Top Banner
Fiberglass Reinforced Plastics Institute Gary Arthur Executive Director and President 508-380-2232 [email protected] Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification
22

Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Jul 06, 2018

Download

Documents

dangminh
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Fiberglass Reinforced Plastics InstituteGary Arthur – Executive Director and President

508-380-2232 [email protected]

Common Questions Asked About FRPI

SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification

Page 2: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

• Who is FRPI?

• Has FRPI certification been adopted into law?

• Why another certification program?

• Is FRPI a tank standard?

• How does certification work?

• Is FRPI certification a risk management practice?

• What are differences between FRPI and other practices?

• Where is inspection headed?

Common Questions Asked About FRPI

SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification

Page 3: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Underwriters

Laboratories

Factory

Mutual

Air Movement

and Control

Association

®

®®

®

UL

Who is FRPI?Industrial Consumer Protection Company Like Others

Page 4: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

• Founded 2003

• Massachusetts Non-profit Corporation

• IRS Tax Exempt 501(c)(6) Organization

• Mission (exempt purpose):

– Improve Business Conditions and Safety

– Eliminate Risks

• Organization Driven By:

– Owner/End Users

– Engineering Firms

– Regulators

Who is FRPI?Certifying Entity

Page 5: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Has FRPI certification been

adopted into law?Commonwealth of Massachusetts

Page 6: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Why another certification program?Premature Failure

Page 7: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Why another certification program?Estimated failure cost and risk to US industry

• $5.1 billion “Corrosion” equipment purchased 2014

• $3.86 billion avg. per year purchased past 30 years

• $115.8 billion installation base

• Premature failure $357 million/year or 7% of sales

• 1 out of 3 to 3 out of 5 bids off spec = 30 to 60% Risk Exposure

From ACMA and Lucintel Research

TOTAL FRP INDUSTRY MARKET

Page 8: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Unexpected Cost:

• Startup Problems

• Overlooked Warranty Work

• Maintenance and Repair

• Unrealized Design Life

• Catastrophic Failure

Why another certification program?Definition of Premature Failure

Page 9: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Chemical

Attack

Leakage

Why another certification program?Spec, Manufacturing and Installation Compliance Issues

Page 10: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Leakage

No Hub

Reinforcement

Voids

Excessive

Amount

of Air

Inclusions

NaOCl

Permeation

ASTM D3299

Why another certification program?Spec, Manufacturing and Installation Compliance Issues

Page 11: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Why another certification program?Spec, Manufacturing and Installation Compliance Issues

These tanks “met” project

specifications, with Owner

Engineer “Approval” and

Manufacturer “PE Stamp”.

Page 12: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

12’ ID by 35-6” SS

Why another certification program?Ongoing Challenges

These tanks “met” project

specifications, with Owner

Engineer “Approval” and

Manufacturer “PE Stamp”.

Page 13: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Why another certification program?Material Engineering and Manufacturing Challenges

Page 14: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Heat #

Assigned

Heat # Marked

Heat #

Carried

Why another certification program?FRP Riskier Than Steel Plate Processing

Page 15: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Is FRPI a tank standard?Plans, Specs and Standards Compliance Practice

American Standards Institute

ASTM D3299 and D4097

American Petroleum Institute

API 12P

American Water Works Association

AWWA D120

American Society of Mechanical Engineers

ASME RTP-1

American Society of Mechanical Engineers

ASME Section X

®

®

®

®

®

Page 16: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Precise Drawings & Specs Submittal Compliance

Manufacturing

Verification

Installation

Checkup

How does certification work? Four Step Process Utilizing Certified Manufacturers

Positive Material ID with Registration Number

Page 17: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Is FRPI certification a risk

management practice? Spec Driven Compliance

Page 18: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Protect consumers against misleading claims

Is FRPI certification a risk

management practice? Heavily Vetted and Registered Practices

Page 19: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

What are differences between

FRPI and other practices? Flexibility and Span of Control

PRACTICEMFR

QUALIFICATIONBID

SPECIFICATIONPURCHASING

CONTROLSUBMITTAL

REVIEWMFG

SURVEILLANCEINSTALLATION VERIFICATION

AWWA D120

ASTM D3299 and D4097

API 12P and 12Q

X X

ASME RTP-1 and Sect X

X X

FRPI SP9000 and SP9100

X X X X X X

Page 20: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

DuctworkTanks

Vessels

Piping Other

Where is inspection headed? Equipment Certification

Longer Life • Reduced Cost • Hardship Prevention

Page 21: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Where is inspection headed? Inspector Certification

In/Out of Service Source

Longer Life • Reduced Cost • Hardship Prevention

Page 22: Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and … · Common Questions Asked About FRPI SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification. Underwriters ... ASME RTP-1 and Sect X X

Fiberglass Reinforced Plastics InstituteGary Arthur – Executive Director and President

508-380-2232 [email protected]

Common Questions Asked About FRPI

SP9000 and SP9100 Tank Inspection and Certification

Thank you for listening…

Thoughts?