8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
1/15
teaching critical reading
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
2/15
W O R K S H O P S O N T E A C H I N G
S P R I N G 2 0 1 2
teaching critical reading:in the sciences, social sciences and humanities
GSI Teaching & Resource Center301 Sproul Hallhttp://[email protected]
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
3/15
Danielle Champney, Ph.D. Candidate, Math Education
Ben Krupicka, Ph.D. Candidate, Political Science
Kim Starr-Reid, Ph.D., Comparative Literature
teaching critical reading
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
4/15
What assumptions or expectations do students hold or
techniques do they use that hinder their ability to read effectiv
and critically?
teaching critical reading
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
5/15
Understand some of our students assumptions and attitudesabout reading
Address reading as a set of skills to develop
Consider what makes a typical kind of reading for your fielddifficult for students
Develop in-class and homework strategies to get students pastdifficulties with texts in your field
workshop objectives
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
6/15
Critical reading is interactive
The challenge of genres
Setting goals and expectations
The importance of modeling
critical reading strategies
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
7/15
Top-down processing
Students use the knowledgethey have to understandthe text.
Create and encourage activeengagement with the text
an interactive skill
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
8/15
Different texts require differentreading strategies and orientations
Think about the different textualforms in your field:textbook, journal article, historical source,
newspaper/magazine article, lab report,novel, poem, etc.
reading difficult genres
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
9/15
Students need to know the purposeof the reading
How does the reading connect to
the courses overall learning goals?
learning goals and expectations
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
10/15
Demonstrate critical reading insection
Revisit and review readingstrategies throughout the semester
modeling critical reading
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
11/15
Select a sample text from your packetForm small groups of 3-4 people that
have chosen the same text
Develop an in-class activity and
homework assignment you could useto help your students develop theircritical reading skills
teaching critical reading
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
12/15
Teaching Guide for GSIssection on teaching criticalreading
Conferences, workshops, seminars, instituteshandoutsfrom previous workshops on teaching
further resources
http://gsi.berkeley.edu
http://gsi.berkeley.edu/http://gsi.berkeley.edu/8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
13/15
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
14/15
Critical Reading Strategies
Group Activity
1. The purpose of this activity is for you to analyzea common kind of reading that is closeto your teaching field for difficulties students might initially have with it, and to designaclass activity that will address those difficulties. Then add instructions for students to use
when they read this kind of text on their own outside of class.
2. In your handout packet, please find three examples of course texts and choose one thatmay be similar to those assigned in a course from your discipline. The three textual
genres are:Textbook
Academic Journal Article (Biology)Literary Text
Alternatively, think of a kind of text your students are having trouble with this semester.If you have an example with you, take it out for analysis.
3. Cluster with two or three other people who have selected a similar type of text.4. Look closely at the text. Identify things about this reading that could be difficult for
students.
5. For the provided examples, here are the learning objectives of the reading assignment:Textbook
Learning Objective: Students will understand the core concepts andproblems discussed in this chapter and begin using the chapters language
and vocabulary.Journal Article (Biology)
Learning Objective: Students will be able to explain the purposes of theparts of the article (format), identify the main finding, and list questions
they have about terms or unknown concepts.Literary Text
Learning Objective: Students will understand the satiric persona inGullivers Travelsand articulate in their own words the criticisms of
European modernity that the book packs.Notice that these objectives include both contentstudents should gain and skillsthey
should develop as readers. These objectives are not the only ones possible; they areexamples of learning objectives for early in a semester.
If you are using your own example, write down what you want (or what the faculty
member in charge wants) students to gain from itlearning objectives for content and forskill. If this hasnt been made clear yet, try to make it clear from the students
8/13/2019 Critical Reading Feb2012
15/15
perspective.
6. Create a plan or list ofsteps you would want to take with your students to achieve yourlearning objectives, both immediately and in the long term. As well as activities to model
in class, consider handouts to use as guides for their independent reading.
Before the reading assignment . . .
After student have completed the reading assignment . . .
To support students ongoing success with later reading assignments . . .