8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
1/35WWW.AMERICANPROGRESS.O
Climate Change
An Ununded Mandate
By Fran Sussman, Cathleen Kelly, and Kate Gordon October 2013
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
2/35
Climate ChangeAn Ununded Mandate
By Fran Sussman, Cathleen Kelly, and Kate Gordon October 2013
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
3/35
1 Introduction and summary
4 Whats past is prologue
8 How much will responding to climate change
cost the United States?
17 Reducing the long-term cost of climate change
25 Conclusion
26 About the authors & Acknowledgements
27 Endnotes
Contents
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
4/35
1 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Introduction and summary
Tere are many reasons why we should do somehing abou climae change. One
o hem is ha we canno aord no o.
oughly one year ago, Supersorm Sandy swep along he easern seaboard rom
Florida o Maine, evenually reaching as ar wes as Ohio and Michigan.1 Te hur-
ricane caused more han 150 deahs, damaged 659,000 homes, and disruped mil-
lions o lives as ransi sysems, cellular phone neworks, and oher criical services
ailed or closed.2 Te region suered $65 billion in damages and economic losses,including power ouages ha emporarily closed 200,000 small businesses and
led o 2 million los workdays.3 Almos a year laer, in Sepember, a caasrophic
Colorado sorm dumped a years worh o rain in abou 24 hours, washing away
roads in Boulder and nearby owns and causing housands o people o ee.4 Te
sorm caused eigh deahs and an esimaed $2 billion in propery losses.5
Unorunaely, Supersorm Sandy and he Colorado oods are no isolaed evens.
In ac, a Cener or American Progress analysis rom his pas February compiled
daa rom he Naional Oceanic and Amospheric Adminisraion, or NOAA, and
ound ha here were 25 exreme weaher evens in 2011 and 2012 alone ha
caused a oal o $188 billion in economic losses.6 Over he pas hree decades, he
requency o hese billion-dollar evens has increased dramaicallyrom an annual
average o ewer han wo such evens per year in he 1980s o an annual average
o more han nine evens rom 2010 o 2012.7 Scieniss are increasingly nding
evidence direcly linking exreme weaher evenssuch as he ooding caused by
Sandy, as well as he Unied Saes high emperaures in 2012o human-caused
climae change, suggesing ha observed rends are likely o coninue.8
In June, Presiden Barack Obama inroduced his Climae Acion Plan. Te planincludes a suie o execuive acions o curb U.S. emissions o hea-rapping gases
ha conribue o climae change, reerred o as greenhouse gasesor carbon
polluionwhen hey are emited by burning ossil uels. Te plan also includes
acions ha help prepare he naion or he consequences o a warmer world.9
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
5/35
2 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
While hese execuive acions are necessary seps or he Unied Saes o help
rein in climae change and ake a global leadership role, he presiden canno solve
he climae crisis alone. Congress mus also ac bu sadly remains paralyzed. Te
longer we wai o ake meaningul and concree seps o signicanly reduce emis-
sions o hea-rapping polluion, he more we are going o experienceand have
o payhe seep coss o climae change.
esponding o climae change as i occurs, rebuilding and repairing damages, and
preparing or uure exreme weaher will be expensive. Even i he Unied Saes
akes massive seps o ackle climae change oday, he high levels o greenhouse
gas polluion already in he amosphere ensure ha he risks and consequences
o a warmer world will coninue o grow in he years o come. Even wih immedi-
ae acion o curb climae change risks, his will be expensive. Wihou acion,
however, he oal U.S. billor responding, rebuilding, and preparing or he
uurecould reach hundreds o billions o dollars annually. Tese coss will have
o be paid by already overburdened ederal, sae, local, and ribal governmensanddirecly and indireclyby he American people.
In ac, he coss o hese acions may well represen he larges ununded mandae
Congress has ever imposed on he American people.
Te Ununded Mandaes eorm Ac o 1995, or UMR, requires ha Congress
consider he cos burden ha may be imposed on sae, local, and ribal govern-
mens and he privae secor prior o proposing new legislaion. During he oor
debae on he legislaion ha became UMR, sponsors o he measure empha-
sized is role in bringing our sysem back ino balance, by serving as a check agains
he easy imposiion o ununded mandaes.10 Sae and local advocaes view
ununded mandaeswhich are enorceable duies imposed by he ederal govern-
men on sae and local governmensas inconsisen wih a radiional view o
American ederalism, which is based on cooperaion, no compulsion.11 While
Congresss ailure o ake acion on climae change may no all sricly wihin he
leter o UMR, i is cerainly wihin is spiri. Sae, local, and ribal governmens
will be orced o bear he burden and expense o needed acions o reac o and
reduce climae change risks o public healh, saey, and heir local economies.
In his repor, we assess he magniude o he coss o preparing or more exreme
weaher and oher climae change impacs ha Congress is imposing on sae,
local, and ribal governmens by ailing o enac policies o curb U.S. emissions
o hea-rapping polluion. o sop imposing a cosly ununded mandae on he
American people, we recommend ha Congress and he presiden ake immediae
acion in he ollowing hree areas.
The total
U.S. climate
change bill
or responding,
rebuilding, and
preparing or th
uturecould
reach hundreds
o billions o do
annually.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
6/35
3 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Recognize and reverse the unfunded mandate
Congress mus assess he ununded mandae ha i is imposing on sae, local,
and ribal governmens by ailing o enac ambiious climae change policies.
Congress mus require ha all proposed energy legislaion undergo a carbonaudi o reveal is eec on carbon polluion. Bills ha do no mee a minimum
hreshold or perormance should be subjec o review and revision.
Adequately fund community resilience efforts
Congress mus creae a dedicaed und o suppor communiy resilience eors,
which reduce he coss o disaser response dramaically. As much as $4 in
response coss are saved by each dollar invesed in resilience eors.
Te presiden and ederal agencies mus make resilience a core aspec o ederal
disaser and inrasrucure assisance.
Congress mus adequaely und ederal programs ha provide sae and local
governmens wih he climae change risk inormaion and planning ools hey
need o make smar resilience invesmens. I mus also require more analysis o
he cos o climae inacion in he Naional Climae Assessmen.
Lower future climate change risks and disaster-response and rebuilding costs
Te presiden mus coninue o suppor and enorce he Environmenal
Proecion Agencys, or EPAs, carbon-polluion sandards or new and exising
power plans.
Congress mus enac legislaion and he presiden mus use exising EPA
auhoriy o reduce climae-changing super polluans.
Te presiden and Congress mus ac across he board o eliminae unnecessaryand oudaed ossil uel subsidies and o suppor emerging low- and no-carbon
energy-echnology soluions.
Congress mus ulimaely enac legislaion o pu a price on carbon.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
7/35
4 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Whats past is prologue
Te U.N. Inergovernmenal Panel on Climae Change, or IPCC, saed unequivo-
cally in is Sepember 2013 repor ha he climae sysem is warming and ha
many o he observed changesincluding warming o he amosphere and ocean,
diminishing sea ice, and rising sea levelare occurring a raes unprecedened
over previous decades or even millennia. Te IPCC repor urher saes ha, I is
extremely likely ha human inuence has been he dominan cause o he observed
warming since he mid-20h cenurya viewpoin wih which 97 percen o he
worlds climae scieniss concur.12
Scieniss predic a liany o climaic changes, many o which are already uncom-
orably amiliar o us. Climae change has been clearly linked o global projec-
ions o increased inensiy and/or requency o exreme evenssuch as heavy
precipiaion, warm spells and hea waves, and drough in some regionsover he
coming cenury.13 Scieniss also predic ha he rends in ropical cyclone aciviy
in he Norh Alanic are likely o coninue, meaning ha uure sorms, such as
yphoons and hurricanes, will become more inense, wih larger peak wind speeds
and more heavy precipiaion.14 Tomas Socker, co-chair o he working group
ha produced he IPCC repor, urher warns ha, alhough here will be excep-
ions, As he Earh warms, we expec o see currenly we regions receiving more
rainall, and dry regions receiving less.15
Climae change is already alering wha we in he Unied Saes hink o as nor-
mal, as we cope no only wih exreme weaher evens bu also wih higher aver-
age emperauressomeimes coupled wih higher humidiyas well as changes
in he iming and amoun o rain and snowall, he lengh o seasons, and oher
aspecs o weaher ha aec daily lie.16 Climae will become more variable and
more dicul o predic and plan orno only over he course o a season burom one year o he nex.17
I he loss o lie, damages and economic losses, and he environmenal impacs
susained during recen exreme weaher evens are any indicaion o wha we
should expec in he uure, his new climae realiy comes wih a high price ag.
I the loss o
lie, damages
and economic
losses, and the
environmental
impacts sustain
during recent
extreme weathe
events are any
indication o wh
we should expe
in the uture, th
new climate rea
comes with a hi
price tag.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
8/35
5 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Supersorm Sandy was he second-mos expensive hurricane in U.S. hisory
second only o Hurricane Karina. Sandy was also only 1 o 11 U.S. weaher and
climae disaser evens in 2012 ha caused losses exceeding $1 billion, according
o NOAAs Naional Climaic Daa Cener.18 Since 1980, here have been 144 such
evens, wih a oal cos exceeding $1 rillion in 2013 dollars.19
Tese esimaes ake ino accoun a wide range o insured and uninsured losses
rom exreme weaher evens, as well as relie coss borne by ederal, sae, and local
governmens. Bu hey also miss some criical impacs, such as he loss o lie; he
healh care coss associaed wih injuries and illness; he value o damaged and los
dunes, welands, and oher ecosysems; and a whole range o qualiy-o-lie impacs
ha go well beyond wha esimaes o disaser coss ypically capure. Mos cos
esimaes also do no ake ino accoun how disaser losses and damages aec he
broader economy, jobs, and income or how such coss may persis over ime.20
While much o he media atenion highlighs he damages associaed wihexreme sorms, he losses associaed wih oher climae evens, such as droughs
and wildres, are also disurbingly large.
Drough akes is oll on armers over ime, paricularly in regions, such as he
U.S. Souhwes, ha are already dry and expeced o become even drier in he
uure.21 Las years drough, which aiced more han hal o he Unied Saes
or much o 2012, cos an esimaed $30 billion in los harvess.22 In exas, he
2011 drough was he coslies in he saes recorded hisory, causing $5.2 billion
in crop and livesock losses, according o Exension Service economiss. 23 A loss
o his magniude is equivalen o one-quarer o he value o agriculural pro-
ducion in a ypical exas year, and is eecs on agriculural oupu may well go
beyond he drough year.24
In 2012 alone, wildres desroyed more han 9.3 million acres across he Unied
Saes, wih an esimaed aggregae cos o $1 billion.25 Tese damages were
equaled, or in some cases surpassed, by he wildres ha occurred in 2011, 2009,
and 2008.26 Te economic damage caused by he recen Yosemie im res in
Caliornia, which as o early Ocober had scorched more han 250,000 acres o
naional oresland and parkland, have ye o be oaled.27
Noneheless, given hemagniude o he damage, i is likely ha economic and oher losses ied o imber,
ourism, ecosysems, and wildlie will be signican.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
9/35
6 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Moneary measures, however, do no capure all he poenial damages rom wild-
res. According o research published in heProceedings o the National Academy
o Sciences, Coninued warming could compleely ransorm re aciviy in he
greaer Yellowsone ecosysem by he middle o his cenury, wih proound
consequences or many species and or ecosysem services including aesheics,
hydrology, and carbon sorage.28
Yellowsone and Yosemie are no alone in beinghighly vulnerable o wildre; he Naional Park Service is working o develop
re-managemen sraegies o reduce he danger a oher naional parks, such as
Glacier Naional Park in Monanas Norhern ockies and Saguaro Naional Park
in Souhern Arizona.29
Bu changes in average climae condiionswha we migh call everyday
climaealso ake a bie ou o our walles and he economy. Warmer average
emperaures will aec sociey in many ways, including by producing hea sress
and illness, paricularly or he elderly and poor; shorening working hours or
oudoor workers; and creaing ravel delays or business ravelers and peoplecommuing o work and school, as rail racks and armacs buckle in he exreme
hea. Increased precipiaion will also come wih coss rom ooding and prop-
ery damage, consrucion delays, and ransporaion accidens. Similarly, hoter
and drier weaher and earlier snowmel will resul in Wesern wildres sar-
ing earlier in he year, lasing laer ino he all, and damaging more homes and
oress. Te eecs will be as numerous and varied as he ways in which climae
inuences livelihoods and daily lie.30
Ye no every weaher evenwheher disasrous or merely unpleasan and poen-
ially cosly over imecan be laid a he doorsep o climae change. Alhough
scieniss have long sressed a relaionship beween climae change and he occur-
rence o some exreme evens generally,31 unil recenly, hey have been less willing
o exend ha ie o individual evens such as Hurricane Sandy.
Climae scieniss draw an analogy beween he eecs o climae change on
exreme weaher and baseball players who sar aking seroids and begin hiting
20 percen more homeruns han beore. While we canno say wheher any indi-
vidual homerun is he resul o seroids, we can say ha seroid use has increased
he probabiliy o a homerun by 20 percen. Where climae change is concerned,scieniss can calculae he changed odds ha an individual exreme weaher or
climae even can be atribued o climae change.32
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
10/35
7 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
A special Sepember 2013 issue o heBulletin o the American Meteorological
Society presens 18 analyses o 12 dieren exreme weaher evens ha occurred
around he world in 2012. Te ndings suppor he conclusion ha human-
induced climae change played a key role in abou hal o he evens assessed,
wih he remainder inuenced primarily by naural weaher ucuaions. Findings
abou prolonged periods o high emperaures are paricularly sriking: More hanone-hird o he hea waves experienced in he easern Unied Saes beween
March and May 2012 can be atribued o human-induced climae change. Pu
anoher way, we should expec high emperaures such as hose in 2012 o occur
our imes as ofen as hey did in he pas.33 Te ndings also sugges ha he
climae change-relaed increases in sea level ha have already occurred have nearly
doubled he probabiliy o Sandy-level inundaion relaive o 60 years ago. Te
implicaion is ha Sandy-level ooding will occur more requenly in he uure,
even or less-inense sorms.34
Boh o hese rendsrising degrees o hea and sorm damagesare ied direclyo climae change. Te recen pas is, indeed, prologue o wha he Unied Saes
should expec in he uure.
We should expe
high temperatu
such as those in
2012 to occur
our times as
oten as they
did in the past.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
11/35
8 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
How much will responding
to climate change cost the
United States?
Te pas decade oers a preview o he ype o climae change impacs ha he
Unied Saes is likely o experience going orward. As exreme weaher evens
become more requen and more severe, governmens a every level will need
o respond by providing more emergency relie and recovery aid. We will also
need o reac rouinely o he new realiies o climaeby repairing bridges and
roadways and dredging pors more ofen, reaing increased incidence o climae-
relaed disease, purchasing more air condiioners, changing which crops we grow
where, and a hos o oher small and large changes.
We can reduce hese coss by building climae resilience ino our inrasrucure
and insiuions so ha we are less vulnerable o uure weaher evens. Acions
ha can scale back he long-erm coss and impacs o climae change include:
Improving building codes and srenghening ransporaion inrasrucure
raining docors and expanding healh care aciliies
Developing more drough-resisan crops
Proecing welands and oher naural sysems ha reduce sorm surges in
coasal areas and reduce ood risks along rivers
Modiying land use and developmen paterns o minimize ood damages
Unorunaely, here is no comprehensive naional sudy o climae-resilience coss.
Bu he available evidence pains a picure suggesing ha, in aggregae, he com-
bined coss o responding o climae change risks, rebuilding in he wake o moreexreme sorms, and making communiies more resilien o uure weaher-relaed
disasers are likely o be in he ens o hundreds o billions o dollars annually.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
12/35
9 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Sae and local governmens are beginning o recognize he risks ha climae
change poses o heir communiies, and hey are aking seps o proec agains
uure changes. In Grand apids, Michigan, or example, Mayor George K.
Hearwell is aking acion o proec his ciy rom exreme weaher and oher
climae change risks. He noes:
Te City o Grand Rapids is addressing various climate-related threats such as
extreme heat and more intense precipitation events. We see these climate strate-
gies as an extension o responsible governance and an imperative investment in
the uture prosperity o our city. As an inland watershed city, we have ocused
on restoring and maintaining a high quality o water in the Grand River with
over $240 million in combined sewer separation investment. Tis prepares us or
ever-increasing precipitation levels now and into the uture.35
Wih a populaion o 189,000 people in 2012 and a ciy budge o $308 million,
hese cosspaid by he ciy hrough a mix o bonds, loans, ederal assisance, andcapial-projecs nancingare signican, even when spread ou over a number
o years.36 No all ciies will ace he same ypes o issues as Grand apids, bu i
hese coss are represenaive o he magniude o per-capia coss we expec o see
naionally, hen addressing climae hreas could run up a oal bill o more han
$400 billion over he nex 20 years.37
A number o oher counies and ciies have aken iniial seps o proec heir com-
muniies rom climae change. In Washingon sae, or example, he King Couny
Flood Conrol Disric has spen an average o $100,000 per home o assis
propery owners wih home elevaion.38 Seatles Public Uiliies Deparmen has
implemened several pilo projecs o improve he abiliy o urban areas o ac
as naural drainage sysems and absorb runo during heavy rainall and ooding
evens, a an average cos o $280,000 per block.39
Many oher ciies and saes are considering acions, wih oal coss ranging rom
a ew million dollars o almos $1 billion. Te Ciy o Puna Gorda, Florida, or
example, is spending $13.8 million on replacing sea walls ha proec he down-
own area rom sea-level rise and sorm surges.40 By conras, he Massachusets
Waer esources Auhoriy is spending more han $850 million on combinedsewer-overow projecs o proec beaches, shellsh beds, and oher sensiive
waers.41 As Washingon, D.C., Mayor Vincen Gray saed:
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
13/35
10 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
We cannot avoid or ignore the evidence o the increased risk a changing climate
poses to the saety o our residents or the health o our economy. We are commit-
tedacross government and the private sectorto act so that we can ensure
that our city is prepared or these coming challenges.42
Despie he real need on he par o governmens and he privae secor o under-sand he coss o managing curren and uure climae risks, litle work has been
done o esimae hese coss naionally. A March Climate Policy aricle surveyed
exising esimaes o he cos o adaping o projeced climae change in he Unied
Saesboh rouine acions and hose ha promoe resilience in he uure.43
able 1 exracs he cos esimaes rom he mos recen and comprehensive sud-
ies in each secor ha are repored in he aricle and convers hem ino annual
coss. For mos secors sudied, annual coss could range rom several billion dol-
lars o ens o billions o dollars.
TABLE 1
Recent estimates of annual costs of adapting to climate change
in the United States, in 2010 dollars
Sector Actions considered in study Rough annual costs, in 2010 dollars
Coastal protection Shoreline armoring and grade elevation $2 billion to $3 billion per year through 2100
Inrastructure
paved and unpaved roadsMaintenance and design changes Around $2 billion in 2050
Inrastructurebridges Strengthening vulnerable bridges Around $2 billion per year through 2090
Wastewater treatment acilitiesMaintenance, replacement, and improvement
o wastewater inrastructureAround $5 billion to $10 billion per year through
Drinking-water utilitiesConservation, ood protection, and changing
water-management practicesAround $14 billion to $26 billion per year throug
Energy demandIncreased residential and commercial expenditures
on energy or air conditioning and heating$40 billion to $87 billion in 2100
Healthasthma Medical treatment costs or increased asthma cases $5 billion in 2025
Air qualityIncremental pollution-control costs to meet
air-quality standards$12 billion in 2050
Source: Fran Sussman, What Will it Cost the United States to Adapt to Climate Change?, Climate Dollars & Sense, October 21, 2013, available at
http://climatedollarsandsense.wordpress.com/%20short-papers/.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
14/35
11 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Yearly expenses o respond o climae change and build climae resilience, however,
could be much larger han hose esimaed by hese sudies. For one hing, hese
naional sudies cover a very limied porion o climae impacs and ypes o acions
ha will be needed o adap o climae change (see he box below), suggesing ha
annual coss could be considerably higher han indicaed. For anoher, coss will
also depend on jus how severe climae change is and how hard we work o resorelos services and inrasrucure. A sudy ha looked specically a he cos o waer
conservaion and developing alernaive waer supplies ound ha annual coss
could rise o more han $300 billion in 2030 i climae change exacerbaes drough
condiions and waer supplies are managed o mainain sreamows.44
Lasly, and perhaps mos imporanly, almos none o he exising naional sudies
look a he coss o climae variabiliy or exreme weaher evens; insead, hey
ocus on wha i will cos o deal wih changes in average climae condiions.
Te coss o rebuilding afer Supersorm Sandy sugges ha i he curren rend
oward high-damage exreme weaher evens coninues ino he uure, he cosso rebuilding afer such evens will be massive.45 Gov. Andrew Cuomos (D-NY)
oce esimaed ha ollowing Supersorm Sandy, recovery and prevenion coss
in New York sae alone will reach $42 billionalmos $33 billion in repairs and
resoraion coss, including $15 billion or New York Ciy alone and more han $9
billion in proecive measures o save o damage rom uure sorms, including
seps o proec he saes power grid and cell phone nework.46
In aggregae, he cos o adaping o climae change will conservaively be in he
many ens o billions o dollars annually, based on published sudies. aking ino
accoun he ypes o coss ha are omited and he evidence rom he acions ha
saes and localiies are already planning, as well as he poenial coss o rebuild-
ing afer exreme evens such as Supersorm Sandy, he acual cos could easily rise
ino he hundreds o billions o dollars.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
15/35
12 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
A burden on public-sector budgets and taxpayers
Mos o he cos o responding, repairing and rebuilding, and planning or a more
resilien uure will be borne by he public secorand, by exension, axpay-
ers. Te Naural esources Deense Council, or NDC, or example, esimaes
ha he ederal governmen suppors he lions share o cleanup afer a disaser.
In 2012, privae insurers covered less han 25 percen o he damages, while he
ederal governmen spen almos hree imes as much.47
Sorms, such as Supersorm Sandy and he blizzard Nemo ha hi New England
in February, demand immediae acion and a rapid allocaion o resources o
recovery. Bu expenses relaed o cleanup, repair, and rebuilding afer a disaser
represen only par o he rue cos o climae change. Te cos o proacively
making invesmens and aking oher acions o reduce our vulnerabiliy o uurechangeor example, designing bridges o beter wihsand sorm impacs and
helping relocae amilies and businesses away rom dangerously high-risk ood
zonesconinue long afer a sorm srikes. So do rouine aciviies, such as repair-
ing ransporaion sysems o keep hem running smoohly in he ace o exreme
weaher and oher climae changes.
According to a recent survey o existing estimates or adapting to
climate change in the United States, only a dozen or so relatively
recent national-level studies exist. Generally, there are only one or two
studies, at most, per sector. The survey suggests that these existing es-
timates are woeully incomplete in their ability to portray the true costs
o adapting to climate change. Limitations noted in the survey include:
Only a ew sectors, including several inrastructure typesprotec-
tion o coastal property rom sea-level rise, wastewater treatment,
water quality and quantity, and roads and bridgeshave been
studied in any detail.
The costs o adapting have not been estimated at all or many criti-
cal impact categories, including but not limited to the eects o cli-
mate change on illness due to waterborne and oodborne dis
ecosystems and parks; transit, rail, air, and water transportatio
agricultural production; and power generation and transmiss
Even in areas that have been relatively well studied, existing a
ments do not look comprehensively at impact categories. Stu
coastal protection, or example, typically ocus on private pro
rather than public inrastructure and thereore do not capture
costs o measures taken to protect or harden public buildings
as schools and hospitals.
Importantly, these studies ocus almost exclusively on changes
average climate and do not take into account the cost o adapt
extreme weather events or climate variability.
Whats missing from the national studies of adaptation cost in the United States?
Source: Fran Sussman and others, Climate change adaptation cost in the US: what do we know? (Washington: Climate Policy, 2013), available at http://www.tandonline.com/doi/ull/10.1080/14693062.2013.777604#preview;
http://www.tandfonline/http://www.tandfonline/http://www.tandfonline/8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
16/35
13 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
ogeher, hese coss could be signican when compared wih public-secor
expendiures, as repored by he Congressional Budge Oce, or CBO.48 Annual
coss or adaping wasewaer reamen sysems o climae changearound $5
billion o $10 billion per year hrough 2050, as repored in able 1could alone
be as much as 10 percen o he oal public spending on waer supply and rea-
men combined, as indicaed in able 2.TABLE 2
Public spending on transportation and water infrastructure in 2007,
in billions of 2009 dollars
HighwaysAviation, mass
transit, and rail
Water supply
and wastewater
treatment
Water transportation
and water resources
Total pub
spending
Capital 87.5 26.6 38.9 7.8 160.8
Operation andmaintenance
67 57 62.4 9.1 195.5
Total 154.5 83.6 101.3 16.9 356.4
Source: Congressional Budget Ofce, Public Spending on Transportation and Water Inrastructure (2010).
Sae and local governmens are already aking he lead on responding and build-
ing resilience o climae change. While he ederal governmen is helping shoulder
some o his cos, much o i alls direcly on sae and local budges. According o
Mayor Brian A. oh o Plymouh, Norh Carolina:
In many smaller coastal towns that are going to be aected, the concern is not
about expanding the current water and sewer inastructure systems in a smart
way. Rather, it is about moving inastructure that has been in the ground or
decades. Some o my pipes are over 100 years old. Smaller, low-wealth com-
munities cannot possibly undertake the fnancial burden o system relocations
without grants om the Federal government.49
I he aggregae cos o sae and local governmens rises ino he billions o dol-
lars, i would become a signican componen o heir budges, many o which are
already sreched o he breaking poin. In 2011, oal sae expendiures rangedrom $4 billion in Souh Dakoa o more han $200 billion in Caliornia, averaging
abou $33 billion across all saes.50 An increase o even a ew percenage poins in
cossrelaive o curren expendiurescould increase he pressure on cash-
srapped sae budges and urher srain unding or schools, hospials, roads, and
oher services ha communiies and businesses rely on daily.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
17/35
14 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Declining revenues and federal funding
Saes are beginning o recognize boh he poenial burden o climae change on
already-sressed sae budges and he likelihood ha less ederal unding will be
available o make up or any shoralls. In he wake o Supersorm Sandy, Gov.
Cuomo cauioned invesors ha climae change posed a long-erm risk o hesaes nances.51 Since he beginning o 2013, climae change has been included as
a op scal risk o he saes bond oerings.52
Even a he ederal levelwhere he Federal Emergency Managemen Agency, or
FEMA, has a hisory o picking up he check or he immediae cleanup and rebuild-
ing o public inrasrucure afer big naural disaser evens53regulaors are saring
o balk a he long-erm risks and coss posed by climae change. A recen repor
rom he Governmen Accounabiliy Oce, or GAO, ound ha he impacs o cli-
mae change presen a signican nancial risk o he ederal governmen. 54 And a a
press conerence las year, ep. Darrell Issa (-CA), he epublican chairman o heU.S. House Oversigh and Governmen eorm Commitee, observed ha as he
requency o exreme weaher evens increases, he saes and ciies hey aec may
no longer be able o depend on he ederal governmen or exra help. 55 Te growing
cos o he ederal budge comes a he same ime ha Congress has cracked down
on ederal expendiures, imposing $1 rillion in ofen arbirary budge cus across all
ederal agencies as par o he plan known as he sequeser.
As he ederal governmen pulls back, saes will have o sep up o address
climae change. Bu hey may have o do so using ax bases ha are shrinking due
o climae change impacs, such as job and business losses, declining housing
values, reduced sales rom ores and armland, and reduced labor produciviy.
Signican producion losses may be el in a number o saes, as he ollowing
exampleswhich are by no means comprehensiveillusrae:
In he Norheas, annual revenues in he maple syrup indusry are expeced o
decline by as much as $12 million annually40 percen.56 Te region should
also expec a 20 percen decline in skiing days, a revenue loss o roughly $500
million per year.
For he agriculurally producive Cenral Valley in Caliornia alone, he esi-
maed economy-wide loss during he dries years is prediced o be around $6
billion per year.57
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
18/35
15 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
New Yorks agriculural yield may drop by as much as 40 percen annually, caus-
ing $1.2 billion in annual losses.58
Te Grea Plains and Midwes will suer, paricularly rom increased requency
and severiy o ooding and drough evens, causing billions o dollars in dam-
ages o crops and propery.59
In he Souh and Souhwes, declining precipiaion levels will srain waer
resources or agriculure, indusry, and households, as occurred during severe
droughs over he pas ew years.60
In 1995, Congress passed UMRA to ocus attention on the costs omandates that the ederal government imposed on other levels
o government and the private sector.61 According to an article
published in the National Tax Journal, the legislations supporters
wanted to ensure that Congress had inormation about the costs o
mandates beore it decided to impose them and to encourage the
ederal government to provide unding to cover the costs o intergov-
ernmental mandates.62
Some viewed the issue even more strongly. William V. Roth Jr. (R-DE),
the ormer chairman o the Senate Governmental Aairs Committee,
said that voters wanted an end to the steady stream o dictates rom
Washington on how to spend locally raised tax dollars.63 This issue has
remained salient with politicians. When ormer Speaker o the House
Newt Gingrich (R-GA) was asked more than a decade ater UMRA took
eect whether he would support a constitutional amendment ban-
ning ununded congressional mandates on states, he replied that he
would be willing to consider it. He added, I think i every governor
and every state legislature would create a national ederal cost analy-
sis, that would be an enormously helpul way o highlighting it.64
UMRA requires that the CBOthe nonpartisan agency charged withconducting independent analyses o budgetary and economic issues
to support the congressional budget processassess each piece o
legislation that is reported out o committee or whether it cona ederal mandate.65 Such mandates might take the orm o en
able duties imposed by the legislation or reduced ederal undi
or existing mandates. Where a mandate exists and the direct c
are likely to be above a legislatively set threshold, the CBO mus
provide an estimate o the cost.66
I the CBO report indicates that the legislation contains intergo
ernmental mandates with costs exceeding the threshold and d
not include authorization or appropriations sucient to cover
costs, UMRAs rules prohibit urther consideration o the legisla
According to the CBO, Although it has rarely used UMRAs expl
enorcement mechanism when considering bills, in some case
Congress had changed legislation beore enactment either to e
nate a mandate or reduce its costs.68
The intergovernmental cost threshold that triggers a CBO analy
and possible action by Congressis currently $75 million annu
or the frst fve years ater the law takes eect.69 As described e
in this report, the costs o needed action by state, local, and trib
governments over the next ew years and decades to reduce th
o climate change to public health, saety, and local economiesar surpasslikely by an order o magnitude or morethe ann
threshold set by Congress or an ununded mandate.
An unfunded mandate on state, local, and tribal governments
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
19/35
16 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
But UMRA is not restricted just to intergovernmental mandates. It also
contains provisions or dealing with private-sector ununded man-
dates, which include enorceable duties imposed by legislation on
households, businesses, educational institutions, and other private-
sector entities. In other words, UMRA protects just about everyonerom ununded mandates. To the extent that FEMA and other ederal
agencies fnance some o the costs o disaster recovery and increas-
ing resilience, inaction rom Congress not only orces an ununded
mandate on states but also pushes costs onto ederal taxpayers. The
costs o actions that all levels o government will takeand pass on
to taxpayersas well as the costs o actions that all directly on the
private sector, add to the burden and the ununded mandate.
In act, Congresss ailure to take action to reduce greenhouse gas pol-
lution in the United States may well be the largest ununded mandate
ever imposed on all levels o governmentederal, as well as state,
local, and tribalnot to mention the American people.
But lets back up or a moment. In point o act, UMRA is concerned
with the actions that proposed legislation requires nonederal govern-
ment entities and the private sector to take. It is not, in the letter o the
law, concerned with the costs imposed by actions resulting rom legis-
lation that Congress does not pass. By ailing to take action, however,
Congress is ensuring that state, local, and tribal governments will not
have a choice; these governments will have to take action i they want
their communities to be sae, healthy, and thriving, and they will have
to bear the costs. The ununded mandate is very real.
Congress has had many opportunities to tackle climate change,
putting a price on carbon, to supporting low-carbon technology
opment and deployment while scaling back subsidies or ossil
to adequately unding ederal, state, and local governments to b
resilience to climate change impacts. Sadly, it has seized none o
While the House o Representatives did pass a bill by Reps. Hen
Waxman (D-CA) and Ed Markey (D-MA) in 2009 aimed at curbin
heat-trapping emissions,70 the Senate ailed to pass a compan-
ion bill, and the eort died in 2010. The single-largest energy b
recently passed in the United States was the American Recover
and Reinvestment Act o 2009, which President Obama champ
and which included $90 billion in clean energy investments an
incentives. But that was just a two-year bill, and its programs h
mostly ended. Aside rom various renewable energy tax credits
passed at the end o 2012, this Congress has made almost no p
ress toward seriously addressing the root causes o climate cha
its immediate impacts.
Even worse, 161 members o Congress continue to deny that
climate change is real, despite the overwhelming scientifc an
meteorological evidence to the contrary.71 Ironically, accordin
to a recent CAP analysis, 47 climate change deniers in Congre
represent the 10 states that received the most ederal disaste
help armers, businesses, and communities rebuild and get ba
their eet ater devastating droughts, wildfres, and storm dam
in 2011 and 2012.72
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
20/35
17 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Reducing the long-term
cost of climate change
Saes, ciies, and ribal communiies have had no choice bu o sep ino he void
lef by Congress. As communiies across he counry experience he rshand
eecs o more exreme hea, oods, sorms, and oher climae change impacs,
more and more sae and local decision makers realize he need o srenghen
aging inrasrucure and ake oher seps o build climae resilience hrough adap-
aion planning,73 long-range developmen plans ha ake climae ino accoun,
and, in some cases, even a radical rehinking o sae budge accouning o iner-
nalize susainabiliy merics.74 A 2011 survey ound ha 58 percen o U.S. ciymanagers are aking acion o build resilience o uure exreme weaher evens.75
Saes and localiies do no have all he resources needed o reac o climae
changemuch less o proacively ake seps o prepare or i on heir own. Te
only way o ruly lessen he burden o paying or climae change impacs is o
ackle he problem nowby rapidly reducing emissions o hea-rapping gases
and increasing resilience so we can lessen he long-erm risks and coss o a chang-
ing climae. Ta is a challenge we mus no ace alone as individuals or localiies
bu, raher, as a naion.
o sop imposing his cosly ununded mandae on he American people, Congress
and he presiden mus ake immediae acion in he ollowing hree areas.
Recognize and reverse the unfunded mandate
Congress must assess the unfunded mandate that it is imposing
on state, local, and tribal governments by failing to enact ambitiousclimate change policies
In he ineres o ransparency and ull disclosure, Congress should ask CBO
o assess he expeced cos o sae, local, and ribal governmens i he curren
naional policies on climae change coninue as hey are. As in UMR, CBO
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
21/35
18 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
should be asked o assess, a a minimum, he direc coss o acions ha hese gov-
ernmenal eniies will have o ake o respond o climae change and ensure ha
necessary servicessuch as healh care, provision o saey, ransporaion and
ransi, elecriciy, drinking waer, and communicaionsconinue o be provided
o communiies. CBO should also be asked o assess he coss o he ull range o
acions ha sae, local, and ribal governmen eniies will likely need o ake andha will no be covered by ederal appropriaions and unds, including:
Costs of responding to extreme events, such as Superstorm Sandy and the
recent Colorado floods, and subsequent rebuilding. Since hese coss will no
be ully covered by ederal aidgiven curren ederal unding or emergency
response and relaed aciviieshey represen an ununded mandae.
Costs of maintaining infrastructure and public service levels, given changes in
average and seasonal weather and in the variability of temperature, precipita-
tion, and humidity. Saesofen in parnership wih he ederal governmenplay a criical role in mainaining ransporaion sysems and public healh
sysems, proecing coaslines, and a hos o oher aciviies ha will become
more expensive as warming coninues.
Costs of building resilience into infrastructure and institutions. As saes ake
he lead on making changes o proacively proec and make heir populaions
more secure agains uure climae change, hese cossmany o which will
come rom declining budgesare an ununded mandae.
Congress must require that all proposed energy legislation undergo a
carbon audit to reveal its effect on carbon pollution
All proposed legislaion should be subjec o an audiusing a widely acceped
mehodo deermine he legislaions eec on emissions o greenhouse gas
polluans during he 10-year period afer he law would ake eec. Eecs on
emissions could be calculaed using esablished echniques or measuring, aggre-
gaing, and projecing emissions. A a minimum, any proposed energy legislaion
should be required o reduce ne greenhouse gas emissions in line wih he presi-dens goal o reduce U.S. emissions by 83 percen below 2005 levels by 2050.76
Te audis purpose would be o preven Congress rom imposing an addiional
ununded mandae by enacing laws ha escalae emissions o greenhouse gases
and uure climae change risks and coss.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
22/35
19 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
In addiion o conducing an audi, Congress should incorporae he principles
o carbon reducion ino is legislaive proposals. Te CBO regularly produces
repors or he House and Senae budge commitees. One o hese is a com-
pendium called educing he Deci: Spending and evenue Opions, which
describes more han 100 legislaive opions ha Congress could adop and
esimaes he eecs each opion would have on he budge. For he mos par, heopions would, i adoped, reduce he ederal budge deci. Te opions cover
an array o policy areas, rom energy o he ax code o deense programs.77 A
similar repor on climae changeone ha liss a range o large and small opions
ha lawmakers could adop o reduce hea-rapping emissionswould enable
Congress o incorporae emissions-reducing measures ino proposed legislaion.
Adequately fund community resilience efforts
Congress must create a dedicated fund to assist community resilience efforts
and save billions of dollars in disaster response
New sources o ederal nancing are needed o adequaely build communiy
resilience.78 Every $1 ha FEMA invess in resilience and in acions o reduce
disaser losses saves he naion $4 in disaser-recovery coss.79 By underinvesing
in resilience oday, we risk acing even higher disaser-relie and recovery coss in
he uure.
Congress and he presiden should ideniy a susainable revenue sream o sup-
por sae and local governmen eors o increase communiy resilience beore
a disaser srikes and while rebuilding in he afermah o a sorm. o his end, a
previous CAP analysis recommends:
the creation o a dedicated und or community resilience with annual rev-
enue equal to one-third o the total ederal disaster relie and recovery spending
om the previous three years. For fscal year 2013, we estimate that the amount
earmarked or such a resilience und would have been approximately $7 billion
using this ormula.
Te money dedicaed or resilience could come rom a small levy on some or all
o he ossil uels ha emi he carbon polluion responsible or climae change,
which scieniss predic will exacerbae exreme weaher.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
23/35
20 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
In addiion, we need an annual and complee accouning o ederal unds spen
on every disaser-recovery program in he previous scal year. Such an accouning
would enable public ocials and everyday ciizens o beter undersand he rue
cos o axpayers o unchecked exreme weaher. An accouning o ederal inves-
mens in resilience programs would highligh he gap beween resilience needs
and available resources.80
Congress and the president must make resilience a core aspect of all federal
infrastructure and disaster-recovery funding
As described in anoher recen CAP analysis, he ederal governmen can also use
exising ederal unds o improve communiy resilience simply by srenghening
exising gran programs.81 In his Climae Acion Plan, Presiden Obama direcs ed-
eral agencies o encourage and suppor smarer, more resilien invesmens, includ-
ing hrough agency grans, echnical assisance, and oher programs, in secors romransporaion and waer managemen o conservaion and disaser relie.82
o deliver on his commimen, he Deparmen o ransporaion, or DO; he
Deparmen o Housing and Urban Developmen, or HUD; he Army Corps
o Engineers; and he EPA should only und inrasrucure-projec designs
ha can wihsand more exreme hea, oods, and sorms. HUD, or example,
should ensure ha he roughly $3 billion available annually or Communiy
Developmen Block Grans, or CDBGs, suppor climae-resilien housing and
oher projecs.83 Similarly, DO should ensure ha he $500 million available
yearly or ransporaion Invesmen Generaing Economic ecovery, or IGE,
Discreionary Granswhich help improve our naions inrasrucuresuppor
sorm-ready roads, rails, ransi sysems, and pors.84
In addiion, HUD should coninue o apply and enorce is new resilience require-
mens or CDBG disaser-recovery assisance in areas hi hardes by Supersorm
Sandy. DO, he Army Corps o Engineers, and oher agencies should also require
ha heir disaser-recovery programs inves in resilien rebuilding projecs ha
can wihsand uure exreme weaher. Building on imporan Sandy elie Ac
reorms o ederal disaser assisance, Congress mus urher amend he ober .Saord Disaser elie and Emergency Assisance Ac o require ha all FEMA-
unded rebuilding projecs are climae resilien. As i sands, FEMA and oher
ederal agencies rely primarily on he poliical will and iniiaive o ederal disaser-
aid recipiens o rebuild resilien communiies and inrasrucure.85
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
24/35
21 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Congress must adequately fund federal programs that provide state and
local governments with the climate change-risk information and planning
tools necessary to make smart resilience investments
Sae and local decision makers need more accurae and up-o-dae ood maps o
allow amilies, businesses, local policymakers, and planners o make smar deci-sions o keep people and propery ou o harms way.86 Congress gave FEMA he
auhoriy o updae is oodplain maps o accoun or sea-level rise as par o he
2012 Naional Flood Insurance Program reorms.87 FEMA also released a sudy
by independen conracor AECOM revealing ha rising seas and more exreme
weaher are expeced o expand he areas o he counry vulnerable o ooding by
up o 45 percen by 2100. Tese changes could double he number o ood-prone
properies naionwide ha are covered by he Naional Flood Insurance Program
and drive up ood losses by 90 percen.88
Despie his new pressure o updae oodplain maps, FEMAs budge or is FloodHazard Mapping and isk Analysis program dropped rom $181.6 million in
2011 o $97.7 million in boh 2012 and 2013.89 Similarly, spending cus enaced
by Congress as par o he sequeser are undermining eors by NOAA, he
Deparmen o he Inerior, and he Deparmen o Agriculure o deliver climae
science and planning ools o help sae and local ocials, coasal managers,
armers, and oher decision makers undersand and build resilience o drough,
ooding, severe sorms, and oher climae change risks.90 Insead o cuting hese
criical programs, Congress and he presiden mus ensure ha hese agencies
have adequae resources o provide climae change-risk inormaion and oher
resiliency services o communiies across he counry.
Include more economic data in the National Climate Assessment
Te Naional Climae Assessmen, or NCA, is a comprehensive repor on climae
change in he Unied Saes ha is required by Congress as par o he Global
Change esearch Ac o 1990. Te curren draf will be he hird assessmen
repor produced and is due o be compleed by he U.S. Global Change esearch
Program, or USGCP, in 2014. Te repor provides inormaion abou observedchanges, he curren saus o he climae, and anicipaed rends or he uure.91
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
25/35
22 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Tus ar, he naional assessmens have no sysemaically included inormaion
on economic impacs or oher coss associaed wih projeced climae change.
Te USGCPs sraegic plan, however, recognizes he imporance o inegraing
socioeconomic and scienic mehods and daa and has ormed a Social Sciences
ask Force wih he goal o beter inegrae a broad range o knowledge and exper-
ise rom across he breadh o he social sciences.92
I will be a large underaking,however, o assess he socioeconomic knowledge base wih anyhing approaching
he level o deail in he science analyses in he curren NCA. Congress should
appropriae unding or he USGCP o assess he exising economic lieraure,
develop socioeconomic scenarios and projecions o assis researchers, and develop
and encourage he use o good pracice guidelines or assessmen.
Lower future climate change risks and
disaster-response and rebuilding costs
The president must continue to support and enforce the EPAs
carbon-pollution standards for new and existing power plants
Presiden Obamas Climae Acion Plan direcs he EPA o complee carbon-
polluion sandards or boh new and exising power plans. Te EPA unveiled is
proposed carbon sandards or uure power plans in Sepember and is expeced
o propose exising plan sandards in June 2014.93 Many epublicans in he
House and Senae, as well as a number o coal-sae Democras, wan o block
hese sandards rom moving orward.94 Te adminisraion should coninue o
move expediiously o complee he carbon-polluion sandards or exising plans
by 2015 so ha Americans can reap he public healh benes.95
Congress must enact legislation and the president must use existing EPA
authorities to reduce super pollutants that contribute to climate change
Super polluans such as mehane; ropospheric ozone; hydrouorocarbons, or
HFCs; and black carbonalso known as shor-lived climae polluans, or orcersare poen hea-rapping emissions ha are harmul o he climae, human healh,
and agriculural produciviy.96 While reducing carbon polluion will be essenial
o ackle climae change over he long erm, quick acion o reduce super-polluan
emissions can slow down warming by as much as 0.5 degrees Celsius by 2050, while
also avoiding 2.4 million premaure deahs rom exposure o air polluion.97
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
26/35
23 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
ep. Scot Peers (D-CA) inroduced he Super Polluan Emissions educion
Ac, or SUPE Ac, in he House in May o sreamline he enorcemen o exising
ederal policies o reduce super polluans, suppor similar policies a he sae and
local levelssuch as Caliornias successul diesel-ruck regulaions and eors
o curb HFCsand ideniy oher bes pracices or reducing super pollu-
ans.98
Sens. Chris Murphy (D-C), ober Menendez (D-NJ), and Al Franken(D-MN) are also preparing a bill o ackle super polluans.99 Congress should
ake immediae seps o enac legislaion o rein in emissions o super polluans.
Presiden Obama reached a hisoric agreemen wih Chinese Presiden Xi Jinping
and he heads o oher G-20 naions in Sepember o iniiae acion under he
Monreal Proocol and oher mulilaeral insiuions o phase down HFCs, widely
used in rerigeraion and car air condiioning.100 In his Climae Acion Plan, he
presiden direced he EPA o ideniy and approve climae-riendly alernaives o
HFCs and prohibi harmul alernaives hrough is Signican New Alernaives
Policy program.101 Te presiden also direced agencies o purchase cleaneralernaives o HFCs and called or an ineragency sraegy o reduce mehane
emissions. Te presiden should also require acion o reduce mehane emis-
sions rom oil and gas wells and coal mines on ederal lands. In addiion, he EPA
should srenghen rules and programs o limi mehane emissions rom oil and gas
operaions, landlls, and coal mines and accelerae he reroting or replacemen
o exising diesel-powered rucks ha emi black carbon.102
The president and Congress must act across the board to eliminate
unnecessary and outdated fossil fuel subsidies and support emerging low-
and no-carbon energy-technology solutions103
According o he Inernaional Moneary Fund, or IMF, global ossil uel subsidies
are a $1.9 rillion, or 2.5 percen o global gross domesic produc, or GDP.104
Te wors oender is he Unied Saes, which provides $502 billion in ossil uel
subsidies annually, aking ino accoun boh ax breaks or ossil uel companies
and ailure o place a price on carbon polluion eiher hrough a carbon ax or a
cap-and-rade program.105 In his Climae Acion Plan and during his visi wih
Nordic leaders in Sepember, Presiden Obama rearmed his 2009 G-20 commi-men o expand mulilaeral and bilaeral cooperaion o end unwarraned ossil
uel subsidies and ax breaks or oil companies.106
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
27/35
24 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Despie he presidens phase-ou commimen, litle progress has been made o
end ossil uel subsidies in he Unied Saes.107 According o invesmen rm DBL
Invesors, ossil uels have received a whopping $447 billionin 2010 dollarsin
cumulaive hisorical subsidies, compared o $6 billion in subsidies or low-carbon
energy ha same year.108 Congress could help by reorming U.S. ax policy o
eliminae expensive ax expendiures or mulibillion-dollar oil companies suchas BP, ExxonMobil, and Chevron, all o which would be proable even wihou
governmen subsidies.109 Tese companies, ogeher wih Shell and Conoco, made
roughly $250 billion in pros in 2011 and 2012 combined.110 Presiden Obamas
2014 budge proposes o eliminae nearly $40 billion in unnecessary special ax
breaks or oil and gas companies over he nex 10 years.111
A he same ime, Congress should coninue supporing he no- and low-carbon
energy policies ha are helping move he Unied Saes oward a more susain-
able energy uure. A number o ax credis or alernaive energyincluding he
Producion ax Credi or wind power, credis or alernaive uels, and credis orenergy-ecien homes and appliancesare se o expire a he end o 2013.112
Wihou a naional price on carbon, hese ypes o incenives help pu low-carbon
alernaives ono an even playing eld wih ossil uels.
Congress must ultimately enact legislation to put a price on carbon
In an AugusNew York imes op-ed, our ormer epublican EPA adminisra-
ors praised Presiden Obama or direcing he EPA o regulae carbon dioxide
rom new and exising power plans under he Clean Air Ac and called or [a]
marke-based approach, like a carbon ax o urher reduce greenhouse gas emis-
sions.113 Congress should heed his call and adop a new plan o pu a price on
carbon using a marke-based approach such as a carbon ax. Legislaion proposed
by Sens. Barbara Boxer (D-CA) and Bernie Sanders (I-V) would place a ee on
carbon a $20 per on.114
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
28/35
25 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Conclusion
I emissions o hea-rapping gases coninue unabaed a curren raes and he
climae responds as expeced, NOAA researchers predic ha by he year 2100,
Washingon, D.C.a ciy already known or ho, humid summerswill eel more
like New Orleans, which is locaed abou 1,000 miles souh o he naions capial.
In urn, New Orleans will eel more like Bahraina ho, dry, and mosly deser
counry in he Persian Gul almos 8,000 miles eas o New Orleanswhere
Augus emperaures hisorically average above 100 degrees Fahrenhei.115
As he climae warms, we will no be able o change how ho New Orleans eels
when we are ouside, bu we will need o deal wih he healh eecs and oher
impacs ha will hi children, he elderly, and low-income households he hard-
es.116 We will no be able o sop sea-level rise combined wih more powerul
sorm surges rom batering our coaslines or preven prolonged drough rom
hreaening waer supplies, devasaing crops and livesock, and raising he risk
o wildres across he Wes and Souhwes, bu we will need o deal wih he
afermah.
Congresss ailure o ake meaningul acion on climae change represens an enor-
mous ununded mandae. Unless Congress works wih Presiden Obama, insead
o agains him, o reduce hea-rapping emissions and prepare communiies or
he ineviable impacs o an already-changing climae, he American people will
coninue o pay he cos o doing oo litle, oo lae o comba climae change.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
29/35
26 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
About the authors
Fran Sussman is an independen consulan wih almos hree decades o expe-
rience analyzing issues aecing energy and he environmen. For almos wo
decades, she has explored a diverse se o opics in he economics o climae
change. Her curren research ceners on undersanding he economic impacs oclimae change and how economic analysis, including bene-cos analysis, can
suppor climae decision making. Her experise has assised a variey o cliens,
including ederal agencies, sae governmens, mulilaeral insiuions, no-or-
pro organizaions, and he privae secor, as well as inernaional organizaions.
She holds a Ph.D. in economics rom he Universiy o Maryland.
Cathleen Kelly is a Senior Fellow wih he Cener or American Progress. She
specializes in inernaional and U.S. climae miigaion, preparedness, resilience,
and susainable developmen policy. Kelly served in he Obama adminisraion a
he Whie House Council on Environmenal Qualiy, where she led a more han20-person agency ask orce in developing a naional climae-resilience sraegy.
Tis sraegy ormed he basis o he climae-preparedness pillar o Presiden
Obamas Climae Acion Plan. Kelly also helped ormulae he Obama adminis-
raions posiions on inernaional susainable developmen and climae policy
issues.
Kate Gordon is a Senior Fellow wih he Cener or American Progress, as well as
he vice presiden and direcor o Climae and Energy a Nex Generaion, a San
Francisco-based hink ank. Gordon is naionally recognized or her work a he
inersecion o clean energy and economic developmen and has done policy anal-
ysis, sakeholder engagemen, and sraegic planning a his inersecion or more
han a decade. She holds degrees in law and ciy planning rom he Universiy o
Caliornia a Berkeley.
Acknowledgements
Tank you o Dan Weiss, ichard Caperon, Bracken Hendricks, ebecca Lefon,
David Hudson, Mark Dennin, Anne Paisley, and Cheser Hawkins or heirconribuions o his repor.
8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
30/35
27 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
Endnotes
1 NBC News, A state-by-state look at superstorm Sandysimpact, October 29, 2012, available at http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/10/29/14781430-a-state-by-state-look-at-superstorm-sandys-impact?lite.
2 Hurricane Sandy Rebuilding Task Force, Hurricane
Sandy Rebuilding Strategy(U.S. Department oHousing and Urban Development, 2013), availableat http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/documents/huddoc?id=HSRebuildingStrategy.pd; A state-by-statelook at superstorm Sandys impact.
3 Hurricane Sandy Rebuilding Task Force, Hurricane SandyRebuilding Strategy; CNN Library, Hurricane Sandy FastFacts, CNN, July 13, 2012, available at http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/13/world/americas/hurricane-sandy-ast-acts/index.html.
4 Boulder Oce o Emergency Management, 9-19-20138:50 p.m. End-o-Day Figures, available at http://boulderoem.com/emergency-status/553-9-18-2013-8-50-p-m-end-o-day-gures (last accessed October2013); Fox News, Death toll in Colorado ooding risesto 8 as rescue crews scour rubble in search o missing,September 16, 2013, available at http://www.oxnews.
com/weather/2013/09/16/colorado-braces-or-more-heavy-rain-deadly-oods/; Keith Cofman, Propertylosses rom Colorado ood projected at about $2 bil-lion, Reuters, September 19, 2013, available at http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/09/19/us-usa-colorado-ooding-idUSBRE98H1BA20130919.
5 Boulder Oce o Emergency Management, 9-19-20138:50 p.m. End- o-Day Figures; Fox News, ColoradoBraces For More Heavy Rain and Deadly Floods; Cof-man, Property losses rom Colorado ood projected atabout $2 billion.
6 Daniel J. Weiss and Jackie Weidman, Going to Ex-tremes: The $188 Billion Price Tag rom Climate-RelatedExtreme Weather, Center or American Progress,February 12, 2013, available at http://www.american-progress.org/issues/green/news/2013/02/12/52881/going-to-extremes-the-188-billion-price-tag-rom-cli-
mate-related-extreme-weather/;National Oceanic andAtmospheric Administration, Billion-Dollar Weather/Climate Disasters, available at www.ncdc.noaa.gov/billions/events (last accessed October 2013).
7 Daniel J. Weiss, Jackie Weidman, and StephaniePinkalla, States o Denial: States with the Most FederalDisaster Aid Sent Climate-Science Deniers to Congress(Washington: Center or American Progress, 2013),available at http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/report/2013/09/12/73895/states-o-denial-states-with-the-most-ederal-disaster-aid-sent-climate-science-deniers-to-congress-2/.
8 Thomas C. Peterson, and others Explaining ExtremeEvents o 201 2 rom a Climate Perspective, SpecialSupplement to theBulletin of the American Meteorologi-cal Society94 (9) (2013).
9 Executive Oce o the President, The Presidents ClimateAction Plan (The White House, 2013), available at http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/deault/les/image/presi-dent27sclimateactionplan.pd.
10 Robert Jay Dilger and Richard S. Beth, Ununded Man-dates Reorm Act: History, Impact, and Issues (Washing-ton: Congressional Research Service, 2013), available athttp://www.as.org/sgp/crs/misc/R40957.pd .
11 Ibid.
12 Working Group I o the Intergovernmental Panel onClimate Change, Contribution to the IPCC Fith Assess-ment Report, Climate Change 2013: A Physical ScienceBasis, Summary or Policy Makers (2013), available at
http://www.climatechange2013.org/images/uploads/WGIAR5-SPM_Approved27Sep2013.pd; National Aero-nautics and Space Administration, Consensus: 97%o climate scientists agree, available at http://climate.nasa.gov/scientic-consensus (last accessed October2013).
13 Working Group I, Contribution to the IPCC Fith Assess-ment Report.
14 U.S. Global Change Research Program, Hurricanes: Acompendium o hurricane inormation, available athttp://www.usgcrp.gov/usgcrp/links/hurricanes.htm(last accessed October 2013); Working Group I, Contri-bution to the IPCC Fith Assessment Report.
15 Ibid.; Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,Human inuence on climate clear, IPCC report says,Press release, September 27, 2013, available at http://
www.ipcc.ch/news_and_events/docs/ar5/press_re-lease_ar5_wgi_en.pd.
16 National Climate Assessment Development AdvisoryCommittee, Federal Advisory Committee Drat ClimateAssessment (2013), available at http://ncadac.global-change.gov/.
17 U.S. Global Change Research Center, National ClimateAssessment: Urban Systems, Inrastructure, and Vulner-ability (2013), available at http://ncadac.globalchange.gov/download/NCAJan11-2013-publicreviewdrat-chap11-urban.pd.
18 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration,Billion-Dollar Weather/Climate Disasters.
19 Ibid.
20 Ibid.; Adam B. Smith and Richard W. Katz, U.S. BillionDollar Weather and Climate Disasters: Data Sources,Trends, Accuracy, and Biases, Natural Hazards 67(2) (2013): 387410; The H. John Heinz III Center orScience, Economics and the Environment, The HiddenCosts of Coastal Hazards: Implications for Risk Assessmentand Mitigation (Washington: Island Press, 2000).
21 National Climate Assessment Development AdvisoryCommittee, Federal Advisory Committee Drat ClimateAssessment.
22 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration,Billion-Dollar Weather/Climate Disasters.
23 AgriLie Today, Texas agricultural drought lossesreach record $5.2 billion, August 17, 2011, available athttp://today.agrilie.org/2011/08/17/texas-agricultural-drought-losses-reach-record-5-2-billion/.
24 Ibid.
25 National Interagency Fire Center, Total Wildland Firesand Acres ( 1960-2009), available at http://www.nic.gov/reIno/reIno_stats_totalFires.html(last accessedOctober 2013); National Oceanic and Atmospheric Ad-ministration, Billion-Dollar Weather/Climate Disasters.
http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/10/29/14781430-a-state-by-state-look-at-superstorm-sandys-impact?litehttp://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/10/29/14781430-a-state-by-state-look-at-superstorm-sandys-impact?litehttp://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/10/29/14781430-a-state-by-state-look-at-superstorm-sandys-impact?litehttp://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/documents/huddoc?id=HSRebuildingStrategy.pdfhttp://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/documents/huddoc?id=HSRebuildingStrategy.pdfhttp://www.cnn.com/2013/07/13/world/americas/hurricane-sandy-fast-facts/index.htmlhttp://www.cnn.com/2013/07/13/world/americas/hurricane-sandy-fast-facts/index.htmlhttp://www.cnn.com/2013/07/13/world/americas/hurricane-sandy-fast-facts/index.htmlhttp://boulderoem.com/emergency-status/553-9-18-2013-8-50-p-m-end-of-day-figureshttp://boulderoem.com/emergency-status/553-9-18-2013-8-50-p-m-end-of-day-figureshttp://boulderoem.com/emergency-status/553-9-18-2013-8-50-p-m-end-of-day-figureshttp://www.foxnews.com/weather/2013/09/16/colorado-braces-for-more-heavy-rain-deadly-floods/http://www.foxnews.com/weather/2013/09/16/colorado-braces-for-more-heavy-rain-deadly-floods/http://www.foxnews.com/weather/2013/09/16/colorado-braces-for-more-heavy-rain-deadly-floods/http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/09/19/us-usa-colorado-flooding-idUSBRE98H1BA20130919http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/09/19/us-usa-colorado-flooding-idUSBRE98H1BA20130919http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/09/19/us-usa-colorado-flooding-idUSBRE98H1BA20130919http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/news/2013/02/12/52881/going-to-extremes-the-188-billion-price-tag-from-climate-related-extreme-weather/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/news/2013/02/12/52881/going-to-extremes-the-188-billion-price-tag-from-climate-related-extreme-weather/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/news/2013/02/12/52881/going-to-extremes-the-188-billion-price-tag-from-climate-related-extreme-weather/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/news/2013/02/12/52881/going-to-extremes-the-188-billion-price-tag-from-climate-related-extreme-weather/http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/billions/eventshttp://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/billions/eventshttp://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/report/2013/09/12/73895/states-of-denial-states-with-the-most-federal-disaster-aid-sent-climate-science-deniers-to-congress-2/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/report/2013/09/12/73895/states-of-denial-states-with-the-most-federal-disaster-aid-sent-climate-science-deniers-to-congress-2/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/report/2013/09/12/73895/states-of-denial-states-with-the-most-federal-disaster-aid-sent-climate-science-deniers-to-congress-2/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/report/2013/09/12/73895/states-of-denial-states-with-the-most-federal-disaster-aid-sent-climate-science-deniers-to-congress-2/http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/image/president27sclimateactionplan.pdfhttp://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/image/president27sclimateactionplan.pdfhttp://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/image/president27sclimateactionplan.pdfhttp://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R40957.pdfhttp://www.climatechange2013.org/images/uploads/WGIAR5-SPM_Approved27Sep2013.pdfhttp://www.climatechange2013.org/images/uploads/WGIAR5-SPM_Approved27Sep2013.pdfhttp://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensushttp://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensushttp://www.usgcrp.gov/usgcrp/links/hurricanes.htmhttp://www.ipcc.ch/news_and_events/docs/ar5/press_release_ar5_wgi_en.pdfhttp://www.ipcc.ch/news_and_events/docs/ar5/press_release_ar5_wgi_en.pdfhttp://www.ipcc.ch/news_and_events/docs/ar5/press_release_ar5_wgi_en.pdfhttp://ncadac.globalchange.gov/http://ncadac.globalchange.gov/http://ncadac.globalchange.gov/download/NCAJan11-2013-publicreviewdraft-chap11-urban.pdfhttp://ncadac.globalchange.gov/download/NCAJan11-2013-publicreviewdraft-chap11-urban.pdfhttp://ncadac.globalchange.gov/download/NCAJan11-2013-publicreviewdraft-chap11-urban.pdfhttp://today.agrilife.org/2011/08/17/texas-agricultural-drought-losses-reach-record-5-2-billion/http://today.agrilife.org/2011/08/17/texas-agricultural-drought-losses-reach-record-5-2-billion/http://www.nifc.gov/fireInfo/fireInfo_stats_totalFires.htmlhttp://www.nifc.gov/fireInfo/fireInfo_stats_totalFires.htmlhttp://www.nifc.gov/fireInfo/fireInfo_stats_totalFires.htmlhttp://www.nifc.gov/fireInfo/fireInfo_stats_totalFires.htmlhttp://today.agrilife.org/2011/08/17/texas-agricultural-drought-losses-reach-record-5-2-billion/http://today.agrilife.org/2011/08/17/texas-agricultural-drought-losses-reach-record-5-2-billion/http://ncadac.globalchange.gov/download/NCAJan11-2013-publicreviewdraft-chap11-urban.pdfhttp://ncadac.globalchange.gov/download/NCAJan11-2013-publicreviewdraft-chap11-urban.pdfhttp://ncadac.globalchange.gov/download/NCAJan11-2013-publicreviewdraft-chap11-urban.pdfhttp://ncadac.globalchange.gov/http://ncadac.globalchange.gov/http://www.ipcc.ch/news_and_events/docs/ar5/press_release_ar5_wgi_en.pdfhttp://www.ipcc.ch/news_and_events/docs/ar5/press_release_ar5_wgi_en.pdfhttp://www.ipcc.ch/news_and_events/docs/ar5/press_release_ar5_wgi_en.pdfhttp://www.usgcrp.gov/usgcrp/links/hurricanes.htmhttp://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensushttp://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensushttp://www.climatechange2013.org/images/uploads/WGIAR5-SPM_Approved27Sep2013.pdfhttp://www.climatechange2013.org/images/uploads/WGIAR5-SPM_Approved27Sep2013.pdfhttp://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R40957.pdfhttp://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/image/president27sclimateactionplan.pdfhttp://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/image/president27sclimateactionplan.pdfhttp://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/image/president27sclimateactionplan.pdfhttp://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/report/2013/09/12/73895/states-of-denial-states-with-the-most-federal-disaster-aid-sent-climate-science-deniers-to-congress-2/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/report/2013/09/12/73895/states-of-denial-states-with-the-most-federal-disaster-aid-sent-climate-science-deniers-to-congress-2/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/report/2013/09/12/73895/states-of-denial-states-with-the-most-federal-disaster-aid-sent-climate-science-deniers-to-congress-2/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/report/2013/09/12/73895/states-of-denial-states-with-the-most-federal-disaster-aid-sent-climate-science-deniers-to-congress-2/http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/billions/eventshttp://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/billions/eventshttp://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/news/2013/02/12/52881/going-to-extremes-the-188-billion-price-tag-from-climate-related-extreme-weather/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/news/2013/02/12/52881/going-to-extremes-the-188-billion-price-tag-from-climate-related-extreme-weather/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/news/2013/02/12/52881/going-to-extremes-the-188-billion-price-tag-from-climate-related-extreme-weather/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/news/2013/02/12/52881/going-to-extremes-the-188-billion-price-tag-from-climate-related-extreme-weather/http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/09/19/us-usa-colorado-flooding-idUSBRE98H1BA20130919http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/09/19/us-usa-colorado-flooding-idUSBRE98H1BA20130919http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/09/19/us-usa-colorado-flooding-idUSBRE98H1BA20130919http://www.foxnews.com/weather/2013/09/16/colorado-braces-for-more-heavy-rain-deadly-floods/http://www.foxnews.com/weather/2013/09/16/colorado-braces-for-more-heavy-rain-deadly-floods/http://www.foxnews.com/weather/2013/09/16/colorado-braces-for-more-heavy-rain-deadly-floods/http://boulderoem.com/emergency-status/553-9-18-2013-8-50-p-m-end-of-day-figureshttp://boulderoem.com/emergency-status/553-9-18-2013-8-50-p-m-end-of-day-figureshttp://boulderoem.com/emergency-status/553-9-18-2013-8-50-p-m-end-of-day-figureshttp://www.cnn.com/2013/07/13/world/americas/hurricane-sandy-fast-facts/index.htmlhttp://www.cnn.com/2013/07/13/world/americas/hurricane-sandy-fast-facts/index.htmlhttp://www.cnn.com/2013/07/13/world/americas/hurricane-sandy-fast-facts/index.htmlhttp://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/documents/huddoc?id=HSRebuildingStrategy.pdfhttp://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/documents/huddoc?id=HSRebuildingStrategy.pdfhttp://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/10/29/14781430-a-state-by-state-look-at-superstorm-sandys-impact?litehttp://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/10/29/14781430-a-state-by-state-look-at-superstorm-sandys-impact?litehttp://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/10/29/14781430-a-state-by-state-look-at-superstorm-sandys-impact?lite8/22/2019 Climate Change: An Unfunded Mandate
31/35
28 Center or American Progress | Climate Change: An Ununded Mandate
26 Ibid.
27 InciWeb, Rim Fire Closures, available at http://inciweb.org/incident/closures/3660/ (last accessed October2013).
28 Anthony L. Westerling and others, Continued warmingcould transorm Greater Yellowstone re regimes bymid-21st century, Proceedings of the National Academyof Sciences 108 (32) (2011): 1316513170, availableat http://www.pnas.org/content/108/32/13165.ull.pd+html.
29 Jeremy Schulman, 7 more national parks threatenedby re, Grist, available at http://grist.org/climate-energy/7-more-national-parks-threatened-by-re/(lastaccessed October 2013).
30 National Climate Assessment Development AdvisoryCommittee, Federal Advisory Committee Drat ClimateAssessment,; Tracey Ross, A Disaster in the Making(Washington: Center or American Progress, 2013),available at http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/poverty/report/2013/08/19/72445/a-disaster-in-the-making/.
31 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, ClimateChange 2007: Synthesis Report (2007), available athttp://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/publica-tions_ipcc_ourth_assessment_report_synthesis_re-port.htm.
32 Thomas C. Peterson, Peter A. Stott, and StephanieHerring, Explaining Extreme Events o 2011 rom aClimate Perspective, Special Supplement to the Bulletinof the American Meteorological Society93 (1) (2013):10411067.
33 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administra-tion, New analyses nd evidence o human-causedclimate change in hal o the 12 extreme weatherand climate events analyzed rom 2012, September5, 2013, available at http://www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2013/20130905-extremeweatherandcli-mateevents.html; Peterson, Hoerling, Stott, and Her-ring, Explaining Extreme Events o 2012 rom a ClimatePerspective.
34 Ibid.
35 Interagency Climate Change Adaptation Task Force,Federal Actions or a Climate Resilient Nation (2011),available at http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/deault/les/microsites/ceq/2011_adaptation_progress_report.pd.
36 City o Grand Rapids, Citizens Guide To The Citys Fi-nances (2012), available at http://grcity.us/Documents/PAFR%202012.pd.
37 The costs or Grand Rapids equal about $1,270 percapita. Scaling these up to a national level, basedon current population estimates, results in costsexceeding $400 billion. Ibid.; Haris Alibaic, BuildingResilient and Sustainable Grand Rapids,GermanAmerican Water Technology Magazine, 2013/2014, p. 30,available at http://www.gaccmidwest.org/leadmin/ahk_chicago/2013_GAWT_Initiative/GAWT_Maga-zine_2013-2014_FINAL.pd.
38 King County, Washington, Flooding services, availableat http://www.kingcounty.gov/environment/water-andland/ooding/buyout.aspx (last accessed October2013).
39 Seattle Public Utilities, Seattle Natural DrainageSystems Program (2011), available at www.seattle.gov/util/groups/public/@spu/@usm/documents/webcon-tent/spu02_019983.pd.
40 James W. Beever III and others, City o Punta GordaAdaptation Plan (Ft. Myers, FL: Southwest FloridaRegional Planning Council and Charlotte HarborNational Estuary Program, 2009), available at https://www.seagrant.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/Punta_Gorda_Adaptation_Plan.pd.
41 Massachusetts Water Resources Authority, The BostonHarbor Project: an Environmental Success Story, avail-able at http://www.mwra.state.ma.us/01news/2008/bhpenvironentalsuccess/bhpenvsuccess.htm(lastaccessed October 2013).
42 Executive Oce o the Mayor o the District o Colum-bia, Mayor Gray Joins 44 Mayors and County Leaders inPledging to Create More Resilient Cities, Press release,June 17, 2013, available at http://mayor.dc.gov/release/mayor-gray-joins-44-mayors-and-county-leaders-pledging-create-more-resilient-cities.
43 Fran Sussman and others, Climate change adaptationcost in the US: what do we know? (Washington: Cli-mate Policy, 2013,: available at http://www.tandonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14693062.2013.777604#preview.
44 Kenneth D. Frederick and Gregory E. Shwarz, Socioeco-nomic Impacts o Climate Availability and Change onU.S. Water Resources (Washington: Resources or theFuture, 2000), available at http://www.rf.org/docu-ments/RFF-DP-00-21.pd; Intergovernmental Panel onClimate Change, Human inuence on climate clear,
IPCC report says.
45 The Disaster Relief Appropriations Act of 2013, Public Law113-2, 113th Cong., 1st sess. (January 29, 2013).
46 Oce o Governor Andrew M. Cuomo, GovernorCuomo Holds Meeting with New Yorks CongressionalDelegation, Mayor Bloomberg and Regional CountyExecutives to Review Damage Assessment or the Statein the Wake o Hurricane Sandy, Press release, Novem-ber 26, 2012, available at http://www.governor.ny.gov/press/11262012-damageassessment.
47 Daniel Lasho and Andy Stevenson, Who Pays orClimate Change? (Washington: National ResourcesDeense Council, 2013), available at http://www.nrdc.org/globalwarming/les/taxpayer-climate-costs-IP.pd.
48 Congressional Budget Oce, Public Spending on
Transportation and Water Inrastructure (2010), avail-able at http://www.cbo.gov/publication/21902.
49 Interagency Climate Change Adaptation Task Force,Federal Actions or a Climate R esilient Nation.
50 National Association o State Budget Ocers, StateExpenditure Report: Examining Fiscal 2010 - 201 2 StateSpending (2012), available at http://www.nasbo.org/publications-data/state-expenditure-report/state-expenditure-report-scal-2010-2012-data. I Updatedthe year and source o data in the text and endnoteokay?
51 Thomas Kaplan, State Tells Investors That ClimateChange May Hurt Its Finances, The New York Times,March 26, 2013, available at http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/27/nyregion/new-york-state-bonds-include-warning-on-climate-change.html?_r=0.
52 Ibid.
53 Ibid.
54 U.S. Government Accountability Oce, Limiting theFederal Governments Fiscal Exposure by Better Manag-ing Climate Change Risks (2013), available at http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-13-283.
http://inciweb.org/incident/closures/3660/http://inciweb.org/incident/closures/3660/http://www.pnas.org/content/108/32/13165.full.pdf+htmlhttp://www.pnas.org/content/108/32/13165.full.pdf+htmlhttp://grist.org/climate-energy/7-more-national-parks-threatened-by-fire/http://grist.org/climate-energy/7-more-national-parks-threatened-by-fire/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/poverty/report/2013/08/19/72445/a-disaster-in-the-making/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/poverty/report/2013/08/19/72445/a-disaster-in-the-making/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/poverty/report/2013/08/19/72445/a-disaster-in-the-making/http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/publications_ipcc_fourth_assessment_report_synthesis_report.htmhttp://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/publications_ipcc_fourth_assessment_report_synthesis_report.htmhttp://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/publications_ipcc_fourth_assessment_report_synthesis_report.htmhttp://www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2013/20130905-extremeweatherandclimateevents.htmlhttp://www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2013/20130905-extremeweatherandclimateevents.htmlhttp://www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2013/20130905-extremeweatherandclimateevents.htmlhttp://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ceq/2011_adaptation_progress_report.pdfhttp://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ceq/2011_adaptation_progress_report.pdfhttp://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ceq/2011_adaptation_progress_report.pdfhttp://grcity.us/Documents/PAFR%202012.pdfhttp://grcity.us/Documents/PAFR%202012.pdfhttp://www.gaccmidwest.org/fileadmin/ahk_chicago/2013_GAWT_Initiative/GAWT_Magazine_2013-2014_FINAL.pdfhttp://www.gaccmidwest.org/fileadmin/ahk_chicago/2013_GAWT_Initiative/GAWT_Magazine_2013-2014_FINAL.pdfhttp://www.gaccmidwest.org/fileadmin/ahk_chicago/2013_GAWT_Initiative/GAWT_Magazine_2013-2014_FINAL.pdfhttp://www.kingcounty.gov/environment/waterandland/flooding/buyout.aspxhttp://www.kingcounty.gov/environment/waterandland/flooding/buyout.aspxhttp://www.seattle.gov/util/groups/public/@spu/@usm/documents/webcontent/spu02_019983.pdfhttp://www.seattle.gov/util/groups/public/@spu/@usm/documents/webcontent/spu02_019983.pdfhttp://www.seattle.gov/util/groups/public/@spu/@usm/documents/webcontent/spu02_019983.pdfhttps://www.flseagrant.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/Punta_Gorda_Adaptation_Plan.pdfhttps://www.flseagrant.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/Punta_Gorda_Adaptation_Plan.pdfhttps://www.flseagrant.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/Punta_Gorda_Adaptation_Plan.pdfhttp://www.mwra.state.ma.us/01news/2008/bhpenvironentalsuccess/bhpenvsuccess.htmhttp://www.mwra.state.ma.us/01news/2008/bhpenvironentalsuccess/bhpenvsuccess.htmhttp://mayor.dc.gov/release/mayor-gray-joins-44-mayors-and-county-leaders-pledging-create-more-resilient-citieshttp://mayor.dc.gov/release/mayor-gray-joins-44-mayors-and-county-leaders-pledging-create-more-resilient-citieshttp://mayor.dc.gov/release/mayor-gray-joins-44-mayors-and-county-leaders-pledging-create-more-resilient-citieshttp://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14693062.2013.777604#previewhttp://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14693062.2013.777604#previewhttp://www.governor.ny.gov/press/11262012-damageassessmenthttp://www.governor.ny.gov/press/11262012-damageassessmenthttp://www.nrdc.org/globalwarming/files/taxpayer-climate-costs-IP.pdfhttp://www.nrdc.org/globalwarming/files/taxpayer-climate-costs-IP.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/publication/21902http://www.nasbo.org/publications-data/state-expenditure-report/state-expenditure-report-fiscal-2010-2012-datahttp://www.nasbo.org/publications-data/state-expenditure-report/state-expendit