Top Banner
Visit www.steel-sci.com for more details and examples of our work SCI EuroCodE WEbInarS 2012 presented by the SCI E: [email protected] T: +44 (0)1344 636 500 w: www.steel-sci.com\courses SCI serving engineers, specifiers, manufacturers and designers in every aspect of steel design since 1988 TM
18

Combined Axial and Bending

Oct 26, 2014

Download

Documents

fidels09
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Combined Axial and Bending

Visit www.steel-sci.com for more details and examples of our work

SCI EuroCodE WEbInarS 2012 presented by the SCI

E: [email protected]: +44(0)1344636500w: www.steel-sci.com\courses

SCI serving engineers, specifiers, manufacturers and designers in every aspect of steel design since 1988

“ “

TM

Page 2: Combined Axial and Bending

1

Combined axial compression and

bending

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Combined compression and bending

Two philosophies

1. Interaction method, 6.3.3

2. General method, 6.3.4

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

BS 5950 – simplified approach

Page 3: Combined Axial and Bending

2

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

BS 5950 – more exact approach

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

BS 5950 – more exact approach

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

EC3 Interaction method, 6.3.3

1

M1

Rkz,

Edz,Edz,yz

M1

Rky,LT

Edy,Edy,yy

M1

Rky

Ed

M

MMk

M

MMk

N

N(Eq 6.61)

(Eq 6.62)1

M1

Rkz,

Edz,Edz,zz

M1

Rky,LT

Edy,Edy,zy

M1

Rkz

Ed

M

MMk

M

MMk

N

N

Edz,Edy, ; MM Are the additional moments due to the shift of neutral axis for Class 4 sections

Page 4: Combined Axial and Bending

3

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Some odd terms

Rky N

Rkz N

Rky,LTM

Rkz,M

yy fA Major axis flexural buckling resistance

yz fA Minor axis flexural buckling resistance

yyLT fW LTB resistance

yz fW Minor axis bending resistance

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

EC3 Interaction method, 6.3.3

1

M1

yz

Edz,yz

Rdb,

Edy,yy

Rdy,b,

Ed

fW

Mk

M

Mk

N

N(Eq 6.61)

1

M1

yz

Edz,zz

Rdb,

Edy,zy

Rdz,b,

Ed

fW

Mk

M

Mk

N

N(Eq 6.62)

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

The k coefficients

Taken from Annex A or B (NA may decide)

UK NA says…. use either

SCI says…..use Annex B• “It looks easier”

M1Rkc,y

Edmy 8.01

N

NC

Page 5: Combined Axial and Bending

4

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Columns in simple construction

From access-steel.com

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Annex B, Cm factors

is the ratio of the bending moment at the ends

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

A simplified approach

I Struct E Technical Note, November 2008

85.0Rkz,

Edz,mz

Rdb,

Edy,my

Rdy,b,

Ed M

MC

M

MC

N

N

78.078.0Rkz,

Edz,mz

Rdb,

Edy,

Rdz,b,

Ed M

MC

M

M

N

N

Page 6: Combined Axial and Bending

5

© 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

A much simplified approach

In the ISE Manual

78.0Rkz,

Edz,mz

yRd,b,

Edy,

zRd,b,

Ed M

MC

M

M

N

N

Combined Bending and Axial

Numerical demonstration

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

590 kN

590 kN30 kNm

Major axis

2 kNm

Minor axis

203 UKC 46 S3555 m long

Page 7: Combined Axial and Bending

new essential eurocode design guidesnew titles have been added to SCI’s growing library of essential design guides to Eurocode 3 and 4.

simple joints • Composite • Beams & Columns • torsion • roBustness

ConCise Guide • BraCed Frames • Worked examples • desiGn data

These publications provide: look-up tables, graphs and relevant advice that assist the design process including: loading, sub-grade, member and connection design.

For further details: tel: +44 (0)1344 636505 • email: [email protected]

New titles Now available:

More eurocode favourites:

P358Joints in Steel Construction: Simple Joints to Eurocode 3 (The ‘Green Book’)

P362Steel Building Design: Concise Guide

P359Composite Design of Steel Framed Buildings

P363Steel Building Design: Design Data (The ‘Blue Book’)

P360Stability of Steel Beams and Columns

P365Steel Building Design: Medium Rise Braced Frames

P385Design of Steel Beams in Torsion

P387Steel Building Design: Worked Examples for Students

P391Structural Robustness of Steel Framed Buildings

TM

Page 8: Combined Axial and Bending

6

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Example N-M

• Classify – Class 1

• Cross section - OK

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Flexural resistance

Major axis

L/iy = 5000/88.2 = 56.7

1 = 76

Minor axis

75.0767.56

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Which curve?• Table 6.2, page 58

Buckling curve

Cross section Limits Buckling

about axis S 275

S 355

t f 40 mm y – y

z – z

a

b

h/b

1

,2

40 mm < t f 100 y – y

z – z

b

c

t f 100 mm y – y

z – z

b

c Ro

lled

sec

tio

ns

hy y

z

zb

tf

h/b

1

,2

t f > 100 mm y – y

z – z

d

d

Page 9: Combined Axial and Bending

7

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Flexural resistance

Major axis

L/iy = 5000/88.2 = 56.7

1 = 76.4

Curve ‘b’

Minor axis

74.04.767.56

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Flexural resistance

Major axis

L/iy = 5000/88.2 = 56.7

1 = 76.4

Curve ‘b’

= 0.75

Nb,y,Rd = 0.75 × 5870 × .355

Nb,y,Rd = 1563 kN

Minor axis

74.04.767.56

Page 10: Combined Axial and Bending

8

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Flexural resistance

Major axis

L/iy = 5000/88.2 = 56.7

1 = 76.4

Curve ‘b’

= 0.75

Nb,y,Rd = 0.75 × 5870 × .355

Nb,y,Rd = 1563 kN

Minor axis

L/iz = 5000/51.3 = 97.5

1 = 76.4

74.04.767.56 28.14.76

5.97

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Which curve?• Table 6.2, page 58

Buckling curve

Cross section Limits Buckling

about axis S 275

S 355

t f 40 mm y – y

z – z

a

b

h/b

1

,2

40 mm < t f 100 y – y

z – z

b

c

t f 100 mm y – y

z – z

b

c Ro

lled

sec

tio

ns

hy y

z

zb

tf

h/b

1

,2

t f > 100 mm y – y

z – z

d

d

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Flexural resistance

Major axis

L/iy = 5000/88.2 = 56.7

1 = 76.4

Curve ‘b’

= 0.75

Nb,y,Rd = 0.75 × 5870 × .355

Nb,y,Rd = 1563 kN

Minor axis

L/iy = 5000/51.3 = 97.5

1 = 76.4

Curve ‘c’

74.04.767.56 28.14.76

5.97

Page 11: Combined Axial and Bending

9

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Flexural resistance

Major axis

L/iy = 5000/88.2 = 56.7

1 = 76.4

Curve ‘b’

= 0.75

Nb,y,Rd = 0.75 × 5870 × .355

Nb,y,Rd = 1563 kN

Minor axis

L/iy = 5000/51.3 = 97.5

1 = 76.4

Curve ‘c’

= 0.40

Nb,z,Rd = 0.40 × 5870 × .355

Nb,z,Rd = 834 kN

74.04.767.56

y 28.14.765.97

z

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

LTB resistance

Triangular BMD

From NCCI, C1 = 1.77

kNm1.3465000

500077.1

z2

t2

z

w2z

2

cr EI

GI

I

IEIM

71.0101.346

355104976

3

cr

yyLT

M

fW

Page 12: Combined Axial and Bending

10

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Choice of curve

h/b = 203/203 = 1.0

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Reduction factor,

86.0LT

LT

Page 13: Combined Axial and Bending

11

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Correction factor, kc

752.033.1

1

033.033.1

1c

k

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

a little more resistance

• 6.3.2.3(2)

fLT

modLT,

2LTc 8.00.2115.01 kf

88.08.071.00.21752.015.01 2 f

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

a little more resistance

• 6.3.2.3(2)

fLT

modLT,

97.088.0

86.0modLT,

kNm171100.1

3551049797.0 63

b.Rd M

Page 14: Combined Axial and Bending

12

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Equivalent moment factors

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Equivalent moment factors

• Major axis

• = 0

• Cmy = CmLT = 0.6

• Minor axis

• = 0

• Cmz = 0.6

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

kyy factor

• Table B2 refers to Table B1

Page 15: Combined Axial and Bending

13

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

kyy factor

M1Rky

Edmy

M1Rky

Edymyyy /

8.01/

)2.0(1

N

NC

N

NCk

72.01/)1563(

590)2.074.0(16.0

78.01/)1563(

5908.016.0

So kyy = 0.72

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

kzz factor

So kzz = 1.19

M1Rkz

Edmz

M1Rkz

Edzmzzz /

4.11/

6.021

N

NC

N

NCk

43.11/)834(

5906.0)28.12(16.0

19.11/)834(

5904.116.0

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

kzy factor

So kzy = 0.80

)/(25.0

1.01

)/(25.0

1.01

M1Rkz

Ed

mLT

M1Rkz

Ed

mLT

zzy

N

N

C

N

N

Ck

74.0)1/834(

590

25.06.0

28.11.01

80.0)1/834(

590

25.06.0

1.01

Page 16: Combined Axial and Bending

14

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

kyz factor

kyz = 0.6 kzz = 0.6 × 1.19 = 0.71

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Verification (6.61)

0.1/)/(/ M1z.Rk

z.Edz.Edyz

M1y.RkLT

y.Edy.Edyy

M1Rky

Ed

M

MMk

M

MMk

N

N

52.01/9.81

271.0

)1/171(

3072.0

1/)1563(

590

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Verification (6.62)

0.1/)/(/ M1z.Rk

z.Edz.Edzz

M1y.RkLT

y.Edy.Edzy

M1Rkz

Ed

M

MMk

M

MMk

N

N

88.01/9.81

219.1

)1/171(

3080.0

1/)834(

590

So the column is satisfactory!

Page 17: Combined Axial and Bending

15

(c) 2010 The Steel Construction Institute

Comments

• At least its not Annex A!

• As a minimum, use a spreadsheet!

Page 18: Combined Axial and Bending

TM

www.steel-sci.com/Membership+44 (0)1344 636 525

For further details: Tel: +44 (0)1344 636525 • Email: [email protected]

SCI MeMberS benefItS

Advisory Service▪▪ Any member employee can call one

of SCI’s advisory engineers direct.

▪▪ Rated as the most important benefit for many member companies.

▪▪ An advisor on hand to answer any type of question, complex and outside of the provision of the relevant design standard.

▪▪ Advice and explanation given to underlying theories.

▪▪ An alternative approach to design issues.

On-line library of Advisory Questions

▪▪ A library of advisory questions and answers is available through Steebiz.

▪▪ Questions and answers of wider interest subjects will be made public for members.

▪▪ No information about any individual, project or company is ever made public via this system the questions are re-written in a general form.

▪▪ Add a “watch” to this area of the Steelbiz site, so that your receive the latest questions and answer when posted.

Contact the Advisory Desk on +44 (0)1344 636 555 or email: [email protected]

Steelbiz▪▪ 24 hour on-line technical resource.

▪▪ Access to view and download any technical resource, guidance, design data, products and services, case studies, worked examples and some CPD lectures.

▪▪ Host to a number of design tools for engineers designing to EC3, within the member content area.

www.steelbiz.org

Publications▪▪ Continued high reputation in providing

information to fill the knowledge gap.

▪▪ Guidance given to latest research and industry standards.

▪▪ Free copy of each latest SCI publication sent to a named member contact.

▪▪ Additional copies available at £250 per office per year.

▪▪ Individual copies can be purchased at a discount (generally 50%) off the full price.

▪▪ Approximately 10 new publications produced per year.

Contact Publications on +44 (0)1344 636 505 or email: [email protected]

www.steel-sci.org/Information/Publications

Training▪▪ Public courses▪▫ Run at various locations▪▫ Opportunity to meet the experts▪▫ Discount on course attendance

▪▪ In-house training provided:▪▫ Can be taken at a venue(s)

of choice.▪▫ Provides corporate wide training

across the company.▪▫ Offers bespoke course content.▪▫ Trains all employees at one time.

▪▪ On-line training via the Internet:▪▫ Reaching a wider audience.▪▫ Learning in the office or at home.

Contact Education on +44 (0)1344 636 500 or email: [email protected]

www.steel-sci.org/courses

Membership of SCI provides essential support to your business in a number of ways . . .