Close Encounters with Close Encounters with Bank Runs Bank Runs •Ray B. Dawn •Chairman •CDIC (Taiwan) •Nov. 1, 2007 6 th IADI Annual Conference
Mar 29, 2015
Close Encounters with Close Encounters with Bank RunsBank Runs
•Ray B. Dawn
•Chairman
•CDIC (Taiwan)•Nov. 1, 2007
6th IADI
Annual Conference
2
The Way We Were
Apocalypse Now
The Day After Tomorrow
Contents
3
The Way We Were
4
Source: www.answers.com/topic/bank-run
CREATED/PUBLISHED: Cin'ti ; N.Y. : Strobridge Lith. Co., c1895. CREATOR: Strobridge & Co. Lith.
History Has It
5
Panic Depositors at a Failed Bank, NYC (1914)
6Source: CDIC (Taiwan)
Depositors at a Failed Bank in Taiwan(Jan. 2007)
7Source: CDIC (Taiwan)
CDIC Staff Tried to Control the Run (Jan, 2007)
8
Source: CDIC (Taiwan)
Piles of Money to be Withdrawn (Jan, 2007)
9
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
1990 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2002 2003 2004 2007
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Deposit depletion ratio
number of bank runs
%
Bank Run: An Inconvenient Truth (1990~2007)
Runs
10
Types of Institutions Number of Bank Runs
Credit Cooperatives 13
Credit Departments of Farmers’ and Fishermen’s Associations (FFA)
31
Banks 14
Total 58
Bank Runs in Taiwan
Source: CDIC (Taiwan)
11
Some Bank Runs Are More Serious Than Others
Deposit Depletion Cases
Less than 10% 18
10~20% 18
20~30% 9
30~40% 5
40~50% 1
50~60% 1
Source: CDIC (Taiwan)
12
Date Number of Institutions Depletion Ratios
1996/5/25 2 credit departments of FFAs 5% & 13%
1997/1/13 2 credit departments of FFAs 10% & 14%
1997/6/11 2 credit cooperatives 32% & 47%
1998/11/2 3 credit departments of FFAs 1%, 1% & 2%
1999/6/28
~7/30
2 credit cooperatives & 2 credit departments of FFAs
5%, 11%, 21% & 63%
2000/5/1
~6/8
3 banks 8%~13%
2007/1/4 2 banks 17%~35%
Bank Runs Can Be Contagious
Source: CDIC (Taiwan)
13
Case Date & Depletion Ratio
Bank A Feb. 1994, 11% + July 1999, 6%
Bank B Sept. 1995, 15% + July 1999, 11%
Bank C Dec. 1995, 12% + May 2000, 8%
Bank D April 2000, 20% + April 2003, 4%
Bank E July 1998, – + Nov. 1998, 1%
Bank F Nov. 1994, 4% + Feb. 1996, 28%
Bank G May 1996, 35% + March 1999, –
Bank H Feb. 1996, 22% + Jan. 2007, 10%
People Barely Learnt from History
Source: CDIC (Taiwan)
14
• Mutual Assistance Network of Credit
Cooperatives
8 runs
• County Assistance Network of Credit
Departments of FFA
24 runs
14 runs
5 runs
• CDIC (Taiwan)
• Financial Restructuring Fund (FRF)
Liquidity Providers to Bank Runs (1990~2007)
15
How Financial Markets Responded to the Run of One Failed Bank (2007/1/5 as 100)
94.00
95.00
96.00
97.00
98.00
99.00
100.00
101.00
102.00
2006/11/23 2006/12/14 2007/1/5 2007/1/26 2007/2/16
%
Taiwan Stock Index
NTD/USD
Overnight Interest Rate
16Note: D-day means the day CDIC took over the FI under the instruction of FSC.
Source: CDIC (Taiwan)
Paces of Deposit Depletion(2006 & 2007)
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6%
D-day
D-5D-10D-15D-20 D+5 D+10 D+15
-35
-30
-25
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10 %
D-day
D-5D-10D-15D-20 D+5 D+10 D+15
-40
-30
-20
-10
0
10
20%
D-day
D-5D-10D-15D-20 D+5 D+10 D+15
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10%
D-day
D-5D-10D-15D-20 D+5 D+10 D+15
Bank K Bank L
Bank M Bank N
17
Passbook Deposits Took the Hit (2007)
Bank X
8.00%
80.60%
11.40%
Bank Y
7.42%
77.88%
14.70%
Bank Z
2.74%
75.83%
21.43%
Checking Accounts
Passbook Deposits
Time Deposits
18
Individuals at the Gate
Bank X
95.29%
4.71%
Bank Y
92.21%
7.79%
Institutions
Individuals
Bank Z
93.14%
6.86%
19
Bank Y
56.66%
43.34%
Bank Z
55.92%
44.08%
Female
MaleBank X
50.26%49.74%
Female Depositors Seemed More Concerned
20
The Mid-Age Appeared More Cautious
Bank X
3.84%15.93%
25.46%
25.05%
17.07%
12.65%
Bank Y
8.81%
19.11%
28.71%
25.05%
18.32%
30-39
40-49
Bank Z
3.63%15.64%
27.10%23.36%
17.19%
13.08%
20-29
Above 60
50-59
Below 20
21
Bank X
98.51%
1.49%
Bank Y
95.58%
4.42%
Below NTD 1 million
Bank Z
96.21%
3.79%
Above NTD 1 million
Small Depositors Were Prone to Panic
22
Apocalypse Now
23
From Main Street to Wall Street
B
AAA
AA
A
WallStreet
NINJ ABorrowers
SubprimeLoans
B
BB
A
BBB
BBB
BB
Mortgage-backed
Securities(MBSs)
CollateralizedDebt Obligations
(CDOs)
AAA
AA
……
.
.
.
24
Events Associated with Subprime Chaos
Date Events
April New Century filed for bankruptcy
May UBS posted a loss of SF 150 million in Q1, 2007
July Bear Stearns lost $20 billion and closed two funds
August 6 AHMI filed for bankruptcy
August 9 BNP Paribas closed three funds
August 9~20 Central Banks injected liquidities to financial markets
September 14 Run on the Northern Rock Bank
2585
90
95
100
105
110
115
2007/1/2 2007/2/13 2007/3/27 2007/5/8 2007/6/19 2007/7/31 2007/9/11
%
DJIA
FTSE
Nikkei 225
Volatile Stock Markets in 2007(2007/1/2 as 100)
26
Central Banks to the Rescue (Aug. 9~16)
Central Banks
Liquidity Injected
(US$ billion)
ECB 290.1
FED 81
Canada 3.8
Japan 13.55
Australia 10.14
Source: Reuters
27
Run on a British Bank
28
Group Blame Factor
The Borrowers
Mortgage Brokers
Appraisers
Mortgage Lenders
Wall Street
Rating Agencies
The Fed
Let the Finger-Pointing Begin
Source: http://money.cnn.com/galleries/2007/fortune/0709/gallery.subprime_blame.fortune/index.html
29
The Day After Tomorrow
30
• The Roles of DIs and IADI
• Cooperation among Safety Net Players Across Borders
• Insurance Schemes for Direct Financing?
• Liquidity Adequacy vs. Capital Adequacy?
What’s Next ?
Thank You