Top Banner
COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION DISCUSSION PAPER NO. 1065 Note: Cowles Foundation Discussion Papers are preliminary materials circulated to stimulate discussion and critical comment. Requests for single copies of a Paper will be filled by the Cowles Foundation within the limits of the supply. References in publications to Discussion Papers (other than mere acknowledgment by a writer that he has access to such unpublished material) should be cleared with the author to protect the tentative character of these papers. SECOND ORDER APPROXIMATION IN THE PARTIALLY LINEAR REGRESSION MODEL Oliver Linton December 1993
48

COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

Apr 11, 2019

Download

Documents

truongtram
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY

Box 2125, Yale Station

New Haven, Connecticut 06520

COWLES FOUNDATION DISCUSSION PAPER NO. 1065

Note: Cowles Foundation Discussion Papers are preliminary materials circulated to stimulate discussion and critical comment. Requests for single copies of a Paper will be filled by the Cowles Foundation within the limits of the supply. References in publications to Discussion Papers (other than mere acknowledgment by a writer that he has access to such unpublished material) should be cleared with the author to protect the tentative character of these papers.

SECOND ORDER APPROXIMATION IN THE PARTIALLY LINEAR REGRESSION MODEL

Oliver Linton

December 1993

Page 2: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

5,���# �+#,+ ���+�jW��AW�� W� AO, ��+AW�wwv wW�,�+

+,B+,55W�� ��#,w

�v �wWV,+ wW�A��

i i @4�?i |�i tiUL?_ Lh_ih ThLTih|�it Lu �@h�L�t ^�@?|�|�it Lu �?|ihit| �? |�i

T@h|�@**) *�?i@h hi}hitt�L? 4L_i*� i LM|@�? @ t|LU�@t|�U i T@?t�L? ��|� hi4@�?_ih

J� E?32>�c ��ihi > �*2c uLh |�i t|@?_@h_�ti_ ti4�T@h@4i|h�U *i@t| t^�@hit it|�4@|Lhc

@ t|@?_@h_ ihhLh it|�4@|Lhc @?_ @ t|�_i?|�ti_ t|@|�t|�U� i �ti |�i tiUL?_ Lh_ih

i T@?t�L?t |L ULhhiU| |�i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh it|�4@|it uLh tiUL?_ Lh_ih igiU|tc @?_ |L

_i�?i @ 4i|�L_ Lu M@?_��_|� U�L�Ui� � 4L?|i U@h*L i Tih�4i?| ThL��_it u@�L�h@M*i

i��_i?Ui L? L�h 4i|�L_ Lu M@?_��_|� U�L�Ui�

k,v`�+#5G 5i4�T@h@4i|h�U it|�4@|�L?c T@h|�@**) *�?i@h hi}hitt�L?c !ih?i*c *LU@*

TL*)?L4�@*c tiUL?_ Lh_ih @TThL �4@|�L?tc M@?_��_|� U�L�Uic @t)4T|L|�U i T@?t�L?t�

Page 3: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

2

�� W�A+�#N�AW��

A�i t�M�iU| Lu |��t T@Tih �t |�i T@h|�@**) *�?i@h hi}hitt�L? 4L_i*c UL?t�_ihi_ �?

,?}*ic Bh@?}ihc +�Ui @?_ i�tt E�bHS�c

+� ' qAt2 n wE~� n " E��

��ihi wE�� �t @? �?!?L�? tU@*@h u�?U|�L? @?_ " �t @ 3ihL 4i@? ihhLh Lh|�L}L?@* |L

ML|� t2 @?_ wE��� A��t 4L_i* i4ML_�it @ UL4ThL4�ti Mi|�ii? i4T*L)�?} @ }i?ih@*

?L?T@h@4i|h�U tTiU��U@|�L? }Et2c ~�c ���U�c �u |�i UL?_�|�L?�?} �@h�@M*it @hi ��}� _��

4i?t�L?@*c �L�*_ *i@_ |L tih�L�t *Ltt Lu ThiU�t�L?c @?_ @ u�**) T@h@4i|h�U tTiU��U@|�L?

���U� 4@) hit�*| �? M@_*) M�@ti_ it|�4@|Lht @?_ �?UL?t�t|i?| �)TL|�it�t |it|t� A�i

�4T*�U�| @t)44i|h) Mi|�ii? |�i igiU|t Lu t2 @?_ ~ 4@) Mi @||h@U|��i ��i? t2 UL?�

t�t|t Lu _�44) Lh U@|i}Lh�U@* �@h�@M*itc @t �? 5|LU! E�bHbc �bb��� A��t tTiU��U@|�L?

@h�tit �? �@h�L�t t@4T*i ti*iU|�L? 4L_i*tc tii ��? @?_ �L�i** E�bb��c �i�i)c �L��

i**c @?_ @*!ih E�bbf�c @?_ wiic +Lti?3�i�} @?_ ��|| E�bb2�� W| �t @*tL |�i M@t�t Lu

@ }i?ih@* tTiU��U@|�L? |it| uLh u�?U|�L?@* uLh4 �?|hL_�Ui_ �? #i*}@_L @?_ 5|i?}Lt

E�bbe��

i uLU�t L? �?uihi?Ui @ML�| q� A@!�?} i TiU|@|�L?t }��i? ~ Lu ML|� t�_it Lu Eqq�c

@?_ t�M|h@U|�?} |��t UL?_�|�L?@* 4L4i?| uhL4 ML|� t�_it �i LM|@�? |�i it|�4@|�?}

i^�@|�L?

+� � .d+�m~o ' qA Et2 �.dt2m~o� n "� E2�

+LM�?tL? E�bHHM� �ti_ E��}�ih Lh_ih� �@_@h@)@� @|tL? !ih?i* it|�4@|it Lu |�i hi�

}hitt�L? u�?U|�L?t .d+�m~o @?_ .dt2m~o |L UL?t|h�U| @ ui@t�M*i *i@t| t^�@hit it|�4@|ieq Lu q� N?_ih hi}�*@h�|) UL?_�|�L?t hit|h�U|�?} |�i _�4i?t�L?t Lu ~ @?_ �4TLt�?}

Page 4: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

tL4i t4LL|�?itt L? |�i @ML�i hi}hitt�L? u�?U|�L?tc �i ThL�i_ |�@|s?E eq � q� �@t

@t)4T|L|�U@**) ?Lh4@*� `�i? |�i ihhLht " @hi ?Lh4@*c |��t it|�4@|Lh @U��i�it |�i

ti4�T@h@4i|h�U �?uLh4@|�L? ML�?_� 5ii @*tL O���i? E�bHH�c ��OiU!4@? E�bHS�c @?_

5TiU!4@? E�bHH� uLh @*|ih?@|��i |hi@|4i?|t�

A�ihi �t tL4i i��_i?Ui |�@| �ht| Lh_ih @t)4T|L|�U _�t|h�M�|�L?t ThL��_i TLLh @T�

ThL �4@|�L?t �? Th@U|�Ui |L |�i t@4T*�?} Mi�@��Lh Lu ti4�T@h@4i|h�U it|�4@|Lhtc @|

*i@t| uLh |�i |)Ti Lu t@4T*i t�3it @�@�*@M*i ��|� iUL?L4�U _@|@ � tii |�i 4L?|i U@h*L

i��_i?Ui Thiti?|i_ �? 5|LU! E�bHb� @?_ 5|L!ih E�bb�� ��L �?_ *itt u@�L�h@M*i UL?�

U*�t�L?t |�@? Ot�i� @?_ �@?t!� E�bH.�� 5i4�T@h@4i|h�U it|�4@|Lht |)T�U@**) hi^��hi

|�i ti*iU|�L? Lu @ t4LL|��?} T@h@4i|ih �E?�c uhi^�i?|*) U@**i_ |�i M@?_��_|�c ���U�

_i|ih4�?it |�i igiU|��i _i}hii Lu T@h@4i|ih�t@|�L? |@!i? M) |�i ?��t@?Ui u�?U|�L?

uLh }��i? t@4T*i t�3i ?c ��ihi |�i ?�4Mih Lu ?��t@?Ui T@h@4i|iht 4�t| �?Uhi@ti ��|�

t@4T*i t�3i @| @ Uih|@�? h@|i� W?|��|�L? }@�?i_ �? @?@*)t�?} |�i t4@** t@4T*i Mi�@��Lh

Lu T@h@4i|h�U it|�4@|Lht � tii +L|�i?Mih} E�bHeM� � t�}}it|t |�@| t4@** t@4T*i

ThLTih|�it _i|ih�Lh@|i ��|� |�i ?�4Mih Lu ?��t@?Ui T@h@4i|iht |L Mi it|�4@|i_( L?i

|�ihiuLhi i TiU|t ti4�T@h@4i|h�U ThLUi_�hit 4@) �?U�h @ t�Mt|@?|�@* t4@** t@4T*i

ULt| hi�iU|�?} |�i @4M�|�L�t }L@* Lu it|�4@|�?} @? @t)4T|L|�U@**) �?�?�|i ?�4Mih Lu

?��t@?Ui T@h@4i|iht�

� Tih�@Tt 4Lhi tih�L�t ThLM*i4 �t |�@| |�i �ht| Lh_ih @TThL �4@|�L? _Lit ?L|

hi�iU| |�i U�L�Ui Lu �E?�� 6hi^�i?|*)c |�i ?�4ih�U@* �@*�i Lu TL�?| it|�4@|it LM|@�?i_

U@? �@h) ^��|i UL?t�_ih@M*) ��|� M@?_��_|�� A�ihiuLhic L?i 4�t| ��i� hiTLh|i_ hi�

t�*|t ��|� tL4i tUiT|�U�t4� 6�h|�ih4Lhic |�i �ht| Lh_ih |�iLh) _Lit ?L| }��i @?)

�?uLh4@|�L? @ML�| �L� |L U�LLti �E?� �? Th@U|�Uic @?_ |�ihiuLhi ThL��_it @? �?UL4�

T*i|i _itUh�T|�L? Lu |�i ThLUi_�hi�

i Mi*�i�i |�@| ��}�ih Lh_ih |�iLh)c @t i TL�?_i_ �? �u@?3@}* E�bHf� @?_ +L|�i?�

Mih} E�bHe@�c U@? @__hitt tL4i Lu |�i ThLM*i4t Thiti?|i_ M) |�i �ht| Lh_ih |�iLh)�

Page 5: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

e

A�iti 4i|�L_t �@�i @ *L?} ��t|Lh) Lu @TT*�U@|�L? |L iUL?L4i|h�U ThLM*i4tc ���**�Tt

@?_ �@h! E�bHH� @?_ ��it�ih @?_ 5T@_) E�bb�� Mi�?} tL4i hiUi?| i @4T*itc @?_ ThL�

��_i ML|� ^�@*�|@|��i @?_ ^�@?|�|@|��i �?uLh4@|�L? @ML�| |�i ThLTih|�it Lu it|�4@|Lht

@?_ |it| t|@|�t|�Ut Mi)L?_ |�@| UL?|@�?i_ �? |�i �ht| Lh_ih |�iLh)�

i _ih��i @ t|LU�@t|�U i T@?t�L? ��|� hi4@�?_ih J� E?32>�c ��ihi f > �*2c

uLh |�i t|@?_@h_�ti_ ti4�T@h@4i|h�U it|�4@|Lh Lu qc @ t|@?_@h_ ihhLh it|�4@|Lhc @?_

@ t|�_i?|�ti_ t|@|�t|�U� i _ih��i @TThL �4@|�L?t |L |�i 4L4i?|t Lu |�i |h�?U@|i_

i T@?t�L?t ���U� @hi |�i? �ti_ |L UL4T@hi �@h�L�t @*|ih?@|��i �4T*i4i?|@|�L?tc |L

_i�?i tiUL?_ Lh_ih LT|�4@*�|)c @?_ |L _i�?i @? @�|L4@|�U 4i|�L_ Lu M@?_��_|�

U�L�Ui� ��h hit�*|t @hi ^�@*�|@|��i*) t�4�*@h |L |�Lti _i�i*LTi_ �? �@hhL** @?_ O�@h_*i

E�bHb� @?_ O�@h_*ic O@h|c �@hhL? @?_ At)M@!L� E�bb2� uLh hi*@|i_ ti4�T@h@4i|h�U

ThLM*i4t� OL�i�ihc �i i |i?_ |�i @?@*)t�t �? ti�ih@* _�hiU|�L?t� 6�ht|*)c �i ThL�i

|�@| L�h |h�?U@|i_ i T@?t�L?t @hi i^�@* �? _�t|h�M�|�L? |L |�i Lh�}�?@* t|@|�t|�U |L

Lh_ih ?32>c hi}�*@h�|) |�@| �t uhi^�i?|*) it|@M*�t�i_ �? |�i ,_}i�Lh|� @TThL �4@|�L?

*�|ih@|�hi � tii +L|�i?Mih} E�bHe@� @?_ +LM�?tL? E�bHH@� � @?_ ���U� Tih4�|t _�t�

|h�M�|�L?@* @TThL �4@|�L? Lu |�i ,_}i�Lh|� |)Tic tii w�?|L? E�bb2� uLh tL4i hit�*|t

�? |��t _�hiU|�L?� i @*tL _i4L?t|h@|i |�@| L�h M@?_��_|� ti*iU|�L? 4i|�L_ ?L| L?*)

hit�*|t �? @s? UL?t�t|i?| it|�4@|Lh Lu qc M�| L?i |�@| �t tiUL?_ Lh_ih LT|�4@*�

5iU|�L? 2 _�tU�ttit |�i it|�4@|Lh @?_ |it| t|@|�t|�Utc ���*i tiU|�L? � }��it |�i

@tt�4T|�L?t� 5iU|�L? e ��t|��it |�i i T@?t�L?tc ���*i tiU|�L? D }��it |�i tiUL?_ Lh_ih

4L4i?| @TThL �4@|�L?t uLh |�i ^�@?|�|�it Lu �?|ihit|� 5iU|�L? S �tit |�i tiUL?_ Lh_ih

@TThL �4@|�L?t |L _i�?i @ ui@t�M*i ULhhiU|�L? |L |�i t|@?_@h_ ihhLhtc ���*i �? tiU|�L?

. �i _i�i*LT @ tiUL?_ Lh_ih LT|�4@*�|) |�iLh)� 5iU|�L? H hiTLh|t |�i hit�*|t Lu @ t4@**

t�4�*@|�L? i Tih�4i?|� 5iU|�L? b }��it L�h 4@�? UL?U*�t�L?t� A�i �TTi?_� UL?|@�?t

|�i ThLLut Lu @** |�iLhi4t�

� �Lh_ L? ?L|@|�L?� i �ti , |L _i?L|i UL?�ih}i?Ui �? _�t|h�M�|�L?c�$ 4i@?t

Page 6: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

D

UL?�ih}i?Ui �? ThLM@M�*�|)c ���*i |�i t)4ML* � _i?L|it @t)4T|L|�U i^���@*i?Ui �?

ThLM@M�*�|)c @** �L*_�?} @t ? $ 4�

2� ,5AW��AW��

wi| |�i LMtih�i_ _@|@ iEt A� c ~A

� �Aj?�'�c ��ihi t� ' E+��c +2�c ��c +(n���

A � E+��c tA2� �

A c

Mi }i?ih@|i_ M)

+�� ' qAt2� n wE~�� n "� ( +_� ' }_E~�� n #_�c _ ' 2c �c ��c ( n �c E��

��ihi q �t @ ( M) � �iU|Lh Lu �?!?L�? T@h@4i|iht @?_ ~� �t @ � M) � �iU|Lh Lu

LMtih�@M*i hi}hittLhtc ���*i "� @?_ #_� @hi 4i@? 3ihL UL?_�|�L?@* L? E~A� c t

A2� �

A @?_

~� hitTiU|��i*)� 5�M|h@U|�?} |�i UL?_�|�L?@* E}��i? ~� 4i@?t uhL4 ML|� t�_it Lu Eqq�c

�i LM|@�? |�i hi}hitt�L? i^�@|�L? Eqq�� wi| D� ' +���}�E~��c ��|� }�E~�� ' .d+��m~�oc

@?_ #� ' E#2�c #��c ��c #(n���A � i i @4�?i |�i ThLTih|�it Lu |�i ui@t�M*i *i@t| t^�@hit

it|�4@|Lh

eq ' d?3�?[�'�

e#�e#A� o3�d?3� ?[�'�

e#�eD�o � 73�e#e# 7e#eDc Ee�

Lu qc ��ihi |�i hit�_�@*t eD� ' +�� � e}�E~�� @?_ e#_� ' +_� � e}_E~��c _ ' 2c ��c( n �c @hi

_ih��i_ uhL4 ?L?T@h@4i|h�U it|�4@|it e}_ Lu }_� O�@h_*i @?_ w�?|L? E�bbe� hi��i�t @

?�4Mih Lu t��|@M*i ?L?T@h@4i|h�U hi}hitt�L? it|�4@|Lht� i it|�4@|i |�i hi}hitt�L?

u�?U|�L?t M) |�i *LU@* TL*)?L4�@* hi}hitt�L? 4i|�L_ t�}}it|i_ �? 5|L?i E�b..� @?_

u�h|�ih i @4�?i_ �? 6@? E�bb2�� W| �t 4L|��@|i_ M) |�i uL**L��?} @h}�4i?|�

wi| �� ' E� f� c ��A� c ��c � ^3�A� �A UL?|@�? @** T@h|�@* _ih��@|��it Lu |�i }i?ih�U hi}hitt�L?

u�?U|�L? } @| |�i TL�?| ~� ' E~��c ��c ~�� �A �T |L Lh_ih ^� �c ��|�c �? T@h|�U�*@hc � f� '

}E~�� @?_ � �� ' EY}*Y~��c ��c Y}*Y~�� �A � W? |L|@* |�ihi @hi 6o '

So�'f

� -�-E�3��- _�t|�?U|

Page 7: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

S

o�|� Lh_ih T@h|�@* _ih��@|��it tL |�@| �� �t @?6 'S^3�

o'f6o M) � �iU|Lh� A�i u�?U|�L? }

U@? Mi i T@?_i_ �? @ ^<|� Lh_ih A@)*Lh tih�it tL |�@| uLh ~� �? @ ?i�}�ML�h�LL_ Q E~��

Lu ~�c }E~�� � �A� %��c ��ihi %�� ' E%f��c %�A�� c ��c %

^3�A�� �A UL?|@�?t |�i ULhhitTL?_�?}

A@)*Lh ULi�U�i?|t ��|�c �? T@h|�U�*@hc %f�� ' � @?_ %��� ' E~�� � ~��c ��c ~�� � ~�� �A �

A��t t�}}it|t it|�4@|�?} �� M) @ *i@t| t^�@hit hi}hitt�L? Lu +� L? %��c uLh ~� 5 Q E~���

W? u@U|c �i it|�4@|i �� � _L�?��i�}�|�?} LMtih�@|�L?t @UULh_�?} |L |�i�h _�t|@?Ui

uhL4 ~�c @?_c uLh UL?�i?�i?Uic *i@��?} L�| |�i �<|� UL?|h�M�|�L? Etii +LM�?tL? E�bH.�

uLh @ _�tU�tt�L? Lu |��t 4L_��U@|�L?� � M)

e�� ' EfA� g�f��

3�fA� g�+c ED�

��|� + ' E+�c +2c ��c +?�A |�i }i?ih�U _iTi?_i?| �@h�@M*i @?_ f� ' E%��c �c fc �c %�?�

A |�i

? M) 6 _@|@ 4@|h� ��|� %�� hiT*@Ui_ M) @ 3ihL �iU|Lhc ���*i g� �t |�i ? M) ? _�@}L?@*

�i�}�|�?} 4@|h� ��|� �<|� i*i4i?| 3ihL @?_ �<|� UL4TL?i?| &EE~� � ~��*��� Oihic

&E�� �t @ ��_�4i?t�L?@* ThLM@M�*�|) _i?t�|) u�?U|�L? @?_ �E?� �t @ tU@*@h M@?_��_|��

�*i@h*)c e�� �t *�?i@h �? i+�j?�'� c @?_ �? T@h|�U�*@h

e}E~�� '[� �'�

���+�c � ' �c 2c ��c ?c ES�

��ihi i���j?�'� �t @ ti^�i?Ui Lu ?L?�t|LU�@t|�U �i�}�|tc LM|@�?i_ uhL4 Eqq�� A��t U*@tt

Lu it|�4@|Lht �t i@t) |L UL4T�|i @?_ �?U*�_it |�i �@_@h@)@� @|tL? it|�4@|Lh � �ti_

M) +LM�?tL? E�bHHM� � @t @ tTiU�@* U@ti E��i? ^ ' ��� A�i hL*i Lu ^ �t t�4�*@h |L |�@|

Lu !ih?i* Lh_ih �? |�i ��}�ih Lh_ih !ih?i* 4i|�L_ Lu �@h|*i|| E�bS��G |�i TL�?|��ti

M�@t Lu e}E~�� �t Lu Lh_ih �^ � tii wi44@ � Mi*L�� 6�h|�ih4Lhic |�i �?|ih�Lh M�@t _Lit

?L| _iTi?_ L? |�i _it�}? _i?t�|) E�| �t _it�}? @_@T|��i�c ���*i |�ihi �t @? @�|L4@|�U

ULhhiU|�L? uLh ML�?_@h) M�@tc tii 6@? @?_ B��Mi*t E�bb2� uLh @ _�tU�tt�L?�

Page 8: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

.

�� �55N��AW��5

��� A�i � i_ hi}hittLht i~�j?�'� �@�i @t |�i�h t�TTLh| @ ML�?_i_ _L4@�? C � W+� �

6�h|�ih4Lhic |�ihi i �t|t @ TLt�|��i _i?t�|) u�?U|�L? s t�U� |�@|

?3�?[�'�

�E~�� $]�E~�sE~�_~c

uLh @?) ML�?_i_ UL?|�?�L�t u�?U|�L? �E���

A�i � i_ ML�?_i_ _it�}? @tt�4T|�L? �t 4@_i uLh |iU�?�U@* UL?�i?�i?Ui( �| @**L�t

�t |L @�L�_ |�i �ti Lu |h�44�?} u@U|Lht Et�U� @t �? +LM�?tL? E�bHHM�� |�@| @hi ?iUit�

t@h) ��i? |�i _i?L4�?@|Lh Lu ��� }i|t @hM�|h@h�*) t4@**� ��h |�iLhi4t @hi @*tL |h�i uLh

|h�@?}�*@h @hh@) _it�}?t t�U� @t ~?� ' �*?c �? ���U� U@ti sE~� ' dUC _~o3�WE~ 5 C�c

��ihi WE�� �t |�i �t�@* �?_�U@|Lh u�?U|�L?c M�| �i �@�i ?L| i T*�U�|*) �?U*�_i_ |��t TLt�

t�M�*�|) |L @�L�_ ?L|@|�L?@* �?UL?�i?�i?Ui� A�i � i_ _it�}? @tt�4T|�L? �t uhi^�i?|*)

i4T*L)i_ �? |�i ?L?T@h@4i|h�U hi}hitt�L? *�|ih@|�hi � tii uLh i @4T*i ���**ih E�bHH�

@?_ O�@h_*i E�bbf�� �tt�4T|�L? �� _Lit ?L| ThiU*�_i i~�j?�'� uhL4 �@��?} Mii? }i?�

ih@|i_ M) tL4i h@?_L4 4iU�@?�t4� 6Lh i @4T*ic t�TTLti |�@| ~� �ihi ��_ ��|�

_i?t�|) sc |�i?

�hd?3�S?

�'� �E~�� $ U�E~�sE~�_~o ' �c

tii �?_hi�t E�bb�@�� W? |��t U@tic �i U@? �?|ihThi| L�h @?@*)t�t @t Mi�?} UL?_�|�L?@*

L? i~�j?�'� c @?_ L�h hit�*|t EA�iLhi4t ��e Mi*L�� �L*_�?} ��|� ThLM@M�*�|) L?i�

�2� A�i ti^�i?Ui Lu �iU|Lht ��' E"�c #2�c ��c #(n���A @hi 4i@? 3ihL @?_ �?_iTi?_i?|c

���*i "� �t �?_iTi?_i?| Lu #� uLh @** �� wi| .d���A� o 'PE~��c ��ihi P '

3EC j2" f

f P##

4FD �

Page 9: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

H

A�i? PE~� �t ML�?_i_ @�@) uhL4 3ihL @?_ �?�?�|) L? C� 6�?@**)c @tt�4i |�@| uLh

tL4i �?|i}iht a @?_ u � Dc 7�R�.dm"�ma o 4 @?_ 7�R�.dm#�muo 4�

5TiU!4@? E�bHH� UL?_�|�L?t L? ML|� Et2c ~� @?_ UL?t�_iht L?*) tU@*@h _it�}?�

+LM�?tL? E�bHHM� i4T*L)t @ 4Lhi }i?ih@* ��_�4i?t�L?@* h@?_L4 _it�}?c ��ihi

Etc~� @hi ��_c ML|� ��|� �?ML�?_i_ t�TTLh|� ��h @tt�4T|�L? �2 Tih4�|t UL?_�|�L?@*

�i|ihL}i?i�|) ��|� hitTiU| |L ~ ���U� �@t ?L| @**L�i_ uLh �? |��t T@Tih� OL�i�ihc �i

t�@** tL4i|�4it �4TLti |�i uL**L��?} @tt�4T|�L? |�@| _�t@**L�t �i|ihLt!i_@t|�U�|)�

�2<� A�i ti^�i?Ui Lu �iU|Lht �� ' E"�c #2�c ��c #(n���A @hi �?_iTi?_i?| @?_ �_i?|��

U@**) _�t|h�M�|i_c ��|� 4i@? 3ihL @?_ UL�@h�@?Ui 4@|h� Pc ���*i "� �t �?_iTi?_i?| Lu

#�� 6�h|�ih4Lhic uLh tL4i a @?_ u : eG .dm"�ma o 4 @?_ .dm#�muo 4�

wi| J| Mi |�i U*@tt Lu @** |�|�4it _�gihi?|�@M*i u�?U|�L?t } _i�?i_ L? C ��Lti |<|�

_ih��@|��it t@|�tu) |�i uL**L��?} w�TtU��|3 UL?_�|�L?G |�ihi i �t|t i : f @?_ K 4c

t�U� |�@| uLh @** %c 5 5 C @?_ uLh @** r ' Er�c ��c r� �A ��|� r� n ��n r� � |c �i �@�i

m}Er�E5�� }Er�E%�m Km5 � %mic

��ihi }Er�E5� ' Yr�n��nr�Yr�5�Yr252��Yr� 5�

}E5��

��� A�i hi}hitt�L? u�?U|�L?t CE~�� ' E}�E~��c }2E~��c ��c }(n�E~���A � E}�E~��c C2E~��

A �A c @hi

@** 4i4Miht Lu J^c ��ihi ^ � 2� 6�h|�ih4Lhic sc P�, 5 J�c uLh �c* '�c2c�c#n��

6�?@**)c �i 4@!i @tt�4T|�L?t @ML�| |�i !ih?i* @?_ |�i M@?_��_|� ti^�i?Ui�

Page 10: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

b

�e� ?�e^ $ f @?_ ?�2� $ 4�

��h M@?_��_|� hit|h�U|�L?t @hi t�4�*@h |L |�Lti �? +LM�?tL? E�bHHM�c i UiT| |�@| ?L

|h�44�?} UL?t|@?| �t ?iUitt@h) _�i |L L�h @tt�4T|�L? |�@| C �t ML�?_i_�

�D� A�i !ih?i* & �@t ML�?_i_ t�TTLh| @?_ �@t L?i UL?|�?�L�t T@h|�@* _ih��@|��it

�? i@U� _�hiU|�L?� 6�h|�ih4Lhic |�i 4@|h�Uit

l?� ' ?3��3�M3�fA� g�f�M

3�

@hi TLt�|��i _i�?�|i ��|� t4@**it| i�}i?�@*�it ML�?_i_ @�@) uhL4 3ihLc ��ihi M '

_�@}iMfc M�c ��c M^3�j �t @? 6 M) 6 _�@}L?@* tU@*�?} 4@|h� ��|� M� @ tU@*@h 6� M)

6� 4@|h� ��|� _�@}L?@* i*i4i?| ��c � ' fc �c ��c ^ � ��

�t ? $ 4c l?� $ sE~��lc ��ihi l �t @ 4@|h� ��Lti i*i4i?|t @hi |�i 4L4i?|t Lu

|�i !ih?i* &� w�?_t@) E�bHb� t�L�i_c �? |�i tTiU�@* U@ti � ' �c |�@| l �t TLt�|��i

_i�?�|i �u &E|� |@!it @| *i@t| ^ � � _�t|�?U| �@*�itc ���U� �L�*_ Mi t@|�t�i_ M) @?)

UL?|�?�L�t !ih?i*�

Page 11: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�f

A�i ThLTih|�it Lu |�i *LU@* TL*)?L4�@* it|�4@|Lhc @| ML|� �?|ih�Lh @?_ ML�?_@h)

TL�?|tc @hi _itUh�Mi_ �? |�i uL**L��?}G

w,��� � E6@? E�bb2c A�iLhi4 �� @?_ +�TTih| @?_ `@?_ E�bb2c A�iLhi4 e�2��

wi| j2E~�� ' T @oE+�m~�� uLh tU@*@h +�c @?_ t�TTLti ����D @hi t@|�t�i_� A�i?c @t

? $ 4c

.de��o� �� � �^G^&�� ( T @ode��o ' j2E~��?

3��3�M3�l3�?� [?�l

3�?� M

3�c

��ihi [?� ' ?3��3�M3�f�g2� f�M

3� @?_ l?� @hi �E��c ���*i

G^&�� ' M3�l3�

?�

Sr�n��nr�'^ }

Er�E~��/Er�?�

/Er�?� ' ?3��3�M3�fA

� g�dT�R'�E

~�R3~�R�

�rRc ��cT�R'�E

~?R3~�R�

�rR oA ' �E���

e� �5v��A�AW� ,j���5W��5

+LM�?tL? E�bHHM� }��it �ih) }i?ih@* UL?_�|�L?t �?_ih ���U� eq �t E�ht| Lh_ih�

@t)4T|L|�U@**) i^���@*i?| |L |�i �?ui@t�M*i *i@t| t^�@hit it|�4@|Lh q |�@| t@|�t�its?SA Eq � q� , �Efc j2� uLh @?) ( M) � �iU|Lh Sc ��ihi j2 ' SAP

3�##P##""P

3�## S �t |�i

�t�@* �@h�@?Ui Lu |�i *i@t| t^�@hit it|�4@|Lh �?_ih �i|ihLt!i_@t|�U�|)c _i�?i_ |�hL�}�

?3�S?

�'� #�#A�

�$ P## @?_ ?3�S?

�'� #�#A� "

2�

�$ P##""� i �?�it|�}@|i |�i ��}�ih Lh_ih

ThLTih|�it Lu eq _i�?i_ �? Eqq� @?_ Eqq� M) @t)4T|L|�U i T@?t�L?t� i @*tL i @4�?i

|�i ThLTih|�it Lu @ t|@?_@h_ ihhLh it|�4@|Lh @?_ Lu @ t|�_i?|�ti_ t|@|�t|�U �? |�i tTiU�@*

Page 12: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

��

U@ti Lu �L4Lt!i_@t|�U ihhLht� W? |��t U@tic |�i @t)4T|L|�U �@h�@?Ui Lus?SA E eq�q� �t

j2 ' j2" SAP3�

## Sc ��ihi j2" ' .d"2� o @?_ P## ' .d#�#

A� o� i it|�4@|i P## M) 7e#e# @?_ j2"

M) ej2" ' 7h0h0 ' ?3�S?

�'� h02� c ��ihi h0� ' eD� � eqA e#�� 6Lh UL?�i?�i?Uic �i hiTLh| hit�*|tuLh |�i tU@*@h t|@?_@h_�ti_ ^�@?|�|�it A '

s?SA E eq � q�*jc 7 '

s?Eej � j�*jc @?_

` 's?SA E eq�q�*ej � �? �4TLh|@?| tTiU�@* U@ti �ihi �t ��ihi S ' Efc ��c fc �c fc ��c f�A

�? ���U� U@ti` U@? Mi �ti_ |L |it| uLh |�i �?_���_�@* t�}?��U@?Ui Lu |�i ULhhitTL?_�?}

T@h@4i|ih it|�4@|i�

�) @ A@)*Lh i T@?t�L? �i �@�i

A ' j3�SAP3�##f� � SAP

3�##f(P

3�##f�

js?

nSAP

3�##f(P

3�##f(P

3�##f�

j?n

-

?s?� A Wn-A c

E.�

��ihi f� ' ?3�*2S?

�'� e#�e"�c ��|� e0� ' eD��qA e#�c @?_ f( 's?E7e#e#�P##� @hi tiUL?_

Lh_ih �i�}�|i_ N�t|@|�t|�Ut � tii wii E�bbf� � ��Lti ThLTih|�it @hi u�h|�ih _�tU�tti_

�? |�i @TTi?_� c ���*i

- ' �j3�SA73�e#e# f(P3�##f(P

3�##f(P

3�##f� � EH�

A�i 4L4i?|t Lu |�i |h�?U@|i_ t|@|�t|�U A W _iTi?_ L? |�i M@?_��_|� �G �? T@h�

|�U�*@hc .dA Wo ' �Es?�2^�c ���*i T @odA Wo ' � n �E?3��3� �� A��tc |�i @t)4T|L|�U

4i@? t^�@hi_ ihhLh Lu eqc�7.E�� � ?3�i� n�E?3��3� � n�E?�e^�jc

�t 4�?�4�3i_ M) U�LLt�?} @ M@?_��_|� �E?� ' �E?3Z�c ��ihi Z ' 2*Ee^ n � �c �?

���U� U@ti @ ULhhiU|�L? |L |�i tiUL?_ 4L4i?| Lu A W Lu Lh_ih ?32> hit�*|tc ��ihi

>' Ee^�� �*2Ee^n� �� A��t M@?_��_|� M@*@?Uit |�i Lh_ih Lu 4@}?�|�_i Lu �@h�@?Ui

@?_ t^�@hi_ M�@t ULhhiU|�L?t tL |�@| �E?�e^� ' �E?3��3� � ' �E?32>� E��i? � ' �

@?_ ^ ' 2c Z ' 2*b @?_ > ' .*�H�� 6�h|�ih4Lhic -A ' J� E?32>��

Page 13: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�2

W? |�i ?i | tiU|�L? �i U@*U�*@|i @TThL �4@|�L?t |L |�i 4L4i?|t Lu A Wc ���U�

�i t�@** �?|ihThi| @t @TThL �4@|�L?t |L |�i <4L4i?|t< Lu A� A��t 4i|�L_L*L}) �@t

@ *L?} |h@_�|�L? Lu @TT*�U@|�L? �? iUL?L4i|h�U ThLM*i4t uL**L��?} �@}@h E�bDb� �tii |�i hiuihi?Uit �? +L|�i?Mih} E�bHe@�� `�i? 7�R?.dA 2o 4c �i i TiU| |�@|

.dA 2o ' .dA W2o n JE?32>�c ThL��_i_ -A ' J� E?32>�c M�| tii 5h�?@�@t@? E�b.f� uLh @

U@�|�L?@h) |@*i �? |��t hi}@h_� A�iti UL?_�|�L?t @hi t@|�t�i_ �? |�i ThLM*i4t i @4�?i_

�? �@hhL** @?_ O�@h_*i E�bHb� @?_ O�@h_*ic O@h|c �@hhL? @?_ At)M@!L� E�bb2�c M�|

?L| �ihi � Ac 7c @?_ ` _L ?L| ?iUitt@h�*) �@�i �?�uLh4*) ML�?_i_ 4L4i?|t� W?

|��t U@tic tL4i @__�|�L?@* ��t|��U@|�L? uLh i @4�?�?} |�i 4L4i?|t Lu |�i |h�?U@|i_

t|@|�t|�U 4�t| Mi }��i?� i it|@M*�t� |�i t|hL?}ih hi}�*@h�|) |�@| A @?_ A W �@�i |�i

t@4i _�t|h�M�|�L? |L Lh_ih ?32> Et�4�*@h �iht�L?t Lu |��t hit�*| U@? @*tL Mi LM|@�?i_

uLh 7 @?_ ` �� A�ihiuLhic L�h 4L4i?| @TThL �4@|�L?t U@? Mi �?|ihThi|i_ @t |�i

4L4i?|t Lu |�i @TThL �4@|�?} _�t|h�M�|�L?�

e�� 5iUL?_ �h_ih �TThL �4@|�L? uLh A

W? |�i @TTi?_� �i LM|@�?

AO,�+,� �� �tt�4i |�@| ����D �L*_c ��|� a @?_ u: �� � �@%i�2c �2>*E��e>�jc ��ihi > ' Ee^ � � �*2Ee^ n � �c @?_ *i| �E?� ' �E?3Z�c ��ihi Z ' 2*Ee^ n � ��

A�i?c E���� A @?_ A W �@�i |�i t@4i _�t|h�M�|�L? |L Lh_ih ?32>c E��2� 7�R?.dA W2o 4c

@?_

E���� .dA Wo 's?�2^E n JE?3>� ( T @odA Wo ' � n ?3��3�Y n JE?32>�c

��ihi |�i �E�� ^�@?|�|�it E @?_ Y @hi

E ' j3�SAP3�## l

#w^ ( Y ' j32SAP

3�## i

?[�'�

j2" E~��P##E~��[� �'�

?��42��jP3�## Sc Eb�

Page 14: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

��

��|� 4�� ' ?3�*2dS

& �'�c& �'��&��&� � 2���o @?_ l#w^ ' ?3�S?

�'�h��Ew� h��EC2�c ��ihi uLh

@?) u�?U|�L? } 5 J^c

h��E}� � �3^d[� �'�

���}E~��� }E~��o ' �E���

+,��+kG `�i? > �S*Hfc �� ' �2c L|�ih��ti ��}�ih 4L4i?|t @hi hi^��hi_�

+,��+kG A�i ?L?T@h@4i|h�U hit�_�@*t e#� @?_ eD� @hi ?L| 3ihL 4i@? �? }i?ih@*�

A��t t�}}it|t |�@| L?i 4@) ��t� |L �ti hiUi?|hi_ hit�_�@*t �? |�i �?@* t|@}i hi}hit�

t�L? Eqq�� 5�4�*@h tiUL?_ Lh_ih 4L4i?| @TThL �4@|�L?t �L*_ uLh |�i �?|ihUiT| �w5

it|�4@|Lh� W? |��t U@tic |�i �@h�@?Ui �t |�i t@4i @t �? A�iLhi4 �c M�| |�i M�@t �?�

�L*�it |�i <_i4i@?i_< U�h�@|�hi 4i@t�hit � ��i� �i �ti |�i uLh4�*@i Lu A�iLhi4 �

M�| hiT*@Ui l#w^ M) l#w^ � lw^ l#^ c ��ihi l#^ ' ?3�

S?�'�

h��EC2� @?_ lw^ ' ?3�S?

�'�h��Ew��

W? 4@?) U@titc �?U*�_�?} @? �?|ihUiT| ��** hit�*| �? @? �4ThL�i4i?| Lu |�i M�@tc tii

Eqq� Mi*L��

�) wi44@ �c �i U@? u�h|�ih @TThL �4@|i h��E}� M) G^&}E~��c E|�i �ht| i*i4i?| Lu

G^&���c ���U� �t @ *�?i@h UL4M�?@|�L? Lu |�i ^�|� Lh_ih T@h|�@* _ih��@|��it Lu } �i�}�|i_

M) u�?U|�L?@*t Lu |�i !ih?i*� �L?t�_ih |�i tTiU�@* U@ti ��ihi �� @hi �L4Lt!i_@t�

|�U @?_ |�i *LU@* *�?i@h ThLUi_�hi �t �ti_ �? it|�4@|�?} C� W? |��t U@tic G^&}E~�� '

k2�E&�}

��E~��*ec @?_c ��i? S ' � @?_ C ' dfc �oc

.dA Wo � s?�ek2

�E&�

Uw��E~�}��2E~�sE~�_~

ej"j#( T @odA Wo � � n ?3��3�k2E&W�c E�f�

��ihi &WE|� ' &�&E|��2&E|� �t |�i <|��Ui_< !ih?i* �? ���U� & �&E|� ' U&E|�r�&Er�_r

�t |�i UL?�L*�|�L? Lu & ��|� �|ti*uc ���*i |�i !ih?i* UL?t|@?|t k�E&� 'U|2&E|�_|

Page 15: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�e

@?_ k2E&� 'U&2E|�_| @hi ML|� TLt�|��i� A�iti UL?t|@?|t U@? Mi U@*U�*@|i_ ^��|i

hi@_�*) uLh 4Lt| uhi^�i?|*) �ti_ !ih?i*t &c tii w�?|L? E�bb��G uLh |�i ^�@_h@|�U !ih?i*

&E|� ' �eE�� |2�WEm|m ��c k� ' f�2 @?_ k2 ' f�H�D� �L� t�TTLti |�@| |�i t�}?@* |L

?L�ti h@|�Lt w��E~�*j" @?_ }��2E~�*j# @hi UL?t|@?| @?_ i^�@* |L B� @?_ B2 hitTiU|��i*)c

���U� �t UL?t�t|i?| ��|� hi}hitt�L? u�?U|�L?t Lu |�i uLh4 }E~� ' B�~2*2 @?_ P Mi�?}

tU@*@h� i UL4T�|i_ |�i�7. @| @ h@?}i Lu M@?_��_|�t uLh t@4T*i t�3i ? ' �ff �t�?}

ML|� Eqq�c ��|� h��E}( �� @?_ YE�� ' S?�'�

S� �'� ?�42�� ���U� �i U@** �i @U|�c @?_ |�i

@t)4T|L|�U @TThL �4@|�L? Eqq�� 6�}�hit ��e _�tT*@) |�i�7. T*L||i_ @}@�?t| *?E�� �tii �@hhL? @?_ @?_ E�bb2� uLh @ _�tU�tt�L? Lu ��) |�i *L}�tU@*i �t 4Lhi @TThLTh�@|i

� uLh uL�h _�gihi?| UL?�}�h@|�L?t Lu B� @?_ B2� A�ihi �t @ _�gihi?Ui Mi|�ii? |�i |�L

@TThL �4@|�L?t uLh *@h}i M@?_��_|�t( �L�i�ihc ML|� �?_�U@|i 4L_it| t4@** t@4T*i

igiU|t uLh M@?_��_|�t ?i@h |�i LT|�4�4c @*|�L�}� �u M@?_��_|� �t U�Lti? TLLh*) |�i

ULt| U@? Mi i Uitt��i�

� � � 6�}t �� e �ihi � � �

� �@*�i Lu B� ' 2f tii4t ^��|i i |hi4i |L �tc @?_ �L�*_ Uih|@�?*) Mi �ih) ThL?L�?Ui_

�? |�i _@|@� i |�ihiuLhi uii* |�@| @| *i@t| uLh tU@*@h ~c |�i t4@** t@4T*i ThLTih|�it

Lu eq t�L�*_ Mi @UUiT|@M*i �?*itt @? i |hi4i M@?_��_|� �t U�Lti?�

e�2� 5iUL?_ �h_ih �TThL �4@|�L? uLh 5 @?_ `

i ?L� UL?t�_ih |�i ThLTih|�it Lu |�i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh it|�4@|i @?_ |it| t|@|�t|�U

�? |�i tTiU�@* U@ti ��ihi |�i ihhLht @hi �L4Lt!i_@t|�U� 5|@?_@h_ ihhLh it|�4@|it U@?

Mi �ih) TLLh*) Mi�@�i_ �? �?�|i t@4T*it i�i? �? t�|�@|�L?t ��ihi *LU@* t4LL|��?} �t

?L| i4T*L)i_c @t ��it�ih @?_ ai��|| E�bH.� �@�i ^�@?|��i_� i ThLUii_ @t uLh A

|L 4@!i @ t|LU�@t|�U i T@?t�L? uLh 7( M�| �? |��t U@tic t�?Ui �i L?*) it|@M*�t� Lh_ih

�? ThLM@M�*�|) ThLTih|�it Lu |�i hi4@�?_ihc �i L?*) UL**iU| |ih4t |�@| @hi *@h}ih |�@?

�� E?3��� A��t hit�*|t �?

Page 16: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�D

7 'I?Eej2"3j2" �2j2"

nSA

I?E73�## 3P3�## �S2SAP3�## S

� dI?Eej2"3j2" �o2Hje"

I?

� dSAI?E73�## 3P3�## �So2

HdSAP3�## So2I?

ndSA

I?E73�## 3P3�## �Sod

I?Eej2"3j2" �o

ej2I?

n�� E?3��c

E���

�L� *i| 7W Mi |�i |h�?U@|i_ t|@|�t|�U LM|@�?i_ @u|ih �t�?} |�i u�h|�ih @TThL �4@|�L?tG

s?E73�

## �P3�## � ' �P3�

##f(P3�## n

P3�##f(P3�##f(P

3�##I

?n�� E?

3��s?Eej2" � j2" � ' fT � 2

I?Eeq3q�Af�I

?n

I?Eeq3q�AP##I?Eeq3q�I

?n�� E?

3��c

��ihi fT 's?E7e0e0 � j20� ��|� e0� ' ev� � qA e#� ' h0� n �I

?

s?E eq � q�A e#��

A�i uL**L��?} |�iLhi4 ThL��_it tL4i �?uLh4@|�L? @ML�| |�i t4@** t@4T*i ThLT�

ih|�it Lu L�h ti4�T@h@4i|h�U t|@?_@h_ ihhLhtG

AO,�+,� 2� �tt�4i |�i t@4i UL?_�|�L?t @t �? A�iLhi4 �c i UiT| |�@| �2<

hiT*@Uit �2� A�i?c

.d7Wo 's?�2^d

lww^2j2"

� SAP3�## l

##^ P3�

## S

2SAP3�## S

o n JE?3>�c

��ihi lww^ ' ?3�S?

�'�dh��Ew�o

2 @?_ l##^ ' ?3�S?

�'�h��EC2� h��EC2�

A � Wuc �? @__�|�L?c ��

@hi t)44i|h�U@**) _�t|h�M�|i_ @ML�| 3ihLc |�i?

T @od7Wo ' r2d� n ?3��3�i?[�'�

[� �'�

?��42��jo n JE?32>�c

��ihi r2 ' �nEVe"nVe#W�*ec ��|� Ve" @?_ Ve#W Mi�?} |�i t|@?_@h_�ti_ uL�h|� U�4�*@?|t

Lu "� @?_ #W� � SAP3�## #��

W?|ihit|�?}*)c |�i @t)4T|L|�U M�@t Lu ej �t Lu |�i t@4i Lh_ih Lu 4@}?�|�_i @t |�@| Lueqc ��i� Lu Lh_ih ?3E>n�*2�c ���*i �|t _�hiU|�L? UL�*_ Mi �T�@h_ Lh _L�?�@h_ @UULh_�?}

|L |�i hi*@|��i 4@}?�|�_it Lu lww^ @?_ l##^ �

Page 17: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�S

�?_hi�t E�bHbM�c +LM�?tL? E�bHb�c 5|L!ih E�bHb� @?_ #i*}@_L @?_ 5|i?}Lt E�bbe�

it|@M*�t� |�i *�4�|�?} Mi�@��Lh Lu �@h�L�t ti4�T@h@4i|h�U |it|�?} ThLUi_�hit� A�i�h

t4@** t@4T*i ThLTih|�it �@�i Mii? �?�it|�}@|i_ M) 4L?|i U@h*L i Tih�4i?|@|�L?� OL��

i�ihc ?L }i?ih@* UL?U*�t�L? U@? Mi _h@�? uhL4 |��t @?@*)t�tG #i*}@_L @?_ 5|i?}Lt

E�bbe� �?_ @ |i?_i?U) |L�@h_t �?_ih�hi�iU|�L? �?_ih |�i ?�**c ���*i +LM�?tL? E�bHb�

�?_t ML|� �?_ih @?_ L�ih�hi�iU|�L? uLh _�gihi?| UL?�}�h@|�L?t� W? ML|� U@titc |�i

TL�ih @TTi@hi_ |L �@h) UL?t�_ih@M*) ��|� |�i 4L_i* T@h@4i|iht @t �i** @t ��|� M@?_�

��_|��

i ThL��_i @?@*)|�U@* hit�*|t |�@| Mi@h L? |�i t4@** t@4T*i Mi�@��Lh Lu |�i t|��

_i?|�ti_ t|@|�t|�U _itUh�Mi_ �? tiU|�L? 2c �?_ih |�i ?�** �)TL|�it�t |�@| q �t |�i |h�i

�@*�i� A�i t|�_i?|�ti_ t|@|�t|�U U@? Mi �h�||i? @t ` ' Ai� n ?3�*27j3�c @?_c i �T@?_�?} L�| |�i _i?L4�?@|Lh @?_ hiT*@U�?} A M) A Wc �i }i|

` ' A W � ?3�*2j3�SAP3�##f�7

W n�� E?3�� � ` W n�� E?

3���

A�i?c t�?Ui �J�df� c ?3�*2f�7

Wo ' JE?32>�c �i �@�i

AO,�+,� �� �tt�4i |�i t@4i UL?_�|�L?t @t �? A�iLhi4 �c i UiT| |�@| �2<

hiT*@Uit �2� A�i?c .d` Wo ' .dA Wo n JE?3>� @?_ T @od` Wo ' T @odA Wo n JE?32>��

Wu |�i |��h_ U�4�*@?|t Lu �� @hi 3ihLc |�i?c ThL��_i_ |�i 4L4i?|t i �t|c |�i t!i��

?itt Lu ML|� A W @?_ ` W E@t �i** @t ��}�ih U�4�*@?|t� @hi JE?32>�� W? |��t U@tic |�i

t�3i Lu |�i �)TL|�it�t |it| M@ti_ L? ` ��**c |L tiUL?_ Lh_ihc Mi *@h}i*) @giU|i_ M)

M@?_��_|� |�hL�}� |�i *LU@|�L? @giU| E|�i M�@t Lu eq�� #iT@h|�hit uhL4 ?L4�?@* t�3i

UL�*_ |@!i i�|�ih _�hiU|�L?c @?_ L?i 4@) �?_ L�ih Lh �?_ih�hi�iU|�L?t ��|� |��t ThL�

Ui_�hi� W? t�|�@|�L?t ��ihi |�i *LU@|�L? igiU| �t t4@** E��i� ��i? wE�� �t U*Lti |L

*�?i@h�c |�i tU@*i igiU| t�L�*_ _L4�?@|i @?_ |�i |it| t�L�*_ L�ih�hi�iU|�

Page 18: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�.

e��� �LhhiU|i_ 5|@?_@h_ ,hhLht

A�i uLh4�*@i Lu A�iLhi4 � U@? Mi �ti_ |L ULhhiU| |�i t|@?_@h_ ihhLht uLh |�i

t4@** t@4T*i igiU| Lu M@?_��_|�� W? |�i tTiU�@* U@ti Lu �L4Lt!i_@t|�U ihhLhtc |�i

@t)4T|L|�U �@h�@?Ui Lus?SA E eq � q� �t

hj2? ' j2d� n ?3��3�i[[� �'�

?��42��jo n JE?32>��

W? |��t U@tic �i hiUL44i?_ �t�?} |�i 4L_��i_ ^�@?|�|)

ejW ' ejd� n ?3��3� i[[� �'�

?��42��j*2o

@t t|@?_@h_ ihhLht uLh eq� 6hL4 A�iLhi4 2cs?Eej � j� ' [ n �� E?

3>�c ��ihi [ '

�� E��c @?_ |�ihiuLhi ej� hj?�?3�*2[ ' �� E?32>� @?_ ejW� hj?�?3�*2[ ' J� E?

32>��

W? |��t ti?tic |�i 4L_��i_ t|@?_@h_ ihhLh ThL��_it Mi||ih UL?�_i?Ui �?|ih�@*t� A�i

ULhhiU|�L? @4L�?|t |L _L�?} @ _i}hiit Lu uhii_L4 @_��t|4i?|c t�4�*@h �? tT�h�| |L

|�Lti _�tU�tti_ �? �?_hi�t E�bb�@��

A�i @t)4T|L|�U M�@t Lu eq U@? @*tL Mi it|�4@|i_ uhL4 |�i uLh4�*@ }��i? �? A�iLhi4

�� A��t �?uLh4@|�L? U@? Mi �ti_ |L @_��t| UL?�_i?Ui t|@|i4i?|t @ML�| eq @?_ |L t�3i

@_��t| |�i |it| t|@|�t|�Uc |�hL�}� ,_}i�Lh|� |)Ti @TThL �4@|�L?t @t �? +L|�i?Mih}

E�bHeU� � tii �@�@?@}� E�bHb� @?_ w�?|L? E�bb2�� OL�i�ihc 4i@t�h�?} |�i *LU@|�L?

igiU| hi^��hit it|�4@|�L? Lu |�i ��}�ih _ih��@|��it Lu |�i hi}hitt�L? u�?U|�L?t� W?

Th@U|�Uic �| 4@) Mi _it�h@M*i |L T�ht�i @ t|h@|i}) |�@| 4�?�4�tit |�i igiU| Lu M�@t L?

�?uihi?Ui� Wu eC �ihi t��U�i?|*) �?_ih t4LL|�i_c ��i� �?Z $ fc |�i @t)4T|L|�U M�@t Lueq 4@) Mi |hi@|i_ @t ?i}*�}�M*i� W? |��t U@tic ejW t�L�*_ ThL��_i �i** Ui?|hi_ UL?�_i?Ui

�?|ih�@*t� A��t t|h@|i}) �t i4T*L)i_ �? 4@?) @TT*�U@|�L?t Lu ?L?T@h@4i|h�U 4i|�L_t

� tii uLh i @4T*i ��ihi?t @?_ �L||���|ih E�bbf� @?_ �@?!tc �*�?_i** @?_ wi�Mi*

E�bb2��

Page 19: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�H

D� 5,���# �+#,+ ��AW��wWAv ��# ���#`W#AO �O�W�,

W? |��t tiU|�L?c �i _i�i*LT @? LT|�4@*�|) |�iLh) uLh it|�4@|Lht Lu q �t�?} L�h

tiUL?_ Lh_ih 4L4i?| @TThL �4@|�L?t� i @*tL t�}}it| @ ui@t�M*i 4i|�L_ uLh @||@�?�?}

|�i LT|�4@* TihuLh4@?Ui�

wi| [E^c � � _i?L|i |�i U*@tt Lu ti4�T@h@4i|h�U *i@t| t^�@hit it|�4@|Lht Lu q M@ti_

L? |�i *LU@* TL*)?L4�@* hi}hitt�L? tU�i4i Lu Lh_ih ^ ��|� @ M@?_��_|� ti^�i?Ui Lu

|�i uLh4 �E?� ' �?3Zc uLh @?) � : f� A�i LT|�4@* it|�4@|Lh ��|��? [ i4T*L)t

�f ' �f?3Zc ��ihi

�f ' E�Y*e^E2��*Ee^n� �c E�2�

�? ���U� U@tic |L @ tiUL?_ Lh_ih @TThL �4@|�L?c

�7.E�� � ?3�q� n ?32>dEe^*� �3e^*Ee^n� � n Ee^*� ��*Ee^n� �oE2�*Ee^n� �Ye^*Ee^n� �

r�

E���

A��t �t @ *L�ih ML�?_ uLh @** it|�4@|Lht ��|��? [�

i i @4�?i Eqq� @?_ Eqq� �? |�i tTiU�@* U@ti _itUh�Mi_ �? 5iU|�L? Dc @?_ uLh

t�4T*�U�|) |@!i B� ' B2 ' B� W? 6�}t D @?_ S Mi*L� �i }h@T� �f @?_ Eqq� @t u�?U|�L?t

Lu B uLh ti�ih@* t@4T*i t�3itG

� � � 6�}t D� S �ihi � � �

,�i? uLh �ih) *@h}i Bc |�i LT|�4@* �7. �t ?L| 4�U� @ML�i �|t @t)4T|L|�U �@*�i�

A��t t�}}it|t |�ihi 4@) Mi UL?t�_ih@M*i �Lh|� �? }i||�?} �? @ ?i�}�ML�h�LL_ Lu |�i

LT|�4@* M@?_��_|� ��i? B �t *@h}i�

Page 20: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�b

A�i LT|�4@* M@?_��_|� �t ?L| ui@t�M*ic t�?Ui �f _iTi?_t L? |�i �?!?L�? ^�@?�

|�|�it C @?_ P� A�ihi @hi ?�4ihL�t |iU�?�^�it uLh @�|L4@|�U M@?_��_|� U�L�Ui �?

|�i ?L?T@h@4i|h�U *�|ih@|�hi � tii O�@h_*i E�bbf� @?_ aL?itc �@hhL?c @?_ 5�i@|�ih

E�bb2� uLh hi��i�t �? |�i UL?|i | Lu ?L?T@h@4i|h�U hi}hitt�L? @?_ _i?t�|) it|�4@|�L?

hitTiU|��i*)� �@?) @TT*�i_ t|�_�it �ti @ uLh4 Lu UhLtt��@*�_@|�L?c �? ���U� � �t U�Lti?

|L 4�?�4�ti @ t��|@M*i Uh�|ih�L? u�?U|�L? t�U� @t @ E*i@�i�L?i�L�|� *i@t| t^�@hit Uh�|i�

h�L? E5|LU! E�bb�� @?_ ,?}*i i| @* E�bHS�� Lh @ Tti�_L�*�!i*��LL_ E+LM�?tL? E�bb�@��

W? ?L?T@h@4i|h�U hi}hitt�L? @?_ _i?t�|) it|�4@|�L? |��t 4i|�L_ }��it |�i LT|�4@*

M@?_��_|� ��i? ��_}i_ M) @? @t)4T|L|�U E�?|i}h@|i_� �7. ihhLh Uh�|ih�L? � tii

O@** E�bH���

6Lh ti4�T@h@4i|h�U ThLM*i4tc ui� t�U� LT|�4@*�|) hit�*|t i �t|�+LM�?tL? E�bb�@�

t�L�t L?*) |�@| �t�?} @ UhLtt��@*�_@|i_ M@?_��_|� _Lit ?L| @giU| |�i �ht| Lh_ih *�4�

�|�?} _�t|h�M�|�L?� W? L�h U@tic |�i LT|�4@* M@?_��_|�t uLh it|�4@|�?} q @?_ uLh

it|�4@|�?} C @hi Lu _�gihi?| Lh_iht Lu 4@}?�|�_i( |�ihiuLhic |�i M@?_��_|� ti*iU|i_

M) UhLtt��@*�_@|�L? ��** Mi |�i �hL?} Lh_ih Lu 4@}?�|�_i� i UL?t�_ih @? @*|ih?@|��i

4i|�L_ � |�i T*�}��?� A��t UL?t�t|t Lu |�L t|@}itG �ht|*)c �f �t it|�4@|i_ UL?t�t�

|i?|*) M) e�f t@)c @?_ |�i? e�f?3Z _i�?it |�i ��?_L� �ti_ |L it|�4@|i q �? @ �?@*

t|@}i� A��t 4i|�L_ �@t i4T*L)i_ M) O�@h_*ic O@h|c �@hhL?c @?_ At)M@!L� E�bb2� uLhs? UL?t�t|i?| ti4�T@h@4i|h�U it|�4@|Lht Lu @�ih@}i _ih��@|��it�

i ?L� _i4L?t|h@|i |�@| t�U� @ ThLUi_�hi U@? @||@�? |�i tiUL?_ Lh_ih ML�?_

Eqq�� wi| e�f Mi @?) ?) UL?t�t|i?| it|�4@|Lh Lu �fc ��ihi > ) � �*2� 6Lh |iU�?�U@*

hi@tL?t � tii ��U!i* E�bH2� uLh @ t�4�*@h @TT*�U@|�L? Lu |��t _i��Ui � �i t�@** i4T*L)

@ _�tUhi|�ti_ @?_ `�?tLh�3i_ �iht�L? h�f |�@| �t _i�?i_ @t |�i U*Ltit| TL�?| |L e�f �?

|�i }h�_

q�?3) G f �u � �?3) � �L 4c � �?|e}eo

rc

Page 21: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

2f

��ihi �u @?_ �L @hi ti*iU|i_ �? @_�@?Ui� �hL��_i_ �f 5 d�uc �L o c h�f �t @*tL ?)

UL?t�t|i?|� i �ti h�f ' h�f?3Z |L _i�?i L�h �?@* it|�4@|Lh Lu qc eqEh�f��6�ht|*)c ?L|i |�@|

A Eh�f� ' A WEh�f� n-A Eh�f�c��ihi A WEh�f� @?_ -A Eh�f� @hi |�i |h�?U@|i_ @?_ hi4@�?_ih t|@|�t|�Ut _i�?i_ �? Eqq�

@?_ Eqq� i�@*�@|i_ @| |�i M@?_��_|� h�f� �) |�i 4i@? �@*�i |�iLhi4c

A WEh�f� ' A WE�f� n Eh�f � �f�YA W

Y�Eh�Wf�c

��ihi h�Wf *�it Mi|�ii? h�f @?_ �f� A�i uL**L��?} |�iLhi4 it|@M*�t�it |�@| ML|� Eh�f ��f�

YA W

Y�Eh�Wf� @?_ -A Eh�f� @hi t4@** �? _�t|h�M�|�L?�

AO,�+,� e� wi| � )� �tt�4i ��c �2<c @?_ ����D �L*_c ��|� acu��2c ��ihi

�2 � �@%i�S>nHE)3��sn�

c H>neE)3��sn�*2

c e>n2E)3��)3> c �2>n�SE)3��

�3e> jc ��|� s ' ) � > � d> � >Wo

@?_ >W ' Ee^ � �� �*2Ee^ n � �c @?_ |�@| �f 5 d�uc �L o � 5�TTLti @*tL |�@| uLh tL4i

b : fc

�S� �hd?�mh�f � �fm : bo ' JE?32>��

A�i? |�i _�t|h�M�|�L?t Lu A Eh�f� @?_ A WE�f� _�gih M) JE?32>��

A�ihiuLhic |�i T*�}��? it|�4@|Lh �t @t)4T|L|�U@**) i^���@*i?| |L Lh_ih ?32> �? _�t|h��

M�|�L? |L |�i tiUL?_ Lh_ih LT|�4@* it|�4@|Lh�

i ?L� _�tU�tt �L� �f �t |L Mi it|�4@|i_� �*i@h*)c P U@? Mi hiT*@Ui_ M) eP( |�i^�it|�L? �t �L� |L it|�4@|iG

h��E}( �f� ' �3^f d[� �'�

���E�f�}E~��� }E~��o ( YE�f� '[[� �'�

?��f 42��E�f�� E�e�

Page 22: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

2�

�L|i |�@| YE�f� � YE�� uLh @?) M@?_��_|� ti^�i?Ui � t@|�tu)�?} �e� A�ihiuLhic

YE�f� U@? Mi it|�4@|i_ M) YE��� i _�tU�tt |�L @*|ih?@|��i 4i|�L_t Lu it|�4@|�?}h��E}( �f�� 6�ht|*)c |@!i h��Ee}�W( �W�c ��ihi e}�W �t @ Thi*�4�?@h) it|�4@|i Lu } M@ti_

L? @ M@?_��_|� �W� A��t 4i|�L_ �t UL?�i?�i?| |L �tic @?_ TihuLh4i_ �i** �? |�i

t�4�*@|�L?t hiTLh|i_ Mi*L�� A�i tiUL?_ 4i|�L_ �tit |�i @t)4T|L|�U @TThL �4@|�L?h��E}( �f� � G^&}E~�� @?_ hiT*@Uit G^

&}E~�� M) @? it|�4@|i gG^&}E~��� A�i ^�|� T@h|�@*

_ih��@|��it Lu } U@? Mi it|�4@|i_ M) @ *LU@* TL*)?L4�@* hi}hitt�L? it|�4@|Lh Lu Lh_ih

^W : ^ ��|� M@?_��_|� �Wc M�| @*tL M) |�i tih�it 4i|�L_ Lu �?_hi�t E�bb�@��

i ?L� ThL�i |�@| |��t *@||ih 4i|�L_ U@? t@|�tu) E�S�� wi| � Mi |�i �iU|Lh UL?�

|@�?�?} l#w^ @?_ |�i �?�^�i i*i4i?|t Lu P� A�i? �f ' �E�f�c ��ihi �E�� �t UL?|�?�L�t*)_�gihi?|�@M*i @| �f� �) |�i 4i@? �@*�i |�iLhi4

e�f � �f ' ��E�Wf�

A E e�f � �f�c

��ihi �� �t |�i �ht| _ih��@|��i �iU|Lh Lu �c ���*i �Wf �t �?|ih4i_�@|i Mi|�ii? e�f @?_ �f�

�hLTih|�it Lu @�ih@}i _ih��@|��i it|�4@|Lht t�4�*@h |Lgl#w^ ' ?3�

S?�'�

gG^&wE~��

gG^&C2E~��

@hi UL?t�_ihi_ �? �?_hi�t E�bb�@�c O�@h_*i @?_ 5|L!ih E�bHb�c @?_ �L�i**c 5|LU! @?_

5|L!ih E�bHb�� `�i? C �t t��U�i?|*) t4LL|�cgl#w^ E@?_ �i?Ui e�f� t�L�*_ Mi UL?t�t|i?|c

@?_ i�i?s? UL?t�t|i?| �?_ih 4L4i?| @?_ t4LL|�?itt UL?_�|�L?t @?_ @TThLTh�@|i

hit|h�U|�L?t L? ^W @?_ �W� Wu 7�R?.dm?)E e�f��f�m8 o 4c ��ihi 8 E)� �� : 2>c |�i?

�hdm?�E e�f � �f�m : bo � .d�?)Ee�f3�f��8 ob8?E)3��8 ' JE?32>�

M) �@h!L�<t �?i^�@*�|)� A�@| |�i hi^��hi_ 4L4i?|t i �t| U@? Mi �ih��i_ uLh *LU@*

TL*)?L4�@* it|�4@|Lht Lu @�ih@}i _ih��@|��it �?_ih t4LL|�?itt @?_ 4L4i?| UL?_��

|�L?t� AL �@?_*i ��E�Wf� @ |h�?U@|�L? @h}�4i?| �t �ti_�

Page 23: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

22

��+�ww�+vG �tt�4i |�@| ����D �L*_c ��|� a @?_ u: �� � e>*dE)���oc @?_

�? @__�|�L? C 5 J^W� 6�h|�ih t�TTLti |�@| ?�W2E^W3^� $ f @?_ ?�WE�n^� $ 4� A�i?

�S �t t@|�t�i_�

`�@|i�ih 4i|�L_ �t i4T*L)i_ |L it|�4@|i �fc @? @__�|�L?@* t4LL|��?} T@h@4i|ih

�@t |L Mi ti*iU|i_c @?_ �? |��t ti?ti |�i T*�}��? 4i|�L_ �t ?L| u�**) @�|L4@|�U� OL��

i�ihc i��_i?Ui Thiti?|i_ �? �@h! @?_ �@hhL? E�bbf� @?_ 5�i@|�ih @?_ aL?it E�bb��

t�}}it|t |�@| |�i �?@* it|�4@|i 4@) ?L| Mi tL ti?t�|��i |L |�i U�L�Ui Lu |�i tiUL?_@h)

t4LL|��?} T@h@4i|ihc @?_ L?i U@? i4T*L) tL4i @hM�|h@h) h�*i uLh it|�4@|�L? Lu |�i

M@?_��_|� UL?t|@?|t ��|� *�||*i ULt|� A�i tL�U@**i_ h�*i Lu |��4M @TThL@U�c tii 5�*�

�ih4@? E�bHS� @?_ �?_hi�t E�bb�M�c Lgiht @? @*|ih?@|��i T*�}��? �4T*i4i?|@|�L?

|�@| _Lit ?L| hi^��hi @? i T*�U�| Thi*�4�?@h) M@?_��_|� |L Mi U�Lti?� W? |��t @T�

ThL@U� L?i tTiU��itc uLh |�i T�hTLtit Lu M@?_��_|� U�L�Ui L?*)c @ T@h@4i|h�U 4L_i*

uLh CE�� t�U� @t 4@!�?} �| @ TL*)?L4�@* u�?U|�L? Lu ~� �@h@4i|h�U ThLUi_�hit @hi

|�i? �ti_ |L }i| @ Thi*�4�?@h) �| fCW @?_ _ih��@|��it |�ihiLu ���U� @hi |�i? T*�}}i_

�?|L |�i LT|�4@* M@?_��_|� uLh4�*@� A��t 4i|�L_ @U��i�it |�i 4Lhi 4L_it| LM�iU�

|��i Lu Mi�?} tiUL?_ Lh_ih LT|�4@* uLh |�i T@h|�U�*@h 4L_i* U�Lti? uLh Cc @*|�L�}�

|�i ULhhiU| Lh_ih Lu 4@}?�|�_i uLh e� �t }�@h@?|ii_ uLh @** C�

S� 5W�Nw�AW��5

A��t tiU|�L? UL?|@�?t |�i hit�*|t Lu @ t�4�*@|�L? i Tih�4i?| _it�}?i_ |L i�@*�@|i

L�h M@?_��_|� ti*iU|�L? ThLUi_�hi�

i }i?ih@|i_ 2fc fff t@4T*it Lu t�3i ? ' �ff uhL4G

+�� ' � n +2� n f�DB�~2� n "�c +2� '

*?EB2 n ��i TE*?EB2 n ��~�� n #�c

Page 24: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

2�

��ihi E"�c #�� �ihi ��_ B@�tt�@? ��|� �?�| UL�@h�@?Ui 4@|h� c ���*i ~� ' �*?c � '

�c 2c ��c ?� �L|i |�@| ?3�S?

�'� w��E~��}

��2E~�� ' B�B2� i i @4�?i_ |�i uL**L��?} T@h@4�

i|ih �@*�itG W EB� ' �2fc B2 ' e�c WW EB� ' �Dfc B2 ' �f�c WWW EB� ' ��ffc B2 ' 2f�c @?_

WV EB� ' ��Dfc B2 ' �f�� �** hi}hitt�L? u�?U|�L?t �ihi it|�4@|i_ M) *LU@* *�?i@h hi�

}hitt�L? ��|� ^�@_h@|�U !ih?i*� ,^�@**) tT@Ui_ _it�}?t @hi ?L| i?UL�?|ihi_ uhi^�i?|*)

�? iUL?L4i|h�U @TT*�U@|�L?t� OL�i�ihc L�h Th�4@h) T�hTLti �ihi �t |L i�@*�@|i |�i

^�@*�|) Lu L�h @t)4T|L|�U @TThL �4@|�L?t @?_ uLh |��t hi@tL? �i @_LT| |�i 4Lt| UL?�

�i?�i?| t@4T*�?} tU�i4i |�@| @**L�t �t |L �@h) ��@| �i |��?! @hi |�i !i) T@h@4i|iht

Lu L�h uLh4�*@i�

i �ht| i�@*�@|i_ |�i TihuLh4@?Ui Lu eq uLh i@U� Lu 4L_i*t W�WV @| @ }h�_ Lu 2f

_�gihi?| M@?_��_|�t� 6�}�hit . � �f t�L� |�i t�4�*@|�L? �7. EtU@*i_ M) �ff� uLh

4L_i*t W�WV�

8886�}�hit .��f �ihi888

A�iti hit�*|t UL?�h4 |�i �@*�_�|) Lu L�h tiUL?_ Lh_ih @TThL �4@|�L?t( ��|?itt 6�}�

�hi �� ���U� t�Tih�4TLtit |�i t�4�*@|�L? �7. @?_ tiUL?_ Lh_ih @TThL �4@|�L?

EU@*U�*@|i_ uhL4 Eqq�� uLh 4L_i* WV�

8886�}�hi �� �ihi888

A�i @TThL �4@|�L?t @hi hi4@h!@M*) U*Lti |L |�i @U|�@* TihuLh4@?Ui Lu |�i it|�4@|Lh

uLh M@?_��_|�t �? |�i �?|ih4i_�@|i h@?}i U*Lti |L |�i LT|�4�4�

6�?@**)c �i i�@*�@|i_ L�h T*�}��? ThLUi_�hi� A�i �?�|�@* M@?_��_|� �W ' f�2D �@t

�ti_ |L it|�4@|i |�i M�@t @?_ �@h�@?Ui UL?t|@?|t M)

h��Ee}�W( �W� ' �W32kS

� �'����E�W�e}�WE~��� e}�WE~��

l( YE�W� 'SS

� �'�?�W42��E�

W��

Page 25: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

2e

i _�_ ?L| `�?tLh�3i ?Lh _�tUhi|�3i |�i hit�*|�?} e�f� 6�}�hi �2 t�L�t |�i _i?t�|) Lu

*?Ee�f� uLh 4L_i*t W�WV�

8886�}�hi �2 �ihi888

6�?@**)c |�i TihuLh4@?Ui Lu |�i hit�*|�?} it|�4@|Lh eqEe�f� �t }��i? Mi*L�G

A��w, �� �,+6�+����, �6 eqEe�f�

�L4i?|t "�@?|�*it

�L_i* % r �I 2DI DfI .DI bbI

W f�bb.� f��feD f�.D�� f�b2Sb f�bbSS ��fSS� ��2eD�

WW f�bb.� f��fDH f�.ebH f�b2.f f�bbSH ��fSH� ��2e.2

WWW f�bb.� f��f.e f�.eS2 f�b2eH f�bb.S ��fSHb ��2D2�

WV f�bbSb f��fH. f�.e�D f�b2�b f�bb.D ��fSbf ��2De2

��ihi % @?_ r _i?L|i t�4�*@|�L? 4i@? @?_ t|@?_@h_ _i��@|�L? hitTiU|��i*)�

.� ����wN5W��5

��h �Lh! t�}}it|t ti�ih@* ^�@*�|@|��i Thi_�U|�L?t @ML�| |�i ��}�ih Lh_ih ThLTih|�it

Lu |�i �@h�L�t ti4�T@h@4i|h�U t|@|�t|�Ut �i UL?t�_ihi_� `�i? �t�?} t�U� ThLUi_�hit

|�i Th@U|�|�L?ih �@t UL?t�_ih@M*i *@|�|�_i �? U�LLt�?} |�i ?�4Mih Lu ?��t@?Ui T@h@4�

i|iht |L it|�4@|i� `��*i |��t U�L�Ui �t ?L| hi�iU|i_ �? |�i �ht| Lh_ih |�iLh)c �| U@?

�@�i UL?t�_ih@M*i �4T@U| L? |�i @U|�@* TihuLh4@?Ui Lu it|�4@|Lht @?_ |it| t|@|�t|�Ut�

Page 26: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

2D

W? T@h|�U�*@hc �i uL�?_ @ �@h�@?Ui �?�@|�L? ThLTLh|�L?@* |L ?3��3� ���U� uLh t4@**

M@?_��_|�t U@? Mi Lu UL4T@h@M*i 4@}?�|�_i |L |�i @t)4T|L|�U �@h�@?Ui� A�i M�@t Lu

|�i it|�4@|Lh �t 4Lhi _��U�*| |L 4i@t�hi t�?Ui �| _iTi?_t L? |�i �?!?L�? hi}hitt�L?

u�?U|�L?tc ?i�ih|�i*itt |�i _�hiU|�L? Lu |�i M�@t 4@) Mi �?uihhi_ uhL4 �?uLh4@|�L?

@ML�| |�i�h UL?U@��|)�

�UUL�?|�?} uLh |�iti ��}�ih Lh_ih ThLTih|�it �t itti?|�@* �u hi*�@M*i �?uihi?Ui �t |L

Mi U@hh�i_ L�|( �i t�}}it|i_ �@)t Lu @UUL4T*�t��?} |��t� W? T@h|�U�*@hc |�i _i}hiit

Lu uhii_L4 @_��t|4i?| UL?t�_ihi_ �? tiU|�L? S �t hi*@|��i*) i@t) |L �4T*i4i?| @?_ @|

*i@t| hi�iU|t |�i M@?_��_|� �? @ �@) ���U� }�@h_t @}@�?t| �|t �?@TThLTh�@|i �ti�

i @*tL UL?t|h�U|i_ @? it|�4@|Lh Lu q |�@| �@t tiUL?_ Lh_ih LT|�4@*� �*|�L�}�

L�h t|@?_@h_ Lu LT|�4@*�|) UL4T@hit it|�4@|Lht L?*) ��|��? @ 4�U� 4Lhi hit|h�U|i_

U*@tt |�@? |�i �ht| Lh_ih LT|�4@*�|) |�iLh) Lu ��U!i* i| @* E�bb�� @?_ �i�i) E�bbf@�c �|

_Lit ThL��_i @ Mi?U�4@h! @}@�?t| ���U� |L UL4T@hi @*|ih?@|��i �ht| Lh_ih i^���@*i?|

ThLUi_�hit� W? Th@U|�Uic L�h ThLUi_�hi tii4t |L �Lh! ^��|i �i** i�i? uLh t@4T*it @t

t4@** @t �ffc ThL��_i_ |�ihi �t ?L| |LL 4�U� ?L?*�?i@h�|)�

��h @TThL �4@|�L?t @hi M@ti_ L? UL4T�|�?} |�i �ht| |�L 4L4i?|t Lu |�i |h�?�

U@|i_ A@)*Lh tih�it @TThL �4@|�L? |L |�i t|@?_@h_�ti_ t|@|�t|�Ut� A�iti U@*U�*@|�L?t

U@? Mi U@hh�i_ L�| uLh @ 4�U� ��_ih U*@tt Lu ti4�T@h@4i|h�U 4L_i*t TLttitt�?} t4LL|��

?itt ThLTih|�it� 5L4i Thi*�4�?@h) �Lh! _i@*�?} ��|� t�U� @ }i?ih@* t�|�@|�L? �t Thi�

ti?|i_ �? w�?|L? E�bb2��

��k��`w,#B,�,�A5

W �L�*_ *�!i |L |�@?! AL4 +L|�i?Mih}c ��h�t �@�@?@}�c #L? �?_hi�t @?_ L*u�

}@?} O�@h_*i uLh �i*Tu�* UL44i?|t� A�i UL�i_�|Lh @?_ |�L hiuihiit _itih�i UL?t�_ih@M*i

Uhi_�| uLh |�i�h �i*T �? ThiT@h�?} |��t 4@?�tUh�T|� +i4@�?�?} ihhLht @hi 4�?i�

Page 27: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

2S

�L�*it 6L�?_@|�L? uLh +iti@hU� �? ,UL?L4�Utc v@*i N?��iht�|)�

Page 28: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

2.

���,�#Wj

W? |�i �ht| tiU|�L? �i }��i tL4i Thi*�4�?@h) *i44@t |�@| _itUh�Mi |�i ThLTih|�it

Lu |�i *LU@* TL*)?L4�@* it|�4@|Lh @?_ �@h�L�t @�ih@}it _ih��i_ uhL4 �|c ���*i �? tiU|�L?

� �i }��i ThLLut Lu |�i |�iLhi4t�

W? |�i ti^�i*c *i| m@m ' E@�@��*2 Mi |�i ,�U*�_i@? ?Lh4 Lu |�i � ��iU|Lh @c @?_ *i|

n�n 'b4@ E�� � �@%@@��@@�@ Mi |�i 4@|h� ?Lh4 Lu @?) hi@* t)44i|h�U 4@|h� �c

��ihi b4@ _i?L|it *@h}it| i�}i?�@*�i� i 4@!i �ti Lu |�i uL**L��?} @h}�4i?|� wi| @

@?_ K Mi �iU|Lht @?_ *i| � @?_ � Mi 4@|h�Uit� A�i? m@���Km � E@��2@��*2EK��2K��*2

M) |�i �@�U�)�5U��@h3 �?i^�@*�|)c ���*i uLh TLt�|��i _i�?�|i �c @��@ ' @�@@��@@�@ �

@�@ n�n �A�ihiuLhic

m@���Km � m@mmKm n�n n�n � E�D�

6�?@**)c �i ��** �ti ��c �2c �� |L _i?L|i TLt�|��i �?�|i UL?t|@?|t�

�� �+,wW�W��+v w,���5

��� �hLTih|�it Lu wLU@* �L*)?L4�@* `i�}�|t

i ?L� _ih��i �@h�L�t ThLTih|�it Lu |�i �i�}�|�?} ti^�i?Ui i���j?�c�'� _i�?i_ �?

ES� ��|� � ' �E?3Z��

w,��� 2GS

� �'���� ' � (S

��'� ��� ' � n JE���

w,��� �G wi| 4�� ' ?3�*2dS

& �'�c& �'��&��&� � 2���o @?_ *i| 4�� ' ?3�*2S

& �'��2&��

A�i?SS��'�

?3��2��c

SS��'�

42��c @?_ ?3�*2S?

�'� 4�� @hi �E?3��3� �c ���*iS?

�'� 42�� '

�E?32�32� ��

Page 29: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

2H

�+��6G �) |�i |h�@?}*i �?i^�@*�|)c �i �@�i

[[��'�

42�� � Hi[[��'�

d?3�*2E[

& �'�c& �'��&��&��o

2 n ?3�[[��'�

�2��jc

@?_ M) �@�U�)�5U��@h3

d?3�*2[

& �'�c& �'��&��&�o

2 � d?3�*2[

& �'�c& �'��2&�od?

3�*2 [& �'�c& �'�

�2&�o�

�) @tt�4T|�L?t �� @?_ �DG

�� r i� G ��� 9' fj ' �E?�� �

�2 m���m � ��?3��3� c

��ihi r� _i?L|it |�i U@h_�?@*�|) Lu @ ti| �c @?_ �� �L*_t �?�uLh4*) �? �� A�ihiuLhicS& �'�c& �'��2

&� � �2?3��3� �?�uLh4*) �? �c @?_ |�i �ht| |�L hit�*|t uL**L�� �*tLc M)

�?|ihU�@?}�?} t�44@|�L?tc ?3�*2S?

�'� 4�� ' ?3�S

& �'�ES?

�'��2&��c ���U� �t �E?3��3� �

M) |�i t@4i @h}�4i?|t @t @ML�i� 5�4�*@h*) uLhS?

�'� 42���

w,��� eGSS� �'�

dY4��Y�

o2 ' �E?3��3E�n2���

�+��6� �TT*)�?} |�i |h�@?}*i �?i^�@*�|) @?_ �@�U�)�5U��@h3c �| t��Uit |L it�

|@M*�t� |�i Lh_ih Lu 4@}?�|�_i LuSS��'�

dY���Y�

o2 � wi| ig� Mi |�i _�@}L?@* 4@|h� ��|�

|)T�U@* i*i4i?|

Y

Y�&E

~� � ~�

�� ' ��3�

�[R'�

&RE~� � ~�

��E~�R � ~�R

��c

��ihi &RE|� 'YY|R

&E|�� A�i?c MiU@�ti i@U� &RE|� �t ML�?_i_ @?_ Lu ML�?_i_ t�TTLh|c

|�ihi i �t|t @ �� t�U� |�@|

�@%�c�$?

m YY�

&E~� � ~�

��m � ���

3��

Page 30: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

2b

A�ihiuLhic t�?Ui Y���Y�

�t |�i �<|� i*i4i?| Lu |�i �ht| hL� Lu

�EfA� g�f��

3�EfA�ig�f��Ef

A� g�f��

3�fA� g� n EfA

� g�f��3�fA

�ig�c

|�ihi i �t|t �e t�U� |�@| mY���Y�

m � �e?3��3E�n��� 6�h|�ih4Lhic riE�c �� G Y���

Y�9' fj '

�E?2�� �c M) |�i ML�?_i_ t�TTLh| Lu &� A�ihiuLhic ?3��3E�3��M3�fA�ig�f�M

3�c

?3��3E�3��M3�fA�ig�g�f�M

3� @?_ ?3��3E�32�M3�fA�ig2� f�M

3� @hi �E��c �?�uLh4*)

�? �c @?_ |�i hit�*| uL**L�t�

�2� �hLTih|�it Lu 5|@?_@h_�ti_ ��ih@}it Lu wLU@* �L*)?L4�@* ,t|�4@|Lht

A�i |h�?U@|i_ t|@|�t|�Ut A Wc 7Wc @?_ ` W _iTi?_ L? |�i �i�}�|i_ N�t|@|�t|�Ut f(c

f� c @?_ fT c ��ihiG

f� � s?7#" ' ?3�*2

S?�'�d#� � E�#� n T#��od"� � E�w� n T"��o

f( � s?E7## � P##� ' ?3�*2

S?�'�

qd#� � E�#� n T#��od#� � E�#� n T#��o

A � P##

rfT � s

?E7e0e0 � j20� ' ?3�*2S?

�'� id0� � E�w� n T0��o2 � j20j c

��ihi 7e0e0 ' ?3�S?

�'� e02� c ��|� e0� ' ev� � qA e#�c ���*i ?3�S?

�'� 02�

�$ j20c @?_ �#� '

E�2�c ��c �(n�c��A c T#� ' ET2�c ��c T(n�c��

A c ��|� uLh _ ' �c 2c ��c( n �G

T_� 'S

� �'����d+_� � }_E~��o ( �_� 'S

� �'����d}_E~��� }_E~��oc

�w� ' ��� � qA�#� 'S

� �'����dwE~��� wE~��o ( T"� ' T�� � qAT#� 'S

� �'����"��

�L|i |�@| uLh i @4T*i ��� ' �2 h��E}��� �) i T@?_�?} L�| |�i Mh@U!i|t @?_ UL**iU|�?}

|ih4t �i LM|@�?

f� ' if� n K� nu� n'� c f( ' if( n K( nu( n'(c fT ' ifT n KT nuT n'T c

��ihi |�i �� E�� *i@_�?} |ih4t @hiG

Page 31: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�f

ifT ' ?3�*2?[�'�

E"2� � j2"� (if� ' ?3�*2

?[�'�

#�"� ( if( ' ?3�*2?[�'�

E#�#A� � P##�c

���*i |�i M�@tit |ih4t @hiG

K� ' ?3�*2S?

�'��#��w�

K( ' ?3�*2S?

�'��#��A#� n ?3�*2

S?�'�.dT#�T

A#� o � K(� n K(2

KT ' ?3�*2S?

�'��2w� n ?3�*2

S?�'�.dT 2

"�o � KT � n KT 2�

A�i *�?i@h @?_ ^�@_h@|�U t|@|�t|�Ut @hi

u� ' ?3�*2S?

�'�ET#� � #���w� n ?3�*2S?

�'��#�ET"� � "�� nS?

�'� 4��"�#� �S�

�'�u��

u( ' ?3�*2S?

�'�ET#� � #���A#� n ?3�*2

S?�'��#�ET#� � #��

A nS?

�'� 4��E#�#A� � P##� � S�

�'�u(�

uT ' 2?3�*2S?

�'�ET"� � "���w� nS?

�'� 4��E"2� � j2"� � uT � n uT 2

'� 'SS��'�

4��"�#� ( '( 'SS��'�

4��#�#A� ( 'T '

SS� �'�

4��"�"�c

��ihi 4�� ' ?3�*2S

& �'��2&� @?_ 4�� ' ?3�*2d

S& �'�c& �'��&��&� � 2���oc � 9' ��

A�i ThLTih|�it Lu f� c f(c @?_ fT U@? Mi _i|ih4�?i_ uhL4 |�i *i44@t Mi*L��

w,��� DG �t ?$ 4c

K� � s?�2^i?3�S?

�'�G^&wG^

&C2E~��jK(� � s

?�2^i?3�S?�'�G^

&C2G^&C

A2 E~��j

KT � � s?�2^i?3�S?

�'� dG^&wE~��o

2j�

�+��6� wi44@ � U@? Mi @TT*�i_ _�hiU|*)�

w,��� SG K(2c KT 2 'SS��'�

?3�*2�2��jE~�� ' �E?3�*2�3� �c ��ihi j2 �t i�|�ih |�i

tU@*@h j20 Lh |�i 4@|h� P##� 6L**L�t uhL4 �� @?_ �2�

Page 32: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

��

w,��� .G u(�c u(2c uT �c u��c u�2 ' J� E�^�c M�| u(�c u��c uT 2 ' �� E?

3��3� ��

�+��6� �L?t�_ih u�� ' ?3�*2S?

�'�ET#� � #���w�� �) �?|ihU�@?}�?} t�44@|�L?tc

�i LM|@�? u�� ' ?3�*2S?

�'� 1�#�c ��ihi 1� ' dS

� �'�����w� ��w�o� A�ihiuLhic

nT @odu��on '

�����?3�?[�'�

12�P##E~��

����� � �D?3�

?[�'�

12� �

6�h|�ih4Lhic M) |�i |h�@?}*i �?i^�@*�|) @?_ �@�U�)�5U��@h3c

12� � 2dES

� �'���� � ���w�o2 n 2i�@%

�$?E�w� ��w��

2jS� �'��2

��o ' JE�2^��

�?�uLh4*) �? �c MiU@�tiS

� �'��2�� ' �E?3��3� � M) �� @?_ �2 @?_

S� �'������ ' JE��

M) wi44@ 2�

6Lh u�� �i �@�i

nT @odu��on '

�����?[�'�

42��j2" E~��P##E~��

����� � �Sm?[�'�

42��m ' �E?32�32� �c

M) |�i ML�?_i_?itt Lu j2" E~��P##E~�� @?_ wi44@ ��

w,��� HG '(c '� c 'T ' �� E?3�*2�3�*2�� 6�h|�ih4Lhic

T @od'� o 'SS��'�

42��j2" E~��P##E~�� � S

� j2" E~��P##E~��

S� �'� 42��

T @od'T o 'SS��'�

42��j2" E~��j

2" E~�� � S

� je" E~��

S� �'� 42��

�+��6� A�i Lh_ih Lu 4@}?�|�_i uL**L�t uhL4 wi44@ �c MiU@�ti PE~�� �t �?��

uLh4*) ML�?_i_� A�i @TThL �4@|�L? �t �@*�_ MiU@�ti P 5 J��

w,��� bG �tt�4i |�@| ����D �L*_c ��ihi acw: 2� uLh tL4i �?|i}ih �� A�i?

7�R?.dmf� m� o 4 @?_ 7�R?.dnf(n� o 4�

�+��6� 6�ht|c �t�?} @ t|@?_@h_ �?i^�@*�|)

Page 33: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�2

.dmf� m� o � �.E.dmif� m� o n mK� m� n .dmu� m� o n .dm'� m� o��

�) t|@?_@h_ hit�*|t uLh �?_iTi?_i?| h@?_L4 �@h�@M*itc 2� �?�uLh4*) ML�?_i_ 4L�

4i?|t @hi t��U�i?| |L }�@h@?|ii |�@| 7�R?.dm?3�*2S?�'� #�"�m� o 4� 5�4�*@h*)

7�R?.dmu� m� o 4c ���*i 7�R?mK� m� 4 MiU@�ti Lu |�i ML�?_i_?itt Lu |�i ^<|�

_ih��@|��it Lu C�

i ?L� it|@M*�t� |�@| 7�R?.dm'� m� o 4c ��ihi

'� �[[�:�

4��"�#�n[[�:�

4��"�#��

`�|�L�| *Ltt Lu }i?ih@*�|) hit|h�U| @||i?|�L? |LSS��

4��"�#�� wi| `� 'S

�:� 4��"�#� uLh

i@U� �c |�i?SS��

4��"�#� 'S

�`�c ��ihi i`�j uLh4t @ 4@h|�?}@*i _�gihi?Ui ti^�i?Ui

��|� hitTiU| |L |�i t�}4@ �i*_ }i?ih@|i_ M) i��3�c ��c ��j� �) |�i t|@?_@h_ 4@h|�?}@*i

|iU�?�^�it Lu O@** @?_ Oi)_i E�bHf�c

.dm[�

`�m� o � �HE[[�:�

42����*2c

ThL��_i_ 7�R�.dm"�m� o 4 @?_ 7�R�.dm#�m� o 4c tii ��!LtU� E�bb��c wi44@ ����

A�ihiuLhic @TT*)�?} wi44@ �c |�i hit�*| �t it|@M*�t�i_�

A�i t@4i @h}�4i?|t @TT*) |L f(�

w,��� �fG �tt�4i |�@| ����D �L*_c ��ihi acw: 2� uLh tL4i �?|i}ih �� A�i?

w�� 7�R?.dm?E>3Z�Yf�

Y�m� o 4 ( w2� 7�R?.d

�����?E>W3Z�Yf(

Y�

������

o 4c

��ihi >W ' Ee^ � �� �*2Ee^ n � ��

�+��6�6 w�� �) ��c YK�Y�

' �Es?�2^3��c ��ihi � ' �E?3Z�c tL |�@| ?E>3Z� YK�

Y�E�� '

�E��� i UL?t�_ih Yu��

Y�E�� ' ?3�*2

S?�'�

Y1�Y�#�c ��ihi

Page 34: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

��

Y1�Y�

' E[� �'�

dY���

Y��w� n ���

Y�w�

Y�o� Y�w�

Y���

5�?UiS

� �'�dY���Y�

o2 ' �E?3��3E�n2�� @?_ Y�w�Y�

' �E�^3��c �i �@�i T @odYu��

Y�E��o '

�E�2^32�� A�ihiuLhic t�?Ui |�i hi^��hi_ 4L4i?|t i �t|c .dm?E>3Z� Yu��

Y�E��m� o ' �E���

5�4�*@h*) uLh Yu�2

Y�� h�|�?} Y'�

Y�'SS��'�

Y4��Y�

"�#�c �i �@�i

.dm?E>3Z�Y'�

Y�E��m� o � �bi

[[��'�

?2E>3Z�dY4��Y�

o2j�*2c

��ihi Y4��Y�

' YY�d?3�*2E

S& �'�& �'�

�&��&��2����oc ThL��_i_ 7�R�.dm"�m� o 4 @?_ 7�R�.dm#�m� o

4� �) wi44@ ec |��t �t ML�?_i_� A�ihiuLhic .dm?E>3Z� Y'�

Y�E��m� o ' �E��� �) |�i

|h�@?}*i �?i^�@*�|)c 7�R?.dm?E>3Z� Yf�

Y�m� o 4 @t hi^��hi_�

5�4�*@h @h}�4i?|t @TT*) |L w2c @*|�L�}� �? |��t U@ti YK(2

Y�' �E?3�*2�3E�n���c

���U� @UUL�?|t uLh |�i _�gihi?| �@*�i Lu |�i ?Lh4�?} UL?t|@?| >W�

Page 35: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�e

�� �+��6 �6 AO,�+,�5

�+��6 �6 AO,�+,� �

E���� AL it|@M*�t� |��t �i �ti |�i uL**L��?} hit�*| Lu 5@h}@? @?_ ��!�@�* E�b.��G

uLh @** % @?_ lc

m�hdA � %o� �hdA W � %om � �hdm-A m : lo n �hdmA W � %m loc E�S�

tii +L|�i?Mih} E�bHe@�� �hL��_i_ A W �@t @ ML�?_i_ _i?t�|)c |�i *@t| |ih4 �t �El�

@t l $ f� i |�ihiuLhi U�LLti l ' �Ed?2> *L} ?o3�� @?_ t�L� |�@| uLh tL4i TLt�|��i

UL?t|@?| ��fc

�hdm-A m : ��f?s?

?2> *L} ?o ' JE?32>��

wi| � 'qm-A m : ��f?

I?

?2> *L}?

r@?_ � ' in7##n : ���j � i �@�i

�hd�o � �hd� _�o n �hd�Soc E�.�

��ihi

�hE�S� � �hEnf(n : ��2

s?� � ���

.dnf(n2o?

M) �@h!L�<t �?i^�@*�|)� A�ihiuLhic ThL��_i_ 7�R?.dnf(n2o 4c �hd�So ' JE?32>��

�) E��qq�G ��i? n7##n : ���c m-A m � ��emf� m nf(n� � A�ihiuLhi � _ � � �c

��ihi � 'qmf� m nf(n� : ��D?

I?

?2> *L}?

rc @?_

�hd� _�o � �hd�o � ��Sd*L} ?o4.dmf� m4 nf(n�4o

?E�232>�4

uLh @?) 4� �hL��_i_ |�i hi*i�@?| 4L4i?|t @hi �?�uLh4*) ML�?_i_ @?_ E�2�2>�4 : 2>c

|�i hit�*| uL**L�t�

Page 36: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�D

5�?Ui a cu : ��c |�i hi*i�@?| 4L4i?|t i �t|c M) |�i uL**L��?} @h}�4i?|� �)

O�L*_ih<t �?i^�@*�|)

.dmf� m4 nf(n�4o � i.dmf� me4oj�*ei.dnf(ne4oj�*ec

���*i 7�R?.dnf(ne4o 4 @?_ 7�R?.dmf� me4o 4c ThL��_i_ H4 4L4i?|t i �t|c M)

wi44@ b�

E��2� �) E��qq� @?_ O�L*_ih<t �?i^�@*�|)c

.mA Wm2 � ��..dmf� m2 nf(neo � ��.i.dmf� mSoj�*�i.dnf(nSoj2*�c

���*i 7�R?.dnf(nSo 4 @?_ 7�R?.dmf� mSo 4 M) wi44@ bc t�?Ui ac u � �2�

E���� 5�?Ui f( ' �� E��c �i U@? _hLT |�i *@t| |ih4 L? |�i h�}�| Lu Eqq�� 6�h�

|�ih4Lhic tL4i Lu |�i UhLtt |ih4t �?SAP

3�##f(P

3�##f�

jI?

U@? Mi _hLTTi_ MiU@�ti f( 'if( n K(2 n�� E?3>� @?_ f� ' if� n�� E?

3>�� A�ihiuLhic

A W ' j3�SAP3�##

�if� n K� n'� n u�� n u�2 n du�� � KA(2P

3�##

hf�I?

o� hfA(P3�##

hf�I?

�n J� E?

32>�

� A WW n J� E?32>�c

E�H�

6hL4 wi44@ .c u��c u�2 ' J� E�^�c ���*i ML|� @hi �?ULhhi*@|i_ ��|� if� c t�?Ui

.d"�#�#A� o ' f ' .d"2� #�oc M) �2� A�ihiuLhic t�?Ui � ' �E?32*Ee^n� ��c ?i�|�ih u�� ?Lh

u�2 UL?|h�M�|i |L |�i tiUL?_ 4L4i?|t Lu A W |L �E?32>�� 6hL4 wi44@t S @?_ .c

K(2 ' �E?3�*2�3� � @?_ u�� ' �� E?3��3� �� OL�i�ihc @*|�L�}� u�� @?_ KA(2P

3�##

if�

@hi ML|� �?_���_�@**) ULhhi*@|i_ ��|� if� c |�i *�?i@h UL4M�?@|�L? u�� � KA(2P

3�##

hf�I?

�t

?L|� 6�h|�ih4Lhic |�i UL�@h�@?Ui Mi|�ii?hfA(P3�##

hf�I?

@?_ if� �t �E?3��� A�ihiuLhic

.dA Wo ' j3�SAP3�## K� n JE?3>� ( T @odA Wo ' T @odif� o nT @odj3�SAP

3�##'� o n JE?32>�c

Page 37: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�S

��ihi K� �t @TThL �4@|i_ �? wi44@ Dc ���*i T @od'� o ' �E?3��3� � �t }��i? �?

wi44@ H�

�+��6 �6 AO,�+,� 2

�) �t�?} |�@| f� ' if� n �� E?3>�c f( ' if( n K(2 n �� E?

3>�c fT ' ifT n

KT 2n�� E?3>�c @?_

s?E eq� q� ' P3�

##if� n�� E?

3>�c �i U@? _hLT 4@?) UhLtt |ih4tc

@?_ �?_

7W 'dfT 3 �I

?hfA�P3## hf� o

2j2"� SAP3�##f(P

3�## S

2SAP3�## Sn

SAP3�## thf(nK(2�P3�## thf(nK(2�P3�## S2SAP3�## S

I?

�dhfT nKT 2o

2

Hje"I?

� dSAP3�## thf(nK(2�P3�##So

HdSAP3�## So2I?

� SAP3�## thf(nK(2�P3�## SdhfT nKT 2o

ej2I?

n J� E?32>�c

E�b�

6�h|�ih4Lhic |ih4t �?�L*��?} ?3�*2K2(2c ?3�*2K2T 2c Lh ?

3�*2K(2KT 2 @hi J� E?32>�c t�?Ui

s?�� $ 4� A�i UL�@h�@?Uit Mi|�ii?fT c f( @?_G ?3�*2ifA

�P3�##

if� c ?3�*2SAP3�

##if(P

3�##

if(P3�## Sc

?3�*2dSAP3�##

if(P3�## So

2c ?3�*2SAP3�##

if(P3�## S

ifT c @?_ ?3�*2if2T c @hi JE?

32>�� 6�?@**)c �i

t�Mt|�|�|i KT 2 's?Z?j

2" @?_ K(2 '

s?Z?P## �?|L E��qq�c ��ihi Z? '

SS� �'�

?3��2�� '

�E?3��3� � M) wi44@ �c @?_ LM|@�? ti�ih@* U@?Ui**@|�L?t� W? UL?U*�t�L?c �i �@�i |L

U@*U�*@|i |�i tiUL?_ 4L4i?|t Lu

7WW 'fT

2j2"� SAP3�

##f(P3�## S

2SAP3�## S

n Z?

;?=SAP3�##

if(P3�## S

SAP3�## S

�ifT

ej2"

<@> c

i �ht| U@*U�*@|i |�i 4i@? Lu 7WW� A��t �t

KT2j2"

� SAP3�## K(P

3�## S�

2SAP3�## S

n JE?3>� 'KT �2j2"

� SAP3�## K(�P

3�## S

2SAP3�## S

n JE?3>�c

t�?Ui KT 2

2j2"� SAP3�## K(2P

3�## S

2SAP3�## S' f� A�ihiuLhic |�i M�@t �t @t t|@|i_�

i ?L� U@*U�*@|i |�i �@h�@?Ui� 6�ht|*)c �i hi@hh@?}i 7WW tL |�@|

7WW 'fT � Z?ifT

2j2"� SAP3�

##f(P3�## S� Z?S

AP3�##

if(P3�## S

2SAP3�## S

Page 38: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�.

6�h|�ih t�4T*��U@|�L? hit�*|t MiU@�tiG �J�duT 2 � Z?ifT c ifT o ' f @?_ �J�du(2 �Z?if(c if(o ' f ���*i �u |�i |��h_ 4L4i?| @hh@) Lu �� �t 3ihLc �J�duT �c ifT o ' f '

�J�du(�c if(o� A�ihiuLhic |�i �@h�@?Ui Lu 7WW �t

T @odifT o n T @od'T o

eje"n

T @odSAP3�##

if(P3�## So n T @odSAP3�

##'(P3�## So

edSAP3�## So

2c

@?_ |�i hit�*| uL**L�t M) wi44@ H�

�+��6 �6 AO,�+,� �

6hL4 E��qq�c 7 'hfT

2j2"� SAP3�## hf(P

3�## S

2SAP3�## Sn�� E?

3>�� A�ihiuLhic

` W ' A WW � SAP3�##

if�

js?

;?= ifT

2j2"� SAP3�

##if(P

3�## S

2SAP3�## S

<@>n J� E?32>��

A�i UL�@h�@?Ui Lu ?3�*2if�

� hfT

2j2"� SAP3�## hf(P

3�## S

2SAP3�## S

���|� if� �t �E?3��c tL |�@| |�i tiU�

L?_ 4L4i?|t Lu ` W @}hii ��|� |�Lti Lu A WW |L |�i hi^��hi_ Lh_ih�

�+��6 �6 AO,�+,� e

i �@�i |L t�L� |�@|

e�� �hdm-A Eh�f�m : ��H?I?

?2> *L}?o ' JE?32>�

e�2 �hdmh�f3�f�f

�fYAW

Y�Eh�Wf�m : ��H

?2> *L}?o ' JE?32>��

i �ht| it|@M*�t� e��� wi| Q�f ' d�f � b?3�c �f n b?3�oc @?_ *i| F�c ��c F' Mi ti|t

Lu _�@4i|ih �E?3)� |�@| UL�ih Q�f� ,@U� F� UL?|@�?t L?*) @ �?�|i ?�4Mih Lu TL�?|t

_� � _ uLh tL4i _ 4c ���*i ' ' �E?E)3���� wi| � 'qm-A Eh�f�m : ��H?

I?

?2> *L}?

r@?_

Page 39: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�H

� ' ih�f 5 Q�fj � A�i? �hd�So ' JE?32>� M) @tt�4T|�L?� wi||�?} �� ' ih�f 5 F�j c �i�@�i �hd� _�o � S'

�'��hd� _��oc ���*i

� _�� � �� '

+�@%��

mf� m nf(n� : ��b?s?

?2> *L} ?

,�

5�?Ui F� �t @ �?�|i ti|c �i U@? @TT*) |�i �L?uihhL?� �?i^�@*�|) |L LM|@�? |�@| uLh tL4i

�2fc

�hd� _�o � �2f?E)3��d*L}?o4

.dmf� m4 nf(n�4o?E

�232>�4 ' JE?32>�c

ThL��_i_ E�� e>�4 : e>n 2E)� ��� �TT*)�?} E��qq�c e�� uL**L�t�

i ?L� it|@M*�t� e�2� A��t ThLM@M�*�|) �t ML�?_i_ M)

�2�?E)3���hdm?E>3Z�YA

W

Y�E�&�m : �22?

E)3>�

*L} ?o n JE?32>�c

uLh tL4i �&c t�U� |�@| �&?Z � �& 5 F&� ,4T*L)�?}

mYAW

Y�m � �2e

;?=mYf�

Y�mn

���Yf(

Y�

��� mf� ms?

n ��n

���Yf(

Y�

��� nf(n mf� m?

<@> c

@?_ �@h!L�<t �?i^�@*�|)c �i �@�i |L it|@M*�t�

e�2�� 7�R?.dm?E>3Z� Yf�

Y�m4W� o 4c E)� >�4W� : 2>n )� �

e�2�2 7�R?.d���?E>W3Z� Yf(

Y�

���4W2 mf� m4W2 o 4c E)� >n �2� d>W � >o�4W2 : 2>n )� �

e�2�� 7�R?.d���?E>W3Z� Yf(

Y�

���4W� nf(n4W� mf� m4W� o 4c E)�>n��d>W�>o�4W� : 2>n)��c

@** ^�@?|�|�it i�@*�@|i_ @| @ M@?_��_|� �&� �) �@�U�)�5U��@h3c

.d���?E>W3Z� Yf(

Y�

���4W2 mf� m4W2 o � .�*2d���?E>W3Z� Yf(

Y�

���24W2 o.�*2dmf� m24W2 o.d

���?E>W3Z� Yf(

Y�

���4W� nf(n4W� mf� m4W� o � .�*2d���?E>W3Z� Yf(

Y�

���24W� o.�*ednf(ne4W� o.�*edmf� me4W� o

Page 40: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

�b

A�ihiuLhic ThL��_i_ �2 4L4i?|t i �t|c |�i hit�*| uL**L�t M) @TT*�U@|�L? Lu wi44@

�f�

�+��6 �6 ��+�ww�+v

A�i *LU@* TL*)?L4�@* it|�4@|Lht gG^&wE~�� @?_

gG^&C2E~�� @hi ML|� *�?i@h �? + ��|�

�i�}�|tq�^��

rc @?_ U@? Mi _iUL4TLti_ @t

gG^&wE~�� ' G^

&wE~�� n�^w� n T ^

w� (gG^&C2E~�� ' G^

&C2E~�� n�^#� n T ^

#�c

��ihi T ^_� '

S� �

^��#_� ' �� E?

3�*2�W3E�n^�*2� @?_ �^_� ' �E�WE^

W3^�� uhL4 wi44@ ��

6�h|�ih4Lhic

gl#w^ � l#w^ ' ?3�

S?�'�

q�^w��

^#� nG^

&wE~���^#� nG^

&C2E~���^w�

rn ?3�

S?�'�

qG^&wE~��T

^#� nG^

&C2E~��T^w�

rn ?3�

S?�'�

q�^w�T

^#� n�^

#�T^w�

rn ?3�

S?�'� T

^w�T

^#��

A�i �ht| hL� �t _i|ih4�?�t|�U @?_ �E�WE^W3^��� A�i tiUL?_ �t �� E?

3�*2� M) �?|ihU�@?}�

�?} t�44@|�L?t� A�i |��h_ �t �� E?3�*2�WE^

W3^��c ���*i |�i *@t| �t �� E?3��W3E�n^�*2��

6Lhs? UL?t�t|i?U) Lu

gl#w^ �| �t ?iUitt@h) |�@| ?�W2E^

W3^� $ f @?_ ?�WE�n^� $ 4�

i @TT*) |�i ThLLu |iU�?�^�i Lu A�iLhi4 �� wi| � ' im��E�Wf�m �2Dj c |�i?

imgl#w^ � l#w^ m �2Sj ^ i���eP�P

��� �2Sj � �

uLh tL4i �2Sc M) |�i UL?|�?��|) Lu ��f� Nt�?} @ �iht�L? Lu wi44@ b uLhgl#w^ � l#w^ c �i

LM|@�? �hd�So ' JE?32>�� i @TT*) E��qq�c @?_ |�i hit�*| uL**L�t�

Page 41: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

ef

-.8.-.��.7

d�o �O�c O�c ��# a�w� ��`,ww E�bb��G �,t|�4@|�L? Lu �i?tLhi_ 5i*iU|�L? �L_i*t

��|� @ �L?T@h@4i|h�U 5i*iU|�L? �iU�@?�t4�� aL�h?@* Lu ,UL?L4i|h�Utc DHc ���f�

d2o ��#+,`5c #�`�k�c E�bHb@�G �5i4�T@h@4i|h�U ,UL?L4i|h�U �L_i*tG W ,t|��

4@|�L?�� �L�*it 6L�?_@|�L? #�tU�tt�L? T@Tih ?L� bfH�

d�o ��#+,`5c #�`�k�c E�bHbM�G �5i4�T@h@4i|h�U ,UL?L4i|h�U �L_i*tG WW Ait|�

�?}c� �L�*it 6L�?_@|�L? #�tU�tt�L? T@Tih ?L� b�f�

deo ��#+,`5c #�`�k�c E�bb�@�G ��t)4T|L|�U �Lh4@*�|) Lu 5ih�it ,t|�4@|Lht uLh

�L?T@h@4i|h�U @?_ 5i4�T@h@4i|h�U +i}hitt�L? �L_i*t�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c Dbc �f.�

�eS�

dDo ��#+,`5c #�`�k�c E�bb�M�G �Oi|ihLt!i_@t|�U�|) @?_ ��|LULhhi*@|�L? �L?t�t�

|i?| �L�@h�@?Ui �@|h� ,t|�4@|�L?�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c Dbc H�.�HDH�

dSo ���k5c a�c +� �wN�#,wwc ��# �� w,`�,wc E�bb2�G �"�@_h@|�U ,?}i*

��h�itc i*u@hi �i@t�hi4i?| @?_ �L?t�4ih #i4@?_�� W65 Lh!�?} �@Tih b2�

�e�

d.o ��+Aw,AAc ��5�c E�bS��G �5|@|�t|�U@* ,t|�4@|�L? Lu #i?t�|) 6�?U|�L?tc�

5@?!�)@ 5ih �c 2Dc �eD��De�

dHo �W�k,wc ��a�c E�bH2�G ��? �_@T|��i ,t|�4@|�L?�� �??@*t Lu 5|@|�t|�Utc �fc Se.�

S.��

Page 42: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

e�

dbo �W�k,wc �� a�c �� �� a� kw��55,�c v� +WA�Vc a� �� `,ww�,+ E�bb��G

,�U�i?| @?_ �_@T|��i W?uihi?Ui �? 5i4�T@h@4i|h�U �L_i*tc 6Lh|�UL4�?} �L?L�

}h@T�� �@*|�4LhiG aL�?t OLT!�?t N?��iht�|) �hitt�

d�fo �W,+,�5c O�a�c E�bH.�G �kih?i* ,t|�4@|Lht Lu +i}hitt�L? 6�?U|�L?t�� �? �_�

�@?Uit �? ,UL?L4i|h�UtG 6�u|� `Lh*_ �L?}hittc VL* �c i_� M) A�6� �i�*i)� �@4�

Mh�_}i N?��iht�|) �hitt�

d��o �W,+,�5c O�a�c ��# O��� ��AA��NA,+c E�bbf�G �5TiU��U@|�L? Lu OL�ti�L*_

,?}i* ��h�it M) �L?T@h@4i|h�U +i}hitt�L?�� ,UL?L4i|h�U +i��i�tc bc �2���He�

d�2o ��++�wwc +�a�c ��# `�O��+#w,c E�bHb�G �5iUL?_ �h_ih ,giU|t �? 5i4��

T@h@4i|h�U i�}�|i_ wi@t| 5^�@hit +i}hitt�L?�� 5|@|�t|�Utc 2c �.b��HS�

d��o ��V���BOc ��a� E�bHb�G �A�i �Lt| Lu �_@T|�?} uLh Oi|ihLtUi_@t|�U�|) �? w�?�

i@h +i}hitt�L? �L_i*t�� N?T�M*�t�i_ �@?�tUh�T|c O@h�@h_ N?��iht�|)�

d�eo �O,�c O� E�bHH�G ��L?�ih}i?Ui +@|it uLh �@h@4i|h�U �L4TL?i?|t �? @ �@h|*)

w�?i@h �L_i*c� �??@*t Lu 5|@|�t|�Utc �Sc ��S��eS�

d�Do �O,5O,+c ��c ��# W� a,`WAAc E�bH.�G �A�i ��@t Lu @ Oi|ihLt!i_@t|�U�|)

�L?t�t|i?| �L�@h�@?Ui �@|h� �� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c DDc �2�.��222�

d�So �O,5O,+c ��c ��# +� 5��#v E�bb��G ��t)4T|L|�U , T@?t�L?t Lu |�i W?uLh�

4@|�L? �@|h� Ait| 5|@|�t|�U�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c Dbc .H.�H�S�

d�.o #,wB�#�c �� ��# A� 5A,�B�5 E�bbe�G �5i4�T@h@4i|h�U 5TiU��U@|�L? Ait|�

�?} Lu �L?�?it|i_ ,UL?L4i|h�U 4L_i*t�� +i��i� Lu ,UL?L4�U 5|�_�itc S�c 2b��

�f��

d�Ho #,wB�#�c �� E�bb2�G �5i4�T@h@4i|h�U Bi?ih@*�ti_ wi@t| 5^�@hit �? |�i ��*�

|��@h�@|i �L?*�?i@h +i}hitt�L? �L_i*�� ,UL?L4i|h�U A�iLh)c Hc 2f��222�

Page 43: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

e2

d�bo ,�Bw,c +� 6�c �� `� a� B+��B,+c a� +W�,c ��# �� `,W55 E�bHS�G

�5i4�T@h@4i|h�U ,t|�4@|it Lu |�i +i*@|�L?t��T �i|�ii? i@|�ih @?_ ,*iU|h�U�|)

5@*itc� aL�h?@* Lu |�i �4ih�U@? 5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?c H�c ��f��2f�

d2fo 6��c a� E�bb2�G �#it�}?��_@T|��i �L?T@h@4i|h�U +i}hitt�L?�� aL�h?@* Lu |�i

�4ih�U@? 5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?c H.c bbH��ffe�

d2�o 6��c a� @?_ W�BWa�,w5 E�bb2�G �V@h�@M*i �@?_��_|� @?_ wLU@* w�?i@h +i}hit�

t�L? 54LL|�iht�� �??@*t Lu 5|@|�t|�Utc 6Lh|�UL4�?} �

d22o O�wwc ��c ��# �� O,v#, E�bHf�G�@h|�?}@*i w�4�| A�iLh) @?_ �|t �TT*�U@|�L?�

�i� vLh!c �U@_i4�U �hitt�

d2�o O�wwc ��c E�bH��G �w@h}i 5@4T*i �T|�4@*�|) Lu wi@t| 5^�@hit �hLtt��@*�_@|�L?

�? #i?t�|) ,t|�4@|�L?�� �??@*t Lu 5|@|�t|�Utc ��c ��DS���.e�

d2eo O��+#w,c `�c ��O�wwc ��# O� W�OW�N+� E�bb2�G ��T|�4@* 54LL|��?} �?

5�?}*i W?_i �L_i*t�� ��+, #�tU�tt�L? �@Tih ?L� b�f.�

d2Do O��+#w,c `�c a� O�+Ac a� 5� ��++��c ��# �� �� A5v��k�V E�bb2�G

��@?_��_|� ��L�Ui uLh ��ih@}i #ih��@|��i ,t|�4@|�L?c� aL�h?@* Lu |�i �4ih�U@?

5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?c H.c 2�H�22S�

d2So O��+#w,c `�c ��# �� wW�A�� E�bbe�G ��TT*�i_ ?L?T@h@4i|h�U 4i|�L_tc�

A�i O@?_MLL! Lu ,UL?L4i|h�Utc VL*� WVc i_t #�6� �U6@__i? @?_ +�6� ,?}*i WWW�

�Lh|� OL**@?_�

d2.o O��+#w,c `�c ��# A� �� 5A�k,+ E�bHb�G �W?�it|�}@|�?} 54LL|� ��*|�T*i

+i}hitt�L? M) |�i �i|�L_ Lu ��ih@}i #ih��@|��itc� aL�h?@* Lu |�i �4ih�U@?

5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?c Hec bHS�bbD�

Page 44: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

e�

d2Ho O��+#w,c `� E�bbf�G �TT*�i_ �L?T@h@4i|h�U +i}hitt�L?� �@4Mh�_}i N?��iht�|)

�hitt

d2bo O,�k���c ��,�c E�bHS�G �5T*�?i 54LL|��?} �? @ �@h|*) w�?i@h �L_i*�� aL�h�

?@* Lu |�i +L)@* 5|@|�t|�U@* 5LU�i|)c 5ih�it �c eHc 2ee�2eH�

d�fo O5W,Oc #���c ��# ��6� ���5kW E�bH.�G ��L?|i �@h*L ,��_i?Ui L? �_@T|��i

�@ �4�4 w�!i*��LL_ ,t|�4@|�L? Lu @ +i}hitt�L?�� �??@*t Lu 5|@|�t|�Utc �Dc De��

DD��

d��o a��,5c ����c a�5� ��++��c ��# 5�a� 5O,�AO,+ E�bb2�G ��hL}hitt �? #@|@�

�@ti_ �@?_��_|� 5i*iU|�L? uLh kih?i* #i?t�|) ,t|�4@|�L?c� ��t|h@*�@? Bh@_�@|i

5U�LL* Lu �@?@}i4i?|c N?��iht�|) Lu �5`c Lh!�?} �@Tih b2�f�e�

d�2o w,,c ��a�c E�bbf�G N�5|@|�t|�UtG A�iLh) @?_ �h@U|�Ui� �@hUi* #i!!ih�

d��o w,,c w�6c ��+� +�5,�~`,WBc ��# ���� �WAAc E�bb2� �A�i ,giU|t Lu

W4ThL�i_ ��|h�|�L?c 5@?�|@|�L?c @?_ @|ih ��h�|) L? ���*_ Oi@*|� �? O�}��

�Lh|@*�|) �LT�*@|�L?tc� N?T�M*�t�i_ 4@?�tUh�T|�

d�eo wW�#5�vc ��B� E�bHb�G ��? |�i #i|ih4�?@?|t Lu �L4i?| �@|h�Uit�� �??@*t Lu

5|@|�t|�Utc �.c .���.2��

d�Do wW�A��c ���� E�bb��G ,_}i�Lh|� �TThL �4@|�L? �? 5i4�T@h@4i|h�U +i}hitt�L?

�L_i*t ��# |�it�tc #iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4�Ut N� �ih!i*i)�

d�So wW�A��c ���� E�bb2�G �,_}i�Lh|� �TThL �4@|�L? uLh Bi?ih@*�ti_ ��?�4�4

�L?|h@t| ,t|�4@|Lht �? 5i4�T@h@4i|h�U +i}hitt�L? �L_i*t�� ���i*_ �L**i}i

#�tU�tt�L? T@Tih ?L .��

d�.o ��++��c a�5� ��# ���� ��# E�bb2�G �, @U| �i@? W?|i}h@|i_ 5^�@hi_

,hhLh�� �??@*t Lu 5|@|�t|�Utc 2fc .�2�.�S�

Page 45: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

ee

d�Ho �Wk�5�Oc A� E�bb��G �6�?U|�L?@* w�4�| A�iLhi4t uLh +@?_L4 "�@_h@|�U

6Lh4t�� 5|LU�@t|�U �hLUittit @?_ |�i�h �TT*�U@|�L?tc �.c H��bH�

d�bo ��Nww,+c O� B� E�bHH�G �L?T@h@4i|h�U +i}hitt�L? �?@*)t�t Lu wL?}�|�_�?@*

#@|@� wiU|�hi �L|it �? 5|@|�t|�Utc VL*� eS� Oi�_i*Mih}%�i� vLh!G 5Th�?}ih�

Vih*@}�

defo ��B�+c ��w�c E�bDb�G �A�i ��@t @?_ �L4i?| �@|h� Lu |�i Bi?ih@* !��*@tt

,t|�4@|Lht Lu |�i �@h@4i|iht �? 5�4�*|@?iL�t ,^�@|�L?tc� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c 2.c

D.D�DbD�

de�o �,`,vc `�k� E�bbf@�G �5i4�T@h@4i|h�U ,�U�i?U) �L�?_tc� aL�h?@* Lu �T�

T*�i_ ,UL?L4i|h�Utc Dc bb���D�

de2o �,`,vc `�k� E�bbfM�G �,�U�i?| W?t|h�4i?|@* V@h�@M*it ,t|�4@|�L? Lu �L?�

*�?i@h �L_i*t�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c DHc Hfb�H�.�

de�o �,`,vc `�k�c a�w� ��`,wwc ��# a�+� �wk,+c E�bbf�G �5i4�T@h@4i|h�U

,t|�4@|�L? Lu 5i*iU|�L? �L_i*tG 5L4i ,4T�h�U@* +it�*|t�� �4ih�U@? ,UL?L4�U

+i��i�c Hfc �2e��2H�

deeo ��+kc ��N�c ��# a�5� ��++��c E�bbf�G ��L4T@h�tL? Lu #@|@�#h��i? �@?_�

��_|� 5i*iU|Lhtc� aL�h?@* Lu |�i �4ih�U@? 5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?c HDc SS�.2�

deDo �6��~�Bwc a�c E�bHf�G ��t)4T|L|�U , T@?t�L?t �? �@h@4i|h�U 5|@|�t|�U@* A�i�

Lh)c� �?G #i�i*LT4i?|t �? 5|@|�t|�Utc ��c E��+�kh�t�?@�@� i_� �U@_i4�U �hitt�

deSo �OWwwW�5c ����� ��# a�v� ��+k E�bHH�G ��? |�i 6Lh4�*@|�L? Lu @*_ Ait|t

uLh �L?*�?i@h +it|h�U|�L?t�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c DSc �fSD��fH��

de.o ��`,wwc a� w�c a� O� 5A��kc ��# A� �� 5A�k,+ E�bHb�G �5i4�T@h@4i|h�U

,t|�4@|�L? Lu W?_i �Li�U�i?|t�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c D.c �ef���e�f�

Page 46: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

eD

deHo +W�,c a� E�bHS�G ��L?�ih}i?Ui +@|it uLh �@h|�@**) 5T*�?i_ �L_i*t�� 5|@|�t|�Ut

@?_ �hLM@M�*�|) wi||ihtc ec 2f��2fH�

debo +��W�5��c �� �� E�bH.�G ��t)4T|L|�U@**) ,�U�i?| ,t|�4@|�L? �? |�i �hiti?Ui

Lu Oi|ihLt!i_@t|�U�|) Lu N?!?L�? uLh4�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c DSc H.D�Hb��

dDfo +��W�5��c �� �� E�bHH@�G �A�i 5|LU�@t|�U #�gihi?Ui Mi|�ii? ,UL?L4i|h�U

5|@|�t|�Utc� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c DSc D���DeH�

dD�o +��W�5��c �� �� E�bHHM�G �+LL|����L?t�t|i?| 5i4�T@h@4i|h�U +i}hitt�L?c�

,UL?L4i|h�U@c DSc b���bDe�

dD2o +��W�5��c �� �� E�bHHU�G �5i4�T@h@4i|h�U ,UL?L4i|h�UtG � 5�h�i)c� aL�h?@*

Lu �TT*�i_ ,UL?L4i|h�Utc �c �D�D��

dD�o +��W�5��c �� �� E�bHb�G �O)TL|�it�t Ait|�?} �? 5i4�T@h@4i|h�U @?_ �L?�

T@h@4i|h�U �L_i*t uLh ,UL?L4�U A�4i 5ih�it�� +i��i� Lu ,UL?L4�U 5|�_�itc DSc

D���D�e�

dDeo +��W�5��c �� �� E�bb�@�G ���|L4@|�U 6hi^�i?U) #L4@�? W?uihi?Ui L? 5i4��

T@h@4i|h�U @?_ �L?T@h@4i|h�U �L_i*t�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c Dbc ��2b���Se�

dDDo +��W�5��c �� �� E�bb�M�G ��it| �L?*�?i@h A�hii�t|@}i wi@t| 5^�@hit ,t|��

4@|�L? Lu Uih|@�? ,UL?L4i|h�U �L_i*t�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c Dbc .DD�.HS�

dDSo +�AO,��,+Bc A�c E�bHe@�G ��TThL �4@|�?} |�i #�t|h�M�|�L?t Lu ,UL?L4i|h�U

,t|�4@|Lht @?_ Ait| 5|@|�t|�Ut�� ����e �?G O@?_MLL! Lu ,UL?L4i|h�Utc VL* 2c i_�

M) ~� Bh�*�U�it @?_ ��W?|h�*�}@|Lh� �Lh|� OL**@?_�

dD.o +�AO,��,+Bc A�c E�bHeM�G ��TThL �4@|i �Lh4@*�|) Lu Bi?ih@*�3i_ wi@t|

5^�@hit ,t|�4@|it�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c D2c H���H2D�

Page 47: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

eS

dDHo +�AO,��,+Bc A�c E�bHeU�G �O)TL|�it�t Ait|�?} �? w�?i@h �L_i*t ��i? |�i

,hhLh �L�@h�@?Ui �@|h� �t �L?tU@*@h�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c D2c H2.�He2�

dDbo +�AO,��,+Bc A�c E�bHH�G ��TThL �4@|i �L�ih 6�?U|�L?t uLh tL4i +LM�t|

Ait|t Lu +i}hitt�L? �Li�U�i?|t�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c DSc bb.��f�b�

dSfo +N��,+Ac #� ��# ���� ��# E�bb2�G ���*|��@h�@|i i�}�|i_ wi@t| 5^�@hit

+i}hitt�L?�� +�Ui N?��iht�|)c #iT@h|4i?| Lu 5|@|�t|�Ut AiU�?�U@* +iTLh| ?L b2�e�

dS�o 5�+B��c a�#�c ��# `����WkO�Wwc E�b.��G �� Bi?ih@* �TThL �4@|�L? |L

|�i #�t|h�M�|�L? Lu W?t|h�4i?|@* V@h�@M*it ,t|�4@|it�� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c �bc ����

�Sb�

dS2o 5O,�AO,+c 5�a�c ��# ���� a��,5c E�bb��G �� +i*�@M*i #@|@�M@ti_ �@?_�

��_|� 5i*iU|�L? �i|�L_ uLh kih?i* #i?t�|) ,t|�4@|�L?c� aL�h?@* Lu |�i +L)@*

5|@|�t|�U@* 5LU�i|) 5ih�it �c D�c SH��Sbf�

dS�o 5WwV,+���c �� E�bHS�G #i?t�|) it|�4@|�L? uLh t|@|�t|�Ut @?_ _@|@ @?@*)t�t�

wL?_L?c ��@T4@? @?_ O@**�

dSeo 5�,�k���c �� E�bHH�G �kih?i* 54LL|��?} �? �@h|�@* w�?i@h �L_i*tc� aL�h?@*

Lu |�i +L)@* 5|@|�t|�U@* 5LU�i|) 5ih�it �c Dfc e���e�S�

dSDo 5+W��V�5��c A��� E�b.f�G ��TThL �4@|�L?t |L 6�?�|i 5@4T*i �L4i?|t Lu ,t�

|�4@|Lht ��Lti , @U| 5@4T*�?} #�t|h�M�|�L?t @hi �?!?L�?c� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c �Hc

D���De��

dSSo 5A��kc a� O� E�bHb�G ��L?T@h@4i|h�U �L*�U) �?@*)t�tc� aL�h?@* Lu |�i �4ih��

U@? 5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?c Hec DS.�D.S�

Page 48: COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT … · COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AT YALE UNIVERSITY Box 2125, Yale Station New Haven, Connecticut 06520 COWLES FOUNDATION

e.

dS.o 5A��kc a� O� E�bb��G ��L?T@h@4i|h�U �L*�U) �?@*)t�tG �? �TT*�U@|�L? |L

,t|�4@|�?} O@3@h_L�t @t|i �*i@?�T �i?i�|tc� �? �L?T@h@4i|h�U @?_ 5i4��

T@h@4i|h�U �i|�L_t �? ,UL?L4i|h�Ut @?_ 5|@|�t|�Ut� ,_t �@h?i||c �L�i**c @?_

A@�U�i?�

dSHo 5A�k,+c A��c E�bHb�G �Ait|t Lu ��ih@}i #ih��@|��i �L?t|h@�?|tc� +i��i� Lu

,UL?L4�U 5|�_�itc DSc D�D�DD2�

dSbo 5A�k,+c A��c E�bb��G �54LL|��?} ��@t �? #ih��@|��i ,t|�4@|�L?�� aL�h?@* Lu

|�i �4ih�U@? 5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?c 6Lh|�UL4�?}�

d.fo 5A��,c ��a� E�b..�G ��L?t�t|i?| �L?T@h@4i|h�U +i}hitt�L?c� �??@*t Lu 5|@|�t�

|�Utc Dc DbD�S2f�