Contest Rules and Judging criteriaR1.ppt

4th Continual Improvement and Innovation Symposium / World Quality Day

28-Nov-2012

Case Study Competitions Rules and Judging Criteria

• Kaizen• Breakthrough Process Improvement• Innovation• Best Practice in Management of Improvement and Innovation

Assessment Process

Select Define & Define & agree Evaluators Final

2

Select Evaluators

Define & Agree Criteria

agree Range & scoring

Evaluators final

consensus

Final Selection

KAIZEN COMPETITION

Contest Rules & Judging Criteria

Kaizen Judging Criteria

• Creativity 10%• Thoroughness in implementation 20%• Benefits 25%• Participation 20%

4

• Participation 20%• Standardization 15%• Replicability 10%

Timing

• Green light at 2 minutes• Amber light at 3 minutes• Red light at 4 minutes

5

• Presentation must stop within 30 seconds• Questions by Judges (2 minutes)

INNOVATION COMPETITION

Contest Rules & Judging Criteria

6

Innovation Judging Criteria

• Creativity 10%• Thoroughness in implementation

– Implementation planning 10%– Extent of Implementation 10%

7

– Extent of Implementation 10%• Benefits 15%• Participation 20%• Standardization 20%• Learning and Replicability 15%

Timing

• Green light at 5 minutes• Amber light at 7 minutes• Red light at 8 minutes

8

• Presentation must stop within 30 seconds• Questions by Judges (3 minutes)

BREAKTHROUGH IMPROVEMENT COMPETITIONIMPROVEMENT COMPETITION

Contest Rules & Judging Criteria

9

Breakthrough Process Improvement Judging Criteria

• Project Identification & Selection 10%• Chartering 15%• Methodology & Use 40%• Results 20%

10

• Results 20%• Learning’s & Leveraging 5%• Overall Views of the Judges 10%

Timing

• Green light at 5 minutes• Amber light at 7 minutes• Red light at 8 minutes

11

• Presentation must stop within 30 seconds• Questions by Judges (3 minutes)

BEST PRACTICE IN MANAGING

IMPROVEMENT AND IMPROVEMENT AND INOVATIONContest Rules

& Judging Criteria

12

Best Practice in Managing Improvement and Innovation

• Involvement of leaders 15%• Alignment with policy and strategy 10%• People engagement 20%• Resources utilised 10%• Processes for improvement and innovation 10%

13

• Processes for improvement and innovation 10%• Value addition to customers 10%• Contribution to Society 10%• Contribution to key results 15%

Timing

• Green light at 5 minutes• Amber light at 7 minutes• Red light at 8 minutes

14

• Presentation must stop within 30 seconds• Questions by Judges (3 minutes)