Top Banner
CONFLICTS of INTERFACE Mushon Zer-Aviv
106

Conflict of Interface (eng)

Jun 19, 2015

Download

Social Media

Mushon Zer-Aviv

The internet, once associated with openness and decentralization, is increasingly understood in terms of control exerted by government agencies (like the NSA) and advertising (targeted ads). What is less commonly discussed is how this subliminal control is embedded in interface design. Web interfaces demand our silent obedience with every page load. This talk offers new approaches to challenging the politics of the interface.

After the talk three projects were discussed:
- ShiftSpace
- The Turing Normalizing Machine
- Adnauseam
Originally presented at Eyebeam, NYC on March 11th, 2014
http://eyebeam.org/events/the-politics-of-interface-and-obfuscation
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Conflict of Interface (eng)

CONFLICTS of INTERFACE Mushon Zer-Aviv

Page 2: Conflict of Interface (eng)

1. Communication Cycle

2. Protocol

3. Interface for Resistance

Page 3: Conflict of Interface (eng)

1. Communication Cycle

2. Protocol

3. Interface for Resistance2 project examples + 1 post-mortem

Page 4: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Life Online

Page 5: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Online Life

Page 6: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Interface

Page 7: Conflict of Interface (eng)

“a common boundary or interconnection

between systems, equipment, concepts, or human beings”

Page 8: Conflict of Interface (eng)

“a common boundary or interconnection

between systems, equipment, concepts, or human beings”

Page 9: Conflict of Interface (eng)

“a common boundary or interconnection

between systems, equipment, concepts, or human beings”

Page 10: Conflict of Interface (eng)

1. Communication Cycle

Page 11: Conflict of Interface (eng)

A B

Page 12: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Stuart Hall

Page 13: Conflict of Interface (eng)

A B

Page 14: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 15: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Textua

l Dete

rmini

sm

Page 16: Conflict of Interface (eng)

ENCODING

A

B

Page 17: Conflict of Interface (eng)

MEANINGFUL DISCOURSE

B

Page 18: Conflict of Interface (eng)

DECODING

B

C

Page 19: Conflict of Interface (eng)

ENCODING/DECODING

Page 20: Conflict of Interface (eng)

DOMINANT/HEGEMONIC

Page 21: Conflict of Interface (eng)

NEGOTIATED

Page 22: Conflict of Interface (eng)

OPPOSITIONAL

Page 23: Conflict of Interface (eng)

?

Page 24: Conflict of Interface (eng)

ENCODING (via interface)

A

B

Page 25: Conflict of Interface (eng)

A

B

CDECODING

B

Page 26: Conflict of Interface (eng)

ENCODING + DECODING (dominant interface)

Page 27: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 29: Conflict of Interface (eng)

THE INTERFACE TEACHES OBEDIENCE

Page 30: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Lisa Nakamura

Page 31: Conflict of Interface (eng)

!MENU DRIVEN IDENTITIES

Page 32: Conflict of Interface (eng)

2. Protocol

Page 33: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 34: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Consistant Protocol

Page 35: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 36: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Consistant Protocol

Page 37: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 38: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Consistant Protocol

Page 39: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Internet Protocol Layer

Application Layer

Page 40: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Flexible Protocol

Page 41: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Interface

Internet Protocol Layer

Application Layer

Page 42: Conflict of Interface (eng)

The Interface Question = A Governance Question

Page 44: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 45: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 46: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 47: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 48: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 49: Conflict of Interface (eng)

!The Medium is the Message

Page 50: Conflict of Interface (eng)

!The Medium is the MessageInt

erfac

e Dete

rmini

sm

Page 51: Conflict of Interface (eng)

!The Interface is the Message

Page 52: Conflict of Interface (eng)

!The Interface is the Message

Techn

o Dete

rmini

sm

Page 53: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Donald Rumsfeld

Page 54: Conflict of Interface (eng)

There are Known Knowns

Page 55: Conflict of Interface (eng)

There are Known Knowns There are Known Unknowns

Page 56: Conflict of Interface (eng)

There are Known Knowns There are Known Unknowns

There are Unknown Unknowns

Page 57: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Slavoj Žižek

Page 58: Conflict of Interface (eng)

There are Unknown Knowns

Page 59: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Steve Krug

Page 60: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 61: Conflict of Interface (eng)

3. Interface for Resistance

Page 62: Conflict of Interface (eng)

User Generated Content

Page 63: Conflict of Interface (eng)

User Generated ContextContent

Page 64: Conflict of Interface (eng)

ContextUser Generated Interface

Content

Page 65: Conflict of Interface (eng)

1. Tactical Resistance

Page 66: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Interface Layer

Internet Protocol Layer

Application Layer

Page 67: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 68: Conflict of Interface (eng)

HIT & RUN

Page 69: Conflict of Interface (eng)

HACKING / CULTURE JAMMING

Page 70: Conflict of Interface (eng)

2. Strategic Resistance

Page 71: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Interface Layer

Internet Protocol Layer

Application Layer

Page 72: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 73: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 74: Conflict of Interface (eng)

HIT & STAY

Page 75: Conflict of Interface (eng)

SERVICE DEVELOPMENT

Page 76: Conflict of Interface (eng)

3. Logistic Resistance

Page 77: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Interface Layer

Internet Protocol Layer

Application Layer

Page 78: Conflict of Interface (eng)

CHANGE THE PROTOCOL

Page 79: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 80: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Evgeny Morozov

Page 81: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Technological defeatism

Page 82: Conflict of Interface (eng)

But that’s just online… It isn’t “REAL”

Page 83: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 84: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 85: Conflict of Interface (eng)

THE INTERFACE TEACHES OBEDIENCE

Page 86: Conflict of Interface (eng)

24/7

Page 87: Conflict of Interface (eng)

…and not only online.

Page 88: Conflict of Interface (eng)

AFK

Page 89: Conflict of Interface (eng)

dominant interfaces of control

are not new

Page 90: Conflict of Interface (eng)

…but so does the resistance

Page 91: Conflict of Interface (eng)

1. Tactical Resistance

Page 92: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 93: Conflict of Interface (eng)

2. Strategic Resistance

Page 94: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 95: Conflict of Interface (eng)

3. Logistic Resistance

Page 96: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 97: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 98: Conflict of Interface (eng)

?

Page 99: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 100: Conflict of Interface (eng)

Thank you Mushon Zer-Aviv

@mushon / mushon.com

Page 101: Conflict of Interface (eng)

(wait)

Page 102: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 103: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 104: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 105: Conflict of Interface (eng)
Page 106: Conflict of Interface (eng)