DEATH PENALTY JOLIEN VERBRUGGEN JEF VERCAMMEN
DEATH PENALTY
JOLIEN VERBRUGGENJEF VERCAMMEN
Death Penalty
Definition Examples
» Jesus (33), Joan Of Arc (1431), » Che Guevarra (1967), Timothy McVeigh
(2001), Saddam Hussein (2006)
Movies» The Green Mile» The Life Of David Gale » Dead Man Walking
Books» Charles Dickens (A Tale Of Two Cities)» Victor Hugo (The Last Day Of A Condemned
Man)
Death Penalty in USA
Sanctioned by 37 of the 50 states By the federal government and the military Different laws No executions under the age of 18 Controversial issue 1098 executions since the reinstatement in 1976 67% overturned 7% of the overturned sentences have been acquitted
Death Penalty in UK
1st method introduced: 5th Century» Hanging by the neck
1770-1830: England and Wales» 35,000 death sentences
» 7,000 carried out
Abolished for murder in 1965
On statute book until 1998» Treason
» Espionage
» Piracy with violence
Death Penalty in UK
After abolition for murder » Parliament free vote restoration of capital punishment. » Always defeated
Last woman executed: » Ruth Ellis (July 13th 1955)
Last executions: 1964 » Peter Anthony Allen and Gwynne Owen Evans» Murder of John Alan West
In the rest of the world
After World War II» A lot of countries abolish death penalty
Comparison» 1977: 16 countries were abolitionist » Currently: countries are abolitionist
64 countries retain death penalty Where?
» Especially in Asia (Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, etc.)» Africa» Middle East
European Union» Against Death Penalty
Death Penalty in the world
Methods of execution
Decapitation/Beheading» What? Removal of living organism’s head» Axe, sword, knife, wire» Honourable death» Relatively painless
Electrocution» What? Electrodes placed on the body» US and Philippines» 1886» New, more human way to replace hanging» 1889: AC Electric Chair
Methods of execution
Firing Squad» Times of war» Blindfoolded/hooded + restrained» All members: fire simultaneously
No interruption of procees No identification of lethal shot
Gas Chamber» Poisonous or asphyxiant gas
Carbon Monoxide Carbon Dioxide Hydrogen Cyanide
» 1920s US» Holocaust Genocide Program
Methods of execution
Hanging» 1st method of execution in UK» Lethal suspension of a person by a ligature » Different methods
Lethal Injection» Injecting a fatal doses of poisonous drugs» More human 20th century» Method
Induce rapid unconsciousness Paralysis of respiratory muscles Induce cardiac arrest through depolarization of cardiac muscle cells
Other
PRO Death Penalty
The death penalty frightens potential criminals
The cost for society is less
Chance for convict to regain freedom after good behaviour
You prevent that this criminal restarts his crimes
Executions these days are more ‘human’ then ever.
An eye for an eye.
AGAINST Death Penalty
Irreversible: some convicts are innocent
Racist
Death penalty does not deter crime
Prevents the opportunity for rehabilitation, repair, redemption, & restoration
The person who does the execution is also a murderer
Discussion
Do you think death penalty scares people of committing a serious crime?
What do you think is the worst punishment: life imprisonment or capital punishment? Why?
Why should someone’s life be ended, when they can also get life imprisonment?
On the other hand, you can also think: how can the convict be punished when he/she is dead?
There are people who commit (little) crimes to get in prison. Do think that prisons are getting more and more free hotels.
Discussion
Sometimes people are also influenced by their social environment, do you think the judge and jury should take that in account when reaching its verdict?
Some states in the USA brought back the death penalty as a solution for the overpopulated prisons. Do you think that’s a good idea and why (not)? If you are against it, what would be a good alternative to solve the problem?
This one is for the people who support the death penalty! For which crimes would you prosecute someone to the death penalty?
Discussion
Is the murderer who gives the lethal injection also a murderer or not? Why?
A lot of people found it horrible when Saddam Hussein got hung up. Some even had mercy with him when they saw the pictures of his dead. What do you think of the case? Keep in mind that Saddam was responsible for the dead of thousands of Iraqis.
Thank you