The second issue is that many Indian companies have tried to cut losses and switched over

to rupee financing. However, it is not possible to cut long-term loans and change the structure from foreign currency to

rupee.

I think many companies had financed a whole lot of working capital through foreign currency funding. But this year,

many companies have switched their loans from foreign currency to rupee. In fact, one reason for increase in credit for

the domestic banking sector on the working capital side is because of the substitution that is taking place from foreign

currency funding.

Puri: If foreign banks want to sell their loans to each other, it still remains their risk. Within that, there are companies

that would have their cash flows. Even if they cover now, it will be like taking a rupee loan. So if somebody hasunhedged exposure, he has a larger principal to repay, but that's over 10 years. This time around, it is only one

instalment that's due. Will they need some hand holding? Yes they would. If it is a crisis, it's between the bank and the

borrower. It's definitely not a country crisis.

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 6/13

Read more on:

Gdp

|

Rbi

|

Debt Restructuring

|

Banking Annual

|

Round Table

|

Pramit Jhaveri

|

Debabrata Sarkar

|

Stuart Milne

|Aditya Puri

|Chanda Kochhar

|

Shikha Sharma.

Read More

Can he pull it off?

Plain speak and decisive action have become Raghuram Rajan's trademark. But in coming to grips with issues like

inflation-growth dynamics and ...

No-Annual Fee Credit Card

Get Best Credit Card For Free, Apply Online in 2 min Now. www.policybazaar.com/credit-Cards

Citibank™ Credit Cards

Enjoy 10X Rewards, Fuel Savings, 10,000 Air Miles & More. Apply now! citibank.co.in/Credit_Cards

Ads by Google

Advertisements

Look more professional with custom email from Google Apps.

Hospitality as legendary as our landscape.

The Future of Finance Starts with You. Learn More

India's Biggest Shopping Poll. Click here to know more

Biggest, deepest and fastest growing port in India. Click here to know more

The Holiday You Take Home with You. Know more

Organize your business finances, anytime, anywhere. Click here

Home

Market

Companies

Opinion

ElectionsTechnology

Specials

Personal Finance

Portfolio

My Page

BS HeadlinesNews Now

Economy

Finance

Current Affairs

International

Management

Beyond Business

The StrategistWeekend

Billionaire Club

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 7/13

Tweet 0 0 0Share

Quick Links

Beyond Business

Go

Latest News

In this section

All News

Building a Global Enterprises-India. 28 APR-01 May 2014. Apply now

The Real Family Sedan Multiplies your life. Booking new open.

Introducing the new 11th generation corolla altis.

Brazil's Largest Petrochemical Facility will operate with technology.

How cost and time efficiencies can be achieved through automation

Your Favourite Cruise Superstar Virgo Book 90 Days in Advance. Know more

Add to My Page

Comments (0):

There are no comments to display.Be the first one to comment!

Post a comment

Back to Top

0Like

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 8/13

Companies line up initiatives to increase

insurance awareness

Bandhan sees 37% growth in gross loanportfolio

New govt's fiscal policy to affect RBI's

monetary stance

Insurance: New premiums not to be

impacted by Jan diktat

PNB sells its stake in India Factoring for

Rs 108 cr

Foreign exchange reserves swell $2.8 bn

Non-life insurers: Down, but not out

Govt bond auction: Bonds bank on

insurers to sail through

Piramal, Shriram and Sanlam to create fin

services powerhouse

NBFCs approach RBI, govt over new

companies Act

PM delivered 1100 speeches, he is not

'Maun' Mohan Singh: Modi

India's dependence on imported edible oil

to hit new record

Rahul accuses Modi of dividing people

Third phase: Campaign gains momentum in

JharkhandArticle 370 part of BJP agenda not

NDA's: Gadkari

Geelani's statements are bunch of lies: BJP

Declare 'May Day' as gazetted holiday:

NMC to PM

Rahul lets have a face-off: Modi

Article 370 part of BJP agenda not

NDA's: Gadkari

FIR against Vishwas for staging dharna

inside police station

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 9/13

Most Popular

Read

Shared

Commented

2 States: Bad book, worse film

FDI policy needs to be reviewed, says

Modi

RIL posts highest quarterly profits in two

years

Tata Sons raising funds for new businesses,

rights issues

The less we hire, the better off we are: T K

Kurien

Groundnut oil production may touch 700k

tonnes

Hopes rise for Crompton Greaves amid

stake-sale rumours

TCS' 300,000-strong workforce to get

55,000 new members this year

Official gold supply dries up further

T N Ninan: Paying the price

Rahul Jacob: In defence of Manmohan

Singh

Narendra Modi pours cold water on

Mamata, Jayalalithaa and Mayawati's

kingmaker plan

Asit K Biswas & Peter Brabeck-

Letmathe: The Third World's drinking

problem

I spoke to media on 2002 riots, none tried

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 10/13

to understand the truth: Modi

Zero tolerance

News

LIC Housing Finance takesover Orbit Corp's Mumbaiproperty

Orbit's total amount outstanding is Rs 95.50 crore

including interest, expenses and other charges

VCES a rare opportunity,make fresh start, saysChidambaram

The FM asked hose in trade and industry to seize

the offer

Govt allows greaterflexibility for pension fundinvestments

But the EPFO board would need to approve the

changes before they become official

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 11/13

Business Standard

262,082 people like Business Standard.

Facebook social plugin

Like

Back to Top

Hi

Click here to go My Page

iPhone

iPad

android

wap

facebook

twitter

Google+

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 12/13

RSS

Youtube

From BS WebsiteHome

Markets

Companies

Opinion

Technology

Specials

Personal Finance

General News

General Videos

Events

About BS

About Us

Code of Conduct

Terms & Conditions

Disclaimer

Support & Contact

Partner with Us

Careers

Advertise with Us

Contact Us

Feedback

Subscribe

E-Paper

BS Magazines

Portfolio Tracker

BS Products

BS Hindi

BS Motoring

BS Books

B2B Connect

iPhone

iPad

android

wap

Connect with BS

Facebook

Twitter

4/19/2014 'Debt restructuring a good concept in India' | Business Standard

http://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/debt-restructuring-a-good-concept-in-india-114021200068_1.html 13/13

Google +

Youtube

RSS

Copyrights © 2014 Business Standard Ltd. All rights reserved.