Diagnostic challenges in COVID-19 associated invasive aspergillosis (CAPA) Mohammad T. Hedayati Professor of medical mycology Invasive Fungi Research Center/ Department of Medical Mycology, Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences, Sari, Iran
Diagnostic challenges in
COVID-19 associated invasive aspergillosis
(CAPA)
Mohammad T. Hedayati Professor of medical mycology
Invasive Fungi Research Center/ Department of Medical Mycology,
Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences, Sari, Iran
Low risk Intermediate risk High risk
Autologous HSCT Acute lymphoblastic leukaemia Acute myeloid leukaemia
Hodgkin’s lymphoma Chronic lymphocytic leukaemia Allogeneic HSCT
Chronic myeloproliferative disorders (CML, Ph- diseases)
Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma Heart, lung, liver transplantation
Solid cancer COPD CGD
Myeloma AIDS Severe influenza Kidney transplantation Myelodysplastic syndromes COVID-19 Chronic immunological disease
Systemic lupus erythematosus
Classification of risk for IFD
Similar to those identified for influenza-
IPA superinfections
The most important risk factors include
Severe lung damage during the course of
COVID-19
Using corticosteroids in those with ARDS
Risk factors predisposing for CAPA
Widespread use of broad-spectrum antibiotics in
ICU
Presence of comorbidities such as structural lung
defects
Underlying medical conditions - hypertension diabetes
- obesity COPD
- heart diseases asthma
Cont. (Risk factors predisposing for CAPA)
Diagnostic algorithms
Lack of a consensus on a diagnostic algorithms in
COVID-19
Revised (EORTC/MSG-2020)
AspICU algorithm (Blot et al)
Recently proposed diagnostic algorithms for
CAPA (Koehler et al)
8
-Host factors
and
-Clinical criteria
-Host factors and
-Clinical criteria
and
-Mycological criteria
-Histopathology, Cytology or
-Culture on normal sterile areas
and
-clinical and radiological
The Consensus Definitions of Invasive Fungal Disease From the European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer and the Mycoses Study Group Education and
Research Consortium (EORTC/MSG-2020)- IFI
Diagnosis Outcome
Possible
Probable Proven
15
A single positive aspergillus PCR in plasma, serum, or whole
blood, and a single positive in BAL fluid (any threshold cycle
permitted)
Mycological evidences
At least one of the following
Microscopic detection of fungal
elements in BAL, indicating a mold Positive BAL culture
Serum GM index >0・5 or
serum LFA index >0・5
BAL GM index ≥1・0 or
BAL LFA index ≥1・0
Two or more positive aspergillus
PCR tests in plasma, serum, or
whole blood
A single positive
aspergillus PCR in BAL
fluid (<36 cycles)
Probable IA
Or
17
Non-bronchoscopic lavage GM index >1・2 plus
another non-bronchoscopic lavage mycology test
positive (non-bronchoscopic lavage PCR or LFA)
Microscopic detection of fungal
elements in non-bronchoscopic
lavage indicating a mold
Positive non-
bronchoscopic lavage
culture
Single non-bronchoscopic
lavage GM index >4・5 Non-bronchoscopic lavage GM
index >1・2 twice or more
Possible IA
Or
Mycological evidences
At least one of the following
18
Microscopic Culture GM
detection
non-
bronchoscopic
lavage
BAL or
Blood
Probable CAPA Possible CAPA
Biopsied
materials
Histopat
hology Culture PCR
GM
detec
tion
Cultu
re
Micro
scopi
c
PCR
Proven CAPA
19
In case of patients with COPD or chronic
respiratory disease, the PCR or culture results
should be confirmed by galactomannan testing
to rule out colonization or chronic aspergillosis.
Classification of possible CAPA will most
likely be sufficient to initiate antifungal
therapy in the clinic
BAL and non-bronchoscopic lavage are
currently not considered equal for diagnosing
CAPA.
20
Lateral-flow Device Test
An immunochromatographic assay The JF5 Ag and monoclonal Ab (JF5) (extracellular glycoprotein antigen from Aspergillus spp., only secreted during active growth) Highly specific for Aspergillus species No cross-reactivity (Only cross-reactions with Penicillium spp.)
21
(1,3)-β-D- Glucan assay (BDG) Cell wall polysaccharide in the of most pathogenic fungi, such as Aspergillus, Candida, Fusarium, Acremonium, Penicillium, Paecilomyces, and Pneumocystis jirovecii, - - Important exception of Mucorales and Cryptococcus spp?!. was not considered to provide mycological evidence for IA Facilitation of early diagnosis Useful for patients receiving antifungal prophylaxis Approved for use in serum only
For Candidiasis and Pneumocystosis: (Fungitell) ≥80 ng/L
(pg/mL) detected in at least 2 consecutive serum samples provided
that other etiologies have been excluded
22
a water-soluble cell-wall polysaccharide
released by the growing hyphae
detectable in body fluids
detectable a median of 5 to 8 days (range 1 to 27 days) before clinical signs
positive results 10±4 days before culture methodologies
correlate with fungal tissue burden
Various assays, Platelia™Aspergillus EIA (Bio- Rad, France)
surrogate marker to follow the efficacy of treatment
23
Mehmet Ergün et al. Aspergillus test profiles and mortality in critically-ill COVID-19 patients. J Clin Microbiol. 2021 Sep 8;JCM0122921.
•.
Methods A multinational case-control study, in which Aspergillus test results, use of antifungal therapy and
mortality were collected from critically-ill COVID-19 patients. Patients were classified using the 2020
ECMM/ISHAM consensus case definitions. Results 219 critically-ill COVID-19 cases were analyzed,
including one proven, 38 probable, 19 possible CAPA cases, 21 Aspergillus colonized patients, seven
patients only positive for serum (1, 3)-ß-D-glucan (BDG), and 133 cases with no evidence of CAPA. Mortality
was 53.8% in CAPA patients compared to 24.1% in patients without CAPA (p=0.001). Positive serum
galactomannan (GM) and BDG were associated with increased mortality compared
to serum biomarker negative CAPA patients (87.5% versus 41.7%, p=0.046; 90.0% versus
42.1%, p=0.029, respectively). For each point increase in GM or ten-point BDG serum concentration, the
odds of death increased (GM, OR 10.208, 95%CI 1.621-64.291, p=0.013; BDG, OR 1.247, 95%CI 1.029-
1.511, p=0.024). Conclusions CAPA is a complex disease, probably involving a continuum of respiratory
colonization, tissue-invasion and angioinvasion. Serum biomarkers are useful for staging CAPA disease
progression and, if positive, indicate angioinvasion and a high probability of mortality.
There is need for a biomarker that distinguishes between respiratory tract colonization and tissue invasive
CAPA disease.
Take Home Message
None of the currently available diagnostic tests provides sufficient sensitivity and specificity alone
The hallmark of IFI diagnosis: - a combination of various testing
strategies