Top Banner
" Journal of Applied Communication Research Vol. 29, No.4, November 2001, pp. 297-316 Crafting Policies about Controversial Values: How Wording Disputes Manage a Group Dilemma Karen Tracy and Catherine Ashcraft ABSTRACT Over a six-month time period a school board and its community discussed their district's strategic plan goals about diversity. This article analyzes that discussion within the practical theory frame articulated by Craig. Meeting talk and documents were analyzed to determinehow the group's policy deliberation becamean argument over what words to have (or avoid) in the strategic plan document. Proposals about document language wereframed as technical editing, as inadvertent changing of a policy, and as wordsmithing. fu addition to each frame being used, each was also challenged as to its being used to advance some group members' interests at the expenseof others. Moving back and forth between using and resisting wording proposal frames, we suggest,is a reasonable way for groups to manage a dilemma they face in crafting policies about controversial, abstract issues. The paper concludes by identifying implications for di- lemma theorizing and future study of groups. KEY WORDS: Practical theory, group deliberation, institutional discourse, policy discus- sion, interactional dilemmas, wordsmithing. W hen decision-making groups craft policies, word wars are frequent. As one school board president observed after a vote that followed six months of contentious discussion, "This discussion reminds me a lot of the discus- sion ...that we had over the mission statement and it went on and on and on. And it was only one sentence and it went on and on and on for probably a year before seven of us could agree on one sentence."l Word disputes, especially once they are over, are assessed as frustrating, inconsequential, a waste of time, nit picking, and so on. Although these assessments may be deserved, the picture is considerably more complicated. Disputing about a document's words, this article will claim, is not only a common occurrence in policy discussions, but is also an effective strategy for managing an interactional dilemma. We provide evidence for KaxenTracy is Professor of Communication and CatherineAshcraft is a doctoral student in Education; both axeat the University of Colorado-Boulder. Our thanks go to two anonymousreviewers and Dan O'Hair for helpful comments. Eaxlier versions of the paper were presented at the NCA meeting (2000) and to the NCA/AFA conference on Argumentation (Ashcraft, 2000; Tracy, 2000). Correspondence should be addressed to Kaxen Tracy, UCB 270, Communication Department, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO 80309;Kaxen. [email protected]. Copyright 2001,National Communication Association .' "'" _"""Ii""w
11

Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

May 08, 2023

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

"

Journal of Applied Communication ResearchVol. 29, No.4, November 2001, pp. 297-316

Crafting Policies aboutControversial Values: How WordingDisputes Manage a Group Dilemma

Karen Tracy and Catherine Ashcraft

ABSTRACT Over a six-month time period a school board and its community discussedtheir district's strategic plan goals about diversity. This article analyzes that discussionwithin the practical theory frame articulated by Craig. Meeting talk and documents wereanalyzed to determine how the group's policy deliberation became an argument over whatwords to have (or avoid) in the strategic plan document. Proposals about documentlanguage were framed as technical editing, as inadvertent changing of a policy, and aswordsmithing. fu addition to each frame being used, each was also challenged as to itsbeing used to advance some group members' interests at the expense of others. Movingback and forth between using and resisting wording proposal frames, we suggest, is areasonable way for groups to manage a dilemma they face in crafting policies aboutcontroversial, abstract issues. The paper concludes by identifying implications for di-lemma theorizing and future study of groups.KEY WORDS: Practical theory, group deliberation, institutional discourse, policy discus-sion, interactional dilemmas, wordsmithing.

W hen decision-making groups craft policies, word wars are frequent. As oneschool board president observed after a vote that followed six months of

contentious discussion, "This discussion reminds me a lot of the discus-sion ...that we had over the mission statement and it went on and on and on.And it was only one sentence and it went on and on and on for probably a yearbefore seven of us could agree on one sentence."l Word disputes, especially oncethey are over, are assessed as frustrating, inconsequential, a waste of time, nitpicking, and so on. Although these assessments may be deserved, the picture isconsiderably more complicated. Disputing about a document's words, this articlewill claim, is not only a common occurrence in policy discussions, but is also aneffective strategy for managing an interactional dilemma. We provide evidence for

Kaxen Tracy is Professor of Communication and Catherine Ashcraft is a doctoral student in Education;both axe at the University of Colorado-Boulder. Our thanks go to two anonymous reviewers and DanO'Hair for helpful comments. Eaxlier versions of the paper were presented at the NCA meeting (2000)and to the NCA/AFA conference on Argumentation (Ashcraft, 2000; Tracy, 2000). Correspondenceshould be addressed to Kaxen Tracy, UCB 270, Communication Department, University of Colorado,Boulder, CO 80309; Kaxen. [email protected].

Copyright 2001, National Communication Association

.'"'"

_"""Ii""w

Page 2: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

~

] ~

'!i;

§ ~

g

1;' ~

O .~

~

.~

] ~

.8.s.8.a .~

g

~

~.~

..;g ~

~

.a

:gj ]

~

g 0:0 ~

g 'j

~

.s 1

~.;m

§

] :s

j p.!

8.'~

~

Gb ~

'f§ ] :;::I ~

..g ~

~

g

g.~

g ~

lJ

.~

-0 ~

;§ ~

~

.g ~

~

]

~

~

~

~

.; :£:;- r:S

~

.s

~.8

~

~

~].~

;g.s:~

s-arg.s~.~

~

'"§] ~

~.s:~

.s ~

:S8.p.!:).."C

..2 tIC

:~;a~

:E

~

g;a.::.~

~g

~~

E

-t C

d :,d +

"' ~

0

'" '"

:,d m

+

"' '"d

Q)

0 ~

;j

Q)

!'oI +

"' ~

'"

S

:,d m

'"

'" +

"' tIC

m

Q)

.~

m

~

m

..8"' "-- +

"' 0

'"d ~

.1:: ~

~

~

d

0 d

Q)

..0 0""':'

r:::: m

Cd

.'~

U

tIC '"

:=

.,; 0

d !'oI m

.ra '"'tj

~)

.u 0

-.d '"d u

.!::;' '"d

Q) 0

0 Q

) '"1 .u U

~

..o ""

'" ~

M

..d

'"d m

~

'-'

~

.::'1 Q)

'" i>

: ~

!'01 .::::: :;::I

':t:J ~

~

'"(d"E

~

~

u.l:::£:;-

8 ~

u

~.I::

m

~

0 t3..

~

':t:J ~

Q

)..s Q

) ~

~

-0

~

'" '"d

o:S

.S

:s +

"'

~

~

p. ~

~

~

~

.S

Q

) 0

.m

~..o

~

0 00

Q)

p. Q

) .s

-:S

~:

~~

8

'"d ~

~

.~

~

~

0

'"(d Q

).E."'"

u u

lJ ~

~

.§ 'S

8

p. o.§

0 C

I); !'oI

Q)

.~

bIJ~

~

:>

~

~

u ~

'"d

8 N

m

~

S

~

~

~

;j

m

~

~

'g g.?oj:~

'"d

E-t

Q)

~p.~

0':::::Q)Q

) "'.

~"';:J.s;jm

mQ

)~-om

"'~m

~

"'C)N

'fjtICQ)

~!=1"Z",u

.::'I:>~~.:>

+"' tIC

+", ,

+"' Q)

m C)

m .~

'" Cd

'" Q)

~

~

..g ~

8.~

~

~

]

~

~

~

.5~

tIC.+

"'~.'"

.~

~

..g ~

-:S

-0

..,g ~

~

0.

8" ~

s.:§

&.s

~

.~.s

~

~

g ~

-0

'"d0

Q)

U"'"

'"d."" ~

u

Cd ':t:J

Q)

~

.!'oI ':t:J

'" ~

~

."".

0 m

.n -.d

Q)

+"'

0 ';I

'" ~

~

~

"""

0 Q

)~

~

m

. '"(d

0) -:S

8

8 8

a)' ~

~

.s

~

u ~

~

Q

).~].s

~

t3 "rn

Q

gfJ!'oI ~

';o:J '"d

'iii S

~

"0

~

0 !'oI

Q).:S

-B

t1

"0 ~

~

~

~

~

~

'::..~

~

-:S

m

~:9

~

8 r~

-:S

~

.S

~

g '"(d

eQ)

~

tic'~

~

:g i:f.:;a

~

~]

.s 's

-: :

~0): '*

m!'olm

""'O

m...""'Q

)",i>

"""'-:SU

'-'~!'01

Om

Q)U

~+

"" .O

).""+""""

~O

g

"0 9

~;

-:S..2

~

~

.; ~

8.

§ .'5'

'ti'.~

8 ~

.~

~

~

~

.S'~

~

~

!:).. §

~

~

~

~

: ~

~

§

~

~

If]+

"' 0)

8 ~

§

;j Q

) ~

E

8

+"'

~.8

'"dQ)

~;;:;:

~

:g 8

..o.@,

~.s

;'!'01 $!.

~

Q)

'" '"d

d '"d

~

-!;1 ~

-:S

;j

~

'"(d ~

:t;-'"d

0

'" U

0

Q)

.",,' ;j

m

-;j m

Q

) +

"' ~

m

Q

)..o .O

"".LJ

:.a ~

"0

:s :g..o

s=

.S:g

0 0

-:S

~

~

g s.

z .S

' .n

8 Q

) '"(d

'"d§~

m

.s ~

0) >

m

~

~

.~

'"

~:>

~

~

~

':t:J ~

m

m

0

d ..0

"", U

~

",

Q)

C/)

0) bIJ

U

0 tIC

~

m

..0 ~

'"d

'"d 0

C

~

~

Q)

U~

i>

"'~

O.::'I:t;-m

'"(dO

~O

)!'oI :.!'oI

~.

""""s=~

~.S

ON

.~

ra ';!..,O

~'"d.~

:t:.a)'-:ScS

u+"'!'oIm

~

~."""'!'oI!'oI""'.""dO

!:;m

S",O

)!'oI Q

)+"'.",,0""'!'01+

"'~:d

U

r\~d

U"'"

1-4 """ c ;j

0 Q

) '" +

"' +

"' I

~

~

;... 0)..0

Q)

~

U

U

U

0 w

, ~

~

;j c

'"d Q

) m

Cd 0

~

'"d 0)

U...

0 ~

0)

i>

o. U

0

U

s=

0 tIC

.+"' 0)

+"' '"d

C)

i>

0 O

J C

/) +

"' '"

Cd

0

g '-;;

+"'..0

'" ~

'""' 1U

tIC

~

.s Q

) Q) ~

~

U

8

~

p..::::: .s ~

.~

.S

:g ~

~

~

-o.~

.s ~

.s

u ..t:

:>

::&'

;j ~

.~

-:S

] 0

+"'

~

m

~

.'" 0) ~

8

s= '"

~

~

U

:>

~

~

'" ~

0

0) tIC

:t;- m

8

Q) m

~

~

~

~

!'oI° s= .,;

E-

6 tIC

..o 0"'"

~

'"(d

U

s=

s= i>

.~

-:S ':t:J a.

O);j

~

0) +

"' Q

) gj 0

p. .~

. 0

:E

+"'

m

"'0> ::

~..s

0 ;j

~

.:£:;- 0

0) .~

gj:~

~:~

.~!:ri

~.s

~

-:S- ~

f!:

~.~

:

] ]

~

~

~

~

~

J ~

l

g ~

e.

~;:§

~

fi:.~

§.~

~

~

j ~

.-:E

' ~ Ii

-:S

~

~

;..~~

i]

~

m §

~

~ ~~

~

.~

.:S

8

';' ~

~

~

.?;.

~.~

~

..~

~

~

~

~.~

~

<

: ~

~

~

§"8.

is ~

.~

~

.~

d ~

.~m

C

d ':t:J +"'

8 uS

."" §

'" ;j

...0) !'oI '"

~'"d

;j '-'

0 -@

'"d

Cd C

) '"

U

+"'

'" ~

S

C

d ~

.

r.I:I 0'" "0

"C

~

$!..S

0 Q

) ~

. ~

U

..o <

;a o..§

~

g ~

"0

~

0 ~

~

~

~

~

~

0) ~

U

~

~

'"(d :t;-

-0 §""'.

U

~

~

~tIC

~ ~

~

Q

~

~

~

-:S

.S

""

d ~

~

<

Ii.'" bIJ ~

'"d

8 ~

'"

g ~

S

..§

-:S

;j ~

~

.s

.S

.:t;- ""'"

5 ."'0>

.~

..2 8]

~

~

~

O)..g

.<

m

""'!'01 >

""",."" ;>

:. ~

~

U

~

0) Q

) '"d

0 '"

<

+"'

0 ~

'"

;:J"'" ~

Q

) S

0)

U

':t:J'" ':t:J

;j "E

~

z ~

~

J3

i ~

'=

§ ~

~

.'E "'g.:S

' g]

5 -:S

] ~

a} ~

~

1

.a !tJ

.s "'g ..s.]

j 0) ~

~

~

:

~

;f3 C

/) ~

:t;- s

~

g. ~

s

~

"0 -:S

.s d's=

~

e

~

'.:S'~

",..0

8 G

b-B

.,; ~

.8 s=

.E.

~

~

.s g.~

~

- -:S

] .:a

~

s= g

'" 'E

;' ~

'S

~

:s ~

~

s=

.~

.~ !

~

~

s] ~

~

~

~

~

; .s

~

~:s

~]

~

.@, ~

~

~:;

~

~

E

~

.~.s

~

~

~

.E

.~

.~

~

;a ~

§

: 2.:a

~.~

..?1' '"d ~

+"'

8 tIC

'"d -:S '"(d !'oI ~

.~

"E '3

s= ~

~

~

0

~

~

~]

:d ~

0

~

p. 0

s= '"d .8

~

~

e~

s=

!'oI ~

.~

g

e ~

~

U

m

;j .,;

Q)

0 ~

~

0

:>

0 0)

0 9

0 "'.~

d

0 0)

0)'" Q

) ~

0"'"

0 c

m

d'~

Q)

0) ~

~

~

Q

) ...~

~

~

~

~..o

u g.s=

0) +

"' ': .S

~

~

~

~

+

"' ~

.S

.::'1 '"(d ~

""' ..§

O).:S

.~

~

~

g:g C

d gj §

;s; -:S

!'oI '"d

u S

-B

~

~

'"

~

""'NN

.~::S

:£:;-"':;§-:S

~

~

s=~

s=

"'~

gj ~

'"(d i~

] -'g'E

-:S

0 &

=o.S

~:E

i::j

t..S"'"

'ti'-B

u 0

]:S.':::!

~

o.~o'g

i ~

~

~

'S

5

~

-:S

'"d :<

-!;1

g...g ~

0)

~

~.E

. ~

's ~

.:::: '"d

'S

~

.s '"d

8 ~

~

~

.~

..s

~

~

~

:s ::S

~

~

~

] ';'

:t;- ~

~

u

t .~

~

~

~

~

19.~

a

~

e ~

~

~

.s.§

~

~

~.~

B

~

~

.S

~

e ~

.S

:: ro

8 ~

~

~

~

~

a1

bIJ 8 .s'S

;j

~

.S

..+"'

..'" .s=

I

'" U

'"

'" +

"' '" tIC

tIC Q

) I

Q) ~

0)

Q) 0) '"d

.+"'

~

00 I

.'" '"

'" I

-Q)

+"'

'" '"

Q)

I 0)

m

I

5 ..s

§ jg

ri..§ .~

.§.~

~

:;§ j

~

;§ ! ~

~

-:S

~

~

-:S

~

~

.§. ~

]

.[ ~

ri"8

"'g i ~

~

~

.5

-~

~

§ i

~

"0 ]

~

~

~

~

~.~

~

~

~

:g

.s :

8 ro ~

~

.:S

~

~

~

5 ~

] §.

~

<

~

.N';a

g..8 ~

~

~

.~

.~

gj ~

.~

.:S

] .:S

--a. ~~

-0

~

~

~

;j ~

!:)...:

!:)""'d ~

'"(d :

s ~

I:j

@ -:S

~

~

~

:g

0 tIC

~

.S

.~

~

~

§ ~

.0"; "8 -:S

5

~

m

5 ~

; '"d

~

13

d S

:d

.s .~

8.~

~

8

t1.g 0

.5 s:E

~

0

~

~,~

;a..g ro

bIJ .S

:t::: ~

Q

) '"d '"d 8

'"(d -:S ~

.~

.~

n

~

o.~

~

><

!'oI~

'"

!'oI S

!'oI ~

Q) 0)

~

~:,d

d ~

'"d

0) 0

Q)

U

Q) s=

S

m

...;j""'"",

8 d

X

+"'

m

~

0)"'" .>

i>

Q

) 03

~

:' ~

U

0

e- m

::c ~

0

8 ~

§..o

s='

§~

~

8'S

m

-:S

0

.8 8

0 ~

5

0 0

.::'1 ~

0)

'"; ~

0

~.s

~

m

.s c'~

, m

op:>

.o U

.s

.S

0 !'oI

U

~!'01

U

s=

Q)

~

:P

~

f:). ~

m

"'.~

U

~

U

'"(d .s::s

gj 0

.~

-0 .0

~

~

Cd

~

~

.S

~.]

~

"0 s

g f:).]]

tIC~

~

.§ .~

~

~

.?;- ~

~

i3

;:§tIC.~

~

~

]

~.:S

~

§

§ g.

~

5 ~

19

ri;.:; ~

~

.s° ~

~

.:S'"d

~

':t:J ~

'"d ~

~

~

':t:J 5'0.

8 ~

..o ~

'"i.1 ~

tic @ s=

. Q

~

~

"0

U

~

~

5 ~

bO

)O

~.~

;j

t3 o.~

-!;1 e 8.~

Q

) ::;~

o"""""S':t:J'"

"""O)°m

S=

s="'O

) -0)

-:§""'ubIJ""""~S

"",uo"'

U

Q)O

~

t~

~

~

~

~.~

~

] ~

j

~

~

.~

~

~].s

~

j] ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

.~§

~ 1

~

~

~

l~]

~

~

~].~

~

g ~

~

~

-:S

~

-:S .t;

tIC:.s

~

s .~

.:§ ~

~

~

~

!iJ>

~ ~

.P

~

~

0

~.s

-:S

!'oI ~ ~

.~

~]

m "0

!'oI S

~

.?oj: .~

~

~

! i i~~

~i.[11~

1! Ij1hll-H;!

1 i.~~

!lii ~~

1 ii!jf ~

1i~{

! ~

-:S

'c;;' ~

~.[J.8

"';;; '" ~

:g m

..2

~

8. a}

Cd.§

!iJ> ~

~

.s.~

"1;0 &

'E

g

i ~

~

8

~. oS

-:S

bIJ m.~

.n '"d

.~

~

: ~

.~

j.g '"(du

~

~

1U ~

-;; ~

'"(d ~

~

8 '"

~

~

~

~

~

~

~-:S

~

8 ~

U

'+

:, ~

o~

-5 ~

.,;'~

~

~

~

5

§ ~

"0

tIC ~

:g

'" .~

-'"

+"'

Q) S

='S

~

8

Q) 0

0 ~

':t:J 0

m'"

tIC 0)

-':t:J ~

-+

"' co

.u !'oI +

"' ;s; .0

Q) S

~

'"d

S=

;j U

1 ~

~

i

~

~

~

-5 ~

~

~

'"(d ';§ ~

~:

~.s

~

~

'~j

.a-:s ~

~

;§ g.~

;~

~

~.~

~]].g

-5 ~

~

"O

]}~

~I

s=

f:). '0 ~

.~

:g

o:S.S

~

~

8

m

Q) ."';; ~

~

on gj

+"' ~

cO

~

S

ia Q

) ~

Gb 0

~

.S

~.u""E

~

~

!'oI ~

~.o

gj ':t:J Q)

~"j'

! ~

~

~

.~

c9 ~

~

.; ~

~

i

~

~.~

~

1 j

j~..e

~

~

j.~

~.~

~

~

] I

§. ~

i ~

:§ ~

~

~;

j .~

]

~

1]i

.~

:;§ 8

u ~

+

"' -:S

U

~

~

S

~'"d

+"'..0

'" U

Q

) ~~

'-';a

>

;j -:S

U

'"

0) 0

0 ~

';j

Q) m

.+"'

m

~

~

0) U

'"

'" ~

I "'.

0 ~

0)

~.5

'"(d Q

) ~

S=

:E

~

0'" ~

$!. ~

~

-:S

~.:a

~!'01

e ~

'"d

0) gfJ ~

1U

bIJ ~ m

~

'"d ~

§

"'] 8.?;

Q) 5

-0 '"d

: ~

.ri' ~

~

~

~

~

'" ..g -:S

0

8"C

.'" .~

..g ~

.u

.s ~

~

m

~.s

g '0

g ~

g

~

~

~

~

"O;g

~

.~

m

~

~

~

~

: ..g]

1U

I .s

-0 2

~

&

~

m

U -E

;.:S

~

:s. -!;1 s

~

~.E

0

-:S .s

~

~

(,J s=

"C

'" '"

"'d -:S

'" 0

~

~

~

~

~

~

.~

'"d .s

.5 ~

~

~

! !i};.

~

~

~

E

~

"0 :E

£

~

~

0) ~

:£:;-;a.~

t1

Q) ~

~

~

- ~

~

..§

~

~

~

: i:§

~

'a ;

.~

~

5 -:S

~

~

§ ~

~

'"

s-'~

c:§

i !

1 ~

~

i

.~

.~

.~

~

~

j-1 i.~

i

1 ~

~

~

~

i

I j

; i

~

~

~

~

~

11 J

~

~]

~

~

-I ]

! I

~

:j .~

!

§ ~

~

~

] ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

§

fl.: ~

g.:5

j ~

~

~

g:;:a

.~.S

.~

I ~

~

~.~

~

~

~

~

g

~~

~

]" ~

~

~

.;

~

~;E

~

~

'iii

~]

~

[~1

~

~

~

i .§

'&

.~

g ;

~

~]

~

;§ ~

]] I

~

.i ~

~

.~

~

~

~

19 .~

: ~

~

~

i

~'"

0 E

-t 0

Q) C

) 0

'"d ~

m

~

U

4

+"'

0 0)

'" ~

@

~

@

'-' m

~

8

'" ~

+

"' ~

'-'

+"'

0)"'" Q

)"'" m

C/)

Cd ~

:;§ ~

~

~

~

~

~

-:S

.s ro ~

.§ ~

~

~

-:S

B

~

~

~

~

§

f:). 8;a

~.S

6'o;:J

~.5

"0 Jj

~

~

-:S

8. -:S

~

.s "0

e

Page 3: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

00 >

, -=

d ~

cd C

~

cd 0>

~

>, ~

Q

) >

..:: d

0.-::: ~

00"'"

~

cd ~

>-

' d ~

Q

) Q) ~

Q

) '" f

.~

~

Cd.n

~C

d- >

."".-:::0'" "O

O~

"" d~

.""~

Q)

".S.~

(1j"'.n(1j~

Q)Q

);:g

(1j ..8 -"+

J .i:';o'a.~

§

:,:I 00 "':,:I

~

a .S

.~

~

~

~

.ijj

=

6) -~

:j:j

c,.q ~

"+J

~

Q)

0) !::I R

~

.J3 cd p. -=

.~

u ~

.~

cd.~

6) cd ~

;3

~

~

~

Q);3

rJ) :S

~

cd.""

.s i

~.-:::

;> "0

.u :E

~

g

~

~~

~

S

.~,.c

6).61> >

, ~

S

:g

.~

.§ (1j

§ "C

d;e ~

~

u

S.~

Q

).~

~

§ -:S

p.

p.~

~

'" ~

~

~

ai

~

~

~

8. ~

'P1 ~

- ~

E

] .~

~

s ~

.5 ~

8

~

]..s 00.g

~

.~ ~

l

~

8 :

~

.~;E

..s

j p. '?;

~

~

gj ~

~

~

~

§ ~

.[

~

'" "'" ~

.~

"!;<

6 ~

-"0 a

d .s ..§ .~

.s ~

6'

~;=

: ~

~

~

"'cO

~

~

d §

~

~

j ~

~

~'""

d .a

Q) 00 -..:I

Q)

'-' '"

.Cd ~

~

Q) >

.n

cd Q

) ~

'" b

"",.q.~

'" 0

~

f-4 Q

)~

~

~..s

~

foE -:S

..§ .:e ~

~ "g

§ ~

6) oo.~

0 S

~

"g "+

J.S

~

-:S

"0 ~

'"

~

~

$ $

~

0 ,9

.{3 "j:j'"

"0 Q

) p.

Q) 0

u"" ~

. Q

) ~~

Q

) ,.c

cd U

00 ~

~

... Q

).:E..n.~

rJ) .[:!

Q) C

d 0

0 Q

) P

ot.E 0"

{/) Q

)~

""cd~""Q

)OO

O-:S

Q

)~

aQ)~

"'~c

u~p.u"+

J./j",;s-:S-~

»-:s S

p -U

S~

§'

~

~

'" Q

) "g ;}-~

.s

-:S

13 ;3 ~

oo::§

ta C

d ;e

~

~

~

.~

.~

.!.9. ~

~

~

~

~

-.;:'"aJ

~

m

:s ~

S

0 ~

'"

~

~

~

~

~

~

<

~

~

0 ~

p..~

~

Q

) Q

),.q -$

'" ~

]

-0 tn

0 $

~"~

;=1

0 .~

u

m

bbQ)g>

,$]Q)Q

)~

.:E::::~

~

"'~"g!]

~~

£~6..s00~

~2~

cdS~

?~

gg g.~

.g?J>

~

""d ~

~

~

$ ::E

-:s =~

~

~

] ..s

J?:. s ~

~

"'iiJ .§ ~

3 ~

! ~

6) ~

.I::i ..g ~

~

~

.~

~

] ~

~

Q

: ..s..s

'" "'Q

)""O

~~

"",S"+

Jp. 0

rl:!o ;>

~

.n""o>

;>~

~

"'u", 0)-

;e Q

) >

.s p.

Q) 0

0 ~

Q

) Q) 0

><

.s cd U

) 0

p. ~

.i:j ~

~

0 ~

~

~

Q

) 0 ~

~

g;=1 ~

c

>,

~'S

Q

) ~

~

~ ~

~

Q

),.c Q

) ~

~

Q

) a>

Q)

Q) ~

,.q.§.~

Q) -:S

Q) ~

~

Q)

.t:.D

0) .-u

,] ~

~

.s ..§ ~

:E

:a ~

~

?J>

§ .§

JJ 6 .:t:"O

~

-:..§ ~

"g ~

~

(/) ~

.s ~

8. "0 ~

i

8 -:S

.8 5. g?;

.~

&$

OO

OS

cdQ)~

Q)r--'{/)

",:,:jcd ~

Q)~

cdQ)

.-!-Q)

Q)~

"'~O

{/) -F

-j~

.$0).,9 Q

) ~

"E~

Z

..§ .F

:: .s ~

.,g ~

::.:-.'§ ~

6) ~

~

~

~

~

$

~

~

"N

S

~

o,.c ~

0

~

i ~

~

~

~

~

-.s

~

~

~

~.s

Q)

Q) u

S

m

(/) bO

-!::' (/) ..p ~

~

+-'

~

Cd ~

Q

) ~

.0"'iiJ:E

~

=

>,

p. ~

0..,9

<

~

~

0 --"+

J '"

~"

.s Q

).~.~

~

a

~'",

(1j u cd.~

~

0

~

~

-~

Q)

~

(/) "";=:

~

§ :E

"E

-00 u

~

0"£ ~

0

cd.:t:J

Q) S

"8 ~

(/)

0 :3

6) (/) ~

.! ~

0

J:J 8.]..§

~

§.~

~

cd.,g:: _°.:E

.§ ~

.~

§ Q

) I::i =

~

ta

~

~

0 ~

a §

~

g;e ~

:g ~

~

.cd 8

.i:';o~

~

~

~

S

E-t

§ S

a>

6).,g.§

~

B

~

~.~

§

~.~

~

..g

$l.S

g O

)e

.~

.]§."+

J '

~

00 'S

~~

",uO

).a» ;eQ

) ..."'_U

.~

.~>

.- {/)"+

J

~

~

] .s..s

8 ~

.~

~

~.~

] ~

~

~

.tio j

;..s g

§ §

i ~

~

~

i

.i ]

j ~

~

1 ]

~

~

~

~

~

~

i ~

~

~

u ~

0

00- 0

(/):,:I O

)"+J

S

00 c ~

j:4

~

.~

0) 0

>,

>

S

'" cd -:S

~

""0

cd 0)

0) 0

~

"" ~

cd

:s .~

.J!J ~

§

~

"Cd..s

0 ;}-

Q) ~

~

S ~

:,:I -~

6

~

"".c cd ~

u

:og ~

;e;=:

~

~

~ p.

§ Q

) -:s .0

'"t;:Q ~

~

~

Jj I-

~

6'0(/) ~

"+J

~

~

(/) (/) ~

s

Q) ~

u

p. p.

u 00 ~

,.c Q

) s ~

.s

(/) >,

~

"" cd ~

00 g..~

~

Q

) 0) :§

ta --u (/)

fI) ~

~

;e ~

00 u

..g'x ~

~

:!? g

=~

p.] ~

.~

~..8

8 :

-:S ~

] ~

~

~

.~

.;a- ~

8 =

", ...e ..§ ~

~

.0 ~

~

~

~

.~

~

Q.J!J

-cd

~

'" cd

Q) ;>

(/)

0 ~

cd C

d'-' 00 Q

) Q)

~

~

'-' ~

..p

~

cd 0

'u Q

) -u ~

>

..,.

ta .~

'" -:S

U

)"+J

Q)

~..p

~

"E

Q) >

, ~

s =

~

U

'"

$ -'"

~

~

0."" Q

) ~.>

Q

) ~

-o.S

~

~

"E

~

0 .~

.o cd

Q)

..,. -.s Q

).~

>

~.n

(/)~

Q)Q

)Q)-:S

UQ

)""'Q)Q

)""{/)..,9cd- ~

:;::p.Q)~

00)00.

,.c""Q)~

>~

S

-:s 0)

-.s~

~

"+J

~

"t:IO

~

.~

.~

;=:

~

~

,.c !I::

~

"E

~

b 0

",'", (/)

~

E-t

~

S

S

cd ~

,.c.s ~

..§'F::

~

~

~."""i:f

~

=~

'+

-. -u,.q aJ

~

'"

.8 ~

.-::: 0

(1j 8.;=

: 0

.~

Q)

Q)

"':"' Q

) ~

~

.~

.~

0 6'0

~

~

~

cd 0

~

~

~

g. Q

) .S

~

0

1::1 ~

~

~

§ ~

"!;<

u "C

d -:S

~.i:';o

g 6)

S

~

6'0 Q) -00'S

~

Q

) ~

.i:';o"+J ~

~

c

~

$ .§

~

u ~

~

0] a

-:s ~

~

-<

.s

u:,:I ~

Q

) ~

~

~

..s -:S

.~

~,.c

~ p.

~

-:S.S

C

D >

< -:s

o'~

~

..,9 r- ~

.>

~

Q

) ~.g ~

Q

) ~

E-t

0 ;3.[:!

~

::J 0) iii

~

oo~cd .>

~

:,:I ~

Q

) 6) -S

"g

M" (/) "0

~

~

Q) ~

~ u

6).§ $

~

: -:S

S

0) ~

-:S ,.gj ..;

~

g os;

:: ~

~

g;

~

.~.S

~

Q

) cd (/) 6'0 ~

§ ~

6 ~

~

$ $

~

0 ~

.i:';o.s .~

.s 00.:E

. ~

O,.c

~:.

.i:';o (/) ~

E-- ~

u ~

~

P

.~

.0 ~

6)

>0.s

Q)

.~'""O

~

00

~

>

Q)

~

Q)

.Q)'.""

~

.~

~

0) .~

.~ ]

~

~ i

~

] ~

g

~]

: i

~

i =

~ ~

1

~ ~

.z

~

t ~

~

~

]

] j 1

i] ~

! J

] t

~

~

~

~

i ]

~

~.:a

~

8 ] E

-- ~.§

~

~..8

~

z] ~

~

S .:a .S

~

~

~

.g;}-~

~

p..s

~

~ .s.

cd.:a ~

~

(/)

8 ~

, Q

) Q

) Q)~

Q

)' '(/)

cd Q) Q

) C

X)~

"" ~

, .~

, O

)~

"'- ~

Q

) '" ~

~

~

Q)

Q) ~

S

S

O

O~

.i:';o'I

] -:s

~

$ ~

~

~

.8-.§ -.s -:s

~

1 -B

.;g

i 'E

1

~

~

~

§ ~

~

g.s

~

~

1a ~

~

~

~

-:S

-:s

u Q

).~.S

O

'~

§I

~

M"]

~

.S

u ~

.>

,"" ~

..-!

~.(/)

~

S

6""".?;- Q

) ~.~

~

~

~

~

S

~

"'iiJ J:J

0 $

§.S

"O.~

~

$

~

~

6) ~

: $

Cd ~

"E

Q) cd 6)

0 0

"'" >

."'iiJ ~

;e ~

Q

) ~

~

Q)

-:S

~

rji -'" ~

.-:;: Q

) ~

~

oo~

~

0

~

S

S.~

~

! ~

~

~J

~!J

i~~

r]%

.~1.~

~i~

~

~]!.~

11~

~

i~~

~:

~1

t~j1.~

:§i~I

~

0 p.O

0

~

u Q

) 00' ""0 S

.fj

(/) :,:j S

,.c p.

~

-!::"~

Q) (/) (1j

(/) -00 ~

cd Q

) ~

=a

S

c."" -Q

)!

i :g ..s ~

~

~

.S

"'m

~ -$' .,g~

.s .g .~

..s ~

S

~

"g .S

~

~

.~

.~ -:S

g ~

~

:a ~

.~

§ .;g §..£

.s <

~

o.~

1 ~

?J>

I '0

g 0 ~

~

S

~

~

~

.~

~

"E

(/) ~

~

+",.g

~.~

~

~

Q

).~

~

.s ~

Q

) --d "+J -:S

..c.Cjj

Q) ~

~

gr ~

~

! '"C

d 8 6) ~

.s ~

~

-:s

p. ~

:":§ .s

~

~

~

~.s

~::.

~

~

"E

] .3

.a 'S

~

.~

~

~

~

.gj

oS ~

~

~

~

,.c ~

:g

§ Q

) a.s -=

i

$u

~""':t:J

'-' Q

)Q)

u ~

. Q

)""taO'-"U

. U

oo>'

Q)cd

Q)

] ..s

g.~

.~.s

.g ~

i ~

..s.a m

~

~.;

~

s ~

['"

.§ :":§ -:S

~

.§.~

~

~ ~

~

"g ~

~ ~

.s

S b

.s ~

~

~

~

~O

' Q

) a>

~

p..~

~

s S

,.c 0

~

~

s ~

...:. ~

u

(/) ~

-::: ~

~

'" a>

"E R

'"

Q) 0 ~

~

~

~

?.~

S

~

1!J.S

~

.-!~ .§ ::; "g

~

Q) ~

g

R"O

§

~

b 6) 8

~

~:9;;.

~

.s =

- ~ ~

JiJ ..§ ~

~

5

~

.;:j -:S ~

.g ~

~

6 ~ o' ~

~

~

""d

.""S

.-!{/)'-'>

{/) ~

~

.""v.

v' '-lot"{/)

::ccd;>~

""";:::1 ~

00-

Q)

(/)~i

..s ~

8 .H~

.~

j ~

~

~

: ~

~

~

~

~

~

:3 ~

~]

g !

.Hg

~]

~]

~

~ ~

~

.; i.~

~

~

] "g ~

~

~

.~

~

i .~

~

Q

) m

2 "0 ~

<

' ~

~

g';8

:s "'g ~

~

.:a ~

p. ~

~

~

~

m

:E

S

~ ~

~

;}- ~

:

~ ~

E

~

~

~

~

~

..s ~

~

~

~

~

..:ra~

rao~ ~

§

~

"ri ~

] ~

E

-: ~

~

~

.g ~

~]

~

§ >

. -:s S

~

~?s

~.~

~

~

.;g ~

~

~(/) .-:::

~]

~Q)

d""d ~

~

~

~

~

-~

~

:,:I S

C

d ~

Q

) ;>

0

>,

Cd

~:,:I

U

"""""+J

~

rji."" (/).~

-Q

):,:I (/)

"+J

U

~

~

0 00

I (/)

~

~~

8 ~

]:~

~£.s

~-:S

"g~~

§-g

§-E

~~

~

; ~

~

~~

:g e$$

~g'S

-B

~

~2]..i:';o,5i?

~~

..§I

.;:j u

'" p.~

0)

(/) ""

~

(/) 0

~,.c

0 Q

) '"

0 00 S

p.

'" o.~

51 (/)

Q) '"

~

c ~

-Q

) -;>

-:S

cd

! ~

.~

~.~

~

.."

.~

-:a ~

].s 6.g

-:S .?c: ~

.5

~

f.":9 ~

i

~.~

§

6 Q

).J!J.:a .":9..s

~

~

S;a

p. bdo a

.i:';o ~ .J!J ~

a

.~!

"0 p.-:S

~

S

~

~

g

~.:a

Cd .~

~

.~

.[:!

c ~

U

d>

"""

d Q

) "0 ~

~

S

"+J

cd Q

) -+-"

'E

Q) ~

$:3

'S

~

"+J..§

o.~,

(/) ~

",,~

~

_Q)"";S

CdQ

)Cd"'_:;::

~

.-;~

'-' cd(1j

~

(/) ~i!

.~ ~

~

] ~

.~

~Q

):

1 ~

~

'&

~]

~ ~

;

~;

.i] ~

§

1 ~

i

~

~ 1

~

E

~

~!

~-~

j]

.~~

§.:

..§.~

~ ~

+J~

Q)a-"'"

~>

Q

) "'.""~

{/)Q)(1j{/)"'cd

.-,.c~C

d~~

~

Q)"'p.~

""~ca~

Q

)-P°JjQ

)Q){/)+

J

: ..s

~.~

] ~

..s ~

.s :

.s 1 ~

~

~

~

~

-@

~ ~

P

. i ~

~

'O

];~

~

.s ~

S

i ~

§

~

(/) tJ ~

~

~

~

~

s ~

~

g+

"""- .~

Q)N

>..""

u~

~"E

.nQ)~

.~

u O

{/)O

-{/)~~

{/){/)~"""

~

(.;Jc ~

-:::OO

'"I

:;: ~

{/)"'"

13 ~

~

::Q

"

s "g

c (/)

] ~

Q

)"+J

~

{/).g u

~

~

~

~

+"'

Q)

u ~

>

, ~

~

>

.- "5.

Cd.J!J

Q)

~

~

cd

~

u "'Q

)cd§.""S

Cd.;:j~

C

d R

O

Q)O

'- ~

(1j-(1j~",

~

td-~

o~

';j;;J,.c"+J:,:I

) '"

~

m ~

.; ~

~

.u .~

§

0 ;

'a. ~

~

(/) i ~

~

~

6) ~

Q

~

i cd ~

6

u..c..~:g

e ~

.~

~

S

'..g ~

~

-E

.s .§.~

m

Q

)I

§..,9 s;e

6) g. ~

i

S

S

u ~

..s.s ~

~

~

(/).S

~

~

.g ~

rl:! ~

-=

$ ~

~

~

'2 p.

0 .:t:: ~

(/).~

~

$ '0

~

S

0 §

S

~I

Q)""d~

'd'" S

.i:';ooo (/)~

sx~~

{/)Q)"Q

) fI)

Q){/)O

s>']""

cd~S

~~

p.

cdOp.{/)Q

)_{/)C

~ o

-.s 0

.s !:::.s

8.:5 -::: "0 ~

ta.d

~

~

~

P.

~

Jj ~

-:s -:s ~

Q

).~

p..§.J!J >

. $ ~Q

)(/) ~

~

~

~

~

~

-.s.:e

p.:a.J!JI

~C

d ~

(/)'-'

'U

~~

.~

u (/)

>

~

S-Q

) "+

J~U

~

:,:I-~Q

)~~

{/)cd u"+

J"+J

j ~

~~

"O.~

N:-E

! §~

..s g.~

~~

] ~

.~i.s

~

~'-g

Q

~

0 a~

8.':§:s

~~

,*.s..g"S

c,; ~

~

Q)~

j~"O

.~~

""

~

~

~ ~

~

.; .s .S

~

~

~

~

g ~

~

~

.:g ~

] ~

~

~

~

~

~.~

~

~

]] ~

.~

j

] ]

.~ ';@

] ~

g ~

cb m

.8 ~

E

]

~I

..,9 ~

~

$ ~

p.

cd S

~ ~

~

'"

.s ~

~

C

d.:;:: E-t ~

~

(/) cd ~

"+J

Cd cd ~

cd C

d Cd p.,.c

i>

0 ~

a>

cd 0

{/) ~

Page 4: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

"d ~

Q

)"d"d <

D 00 =

0

"'cd 00'"Cd"d "'0 dJ ;>

'--b O~

cC

~

<D

<D

'"Cd rb =

'E

! s

i ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

13 ~

~ E o,.. .~

§

.~ .~

.:S ~

.~

~

~'S

1

~

~

.~

.§~o

~

~~

~

~ §

ta ""'"O

..d ""~

X-o"""'~

""pO""

;>

:;j~""+

"'~

' <

D~

~

0);>

...00

.~~

.,..

'+J

~

<D

cC <

D <

D

,LJ 0

So""

<D

Q) P

ot 0 tJ

'+:I tJ

0 ~

..d ~

~

<

D

".. m

~

p

+"' >

e

...~'tj~

<D

S~

'""~

~

o ~

tJo:S

Q)~

Q

)06j~.Q

"d~

'+J

'tj"d ~

~

>8~

:>'0

~

~. g

~.$.:S

~

~

~

~.:S

~

';

~

~

~

~

~

~"d

o:S oS

~

e

~

~:

~

~

:;:: o~ ~

.~

~

~

-s ~

~

~

~

-oiJ :9

~

~

~

~

~.::S

j

.:S "a) ~

~

~

] ~

~

~

.~

~

~

~

~

i g.~

!! g:"§

~]

g.8 ~

] ~

]'::§ §.¥J :

g §

s:: P

~u~

001:f~;>

o:S~

c:I::~.D

"d~6.t11:1.~

'~

8"'tG@

~

.$~1a~

~~

~

.:E

~~

';~]g~

+"'

~

0. fl

~

..@ .~

;§ ~

~

£

1a ! ~

J!J g

~

8 ~

~

~

~

~

.:S -:S

-oiJ .; ~

:j2 'f3 'a

J!J :8 ~

.~

~

~

~.:S

~

"8 '~~

+"' C

;- ~

~

~

~

U

<D

~

'+J

P

<D

"d '"" <

D

Q):>

' jj ..d

<D

;>. ~

'+

J 'u d"'"

m

~

~ -:S

0';.:9

2 ~

~

a5 ~

~

.-:

~

s .a

~:E

:S

8. 'E

o:S ~

~

~

~ ~

~

-: .:S

U.~

.S

00 ~

S :E

~

-:S

S.~

;t:1.:S

0) S'

: ~

.~

~

]0

~

~.g]

~

:; ~

oS

~

] ~

~

~

',~

15 ~

~;:g

&;.§

~

~

.~8.

] ~

.g

~

:;: ~

~

:;.§

~.S

~

'~

+"' ;a

I 0

-~

f <

D'-"

~

U

<D

m

'"" 0

~

m ~

d

;>

~

<D

u.-f '"

+"'

~0)

0) 0)

~

, ]

~

~

.s"d ~

d

>

"d 2.

o:S N

"d

'C -~

<

D

S

0 0

:>.

"'cd.:a ~

-:s

m

co d

8 .s 'tj°..d

m" u.Q

i>

~

0) P

U

~

I

<D

><

'~""

<D

'~

<D

<D

<

D 1:1.;>

"'" =

+

"' "'tG ~~

<

D <

D ~

~

Po:>

. ,-.

R ~

tJ. u

~

+"' m

.s~

<D

~<

D§'~

~

oo1:i~S

~~

S~

~o:S

~e'a

..g~.§aj~

.!:I_"d'iS

~

:g~

:g~~

,"".g.a,g'tj

.~

.~

~

S

~

~

oS .~

1] a

'E

~

i ~

.:S

~

:;::.:s S

~

~

~

~

'5 j

~

1.~

~

1.~]

:~

.~

~i

"§ ~

o:.: ~

:

"0 aj

E"d

~

S"d

~

~

{I)"d..!!-"d ~

"d ('-'"d

<D

u) ~

0

."'.'" Q

) +"'

~

~

"Q1"d""

t3 +"'

1:1. ~ .,,- 0) ~

g

0) ~

.t.§ ~

~

:3 ~

1a ~

~

8.s.~

~

~

~

] cC

.~

1a ~.:S

~

:

~ i

-:s .:S

* ~

~

~

~

.~

;f3 .~

.:S ':

g ~

~

'21 :S

-:s.s. §

"d ~

~

~

~

0

"'iU

,LJ :3 ~

~

~

.J?;'-"d 0

~

6 ~

8 ~

'd

'C;>

. 8. ~

!d

<D

~

.S

+"' ~

"8

,~o

0) ~

[ 1 @

.:S.]

~

~

~

~ 1

~

~

~ 1

~

~.~

]!.§ j

~

i ~

~

.~

: ~

1 [i

~ ~

~

~

]

~

ij ~

~

~

~

Q)

~;>

.~

bO"".:a

~

~ ('-. 0

§"d "'cd ~

~

<

D .§

'"" <D

d

0) 00 0 u

~

Q)

N

cC

'" +

"' ~

us'"

~

~

0 ~

j

.:S:~

]]'g] ~

;

~

§ E

~

-;

~

~ ;

:. ~

~

~

"'" ~

.~ ~

B

&

.:S

~

E

.~ ~

~

~

~

t

~

~

g. r'~

~

[~~

,~

.~

'""""'2'"Cd'+

J-'U<

D{I)<

D~

<D

~-~

~cd~

C

CQ

00:>

- "d~

C""""'<

Do

wv

;:1 w

v jj""~

,-.'"

?J' §i 'E

01:1.

~

:j ~

<

D ;>

. ~

~

~

Q)'C

o:S.g

R ~

<

D Uo (d

-E Q

) ~ .s

~~

~

C

~~

~

0

~.

-E

~

~

-E.s

"'.~

-=

.S

9 g.

~00

0 """">

<~

""U<

D1:1.

so ca<

DO

O

~

Q)~

'>+

"' +

"' (d

1:1. 2

Q)':+

:I~

Q)O

)o"':>'o

"'Q)':+

:I

~

>.

~ o~

;;-~

~~

.@~

~

~

§

~

~~

~

~

o:S cC

~::

~-:s

p §i

0)~

"d

00J!J <

D

Po"'cd

C

~

0) ~

~

~"O

~~

.s.~

1:1.~~

+

"' .~

'+

J <

D,

0 ~

~

~

. Q

) ~

~

cC

"" ~

+

"'.~

!d ~

'+

J o:S

o:S

cC

..,.

'" ..,

0 ta

0)

~:~

'S

]:(;..a] o:S

E

; ~

~

.Cd

~

~

~

-;:; E

g

§ 1a

a o:S

~

6'.s ~

.§ 0

~

"d ~

bb;>

..§- ~

.g; ~

~

"8

: 11

:f.. "§

g:S

.~ 1

: E

.~

g.~

~

§' ~

.:S

~;~

.:S

g ~

§

~

~.~

~

~

~

1 ~

~

] ~

.~

j

~

~

;§.~

~;;g

~

~

~

~

~

.~ ~

~

~

~

m"

oo~.:a

bb ~]

1a .S

s.s :>

-.s.s .$

~

~.~

~

(I) ~

~

0 ~

.;

~

§. .2

i>.~

~

1:1. ~

§

~

'-- 0

.s ~

8;a

.~

"0 ~...tJ

~

~

s ~

..d S

~

~

"ca ~

~

!d

~

...0 0

co '\II +

"' ~

'tj

~

:t:' S

~

0

Ir) tJ

~

10 ~

:>

. aj ;:;. ~

:>

.S

~

.:a

P

~.:S

.'+

J ~

S

~

~

0

~

~

!;::.~.,p

~

~

Q.~

.:S.:S

~

+

"'.s P

oo.a.

cC:3

~

1:5..:>.'~

e

~.s

~

Ef""

~

.~~

'E

"d.$."" ~

~

<

D ~

~

'8

.$ ~

:g ':;::;" <

D 0

~

.:a ~

U

~',-.

'd ~

s

o.s 3

00 00 cC

~

~.D

Q

) 8 ~

~

~

.~

~

~

~

~

~

ca S

~

§ ~

~

'$

~

~'i::

~

§ ~

~

gj ca]

~

~

-~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

s ~

..§ .~

.~

r~

~,~

t~

~

E

~

~

~

:S

~

~~

~

.E

0

>

~

~"O

~

~

.::::, ~

.~

~.~

'Cd

~

'C"d

00 ~:P

~

"I:

0) tJ ~

.q:;

CD

S

<D

."".~

00 '""...

~

aj '""

;>. I-t

<D

'r"' 0..Q

.""..d Q

J '"" 00 0

0 ca

d -0

oj"d '""

~

1:1.,LJ ~ (I) ;>

cC ~

(I)"d

'+J 1:1. 0

cC

OO

~.~

:: U

U

U

~

<

D U

.,!,

;>.

~<

D ~

~...;

<D

<D

"d <

D

00' I

..:: ca"d '

00 C

'!-! "d <

DU

U

' U

ca

U

0 <

D U

P

"d

~

1:= ~

X

<

D

U.,p ~

-:S

ca"d

.$ '"" ~

o:S

~

'

'"" 'd

.-, :

~..§

U

~

.fiJ.~

~

1a <

D

.$ "d

~

d' 0

~

0 S

~

<

D

~

<D

S

S

~

Q)

~

'... co 'tj

0 P

0

U

~

-~

.:i::i' S

~

<D

.~

'r;o

~

Po. P

;: ~

~

n ~

~

*

~

.s'1:=

gg.m

:s ~

~

'a

-oiJ 5J.:E

J ~

~

8

8.] .ri'

J!J '~.,g

8 ~

~

~o

,] ~

.~"d"""rz..~

o ~

<

DP

~

O)A

'tj (I)<

D

00 ~

"d-'+J-

~

aj§

(I) <D

~.S

..!:I U

~

<

D ~

'""

'"", ~ -:s ~

0

aJ ~

~

'fiJ ~

O

"d ~

"d U

"d '"C

d ~ 6

~

.'" .

'"Cd1:::"'<

D"d~

ca"d~

<

D

'" +

"'S

OO

"'CO

~

:PcC

""<D

;>.<

Dp<

D

ca~~

<

D 8

~

.$ cC

~

;>. ~

~.

~

o:S

~

~

~

aj s .~

:

-:"d g

~

~

"'iU ~

t) ">

( ;p, ~

~

x

'c

go] gj ~

2

~

~

] ~

1a ~

~

1

~

;.~

§ t:!..:S

i!d.s

~

0 E

~

--a1 .$ ~

~

.~

~

~

'"" ~

R"d

~

R

R

<D

U

<

D ~

p. 0) ~

~

aj ~

"d 0

S

~

~

~

cC

'+J

00 1:1

ca !d 0

ca ta' S

~

~

'"" ~

~

~

oo~

0)

"I: 23 6j

] ~

~

'ti'

0 ~

~

~

<

D <

D

aj.9. 2?

;§OO

N.tI

~

~.tI

~

~

C:;§

~:

~

-:s 6 0

~

~

g..~

U J!J.~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

0 §

8 ~

.'--"~O

.!:;'cCcC

~

..d~

""0)+"',,,

...uOO

.$'+

J"d0~~

i>

ca <

D

:;j, ~

00"'" E

~

~

.~

'f3 "0 '+J ~

0

~

~

"'tG -3

lI:I U

00

:: <

D §

1:1.'E 23 "'cd ~

0] ~

~

~

.s

~ ..§ ~

§" g.~

~

"m

.s -a. ]0 ~

§ ~

~

-: .~

+-'

~

] .~

~

]~]

~.§

-:S ..@

.s ~

; :§

t "0

~;a

~

~

<D

i>

;>

.!:I ;>. R

~

.:a ~

'"

Q) ~

ti §i

~ ~

"d

~

~

cC ~

~

2 ~

"d ~

,~

5.,,- ~

'5) <

D g;

<D

~ ~

~

0

~

~

U ::0

.~.s

~

.~ ~

~

§

"d 0

~

~ ~

.S

g

~

"'cd ~

~

~

~

;f3.g ~

o:S]

~

o:S ~

~

::; ~

~

<

D g.;

~

~:S

8 "8 ~

§

~

~

ca -.g .~ .~

~

<D

S.:S

~

.S"d

~ ~

+

"''E

]

~

"0 ~

,] ~

~

~

~

-5

~

§ ~

'r;o; ~

~

~

.tI

J}. .tI

S

~

~

~

-B ]

"'cd ~ ~

1a

~

.~

:E

~

~

~

E

gj g g

~

~

~

~

@8

'tj'~

§ i ~O

);a

05 "d !

<D

f:]

~

] 'a

~

~.~

C

O;>

. ~

S

~

<D

R

--c!d

~

S

...i>

'+"'

.1a ~

..d

0 <

D

Cd..E

~

-U

~

'""

1a'-":;§Sca~

~

Cd"d<

D~

ug~;aS

"'~.s

-=-

~'+

Jo:S~

o:S"d~

:>"-"u

~

"'m"

S -?'s

~ ~

:3

~

'f3 ~

~

~.J5

-: Q

) .s ~

~ ~

~

]

~

'f3 :;::.~

<D

~

~

";' ~

': ~

8.

-:-., ~

~

g

<D

~.a

S o:S

~

~

.s g

~

g o~

~

~

~

~

~

1a ,~

~

j

~

~

~

-:S ~

~

:.

8. g ~

§

.~~

~

~

o:S..1!J ~

00...;' 2 .$

'E:E

~

"d ~

~

6'~

~

:: S

~

~

~

~

~

"P..S

~

~

.~ ]

*.:g ~

.:S

.:a ~

~

'B ~

'a ~

.S'~

~

~

U

.~ ~

~

~

~

~

.:S

~

"'tG,LJ

.s g

.~ .~

.~

.E

t-o .~ ~

~

].s ~

"'.~

:::.a

"'" 1:1. 0

.$ 8

<D

o:S

~.g

~::

'"bQ.~

~ ~

~

+

"' -:s

:s ~

1;;' o:S

~

f:J. ."" ~

~

'--" ~

S

..g § ~

:>

~

8 ~

(I) :3 o:S

cC

"d <

D <

D

'S

~

S

°;a.S

m

0) P

<

D

"d S

1a ~

"d ~

§ <

D.c

C:! ~

.Q

...

1J 1:1.!

~:g

"'cd ] .~

~

o:S

~ ~

"gj §'

s ~

aj s ~

. ~

8

~

~

~

~

8"p' 0

~

~

~

g..~

'§ 'tj .:S

~

-.~

S,LJ

<D

~ ~

a

~.S

J!J P

~

~

: 8

.~ ~

~

~

] "8

~o <

D

~

'"" 2 gj.u

1a g ~

0

~

].. '5

~

§ g

o~ ~

ca ~

"d

0) ~

<

cC

'+J .~

.::;' 0) § 'tj

;> ~

Q

)::§ ':+:I

+"'

<D

<D

U

6b 0::

~

<D

0 0 "d

,'" 0

.~

~

~

~.:S

~

.s ~

~

..§ ~o

~~

'f3

~.~

~

,~~

.* ~

~

'""

~

.[''OJ

~~

~

~

.§>

..@

~.s

~

~~

.s ~

~

1

~

~

:~~

1:1. i>

u:e. 00"'"

e >

,,'"

m

~

~

0) ,

'" i>

~

-~

~

0

d ~

..d

-~

f.-f :>

. 0

c-'.0

"d ~

-d

~

:P

IJJ;>'.:S

.~

~

3.:a

~

~

0) ~

~

~

a §'

E

~

~

gp.s ~

~

~

~

(I)

S.o

oo!ij cC

'+

J ~

'-"

';::;' ~

~

N:p<

D"d<

DcaX

ca ca"d

>'.,;>

0

u'd~~

§m",,-.O

) (d

<D

;>.<

D

<D

<D

~~

""'"d.,"" !Y

)O)O

0)

~~

1a§~:]

~

!':]"'cd.g~

i~s:§~

"8~~

~~

!; 'f3~

§§~~

.:S-:S

;::g'~:~

~~

~

e.~.B

~~

1:1..tI <

DO

~

~

~

,LJ .2

~.U

"d ~

J!J

0 Q

);'; ..;,;

'E

§ U

~

~

s <

D ~

~

P

~

~

~

>

, ~

~

'"

~

~t)

~

00 -<

D

0 .I:

~.a

§ :P

'+

J ~

~

aJ

C/) ..0)

0 ~

"'0

C

00 0 1::: <

D"lj

O""..d

0 U

>

< 0)

0) ...Q)

~

~

1a 'f3 '"C

d ~

~

~

<.:g

Q) ~

"'cd ~

~

&

:: 0

~

&::

~

1;;' ~

z ~

.S

~.§

~

~"d]

~

'+J U

~

~

~

-:s

0 ~

~

1:1. 'f3 §

C§.tI

§ ~

.$

o:S S

o:S

~

<

ca S

'5 ~

0

I:1..S

.$ 1a

0 ~

.S

1:1.

---

Page 5: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

: ~

=>

'"d"d~Q

)~Q

) "d~

Q)00-!.~

"'~

"" ~

,,

"Q)::E

""'fa"'-:S~

-:S

""'0"d~

':j:J ~

Q

) tJ

~

.~!

Jg 'f' ~~

8 .~

"'tU g"d

g ~ Jg :g .~

.~ ~

~

~

':§ .s 15:3 ~

~ ~

~ "'gj ~ ~

.~ ~

.9 ~

~ ~

"6 ~

..9 ~I.a

"dO

~""""Q

) U

"'Q

)O

Q)Q

) d

,g",ul;l,§..I4tdbOid~

':5~Q

)O

o~':5~

~

oI

1J.9 '3

~

'" "'tU

.s .tJ -:S

"d "'tU

"'tU

$"d S

tJ ~

..I::I..I::I t:: C

d .~

.~

~

'to' -£ ~

s

~

Q) ~

: :E

-a "t

~

bQ Q

j .0

tJ;

;';3 ~

8 Q

) ~

-:S ;

;>:. S

~

'"Cd

-:S ~

fa Q

) ~

~

~]

8.] .s -:5 ~

~

q '"E

.§ ~

~

~

~

~;

&.~

.S

~

'-§ rif

~ .q

'" -:s

p. Q

) EJ ca.a

a ~

00 Q

) -:s ~

.~

@ ':j:J p.

iU

.'" ~

'"a 0 'c ~

~

"'

-~

S

id 1t:! p. ~

'S

~

"0 -:s

g ~

'E -~

§.~

;§. 'C

j ~

Q)

:§.§ ~

d"d

§ ~

"d ~

d

~.I::I :>

~ B

GO

~

.:S "'0 -a ~

0 ~

:$ ~

~

53 ~ '"

Q)

~p

"d"" Q

) ~

';Oj00~

Q

) ~

va

, G

O

~

"1:j"'-a'" -oW

'" Q

)OO

'"aa~

~

fa]£ 'O

~-:S

jg S

'a~cti~

~~

~g;E

~

?J>.9.:S

'"E~

o:S.S

.s:;Ed§~

~

-::;.~~

;:cB

i>

p.':j:J Q

) """' ~,

,';;;J ~

~

H

"" Q

) Q)

ca '"'

0 Q

) id

0 .D

0'"

.-Q)

><

u

-:S a

-Q)

td 00 Q) Q

) 0

CO

"d ~

~

~

Q) Q

) 0 !;'

'" ..;

~

""'" ~

Q)

~

Q;"

00 "d

.§ ti

~

~

.@ ~§"".E

a:; :.e

~

r;: ~

]

-:S

~

~

~.~

~

-;

~

Is ~

~

~

~

~

~

.g .;

.~ .:s :'

~

; .s ~

~

':5

8. ~

GO

'~

~

o ..Q

U

'" .~

!:..~

~,-~

u..l::l8 ",o

lJo.~-ao~

Q)C

:3;j]GO

.-.s~

;:.,~

~..rj

Q.

d d

Q) "'(j

~

;>

~

~

"d '"C

'"

Q)

, ~

.q d

-oj '"

.,,",.D

id G

O

ca ~

t.) .t.) ~

a

~

-a 00 t)

u"d ~

M

-:S

"'cd Q)

"""' Q

) ""'"

..Q

"i:i '" IJ

GO

id -a ~

Q

) ...bO'"

~

GO

'... .:q

'" ~

]~tIC

~..g~

tIC.~

g .§~

~~

;g§~..g-.E

"g ~

~~

§.~~

~~

g~~

~!~

]~

l~

..:~.~

-a U

Q

).8 :>

':>"""

.~

'"0 0

~

>

~..Q

-:S

0

~

~

i3 ~

~

.D

:>

Q)

0 ~

Q

j ~

'" '"

~

~

.-.:1 '"C

d a"a:~

"'tU

~~

UcdS

'-§p.o "":>

,~cd~

cd 9~

Q

~2g.";S

:>..-~

.s]'"CS

;j~

::sQ)..g~

S

; ~

-:s"T ~

i ~

00 ~

"'i:J ~ .~

~ !

-: ~

~

.~ 's

8.: Q

) ~ 8.~

.~ .:S

] ]

] ~

~

~ ~

g "cd ~

.s .so "2 ~

~ Ii

1 i

; ~

~

j ~

i

$ .~

~

F!

1 !

.i i

! ~

f

~]

~]

1 i

j ~ ~

~

~ !

~ ~

~

~ :11

:~ ~

Q) 1::

U

;3 g tIC

","d ~

., ~

.f:j .s §

fa"" p. § >

<

0 GO

---a

IJ -< ~

Q

) ~ ~ -~

. -~

'"

~

~~

~.g

~~

00 ~.:S

&b ~ .9 .~

~

§ ::. r.S ];,

~ <

: ~:~

~

i

g ~

:§ ~

].~

ti ~ ~

~

s .~]

~ ;

j g ~

p. ~

~:9.S

~

g ~

.a"g]

.~ ~

18 ~

.§ $

i ~

~

.§ -;.~

.~

.~ [~

j ~

$1 ~

~]

'it:;- ~ 1 ~

:= ~

S'~

].s .9 ~

..9 <: ~

'S iU

[;' fa"'" U Q

) Q) >, Q

) ;.s ';O

J fa 8..s.:g -:S

;.s ..Q

p...9:: ~

~

d:a -a 8 oj C:3.q

~:§

s 8 0 po s

"g ~ca

Co!"" ~..I::I

'"d :I::: ~ -:S

~

.s

0) a ~

"""' ~

'§ Q

) -~

..; -id cO

~ '"

?J>

t.) ;j "":>

.. ""' ~ ~

u'~

.~ g"8.

§'~

8. ~ ~

~ ~

s r'S

:2

~ ~

~

~ ~

~

:§ ~ g -;

~.~

~

~

~ '~

~ ~

: : ~

~

!] [~

~

;§ -g ~

~

~]

~ ~

.S

~ ~

Q ~

53 0) ~

cd p. J!?

~

cd '0] ~

~ ~

tJ §.:S

~

~

S.:S

~~

:>..~

'S ;j

: i3 ~ ~

~ -a ~

g p.=

a § ~

00 '"o:S

~ t

Q) g ~

~

~ -:S

~ ~

~

53 E

~

~

p..~.S

.:S ~

"::'..9 ~

~

~ ~

S

' J ~ ~

S

~

~ ~

~

::-;:.§ § ~.r?i.§ § ~

~

~' ]

~.~

-£ ~

~.9.53§1!J'~

tIC§~

-E

~

~~

fa.~Q

)gB"g~

~

8g.~-a~

i']!~~

.~.s"cdJ:;']~

.m~

:s~.:S

~:S

'O,g

~ ~

.§"d U

~ .9 ;§ -Ia '"

~

B

g '0 ~

;.s 1 a:;.=

E "'i:J

~

S' ~ E

-o fa -1.8 ]

j o:S

p.':5.-.s ~ .9 ~ S

':5 .~

oO~

~ji

~~

~.i1

~~

~

~

I ~

;!

~~

g..9~

] ~

'§~

~8JJf~

~]j~

~~

]~

~j~

] t~

1 ~

jO

"cd'" Q

)Q)"'>

<C

d""'OO

"d~~

"dQ

)"'tUS

Q)~

>,~

U'"C

d'-' ""'~

:>

~.q~

IJ",;jOV

"'Q)E

I::I~~

!!)~

~~

U)

~;j

:a"t g.;a

~

+-' ~

~

~

~

.~

~

-:S

~

-:S

..8 .~

..8;::;. ~

a:;

~~

"O:a.~

~

ca .~

&

.g ~

-;g,~

o;S

'" -<

g

~

~

~

~

+-'

~

';;;J ~

0) .~

Q

) a ~

~

-:S

00 """'

Q)

'"0 C/)

tIC Q

)..Q

t.).. ..'0

.~

: <

: .s~

~~

~~

Rg.~

~

~

<~

~g>

~~

p.Q§~

m

~~

~

~

~d

Q)

~

0 @

~

-0

Q)

Q) """'

"""1::: rn

a .f:j

d d

a,

.~

~

Q..I::I

U

~

p. t;

U

~

..Q..Q

a

~

O).~

0

"'.~

~

U

I '"Cd

0) Q ctI 0) ~

~

"'i:J as '"C

d ~ fa >

, >'"d

Q)"d.~

'"!

~ ..g ~

§ S

~

"a1 ~ ~

"a1 ~

~

~

] o:S

. .~ ] ~

f!

~

~ -:S

~;§ ~

~

~ .§ 1

.:S ~

g .~

] :gj

.8 ..§ 1!i:

Q) Q

).Cd

:;:1.0 0 ~ ~

~

~

~

""'"0

'" ~

-:S ~

~

..1::1

00 >, Q

) Q) p.~

.9 ~

.9 '"

rn ~ ""' "cd.~

~

"g ca.a:

>

5- rn .§ 00 -:>

.. 13 Q

) :> .'"

~

~

~

~ '"C

d ~

U

"""' Q) ~

~

cd ~

""ciJ Q) '"

GO

~ ~

'i:3 .~

2?; ?J>:

a ~

0)

.'" ~ ~

Q

) u ~

8:§ ..g >

..'"

~

'" ~

~

0 -:S

.~

iU 53 Q

~

",..Q

tIC

"i:i ~.Q

.~

':;:: .s .~

OJ ~

: "§

~..I::I

S""

Q) o;S

Q>

'"' Q

) ~

~

'8::§

~

0.9 ;.:: ~

, t;"t

3J ~

°"d .9

Q) Q

> ~ -E

g.~

::: ~

0

: ]

~~

~

~o' ~

].-.s~

~ B

f ]~

:.g ~

.:S ~

~

8.~

g ~

.~ ~

~

~

g] ~s

i~]

~13].8" ~

~ ~

I""'H

ca

ca-a U

""', ""

0).::§

i>.,""

'"'Q

)~

--ou Q

) 00

~

00>.

'~-Q

)"'" "'0-

bQ""',g;j

Q>

: ].fI.

S

.:s ~

~

'": ~

~

~

§

'"Cd ~

"0 m

.9

.S

.s ~

~

~

"a1 .9

~

$ .£

~

t; .:s ~

.~

~

:S

~

~

~

~

"$

~

..9 ~ E

~

i:§ -g ~

~ .~

~

[] ~

~].g

~ .:S

.s ~ ~

: g j

~.~

S

~

[.~

~.'fi'~

~

~

~ ~

'-g !J; ~

~

~ ~

.i ~

~ ~

§ ~

.:S

~ ~

.E

~ ~

.S

§.g ~

~ m

~ ]

;.s ~

~

~

~:

; ~ §

~]

~ s

~

~ ~

j~

:::silJ.~:g.~

§'S

~

~

~~

.: fa"§..9

tlC9

~

~-:S

~.:S

-:S..§

~.s~

~:g

~~

.!fJ~.9

"d"" -.~

."0

Q) Q

) 0 .~

~

-:S

cd ~ cd

'" tIC

tIC.

cd ~

&b Q

) """'9

.~

0) --~.~

~

' 0) ~

-aQ

"d~

Q)5?, .:>

"a:~o:S

~~

~

o oQ

)O)"d

cdQ~

UQ

)p.fa..l::lo. ~

+

-,~-..I4~

~o:S

oo>.2

),~

~

<

~

~

~

.!fJ S

~

~

~

.§ 'C

j Q

~

~

.~

~

~

.~

~

~

.g.jj

~..I::I

~

"'i:J "'i:J g .~

6

~

6 .~

§

~

.~

;§.; .

Q~

-",...~

-Q

) '"

dO""Q

)"",,"",~

dO~

~U

~.""Q

) "Q

)":>""""oolJ;j

-.~I

.""""" ~

bO

cO

:a G

O g

U

:>

S.a

.~

~

~

Q)

cd Q

) ~

.f:j

'"C

><

(t)

O"d

Q)

* ,..

-a Q

>

~

,"'" '--

p..D

ta!

"""'0 S

-00~

Q>

00~

"".~U

';;;J~"d.f:j

00p.0)~Q

)""Q)""p..:jp.

_i>_",C

:3.r:o;;Q

o.q.~

..g 0

.s .S

13

a ~

IJ

'" ~

.tJ

U

$ ~

Q

) 0)

a '"

:I::: ~

a

d p..Q

~

~

Q

) ~

;j ;j

"t; t/J ~

0

Q)-a

i ~

~

~

.;0 ~. ~ -£ 0 ~

:; .~

: ~

~

~ ~

~ Jg 1

2 ~

~ ~

~

~ ~

~ ~

~ ~

~

:§ ! ]

.~.~

~.:S

, m ~

~

! .:S

~ ~

~ ;.-.s ~

.[ ~

~ .:S

-:5 ~

~

~ ]

~;:g

§ ~

.g. ~

1 'S

.s ~

~

: "'cd so

S ~

-a § ~~

,::;;].:s ~

]j::

"",""'s~

Q>

""':>"

Q).O

i>O

"""."" s~

"'~

"':>,cd~

Q

>13~

caQjI::l~

i>

,~

S"""'.U

.~

oO.O

'~.

g."".D

"'tU'-cao~

O~

"'i:J ~

:Pdg.g~

~O

)~';;;J:I:::

~.q,,",Q

j"'g-<Q

)BO

)Q)

) oo~

"'-""'00:>

" Q

jOO

-a Q

) :I:

"";>Q

) ~

Cd

_as tIC

~

o:S~

~"'~

'" ~

~

~:

~

"S .g

::§ ~

8 2?; -:g oS

'"a .a ~

.f:j S

+-' ~

g

Q) :I:::

Q)

~

P:-'p., p.r.S

C

.J a "'cd .9 '"0

0 8'~

.8 §

~

.q .S

Q>

g.;>

co p.

~'~

.D

Q>

-a oo"d

U ';;;J

S

cd 0);>

Q

) tIC

Q) Q

) :I::: -:S

~

0 '"'""'.D

~

'"

o:S -0

S

j ..9.8'S

~

J~.E

~~

.~~

§j ~

~.g§~

~'S

~

:-:S

.~~

~~

:§,:~~

~

E~

i~~

1~gj~

~~

~

; ~

.:S ~

.!! i

o:S ~

~ ~

] .~

!.s .go ~

8 ~ ~

g ~

B

~]

E

~ ~

~

~

.~.§

.~ ]

~

g'Q 2 § g ~

~ ~

~

~

~ lJ

j °"d

a ";'~

S

§ ~

0 ~

~ ~

:P

-:S """' a

@.~

g >

. ~

~

'" "".

~ ~

U

~

f-i .s ~

"t; ~

Q) ~.D

~

0) ::J-a

.~~

::&b

~.s.go:S

~~

~:.n.s.~

[~

~g~

-:s,,; ~

..9~

~.:S

]:E'"C

d.:a§b~

~o:S

;.~.s~

~i~

]~~

~

I §.~

~

g ~

.~

; ;

-; ::s ~ ~

~

:>";

] §

§' -:S.

~

~ ~

';;;J Q) 8. ~

g .:S :g ~

~

.;: .:S

"cd ~.8 1a ~ g -~

"a1.E1

~

cd -f ~

-a ~

ca ca.-.s § §

S ~

I-t iU

: a

Q) &

b ~

'.9

~

p. ~

"d Q ~

cd

~ "0 -:5 bO

"g ~ 'g p.::J ca t5 ~

~

1 53?

~

§ ~ ~

£i;:.§.~

s ~

~

8."g:::;a"g ~

~

fa

~"8

~

§ ~

: ~

~

1a:§ ~

j ~

~

~ .~

.~

Page 6: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

; ciJ"C

"C"C

-~cC

>"+

o°o)~o)-'"

f;o>'6d","0)~

.!.>'~

"'F-4F

-4+"'~

+"'0.0)'

0)0) -"

, -O

D,

+"'

23 [a

0)"+:1

~

~

+"'

-:S

~

~

=

F-4

Cd

cC

~

0 ...':;:j

.w

S

0) 0)

'" 0

~

;j '"

~

0 ~

X

S

oS

F

-4 ~

~

~~

ot §~

~~

..d]°..g ~

oo."'"'Oo~

:g8~-:S

~-:S

-:S~

:P~

8~8:3.~

o gJ"O

~~

.~:Pi

i ~

..c ~

0

'" o.S

~

~

'"0

"0 ~

S

0

cC

~

OD

0)

0) .-"",

0]] ~

0)

OD

.>

] cC

~

0

"Cd

'id U

'+

.J. §

~

~i!

.£ ~

..'l?J ..co

~

o:S ~

.a 8.

~

g 0

~

.:a08":;;

.£.8 ]

"8 o:S

.~

:a: u.

~

~

~'.:;1

~

~.:s

~"u5

.~

o:S

OD

~>

~

~

].~

.-9

S

.~

i """""+

:1 "".""",~

",O)+

",""'o. ~

.- o.~

O

DO

) ~

S~

F-4O

) 'W

O)~

o. ",~

~':jj

.w

o)

.~"'iiJ

'H

~

2 ~

8

0) ~

~

.s '0

00. ..'l?J 0

~

~

~

'"0 ~

"'" ~

.I:: ~

0

0 0)

't) 0)

~

~

..9 >

'.1:: d

0g;t:J

O."'"0

.s ~

)

>

0 '"O

.w

A

"+:I

0 >

< '-"

0) +

"' ...F

-4 +

"' 0

Cd

'" Q

) 8

'"0 :

~~

~

1.~'~

.J.s ~

~

j~!

.~

f ~

~

~

!j~]]jj,~

~

i ~

~~

~

~i~

~

~

ii~i

] j

~

"+:I

"'iiJ ~

F

-4 '"0

0) ~

as

0) ~

0

+"'

0) ~

,~

~

F-4

"Cd

"+:I

0. '"

~

d 0

~

..d ~

"C

o..d

~

".P

Q)

gJ.;:I"U

d'"0

+"'

0 ~

'"O,~

o).s

E

"Cd

.~

~

.~

:g: ~

] ~

O

).:S

.""" :"'.:a

cC

Cd

0 0)

"IS

"+:1"0

.0 fJ

~

>."+

:1 ~

~

-:S

~

Q

) 0)

] .~

~

.~

E-t

o:S

~

~

~

~

~

.g 0

0 5

~

'"0 ~

0)

8 e-

~

~

J!J '"0

E-t

S

.s ~

~

0.

§ 8

'CD

'"S

'" .s

§ ~

.i::',~

~

.~

!

f::1 E

-t ~

F-4

"' o.

Q)

.0) cC

0)

0) ~

c

d .0

' ~

8

0 +

"' >

. 0)

+"'

cC

.;;1 ...J:j

S

,"'"

O'~

d

~

~

0 E

-t :p'

~~

..c"'iiJ 'I::

>.

>,

a In

~-

~

:'" .~

C

d 'ii)

~

"'iiJ] 0."'"

'"0 ~

e-

'" ~

~

] S

a

0 '+

OJ.2

>,

'r;; >

. 0)

(/) '"O

.S

-~

~

>,.$

'"0 aJ

~

aJ ~

on

0..9 -::::

~

~

OD

+

"' -F

-4 '"

+"'

'" S

C

d aJ

'" ~

:: aJ

'" "C

d.O

0 S

"C

d §

u ~

~

,f::1

-:S

". aJ

~]

~

:.s ~

.~

~

EJ

~

~

0 .$]

S-]

£ ~

~

~

6 E

~

..g ~

~

.~

~

~

~

:sg F

-4" ~

aJ

~

.~

.:s ]

s ~

.g.:E

~

:3

'8..S

~~

,~

~

~

~

,~

EJ

0) : O

D 6b~

!.

~

: ~

~

~

:g

~

; :6

:§ M

.~

]

~

i -::"t;

~

~

~

~

~;§

~

8 ~

~

i'

~

.S

"0 ~

d fJ

'"0 ~

~

'"0

.:a "C

d -:S ~

,~

] g

EOD

~

g

&U

~

~

o:S

~

~

0)

o:S

~

"0 0

jg.~

~..!!:.,

~

0 '"0

S

g .§

~.g

~

.~

~

+"'

Cd

'"0 0

aJ -~

0'"

+"'.

°:p ~

aJ

'"-' '"

0) F

-4 0)

~

F-4"+

:1 tV

,.I:I aJ

0 ~

~

0)

'"0 ~

d

~.-.

"" 0)

0

~

0. fJ

~

u o:S

~

~

~

0

~

~.o

~

~

aJ] ~

~

§

~

~

~

] ..!!:.,

~

.a J!J

oS]

~.

-:Q

~

",,"'" ~

~

.s.:a

~

~

p. ~

.~

~

aJ f;o

+"'

aJ ~

.~

'" C

d +

"'.'" ~

:g

0) .s

0) ~

~

0

'"0 .0

.::; 0

EJ

a.S

~

B

'"0 '"0

~

cC

~

0 '-g

0 0

Q)

Q)

...~.s

.:a:a '"0

§.~

~

~

J .~

~

~

'5]

~.:S

.~

~.E

~

§

..g ~

cC

-;.g

$ ~

.~

~

~.:S

~

~

~

~

-g.

~~

~

] ~

i~

~

~

f

"'in 0.]

j ~ .~

.@

~ j ~

] ~ Ii

&~

.:S j J ~

1.~ ~ .~

.~ i i~

.~ ~ ~

; ~ :~

1 i;§; j i ~

~ j ~

:~ j

.~ ~ ~

8 '"0

.a] 0

,~

§:.s ~

~

.a 6]

,gr ""

.s 23

~

S

23 S

£

~

EJ

~::o

.s +

"' .s

-E

.~

"Cd

~

J!J O

D

>.

'"0 ~

S

~

~

~

~

23

"" ~

~

~

'"0 S

J!J

0 ~

+

"' E

J [a

S

60 ~

.§ ~

+

",:sg ~

..:c: ~

8

on.:s "C

d ~

5."'O

.S

S

~:o

~

~

aJ.§ ~

~

..c

~

~

-oS

.:a ~

~

.~

~'"O

..c ~

aJ

"Cd

0 0""

0 ...ca

0 cC

0)

x "C

d '"

>.

0 cC

~

0)

.+"'

0)' >

<

S

Cd

'" :p

'"0 .~

'"

'" '"

;>

~

~82

~~

~

g

~~

~

~

~~

'8.~

~~

~

m

s: ~

~~

jJ};].~~

~=

EJ

:!@

S;§.[~

)

~~

~J

g :2fj~

'f:'5 0)

aJ~

"';:9 ",,]"+

:1 goO

) S

~

~

o.~

0 ~

'ii) ~

.s ~

o.~

~

~

.so f;o].S

~

0

0) ~

~

E

J O

)-:S~

'S

>.-:

~'"O

0.

.~

'" o:S

~

';

"0 5

~

~

a,.l:l o:S

cC

-$ '"0

:9 ~

'"0

'"0 ~

~

'-g

"'Q)

§ fJ

aJ ~

O

D(/).~

gJ]

~

~

o:S

o:S

.~

~

~

.~

t:7'.:S.,.s

5 ~

'"

~

0 0

~

~

u ~

""

F-4

S

~

OD

.§.'" 1a

8. ~

8

~

~

'"0 '"

S

o:S

'"0 .S

:>

0) cC

'U

"" ..§'-:5]

>.]

~

-:S

0 ~

Q

) 0

~

.:s ~

::

"'iiJ §.~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

'"0 @

0.

~:sg

~

-;;.s ~

§'

~

~]

§' ~

~;E

; $

.S

~

~

'~~

~

$

~.~

1

j.s ~

].~

.:SaJ

~

~

'" ~

~

-:5

;>

...0 0

.::; >

"C

d ..d J!J

+"'

~

X

0 cC

0

O).:a

OD

--0 S

=

aJ

0) .."-

=

><

'+O

J t:7'. 0;>

~..'l?J

S:.§

g 'U

~

~

fJ

0 ~

$

8 fJ

~

~

~

~

~

~

;::;. aJ

60 ~

£

~

60 ~

~

.s ~

-:!J

~.c

~

'"0 ~

.~

:::.g

m

.~

~

~

..c].s

>"+

:1 ~

~

:t"'.s §

0 >

.] ~

0)

0. ~

.s >

S

.1::

aJ 0

"Cd

$ 0)

+"'

~

~

cC

;>

'" E

~

",.1::

OD

"C

d ~

'"

0. '"

SO

"O

Q)

'" 0)

~

OD

O).S

g

$ ~o

~

:-E

'-g .-g

gJ:F-4.go

d' 0)

;::;. ~

: O

D.:S

~

,~

'"O

~

] 'S

' "'"

~

~

~

~

~

~

.r; 6?

~

§] ~

; :s

~

~.~

-:S

'"0

~

:s: +

"' '"0

d ...~

'"

F-4

aJ '"0

0 ~

~

~

... ~

"I::

~

aJ'--' cC

':;:j

~

0) aJ

~

cC:E

. '"0

aJ 0

"'.;; '-'

~

0 "'.-.

-0) F

-4

i :

~

0) ~

£

~

I.Q

B

~

~

EJ :c..g

~

~

fa §

:g aJ ~

E

5

t :p

~

6b ~

~

aJ

§ 0

~

~

E-t

EJ ~

.~

8.

aJ ~

<

.:a

~]

8. j

~

8

t S

-:5s.-::::2~.a.:s~

~cC

~~

"a..a23~

~",~

~aJo[a~

.og.~gs'5

~>

~.$S

E

-o~~

, ~

O

D

OD

"0

OD

"'iiJ

~

'" '"0

"O!1:i

~

"Cd

aJ fJ

0 ,,'"0

0) aJ.

-::: ood

>-

'" F

-4 O

D

'" J!J

OD

0)

0. '"

cC

'" '"

0) 0

! ~

~

:g] ~

.[

@

:~

.~

.$ 8

~

~

"E

~

'"0 'S

o:S

.-:S

~

~i

~

.:a. E

'~

~

~

~

~

~

'>

.~.:a

~

g .s]

"go;: ~

!... Q

) ~

S

.£.~

dO

+"'

0 cC

~

aJ

~

0) ,-::::

aJ 0.

'"0 aJ.~

'"

aJ 0'--'

~.I::'--'

0 ""

'"0 O

D

Cd

'" O

D

0 0

aJ

; J?;

~

~

~

~

~

Cd

'"0 ~

~

~

0)

S

,"'g 0

~

0 E

J O

D

cC

"OJ

'"O:p.

o.~

~

~

,-:::: ~

.-:::: -:a

~

~

."'"'iiJ "E

.r;; 60

OD

.go

.1 ~

i ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

.~

! ~

~

~

~

§

~

~

.§ §

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

] ]

:;§ ]

~

] ;

'~

]

~

~

~

~

~

~.g

-:S.§

go'~

~

~

20)

~

~

] ~

~

]

~

~

§ ~

.s §:g

£ ~

.~

"E

~.s

s ~

§

~

s ~

~

go

s ~

0) fJ

~

Q) ~

'"

0 +

"' ~

cC

0

a C

d +"'

0 0)

cC "C

aJ

~

Z

0) .w

0)

'" 0

>.""'.

~

~

-:5.,; ]~

.:S~

~

§]~.s

:r;::;~~

.:S~

]: ~

.E.~

~~

J5~~

~~

~§~

~;§~

j~~

~

]~.::S

:Q

Q) .d

~

m

~

E

OD

.§ ~

"C

d ~

23 ~

>

-~

~

-5 ~

§'

S..caJ ~

"C

.~

.§ '"0

'"O'~

8:=

1 -:s

~

J!J '"0 ~

S

0."'iiJ

~

g'Q-:s

cC

>

;j td

0 Q

) S

~

:p

~

~

0 0

~

~

'" ~

0)

+"'

cC ~

os

~

d ~

~

tV

0 cC

~

0)

0.$ O

D aJ

+"'

dgJ ,-::::

-Q) "0

g. ~

0

~

aJ cC

~

cC

>

0.

cC

aJ 0)

~

S

~

F-4 ~

.~

,.1:1 +

"' 0

0 C

d aJ

0 0

+"'

OD

aJ '"

aJ..c ~

~

0;;::: :p

~

B

~

~

g .s

~

~

:.a S

.~

0)

~.'f:

f;o 's..s ~

~

'"0

a ~

0;;::: -:a ]

~

~

~

~

o:S

g ~

.-::::]

S

'* o:S

~

.>

~

.E

~..g

'" '"0

...~

..., Q

) -'"

~

0 ~

~

'

", >

. F

-4 ~

0

aJ >

~

"+

J ~

0)""

~

+"'

OD

"+:I

S

'"0 +

"' cC

'"0

So..

.:a ~

'~

:

~

§ .,.s

~

~

: '5

~

~

~

~

E-t

a.~

EJ

::J ~

"+

.:"S

u ~

~

J?;

~

o:S

..g ~

£

~

,S

.s 8

'"0 g

~

~

J?; .~

0

0 ~

.~

;j "0

'" '"

0) E

J ~

.~

tiiJ aJ

' >

.In

~

~

0 ~

::: aJ

fJ.c 0

0"+:1

+"'

0 '"

S

-:5 '"

~

0) '"

a 0

~

~

(/) O

D.r;;

~ o]

~

~

j ~

~

~

! ~aJ

~

~

.; ]

~

1.:S

~

; ~

§

~

~

.~aJ~

[~

::g i

~

j io

j .~

]

1 ~

!

] g

§ ~

~

~

§

Q)

Q)

...~

tV

~

0)"+:1

0) ~

'

'"0 ""

0 ~

~

.;::0 "+

:I.+"'

...'"0 ;;..

-:5 ~

~

C

d aJ

] ~

~

~

i

~

~

~

~

~.s

~

~

~

i ~

~

-:

~

i ~

~

:; ~

1"'iiJ

1 ]

~

-].~

~

~

~.g

t!. i

~

1] "[.~

:a -:

~

]

aJ"'iiJ o;j~

.s'+O

J O

)fJ"""'"O

""a cC

aJo oaJ~

O)bocC

~..c+

",~'"O

(J) '"-'~

ca~O

)o..~~

..ccCcC

EJ

-:5 .~

"i]

8.~

1 g.

aJ .~

~

~

~.:S

~

~

.E

§'.s $

d' ~

~

-:s

~

l.s ~

~

;§ ~

j

6 §.Q

~

aJ

~:s

@,~

.~

~

~

~:::.

] ~

~

~

!

~

~

! ~

;E

; .~

~

~

~

.~

~

5.] ~

J

~

~

] j

~

~'"O

~

~

"0

S

.s ~

]

i' s

; .gj'

~~

.s ~

: ~

;.8

~

~

"bO"O

~

-:S

~

.~

E

J '"0" 0

23 ~

It)

~

.-:::: ~

~

F-4" 0

6b,.l:l ~

0)

0 ~

~

~

~

"g

:p ]

-:s ~

:p ~

6

~'s

0..9 ~

5

~

0 ~

0 0

~

~

~

Q)

(.J ~

aJ

~

U

0) 0

~

~

S

"+:I

aJ '"0 0)

~

~

>

'" 0.

~

~"+

:I 0)

'"0 '"0

~

F-4 cC

"+:I

0 c

U

~

.r;; ~

'"

;; ~

~

1

~

1 ~

.:S

i

~

] ~

}

~

.:S

.~

~

g ~o

1,~

~:~

~

~

.:;;

§ ~

.E

] ~

~

:.§.:S

[~

] ~

i

~

~.s

~

811~

~

Q

).- ~

>

"+

:I "'...

'"Eb

+"'

0 0)

Q)

"+--

~

+"'

0) .,p

0 d"+

:l aJ

'" V

J.~""

0."" +

","+:1

~

cC

o:S

ca d

~

0 +

"' ~

~

Jj

~

8. tiiJ

cC

:: aJ

~

6 ~

~

:r::

'"0 cC

~

~

~

ta.c

~

"" 0)

~

'" aJ

+"'

OD

~

'"

~

;>

~

",'s as

Cd

+"'

~.:S

~

~

~

~

~

-:S

..§.-::::.s] g

~

S

~

~

~

u5 ~

.~

8. S

~

o.~

:ti:

.s ..§

-:s §

~

~

~]

-E

$ "i:j

~

~

~

~

§ ..§

'5 ~

~

~

~

~

S

0 0)

>""0

~

0) 0

O).:a

'" S

~

S

,.I:I cC

Q

) >

. 0)

0) '"0

aJ ~

'"0

.cC

0."+J

~

0)"+:1

0 0.

F-4

>.

-"0

~

"g ~

;j §

~

~

s ::;:a J?; "O

D ;;..$

~

g }

E-t

~

§ J?;

0) .t)

~

0 ~

fJ o:S

'[;

~

~

0 ~

.~]

g. 's

EJ

S

S

'" 0.0

~

"oJ ~

~

0.

.~

~

'i?: ~

.~

] .~

~

~

:.p .~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~].~

~

:s

~.~

§

~

"0; S

~

'!§:

~

~

] ~

"E

E

. ~

~

s

~

~

~

~

~

~

B

'"O.s

:.g U

."0

Q)

.:a:9 s

~

~

1-:5 ~

~

0

~

~..g

~

§ ,o-",,:g

~.'f:

~

+"'

aJ..c -:S

aJ,.I:I

~

~

~

'" cC

:P

'" ~

~

.~

0 ~

'"

~

'"0 ~

:;;;;'f3 ~

-~

~

g

ti 8.S

~

0"';

0 ~

..g ~

cC

:3 ~

:g

6.9'.~

1o..g ~

§

8 aJ ~

.~

8 -'"0

m

.s <

§

~

aJ..t:i":g: §

>.

aJ t.)

td .-.;j

0 C

d ' 0

-:S

tV

S

~

0. cC

E

cC

aJ "::1,.1:1

0 O

D aJ

cC '"0

>,

~

0. tV

I.Q

~

0) 0

0. :p

~

a D

O cC

-:p

~

$ ~

~

.:S

] ~

~

:<

~

~

~

S

'<

.g

's ~

~

~

~

.a

~

~

~

~

~

~

'-;;; 10'~

~

-S]

: J!J ]

~

.~

g. 6

~

.r;; ~

B

6

$ ]

.r;;

:p ~

8

-:S .:s

] ~

'""

o:S.a

~

z .S

~

:"".a

0.,J}. -:S

~

~

~

~

;-'

-:S

~

~

>

~

~

60] 8.

..g -:S

,S

~

8.

Page 7: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

;EI :;;' 0: ~

~

"">.s "@

0 ~

~,:t;o":"

S ~

~

~

rn" 2

~

~"d

0 00

=

U).!.

I "-' ...

':t;J ..Q

~

,-. 'v p.

Q) Q

) 0 Q

) Q) ca 0

0 Q

) "-' ~

"-' "-' ...p. U

Q)

"d .~

~

:p =

~

.::; ~

~ '"

Q)

-~

p. U)

;j >

- Q) ..;j

..Q Q

) -"U

U

~

0 Q

)"d '"

g ."f: ~ .£ ..g

~ ~

~ ~

.§Q) ,,8 Jij. ~

"2

Q) ~

§ ~

~ j

.§ ,*,.~

~s* ~

~

~

~

§ ~

.~ ~

.~

~

!>~

8-~

Q)p.;:j':t;J""u

p.p.du~U

)Q)p.

sctS

~

~

. Q

) ,,-,Q

) ~

o ~

"'Q)p.~

Q)

~U

).~""ctS

=0

"0' U

).;:IU);=

:ctS~

p. ~

~o.c

Q)~

_I..p.o

-:SU

)r"l :>

->

-I.. Q

) rn"" Q

). Q

) Q) N

ctS

!>

Q) F

-4 '"

~ 0

-U)

00'""' -:

Q) S

Ol..

ctS Q) .f::I "tJ E

.D

>

Q) U

) ...00 0 Q

) ~

Q

) ...:p

I.. I.."d ~

.~~

;a -:s >- ~

u"

R ~

Q

).. rn

':t;J :P ~

'4j Q) 0 ~

Q

) 'tj ~

~

.-2J "U

ca ~

p. 2

ctS

"E

0U

). Q

)SI:::'::;-p.U

)ctS

cIS

~~

~:P

.Qca

~Q

)~"'Q

) O

"-'~Q

)"a)Q)

.c~

§ !:s

~

~

2 ~

~ .:g -~

.§ ; :

~ -g ;$: ~

~

~:-

~

~.E

]

~

~

~

-;.:S

~ ~

s

~

~

..;-Q

) Q

) Q) ~

~

~

"-' Q) -~

"-'

Q) U

) p. ~

Q) 0

bO 00

-0 .-~

U

) ~

0) 0

~

~ i

~ i

~ ~

i

.~ ~

] [~

~

~

~ ~

.~

~;

if; ~

~

i [

] ~

~

~

~

i.~

] ~

i

1Q

) td~

00~

'tj'-""""~I..

U'tj>

'tj-:SQ

)S

td ~

""'~

s~s

,,-,Q)...cIS

~

.c.E

-U

) p..oo

~

g. ~

Q

);a U

) Q

) ~

" ~

~

'"3"

00 -~

.S

~

p.

0 .'"

~

.0) ~

'a; 00 g.

o..g.~

Q)

23 0)

;; 1

: ~[j~

ctS

~ ..g ~

U

) ~ -:S

.g .£ U

) .~ 8 .s .3 .E

'§, ~

~..g :~[j

,::;,] ~

~

~

~

.s

00 ~

S

~

~

.s

.~

-0 ..c:I

U

U)

0 ~

00

U",

ctS,..

'"- 0

0 0/)

0 ~

2

~

9 '"

D

~

=

Q)

1-1 U

"U

..,

d..., U

".;jQ

) ~

~

cIS~

""""~

O'

, '"

"'UQ

) Q

)""" ':t;J0,,-,

Q)

,.."",~

-p.

S;:j

U)

oo.~

~

'E

';1 I..

53 =

-.E

53

~

';::, p.

as O

).s p.

.~

0) U

~

0)

t) s""ta

U

'tj c,)

~

~

s

~

.E .E

.~

~

'§ ~

8. ~

"E

~.~

~

i

~

~

~ !

~

~.g

~

.5 ~

~

~

~

: j

~

~

~

~

~ i.~

~

~

>

~

I.. Q)

.D ~

U

) .'"1 Q) ~

Q)

U) ,,-,.Q

ro ':t;J a

~

U) p..~

-.~

0) ~

rn ~

,.. .00 I.. 0'1::: "-'

0 0)

0 0 :.: ~

-:S

E

S

:s '"0 .§ 'tj

~ -:S

~

~

8"C

].S

oS .~

'tj 5.

~ ~

;S

g "U

b ~

~

" 'p

"-' ~

"5 ~S

00 ~

':t;J U)

Q)'O

O

~

cIS Q

) 0 00

" Q

)' Q) 2

is Q) ~

'tj ~

g;' >

. ~

~ .S

'a ..c:I.1::: ~

~

~

~

'" ~

~-'~

~

] ~

.E

'§.~

~

..§ ~

.~ .~

"'g .S

] § =

~ ~

.SS

~]

~]

~

is :§

~

~

~

~

~

g .~

S

'g ~

§

-:S ~

.I.. >

- ~

U

) 0 00...

p. Q

) .~

"-'

rn 8""ta "-' 00 td C

/J Q

):9 >

s"U

S

~

~

I.. 'tj

g Q

)"d

~

-cIS "t

1 ~

"~

$ ]

:§ ~

~

~

~

8 ~

~

,,>

;~

~

".5 ~

~

~

~

§] b

~

8 21

j ~

~

e

"5 .sQ

) rn

0>

~

-to 0>

U

~

0 ':t;J 'tj

~

"-' >

< 0>

:>

p..~

~

"-' cIS

~

'" >

,~

~

cIS

g. ~

0> S

~

~

U

~

"-' :s

.s 0>

Q) oo"d

a).E

0> S

"'cO

gj ~

~ -:S

8 'a; ~

~

;:j <

~

Q

) ~

.~ ~

.~

,,~~

j

s ~

~.S

~

~

~

~

~ g

~ .~

~

g ~

~ ~

~

~

1

~

~ ~

~

~ ~

'f};

'E'~

r:; ~

"E g

'"@ ~ ~

c:Id>-

>-'tj

cIS...~

.D-

S..."'-'uo-

""0' U

)"'" """

;;J ~

-C

/JtdC/JO

""'~.

:0>,'""'

~

~

U

~

g ca

~

S

C/J

0 g.

':t;J ~

.~

0>

~

.~

~

~O>

U

"tJ 0>

p.

~

S.~

.E

~

-fd.:a ~

~

0>

~

"-'

~

cd 2

~

~

8.

g~.~

.g~

S,9;...:.s$~

~~

~

.S~

:'::~-'[j

a)~~

.i:::' ~

!"'cO~

~

~dS

8S

'~ft~

~~

~

~]~

,,-,'" -,

, ':t;JU

)""',""uuI.. U

)."" ~

.. ",O

dS

a)"""""'" .§' § .~

.i:::' -E ~

. ~

~::a

oo~

U) ~

-E ~

0>

~ ~ =

~ ~

fa oS ~ -:S

~ -E

~

~

tj ~

'0 ~

~

~

0 ~

.~

cIS ..g '0'0 53 ~

g1; ~ Jf3

".;j ~

.""C/J"tJ"a)':t;J;:j.

~U

)'tjU)

"",u~,,-,"'"

~~

~"

1..0>

'"-'~.~

,"-,>

,O>

U

,,-,O>

u~U

"-' '0"'"

~ ~

;§ E

8 ~

§.s ~

0>

~ ~ .~

~

~

:6 ~

~ ~

~ ~

~

~

.s i ~

§ 1

~ ~

§ ~

1 ~

~

.[ ~

-!g ~ 8!

§ ~

~~

g .~

~ .~

,,~~

~

~

S

~ :g.S

8

~ ]

.~ -~

~ ~

.~

"-E ~

~

§ -:S

;!: '0 ~ 'g

~ g 1

] ~

~ '"g t: .~

.s.s ~

.:S ]

~

00 p ~

".;j a).8

~

c,) 'tj p.

~

':t;J I.. -a)

00 =

0>!d:P

C

.J 00 ~

O

d ...~

,..

0) 0

N

0 a)

"-' ~

~

...+

-'~

~

00 ~

~

R

'S

?

~

~O~

...~

00 Q

)~

'tj p.

S

~.s

"tJ "0' '+;j

;:j =.

~e-..9

gj '0 e

~

-:S

u;=:

~

~

~

~..8

e- 9

~~

a)~

.""~I:::

~

""'O>

R

a)cd'" "-',..

~a).

qI ~

qI

'u 0

qI"'(Ij

+-'

.f::I. p.

0>

0>

".;j cIS

..;j

00 ".;j

0 a)

0>

~

~

p. 'tj

'4j ;:j

'tj to

Q)

...to S

-a)

cIS.~

a).""

0>

0 to

'" ~

~

~

If; ~ ~

~

~ 'P

. 5;"§ 51 .~

.$:I: ~

-:S ~ ~

~

~

"d ~

] ~

~

~

~ i

.g ~

~

~ ~

~

~

-:S .~

.~ ~

':

~ ~

.sfE

' cIS

~

U) 8 -:S

8

g.-:S p.-:S

g. a) ~ ~

.~ -:S

~

~ ,,'" ~

~

a) ,,>

~

t) 'E .S

8. ~ -E

.~

'E ~

00 ~

cIS cIS

R >

- 0> ~

cIS0...; >

-"d d""

U) 'tj

Q)'

I 0

0 'tj

I00

...S.D

'tj ~

I::: ':;j S

>

- ..., ca a).;:j o.~

a)

Q) p

cIS "-' U

) 0 ~

0>

Q)

~~

~

~

§ ~

E

':t;J ~

.~ 2

~

~

S ~

~

'g j"8

~

~ j

~

S

~

~

~~

~

.l:;I ~

~

""ta §:.g "I:: ='"

"U

0> cIS

I.. -~

"'-' >

< I.. U

) "-' O

d '+J"'" 0) 0 '+J

p. a) ta 0>."" Q

) a) ~

..c:I p ".;j 0>

0

;=:

~

~ ~

~

.$ >

~

] ~

~

~

15 ~

s-1 .£ 'a; :

~

~ .!!1

~

~ ~

~

1-!1 g:

~:

2 ~

'§ 5;.~

g; ~

>-

>'>

'" ctS

~]

s>

-;:j~..c:I8tO

2a) ",~

~

c..; 0>

~0p.,,-,I..,,-,

"-'clSS

"O'p.~

.l:;I ~

C/J

~

s.~~

.f::I~

td u~

.~~

S..c:l,,-,.=

:i ~

"'cOQ

)~"U

Q)

~;:j".;j;:j~

~"'"

-:;..c:I,:...,p.oOQ

) o;:j

'" ~

,.. cIS

R

>

;:j ...U

a) cd to :>

~

P..~

":;::j :> cIS

U) 0 a) 'tj

0 ~

0

~ :I:'"

.Q a)

§ ~

~"U

tdooc>

", ~

"0"2.s-:ss:;~

.:a~~

p.oO

1::i~~

~"d'"3C

/J ~

~0>

.:S"-'>

-0 ~

-E:-e

~ ~

g .~

.s ',1;' cIS

-E R

Q) ~ 'tj"

~

0 0) ...~

-~

.s- .0 ~

gp a) E

0 () ;:j C

> co

~.~

"-'

U)

U)

.~

'4j a) cIS.i:::' U

) I::: ~

;:j a) -=

:P

~ 0 u.:S

.-.b :Ij 'tj

U) -:S

U) ~

>

-~

~ 'tj ~

E

~

,,-,.s

~

.2 ~

~ j

~ ~

j

.~

8 ~

~ ~

~

~~

.~'[

F .f~

~

J i ~

~ ~

~

.~ ~

i

~

~ ~

] ~

'E ~

.~

~:s

.~ ;

:B ~

fa [~

~

.~;

~ .s ~

"8..~

~

~ .R

~ ~

.s ~

j

~ ~

~

~ 'E

~

.~ ~

.~

~

~

~ ~

~

~]

~ !a.~

~

'"tj ~ ~

00

"'cd ~

~

JJ.E § ~

~

~

1 ~

~

] .S

'tj

E S

~ 15 ~

..:S

~

~

~ ~

~

~ ~

(l) ~

f,..

0 'P..J!J!a

~

0 .s ~

0 ~

p. .:P

S

~

-:S!i3 § Q

) tj ~

~

o"d ~

~

cIS a)

ta U) oS

~ .:g;o 0> .~

~ ;=

:oS

~

"U'+

J~

"-'53".;j;:j C

/J"'" S

~cIS

~'tj

:p~'a;~

O

>"-'~

clSp.'tj~

~

<l::oo"'~

p.g..s~~

.~ ~

~

~

] ~

~

~

.cIS~

~

8 ~~

:§ ~

:~

~.E

1. ~

~

~

1 ~

~

j

~].~

~

~

~

..g.§ .i-~

~

~

~

5.~a

_p'~

.a° a)

Q)~

>-ca;:j~

U)

OO

)"~O

Q)

td,..o>C

/) 0

~rn;S

;S

-td'tj ~

Q)

53.a ""S

"'cO

~""'.

u)o>

C/JU

"'~

"d"U0..Q

"" O

.Q

."d.su "'U

).Q;:j~

a)""'u)"""

-:S.s

~

~ ::: g ~

~Q).E

~ ~

~

~

-E :

~ :6 'tj §a) ~

~

§ ""(d~

~Os ~

~

§' ~

~

jg ~

=...

"t ~

~ 'E

]a) ~

~

~

~

.q~

a) U

...; 0

;:j '.::;

Q) 0)

O)::§

a) .~

U) cIS

0> ~

U

0>

ta >

- ,

U) C

/J0) .~

g;'

a) 'tj ~

;:j U

'+"c 0

~

a) 0) .c

~

>-

a) p.

~

a) U

.C

/J ...

'" -:S

§ Q

) 53 ~

.s ~

C

/J ~ a) ~

0 'tj

~

.c"U

~

g."U "'cO

'tj

~

S

a) Q)- fE

' rn]

00 U.~

O

'~.:E

I)() ~

~

~

~ :§ ~

j

.~ 1

g ~

~

5;' 8. ~

5;' ~

~

S

~ g

~

~ ~

-:S

g 1 ~

.s~.a

,,~

,,~~

§

~ i;

ci ~

~

;ap.~

Q

)g.]o ~

oogp

.E-:S

§">--:S

-:SI)()~

+

-,~~

'E~

~

.EC

/J~-:S

~~

u) 1::i'~

~a)05g!::1a)00

] ~

~

~

FI ;

~

.E ~

~

~

~

5;'.E

~ =

U) ~

'"8

~

g ::; .s 'a; .j!J .-fJ 0 ~

.~'s

~.E

~

..g ~>

~e:

~~

Q».~

~.~

~':t;J

""'P.~

'""'Db

a) 'v 0;:j-:S

.Q

cIS'V

Q)

'" 0.c0):>

~

"'p."'"

U

O'V

,..

a)a)~

;] 1

J] :J~

~

~

'~~

..g ~

~]~

~

~~

~

1; =

:-i!t] ~

!~

1.~]!

j ~

]!lj:l] 1;

~

~

~ ~

~

j j

.s ~

£~

~

t E

>:. ~

~

~

s .~]

~ ~

i ~

~

~ ~

i

~.~

;]

i ~

~

§

~o~

~ ~

~

~ 00> ~ &

.;:j It)

0 O

O'+

J U

) ~

00 u, ta

d 0

It) ~

0) ~.

'+J

p. I.. ~

"-' ':t;J 0> "'"

.",,'.;j S

'" .@

~

...~

-E

-;::;:;:.~

"'cO ~

53 ~

~

~

~

~

'"3 ~

"p;.;:1 ~

6i>

"-' -;::; 0

~ ~

U

-0) ,'" cIS

1-1 ro ~

"E ..c:I .s

+-' 'E

.~

S

0 ~

~

"-'

p..c ~

~C

/J ~

tca~.

~~

~-:S

a)~~

00~~

2053 ~

OO

"U~

~~

'=:

oo g.S

a)E--'tj~

a)gg~"'.Q

~.~

~.s

~

§ ~

~

] ~

~

~

.£J.~'~

~

a) g

.~ .s

~

~

~"S

~

:

§:s 8

t)I)~

;§ g

~

~

~

e::o ~ S

.8 ~

U

~

: ~

.s

~::a

~U

...~

~

u u)oo...

OQ

»ta Q

)tO"

a) "':>

O)~

oo~~

"" §

'+;j~

a)O~

O:6c1S

.i:::'.:EcIS

:: ;:I""'~

~.::oS

~ ~

~ ~

.~~

~ i

~.f

~ ~

~

S

~

~ ~

~~

~

~

I ~

.5 s ~

~

~;;:

j ~

~~

i ~

.::oS.E

.?o ~

~

11].::oS

:~o

~.D

!a~

to""o>

;:jd.""I..~>

-~I...

>,..~

O)ouo

O>

~~

u~

;:j':t;J"-'O""'U

)uU)""""-'

-~

~

0 t)I) U

E

-- p.

Q)

>

0 ~

U

) ~

...a)"d;=

: to.~

~

;>

P'

Q

'" ca

U

~.Q

"-'

Q)

C>

.U

)... <

I:: ~

~~

~~a)

0>

a) <

Q)

cd ~

a) .D

Q

0 >

-.D ~

0 O

.D

E-- O

.D 0

a) ~

0 8

0 ~

.D

~

.D>

... rn':t;J'tjrn

p.U~

':t;J~p..£J':t;J

"~':t;J~

"-,~",,,

:P

=

':t;J0" ':t;J

Page 8: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

~

a5 ~

F-4 tIC

It! ~

.,;

It! Q

) Q

) +

-' F

-4 .!. ..+

-' '"

>,

0 .-'"

>,

p,- +

-' Q

)' -C

Q

)" Q

) F

-4 -C

~

F-4

..cn ,

~

>

~

.s .s

§ -.."0

~

[d [d

5 ..3.>

~

~

1:!

~

+-'

~.C

d ~

It!

~

~

~

0 "tIC

It! -:S

~

tIC

0 1a

~'03

~

~

;j] ~

§'

~

~~

E

'f1~-:S

~~

;~~

~

gj]]>-~

~-E

~~

~;

~~

~~

~-:~

~~

~cng-:S

~]£.§.

§~~

~

~

E

'&

S

~

i;

[d ~

~

-:S

. .S

~

~

~

;§ ~

~

~

~

g

~

.s It!

~

~.s

.§ ['-:

r j

~

~

~

i] ~

~

~

~

S

:tJ

>

~

~

~]

53 0

F-4 '"3

cn "0 "0

"'cd S

Q

) p,

53 S

'0

"0 Q

) 8"'

1'J "'cd

It! 00

'0 .~

~

-~

1a Q

) cn

"Q)

0 1'J

Cd

Q)

tr'.tIC

S

.s ~

) "+

J Q

~

Q

) S

~

.o I:i

§ 1a

~

Q).~

~

It!

8 cn

'+:t

Q)

S

..a; ~

-:S

cn

~

~

0 ~

§..d.j;

,£) d

Q)

.,; -:S

~

~

0

-c ~

~

"'cd Q

) U

~

Q

) ~

~

Q

) ~

~

o:S

-:S

8"+J

"ij' ;3

~

~

'E

.s.S

p, Q

) ] "0

rn.~

Q) ~

"+

J .riJ

"'cd ~

5:J 'P.

~

~

~

~

m

Q)

~-:S

-<

.,;Q

),£)+-,~

-:SQ

)63 "'Q

)Q)"O

"O°g.,§~

~cnQ

)"'cd tIC

~Q

)~"O

.:£?:;-~~

o~;E

-:so$o~.s.""

~"'cd

F-4 'i

iIi ~

,£) ~

It!

"0 .,;

§ -:S

1:;"'0

~

1a ~

"0

~

Q)

tIC .>

.~

-:S

1a .~

"'cd ~

b ~

Q

) .s ~

cn

S

~

+-'

~

+-'

cn ~

'&

-:S

~

~

~.~

~

~

~

~

] .:S

~

&

~

!

~

] ..§

~

.~

; ~

~

§ ~

~

g

] ~

]

.~

~

~

~

~

j ~

~

~

~

~

~

.~

.;

!i

~

F-4.

-cn ~

d

~

Q)

i>

~

Q)

cn"+J

.fj Q

) It!

Q)

t:..d ~

~

~

~

Q

)..d 0

d C

d tIC

Q

) ~

d"'"

~

0 "

tIC

S

0 0

"0 ~

:tJ

Q)

~

~.

,£) .0

~

-:S

.$ tiiJ~

~

~

:g

~"+

J ~

aj

"'U

0 F

-4"+J

~

-Cd

tIC

.5 .j;

.~

1:! ~

C

d Q

) S

53'>

cn

S

~

p,

!] I

~

J! I

! f1

i i

! ~

i.E

j

~

~

i~

i ~

.~

i

! .~

t!

f 11~

.!

~~

~

i

J.j f!

1 ~

i

iQ

) .bb

i6 ~

~

gj"+

J ~

C

d gj]

"0 ~

Q

) ~

It!

~

S

cn >

, ~

.s

~,£);a

"ij' ~

~

.~

gj

gj ~

~

"0

8] cn

~

~

~

-Q)

It! .-"+

J F

-4 Q

) ~

.$ Q

) F

-4 !:-.

~

tIC

~

Q)

j;" "!:

It! 0

(/] 0

cn0

~

Q)

O~ It!

-F-4

S

~

"0 >

0

~-cn

II) ~

~!::JIt!;jO

~"'Q

) -R

Ia5"US

,£)+-,O

Q)O

cn~

+-'.

tIC::.

;j1t!,-,o~cnF

-4 cn

g -d';a

~.S

.C

d ~

.p (/]

0 ~

~

oh.~

1:!

1'J cn

ca d>

.s.~

>,

aj 1a

Q).S

+

-'" ;a

~

g ~

" ~

"'cd '&

S

>

, '0

~

~:s

~

It! ~

.s

~.~

~

~

.§.~

Q)

~

.tIC~

~

j ~

.~

g ~

~

.g ~

~

.E

11.5 j

'd'~

~

'fJ] It!

~::~

~

.~

,~

-:S

f! §

~

~

'i ~

"0

~

11 ~

E

'-g

.E

~

~

b:g 0

§ ~

"+J

Q)

ca 0

.~

"+J

F-4

Q)

>

°:p ~

~

Q

):.~

~

';j Q

) ~

:g

-Q)

~

0 +

-' Q

) ~

It!

>

~,£)

~

Q)

(/] U

C

+

-' ~

'"-"

.s S

Q

) 0

.s ~

S

Q

) Q

) i>

Q

) Q

) ~

. Q

) (/]

-0 ~

Q

)"-o Q

) 0

b 0

.;j >

~

>

, 0

+-'

0 ~

Q)

It! 0

0 ~

"0

cn +

-' S

~

]

"0 S

(/]

~

~

Q),£)

-:S

-:S

...:. S

S

~

.s ~

1a

~

~

~

Q)

~~

~

::::;

P

,£) .fJ

'8 ~

~

~

;j ~

0

...,

.~

.B

':J; (J

8"' Q

) 1:!

p, 5

§ .:!3

§": 1'J

~

.s ~

.B

'"3 ~

8

Q)

~

>

.~

Q)

tr'15 -:S

'&

~

.s Ia

~

'&"

~

S

;s E

S

"ij'

.5

~..§

~

].~

~

~!

1 ~

~

~]

~~

J

~

i ~

E

~

~

~

.~

:~

E

i~

j 1

~

~

~

~

~

~~

i

~

~

iJ ~

i

K!]

15!.'!f :

~8.~

:*.~§

8.~.~

:~.§

0: 8.~

8'~~

e.~

..::{J~

~"'cd

~.s:=

~

8.~

~ o~

~~

~

Q

)~~

~

~~

(/] '-'

Q)

td~cnlt!

o+-'-

(/]~o

0 "";j""+

-'1-1 F

-4o..dSR

..dIt!F-4~

~

..I4~F

-4Q)-:S

~

""F-4Q

)1:!.~

Q

) 'u

~.~

~

"'c;)

g,o"'cd +

-' ~

0

"'c;) ~

.$ gj

~.(/]

c: S

g

[ rn

"'cd 0

~"+

J ca"+

J 0::

.~

~

'" ~

cn

~

-:S

Q)

'6'0 S

~

Q

) ~

0 "0

~

==

Q

) Q

) ..a;

0 "0

.~:.~

~

0

0 ;j

tIC

0 F

-4 §

~

tIC

(/] tIC

-:S

~

0 (/]

P

rb >

, +

-' ~

.~"

.~

~

1:! +

"' 0

~

It! 0

ca.::§ 0

~

F-4 ~

~

~

-:S

~O~

-:S

Q);E

-d

It! s.~

~o

.~~

"0 .s

~

Q)"'"

~

;a.s Q

) It!

~

1:! ~

~

~

~

0

+-'

oO~

>

, ~

;j

+-'.:::;

[d ~

+

-' ~

~

+-'

0 ~

-.'U

0

~

>

(/] C

d 0

"0 cn;j

-:S

~.Q

"0

(/] 0"'-

co. +

-' ~

~

It!

i>

0 ...,

Ia ~

-~

'-'"+

J

6 ~

§

O):g

.B

.~

~

_.8 ~

-:S

.s

.s aj

~rb]

~

-E

0 ~

~

*

'0 ~

"0

1'J ~

~

]

"oa'~

'-g ~

.~

1'J S

"ij'

~;E

J ~

s

~

~

~

It! 0

.S

gj cn

Q)

1a ~

ca

It! Q

) >

,.:!3 ~

>

, ~

(/]

"0 Q

) Q

) ~

~

Q) "0

"0 Q

) It!

s §.z:i:J

It! ~

~

.2

'P.

tIC .s

'0 T

Q

) 5

0

gj.B:

.'9: ~

!~

"O:d15]

~

~

[~~

] §.s.~

::E

.~~

~.B

53~

~1i.5~

8;'E

f~j

~

'0: ~

~~

.~

~

~b.bcli

"ij'tIC~

Q

) [dQ

)~Q

)~>

<

>,

;'$:~~

tIC~

Cd_It!"'cd-F

-4'OQ

)~a3co

}>

~cab

"~~

§~0F

-421t!8S

.~..§..g

Q~

]'t:::'.~.,§ ~

o.a.~tIC§.~

~

~

g3.~rb

s~

~~

.§~~

-:S

S'~

~

~-~

]-Jf:::~]

g3~Q

)to

~

§~

~~

~

~

0 ro

>,

~

o. +

"' F

-4 "-0

.Q

+-'

0 C

d It!

~-

~

P

i ~

;S

0>

] '8

Q)

Q)

§ 0

Q)

~

'0 'O

.~

5.~

~

~

"'cd 0]

F-4

~

~

0 "'c;)

~

~

~.g

..a; -:S

1a

~

.E.

go ~

.~

[d '-g

..c ;s

;a

~

~

~

.=,

Cd

p,-:S

-:S

0 ~

-:S

~

S

~

~

-:S

,£)

.:::!, S

~

C

d ~

Q

) ~

;a ~

"'cd

~

~

~

"'cd -:s;a

~

[d.~

~

~

~

~

.s aj

.Q)"'cd.-!.'-a'

1'J~d.stIC

"'U

~~

"O~

"O~

~~

~

~

Q)~

I -.-:S

..d aj

0 Q

) C

d ~

Q

) Q

) ~

Q)

Q)

Q)..d

..14 0

~

~j

:tJ 23

~

.s ~

"+

J >

~

cn..d

0 .:!3 ;a

~~

~

~

b

.F-4 ~

"+

J ~

~

..P.

~

Cd""

~

aj ~

~

'a' ~

.s!

~

.:g;>

-.,; +

"' tIC

It! ~

"+

J +

"' ~

- (/] ~

.S

.s

o:S

~.

Q)

~

.~

;>

Po

Q)

>,

~-

s "'"

.~

+"'

0 "'"

'";

Q)

~.~"g

~.:§~

~.~~

"Q)~"~

s]~

~~

~~

~".'&

"S

~!

5~

-"'i;J~

.F-4~

~~

~gr

~

.Q)iU~U~;jrd~

(/]oocnQ)~"0

"+JuoQ)t:F-4Q).i::.;.g:>'

Q)~Q)~

~-""":Eaj

;0

-sS

~Q

)~

~.'0

S~

0:I;g;j

~~

~~

~~

0~

~~

'"1:::

~~

~+

"'"0

.~a3

.~~

Ui3

.0.s

Q)

Q)

gJ~

"+J

+-'

Q)

p,1a

Q)

'"tIC

.""Q

)Q

)~

~::S

;a+

"'~

~0

It!~

510

§~

Q)

J[d

.g~

.;.g'"'

~F

-4g

~-:S

.~g.~

Q)

;j0

;j.:S-:S

gj::Q

):E'"

~+

"'~

:jcI5

"0-:S

~-..s

~.§

~..s

!].g~

j~i~

gj~

~~

~~

~"~

~§~

~~

:~~

E]!j

i~~

~~

~~

§~j

cnpo~

~(IJ.Q

cn>

,C;j"-o

"O~

::0-

Q)-"

."'",Q

)~6b1t!

'd)'C",Q

);>S

Q)

B-f3

U~

.s~

aj~

8.i;.

~C

d~

.8'=

3-s

'-g~

~~

53~

~~

.~-f3

~"'cd

Q)

.ct'J

~~

~~

"0.g

Cf)

Q)

~Q

);j

'riJ"+J

F-4

caIt!

'U0

~Q

)..d

~~

'>

'O;a

00

Q)

-~0

Q)

~iU

~~

sQ

)it)'~;

'-gm~

~.s~

1'J°0..a;::::;"O

g:g~"+

JQ)~

;g~~

~gr~

"'cdtIC

~~

~~

~~

o(/]

~~

~Q

)g

rb~

0~

.~>

,.:!3~

~::Ia

~~

a~

Q)

oS~

:g-;

~",":S

~"'c;)

.S~

~~

'"~

~~

2.];>

::§j~

§~~

~:c~

:;.~~

.98.~..§.5~

.-d~~

~..8!5.

~~

]'O~

.:5.:5.§~~

~0

~~

~~

~Q

)Q

)"a>It!

F-4

~Q

)"0

'"Q

)Q

)'tI::

2~

""~

~'i::

51~

-~~

-+"'

'0~

0'0

)~

A'O

.s~F

-4;jldP,

~;j~

~~

-:SQ

)I:iS~

oo~.g

aj+",~

.c'O"+

J~""'o

5~alO

>"'~

I~

Q)~

~.;;;

...,~

~(/]

'"~

Q)

Q)

'-'.:s.o

S~

"0+

-'+

-'.cn

"O.:S

Q)~

';J;j

0.~

U~

S~

-:;9

!~

~~

.8~

~s

~.:oS

.~r

'8.§"~§

SE

8~

]~

~~

g3.;J

~~

~.orj

~~

~~

~~

-=.'"

I~

'e:.S

ij.§;.~

~~

.sj

53:g~

~~

.~.s

~~

;S15

.:S.§

~~

S.c.

~d

~~

~:Ii

~.8

~

~.riS

o-1'J"""">

~"O

SQ

)OQ

)F

-4"O.~

00~

tICU

~,..,+

-,~"

Cd

"";>d

aj

!.fj;j

~~

~0

~go

~'"5

~]

~~

~..g

131'J

~~

"0t'

~]

02

1:::~~

~"~

8."0

~~

-:S~

~S

§'~

gI

Q)

p.:>

.-g.S

F-4

~~

§.cn.Cd

+-'

~>

,.s~

~gj

g?,~

Q)

It!~

~.8.~

:>.-:;9

§It!

.gIt!

~'"

~aI

Q)

.s.~

!~

~~

~[

1'J.5

:i..§~

~~

~~

::(/].5.§]

~~

[~;

~.s

.~:

~~

m.~

.Q).s;E

.5'g~

~~

~[~

"'.iJ:

..,..,~~

-~~

~tIC

(IJQ

)~~

(/].E1'J

cn(/]

tICQ

)>

<0

;j::Sgj.'-9

~~

Cf)

.s'"

~-:S

~0

"0~

~+

"'Q

)ow

.sS

Q).;.g

i~

..§~

~~

~,§

~~

~]

~~

g'~;

~

~

~

.~

~

~s~

;g

-~~

~

.,§ ~

~

~

~

~

.B

3 ~~

-5 ~s~

.:S

~

j 'f;'

~

g.Ei>

\l)Q

),",>.'"

Q)

""~Ia

~o.

...d...OQ

) (/]

\l) .",.cw

. '-'

~

-ala 00""'0>

: "0

\l).c 0;>

'+

-0 It!

~

"0 ,.c

'8 0

>,'O

.~;a"+

J"U

tIC-

"'U"

><

"'" \l)

~

:>.

'0 ~

~

"0

Q)

~

~'O

0>

~

g."O

) ~

~

.s S

+

-' ~

~

;E

~

0

'-g "+

.. -:S

cn

~

.fj "Q

) Q

) ~

~

..a;

~

t:o.i:::

'-g Q

) 0

~

13.c;=:

u,~

~!?i:

~

~

Q)

~

~

~..s

~

-+"'

:>

I C

J) '0

aj Q

) Q

) (/]

0 ~

+

-' 0

+-'

~

,.c -:S

1t!"+

J [d

+-'

0) Q

) 0

+"'

'0 bO

0

.Q

~

..CJ)

bO...

F-4 £d

~

0 +

-'

; :o?J

~

s ~

..s.c .§

.:£?:;- ~

.:oS .~

~

1a

g §

8 .s

Q) ~

~

~

a];E

J S

' '"3

~

~

~

51 ~

~

g [d

~

~

~

~:*

~

j ~

~

-:

.:: ~

g

! (/]

~.s.s.g

§ .~

] £

§ .g

-~

-:S

~

§"'O.z

.s ~

-:S

.,§ ~

'0

:s.~

~

~

g ~

~

::§ ~

~

1:;"S

S

0"

~

~

~

8. ~

':

~.~

~

I ~

~

'"

:>

'0 0>

~

~

cn

~

>,-

+-'

Q)

S

tIC

0 tIC

tIC

It!

~

0 -~

~

'-"

td 0

aI Q

) -0

+-'

0 aj

'0..;:0 -;s:

I .g

~

~]"~

~

%

~

~

~

;j

~

~

1a ~

~

~

S

.F:::

g.~

~

,§ ~

~

~

]~;a

~

~

~

~~

~

~

:':15] m

~

~

~

~

~

~

..s .i-:'

, ~

P

o Q

) U

Q

) (/]

ca "0

"+J

~

F-4

(/] 0

-.cn.~

riJ 0"-0

tIC

(/] C

d !::J;j

~

.;:0 :>

0

fj It!

0 6b

~

Q)

S

~

0 0>

a

+"'i!

S

~

g..c .?:;- ~

P

o Q

).!Cj

"0 ~

~

~

~

~

5:J ..a;

~

.~

~

Q)

~

'O.S

Q

)" .Q

)"U

eo Q

) ~

aj ~

~

F-4 -:S

§,.c

It! ~

eo~

~

.g

~

g.~

.~

; ]

! ~

1.i

j ~

~.J

~

~

] ~o

I~.s

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

j ;

1 ~

.~

! ~

.3

j g

~

~

l' ~

8

] ~

!

~

~

~

~

~

~

~)

0 $:

0 '"C

d Q)

F-4

0 >

It!

Q)""'..d

co cn..d

~

>

dJ

~

~

>

;j .s

s~.

~

Q)

.s ~

~

cn

O":+

;J ~

;j"+J

cn ..a; i>

C

d

j

Page 9: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

.s ~

~

: ~

..g:g.~

§ ~ ]

~

~:E

~

"~

~

~

~

.g. §' ~

.~

s ] .S

~

.s "8 ~

3 :S

8

:0] ~

'"ia ~

.§.g ~

] ~

~

]

~tI)a>

">~

O),s:e:P

.fj.~

,s~ro[ij~

roorotl)OO

~~

o) -:S

I-I~::I::I~

"".@

~O

)tJ>~

~

tJcaO)

tI)

I f

~ .~

~

~

~

~ i

~

~

j ~

;

~

~ ~

j.~

~

~ ;

~

~

~

[~~

~

~

t ~

j 1

] ~

~

]

~

.~ i

~ !

i i

j§- s

0) ~ "C

~ ~

Q

) Q

) ~

>. tI) tJ tJ E

o ~ '0

.~

~

~

ro ...~

~

0) ~

ro ~

0 ro §

.s ~

tI) 8 '0

~

tI) ~

"~

~

tI) ~ >

.

~]~

~~

~

~~

~~

g ~

~.§~

~~

.:Si']]j~

~

~~

~

~~

~.:]

~

l':~~

.;g ~

c13 8~

~~

'; 5::~

~ ..8 .s

~ -:S

::3 S

a>" ~

1-1 -g .s J?;- § e

~

oS ~

~ fS

~0

bO.§ ~

[5::

Q ~

gJ 'i:;o ~

~

~

c ~

::. -:S tJ ~

S

.S

~

~

~

S ~

&

1"".-.

tJ ~

\.I S

tJ "C

""C

>. Q

) 0 p.

tI) ~

1-1 S

"" 0

c (/)

Q):'p

Cd ..q ~

"C

O

J S

""'.-. ~

";::

u

] ..8 -;]

g ~ .$ ~

~

~

ro ,] ~

~

~

g .~ ~

~

-: ~

~

:~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

fa ~ §

] i

~ ~

.rj1 ~

] ~

~

] ~

.: .~

.5::" ]

.~~

~

~

..8 ] ]

:oS.S

O).~

~.:=

: ~

~

~

.~"rn

~

S -:S

8 .s ~

~

.s ~

s 'E

..g ~

~ .s

~

DO

..g ~.S

0 : fJ Q

) & ~

"i:J 0

~

~

~

~~

~

]~-.;;

1~i;f~

~li~

~

~]J~

i ~

~~

.~]j"$!l

~j~

fj

:f~~

1~;;.[~

j~~

S E

: ~

0 0) Q

) "C ,..; ~

5 ~

s

>. "C

~

Q).~

::I ~

",j:j ~ -:S

~

~ :

~

"C -:S

~.~

C

d OJ .ca ~

u p. §

~

0 ~ .g ~

.~

tJ

jg ~

tI) ;:§ !

~;~

~

~

~

.£. ~

..9 ].:S

~]

r.a.] j

~ ~

.s.s

a.i":S ~

;

~ ~

.5 ~

~

~.s

[.~

g s.:S

~

~

~

§ ~

~

0) :c' :s ..9 Q

) J?;- S ~

>. §

0 .s ~

~ ~

::I S

S

~

tI),?;':ii

~ ~

6

(;:3 ~ -:S

.g ~

ro ~

.~

~i

~

~

'0 .s ] .~

~

~

N

~

~"!j 5

S

tI) Oo~

~

.s ~

~

.rj1 .:S .$

"!j .:=: 'E

'0 tI) 8

~ .s

Q) .s

5 ~

.-:::: ~

5:: ~ .tI) J?;-

~

~::I

"C !J ~

:P

~

Q) 'E

1-1"

~"C

~~

i~

~.~

~.;

~:J

~

§g;~

~

~~

]'E~

i: ~

ii ~

~~

~

~

~

~1;

~~

~

..g1[~1.a.~

.1].£.~

~

.§ ~

;

~

;s ~

S

J?;-.$ ~

~

.~ .E

~

~

s ~

~

.s ~

~

~

~

a e§ ~

I::i ~

~

a>"

;; ~

~

:s ~

] ~

-g ~

8 ~

~

~ &

~

tI) ~

D

O.; D

O E-o ~ B

~

S

>

tI) b

~

O):s::

.s .s .s tJ '0 .s ~

..g Q

) ~.~

0) -:S

~:P

S

~.~

0]

oS 'E

0) >

. 6b .~

.g..9 §.s

5::':=: ~

~

~

~

"-fj:g ~

~

~

~ .~

.e;;-:S S :s -g ~

tI) ~

.~.s

a.i:oS ~

.s "C

~

0 ~

~

~

-:S ~

~

5 -3 ~

~

~

~

.g:oS

~ s:g

! -:S

~ .~

~

.E .s

~..a

.~ ro.:S

s ~

~

§ ~

'E ~

0- ~

~

j

~-E

~

>. ~

~

~

'0 ~

1 S

'O.:S

6b~

.$.§ ~

~

~

~

~

g i ~

j

~1

~

~ ~

~

~

~ ~

"!j .~

i~.$

~

S ~

~

~.s

i~

~~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~]

~ ~

>

..:S ~

~

"~

~

>.s;a.;.:S

.~~

:p-:s:g~

~s

~.§

p.~

DO

,]].d"~~

>

.-g p.~

: 5::.S

~"P

.~

~

~

i.s..;;a a>

"~ ~

~

~

ro ~~

]~

:g

ro -:S

c -E

~

ro g

Q) ~

~

-g

] .s

~

..§ .:=: ~

:p

.:=: ~

~

~

5

~

~

6: ~

.~

~

~

.C13 ~

::I fa

ro Jg "'i;; ~

~

fa

fa.s &

1 ~0

'"3 "C

0 0

~

tI) S

d

~..c

~.~

::I

~

~

Q) tI) "C

~

§'

Q) ~

.§ ~

~

.rj1 ::I:oS

.-::: >

< ~

.~

~

-:S

S

p.-g

"-- oS >

~

~

tI)

"5::.~0)::1

~s~

'-'

Q)""~

.'" ~

:-

0 "'0)0

~tJ

s ~

..c~

Q»"",

"$ J ~

~

]

1 ~

:9 ~

~

§ ~

~

~

] -s .~

~

~

~ ~

;; ~

;. ~

.~

.~

5 : ~

~

..E ~

.~

?S

" i ~

8 ~

~

~

8]

~ ~

~

~

~

~tI) ro ~

"C O)

-3 ~

~

r;- >

..s:g ro S

["P

o S

-:S ~

~

ro tl)0)

~ ~

::..s

S

~

fa ~ ~

.~

~'s

Q

~

~

§ ~

~o~

&0)

] W

o ~.;;;

&

~.~

0

tI) -0

""tI).-. S

""bO

tI)

s""'tI) tI)""-tI)~

'

Cd

tJtJ ~

rotJ

i§ J

~!

J ~

~

~

! ~

~

J

~

~

~

~

~

f.~.~

J

~]]

18 i]

j ~

~

j

~

~

~

~.~

~

~

.g~

i~

i ~

.g ~

i]

'0 u

~

ro ~ .s

tJ Q) Q

).s '0 ~

:P

6b ro S oS

~ tJ

tJ '"+J ~

ro..c ~

ro -:S

'0 ~

tJ >

~

tJ ~

..c ~

::1::1

~

ro "'i;; -<

0) ~

0) ~

0)

ro fa

i>J' ~

.~

fa

Q) ro

r;- D

O ~.~

D

O

.s 'E

~

"!j

~

ro ~

D

O~

".-rj ~

~

ro "i:J

"!j 0

I .?;-.~

s

oS ...:;

~

:6...!.. ~

§

..c ~

-:S

~

tJ g

Q)

~

I ;§

1-1 I.S

tI) 1-1 ~..c

~

DO

~

.s 0

Q) 0

'"+J "C

~

0 ~

S

D

O S

0

~

ca "C

~

a S

:P.s

.tI) .~

'0

:S

~

~

'0 1-1 ~

tI);g

~:§

0) ro .s

~

-:s:g g.

S

tI) fa ~

~

tI).tI).S

S

tJ

e "'d) 0) ~

S

S

tJ

tI) ~

-<

~

::I ~

~

]

c13.9 ~

0

~

.~

::I ro '0

>

.~

R.s

Q)

,-, 0);

0 tI)

5:: ::I ~

0

>.

0) D

O~

."" 0

Q) ~

-g p.

~

~

e S

~

~

~

s.~

~

~

'E

[ij..c

8 S

~

~

'O

.jg S

~

&

1 ~..c

u:: ~

~

p. 8

~

tJ..c -E

a tJ

~

u;a oS

Q) ::I ~

s,go.

ro ~

S

S

4:0 ~

1-1 ~ "C

~

ro:oS

>

.J?;- "

8 tI) .~

~

0

~

"E

-:S

tI) ro ~

u

ro -g ro iE

~

~

~

.S

~

~

~

Q) ::I

~

g. 1-1 ~

.$ ..c

"Po"'"

oS ~

fa

0 "'i;; I-I.:S

~

~

Q

) 0 0

~

S

.s .S

.~

~

E

! ~

'0 ro:E

~

0)

~

ro ~

~

~

~

~

~

.:oS

~

0 §

m.a

>.

:.~

~

~

~

5 ~

~

~

~

~

.~

~..9

0 ~

~

s

~

~

oS ~

~

~

~

'610 ~

~

'E

~

~

..9 ] ~

-:S

'[ :

~

~

~

ro ~

;§ ~

::~

;.~

~

~

b

~

~

g .~

~

.~

]

~

:is] 8

~

.;] ~

~

8 ~

~

:g

tJo.£

S

d ~

~

~.~

eo.~

.'" ~

~]

~

~

::I "i:J S 1

~Q

).s -S

~

'E

~.~

..."!j ~

a.i

.s bO

.S ~

g ~

~ ~

8

.~ ]

~

0I-ItI)~

~

rotJ""~>

'::I.""CdO

)OJ

'O~

-D

O

~

""o..c~

tl)c ~

o ~

."'

"C

.Q.. 5:: o.:=

: ro.$

~

::. ~

'"E

0 fa

-:S :c'

§ ~

ro

0 ~

.~ "C

...tI)

tI) ~

.O..c

ro gJ

~

.~

.~

~

~

~

~

tJ ~

"C

~

"'0

roo S

-:S ~

8.

I::i' ~

8. ~.~

g

6b ~

Wo 0) .rj1

8 ~

~

..c ~

~

~

.§ ~

~

.'-jjJ : i:::

.~

.g -:S

~

; ~

~

;E

S

~

-; §

~tI)

o~roO

I-l ,s

O)~

§~~

~

tI)'OO

)~""cO

tl)~aoco>

<

tJO)"C

IO)tI)::I

SDOQ):p::l

~ DO

c..d ~

0 "E

tI) ~

S -:S

S..Q 0)

~ ~"O)..c

0 ~

0: ~

~ U

~ ~

> ~

':=:..d C

~..d ro..c]

0) tJ

Q)

~'"+

J~C

d'"+JO

) "cd

1-1::1 .tJtI)O

) tI)~

""S

~.rj1O

)tJ~°'"C

d~""

~'"+

JCdtO

'"+JO

)~C

d~~

tJQ)1-I

~

~ ~

"P

o.~ ~

~

~ ~

~

.:S ~

~

r;-~

~

~

5 ~

~

.S ~

~

~

~

8 "C.~

~

~

~

.~

ro '[;::' ~

..9 ~

..g .~::::

iE ~

~

~0

Q) Q

) >

S

tI) ~

>

g C

(J.-. Q

) 6b ~

"t >

."" .-.~

D

O ~..c

fI) S

C) ...0)

~

'-' ca

.E!

1-1~

:g §

~ i

-:S ~

§' S

m

. § :g .~ '&

11 ~

~

": ~

[i

~ .&

§' -s § ~

ro -g

§ §

j ~

~

6 8.EJ

8. ~

.610 i

~.~

~

~ ~

~

;g ~

&

~

~

~.g:!f~

1

s ~

~

~

~ .s §

..9 .~ ;

;EO)

~

~

~.~

~

~

Q)

° .~

~

:g §;a

~

s I:i.":

-:S~ E

] :g ~

: ~

.jj '"+J..d ::I

,., d

'u ~

tJ -~

"";..

.-."'" 1-1 ~

d:P

~

0 U

:p tI) 'u 0.""

0 ~

::I

'"+J..c tI) ..: =

' .~

>

-0) ~

~

~

oS

"";: 1-1

0 ~ ~

tI) oS

S

0) d :=

ro."" ~

D

O~

0) :0 '0

-:::: 0 ~s~

O

) Q

) ..c 1-1 1-1 0) D

O.'"

""~::Iw

rofaQ

) tJS

roo""~

Q.

1-I00o--' tI)tI)tI)~

"'Q)""

\.IS

8..~.s

~]

~

~ ~

:i] '0 0:

S ~

.s:p: 5"!j

~!i..9

~

tJ ~

g;E.

.R tJ ~.s

e ~

~

cX

J" §.$

~

~ .s

§ '0..8 -g.:S

8 §'~

§'.~

8. ~

~

"C

5:: fa ti"!j .s]

~

~

..c.:oS -:S

.t"" iE ~

.s.:g

~

fa 8 g ~

§' -~

.~

~

~

] .$ ~

]

~

§ ~

~

"'O

tI)..c°:oSO

)Q)

c>tI)l-I..c

~O

) tl)ro-<

Wo~

~I-I-:S

~

1-1~

0 'O

~

~~

~.~

'"+J°:p:§

>'a.i

fa ~ .~

6b §'-:S

~

8 C

d ~ 'i 8.~

~

~ ~

~

~

§

a.i .s ~

8

~

S ~

..8.s

§- ~ ~

6b

~~

--J 5:: §.g

~

fa ~.$.~

~

E :g

~

8. ~

~

~

~ ~

~

O)tI) 8:S

j

.s ;.g -:S j

~.~

.$ ~

E

~

~

'E

~.:::: ;

'E

fa.g ~

: 5 -<

"'d) ~ :g .:S

J:j: -:S ~

~ ~

~

g..§

::I ro

Q) ~

co .

§~

tI) 0)

DO

ro

.jj '0

~

1-1 tI);>

ca

0) \.1::1

0 ""'"

0) H

~

>..

DO

~

tJ

.;:. tI).-.

1-1 1-1

tJ Q

)

0-1..d '-

ro u

>..-::::

0)'-' 0)

~

."C

:: >

tJ

Q)

0) tI)

>0

='

tI) .-.D

O

1..." ~

.D

O

tI) ro

~,~

..,

ro tI)

0)

ca'"+J.""

~.

0 0)

tI) ~

. 0);..

,...~

'-' ~

- 1-1

>

>.:g 3

'E

0) ~

tI).~ ~

~

~

JS ]

~

DO

a ~

~

~

::I ~

~

&1 ~

~.~

Q

) DO

8 0) ~

~

::I ~

~

§ ~

.~

§,..;

ro ~~

.g.~ro~

tJ'i:;o'O~

I-IS;a::l

ro.""O)tI)S

tJ

°OJ::Il-ltI)tI)~

'-'SbO

~Q

) D

C'

S"C

~O

)OS

oO)(/)~

~

~ ~

5.~

~

.s ~

~

ro 8..?;-1..a §

§' 8.a~

s ~

~

~

~]

] i

':§'~

ro ~::tI)

~.S

~

.~

~ ~

~

;a ~

~

..g ..§.-ci ~

.~ ~

~

.~

g .s.~

~ ~

tI) ~

~

.~ ~

::. ~

~

.::: ~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

""&

; .~ ~ ci

fa "E

g .§ ~

~

~

~

~

~

r.:i:;; ~

5 ~

:oS~

~

0)

~

~

ca 0) ;

\.I Q

) 0."" .-.D

O"

'u ::I

(/).-. 0

~'

'"+J"" '0'-'

0"C

S

1-1 ~.g

~

tI).'" S

'0 ~

I-I.?

fa 0) ro ~

~ ~

~

-:S 0]

~ ~

tI) ::. 'U

D

O

:>

tI) ~

0) ro bO

::I :p "C D

O S "C

~.

"~.S

] ~

~

i

[~s

~

~~

~

~

~]

~::fi:

.s~

fa ~]

; [~

~

-g J ~

~

~

~

.~

~

~

~

~ .§]

8 .[~

fa ~

i0) ~

~

:S

tJ p. 0

~

-g .~

ro ~:s

>.

to DO

-tI) U ~

~

Q

).EJ "".:S

>

~

ro §:"""' .~

§

~

u Q

) D

O E

1 ."..9:oS

::. ~

0)

1.i i

~ I

~ 1

~

] .~

.1 ~

j

~.~

1

F ~

;

1 ~

~

~

II ~

~

] ~

~

:g .~

~

8!

~

~

1 i

~

~

~]

~

~]

Page 10: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

~

~ ~

'0 oS

~ ,~

~

'~

t .§

...;: g ci.

d:!3 ,6 ~

~

§

oS .,::

:a -a

.~

§: d >

<:.;::

~.,-

...;: ,~-.0

,~>

, a;.S

~

Q

);3 >

+1

"O:3.!:;-

.S

S

p."',1 :c

,0 S

0

GO

aid Q

) U

o~

"'=

~

~ ~

] j

] ...~

~

§ ~

r;:9

§ ~

§

[ 8 ~

.~

,8 5>

~ tIj

~

g :3 ~

§

~

;:: ] ~

.s~

s .~

C/)

Q) ~

5 0 Z

0 Q

) I:j ~

:c 0

Cj

p. 't:j 0 ci. ~

:

,. oj

., ~

.9; -<

°""lO

0 ~

I:j .::::

~

Q)'5.5

~~

~

--:-.-:.

,s~

.~Q

).§ :8

b :§(i).!:;-

s ,~

~

~

"0 "0'

r..;~

.S

0 ~

~

~~

~

~ >!.s

~~

]

~~

1~

~

.] .~

~

]j~

~

1i J

~

~:s~

§.]

~N

:=

=C

/)'~

~~

0"

C

Q)"""

~~

~

o ~

~

P

",v

0 ",

0 ~

oS

I

~

r..; ~

~

s

~

~

,:; ~

~

§:';;j"

oS

j C

~

~

~

=

"0 ~

3

=0'

~

~

g 5

8. ~

~

~

]

0...~

~

'S'.

c; Q

) 0

v C

/) .-.'" p.

IV '"0

' u

I Q

) ,,'~

'"

~

0 -"i

'" 6b

Q)

~

p. E

-o N

.,

~

oS :e

u ~

§

u go

,~.!:;-

~

f:J. S

~

.s

cO' d

d .~

~

e

g ~

.p..-:.

&.

'5 p.

p. .'0

.': I:i.

:.:.:e;.~

.Q

)~

.""".~.,

'-"" u"O

:-. '"

~'~

~

>

'o.-<:c

0 ",0)

~.

"'~

Q)=

Q

) I:jp.

i>1:j

] U o<

: g

.~

~

~

~:

.-i. a

~

~

'~g"

-5 ~

'0

~

1 ~

t:-: ]

.~

.s! .5

:g ~

~

i

~

:!: ~

g

~.J

~:

...~

Q) ~

fa ."'

E.~

~

~

;a ~

C

Q)

"' Q)'"

'" Q

) ..." c;

Cj

~ .v

0 "N

"0 U

Q)

~

~..

~

o"O'E

~

.s;a~0..e

r:::3 .~

~

;:ss"O'

8 :8 ci.

.~

"0' ~

p..'g

.~<

~

§ :a.-g

gu.v

";oJ '" ~

.~

Q) =

50' "ta

~

o 0 '" =

3

0", '"

'" Q

) OJ

,S 0 U

B

= ~

,~

,

1 ]~

~

.~!~

~

~]

a~

.~~

! ~

~

] ~

1~§

~

"i'i g

~

] ~

§ ~

~~

g. ~

~

~

~'.f;.

't:j"" .§,

-<

~

tI ~

U

~

It) .S

Q)

~

2:==

c;' ~

§

tI ~

~

~

Q

) .2;

..0 0

e .,

~

Il. ~

.~

§§

~

~ ';;;' ~

~

oS ~

p..~

p. 'I g

~s b

~

~ ~

.s S

"B

~~

j ::I

~

~.

-a.-E

I:jo~"O

§o

'5 ~

§

I:j ~~

00

0 .t:j"O

l;;.e '

.,Ii! IV

"tIj 0

---v cd

~"'.~

o ~

°u""

'§ ~

~~

.~

f:J.Q)~

j5

;~

.S:!:...;:

.:S.5

~u~

~

.~

.,~

~

~

~£,~

~

1~~

~

$ 9'S

~

~

~

]~~

}Jl~

:~

~

~~

1t~

,~

:B']

~.;~

,~

~

~~

,~

~

~

.~i.[

~~

~~

l

~~

~

~,.:;

~.~

~

.'.!:>','"

"0.,1... Q

)i:';-.+J "'~

t?;

R'-'~

f:J..S

=Q

)"O'~

~'"

'.~tJ'~

P

~

IV8

",'-d

'~~

"'o; !J i>

§:r;. ~

§

g 1!! ~

~

~

d ~

m

Q

) ~ ~

>,

] ~

E

. c;

:] ~

§ ~

~ .0 ~

~

'S

.~

~ §:

~

bO ~ ~

~

~ ~

~

u) ~ ~

~ i

r% § ~

~

~:

:B

~ -:; ~

1 '2J

.~ ~

~

~

~

~ :r;.:E

~ ~

g .8 Q)

§ ~

s ~

~~

,S

~ ~

:ta ,!:t' ~ :E

~J,~ .~

]

2 0.C/)~

~ '5 .;1J

~~

~

]

~ g.g

1;; ~

~

.~

.~

~ § .d ~

g -a ~

§ ;g

~

~ §

~ .Q

.~

$ v

EJ m

~..p.

~

IV

0 Ii)

Q)

CD

=

... "0

Q)

C/)

...g "0

~

E-o""

0"" '"

0 ~

'"

Ii) 0

u Q

) 't:j

~

.-;J f:J.

~

Q)

~

., "

IV

0 8

'.. :c

Q)

.-, ~

.p.

"0 I:j

~.

CD

0

~

~

~

.Q)

o","'"

'!3;.:::1 a

=

u) :c

0" .z:J

~~

'"

p."" 0...

' c;~

C

D

ON

.,

~-

""- '"

'" <

t; '"

O<

O.~

p.-

";oJ ~

rJ Q

) "0 '1j

~

,'" ~

;a

,:3 ~

§

'-' ~

§

Q).

,~

,~

,,>.

la"O

'E'

:3 =

"3

p. S

u.s

'>

~

=

~

~

0 ~

N

-a

~

5 "0

8~

=~

"

tip... 0

~."O

e~>

"",-,N

I.. "'0°""

>-

°u 0

oS""~

E::O

~

u 1.,

0", =

Q)

oS

~

IV.-.

~

.,; oJ"

c; .~

... =

u

~

...e ~

i>

~

. I

~

~...

Cj

' -.p:c

:8 u

g Il.

0 C

j -.p"O

~

bC

'-:' ~

'"

~

~

id '"

d.M

Q) ~

c;' .>

~

0 ~:iF

.- ~ .~

0

ci ~

8 ~

~

g 'ii) ~ .£I

:E ~

~

~

.~

,E

"3 '~

..: §- :3 § ~

~

't1 .~ ~

"g :§ g

~

"0 .-:. ...:;

§ ~..~

~

i>

0

!J"O

Q)

Ii) 0;:\2 0 ~

8

"0 oS

g,' N ~

."

~

CIj"O

.,; .~

E

S

"ta" 0 $

-.p E

~

a u ~

,C

; ~

"0 .~

"~

""3

U ~

.g, ~

~

]'g '§.s

~

e ~

] .S

~ -d ..,a ~

Ir).~

~:'"

ci ~

~

~ -e '"

.~ ~

~

"i' ~

;5 ~

§'>

~

:3 ~

~

E

'-:' ~ ~

g,' f:J.

E

~~

~

0 ok!"" .-=

0 a1

tI) 8 '5 .~

Q) ';:4' -a. c; ~

.s.o .~

tJ .:. §

Q) ~

~ ~

-<

~

"-g .~

CD

~ .-:. ., "0 ~

0 S ~

'5 ~

'" u

",' '" ~

~

~

~

~

-~ ~

~

~

&

'E'~

to S

~

tJ ~

<0 p.-E

~ ~

:g ~

0 ~

... ~

~

:,q ~

"'.-:.

I""£: =

It) ~

U ~

s'~

:C

0 o.~

§::a-:-8 ~

,..;j ~

~

e-'u

] ~

~

$

[ ~

~

~

;f

~ 8

7 £

~ ~

~.~

~

~

£

~ ~

; ~

0 ! ~

~

t

~

~

~ ~

~

~.

~

~ ~

&

: ~

.~ ~

&

5' ~

~

~

8 .-i. ~

$ ~

~.8-'"

,..,.-:.~.-:."O

.-:..

.IV~

;:c'~.-:

0 "-:'

"'-;::"'~...~

'" .'.~

N

'-:'~~

=

~.-:.

.~'-:'u

]~;~

§]~~

~g~

~~

~~

:~~

~

~~

~~

~~

~~

~

~~

~~

~~

~

~1~

~~

~;~

'z~~

~~

~~

~

I~~

~:

0 c;;- 0) ~

Q) oS

...S

~

~""'~

"Q1

C/) ~

Q) ~

0 ~

~ ~

-.u

rzj ~ ~

r..; bO

~ U

.~

0) e

~

~ f:J.;':;'-:' '"

'~

~

-~

~

u ~

Il."; =

...~!J9';]

g ~

dl:!:S(/j=

.r-'~~

r-'oS"'ar-'~

r-'Zr-'r-'

§>

c;ooS~

o-g~,

~~

~

~~

~~

<.8:~

!$.<:~

~,..;j'§'-:'

ok! g~d~

g ~

0-:: -5 .1J

.,; ~

~

'd i

~

'os: ~

~.

.§ .~

~

i

~

-;;;: ~

~

§ ci ~

j

d ~

'.1 P

j; .r g :

~

~

~

§-,..;j ~

~

',:-' ""':;

~

] ~

~

§

'; .;

~

G1, j

..e. ::j

op.~O

C;

.>

"OP

aD~

O

O~

~bO

bO

'" 00'"

Q) u

000 ~

Q)=

O"

Q)'O

.'cd

C;Q

)"O

"" fa...

00 .,.,O

~.,

~

.!:;-:5. ~

8

~

r..; "0' §

8:~

ok! ~:~

~

:"::j .~

%

:~

~

:l:~

a -~

.~

g

~

~

~

~

,~~

~

u

~

F: t3

~

~

~

-E

~

f:J. ~ .~

~

~

~

a

j ~

~

;g

z"E-

oS ~

u u

u u

u ~

u

uu u

P

P

~

~

~

~

'-' ~

-~

1l.1l. C

/) C

/) E

-o

Q)6°O

oo00Q)"C

6 Q

)""..;;~gj

Q)

"0 a=

"~'"

oSQ

)Q)~

Q)"'~

Q

) 't:;oQ

).; a;

.'"-5

~.s

.@ .s;c

~

m

~

§ ';j:O

~

oS

§ ~

] ~

:~

§ .~

oS ~

~

g .s .~

~

'f! '5

:8 "E

.g' ~

.~

m o..~

~

.~

.~

s. '? ~

~

6. .,

~

.~

,c ~

~ :s 2

~ -i

~

~ ~

~

~

0.,

~

0 .s .~

::a

~.a

s g.'-"'

~.~

~

~

~

.~

;g ~

.~

~

~

~~tJ ~

.tJ" ~

.~

g

~.:S

~

g

~

~

~.§

e. ]

~

"0 ~

S

0 ~

"C

>

<

'" ...'"

fa =

";oJ

~

Q)"

'" ..oS

' p.

00 =

"0 .~

.,

'-' fa

.u tJ

§~

100 ~

~

-:s

;§ :g

: ~

8

,S

oS

~

'E

[d ~

.~

..a 13.,

~

4;;j:;J tJ

8 ci

[d'~

.:e; ~

~

~

la

"""'" ",0""

CD

, ",'0'"

=

0 0

(/) :t;..C; 0

1!J 100 ~

.~

Q

) "0 ~

~

0 ~

x ~ '"

,S ~

Q

) I;J ~ ...§ =

~

,c ~

s 0 5:(!

0 Z

8 .~ ~

~

~

~

; :

~ :

i ~

~

~

~

i i

.; ;

i ~

~ ~

~

;§ ~

.; ~

]

§ ~

~

] ~

]

"E ~

m

..o m

~

0..0 ~

~:g

~ 0

.s ~

., g.~

Q

) ~ g ]

] o:S

:: ~

§

~

~ t;

.~

Z ~

~

.:

~

d (/) ~

-

0...aD,

Q).~

N

0

"0 ...00

~

~

0 ...'"§

,c IV

tI

=...

.,; ~

0)

0Ioo(/)

~m

+

-' -.p'"

It) ,

Q)O

~

0Q)

0' ~

Q

.o"" u-

~S

~

I~

m(/)oo~

~

~d~

"§.e ~

~

~~:s:~

g ~

:6~.,ss

s 8

.S"~

"O

~-a

'-:' ~

~

>.

~

~

"'" ~

>

cd

~

0. '"

0 ,c,

Q)'p

=

Q)

~

'c .Q

) ~

-5

.~

~

Q).~

<

: E

-o

;a ;c ..."'cd '"Q

:; .~ -.g ~

oS .S

'd' ~

~ 1J ~

.S

~

]

~

~

~

-.:: oS ~ ~

]

oS

] ,g § ~

.~

~

~

gj

.s §.~

-:s ~

..g.~';"

,s ~ ~

.§ § ~

1 §

~1

§ ~ ~

1

~ .s ~

~

] .S

]

~ ~

.( ~

~

.s ~

]

~

~..:!J-:

I loom

or

p.'1j~~

~

coo

~';;;"""'O

§ .e:3:gQ

)~"O

~

~

"O:e§~

§~

~

u

;c 0 :g ~

":

§ g; S

~

~

~]la

&.1::.~

~Q)

'S

:g ~.;

"t S

~

~:g ~

.;a ~ ~

'5 ~

~

~ ~

~

gj g ok!

'0~

Ioo ~

m(/)~

~

CD

"'.z:J

-"i Q

)~"m

,,=

0 Q

)=,~

=

~

0Q

)0'" ~

'" '

Q)

~

m

(/)""" ~

0

Q)

I:j bO

~

. ~

0

~

p..~

Cd

~.,

>

0"0 -.p

'" '.-.

~

'a '1j

~

~

0 P

g tJ s. "d .g ~

.~

> 0m

'A

~

~

]..§

~.S

~

.S

go.:;;; i

IV ~

~

~

oS

'0 ~

C

D

g ~

f/)

~

'0 -"ci :3

~

~

~

g'm

00 '+

;J 00

v, .,

IV

OJ.,

Q)

00 '"

= ..,.

x ~

aD

>"0

0'" G

J ";oJ

=

C; e

IV.

~"ca1dm

+-,~

"Co.S

~

J!. [dQ

)~Q

)~e>

,..§ Q

)g~Q

)bQ)"o=

.S"O

"""O~

U

bO

O

li)e~~

"O

.s 0

~U~:~

~~

Page 11: Crafting policies about controversial values: How wording disputes manage a group dilemma

~~

..'0<

S

'

.~

[~

~~

~

go

d~

p;

0 Q

o., 0

.., .,

~

~

Q,"[

~~

~

~

~

~C

/) 0

..toJ

00 ,-,

0<

"'m

tJ

~

.S

~

~

~~

u

" ~

N

~

.~~

~"

.": 0

u ..tJ

.§ to

"3 .~

0

~

O~~

Q

o 0

><

~

Q)

~'"

..."'" C

/) ~

~..,=

. ~

U

~S

..'"

.o~N

f-4

as<t;.

t:: Z

' '0'

] <

~~

"oj ;~

~.d

..~

I C

/) O~

~

§ ~

Z

'~~

.g

.s~~

Q)

to "

~.o...

8 ';'

§~

U

to "'

., 0""

...Qo

.§ --.1

~

o~g;

~

~~

"'5 ~

'.

" ~

~

~

0

~to

--.1"" 0

u...~

~

Zo",,~

~

.~o~

5 ".0

0 ('-.:3

~

~u

:f:j ~

]

~~

:E,

~

1~~

r/) ~

S

' 3

5~.s

.S

~8.t3

[:jtJ

.~

.S!

tJ U

."':1 C

/)~

to"

~

lJ Q

o~

~

.=

a ~

~

:a

~..

~

~

't- ..g

.~

tJ '"'.~

0

"3 ~

I-;

>.."

>.

.~oo

.0." t,;

-, tJ

~

S

00"" '01' ...'"

~

~

.~

d Q

o .!:! .~

'0

~

~

~

.~~

~

:3

~

~~

0

I ~

~~

C/)

8. s

~

8.~~

~

'oI'Q)d3

~

~

~

" p;.~

'"

~

U ~

~

-5

a 0

't-z§ ~

:::,~S

]

O'

U

to ..,

'"'<".0

~

~

'-a :8

,,;.;~

g.;] ~

2..,=.'"3

~

~

~

~"E

~~

oo.~o",

z d

.S

Q)

0 "'..

Qo

~

'"0

6 "'5

.>

~

~

Qo ';:;

~~

S

"I

coU

.to.N

~

;;::...~

0~1-;8"'.~

"S

~

.~

;j """'~

""~."

~

~

" ..o~

<..,=

.o"""t:::J

S

~

p. 6~

0 8".O

=p.@

...

@

'"3 ()

.§ .§

00 ~

g ~

.8

., ..e:~

g

-I: .tJ

..,=.

~.~

o-.S

".0 ~

~

~

~

to g

N:c

'" 0

tJ" .:3

~Q

o..,=.

.~

~

~

.0 "iJ ::2 ~~

.~

:I:. 6 .( -:a ~ ~

~0

~~

<

u ~

~~

§ .~

~

~~

..,=

. .~

, ...,=

... -uG

~~

...a

0~

~

.."in'.-o::'o~

-a ~

~~

~

~~

. "'~

"'~O

~O

"'b"o~tj.

bQ"

~

~

.~~

~"'~

O(lju~

~"'~

~

;j~~

~

~

.~

~

'"1' ~

~

~

-; ~

~

--:.05

<

~

!u.£.~

<~

~~

~

3g~1~

~u

]~

'"'~

""""'.""'"'~

>~

0 p.",

.>'>

'1:;"'>'

Q)~

., .--

!D

>,.:t;:s~

t'"'I'uuQo

zasu~:;:~

!::I ~

~.."'O

as,","oItJ

as ,,,,~

.,u

,;;; f-4

f-4 ~

~

~

~

$: $:

~<

."'"

--,"",..-