Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman, Ph.D., P.E. Houston Engineering Solutions, LLC (+1) 832-838-4894 [email protected]
Costly Lessons Learned from
Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums
RefComm
2019
Galveston, TX
Mahmod Samman, Ph.D., P.E.Houston Engineering Solutions, LLC
(+1) 832-838-4894
www.hes.us.com
Company Background
2
www.hes.us.com
Overview
• Inspection of cone side of skirt attachment
• Smoothing of laser data
• Internal inspection of seam weld cracks
3
www.hes.us.com
Inspection of Cone Side of Skirt
Attachment
4
www.hes.us.com
In-Line Skirt
5
API 1996 Survey
www.hes.us.com
Shear Wave Ultrasonic Testing
6
www.hes.us.com
Case Study
7
Through-wall crack not detected
www.hes.us.com
Smoothing of Laser Scan Data
8
www.hes.us.com
Why?
• Drill-stem vibrations
• Digital noise
9
www.hes.us.com
Vibration Effect
10
www.hes.us.com
Signal Distortion
11
www.hes.us.com
Signal Filtering
12
www.hes.us.com
Signal Zoom
13
www.hes.us.com
Case StudyRadius map
Less smoothing More smoothing
14
www.hes.us.com
Case StudyBulging Severity (PSI)
Less smoothing More smoothing
15
Incorrect assessment of severe bulges
www.hes.us.com
Internal Inspection of Seam Weld
Cracks using Alternating Current Field
Measurement (ACFM)
16
www.hes.us.com
Classic Tri-Metal Joint Cracks
Base Metal
Circumferential Weld
Clad
Restoration Weld
www.hes.us.com
Common OD Cracks
Base Metal
Circumferential Weld
Clad
Restoration Weld
www.hes.us.com
Case Study
Base Metal
Circumferential Weld
Clad
Restoration Weld
Sensor Array
Almost through-wall crack not detectable using internal ACFM.
Need internal AND external ACFM, UT, or AET
www.hes.us.com
Recap
• Inspection of cone side of skirt attachment
• Smoothing of laser data
• Internal inspection of seam weld cracks
20