Neil Love, MD September 17, 2005 Current Patterns of Care Current Patterns of Care in Breast Cancer: in Breast Cancer: Use of Adjuvant Trastuzumab Use of Adjuvant Trastuzumab
Jan 19, 2016
Neil Love, MD
September 17, 2005
Current Patterns of Care Current Patterns of Care in Breast Cancer:in Breast Cancer:
Use of Adjuvant TrastuzumabUse of Adjuvant Trastuzumab
Recent Trends in Adjuvant Systemic Recent Trends in Adjuvant Systemic Therapy of Early Breast CancerTherapy of Early Breast Cancer
Chemotherapy Taxanes Dose-dense chemotherapy Use of computer models like Adjuvant! Oncotype DX™ assay
Endocrine therapy Aromatase inhibitors
Biologic therapy Trastuzumab
35 years old 65 years old 75 years old
CI CO CI CO CI CO
No 100% 94% 100% 96% 100% 95%
Yes 0% 6% 0% 4% 0% 5%
Trastuzumab in the Adjuvant SettingTrastuzumab in the Adjuvant Setting
1.2-centimeter, Grade II tumor ER-negative, HER2-positive 3 positive nodes
Would you utilize adjuvant trastuzumab off protocol?
CI = Clinical Investigators
CO = Community Oncologists
Source: Breast Cancer Update Patterns of Care Study; Vol2(1): February 2005.
Clinical Use of Adjuvant TrastuzumabClinical Use of Adjuvant Trastuzumab
Would you recommend adjuvant trastuzumab to a 65-year-old woman with an ER-negative, HER2-positive tumor with 10 positive nodes?
CI CO
No 73% 82%
Yes 27% 18%
CI = Clinical Investigators
CO = Community Oncologists
Source: Breast Cancer Update Patterns of Care Study; Vol2(1): February 2005.
Use of Adjuvant TrastuzumabUse of Adjuvant Trastuzumab
Have you ever utilized adjuvant trastuzumab in a nonprotocol setting?
CI CO
No 57% 82%
Yes 43% 18%
For those answering “yes,” in how many patients?
Median 2 patients 3 patients
CI = Clinical Investigators
CO = Community Oncologists
Source: Breast Cancer Update Patterns of Care Study; Vol2(1): February 2005.
Breast Cancer Survivors’ Perspectives Breast Cancer Survivors’ Perspectives on Adjuvant Trastuzumabon Adjuvant Trastuzumab
Case scenario: 40-year-old woman with ER/PR/HER2-positive IDC and 6 positive nodes
New York Miami Houston
Would want trastuzumab off protocol
15% 35% 48%
Would participate in a randomized adjuvant trastuzumab trial
21% 44% 40%
Source: Love NL et at. San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium, 2003.Abstract 142.
35yo 55yo 75yo 85yo
Trastuzumab 88% 88% 56% 36%
6 months
1 year
2 years
5%
90%
5%
5%
95%
—
14%
86%
—
22%
78%
—
Concurrent
Sequential
73%
27%
73%
27%
64%
36%
50%
50%
Current Patterns of Care: Case A — 1.2-cm Current Patterns of Care: Case A — 1.2-cm IDC, ER/PR/HER2-positive, 3 positive nodesIDC, ER/PR/HER2-positive, 3 positive nodes
Source: Breast Cancer Update Patterns of Care Study; Vol2(2): August 2005.
35yo 55yo 75yo 85yo
10+ nodes, 1.2 cm 96% 96% 84% 52%
3+ nodes, 1.2 cm 96% 96% 72% 32%
1+ node, 1.2 cm 96% 96% 68% 32%
Node-neg, 2.4 cm 92% 92% 64% 28%
Node-neg, 1.2 cm 80% 76% 56% 28%
Current Patterns of Care: Case B — Current Patterns of Care: Case B — ER/PR-negative, HER2-positive, Grade II IDC:ER/PR-negative, HER2-positive, Grade II IDC:
Would You Recommend Trastuzumab?Would You Recommend Trastuzumab?
Source: Breast Cancer Update Patterns of Care Study; Vol2(2): August 2005.
Time since completion of AC T
6 mo 1 yr 2 yr 4 yr
Node-neg 56% 32% 4% —
3+ nodes 80% 60% 16% 4%
10+ nodes 84% 72% 44% 28%
Current Patterns of Care: Case C — a 55 yo Current Patterns of Care: Case C — a 55 yo with a 2.4-cm, Grade II, ER/PR-negative, with a 2.4-cm, Grade II, ER/PR-negative,
HER2-positive IDCHER2-positive IDC
Would you start delayed trastuzumab?Would you start delayed trastuzumab?
Source: Breast Cancer Update Patterns of Care Study; Vol2(2): August 2005.
Sources of Information about Sources of Information about ASCO Adjuvant Trastuzumab TrialsASCO Adjuvant Trastuzumab Trials
Attended ASCO 36%
Meetings (CME, tumor board, ASCO review, etc)
56%
Medical/scientific journals 44%
Breast Cancer Update audio series 40%
Lay press/news media 16%
Other 16%
Source: Breast Cancer Update Patterns of Care Study; Vol2(2): August 2005.
Case of Dr Barbara Fallon Case of Dr Barbara Fallon New Britton, ConnecticutNew Britton, Connecticut
42 yo woman: ER/PR-negative, HER2-positive IDC, 5 positive nodes
Enrolled on NSABP-B-31 — randomized to AC T
Patient is now 28 months since start of adjuvant chemotherapy
• Should trastuzumab be administered at this time?
• If she presented today, what would you recommend?
Case of Dr Gary Steinecker Case of Dr Gary Steinecker Oak Lawn, IllinoisOak Lawn, Illinois
76 yo woman: 3.5-cm, ER/PR-negative, HER2-positive, node-negative IDC (2/2005)
CALGB 49909: randomized to A/C paclitaxel trastuzumab
Significant toxicity with chemotherapy (colitis) Post AC MUGA: drop from 66% to 50% — not eligible for
trastuzumab as per protocol Repeat MUGA : EF 71%; 2D Echo: EF 45%
• Should trastuzumab be administered at this time?
• If she presented today, what would you recommend?
Use of Media to Assist with Informed Consent:Use of Media to Assist with Informed Consent: NCI SBIR Grant R43CA103264-01A1 NCI SBIR Grant R43CA103264-01A1
Sandra Franco, MDRichard Margolese, MD
Ms M, a participant in NSABP-B-31
Ms R, a participant in NSABP-B-38
Ms F, a participant in NSABP-B-38
Ms L, a participant in NSABP-B-35
Cynthia Frankel, RN
AgendaAgenda
12:00 PM Dr Wolmark: Introduction
12:05 PM Dr Love: Current patterns of care in the community
12:15 PM Dr Romond: Combined analysis: NSABP-B-31/NCCTG-N9831
12:35 PM Dr Slamon: BCIRG 006: Background, design, initial results
12:55 PM Dr Leyland-Jones: First results of the HERA trial
1:15 PM Dr Kaufman: NCCTG-N9831: Sequential versus concurrent trastuzumab and chemotherapy
1:35 PM Dr Geyer: NSABP-B-31 cardiac toxicity data
2:00 PM Close