Part II – Responses to Comments Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-523 COMMENTS AND RESPONSES: POSEIDON (APPLICANT) CONTENTS COMMENTS AND RESPONSES: POSEIDON (APPLICANT) ...................... II-523 Comment Set AP1: Poseidon (Applicant) ...................................................... II-524 Comment Set AP2: Poseidon (Applicant) ..................................................... II-609 The master responses provided in Section II.2, Master Responses, MR-1 through MR-8, address similar comments received from multiple commenters on the Draft Supplemental EIR and, therefore, many individual responses to comments refer back to the master responses. These Master Responses are: • MR-1, Scope of the Commission’s Discretionary Action • MR-2, Lease Modification Project Scope • MR-3, Responsible Vs. Lead Agency & Supplemental Vs. Subsequent EIR • MR-4, Piecemealing • MR-5, Diffuser Entrainment Mortality and Species Affected • MR-6, Marine Protected Areas • MR-7, Cumulative Impacts • MR-8, Alternatives
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Part II – Responses to Comments
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-523
COMMENTS AND RESPONSES: POSEIDON (APPLICANT)
CONTENTS
COMMENTS AND RESPONSES: POSEIDON (APPLICANT)...................... II-523
Comment Set AP1: Poseidon (Applicant)...................................................... II-524
Comment Set AP2: Poseidon (Applicant)..................................................... II-609
The master responses provided in Section II.2, Master Responses, MR-1 through MR-8,
address similar comments received from multiple commenters on the Draft
Supplemental EIR and, therefore, many individual responses to comments refer back to
the master responses. These Master Responses are:
• MR-1, Scope of the Commission’s Discretionary Action
• MR-2, Lease Modification Project Scope
• MR-3, Responsible Vs. Lead Agency & Supplemental Vs. Subsequent EIR
• MR-4, Piecemealing
• MR-5, Diffuser Entrainment Mortality and Species Affected
• MR-6, Marine Protected Areas
• MR-7, Cumulative Impacts
• MR-8, Alternatives
Part II – Responses to Comments
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-524
Comment Set AP1: Poseidon (Applicant)
AP1-1
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-525
AP1-1cont.
AP1-2
AP1-3
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-526 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-3cont.
AP1-4
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-527
AP1-4cont.
AP1-5
AP1-6
AP1-7
AP1-8
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-528 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-8cont.
AP1-9
AP1-10
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-529
AP1-10cont.
AP1-11
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-530 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-12
AP1-13
AP1-14
AP1-15
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-531
AP1-16
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-532 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-17
AP1-18
AP1-19
AP1-20
AP1-21
AP1-22
AP1-23
AP1-24
AP1-25
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-533
AP1-25cont.
AP1-26
AP1-27
AP1-28
AP1-29
AP1-30
AP1-31
AP1-32
AP1-33
AP1-34
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-534 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-34cont.
AP1-35
AP1-36
AP1-37
AP1-38
AP1-39
AP1-40
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-535
AP1-41
AP1-42
AP1-43
AP1-44
AP1-45
AP1-46
AP1-47
AP1-48
AP1-49
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-536 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-49cont.
AP1-50
AP1-51
AP1-52
AP1-53
AP1-54
AP1-55
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-537
AP1-56
AP1-57
AP1-58
AP1-59
AP1-60
AP1-61
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-538 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-61cont.
AP1-62
AP1-63
AP1-64
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-539
AP1-64cont.
AP1-65
AP1-66
AP1-67
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-540 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-67cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-541
AP1-67cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-542 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-67cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-543
AP1-67cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-544 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-67cont.
AP1-68
AP1-69
AP1-70
AP1-71
AP1-72
AP1-73
AP1-74
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-545
AP1-75
AP1-76
AP1-77
AP1-78
AP1-79
AP1-80
AP1-81
AP1-82
AP1-83
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-546 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-83cont.
AP1-84
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-547
AP1-84cont.
AP1-85
AP1-86
AP1-87
AP1-88
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-548 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-88cont.
AP1-89
AP1-90
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-549
AP1-90cont.
AP1-91
AP1-92
AP1-93
AP1-94
AP1-95
AP1-96
AP1-97
AP1-98
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-550 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-98cont.
AP1-99
AP1-100
AP1-101
AP1-102
AP1-103
AP1-104
AP1-105
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-551
AP1-105cont.
AP1-106
AP1-107
AP1-108
AP1-109
AP1-110
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-552 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-111
AP1-112
AP1-113
AP1-114
AP1-115
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-553
AP1-116
AP1-117
AP1-118
AP1-119
AP1-120
AP1-121
AP1-122
AP1-123
AP1-124
AP1-125
AP1-126
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-554 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-126cont.
AP1-127
AP1-128
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-555
AP1-129
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-556 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-129cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-557
AP1-129cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-558 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-130
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-559
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-560 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-561
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-562 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-563
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-564 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-565
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-566 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-567
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-568 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-569
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-570 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-571
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-572 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-573
AP1-130cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-574 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-131
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-575
AP1-131cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-576 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-131cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-577
AP1-131cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-578 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-131cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-579
AP1-131cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-580 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-131cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-581
AP1-132
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-582 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-132cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-583
AP1-132cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-584 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-132cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-585
AP1-132cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-586 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-132cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-587
AP1-132cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON (cont.)
October 2017 Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease AmendmentPage II-588 Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project
AP1-132cont.
Part II – Responses to Comments
RESPONSE TO COMMENT SET AP1: POSEIDON
Final Supplemental EIR – PRC 1980.1 Lease Amendment October 2017Poseidon Seawater Desalination at Huntington Beach Project Page II-589
AP1-1 This comment summarizes the background and proposed project included
in the Lease Modification Project.
AP1-2 The commenter summarizes the significant impacts identified in the DraftSupplemental EIR. With respect to the severity of the adverse impacts to
marine life, please see Responses to Comments AP1-3 through AP1-14.