CLIC related CERN-KEK collaboration J.P.Delahaye for the CLIC study team
Dec 27, 2015
CLIC related CERN-KEK collaboration
J.P.Delahaye
for the CLIC study team
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 2
Outline
• Long standing collaboration between CERN & KEK in the frame of Linear Colliders R&D
• CERN participation in KEK Accelerator test facility (ATF):– Generation of low emittance beams (micro rad-m)
– Focusing to extremely low beam sizes (nm)
• KEK participation in High Gradient RF structures R&D (100 MV/m):– Fabrication of normal conducting structures@KEK
– Tests with power of structures @ KEK
CERN Participation in ATF
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 4
ATF collaborationATF collaboration damping-ring prototype ATF at KEK
achieves world’s smallest emittance beams;pioneered numerous diagnostics developments(laser wires, diffraction radiation, X-ray optics, interferometry, …)
tuning & correction schemes
trains young generation of accelerator physicists final focus ATF-2
truly international projectuses low-emittance beam extracted from ATF ring
aims to produce 30 nm spot size with less than 5% orbit “jitter”
test of diagnostics (nm-BPMs, spot-size monitors)test of feedbacks & stabilization schemes
polarized e+ source via Compton back-scattering(PosiPol collaboration; beam tests at ATF)
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 5
QD31T
ML5TBPM.2
BH1R
BH1R.36BH1R.19
BH1R.18
BPM.1
ZV51RZH48RBPM.48
BPM.49
QF1R.14 ZV24R ZH23R
QF2R.14 QF2R
QF1R.28
QF31T
ZH30T
ZV30T
Beam Dump
MW1XMW1X
MW2XMW3X
MW4X
ATF Damping Ring
Electoron Linac
BT( Beam Transport Line )
Extraction Line
SR Monitor
RF Cavity
Wiggler
Injection Kicker
Seputum Magnets
Extraction KickerWiggler
East Arc
North Straight
South Straight
West Arc
Wire scanner
E=1.28GeVNe=1x1010 e-/bunch 1 ~ 20 bunches
Rep=1.5HzX emit=2.5E-6 m ( at 0 intensity)
Y emit=2.5E-8 m ( at 0 intensity)
Accelerator Test Facility
Damping ring
Linac
H. Hayano
ATF is the largest LC Test Facility
~ ILC emittance requirements
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 6
ATF demonstrated single bunch emittancex~3.5-4.3 m
(1.4-1.7 nm)y~13-18 nm
(5-7 pm)at 8x109 e-/bunch
CLIC target valuesx~0.5 m y~3 nm at 4x109 e-/bunch
?
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 7
Beam sizes at Collisions
R.M.S. Beam Sizes at Collision in Linear Colliders
ILC500
CLIC500
CLIC3000
FFTBSLC
ATF2
0.1
1
10
100
1000
10 100 1000Horizontal Beam Size (nm)
Ver
tica
l B
eam
Siz
e (n
m)
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 8
KEK Crab Cavity Group has relocated clearing space for ATF2.Floor refurbishment finished this fall. ATF2 requires rearranging extraction line components and connecting it to ATF2 beam line during 2008 summer shutdown.
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 9
ATF/ATF2 master scheduleconsistent with CLIC feasibility study by 2010
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 10
effective since August 1, 2005
ATF-MoU
about 20 member institutes
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 11
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 12
ATF Spokesperson(s)J. Urakawa, KEKThree Deputies (with help of sub-Deputies from KEK) Deputy for Beam operation: S.Kuroda (T.Okugi)Deputy for Hardware maintenance: N.Terunuma (M.Kuriki)Deputy for ATF2: A.Seryi (T.Tauchi)
ATF System and Group Coordinators (SGC)H.Weise, DESYF.Zimmermann, CERNPhilip Burrows, UKGrahame Blair, UKP. Bambade, LALM. Ross, FNALJ. Nelson, SLACA. Seryi, SLACR. Meller, Cornell (US Univ),J.Gao, IHEP/Beijing,E.S.Kim, KNU,/KoreaK.Kubo,S.Kuroda,N.Terunuma,M.Kuriki,T.Tauchi,T.Okugi,R.Sugawara, KEK,T.Sanuki, University of Tokyo
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 13
ATF Technical Board (TB)
Europe…………………………...E. Elsen, DESYG. Blair, RHUL (Royal Holloway, University of London) P. Burrows, Oxford University+ QMULF. Zimmermann, CERNA. Wolski, CI
North America…………………..T. Raubenheimer, SLACM. Ross, FNAL
Asia………………………………K. Yokoya, KEKN. Toge, KEKT. Sanuki, University of TokyoJ. Gao, IHEPE-S. Kim, KNU
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 14
ATF International Collaboration Board (ICB)
Bob Kephart FNALBrian Foster OxfordDavid Miller UCLMitsuaki Nozaki KEKMichael Harrison BNLJ.P. Delahaye CERNJai Gao IHEPJohn Corlett LBNLKaoru Yokoya KEKEckhart Elsen DESYNobaru Sasao Kyoto UniversityPaterson, Ewan (chair) SLACPhilip Burrows OxfordRobert Meller Cornell UniversitySachio Komamiya University of TokyoTsutomu Nakanisi Nagoya UniversityWashio Masakazu Waseda UniversityJinhyuk Choi PAL
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 15
CERN hardware contribution to ATF-2• honeycomb table (from TMC)
• honeycomb structure with length 2.4 m, width 0.8 m, height 0.8 m
• absence of structural resonance below 230 Hz• table previously used for CLIC stabilization study• presently on loan at LAPP/Annecy• ATF purpose: to stabilize the final quadrupoles
• stabilizing feet (STACIS2000 from TMC)• equipped with geophones, rubber pads for passive damping,
and piezo-electric movers for active damping of load vibrations induced from the ground
• had been offered too, but LAPP found: not useful for ATF2 • value about 100,000 CHF (8.72 MYen)
LAPP/Annecy will ship honeycomb table (or identical new table it will purchase) table to KEK in 2008
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 16
CLIC test stand for vibration measurements & magnet stabilization studies
S. Redaelli, R. Assmann
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 17
ongoing & planned CERN ATF “studies” development of commissioning strategy;
already wrote section of design report
• investigation of optimum beam-based alignment pro-cedures with pertinent specification of BPM ranges
• simulation of IP tuning and maximum tuning knobranges
• survey of relevant collective effects in ATF-2and ATF extraction line; particularly wake fields + ions
• participation in commissioning activities
1 person month
3 person months
3 person months
4 person months
1 person month in total:1 person yearapproved by CSCon 13.10.2005
EUROTeV&BDIR LondonMeeting 2005;Nanobeam’05
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 18
CERN live participation
• many pre-2004 visits (J.-P. Potier, F. Zimmermann)• 7th Int’l ATF coll. mtg 2001 (H. Braun, F. Zimmermann)• 3-wk ATF visit by M. Korostelev 12/2004 - measurements of ATF DR damping times
with and w/o wiggler - alternative low-emittance DR design
• 3-wk ATF visit by R. Tomas 12/2006 - measurements of resonance driving terms in ATF damping ring
- skew quadrupole requirements for vertical dispersion correction at ATF2 - feasibility study of octupole tail folding for ATF2
• 2-wk ATF visit by R. Tomas 12/2007• 1-wk ATF visit by F. Zimmermann 12/2007• ATF collaboration meetings and IFIC-LAL-CERN meetings in Annecy,
Geneva, Hamburg, Valencia and Paris (H. Braun, R. Tomas, F. Zimmermann); ATF TB & SGC meetings
• regular ATF2 and PosiPol phone meetings
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 19
25% of ATF Reports in 2006 with CERN lead authors
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 20
CERN-IFIC-LAL-UK collaboration on ATF
participants: P. Bambade (LAL), A. Faus-Golfe (IFIC), R. Tomas, F. Zimmermann (CERN), R. Appleby (CI); >4 PhD students and postdocs
anomalous current-dependent emittance growth between ring and extraction line;
topics: four-dimensional emittance diagnostics in the extraction line
bi-monthly meetings and discussions
first beam studies in November/December 2007
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 21
additional future collaboration subjects• beam halo studies • IBS effects (bunch shape & tails) • flight simulator• code comparisons• Compton e+ stacking studies
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 22
polarized e+/e- sourcebased on laser Compton back scattering
M. Kuriki, T. Omori, J. Urakawa, KEKK. Moenig, A. Variola, F. Zomer, LALE. Bulyak, P. Gladkikh, NSC KIPT
highly polarized e+ and e- (>90%); fully independent e+ generation
Compton e- ring
experimental verification at ATF (e.g. Phys.Rev.Lett.96:114801,2006)
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 23
Draft of Collaborative agreement being preparedas a follow-up of visit@CERN of Prof Suzuki on 02/07/07
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 24
Collaboration agreement
• "Agreement on Collaborative Work", under reference ICA- JP-0103. Two signature versions are at CERN with the Legal Service, awaiting green light by KEK for signature.
• Appendix 1: 2003 Memorandum concerning the Participation of Japanese Summer Students in the CERN Summer Student Programme
• Appendix 2: general “umbrella” for high-gradient studies & collaboration on High Gradient Accelerator Technology and Fabrication and Tests of X-Band Accelerating Structures
• Appendix 3 to Agreement on Collaborative Work: Design, fabrication and test of high gradient accelerating structures T18_vg2.4_disk and TD18_vg2.4_quad
• Appendix 4: next to be written, accelerating structures disk damped + next round of structures based on test results
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 25
High-gradient accelerating structure production
• Objective of the collaboration:Both KEK and CERN in the past decade have been forerunners in
the world for the R&D’s of high gradient acceleration on the basis of normal conducting accelerator structures. The objective of this collaboration is to facilitate further development of related key technologies, in particular the X-band technologies, by the two parties
• Technical contacts:– KEK:
• Yukihide Kamiya, Director of Accelerator Laboratory of KEK• Toshiyasu Higo, Accelerator Laboratory of KEK• Shigeki Fukuda, Accelerator Laboratory of KEK
– CERN: • Jean-Pierre Delahaye, CLIC study leader • Walter Wuensch, CLIC structure leader• Germana Riddone, CLIC structure production• Steffen Doebert, CLIC structure testing
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 26
• Acceptable Breakdown Rate in linear collider operation not higher than 10-6
• Reduction of accelerating field by about 30 MV/m for low BR with Cu
Cu
Mo
CLIC High-Power tests various materials results @ 30 GHz
CLIC operational
goal
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 27
The beauty of 12 GHz
• Close to maximum Performance and minimum Cost (14 GHz)• Accelerating gradient of 100 MV/m already demonstrated at low breakdown
rate with short pulse in non fully equipped structures• Very close to the NLC and JLC frequency: 11.4 GHz
– Building up on wide expertise and long-term R&D made during many years on warm structures, RF power sources, beam dynamics at SLAC and KEK
– Take advantage of low(er than 30 GHz) frequency for easier fabrication (tolerances, vacuum), relaxed requirements (alignment, timing, etc…),
• RF power generation and frequency multiplication in CLIC TBA RF Power Source– High gradients achievable with short RF pulse provided by TBA RF
power source– Easy adaptation of CTF3 (multiplication factor by 8 instead of 10)
• Stand alone power sources available:– Makes the best use of developments and equipments at SLAC and KEK
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 28
X-band (11.4 GHz) Test Facilities at KEK
Single Klystron (50 MW) test stand up and running
NEXTEF: Available from fall 2007, 2x50 MW, 400 ns, 24/7 operation
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 29
The state of the Art in x-band structures
Final NLC/GLC prototype, fully equipped with higher order mode damping, a pair of these structures made by KEK was tested in the ASSET facility at SLAC to determine the wake fields and demonstrated the extremely high standards in precession machining achieved by KEK.
Tests of old NLC structures at short pulses
T53vg3MC can be used as a first reference for the new CLIC parameters
CLIC goal
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 31
2007 2008
Nov Dez J an Feb Mar Apr May J un J ul Aug Sept Oct Nov
Facility Structure
CTF3 30 GHz NDS4_vg3.6_thin
C30_vg4.7_quad
C30_vg2.6
C30_vg8.2
C30_vg2_TM02
HDS11_vg2
C30_vg4.7_sb
CLEX 12 GHz Pets 12 GHz
T18_vg2.4_disk
NEXTEF 11.4 GHz KX03
Old CLI C vg1.1
T18_vg2.4_disk[2]
T18_vg2.4_disk[3]
TD18_vg2.4_quad[2]
TD18_vg2.4_disk[2]
SLAC Station 1 TD18_vg2.4_quad[1]
11.4 GHz C10vg0.7[1]
C10vg1.3[1]
C10vg3.3[1]
C10vg2.2_thick[1]
HXD11 Cu big grains
SLAC Station 2 T28_vg2.9
C10vg0.7[2]
C10vg1.3[2]
C10vg3.3[2]
C10vg2.2_thick[2]
T53vg3MC
SLAC Station 3 T18_vg2.4_disk[1]
T18_vg2.4_disk[4]
PETS 11.4 GHz
TD18_vg2.4_disk[1]
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 32
Near future accelerating structures
• T18_VG2.4_disk (disk undamped): 3 structures– Objective: to use JLC espertise in structure fabrication to study a
structure with rf parameters close to nominale ones, huigh quality data by testing multilple structures (a forth structure will be fabricated by EU company and tested at CERN)
– #1, #2: fabrication of disks by KEK, delivered to SLAC, ready for bonding, then tested at SLAC and KEK
– #3: all made and tested by KEK
• TD18_VG2.4_quad (quadrant damped): one structure– Objective: learn about quadrant fabrication and assembly– Test cutting by 5 companies: HITACHI, I I C, YASDA,
Morikawa, U-corporation– Select one company to make a prototype quadrant– Fabrication of one full structure– Test full structure at KEK
June
-07
to M
ay-0
8 (t
est
not
incl
uded
)
July
07
to J
une-
08
(tes
t no
t in
clud
ed)
Red: to be done
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 33
Kek’s schedule for structure testing using the NEXTEF facility
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 34
T18_VG2.4_disk
Structure elements for #1 and #2
Bead pull system for rf measurements
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 35
Input matching and transmissionin clamped T18_VG2.4_disk (#1 and #2) cavity
Very good performance!
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 36
TD18_VG2.4_quad
3D dimensional control under way
Test piece received in Nov 2007
CERN-KEK Committee 07/12/07J.P.Delahaye 37
Conclusion
~Excellent collaboration between CERN and KEK about Linear Colliders & CLIC related activities:
• ATF 1,2 @ KEK:– Strong CERN involvement– microrad beam emittances,nm spot sizes & nm stability crucial for CLIC– looking forward to <40 nm spot sizes in 2008/09!
• High Gradient RF structures R&D– Excellent KEK expertise and vital contribution– CERN/KEK/SLAC fruitful collaboration – Fabrication and tests of RF structures on existing Test stands– Participation in RF designs– looking forward to > 100 MV/m accelerating gradient in 2008/09!
• Possible future collaboration:– More exchange of exoperts and visits – Modulator development: one KEK expert on CTF3 modulator for one year– High power X band klystron developments– Number of R&D subjects in the frame of CERN-Japan fellowship program