Page 1
Comparative morphometry biochemical and elemental
composition of three marine sponges (Petrosiidae) from
Gulf of Mannar India
Ramjee Pallelaac Srikanth Koigooraa Venu Gopal GundaaMadhavendra Sakunthala Sunkarab and Venkateswara Rao Janapalaa
aToxicology Unit Biology Division Indian Institute of Chemical Technology Hyderabad - 500 607 IndiabElectron Microscopy Division Indian Institute of Chemical Technology Hyderabad - 500 607 IndiacMarine Bioprocess Research Center Pukyong National University Busan - 608 737 Republic of Korea
E-mail jvraoiictgmailcom
ABSTRACT
Three marine sponges Neopetrosia similis Xestospongia testudinaria and Petrosia nigricans from the Gulfof Mannar Southeast coast of India were compared based on their morphometric parameters and theirbiochemical and elemental composition These sponges showed differences in spicule protein (spongin)ratio of 5 1 11 1 and 13 1 respectively Xestospongia testudinaria possessed the longest oxeae 305times than P nigricans and 147 times than N similis Spectral analysis revealed that the spicules of thesesponges are mostly composed of O (450) and Si (29ndash45) whereas Al and Ca (4ndash5) were additionallydetected only in the spicules of P nigricans In contrast the percentage elemental composition inpinacodermal sections was significantly different as O and Si were the maximum (23ndash50) followedby Cl and Al as moderate (1ndash17) and Na S Fe and Ca in minor quantities (02ndash6) Cluster analysisand traditional taxonomic arrangements show that X testudinaria and N similis have a close relationshipwhereas P nigricans was hypothesized to be their sister group The present findings could be the key foridentifying sponges in situ as well as determining whether sponges could be used to assess pollution inthe sea
Keywords marine sponges petrosiidae spicules elemental composition Gulf of Mannar
INTRODUCTION
Sponges (Porifera) are the most ancient metazoans with
ubiquitous benthic distribution They are distributed along
all latitudes from intertidal to deep-sea Many sponge
species produce toxic substances enabling their survival in
competitive marine environments Some of the metabolites
have beneficial pharmaceutical effects for humans with anti-
inflammatory cytotoxic antitumor antibiotic and anti-viral
activities (Scheuer 1978 ndash 1983 Faulkner 1984 Uemura
et al 1985 Kim et al 1998 Gunasekera et al 1990)
Recently several researchers have tried to develop in vitro
cultivation systems for sponges (Demospongiae) to
produce compounds of medicinalypharmaceutical value in
biotechnological processes without disturbing the
ecosystem Most of these workers collect the specific
sponge species for microbial and sponge cell cultures
The taxonomical identification of specimens during the
collection period is a complex task More complete infor-
mation on the anatomy and morphometry of sponges may
be helpful to identify the collected sponges up to genus
level
The majority of sponges are divided into three classes
viz Calcarea (sponges with spicules composed of calcium
carbonate) Hexactinellida (the glass sponges with siliceous
spicules) and Demospongiae (having opaline or anhydrous
siliceous spicules andyor proteinaceous fibres) according to
the composition of their skeleton (Bergquist 2001 Hooper
et al 2002) Demosponges possess leuconoid structure
with folded choanoderm and continuous pinacoderm
Formation of the mesohyl is more diverse in the
Demospongiae which are characteristically thickened with
spicules of both mega and microscleres with one to four
rays and dispersed collagenous fibres (spongin) both or
neither (Harrison and de Vos 1991) Sponge taxonomists
have focused their attention on understanding the character-
istic skeletal organization in order to identify individual
species On the other hand cell biologists are also investi-
wwwchemspecbiocouk
doi 103184095422911X12966340771966
16 Chemical Speciation and Bioavailability (2011) 23(1)
gating these primitive metazoans to understand their orga-
nization on the cellular and skeletal level for more enhanced
biotechnological applications (Muller et al 2004) Besides
the intrinsic components demosponges can incorporate
sediments and foreign substances into their spicules
skeleton (Araujo et al 1999) Previous studies have
demonstrated that accumulation of elements in marine
sponges can be used as a biomarker to assess pollution
risks and ecosystem health in the ocean (Venkateswara Rao
et al 2006 2007 2008) Therefore species identification
based on morphological and elemental composition would
further facilitate sorting of species for use in applied
biotechnology
Numerous biologically active molecules have been
isolated from sponges belonging to the family Petrosiidae
(Kim et al 1998 Giner et al 1999 Aoki et al 2002
Venkateswarlu et al 1993 Choi et al 2004 Blunt et al
2006 Park et al 2007) The sponges included in this
family have thus been valuable to chemists and have also
found their way into biotechnological applications
However many genera have been included in this family
and characterizing the discriminating features between the
species is essential to identify specific genera Hence here
qualitative and quantitative morphological variations and
elemental compositions of three sponges belonging to
Petrosiidae collected at Gulf of Mannar India are
compared According to the World Sponge Database
these three sponges are identified as Xestospongia testudi-
naria Lamarck 1815 Neopetrosia similis Ridely and Dendy
1886 and Petrosia nigricans Lindgren 1887
(Desqueyroux-Faundez and Valentine 2002) Previously
they were considered as three different species under
Petrosia genera ie P testudinaria P similis and P
nigricans respectively The structural dissimilarities
between these three taxa were analysed using advanced
microscopy The present findings on the morphological and
elemental variations between the taxa are essential for in
situ identification and form a basis for in vitro cellyfragment
cultures for producing bioactive secondary metabolites
(Gunda and Janapala 2009)
METHODOLOGY
Sampling
Sponge samples were collected during low tide from the
shallow sub-tidal regions between 15 and 25 feet by
snorkelling and skin-diving The sponges were collected
at the Mandapam region (Lat 9 10 0 to 9 50 0 N Long 78
10 0 to 79 07 0 E) of the Gulf of Mannar Biosphere Reserve
India (Figure 1) Sponges were gently removed from the
substratum without any tissue damage and were placed in
plastic bags underwater then transferred into large
containers of aerated seawater for transport to the labora-
tory Before analysis the sponges were thoroughly cleaned
by mechanical removal of foreign materials followed by
repeated washing with artificial sea water (Millero 1996)
The voucher specimens were submitted to the National
Institute of Oceanography (NIO) Goa for depository
purposes and were identified as Xestospongia testudinaria
Neopetrosia similis and Petrosia nigricans (Class
Demospongiae Order Haplosclerida Family Petrosiidae)
at Vizhinjam Research Centre of Central Marine Fisheries
Research Institute (ICAR) Vizhinjam
Thiruvananthapuram India Based on our earlier expedi-
tions (2000 to 2007) it was noticed that only these three
genera of Petrosiidae family exist at the Mandapam coast of
the Gulf of Mannar India
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 17
Figure 1 Location Map of sponge sampling site (Mandapam region Gulf of Mannar Southeast Coast of India)
Morphology and architecture of the sponges
The differential surface views of individual sponges and
their tangential sections of the choanosome were observed
with the help of a video microscope (High scope Compact
Micro vision system Model No KH-2200 MD2) and
digital photographs were obtained
Morphometry of spicules
Specified pieces of individual species consisting of two
primary layers of cells (pinacoderm and choanoderm) and
an inner cellular region (mesohyl) were (a minimum of
three replicates each) digested with concentrated HNO3 and
allowed to stand for 2 ndash 3 h until all the pieces were
dissolved and then heated gently over a Bunsen flame
until the liquid was clear The aliquots were centrifuged
at 5000 g for 10 min and the precipitates were re-centrifuged
after every wash with distilled water for three times
Additional organic matter was removed with H2O2 and
finally washed with absolute ethanol and air dried The air-
dried spicules on microscopic glass slides were mounted
with a DPX mount and then covered with a glass cover slip
to study the length and width of spicules (n frac14 500) of
individual sponges by a compound microscope
(POLYVAR Reichert- Jung light microscope) attached to
Ethovision-version 23 (Noldus Information Technology
The Netherlands) through a CCD camera (Sony CCD
IRIS Model No SSC-M370CE) The magnification was
calibrated with the aid of ocular and stage micrometers
(ERMA Tokyo Japan)
Analytical methods
The elemental composition of pinacoderm (Al Ca Cl Fe
Na O S and Si) and spicular membrane (silicalemma) in
each test sponge (n frac14 5) was analysed by HITACHI S-520
scanning electron microscope equipped with energy disper-
sive X-ray analysis (EDXA) Briefly the processed samples
were mounted on aluminium stubs using double adhesive
tape coated with gold in HITACHI HUS-SGB Vacuum and
observed in Hitachi S-520 SEM Then EDXA was carried
out with an Oxford Link ISIS-300 detector calibrated with
cobalt standard at an acceleration voltage of 20 kV Built-in
standards were used for the quantification of each element
For quantifying the total protein and carbohydrates 1 g of
each individual sponge species was chopped into small
pieces and homogenized in sufficient volumes of phosphate
buffer by the Heidolph DIAX 900 homogenizer The total
carbohydrate content was assayed by the phenolndash sulfuric
acid method (Taylor 1995) whereas the total protein was
estimated by Bradfordrsquos method (Bradford 1976)
Data analysis
The mean value and standard error (+ SE) of the length
and width of spicules percentage amount of spicules per
gram (dry weight) total protein content and elemental
composition in silicalemma and pinacoderm were calcu-
lated for each variable of the independent species The
suitability of the data was evaluated to examine the indi-
vidual variables for the differences among test species by
one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) When populations
were significantly different multiple comparison post-hoc
tests (Tukeyrsquos HSD) were performed to see which popula-
tions differed from one another
Phylogenetic relationships among the three sponges of
lsquoPetrosiidaersquo family were analysed using STATISTICA
software (STATSOFT Inc Version 60) The percentage
ratios of individual parameters such as pentose hexose
spicule length width and lengthywidth and silicon ratio of
spicule versus pinacoderm were taken in multiple replicates
as the input to analyse the phylogenetic relationships among
the test sponges For each parameter cluster analysis (CA)
was used to elucidate the closest potential of the measured
cluster between the three genera where CA was represented
as hierarchical tree plots and a dendrogram was prepared
based on the single linkage (nearest neighbour) method
RESULTS
Morphology and architecture of the sponges
The three test species analysed in the present experiments
were collected at the same depth and locality under identical
environmental conditions The current study is mainly
based on the distinct morphological and biochemical differ-
ences between these sponges (Table 1) The external
morphology of each species varies from thick encrusting
globular to a more massive form and the colour patterns are
from a brown-beige colour to blackish blue often asso-
ciated with well-lit environments The external surface of X
testudinaria is smooth and compact which appears to be
covered by a fine ectosomal layer Small bundles of slender
oxea are grouped at nodes to give granular surface in N
similis However the architecture of P nigricans was
totally different from the other species by the zig-zag
brushy arrangement of oxeae
It is evident from the video microscopic images that a
significant difference in the surface view was found
between the three species The images indicated that the
differences in the architecture of walls surrounded by ostia
were quite distinctive between the sponges When
compared to the other two sponges X testudinaria is
hispid to touch with clear openings of ostia surrounded
by precise arrangement of spicules (oxeae) bounded with
spongin In addition a number of large and slender oxeae
crowded as rounded meshes were present where dense
interstitial reticulation of free spicules offered the sponge
a stony texture (Figure 2)
Morphometry of spicules
All the test species possessed similar type of oxea spicules
(85 ndash 95) but differed in their sizes (Figure 3) The mean
lengths (L) and widths (W) of oxeae among the three
species were statistically different (L One way ANOVA
Ffrac122597 frac14 46365 Tukeyrsquos HSD P50001 and W
Ffrac122597 frac14 32245 Tukeyrsquos HSD P50001 respectively)
It is evident from the Table 1 that the length and width
ratios did not differ significantly (P5005) The LyW ratio
of X testudinaria was comparatively high (3703) while
18 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
compared to other two genera P nigricans and N similis
(3061 and 3585 respectively)
Analytical methods
The amount of protein (mostly referred to as spongin)
required for binding the spicules to form unique skeletal
architecture is significantly different in all the species
Comparatively the amount of protein estimated in N
similis was 35-fold higher than P nigricans and 16-fold
higher than X testudinaria The spicule protein ratio
(mg g 1) between the species was significantly different
at P5001 at 13 1 11 1 and 5 1 in P nigricans X
testudinaria and N similis respectively However the
pentose and hexose (carbohydrate) contents were signifi-
cantly higher (415 times) in P nigricans than in the other
two sponges
The composition of the inorganic envelope (silicalemma)
of spicules and uptake of the elements in the pinacosomal
sections of each test sponges was analysed by SEM
equipped with an EDXA which indicated that the silica-
lemma of spicules in all test species was composed almost
exclusively of O (55 ndash 61) and Si (36ndash 49) however Al
and Ca (4 ndash 5) were additionally quantified in P nigri-
cans The mean percentage composition of O in spicules
did not differ significantly (ANOVA analysis
Ffrac12212 frac14 0033 P frac14 0968) However the percentage accu-
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 19
Figure 2 Video micrographs of surface view and choanosomal sections of three marine species a Petrosia nigricans b Neopetrosia similis
c Xestospongia testudinaria 1 surface view (406) 2 section of choanosomal layer (406) and 3 at 220X
Figure 3 Micro morphological variations (by light microscopy
and scanning electron microscopy) in the spicules (oxeae) of three
different Petrosiidae sponges
mulation of Si in X testudinaria was significantly different
in P nigricans at P5005 (Ffrac12212 frac14 2708 P frac14 0107) It
is evident from the results that the relatively high composi-
tion of O was noticed in the spicular envelopes of P
nigricans N similis and X testudinaria (167 123 and
113 respectively) compared with that of Si (Figure 4)
The elemental analysis of surface pinacosome of the
three genera indicated the accumulation of elements such
as Al Ca Cl Fe Na O S and Si in different proportions
The order and range of percentage accumulation of the
elements in these genera were oxygen (28 ndash 50) and silicon
(23 ndash 35) as maximum chlorine (8 ndash 16) and aluminium (1 ndash
17) as moderate and sodium (3 ndash 6) sulfur (06 ndash 14) iron
(02 ndash 21) and calcium (03 ndash 27) in minor quantities One
way ANOVA (p5005) and mean values were compared
using Tukeyrsquos HSD pair wise comparison test which
indicated that O and Na are not significant among P
nigricans and N similis While comparing N similis and
X testudinaria all the elements are significantly different
except S (Figure 5)
The majority of chosen parameters (hexose pentose
spicule length and the ratios of spicule lengthywidth and
silicon of silicalemmaypinacoderm) used to study the
phylogenetic relationship through dendrogram analysis
between the sponges revealed that X testudinaria and N
similis are more closely related as compared to P nigricans
(Figure 6) It is apparent from the results that morphometric
biochemical and elemental parameters could also be used as
markers to assess the taxonomic similarities and dissimila-
rities between the sponges
DISCUSSION
This is the first study to show distinct morphological and
structural variations in the spicule morphometry and
aquiferous outlook of sponges (Family Petrosiidae) avail-
able from the Gulf of Mannar It is evident that the test
species were visually different and exhibited significant
variations in their ostia (number shape and diameter) and
morphometry of oxeae The protein (spongin) and carbo-
hydrate components differed between the sponges These
components are responsible for binding the spicules to
build up a specialized shape of ostia that influence the
water flow into the sponge body It is well known that
each genus has its own architecture as demonstrated by the
different morphology of ostia This has been demonstrated
and documented between the seven species collected at
SW Sulawesi reefs (Eastern Indonesia) which have char-
acteristic differences in their shape and sizes of ostia (de
Voogd and van Soest 2002)
The striking difference in percentage spicules by dry
weight in X testudinaria was relatively higher (amp 2 fold)
than P nigricans and 16 fold than N similis Also X
testudinaria possessed 305 times longer spicules than P
nigricans and 147 times that of N similis The growth of
the spicule is mainly based on specialized cells called
sclerocytes and axial filament which is formed by silica-
teins responsible for elongation of spicules and their
width is enhanced by the apposition of the silica
(Garrone 1978 Simpson 1984) In addition Aizenberg
et al (1996) concluded that intra-crystalline macromole-
cules (protein carbohydrates etc) play an important role
by their direct or indirect apposition and deposition to
form canalicular tracts of the sponge skeleton
EDXA of inorganic envelope spicular silicalemma and
the pinacodermal surface of the three sponges exhibited
significant changes in elemental composition The present
results indicated that some of the elements are limited to
the surface but many more might have been accumulated
in body wall The EDXA analysis is restricted only to
surface elemental composition and not to the tissue
accumulation which may be a key to identify the different
genera of Petrosiidae family It is evident from our earlier
ICP-MS analysis that more number of metals of higher
amount were quantified in P testudinaria (X testudinaria)
(Venkateswara Rao et al 2006) The elemental variation
between individual sponges between the species is well
documented (Patel et al 1985) and these variations in
elemental deposition may reflect the anatomical differences
of the individual sponges (Garrone et al 1981 Simpson
1984)
DNA based markers have been efficiently used in the
phylogenetic analyses of sponges Molecular biologists are
working on the sponge genome to understand the mole-
cular mechanism of evolution of metazoan genes and
diseases but knowledge of their biological and ecological
characteristics is so far very limited (Yi et al 2005)
Further analyses using specific loci have provided informa-
tion on the reproductive isolation of the species which
reinforced the conclusion that spicular morphology would
20 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Figure 4 The percentage elemental composition of inorganic
envelope (silicalemma) in three sponge species (Family Petrosii-
dae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf of Mannar Statistical
analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were
compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pair-wise comparisons test Statis-
tical significance as compared to P nigricans ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 21
Figure 5 Percent elemental uptake in the pinacosomal layer of each sponge species (Family Petrosiidae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf
of Mannar Statistical analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pairwise comparisons
test Statistical significance as compared to P nigricans (a) Statistical significance as compared to N similis (b) ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Figure 6 Dendrogram as obtained from average linkage cluster analysis (STATISTICA Ver 60) using the parameters of morphometry
biochemical and elemental analysis to assess the phylogenetic relationship between the three sponges of the Petrosiidae family
be useful in discriminating Petrosia spp (Bavestrello and
Sara 1992) In the present work we have analysed the
phylogenetic relationship based on the relative morpho-
metry biochemical and elemental composition which is a
new sequential approach to assess the linkage evidence
among the sponges The current non-genetic approach is
simple and may be useful to non-specialists as it does not
require the use of traditional genetic tools The present
comparison gives us the opportunity to analyse phyloge-
netic relationships thus giving useful insights for the
identification of sponges by non-taxonomists
As the demand for pharmacologically potent natural
products is constantly increasing attempts for the biotech-
nological production of sponge tissues are being made
Several studies suggest secondary metabolite production
by sponge symbionts (Molinski 1993 Oclarit et al 1994
Bewley et al 1996 Hentschel et al 2001) whereas
others indicate their production by sponge cells (Uriz
et al 1996 ab Garson et al 1998 Turon et al 2000)
Sponges possess strong regenerative capacities (Simpson
1984) and pieces of live sponge tissue are able to grow
and regenerate into healthy sponges This potency has
been used on a broad range of sponge species for the
cultivation of sponge tissue samples in both half-open
systems and open sea aquaculture (Osinga et al 1999)
CONCLUSION
Marine demosponges have been widely utilized for their
economical pharmaceutical as well as taxonomical
purposes in the past few decades The present observations
are particularly remarkable for ascertaining in situ discri-
mination of three members of Petrosiidae by observing
their morphological features along with their spicular and
anatomical aspects by advanced microscopic analyses
From our present and previous results we can conclude
that the sponges available at the Gulf of Mannar are
undergoing a timely anthropogenic disturbance that made
these organisms potential bio-indicators In their turn the
morphometric characteristics of these findings could be a
possible key for the chemical and analytical speciation of
future species available in any marine environment
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank the Director IICT for providing the
facilities and constant encouragement throughout the study
and also to Task-force project (CMM 004) of Council of
Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) which is the
funding source for the present work We are also grateful
to Mr T Sathish Bioengineering and Environmental
Centre IICT for calculating phylogenetic relationship
among the sponges The authors RP SK and GVG
thank CSIR for providing Senior Research Fellowships
REFERENCES
Aoki S Naka Y Itoh T Furukawa T Rachmat R Akiyama
S and Kobayashi M (2002) Lembehsterols A and B novel
sulfated sterols inhibiting thymidine phosphorylase from the
marine sponge Petrosia strongylata Chem Pharm Bull
50(6) 827 ndash 830Aizenberg J Ilan M Weiner S and Addadi L (1996) Intra-
crystalline macromolecules are involved in the morphogenesis
of calcitic sponge spicules Conn Tiss Res 34(4) 255 ndash 261
Araujo MF Cruz A Humanes M Lopes MT da Silva JAL
and da Silva JJRF (1999) Elemental composition of Demos-
pongiae from the eastern Atlantic coastal waters Chem Spec
Bioavail 11(1) 25 ndash 36Bavestrello G and Sara M (1992) Morphological and genetic
differences in ecologically distinct populations of Petrosia
(Porifera Demospongiae) Biol J Linn Soc 47(1) 49ndash 60
Bergquist PR (2001) Porifera (sponges) encyclopedia of life
sciences John Wiley and Sons Ltd New York
Bewley CA Holland ND and Faulkner DJ (1996) Two classes
of metabolites from Theonella swinhoei are localized in
distinct populations of bacterial symbionts Cell Mol Life
Sci 52(7) 716 ndash722Blunt JW Copp BR Munro MHG Northcote PT and
Prinsep MR (2006) Marine natural products Nat Prod
Rep 23(1) 26 ndash 78Bradford MM (1976) A rapid and sensitive method for the
quantitation of microgram quantities of protein utilizing the
principle of protein-dye binding Anal Biochem 72(1 ndash 2)
248 ndash 254Choi HJ Bae SJ Kim ND Jung JH and Choi YH (2004)
Induction of apoptosis by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacety-
lene from the sponge Petrosia sp in human skin melanoma
cells Int J Mol Med 14(6) 1091ndash 1096de Voogd NJ and van Soest RWM (2002) Indonesian sponges
of the genus Petrosia vosmaer (Demospongiae Haploscler-
ida) Zoologische Mededelingen (Leiden) 76(16) 193 ndash 209
Desqueyroux-Faundez R and Valentine C (2002) Family Petro-
siidae van Soest 1980 In Hooper JNA and van Soest
RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A guide to the classification
of sponges pp 906 ndash917 Kluwer AcademicyPlenum Publish-
ers New YorkFaulkner DJ (1984) Marine natural products metabolites of
marine invertebrates Nat Prod Rep 1 551 ndash598Garrone R (1978) Phylogenesis of connective tissue Morpholo-
gical aspects and biosynthesis of sponge intercellular matrix
In Robert L (ed) Frontiers of matrix biology Vol 5 pp 1 ndash
250 Karger Press BaselGarrone R Simpson TL and Pottu-Boumendil J (1981) Ultra-
structure and deposition of silica in sponges In Simpson TL
and Volcani BE (eds) Silicon and siliceous structures in
biological systems pp 495 ndash 525 Springer-Verlag New York
Garson MJ Flowers AE Webb RI Charan RD and McCaf-
frey EJ (1998) A spongeydinoflagellate association in the
haplosclerid demosponge Haliclona sp cellular origin of
cytotoxic alkaloids by Percoll density gradient fractionation
Cell Tiss Res 293(2) 365 ndash373Giner JL Gunashekar SP and Pomponi SA (1999) Sterols of
the marine sponge Petrosia weinbergi implications for the
absolute configurations of the antiviral orthoesterols and
weinbersterols Steroids 64(12) 820 ndash824Gunasekera SP Gunasekera M Longley RE and Schulte AK
(1990) Discodermolide a new bioactive polyhydroxylated
lactone from the marine sponge Discodermia dissolute J
Org Chem 55(16) 4912ndash 4915
22 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Gunda VG and Janapala VR (2009) Effects of dissolved oxygen
levels on survival and growth in vitro of Haliclona pigmenti-
fera (Demospongiae) Cell Tiss Res 337(3) 527 ndash 535
Hooper JNA van Soest RWM and Debrenne F (2002)
Phylum Porifera Grant 1836 In Hooper JNA and van
Soest RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A Guide to the
classification of sponges pp 9ndash 13 Kluwer Academic
Plenum Publishers New York
Harrison FW and de Vos L (1991) Porifera Vol 2 In Harrison
FW and Westfall JA (eds) Microscopical anatomy of
invertebrates pp 29 ndash 89 Wiley-Liss New York
Hentschel U Schmid M Wagner M Fieseler L Gernert C
and Hacker J (2001) Isolation and phylogenetic analysis of
bacteria with antimicrobial activities from the Mediterranean
sponges Aplysina aerophoba and Aplysina cavernicola FEMS
Microbiol Ecol 35(3) 305 ndash 312
Kim JS Im KS Jung JH Kim YL Kim J Shim CJ and
Lee CO (1998) New bioactive polyacetylenes from the
marine sponge Petrosia sp Tetrahedron 54(13) 3151ndash 3158
Millero FJ (1996) Chemical Oceanography 2nd edn p 469
CRC Press Boca Raton
Molinski TF (1993) Marine pyridoacridine alkaloids structure
synthesis and biological chemistry Chem Rev 93(5) 1825ndash
1838
Muller WEG Grebenjuk VA Pennec GL Schroder HC
Brummer F Hentschel U Muller IM and Breter HJ
(2004) Sustainable production of bioactive compounds by
sponges-cell culture and gene cluster approach A review
Mar Biotechnol 6(2) 105 ndash 117
Oclarit JM Okada H Ohta S Kaminura K Yamaoka Y
Iisuka T Miyashiro S and Ikegami S (1994) Anti-bacillus
substance in the marine sponge Hyatella species produced by
an associated Vibrio species bacterium Microbios 78(314)
7 ndash 16
Osinga R Tramper J and Wijffels RH (1999) Cultivation of
marine sponges Mar Biotechnol 1(6) 509 ndash532
Park C Jung JH Kim ND and Choi YH (2007) Inhibition of
cyclooxygenase-2 and telomerase activities in human leukemia
cells by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacetylene from the marine
sponge Petrosia sp Int J Oncol 30(1) 291 ndash 298
Patel B Balani MC and Patel S (1985) Sponges lsquosentinelrsquo of
heavy metals Sci Tot Environ 41(2) 143 ndash 152
Scheuer PJ (1978-1983) Marine natural products Chemical and
biological perspectives Vol (1 ndash 5) Academic Press Inc New
York
Simpson TL (1984) The cell biology of sponges pp 1 ndash 662
Springer-Verlag New York
Taylor KACC (1995) A modification of the phenolysulfuric
acid assay for total carbohydrates giving more comparable
absorbances Appl Biochem Biotechnol 53(3) 207ndash 214
Turon X Becerro MA and Uriz MJ (2000) Distribution of
brominated compounds within the sponge Aplysina aero-
phoba coupling of X-ray microanalysis with cryofixation
techniques Cell Tiss Res 301(2) 311 ndash 322
Uemura D Takahashi K Yamamoto T Katayama C Tanaka
J Okumura Y and Hirata Y (1985) Norhalichondrin A an
antitumor polyether macrolide from a marine sponge J Am
Chem Soc 107(16) 4796ndash4798
Uriz MJ Becerro MA Tur JM and Turon X (1996a)
Location of toxicity within the Mediterranean sponge
Crambe crambe (Demospongiae Poecilosclerida) Mar
Biol 124(4) 583 ndash 590
Uriz MJ Turon X Galera J and Tur JM (1996b) New light on
the cell location of avarol within the sponge Dysidea avara
(Dendroceratida) Cell Tiss Res 285(3) 519 ndash 527
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Chakra Reddy N and Gnanesh-
war Rao T (2006) Petrosia testudinaria as a biomarker for
metal contamination at Gulf of Mannar southeast coast of
India Chemosphere 65(4) 634 ndash 638
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Srikanth K Usman PK and
Gnaneshwar Rao T (2007) Environmental contamination
using accumulation of metals in marine sponge Sigmadocia
fibulata inhabiting the coastal waters of Gulf of Mannar India
Toxicol Environ Chem 89(3) 487 ndash 498
Venkateswara Rao J Srikanth K Ramjee P and Gnaneshwar
Rao T (2009) The use of marine sponge Haliclona tenuir-
amosa as bioindicator to monitor heavy metal pollution in the
coasts of Gulf of Mannar India Environ Mon Assess
156(1 ndash 4) 451ndash 459
Venkateswarlu Y Reddy VRM Srinivas KNVS and Venka-
teswara Rao J (1993) A new isoquinoline from a sponge
Petrosia sp Ind J Chem 32(B) 704
Yi Q Wei Z Hua L Xingju Y and Meifang J (2005)
Cultivation of marine sponges Chin J Oceanol Limnol
23(2) 194 ndash 198
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 23
Page 2
gating these primitive metazoans to understand their orga-
nization on the cellular and skeletal level for more enhanced
biotechnological applications (Muller et al 2004) Besides
the intrinsic components demosponges can incorporate
sediments and foreign substances into their spicules
skeleton (Araujo et al 1999) Previous studies have
demonstrated that accumulation of elements in marine
sponges can be used as a biomarker to assess pollution
risks and ecosystem health in the ocean (Venkateswara Rao
et al 2006 2007 2008) Therefore species identification
based on morphological and elemental composition would
further facilitate sorting of species for use in applied
biotechnology
Numerous biologically active molecules have been
isolated from sponges belonging to the family Petrosiidae
(Kim et al 1998 Giner et al 1999 Aoki et al 2002
Venkateswarlu et al 1993 Choi et al 2004 Blunt et al
2006 Park et al 2007) The sponges included in this
family have thus been valuable to chemists and have also
found their way into biotechnological applications
However many genera have been included in this family
and characterizing the discriminating features between the
species is essential to identify specific genera Hence here
qualitative and quantitative morphological variations and
elemental compositions of three sponges belonging to
Petrosiidae collected at Gulf of Mannar India are
compared According to the World Sponge Database
these three sponges are identified as Xestospongia testudi-
naria Lamarck 1815 Neopetrosia similis Ridely and Dendy
1886 and Petrosia nigricans Lindgren 1887
(Desqueyroux-Faundez and Valentine 2002) Previously
they were considered as three different species under
Petrosia genera ie P testudinaria P similis and P
nigricans respectively The structural dissimilarities
between these three taxa were analysed using advanced
microscopy The present findings on the morphological and
elemental variations between the taxa are essential for in
situ identification and form a basis for in vitro cellyfragment
cultures for producing bioactive secondary metabolites
(Gunda and Janapala 2009)
METHODOLOGY
Sampling
Sponge samples were collected during low tide from the
shallow sub-tidal regions between 15 and 25 feet by
snorkelling and skin-diving The sponges were collected
at the Mandapam region (Lat 9 10 0 to 9 50 0 N Long 78
10 0 to 79 07 0 E) of the Gulf of Mannar Biosphere Reserve
India (Figure 1) Sponges were gently removed from the
substratum without any tissue damage and were placed in
plastic bags underwater then transferred into large
containers of aerated seawater for transport to the labora-
tory Before analysis the sponges were thoroughly cleaned
by mechanical removal of foreign materials followed by
repeated washing with artificial sea water (Millero 1996)
The voucher specimens were submitted to the National
Institute of Oceanography (NIO) Goa for depository
purposes and were identified as Xestospongia testudinaria
Neopetrosia similis and Petrosia nigricans (Class
Demospongiae Order Haplosclerida Family Petrosiidae)
at Vizhinjam Research Centre of Central Marine Fisheries
Research Institute (ICAR) Vizhinjam
Thiruvananthapuram India Based on our earlier expedi-
tions (2000 to 2007) it was noticed that only these three
genera of Petrosiidae family exist at the Mandapam coast of
the Gulf of Mannar India
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 17
Figure 1 Location Map of sponge sampling site (Mandapam region Gulf of Mannar Southeast Coast of India)
Morphology and architecture of the sponges
The differential surface views of individual sponges and
their tangential sections of the choanosome were observed
with the help of a video microscope (High scope Compact
Micro vision system Model No KH-2200 MD2) and
digital photographs were obtained
Morphometry of spicules
Specified pieces of individual species consisting of two
primary layers of cells (pinacoderm and choanoderm) and
an inner cellular region (mesohyl) were (a minimum of
three replicates each) digested with concentrated HNO3 and
allowed to stand for 2 ndash 3 h until all the pieces were
dissolved and then heated gently over a Bunsen flame
until the liquid was clear The aliquots were centrifuged
at 5000 g for 10 min and the precipitates were re-centrifuged
after every wash with distilled water for three times
Additional organic matter was removed with H2O2 and
finally washed with absolute ethanol and air dried The air-
dried spicules on microscopic glass slides were mounted
with a DPX mount and then covered with a glass cover slip
to study the length and width of spicules (n frac14 500) of
individual sponges by a compound microscope
(POLYVAR Reichert- Jung light microscope) attached to
Ethovision-version 23 (Noldus Information Technology
The Netherlands) through a CCD camera (Sony CCD
IRIS Model No SSC-M370CE) The magnification was
calibrated with the aid of ocular and stage micrometers
(ERMA Tokyo Japan)
Analytical methods
The elemental composition of pinacoderm (Al Ca Cl Fe
Na O S and Si) and spicular membrane (silicalemma) in
each test sponge (n frac14 5) was analysed by HITACHI S-520
scanning electron microscope equipped with energy disper-
sive X-ray analysis (EDXA) Briefly the processed samples
were mounted on aluminium stubs using double adhesive
tape coated with gold in HITACHI HUS-SGB Vacuum and
observed in Hitachi S-520 SEM Then EDXA was carried
out with an Oxford Link ISIS-300 detector calibrated with
cobalt standard at an acceleration voltage of 20 kV Built-in
standards were used for the quantification of each element
For quantifying the total protein and carbohydrates 1 g of
each individual sponge species was chopped into small
pieces and homogenized in sufficient volumes of phosphate
buffer by the Heidolph DIAX 900 homogenizer The total
carbohydrate content was assayed by the phenolndash sulfuric
acid method (Taylor 1995) whereas the total protein was
estimated by Bradfordrsquos method (Bradford 1976)
Data analysis
The mean value and standard error (+ SE) of the length
and width of spicules percentage amount of spicules per
gram (dry weight) total protein content and elemental
composition in silicalemma and pinacoderm were calcu-
lated for each variable of the independent species The
suitability of the data was evaluated to examine the indi-
vidual variables for the differences among test species by
one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) When populations
were significantly different multiple comparison post-hoc
tests (Tukeyrsquos HSD) were performed to see which popula-
tions differed from one another
Phylogenetic relationships among the three sponges of
lsquoPetrosiidaersquo family were analysed using STATISTICA
software (STATSOFT Inc Version 60) The percentage
ratios of individual parameters such as pentose hexose
spicule length width and lengthywidth and silicon ratio of
spicule versus pinacoderm were taken in multiple replicates
as the input to analyse the phylogenetic relationships among
the test sponges For each parameter cluster analysis (CA)
was used to elucidate the closest potential of the measured
cluster between the three genera where CA was represented
as hierarchical tree plots and a dendrogram was prepared
based on the single linkage (nearest neighbour) method
RESULTS
Morphology and architecture of the sponges
The three test species analysed in the present experiments
were collected at the same depth and locality under identical
environmental conditions The current study is mainly
based on the distinct morphological and biochemical differ-
ences between these sponges (Table 1) The external
morphology of each species varies from thick encrusting
globular to a more massive form and the colour patterns are
from a brown-beige colour to blackish blue often asso-
ciated with well-lit environments The external surface of X
testudinaria is smooth and compact which appears to be
covered by a fine ectosomal layer Small bundles of slender
oxea are grouped at nodes to give granular surface in N
similis However the architecture of P nigricans was
totally different from the other species by the zig-zag
brushy arrangement of oxeae
It is evident from the video microscopic images that a
significant difference in the surface view was found
between the three species The images indicated that the
differences in the architecture of walls surrounded by ostia
were quite distinctive between the sponges When
compared to the other two sponges X testudinaria is
hispid to touch with clear openings of ostia surrounded
by precise arrangement of spicules (oxeae) bounded with
spongin In addition a number of large and slender oxeae
crowded as rounded meshes were present where dense
interstitial reticulation of free spicules offered the sponge
a stony texture (Figure 2)
Morphometry of spicules
All the test species possessed similar type of oxea spicules
(85 ndash 95) but differed in their sizes (Figure 3) The mean
lengths (L) and widths (W) of oxeae among the three
species were statistically different (L One way ANOVA
Ffrac122597 frac14 46365 Tukeyrsquos HSD P50001 and W
Ffrac122597 frac14 32245 Tukeyrsquos HSD P50001 respectively)
It is evident from the Table 1 that the length and width
ratios did not differ significantly (P5005) The LyW ratio
of X testudinaria was comparatively high (3703) while
18 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
compared to other two genera P nigricans and N similis
(3061 and 3585 respectively)
Analytical methods
The amount of protein (mostly referred to as spongin)
required for binding the spicules to form unique skeletal
architecture is significantly different in all the species
Comparatively the amount of protein estimated in N
similis was 35-fold higher than P nigricans and 16-fold
higher than X testudinaria The spicule protein ratio
(mg g 1) between the species was significantly different
at P5001 at 13 1 11 1 and 5 1 in P nigricans X
testudinaria and N similis respectively However the
pentose and hexose (carbohydrate) contents were signifi-
cantly higher (415 times) in P nigricans than in the other
two sponges
The composition of the inorganic envelope (silicalemma)
of spicules and uptake of the elements in the pinacosomal
sections of each test sponges was analysed by SEM
equipped with an EDXA which indicated that the silica-
lemma of spicules in all test species was composed almost
exclusively of O (55 ndash 61) and Si (36ndash 49) however Al
and Ca (4 ndash 5) were additionally quantified in P nigri-
cans The mean percentage composition of O in spicules
did not differ significantly (ANOVA analysis
Ffrac12212 frac14 0033 P frac14 0968) However the percentage accu-
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 19
Figure 2 Video micrographs of surface view and choanosomal sections of three marine species a Petrosia nigricans b Neopetrosia similis
c Xestospongia testudinaria 1 surface view (406) 2 section of choanosomal layer (406) and 3 at 220X
Figure 3 Micro morphological variations (by light microscopy
and scanning electron microscopy) in the spicules (oxeae) of three
different Petrosiidae sponges
mulation of Si in X testudinaria was significantly different
in P nigricans at P5005 (Ffrac12212 frac14 2708 P frac14 0107) It
is evident from the results that the relatively high composi-
tion of O was noticed in the spicular envelopes of P
nigricans N similis and X testudinaria (167 123 and
113 respectively) compared with that of Si (Figure 4)
The elemental analysis of surface pinacosome of the
three genera indicated the accumulation of elements such
as Al Ca Cl Fe Na O S and Si in different proportions
The order and range of percentage accumulation of the
elements in these genera were oxygen (28 ndash 50) and silicon
(23 ndash 35) as maximum chlorine (8 ndash 16) and aluminium (1 ndash
17) as moderate and sodium (3 ndash 6) sulfur (06 ndash 14) iron
(02 ndash 21) and calcium (03 ndash 27) in minor quantities One
way ANOVA (p5005) and mean values were compared
using Tukeyrsquos HSD pair wise comparison test which
indicated that O and Na are not significant among P
nigricans and N similis While comparing N similis and
X testudinaria all the elements are significantly different
except S (Figure 5)
The majority of chosen parameters (hexose pentose
spicule length and the ratios of spicule lengthywidth and
silicon of silicalemmaypinacoderm) used to study the
phylogenetic relationship through dendrogram analysis
between the sponges revealed that X testudinaria and N
similis are more closely related as compared to P nigricans
(Figure 6) It is apparent from the results that morphometric
biochemical and elemental parameters could also be used as
markers to assess the taxonomic similarities and dissimila-
rities between the sponges
DISCUSSION
This is the first study to show distinct morphological and
structural variations in the spicule morphometry and
aquiferous outlook of sponges (Family Petrosiidae) avail-
able from the Gulf of Mannar It is evident that the test
species were visually different and exhibited significant
variations in their ostia (number shape and diameter) and
morphometry of oxeae The protein (spongin) and carbo-
hydrate components differed between the sponges These
components are responsible for binding the spicules to
build up a specialized shape of ostia that influence the
water flow into the sponge body It is well known that
each genus has its own architecture as demonstrated by the
different morphology of ostia This has been demonstrated
and documented between the seven species collected at
SW Sulawesi reefs (Eastern Indonesia) which have char-
acteristic differences in their shape and sizes of ostia (de
Voogd and van Soest 2002)
The striking difference in percentage spicules by dry
weight in X testudinaria was relatively higher (amp 2 fold)
than P nigricans and 16 fold than N similis Also X
testudinaria possessed 305 times longer spicules than P
nigricans and 147 times that of N similis The growth of
the spicule is mainly based on specialized cells called
sclerocytes and axial filament which is formed by silica-
teins responsible for elongation of spicules and their
width is enhanced by the apposition of the silica
(Garrone 1978 Simpson 1984) In addition Aizenberg
et al (1996) concluded that intra-crystalline macromole-
cules (protein carbohydrates etc) play an important role
by their direct or indirect apposition and deposition to
form canalicular tracts of the sponge skeleton
EDXA of inorganic envelope spicular silicalemma and
the pinacodermal surface of the three sponges exhibited
significant changes in elemental composition The present
results indicated that some of the elements are limited to
the surface but many more might have been accumulated
in body wall The EDXA analysis is restricted only to
surface elemental composition and not to the tissue
accumulation which may be a key to identify the different
genera of Petrosiidae family It is evident from our earlier
ICP-MS analysis that more number of metals of higher
amount were quantified in P testudinaria (X testudinaria)
(Venkateswara Rao et al 2006) The elemental variation
between individual sponges between the species is well
documented (Patel et al 1985) and these variations in
elemental deposition may reflect the anatomical differences
of the individual sponges (Garrone et al 1981 Simpson
1984)
DNA based markers have been efficiently used in the
phylogenetic analyses of sponges Molecular biologists are
working on the sponge genome to understand the mole-
cular mechanism of evolution of metazoan genes and
diseases but knowledge of their biological and ecological
characteristics is so far very limited (Yi et al 2005)
Further analyses using specific loci have provided informa-
tion on the reproductive isolation of the species which
reinforced the conclusion that spicular morphology would
20 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Figure 4 The percentage elemental composition of inorganic
envelope (silicalemma) in three sponge species (Family Petrosii-
dae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf of Mannar Statistical
analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were
compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pair-wise comparisons test Statis-
tical significance as compared to P nigricans ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 21
Figure 5 Percent elemental uptake in the pinacosomal layer of each sponge species (Family Petrosiidae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf
of Mannar Statistical analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pairwise comparisons
test Statistical significance as compared to P nigricans (a) Statistical significance as compared to N similis (b) ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Figure 6 Dendrogram as obtained from average linkage cluster analysis (STATISTICA Ver 60) using the parameters of morphometry
biochemical and elemental analysis to assess the phylogenetic relationship between the three sponges of the Petrosiidae family
be useful in discriminating Petrosia spp (Bavestrello and
Sara 1992) In the present work we have analysed the
phylogenetic relationship based on the relative morpho-
metry biochemical and elemental composition which is a
new sequential approach to assess the linkage evidence
among the sponges The current non-genetic approach is
simple and may be useful to non-specialists as it does not
require the use of traditional genetic tools The present
comparison gives us the opportunity to analyse phyloge-
netic relationships thus giving useful insights for the
identification of sponges by non-taxonomists
As the demand for pharmacologically potent natural
products is constantly increasing attempts for the biotech-
nological production of sponge tissues are being made
Several studies suggest secondary metabolite production
by sponge symbionts (Molinski 1993 Oclarit et al 1994
Bewley et al 1996 Hentschel et al 2001) whereas
others indicate their production by sponge cells (Uriz
et al 1996 ab Garson et al 1998 Turon et al 2000)
Sponges possess strong regenerative capacities (Simpson
1984) and pieces of live sponge tissue are able to grow
and regenerate into healthy sponges This potency has
been used on a broad range of sponge species for the
cultivation of sponge tissue samples in both half-open
systems and open sea aquaculture (Osinga et al 1999)
CONCLUSION
Marine demosponges have been widely utilized for their
economical pharmaceutical as well as taxonomical
purposes in the past few decades The present observations
are particularly remarkable for ascertaining in situ discri-
mination of three members of Petrosiidae by observing
their morphological features along with their spicular and
anatomical aspects by advanced microscopic analyses
From our present and previous results we can conclude
that the sponges available at the Gulf of Mannar are
undergoing a timely anthropogenic disturbance that made
these organisms potential bio-indicators In their turn the
morphometric characteristics of these findings could be a
possible key for the chemical and analytical speciation of
future species available in any marine environment
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank the Director IICT for providing the
facilities and constant encouragement throughout the study
and also to Task-force project (CMM 004) of Council of
Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) which is the
funding source for the present work We are also grateful
to Mr T Sathish Bioengineering and Environmental
Centre IICT for calculating phylogenetic relationship
among the sponges The authors RP SK and GVG
thank CSIR for providing Senior Research Fellowships
REFERENCES
Aoki S Naka Y Itoh T Furukawa T Rachmat R Akiyama
S and Kobayashi M (2002) Lembehsterols A and B novel
sulfated sterols inhibiting thymidine phosphorylase from the
marine sponge Petrosia strongylata Chem Pharm Bull
50(6) 827 ndash 830Aizenberg J Ilan M Weiner S and Addadi L (1996) Intra-
crystalline macromolecules are involved in the morphogenesis
of calcitic sponge spicules Conn Tiss Res 34(4) 255 ndash 261
Araujo MF Cruz A Humanes M Lopes MT da Silva JAL
and da Silva JJRF (1999) Elemental composition of Demos-
pongiae from the eastern Atlantic coastal waters Chem Spec
Bioavail 11(1) 25 ndash 36Bavestrello G and Sara M (1992) Morphological and genetic
differences in ecologically distinct populations of Petrosia
(Porifera Demospongiae) Biol J Linn Soc 47(1) 49ndash 60
Bergquist PR (2001) Porifera (sponges) encyclopedia of life
sciences John Wiley and Sons Ltd New York
Bewley CA Holland ND and Faulkner DJ (1996) Two classes
of metabolites from Theonella swinhoei are localized in
distinct populations of bacterial symbionts Cell Mol Life
Sci 52(7) 716 ndash722Blunt JW Copp BR Munro MHG Northcote PT and
Prinsep MR (2006) Marine natural products Nat Prod
Rep 23(1) 26 ndash 78Bradford MM (1976) A rapid and sensitive method for the
quantitation of microgram quantities of protein utilizing the
principle of protein-dye binding Anal Biochem 72(1 ndash 2)
248 ndash 254Choi HJ Bae SJ Kim ND Jung JH and Choi YH (2004)
Induction of apoptosis by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacety-
lene from the sponge Petrosia sp in human skin melanoma
cells Int J Mol Med 14(6) 1091ndash 1096de Voogd NJ and van Soest RWM (2002) Indonesian sponges
of the genus Petrosia vosmaer (Demospongiae Haploscler-
ida) Zoologische Mededelingen (Leiden) 76(16) 193 ndash 209
Desqueyroux-Faundez R and Valentine C (2002) Family Petro-
siidae van Soest 1980 In Hooper JNA and van Soest
RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A guide to the classification
of sponges pp 906 ndash917 Kluwer AcademicyPlenum Publish-
ers New YorkFaulkner DJ (1984) Marine natural products metabolites of
marine invertebrates Nat Prod Rep 1 551 ndash598Garrone R (1978) Phylogenesis of connective tissue Morpholo-
gical aspects and biosynthesis of sponge intercellular matrix
In Robert L (ed) Frontiers of matrix biology Vol 5 pp 1 ndash
250 Karger Press BaselGarrone R Simpson TL and Pottu-Boumendil J (1981) Ultra-
structure and deposition of silica in sponges In Simpson TL
and Volcani BE (eds) Silicon and siliceous structures in
biological systems pp 495 ndash 525 Springer-Verlag New York
Garson MJ Flowers AE Webb RI Charan RD and McCaf-
frey EJ (1998) A spongeydinoflagellate association in the
haplosclerid demosponge Haliclona sp cellular origin of
cytotoxic alkaloids by Percoll density gradient fractionation
Cell Tiss Res 293(2) 365 ndash373Giner JL Gunashekar SP and Pomponi SA (1999) Sterols of
the marine sponge Petrosia weinbergi implications for the
absolute configurations of the antiviral orthoesterols and
weinbersterols Steroids 64(12) 820 ndash824Gunasekera SP Gunasekera M Longley RE and Schulte AK
(1990) Discodermolide a new bioactive polyhydroxylated
lactone from the marine sponge Discodermia dissolute J
Org Chem 55(16) 4912ndash 4915
22 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Gunda VG and Janapala VR (2009) Effects of dissolved oxygen
levels on survival and growth in vitro of Haliclona pigmenti-
fera (Demospongiae) Cell Tiss Res 337(3) 527 ndash 535
Hooper JNA van Soest RWM and Debrenne F (2002)
Phylum Porifera Grant 1836 In Hooper JNA and van
Soest RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A Guide to the
classification of sponges pp 9ndash 13 Kluwer Academic
Plenum Publishers New York
Harrison FW and de Vos L (1991) Porifera Vol 2 In Harrison
FW and Westfall JA (eds) Microscopical anatomy of
invertebrates pp 29 ndash 89 Wiley-Liss New York
Hentschel U Schmid M Wagner M Fieseler L Gernert C
and Hacker J (2001) Isolation and phylogenetic analysis of
bacteria with antimicrobial activities from the Mediterranean
sponges Aplysina aerophoba and Aplysina cavernicola FEMS
Microbiol Ecol 35(3) 305 ndash 312
Kim JS Im KS Jung JH Kim YL Kim J Shim CJ and
Lee CO (1998) New bioactive polyacetylenes from the
marine sponge Petrosia sp Tetrahedron 54(13) 3151ndash 3158
Millero FJ (1996) Chemical Oceanography 2nd edn p 469
CRC Press Boca Raton
Molinski TF (1993) Marine pyridoacridine alkaloids structure
synthesis and biological chemistry Chem Rev 93(5) 1825ndash
1838
Muller WEG Grebenjuk VA Pennec GL Schroder HC
Brummer F Hentschel U Muller IM and Breter HJ
(2004) Sustainable production of bioactive compounds by
sponges-cell culture and gene cluster approach A review
Mar Biotechnol 6(2) 105 ndash 117
Oclarit JM Okada H Ohta S Kaminura K Yamaoka Y
Iisuka T Miyashiro S and Ikegami S (1994) Anti-bacillus
substance in the marine sponge Hyatella species produced by
an associated Vibrio species bacterium Microbios 78(314)
7 ndash 16
Osinga R Tramper J and Wijffels RH (1999) Cultivation of
marine sponges Mar Biotechnol 1(6) 509 ndash532
Park C Jung JH Kim ND and Choi YH (2007) Inhibition of
cyclooxygenase-2 and telomerase activities in human leukemia
cells by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacetylene from the marine
sponge Petrosia sp Int J Oncol 30(1) 291 ndash 298
Patel B Balani MC and Patel S (1985) Sponges lsquosentinelrsquo of
heavy metals Sci Tot Environ 41(2) 143 ndash 152
Scheuer PJ (1978-1983) Marine natural products Chemical and
biological perspectives Vol (1 ndash 5) Academic Press Inc New
York
Simpson TL (1984) The cell biology of sponges pp 1 ndash 662
Springer-Verlag New York
Taylor KACC (1995) A modification of the phenolysulfuric
acid assay for total carbohydrates giving more comparable
absorbances Appl Biochem Biotechnol 53(3) 207ndash 214
Turon X Becerro MA and Uriz MJ (2000) Distribution of
brominated compounds within the sponge Aplysina aero-
phoba coupling of X-ray microanalysis with cryofixation
techniques Cell Tiss Res 301(2) 311 ndash 322
Uemura D Takahashi K Yamamoto T Katayama C Tanaka
J Okumura Y and Hirata Y (1985) Norhalichondrin A an
antitumor polyether macrolide from a marine sponge J Am
Chem Soc 107(16) 4796ndash4798
Uriz MJ Becerro MA Tur JM and Turon X (1996a)
Location of toxicity within the Mediterranean sponge
Crambe crambe (Demospongiae Poecilosclerida) Mar
Biol 124(4) 583 ndash 590
Uriz MJ Turon X Galera J and Tur JM (1996b) New light on
the cell location of avarol within the sponge Dysidea avara
(Dendroceratida) Cell Tiss Res 285(3) 519 ndash 527
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Chakra Reddy N and Gnanesh-
war Rao T (2006) Petrosia testudinaria as a biomarker for
metal contamination at Gulf of Mannar southeast coast of
India Chemosphere 65(4) 634 ndash 638
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Srikanth K Usman PK and
Gnaneshwar Rao T (2007) Environmental contamination
using accumulation of metals in marine sponge Sigmadocia
fibulata inhabiting the coastal waters of Gulf of Mannar India
Toxicol Environ Chem 89(3) 487 ndash 498
Venkateswara Rao J Srikanth K Ramjee P and Gnaneshwar
Rao T (2009) The use of marine sponge Haliclona tenuir-
amosa as bioindicator to monitor heavy metal pollution in the
coasts of Gulf of Mannar India Environ Mon Assess
156(1 ndash 4) 451ndash 459
Venkateswarlu Y Reddy VRM Srinivas KNVS and Venka-
teswara Rao J (1993) A new isoquinoline from a sponge
Petrosia sp Ind J Chem 32(B) 704
Yi Q Wei Z Hua L Xingju Y and Meifang J (2005)
Cultivation of marine sponges Chin J Oceanol Limnol
23(2) 194 ndash 198
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 23
Page 3
Morphology and architecture of the sponges
The differential surface views of individual sponges and
their tangential sections of the choanosome were observed
with the help of a video microscope (High scope Compact
Micro vision system Model No KH-2200 MD2) and
digital photographs were obtained
Morphometry of spicules
Specified pieces of individual species consisting of two
primary layers of cells (pinacoderm and choanoderm) and
an inner cellular region (mesohyl) were (a minimum of
three replicates each) digested with concentrated HNO3 and
allowed to stand for 2 ndash 3 h until all the pieces were
dissolved and then heated gently over a Bunsen flame
until the liquid was clear The aliquots were centrifuged
at 5000 g for 10 min and the precipitates were re-centrifuged
after every wash with distilled water for three times
Additional organic matter was removed with H2O2 and
finally washed with absolute ethanol and air dried The air-
dried spicules on microscopic glass slides were mounted
with a DPX mount and then covered with a glass cover slip
to study the length and width of spicules (n frac14 500) of
individual sponges by a compound microscope
(POLYVAR Reichert- Jung light microscope) attached to
Ethovision-version 23 (Noldus Information Technology
The Netherlands) through a CCD camera (Sony CCD
IRIS Model No SSC-M370CE) The magnification was
calibrated with the aid of ocular and stage micrometers
(ERMA Tokyo Japan)
Analytical methods
The elemental composition of pinacoderm (Al Ca Cl Fe
Na O S and Si) and spicular membrane (silicalemma) in
each test sponge (n frac14 5) was analysed by HITACHI S-520
scanning electron microscope equipped with energy disper-
sive X-ray analysis (EDXA) Briefly the processed samples
were mounted on aluminium stubs using double adhesive
tape coated with gold in HITACHI HUS-SGB Vacuum and
observed in Hitachi S-520 SEM Then EDXA was carried
out with an Oxford Link ISIS-300 detector calibrated with
cobalt standard at an acceleration voltage of 20 kV Built-in
standards were used for the quantification of each element
For quantifying the total protein and carbohydrates 1 g of
each individual sponge species was chopped into small
pieces and homogenized in sufficient volumes of phosphate
buffer by the Heidolph DIAX 900 homogenizer The total
carbohydrate content was assayed by the phenolndash sulfuric
acid method (Taylor 1995) whereas the total protein was
estimated by Bradfordrsquos method (Bradford 1976)
Data analysis
The mean value and standard error (+ SE) of the length
and width of spicules percentage amount of spicules per
gram (dry weight) total protein content and elemental
composition in silicalemma and pinacoderm were calcu-
lated for each variable of the independent species The
suitability of the data was evaluated to examine the indi-
vidual variables for the differences among test species by
one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) When populations
were significantly different multiple comparison post-hoc
tests (Tukeyrsquos HSD) were performed to see which popula-
tions differed from one another
Phylogenetic relationships among the three sponges of
lsquoPetrosiidaersquo family were analysed using STATISTICA
software (STATSOFT Inc Version 60) The percentage
ratios of individual parameters such as pentose hexose
spicule length width and lengthywidth and silicon ratio of
spicule versus pinacoderm were taken in multiple replicates
as the input to analyse the phylogenetic relationships among
the test sponges For each parameter cluster analysis (CA)
was used to elucidate the closest potential of the measured
cluster between the three genera where CA was represented
as hierarchical tree plots and a dendrogram was prepared
based on the single linkage (nearest neighbour) method
RESULTS
Morphology and architecture of the sponges
The three test species analysed in the present experiments
were collected at the same depth and locality under identical
environmental conditions The current study is mainly
based on the distinct morphological and biochemical differ-
ences between these sponges (Table 1) The external
morphology of each species varies from thick encrusting
globular to a more massive form and the colour patterns are
from a brown-beige colour to blackish blue often asso-
ciated with well-lit environments The external surface of X
testudinaria is smooth and compact which appears to be
covered by a fine ectosomal layer Small bundles of slender
oxea are grouped at nodes to give granular surface in N
similis However the architecture of P nigricans was
totally different from the other species by the zig-zag
brushy arrangement of oxeae
It is evident from the video microscopic images that a
significant difference in the surface view was found
between the three species The images indicated that the
differences in the architecture of walls surrounded by ostia
were quite distinctive between the sponges When
compared to the other two sponges X testudinaria is
hispid to touch with clear openings of ostia surrounded
by precise arrangement of spicules (oxeae) bounded with
spongin In addition a number of large and slender oxeae
crowded as rounded meshes were present where dense
interstitial reticulation of free spicules offered the sponge
a stony texture (Figure 2)
Morphometry of spicules
All the test species possessed similar type of oxea spicules
(85 ndash 95) but differed in their sizes (Figure 3) The mean
lengths (L) and widths (W) of oxeae among the three
species were statistically different (L One way ANOVA
Ffrac122597 frac14 46365 Tukeyrsquos HSD P50001 and W
Ffrac122597 frac14 32245 Tukeyrsquos HSD P50001 respectively)
It is evident from the Table 1 that the length and width
ratios did not differ significantly (P5005) The LyW ratio
of X testudinaria was comparatively high (3703) while
18 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
compared to other two genera P nigricans and N similis
(3061 and 3585 respectively)
Analytical methods
The amount of protein (mostly referred to as spongin)
required for binding the spicules to form unique skeletal
architecture is significantly different in all the species
Comparatively the amount of protein estimated in N
similis was 35-fold higher than P nigricans and 16-fold
higher than X testudinaria The spicule protein ratio
(mg g 1) between the species was significantly different
at P5001 at 13 1 11 1 and 5 1 in P nigricans X
testudinaria and N similis respectively However the
pentose and hexose (carbohydrate) contents were signifi-
cantly higher (415 times) in P nigricans than in the other
two sponges
The composition of the inorganic envelope (silicalemma)
of spicules and uptake of the elements in the pinacosomal
sections of each test sponges was analysed by SEM
equipped with an EDXA which indicated that the silica-
lemma of spicules in all test species was composed almost
exclusively of O (55 ndash 61) and Si (36ndash 49) however Al
and Ca (4 ndash 5) were additionally quantified in P nigri-
cans The mean percentage composition of O in spicules
did not differ significantly (ANOVA analysis
Ffrac12212 frac14 0033 P frac14 0968) However the percentage accu-
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 19
Figure 2 Video micrographs of surface view and choanosomal sections of three marine species a Petrosia nigricans b Neopetrosia similis
c Xestospongia testudinaria 1 surface view (406) 2 section of choanosomal layer (406) and 3 at 220X
Figure 3 Micro morphological variations (by light microscopy
and scanning electron microscopy) in the spicules (oxeae) of three
different Petrosiidae sponges
mulation of Si in X testudinaria was significantly different
in P nigricans at P5005 (Ffrac12212 frac14 2708 P frac14 0107) It
is evident from the results that the relatively high composi-
tion of O was noticed in the spicular envelopes of P
nigricans N similis and X testudinaria (167 123 and
113 respectively) compared with that of Si (Figure 4)
The elemental analysis of surface pinacosome of the
three genera indicated the accumulation of elements such
as Al Ca Cl Fe Na O S and Si in different proportions
The order and range of percentage accumulation of the
elements in these genera were oxygen (28 ndash 50) and silicon
(23 ndash 35) as maximum chlorine (8 ndash 16) and aluminium (1 ndash
17) as moderate and sodium (3 ndash 6) sulfur (06 ndash 14) iron
(02 ndash 21) and calcium (03 ndash 27) in minor quantities One
way ANOVA (p5005) and mean values were compared
using Tukeyrsquos HSD pair wise comparison test which
indicated that O and Na are not significant among P
nigricans and N similis While comparing N similis and
X testudinaria all the elements are significantly different
except S (Figure 5)
The majority of chosen parameters (hexose pentose
spicule length and the ratios of spicule lengthywidth and
silicon of silicalemmaypinacoderm) used to study the
phylogenetic relationship through dendrogram analysis
between the sponges revealed that X testudinaria and N
similis are more closely related as compared to P nigricans
(Figure 6) It is apparent from the results that morphometric
biochemical and elemental parameters could also be used as
markers to assess the taxonomic similarities and dissimila-
rities between the sponges
DISCUSSION
This is the first study to show distinct morphological and
structural variations in the spicule morphometry and
aquiferous outlook of sponges (Family Petrosiidae) avail-
able from the Gulf of Mannar It is evident that the test
species were visually different and exhibited significant
variations in their ostia (number shape and diameter) and
morphometry of oxeae The protein (spongin) and carbo-
hydrate components differed between the sponges These
components are responsible for binding the spicules to
build up a specialized shape of ostia that influence the
water flow into the sponge body It is well known that
each genus has its own architecture as demonstrated by the
different morphology of ostia This has been demonstrated
and documented between the seven species collected at
SW Sulawesi reefs (Eastern Indonesia) which have char-
acteristic differences in their shape and sizes of ostia (de
Voogd and van Soest 2002)
The striking difference in percentage spicules by dry
weight in X testudinaria was relatively higher (amp 2 fold)
than P nigricans and 16 fold than N similis Also X
testudinaria possessed 305 times longer spicules than P
nigricans and 147 times that of N similis The growth of
the spicule is mainly based on specialized cells called
sclerocytes and axial filament which is formed by silica-
teins responsible for elongation of spicules and their
width is enhanced by the apposition of the silica
(Garrone 1978 Simpson 1984) In addition Aizenberg
et al (1996) concluded that intra-crystalline macromole-
cules (protein carbohydrates etc) play an important role
by their direct or indirect apposition and deposition to
form canalicular tracts of the sponge skeleton
EDXA of inorganic envelope spicular silicalemma and
the pinacodermal surface of the three sponges exhibited
significant changes in elemental composition The present
results indicated that some of the elements are limited to
the surface but many more might have been accumulated
in body wall The EDXA analysis is restricted only to
surface elemental composition and not to the tissue
accumulation which may be a key to identify the different
genera of Petrosiidae family It is evident from our earlier
ICP-MS analysis that more number of metals of higher
amount were quantified in P testudinaria (X testudinaria)
(Venkateswara Rao et al 2006) The elemental variation
between individual sponges between the species is well
documented (Patel et al 1985) and these variations in
elemental deposition may reflect the anatomical differences
of the individual sponges (Garrone et al 1981 Simpson
1984)
DNA based markers have been efficiently used in the
phylogenetic analyses of sponges Molecular biologists are
working on the sponge genome to understand the mole-
cular mechanism of evolution of metazoan genes and
diseases but knowledge of their biological and ecological
characteristics is so far very limited (Yi et al 2005)
Further analyses using specific loci have provided informa-
tion on the reproductive isolation of the species which
reinforced the conclusion that spicular morphology would
20 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Figure 4 The percentage elemental composition of inorganic
envelope (silicalemma) in three sponge species (Family Petrosii-
dae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf of Mannar Statistical
analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were
compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pair-wise comparisons test Statis-
tical significance as compared to P nigricans ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 21
Figure 5 Percent elemental uptake in the pinacosomal layer of each sponge species (Family Petrosiidae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf
of Mannar Statistical analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pairwise comparisons
test Statistical significance as compared to P nigricans (a) Statistical significance as compared to N similis (b) ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Figure 6 Dendrogram as obtained from average linkage cluster analysis (STATISTICA Ver 60) using the parameters of morphometry
biochemical and elemental analysis to assess the phylogenetic relationship between the three sponges of the Petrosiidae family
be useful in discriminating Petrosia spp (Bavestrello and
Sara 1992) In the present work we have analysed the
phylogenetic relationship based on the relative morpho-
metry biochemical and elemental composition which is a
new sequential approach to assess the linkage evidence
among the sponges The current non-genetic approach is
simple and may be useful to non-specialists as it does not
require the use of traditional genetic tools The present
comparison gives us the opportunity to analyse phyloge-
netic relationships thus giving useful insights for the
identification of sponges by non-taxonomists
As the demand for pharmacologically potent natural
products is constantly increasing attempts for the biotech-
nological production of sponge tissues are being made
Several studies suggest secondary metabolite production
by sponge symbionts (Molinski 1993 Oclarit et al 1994
Bewley et al 1996 Hentschel et al 2001) whereas
others indicate their production by sponge cells (Uriz
et al 1996 ab Garson et al 1998 Turon et al 2000)
Sponges possess strong regenerative capacities (Simpson
1984) and pieces of live sponge tissue are able to grow
and regenerate into healthy sponges This potency has
been used on a broad range of sponge species for the
cultivation of sponge tissue samples in both half-open
systems and open sea aquaculture (Osinga et al 1999)
CONCLUSION
Marine demosponges have been widely utilized for their
economical pharmaceutical as well as taxonomical
purposes in the past few decades The present observations
are particularly remarkable for ascertaining in situ discri-
mination of three members of Petrosiidae by observing
their morphological features along with their spicular and
anatomical aspects by advanced microscopic analyses
From our present and previous results we can conclude
that the sponges available at the Gulf of Mannar are
undergoing a timely anthropogenic disturbance that made
these organisms potential bio-indicators In their turn the
morphometric characteristics of these findings could be a
possible key for the chemical and analytical speciation of
future species available in any marine environment
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank the Director IICT for providing the
facilities and constant encouragement throughout the study
and also to Task-force project (CMM 004) of Council of
Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) which is the
funding source for the present work We are also grateful
to Mr T Sathish Bioengineering and Environmental
Centre IICT for calculating phylogenetic relationship
among the sponges The authors RP SK and GVG
thank CSIR for providing Senior Research Fellowships
REFERENCES
Aoki S Naka Y Itoh T Furukawa T Rachmat R Akiyama
S and Kobayashi M (2002) Lembehsterols A and B novel
sulfated sterols inhibiting thymidine phosphorylase from the
marine sponge Petrosia strongylata Chem Pharm Bull
50(6) 827 ndash 830Aizenberg J Ilan M Weiner S and Addadi L (1996) Intra-
crystalline macromolecules are involved in the morphogenesis
of calcitic sponge spicules Conn Tiss Res 34(4) 255 ndash 261
Araujo MF Cruz A Humanes M Lopes MT da Silva JAL
and da Silva JJRF (1999) Elemental composition of Demos-
pongiae from the eastern Atlantic coastal waters Chem Spec
Bioavail 11(1) 25 ndash 36Bavestrello G and Sara M (1992) Morphological and genetic
differences in ecologically distinct populations of Petrosia
(Porifera Demospongiae) Biol J Linn Soc 47(1) 49ndash 60
Bergquist PR (2001) Porifera (sponges) encyclopedia of life
sciences John Wiley and Sons Ltd New York
Bewley CA Holland ND and Faulkner DJ (1996) Two classes
of metabolites from Theonella swinhoei are localized in
distinct populations of bacterial symbionts Cell Mol Life
Sci 52(7) 716 ndash722Blunt JW Copp BR Munro MHG Northcote PT and
Prinsep MR (2006) Marine natural products Nat Prod
Rep 23(1) 26 ndash 78Bradford MM (1976) A rapid and sensitive method for the
quantitation of microgram quantities of protein utilizing the
principle of protein-dye binding Anal Biochem 72(1 ndash 2)
248 ndash 254Choi HJ Bae SJ Kim ND Jung JH and Choi YH (2004)
Induction of apoptosis by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacety-
lene from the sponge Petrosia sp in human skin melanoma
cells Int J Mol Med 14(6) 1091ndash 1096de Voogd NJ and van Soest RWM (2002) Indonesian sponges
of the genus Petrosia vosmaer (Demospongiae Haploscler-
ida) Zoologische Mededelingen (Leiden) 76(16) 193 ndash 209
Desqueyroux-Faundez R and Valentine C (2002) Family Petro-
siidae van Soest 1980 In Hooper JNA and van Soest
RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A guide to the classification
of sponges pp 906 ndash917 Kluwer AcademicyPlenum Publish-
ers New YorkFaulkner DJ (1984) Marine natural products metabolites of
marine invertebrates Nat Prod Rep 1 551 ndash598Garrone R (1978) Phylogenesis of connective tissue Morpholo-
gical aspects and biosynthesis of sponge intercellular matrix
In Robert L (ed) Frontiers of matrix biology Vol 5 pp 1 ndash
250 Karger Press BaselGarrone R Simpson TL and Pottu-Boumendil J (1981) Ultra-
structure and deposition of silica in sponges In Simpson TL
and Volcani BE (eds) Silicon and siliceous structures in
biological systems pp 495 ndash 525 Springer-Verlag New York
Garson MJ Flowers AE Webb RI Charan RD and McCaf-
frey EJ (1998) A spongeydinoflagellate association in the
haplosclerid demosponge Haliclona sp cellular origin of
cytotoxic alkaloids by Percoll density gradient fractionation
Cell Tiss Res 293(2) 365 ndash373Giner JL Gunashekar SP and Pomponi SA (1999) Sterols of
the marine sponge Petrosia weinbergi implications for the
absolute configurations of the antiviral orthoesterols and
weinbersterols Steroids 64(12) 820 ndash824Gunasekera SP Gunasekera M Longley RE and Schulte AK
(1990) Discodermolide a new bioactive polyhydroxylated
lactone from the marine sponge Discodermia dissolute J
Org Chem 55(16) 4912ndash 4915
22 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Gunda VG and Janapala VR (2009) Effects of dissolved oxygen
levels on survival and growth in vitro of Haliclona pigmenti-
fera (Demospongiae) Cell Tiss Res 337(3) 527 ndash 535
Hooper JNA van Soest RWM and Debrenne F (2002)
Phylum Porifera Grant 1836 In Hooper JNA and van
Soest RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A Guide to the
classification of sponges pp 9ndash 13 Kluwer Academic
Plenum Publishers New York
Harrison FW and de Vos L (1991) Porifera Vol 2 In Harrison
FW and Westfall JA (eds) Microscopical anatomy of
invertebrates pp 29 ndash 89 Wiley-Liss New York
Hentschel U Schmid M Wagner M Fieseler L Gernert C
and Hacker J (2001) Isolation and phylogenetic analysis of
bacteria with antimicrobial activities from the Mediterranean
sponges Aplysina aerophoba and Aplysina cavernicola FEMS
Microbiol Ecol 35(3) 305 ndash 312
Kim JS Im KS Jung JH Kim YL Kim J Shim CJ and
Lee CO (1998) New bioactive polyacetylenes from the
marine sponge Petrosia sp Tetrahedron 54(13) 3151ndash 3158
Millero FJ (1996) Chemical Oceanography 2nd edn p 469
CRC Press Boca Raton
Molinski TF (1993) Marine pyridoacridine alkaloids structure
synthesis and biological chemistry Chem Rev 93(5) 1825ndash
1838
Muller WEG Grebenjuk VA Pennec GL Schroder HC
Brummer F Hentschel U Muller IM and Breter HJ
(2004) Sustainable production of bioactive compounds by
sponges-cell culture and gene cluster approach A review
Mar Biotechnol 6(2) 105 ndash 117
Oclarit JM Okada H Ohta S Kaminura K Yamaoka Y
Iisuka T Miyashiro S and Ikegami S (1994) Anti-bacillus
substance in the marine sponge Hyatella species produced by
an associated Vibrio species bacterium Microbios 78(314)
7 ndash 16
Osinga R Tramper J and Wijffels RH (1999) Cultivation of
marine sponges Mar Biotechnol 1(6) 509 ndash532
Park C Jung JH Kim ND and Choi YH (2007) Inhibition of
cyclooxygenase-2 and telomerase activities in human leukemia
cells by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacetylene from the marine
sponge Petrosia sp Int J Oncol 30(1) 291 ndash 298
Patel B Balani MC and Patel S (1985) Sponges lsquosentinelrsquo of
heavy metals Sci Tot Environ 41(2) 143 ndash 152
Scheuer PJ (1978-1983) Marine natural products Chemical and
biological perspectives Vol (1 ndash 5) Academic Press Inc New
York
Simpson TL (1984) The cell biology of sponges pp 1 ndash 662
Springer-Verlag New York
Taylor KACC (1995) A modification of the phenolysulfuric
acid assay for total carbohydrates giving more comparable
absorbances Appl Biochem Biotechnol 53(3) 207ndash 214
Turon X Becerro MA and Uriz MJ (2000) Distribution of
brominated compounds within the sponge Aplysina aero-
phoba coupling of X-ray microanalysis with cryofixation
techniques Cell Tiss Res 301(2) 311 ndash 322
Uemura D Takahashi K Yamamoto T Katayama C Tanaka
J Okumura Y and Hirata Y (1985) Norhalichondrin A an
antitumor polyether macrolide from a marine sponge J Am
Chem Soc 107(16) 4796ndash4798
Uriz MJ Becerro MA Tur JM and Turon X (1996a)
Location of toxicity within the Mediterranean sponge
Crambe crambe (Demospongiae Poecilosclerida) Mar
Biol 124(4) 583 ndash 590
Uriz MJ Turon X Galera J and Tur JM (1996b) New light on
the cell location of avarol within the sponge Dysidea avara
(Dendroceratida) Cell Tiss Res 285(3) 519 ndash 527
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Chakra Reddy N and Gnanesh-
war Rao T (2006) Petrosia testudinaria as a biomarker for
metal contamination at Gulf of Mannar southeast coast of
India Chemosphere 65(4) 634 ndash 638
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Srikanth K Usman PK and
Gnaneshwar Rao T (2007) Environmental contamination
using accumulation of metals in marine sponge Sigmadocia
fibulata inhabiting the coastal waters of Gulf of Mannar India
Toxicol Environ Chem 89(3) 487 ndash 498
Venkateswara Rao J Srikanth K Ramjee P and Gnaneshwar
Rao T (2009) The use of marine sponge Haliclona tenuir-
amosa as bioindicator to monitor heavy metal pollution in the
coasts of Gulf of Mannar India Environ Mon Assess
156(1 ndash 4) 451ndash 459
Venkateswarlu Y Reddy VRM Srinivas KNVS and Venka-
teswara Rao J (1993) A new isoquinoline from a sponge
Petrosia sp Ind J Chem 32(B) 704
Yi Q Wei Z Hua L Xingju Y and Meifang J (2005)
Cultivation of marine sponges Chin J Oceanol Limnol
23(2) 194 ndash 198
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 23
Page 4
compared to other two genera P nigricans and N similis
(3061 and 3585 respectively)
Analytical methods
The amount of protein (mostly referred to as spongin)
required for binding the spicules to form unique skeletal
architecture is significantly different in all the species
Comparatively the amount of protein estimated in N
similis was 35-fold higher than P nigricans and 16-fold
higher than X testudinaria The spicule protein ratio
(mg g 1) between the species was significantly different
at P5001 at 13 1 11 1 and 5 1 in P nigricans X
testudinaria and N similis respectively However the
pentose and hexose (carbohydrate) contents were signifi-
cantly higher (415 times) in P nigricans than in the other
two sponges
The composition of the inorganic envelope (silicalemma)
of spicules and uptake of the elements in the pinacosomal
sections of each test sponges was analysed by SEM
equipped with an EDXA which indicated that the silica-
lemma of spicules in all test species was composed almost
exclusively of O (55 ndash 61) and Si (36ndash 49) however Al
and Ca (4 ndash 5) were additionally quantified in P nigri-
cans The mean percentage composition of O in spicules
did not differ significantly (ANOVA analysis
Ffrac12212 frac14 0033 P frac14 0968) However the percentage accu-
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 19
Figure 2 Video micrographs of surface view and choanosomal sections of three marine species a Petrosia nigricans b Neopetrosia similis
c Xestospongia testudinaria 1 surface view (406) 2 section of choanosomal layer (406) and 3 at 220X
Figure 3 Micro morphological variations (by light microscopy
and scanning electron microscopy) in the spicules (oxeae) of three
different Petrosiidae sponges
mulation of Si in X testudinaria was significantly different
in P nigricans at P5005 (Ffrac12212 frac14 2708 P frac14 0107) It
is evident from the results that the relatively high composi-
tion of O was noticed in the spicular envelopes of P
nigricans N similis and X testudinaria (167 123 and
113 respectively) compared with that of Si (Figure 4)
The elemental analysis of surface pinacosome of the
three genera indicated the accumulation of elements such
as Al Ca Cl Fe Na O S and Si in different proportions
The order and range of percentage accumulation of the
elements in these genera were oxygen (28 ndash 50) and silicon
(23 ndash 35) as maximum chlorine (8 ndash 16) and aluminium (1 ndash
17) as moderate and sodium (3 ndash 6) sulfur (06 ndash 14) iron
(02 ndash 21) and calcium (03 ndash 27) in minor quantities One
way ANOVA (p5005) and mean values were compared
using Tukeyrsquos HSD pair wise comparison test which
indicated that O and Na are not significant among P
nigricans and N similis While comparing N similis and
X testudinaria all the elements are significantly different
except S (Figure 5)
The majority of chosen parameters (hexose pentose
spicule length and the ratios of spicule lengthywidth and
silicon of silicalemmaypinacoderm) used to study the
phylogenetic relationship through dendrogram analysis
between the sponges revealed that X testudinaria and N
similis are more closely related as compared to P nigricans
(Figure 6) It is apparent from the results that morphometric
biochemical and elemental parameters could also be used as
markers to assess the taxonomic similarities and dissimila-
rities between the sponges
DISCUSSION
This is the first study to show distinct morphological and
structural variations in the spicule morphometry and
aquiferous outlook of sponges (Family Petrosiidae) avail-
able from the Gulf of Mannar It is evident that the test
species were visually different and exhibited significant
variations in their ostia (number shape and diameter) and
morphometry of oxeae The protein (spongin) and carbo-
hydrate components differed between the sponges These
components are responsible for binding the spicules to
build up a specialized shape of ostia that influence the
water flow into the sponge body It is well known that
each genus has its own architecture as demonstrated by the
different morphology of ostia This has been demonstrated
and documented between the seven species collected at
SW Sulawesi reefs (Eastern Indonesia) which have char-
acteristic differences in their shape and sizes of ostia (de
Voogd and van Soest 2002)
The striking difference in percentage spicules by dry
weight in X testudinaria was relatively higher (amp 2 fold)
than P nigricans and 16 fold than N similis Also X
testudinaria possessed 305 times longer spicules than P
nigricans and 147 times that of N similis The growth of
the spicule is mainly based on specialized cells called
sclerocytes and axial filament which is formed by silica-
teins responsible for elongation of spicules and their
width is enhanced by the apposition of the silica
(Garrone 1978 Simpson 1984) In addition Aizenberg
et al (1996) concluded that intra-crystalline macromole-
cules (protein carbohydrates etc) play an important role
by their direct or indirect apposition and deposition to
form canalicular tracts of the sponge skeleton
EDXA of inorganic envelope spicular silicalemma and
the pinacodermal surface of the three sponges exhibited
significant changes in elemental composition The present
results indicated that some of the elements are limited to
the surface but many more might have been accumulated
in body wall The EDXA analysis is restricted only to
surface elemental composition and not to the tissue
accumulation which may be a key to identify the different
genera of Petrosiidae family It is evident from our earlier
ICP-MS analysis that more number of metals of higher
amount were quantified in P testudinaria (X testudinaria)
(Venkateswara Rao et al 2006) The elemental variation
between individual sponges between the species is well
documented (Patel et al 1985) and these variations in
elemental deposition may reflect the anatomical differences
of the individual sponges (Garrone et al 1981 Simpson
1984)
DNA based markers have been efficiently used in the
phylogenetic analyses of sponges Molecular biologists are
working on the sponge genome to understand the mole-
cular mechanism of evolution of metazoan genes and
diseases but knowledge of their biological and ecological
characteristics is so far very limited (Yi et al 2005)
Further analyses using specific loci have provided informa-
tion on the reproductive isolation of the species which
reinforced the conclusion that spicular morphology would
20 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Figure 4 The percentage elemental composition of inorganic
envelope (silicalemma) in three sponge species (Family Petrosii-
dae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf of Mannar Statistical
analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were
compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pair-wise comparisons test Statis-
tical significance as compared to P nigricans ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 21
Figure 5 Percent elemental uptake in the pinacosomal layer of each sponge species (Family Petrosiidae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf
of Mannar Statistical analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pairwise comparisons
test Statistical significance as compared to P nigricans (a) Statistical significance as compared to N similis (b) ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Figure 6 Dendrogram as obtained from average linkage cluster analysis (STATISTICA Ver 60) using the parameters of morphometry
biochemical and elemental analysis to assess the phylogenetic relationship between the three sponges of the Petrosiidae family
be useful in discriminating Petrosia spp (Bavestrello and
Sara 1992) In the present work we have analysed the
phylogenetic relationship based on the relative morpho-
metry biochemical and elemental composition which is a
new sequential approach to assess the linkage evidence
among the sponges The current non-genetic approach is
simple and may be useful to non-specialists as it does not
require the use of traditional genetic tools The present
comparison gives us the opportunity to analyse phyloge-
netic relationships thus giving useful insights for the
identification of sponges by non-taxonomists
As the demand for pharmacologically potent natural
products is constantly increasing attempts for the biotech-
nological production of sponge tissues are being made
Several studies suggest secondary metabolite production
by sponge symbionts (Molinski 1993 Oclarit et al 1994
Bewley et al 1996 Hentschel et al 2001) whereas
others indicate their production by sponge cells (Uriz
et al 1996 ab Garson et al 1998 Turon et al 2000)
Sponges possess strong regenerative capacities (Simpson
1984) and pieces of live sponge tissue are able to grow
and regenerate into healthy sponges This potency has
been used on a broad range of sponge species for the
cultivation of sponge tissue samples in both half-open
systems and open sea aquaculture (Osinga et al 1999)
CONCLUSION
Marine demosponges have been widely utilized for their
economical pharmaceutical as well as taxonomical
purposes in the past few decades The present observations
are particularly remarkable for ascertaining in situ discri-
mination of three members of Petrosiidae by observing
their morphological features along with their spicular and
anatomical aspects by advanced microscopic analyses
From our present and previous results we can conclude
that the sponges available at the Gulf of Mannar are
undergoing a timely anthropogenic disturbance that made
these organisms potential bio-indicators In their turn the
morphometric characteristics of these findings could be a
possible key for the chemical and analytical speciation of
future species available in any marine environment
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank the Director IICT for providing the
facilities and constant encouragement throughout the study
and also to Task-force project (CMM 004) of Council of
Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) which is the
funding source for the present work We are also grateful
to Mr T Sathish Bioengineering and Environmental
Centre IICT for calculating phylogenetic relationship
among the sponges The authors RP SK and GVG
thank CSIR for providing Senior Research Fellowships
REFERENCES
Aoki S Naka Y Itoh T Furukawa T Rachmat R Akiyama
S and Kobayashi M (2002) Lembehsterols A and B novel
sulfated sterols inhibiting thymidine phosphorylase from the
marine sponge Petrosia strongylata Chem Pharm Bull
50(6) 827 ndash 830Aizenberg J Ilan M Weiner S and Addadi L (1996) Intra-
crystalline macromolecules are involved in the morphogenesis
of calcitic sponge spicules Conn Tiss Res 34(4) 255 ndash 261
Araujo MF Cruz A Humanes M Lopes MT da Silva JAL
and da Silva JJRF (1999) Elemental composition of Demos-
pongiae from the eastern Atlantic coastal waters Chem Spec
Bioavail 11(1) 25 ndash 36Bavestrello G and Sara M (1992) Morphological and genetic
differences in ecologically distinct populations of Petrosia
(Porifera Demospongiae) Biol J Linn Soc 47(1) 49ndash 60
Bergquist PR (2001) Porifera (sponges) encyclopedia of life
sciences John Wiley and Sons Ltd New York
Bewley CA Holland ND and Faulkner DJ (1996) Two classes
of metabolites from Theonella swinhoei are localized in
distinct populations of bacterial symbionts Cell Mol Life
Sci 52(7) 716 ndash722Blunt JW Copp BR Munro MHG Northcote PT and
Prinsep MR (2006) Marine natural products Nat Prod
Rep 23(1) 26 ndash 78Bradford MM (1976) A rapid and sensitive method for the
quantitation of microgram quantities of protein utilizing the
principle of protein-dye binding Anal Biochem 72(1 ndash 2)
248 ndash 254Choi HJ Bae SJ Kim ND Jung JH and Choi YH (2004)
Induction of apoptosis by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacety-
lene from the sponge Petrosia sp in human skin melanoma
cells Int J Mol Med 14(6) 1091ndash 1096de Voogd NJ and van Soest RWM (2002) Indonesian sponges
of the genus Petrosia vosmaer (Demospongiae Haploscler-
ida) Zoologische Mededelingen (Leiden) 76(16) 193 ndash 209
Desqueyroux-Faundez R and Valentine C (2002) Family Petro-
siidae van Soest 1980 In Hooper JNA and van Soest
RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A guide to the classification
of sponges pp 906 ndash917 Kluwer AcademicyPlenum Publish-
ers New YorkFaulkner DJ (1984) Marine natural products metabolites of
marine invertebrates Nat Prod Rep 1 551 ndash598Garrone R (1978) Phylogenesis of connective tissue Morpholo-
gical aspects and biosynthesis of sponge intercellular matrix
In Robert L (ed) Frontiers of matrix biology Vol 5 pp 1 ndash
250 Karger Press BaselGarrone R Simpson TL and Pottu-Boumendil J (1981) Ultra-
structure and deposition of silica in sponges In Simpson TL
and Volcani BE (eds) Silicon and siliceous structures in
biological systems pp 495 ndash 525 Springer-Verlag New York
Garson MJ Flowers AE Webb RI Charan RD and McCaf-
frey EJ (1998) A spongeydinoflagellate association in the
haplosclerid demosponge Haliclona sp cellular origin of
cytotoxic alkaloids by Percoll density gradient fractionation
Cell Tiss Res 293(2) 365 ndash373Giner JL Gunashekar SP and Pomponi SA (1999) Sterols of
the marine sponge Petrosia weinbergi implications for the
absolute configurations of the antiviral orthoesterols and
weinbersterols Steroids 64(12) 820 ndash824Gunasekera SP Gunasekera M Longley RE and Schulte AK
(1990) Discodermolide a new bioactive polyhydroxylated
lactone from the marine sponge Discodermia dissolute J
Org Chem 55(16) 4912ndash 4915
22 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Gunda VG and Janapala VR (2009) Effects of dissolved oxygen
levels on survival and growth in vitro of Haliclona pigmenti-
fera (Demospongiae) Cell Tiss Res 337(3) 527 ndash 535
Hooper JNA van Soest RWM and Debrenne F (2002)
Phylum Porifera Grant 1836 In Hooper JNA and van
Soest RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A Guide to the
classification of sponges pp 9ndash 13 Kluwer Academic
Plenum Publishers New York
Harrison FW and de Vos L (1991) Porifera Vol 2 In Harrison
FW and Westfall JA (eds) Microscopical anatomy of
invertebrates pp 29 ndash 89 Wiley-Liss New York
Hentschel U Schmid M Wagner M Fieseler L Gernert C
and Hacker J (2001) Isolation and phylogenetic analysis of
bacteria with antimicrobial activities from the Mediterranean
sponges Aplysina aerophoba and Aplysina cavernicola FEMS
Microbiol Ecol 35(3) 305 ndash 312
Kim JS Im KS Jung JH Kim YL Kim J Shim CJ and
Lee CO (1998) New bioactive polyacetylenes from the
marine sponge Petrosia sp Tetrahedron 54(13) 3151ndash 3158
Millero FJ (1996) Chemical Oceanography 2nd edn p 469
CRC Press Boca Raton
Molinski TF (1993) Marine pyridoacridine alkaloids structure
synthesis and biological chemistry Chem Rev 93(5) 1825ndash
1838
Muller WEG Grebenjuk VA Pennec GL Schroder HC
Brummer F Hentschel U Muller IM and Breter HJ
(2004) Sustainable production of bioactive compounds by
sponges-cell culture and gene cluster approach A review
Mar Biotechnol 6(2) 105 ndash 117
Oclarit JM Okada H Ohta S Kaminura K Yamaoka Y
Iisuka T Miyashiro S and Ikegami S (1994) Anti-bacillus
substance in the marine sponge Hyatella species produced by
an associated Vibrio species bacterium Microbios 78(314)
7 ndash 16
Osinga R Tramper J and Wijffels RH (1999) Cultivation of
marine sponges Mar Biotechnol 1(6) 509 ndash532
Park C Jung JH Kim ND and Choi YH (2007) Inhibition of
cyclooxygenase-2 and telomerase activities in human leukemia
cells by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacetylene from the marine
sponge Petrosia sp Int J Oncol 30(1) 291 ndash 298
Patel B Balani MC and Patel S (1985) Sponges lsquosentinelrsquo of
heavy metals Sci Tot Environ 41(2) 143 ndash 152
Scheuer PJ (1978-1983) Marine natural products Chemical and
biological perspectives Vol (1 ndash 5) Academic Press Inc New
York
Simpson TL (1984) The cell biology of sponges pp 1 ndash 662
Springer-Verlag New York
Taylor KACC (1995) A modification of the phenolysulfuric
acid assay for total carbohydrates giving more comparable
absorbances Appl Biochem Biotechnol 53(3) 207ndash 214
Turon X Becerro MA and Uriz MJ (2000) Distribution of
brominated compounds within the sponge Aplysina aero-
phoba coupling of X-ray microanalysis with cryofixation
techniques Cell Tiss Res 301(2) 311 ndash 322
Uemura D Takahashi K Yamamoto T Katayama C Tanaka
J Okumura Y and Hirata Y (1985) Norhalichondrin A an
antitumor polyether macrolide from a marine sponge J Am
Chem Soc 107(16) 4796ndash4798
Uriz MJ Becerro MA Tur JM and Turon X (1996a)
Location of toxicity within the Mediterranean sponge
Crambe crambe (Demospongiae Poecilosclerida) Mar
Biol 124(4) 583 ndash 590
Uriz MJ Turon X Galera J and Tur JM (1996b) New light on
the cell location of avarol within the sponge Dysidea avara
(Dendroceratida) Cell Tiss Res 285(3) 519 ndash 527
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Chakra Reddy N and Gnanesh-
war Rao T (2006) Petrosia testudinaria as a biomarker for
metal contamination at Gulf of Mannar southeast coast of
India Chemosphere 65(4) 634 ndash 638
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Srikanth K Usman PK and
Gnaneshwar Rao T (2007) Environmental contamination
using accumulation of metals in marine sponge Sigmadocia
fibulata inhabiting the coastal waters of Gulf of Mannar India
Toxicol Environ Chem 89(3) 487 ndash 498
Venkateswara Rao J Srikanth K Ramjee P and Gnaneshwar
Rao T (2009) The use of marine sponge Haliclona tenuir-
amosa as bioindicator to monitor heavy metal pollution in the
coasts of Gulf of Mannar India Environ Mon Assess
156(1 ndash 4) 451ndash 459
Venkateswarlu Y Reddy VRM Srinivas KNVS and Venka-
teswara Rao J (1993) A new isoquinoline from a sponge
Petrosia sp Ind J Chem 32(B) 704
Yi Q Wei Z Hua L Xingju Y and Meifang J (2005)
Cultivation of marine sponges Chin J Oceanol Limnol
23(2) 194 ndash 198
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 23
Page 5
mulation of Si in X testudinaria was significantly different
in P nigricans at P5005 (Ffrac12212 frac14 2708 P frac14 0107) It
is evident from the results that the relatively high composi-
tion of O was noticed in the spicular envelopes of P
nigricans N similis and X testudinaria (167 123 and
113 respectively) compared with that of Si (Figure 4)
The elemental analysis of surface pinacosome of the
three genera indicated the accumulation of elements such
as Al Ca Cl Fe Na O S and Si in different proportions
The order and range of percentage accumulation of the
elements in these genera were oxygen (28 ndash 50) and silicon
(23 ndash 35) as maximum chlorine (8 ndash 16) and aluminium (1 ndash
17) as moderate and sodium (3 ndash 6) sulfur (06 ndash 14) iron
(02 ndash 21) and calcium (03 ndash 27) in minor quantities One
way ANOVA (p5005) and mean values were compared
using Tukeyrsquos HSD pair wise comparison test which
indicated that O and Na are not significant among P
nigricans and N similis While comparing N similis and
X testudinaria all the elements are significantly different
except S (Figure 5)
The majority of chosen parameters (hexose pentose
spicule length and the ratios of spicule lengthywidth and
silicon of silicalemmaypinacoderm) used to study the
phylogenetic relationship through dendrogram analysis
between the sponges revealed that X testudinaria and N
similis are more closely related as compared to P nigricans
(Figure 6) It is apparent from the results that morphometric
biochemical and elemental parameters could also be used as
markers to assess the taxonomic similarities and dissimila-
rities between the sponges
DISCUSSION
This is the first study to show distinct morphological and
structural variations in the spicule morphometry and
aquiferous outlook of sponges (Family Petrosiidae) avail-
able from the Gulf of Mannar It is evident that the test
species were visually different and exhibited significant
variations in their ostia (number shape and diameter) and
morphometry of oxeae The protein (spongin) and carbo-
hydrate components differed between the sponges These
components are responsible for binding the spicules to
build up a specialized shape of ostia that influence the
water flow into the sponge body It is well known that
each genus has its own architecture as demonstrated by the
different morphology of ostia This has been demonstrated
and documented between the seven species collected at
SW Sulawesi reefs (Eastern Indonesia) which have char-
acteristic differences in their shape and sizes of ostia (de
Voogd and van Soest 2002)
The striking difference in percentage spicules by dry
weight in X testudinaria was relatively higher (amp 2 fold)
than P nigricans and 16 fold than N similis Also X
testudinaria possessed 305 times longer spicules than P
nigricans and 147 times that of N similis The growth of
the spicule is mainly based on specialized cells called
sclerocytes and axial filament which is formed by silica-
teins responsible for elongation of spicules and their
width is enhanced by the apposition of the silica
(Garrone 1978 Simpson 1984) In addition Aizenberg
et al (1996) concluded that intra-crystalline macromole-
cules (protein carbohydrates etc) play an important role
by their direct or indirect apposition and deposition to
form canalicular tracts of the sponge skeleton
EDXA of inorganic envelope spicular silicalemma and
the pinacodermal surface of the three sponges exhibited
significant changes in elemental composition The present
results indicated that some of the elements are limited to
the surface but many more might have been accumulated
in body wall The EDXA analysis is restricted only to
surface elemental composition and not to the tissue
accumulation which may be a key to identify the different
genera of Petrosiidae family It is evident from our earlier
ICP-MS analysis that more number of metals of higher
amount were quantified in P testudinaria (X testudinaria)
(Venkateswara Rao et al 2006) The elemental variation
between individual sponges between the species is well
documented (Patel et al 1985) and these variations in
elemental deposition may reflect the anatomical differences
of the individual sponges (Garrone et al 1981 Simpson
1984)
DNA based markers have been efficiently used in the
phylogenetic analyses of sponges Molecular biologists are
working on the sponge genome to understand the mole-
cular mechanism of evolution of metazoan genes and
diseases but knowledge of their biological and ecological
characteristics is so far very limited (Yi et al 2005)
Further analyses using specific loci have provided informa-
tion on the reproductive isolation of the species which
reinforced the conclusion that spicular morphology would
20 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Figure 4 The percentage elemental composition of inorganic
envelope (silicalemma) in three sponge species (Family Petrosii-
dae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf of Mannar Statistical
analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were
compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pair-wise comparisons test Statis-
tical significance as compared to P nigricans ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 21
Figure 5 Percent elemental uptake in the pinacosomal layer of each sponge species (Family Petrosiidae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf
of Mannar Statistical analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pairwise comparisons
test Statistical significance as compared to P nigricans (a) Statistical significance as compared to N similis (b) ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Figure 6 Dendrogram as obtained from average linkage cluster analysis (STATISTICA Ver 60) using the parameters of morphometry
biochemical and elemental analysis to assess the phylogenetic relationship between the three sponges of the Petrosiidae family
be useful in discriminating Petrosia spp (Bavestrello and
Sara 1992) In the present work we have analysed the
phylogenetic relationship based on the relative morpho-
metry biochemical and elemental composition which is a
new sequential approach to assess the linkage evidence
among the sponges The current non-genetic approach is
simple and may be useful to non-specialists as it does not
require the use of traditional genetic tools The present
comparison gives us the opportunity to analyse phyloge-
netic relationships thus giving useful insights for the
identification of sponges by non-taxonomists
As the demand for pharmacologically potent natural
products is constantly increasing attempts for the biotech-
nological production of sponge tissues are being made
Several studies suggest secondary metabolite production
by sponge symbionts (Molinski 1993 Oclarit et al 1994
Bewley et al 1996 Hentschel et al 2001) whereas
others indicate their production by sponge cells (Uriz
et al 1996 ab Garson et al 1998 Turon et al 2000)
Sponges possess strong regenerative capacities (Simpson
1984) and pieces of live sponge tissue are able to grow
and regenerate into healthy sponges This potency has
been used on a broad range of sponge species for the
cultivation of sponge tissue samples in both half-open
systems and open sea aquaculture (Osinga et al 1999)
CONCLUSION
Marine demosponges have been widely utilized for their
economical pharmaceutical as well as taxonomical
purposes in the past few decades The present observations
are particularly remarkable for ascertaining in situ discri-
mination of three members of Petrosiidae by observing
their morphological features along with their spicular and
anatomical aspects by advanced microscopic analyses
From our present and previous results we can conclude
that the sponges available at the Gulf of Mannar are
undergoing a timely anthropogenic disturbance that made
these organisms potential bio-indicators In their turn the
morphometric characteristics of these findings could be a
possible key for the chemical and analytical speciation of
future species available in any marine environment
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank the Director IICT for providing the
facilities and constant encouragement throughout the study
and also to Task-force project (CMM 004) of Council of
Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) which is the
funding source for the present work We are also grateful
to Mr T Sathish Bioengineering and Environmental
Centre IICT for calculating phylogenetic relationship
among the sponges The authors RP SK and GVG
thank CSIR for providing Senior Research Fellowships
REFERENCES
Aoki S Naka Y Itoh T Furukawa T Rachmat R Akiyama
S and Kobayashi M (2002) Lembehsterols A and B novel
sulfated sterols inhibiting thymidine phosphorylase from the
marine sponge Petrosia strongylata Chem Pharm Bull
50(6) 827 ndash 830Aizenberg J Ilan M Weiner S and Addadi L (1996) Intra-
crystalline macromolecules are involved in the morphogenesis
of calcitic sponge spicules Conn Tiss Res 34(4) 255 ndash 261
Araujo MF Cruz A Humanes M Lopes MT da Silva JAL
and da Silva JJRF (1999) Elemental composition of Demos-
pongiae from the eastern Atlantic coastal waters Chem Spec
Bioavail 11(1) 25 ndash 36Bavestrello G and Sara M (1992) Morphological and genetic
differences in ecologically distinct populations of Petrosia
(Porifera Demospongiae) Biol J Linn Soc 47(1) 49ndash 60
Bergquist PR (2001) Porifera (sponges) encyclopedia of life
sciences John Wiley and Sons Ltd New York
Bewley CA Holland ND and Faulkner DJ (1996) Two classes
of metabolites from Theonella swinhoei are localized in
distinct populations of bacterial symbionts Cell Mol Life
Sci 52(7) 716 ndash722Blunt JW Copp BR Munro MHG Northcote PT and
Prinsep MR (2006) Marine natural products Nat Prod
Rep 23(1) 26 ndash 78Bradford MM (1976) A rapid and sensitive method for the
quantitation of microgram quantities of protein utilizing the
principle of protein-dye binding Anal Biochem 72(1 ndash 2)
248 ndash 254Choi HJ Bae SJ Kim ND Jung JH and Choi YH (2004)
Induction of apoptosis by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacety-
lene from the sponge Petrosia sp in human skin melanoma
cells Int J Mol Med 14(6) 1091ndash 1096de Voogd NJ and van Soest RWM (2002) Indonesian sponges
of the genus Petrosia vosmaer (Demospongiae Haploscler-
ida) Zoologische Mededelingen (Leiden) 76(16) 193 ndash 209
Desqueyroux-Faundez R and Valentine C (2002) Family Petro-
siidae van Soest 1980 In Hooper JNA and van Soest
RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A guide to the classification
of sponges pp 906 ndash917 Kluwer AcademicyPlenum Publish-
ers New YorkFaulkner DJ (1984) Marine natural products metabolites of
marine invertebrates Nat Prod Rep 1 551 ndash598Garrone R (1978) Phylogenesis of connective tissue Morpholo-
gical aspects and biosynthesis of sponge intercellular matrix
In Robert L (ed) Frontiers of matrix biology Vol 5 pp 1 ndash
250 Karger Press BaselGarrone R Simpson TL and Pottu-Boumendil J (1981) Ultra-
structure and deposition of silica in sponges In Simpson TL
and Volcani BE (eds) Silicon and siliceous structures in
biological systems pp 495 ndash 525 Springer-Verlag New York
Garson MJ Flowers AE Webb RI Charan RD and McCaf-
frey EJ (1998) A spongeydinoflagellate association in the
haplosclerid demosponge Haliclona sp cellular origin of
cytotoxic alkaloids by Percoll density gradient fractionation
Cell Tiss Res 293(2) 365 ndash373Giner JL Gunashekar SP and Pomponi SA (1999) Sterols of
the marine sponge Petrosia weinbergi implications for the
absolute configurations of the antiviral orthoesterols and
weinbersterols Steroids 64(12) 820 ndash824Gunasekera SP Gunasekera M Longley RE and Schulte AK
(1990) Discodermolide a new bioactive polyhydroxylated
lactone from the marine sponge Discodermia dissolute J
Org Chem 55(16) 4912ndash 4915
22 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Gunda VG and Janapala VR (2009) Effects of dissolved oxygen
levels on survival and growth in vitro of Haliclona pigmenti-
fera (Demospongiae) Cell Tiss Res 337(3) 527 ndash 535
Hooper JNA van Soest RWM and Debrenne F (2002)
Phylum Porifera Grant 1836 In Hooper JNA and van
Soest RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A Guide to the
classification of sponges pp 9ndash 13 Kluwer Academic
Plenum Publishers New York
Harrison FW and de Vos L (1991) Porifera Vol 2 In Harrison
FW and Westfall JA (eds) Microscopical anatomy of
invertebrates pp 29 ndash 89 Wiley-Liss New York
Hentschel U Schmid M Wagner M Fieseler L Gernert C
and Hacker J (2001) Isolation and phylogenetic analysis of
bacteria with antimicrobial activities from the Mediterranean
sponges Aplysina aerophoba and Aplysina cavernicola FEMS
Microbiol Ecol 35(3) 305 ndash 312
Kim JS Im KS Jung JH Kim YL Kim J Shim CJ and
Lee CO (1998) New bioactive polyacetylenes from the
marine sponge Petrosia sp Tetrahedron 54(13) 3151ndash 3158
Millero FJ (1996) Chemical Oceanography 2nd edn p 469
CRC Press Boca Raton
Molinski TF (1993) Marine pyridoacridine alkaloids structure
synthesis and biological chemistry Chem Rev 93(5) 1825ndash
1838
Muller WEG Grebenjuk VA Pennec GL Schroder HC
Brummer F Hentschel U Muller IM and Breter HJ
(2004) Sustainable production of bioactive compounds by
sponges-cell culture and gene cluster approach A review
Mar Biotechnol 6(2) 105 ndash 117
Oclarit JM Okada H Ohta S Kaminura K Yamaoka Y
Iisuka T Miyashiro S and Ikegami S (1994) Anti-bacillus
substance in the marine sponge Hyatella species produced by
an associated Vibrio species bacterium Microbios 78(314)
7 ndash 16
Osinga R Tramper J and Wijffels RH (1999) Cultivation of
marine sponges Mar Biotechnol 1(6) 509 ndash532
Park C Jung JH Kim ND and Choi YH (2007) Inhibition of
cyclooxygenase-2 and telomerase activities in human leukemia
cells by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacetylene from the marine
sponge Petrosia sp Int J Oncol 30(1) 291 ndash 298
Patel B Balani MC and Patel S (1985) Sponges lsquosentinelrsquo of
heavy metals Sci Tot Environ 41(2) 143 ndash 152
Scheuer PJ (1978-1983) Marine natural products Chemical and
biological perspectives Vol (1 ndash 5) Academic Press Inc New
York
Simpson TL (1984) The cell biology of sponges pp 1 ndash 662
Springer-Verlag New York
Taylor KACC (1995) A modification of the phenolysulfuric
acid assay for total carbohydrates giving more comparable
absorbances Appl Biochem Biotechnol 53(3) 207ndash 214
Turon X Becerro MA and Uriz MJ (2000) Distribution of
brominated compounds within the sponge Aplysina aero-
phoba coupling of X-ray microanalysis with cryofixation
techniques Cell Tiss Res 301(2) 311 ndash 322
Uemura D Takahashi K Yamamoto T Katayama C Tanaka
J Okumura Y and Hirata Y (1985) Norhalichondrin A an
antitumor polyether macrolide from a marine sponge J Am
Chem Soc 107(16) 4796ndash4798
Uriz MJ Becerro MA Tur JM and Turon X (1996a)
Location of toxicity within the Mediterranean sponge
Crambe crambe (Demospongiae Poecilosclerida) Mar
Biol 124(4) 583 ndash 590
Uriz MJ Turon X Galera J and Tur JM (1996b) New light on
the cell location of avarol within the sponge Dysidea avara
(Dendroceratida) Cell Tiss Res 285(3) 519 ndash 527
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Chakra Reddy N and Gnanesh-
war Rao T (2006) Petrosia testudinaria as a biomarker for
metal contamination at Gulf of Mannar southeast coast of
India Chemosphere 65(4) 634 ndash 638
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Srikanth K Usman PK and
Gnaneshwar Rao T (2007) Environmental contamination
using accumulation of metals in marine sponge Sigmadocia
fibulata inhabiting the coastal waters of Gulf of Mannar India
Toxicol Environ Chem 89(3) 487 ndash 498
Venkateswara Rao J Srikanth K Ramjee P and Gnaneshwar
Rao T (2009) The use of marine sponge Haliclona tenuir-
amosa as bioindicator to monitor heavy metal pollution in the
coasts of Gulf of Mannar India Environ Mon Assess
156(1 ndash 4) 451ndash 459
Venkateswarlu Y Reddy VRM Srinivas KNVS and Venka-
teswara Rao J (1993) A new isoquinoline from a sponge
Petrosia sp Ind J Chem 32(B) 704
Yi Q Wei Z Hua L Xingju Y and Meifang J (2005)
Cultivation of marine sponges Chin J Oceanol Limnol
23(2) 194 ndash 198
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 23
Page 6
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 21
Figure 5 Percent elemental uptake in the pinacosomal layer of each sponge species (Family Petrosiidae) under sympatric conditions at Gulf
of Mannar Statistical analysis was determined using ANOVA (P5005) and means were compared using Tukeyrsquos HSD pairwise comparisons
test Statistical significance as compared to P nigricans (a) Statistical significance as compared to N similis (b) ns no significant
difference (P5005)
Figure 6 Dendrogram as obtained from average linkage cluster analysis (STATISTICA Ver 60) using the parameters of morphometry
biochemical and elemental analysis to assess the phylogenetic relationship between the three sponges of the Petrosiidae family
be useful in discriminating Petrosia spp (Bavestrello and
Sara 1992) In the present work we have analysed the
phylogenetic relationship based on the relative morpho-
metry biochemical and elemental composition which is a
new sequential approach to assess the linkage evidence
among the sponges The current non-genetic approach is
simple and may be useful to non-specialists as it does not
require the use of traditional genetic tools The present
comparison gives us the opportunity to analyse phyloge-
netic relationships thus giving useful insights for the
identification of sponges by non-taxonomists
As the demand for pharmacologically potent natural
products is constantly increasing attempts for the biotech-
nological production of sponge tissues are being made
Several studies suggest secondary metabolite production
by sponge symbionts (Molinski 1993 Oclarit et al 1994
Bewley et al 1996 Hentschel et al 2001) whereas
others indicate their production by sponge cells (Uriz
et al 1996 ab Garson et al 1998 Turon et al 2000)
Sponges possess strong regenerative capacities (Simpson
1984) and pieces of live sponge tissue are able to grow
and regenerate into healthy sponges This potency has
been used on a broad range of sponge species for the
cultivation of sponge tissue samples in both half-open
systems and open sea aquaculture (Osinga et al 1999)
CONCLUSION
Marine demosponges have been widely utilized for their
economical pharmaceutical as well as taxonomical
purposes in the past few decades The present observations
are particularly remarkable for ascertaining in situ discri-
mination of three members of Petrosiidae by observing
their morphological features along with their spicular and
anatomical aspects by advanced microscopic analyses
From our present and previous results we can conclude
that the sponges available at the Gulf of Mannar are
undergoing a timely anthropogenic disturbance that made
these organisms potential bio-indicators In their turn the
morphometric characteristics of these findings could be a
possible key for the chemical and analytical speciation of
future species available in any marine environment
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank the Director IICT for providing the
facilities and constant encouragement throughout the study
and also to Task-force project (CMM 004) of Council of
Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) which is the
funding source for the present work We are also grateful
to Mr T Sathish Bioengineering and Environmental
Centre IICT for calculating phylogenetic relationship
among the sponges The authors RP SK and GVG
thank CSIR for providing Senior Research Fellowships
REFERENCES
Aoki S Naka Y Itoh T Furukawa T Rachmat R Akiyama
S and Kobayashi M (2002) Lembehsterols A and B novel
sulfated sterols inhibiting thymidine phosphorylase from the
marine sponge Petrosia strongylata Chem Pharm Bull
50(6) 827 ndash 830Aizenberg J Ilan M Weiner S and Addadi L (1996) Intra-
crystalline macromolecules are involved in the morphogenesis
of calcitic sponge spicules Conn Tiss Res 34(4) 255 ndash 261
Araujo MF Cruz A Humanes M Lopes MT da Silva JAL
and da Silva JJRF (1999) Elemental composition of Demos-
pongiae from the eastern Atlantic coastal waters Chem Spec
Bioavail 11(1) 25 ndash 36Bavestrello G and Sara M (1992) Morphological and genetic
differences in ecologically distinct populations of Petrosia
(Porifera Demospongiae) Biol J Linn Soc 47(1) 49ndash 60
Bergquist PR (2001) Porifera (sponges) encyclopedia of life
sciences John Wiley and Sons Ltd New York
Bewley CA Holland ND and Faulkner DJ (1996) Two classes
of metabolites from Theonella swinhoei are localized in
distinct populations of bacterial symbionts Cell Mol Life
Sci 52(7) 716 ndash722Blunt JW Copp BR Munro MHG Northcote PT and
Prinsep MR (2006) Marine natural products Nat Prod
Rep 23(1) 26 ndash 78Bradford MM (1976) A rapid and sensitive method for the
quantitation of microgram quantities of protein utilizing the
principle of protein-dye binding Anal Biochem 72(1 ndash 2)
248 ndash 254Choi HJ Bae SJ Kim ND Jung JH and Choi YH (2004)
Induction of apoptosis by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacety-
lene from the sponge Petrosia sp in human skin melanoma
cells Int J Mol Med 14(6) 1091ndash 1096de Voogd NJ and van Soest RWM (2002) Indonesian sponges
of the genus Petrosia vosmaer (Demospongiae Haploscler-
ida) Zoologische Mededelingen (Leiden) 76(16) 193 ndash 209
Desqueyroux-Faundez R and Valentine C (2002) Family Petro-
siidae van Soest 1980 In Hooper JNA and van Soest
RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A guide to the classification
of sponges pp 906 ndash917 Kluwer AcademicyPlenum Publish-
ers New YorkFaulkner DJ (1984) Marine natural products metabolites of
marine invertebrates Nat Prod Rep 1 551 ndash598Garrone R (1978) Phylogenesis of connective tissue Morpholo-
gical aspects and biosynthesis of sponge intercellular matrix
In Robert L (ed) Frontiers of matrix biology Vol 5 pp 1 ndash
250 Karger Press BaselGarrone R Simpson TL and Pottu-Boumendil J (1981) Ultra-
structure and deposition of silica in sponges In Simpson TL
and Volcani BE (eds) Silicon and siliceous structures in
biological systems pp 495 ndash 525 Springer-Verlag New York
Garson MJ Flowers AE Webb RI Charan RD and McCaf-
frey EJ (1998) A spongeydinoflagellate association in the
haplosclerid demosponge Haliclona sp cellular origin of
cytotoxic alkaloids by Percoll density gradient fractionation
Cell Tiss Res 293(2) 365 ndash373Giner JL Gunashekar SP and Pomponi SA (1999) Sterols of
the marine sponge Petrosia weinbergi implications for the
absolute configurations of the antiviral orthoesterols and
weinbersterols Steroids 64(12) 820 ndash824Gunasekera SP Gunasekera M Longley RE and Schulte AK
(1990) Discodermolide a new bioactive polyhydroxylated
lactone from the marine sponge Discodermia dissolute J
Org Chem 55(16) 4912ndash 4915
22 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Gunda VG and Janapala VR (2009) Effects of dissolved oxygen
levels on survival and growth in vitro of Haliclona pigmenti-
fera (Demospongiae) Cell Tiss Res 337(3) 527 ndash 535
Hooper JNA van Soest RWM and Debrenne F (2002)
Phylum Porifera Grant 1836 In Hooper JNA and van
Soest RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A Guide to the
classification of sponges pp 9ndash 13 Kluwer Academic
Plenum Publishers New York
Harrison FW and de Vos L (1991) Porifera Vol 2 In Harrison
FW and Westfall JA (eds) Microscopical anatomy of
invertebrates pp 29 ndash 89 Wiley-Liss New York
Hentschel U Schmid M Wagner M Fieseler L Gernert C
and Hacker J (2001) Isolation and phylogenetic analysis of
bacteria with antimicrobial activities from the Mediterranean
sponges Aplysina aerophoba and Aplysina cavernicola FEMS
Microbiol Ecol 35(3) 305 ndash 312
Kim JS Im KS Jung JH Kim YL Kim J Shim CJ and
Lee CO (1998) New bioactive polyacetylenes from the
marine sponge Petrosia sp Tetrahedron 54(13) 3151ndash 3158
Millero FJ (1996) Chemical Oceanography 2nd edn p 469
CRC Press Boca Raton
Molinski TF (1993) Marine pyridoacridine alkaloids structure
synthesis and biological chemistry Chem Rev 93(5) 1825ndash
1838
Muller WEG Grebenjuk VA Pennec GL Schroder HC
Brummer F Hentschel U Muller IM and Breter HJ
(2004) Sustainable production of bioactive compounds by
sponges-cell culture and gene cluster approach A review
Mar Biotechnol 6(2) 105 ndash 117
Oclarit JM Okada H Ohta S Kaminura K Yamaoka Y
Iisuka T Miyashiro S and Ikegami S (1994) Anti-bacillus
substance in the marine sponge Hyatella species produced by
an associated Vibrio species bacterium Microbios 78(314)
7 ndash 16
Osinga R Tramper J and Wijffels RH (1999) Cultivation of
marine sponges Mar Biotechnol 1(6) 509 ndash532
Park C Jung JH Kim ND and Choi YH (2007) Inhibition of
cyclooxygenase-2 and telomerase activities in human leukemia
cells by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacetylene from the marine
sponge Petrosia sp Int J Oncol 30(1) 291 ndash 298
Patel B Balani MC and Patel S (1985) Sponges lsquosentinelrsquo of
heavy metals Sci Tot Environ 41(2) 143 ndash 152
Scheuer PJ (1978-1983) Marine natural products Chemical and
biological perspectives Vol (1 ndash 5) Academic Press Inc New
York
Simpson TL (1984) The cell biology of sponges pp 1 ndash 662
Springer-Verlag New York
Taylor KACC (1995) A modification of the phenolysulfuric
acid assay for total carbohydrates giving more comparable
absorbances Appl Biochem Biotechnol 53(3) 207ndash 214
Turon X Becerro MA and Uriz MJ (2000) Distribution of
brominated compounds within the sponge Aplysina aero-
phoba coupling of X-ray microanalysis with cryofixation
techniques Cell Tiss Res 301(2) 311 ndash 322
Uemura D Takahashi K Yamamoto T Katayama C Tanaka
J Okumura Y and Hirata Y (1985) Norhalichondrin A an
antitumor polyether macrolide from a marine sponge J Am
Chem Soc 107(16) 4796ndash4798
Uriz MJ Becerro MA Tur JM and Turon X (1996a)
Location of toxicity within the Mediterranean sponge
Crambe crambe (Demospongiae Poecilosclerida) Mar
Biol 124(4) 583 ndash 590
Uriz MJ Turon X Galera J and Tur JM (1996b) New light on
the cell location of avarol within the sponge Dysidea avara
(Dendroceratida) Cell Tiss Res 285(3) 519 ndash 527
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Chakra Reddy N and Gnanesh-
war Rao T (2006) Petrosia testudinaria as a biomarker for
metal contamination at Gulf of Mannar southeast coast of
India Chemosphere 65(4) 634 ndash 638
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Srikanth K Usman PK and
Gnaneshwar Rao T (2007) Environmental contamination
using accumulation of metals in marine sponge Sigmadocia
fibulata inhabiting the coastal waters of Gulf of Mannar India
Toxicol Environ Chem 89(3) 487 ndash 498
Venkateswara Rao J Srikanth K Ramjee P and Gnaneshwar
Rao T (2009) The use of marine sponge Haliclona tenuir-
amosa as bioindicator to monitor heavy metal pollution in the
coasts of Gulf of Mannar India Environ Mon Assess
156(1 ndash 4) 451ndash 459
Venkateswarlu Y Reddy VRM Srinivas KNVS and Venka-
teswara Rao J (1993) A new isoquinoline from a sponge
Petrosia sp Ind J Chem 32(B) 704
Yi Q Wei Z Hua L Xingju Y and Meifang J (2005)
Cultivation of marine sponges Chin J Oceanol Limnol
23(2) 194 ndash 198
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 23
Page 7
be useful in discriminating Petrosia spp (Bavestrello and
Sara 1992) In the present work we have analysed the
phylogenetic relationship based on the relative morpho-
metry biochemical and elemental composition which is a
new sequential approach to assess the linkage evidence
among the sponges The current non-genetic approach is
simple and may be useful to non-specialists as it does not
require the use of traditional genetic tools The present
comparison gives us the opportunity to analyse phyloge-
netic relationships thus giving useful insights for the
identification of sponges by non-taxonomists
As the demand for pharmacologically potent natural
products is constantly increasing attempts for the biotech-
nological production of sponge tissues are being made
Several studies suggest secondary metabolite production
by sponge symbionts (Molinski 1993 Oclarit et al 1994
Bewley et al 1996 Hentschel et al 2001) whereas
others indicate their production by sponge cells (Uriz
et al 1996 ab Garson et al 1998 Turon et al 2000)
Sponges possess strong regenerative capacities (Simpson
1984) and pieces of live sponge tissue are able to grow
and regenerate into healthy sponges This potency has
been used on a broad range of sponge species for the
cultivation of sponge tissue samples in both half-open
systems and open sea aquaculture (Osinga et al 1999)
CONCLUSION
Marine demosponges have been widely utilized for their
economical pharmaceutical as well as taxonomical
purposes in the past few decades The present observations
are particularly remarkable for ascertaining in situ discri-
mination of three members of Petrosiidae by observing
their morphological features along with their spicular and
anatomical aspects by advanced microscopic analyses
From our present and previous results we can conclude
that the sponges available at the Gulf of Mannar are
undergoing a timely anthropogenic disturbance that made
these organisms potential bio-indicators In their turn the
morphometric characteristics of these findings could be a
possible key for the chemical and analytical speciation of
future species available in any marine environment
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank the Director IICT for providing the
facilities and constant encouragement throughout the study
and also to Task-force project (CMM 004) of Council of
Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) which is the
funding source for the present work We are also grateful
to Mr T Sathish Bioengineering and Environmental
Centre IICT for calculating phylogenetic relationship
among the sponges The authors RP SK and GVG
thank CSIR for providing Senior Research Fellowships
REFERENCES
Aoki S Naka Y Itoh T Furukawa T Rachmat R Akiyama
S and Kobayashi M (2002) Lembehsterols A and B novel
sulfated sterols inhibiting thymidine phosphorylase from the
marine sponge Petrosia strongylata Chem Pharm Bull
50(6) 827 ndash 830Aizenberg J Ilan M Weiner S and Addadi L (1996) Intra-
crystalline macromolecules are involved in the morphogenesis
of calcitic sponge spicules Conn Tiss Res 34(4) 255 ndash 261
Araujo MF Cruz A Humanes M Lopes MT da Silva JAL
and da Silva JJRF (1999) Elemental composition of Demos-
pongiae from the eastern Atlantic coastal waters Chem Spec
Bioavail 11(1) 25 ndash 36Bavestrello G and Sara M (1992) Morphological and genetic
differences in ecologically distinct populations of Petrosia
(Porifera Demospongiae) Biol J Linn Soc 47(1) 49ndash 60
Bergquist PR (2001) Porifera (sponges) encyclopedia of life
sciences John Wiley and Sons Ltd New York
Bewley CA Holland ND and Faulkner DJ (1996) Two classes
of metabolites from Theonella swinhoei are localized in
distinct populations of bacterial symbionts Cell Mol Life
Sci 52(7) 716 ndash722Blunt JW Copp BR Munro MHG Northcote PT and
Prinsep MR (2006) Marine natural products Nat Prod
Rep 23(1) 26 ndash 78Bradford MM (1976) A rapid and sensitive method for the
quantitation of microgram quantities of protein utilizing the
principle of protein-dye binding Anal Biochem 72(1 ndash 2)
248 ndash 254Choi HJ Bae SJ Kim ND Jung JH and Choi YH (2004)
Induction of apoptosis by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacety-
lene from the sponge Petrosia sp in human skin melanoma
cells Int J Mol Med 14(6) 1091ndash 1096de Voogd NJ and van Soest RWM (2002) Indonesian sponges
of the genus Petrosia vosmaer (Demospongiae Haploscler-
ida) Zoologische Mededelingen (Leiden) 76(16) 193 ndash 209
Desqueyroux-Faundez R and Valentine C (2002) Family Petro-
siidae van Soest 1980 In Hooper JNA and van Soest
RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A guide to the classification
of sponges pp 906 ndash917 Kluwer AcademicyPlenum Publish-
ers New YorkFaulkner DJ (1984) Marine natural products metabolites of
marine invertebrates Nat Prod Rep 1 551 ndash598Garrone R (1978) Phylogenesis of connective tissue Morpholo-
gical aspects and biosynthesis of sponge intercellular matrix
In Robert L (ed) Frontiers of matrix biology Vol 5 pp 1 ndash
250 Karger Press BaselGarrone R Simpson TL and Pottu-Boumendil J (1981) Ultra-
structure and deposition of silica in sponges In Simpson TL
and Volcani BE (eds) Silicon and siliceous structures in
biological systems pp 495 ndash 525 Springer-Verlag New York
Garson MJ Flowers AE Webb RI Charan RD and McCaf-
frey EJ (1998) A spongeydinoflagellate association in the
haplosclerid demosponge Haliclona sp cellular origin of
cytotoxic alkaloids by Percoll density gradient fractionation
Cell Tiss Res 293(2) 365 ndash373Giner JL Gunashekar SP and Pomponi SA (1999) Sterols of
the marine sponge Petrosia weinbergi implications for the
absolute configurations of the antiviral orthoesterols and
weinbersterols Steroids 64(12) 820 ndash824Gunasekera SP Gunasekera M Longley RE and Schulte AK
(1990) Discodermolide a new bioactive polyhydroxylated
lactone from the marine sponge Discodermia dissolute J
Org Chem 55(16) 4912ndash 4915
22 Elemental composition of three marine sponges in Gulf of Mannar
Gunda VG and Janapala VR (2009) Effects of dissolved oxygen
levels on survival and growth in vitro of Haliclona pigmenti-
fera (Demospongiae) Cell Tiss Res 337(3) 527 ndash 535
Hooper JNA van Soest RWM and Debrenne F (2002)
Phylum Porifera Grant 1836 In Hooper JNA and van
Soest RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A Guide to the
classification of sponges pp 9ndash 13 Kluwer Academic
Plenum Publishers New York
Harrison FW and de Vos L (1991) Porifera Vol 2 In Harrison
FW and Westfall JA (eds) Microscopical anatomy of
invertebrates pp 29 ndash 89 Wiley-Liss New York
Hentschel U Schmid M Wagner M Fieseler L Gernert C
and Hacker J (2001) Isolation and phylogenetic analysis of
bacteria with antimicrobial activities from the Mediterranean
sponges Aplysina aerophoba and Aplysina cavernicola FEMS
Microbiol Ecol 35(3) 305 ndash 312
Kim JS Im KS Jung JH Kim YL Kim J Shim CJ and
Lee CO (1998) New bioactive polyacetylenes from the
marine sponge Petrosia sp Tetrahedron 54(13) 3151ndash 3158
Millero FJ (1996) Chemical Oceanography 2nd edn p 469
CRC Press Boca Raton
Molinski TF (1993) Marine pyridoacridine alkaloids structure
synthesis and biological chemistry Chem Rev 93(5) 1825ndash
1838
Muller WEG Grebenjuk VA Pennec GL Schroder HC
Brummer F Hentschel U Muller IM and Breter HJ
(2004) Sustainable production of bioactive compounds by
sponges-cell culture and gene cluster approach A review
Mar Biotechnol 6(2) 105 ndash 117
Oclarit JM Okada H Ohta S Kaminura K Yamaoka Y
Iisuka T Miyashiro S and Ikegami S (1994) Anti-bacillus
substance in the marine sponge Hyatella species produced by
an associated Vibrio species bacterium Microbios 78(314)
7 ndash 16
Osinga R Tramper J and Wijffels RH (1999) Cultivation of
marine sponges Mar Biotechnol 1(6) 509 ndash532
Park C Jung JH Kim ND and Choi YH (2007) Inhibition of
cyclooxygenase-2 and telomerase activities in human leukemia
cells by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacetylene from the marine
sponge Petrosia sp Int J Oncol 30(1) 291 ndash 298
Patel B Balani MC and Patel S (1985) Sponges lsquosentinelrsquo of
heavy metals Sci Tot Environ 41(2) 143 ndash 152
Scheuer PJ (1978-1983) Marine natural products Chemical and
biological perspectives Vol (1 ndash 5) Academic Press Inc New
York
Simpson TL (1984) The cell biology of sponges pp 1 ndash 662
Springer-Verlag New York
Taylor KACC (1995) A modification of the phenolysulfuric
acid assay for total carbohydrates giving more comparable
absorbances Appl Biochem Biotechnol 53(3) 207ndash 214
Turon X Becerro MA and Uriz MJ (2000) Distribution of
brominated compounds within the sponge Aplysina aero-
phoba coupling of X-ray microanalysis with cryofixation
techniques Cell Tiss Res 301(2) 311 ndash 322
Uemura D Takahashi K Yamamoto T Katayama C Tanaka
J Okumura Y and Hirata Y (1985) Norhalichondrin A an
antitumor polyether macrolide from a marine sponge J Am
Chem Soc 107(16) 4796ndash4798
Uriz MJ Becerro MA Tur JM and Turon X (1996a)
Location of toxicity within the Mediterranean sponge
Crambe crambe (Demospongiae Poecilosclerida) Mar
Biol 124(4) 583 ndash 590
Uriz MJ Turon X Galera J and Tur JM (1996b) New light on
the cell location of avarol within the sponge Dysidea avara
(Dendroceratida) Cell Tiss Res 285(3) 519 ndash 527
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Chakra Reddy N and Gnanesh-
war Rao T (2006) Petrosia testudinaria as a biomarker for
metal contamination at Gulf of Mannar southeast coast of
India Chemosphere 65(4) 634 ndash 638
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Srikanth K Usman PK and
Gnaneshwar Rao T (2007) Environmental contamination
using accumulation of metals in marine sponge Sigmadocia
fibulata inhabiting the coastal waters of Gulf of Mannar India
Toxicol Environ Chem 89(3) 487 ndash 498
Venkateswara Rao J Srikanth K Ramjee P and Gnaneshwar
Rao T (2009) The use of marine sponge Haliclona tenuir-
amosa as bioindicator to monitor heavy metal pollution in the
coasts of Gulf of Mannar India Environ Mon Assess
156(1 ndash 4) 451ndash 459
Venkateswarlu Y Reddy VRM Srinivas KNVS and Venka-
teswara Rao J (1993) A new isoquinoline from a sponge
Petrosia sp Ind J Chem 32(B) 704
Yi Q Wei Z Hua L Xingju Y and Meifang J (2005)
Cultivation of marine sponges Chin J Oceanol Limnol
23(2) 194 ndash 198
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 23
Page 8
Gunda VG and Janapala VR (2009) Effects of dissolved oxygen
levels on survival and growth in vitro of Haliclona pigmenti-
fera (Demospongiae) Cell Tiss Res 337(3) 527 ndash 535
Hooper JNA van Soest RWM and Debrenne F (2002)
Phylum Porifera Grant 1836 In Hooper JNA and van
Soest RWM (eds) Systema Porifera A Guide to the
classification of sponges pp 9ndash 13 Kluwer Academic
Plenum Publishers New York
Harrison FW and de Vos L (1991) Porifera Vol 2 In Harrison
FW and Westfall JA (eds) Microscopical anatomy of
invertebrates pp 29 ndash 89 Wiley-Liss New York
Hentschel U Schmid M Wagner M Fieseler L Gernert C
and Hacker J (2001) Isolation and phylogenetic analysis of
bacteria with antimicrobial activities from the Mediterranean
sponges Aplysina aerophoba and Aplysina cavernicola FEMS
Microbiol Ecol 35(3) 305 ndash 312
Kim JS Im KS Jung JH Kim YL Kim J Shim CJ and
Lee CO (1998) New bioactive polyacetylenes from the
marine sponge Petrosia sp Tetrahedron 54(13) 3151ndash 3158
Millero FJ (1996) Chemical Oceanography 2nd edn p 469
CRC Press Boca Raton
Molinski TF (1993) Marine pyridoacridine alkaloids structure
synthesis and biological chemistry Chem Rev 93(5) 1825ndash
1838
Muller WEG Grebenjuk VA Pennec GL Schroder HC
Brummer F Hentschel U Muller IM and Breter HJ
(2004) Sustainable production of bioactive compounds by
sponges-cell culture and gene cluster approach A review
Mar Biotechnol 6(2) 105 ndash 117
Oclarit JM Okada H Ohta S Kaminura K Yamaoka Y
Iisuka T Miyashiro S and Ikegami S (1994) Anti-bacillus
substance in the marine sponge Hyatella species produced by
an associated Vibrio species bacterium Microbios 78(314)
7 ndash 16
Osinga R Tramper J and Wijffels RH (1999) Cultivation of
marine sponges Mar Biotechnol 1(6) 509 ndash532
Park C Jung JH Kim ND and Choi YH (2007) Inhibition of
cyclooxygenase-2 and telomerase activities in human leukemia
cells by dideoxypetrosynol A a polyacetylene from the marine
sponge Petrosia sp Int J Oncol 30(1) 291 ndash 298
Patel B Balani MC and Patel S (1985) Sponges lsquosentinelrsquo of
heavy metals Sci Tot Environ 41(2) 143 ndash 152
Scheuer PJ (1978-1983) Marine natural products Chemical and
biological perspectives Vol (1 ndash 5) Academic Press Inc New
York
Simpson TL (1984) The cell biology of sponges pp 1 ndash 662
Springer-Verlag New York
Taylor KACC (1995) A modification of the phenolysulfuric
acid assay for total carbohydrates giving more comparable
absorbances Appl Biochem Biotechnol 53(3) 207ndash 214
Turon X Becerro MA and Uriz MJ (2000) Distribution of
brominated compounds within the sponge Aplysina aero-
phoba coupling of X-ray microanalysis with cryofixation
techniques Cell Tiss Res 301(2) 311 ndash 322
Uemura D Takahashi K Yamamoto T Katayama C Tanaka
J Okumura Y and Hirata Y (1985) Norhalichondrin A an
antitumor polyether macrolide from a marine sponge J Am
Chem Soc 107(16) 4796ndash4798
Uriz MJ Becerro MA Tur JM and Turon X (1996a)
Location of toxicity within the Mediterranean sponge
Crambe crambe (Demospongiae Poecilosclerida) Mar
Biol 124(4) 583 ndash 590
Uriz MJ Turon X Galera J and Tur JM (1996b) New light on
the cell location of avarol within the sponge Dysidea avara
(Dendroceratida) Cell Tiss Res 285(3) 519 ndash 527
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Chakra Reddy N and Gnanesh-
war Rao T (2006) Petrosia testudinaria as a biomarker for
metal contamination at Gulf of Mannar southeast coast of
India Chemosphere 65(4) 634 ndash 638
Venkateswara Rao J Kavitha P Srikanth K Usman PK and
Gnaneshwar Rao T (2007) Environmental contamination
using accumulation of metals in marine sponge Sigmadocia
fibulata inhabiting the coastal waters of Gulf of Mannar India
Toxicol Environ Chem 89(3) 487 ndash 498
Venkateswara Rao J Srikanth K Ramjee P and Gnaneshwar
Rao T (2009) The use of marine sponge Haliclona tenuir-
amosa as bioindicator to monitor heavy metal pollution in the
coasts of Gulf of Mannar India Environ Mon Assess
156(1 ndash 4) 451ndash 459
Venkateswarlu Y Reddy VRM Srinivas KNVS and Venka-
teswara Rao J (1993) A new isoquinoline from a sponge
Petrosia sp Ind J Chem 32(B) 704
Yi Q Wei Z Hua L Xingju Y and Meifang J (2005)
Cultivation of marine sponges Chin J Oceanol Limnol
23(2) 194 ndash 198
Ramjee Pallela Srikanth Koigoora Venu Gopal Gunda Madhavendra Sakunthala Sunkara and Venkateswara Rao Janapala 23