D6.2 Demonstrator Risk Assessmentheimdall-h2020.eu/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/HEIMDALL_D6... · 2019. 5. 6. · implemented for the upcoming release C and the final release. The document

D6.2

Demonstrator Risk Assessment

Instrument Collaborative Project

Call / Topic H2020-SEC-2016-2017/H2020-SEC-2016-2017-1

Project Title Multi-Hazard Cooperative Management Tool for Data Exchange, Response Planning and Scenario Building

Project Number 740689

Project Acronym HEIMDALL

Project Start Date 01/05/2017

Project Duration 42 months

Contributing WP WP 6

Dissemination Level PU

Contractual Delivery Date M24 (04/2019)

Actual Delivery Date 06/05/2019

Editor Christian Knopp (DLR)

Contributors Monika Friedemann (DLR), Alessandro Burastero, Eva Trasforini, (CIMA), Stéphanie Battiston, Stephen Clandillon (UNISTRA), Guido Luzi (CTTC), Cláudia Abanco (ICGC)

HEIMDALL [740689] D6.2

06/05/2019 i

Document History

Version Date Modifications Source

0.1 20/04/19 TOC DLR

0.2 24/04/2019 First draft DLR

0.3 29/04/2019 QA version DLR

1.0.F 06/05/2019 Final version submitted DLR


06/05/2019 ii

Table of Contents

List of Figures ........................................................................................................................ iii

List of Acronyms .................................................................................................................... iv

Executive Summary .............................................................................................................. 6

1 Introduction .................................................................................................................... 7

2 Technical requirements .................................................................................................. 8

3 Integration and Demonstration ....................................................................................... 9

3.1 Exposure data ........................................................................................................10

3.2 Hazard ...................................................................................................................13

3.3 Impact ....................................................................................................................14

4 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................16

5 References ....................................................................................................................17


06/05/2019 iii

List of Figures

Figure 3-1: Interaction with the HEIMDALL system by partners from CRI during the last end-user workshop in April 2019 at CIMA in Savona, Italy. ........................................................... 9

Figure 3-2: Explanation of the different features of the HEIMDALL platform and in particular of the risk assessment functionality during the last end-user workshop in April 2019 at CIMA in Savona, Italy. ..................................................................................................................... 9

Figure 3-3: Screenshot of the HEIMDALL GUI showing the building stock layer as part of the exposure information prepared and integrated for the demonstration of the system on landslide risk assessment. ....................................................................................................11

Figure 3-4: Screenshot showing the integrated transportation networks as part of the prepared exposure information. ............................................................................................11

Figure 3-5: The available critical infrastructures for the selected demonstration area were integrated into the exposure data set and used throughout the demonstration activities. ......12

Figure 3-6:Screenshot of the SP showing the observed landslide extent generated through the methods described in [3]. The black outlines correspond to the observed extent. ...........13

Figure 3-7: Result of the landslide simulator showing areas of low(green) - medium(yellow) - high(red) likeliness of landslide occurrence. .........................................................................13

Figure 3-8: Generated observation-based impact assesssment, showing here the impacted buildings identified using the extracted landslide extent. .......................................................14

Figure 3-9: Identification of affected or blocked roads within the demonstration area using the landslide extent. ...................................................................................................................14

Figure 3-10: Output of the simulation-based impact assessment showing the simulated damage ratio, the affected building type, hazard type and estimated economic values affected. ...............................................................................................................................15


06/05/2019 iv

List of Acronyms

AVA Avanti Communications LTD

CIMA Centro Internazionale in Monitoraggio Ambientale – Fondazione CIMA (CIMA Foundation)

CTTC Centre Tecnològic de Telecomunicacions de Catalunya (Catalan Tecnological Telecommunications Centre)

DLR Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt e.V.

RVA Risk and Vulnerability Assessment

SP Service Platform

SPH Space Hellas S.A.

TSYL Tecnosylva S.L.

WP Work Package


06/05/2019 v

Intentionally blank


06/05/2019 6

Executive Summary

This document provides a comprehensive presentation and description of the integrated risk assessment methods in the HEIMDALL platform. The application of the modules was tested during two demonstrations performed by the different end-users. The methods were tested and evaluate by the user in order to retrieve feedback and prioritize additional features to be implemented for the upcoming release C and the final release.

The document provides insight into current status of integration of the risk assessment methods and the demonstration efforts taken, the integration into the HEIMDALL GUI and other system components. The demonstration is part of the WP6/Task6.1.

The details on methodology are outlined in D6.1 and the technical documentation is described in D6.4. The document at hand shall serve as demonstrator of the implemented methods and will therefore refer to the associated deliverable where necessary.


06/05/2019 7

1 Introduction

Within HEIMDALL a risk assessment methodology integrating multiple hazard types was defined. The methods address simulated and observed hazard information in order to cope with the different levels of detail in hazard information. This document will provide a comprehensive demonstration about the implemented methods integrated in the SP and tested during End User Workshop 3.

The underlying technical requirements determining the implemented methods are outlined in [1]. The following section will provide an overview about the efforts taken during the last end-user workshop to demonstrate the implemented work to the end users.


06/05/2019 8

2 Technical requirements

The technical requirements are outlined in a dedicated deliverable describing the overall concept of risk assessment within HEIMDALL [1]. The technical requirements were derived from the user and system requirements collected during the various end-user workshops.


06/05/2019 9

3 Integration and Demonstration

This sections demonstrates the current status of application of the risk assessment concepts outlined in [1], [2]. The demonstration area of the end-user workshop EUW3 hosted by CIMA in Savona, Italy from 16th to 18th of April 2019 is taken as a reference.

The section will show the different sub modules products of the RVA integrated in the HEIMDALL SP.

Figure 3-1: Interaction with the HEIMDALL system by partners from CRI during the last end-user workshop in April 2019 at CIMA in Savona, Italy.

Figure 3-2: Explanation of the different features of the HEIMDALL platform and in particular of the risk assessment functionality during the last end-user workshop in April 2019 at CIMA in Savona, Italy.


06/05/2019 10

3.1 Exposure data The landslide used for demonstration during EUW3 occurred in the village of Monesi di Mendatica in the Liguria region of Northern Italy. Exposure data was carefully gathered and integrated in the SP. This sections shows the how the selected data was presented to the end users and advisory board members.


06/05/2019 11

Figure 3-3: Screenshot of the HEIMDALL GUI showing the building stock layer as part of the exposure information prepared and integrated for the demonstration of the system on landslide risk assessment.

Figure 3-4: Screenshot showing the integrated transportation networks as part of the prepared exposure information.


06/05/2019 12

Figure 3-5: The available critical infrastructures for the selected demonstration area were integrated into the exposure data set and used throughout the demonstration activities.


06/05/2019 13

3.2 Hazard As described in the concept definition [1], different levels of detail in hazard information are integrated in the system. This sections demonstrated the integrated observed information of past or present incidents (Figure 3-6) documented in [3] and the hazard information retrieved by modelling and simulation (Figure 3-7) documented in [4].

Figure 3-6:Screenshot of the SP showing the observed landslide extent generated through the methods described in [3]. The black outlines correspond to the observed extent.

Figure 3-7: Result of the landslide simulator showing areas of low(green) - medium(yellow) - high(red) likeliness of landslide occurrence.


06/05/2019 14

3.3 Impact As outlined in the risk assessment impact concept [1], two different approaches are necessary to retrieve consistent Impact Assessment results. This sections demonstrates the observation-based and the simulation-based impact assessment results for the landslide hazard.

Figure 3-8: Generated observation-based impact assesssment, showing here the impacted buildings identified using the extracted landslide extent.

Figure 3-9: Identification of affected or blocked roads within the demonstration area using the landslide extent.


06/05/2019 15

Figure 3-10: Output of the simulation-based impact assessment showing the simulated damage ratio, the affected building type, hazard type and estimated economic values affected.


06/05/2019 16

4 Conclusion

The defined risk assessment concept was implemented and integrated according to the release plan. The past end-user workshops showed a high interest in the features already implemented and planned for the upcoming releases. The document at hand provides insights into the activities performed and the successful demonstration of the system to the involved end-users and advisory board members during EUW3 in April 2019.


06/05/2019 17

5 References

[1] C. A. (ICGC) Monika Friedemann (DLR) Roberto Rudari Eva Trasforini (CIMA) Stéphanie Battiston Stephen Clandillon (UNISTRA) Guido Luzi (CTTC) Christian Knopp (DLR), “D6.1 Concept design for risk analysis methods and components – Detailed concept design and documentation of methods on risk analysis - Draft,” H2020-Project HEIMDALL.

[2] C. A. (ICGC) Christian Knopp (DLR) Sandro Martinis (DLR) Roberto Rudari (CIMA) Eva Trasforini (CIMA) Stéphanie Battiston (UNISTRA) Stephen Clandillon (UNISTRA) Guido Luzi (CTTC) Miguel Mendes (TSYL), “D6.4 Technical Specifications on Hazard, Scale and User-Specific Risk Assessment Information, Products and Service Workflows- Draft,” H2020-Project HEIMDALL.

[3] J. B. (UNISTRA) Stéphanie Battiston (UNISTRA) Stephen Clandillon (UNISTRA) Claire Huber (UNISTRA) Michaela Bettinger (DLR) Guido Luzi (CTTC) Maria Cuevas (CTTC) Michael Nolde (DLR) Sandro Martinis (DLR), “D5.1 EO Tools and Products – Specifications – Draft,” H2020-Project HEIMDALL.

[4] M. Mendes, “D5.12 Modelling and Simulation Services – Specifications – Draft.” .

D6.2 Demonstrator Risk Assessmentheimdall-h2020.eu/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/HEIMDALL_D6... · 2019. 5. 6. · implemented for the upcoming release C and the final release. The document

Documents