Top Banner
Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman, Ph.D., P.E. Houston Engineering Solutions, LLC (+1) 832-838-4894 [email protected]
20

Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

May 03, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

Costly Lessons Learned from

Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums

RefComm

2019

Galveston, TX

Mahmod Samman, Ph.D., P.E.Houston Engineering Solutions, LLC

(+1) 832-838-4894

[email protected]

Page 2: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Company Background

2

Page 3: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Overview

• Inspection of cone side of skirt attachment

• Smoothing of laser data

• Internal inspection of seam weld cracks

3

Page 4: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Inspection of Cone Side of Skirt

Attachment

4

Page 5: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

In-Line Skirt

5

API 1996 Survey

Page 6: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Shear Wave Ultrasonic Testing

6

Page 7: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Case Study

7

Through-wall crack not detected

Page 8: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Smoothing of Laser Scan Data

8

Page 9: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Why?

• Drill-stem vibrations

• Digital noise

9

Page 10: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Vibration Effect

10

Page 11: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Signal Distortion

11

Page 12: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Signal Filtering

12

Page 13: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Signal Zoom

13

Page 14: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Case StudyRadius map

Less smoothing More smoothing

14

Page 15: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Case StudyBulging Severity (PSI)

Less smoothing More smoothing

15

Incorrect assessment of severe bulges

Page 16: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Internal Inspection of Seam Weld

Cracks using Alternating Current Field

Measurement (ACFM)

16

Page 17: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Classic Tri-Metal Joint Cracks

Base Metal

Circumferential Weld

Clad

Restoration Weld

Page 18: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Common OD Cracks

Base Metal

Circumferential Weld

Clad

Restoration Weld

Page 19: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Case Study

Base Metal

Circumferential Weld

Clad

Restoration Weld

Sensor Array

Almost through-wall crack not detectable using internal ACFM.

Need internal AND external ACFM, UT, or AET

Page 20: Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums · 2019-04-12 · Costly Lessons Learned from Inspection Pitfalls of Coke Drums RefComm 2019 Galveston, TX Mahmod Samman,

www.hes.us.com

Recap

• Inspection of cone side of skirt attachment

• Smoothing of laser data

• Internal inspection of seam weld cracks

20