Comments from T-Birds Regarding Proposed Thunderbird-Laureate Joint Venture

Recipient: Larry Penley and Ann Iverson

Letter: Greetings,

As a T-bird, I am deeply concerned about the proposed partnership between

Thunderbird and Laureate Education, Inc. While I recognize and acknowledge the

changing face of graduate education, this proposal is a short-sighted and ill-

advised solution that will cause permanent and irreparable harm to the

Thunderbird brand, ranking, and academic reputation.

For-profit education may have its place, but it certainly does not align with the

goals, culture or mission of Thunderbird. Furthermore, this selling out of the

Thunderbird name will further dilute the brand, and as a result cheapen the value

of the degree.

I call upon Dr. Larry Penley and the Thunderbird Board of Trustees to immediately

suspend the proposed partnership. Thunderbird’s Global Alumni and student

network, at the absolute core of the “Thunderbird Mystique” MUST have a voice in

this matter.

While past administrations have focused on “Thunderbird for Good,” now is the

time for us turn our attention to what is good for Thunderbird.

Comments

Name Location Date Comment

Aaron Ohms Denver, CO 2013-03-29 Because I want to maintain the standard of excellence set forth by the

Thunderbird brand

Richard Koehler Visby, Sweden 2013-03-29 For the future of Thunderbird, the alumni and current students.

Abhinav Kant Westland, MI 2013-03-29 I am a Thunderbird Alum. I am concerened about the brand dilution of the

School name.

Juan Carlos Hussong Oslo, Norway, Norway 2013-03-29 The future reputation of Thunderbird is at stake! Please rethink this decision.

Matt G. AZ 2013-03-29 I highly value the brand that is Thunderbird. We need to preserve our brand

similar to likes of a Harvard or Stanford. While we may not have the same

funds as these schools, we have a Global Network that is in a class all by itself.

Patty Vukanovich San Francisco, CA 2013-03-29 For the sake of Thunderbird's and its alumni's ongoing success

Jeremy Snyder Glendale, AZ 2013-03-29 I am a concerned alumni.

Daniel Gaines Washington, DC 2013-03-29 I love Thunderbird. I love the Thunderbird brand. The Thunderbird brand is part

of MY brand. To be candid, I think this move cheapens the school's brand and

takes away from our prestige. I strongly urge you to suspend the proposed

partnership.

Massoud Marzban Rockville, MD 2013-03-30 Not keen on the watered down of the worth of my degree to be linked with an

online education system

Kush Brahmavar Lima, Peru 2013-03-30 The Thunderbird brand is doomed for dilution with the Laureate partnership.

Please reconsider and abandon this venture.

Nirvana Law Earth, NY 2013-03-31 <a href="http://www.change.org/petitions/do-your-part-in-helping-god-to-

establish-the-kingdom-of-heaven-on-earth"

rel="nofollow">http://www.change.org/petitions/do-your-part-in-helping-god-to-

establish-the-kingdom-of-heaven-on-earth</a>

Evgeny Romakin Middletown, CT 2013-03-31 Partnership or even assosiating Thunderbird name with mass degree producer,

Laureat, will force potential Thunderbird students seeking a real MBA to look at

other schools. Yet, it is not fair in relation to Thunderbird alumni.

Lawrence (Larry) Schulz Germany 2013-03-31 The Thunderbird brand is important. Additionally I mistrust the "for-profit"

education processes as they too often skimp on education to optimize the

benefits for their shareholders.

Charles Clausen Fot Wayne, IN 2013-03-31 This will dilute the Thunderbird brand & mystic!

Jaclynn Fimrite Calgary, Alberta, Canada 2013-03-31 To protect the long term value of the Thunderbird Brand.

Arnal Chandra Tustin, CA 2013-04-01 Value of my MBA, and Thunderbird's future.

Toshiaki HANAOKA Japan 2013-04-01 I am go with this petition.

John Young Phoenix, AZ 2013-04-01 Dilution of the brand. Extremism from the new administration that does not

understand Tbird.

Ankit Dhawan India 2013-04-01 To avoid Brand Dilution and maintain the value of my Degree

Carlos Quinonez San Salvador, El

Salvador

2013-04-01 This agreement threatens to bring the Thunderbird name to the level of "fast

food" education (xxx being served... Available around your neighborhood

corner...)

Eduardo Lepori Santiago, Chile, Chile 2013-04-02 Dilution of the brand, confusion with a low reputation standard of Laureate.

Yuheng Fei Shanghai, China 2013-04-02 To help my school stay at the top

Catherine STONE Lexington, MA 2013-04-02 Concerned as a Thunderbird Alumni


Renato Reategui São Paulo, Brazil 2013-04-02 Because it will dilute the value of my degree.

Yvette Morrill Walpole, MA 2013-04-02 To maintain its reputation and the quality of the education it offers, I think it's

important for Thunderbird to remain independent and not align itself with for-

profit educational institutions.

Steven Pantier Australia 2013-04-02 This looks like a great thing for Laureate, but I don't see the benefit for

Thunderbird or it's Alumni.

Stanislaus Haribowo Singapore, Singapore 2013-04-02 I am not convinced on how the proposed partnership will improve the way the

school is currently managed.

Kunal Gupta Singapore, Singapore 2013-04-02 Thunderbird should maintain it's niche in providing global management

education rather than focussing on revenues from other courses in the non-

focussed segment that might attenuate school's image in the global arena.

Berton Lerner Middleboro, MA 2013-04-02 As a longtime alumnus, I cherish and relish the established tradition that

"Thunderbird" has achieved and enduring over these many years.

Ruth Nagle Newton, MA 2013-04-02 This degrades the school's reputation.

Samarth Sangal India 2013-04-02 Thunderbird going the commercial way will further dilute the image of the

school. Not a match made in heaven type of deal. Thunderbird should

concentrate on improving the placement records, quality of student intake and

alumni networking rather than going after the money.

William Hughes Rolle, Switzerland 2013-04-02 This will dilute the Thunderbird brand further. Thunderbird education helps

guide some of the largest companies in the world. Use some of the knowledge

that the school is imparting to its students to do something creative to expand

the brand.

Hans Eric Destrée Hilversum, Netherlands 2013-04-02 Don't dilute the brand!

Joy Nakfoor Knoxville, TN 2013-04-02 I feel this is a bad move for Thunderbird and will lessen the image of the school

that many already consider to be an online degree.

Joe Lynch Brockton, MA 2013-04-02 I feel that this alliance will harm the prestige of the Thunderbird Degree.

Beth Burlingame Providence, RI 2013-04-02 There has to be a better option than this.

George Pool Houston, United States 2013-04-02 I am a Thunderbird Alum, and very concerned about this proposed partnership

that may greatly reduce the image, standing and all around greatness of

Thunderbird.

Lisa Griffith Cambridge, MA 2013-04-02 There has to be a better way to get a 'cash infusion' than to resort to a

partnership that will cheapen the brand image of T-bird. T-bird produces

amazing entrepreneurs and managers - why not turn to us to find a better

solution?

David Macaulay Nantuclet, MA 2013-04-02 'For Profit' graduate education by nature diminshes what is invested in the

institution in favor of the shareholders. Affiliating TBird with it will diminish the

brand. This looks like a short term strategy which I believe Drs. Cabrera,

Herberger and my President, Voris would never abide.

David Macaulay Nantuclet, MA 2013-04-02 Thunderbird changed my life

Barbara Langston Lexington, MA 2013-04-02 Must protect Thunderbird and alumni brand

Erika Hogele Stovall Morristown, TN 2013-04-02 I don't believe this is the direction Thunderbird should take.

N. Raymond Hays Tucson, AZ 2013-04-02 I do not feel that a partnership with for-profit education aligns with

Thunderbird's culture or goals.

Jalal Mitri Phoenix, AZ 2013-04-02 Past present and future. Respect tradition.


Eric Denniston Mayer, AZ 2013-04-02 I am a founding board member of the Thunderbird Alumni Association and

served as a chapter leader for 30 years. The culture of the school, its alumni,

staff and stakeholders must be a top priority in considering any move like this. I

accept that the culture will change and adjust, but the move to partner with a

for-profit institution has the potential to produce some serious undesirable

consequences. On the surface this looks like an "easy fix" to a deeper systemic

issue.

keith johnson los angeles, CA 2013-04-02 I am very disappointed that Thunderbird is considering this proposition. A for-

profit school will definitely cheapen the value of a degree there.

Kristen van Houten Washington, DC 2013-04-02 Please do not degenerate the brand name of Thunderbird with the Laureate

partnership. Thunderbird will become equated solely with a cheap, low quality

online education and become synonymous with the University of Phoenix and

Strayer University.

Bill Bindseil Encintas, CA 2013-04-02 This arrangement between Thunderbird and Laureate does Education does not

bring any substantial value to the global recognition, brand and academic

reputation of Thunderbird. Thunderbird was built on 60 years

of excellence in higher education and the tens of thousands of students that

have contributed to the legacy. Please rethink the partnership in context with

the bigger vision and values of Thunderbird.

Nancy Trevino Tustin, CA 2013-04-02 My father was a1948 graduate, a Jonas Meyer award recipient. My brother

and I both followed in his footsteps. With the proliferation of on line and for

profit universities it seems very tempting. But why would you want to do this if

we are already number one? Whatever happened to preserving the

Thunderbird mystique? I have heard of one ideal student not getting accepted,

who will choose the future candidates how many students will graduate each

year? We already have campus' elsewhere... Do we really need more?

John Lindblom Singapore 2013-04-02 Have full appreciation for the importance that degree holds in its networking

value, have spent my entire career working and living overseas.

Julie Hamlin Sturgeon Bay, WI 2013-04-03 While other organizations and institutions are spending millions on brand

revitalization efforts, Thunderbird risks diminishing the value of its own brand

overnight -- and without a penny spent. Mr. Penley, please be very, very

careful. This might be one misstep too many.

Joseph Yin Franklin Park, NJ 2013-04-03 The tradition, integrity, and reputation of the school/program is at stake.

Claire Romera Minneapolis, MN 2013-04-03 My husband and I both have Thunderbird degrees. We have seen first-hand

the value (or lack thereof) the Thunderbird degree has among employers in this

economy. I strongly believe that this would be one step too far.

Vibhor Gupta new york, NY 2013-04-03 This partnership just dilutes the thunderbird brand. How many of the top 50

schools do this? My guess is 0.

Antonio romera sevilla, Spain 2013-04-03 I believe this partnership will dilute the brand and we will lose the reputation of

the school. Can you name one top-ranked business school that has a for-profit

partnership like this one?

Alla Kamins Rangoon, Singapore 2013-04-03 Since my graduation in 2000 it has been frustrating to see the school's inability

to define a long-term strategy that would not strengthen its brand. This

partnership will further weaken it.

Tracy K. Hastings Belfast, ME 2013-04-03 I am one of the very early grads still alive (AIFT 1948) and I think the Laureate

idea is a

huge mistake. Despite claims of "independence" we'll be perceived as just

another for-profit issuing "mail-order degrees."

Tiffany Pogue Walnut Creek, CA 2013-04-03 Making the institution a for profit entity will dilute the brand and the value of the

thunderbird degree by employers.


Kristin Stone York, PA 2013-04-03 Please, please don't do this! What are you thinking? For one thing, you'll anger

your alumni and lose donors. Don't do it!

Benjamin Auslander Farmington Hills, MI 2013-04-03 This partnership is NOT in our best interest

THULASI DEVADAS Alexandria, VA 2013-04-03 I disagree with the partnership as it would dilute the brand. Please don't find

easy money by hurting long term prospects of the prestigious institution

Pradnesh Kulkarni Fremont, CA 2013-04-03 Partnering with Laureate will result in dilution and will further dim the

recruitment and growth chances of current students and alumni alike. I

denounce this partnership

Rishab Jain India 2013-04-03 This would definitely hurt the mystique of the brand Thunderbird.

Ajay Vaddi Glendale, AZ 2013-04-03 This proposed move would definitely hurt the mystique of the brand

Thunderbird.

Daniel Hunkeler Solothurn, Switzerland 2013-04-03 I am a Thunderbird, not a laureate. Laureate manages 3 schools in

Switzerland, that it claims to be top institutions, when really they are at the

bottom of the scale of educational quality. We cannot let that happen to

Thunderbird.

Gary Napadov Glendale, AZ 2013-04-03 An excerpt from the letter I wrote to President Penley last week:

With this letter, I urge you to take a very serious look at the outcry from the

Thunderbird students, alumni, and broader community and consider, very

carefully, all of the concerns and possible ramifications of this deal going

forward. Now there's no need to tell us again that the partnership is not a

merger or acquisition, and that our name won't change, or make any further

mention of the 501c3 status. We get it. What I urge you to consider is that why,

in all of actions and communications, there's no mention of second thought or

concern over the Joint Venture being very much a For Profit Education entity? I

know we touched on this during the Town Hall, but I, and many of my fellow

students, were not pleased with the answer. The recent Senate Committee

Report on For-Profit Colleges makes little exception in saying that such For

Profit institutions are infamous for:

"Exorbitant tuition, aggressive recruiting practices, abysmal student outcomes,

taxpayer dollars spent on marketing and pocketed as profit, and regulatory

evasion and manipulation... These practices are not the exception — they are

the norm. They are systemic throughout the industry, with very few individual

exceptions.”

Now I do acknowledge that the gentlemen from Laureate said they were one of

those "very few individual exceptions", but I have yet to find any record of that.

And if that was the case, why not shine more light on it? The fact of the matter

is that we live in a world of public opinion, and at this juncture the public view of

"For Profit Education" is VERY poor. The forthcoming JV will bare the name

"Thunderbird" and thus, in the public eye, Thunderbird will drop to the ranks of

University of Phoenix and Grand Canyon University. And while it's important to

continuously note that Thunderbird will remain an "independent, private, non-

profit (501c3) organization", the JV will undoubtedly get the bulk of exposure,

and thus all of Thunderbird entity will be viewed as yet another For Profit

Education entity. This is especially the case as all academic programs,

including those in the JV entity, will be under the academic control of

Thunderbird faculty, administrators and the board of trustees.

Stephanie Benson Glendale, AZ 2013-04-03 I strongly believe for-profit methods are anathema to what education is all

about. I understand that Thunderbird struggles with name recognition, but this

will only worsen matters.


Eric Roux Coppet, Switzerland 2013-04-03 Education and maximising profitability do not mix. This will ultimately lead to

dilution of the brand and positioning of Thunderbird. Focus on the core and

stick to the basics: retain and promote Thunderbird's position as the leader in

an International Business Education. Improve the placement results from 58%.

That is two core strategic topics that require full time attention.

Lawrence Masle Amsterdam, Netherlands 2013-04-03 There may be a place for this sort of partnership within Executive Eduction, but

it does not seem to align with Thunderbird's core degree programs. A broader

reassessment should be considered. Thank you and good luck!

Landa LaMotta Scarsdale, NY 2013-04-03 Top tier b schools do NOT pursue these types of online endeavors, which do

more to devalue the degree than to elevate online education.

We are a niche brand in a growing segment. I would rather see online

expansion of courses geared toward continued education--specific coursework

designed for alumni to keep their degree relevant in a rapidly changing

environment.

T-bird doesn't need Laureate, U of Phx or any other online "expert" education.

This is a bad idea that has already gone too far!

Ruben Romero Acton, CA 2013-04-03 I'm an alumni

Jake Snyder San Leandro, CA 2013-04-03 I'll be sending back my diploma as it will soon be even more worthless. Thanks

for nothing T-bird

Anna Maria Fosteras Inverness, IL 2013-04-03 The Thunderbird brand is valuable to me as an alumna of the school and

should remain so for all future alumni. I chose to go to thunderbird over other

very good business schools & I want to protect its reputation.

Jessica Hynes London, United Kingdom 2013-04-03 In London we are part of the US X-MBA community - Harvard, Wharton,

Cornell. This will make us a part of the on-line hospitality club. It's hard

enough explaining what Thunderbird is. This does not help at all.

Eugenia Brooks Walkington, United

Kingdom

2013-04-03 I see no long term value for Thunderbird with this and would suspect that Col

Yount would be wholeheartedly opposed to the denegration of the brand that

this association will bring. Really BOD??? What are you thinking? Feels like

desperation rather than a well thought out strategy on how to develop the

school and the brand.

Lawrence Smith Australia 2013-04-03 On line education is not well regarded internationally

Joseph Kazacos Reston, VA 2013-04-03 Associating the Thunderbird name with for-profit education will harm the validity

of the Thunderbird degree, for both current students and all alumni.

Furthermore, it will diminish the perceived value of all faculty, speakers, and

stakeholders who have contributed expertise and/or resources to Thunderbird.

Ana Iglesias Somerville, MA 2013-04-03 Because I do not want my Thunderbird degree to be worth nothing and

compared to a cheap online MBA school.

Christiane Krauss Germany 2013-04-03 the partnership would dilute the value of my degree

Jacqueline Torres Flushing, NY 2013-04-03 Living in the Northeast US where some of the finest institutions in the country

can be found, I've had to explain and defend the Thunderbird name on

numerous occasions. I've constantly had to explain that we had NO affilation

with for-profit online degree mills. To hear that Thunderbird is making the move

to dilute the brand and make a mockery of the investment I've made is

incredibly disheartening. Thunderbird, do NOT go through with this

partnership!

wake margo dallas, TX 2013-04-03 Does not seem like the right match


Randy Hertog Lee, NH 2013-04-03 Thunderbird has a tremendous history of providing an outstanding International

educational experience that appears will be highly compromised by the joint

venture with Laureate. Understanding the current financial challenges

Thunderbird is facing are of grave concern but it does appear, at least on the

surface, this is somewhat of a knee jerk reaction to provide a short term

solution that will unfortunately have dire consequences to the long term

reputation and viability of Thunderbirds educational experience, International

ranking and overall credibility.

Oscar Neiras Spain 2013-04-03 I am a T-Bird alumn, and as a former Full-time student see this partnership as

selling the brand with very little regard to the quality of the education,

something that already started with the on-line programs. Nothing can replace

a good on-site, face-to-face experience, and this only furthers this degradation

of the educational experience.

Rod South Idaho Falls, ID 2013-04-03 I value the education I received from Thunderbird. However, I fear that joining

with Laureate will weaken the reputation and brand Thunderbird has worked so

hard to build.

Leigh Taylor Castle Rock, CO 2013-04-03 The partnership with Laureate Education will only serve to do away with the

Thunderbird mystique by diluting the brand.

Matthew Venezia Groveland, MA 2013-04-03 One of the main benefits from attending the (brick and mortar)Thunderbird is

the interrelationships with student from all over the world. This would be lost.

Meredith McKenna Mercer Island, WA 2013-04-03 My degree was too expensive to be cheapened in t his way.

Santiago Mejia North bay village, FL 2013-04-03 We do not want to turn out to be another University of Phoenix

Lawrrence Giessinger Bangkok, Thailand,

Thailand

2013-04-03 Dear Sirs: I do realize the potential value of online education and the impact it

will have in the future. However, TBird loses it's unique approach to the

international business community through this initiative. If we believe that

Laureate can devise online programs that would benefit TBird, then let's

contract them to formulate an online program that TBird can buy and offer in its

own name.

Sincerely, LarryG

Jennifer Galek Austin, TX 2013-04-03 It has a direct impact on the value of my Thunderbird degree.

Barry Miller Chicago, IL 2013-04-03 I spent 100k plus on a premium education and its value is dropping daily. I

can't see the value of my degree drop any further

Saloni Patil Chicago, IL 2013-04-03 Thunderbird's rankings are already slipping. This will further dilute the brand.

Gerhard Hachmann Buenos Aires, Germany 2013-04-03 Defending the Brand is the most important issue for a niche player like

Thunderbird. Walden has absolutely nothing to bring to the table except a

badly run online education system. If Thunderbird feels like they need to

modernize their program its not with a partner who clearly doesn't understand

the business.

Jeri Denniston Mayer, AZ 2013-04-03 I have not seen an instance where a for profit educational institution has

equaled or out-performed the quality of education that non profit institutions

provide. This will hurt rather than help Thunderbird.

Dawn Novak Redmond, WA 2013-04-03 Keep Thunderbird strong!

Benjamin Berger Quito, Ecuador, Ecuador 2013-04-03 I´m a Thunderbird graduate, and agree that this action will deeply hurt the

value of the Thunderbird brand.

Swati Jain Brooklyn, NY 2013-04-03 Dilutes Thunderbird

Hillary VanderBand Falls Church, VA 2013-04-03 Proposed change will significantly devalue my degree and investment in my

Thunderbird MBA. Plus, I think that there are better non-profit, more highly

ranked institutions out there for Thunderbird to partner with, if that HAS to be

done...


Duncan Blount Miami, FL 2013-04-03 The primary reason I'm against this partnership is the fact that it cheapens the

Thunderbird brand...potentially to the level that would dissuade future interest

by prospective students and discourage involvement and donations by current

alumni - myself included.

Bharath Arvind Mumbai, India 2013-04-03 This is our alma mater and we care deeply about the brand!

Rafael Valadez San Pedro Gza Gcia,

Mexico

2013-04-03 With that partnership is clear in time will change the focus and objective of

Thunderbird. There are changing for money the real spirit.

Robert Richter Panama, Panama 2013-04-03 This is important to me because I would like the board and the Thunderbird

community to take a collaborative critical look at the pros and cons of this

partnership. I want to ensure that future generations of Thunderbirds continue

to be a better and better quality, constantly improving the caliber, not stepping

back. This may be a good move, I do not know, but I am signing this petition to

halt the process while it can be acutely reviewed by the Thunderbird

community.

Brent Crenshaw Dallas, TX 2013-04-03 When I tell people I got my MBA from Thunderbird, I would like that to have

meaning and not drawing comparisons to University of Phoenix.

Susan Marris London, United Kingdom 2013-04-03 As a proud (until now at least) Thunderbird alum, I am very concerned that this

association will tarnish the image of the school.

Eli Mercer Austin, TX 2013-04-03 Dear Thunderbird Management,

I am utterly disappointed that I, along with all Thunderbird alumni, was not

informed in advance of these plans and included in the dialogue prior to action

being taken. This is one of the first lessons we learn at Thunderbird in cross-

cultural communications, that a constructive and inclusive dialogue is

necessary to gain buy-in and support in a multicultural environment. It appears

the decision makers involved may not be graduates of our university, or

perhaps this was overlooked in a rush to get a deal done. This is the second

lesson we learn as Thunderbirds, that it takes time and patience to put together

a good deal, especially across cultures. I therefore suggest that we slow down

the process and take our own core philosophy into account.

It is not too late for this to take place. I encourage the new administration to

place partnership plans on hold, and to make a concerted effort to reach out to

alumni in order to make sure this move is in keeping with our mission and

goals. As Thunderbird graduates, we are the torch bearers and therefore the

ultimate authority regarding our brand and our community.

If the partnership proves to be a good one, it will only be strengthened by the

dialogue and scrutiny. If it is not, this pause could save us from a big mistake.

If the institution is in such dire straits that short-term cash is needed, then be

transparent and open up the books and your financial needs to the alumni, I'm

confident that we can find a short-term solution in order for us to allow time to

make solid long-term decision regarding this or other possible partnerships.

Sincerely,

Eli D. Mercer

+1) 972-896-3780

Galit Smocha Arlington, VA 2013-04-03 This will make Thunderbird like every other Bschool, all about the money.

Thunderbird is all about being Global and DO GOOD! We wrote the Oath - It is

not consistent with what Thunderbird stands for.


Marina Pappone São Paulo, Brazil 2013-04-03 Because it is not aligned to Tbird values and will deeply damage the TBird

brand

Harshit Shah India 2013-04-03 As a recent alum, Thunderbird memories are very fresh in my mind. I am aware

that the brand was already at a low and the Laureate partnership does not help

it in any way.

Daniel Kryzanowski Austin, TX 2013-04-03 Brand Dilution and Lack of Transparency

Shelley Pursell Bogota, Colombia 2013-04-03 I chose to attend Thunderbird because of its high reputation, quality program

and curriculum, and network. I am scared that the partnership with a for-profit

program will dilute the brand and the school's integrity. Please reconsider.

Tiffany Benson Austin, TX 2013-04-03 This feels rushed, potentially harmful to our school and community, brand and

prestige, and a sign that our new administration is disconnected from the spirit

and the will of our alumni.

Ermelinda Kraft Paradise Valley, AZ 2013-04-03 I was disappointed to read about the Thunderbird-Laureate partnership. I

strongly believe that a partnership with a proprietary institution such as

Laureate will definitely dilute the Thunderbird brand.

Kayla Wu Taipei, Taiwan 2013-04-03 I support Thunderbird as our own brand as being proud of a Tbird'

Dan Baird Salt Lake City, UT 2013-04-03 As an alumni I worry about damaging the brand. Somethings don't mix well

with profit. I want education to be first and foremost the most important goal of

the school

nate comly washington, DC 2013-04-03 alumni

ALAN SAURAN Australia 2013-04-03 ALTHOUGH I AM NOW RETIRED, IT IS VERY DISAPPOINTING TO SEE MY

SCHOOL MAKE A HUGE BRANDING ERROR WHILE TEACHING ITS OWN

MARKETING 101 STUDENTS THE OPPOSITE.

Rodrigo Diaz Brown Mexico 2013-04-03 Protect the Thunderbird brand as is and solidify the future rankings and

reputation.

Fernando Alandia Elmhurst, IL 2013-04-03 Disappointing that these sorts of strategic decisions appear to lack the

appreciation of the deep history of what truly separated Thunderbird’s name

and program. In recent years it appears that the school has accepted a need

to compete within the constraints/drivers of other MBA programs rather than to

embrace and promote our difference. Thunderbird has always been and should

continue to represent an unique difference in experience and graduate. This is

our value, our selling point, our niche. To acknowledge and compete on the

same level with other programs - some of which claim to have international

programs - suggests that Thunderbird believes these schools are closing the

gap to us or on the same level. Simply said - they are not. I take pride in what

Tbirds achieve and am witness to the difference we make globally. While other

programs may produce industry leaders in other core areas, no one produces

global leaders like Thunderbird. Let's celebrate and protect that, act like we

believe in our difference, and truly challenge other programs to demonstrate

their competitiveness. Our value is measured in quality of graduates - not

number of graduates.

Trina Karstrom Australia 2013-04-03 for profit partnership is not an option, still face to face in school time is the most

important. I was an 1980 graduate, now my children may consider this school,

not an option if they go ahead with this partnership.

Rommel Mayer

Rodriguez

Santiago de Querétaro,

Mexico

2013-04-03 Because I'm a T-bird by heart and don't want to see it fail and become

something that does not represent the alumni!

Jason McLeod Taylor, MI 2013-04-03 I simply echo the sentiment of my fellow alumni that this can only cheapen the

Thunderbird brand. Management should focus on improving the rankings, not

partnering with institutions that will never appear on any.


claudia barbabosa Mexico city, Mexico 2013-04-03 Because I wish to return to study in Thunderbird.

David Mitchel Dallas, TX 2013-04-03 I have not seen Ivy League or other top level private schools pursuing this type

of arrangement.

debo adebayo glendale, AZ 2013-04-03 chnage in brand and negative perception

Keith Meyer Australia 2013-04-03 As a 1992 graduate of Thunderbird and an alumni living overseas, my degree

has been invaluable to my career. If the name is diluted, it would be

detrimental to all of our careers going forward. Diluting the strong alumni

network would be a negative as well, one thing that has been very supportive

to my living in many different places.

Steven Schultz Schenectady, NY 2013-04-03 I fully agree to the letter and content.

Juan Rodriguez Mexico 2013-04-03 Thunderbird students are recognized in the world as the top ranked bussiness

school. I really believe that a partnership is not help our prestige as former

students and comunity.

Cameron Cavette Beverly Hills, CA 2013-04-03 As a Thunderbird Alumni, I value the current Thunderbird reputation and am

dissapointed to see its dilution with a short-term perspective of parternering

with a for-profit educator.

Daniela Monroy México df, Mexico 2013-04-03 As far as I know, Laureate Education Inc is absolutely not good at education, all

they care is about money and the institutions they have in my country are some

of the worst at education. Therefore, I would be extremely disappointed if

Thunderbird were to join this institution. I believe and hope that we are not at

the same level as Laureate if this is so then i would revaluate wether to write

down Thunderbird on my CV or not!

Margaret McNiel El Paso, TX 2013-04-03 It is important that the Thunderbird education remain the "Tiffany" of

international business degrees and not "partner" with a "Walmart" of mass

degree distribution.

Margaret McNiel El Paso, TX 2013-04-03 This downgrades the Thunderbird degree. It would be like taking Tiffany jewels

and mass distributing them through Walmart. Tiffany would never allow it and

neither should Thunderbird.

Peggy McNiel-Thunderbird Alumnus

Iván Vila Echagüe Santiago, Chile 2013-04-04 I agree that this partnership will be the worst thing to do for the Schools name

and reputation

Julian Aguilar Santiago, Chile 2013-04-04 Laurete is very well known in Chile for manage third tier universities. It will be

disapointing that T-Bird continue with this Partnership.

Ted Ketterer Atlanta, GA 2013-04-04 I agree that Thunderbird like any brand must innovate. I am a brand manager

for the world's #1 valued brand, Coca-Cola. We deal with the same challenge.

That said, strategic moves and partnerships must create long term "sustainable

value". The fair question that everyone is asking is will this?

MARIO BECERRIL México City, Mexico 2013-04-04 I am proud to be a T-bird and I also studied in a Laureate Education, Inc.

school, and believe me when I say is a huge difference about values, quality,

etc., they are good, but Thunderbird is hundred times better, stop this process.

ALLAN ACOSTA Glendale, AZ 2013-04-04 Potential long-term depreciation of the value of my degree. Thunderbird-

Laurete is not what I signed in for when enrolled in the Executive Program.

Pablo Herdener Santiago, Chile, Chile 2013-04-04 Such proposed partnership would make weaker the already fragile brand

image and turn Thunderbird into a "commodity" MBA. I strong believe that the

school should turn into exactly the opposite direction.

Jose Sanzana Santiago, Chile 2013-04-04 Thunderbird is a great school and It can't compromise its good name

Nitin Kaushal Scottsdale, AZ 2013-04-04 have invested in t-bird brand and it needs to be preserved at all costs


Cornelis Everaert Hong Kong, Hong Kong 2013-04-04 Thunderbird aligning with Laureate is the same as Bank of America buying

Countrywide just before sub-prime broke. Countrywide was the winner, and so

is Laureate. Don't do it.

nathan weber old mill creek, IL 2013-04-04 because it matters...

Mike Cordaro Prairie Village, KS 2013-04-04 While at Thunderbird I learned about brand equity, what it means to build it,

and what it means to lose it. I am afraid that this will greatly weaken

Thunderbird's standing in the eyes of employers, prospective student, and

alumni. I look back so fondly on the experiences I had at Thunderbird. I knew

that I could meet an alum at the Pub back for their 20th reunion and know that

we still shared a common bond and perspective. I am afraid that this will not

be the case when I return for my 20th.

Adriana Munoz Mexico 2013-04-04 This is not a wise choice for Thunderbird's future.

Jeffrey Boyd Washington, DC 2013-04-04 brand dilution...

Juan Calfunanco Santiago, Chile 2013-04-04 I think this partnership will dilute Thunderbird brand which is recognized as as

synonymous of values, quality and multicultural mindset.

Kent Deitemeyer Christchurch, New

Zealand

2013-04-04 Dear President Penley,

I am an older T-Bird alumni. For us, the Thunderbird mystic, brand and

program are unique. T-Bird determined my entire business career and destiny.

It is of huge value to us and not something we ever expected to be bartered off

in a partnership with an unknown quantity. Our brand must stand alone and

certainly not married with a 'for profit' private equity-owned diploma mill. Please

do not go down this route. There is no need to 'go big' like this. The risks are

too high for disappointment and potential failure particularly when you sign up

with private equity who are notorious for short-term financial gain with no long-

term vision. Their financial goals will always conflict with ours. Stay totally

independent. For alumni, we must have full control of our core program. I would

rather see Thunderbird expand into a full research institution with a PhD

program offering that will strengthen our academic leadership and status vis-a-

vis the top graduate business schools. We will never move into the top

rankings without a formal PhD and top research program. By the way, I am

both a Colorado State University and Thunderbird alumni and feel very strongly

about the reputation of both of these institutions that both you and I value. I

have lived overseas for 36 years as a T-bird alumni and know the reputation

our school has. I want to see it strengthened but not in this manner. Let us

move in a more progressive direction by strengthening our inner academic and

research core. I only see a rocky road ahead with Laureate Education where

we will lose the control of our own destiny and if things go wrong, our recovery

will be a very long road.

Please seriously reconsider this proposed partnership. I urge you to build our

academic and research quality. As alumni, we want qualitative growth, not

quantitative growth.

Respectfully,

Kent Deitemeyer

Thunderbird, 1976

Colorado State University, BS, 1970

Lincoln University (NZ), MAppSci, 2002

(BTW: I stay closely connected with CSU as Prof Bernie Rollin is one of my

dearest and closest friends with whom I have collaborated in veterinary

ethics).


Ileana Ferber Spring, TX 2013-04-04 Because I'm a T-Bird alumna

Ronald Greene Lakewood, CA 2013-04-04 I am most concerned about brand dilution. The school should first reach out to

alumni agressively to raise cash.

Ravi Kaushik Bangalore, India 2013-04-04 As a Thunderbird I am extremely concerned about the brand of my school and

what it stands for. being from India, I do not know much about the Laureate

brand but from what I am reading, it does seem to be very good and clearly

does not fit with Thunderbird's mission. I understand that Thunderbird is in

serious need of financial support, so it would be a good idea for us to have an

open debate on what options do we have and how can we take our school out

of this situation.

Krishna Chilukuri India 2013-04-04 This partnership will dilute the quality of education at Thunderbird. I have great

respect and really enjoyed the quality of teaching of our professors and I fear

the school will potentially loose them. Who wants to be associated in the same

league as the University of Phoenix!

Bharath Sekar India 2013-04-04 I am a proud Thunderbird. I have seen several "for-profit" universities in India

and the amount of skepticism and flak that they draw. I am not going to let that

happen.

Divy Jaisingh Mumbai, India 2013-04-04 Don't agree with the choice of partner.

Dipak Sundaram India 2013-04-04 I am a proud alumni of Thunderbird. This a third rte partnership and is not ging

to improve the schools brand image and what it stands for.

Anggelos Skutaris Athens, Greece 2013-04-04 Because I want Tbird to remain a top-business school.

Antonio Fernandez Scottsdale, AZ 2013-04-04 As an alumnus, I'd like a vote. We're stakeholders too!

Rrahul Dalmia New York, NY 2013-04-04 The Thunderbird Brand will dilute; it will affect the credibility and reputation of

my MBA degree!!

Anshuman Narain New Delhi, India 2013-04-04 Terrible idea...

Gale A. Kirking Brno, Czech Republic,

Czech Republic

2013-04-04 Since attending Thunderbird, I have been concerned about academic quality,

poor career placement, and sporadic management of the school and its

reputation. I question whether the Laureate Partnership is the way to address

these issues.

Pavel Kriz Praha, Czech Republic 2013-04-04 As an oldtimer ('70), perhaps I stick to the Thunderbird Mystique a bit more

than more recent alumni and students. I think that this partnership can only

dillute it even further. Is an unguaranteed solution of the school's financial

straits a good price for the loss of the reputation and brand weight. The inflation

of cheap online MBA and EMBA degrees is overwhelming. We should not add

Thunderbird degrees to their ranks.

Shoma Mukherji India 2013-04-04 Thunderbird cannot be a mass product - the degree loses its value.

Jessica DuFresne Argentina 2013-04-04 Dilution of the school brand.

Dennis Diokno Budapest, Hungary,

Hungary

2013-04-04 I'm very concerned with the potential dilution of the Thunderbird brand. I know

that the school had other options. It's amazing how Thunderbird can attract

excellent professors and turn out great managers but it can't run itself properly

as a business. Finally the continuous lack of transparency with decisions such

as this is a disgrace.

Glenn Cameron Lima, Peru 2013-04-04 We cannot let T'birds name be diluted with all these online second tier

institutions.

Tory Kinson Knoxville, TN 2013-04-04 I do not want my hard-earned (and costly) MBA degree to be associated with

the Lauerate program.

Maricarmen Cano Houston, TX 2013-04-04 I can not imagine losing the entire investmen of my education because of such

a partnership. It is an embarrasement that this would even be considered.


Henri Kinson Greenfield, IN 2013-04-04 If the Thunderbird can't find even one high-quality institution that Laureate has

partnered with to put in its press release, then there isn't one.

Minh Le Peoria, AZ 2013-04-04 I am totally agree with Benjamin Piper and deeply concern about this

partnership.

Jeanne Savelle Smryna, GA 2013-04-04 This selling out of the Thunderbird name will further dilute the brand, and as a

result cheapen the value of the degree.

Adolfo Blanco Mexico 2013-04-04 Choice of partner.

Joseph O'Dowd New Orleans, LA 2013-04-04 I am certainly not in favor of this type of 'partnership'…especially with a private

equity fund backed enterprise such as Laureate. It is unclear how any such

arrangement will benefit the institution, its students or alumni. My sense is it will

quickly dilute, and perhaps terminally damage, the institution’s reputation and

Thunderbird brand.

Mathew Katz glencoe, IL 2013-04-04 Brand Dilution

Diego Foncerrada Mexico, Mexico 2013-04-04 Thunderbird should be looking for alliances that enhance its reputation and that

elevates the recognition of the graduates instead of join institutions that only

represent wider presence and economical volume.

fayda khalek geneva, Switzerland 2013-04-04 harmful to the brand

Matthew Goff San Jose, CA 2013-04-04 This partnership dilutes what so many people have worked to achieve. Why

kick so many people in the face?

Luis Wu Gilbert, AZ 2013-04-04 As stated exactly on the petition.

Kelly Tiller Glendale, AZ 2013-04-04 I am a current student and do not believe in for-profit education.

Pakornsak

Ratanawongpitak

Glendale, AZ 2013-04-04 A current Student.

Frank Ruffing Arlington, VA 2013-04-05 Turn over the keys to ASU. Ironic the school has so woefully failed to adapt to

the new reality that today all business is global. Trustees should be ashamed.

Mark Perkins Mesa, AZ 2013-04-05 I do not want the Thunderbird brand diluted...

Jason Teague Washington, DC 2013-04-05 I agree that the partnership with Laureate will erode the Thunderbird brand and

irreparably diminish the value of the degree. I strongly urge Mr. Penley and the

board to revisit this issue and find alternative means to ensure Thunderbird's

solvency.

Erich Bentz Wien, Austria 2013-04-05 I did not attend Thunderbid to achieve a "Univ. of Phoenix" graduate diploma.

Dilution of our investment and loyalty in Thunderbird as an experience and

brand is at stake here.

rene jaspers amsterdam, Netherlands 2013-04-05 don't mess with this brand, fix what needs to be fixed.

Bret Collins Irvine, CA 2013-04-05 I believe this merger devalues the Thunderbird brand and my MBA that I

worked so hard for. This action ruins the very spirit that makes Thunderbird

special and what cannot be replicated elsewhere. It is why Thunderbird has

been ranked #1 for so long and why people travel from all the corners of the

world to be a part of this elite network.

Mossé Jean-Paul France 2013-04-05 Daniel Gaines say it all :

quote

I love Thunderbird. I love the Thunderbird brand. The Thunderbird brand is part

of MY brand. To be candid, I think this move cheapens the school's brand and

takes away from our prestige. I strongly urge you to suspend the proposed

partnership.

unquote


Bill Swift Leawood, KS 2013-04-05 The reputation and value of a T-Bird education must not be watered down in

order to play in the online sphere. Sure times are tough and competition is

fierce, but why not partner with one or more major universities who are

developing online curricula? Teaming up with the strip-mall, grade-school

tutoring brand "Sylvan" is a short-sighted and foolish approach for a graduate

business school of global significance. My adult son has expressed interest in

attending Thunderbird, but if this dumb plan goes forward I'll urge him to go

elsewhere. Pedigree matters in graduate education and what a huge

disappointment to hear about this from our own Thunderbird.

tom coler sarasota, FL 2013-04-05 Thunderbird is good for Laureate but Laureate is not good for Thunderbird. Go

to the alumni for direction. We have been there globally..

Margaret Amein Germany 2013-04-05 The education industry is a non-profit sector for a reason. Attempts to make a

profit out of eduction have ended up at the cost of the students, alumni, staff

and professors for the benefit of the very few. Don't be naiive...while private

equity can be great for start-ups, it's about not about destroying and cashing

out rather than creating a moderate, sustainable business.

Maria Botta Marietta, GA 2013-04-05 I invested heavily in my education at Thunderbird and do not want to see my

investment aligned with a less than stellar organization like Laureate. This

move is not consistent withe the Thunderbird brand that I invested my time and

money into.

Luis Pereira Miramar, FL 2013-04-05 I want to keep the quality of the education at Thunderbird at very high

standards. MBA '05

Sol Dworkin Dallas, TX 2013-04-05 I went to Thunderbird for its uniquely practical instruction and opportunity to

learn among a widely diverse population. Personal contact with people and

first-hand experience with different cultures were critical success factors in my

now more than 30 year career. Schools such as University of Phoenix serve a

purpose, but not this purpose. Before AGSIM, Thunderbird loses any more

credibility care should rather be taken to upgrade its academic reputation It is

no longer unique as an institution at which students engage and specialize in

global management studies.

T'bird '82!

Olivier Portet Orinda, CA 2013-04-05 In a t-bird alum and think this will dilute Thunderbird brand name and

reputation.

Justin Espineli Japan 2013-04-06 I have done extensive research on for-profit education as a recent business

school applicant and matriculating T-bird. Currently, the public opinion of for-

profit educational systems is very negative. I believe it is in Thunderbird's best

interest to suspend the proposed partnership with Laureate. The immediate

dilution of the Thunderbird brand will outweigh any capital support

Thunderbird receives. In the long run, this partnership may signal

Thunderbird's decline as top-ranked business school.

Kelly Connors sonoma, CA 2013-04-06 the reupation of Thunderbird


Melville Brown Gabarone, Botswana,

Botswana

2013-04-06 This parnership represents the latest step in the long decline of T-Bird as a

unique educational paradigm. First we lost the wisdom of professors who have

'Been there, Done that' in favor of academic professionals. The emphasis has

shifted 180 degrees away from practical instruction to academic theory which

has proven to be no different than the wrong-headed approach of other

institutions, Over the years we lost the uniqueness of native speakers as

language instructors because they didn't have the academic qualifications

required to meet acreditation requirements. The school has lost its original

mission of preparing US citizens for living and working internationall and has

become a training ground for wealthy foreign students (no one esle can afford

the tuition) who do not add value to the T-Bird reputation when they only return

to their home country--or stay in the US. I fully agree with the statement in the

petition that "this proposal is a short-sighted and ill-advised solution that will

cause permanent and irreparable harm to the Thunderbird brand, ranking, and

academic reputation." As an early gradutate of the Toot (June '69) who was

awarded the Distigusished Alumni Award in 2005 and has lived and worked

internationally for over 40 years (I am currently emplyed by the Government of

Botswana and living in Gaborone--at age 69!) I believe my opinion on this

matter should carry some weight. Sincerely, Mel Brown

Luis Cargiulo Panama, Panama 2013-04-06 I believe that the partnership or merger will have a negative effect on the

Thunderbird Brand and reputation. I am against the merger.

George Bradbury IV Surprise, AZ 2013-04-06 I think the partnership destroys the core principals of Thunderbird and will very

quickly make the degree worth far less than it is today.

Abdias Basto Panamá, Panama 2013-04-06 I'm enrolled in an executive program with Tbird and Tec de Monterrey and I

totally agree with the facts expossed here. I strongly disagree with this

partnership and I'm in favour of the suspension of such joint venture.

Rob Angstadt Chesapeake, VI 2013-04-06 While examining my options of graduate schools, I ran across Laureate

Education, Inc. under the guise of the University of Liverpool. Despite the

University's outstanding reputation and ranking, a quick google search

informed me that the University of Liverpool had very little to do with this

program, and that not even the school's professors were teaching the courses.

I chose Thunderbird because of the quality of education I received and its

global prestige. Without these two things, my MBA is of little value. Please

maintain the integrity of the Thunderbird brand and discontinue this partnership

immediately.

Nick Tillmann Houston, TX 2013-04-06 To protect the integrity of the Thunderbird brand.

Alejandro Esponda-

Berrios

Weston, FL 2013-04-06 I'm very concern with how Thunderbird has been mangaged the last couple of

years, this would be a disaster for the Thunderbird brand.


Leonardo Gonzalez

Lopez

Frisco, TX 2013-04-06 I don't see how partnering with a lower ranking institution elevates the

Thunderbird brand.

I appreciate the hard work of the people who participate creating future growth

paths for Thunderbird and organizing this alternative, and given the

fundamental flaws of this strategy and the potential impact it could have on our

School's reputation, we urge you to reconsider a different road to continue

building a premiere global education institution.

As you can see in this list, you can count with a very diverse group of alumni

who care for the school and are willing to contribute to this process with great

ideas and smart work.

Leonardo Gonzalez

Ahmed Mouti Dubai, United Arab

Emirates

2013-04-06 this selling out of the Thunderbird name will further dilute the brand, and as a

result cheapen the value of the degree.


Michael Goodsite Herning, Denmark 2013-04-06 As a very proud Thunderbird graduate who as since maintained a very close academic

relationship my School, I am joining this petition because I am not at all following the

rationale for the partnership. I strongly encourage the leadership of Thunderbird to have

their communications department reevaluate how and what they have communicated to

the Alumni. What does Laureate get out of this partnership? I am wondering: why would

Laureate expand their portfolio with a partner where it is not clear how they differentiate

from another partner already in their network? The reason that I ask this is that Laureate

has already partnered with the University of Liverpool and even expanded its international

collaboration (see the announcement made in 2007: <a

href="https://news.liv.ac.uk/2007/04/30/university-of-liverpool-and-laureate-announce-

expanded-international-collaboration/"

rel="nofollow">https://news.liv.ac.uk/2007/04/30/university-of-liverpool-and-laureate-

announce-expanded-international-collaboration/</a> ). I am wondering if anyone could

brief what the realised benefits for the U. of Liverpool have been since the above

announcement? What is the gap identified that the UoL is not fulfilling in the Laureate

market and how will Thunderbird fill it? The University of Liverpool has produced (to the

best of my knowledge) eight Nobel Laureates (during the period of 1902 to 1995).

Granted, I find it difficult to directly link these esteemed scholars with an MBA in Global

Management - still the University is arguably a standout amongst the current partners in

the Laureate portfolio ( <a href="http://www.laureate.net/OurNetwork"

rel="nofollow">http://www.laureate.net/OurNetwork</a> ). Examining the online offerings

of the University of Liverpool, I find: <a href="http://www.liv.ac.uk/study/online/index.htm"

rel="nofollow">http://www.liv.ac.uk/study/online/index.htm</a> that they include a MBA

with a specialisation in International Business. So again, what exactly does Laureate hope

to gain? The announcement focusses on what Thunderbird will gain (<a

href="http://www.laureate.net/LGGSite/LGG/OurNetwork/Highlights/2013/03/Thunderbird%

20Plans%20Partnership%20With%20Laureate%20Education%20Inc%20Expands%20Glo

bal%20Presence.aspx)"

rel="nofollow">http://www.laureate.net/LGGSite/LGG/OurNetwork/Highlights/2013/03/Thun

derbird%20Plans%20Partnership%20With%20Laureate%20Education%20Inc%20Expand

s%20Global%20Presence.aspx)</a> but does not explain just how Thunderbird will

differentiate itself from other Laureate online offerings - including those from the very

successful University of Liverpool? In other words, if I were a student in Europe or

elsewhere, who has decided to study online, why exactly would I choose Thunderbird over

the University of Liverpool in the Laureate network? Why would I choose a new Bachelor

Degree from Thunderbird and pay for it, when many of the National Universities in the

market that the Network covers offer already well established programmes with very

competitively priced bachelor degrees in Business. The University also offers Doctorates

as part of their online portfolio, so students could conceivably continue study to the highest

academic level. As an academic leader and alumni, I would be happy to examine the

possibilities for Thunderbird in an advisory role to the BoT together with other stakeholders

and independent experts. I am quite certain that there are many external (to the BoT)

experts with experience in international educational management, maybe even among the

alumni, who if given access to the options that the BoT said that they considered, could

provide independent insight which might even end up endorsing the decision. As the

situation stands now, I as an alumni feel left out of the process and concerned that my

degree may be devaluated, a concern that I have had since experiencing a drop in

relevant MBA rankings. I strongly encourage Dr. Penley and the BoT to appoint an

independent evaluation team to assess the options for our School. As an alumni I would

be happy to serve and I am quite certain that any of us would. We all want the best for

Thunderbird and the communication to us so far regarding this decision has unfortunately

not been compelling, convincing or presented in a rigorous manner. At the time I am

signing this petition, I can see that 755 people have already signed this, I hope therefore

that the leadership addresses our concerns. I think we are all trying to formulate these in

an open and constructive manner, so that we may wholeheartedly continue to support the

actions of our schools leadership and help it succeed. Sincerely, Michael Goodsite Ph.D.

Samuel Aleman Spain 2013-04-06 Deeply concerned about what this partnership will do to our loved school's

academic reputation and brand value.


Michael Goodsite Herning, Denmark 2013-04-06 As a very proud Thunderbird graduate who as since maintained a very close academic

relationship my School, I am joining this petition because I am not at all following the

rationale for the partnership. I strongly encourage the leadership of Thunderbird to have

their communications department reevaluate how and what they have communicated to

the Alumni. What does Laureate get out of this partnership? I am wondering: why would

Laureate expand their portfolio with a partner where it is not clear how they differentiate

from another partner already in their network? The reason that I ask this is that Laureate

has already partnered with the University of Liverpool and even expanded its international

collaboration (see the announcement made in 2007: <a

href="https://news.liv.ac.uk/2007/04/30/university-of-liverpool-and-laureate-announce-

expanded-international-collaboration/"

rel="nofollow">https://news.liv.ac.uk/2007/04/30/university-of-liverpool-and-laureate-

announce-expanded-international-collaboration/</a> ). I am wondering if anyone could

brief what the realised benefits for the U. of Liverpool have been since the above

announcement? What is the gap identified that the UoL is not fulfilling in the Laureate

market and how will Thunderbird fill it? The University of Liverpool has produced (to the

best of my knowledge) eight Nobel Laureates (during the period of 1902 to 1995).

Granted, I find it difficult to directly link these esteemed scholars with an MBA in Global

Management - still the University is arguably a standout amongst the current partners in

the Laureate portfolio ( <a href="http://www.laureate.net/OurNetwork"

rel="nofollow">http://www.laureate.net/OurNetwork</a> ). Examining the online offerings

of the University of Liverpool, I find: <a href="http://www.liv.ac.uk/study/online/index.htm"

rel="nofollow">http://www.liv.ac.uk/study/online/index.htm</a> that they include a MBA

with a specialisation in International Business. So again, what exactly does Laureate hope

to gain? The announcement focusses on what Thunderbird will gain (<a

href="http://www.laureate.net/LGGSite/LGG/OurNetwork/Highlights/2013/03/Thunderbird%

20Plans%20Partnership%20With%20Laureate%20Education%20Inc%20Expands%20Glo

bal%20Presence.aspx)"

rel="nofollow">http://www.laureate.net/LGGSite/LGG/OurNetwork/Highlights/2013/03/Thun

derbird%20Plans%20Partnership%20With%20Laureate%20Education%20Inc%20Expand

s%20Global%20Presence.aspx)</a> but does not explain just how Thunderbird will

differentiate itself from other Laureate online offerings - including those from the very

successful University of Liverpool? In other words, if I were a student in Europe or

elsewhere, who has decided to study online, why exactly would I choose Thunderbird over

the University of Liverpool in the Laureate network? Why would I choose a new Bachelor

Degree from Thunderbird and pay for it, when many of the National Universities in the

market that the Network covers offer already well established programmes with very

competitively priced bachelor degrees in Business. The University also offers Doctorates

as part of their online portfolio, so students could conceivably continue study to the highest

academic level. As an academic leader and alumni, I would be happy to examine the

possibilities for Thunderbird in an advisory role to the BoT together with other stakeholders

and independent experts. I am quite certain that there are many external (to the BoT)

experts with experience in international educational management, maybe even among the

alumni, who if given access to the options that the BoT said that they considered, could

provide independent insight which might even end up endorsing the decision. As the

situation stands now, I as an alumni feel left out of the process and concerned that my

degree may be devaluated, a concern that I have had since experiencing a drop in

relevant MBA rankings. I strongly encourage Dr. Penley and the BoT to appoint an

independent evaluation team to assess the options for our School. As an alumni I would

be happy to serve and I am quite certain that any of us would. We all want the best for

Thunderbird and the communication to us so far regarding this decision has unfortunately

not been compelling, convincing or presented in a rigorous manner. At the time I am

signing this petition, I can see that 755 people have already signed this, I hope therefore

that the leadership addresses our concerns. I think we are all trying to formulate these in

an open and constructive manner, so that we may wholeheartedly continue to support the

actions of our schools leadership and help it succeed. Sincerely, Michael Goodsite PhD

Zyanya Bejarano Los Angeles, CA 2013-04-06 Worried about reputation of MBA program and my investment in choice of

education


Rick Lee Gurnee, IL 2013-04-06 This proposed partnership with Laureate Education, Inc. would damage

Thunderbird academic reputation!

barry miller Chicago, IL 2013-04-06 Maintain the value of my degree

elias zaga buzali mexico df, Mexico 2013-04-06 We need to make sure the Thunderbird name is still valued as much tomorrow

as it was when we decided to link our names to it.

James Fink Japan 2013-04-06 I have supported the school with donations and introductions of students. If we

need a partner why not find a high quality merger like The Monterey Institute of

International Studies made with Middlebury College instead of destroying the

brand.

Michel Cardenas Mexico 2013-04-06 Here in Mexico Laurete is consider a third tier University and I think the image

Thunderbird offers is completely different from the one that Laurete does. This

partnership would damage the reputation of Thunderbird, which would be

associated in Mexico as a third tier institution. Here in Mexico Thunderbird

brand is not known by many people, but Laurete's brand recognition as a place

for studies that are both cheap and with low acceptance requirements is known

nation wide.

Mike Robinson Smyrna, GA 2013-04-06 Laureate is a suspect institution. My wife was a teacher in the public school

system for years and would actively discourage parents from enrolling their

kids in Laureate (Sylvan at that time). The focus is on the dollars and not the

education. This is not a wise move for Thunderbird. I would expect more from

the institution that has so many professors that I maintain in such high esteem.

We are better than this kind of thinking.

Michael Crotty Shanghai, China 2013-04-07 As a 1974 graduate with many years being associated in the alumni

association, I can attest that the Thunderbird Mystique is a very unique and

powerful network. Aligning ourselves with the "for profit" academic sector will

definitely compromise this Network and cheapen the brand.

I am sure there were other options being considered and it would be a wise

decision for the school to share those with the alumni and reconsider this

proposed partnership.

Juan Serrano Aventura, FL 2013-04-07 Thunderbird is so fragile to loose its ranking and fall into a massive and cheap

brand.

Jorge Pedraza Miramar, FL 2013-04-07 I have not been shown any evidence as to how this will be beneficial to adding

value to the Thunderbird Brand or or to my Alumni worldwide.

Juan Corral Mexico 2013-04-07 This partnership is a shame... the current partnerships with the ITESM will be

degraded

Patrick Moggridge Phoenix, AZ 2013-04-07 Keeping our brand strong does not include any affiliation with Laureate.

Sandra Maycotte Mexico 2013-04-07 Laureate is associated in Mexico with the UVM university (Universidad del

Valle de Mexico) which lacks academic prestige and quality certifications. It

would be very disappointing to see the Thunderbird brand associated with this

university.

Maria Alcala San pedro garza garcia,

Mexico

2013-04-07 Value of brand

Ricardo Garcia Mexico 2013-04-07 Thunderbird alumni

Susan Caolo Atlanta, GA 2013-04-07 I'm signing because I cannot trust our Thunderbird Board of Trustees'

judgement based on all the past poor decisions leading to this desperate effort

to cover financial debts. I think this Laureate partnership will cheapen our TBird

brand.


Shri Sundaram Sunnyvale, CA 2013-04-07 I agree with some of the comments. Can't let T-Bird brand be diluted. We must

maintain our independence and exclusivity.

Cheryl Wilson van Tilburg Singapore, Singapore 2013-04-07 Class of '86. I'm would like to see a cooling-off period before this deal is inked.

There are too many questions -- and too high a price to pay for alums if things

go wrong -- to hurry this deal along.

Janet Caristo-Verrill Wayland, MA 2013-04-07 Why is this important to you?I want(Optional)

ShaoPing Paul Pan Taipei, Taiwan, Taiwan 2013-04-07 I care about my school.

Thomas Steck Germany 2013-04-07 This issue/scandal is already damaging the reputation of the USA /

Thunderbird MBA degree in Germany (First hand information of a new

colleague at my company).

Karina Larsen O'Halloran Zurich, Switzerland 2013-04-07 I am proud of being a T-bird and happy to have a 'real' MBA degree vs. so

many I come across that list degrees from schools I always question the value

of.

Nancy Frohman Singapore, Singapore 2013-04-07 I graduated from what was the top school for graduate international education-

not a for profit on line university. Please don't align Thunderbird with this

calibre of degree!

Sandra Parr Londonderry, NH 2013-04-07 In my career in global business I can tell you that the Thunderbird name is

globally respected in a way that the brands of this partner are not. This

partnership simply does not make sense.

Jukka Majanen Singapore, Singapore 2013-04-07 We went there for the Thunderbird experience. It was called the Thunderbird

Mystique then. That shared experience what bonds us. It should not be diluted

in any way. Laureate partners are a very different bunch. "Oil and water don't

mix".

gina henry austin, TX 2013-04-07 We must make sure we keep the integrity of Thunderbird.

Ajoy Philip Latvia 2013-04-07 The value of the Thunderbird graduate degree can be significantly affected if

the mode and quality of degrees offered with proposed partners is anything

less than world class. If not properly managed, such degrees can lower student

quality, standards of the degree and corporate recognition of the Thunderbird

brand for international business. The harm can be long term and not easily

repaired

Arturo Melendez Mexico 2013-04-07 Financially is a good decision, but brand reputation will be damage as we know

it for sure. Education is changing and maybe the way of ranking education will

do also. But maybe the real challenge for us is to keep THUNDERBIRD name

alive thanks to our good works and leadership. if we want this, we better

present solutions, that will increase the number of students that will become

loyal T-Birds in the near future. And we better do it now, to avoid this.

Marcela Rojo Mexico 2013-04-07 .

Humberto Padilla Mexico 2013-04-07 This is vital for me as I have spent money and time, devoting resources and

efforts to getting my MBA and now my university will partner with Laurate

Education, an university that is regarded as the worst quality in Mexico? No

way! I urge the BOT to revoke this partnership as this move will KILL the

Thunderbird brand and image. Not only will new students not opt for this school

but current students and graduates will loose identity and the pride that we

have in the school. Even if in financial distress, NO UNIVERSITY IS ENTITLED

TO REDUCE AND CHEAPEN THE VALUE OF THE TITLES OF

THOUSANDS OF STUDENTS THAT MADE A LOT OF EFFORT TO GET

THAT TITLE, IT IS LIKE ROBBING THEM. Please stop this move and rather

use all the expertise of the professors and alumni to think of a better solution.

Vipon Kumar Conshohocken, PA 2013-04-07 I want to keep the Thunderbird mystique alive..


Trevor Norris Lima, Peru, Peru 2013-04-08 At T-Bird, concepts surrounding "stakeholders" was drilled in every

managment class.

Thunderbird has no greater group of staeholders than its famed alumni, now

multigenerational global alumni.

Excluding alumni from the process, and even denying transparent disclosure is

a terifically hipocritical decision by current management, which by definition is

more transitory than the alunmi body.

Ron Fulmer Mountain View, CA 2013-04-08 I strongly urge you to suspend the proposed partnership. Moving forward would

destroy the Thunderbird Mystique.

Alex Dubrovskiy Moscow, Russian

Federation

2013-04-08 I share all concerns raised by Mr Piper and fully support this petition.

Sergio Ortega Fair Oaks, CA 2013-04-08 My MBA title will lose value with the proposed partnership.

Eric Johnson Ardmore, TN 2013-04-08 When schools become for profit, it's about the profit, not the education.

Drew Smith St. Paul, MN 2013-04-08 This is a short-sighted decision. Choosing a for-profit/PE-owned partner

introduces a mis-alignment of interests that will hurt the Thunderbird brand in

the long run.

Walter Baker Tampa, FL 2013-04-08 Partnerships like this do not happen overnight. This has obviously been in the

works at a board level for far longer than the new President has been in office.

(Was it a reason Dr. Cabrera left?)

Given that, one could assume Dr. Penley knew about it prior to accepting the

position. This begs the question as to how many candidates for the position

were either not interested or scared off by this pending transaction. In other

words, did we get the best candidate for the position based on this transaction,

or just the one who was willing to put up with this joint venture?

In closing, Thunderbird has both a unique and differentiated position in the

world of advanced business education. One that has been both acknowledged

and embraced by both corporate and comparable institutions. In my opinion,

rather than enter into an ill advised relationship with a for profit entity, the

school would be better served to identify and recruit for two key positions:

First, a proven and world-class fundraiser who can ensure the school has a

sustainable future through the creation of a significant endowment. Secondly,

a proven leader who has the vision, leadership style, and global credibility to

ensure the progress made to date is secure, and expand that reputation to

allow the school to maintain it both its independence and leadership position in

the field of Global Management.

Mario Plata Bogotá, Colombia 2013-04-08 Llinking the Thunderbird brand to a For-Profit education entity as Laureate will

diminish its quality perception. As a consequence, its value for employers will

be affected, even if its just by a matter of perception, As the spanish adage

says: ni importa solo serlo, sino parecerlo (it not only mattters to be, but to

have the appearance of it)


Fernandez Luis

Fernando

Mexico City, Mexico 2013-04-08 The greatest concern in regards to this partnership between Thunderbird and

Laureate Education is that our school hasn't open a discussion with all the T-

bird community. This move can have a significant impact in how Thunderbird is

seen around the globe and thus the BOT should open discussion. I myself

don't know enough about Laureate Education but that in itself tells us that such

institution does not carry a global reputation which could enhance

"Thunderbird's Mystique" as a top notch International MBA program.

I sincerely hope that the T-bird management take pause and let our voices be

heard.

Scott Stallwood Flemington, NJ 2013-04-08 This is very disturbing for a number of reasons, but first in no way does an

affiliation with Laureate enhance the Thunderbird brand and will undoubtedly

have the opposite effect in the marketplace. Laureate is not on anybody's list

of top learning institutions and neither are any of the schools with which they

have affiliations. The Thunderbird reputation and prestige will be lost and the

value of the degree will correspondingly suffer. This short-sighted and ill-

advised partnership should be stopped.

Amy Havekost Hoboken, NJ 2013-04-08 I'm also concerned this dilutes the Thunderbird brand. When people who are

familiar with Thunderbird find out I went there, they are always impressed and I

don't want to cheapen that. Occasionally, someone who isn't familiar with

Thunderbird asks me if it's an online degree program. I certainly don't want to

be in a position where I have to defend that. I understand the need/desire to

partner with other institutions - especially overseas. Those institutions should

have the same, if not better, academics and reputation as Thunderbird. If there

are other reasons for doing this, please be transparent with the alumni. We've

all invested in Thunderbird. It's in our best interest to do whatever possible to

protect its name and brand.

Suneet Ashburn Lexington, KY 2013-04-08 This move will dilute the Thunderbird Brand irrevocably.

Daniel Cody Santa Monica, CA 2013-04-08 I strongly oppose this decision to go to market with a for-profit "educational"

entity. It dilutes the brand and endorses poor public policy. I strongly

encourage the current administration to reassess this decision and listen to the

alumni and friends of the school.

Enrique Madrigal Mexico 2013-04-08 Is very important to maintain the value of the Thunderbird Brand. A partnership

like this will put on risk this great school. A for-profit institution is just for profit,

nothing else.

Scott Williams Shanghai, China 2013-04-08 Alumni is in the dark on this. Many have never heard of Laureate Education.

Who are they, what are their strengths and weaknesses and why are they a

good match for the number one private international graduate institution

globally? It is not clear and it should be.

Michael Haerting Miami, FL 2013-04-09 It seems like a quick fix ignoring deeper problems

C. Ross Croulet Lake Worth, FL 2013-04-09 To maintain the value and power of the Thunderbird brand for the graduate

degrees for which we worked hard to earn. Would we turn Harvard University

over to the Univ. of Phoenix? I don't think so, and so should you on

maintaining the reality and legend that is Thunderbird.

Steven Sarwin Richardson, TX 2013-04-09 I will no longer be supporting Thunderbird financially or otherwise if their

leadership decides to transform to the despicable and cheap Univ of Pheonix

or Walden model.


John Hager miami, FL 2013-04-09 While an association with perhaps some other recognized institution of higher

learning that has established credentials and whose longer-term vision shares

that of maintaining the historical preeminence of the Thunderbird reputation

while adapting to an everchanging global environment may be beneficial, it is

clear that the announced but ill-considered alignment with a for-profit institution

like Laureate does not further this goal and will only contribute to diluting the

Thunderbird brand in the coming years. I propose that this merger be

suspended for now and that a fundamental review of the process and the

reasons behind it be held with the engagement of the full alumni community

and the other stakeholders to evaluate what other options exist if some kind of

financial fix is required. A hasty decision of this kind may very well result in the

erosion of alumni support for years into the future.

F. Bruno De La Mata Carlsbad, CA 2013-04-09 Thunderbird had a great reputation but this move is selling the reputation to the

Alberto Cruz Santo Domingo,

Dominican Republic

2013-04-09 Brand name dilution

Jim Peebles Panama, Panama 2013-04-09 Thunderbird's Legacy is to teach global managers. Not to be the marionette of

Sylvan OnLine Learning and lampooned in Doonesbury

Hani Khouri Miami, FL 2013-04-09 When I was at Thunderbird in the 1970's and Mr. Voris was the president of the

school and it was called American graduate School of International

Management. My degree is an MIM not an MBA. Had I wanted am MBA, I

could have stayed at the graduate programme I was in, but it was weak on

international business and management. Thunderbird had already devalued

the degree by switching to an MBA programme instead of keeping the MIM.

The School did offer to have the MBA degree replace the MIM! I wonder how

many alumni made the switch?! That was a one calendar year degree. No

breaks. It was more like boot camp, especially if your dorm room was in the

barracks.

Thunderbird can't become a "pay your fees, get your B's" for profit school, or

even linked with Laureate. Comparable institutions to the ones that Laureate

operates are, for example; DeVry, Kaplan College & ITT Technical Institute. I

wouldn't want my heard earned degree which has served me well to be

degraded.

I join other alumni in urging you to suspend the joint venture with Laureate.

Mark Hornor Cupertino, CA 2013-04-09 The propose partnership will cheapen the Thunderbird brand. It makes no

sense.

Geoff Horsfield Yorba Linda, CA 2013-04-09 I laugh (quietly) at online MBA degrees and in the faces of University of

Phoenix so-called graduates........ And I laugh at their certificates on the wall.

Emilio Margarit Spain 2013-04-09 Because I am proud to be a T-bird, and, yes, th once powerful Thunderbird

prestige has beenn already diluted enough. It is time to stop the hemorraging

and look for other strategic soulution, but Laureate Education has to be th

worst of all options. Please keep th Thunderbird mistique alive !!!!

Albertina Gonzalo Posada de Valdeón,

Spain

2013-04-09 I am a T-Bird and I donot agree with this proposal that will downgrade

Thunderbird High Level Education.

Marc Petznick Bay Harbor Islands, FL 2013-04-09 Harm to the Thunderbird brand, ranking, and academic reputation


Pamela Frank Boston, MA 2013-04-09 This will indeed dilute the brand, which will affect recruitment and overall

rankings. I realize I also have to take ownership in this situation because I

have not given enough of my annual donations to Thunderbird. Quite honestly I

was unaware of how dire the Financial situation was. I hope that if we are

successful at blocking this partnership, every opposing voice will make

Thunderbird a priority in their annual contributions going forward. I certainly will.

Dean McCaskill Paris, TX 2013-04-09 Laureate is a 'for profit' diploma factory and Thunderbird will not benefit from

any association with them.

Erendiora Hernandez Mexico 2013-04-09 Tbird graduate.

Maria del Pilar Cordoba

Algara

Mexico 2013-04-09 I'm a Thunderbird Alumni and care deeply about how this affects my MBA

degree, I wish Thunderbird to keep it's excellent reputation and educational

standing.

Frank Corbishley Coral Gables, FL 2013-04-09 I have always been skeptical of for-profit "universities," and many others are as

well. Educational instiltutions should be about academic freedom and teaching

people how to think, not abouit promoting the ideology or self-interest of the

Board of Directors of a for-profit corporation. For me, by partnering with

Laureate, Thunderbird would become absolutely meaningless.

Christopher Bates Taipei, Taiwan 2013-04-09 Tbird class of 1978

Emilio Lamar coral gables, FL 2013-04-09 wrong direction

Jaime ( a.k.a.jimmy)

Sanchez

rockwall, TX 2013-04-09 downgrade of brand image which is most import school asset

Warren Feller Fort Lauderdale, FL 2013-04-09 I do not want the Thunderbird brand diluted, as associating with Laureate will

surely dol

Gregg Lee Emmett, ID 2013-04-09 Thunderbird is not a vocational school. Partnering with Sylvan Learning

Centers is a step in the wrong direction for the purposes of securing funding.

Transforming Thunderbird to a glorified "University of Phoenix" is most

disappointing. Please reconsider this idea before it is too late for all of us.

Alex Hawk SCOTTSDALE, AZ 2013-04-09 Dear T-birds, what we are saying here is: the dialogue is needed and so is the

change. This movement is not to suspend the change but to engage all the

potent leadership Thunderbird has produced thus far and make it work towards

the expansion of the brand, not collapse as many may see it.

Seems like this is how 40,000 global leaders that were once charged to create

sustainable prosperity worldwide are simply refusing to exclude the home

ground from the prosperity creation process.

This conversation about profit vs. not-for-profit is outdated. The world is moving

way faster than these labels. We are capable of developing our own unique

model and while providing world class inspiration and education still be

financially sound. Let's focus on this instead of just trying to stop or stall

change. We can do better than that. We have talented communicators and

facilitators among t-birds - let's have a new round of global dialogues and

together with faculty, alumni and administration re-design our future.

Respectfully,


Lamar Stone San Antonio, TX 2013-04-09 I would prefer to have the the school suffer slightly more in the short term, only

to retool and resurface (like the Phoenix) under our own aegis. At least then

the school would be more beholden to its founding principles and,

subsequently, its own destiny. This would preserve the mystique and allow for

more input and/or support from the alumni base. It is embarrassing to see

large recent gifts, a la Garvin, seemingly evaporate so quickly to necessitate a

decision like this. My fellow graduates have made very good arguments on this

petition and those should be weighted at least on par with this potentially lethal

"strategic" decision.

Morgan Siegal Scottsdale, AZ 2013-04-09 Brand strength

Terry Burton Fort Myers, FL 2013-04-09 I do not trust for profit education. ITT Tech is a prime example of

mismanagement.

Gerardo Rodriguez Monterrey, Mexico 2013-04-09 To keep improving it.

Nancy Cubillos Bogota, Venezuela,

Bolivarian Republic of

2013-04-09 I am a student of Global MBA for Latin American Managers

Bryan Dsouza Bellevue, WA 2013-04-09 Because I graduated from Thunderbird

Hector Esparza Mexico 2013-04-09 I still remember my first conversation with recruiters before starting my MBA

and my decision to study at Thunderbird was based on the quality and

reputation of the school that was discussed during several interviews with

recruiters. The partnership with Laureate Education Inc will only deteriorate the

reputation of Thunderbird as they have not the same quality and standards in

education. I disagree with the partnership and I highly recommend to reassess

this decision.

Oliver Aponte Guadalajara, Mexico 2013-04-09 I'm an alumni and I don't think this is benefical for the institution.

ricardo bolanos Mexico 2013-04-09 Thunderbird number one, lauerate, JUST BUSINESS

Frederick Suarez Miami, FL 2013-04-09 Partnership will ruin our position as top grad school for International

Management . Laureate is a vulture business with no image ,credibility or

rating.

Amit Airon Stafford, TX 2013-04-09 I am a T-bird and I dont want to see its brand getting diluted. Thunderbird is

already in trouble. I dont want to see it getting deeper in it.

Harold Brown Billings, MT 2013-04-09 Because I'm a '71 Grad concerned about the school's future and I'm opposed

to change for change's sake. Adjust to the needs of the market, but to change

T'bird's product to a "for profit" academic institution would sully the reputation -

compare Walden to Williams for Academic excellence.

Gabriela Montenegro San Salvador, El

Salvador

2013-04-10 it represents the school reputation and differentiation, and ultimately the value

of my investment in obtaining my Masters Degree and of my fellow t-bird

mates.

Julia Collins Lakewood, OH 2013-04-10 Thunderbird = Competing Through People, Leading Change, Data Analysis,

Global Strategy, Global Marketing. Laureate = Easy Access to Education.

Thunderbird + Laureate Partnership = No More Mystique

Heidi Stephens Metz Kirkland, United States 2013-04-10 Laureate is not a good choice of partner

Martha McCaskill Longview, TX 2013-04-10 Because as a graduate, I'd like to see the school keep its reputation for

excellence.

Jessica Quezada Mexico, Mexico 2013-04-10 I chose this MBA because the importance of the university and the importance

of it by giving me a certain status in my resume and by being in a job that

represents the growth and mission of my life followed by the Thunderbird

Standards of education. The ideal of this program was the global knowledge

and the values it gave me.


Michael Greve Miami, FL 2013-04-10 Do not sign any partnership outside of our, the alumni's approval. Do not dilute

our brand of Tbird, which should remain its own with no partners!

Andrew Strider Pleasanton, CA 2013-04-10 This line says it everything you need to know about why this is not the right

direction for Thunderbird:

"Laureate’s US flagship product, Walden University, was highlighted in the

report. The school spent $1,574 per student on instruction in 2009, compared

to $2,230 per student on marketing and $1,915 per student on profit. "

30% more profit that spending per student. I think that sums it up.

WRONG FOR THUNDERBIRD. WRONG FOR STUDENTS. WRONG.

ignacio nunez Mexico 2013-04-10 Quality of education

Carlos Quezada Ciudad de México,

Mexico

2013-04-10 I'm afraid that Thunderbird will lose its independency, also its strong positioning

as a social consciousness school and finally the ability to continue educating

global leaders.

Patrick Galvin Portland, OR 2013-04-10 I'm a proud '94 Thunderbird graduate who is very concerned about the

partnership with Laureate Education due to that company's questionable

business practices. I believe strongly in the adage that "you are the company

that you keep." The overall quality of Laureate Education and its affiliated

institutions fall far short of what Thunderbird offers.There must be a better way

than partnering with Laureate to guarantee a bright future for Thunderbird.

Please stop this ill-conceived partnership!

Wesley Schrock Goshen, IN 2013-04-10 I care about Thunderbird and don't think this partnership is in best interests of

school.

Steven Misshula jupiter, FL 2013-04-10 the reasons are obvious...

Ivan Amayo Miami, FL 2013-04-10 I would no longer be proud of my Thunderbird degree and would simply tell

people I have an MBA instead of having them think I went to a Mickey Mouse

online school of extremely dubious quality. Don't do it!

Charles 'Cap' Rucquoi Delray Beach, FL 2013-04-10 dillutes the brand and my degree

Justin Olson Salt Lake City, UT 2013-04-10 As a Thunderbird graduate, I don't want to see further brand dilution.

Carlos Carrera Mexico 2013-04-10 I don't see Laureate just helping Thunderbird, they will take over our university

in the future, we need prevent Thunderbird to lose its non-profit heart.

Anabell Iglesias San Salvador, El

Salvador

2013-04-10 A superb, recognized and respected institution such as Thunderbird, will suffer

from a partnership with Laureate. I urge you to take a hard look at how the

Thunderbird brand will suffer, and how this partnership affects alumni, faculty,

research coming out of Thunderbird, and the profile of incoming students.

Thunderbird is not meant to be a mass-produced school, it is a unique and

differentiated institution that attracts superb candidates from all over the world

who share the mindset of global citizenship. The partnership with Laureate will

lower the bar.

Andrew Brewer Lake Charles, LA 2013-04-10 To avoid stripping the mystique and uniqueness of our school

Vibhor Gupta new york, NY 2013-04-10 I have friend that used to work at laureate and he says its a diploma mill just

like university of phoniex where no fortune 500 company would values their

degree's. This partnership could mean the same for Thunderbird which is

scary.

Alejandro Gonzalez

Garcia

Mexico 2013-04-10 In mexico Laureate Education has no reputation at all. I will rather say I studied

at ITESM than Thunderbird it that case.


Bridget Rodgers (MIM

'89)

Ann Arbor, MI 2013-04-10 Loyalty to the true Thunderbird value.

David Dodson redwood city, CA 2013-04-10 Making this deal will dilute and devalue our degree and turn this institution into

a marketing machine. The value of the degree will be lost as the quality of the

students will deminish and the quality of the education diluted. I know this

company well and know what it will not be good for the Thunderbird alum or

future graduates. I love our school and will be sad to see it lowered dilluted.

Being a T-Bird still means something today.

Thomas Nowakowski Australia 2013-04-11 I am a graduate of Thunderbird and would like protect the principles upon

which the school was founded ... Leave its excellence for future generations

Melchor Espinosa Kissimmee, FL 2013-04-11 I strongly agree with all the issues assessed in the letter.

Elide Romero Mexico 2013-04-11 I am concerned about in Thunderbird reputation.

Ricardo Ivison Mexico 2013-04-11 To keep the T-bird brand , we should not go for this partnership

Arjan Shahani San Pedro, Mexico 2013-04-11 I am a T-Bird and I'm proud of it. In the future, I would want to see the

reputation behind my title to increase, not decrease due to being part of a

partnership with a questionable institution. I understand the financial situation

that is promoting this decision but I am sure there are alternatives.

Billy Kennedy Pontiac, MI 2013-04-11 I take great pride in the relevance of my Thunderbird degree. This proposed

action is NOT congruent to the Thunderbird Mystic". Indeed. it may well be the

"Thunderbird Mistake" that kills the school!

Elizabeth Martins Sao Paulo, Brazil 2013-04-11 Please, please don't wash down the name of the Thunderbird brand by

entering this partnership! THunderbird is unique - let's keep it that way!

Julia Stowell Toronto, Canada 2013-04-11 Our brand is unique and should never be comprised!

Joseph Burke Harare, Zimbabwe 2013-04-11 If for financial reasons T'bird must partner, then let it pdo so with an outstadning

institution not the purveyor of third class distance degreees.an approprate

Jorge Alejandro Martínez San Pedro Garza García,

Mexico

2013-04-11 As a Thunderbird I feel that our board should consider a more serios partner

with stronger backgrownd, if for example Thunderbird were to partner with

Hardvard School of Business I wouldn't have a problem!

Mark Friebel Palo Alto, CA 2013-04-11 I do not think that it is wise to partner with a for-profit organization. The board

only is thinking of today's needs. In the long run, it will tarnish the reputation of

the school.

Jeff Snyder London, United Kingdom 2013-04-11 An on-line university? You have got to be kidding me.

Rob Bagby Richmond, United

Kingdom

2013-04-11 I went to Thunderbird because of it's reputation. Graduates were always so

proud of being a TBird (as was I). It seems to me that over the past few years

the leaders at Thunderbird have been forgetting some of the basics of business

and are simply chasing the almighty dollar. We need to help them understand

that they need to re-focus on the core values and mission of Thunderbird:

"educating global leaders".

Danial Carlson Unionville, IN 2013-04-11 I am a student at Thunderbird, and I am concerned about the brand.

William Cone Miami, FL 2013-04-11 Alumni should have more info and a clearer voice in the discussion. I would

like to see a pro and con analysis of why this should or should not happen. It

does appear on first review to cheapen the great global brand but I'm open to

hear a strong case for the partnership and assurances that it is outside the

regular T-bird degree program.

Lora Mazza Grosse Pointe Farms, MI 2013-04-11 I am concerned that partnering with Laureate will degrade the Thunderbird

image.


Patrick Dodd Auckland, New Zealand 2013-04-11 I went to Thunderbird because of it's reputation. Graduates were always so

proud of being a TBird (as was I). It seems to me that over the past few years

the leaders at Thunderbird have been forgetting some of the basics of business

and are simply chasing the almighty dollar. We need to help them understand

that they need to re-focus on the core values and mission of Thunderbird:

"educating global leaders".

Susan Duby Corona del Mar, CA 2013-04-11 Devalues the Thunderbird name and cheapens the Thunderbird brand

Edward Chenard Eden Prairie, MN 2013-04-12 I am very familiar with Laureate and their poor practices. This is one of the

worst ideas I have ever seen. Use some of that business and strategy

brainpower to come up with a better solution, like fixing recruiting practices. Do

that and you won't need these kind of deals. Laureate has a bad rep, don't

harm our careers with this move.

Scott Sheridan Lexington, KY 2013-04-12 The Thunderbird brand and reputation should be paramount to any short-term

financial issues that the school is encountering.

Jim McGough Northbrook, IL 2013-04-12 In the 21st century increasingly what makes you different makes you standout.

We want to be "selectively famous" and resonating with the types of people

Thunderbird has always attracted. The proposed alliance will forever change

this.

Michael Greve Miami, FL 2013-04-12 The lack of understating of what this new relationship means for Thunderbird's

market position and the harm it will cause its reputation should concern anyone

who has been part of its history as a student or faculty. This decision flies in

the face of everything that the institution represents. It is a myopic,

shortsighted and based on an irrational proposal for a school of such stature. I

urge that this decision be reconsidered.

Leslie Sturino Doha, Qatar, Qatar 2013-04-12 The proposed deal will diminish the value of my degree. This will be very

damaging to the careers of all T-bird alumni.

Jacob Young Washington, DC 2013-04-12 I am a Thunderbird/Indiana Dual Degree alum. My cohort and I spent two and

half years working for degrees from two institutions that are independently

strong and in which we have great pride. I don't want to see any alum's hard

work diluted and diminished by a partnership that is not inline with what we

worked so hard to achieve.

Peggy (Margaret)

Angevine

Madison, WI 2013-04-12 It 'cheapens' our TBird brand.

Ying Wang Shanghai, China 2013-04-12 I care about Thunderbird, very much!

Pedro Cejas Coral Gables, FL 2013-04-12 The Thunderbird brand was not built overnight, and with this move it will most

likely be destroyed in seconds. The administration appears to have lost focus

on Thunderbird’s core strengths and succumb to short-sighted decisions that I

can only assume are purely based on immediate potential economic benefits.

The problem with looking short-term is that these types of decisions tend not to

contribute to long term success. The Thunderbird brand has value to potential

students, new students and alumni alike. I fear that this decision will dilute my

degree to the point where I may consider removing it from my bio. Please

reconsider.

Sharon Cook San Francisco, CA 2013-04-12 As an alumni of Thunderbird I want to protect the integrity of the school for

future students. I want them to have the opportunity that I did to receive a top

tier masters degree in International Business through a unique program that

offers great interaction across borders because of the high quality of

international students enrolled in the program.

Alejandra Elsea New Rochelle, NY 2013-04-12 Disagree strongly!!!


fabienne rodet San Jose, CA 2013-04-12 We need to maintain the credibility of our institution. Thunderbird was once a

top name school - it was why I chose the program.

Curt Howell Indianapolis, IN 2013-04-12 I want to preserve the mystique

William Darby Atlanta, GA 2013-04-12 There was time when my degree from Thunderbird was worth more than 40

pieces of silver. What an utter betrayal of what was once a proud tradition, a

top tier school, and a true differentiator in the business world!

Wayne Seewald Houston, TX 2013-04-12 As a Tbird graduate I do not want to see the Thunderbird name associated with

an online for profit instituion. If this occurs I will end any further donations to

Thunderbird.

Philip Dursey Tucson, AZ 2013-04-12 There are better options. Look at what Stanford is doing in this space, open

source learning platforms are more consistent with Thunderbird's mission,

more secure and more flexible. Clearly class2go and others are superior.

Don'ts cheapen the brand, elevate it with the ethical pressure of open source.

Greg Fitzgerald Austin, TX 2013-04-12 In favor of expanding T-bird brand but need to be careful in process.

Gabriel Areas Miami, FL 2013-04-12 Alumni

Anne Friberg New York, NY 2013-04-13 The school's reputation is all that matters and is jeopardized by this

partnership.

Ching Wang milpitas, CA 2013-04-13 So expected the good changes will come along the new president. Apparently

not, it's getting worse. Please hold and protect T-bird brand as premium.

Theo van der Loo São Paulo, Brazil 2013-04-13 I am concerned about the impact on Thunderbird's reputation.

Victor Pedrosa Miami Beach, FL 2013-04-13 School quality and reputation

Tara Tamboowalla Collegeville, PA 2013-04-13 I am willing to say what perhaps others may not. Degrees from for profit

institutions do not carry the same weight as those from traditional Universities. I

have been an HR Manager hiring at all levels since graduating as a proud T-

bird. For profit degrees are discounted, do not devalue my degree.

Jaime Ayala Mexico 2013-04-13 To keep the tradition of the Thunderbird.

Jose Papa Neto São Paulo, Brazil 2013-04-13 Today's business education environment definitively requires bold initiatives. I

must say though that scaling at any cost is short sighted and potentially

destructive on the long road. I have to agree with the dismay of many within the

Thunderbird community.

Here in Brazil, and, as I understand now, all over its network, Laureate

operates second and third tier programs and schools. Only time will prove the

success of this venture, but then, it might be too late.

Pattie Craumer Great Falls, MT 2013-04-13 Affiliation with a for profit organization like Laureate and its former name Sylvan

Learning says to the world that Thunderbird is a 'commodity' school. Let's not

descend to the depths of commercialism at the expense of a broader, grander,

and deeper mission. I implore you to suspend the partnership you have

announced. Thunderbird's strength is in what has already been built.

Michael Byron Austin, TX 2013-04-13 Having worked in for-profit education. I can concur with the concerns

addressed in this petition. MB'94

Christoph Adams Germany 2013-04-13 Laureate is not good for Thunderbird. Laureate manages 2 schools in Germany

and they are not well known. I'm afraid Thunderbird will not benefit from the

partnership as much as expected.

Michael Greve Miami, FL 2013-04-13 The Thunderbird mystique is what drew me to Thunderbird in the 90's. The

fiercely independent spirit of T-Bird and its alums is what still draws me to the

school. This is not a good partnership, it dilutes the brand and in turn hurts all

of us.


Michael Lane Chicago, IL 2013-04-13 The Thunderbird mystique is what drew me to Thunderbird in the 90's. The

fiercely independent spirit of T-Bird and its alums is what still draws me to the

school. This is not a good partnership, it dilutes the brand and in turn hurts all

of us.

Eddie Powell Austin, TX 2013-04-13 This partnership will kill the once great reputation that Thunderbird had. I

implore you to find another partner.

Lisa Spicka White Salmon, WA 2013-04-13 I get it. Thunderbird needs financial stability, improved career services, and

increased global operational capacity. But rather than partner with a for-profit

company that at best is laughable in distinguished academic circles, why not

explore strategic partnerships that will enhance, rather than hurt, our

reputation? Better the longer and perhaps more immediately painful road to

the right solution, rather than have Thunderbird students, alumni, and faculty

state their educational and professional merits are based on a partnership with

a for-profit learning center. Please don’t make me qualify my (very expensive)

education with “Well, you see I graduated BEFORE Thunderbird partnered with

Laureate.”

Jordi Argente Menlo Park, CA 2013-04-13 While I support creative thinking on distribution channel options for

Thunderbird, I do see this one is the right one.

Andrew Rubey Dallas, TX 2013-04-13 Dilution of the Thunderbird brand.

Alan Gottlieb Arlington, VA 2013-04-14 T-Bird Graduate. This partnership is nuts.

Susan Mitchell New York, NY 2013-04-14 it dilutes TBird and makes it a street level rather than academic educaiton

Luis Osuna Mexico 2013-04-14 I am an Alumni

Debbie Waitkus Phoenix, AZ 2013-04-14 There is tremendous value in the group learning offered at Thunderbird -

diverse ideas/experiences in action. The resulting long term relationships are

powerful, meaningful and span decades. A merger with Laureate Education

cheapens and contradicts the value that Thunderbird brings to the table.

Sarah Barker Sudbury, MA 2013-04-14 I would like more information to understand how this partnership affect the

Thunderbird brand.

JoAnn Mackenzie Lafayette, CO 2013-04-14 Preserve Thunderbird core mission

eliz valas san diego, CA 2013-04-15 damage and cheapen Thunderbird

Xiaobo Luo Gaborone, Botswana 2013-04-15 I'm a new admitted Thunderbird MBA students. I'd like to see the school keep

its brand alive.

pamela tomer cos cob, CT 2013-04-15 This will damage the name of the school to which I chose to spend my money

on a degree which carried a certain weight in terms of name/reputation. This

would dilute the name and damage the reputation terribly.

Amy Ahlers San Jose, CA 2013-04-15 I have SIGNIFICANT investment in Thunderbird and this change will reduce it -

and reduce my confidence as alumnae.


Jesus Romero Monterrey, Mexico 2013-04-15 In Mexico, between 2000 and 2008, Laureate bought three private universities

(UVM, UNIDEP and UNITEC) who were ranked significantly below the top

universities in Mexico and that target the medium and medium-low social class

(considering that tuition of these schools use to be 50% of the tuition from top

universities in Mexico). With these three universities, Laureate is today the

private school with more students in Mexico and it may have improved the

quality of these schools due to the high investment they have done (in Mexico

there are tax exceptions for most of the schools) but they still significantly

behind the top universities in Mexico.

Laureate may not be a bad institution, but when you compare it with

Thunderbird it simply does not match (values, market targeted, quality,

tuition…you name it) and definitely the impact of such partnership will be

negative for Thunderbird brand and academic reputation.

Jon Herman Sioux Falls, SD 2013-04-15 I am an alum

Fara Ferguson

Carvalhinhos

Lisbon, Portugal 2013-04-15 I think association with the Sylvan Learning Center will definitely cheapen the

value of the Thunderbird brand, and therefore all of our degrees.

Kristine A Swank Tucson, AZ 2013-04-15 My undergrad, Dana College, attempted such a partnership w/ a for-profit

educational provider, and it so destabilized their mission that they lost

accreditation and ended up closing their doors, quickly. The goal of for-profit

organizations, as I learned at T-bird, is to make profit, while the goal of T-bird

has always been to provide a world-class education. Those 2 goals are rarely

compatible. Please suspend this deal and seek alternate financing.

Maryl Widdows Bellevue, WA 2013-04-15 Thunderbird can do better. Partnering with a substandard education brand like

Laureate will be a nail in the coffin. Short term cost savings may be gained, but

this will hurt recruiting, rankings, job placement for recent graduates and

fundraising. Please find a better solution that preserves the integrity of the

Thunderbird brand.

David Heap New Orleans, LA 2013-04-15 I'd rather the school go out of business than collaborate with Laureate. At least

what it means to be a Tbird would endure. This partnership cheapens

everyone's degree.

John Leigh Lima, Peru 2013-04-15 Thunderbird is making really bad decisions lately

Lisa Umar Phoenix, AZ 2013-04-15 As a current student, I was blindsided by the announcement, and the lack of

transparency has been troubling. The fact that students and alumni were not

consulted prior to the deal is concerning and not appreciated.

Cristiano Andrade Natal, Brazil 2013-04-15 I worked as Commercial Director at a university that was acquired by Laureate

in Brazil for more than 4 years after the acquisition. The business philosophy

and growth of Laureate is 100% based on the significant increase in new

enrollments since its marketing strategy aims to fill classrooms without leaving

a single empty seat. No problem with that, not for the fact that investments in

academic quality are inversely proportional to the growth of the institution,

otherwise the bill would not close.

The institution has lost a lot of prestige and academic quality by which it was

known, and the brand was severely damaged.

It is certainly not the future scenario I want to Thunderbird.

Bethel Nathan San Diego, CA 2013-04-15 This does not fit the T-Bird that I loved attending and supporting!

tod rankin la verne, CA 2013-04-15 For profit is not a good future for T-Bird

Greg Skutnik Seattle, WA 2013-04-15 The need to not only maintain but reinstate the reputation of the program.

Mauricio Carmagnani São Paulo, Brazil 2013-04-15 Thunderbird cannot be transformed in a corporation aiming for profitability.

Kelly Egan Phoenix, AZ 2013-04-15 Because T-Bird is committing brand suicide.


Denny Basham Denver, CO 2013-04-15 I value the Thunderbird values and the Thunderbird mystique and I do not want

to see this devalued by a for-profit partnership. Please involve the alumni in this

decision rather than leaving this up to a new president who may not be aligned

to our core values. I will make a difference to Thunderbird in any way I can -

just ask.

Carol Kraemer Orlando, FL 2013-04-16 For profit education is not inline with T-bird mentality and mindset....it goes

against all T-bird stands for!

Phil Ouellette Madison, WI 2013-04-16 I admit to being out of touch on the situation at Thunderbird but completely

agree this proposed partnership is at odds with the brand that has been built

over many decades. This is a decision that will have a profound impact on both

the relevance to future students and our ability to stand out among our peers. I

certainly do not understand the severity of the financial pressures the school

faces and must ultimately trust in the board. But if there is a chance to choose

an alternative course of action, I urge the board to suspend this pursuit until

those alternatives can be explored including a challenge to the Alumni

Network. If a challenge in this context was made in the past, I must have

missed it. Give us all a chance to put up or shut up.

Mark Ye woodinville, WA 2013-04-16 I'm an alum, I'm a fan of T-bird, and I don't want the brand diluted with a low

end for-profit company

Kelly Killian ASTORIA, NY 2013-04-16 Please see my commentary on the NYC Alumni Facebook group.

Mark Bradt Tiburon, CA 2013-04-16 I am a concerned alumni.

Devin Wright Salt Lake, UT 2013-04-16 Thunderbird is a strong enough name to stand on it's own. It's not about the

QUANTITY of students, rather the quality. If necessary, reduce the size of the

student body and make commensurate reductions in staff and overhead. I am

a t-bird for several reasons--a strong curriculum, a diverse, tight and motivated

student body, a reputation as THE leader in global business and an incredibly

fun yet challenging experience---which is THUNDERBIRD!

zuly cheng redondo beach, CA 2013-04-16 because i paid a lot of my education and it is a great school

James Roos Littleton, CO 2013-04-16 Don't cheapen the T-Bird name any further than it's already been lessened by

poor leadership.

May 1976 Grad

Anne Clement France 2013-04-16 I totally agree. Who is Laureate ? It's nice to get a financial injection but this

would definitely hurt the brand.

Gail Gibford-Capdepon Hilversum, Netherlands 2013-04-16 We have a tradition of excellence that the t-birds before us created and doing

this sells not only our future but the unique past that makes us special as T-

birds.

Craig Crossley Sarasota, FL 2013-04-16 Cheap brand = no brand

Timothy Lamb Easton, MD 2013-04-16 The seemingly myopic and capricious search to reinvent my alma mater.

Neil Mogre India 2013-04-16 I am proud to be from Thunderbird and I dont want to see the Thunderbird

brand get diluted!!

Alvaro Oliveira São Paulo, Brazil 2013-04-16 T-bird long standing tradition

gregory gottheimer weehawken, NJ 2013-04-16 poor choice of partner

George Vance Tucson, AZ 2013-04-16 Alumnus

Alexander von Gimbut Stockton, CA 2013-04-16 Are you kidding? This would be as bright an idea as it was calling us the Garvin

School... Shows again how wicked corporate thinking can get!

Dan Bartal Haifa, Israel, Israel 2013-04-17 Thunderbird is more than just an educational institution. It is a way of life. No

other institution could understand this.


Marcus Schaefer Winston Salem, NC 2013-04-17 While Laureate may be building some interesting programs overseas working

with ordering governments and international finance agencies, the jury is still

out on their role & reputation in the U.S.; I hate to see Thunderbird's reputation

tied to that brand until the picture is clearer.

Jairaj Mashru India 2013-04-17 Thunderbird is the most important experience of my life till now and I would like

future students to be able to benefit in the same way as I did. I do not believe

this new partnership with Laureate Education to be a good thing for past,

present and future students of Thunderbird. I am afraid that Laureate

Education's brand will significantly dilute Thunderbird's brand which would

outweigh any short-term financial benefit resulting from the partnership. Please

stop this before any irreparable damage is done.

William Amsden Japan 2013-04-17 I am deeply disappointed that this is happening, as it will cheapen

Thunderbird's brand and will lower the value of the degree that I earned there.

Right now I am wishing that I had gotten an MBA from the University of

Washington or an MIM from Portland State, two educational institutions that will

not 'sell out' as Thunderbird has decided to do.

William Amsden

Deva Panambur Jersey City, NJ 2013-04-17 Dilutes the brand. For profit has a poor reputation. I would have preferred a tie

up with a real university

Kevin Hatland Lafayette, CO 2013-04-17 I'm concerned that our school's reputation and brand is going to suffer.

Barbara Lanning Orlando, FL 2013-04-18 I feel this partnership is detrimental to the school's reputation as one of the

premier global business management graduate schools and will further

damage the character and tradition of the school.

Bill Queen Richmond, VA 2013-04-18 As a proud May 1984 graduate of AGSIM (as it was then called) I strongly urge

Thunderbird not to pursue this partnership into for-profit education.

Martyn Lindley Eugene, OR 2013-04-18 We need to protect the Thunderbird brand.

David Alfaro Zapopan, Mexico 2013-04-19 Im alumni from Thunderbird MBA with partnership with TEC de Monterrey. But

Laureate University will make my MBA feel cheaper and their reputation will be

afected.

Ismael Villa Mexico 2013-04-19 I'm a proud TB.

When we started our GMBA program, we were enrolling into both universities

(TB & Tec de Monterrey) as TOP universities.

Laureate Education, with all due respect, in Mexico is associated with 2nd level

education programs such as the UVM (Universidad Valle de Mexico) and it is

simply very easy to understand the differences between the educational

programs, the values that each institute promotes, and not to mention

installations and added value extra-curriuclar activities available for students.

I am concern that this partnership will take place, I believe it will downgrade the

value of our diploma.

Please stop this partnership!

Ismael Villa

GMBA 2012


Ismael Villa Mexico 2013-04-19 I'm a proud TB.

When we started our GMBA program, we were enrolling into both universities

(TB & Tec de Monterrey) as TOP universities.

Laureate Education, with all due respect, in Mexico is associated with 2nd level

education programs such as the UVM (Universidad Valle de Mexico) and it is

simply very easy to understand the differences between the educational

programs, the values that each institute promotes, and not to mention

installations and added value extra-curriuclar activities available for students.

I am concern that this partnership will take place, I believe it will downgrade the

value of our diploma.

Please stop this partnership!

Ismael Villa

GMBA 2012

Ricardo Lazo de la Vega Mexico 2013-04-21 Laurate Education is net well recognize for its standards in education adn in

Mexico is associated with another University which has not as good reputation

as the ITESM. Does this means that Thinderbird will become a mediocre

Education Institution? I hope not otherwise for sure I will ask for my refund and

will change to another ITESM program. Thanks

Maria Sol Delgado Lima, Peru 2013-04-21 It is scary. This is not what I signed up for when I was recruited. I feel like

dropping the GMBA program. Dr. Toro's (TEC) speech was not convincing at all

and I believe we do deserve a better explanation for this unexplainable non-

sense decision

Juan Venegas Lima, Peru 2013-04-21 I am currently on the Global MBA for Latin American Managers; and this would

the the last class of the program since they stopped recruiting people for next

year.

Christine Wilfer Appleton, WI 2013-04-22 The partnership with Laureate does nothing to improve the quality of education

at Thunderbird, weakens the brand, and severely undermines the credibility of

all current degree holders.

James Bruton Washington, DC 2013-04-22 I agree with aforestated comments that T-Bird must not delute its quality or

reputation.

Fred Hadlow Westmoreland, NH 2013-04-23 I believe there are better partnerships that Thunderbird could pursue.

Michael Eckhardt Vancouver, WA 2013-04-23 This "partnership" is ill-conceived and seriously dampens Thunderbird's brand.

I didn't pay $100,000 for a third rate off the shelf diploma.

Robert Dungan Asheville, NC 2013-04-23 I am a 1972 graduate of Thunderbird. There is a proud, global network of

alumni. I believe that this "merger" based on what I have seen will devalue and

ultimately destroy a fine institute. I thought laureate had to do with hair when I

first saw this. Thanks to the petitioners and may more join.

Janie Naber Tempe, AZ 2013-04-25 Thunderbird has always had a high recognition for its graduates. I feel by

partnering with Laureate Ed., Inc, you will be watering down the validity of the

degree.

Ricardo Parada Mexico 2013-04-25 The Thunderbird Brand is at stake because of this partnership and we should

raise our voice against it. I didn´t invest my money in getting and MBA from any

school related with Laureate. I chose Thunderbird because of it´s ranking and

because of it´s values. As alumni we should defend or alma matter, because at

the end we are the most affected.

Jennifer Hering Butler Newton, MA 2013-04-25 To not dilute the Thunderbird brand by allying with an organization of little or no

recognition or educational status.


augusto arce San Jose, Costa Rica 2013-04-25 Laureate in my country is seen as a merely commercial educational company

Joseph Vias Greenfield, MA 2013-04-26 At my first interview after graduation I was denied a position because the HR

person thought Thunderbird was an online MBA school like University of

Phoenix. Don't let this become a reality.

Travis Soto Draper, UT 2013-04-26 I don't think this change is good for the Thunderbird brand.

Erich Flynn Sandy, UT 2013-04-26 I am concerned that the association with Laureate will tarnish the Thunderbird

brand. It will also devalue the education received by thousands of alumni to

date.

John Osmun Cedar Hills, UT 2013-04-26 The degree I earned needs to maintain it's credibility in the business world.

takeo ishii miami, FL 2013-04-26 I chose and paid Thunderbird for many reasons, and certainly a partnership

(brand dilution and credibility of my MBA degree) with Laureate Education was

not one of them.

Steven Elliff Park City, UT 2013-04-26 Utter stupidity. Who in the hell thought this up?

James Sinor Los Angeles, CA 2013-04-26 I didn't pay $80k to attend the Sylvan Learning Center School of Business. Do

not degrade my degree! It is a terrible disservice to alumni. We can't

disassociate ourselves from Thunderbird now and go elsewhere to get our

degrees. We have them! This is the wrong path. Please kill the deal. NOW!

Vishal Jadhav India 2013-04-27 This proposed partnership is a frightening prospect for all stakeholders of

Thunderbird - alumni, students and employers, of the future of this school and

the quality of its education.

I am pained to observe the direction that this business school has been taking

over the past decade and question the motivation and desire of management to

establish the Thunderbird brand as a premier business management school.

Alexander Hume Alpine, UT 2013-04-28 Partnership with a low quality for-profit educational entity will not address

Thunderbird's financial issues. The partnership will reduce the value of the

school to future students and drive away the high quality students.

Kymberly Eide Minneapolis, MN 2013-04-29 I am very disappointed that Thunderbird would choose to partner with Laureate

Education. This alignment will drive substantial erosion of the brand and

prestige associated with a Thunderbird degree. We, as alumni, will suffer the

impact of this erosion - as will future graduates. I ask that you reconsider this

partnership.

Lucienne Mayberry Vienna, VA 2013-04-29 The quoted phrase : "This will cause permanent and irreparable harm to the

Thunderbird brand, ranking, and academic reputation" reflects exactly what I

think about this partnership.

Jose Aun Culiacán, Mexico 2013-04-30 I care about THUNDERBIRDS future.

Ariel Santamaria México, Mexico 2013-04-30 Laureate doesn' t have an excellent reputation in Latin America, in Mexico,

their must important university is Universidad del Valle de México that is a mid

Ranked School.

Dilip Sarangan Plano, TX 2013-04-30 The brand of Thunderbird has remained strong for over 65 years due to its

exclusivity and strength of its student body and level of education. Affiliation

with a third-party institution will dilute that exclusivity and cheapen the brand. I

love Thunderbird and my brand will forever be associated with it. Such a move

is likely to dilute the education of over 35,000 alumni globally and the school

must take steps to remain autonomous.

Michael Johnston Palm Desert, CA 2013-04-30 Need to stop the current decision

JUAN MANUEL DE

CARDENAS

Lima, Peru 2013-04-30 Thunderbird seems to be desperate to change its name every couple of years.

Either because of a multimillion donation or whetever reason, there seems to

be no interest in tradition. Keep your eyes on the ball is my message: quality

versus quantity both in faculty and job opportunities.


Fernando Gonzalez Mexico 2013-05-01 As a GMBA graduated, I am very concerrned of the results this partnership will

bring to the quality of education from Thunderbird.

Steve Nilsen St Petersburg, FL 2013-05-01 I hold a Thunderbird degree ('89)

Talia Castellanos Dallas, TX 2013-05-01 Because I'm a T-bird graduate and I wouldn't like to see the t-bird name

associate with this type of institution

Ajay Gundecha Singapore, United

Kingdom

2013-05-02 I think this deal weakens our brand. I fully understand we are in a weak

financial position, but believe we should merge with a high-quality institution for

survival not go bargain-bucket shopping at Laureate. I agree with James Fink

that we should follow the Monterey Institute of International Studies example,

or the more recent announcement of Reims and Rouen. I am sure there are

many schools who would be interested in Thunderbird and its brand.

Philippe DEYMES France 2013-05-02 The Thunderbird brand is an asset that belongs to all our community, alumni

included, and not just a few short-sighted managers. The lack of transparency

of this proposed transaction and the poor choice of partners are

obvious.Philippe J.E Deymes MIM , Class of DEC 71

MAGDA SOLIS Tegucigalpa, Honduras 2013-05-02 I want the school to continue to be an academical institution not a profit

oriented one.

Charles Nunu Houston, TX 2013-05-03 Thunderbird is lost and the Board and leadership have lost the vision of what

made us Unique.

Stephen Rutherford Long Beach, CA 2013-05-03 Class of !984. Did not sign up for a mail order degree. To associate the school

with a degree mill. If I wanted to be a barber or a chef I would have sign up with

Laureate. Keep the mystique. I have numerous storie and examples how the

uniqueness of Thunderbird has opened doors to boardroom.

Barbara Zucker Cary, NC 2013-05-06 My degree and Thunderbird's brand is being undermined. Please stop this

Partnership fro going forward.

vic fontaine boca raton, FL 2013-05-07 T-Bird has always been an environment where uniqueness of focus and

previously demonstrated interest in international studies has been at the

forefront. Many of the alumni I know have had as a result unique global impact.

The school 's products very frequently have become " A Peacock in the Land of

Penguins" a book which I consider mandatory reading for the life and career

changer folks I mentor and coach. As a resume and presentation must stand

out above the crowd in today's world if one expects to succeed, I concur with

the concerns and sentiments express by others signing this petition.

--

Vic Fontaine

<a href="http://www.aspirationaldirections.com"

rel="nofollow">www.aspirationaldirections.com</a>

<a href="http://www.lifeandcareerchangers.com"

rel="nofollow">www.lifeandcareerchangers.com</a>

<a href="mailto:[email protected]"

rel="nofollow">[email protected]</a>

Cell: 561-350-4514

Home Office 561 241-7242


Patrick Buckley Austin, TX 2013-05-08 It was not until recently I heard about a potential merger between Thunderbird

and Laureate. Not once, have I have been contacted, notified, updated on this

merger. I am deeply I am deeply concerned about the future value of the

Thunderbird brand and degree. I understand that the primary reason for

Thunderbird seeking a third party with whom to partner is financial. Why, then,

have I NEVER been contacted by mail, phone or email by anyone at

Thunderbird asking for a donation? I would have gladly done so. Alumni need

to unite to understand more about this potential merger and its potential

benefits and negatives.

Lakshmi Deepthi

Seethalam

India 2013-05-08 Partnering with an unworthy party for financial reasons will not bode will for

Thunderbird. It will further degrade the brand and the school's relationship with

its alumni network. Please do not let our brand get diluted thus. Either decide

on a better represented partner or try solving the financial crisis in some other

way. Include all stakeholders in the decision.

Robert Hans Coral Gables, FL 2013-05-09 I echo the views herein.

Jose Ignacio Ruelas

Rodriguez

La Jolla, CA 2013-05-09 Because I am a T-Bird

Victor Sanchez Vaughan, Canada 2013-05-09 Is important to mantain the reputation level of the school, I have seen this type

of agreements with other institutions and the only benefited is the most lower

ranked school, I think we should mantain our reputation by keeping quality

standards

Sebastien Le Calvez Toronto, Canada 2013-05-09 Because I'm an ex-alumni

Shannon Dinwoodie Oklahoma City, OK 2013-05-10 <a href="mailto:[email protected]"

rel="nofollow">[email protected]</a>

Scott Avirett Hong Kong, Hong Kong 2013-05-10 it's a bad partnership

Coleen Curry Muir Beach, CA 2013-05-10 Damage to Thunderbird Brand

Ronald Mark Logan Phoenix, AZ 2013-05-10 Because I'm a proud T-Bird! Someone who sought the MIM out for it's

unquiness and international expertise. The administration, BoT, career center,

Pres., among other have failed to live up to the standards of the vast majority of

alum. As a result, they've decided to sell the Mystique, reputation, vested value

in alum, and brand...to a low quality, mass produced, education retailer. If this

deal goes through......it'll be a shame.

Jeffrey Markley Hong Kong, Hong Kong 2013-05-10 The Laureate Partnership is Wrong

Dieter Bruns Macau, Macao 2013-05-11 Dilutes tbird brand and its future

Peter Deneen Hong Kong, Hong Kong 2013-05-11 Alumnus Class of May 1984

Dirk Russell Japan 2013-05-12 There has been no word from the School's management. What is really going

on?

Avinder Singh Bindra India 2013-05-12 I think this partnership dilutes the academic value of the Thunderbird brand

value.

Mireille Quintin Mexico 2013-05-12 No partnership with Laureate Education. I regect it

Nevin Hill CAYCE, SC 2013-05-12 I, in no way shape or form, want my education compared to anything that

Shaquille O'Neal has achieved academically...

Hanson Wong Hong Kong, Hong Kong 2013-05-13 The Thunderbird Laureate Partnership will permanently damage Thunderbird

brand name and reputation. I as a T-bird care so much about Thunderbird.

Douglas Morin Hong Kong, Hong Kong 2013-05-13 I don't see the synergy with hospitality and culinary arts. Not interested in

having an MBA from an on-line university!

Peter HOng Huynh Hong Kong, Hong Kong 2013-05-13 Simple, T-bird brand is too strong for this partnership;our interest is different


Erik Saether Trondheim, Norway 2013-05-14 As a Tbird alum, I am worried about a for-profit education provider damaging

the mission and brand of Tbird and would like to understand the alternatives.

Lorena Garcia Scottsdale, AZ 2013-05-14 I'm an alumni and care about the school

Antoine Eloi Philadelphia, PA 2013-05-15 This partnership will effectively destroy the Thunderbird brand and would

render our diplomas useless. Why more efforts are not being invested into

making T-birds more employable/marketable is beyond me.

kimberley kalesnik macau, Macao 2013-05-15 want more details of this prposal. does not sound like a good fit for tbird

Christopher Carroll Phoenix, AZ 2013-05-16 I have no desire to see Thunderbird's already fragile brand be further damaged

by affiliation with for-profit education, specifically Laureate.

If the school has problems that need resolving, it need look no further than to

its 40,000+ alumni for solutions that place the value and well-being of

Thunderbird first.

Irvin Varkonyi Fairfax, VA 2013-05-16 I am a Tbird and greatly value the brand Tbird for my professional career.

Michelle To Hong Kong, Hong Kong 2013-05-18 We defend the brand of Thunderbird against the proposed partnership with

Laureate Education, Inc.

Joseph Urso Seoul, Korea, Republic of 2013-05-19 I am a T-Bird Alum

Todd Judy Singapore, Singapore 2013-05-19 Save the Thunderbird brand

John Xue 大理, China 2013-05-20 No. 1 vs one of 1,000

Alessandro Perri Columbia, SC 2013-05-21 Profile and calibre of partner institutions is inferior - will diminish prestige of the

Thunderbird brand and weaken its commitment to excellence- the school

needs creative partnerships with top ranking institutions corporations and

international organizations, more high level graduate and possibly doctoral

program - not a slide down the university of Phoenix lane...

Richard Strayer tucson, AZ 2013-05-23 The "Financial Motive" and alternatives need to be shared with the Alumni. We

are 40,000 strong and have a vested interest in the value of our degrees and

the future value as we go forward. Please reconsider our input prior to a

decision, which currently on the surface, will negatively affect our relationship

and unique place within Global Management.

Jagriti Chadha New York, NY 2013-05-26 Marketing 101 - lets look at brand fit. Is this the quality of our thinking now at

Thunderbird?

ERIN GOLDEN PROVINCETOWN, MA 2013-05-26 To repeat the obvious - Thunderbird will be damaged by any relationship with

these for-profit "higher education wannabes" who overcharge students and

underperform against their promises to students. Stop this insanity now! Focus

on building a better brand for Thunderbird. There is a new generation of

"millenials" who are more international in their thinking than ever before -

including my son, a sophomore studying International Relations at Tufts

University in Boston. He was originally considering Thunderbird for his

graduate work - but, if the deal with Laureate goes through - I will make sure

that he does not even apply to my Alma Mater, Thunderbird. This makes me

very frustrated and sad. What a pathetic ending this will be for what was once

a school to be proud of. Erin Golden

Kimberly Rifflard Trumbull, CT 2013-05-26 I think partnering with a school of their type is a big mistake. I value the

reputation of the school from which I obtained my degree.

Vicki Harder Salt Lake City, UT 2013-05-29 The reputation of the school is at stake here!

Tucker White Reno, NV 2013-05-30 Dilution of Degree Value

Paul Hamlin Sturgeon Bay, WI 2013-05-30 The agreement was not made public, it is unclear what Sylvan gets and what

Thunderbird gets and in my view this will tremendously harm the school.


Rob Fox Chicago, IL 2013-05-30 - Over the last few months, I have met up with numerous Thunderbirds from a

variety of classes. Inevitably the potential partnership with Laureate comes up

and makes Thunderbird look like a joke. These alum are not you average

never involved kind, these are people were/are the face of the institution -

Presidents of TSG, leaders of the Tower Project, Campus Ambassadors,

Foundations Leaders, Club Leaders, ... you name it.

- While there have been communications to try to add further detail the

partnership. They are continually vague and don't answer questions in any

additional detail.

Francois de Vincens de

Causans

Los Altos, CA 2013-05-30 Avoid brand dilution - do not feel this is really needed.

Antony Sakellaropoulos Αθήνα, Greece 2013-05-31 Thunderbird has a unique brand, let's not dillute it for any reason!

Ralph B. McIntyre Oakmont, PA 2013-06-02 Dilutes the academic integrity of Thunderbird's International MBA. Better to

reinstate language training & facility as part of core curriculum.

Comments from T-Birds Regarding Proposed Thunderbird-Laureate Joint Venture

Documents

thunderbird alumni

future of thunderbird

assosiating thunderbird

thunderbird mystique

mission of thunderbird

potential thunderbird

thunderbird board of

schools brand andtakes