Dean Karlen University of Victoria & TRIUMF IPP Town Hall Meeting June 4, 2005, TRIUMF
Dean KarlenUniversity of Victoria & TRIUMF
IPP Town Hall MeetingJune 4, 2005, TRIUMF
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 33
The International Linear ColliderThe International Linear Collider
Next in the line of Next in the line of ee++ee-- colliderscolliders at the high at the high energy frontier of particle physicsenergy frontier of particle physics
SLAC/SLC
CERN/LEP
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 44
year
1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030
Cen
tre-o
f-mas
s en
ergy
(GeV
)
100
1000PETRAPEPTRISTANSLCLEP - ILEP - IIILCILC - II
ee++ee−− colliderscolliders at the frontierat the frontier
Z0 threshold
W+W− threshold
tt thresholdHZ0 threshold?
dark matter threshold?
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 55
Why Linear?Why Linear?
Centre-of-mass Energy (GeV)
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
Circ
umfe
renc
e / L
engt
h (k
m)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
$
circular colliders
linear colliders
2ER ∝
EL ∝
A circular 500 GeVmachine would be170 km around andconsume 45 GW
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 66
““Energy FrontierEnergy Frontier”” Particle PhysicsParticle Physics
Increasing the collision energy allows for new Increasing the collision energy allows for new fundamental processes to be observed and probes fundamental processes to be observed and probes matter and space at smaller distance scalesmatter and space at smaller distance scales
precision measurements sensitive to mass scales well above precision measurements sensitive to mass scales well above √√ss
The two main energy frontier tools in the past three The two main energy frontier tools in the past three decades: proton decades: proton colliderscolliders and electron and electron colliderscolliders
protons are more easily accelerated to high energies because protons are more easily accelerated to high energies because they radiate less synchrotron radiation in a circular acceleratothey radiate less synchrotron radiation in a circular acceleratorrelectron interactions are more easily studied because the initiaelectron interactions are more easily studied because the initial l state is simplerstate is simplerboth tools have been essential to advance our knowledge of both tools have been essential to advance our knowledge of fundamental physics:fundamental physics:
discoveries of new phenomenadiscoveries of new phenomenatesting models that account for these phenomenatesting models that account for these phenomena
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 77
Interplay of proton and electron Interplay of proton and electron colliderscolliders
proton proton colliderscolliders electron electron colliderscolliders1980’s: SppS• discovery of the Z0, W+, W−
1990’s: LEP/SLC• detailed investigation
of Z0, W+, W− production• indirect influence of top
quark – definitive predictionof its mass
• indirect influence of Higgsboson – mass estimated
2010’s: ILC• detailed study of the Higgs• detailed study of dark matter
2000’s: LHC• discovery of the Higgs boson?• discovery of the dark matter
particle?
1990’s: Tevatron• discovery of the top quark
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 88
Linear Collider Physics: ILinear Collider Physics: IThe electromagnetic and weak forces are now known to The electromagnetic and weak forces are now known to arise from a unifying symmetry in naturearise from a unifying symmetry in nature
most precisely demonstrated by the LEP/SLC experimentsmost precisely demonstrated by the LEP/SLC experiments
The symmetry between the electromagnetic and weak The symmetry between the electromagnetic and weak forces is broken (weak bosons are heavy)forces is broken (weak bosons are heavy)
The Higgs model is an ad hoc component of the Standard Model The Higgs model is an ad hoc component of the Standard Model that accounts for the broken symmetry that accounts for the broken symmetry –– does not explain whydoes not explain why
it works for low energy processes but falls apart at high it works for low energy processes but falls apart at high energiesenergies
the model predicts that a new particle exists (the Higgs the model predicts that a new particle exists (the Higgs boson) with definite propertiesboson) with definite properties
the ILC will be able to make a large variety of precision the ILC will be able to make a large variety of precision measurements that will provide critical data to understand measurements that will provide critical data to understand the real nature of electroweak symmetry breakingthe real nature of electroweak symmetry breaking
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 99
The golden processesThe golden processes
At LEP, the golden processes for studying the At LEP, the golden processes for studying the electroweak sector were:electroweak sector were:
At the ILC, the golden processes for At the ILC, the golden processes for studying the Higgs sector are:studying the Higgs sector are:
LEP beam energies were not sufficiently high enough LEP beam energies were not sufficiently high enough for these process to occurfor these process to occur
0Zee →−+ −+−+ → WWee
HZee 0→−+νν→−+ Hee
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 1010
Higgs production at a LCHiggs production at a LC
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 1111
Linear Collider Physics: IILinear Collider Physics: II
From astrophysical observations, it appears that From astrophysical observations, it appears that ~25% of the Universe is ~25% of the Universe is ““Dark MatterDark Matter””
neutral, stable, cold (massive), nonneutral, stable, cold (massive), non--baryonicbaryonicnew physics new physics –– a new (conserved) quantum number?a new (conserved) quantum number?production and detection of dark matter particles at production and detection of dark matter particles at future future colliderscolliders would be very exciting!would be very exciting!
One possible explanation: One possible explanation: supersymmetrysupersymmetrynot developed specifically to solve the DM problem!not developed specifically to solve the DM problem!the LSP is an excellent candidate for DMthe LSP is an excellent candidate for DM
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 1212
Dark Matter at the ILC?Dark Matter at the ILC?
There are strong hints that dark matter could be There are strong hints that dark matter could be produced at the ILCproduced at the ILC
SUSY favours SUSY favours sparticlesparticle masses below ~ 1 masses below ~ 1 TeVTeVThe dark matter density is consistent with a neutral The dark matter density is consistent with a neutral particle having particle having ““weakweak”” strength couplingsstrength couplings
The LHC has the best chance to discover The LHC has the best chance to discover strongly interacting strongly interacting sparticlessparticles ((gluinosgluinos, , squarkssquarks))
challenging study at LHC: initial state is not well challenging study at LHC: initial state is not well known, final state involves a cascade of known, final state involves a cascade of sparticlesparticledecays, with at least two massive invisible particlesdecays, with at least two massive invisible particles
ILC can study the weakly interacting ILC can study the weakly interacting sparticlessparticlesLHC+ILC data can LHC+ILC data can ““predictpredict”” DM relic density DM relic density
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 1313
ILC/LHC ILC/LHC complementaritycomplementarity
Well documented study underway:Well documented study underway:LHC/ILC Study Group:LHC/ILC Study Group:
http://www.ippp.dur.ac.uk/~georg/lhclc/http://www.ippp.dur.ac.uk/~georg/lhclc/Recent document:Recent document:
““Physics Interplay of the LHC and the ILCPhysics Interplay of the LHC and the ILC””hephep--ph / 0410364ph / 0410364470 pages:470 pages:
all cases: ILC + LHC data complementaryall cases: ILC + LHC data complementary
• Higgs Physics• Strong Electroweak Symmetry Breaking• Supersymmetric Models• Electroweak and QCD Precision Physics• New Gauge Theories• Models with Extra Dimensions
http://www.ippp.dur.ac.uk/~georg/lhclc/
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 1414
Consensus in the HEP communityConsensus in the HEP community
Given the broad range of fundamental physics Given the broad range of fundamental physics questions that it addresses, the HEP community questions that it addresses, the HEP community sees the ILC to be the next step that is needed sees the ILC to be the next step that is needed to advance the fieldto advance the field
over 2700 particle physicists have signed a document over 2700 particle physicists have signed a document supporting the physics potential of the ILCsupporting the physics potential of the ILCthe US DOE places the ILC as the top priority for midthe US DOE places the ILC as the top priority for mid--term new facilities term new facilities committees for future accelerators (ICFA,ACFA,ECFA) committees for future accelerators (ICFA,ACFA,ECFA) also put the ILC as their first priorityalso put the ILC as their first priority
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 1515
Building the ILCBuilding the ILC
Over the past decade, significant effort has gone Over the past decade, significant effort has gone into the necessary R&D to design a linear into the necessary R&D to design a linear collider to reach the required specifications:collider to reach the required specifications:
Centre of mass energy: 500 Centre of mass energy: 500 GeVGeV –– 1000 1000 GeVGeVrequires RF cavities with a large accelerating requires RF cavities with a large accelerating gradient (>30 gradient (>30 MeV/mMeV/m))
Luminosity: > 10Luminosity: > 103434 cmcm−−2 2 ss−−11
requires large numbers of electrons (> 10requires large numbers of electrons (> 101010) ) packed into very small bunches (< 500 x 5 nmpacked into very small bunches (< 500 x 5 nm22) ) brought into collision at high rate (> 10brought into collision at high rate (> 1044 ss−−11))
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 1616
Building the ILCBuilding the ILC
Two complete designs were prepared that met Two complete designs were prepared that met these requirementsthese requirements
the key feature distinguishing them was the nature of the key feature distinguishing them was the nature of the RF accelerating cavities:the RF accelerating cavities:
US + Japan US + Japan –– high frequency, room temperaturehigh frequency, room temperatureGermany Germany –– lower frequency, superconductinglower frequency, superconducting
international technical review found both suitableinternational technical review found both suitable
In 2004, the International Technical In 2004, the International Technical Recommendation Panel selected the Recommendation Panel selected the superconducting optionsuperconducting option
the worldthe world’’s labs now working towards a single designs labs now working towards a single design
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 1717
Superconducting accelerator cavitiesSuperconducting accelerator cavities
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 1818
Possible Tunnel LayoutPossible Tunnel Layout
Need a 30 km tunnel to reach energy goalNeed a 30 km tunnel to reach energy goal
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 1919
Damping ring R&DDamping ring R&D
ATF facility in Japan hasATF facility in Japan hasdemonstrated necessarydemonstrated necessaryreduction in reduction in emittanceemittance
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 2020
Final focus R&DFinal focus R&D
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 2121
Linear collider detector conceptsLinear collider detector concepts
LDC
SiD
GLD
LDC: start from TESLA designCoordinators:• Ties Benke: Germany• Henri Videau: France• Marco Battaglia: USA• Dean Karlen: Canada• Bob Hsiung: Taiwan• Yasuhiro Sugimoto: JapanSee: www.ilcldc.org
http://www.tiscali.co.uk/reference/encyclopaedia/countryfacts/images/flags/large/c04973.gif
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 2222
Linear collider detector challengesLinear collider detector challenges
Compared to the LHC, the ILC environment is Compared to the LHC, the ILC environment is much less severe, but the performance much less severe, but the performance requirements are much more demanding:requirements are much more demanding:
VertexingVertexing: : σσipip ~ 5 ~ 5 μμm m ⊕⊕ 5 5 μμm/(p sinm/(p sin3/23/2 θθ))1/5 1/5 rrbeampipebeampipe, 1/30 pixel area, 1/30 thickness c.f. LHC, 1/30 pixel area, 1/30 thickness c.f. LHC
Tracking: Tracking: σσ(1/p(1/ptt) ~ 5 ) ~ 5 ××1010--55 GeVGeV--111/10 of LHC. 1/6 material in tracking volume1/10 of LHC. 1/6 material in tracking volume
CalorimetryCalorimetry: : σσEE ~ 0.3 ~ 0.3 √√EE1/200 granularity of calorimeter c.f. LHC1/200 granularity of calorimeter c.f. LHC
1/3 SLD
1/10 LEP
1/2 LEP
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 2323
Vertex detectorVertex detector
Precise Precise SiSi pixel detectors near the collision point pixel detectors near the collision point to detect the displaced vertex of particles coming to detect the displaced vertex of particles coming from the decay of a particle with a very short lifetime from the decay of a particle with a very short lifetime (less than 10(less than 10−−1212 s)s)
examples: charm, bottom quarks, examples: charm, bottom quarks, tautau leptonsleptons
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 2424
Tracking detectorTracking detector
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 2525
Tracking challengeTracking challenge
Example: Higgs recoil massExample: Higgs recoil mass
σ(1/pt) ~ 5 ×10-5 GeV-1is necessary!
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 2626
Tracking technologyTracking technology
Two technologies considered: Two technologies considered: SiSi (few precise (few precise measuring layers) or gas (continuous) measuring layers) or gas (continuous) Gas tracker: Time projection chamberGas tracker: Time projection chamber
to achieve resolution goal requires an advance to achieve resolution goal requires an advance in TPC technologyin TPC technologyCanadian groupsCanadian groupshave made bighave made bigadvances towardsadvances towardsthis goalthis goal……
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 2727
LC TPC R&D in CanadaLC TPC R&D in Canada
Prototype Prototype TPCsTPCs built to use MPGD readout:built to use MPGD readout:Carleton/Montreal group has Carleton/Montreal group has pioneered the method of charge pioneered the method of charge dispersion with a resistive anode dispersion with a resistive anode for GEM and for GEM and MicromegasMicromegas TPC TPC readoutreadoutVictoria group has operated Victoria group has operated a GEMa GEM--TPC in magnetic TPC in magnetic fields up to 5 Tfields up to 5 Tboth prototypes have both prototypes have demonstrated significantly demonstrated significantly better resolution as compared to traditional better resolution as compared to traditional TPCsTPCssee presentations on Wednesday at CAP congresssee presentations on Wednesday at CAP congress
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 2828
Future plans for LC TPC R&D in CanadaFuture plans for LC TPC R&D in Canada
The Canadian group plans to The Canadian group plans to participate in test beam studies at KEK and DESYparticipate in test beam studies at KEK and DESYparticipate in the design and construction of a large participate in the design and construction of a large scale prototype in collaboration with other groups scale prototype in collaboration with other groups from around the worldfrom around the world
how to segment and tile how to segment and tile MPGDsMPGDs on a large on a large endplate?endplate?
perform simulation studies to answer questions perform simulation studies to answer questions arising in the detector conceptsarising in the detector concepts
pattern recognition in jetspattern recognition in jetshow well can nonhow well can non--uniform magnetic fields be uniform magnetic fields be determined and corrected for? determined and corrected for?
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 2929
CalorimeterCalorimeter
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 3030
Jet Energy Resolution RequirementsJet Energy Resolution Requirements
Goal: distinguish W and Z when they decay into quarksGoal: distinguish W and Z when they decay into quarksrequires excellent jet energy resolution, requires excellent jet energy resolution, σσEE ~ 30% ~ 30% √√EE
, νννν ZZeeWWee →→ −+−+example:
E%30E%60
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 3131
Calorimeter technologyCalorimeter technology
To reach goal requires narrow showers and fine To reach goal requires narrow showers and fine segmentation: ECAL: segmentation: ECAL: Si+WSi+W HCAL: HCAL: SS+ScintSS+Scint??
Iron Tungsten
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 3232
LC LC CalorimetryCalorimetry R&D in CanadaR&D in Canada
Canadian group is just starting to join existing Canadian group is just starting to join existing LC calorimeter efforts:LC calorimeter efforts:
Regina group has experience with Regina group has experience with SiPMSiPM readout readout ––very attractive option for HCAL readoutvery attractive option for HCAL readoutMcGill group to participate in test beam studies of McGill group to participate in test beam studies of prototype calorimeter systems (CALICE collaboration) prototype calorimeter systems (CALICE collaboration)
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 3333
Bringing the ILC into realityBringing the ILC into reality
An international structure has been set up to An international structure has been set up to complete the global design of the ILCcomplete the global design of the ILC
Leader of the Global Design Effort: Barry Leader of the Global Design Effort: Barry BarishBarish
ILCSC
GlobalDesignEffort
Asia Regional Team
N. American Regional Team
EuropeanRegional Team
Participating Labsand Universities
Participating Labsand Universities
Participating Labsand Universities
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 3434
ILC timescaleILC timescale2005:2005:
GDE put togetherGDE put togetherDetector concept groups in formationDetector concept groups in formation
2006:2006:GDE to prepare the ILC Conceptual DesignGDE to prepare the ILC Conceptual DesignDetector concept groups to prepare Detector concept groups to prepare ““detector outlinesdetector outlines””
2007/8:2007/8:GDE to complete the ILC Technical DesignGDE to complete the ILC Technical DesignDetector concepts complete Conceptual DesignsDetector concepts complete Conceptual Designs
2008/9:2008/9:Site selection, government approvals, begin constructionSite selection, government approvals, begin constructionDetector collaborations formDetector collaborations form
2015?:2015?:earliest start of experimental programearliest start of experimental program
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 3535
Next stepsNext steps
Later this summer, a twoLater this summer, a twoweek workshop is beingweek workshop is beingheld at Snowmassheld at Snowmass
finalize baseline accelerator parameters for CDRfinalize baseline accelerator parameters for CDRstrong focus on detector concept studiesstrong focus on detector concept studies450 registered already450 registered alreadya good opportunity for newcomers to join the efforta good opportunity for newcomers to join the effort
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 3636
Canadian planningCanadian planning
Canadian ILC R&D funded through NSERC Canadian ILC R&D funded through NSERC discovery grantsdiscovery grants
egeg. 5 grantees on last TPC request (2004). 5 grantees on last TPC request (2004)
Travel to ILC workshops have been supported Travel to ILC workshops have been supported through IOF grantsthrough IOF grants
14 grantees on last request (2002)14 grantees on last request (2002)
Nucleus of Canadian group is meeting to plan Nucleus of Canadian group is meeting to plan for future ILC activity:for future ILC activity:
Montreal / McGill / Carleton / Toronto / Regina / Montreal / McGill / Carleton / Toronto / Regina / UBC / VictoriaUBC / VictoriaNext meeting: June 6, 5:15pm, room: CEME 1202Next meeting: June 6, 5:15pm, room: CEME 1202(follows PPD session) All are welcome(follows PPD session) All are welcome
June 4, 2005June 4, 2005 The International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall MeetingThe International Linear Collider / IPP Town Hall Meeting 3737
SummarySummary
The physics case for a Linear Collider is very The physics case for a Linear Collider is very compellingcompellingThe technologies for the machine and the The technologies for the machine and the experiments are in handexperiments are in handThe international HEP community is solidly The international HEP community is solidly behind the project and is working together to behind the project and is working together to bring it to realitybring it to realityTo ensure a strong future for particle physics in To ensure a strong future for particle physics in Canada, it is important for us to participate in Canada, it is important for us to participate in this projectthis project
Please join us. For more information see:Please join us. For more information see:www.linearcollider.orgwww.linearcollider.org www.linearcollider.cawww.linearcollider.ca
The International Linear Collidere+e- colliders at the frontierWhy Linear?“Energy Frontier” Particle PhysicsInterplay of proton and electron collidersLinear Collider Physics: IThe golden processesHiggs production at a LCLinear Collider Physics: IIDark Matter at the ILC?ILC/LHC complementarity Consensus in the HEP communityBuilding the ILCBuilding the ILCSuperconducting accelerator cavitiesPossible Tunnel LayoutDamping ring R&DFinal focus R&DLinear collider detector conceptsLinear collider detector challengesVertex detectorTracking detectorTracking challengeTracking technologyLC TPC R&D in CanadaFuture plans for LC TPC R&D in CanadaCalorimeterJet Energy Resolution RequirementsCalorimeter technologyLC Calorimetry R&D in CanadaBringing the ILC into realityILC timescaleNext stepsCanadian planningSummary