CriticalDebatersHandbook_

8/2/2019 CriticalDebatersHandbook_

1/82

!"#$#!%&'()*%$)"+',%-(*../'

*01'2%!/#)'3%++)0''

4566'

(#")!$."'.7'()*%$)'

8-#9)"+#$0'.7'./&%,.3%'

+..-)"()*%$):!.3'

'

!

!

!

"#$%!&'&()!*&+,%&(!-,.!/0%!0.%$!%1&!234,(&!1$5&!$/!6$50-)!*&+,%&7!!8$9&!6&$65&!.&&*!($4.*!1$5&2:!$(!$+%42&!$.&2!$(!.$!1$5&!,%!,557!!;!%10..!

2%)5&!%$!*&+,%&7!!?1&!34&2%0$.!02:!*$!%1&)!%,2!

%1&9!%$!,--&22!%1,%!2%)5&@A!

'

'

$;


2/82


3/82

E8I!CO!IW;DI#FIG77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777_L!

FBC88aIbJP;#J?;C#G 7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 7777777777777777777777777777_X!

QKJ?!;8!J#!CWIBW;IQ^7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777_H!

MI;#Z!TBITJBID!C#!?KI!RI[!JBZEPI#?877777777777777777777777777777777777777777 77777777777777777777777777777__!

MI;#Z!J!ZCCD!IWI#`;O!DIMJ?IB^ 777777777777777777777777777777777777777 777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 777777_c!

FK;?aFKJ?777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 7777777_S!

DIMJ?I!LYL!8EPPJB[77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777_V!

FJT;?JU;8P!R!M;MU;CZBJTK[777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777cY!

DIMJ?I!JMCE?!DIMJ?I!M;MU;CZBJTK[77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777cH!

O;B8?!TB;CB;?[!?C!O;B8?!JPIB;FJ#8!M;M;CZBJTK[77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777cS!

OBJPIQCBR!R!8ETTCB?`DIMJ?I!JMCE?!DIMJ?I 777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 77777777777777c]!

OBJPIQCBR!J#?;aR!M;MU;CZBJTK[777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777SL!

KI;DIZZIB!R!M;MU;CZBJTK[7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777SN!

QK;?I#I88!R!M;MU;CZBJTK[^77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777Sc!

FCPPC#!J#8QIB8!?C!RB;?;R8 777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 7777777777777VY!


4/82

INTRODUCTION:

!

D&+,%&!02!>1,%!>&!9,1$!-$96&%&!0.!-($22a&d,90.,%0$.!$(!6$50-)!*&+,%&!$.!%1&!10=1!2-1$$5!,.*!-$55&=&!5&'&57!

?1&(&!,(&!9,.)!*0//&(&.%!6&(26&-%0'&2!$.!>1&.!%1&!"R(0%0,2!/0(2%!4%050e&*!0.!-$55&=&!*&+,%&7!!;!1,'&!1&,(*!,!/&>!*0//&(&.%!2%$(0&27!!J55!;!-,.!*$!02!=$!>0%1!9)!2%$()!

$.!1$>!;!>,2!,%%(,-%&*!%$!%102!%)6&!$/!*&+,%&7!!;!>,2!,!/$(9&(!8;E!*&+,%&(!4.*&(!%1&!

*0(&-%0$.!$/!M05&7!!Q1&.!;!,((0'&*!,%!8;E:!%1&)!>&(&!*$0.=!2$9&%10.=!4.034&!0.!*&+,%&7!!;.!%1&!/0.,5!($4.*!$/!FIDJ!0.!L]V]:!%1&)!65,)&*!>1,%!>&!-,55&*!f,ee7!!;.2%&,*!

$/!*&+,%0.=!$4%!%1&!5&=,5!6(&-&*&.-&!$/!5,>!>0%1!Z$.e,=,:!8;E!9,*&!,.!,(=49&.%!%1,%!5,>!02!6,%(0,(-10,5!,.*!%1,%!>&!942%!34&2%0$.!%1$2&!.$%0$.2!+&/$(&!>&!-,.!

*02-422!>1,%!02!"g42%A7!!;!=$%!0.'$5'&*!0.!%1&!&.'0($.9&.%,5!&%10-!,(=49&.%!,.*!/$4.*!%102!-$.-&6%!$/!1$5029!%1,%!>,2!(,%1&(!,%%(,-%0'&!,.*!2&&9&*!50


5/82

$66$.&.%!>055!+&!,%!%1&0(!+&2%7!!?>$!%10.=2!(02&!%$!%1&!%$6!0.!,!=$$*!*&+,%&7!!Q1$!1,2!

,!=$$*!,(=49&.%!,.*!>1$!1,2!=$$*!&'0*&.-&!%$!2466$(%!%1&0(!,(=49&.%@


6/82

NE'?GE'?BB'PEGJIG>?@RE'KE?>=W:#KX='?BB'?'PEGJIG>?@REWW'

?1&!+&2%!R!*&+,%&(2!,(&!%1&!$.&2!>1$!4.*&(2%,.*!1$>!6&$65&!9020.%&(6(&%!>1,%!R!

*&+,%&(2!*$:!,.*!1$>!9$2%!,(=49&.%2!9,*&!,=,0.2%!-(0%0-,5!6$20%0$.2!$.5)!/4.-%0$.!

,($4.*!/,52&!2%&(&$%)6&27!J2!)$4!>055!2&&:!0/!)$4!*$!.$%!&.=,=&!0.!/,45%)!R!*&+,%&:!%1&.!9$2%!$/!%1&!-$99$.!%1&$()!,(=49&.%2!%$!*029022!-(0%0-0292!1,'&!.$!096,-%!$.!

)$4(!,(=49&.%7!!8%,)!,1&,*!$/!%1&!-4('&7!!Q1,%!,(&!6&$65&!9$2%5)!2,)0.=:!,.*!1$>!*$!;!,'$0*!*&+,%0.=!0%!$(:!1$>!*$!;!*&/&,%!0%!2$4.*5)@!J2!)$4!4%050e&!%102!=40*&:!)$4!

>055!2&&!1$>!)$4!-,.!65,)!$//!$/!%1&!9020./$(9&*!6&(26&-%0'&2!6&$65&!1,'&!,+$4%!R!

*&+,%&(27!!P4-1!$/!%102!-$9&2!/($9!6&$65&!>,.%0.=!%$!.$%!=$!0.!%1&!234,(&!1$5&:!+4%!5,-5&*=&!,.*!&d6&(0&.-&!%$!%,&!1,'&!

+,*!R!*&+,%&:!g42%!50&!1,'&!+,*!6$50-)!*&+,%&7!

Q1,%!02!,!R(0%0,.%!%$!=0'&!,.!&d-5420$.,()!&d,965&!%1,%!>$45*!6(&'&.%!

-&(%,0.!,(=49&.%2!/($9!+&0.=!,!R(0%0&!>&(&!%,4=1%!%1&!+,20-!_!6(09,a/,-0,!0224&2!%1,%!942%!+&!9&%!%$!1,'&!,!5&=0%09,%&!,//0(9,%0'&7!!P,.)!

,(=49&.%2!>&(&!>1,%!;!>$45*!-,55!6($-&22a$(0&.%&*!,(=49&.%27!!J2!6&$65&!>&(&!

%,4=1%!%$!1,'&!,*',.%,=&2!%$!%1&0(!65,.:!,.*!*02,*',.%,=&2!%$!%1&!$%1&(!%&,92!65,.27!!?1&(&!%1&.!+&-,9&!%1&!-$99$.!%1&9&!$/!1,'0.=!,!/&>!-$96$.&.%2!$/!,!

k*02l,*',.%,=&!%1,%!0.-54*&!m!JG!U0..%4(.!,.*!9$(&!4.&965$)9&.%!>,2!&.$4=1!%$!>0.!*&+,%&27!!?1&.!$.&!*,)!

2$9&$.&!(&,50e&*!%1,%!>1,%!>&!>$45*!/&,(!%1&!9$2%!02!,!>,(7!!?102!096,-%!=(&>!%$!

,.!&2-,5,%0.=!>,(!%1,%!>$45*!%1&.!%4(.!.4-5&,(7!!;%!>,2!%1&!*(0'&!%$!/0.*!%1&!+0==&2%!096,-%!%1,%!-$45*!,//&-%!%1&!9$2%!6&$65&7!!M4%!0%!>,2!,52$!,5$.=!%1&!2,9&!

9&%1$*$5$=0-,5!50.&2!,2!%1&!2-,(&!%,-%0-2!4%050e&*!*4(0.=!%1&!-$5*!>,(7!!8$!/$(!9,.)!)&,(2:!6&$65&!>$45*!5$$,(7!!?1&(&!>&(&!

6&$65&!>1$!>$45*!,(=4&!(,-029!,2!,.!096,-%:!+4%!9,.)!%09&2!+&-,42&!(,-029!&d02%2:!

,.*!02!1,(*!%$!9&,24(&:!%1&!(02,(!$4%>&0=1&*!0.-(&9&.%,5!90%0=,%0$.2!$/!(,-0297!!?1&!2,9&!-$45*!+&!2,0*!/$(!2&d029!$(!

1$9$61$+0,7!!8$!>1,%!02!,!-(0%034&@!!;%!02!%1&!-(0%0-0e0.=!$/!%1&!',54&2`0*&,52!`6105$2$61)!&9+$*0&*!>0%10.!%1&!+,20-!2466$(%!/$(!%1&!65,.7!!!?102!-$45*!+&!,.!

&d,90.,%0$.!$/!9$*&2:!9&%1$*2:!$.%$5$=0&2:!&%10-2:!*02-$4(2&!$(!2$54%0$.27!!Q1,%!

9,*&!0%!'&()!1,(*!/$(!%1&2&!096,-%2!%$!+&!0.-54*&*!0.!*&+,%&!02!1$>!%1&)!-$96,(&!%$!,2,2!1,(*!%$!>0.!,!*&+,%&7!!I26&-0,55)!>1&.!6&$65&!5&,(.!%$!42&!,(=49&.%2!50&!.&&*!%$!>$(()!,+$4%!%102!21$(%a%&(9!

096,-%!%1,%!>&!-,.!-,5-45,%&:!(,%1&(!%1,.!096,-%2!%1,%!>&!-,.!.&'&(!2&&!2$54%0$.!$(!/0.,5!096,-%!/($97!!8$!>1&.!)$4!(&,*!,!-(0%034&!,.*!%1&!$%1&(!%&,9!(&,*2!

"-,5-45,+050%)!=$$*A:!)$4!-,.!2&&!>1&(&!24-1!,.!,(=49&.%!=&%2!0%2!2%(,%&=0-!+,2&7!

'

'


7/82

#+'()*%$)'%'U%3)'."'%'$"%#-#-U'U".8-('7."'%(9.!%!0Y'

;2!*&+,%&!,!=,9&!$(!02!0%!,!65,-&!%$!6(,-%0-&!,*'$-,-)@!!?102!02!>1&(&!;!/0.*!,!5$%!$/!

6&$65&!*&-0*&!%1&)!>$45*!(,%1&(!+&!,!R!*&+,%&(!%1,.!,!6$50-)!*&+,%&(7!!;%\2!$


8/82

%"U83)-$1'

Q1,%!02!%1&!*0//&(&.-&!+&%>&&.!)$4(!,(=49&.%!,.*!9)!,(=49&.%:!,.*!>1)!02!%1,%!

096$(%,.%@!

C.&!%10.=!)$4!>055!/0.*!,+$4%!9)!,*'0-&!0.!(&5,%0$.!%$!%1&!>,)!*&+,%&!,(=49&.%2!,(&!

-$.2%(4-%&*!(&'$5'&2!,($4.*!.$%0$.2!$/!,+2$54%0297!!;/!)$4!-,.!5&,(.!1$>!%$!-(0%0-0e&!,(=49&.%2!%1,%!/$(&-5$2&!%10.,+$4%!%1$2&!%10.=2!%1,%!-,.!+&!9&,24(&*!$+g&-%0'&5):!,.*!%142:!-,.!+&!>(0%%&.!$//!0.!

/,'$(!$/!9$(&!"%,.=0+5&A!%10.=2!%1,%!6&$65&!1,'&!*&-0*&*!%$!+&!(&,5!$(!%(4&7!!J!=$$*!,(=49&.%!2,)2!%1,%G!

,7 [$4(!50%&(,%4(&!02!+,*`)$4(!%1&$(0&2`2-1$$52!$/!%1$4=1%!&%-7!+7 [$4!*$.\%!2$5'&!m!,!+&%%&(!R!1,2!,!R(0%0

?1&(&!02!94-1!*&+,%&!,+$4%!"*$!)$4!.&&*!,.!,5%&(.,%0'&@A!!;.!9)!'0&>:!%1&!%1&$(0&2!,+$4%!1$>!%1&!-$96$.&.%2!$/!%1&!R!21$45*!/4.-%0$.!,(&!$.5)!(&26$.2&2!%$!%1&!

9&%1$*2!-1$2&.!+)!%1&!6$50-)!*&+,%&(2!%$!,.2>&(!%1&!R7!!J%!/0(2%!0%!>,2!/(,9&>$(,2.\%!,.!,(=49&.%7!!?1&.:!0%!>,2!g42%!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.:!6,22!%1&!65,.!

,.*!2,)!b!02!+,*7!!?1&.:!%1&!R!(&26$.2&!>,2:!">&55!0/!%1,%!02!,55!%1,%!-,.!+&,%!9&:!L.(!

>055!9,&!>055!.$%!5$2&!%1&!6&(97A!!J/%&(!L,(\2!*&-0*&*!%102!>,2!%$$!94-1:!,.$%1&(!2%(,%&=)!-,9&!,5$.=G!"Q1,%\2!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&@A!!?1&.:!%1&!2%,.*,(*!(&26$.2&!

+)!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!>,2!%1,%!%1&!.&=,%0'&!>,2!2%4-0%1!%1&!2%,%42!34$7!!8$:!%1&!R!

(&26$.2&!>,2!(,%1&(!54-0*:!,5%&(.,%0'&2!50&!21$45*!'$0*!$4(!50/&!$/!"*&20(&AA!$(!">&!21$45*!&9+(,-&!$4(!0.2&-4(0%0&2A7!!?1&(&!>,2!

.$!>,)!/$(!%1&2&!,5%&(.,%0'&2!%$!+&!,-%4,50e&*:!>10-1!(&245%&*!0.!%1&!-,%&=$(0e,%0$.!$/!R!*&+,%&!,2!%$$!"E%$60,.A:!>10-1!26,($(02&!0%!+&-$9&2!,!205'&(!+455&%!,=,0.2%!)$4(!+($,*a+,2&*!,(=49&.%7!!

?1&.!2$9&!*&+,%&(2!%(0&*!%1&!/5$,%0.=!60-!k65,.!0.-5420'&!-$4.%&(a65,.l7!"Q&!2466$(%!,55!$/!)$4(!,//0(9,%0'&!&d-&6%!)$4(!(&6(&2&.%,%0$.2A:!,.*!%1&.!,(=4&*!%1&(&!>&(&!

(&6(&2&.%,%0$.2!0.!%1&!L,-!%1,%!>$45*!9,$(2&7!!?1&!/5$,%0.=!60-2!%1&$()!

+5$-


9/82

&d,965&2!$/!>1&(&!)$4!-,.!/0.*!,!65,-&!%$!*02,=(&&:!,.*!%1&.!+&!6(&6,(&*!%$!,(=4&!

>1)!%102!02!9$2%!096$(%,.%7!

;!>055!2,)!%1,%!%1&(&!,(&!2%(,%&=0-!(&,2$.2!%$!42&!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!50,2!%()0.=!%$!42&!%1&0(!096,-%2!%$!$4%>&0=1!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&:!,.*!%102!>,2!24-1!,.!461055!2%(4==5&7!!M4%!%1&.!0/!)$4!=&%!2%(,%&=0-:!)$4!-,.!9,.1055!g$)(0*&7!!;/!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!2$5'&2!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&:!%1&.!)$4!$.5)!1,'&!%$!>0.!096,-%2!%$!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!/($9!)$4(!50.

*&-0*0.=!*&+,%&2!$/!65,.!'27!-$4.%&(a65,.n0%!02!$.&!>,)!%1&)!-,.!.$%!%$%,55)!-$96(&1&.*!%1&!R:!+4%!2%055!+&!,+5&!%$!2&&!%1,%!0%!02!6(&/&(,+5&!%$!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&7!!

?102!02!,52$!,!=$$*!&d65,.,%0$.!,2!%$!>1)!>$(*!&d-5420$.!-$4.%&(a65,.2!,(&!=$$*7!![$4!(&>(0%&!%1&!65,.!>0%1$4%!,!6,(%0-45,(!>$(*!0.!0%:!,.*!%1&.!1,'&!,(=49&.%2!,2!%$!

>1)!%102!>$(*!)$4!5&/%!$4%!02!,!+,*!>$(*!,.*!.$%!420.=!0%!02!+&%%&(7!!T&$65&!,52$!42&!

%1&!"&(,24(&A!9&%1$*:!>1&(&!%1&)!1,'&!,!-$4.%&(a65,.!%1,%!64%2!%1&!>$(*!4.*&(!&(,24(&7!!kD&((0*,l!!8$9&!6&$65&!*(,>!50.&2!%1($4=1!%1&!*&+,%,+5&!>$(*2!0.!%1&0(!

65,.:!,.*!,(&!(&,*)!%$!,(=4&!&(,24(&!2$5'&2!+&%%&(!%1,.!*$0.=!%1&!65,.!>0%1$4%!%1&!>$(*7!!k;I!m!*$.\%!/$(=&%!%1&!6,2%!02!$.&!,(=49&.%l7!

?1&(&!02!.$!$.&a>,)!%$!+&!,!R!*&+,%&(:!)$4!(&,55)!1,'&!%$!2&&!%1&!*0//&(&.%!2%(,%&=0&2:!,.*!-1$$2&!%1$2&!>02&5)!+,2&*!46$.!%1&!&'0*&.-&!,.*!%1&!,(=49&.%!)$4!>,.%!%$!

9,E@K:''#@'RI>PEK>I@'=KG?KEHF'I@'K;E'@EH?K0.l!

J.*!%1&(&!)$4!1,'&!0%7!!;!-1$$2&!%$!*02,=(&&!>0%1G!

?1&0(!U,.=4,=&!-1$0-&!m!;I!!U,.=4,=&!R(0%0


10/82


11/82

")+)%"!,1'F1$$2&!,.!,(&,!$/!%1&!50+(,()!m![$4!.&&*!&'0*&.-&!%$!24('0'&!%1&!*&+,%&!,/%&(!%1&!

*&+,%&7!!Q1,%!02!%1,%@!!?1,%!02!>1&.!%1&!g4*=&k2l!%,055!2,)!

%1,%!)$4!.&&*!%$!26&.*!%09&!,%!%1&!50+(,():!$(!-(&,%&!)$4(!$>.7!!?1&(&!2&&92!%$!+&!2$9&!4.034&!',54&!0.!+$$0%1!0%!,%!/0(2%7!!R&&6!>0%1!0%7!!?102!02!>1&(&!(&2&,(-1!+&-$9&2!

096$(%,.%7!!;/!)$4!(&,55)!!)$4(!,(&,!$/!%1&!50+(,():!,2!2$$.!,2!%1&!$%1&(!%&,9!9&.%0$.2!%1&!.,9&!$/!,.!,4%1$(:!)$4!21$45*!!>1,%!%1&!9$2%!,.*!+&2%!

,(=49&.%2!%1,%!-$45*!+&!9,*&!+)!%1,%!,4%1$(7!!!;/!)$4!1,'&.\%!(&,*!0%:!%1&.!=&%!%1&!

-0%,%0$.:!,.*!9,105&!%1&!R!%&,92!1,'&!&'0*&.-&!(,%1&(!%1,.!%1&$()!+5$-.!%1&!-,55!.49+&(2!,.*!=$!%$!&,-1!-,55!.49+&(7!!f$%!*$>.!%1&!-,55!.49+&(2:!,.*!%1&.!26&.*!%09&!0.!%1,%!>1$5&!2&-%0$.!$/!%1&!50+(,()7!!U,)!)$4(!+,=!*$>.7!!8&%!46!

-,967!

8%&6!L!m!T455!$//!,55!+$$!$(!(&5&',.%7!

?$!*&%&(90.&!.&>:!0%\2!&,2):!5$$

02!.$%!%1,%!-(,/%)7!!;!424,55)!5$$$(*2!,.*!%1&.!5$$

8%&6!X!m!8$(%!$4%!%1&!g4.1&(&!)$4!%1&.!=$!%1($4=1!%1&!XY!+$$!6,=&2:!%$!*&%&(90.&!0/!%1&)!>055!+&!2,)0.=!>1,%!;!.&&*7!


12/82

8%&6!N!m!O0.*0.=!,(=49&.%!-$96$.&.%2:!.$%!6,(,=(,612!

;%!02!$

%09&!%$!64%!&,-1!-$96$.&.%!$/!5&*=&!0.%$!&'0*&.-&7!!;/!%1&!>(0%0.=!02!

&d65,.,%$()!$(!"/,-%!+,2&*A:!%1&.!)$4!*$.\%!(&,55)!.&&*!0%!,2!&'0*&.-&7!!?102!02!>1)!;!501$5&!,(=49&.%!!k*(,>!0%!$4%!0.!,!-1,(%!>0%1!,.2>&(2!%$!&%-7l:!

,.*!%1&.!>1&.!;!(&,*:!0/!0%!*$&2.\%!/,55!0.%$!,!6,(%!$/!9)!,(=49&.%!2%(4-%4(&:!%1&.!;!*$.\%!"-4%!0%A!,2!&'0*&.-&:!;!2$,5&*=&7!

8%&6!H!O0.021^!

D$.\%!+&!%1&!$.&!>1$!,5>,)2!1,*!2%4//!$.!%1&0(!g496!*(0'&!$(!1,*!%1&!-,(*2!-4%:!+4%!

.$!%,=27!![$4!1,'&!%$!/0.0217!![$4!-,.\%!*$!&'&()%10.=!,%!$.-&:!2$!)$4!1,'&!%$!2&%!*$>.!,.*!*$!29,55!6($g&-%2!%1,%!(&245%!0.!/0.021&*!42,+5&!0%&927!!D$.\%!%,!

6($g&-%2!4.%05!)$4!-,.!/0.021!%1&!$.&!)$4\(&!$.7!!C%1&(>02&!)$\(&!,5>,)2!$.5)!1,5/>,)!(&,*)7!

'

BI8IJBFK!?;T8!

a 7IBBIC'K;E'JIIK@IKE=Q'K;EF'BE?D'FIA'KI'HGE?K'PB?RE='a *IIO=';?LE'K;E'ME=K'\?@=CEG='KI]W'a (I@XK'RAK'ELEGFK;


13/82

()*%$)'%*.8$'()*%$)1'J2!;!2,0*!&,(50&(:!D&+,%&!02!>1,%!>&!9,

P)!6&(26&-%0'&!$.!,*'$-,-)!$'&((0*&2!9)!5$'&!/$(!"%1&!=,9&A!$/!*&+,%&7!!;!/&&5!50,)!%$!-(0%0-,55)!%&2%!,(=49&.%2!$(!0*&,2!-,..$%!+&!/$4.*!0.!%1&!1&,*a

$.!*&.0,5!$/!)&2`.$!$(!=$$*`+,*7!!J2!%1&!,(=49&.%2!65,)!$4%!/$(!2>0%-1!20*&!*&+,%&:!

%1&)!+&=0.!>0%1!%1&!-$.-&6%!%1,%!%1&!+&2%!>,)!%$!5&,(.!,+$4%!2$9&%10.=!02!%$!(&2&,(-1!+$%1!20*&2!$/!%1&!0224&7!!C.&!$/!%1&!+&2%!,(=49&.%2!/$(!"2>0%-1!20*&A!*&+,%&!

02!+,2&*!46$.!%102!-$.-&6%!$/!5&,(.0.=!%1&!9$2%!,+$4%!2$9&%10.=7!!K$>&'&(:!%1&!0%1@!!81$45*!)$4!64+50-5)!4%%&(!(,-029!02!=$$*!/$(!%1&!64(6$2&!$/!1,'0.=!,!*&+,%&@!!?1&!

6,(%!,+$4%!5&,(.0.=!+$%1!20*&2!-,.!1,66&.!>0%1$4%!,-%4,55)!2,)0.=!0%!0.!%1&!*&+,%&:!%1&!*&20(&!%$!>0.!0.!*&+,%&!/$(-&2!)$4!0.%$!(&2&,(-10.=!+$%1!20*&27!!!D$!)$4!(&,55)!

.&&*!%$!4%%&(!%10.=2!)$4!*02,=(&&!>0%1@!!;!/&&5!%1,%!)$4!21$45*!.$%:!&26&-0,55)!0.!

*&+,%&7!!;/!)$4!,(&!,.!0.*0'0*4,5!%1,%!1,2!&d6&(0&.-&*!,.)!/$(9!$/!$66(&220$.:!>1)!>$45*!)$4!>,.%!%$!65,)!%1&!($5&!$/!%1&!$66(&22$(@!!!?102!02!>1&(&!;!,52$!/&&5!-(0%0-,5!

%10.


14/82

,EGE'?GE'=I>E'HIID'?GHA>E@K='JIG'C;F'DEJE@D2!$.&!-5$2&!%$!%1&!90**5&!

_7!?&-1.034&!0.!*&+,%&!*$&2!.$%!%(,.25,%&!0.%$!&//&-%0'&!-$994.0-,%0$.!20%-1!20*&!*&+,%&!/$(-&2!$.&!%$!(&65,-&!+&50&/2!>0%1!,66(&-0,%0$.!/$(!%1&!6($-&227!

#='DEM?KE'G;EKIG


15/82

+;IABD'DEM?KEG='ME'JIGRED'1&(&!)$4!-,.!=&%!,55!$/!%1&!%1&$(&%0-,5!+&.&/0%2!$/!2>0%-1!20*&!*&+,%0.=:!>0%1$4%!4%%&(0.=!

%1&!'&()!>$(*2!%1,%!/$2%&(!6&(2$.,5!$66(&220$.7!

#='.!6&(2$.,5!,=&.-)!02!+&%%&(!%1,.!,%%&96%0.=!%$!,-340(&!,!.&+45$42!9&%1$*!$/!'&(+,50e0.=!%1,%!2&('&2!,2!,!%$$5!%$!-$$6%!(,*0-,5!+&50&/27!

[%"$#!#[%$#.-'9+:'!.3[)$#$#.-'

T,(%0-06,%0$.!02!9$(&!096$(%,.%!%1,.!-$96&%0%0$.7!!?1&!+&.&/0%2!$/!,.!&*4-,%0$.,5!/$(9!$/!*&+,%&!+&0.=!,+5&!%$!,--&22!9$(&!6&$65&!02!+&%%&(!%1,.!,!+,.P;?=0%-1!20*&!%$!%1&!9$*&50.=!$/!

6$50-)!9,.!=,9&7!!#$>!9,.)!*&+,%&(2!-$.2%(4-%!,(=49&.%2!,%%&96%0.=!%$!&34,%&!$4(!/$(49!>0%1!%1&!5&=025,%0'&!1,552:!,.*!%142!$//&(0.=!,!9&%1$*!

$/!&*4-,%0$.!%1,%!1,2!+&&.!*&&9&*!4.a,--&220+5&!+)!6,2%!6($6$.&.%2!$/!2>0%-1!20*&!

*&+,%0.=7!

E20.=!2>0%-1!20*&!*&+,%&!%$!/$(-&!2%4*&.%2!%$!*&/&.*!'0&>2!%1,%!,(&!.$%!%1&0(!$>.!02!,%%&96%0.=!%$!42&!*&+,%&!%$!6($*4-&!%1&!50+&(,5!-0%0e&.:!%142!%(&,%0.=!*&+,%&(2!,2!

"24+g&-%2A!%$!+&!-$.'&(%&*!$.&!,%!,!%09&!%$!+&-$9&!,!%$$5!$/!=5$+,5!=$'&(.,.-&!420.=!4.0'&(2,5!.$(92!/$(!%1&!&d-&6%0$.,502%!24+g&-%!%$!=$'&(.!%1&!>$(5*7!?1&(&!02!,!=$$*!*&+,%&!%$!+&!1,*!,+$4%!0/!%102!02!=$$*!$(!+,*7!


16/82

+$"#!$'+N#$!,'+#()'()*%$)'3%/)+'()*%$)'%'7."3'.7'!8&$8"%&'

$)!,-.&.U0!

?1&!*&+,%&!,+$4%!*&+,%&!10=150=1%2!1$>!-$994.0-,%0$.!+&-$9&2!,.!$+g&-%:!

0.2%(49&.%:!,.*!/0&5*!$/!-45%4(,5!=$'&(.,.-&7!!?102!02!,!6($*4-%0$.!0.!%1&!6$>&(!$/!-45%4(,5!=$'&(.,.-&!%1($4=1!%1(&&!9&-1,.0292!!

L7 ?$!2&6,(,%&!26&&-1!/($9!-$.'0-%0$.!X7 D&-$465&!20.-&(0%)!6(0.-065&!/($9!,(=49&.%!6(&2&.%&*!+)!*&+,%&(7!N7 O$(-&2!$.&!%$!(&65,-&!+&50&/2!>0%1!,66(&-0,%0$.!/$(!%1&!6($-&22!

!

J#8QIB8!?C!PE;B!

P40(\2!2466$(%!/$(!2>0%-1!20*&!*&+,%&!02!+,2&*!46$.!4.0'&(2,5!.$(92!24-1!,2!%$5&(,.-&!,.*!654(,5029:!%1$4=1!P40(!,%%&96%2!%$!-5,09!%1,%!*&+,%&!9,0.%,0.2!,!

2&.2&!$/!9$(,5!*&'&5$69&.%7!!Q&!942%!&d,90.&!1$>!P40(!(&,220=.2!-$.'0-%0$.!%$!

%1&!6($-&22!$/!=&.&(,%0.=!9$(,55)!2$4.*!g4*=9&.%7!!P40(!2&&2!2>0%-1!20*&!*&+,%&!,2!,!%$$5!/$(!*&50+&(,%0'&!*&9$-(,-)!,.*!=,9&!$/!/(&&*$97!!?102!.$%0$.!$/!2>0%-1!20*&!

*&+,%&!6(&a-$./0=4(&2!,!*&50+&(,%0'&!9$(,5!%1&$()!$/!*&9$-(,-)7!

;!>055!,52$!9,,2!,!9$9&.%!+&/$(&!%1&!9&(=&(!>1&(&!6&$65&!!

,%%&96%&*!%$!6($*4-&!64+50-,%0$.2!%$!%()!,.*!6($9$%&!#D?!*&+,%&!$'&(!FIDJ!*&+,%&:!,.*!$%1&(!/$(92!$/!*&+,%&:!+&-,42&!$/!%1&!0.-(&*0+5&!21(0.(0%0.=2!1,*!,!64(6$2&!,%!%1&!%09&!%1,%!>,2.\%!

/,(!/($9!P,*02$.!J'&.4&7!

?1&(&!02!.$!(45&+$$&!,(&!*$0.=!

"2>0%-1!20*&!*&+,%&A7!!;.!%1&!6,2%:!(&2$54%0$.2!>&(&!'&()!=&.&(0-:!,.*!6&$65&!g42%!+,20-,55)!,//0(9&*!%1&!(&2$54%0$.7!!P$2%!,//0(9,%0'&2!>&(&!%1&!2,9&7!!#$>!%1,%!>&!

1,'&!,!=&.&(0-!k+4%!26&-0/0-l!(&2$54%0$.:!,.*!6&$65&!0.*4-%0'&5)!0./&(!%1&0(!65,.!,2!,//0(90.=!%1&!(&2$54%0$.:!>&!,(&.\%!2>0%-10.=!20*&2!$.!,!=&.&(0-!0224&j!>&!,(&!

*&+,%0.=!>1,%&'&(!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!2,)27!

;/!)$4!,(&!,(=40.=!(,-0292!&d02%2:!,.*!%1&!$%1&(!%&,92!2,)2!2>0%-1!20*&!*&+,%&!=$$*:!

)$4!2,)!"2>0%-1!20*&2!%1&.An,.*!,(=4&!%1,%!%1&!-5,09!%$!!02!1$>!>&!1&(&!*&+,%&(2!-5,09!%1&0(!$.5)!=($4.*!02!"(,-029!+,*A!02!,!*$4+5&!%4(.!%$!%1&0(!2>0%-1!20*&!*&+,%&!=$$*!,(=49&.%27!


17/82

7"%3)N."/'7G?>ECIGO1'$;EGE',2!%102!*&+,%&!,+$4%!>1&%1&(!)$4!-,.!

2&6,(,%&!',54&2!/($9!6$50-0&27!!P$2%!-(0%0-,5!%10.$45*!,=(&&!%1,%!%1&2&!%>$!,(&!

0.2&6,(,+5&7!!!

C+'0$425):!>1&.!R!*&+,%&(2!2,)!/0,%!02!05542$():!%1&!6$50-)!*&+,%&(2!,(&!.$%!+5$>.!

,>,):!+4%!(,%1&(!/&&5!,2!%1$4=1!>&!,=(&&!%$!6(&%&.*!%$!+&!6$50-)9,$(,)!%1&)!,(&!420.=!>1,%&'&(!,(=49&.%2!%1&)!-1$$2&7!!8$9&!

,(=49&.%2!>$45*!+&!=&.&(0-!"(45&2!+,*A!,(=49&.%2:!$(!&d-5420$.,()!0*&$5$=0&2!+,*7!!!

P)!2&-$.*!24==&2%0$.!02!%$!42&!%1&!5,.=4,=&!$/!*&+,%&!>1&.!.&-&22,()7!!Id,965&!m!Q1$!-$.%($52!4.034&.&22!$.!/(,9&>$(,(!&'&()!)&,(!

20.-&!0%2!0.-&6%0$.7!!Q&!1,'&!9,.)!29,55!>,(2!,($4.*!%1&!=5$+&:!&.'0($.9&.%,5!

-(02&2:!.,%4(,5!*02,2%&(2!6421&*!+)!%1$2&!&.'0($.9&.%,5!-$.2&34&.-&2:!&-$.$90-!*$>.%4(.2!,.*!260(,527!!P$(&!>,(2!,(&!50


18/82

6&%($5&49!-45%4(&7!!J.*!%102!02!>1&(&!%1&0(!"/(,9&>$(

5,.=4,=&:!02!%1,%!=$$*!6$50%0-2@!!D$&2!0%!&//&-%!0/!65,.!>055!2$5'&!$(!.$%@!!;!$.-&!1&,(*!,!

g4*=&!%&55!,!*&+,%&(!%1,%!0/!$.&!%&,9!42&*!(,-02%!5,.=4,=&:!+4%!%1&!65,.!2$5'&*:!%1&.!1&!>$45*!'$%&!/$(!%1&!65,.:!+4%!*$-

*02-4220$.!,+$4%!"0.!($4.*!096,-%2A7!!?102!9,)!+&!$.&!$/!%1&!>,)2!$45*!,(=4&!%1,%!*02-$4(2&!02!

%1&!9$2%!096$(%,.%!+&-,42&!>1,%!1,66&.2!0.!%1&!*&+,%&!,(&!%1&!$.5)!"(&,5A!096,-%2!0.!%1&!*&+,%&7!!8&d02%`B,-02%`K$9$61$+0-!5,.=4,=&!-(&,%&2!,.!4.>&5-$9&!,.*!

4./,0(!65,)0.=!/0&5*!/$(!%1$2&!>1$9!24-1!5,.=4,=&!*$&2!'0$5&.-&!,=,0.2%7!!?$!9&:!,55!*&+,%&!26&&-1&2!,(&!6$50%0-,5:!,.*!%1&!*&-020$.!1,2!,!5$%!%$!*$!>0%1!6$50%0-27!!J!5,(=&(!

34&2%0$.!02!$.&!%1,%!0.'&2%0=,%&2!1$>!&%10-2:!*02-$4(2&:!&602%&9$5$=):!$.%$5$=)!$(!

6&(/$(9,.-&!*&/0.&2!%1&!6$50%0-,5!,-%7!!?1&!65,.!-,.!$.5)!,260(&!%$!%1&!',54&!$/!%1&!

6$50%0-,5!,-%!,%%&96%0.=!%$!2466$(%!0%7!!?102!02!>1&(&!)$4(!(&2&,(-1!>$45*!,%%&96%!%$!+&!+&%%&(!%1,.!%1&0(2!$.!1$>!94-1!$/!,!($5&!%1&!,(&,!)$4!-1$$2&!%$!*02,=(&&!,%!1,2!

$.!%1&!24--&22!$/!%1&!6$50%0-,5!,-%7!!?1&(&!,(&!2$!9,.)!>,)2!%$!0.'&2%0=,%&!%1&!"6$50%0-,5A7!!

7."!)'$,)'-/'*)$N))-'$,)#"'7"%3)N."/')9#()-!)'%-('$,)#"'

[%"$#!8&%"'%!$#.-'I'&()!/(,9&>$(

%1&!L,-7!!?1&)!9,)!(&,*!LYY!-,(*2!$.!1$>!%1&(&!,(&!=$$*!6$50-)!,-%0$.2:!,.*!1$>!>&!

.&&*!6$50-):!+4%!0%\2!,!34&2%0$.!$/!%1&0(!6$50-)7!!R&&6!%0=1%!$.!%102!*&+,%&7!!?102!02!>1&(&!Fb!+&-$9&2!096$(%,.%!$.-&!,=,0.7!!

$,)'"#+/'.7'%'-/';!.&'&(!50,)2!%1,%!29,(%!6$50-)!%&,92!,(&!.$>!64%%0.=!%$=&%1&(!9$(&!24+2%,.%0'&!,(=49&.%2!0.%$!%1&0(!/(,9&>$(

F$9+0.0.=!%102!0*&,!%1,%!%1&!.&=,%0'&!R!1,2!%$!*&/&.*!%1&!2%,%42!34$!,.*!%1,%!%1&(&!

02!,!-1,.-&!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!90=1%!,--0*&.%5)!90%0=,%&!,!5,(=&(!6($+5&9!0.!,!(02,)2!%$!2,)!>&!942%!,-%7!!?1&(&!,(&!,52$!2$9&!


19/82

-$99$.!,(=49&.%2!%1,%!2,)!R(0%0&!.&&*!-(0%034&!,.*!,-%0$.7!!

?1&2&!,(&!%1&!1&(&!R!*&+,%&(2!=&%!2%4-0%1!>&0=10.=!%1&0(!".$.a4.034&A!096,-%2!,=,0.2%!%1&!"(02&d%0.-%0$.!096,-%7!!P,.)!g4*=&2!/,55!$.!%1&!20*&!$/!&d%0.-%0$.!>1&.!%102!1,66&.27!!?102!9&,.2!)$4!.&&*!%$!2%,)!/$-42&*!$.!>1,%!02!%1&!9$2%!096$(%,.%!0224&!0.!%1&!

*&+,%&7!!?102!,52$!9&,.2!)$4!-,.\%!g42%!26$%!%1&9!&d%0.-%0$.7!!Q1&.!%1&)!2,)!LYYo!(02$45*!,-%4,55)!

"2$5'&A!&d%0.-%0$.:!&'&(7!!?1,%\2!9$($.0-!,.*!$.5)!0.!*&+,%&!*$&2!%1,%!9,

0*&$5$=)!+&10.*!%1&!6$50%0-2!$/!/&,(!4%050e&*!+)!%1&0(!,4%1$(27!!O$(!,!5$%!$/!%102!)$4!*$.\%!.&&*!&'0*&.-&7!!B&,*!%1&!"9,&!>&(&!"($5&a65,)0.=A:!%1,%!*$&2!.$%!*&.)!%1,%!>&!21$45*!.$%!5&,(.!0.!%1&!*&+,%&!

($4.*2!1$>!-&(%,0.!0*&$5$=0&2`6105$2$610&2!-,42&!096,-%2!0.!$4(!>$(5*7!!?1,%!

,(=49&.%!>$45*!$.5)!246&(-1,(=&!)$4(!,(=49&.%!0/!)$4!,(&!0.%&(2&-%0.=!>0%1!%1&0(!0*&,!$/!"6$50%0-,5A7!!;/!)$4!,(&!2,)0.=!>&!,(&!g42%!*&+,%&(2:!,.*!9,


20/82

N,.'!.-$".&+'[.$#!+Y'P,.)!6&$65&!-,55!%102!"-&*&!%1&!6$50%0-,57A!?102!,(=49&.%!-5,092!%1,%!0/!>&!*$!.$%!&.=,=&!0.!6$50%0-2:!%1&.!%1&!(0=1%!>0.=!>055!%,0%10.!%1&!"&'05A!6,(%!$/!%1&!6$50%0-,5!26&-%(49:!>105&!2%055!&.*$(20.=!%1&!2,9&!%)6&!$/!6$50-0&27!![$4!1,'&!%$!+&!,+5&!%$!*&/&.*!>1)!)$4(!6$20%0$.!$/!.$%!&.=,=0.=!6$50%0-2:!0/!)$4!*$!!k1$6&/455)!)$4(!,(=49&.%!02!,+$4%!%1&!6$50%0-,5l:!,.*!;!%10.

-,.!%,1,%!)$4!-,55!%1&!"6$50%0-,5A!02!,!'&()!5090%&*!'0&>!$/!>1&(&!6$50%0-2!1,66&.27!!M4%!;!%10.

%1$2&!>1$!%1&)!-5,09!)$4!>$45*!+&!-&*0.=!%$$:!0.!%102!*&+,%&7!!!;/!)$4!>0.!%1&!$%1&(!

%&,92!,(=49&.%2!$.5)!(&0/)!%1&!&d02%0.=!6$50%0-,5!2)2%&9:!%1&.!-1,55&.=0.=!%1&0(!,(=49&.%!02!,!-1,55&.=&!%$!%1,%!6$50%0-,57!![$4\(&!.$%!-&*0.=:!)$4!,(&!&.=,=0.=7!!?102!

,(=49&.%!>$(1&.!)$4!-1$$2&!%$!.$%!&.=,=&!%1&!"2%,%&A!

+)!*$0.=!24-1!%10.=2!,2!(&/420.=!%$!,//0(9!%1&!E8OZ7!!!M&!6(&6,(&*7!

K&(&!02!,.!&d,965&G!

!EDE='PICEG'KI'?HHGE==0%1!%102!$.&!02G!

%GHA


21/82

7"%3)N."/'!)-$"%&'

+%3[&)'f6'g'7G?>ECIGO'h'1&.!6&$65&!>,.%!%$!

2%,(%!%,51&%1&(!>&!,(&!*&+,%0.=!%1&!"%(4%1A!$/!%1&!(&2$54%0$.7!!!

J55!+0(*2!-,.!/5)7!

J.!$2%(0-1!02!,!+0(*!

?1&(&/$(&!,.*!$2%(0-1!-,.!/5)n77!

P$2%!,//0(9,%0'&2!,(&!$2%(0-1&2:!.$%!+54&!g,)2!$(!($+0.2:!,.*!%142!,(&!&d,965&2!$/!%1&!

(&2$54%0$.:!+4%!.$%!.&-&22,(05)!(&6(&2&.%,%0'&!$/!%1&!=&.&(,5!%(4%1!$/!%1&!(&2$54%0$.7!

'+%3[&)'f4'g'7G?>ECIGO1'$;

)$4!9,$(2&7!!!J52$:!)$4(!64(6$2&!02!%$!+405*!0.!,--&22!6$0.%2!%$!%1&0(!,//0(9,%0'&!>0%1!)$4(!,(=49&.%!%1,%!,55$>!)$4!%$!'$0*!%1&0(!/(,9&>$(

?1&)!26&.*!%09&!$.!/(,9&>$(105&!)$4\(&!26&.*0.=!%09&!,--&220.=!%1&0(!

/(,9&>$(0%1!)$4(!,(=49&.%7!!;!(&,55)!>,.%!%$!2%(&22!%1,%!9$2%!/(,9&>$(,(*2!"/,45%)A!R!*&+,%&!

,.*!2%&(&$%)6&27!!;/!)$4!-,.!*02-$..&-%!%1&0(!%1&$()!k07&7:!/(,9&>$(


22/82


23/82

J*$5/!Z7!Z4.*&(2&.:!XYYY!a!J22$-0,%&!T($/&22$(!$/!T$50%0-,5!8-0&.-&!,%!?&d,2!JpP:!T$50%0-,5!?1&$()!,.*!T,(%02,.!

T$50%0-2:!67!LYVa]!

f$1.!B,>527!L]]]:!?1&!U,>!$/!T&$65&2:!67!_ca_S!

J5,.!F$'&(2%$.&:!L]]_!a!iJ.!;.>,(*!Z5,.-&G!J!B&26$.2&!?$!P0%-1&55h2!C4%>,(*!J-%0'02%!?4(.:i!DBZ:!EBUG!

1%%6G``>>>7>/47&*4`8%4*&.%a$(=,.0e,%0$.2`*&+,%&`P02-80%&2`DBZJ(%0-5&2`F$'&(2%$.&L]]_F10.,71%9!

C>&.!YX:!E.0'&(20%)!$/!8$4%1,96%$.!kD,'0*:!"B&$(0&.%0.=!;.%&(.,%0$.,5!B&5,%0$.2G!C.!T(,=9,%029:!T54(,5029!

,.*!T(,-%0-,5!B&,2$.0.=A:!P055&..049G!f$4(.,5!$/!;.%&(.,%0$.,5!8%4*0&2:!W$57!NL:!#$7!N:!

1%%6G``90572,=&64+7-$9 -=0`(&6(0.% NL`N`c_Nl!

O0.&:!XYYY!a!!D&6,(%9&.%!!$/!8$-0$5$=)!#$(%1>&2%&(.!!E.0'&(20%)!a!Z,():!"ZJPI8!J#D!?BE?K8G!U&,(.0.=!?$!

F$.2%(4-%!8$-0,5!T($+5&92!;.!K0=1!8-1$$5!D&+,%&A:!LYNaLYH7!

!M$==2:!L]]S!a!!T($/&22$(!$/!T$50%0-,5!8-0&.-&:!\]S!a!F,(5:!#,%0$.,5!E.0'&(20%):!?1&$()!p!8$-0&%)!Xc:!D&-&9+&(:!67!

ScYaL7!

8,.,(*!8,0*!,2!,.!;.%&(.,%0$.,5!B&5,%0$.2!?1&$(02%:A!P055&..049G!f$4(.,5!$/!;.%&(.,%0$.,5!

8%4*0&2:!W$57!Nc:!#$7!L:!67!LXH!

f$1.!f7!P&,(21&09&(:!L]]_!a!!B&,5029!1&,')>&0=1%!-1,960$.:!;.%&(.,%0$.,5!8&-4(0%):!W$57!XY:!#$!

J5,2%,0(!f7K7!P4((,):!L]]S!a!!T$50%0-2!J#D!B&,5029!

O4)4,!XYYH\F$.2%&55,%0$.2!W$5!LL!#$7!H!

?$**!P,):!XYY_:!TK;UC8CTK[!p!8CF;JU!FB;?;F;8P!q!'$5!NL!.$2!_mc!q!667!_LSm_NL!

D,'0*!I7!P-F5&,.:!XYYL!a!?1&!F45%4(,5!U&/%!,.*!%1&!U090%2!$/!8$-0,5!K$6&!a!T(&2&.%&*!,%!%1&!XYYL!J..4,5!F$./&(&.-&!

$/!%1&!8$-0&%)!/$(!%1&!J*',.-&9&.%!$/!J9&(0-,.!T105$2$61)7!

T7!K7!U;C??J:!XYY_!a!8&-4(0%)!D0,5$=4&!a!W$57!NckLlG!H]mSY!

!

!


24/82

!"#$#!%&'7"%3)N."/'%"U83)-$+'#7'0.8X")'-)U%$#9)'?1&(&!02!,!%09&!>1&.!)$4!*&+,%&!%&,92!%1,%!>055!.$%!*&/&.*!,.)%10.=7!!?102!02!$.&!(&,2$.!>1)!%1&!L2%!T(0$(0%)!%$!L2%!J9&(0-,.2!,(=49&.%!>,2!,!24--&22/45!*&+,%&!

,(=49&.%7!!?&,92!%1,%!-1$$2&!%$!*&/&.*!.$%10.=:!(&5)!46$.!,!9&%,a,(=49&.%!%1,%!90=1%!2,)!,+2$54%&2!,(&!+,*7!!C(!>&!.&&*!%$!+&!0.!-$.2%,.%!-1,.=&7!!k8&&!P,..!,.*!

D&U&4e&!,.*!Z4,%%,(07l!

[$4!.&&*!,!-(0%0-,5!,(=49&.%!%1,%!2,)2!.$%!%,&!.&&*!%$!&d-54*&!%$!6(&'&.%!

'0$5&.-&7!!!;/!)$4!,(&!,!6&(2$.!>1$!/&&52!)$4!1,'&!%$!2%(4==5&!*,)!%$!*,)!>0%1!$66(&220$.!24-1!,2!2&d029!$(!(,-029:!%1&.!)$4!21$45*!1,'&!,.!,*',.%,=&!$'&(!%1$2&!

>1$!6(0'05&=&!g42%!%10.$45*!2,)!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!,55$>2!.$!26,-&!/$(!)$4!%$!*&+,%&:!,.*!>055!42&!%1,%!,*',.%,=&!%$!>0.!,!-$96&%0%0$.7!!

?102!/$(9!$/!4./,0(!-$96&%0%0$.!-,.!+&!0*&.%0/0&*!,2!1&=&9$.0-!,2!$66$2&*!%$!

-$$6&(,%0'&!-$96&%0%0$.:!>1&(&!*02,=(&&0.=!02!(&340(&*7!?1&2&!,(&!&d,965&2:!,.*!)$4!9,)!/0.*!)$4(!$>.7!!f42%!9,


25/82

$.[#!%$0

Q$(*2!-,.!+&.*7!Q$(*2!-,.!+&!0.%&(6(&%&*!*0//&(&.%!>,)27!!C.-&!,!(&2$54%0$.!02!

>(0%%&.:!0%!02!>1,%!0%!027!!?1&(&!02!.$!$.&!2%,.*,(*!"6(&*0-%0$.A!6&$65&!9,055!0*&.%0/)!2$9&!$/!%1&!1&.!)$4!(&,*!)$4(!,//0(9,%0'&7!!!

;%!+,//5&2!9&!,%!1$>!%1&!/$(-&!$/!%&-1.$5$=)!02!&'&(!-1,.=0.=!$4(!,+050%)!%$!(&2&,(-1!,.*!,--&22!9$(&!0./$(9,%0$.!,%!,!/,2%&(!6,-&:!6&$65&!2%,(%!%$!/&&5!50&!.&&*!%$!

5090%!%1&!6$220+5&!0.%&(6(&%,%0$.2!$/!%1&!%$60-7!!Q1)!*$!>&!>,.%!,!5090%&*!%$60-@!

?102!02!+,2&*!46$.!%1&!6&(26&-%0'&!%1,%!/$(!42!%$!1,'&!=$$*:!&*4-,%0$.,5!*&+,%&:!>&!

.&&*!%$!9,!&.$4=1!2$!%1,%!&'&()$.&!>$45*!1,'&!&'0*&.-&!$.!,55!$/!%1&!6$220+5&!,//0(9,%0'&27!!;/!>&!,55$>!%$$!9,.)!,//0(9,%0'&2:!%1&.!

>&!-,.\%!6$220+5)!(&2&,(-1!,55!$/!%1&97!!;%\2!$**!%1,%!6&$65&!2,)!%102:!+4%!,%!%1&!2,9&!

%09&!(&,*!%1&!2,9&!2-&.,(0$2!,.*!P&,*!&'0*&.-&!)&,(!,/%&(!)&,(7!!!

?1&(&!02!,!5,(=&(!,+2%(,-%!(&,2$.!>1)!;!/&&5!6&$65&!50

Q10-1!5&,*2!%$!%1&!34&2%0$.:!,(&!=&.&(0-!,(=49&.%2!=$$*`+,*!/$(!*&+,%&@!

;!/&&5!%1,%!,!=$$*!,(=49&.%!02!,!=$$*!,(=49&.%7!!;/!2$9&%10.=!02!2$!6($90.&.%!%1,%!0%!

,6650&2!%$!,!5$%!$/!%10.=2:!%1&.!9,)+&!0%!21$45*!+&!*02-422&*:!(,%1&(!%1,.!+&0.=!>(0%%&.!$//!,2!=&.&(0-7!!J.*:!50


26/82

Id,965&!rLa!J!%$60-!%1,%!2,)2!%$!b!".,%0$.2An&26&-0,55)!501$!>(0%&!%1,%!%1&!%&(9!"*&'&5$69&.%A!02!(,-02%7!!8$!0/!)$4!-1$$2&!%$!.$%!+&!%(,*0%0$.,5!9$*&2!$/!"*&'&5$69&.%A!,2202%,.-&:!)$4!1,'&!2$9&!=$$*!(&,2$.2!%$!

6(&/&(!)$4(!0.%&(6(&%,%0$.!%1,%!=$&2!+&)$.*!1$>!0%!5090%2!%1&!%$60-7!

!?@'FIA'GE?BBF'R;II=E'I@E'DEJ

$'&(a5090%2:!,.*!%1&0(!0.%&(6(&%,%0$.2!&d-54*&2!096$(%,.%!*&+,%&7!!Q&0=1!%1&!,9$4.%!

$/!=$$*!0.!*&6%1!*&+,%&!=,0.&*!$'&(!%1&!0.-(&9&.%,5!,9$4.%!$/!+,*!*&+,%&!5$2%7!

K&(&!02!9)!+$5*!2%,%&9&.%!/$(!%102!2&-%0$.7!!?$60-2!,(&!/(,9&*!+,2&*!46$.!X!

096$(%,.%!/,-%$(2!m!Q1,%!&'0*&.-&!02!,',05,+5&!k>1,%!*$&2!%1&!9,0.2%(&,9!50%&(,%4(&!2,)l!,.*!1$>!>$45*!%102!>$(1,%!=($4.*!>$45*!.&=,%0'&!,.*!

,//0(9,%0'&!1,'&l^!!?1&2&!X!/(,90.=!/,-%$(2!,(&!,!6($*4-%!$/!0*&$5$=0-,5`$.%$5$=0-,5`&602%&9$5$=0-,5!6&(26&-%0'&2!%1,%!,(&!g4d%,6$2&*!%$!$%1&(!

6&(26&-%0'&2!$.!%1&2&!0224&2:!+4%!$//&(&*!46!0.!%1&!(&2$54%0$.2!,2!.&4%(,57!!?1&!

>$(*0.=!,.*!",):!.$(!02!0%!0.!0.1&(&.%!0.!,!*&+,%&!%$60-7!!M4%!%1&!-4((&.%!-$55&=&!%$60-!6($-&22!

*$&2!24//&(!/($9!%102!055.&227!!Q&!21$45*!$6&.!46!%$60-2!%$!,55$>!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!50%&(,%4(&!+,2&!=$!,//0(9,%0'&7!!Q1&.!)$4\(&!.&=,%0'&:!)$4!,.2>&(!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&7!!8$!

(,*0-,5`,5%&(.,%0'&`90.$(0%)!2$54%0$.2!%$!%$60-!6($+5&9!,(&,2!,(&!.&'&(!,.!,//0(9,%0'&!$6%0$.!>0%1$4%!1,'0.=!%$!*&+,%&!%$60-,50%)!0.!9$2%!*&+,%&27!!!

#@'FIAG'DEJE@=E'IJ'FIAG'


27/82

$,)'$.[#!%$0'U%8-$&)$V'

[$4!.&&*!%$!+&!(&,*)!%$!>,5

>,.%!%$!+&!,!24--&22/45!R!*&+,%&(7!!P)!'0&>!02!%1,%!)$4!21$45*!>0.!9$2%!$(!,55!$/!

)$4(!.&=,%0'&!($4.*2:!,.*!4.2%$66,+5&!24--&22!(&,55)!*&6&.*2!$.!)$4!1,'0.=!,!=$$*!,//0(9,%0'&7!8$!0/!)$4!>,.%!%$!+&!=$$*!$.!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&:!$.&!%10.=!)$4!1,'&!%$!+&!

,+5&!%$!*$!02!6($'&!)$4(!,(=49&.%!,2!6($-&*4(,55)!5&=0%09,%&7!

K&(&!,(&!2$9&!%10.=2!%1,%!)$4!.&&*!%$!+&!,>,(&!$/7!

L!m!M&!-5&,(!0.!Fb!>1,%!)$4(!,//0(9,%0'&!,//0(927!!;/!)$4!,(&!21,*):!0.-$.202%&.%!$(!

,+420'&:!)$4!>055!+&!64.021&*!>1&.!*&+,%0.=!,!*&+,%&(!%1,%!02!=$$*!,%!>0..0.=!%1&!

,(=49&.%!%1,%!)$4!1,'&!%$!+&!,+$4%!%1&!(&2$54%0$.7!!F($22!Id,90.,%0$.!02!)$4(!6,22!$(!)$4(!*&,%1!2&.%&.-&7!

X!m!D$.\%!"#CaU;#RA!$4%!$/!,(=49&.%27!![$4!21$45*!&.=,=&!0.!9$(&!"#C!;#?IB#JU!

U;#RA!2%)5&!,(=49&.%27!!!M&!1$.&2%:!0/!6&$65&!,(&!(&,*0.=!P&,*!$(!M&,(*&.:!>1)!.$%!

=$!,/%&(!%1&!6,(%!$/!%1&!,(=49&.%!%1,%!2,)2!$.-&!)$4!50.,(7!!I'&()!%09&!)$4!2&%!46!%$!,.2>&(!,!.&=,%0'&!,(=49&.%:!)$4!942%!%10.!

%102!>055!0.%&(,-%!>0%1!%$60-,50%)7!

N!m!M&!(&,*)!%$!0*&.%0/)!*&+,%,+5&!.&=,%0'&!=($4.*7!!?102!02!096$(%,.%!%$!,!5$%!$/!

-(0%0-27!!P,,)2!1,'&!,.!

0.%&(6(&%,%0$.!$/!%1&!%$60-7!

_!m!;/!)$4!*$!.$%!(&,*!,!65,.:!+&!(&,*)!%$!9,$45*!45%09,%&5)!2,)!"-(0%0-,5!=($4.*A!02!9$(&!096$(%,.%!%1,.!-$4.%&(a65,.!=($4.*7!![$4!,(&!2,)0.=!%1,%!

6($-&22!2%)5&!,(=49&.%2!(&9$'&!*02-4220$.!,>,)!/($9!4.*&(2%,.*0.=!%1&!0224&27!!?1&!%)60-,55)!")&2!>&!!%1,%:!5&%\2!*$!2$9&%10.=!,+$4%!0%A!21$45*!.$%!/5)!1&(&7!!

[$4(!,(=49&.%!.&&*2!%$!+&!%1,%!",-%0$.A!>0%1$4%!%(4&!4.*&(2%,.*0.=!&0%1&(!6,-0/0&2!$4(!.&&*!/$(!(&,5!-1,.=&:!$(!(&245%2!0.!.&=,%0'&!-$.2&34&.-&27!

c!m!R.$>!%1&!102%$()!$/!*&+,%&!,.*!)$4!>055!=&%!+)!94-1!&,20&(7!!M,-&(&!(&,*0.=!65,.2:!>105&!$%1&(2!>&(&!.$%7!!?1&!

-$994.0%)!>,2!14=&!%1&.7!!?1&(&!>&(&!$'&(!NYY!%&,92!,%!FIDJ!#,%0$.,527!!?1&!*0'&(20%)!$/!,66($,-1!0.!%1&!(&2$54%0$.!+($4=1%!*&+,%&!%$!0%2!10=1&2%!6,(%0-06,%0$.!

.49+&(27!!#$>!%1&!,%%&96%!%$!2,)!>&!942%!*&+,%&!50

61,2&*!$4%@!!k;%!>$.\%sT4%%0.=%1&R0.*&+,%&l!

S!m!K,'&!(&,2$.2!>1)!)$4(!9&%1$*!$/!,//0(90.=!%1&!(&2$54%0$.!02!=$$*!/$(!*&+,%&7!


28/82

!

?1&(&!,(&!2$9&!,(=49&.%2!%1,%!9$2%!%&,92!>1$!(&,*!%$60-,50%)!90=1%!9,!

9,.)!%09&2!%1&2&!>055!$'&(5,6!>0%1!/(,9&>$(

+&!(&,*)!%$!*&+,%&!%1&9!,.*!1,'&!)$4(!,.2>&(2!>(0%%&.!*$>.7!

;"0*3)1*%),*$(*"1*(!+*1+/)($>*

?@(-)*A="5$3)#*

?>>+3(%*="5$3)#*

B"(()*!)


29/82

()*%$#-U'%77#"3%$#9)1'P)!'0&>!$/!1$>!%$!*&+,%&!-(0%0-,55)!$.!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!1,2!-1,.=&*!$'&(!%1&!)&,(27!!!

?1&(&!>&(&!%09&2!>1&.!;!/&5%!50,2!g42%!,!+,*!0*&,:!,.*!%1$4=1%!

%1,%!,(=49&.%2!2,)0.=!(&g&-%!%1&!(&2$54%0$.!$.!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!>&(&!5&=0%09,%&7!!;!$>&!,!5$%!%$!81,.,1,.!+&-,42&!1&!,.*!;!1,*!2$9&!1&,%&*!,(=49&.%2!,+$4%!2$9&!

0224&2:!,.*!$.&!%10.=!;!5&,(.&*!02!%1,%!)$4!21$45*!>,(6!%1&!9&,.0.=!$/!%1&!%$60-:!

(,%1&(!%1,.!2,)!0%!1,2!%1&!6$>&(!%$!214%!)$4!$4%7!

#C?!JUU!FB;?;FJU!JOO;BPJ?;WI8!?KJ?!?JUR!JMCE?!CTTBI88;C#!CB!D;8FB;P;#J?;C#!JBI!TBCfIF?8^!

M&!(&,*)!%$!65,)!$//!$/!%1027!?102!02!,!-$99$.!902%,,.%!%$!9,


30/82

Q055!;!50.

Q055!;!+&!,+5&!%$!-$96&%&!>0%1!%1&!+&2%!R!*&+,%&(@!

Q1,%!02!9)!,.2>&(!%$!/(,9&>$(&(!%$!%$60-,50%)@!

K$>!>055!;!$4%>&0=1`/(,9&!21$(%a%&(9!*02,*2@!

F,.!;!0*&.%0/)!.&=,%0'&!=($4.*@!

K$>!>055!;!,**(&22!-$4.%&(65,.2`-$4.%&(a,*'$-,-0&2@!

K$>!>055!;!,.2>&(!%1&!-,60%,5029!1&.!(&,*0.=!,!T5,.:!)$4!>055!1,'&!%$!-$9+,%!-$4.%&(a65,.27!!Z$$*!6$50-)!*&+,%&(2!1,'&!,!2%$(,=&!-5$2&%!/455!$/!',(0$42!

&d&-4%0'&!$(*&(!kbCl!-$4.%&(a65,.2:!2%,%&2!-$4.%&(a65,.2:!-$4(%2!-$4.%&(a65,.2n72$!

0/!)$4!(&,*!,!65,.:!)$4!1,'&!%$!-$.20*&(!1$>!*$!;!*&/&.*!,=,0.2%!%1&2&!,(=49&.%2@!

;/!)$4!-1$$2&!%$!(&,*!,!65,.:!$.&!2%(,%&=)!02!%$!2,)!%1,%!$.%$5$=)!$(!&%10-2!-$9&!/0(2%:!

,.*!0/!)$4(!65,.!-,.!+&!5&=0%09,%&*!$.!,.!$.%$5$=0-,5!5&'&5:!%1&.!)$4!>$45*!>,.%!%$!+&!6(&6,(&*!%$!,(=4&!%1,%!%102!02!>1,%!02!9$2%!096$(%,.%!07&7:!$.%$5$=)!-$9&2!L2%7!![$4!

>$45*!-5,09!%102!*&+,%&!-$9&2!+&/$(&!5$$0%1!-(0%0-,5!096,-%27!!C.&!%10.=!%$!-$.20*&(!02!%1,%!0/!)$4!*&+,%&!%1&!+&2%!R!%&,92:!)$4!9$2%!50055!24//&(!/($9!)$4(!$>.!-$=.0e,.-&!$/!0.=!%1,%!)$4!50.055!6($+,+5)!2$5'&!)$4(!,//0(9,%0'&!096,-%2!+&%%&(!%1,.!

420.=!%1&!"2%,%&A!6&(!2&7!!!

[$4!1,'&!%$!9,1&(&!)$4!>$45*!50$45*!(,%1&(!1,'&!"=$%%,!1,'&!,!65,.A!*&+,%&!%1,.!,!"FT!$/!

%1&!>&&


31/82

+$"%$)U#!'%77#"3%$#9)'$,#-/#-UV'Q1&.!)$4!>(0%&!)$4(!,//0(9,%0'&:!%,!%$!2%(,%&=0-,55)!,66($,-1!)$4(!

,//0(9,%0'&7!

#ERI!QJB`Ib?;#F?;C#!;#IW;?JMUI!JTTBCFK!!kWC;D!?KI!DJ!;PTJF?8l!?102!%)6&!$/!,66($,-1!2,)2!>&!,(&!,55!=$0.=!%$!*0&:!2$!096,-%2!,+$4%!*&,%1!,(&!

0((&5&',.%7!!Q1,%!02!9$2%!096$(%,.%!02!bn790=1%!0%!+&!>10%&.&22`',54&!%$!50/&!&%-n!

?1&.!)$4!,(=4&!1$>!%1&!2&-4(0%0e,%0$.`/&,(!$/!*&,%1`.4,(`'0$5&.-&!&%-n7!,(&!

($$%&*!0.!%1&!0.,+050%)!%$!4.*&(2%,.*!"',54&!%$!50/&A!$(!>10%&.&22nn77!

?1&!2%(,%&=)!1&(&!02!%1,%!0/!)$4!>0.!%1&0(!096,-%2!,(&!0.&'0%,+5&:!,.*!$.5)!+)!/$-420.=!

$.!)$4(!,//0(9,%0'&!-,.!>&!,**(&22!%1$2&!6($+5&92:!%1&.!%1&!$.5)!&2-,6&!/($9!%1&!".&=,%0'&A!096,-%2!02!%1($4=1!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&7!

#3[."$%-$'!.3[.-)-$+'.7'0.8"'%77'/'+$"%$)U0';.!-$9+0.,%0$.!>0%1!%102!,66($,-1:!)$4!.&&*!5&'&(,=&!$.!1$>!%1&!-4((&.%!"6$50%0-,5A!$(!6$50-)a9,(0%%&.!&d%&.20$.2!%$!,.%!0.!%1&!X,(!'27!.&=,%0'&!$//!-,2&!

6$20%0$.2:!>1&(&!%1&!L,(!6(&6!/$(!%1&9!02!21$(%:!,.*!6(&-02&!$.!%10.=2!%1,%!)$4!9,)!.$%!+&!(&,*)!/$(7!!J.$%1&(!096$(%,.%!%10.=!%$!1,'&!(&,*)!02!L,(!&d%&.20$.!&'0*&.-&7!!

[$4(!X,(!6(&6!/$(!&d%&.20$.!$/!&'0*&.-&!21$45*!,52$!+&!*$.&:!,.*!%102!,55$>2!)$4!%$!

26&.*!)$4(!6(&6!$.!-$96,(0.=!%1&!096$(%,.%!0224&27!!I'0*&.-&!&d%&.20$.2!,52$!1&56!9,0%10.!)$4(!

&'0*&.-&!%1,%!%1&!X,(!-$.202%&.%5)!&d%&.*27!![$4!1,'&!0./0.0%&!6(&6:!%1&!34&2%0$.!02!>1,%!*$!)$4!6(&6@!

?1&!.&d%!%10.=!)$4!1,'&!%$!-$.20*&(!>0%1!)$4(!,//0(9,%0'&!02!1$>!)$4!>055!,.2>&(!$%1&(!%&,92!R(0%01&(&!%1&!

,//0(9,%0'&!/&&52!501&(&!%$!*02,=(&&7!!?1&!,//0(9,%0'&!.&&*2!%$!1,'&!%1&0(!6&(94%,%0$.!&'0*&.-&!(&,*)!%1,%!2,)2!%1&!=$$*`+&.&/0%2!$/!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!$4%>&0=1!$%1&(!-(0%0-,5!

50.


32/82

()*%$#-U'-)U%$#9)1'#J'=I>EI@E'HEK='AP'?@D'=PE?O='JIG'@0%1!&'&()%10.=!%1&)!2,):!g42%!/0.*!$.&!65,-&!%$!*02,=(&&:!,.*!

1,'&!=$$*!,(=49&.%2!$.!>1)!%102!02!%1&!096$(%,.%!65,-&!%$!*02,=(&&7!

K&(&!,(&!2$9&!!>1&.!*&+,%0.=!$.!%1&!.&=,%0'&7!!Q1&.!;!2,)!(45&2:!;!9&,.!=$$*!0*&,2!%1,%!(&,55)!*$!65,)!,.!096$(%,.%!($5&!0.!>0..0.=!$(!5$20.=7!

B45&!rL!m!K$>!*$&2!%1&0(!,.2>&(!,665)!%$!%1&0(!,//0(9,%0'&@!

Id,965&!m!?1&)!(&,*!,!26&,1&.!)$4!(&,*!)$4(!R(0%0

0.!%1&!L.-7!!?1&!/0(2%!%10.=!)$4!942%!,2!*$&2!%102!,665)!%$!%1&!

,//0(9,%0'&!9$(&@!

B45&!rX!m!#&'&(!(&,*!,!R(0%0

I26&-0,55)!0.!%1&!X#B7!

B45&!rH!m!D$.\%!+&!2$/%!$.!%1&!'$%0.=!0224&27!!;/!%1&)!,(&!=$0.=!%$!(&,*!"bA!02!,!'$%&(!

$.!%1&$()!,(=49&.%2:!%1&.!)$4!21$45*!,52$!65,)!%102!=,9&!>0%1!9,.)!$/!%1&!,+24(*!,(=49&.%2!%1&)!9,


33/82

%1&!,//0(9,%0'&7!!J55!$/!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!,+420'&:!9$'0.=!%,(=&%!,(=49&.%2!9,&!942%!-1,.=&!>1,%!>&!,(&!*$0.=j!$%1&(>02&!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!096,-%2!,(&!0.&'0%,+5&!4.*&(!%1&!-4((&.%!6,(,*0=97!

#$>!%$!*$!%102:!)$4!942%!-$9&!+,-1,%!9,

($55!$/!4.034&.&22!,.*!%1(&21$5*!,(=49&.%27!X.*!m!E2&!%1&!,(=49&.%!%1,%!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!02!,!9$'&!,>,)!/($9!%1&!-$.%0.4,%0$.!$/!%1&!6($+5&9:!>10-1!9,,(*2!-1,.=&7!

!


34/82

$,)'&%-U8%U)'.7'$,)'/"#$#/';!%10.,.%!%$!10=150=1%!1&(&!

02!%1,%!%1&(&!,(&!H!+,20-!*&+,%&2!0.!&'&()!"1&(&!)$4!,(&!1,'0.=!%1&2&!H!+,20-!*&+,%&27!!?102!,52$!1&562!%1&!L,(!&d%&.20$.2`50.&!+)!50.&!0.!,!>,)!%1,%!%&552!%1&!L,(!%1,%!%1&(&!,(&!H!+,20-!*&+,%&27!!?1&!U,.=4,=&!$/!%1&!R!02!>1&(&!)$4!%,,.%!%$!+&!%(4&!%$!)$4(!",4%1$(A!$(!,(=49&.%:!)$4!1,'&!%$!42&!%1&!

5,.=4,=&!%1,%!%(,.2=(&22&2!)$4(!-(0%0-029!0.%$!%1&!*&+,%&:!$(!0/!)$4\(&!,//0(9,%0'&!)$4!.&&*!%1&!5,.=4,=&!%1,%!,55$>2!)$4!%$!-$96&%&!>0%1!%1&!-(0%0-0297!!?102!+&-$9&2!

'&()!,66,(&.%!$.!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.!*&+,%&:!>1&(&!6&$65&!2,)!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.:!+4%!

.&'&(!0*&.%0/)!%1&!.&%a+&.&/0%2!%$!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.7!!J!=$$*!R!*&+,%&(!02!'&()!,>,(&!$/!%102!.&-&220%)7!!J2!%1&!.&=,%0'&:!>1&.!6&$65&!$.5)!2,)!"6&(9An)$4!.&&*!%$!2,)!

%1,%!0*&.%0/)0.=!".&%a+&.&/0%2!%$!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.!0.!%1&!L,(!,(&!.&>:!,.*!%142!055&=0%09,%&7!!

?1&(&!,(&!X!-$96$.&.%2!$/!-$99$.!-(0%0-,5!,(=49&.%2!%1,%!;!*$!.$%!0.-54*&!+&5$>!%1,%!.&&*!,!2&-%0$.!$/!%1&!R!*&+,%&!0/!%1&)!,(&!(&5&',.%7!

?1&!/0(2%!02!%1&!"B$$%!F,42&A!*&+,%&7!!?102!02!42&*!+)!-(0%0-,5!*&+,%&(2!%$!'$0*!$4%!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!096,-%27!!;/!%1&)!50.

)$4(!,(=49&.%!+&-$9&2!,!20965&!-,2&!%4(.7!!J.*!&'&.!0/!.$%!,!-,2&!%4(.:!%1&)!2%055!*$.\%!2$5'&!0/!)$4!>0.!%102!,(=49&.%7!!;/!)$4\(&!,//0(9,%0'&:!,.*!%102!02!6,(%!$/!%1&0(!

-(0%0-029:!$.&!DJ!%$!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!02!"($$%!-,42&!/$-42!+,*A!$(!20.-&!0%\2!)$4(!

,//0(9,%0'&:!)$4!21$45*!+&!(&,*)!%$!1,'&!,!($$%!-,42&!*&+,%&7!?1&!2&-$.*!02!%1&!"096,-%2!0.&'0%,+5&A!,(=49&.%7!!?102!02!2$9&>1,%!20905,(:!&d-&6%!

2$9&%09&2!)$4!9,)!>,.%!%$!2,)!"&d%0.-%0$.!0.&'0%,+5&A!$(!".4,(!0.&'0%,+5&A!>10-1!,55$>2!%1&0(!096,-%2!%$!+&!2$5&5)!*&6&.*&.%!$.!%09&!/(,9&!,(=49&.%2!%1,%!

-,..$%!+&!-$..&-%&*!%$!P&,*!$(!M&,(*&.:!+&-,42&!%1$2&!,4%1$(2!,(&!%$$!=&.&(0-7!C.-&!,=,0.:!)$4!-,.\%!26$%!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!%1&0(!,*',.%,=&27!

M&5$>!,(&!9)!&d,965&2!/$(!%1&!5,.=4,=&!$/!%1&!$(%1!

)$4(!%09&!%$!9,!

)$4(!,(=49&.%!096,-%2!%1&!*&+,%&7


35/82

-)U%$#9)'&%-U8%U) !

?1&!U0.

7I+*!)*(!+*3-$($3$%&*"0(Q+$/!*(!+*$&5)3(%*">*(!+*)>>$-&)($$-&)($*(!+*3-$($3$%&*4+3)0%+*JJJJJJJ8*a 7(!+-+*)-+*JJJJJJ*9$%)9$-&)($*(!+*)#(+-1)($>$-&)($


36/82


37/82

$,)'-/'()*%$)'#&'&(!&.%&(!,!*&+,%&!>0%1!,!5$20.=!2%(,%&=)7!!C.&!,(*2!64%%0.=!,!-1&-$45*!+&!%$!9,0%1!=$$*!50.0%1!096,-%2!/$(!26&-0/0-!,//0(9,%0'&27!!

?1&!+&2%!50.1&.!)$4(!&'0*&.-&!34$%&2!%1&!$%1&(!%&,92!,4%1$(2!,2!

,!50.,)!%$!>0.!%1&!1&,(%!$/!%1&!6$50-)!g4*=&!>1$!1,66&.2!%$!

+&!2&%%0.=!0.!%1&!+,-!%1&9!)$4!(&2&,(-1:!,.*!*$.\%!+&!,!25$66):!

4%$60,.!R!*&+,%&(7!!M&!(&,57!

M&/$(&!%1&!*&+,%&!2%,(%2!)$4!21$45*!%,(0%&!50.1,%!&'0*&.-&!)$4!1,'&!0.!%1&!L.-!%1,%!

02!=$0.=!%$!-$..&-%!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!>0%1!%1&!-(0%034&7!!;/!)$4!1,'&!$.&!%1,%!02!

*&6&.*&.%!$.!.&>!X.-!50.!9,.)!50.!9,.)!,.2>&(2!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!9,

>,.%!%1&9!%$!+&!%()0.=!%$!,.2>&(7!!J!=$$*!*&+,%&(!02!-,6,+5&!$/!=40*0.=!%1&!$%1&(!%&,9!0.%$!=$0.=!/$(!%1&!,(=49&.%2!)$4!!%1&)!-,..$%!>0.7!

7"%3#-U'$,)'.$,)"'$)%3'

?102!02!$.&!$/!%1&!096$(%,.%!6,(%2!$/!+&0.=!,!R!*&+,%&(!02!)$4(!,+050%)!%$!-$.%($5!%1&!/(,90.=!$/!%1&!*&+,%&7!!!?102!9&,.2!%4(.0.=!,>,)!,55!902(&6(&2&.%,%0$.2!$/!%1&0(!

,(=49&.%2!,.*!-$.%($550.=!%1&!>,)!%1&0(!,(=49&.%!21$45*!+&!6&(-&0'&*7!!?102!02!%(4&!

$.!+$%1!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!,.*!.&=,%0'&7!!;!%,5

/$(-&*!%$!*&/&.*!>1,%!%1&)!2,0*!0.!%1&!L,-:!(,%1&(!%1,.!+&0.=!,+5&!%$!2&(2!%$!1&56!/(,9&!

)$4(!,(=49&.%!,.*!%1&0(!,(=49&.%7!Q1&.!)$4!26&,/(,90.=!$/!)$4!21$45*!,5>,)2!+&!-5&,(&*!46!0.!Fb7!


38/82

#3[%!$'()*%$)''?102!6,(%!$/!%1&!*&+,%&!+&-$9&2!096$(%,.%!/($9!,!9&%,a,+2%(,-%!6&(26&-%0'&7!!D$&2!)$4(!,(=49&.%!&'&.!-$96&%&!>0%1!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&@!!;/!)$4!,(&!%()0.=!%$!g42%!2%(,0=1%!

46!$4%>&0=1!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&:!%1&.!)$4!.&&*!%$!1,'&!,!2%(,%&=0-!,26&-%!%$!)$4(!,(=49&.%!24-1!,2G!942%!,5>,)2!(&g&-%!$(!',54&!%$!50/&!$4%>&0=12!(02,(!$(!&,-1!

,-%0$.!(&0/0&2!%1&!R(0%0055!%10.,)2!=$$*:!4.5&22!)$4!-,.!*&9$.2%(,%&!)$4(!,(=49&.%!$.!,!/&>!5&'&527!!!

?1&!/0(2%!5&'&5!02!%1&!*&.0,5!$/!2$5'&.-)7!!M405%!0.%$!)$4(!-(0%0-029!21$45*!+&!,(=49&.%2!%1,%!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!*$&2!.$%!2$5'&:!%1,%!%1&0(!50%&(,%4(&`5&*=&!+,2&!

02!/5,>&*7!!?1&.!)$4!942%!*&.)!%1&!0.%&(.,5!50.!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!9,$(2&:!%1&!-,2&!%4(.!

6$(%0$.!$/!)$4(!,(=49&.%7!!!

?1&!.&d%!5&'&5!02!>1&(&!)$4!,%%&96%!%$!&.=,=&!0.!>1)!%102!65,-&!)$4!*02,=(&&!02!

096$(%,.%7!![$4!21$45*!+&!(&,*)!%$!1,'&!,.!&d%&.20'&!*&+,%&!,+$4%!>1)!%1&0(!

tttttttttttt!02!096$(%,.%!%$!%1&0(!6$50%0-2!,.*!%1&!$4%-$9&!$/!%1&0(!65,.7!

! aI%10-2!/0(2% C.%$5$=)!/0(2% W,54&!%$!U0/&!/0(2%!

J2!)$4!-,.!2&&:!0/!)$4!>0.!)$4(!$//a-,2&:!%1&.!)$4!21$45*!+&!6($%&-%&*!/($9!9$2%!$/!

>1,%!%1&!L,-!1,2!%$!2,)7!!?102!02!>1)!2$9&!%&,92!-1$$2&!%$!$.5)!(&,*!L!C//:!,.*!.&'&(!=$!%$!-,2&7!!;%!(&,55)!*&6&.*2!$.!>1,%!)$4!>,.%!%$!*$7!!8$9&%09&2!)$4!.&&*!,!

-,2&!*&+,%&!+&-,42&!)$4!-,.!(&,*!9,.)!$%1&(!0.*&6&.*&.%!-(0%0-0292!$/!%1&!

,//0(9,%0'&!%1,%!,(&!.$%!%0&*!%$!)$4(!5,(=&(!$//!-,2&!6$20%0$.7!

D$!.$%!,55$>!)$4(!096,-%!&'0*&.-&!%$!9,$45*!50!%1&)!*&,5!>0%1!0%7!!L,(!/49+5&!9&,.2!)$4!1,'&!,.!&,2)!096,-%!%1,%!$4%>&0=12!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&7!;/!)$4!

=&%!=$$*!,%!0%:!0%!*$&2.\%!9,%%&(!>1,%!%1&!L,(!*$&27!

!


39/82

$,)'[)"38$%$#.-'B&9&9+&(!0.!%1&!+&=0..0.=!>1&(&!;!2,0*!,!(0%%&.!02!+,2&*!$.!+&0.=!.&=,%0'&7!!;/!)$4\(&!

,//0(9,%0'&!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.!-,.!,52$!+&!,!%$$5!/$(!)$47!!P,.)!6&$65&!>(0%&!%1&0(!

,//0(9,%0'&2!2$!,2!%$!.$%!%,,.%!%$!1,'&!

2$9&!-54%-1!6&(94%,%0$.!2%(,%&=0&2!%1,%!,(&!*&20=.&*!%$!2,)!&0%1&(!0%!02!$$45*!+&!.0-&!%$!1,'&!&d%&.20$.!&'0*&.-&!/$(!%1&!L,(7!!J.$%1&(!096$(%,.%!%10.=!%$!4%050e&!02!%1&!5,.=4,=&!$/!*&+,%&7!!

;*&.%0/)!,.*!&d65,0.!%1&!.&%!+&.&/0%2!%$!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.!0.!%1&!X,-7!!D$.\%!g42%!%1($>!%1&!>$(*!,($4.*:!+4%!42&!0%!%$!2%(,%&=0-,55)!&.=,=&!6($'0.=!%1,%!)$4(!,(=49&.%2!*$!

.$%!*02,=(&&!%$!,!5&'&5!%1,%!>$45*!g42%0/)!'$%0.=!,=,0.2%!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&7!!?1&!-(0%0-!

(&,55)!>,.%2!%$!!%1&!.&%!+&.&/0%2!'27!%1&!*02,*',.%,=&2!%$!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.7!!!

QKI#![CE\BI!#IZJ?;WI!

?102!2&&92!%$!1,'&!+&-$9&!,!205'&(!+455&%!,=,0.2%!*&+,%&!,(=49&.%2!%1,%!*$!.$%!

2&&9!6($-&22!$(0&.%&*7!!P)!6($+5&9!>0%1!%1&!"6&(94%,%0$.A!02!6&$65&!,-%!50

,(=49&.%27!!J2!)$4!2%(&.=%1&.!)$4(!50.


40/82

a E2&!%1&!>1$5&!L.(!0/!.&-&22,()!m!P,1,%!,(&!%1&!,*',.%,=&2!,.*!*02,*',.%,=&2!$/!6&(9!

a K,'&!%1&9!>(0%&!$4%!,55!6&(94%,%0$.2!a D$.\%!*($6!?@F!6&(94%,%0$.!ELEG!a [$4(!50.:!,!>$(*!%1,%!02!.&0%1&(!,!-5,09!$(!,!>,((,.%:!

)$4!.&&*!%$!1,'&!,!>,)!%$!,665)!%1&!"9,$(*2!,(&!>(0%%&.!$.!%1&(&:!+4%!.&'&(!6($'0*&!,.!&d65,.,%0$.7!!;!2&&!%1&2&!

,2!055&=0%09,%&!,.*!2$!*$!9$2%!-(0%0-2!,2!5$.=!,2!)$4!0*&.%0/)!%1&9!,2!24-17!!Q1&.!;!

2,0*!2&%!2%,.*,(*2!,+$'&:!;!9&,.!*$!2$9&%10.=!501,%!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.!027!X7 P42%!1,'&!,!-5,09!,.*!,!>,((,.%!N7 P42%!1,'&!.&%!+&.&/0%2!0*&.%0/0&*!+)!%1&!X,-!m!L,(!2,.*+,==0.=!02!,+420'&7!

?1&.!)$4!-,.!,665)!%102!,(=49&.%!%$!,55!$/!%1&0(!6&(94%,%0$.2!%1,%!,(&!.$%!,(=49&.%27!!!

8JPTUI8G!

C+-&*G**

C+-&*9"*4"(!*G*

C+-&*9"*(!+*)#(*A*

J(=49&.%2!50,):!,.*!%1&.!%1&!L,(!>055!260.!%102!,(=49&.%!%$!2,)!%1&!%,=!,+$'&7!!X.(!.&&*2!%$!+&!(&,*)7!


41/82

?&!21$45*!,55!5$'&!&,-1!$%1&(A!,2!;!*&9$.2%(,%&*!&,(50&(7!!?102!02!+,2&*!$.!%1&!0*&,:!%1,%!0/!>&!,55!5$'&*!&,-1!$%1&(:!%1&.!>&!-$45*!*$!

%1&!65,.!,.*!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!$/!5$'&!>$45*!

*$.\%!1,'&!,!4%$60,.!,5%&(.,%0'&:!%1&.!,55!$/!%1$2&!,(=49&.%2!,.*!096,-%2!,665)!%$!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&2!4%$60,.!6&(94%,%0$.7!

=$&+*X-)&+*C+-&*A*D02-422&*!,+$'&7!!?1&)!.&'&(!,55$>!/$(!,!%(4&!%&2%!$/!

-$96&%0%0$.7!?1&2&!6&(94%,%0$.2!9,*&!2&.2&!0.!,!6$50-)!>$(5*!>1&(&!2$9&!

*02,*',.%,=&2!>&(&!%09&!+,2&*!50$(*!1&(&!,52$7!!?102!1,2!+&&.!,!6($*4-%!$/!D&((0*,7!!?1&!(&,2$.!>$45*!+&!%$!.$%!/$(=&%!%1&!+,==,=&!%1,%!1,2!-$9&!

,5$.=!>0%1!%1&!>$(*7!

Y0@()5"%$($"1*5+-&*A*Z%+*(!+*)>>$-&)($*

019+-%()19$1/*(!+*Q"-#9'**T%)&5#+U*A*?1&(&!,(&!*0//&(&.%!>,)2!6&$65&!42&!%102!

,(=49&.%7!!8$9&!6&$65&!42&!0%!%$!2,)!)$4(!-(0%0-029!02!096$220+5&!>0%1$4%!9)!,//0(9,%0'&7!!;!2&&!0%!,2!9$(&!500.!$(!%1&!-(0%0-029!21$45*!+&!0=.$(&*:!4.5&22!)$4!9021,.*5&!%1&!,(=49&.%:!$(!>$(2%!-,2&:!*$.\%!,.2>&(!

0%7!

C+-&*9"*(!+*5#)1*)19*(!+*)#(+-1)($!0%!>055!/4.-%0$.!0.!%1&!>$(5*!$/!6&(94%,%0$.27!


42/82

!

$,)'%&$)"-%$#9)1';!1,*!,!*02-4220$.!&,(50&(!,+$4%!%1&!-$.-&6%!$/!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!0.!*&+,%&7!!?1&(&!,(&!0.2%,.-&2!>1&(&!)$4!90=1%!.&&*!,.!,5%&(.,%0'&7!!K$>&'&(:!;!>,.%!%$!2,)!%1,%!2$9&!

6&$65&!>1$!>,.!%1&!"

The alt is to refuse the politics of the 1AC - this political act is key to exposing the fissures ofdominant ideology which is the most productive method of dissentburke 2007;.!%1&!-,2&!$/!2&d02%`(,-02%2`1$9$61$+0-!5,.=4,=&:!2$9&%09&2!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!02!

.&&*&*!0/!)$4!>,.%!6&$65&!%$!1,'&!,!*0//&(&.%!>$(*!%$!*&2-(0+&!%1&0(!>$(5*7!!?1&(&!,(&!,52$!0.2%,.-&2!>1&(&!,5%&(.,%0'&!/(,9&>$(,2!,!%09&!%1,%!>1&.&'&(!

)$4!2,0*!)$4!1,*!,.!0*&,!/$(!,!R:!2$9&$.&!>$45*!2,)!">1,%\2!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&@An!?1&(&!,(&!2$9&!0.%&(&2%0.=!>,)2!$/!%10.

,5%&(.,%0'&27!!B0=1%!.$>:!*$90.,.%!9$*&2!$/!%10.5)!

6$220+5&!,5%&(.,%0'&27!!8$!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!34&2%0$.!02!2&-$.*,()!%$!%1&!6(09,()!.&&*!$/!&2-,60.=!,!*$90.,.%!6,(,*0=97!!;.!9,.)!*&+,%&2!)$4!>055!1,'&!%$!/&&5!$4%!1$>!

)$4!>,.%!%$!/(,9&!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&7!!;/!0%\2!,!%&,9!%1,%!=0'&2!)$4!%1&!5&&>,)!%$!(&,*!%1&!

,5%&(.,%0'&!500%1!0%7!!M4%!(&9&9+&(:!0/!)$4!>,.%!,!2$50*!,(=49&.%j!g42%!/45/055!%1&!H!5&'&52!$/!,(=49&.%!*02-422&*!&,(50&(G!

,7 [$4(!50%&(,%4(&!02!+,*`)$4(!%1&$(0&2`2-1$$52!$/!%1$4=1%!&%-7!+7 [$4!*$.\%!2$5'&!m!,!+&%%&(!R!1,2!,!R(0%0

?1&.:!0%!*$&2.\%!9,%%&(!1$>!)$4(!%1&$()!,(=49&.%2!=&%!0.%&(6(&%&*7!!O($9!%102:!;!

>,.%!)$4!%$!2&&!1$>!=&%%0.=!%$!65,)!0.!%1&!>$(5*!$/!",5%&(.,%0'&2A!02!$.5)!,.$%1&(!

,'&.4&!/$(!)$4!%$!+&!,+5&!%$!2&,5!%1&!*&+,%&!9$(&!&,205)!+)!65,)0.=!$//!$/!%1&0(!+,*!4.*&(2%,.*0.=!$/!-(0%0-,5!,(=49&.%27!!P,0..0.=!,.!,5%&(.,%0'&!%)6&!,(=49&.%!+&5$>!02!g42%!+$.42!21$%2!,%!>0..0.=7!


43/82

JU?IB#J?;WI8!?KJ?!"8CUWIA!?KI!JOO;BPJ?;WI!

C.&!20965&!$'&('0&>!%$!5,)!$4%!0.!%1&!X#F!02!$.&!%1,%!,55$>2!%1&!-(0%0-!%$!2&&!%1&!

*&+,%&!/($9!,!9&%,a5&'&57!!U00.!0/!%1&)!*0*!.$%!*&.)!%1$2&!%>$!-5,0927!

?1&(&!,(&!%1&$(&%0-,5!0224&2!>0%1!1$>!)$4!/(,9&!)$4(!,5%&(.,%0'&!%1,%!)$4!21$45*!

-$.20*&(!>1&.!%,$45*!+&!%1,%!>&!

21$45*!2466$(%!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!65,.:!>0%1$4%!%1&!L,-!(&6(&2&.%,%0$.27!!?102!>$45*!+&!%1&!L.-!,.*!X.-!,5%&(.,%0'&7!!8$9&!6&$65&!1,'&!(&/&((&*!%$!%102!,2!,!/5$,%0.=!60-7!!;!

%10.,)!%$!21$>!%1&!6$50%0-2!$/!%1&!L,-!>,2!+,*7!!C.&!6($+5&9!>0%1!%102!%)6&!$/!2%(,%&=)!02!>1&.!%1&!X,-!2%,.*2!46!,.*!(&,*2!,**a$.!,*',.%,=&2!$/!

(&6(&2&.%,%0$.2!%1,%!,(&!=$$*!%1,%!)$4!*$!.$%!1,'&!,!(&6(&2&.%,%0$.`5,.=4,=&!R!

,=,0.2%:!,.*!%142!65,.!1,2!9$(&!,*',.%,=&2!%1,.!)$4(!,5%&(.,%0'&!>0%1$4%!%1&!(&6(&2&.%,%0$.27!!8$9&%09&2!%102!9,,)!>0%17!!I26&-0,55)!0/!)$4!!%1,%!)$4!>055!%4(.!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!>0%1!)$4(!,(=49&.%!

>0%1$4%!%1&9!,--&220.=!%1&0(!,*',.%,=&2:!%1&.!)$4!-,.!%()!$%1&(!>,)2!%$!2&,5!%1&!

*&+,%&7!!!


44/82

JU?IB#J?;WI8!?KJ?!"BIfIF?A!?KI!JOO;BPJ?;WI!

?1&2&!,(&!9)!/,'$(0%&!+&-,42&!)$4!&2-,6&!%1&!%1&$()!,(=49&.%2!%1,%!6&$65&!1,'&!

-(&,%&*!0.!(&26$.2&!%$!+,*!-(0%034&!*&+,%&7!!?10.,):!0/!2$9&$.&!2%$$*!46!

,.*!2,0*!>&!,(&!,55!=$0.=!%$!*0&:!,.*!%1&.!-$.'0.-&*!42!$/!%1027!!?1&0(!.&d%!9$'&!>,2!%$!$//&(!,!2$54%0$.7!!Q&!5$$$.\%!,-%4,55)!2$5'&7!!Q$45*!%1&!

2&.,%$(2!g42%!=$!1$9&!,.*!=&%!(&,*)!%$!*0&@!!#$:!%1&)!>$45*!-$9&!+,-0%1!,.$%1&(!0*&,j!9$2%!50:!,.*!.$%!>0%1!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!65,.7!!8$!0%\2!

.&'&(!%()!$(!*0&7!!;/!)$4!.&&*&*!,.!,5%&(.,%0'&!0%!90=1%!+&!=$$*!%$!2,)!>&!-$45*!'0&>!

b!/($9!b!/(,9&>$(!%1&0(!46!%1&0(!1,.*2!,.*!=0'&!467!!M)!

2,)0.=!(&g&-%!%1&!65,.:!)$4\(&!.$%!2,)0.=!5&%\2!,55!=0'&!467!![$4\(&!2,)0.=!.$%!%102!,//0(9,%0'&!0.!1$6&2!%1,%!,.$%1&(!"2&.,%$(A!>055!/0.*!,!+&%%&(!>,)!%$!,**(&22!%1&!

6($+5&97!!?1&!/,55+,-&!90=1%!*&-(&,2&!,!(02`>1$7`>1,%!9&%1$*2!

>055!+&!42&*!%$!,**(&22!%102!-$.-&(.!%1,%!%1&)!1,'&!&5&',%&*!%$!&d%0.-%0$.7!!;/!%1&!2%,%42!34$!02!'0$5&.%:!%1&.!%1&!,//0(9,%0'&!$6&.2!%1&!*$$(!/$(!,.)!,-%0$.!.&-&22,()!%1,%!02!.$%!%1&0(!65,.!%$!,**(&22!%1&!096,-%2!%1&)!0*&.%0/)7!!;/!6&$65&!>,.%!%$!+&!

6$50-)!9,1&.!%1&)!,(&!9,*&7!

D#(+-1)($&!*&+,%&!%1&!

(&2$54%0$.2!,.*!6(&%&.*!%1&!6$50-)!02!6,22&*7!!?1$4=1!,55!$/!%102!02!*&+,%,+5&!,2!/,(!,2!>1)!>&!1,'&!"/0,%A!,.*!02!0%!&'&.!.&-&22,():!%1&!1$9!)$4!,(&!%()0.=!%$!6&(24,*&7!!Q1,%!;!9&,.!02!%1,%!%1&!(&'$54%0$.,()!&.&(=)!0%!%,,)27!


45/82

()*%$#-U'!"#$#!%&'$)%3+';%!02!2$!0.%&(&2%0.=!%$!2&&!6&$65&!%()!%$!-$96(&1&.*!1$>!%$!*&+,%&!$%1&(!-(0%0-,5!

%&,927!!?1&(&!1,'&!+&&.!%&,92!%1,%!%,5!%1&)!>055!*02,=(&&!+&/$(&!%1&!*&+,%&:!,.*!%1&.!1,'&!,!*&+,%&!/($9!%1,%!6$0.%7!!?1&(&!02!,5>,)2!,!65,-&!%$!*02,=(&&7!!

;/!)$4!2%,.*!46!/$(!.0.&!90.4%&2!,.*!26&,055!,5>,)2!/0.*!,!65,-&!%$!*02,=(&&7!!

?1&.!;!.&&*!,!*&+,%&!$.!>1)!%1,%!65,-&!$/!*02,=(&&9&.%!02!096$(%,.%7!!8$!1$>!*$!)$4!*&+,%&!R!%&,92@!![$4!&.=,=&!%1&!50%&(,%4(&7!!;/!)$4\(&!,//0(9,%0'&:!)$4!9$2%!

50055!+&!=$0.=!/$(!,!6&(94%,%0$.7!!;/!)$4!,(&!.&=,%0'&:!%1&.!)$4!.&&*!%$!*$!=$$*!(&2&,(-1!,=,0.2%!%1&!,(=49&.%2!%1&0(!,4%1$(2!,(&!9,,.%!2$9&!$/!

%1$2&!,(=49&.%2!,+$4%!1$>!)$4(!,4%1$(!02!#0&%e2-1&,.:!%$!9,1$!1,2!*$.&!%1&!+&2%!(&2&,(-17!!?1,%!02!*0265,)&*!+)!*$&2!%1&!.&=,%0'&!%&,9!(&,55)!1,'&!,!50.

%1&!.&=,%0'&!=&%2!,!50.!2%)5&2!$/!*&+,%&2:!,.*!%1&!

9&%1$*2!-,.!-1,.=&7!!;/!%1&)!*$.\%!1,'&!%$!+&!%$60-,5:!,.*!)$4!=0'&!%1&9!%1&!=($4.*!%$!.$%!(&,*!,!65,.:!%1&.!)$4!.&&*!%$!1,'&!,!=$$*!*&/&.2&!$/!>1)!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.2!

21$45*!+&!&',54,%&*!*0//&(&.%5)7!![$4!*$.\%!1,'&!%$!*02,=(&&!>0%1!&'&()%10.=!%1&)!2,):!g42%!/0.*!$.&!65,-&7!!B&9&9+&(!%1,%7!!!;/!)$4!,(&!,//0(9,%0'&:!%1&.!)$4!=&%!%$!

6(&%%)!94-1!-1&,%!,2!94-1!,2!)$4!>,.%!>0%1!)$4(!L,-:!,2!5$.=!,2!)$4!,(&!(&,*)!%$!*&/&.*!>1,%!)$4!*$7!!J!=$$*!R!%&,9!>055!1,'&!,!/(,9&>$(

J%!%1&!2,9&!%09&:!>1)!,(&!)$4!.$%!,5>,)2!*&+,%0.=!%102!>,)@!!k>0%1$4%!,!65,.l!!J2!2%,%&*!,+$'&:!%1&!+&2%!,*'0-&!02!%$!*$!)$4(!(&2&,(-1!,.*!6(&6,(&7!!I.=,=&!%1&0(!

,(=49&.%7!!K,'&!2$9&!*02,*',.%,=&2!%$!%1&0(!,5%&(.,%0'&!(&,*):!0/!%1&)!$//&(!$.&7!!I'&()%10.=!;!1,'&!2,0*!,+$'&!,+$4%!/0.*0.=!,!65,-&!%$!*02,=(&&!,.*!6($'0.=!>1)!%1,%!

02!096$(%,.%!,6650&2!%$!*&+,%0.=!&'&()$.&7!!?1,%!02!*&+,%&7!!Q1&.!6&$65&!%()!%$!%10.

$/!,!-(0%0-,5!,//0(9,%0'&!,2!,.)%10.=!9$(&!%1,.!,.!,(=49&.%:!%1&)!9024.*&(2%,.*!>1,%!%1&!,(=49&.%!(&,55)!2,)27!!?1&(&!>055!+&!,.$%1&(!&*0%0$.!$/!%1&!-(0%0-,5!*&+,%&(2!

1,.*+$$!%$!*&+,%&!

"-(0%0-,5A!%&,927!


46/82

3)$,.(b["%Z#+b7."3'%-('!.-$)-$1 !

;!/&&5!501&(&!6&$65&!-,.!(&,55)!/0.*!1$>!%$!+&2%!&d6(&22!

%1&92&5'&27!!?,!%$!+&2%!&d6(&22!)$4(2&5/7!!8$9&!6&$65&!,(&!=(&,%!

2%$()!%&55&(2:!$%1&(2!,(&!6$&%27!!F1,55&.=&!%1&!.$(92!$/!*&+,%&!%1,%!2,)!)$4!1,'&!%$!26&,,)!%$!*&+,%&7!!?1&(&!02!.$!$.&!*&/0.0%0$.!$/!*&+,%&7!!D&+,%&!(&,55)!02!

>1,%!>&!9,:!%$!24--&&*:!)$4!.&&*!%$!4.*&(2%,.*!>1&(&!2$9&!$/!%1&!

-$.'&.%0$.2!0.!*&+,%&!-$9&!/($97!!Q1&.!;!2,)!4.*&(2%,.*:!;!9&,.!(&,55)!,%%&96%!%$!,2-&(%,0.!>1)!%10.=2!1,'&!+&-$9&!%1&!>,)!%1,%!%1&)!,(&7!

C.&!&d,965&!02!1$>!*$!>&!9,&(:!$%1&(>02&!;!>$45*!+&!(0=1%7!!M&-,42&!0/!%1,%!

>&(&!.$%!%1&!2%,.*,(*:!,.*!>&!$.5)!&',54,%&!)$4(!,(=49&.%2!+,2&*!46$.!0/!;!,.2>&(!

%1&9!$(!.$%:!%1&.!;!>$45*!2&5&-%0'&5)!$.5)!",.2>&(A!)$4(!>$(2%!,(=49&.%27!!8$!%1&.!-,9&!%1&!+4(*&.!$/!(&g$0.*&(7!!J5$.=!>0%1!%102!0*&,:!-,9&!%1&!0*&,!%1,%!205&.-&!02!

-$.2&.%7!!U0:!0/!;!24&!2$9&$.&!,.*!%1&)!*$!.$%!(&65):!%1&.!%1&0(!205&.-&!02!,!

=(,.%0.=!$/!%1&!,(=49&.%7!!O($9!%102!6&(26&-%0'&:!%1&!26&&*!$/!*&+,%&2!+&=,.!%$!0.-(&9&.%,55)!-509+7!!86&&*!1,2!+&&.!42&*!0.!*&+,%&!/$(!2%(,%&=0-!64(6$2&2!20.-&!,%!

5&,2%!%1&!90*!SY\27!!#$>:!>&!,(&!%,51&(&!%(&.*2!-,.!+&!2&%!$/!6&$65&!6&(/&-%0.=!

%102!/$(9!$/!*&+,%&7!!;/!)$4!4.*&(2%,.*!1$>!>&!=$%!%$!$4(!/,2%!%&-1.0-,5!*&+,%&2:!

%1&.!)$4!-,.!+&%%&(!4.*&(2%,.*!1$>!%$!*&-$.2%(4-%!%1&97!!8$!*&+,%&(2!2%,(%&*!=$0.=!/,2%:!,.*!g4*=&2!2%,(%&*!%$!+&!*0'0*&*!46!0.%$!%1$2&!>1$!-,.!"/5$>\!,.*!%1$2&!>1$!

-,..$%!"/5$>A7!!?1&!*&+,%&(2:!>1$!>&(&!/,2%:!,.*!%&-1.0-,5:!,.*!1,*!,!5$%!$/!&'0*&.-&!%$!9,%-1!%1&0(!26&&*:!2%,(%&*!%$!+&-$9&!%1&!9$(&!*$90.,.%7!!J2!$.&2!*$90.,.-&!0.!

,.!&'&.%!=($>2:!)$4!>$45*!1,'&!5&22!*&20(&!/$(!%1,%!&'&.%!%$!-1,.=&7!!8$!%1&.!>&!=&%!

%1&!9,.)!.$(92!$/!*&+,%&!%1,%!&d02%!%$*,)7!![&2:!>&!*$!,!5$%!$/!%10.=2!+&-,42&!$/!%1&!.,%4(&!$/!%1&!,-%0'0%):!+4%!0%2!+&2%!%$!%()!%$!4.*&(2%,.*!>1)^!

J2!*&+,%&(2!=$!/,2%&(!,.*!/,2%&(!%1&0(!6&(24,20'&!2&(&!%1&!20965&!*&-0*0.=!/,-%$(2!$/!>1$!>0.2!$(!

5$2&2:!.$%!(&,55)!1$>!94-1!%1&!6&(2$.!,-%4,55)!+&50&'&*!%1&!,(=49&.%7!!;%!(&,55)!>,2!

,!9$'&!%$!%()!,.*!+&!%1&!9$2%!/,0(`$+g&-%0'&!*&-020$.!9,


47/82

*$>.!%1$2&!-$.'&.%0$.2@!!80.-&!9$2%!6&$65&!*$!0%:!0/!)$4!=&%!=$$*!,%!+(&,.:!)$4!21$45*!1,'&!9&,24(&!$/!24--&227!

C.&!%10.=!%1,%!+&-$9&2!-5&,(!>1&.!)$4!*&+,%&!*0//&(&.%5):!02!6&$65&!,(&!5$$,)!%$!60=&$.!1$5&!)$4!$(!/(,9&!)$4!0.%$!,!-&(%,0.!,(=49&.%!2$!%1&)!-,.!,--&22!26&-0/0-!60&-&2!$/!&'0*&.-&7![$4!21$45*!%10.!-,550.=!)$4!

2$9&%10.=!)$4!,(&!.$%!90=1%!1,'&!2$9&!096,-%2!%$!0%7!![$4!21$45*!,52$!+&!,>,(&!%1,%!)$4!942%!1,'&!,.!,(=49&.%7!!#$!9,%%&(!1$>!)$4!2,)!0%:!)$4!942%!+&!,+5&!%$!

-$.%&d%4,50e&!,!*&+,%&!,(=49&.%!/($9!>1,%!)$4!,(&!2,)0.=7!!P,.)!%&,92!>055!.&'&(!

1&,(!)$4(!,(=49&.%:!,.*!$.5)!65,)!$//!$/!)$4(!9&%1$*:!(,%1&(!%1,.!)$4(!,(=49&.%7!!8$9&!6&$65&!2,)!)$4!21$45*!1,'&!,!9&%1$*$5$=)!*&+,%&:!2,)0.=!)$4(!9&%1$*!02!

=$$*7!!;!*$.\%!%10.

9&%1$*$5$=)!02!=$$*:!2$!;!,9!.$%!24(&!>1)!0%\2!,.!,5%&(.,%0'&!2%)5&!*&+,%&(\2!+4(*&.7!!!

#$%!%$!2%&,5!/($9!#00.!*&+,%&27!!P,&(7!!O$(!9,.)!6&$65&!%102!%)6&!$/!*&+,%&!02!/4.7!!Q1&.!)$4!1,'&!,!g4*=&!,.*!,.!

$66$.&.%!%1,%!(&,55)!501&.!"26&&*A!+&-$9&2!*,.=&($427!!?102!1,66&.2!>1&.!)$4!5$2&!

-$.%($5!$'&(!)$4(!-$.%&.%:!=&%!-$.249&*!0.!+(&,*%1!$/!,(=49&.%2!,.*!5$2&!20=1%!$/!%1&!20965&!9,.0/&2%,%0$.!$/!*&+,%&G!Q1&(&!*$!>&!*02,=(&&!,.*!>1)!02!%1,%!

096$(%,.%^!!J2!,!*&+,%&(:!0%!02!.0-&!0/!)$4!1,'&!%1&!26&&*!%$!+,%%5&!,.)!%&,9:!,.*!.&'&(!1,'&!%1&!-$.-&(.!$/!2$9&$.&!9,&(7!

K$>&'&(:!2$9&!6&$65&!,55$>!%102!*&20(&!%$!=$!/,2%!$'&(a-$.249&!%1&9!0.%$!9,1&(&!%1&!,5%&(.,%0'&!*&+,%&(!>,.%2!%$!+&7!!?102!02!%1&!',(0,+5&!$/!5090%0.=!%1&!*&+,%&!%$!0.!*&6%1!X!$(!N!,(=49&.%2:!>105&!

,55$>0.=!)$4(2&5/!%$!*02-$4.%!9$2%!$%1&(!,(=49&.%2!2%(,%&=0-,55)7!!Q1&.!)$4!=&%!

(&,*)!%$!2,)!>1)!%102!02!,.!096$(%,.%!65,-&!%$!*02,=(&&:!)$4!>,.%!%$!+&!*&&67!!?1&.!)$4!-,.!/05%&(!%1($4=1!%1&0(!,(=49&.%2!%1,%!,(&!.$%!,6650-,+5&!%$!%102!*&+,%&:!,.*!

%142!-$.%($5!%1&!26&&*!$/!%1&!*&+,%&7!!!

;!1,'&!X!


48/82

P)!2&-$.*!,(&,!$/!,*'0-&!02!%$!=$!25$>!&.$4=1!>1&(&!%1&!-(0%0-!-,.!-$96(&1&.*!,.*!

4.*&(2%,.*!&,-1!,.*!&'&()!-,(*!)$4!(&,*7!![$4!>,.%!%1&9!%$!+&!>0%1!)$4!,2!)$4!64%!%1&!($4.*!%$=&%1&(7!!8$9&!,(=49&.%2!,(&!%$$!0.a*&6%1!/$(!2$9&!6&$65&!%$!60-

%1&!&'0*&.-&!,/%&(!%1&!($4.*!,.*!4.*&(2%,.*7!![$4!.&&*!%$!+&!%&,-10.=`&d65,0.0.=!)$4(!,(=49&.%!,2!%1&!*&+,%&!02!1,66&.0.=7!

?1&(&!,(&!6&$65&!%1,%!(&,*!%1&!2$a-,55&*!"26&&*A!,.%!%$!*02-$4(,=&!0%7!!;!>055!*&/&.*!0%!+&-,42&!0%!6(0'05&=&2!2%4*&.%2!>1$!-,.!(&-&0'&!

%1&!+&2%!&*4-,%0$.!,.*!1,'&!%1&!9$.&)!%$!,%%&.*!5$.=!0.2%0%4%&2!>0%1!%(,0.0.=!0.!%1&!

%&-1.&!$/!*&+,%&7!!Q1&.!>&!1,'&!2%4*&.%2!>1$!26&.*!94-1!$/!%1&0(!&*4-,%0$.!0.!2-1$$52!>1&(&!2&-4(0%)!02!2$9&1$>!&5&',%&*!$'&(!&*4-,%0$.:!%$!%&55!%1&9!%1&)!1,'&!

%$!+&!,+5&!%$!60-$45*!(,%1&(!340%!*&+,%&!%1,.!%&55!2$9&$.&!%1,%!-,.\%!(&,*!'&()!>&557!!

?1&(&!02!,!%(4&!096,-%!$/!&d-5420$.!0.'$5'&*!>1&.!>&!2,)!"%1,%!02!>1,%!*&+,%&!02A7!!

?102!90=1%!,52$!&d65,0.!%1&!*&9$=(,610-2!$/!>1$!,(&!&50%&!-1,960$.2!0.!-$55&=&!,.*!10=1!2-1$$5!*&+,%&7!!#$%!,55!%1&!%09&:!+4%!9$2%!$/!%1&!%09&7!;!1,'&!2&&.!2%4*&.%2!>,5

,>,)!/($9!*&+,%&!/$(!%1&2&!(&,2$.27!!8%4*&.%2!/($9!,55!(,-&2:!2&d&2:!-5,22&2!,.*!=&.*&(27!!8$!%1&(&!02!,!=$$*!,(=49&.%!,2!%$!>1)!26&&*!02!+,*!/$(!*&+,%&7!!

M4%!1&(&!02!1$>!;!>,.%!%$!*02-$4(,=&!0%7!!?102!02!>1&(&!;!2,)!)$4!21$45*!-,60%,50e&!$.!0%!+)!4%050e0.=!.$.a26&&*!%$!)$4(!,*',.%,=&7!!D$!)$4!(&,55)!%10.

,(&!.$%!'45.&(,+5&!%$!6&(24,20$.@!!8$!5$$,)7!!?1&(&!,(&!,!2&(0&2!$/!

%0&2!)$4!.&&*!%$!,%%&.*!%$!/$(!%1&!64(6$2&2!$/!>0..0.=!,!*&+,%&7!!?1&!/0(2%!$.&!02!+&0.=!,+5&!%$!%$4-1!,55!$/!%1&0(!,(=49&.%27!!?102!9&,.2!%1,%!)$4!1,'&!%$:!0.!2$9&!

>,):!%,055!&d65,0.!%102!$.!%1&!"/5$>`=,9&a+$,(*A!*02-4220$.7!!?1&!2&-$.*!$.&!02!,-%4,55)!&d%&.*0.=!)$4(!&'0*&.-&!,.*!,.2>&(0.=!%1&0(2:!>105&!

-$96,(0.=!%1&!%>$7!!?1&!*&+,%&(!%1,%!-$96,(&2!%1&0(!"&'0*&.-&A!%$!%1&!$%1&(!%&,92!02!,1&,*!$/!%1&!*&+,%&(!>1$!$.5)!&d%&.*2!%1&0(!&'0*&.-&!,.*`$(!,.2>&(2!%1&!$%1&(!

%&,927!!?1&.!0/!+$%1!%&,92!*$!24-1:!>&!1,'&!%1&!"*&+,%&!,/%&(!%1&!*&+,%&A7!?102!02!

>1&(&!%1&!-(0%0-2!(&,*!%1&0(!&'0*&.-&7!!;!/&&5!501&(&!,!=$$*!%&,9!21$45*!>0.!9$2%!$/!%1&0(!*&+,%&27!!;/!)$4!5$2&!%1&!*&+,%&!,/%&(!%1&!*&+,%&:!%1&.!)$4!.&&*!%$!

=$!+,-!>10-1!-,(*2!%$!1,'&!0.!%1&!-(0%0-\2!1,.*2!,%!%1&!&.*!$/!%1&!*&+,%&:!,.*!)$4!1,'&!

,5(&,*)!%$5*!%1&9!1$>!%1&)!-,.!%,

25,%&27!!kD&+,%,+5&!;!l!!

!


49/82

7&.NbU%3)g*.%"(1';!500.!0/!)$4!-,.\%!*(,>!,!=,9&a+$,(*7!![$4!.&&*!%$!!1$>!0%\2!*$.&7!!;%!02!,.!461055!+,%%5&!%$!>0.!>0%1$4%!0.=!1$>!9$2%!*&+,%&!-(0%0-2!

/4.-%0$.!0.!/$(945,%0.=!%1&0(!*&-020$.7!!Q1)!*$!%1&)!*$!0%@!!?$!9,&!/45/055!,!+4(*&.!$/!(&g$0.*&(7!![$4!.&&*!%$!/45/055!,!90.0949!MCB7!U&,(.!1$>!%$!*(,>!,!=,9&a+$,(*!/0(2%:!,.*!2&&!1$>!*&-020$.2!,(&!9,*&!+&/$(&!)$4!*&-0*&!%$!65,)!*&+,%&!

-$965&%&5)!$//!%1&!=,9&a+$,(*7!![$4!1,'&!%$!2&&!1$>!6&$65&!.$(9,55)!4.*&(2%,.*!*&+,%&7!!;2!/5$>0.=!1,(*@![&6:!+4%!=&%!%1027!!?1&(&!1,'&!+&&.!%1$42,.*2!$/!6&$65&!

>1$!%10.

+$,(*2j!%1&!L,-!=,9&a+$,(*!,.*!%1&!L!$//!-,2&!=,9&a+$,(*7!!?1&!X,-!>$45*!%1&.!

1,'&!,!502%!$/!,(=49&.%2!,5(&,*)!6(&6,(&*!,=,0.2%!%1&!"$//!-,2&A!=,9&a+$,(*7!!?1&!*0//&(&.-&!+&%>&&.!$//!-,2&!,.*!-,2&!,(=49&.%2!-,.!+&!&d65,0.&*!50$45*!1,'&!1$>&'&(!9,.)!=,9&a+$,(*2!)$4!-(&,%&!*0'0*0.=!46!%1&!L,-7!!O$(!9)!2,965&G!

J*',.%,=&!;!!kZ,9&a+$,(*!Ll!

8$5'&.-)!!kZ,9&a+$,(*!Xl!

?1&.!%1&!L.-!26&,$45*!9,&!1,'&!%1(&&7!

L7!nn!

X7!nn!

Nnn7!

?1&.!)$4!1,'&!2$5'&.-)!,(=49&.%2!$.!%1&!2&-$.*!=,9&a+$,(*7!

L7!nnnn!

Xnnn!

?1&.!)$4!1,'&!$.&!9&%,!6$20%0$.!>&!>055!-,55!%1&!"$//!-,2&A!,(=49&.%7!!Q1&.!)$4!2,)!"$//!-,2&A!)$4!,(&!2,)0.=!)$4!>,.%!,!.&>!=,9&a+$,(*!/$(!%1&!-(0%0-!%$!%(,-

*&+,%&7!

[CE!DC!#C?!8J[!;!KJWI!X!COO!FJ8I!,.*!H!C#!FJ8I7!!!


50/82

[$4(!($,*9,6!21$45*!2,)!X!C//!-,2&:!,.*!%1&.!0*&.%0/)!>10-1!=,9&a+$,(*!)$4!>$45*!

50,.%!%1&!-(0%0-!%$!+&!>(0%0.=7!!?1&.!>1&.!,.)$.&!02!=$0.=!%$!

(&/&(!%$!%1$2&!,(=49&.%2:!%1&)!%,&(2:!%1&.!%1&!.&=,%0'&!%&,9!1,2!%$!/0=4(&!$4%!2$9&!>,)!%$!%,&(2!0.%$!-$.20*&(,%0$.7!!?1&!X,-!>$45*!%1&.!=$!%$!&,-1!$/!%1&!L,-!=,9&a+$,(*2:!,.*!%,5

$(*&(!$/!m!L7!X7!Nn77g42%!,2!%1&!L.-!1,2!5,0*!%1&9!$4%7!!!;/!,!26&,1,%!%1&)!2,)!0.!%1&!$(*&(!%1&)!2,)!0%7!!T(&%%)!20965&7!

?1&(&!-,.!+&!,!*&&6&(!*02-4220$.!$.!%102!>0%1!0.!,.$%1&(!'$549&:!9)!6$0.%!02!)$4!1,'&!%$!%,1)!,.*!1$>!%1&!.$(9!&d02%2!0/!)$4!>,.%!%$!

*02(46%`$'&(-$9&!0%7!

#$>!%1&(&!,(&!2%(,%&=0&2!,2!%$!>1)!)$4!>$45*!>,.%!%$!*02(46%!%1&!/5$>!0.!,!*&+,%&7!;/!

)$4!/&&5!50!20965&!,(=49&.%2!)$4!.&&*!%$!>0.!%$!>0.!%1&!

*&+,%&:!%1&.!)$4!21$45*!g42%!5,)!$4%!%1$2&!,(=49&.%2!0.!$(*&(:!6($'0*0.=!(&,2$.2!1$>!&,-1!,(=49&.%2!,.2>&(2!&,-1!$//!-,2&7!!8$!%1&!X,-!2,)2:!.$!$(*&(:!$(!.&>!21&&%!

$/!6,6&(7!!?1&!2%(,%&=)!1&(&!02!%1,%!%1&!X.!,.*!%1&!L.!1,'&!*0'0*&*!46!=,9&a+$,(*2!,5(&,*):!,.*!%1&0(!%(,0.&*!>,)!$/!&d%&.*0.=!,(=49&.%2!,2249&2!%1,%!)$4!=$!%$!&,-1!

=,9&a+$,(*:!,.*!02$5,%&!&,-1!*&+,%&:!+4%!0/!)$4!g42%!9,!%1&)!,.2>&(!&,-1!$//!-,2&:!%1&!.&=,%0'&!+5$-!%$!6($-&&*!>1&.!)$4!*$!.$%!2650%!46!%1&!=,9&a+$,(*277!!?1&!L,(!g42%!1,2!%$!&d%&.*!%1&!X,-!,(=49&.%2!

0.!$(*&(:!>105&!,.2>&(0.=!%1&!2$a-,55&*!*($66&*!,(=49&.%2!%1,%!%1&!.&=,%0'&!>055!

&d%&.*7!

?1&(&!,(&!,!/&>!096$(%,.%!%10.=2!;!>,.%!%$!&d6(&22!,+$4%!%1&!=,9&a+$,(*7!C.&!02!%$!

5&,(.!1$>!%$!-,('&!)$4(!1&(&!)$4!*02,=(&&!,.*!>1)!%1,%!02!096$(%,.%7!!;!9&,.!+&!'&()!-5&,(:!">&!>055!1,'&!%1&!

',54&!%$!50/&!*&+,%&!1&(&A7!!;%!02!94-1!+&%%&(!%$!$//&(!46!,!1&(&!

)$4!90=1%!*02,=(&&7!!M&!%1&!*&+,%&(!%1,%!-,.!2%&6!46!,+$'&!%1&!"&d%&.*`)&2`.$A!,.*!

,-%4,55)!*$!%1&!"&'0*&.-&A!-$96,(02$.!/($9!,-%4,55)!(&,*0.=!+$%1!%&,92!&'0*&.-&:!

%1&.!)$4!1,'&!,!+&%%&(!-1,.-&!$/!24--&227!!8%&6!$4%!$/!%1&!94-(0%0.=!$.!)$4(!=,9&a+$,(*7!![$4!21$45*!,5>,)2!+&!>(0%0.=!$.!)$4(!=,9&a

+$,(*!$(!>(0%0.=!$.!6,=&2!%1,%!)$4!>055!0.2&(%!0.%$!%1&!=,9&a+$,(*7!!?102!02!$.&!$/!

%1&!/0(2%!%10.=2!)$4!.&&*!%$!5&,(.!,2!,!*&+,%&(!>1&.!420.=!%1&!=,9&a+$,(*7!


51/82


52/82

[8$$#-U'#$'%&&'$.U)$,)"'#-'$,)'".8-('

!".++g)Z%3#-%$#.-1'';!/&&5!%1,%!%$!+&!,!=$$*!-(0%0-,5!*&+,%&(:!)$4!942%!5&,(.!1$>!%$!+&!&//&-%0'&!0.!Fb7!!?102!02!>1&(&!)$4!-,.!9,0%1!(&-5,090.=!-$.%($5!$/!%1&!/(,90.=!$/!%1&!*&+,%&7!!;/!%1&)!1,'&!/(,9&*!)$4!,2!,!"6&(/$(9,.-&A!$(!,!"6($g&-%A!$.5)!+&-,42&!)$4(!,(=49&.%!0.'$5'&*!2$9&!6&(2$.,5!6$50%0-2:!)$4!.&&*!%$!099&*0,%&5)!9,$(

?1&!/0(2%!,(&,!02!>1&(&!)$4!*02,=(&&7!!;/!)$4!,(&!,//0(9,%0'&:!%1&.!)$4!>,.%!%$!1&*=&!

+,-$45*!+&!/(,9&>$(,.%!%$!0.'&2%0=,%&!%1&!50.,)2!,2(0%%&.!$4%!,.*!0*&.%0/0&*!0.!-($22ad7!!!

\)1*,"0*Q-$(+*"0(*,"0-*)#(+-1)($1&.!)$4!,(&!,//0(9,%0'&!,.*!*&+,%&!,=,0.2%!,.$%1&(!-(0%0-,5!%&,97!!

D$.\%!,55$>!%1&9!%$!=&%!,>,)!>0%1!902>$(*&*!,5%&(.,%0'&2!%1,%!*$!.$%!-$96&%&!>0%1!

%1&!,//0(9,%0'&7!!J.)!,5%&(.,%0'&!%1,%!02!&0%1&(!.$%!)$4(!50%&(,%4(&!+,2&!2%)5&!,5%&(.,%0'&!$(!2%(,0=1%!46!(&g&-%0$.!$/!)$4(!6$50%0-2:!)$4!1,'&!($$9!%$!-,6%4(&!0%!

%1($4=1!%1&!6&(94%,%0$.7!!K,'&!%1&!$%1&(!%&,9!>(0%&!0%!$4%!/$(!)$47!

F$.%($5!%1&!O(,90.=!%1&!D&+,%&G!

J2!2%,%&*!&,(50&(:!9,.)!$/!)$4(!5$22&2!*&+,%0.=!*0//&(&.%5)!>055!-$9&!/($9!6&$65&!

+&0.=!,+5&!%$!/(,9&!)$4!,2!2$9&%10.=!)$4!,(&!.$%:!,.*!)$4!.&'&(!&2-,6&!24-1!

&./(,90.=7!![$4!.&&*!%$!9,!%1&)!/(,9&!)$4:!,.*!-$.%0.4$425)!(&/&(!%$!%1&!$%1&(!%&,9!,2!)$4!9,


53/82

K&(&!,(&!2$9&!(&,55)!+,20-!%062!/($9!$.&!$/!%1&!+&2%!Fb&(2!;!1,'&!&'&(!2&&.!0.!,-%0$.7!

!

aT(&6,(,%0$.!!

aD0(&-%0$.!

aF$.%($5!

aJ'$0*!+0=!$6&.!&.*&*!34&2%0$.2!

aJ2

aP,&!.&&*!%$!>0.!,!BF!,(=49&.%!

aP,,)!)$4!,.2>&(!$(!,2

au4&2%0$.2!21$45*!+&!2.&,&(!21$45*!+&!%$%,55)!$6&.!,.*!1$.&2%!

a81$>+$,%!

aD$.\%!+&!%1&!4.50$(*!

!


54/82

!

N,%$'#+'%-'.9)"9#)NV';!(&9&9+&(!>1&.!>&!42&*!$'&('0&>2!,2!$4(!"%1&202!&d65,.,%0$.A!$/!$4(!,(=49&.%7!!;!>,.%!%$!$//&(!,!*0//&(&.%!>,)!$/!2&&0.=!%1&!$'&('0&>7!!Q1&.!)$4!=0'&!%1&!X,!$(!%1&!

X.:!)$4!>,.%!%$!=0'&!,.!$'&('0&>!%1,%!*$&2!X!%10.=2G!J!a!U$-.!0.%$!,!*&+,%&!,+$4%!%1&!65,-&!)$4!*02,=(&&7!M!m!Z&%!%1&!9,0.!6055,(2!$/!)$4(!,(=49&.%!0.%$!%1&!*&+,%&!0/!%1&)!1,'&!.$%!,55!9,*&!0%!0.%$!%1&!*&+,%&7!!Q(0%&!)$4(!%,=2!$4%!5$.=&(!%$!

&d65,0.!)$4(!,(=49&.%!,2!)$4\(&!=0'0.=!)$4(!26&&-1:!,.*!%142!%1&!$5*!2-1$$5!"%1&202A!$'&('0&>!02!.$%!.&&*&*7!!?1&.!)$4(!$'&('0&>!02!,+$4%!*&+,%&!,(=49&.%2:!(,%1&(!%1,.!

%1&!2%$()!$/!%1&!,4%1$(`,(=49&.%!)$4!-1$2&7!

X#F!8,965&G!

J!!a!F$5$.0,5029!02!%

CriticalDebatersHandbook_

Documents