Commercial Real Estate Outlook IRR-Viewpoint 2010
Commercial Real Estate OutlookIRR-Viewpoint 2010
Commercial Real Estate OutlookIRR-Viewpoint 2010
IndustrialThe Best, The Worst and The Local MarketIndustrialThe Best, The Worst and The Local Market
Top Three Markets By Vacancy…1. Los Angeles, CA – 4.92%2. Orange County, CA – 6.58%3. Seattle, WA – 6.70%
Local Market…50. Charlotte, NC – 14.26% (3Q 2009);14.70% (1Q 2010-NA)
…and the Bottom Three Markets54. Austin, TX – 18.40%55. Boston, MA – 24.76%56. Louisville, KY – 26.01%
Industrial Market PricingIndustrial Market PricingMoodys/REAL Commercial Property Price Index - Industrial
1.0
1.3
1.5
1.8
2.0
Q4
'00
Q2
'01
Q4
'01
Q2
'02
Q4
'02
Q2
'03
Q4
'03
Q2
'04
Q4
'04
Q2
'05
Q4
'05
Q2
'06
Q4
'06
Q2
'07
Q4
'07
Q2
'08
Q4
'08
Q2
'09
Ind
ex
Industrial – Overall Capitalization RatesIndustrial – Overall Capitalization Rates
Institutional NoninstitutionalNational Flex
7.50 %-12.0%
9.38% - Average
100-400 basis points
250 or 11.88% - Average
National Warehouse
7.00%-12.0%
8.60% - Average
100-300 basis points
225 or 10.85 % -Average
Korpacz – Second Quarter 2010 –Investor Survey
• Realty Rates.com – Second Quarter 2010- Investor Survey
Industrial - 9.59%
ApartmentThe Best, The Worst and The Local MarketApartmentThe Best, The Worst and The Local Market
Top Three Markets By Vacancy…1. San Francisco, CA – 3.59%2. Syracuse – 3.94%3. New York City – 4.80%
Local Market…49. Charlotte – 11.64% (3Q–2009);13.6% (1Q 2010)
…and the Bottom Three Markets54. Phoenix – 12.97%55. Naples/Ft. Myers – 13.37%56. Providence – 14.11%
Apartment Market PricingApartment Market Pricing
Moodys/REAL Commercial Property Price Index - Apartments
1.0
1.3
1.5
1.8
2.0
Q4
'00
Q2
'01
Q4
'01
Q2
'02
Q4
'02
Q2
'03
Q4
'03
Q2
'04
Q4
'04
Q2
'05
Q4
'05
Q2
'06
Q4
'06
Q2
'07
Q4
'07
Q2
'08
Q4
'08
Q2
'09
Ind
ex
Apartment – Overall Capitalization RatesApartment – Overall Capitalization Rates
Institutional NoninstitutionalNational Apartment
5.00 %-11.00%
7.68% - Average
0-400 basis points
161 or 9.29% - Average
Korpacz – Second Quarter 2010 –Investor Survey
• Realty Rates.com – Second Quarter 2010- Investor Survey
Retail – 9.50% Average
Office Market CycleOffice Market Cycle
Office – CBD The Best, The Worst and The Local MarketOffice – CBD The Best, The Worst and The Local Market
Top Three Markets By Vacancy…1. Charlotte, NC – 6.43%2. Boise, ID – 8.10%3. Memphis, TN – 8.70%
Local Market…1. Charlotte, NC – 6.43% (3Q–2009); 12.0% (1Q-2010)
…and the Bottom Three Markets54. San Jose, CA – 23.90%55. Detroit, MI – 25.00%56. Dayton, OH – 26.00%
Office – Suburban The Best, The Worst and The Local MarketOffice – Suburban The Best, The Worst and The Local Market
Top Three Markets By Vacancy…1. Dayton, OH – 10.88%2. Pittsburgh, PA – 11.09%3. Los Angeles, CA – 11.30%
Local Market…41. Charlotte, NC – 19.07% (3Q–2009);19.77% (1Q–2010)
…and the Bottom Three Markets54. Detroit, MI – 23.89%55. Phoenix, AZ – 27.41%56. Hartford, CT – 29.45%
Office Market PricingOffice Market PricingMoodys/REAL Commercial Property Price Index - Office
1.0
1.3
1.5
1.8
2.0
Q4
'00
Q2
'01
Q4
'01
Q2
'02
Q4
'02
Q2
'03
Q4
'03
Q2
'04
Q4
'04
Q2
'05
Q4
'05
Q2
'06
Q4
'06
Q2
'07
Q4
'07
Q2
'08
Q4
'08
Q2
'09
Ind
ex
Office – Overall Capitalization RatesOffice – Overall Capitalization Rates
Institutional NoninstitutionalNational CBD
6.00 %-10.50%
8.15% - Average N/A
Suburban
6.00%-12.00%
8.60% - Average
25-300 basis points
141 or 10.01 % -Average
Korpacz – Second Quarter 2010 –Investor Survey
• Realty Rates.com – Second Quarter 2010- Investor Survey
Office – 9.48% Average
Retail Market CycleRetail Market Cycle
RetailThe Best, The Worst and The Local MarketRetailThe Best, The Worst and The Local Market
Top Three Markets By Vacancy…1. San Francisco, CA – 3.08%2. Los Angeles, CA – 4.87%3. San Jose, CA – 5.03%
Local Market…12. Charlotte, NC – 6.77% (3Q–2009); 8.0% (4Q–2009)
…and the Bottom Three Markets54. Providence, RI – 17.00%55. Dayton, OH – 17.30%56. Detroit, MI – 17.35%
Retail Market PricingRetail Market PricingMoodys/REAL Commercial Property Price Index - Retail
1.0
1.3
1.5
1.8
2.0
Q4
'00
Q2
'01
Q4
'01
Q2
'02
Q4
'02
Q2
'03
Q4
'03
Q2
'04
Q4
'04
Q2
'05
Q4
'05
Q2
'06
Q4
'06
Q2
'07
Q4
'07
Q2
'08
Q4
'08
Q2
'09
Ind
ex
Retail – Overall Capitalization RatesRetail – Overall Capitalization Rates
Institutional NoninstitutionalRegional Malls
5.00 %-10.50%
7.93% - Average
25-500 basis points
279 or 10.72% - Average
Power Center
7.50%-10.00%
8.70% - Average N/A
Strip Center
7.00%-11.40%
8.38% - Average
50-1000 basis points
303 or 11.41%- Average
Korpacz – Second Quarter 2010 –Investor Survey
• Realty Rates.com – Second Quarter 2010- Investor Survey
Retail – 9.50% Average
Recent Development in Capitalization RatesRecent Development in Capitalization Rates
Korpacz Survey data for investment grade property and our analysis are presented in the following table:
National Markets4th Q 2007
Value of $1 at 2007 Cap
Rate2nd Q 2010
Value of $1 at 2010 Cap
Rate
Annual Change Cap
Rate(bps)
Annual Change Cap
Rate(%)
Change in Value of $1 from 4th Q
2007 to 2nd Q 2010
Apartment 5.75% $17.39 7.68% $13.02 193 -14.40% -25.13%Regional Mall 6.68% $14.97 7.93% $12.61 125 -10.51% -15.76%Warehouse 6.48% $15.43 8.60% $11.63 212 -13.85% -24.65%CBD Office 6.64% $15.06 8.15% $12.27 151 -10.81% -18.53%Strip Shopping Center 7.24% $13.81 8.38% $11.93 114 -7.64% -13.60%Power Center 7.13% $14.03 8.70% $11.49 157 -8.68% -18.05%Suburban Office 7.20% $13.89 8.60% $11.63 140 -9.48% -16.28%Flex/R&D 7.60% $13.16 9.38% $10.66 178 -9.91% -18.98%Net Lease 7.60% $13.16 8.98% $11.14 138 -7.38% -15.37%Average 6.92% $14.54 8.49% $11.82 156 -10.30% -18.48%
National Markets1st Half
2008
Value of $1 at 2007 Cap
Rate1st Half
2009
Value of $1 at 2010 Cap
RateAnnual
Change (bps)Annual
Change (%)
Change in Value of $1
from 2008 to 2010
Domestic Self Storage 7.55% $13.25 8.45% $11.83 90 -7.12% -10.65%
1
Source: Korpacz
KORPACZ INVESTMENT GRADE
Note: Self storage survey is completed every six months.
CAPITALIZATION RATE DATA
Recent Development in Capitalization RatesRecent Development in Capitalization Rates
Korpacz Survey data for non-investment grade property and our analysis are presented in the following table:
Real Estate Listing Sources – For Sale & For LeaseReal Estate Listing Sources – For Sale & For Lease
• Loopnet http://www.loopnet.com/
• Edis http://www.nccommerce.com/en/BusinessServices/LocateYourBusiness/BuildingsAndSites/(N.C. Department of Commerce Buildings & Sites EDIS)
• Mecklenburg County Real Estate Lookuphttp://meckcama.co.mecklenburg.nc.us/relookup/(Market Analysis Link)
• National & Local Brokerage Firms– Apartment Realty Advisors http://www.arausa.com/Index.cfm– CB Richard Ellis (CBRE) http://www.cbre.com/EN/Pages/default.aspx– Sperry Van Ness http://www.svn.com/– Lincoln Harris CSG http://www.lincolnharris.com/Home/– The Stump Corporation http://www.stumpnet.com/– Marcus & Millichamp http://www.marcusmillichap.com/– NAIGLOBAL http://www.naiglobal.com/
National Real Estate SurveysNational Real Estate Surveys
• IRR.com (Viewpoint – Real Estate Value Trends)
• Marcus & Millchap.com
• NAIGLOBAL
• www.pwc.com (Korpacz Real Estate Investor Survey)
• ACLI (American Council of Life Insurers)
• Realty Rates.com (Developer Surveys, Financial Indicators, Market Surveys, Investor Surveys)
Vacancy and Rental Rate Surveys - SUBSCRIPTIONVacancy and Rental Rate Surveys - SUBSCRIPTION
• Karnes (Office, Retail and Industrial)
• Real Data (Apartments)
• REIS
Real Estate Sales - SUBSCRIPTIONReal Estate Sales - SUBSCRIPTION
• Costar
• REIS
• Real Capital Analytics http://www.rcanalytics.com/
Integra Realty ResourcesNation’s Largest Valuation
and Counseling Firm
Integra Realty ResourcesNation’s Largest Valuation
and Counseling Firm
• 59 Offices in 33 states, plus DC and Mexico• Over 800 Consultants & Advisors• 150+ MAIs company-wide