Top Banner
Criminal Law and International Crimes VOLUME 2 Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability Report of the International Commission of Jurists Expert Legal Panel on Corporate Complicity in International Crimes
71

Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH

Sep 01, 2018

Download

Documents

truongquynh
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH

Criminal Law and International Crimes

VOLUME2

Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability

Report of the International Commission of Jurists Expert Legal Panel on Corporate Complicity in International Crimes

Page 2: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH

While there are situations in which businesses and their o!cials are directly and immediately responsible for human rights abuses, allegations are frequently made that businesses have become implicated with another actor in the perpetration of human rights abuses. In such cir-cumstances, human rights organisations and activists, international policy makers, govern-ment experts, and businesses themselves, now use the phrase “business complicity in human rights abuses” to describe what they view as undesirable business involvement in such abuses. "is development has spawned reports, analysis, debate and questions. What does it mean for a business to be “complicit”? What are the consequences of such complicity? How can busi-nesses avoid becoming complicit? How should they be held to account for their complicity? In many respects, although the use of the term is widespread, there continues to be consider-able confusion and uncertainty about the boundaries of this concept and in particular when legal liability, both civil and criminal, could arise.

In #$$%, in order to address some of these questions the International Commission of Jurists asked eight expert jurists to form the Expert Legal Panel on Corporate Complicity in International Crimes. "e Panel was asked to explore when companies and their o!cials could be held legally responsible under criminal and/or civil law when they are complicit in gross human rights abuses and to provide guidance as to the kind of situations prudent compa-nies should avoid.

International Commission of JuristsICJ33, rue des Bains1211 Geneva 8Switzerland

In this second Volume of its &nal report the Panel asks in what circumstances international criminal law could hold companies and/or their o!cials criminally responsible when they are involved with others in gross human rights abuses that amount to crimes under international law. "is volume also looks brie'y at the important role that criminal law plays in ensuring the accountability, and preventing the impunity, of actors involved in such abuses.

Criminal Law and International Crimes

VOLUME2

Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability

Report of the International Commission of Jurists Expert Legal Panel on Corporate Complicity in International Crimes

Page 3: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 4: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 5: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH

2

Page 6: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 7: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH

2

Page 8: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 9: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 10: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 11: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 12: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 13: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 14: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 15: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 16: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 17: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 18: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 19: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 20: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 21: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 22: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 23: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 24: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 25: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 26: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 27: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 28: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 29: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 30: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 31: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 32: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 33: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 34: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 35: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 36: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 37: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 38: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 39: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 40: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 41: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 42: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 43: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 44: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 45: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 46: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 47: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 48: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 49: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 50: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 51: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 52: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 53: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 54: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 55: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 56: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 57: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 58: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 59: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 60: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 61: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 62: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 63: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 64: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 65: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 66: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 67: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 68: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 69: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 70: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH
Page 71: Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability - … · Corporate Complicity & Legal Accountability ... (* #044" 6HBOEB "NCBTTBEPS +VMJP #"3#0;" ... & NBJM JOGP!JDK PSH XXX JDK PSH