Top Banner
Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak Sébastien Neukirch 1 Sorbonne Université, UPMC Paris 06, CNRS, Institut Jean Le Rond d'Alembert, UMR 7190, Paris Liquid wires
24

Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

Feb 14, 2018

Download

Documents

hoangmien
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets

Paul GrandgeorgeArnaud Antkowiak

Sébastien Neukirch

1

Sorbonne Université, UPMC Paris 06, CNRS, Institut Jean Le Rond d'Alembert, UMR 7190, Paris

Liquid wires

Page 2: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

Nephila golden orb weaver

Biological inspiration

Interesting properties of its capture silk

2

Liquid wires?

Page 3: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

1 mm

Nephila spider capture silk thread coated with small water droplets. Throughout the compression, the fiber does not sag,

it remains under tension. Video credit: Hervé Elettro

3

Nephila capture silkIts highly compressible property

Real TimeH. Elettro et al.

PNAS - 2016

Page 4: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

50μm

4

During the compression, the thread spools inside the water droplets.

Nephila capture silkA closer look inside the droplets

Page 5: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

5

Elastocapillary in-drop spoolingThe movie

Silicone oil droplet on a RTV (silicone polymer) fiber. The system is immersed in a water bath.

Fiber: radius a≈35 μm, Young's modulus E≈1 Mpa. Droplet : radius R=1.5 mm, Δ𝛾≈40 mN/m.

3 mmReal Time

Page 6: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

6

VA = PL1�sv + PL2�sl + L21

2

EI

R2+ P�l�sv

VB = PL1�sv + PL2�sl + L21

2

EI

R2+ P�l�sl +�l

1

2

EI

R2

Elastocapillary in-drop spoolingThe energetic approach

Solid-vapor interface energy

Solid-vapor interface energy

Solid-liquid interface energy

Bendingenergy

Solid-liquid interface energy

Bendingenergy

Page 7: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

7

Circular cross section fiber of

radius : P = 2⇡a

I =⇡a4

4

a

Typical values (spider silk):

If it is thin and elastic enough, a thread can coil inside a droplet!

R ⇠ 100µm

E ⇠ 10 MPa

⇠ 10µm

VA = PL1�sv + PL2�sl + L21

2

EI

R2+ P�l�sv

VB = PL1�sv + PL2�sl + L21

2

EI

R2+ P�l�sl +�l

1

2

EI

R2

�� ⇠ 50 mN/m

Elastocapillary in-drop spoolingThe energetic approach

T = ��V

�l=

✓P�� � 1

2

EI

R2

�V = �l

✓1

2

EI

R2� P��

T > 0 ?

2⇡a� � ⇡a4E

8R2> 0

a <

✓16�

E

◆1/3

R2/3

Page 8: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

8

Elastocapillary in-drop spoolingThe pre-movie II

2 mm

Bear thermoplastic polyurethane microfiber with no droplet sitting on it. Fiber: radius a=3.3 μm, Young's modulus E=20 Mpa.

Real Time

Page 9: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

9

Elastocapillary in-drop spooling

Silicone oil droplets on said thermoplastic polyurethane microfiber. An artificial ultra compressible/extensible device.

Fiber: radius a=3.3 μm, Young's modulus E=20 Mpa. Final droplet : radius R=106 μm, 𝛾=21 mN/m.

The movie II

2 mmReal Time

Page 10: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

10

The coiling fibers

Phase diagram of coiling and non-coiling fibers Fiber: Considered Young's modulus E = 70 MPa.

Droplet : 𝛾≈21 mN/m.

Phase diagram

2⇡a� � ⇡a4E

8R2> 0

Capillary Elastic- > 0

Page 11: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

11

Elastocapillary in-drop spooling

Big silicone oil droplet on a thermoplastic polyurethane microfiber. Gravity kicks in.

Fiber: radius a=3.4 μm, Young's modulus E=20 Mpa. Droplet : radius R=430 μm, 𝛾=20 mN/m.

Gravity

2 mmReal Time

Page 12: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

12

Elastocapillary in-drop spoolingGravity

P�� � 1

2

EI

R2>

mg

2

2⇡a� � ⇡a4E

8R2>

4

3

⇡⇢gR3

2

P = 2⇡a

I =⇡a4

4� < ⇡/2

Page 13: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

13

The coilable fibers

Phase diagram of coilable and non-coilable fibers Fiber: Considered Young's modulus E = 70 MPa.

Droplet : 𝛾=21 mN/m.

Phase diagram

2⇡a� � ⇡a4E

8R2>

4

3

⇡⇢gR3

2

2⇡a� � ⇡a4E

8R2> 0

Page 14: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

14

The coiling fibers

Phase diagram of coiling and non-coiling fibers with gravity. Fiber: Considered Young's modulus E = 70 MPa.

Droplet : 𝛾=21 mN/m, 𝜌g = 9600 N/m3.

Phase diagram

2⇡a� � ⇡a4E

8R2>

4

3

⇡⇢gR3

2

amax

= c(⇢g, �) · E�3/7

Capillary Elastic- > 1/2 Weight

Page 15: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

15

The coiling fibersPhase diagram

Phase diagram of coilable and non-coilable fibers. Droplet : 𝛾=21 mN/m, 𝜌g = 9600 N/m3.

amax

= c(⇢g, �) · E�3/7

Page 16: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

16

Biggest coilable fibreGravity

P = 2⇡a

I =⇡a4

4

P�� � 1

2

EI

R2>

mg

2

2⇡a� � ⇡a4E

8R2>

4

3

⇡⇢gR3

2

� < ⇡/2

Page 17: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

17

Biggest coilable fibreThe tutor

I =⇡a4

4

P = 2⇡a+ Psoft

' Psoft

Psoft

� � ⇡a4E/4 + Esoft

Isoft

2R2

>4

3

⇡⇢gR3

2

P�� � 1

2

EI

R2>

mg

2

Page 18: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

18

Biggest coilable fibreThe tutor

Phase diagram of coiling and non-coiling fibers with gravity. Rigid fiber: Considered Young's modulus E = 70 MPa.

Soft fiber : Young's modulus Esoft=200 kPa, width w = 180 μm, height h = 50 μm. Droplet : 𝛾=21 mN/m, 𝜌g = 9600 N/m3.

Psoft

� � ⇡a4E/4 + Esoft

Isoft

2R2

>4

3

⇡⇢gR3

2

amax

= C(⇢g, Psoft

�, Esoft

Isoft

) · E�1/4

Page 19: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

19

The coiling fibersPhase diagram

Phase diagram of coilable and non-coilable fibers. Droplet : 𝛾=21 mN/m.

am

a

x =c · E �

3/7

amax

= C(⇢g, Psoft

�, Esoft

Isoft

) · E�1/4

Page 20: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

20

Coiling the uncoilableThe tutor

Phase diagram of coilable and non-coilable fibers with tutor. Soft fiber : Young's modulus Esoft=200 kPa, width w = 180μm, height h = 50μm.

Droplet : 𝛾=21 mN/m, 𝜌g = 9600 N/m3.

am

a

x = C · E �1/

4

amax

= C(⇢g, Psoft

�, Esoft

Isoft

) · E�1/4

am

a

x =c · E �

3/7

Page 21: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

21

2 mm

Coiling the uncoilableUncoilable

Silicone oil droplet on a poly-actif acid (PLA) microfiber. Fiber: radius a=4.1 μm, Young's modulus E=2.7 GPa.

Droplet : radius R=256 μm, Δ𝛾≈20 mN/m.

Real Time

Page 22: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

22

Coiling the uncoilable

Silicone oil droplet on a composite poly-actif acid (PLA) microfiber + polyvinyl siloxane (PVS) tutor fiber.

PLA fiber: radius a=4.1 μm, Young's modulus E=2.7 GPa. PVS fiber: width w=100 μm, height h = 35 μm, Young's modulus E=200 kPa,

Droplet: radius R=430 μm, Δ𝛾≈20 mN/m.

The coilabe composite fiber

2 mmReal Time

Page 23: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

23200 μm

Coiling the uncoilableCoiled!

Page 24: Composite liquid wires Micromast Grandgeorge - novoice …grandgeorge/files/Composite_liquid_wires... · Coiling rigid microfibers inside liquid droplets Paul Grandgeorge Arnaud Antkowiak

24

Thank you!

0.5 mmReal Time