Class 3-Law Fall

8/13/2019 Class 3-Law Fall

1/32

EnvironmentalEnvironmental

Law & RegulationLaw & Regulation!"#$%&'(#)%" #% +",)$%"-."#/0 1./0#2!"#$%&'(#)%" #% +",)$%"-."#/0 1./0#2

3'--.$ 45663'--.$ 4566

7/$8 7/$.#/"%9 :2;7/$8 7/$.#/"%9 :2;


2/32

4

Learning ObjectivesLearning Objectives

!!;..&.$/0 /"&


3/32

B

Government andGovernment and The LawThe Law

!! C2. DA3A E%" #2. 0/"&AC2. DA3A E%" #2. 0/"&A

!! ;.>)".< #2. #2. >.&.$/0 ?%,.$"-."# /"& )#)".< #2. #2. >.&.$/0 ?%,.$"-."# /"& )# ?%,.$"-."#A

!! G% 0/F< -/8 (%"#$/&)(# /"8 %> #2. E%"JJ@%F.$@%F.$KK%$ /'#2%$)#8 )" /"8 %". ."#)#8A%$ /'#2%$)#8 )" /"8 %". ."#)#8A

!! C2$.. =$/"(2.< %> ?%,.$"-."#C2$.. =$/"(2.< %> ?%,.$"-."#

!! +0.(#)%"< #% $.@$.


4/32

L

Branches of GovernmentBranches of Government

!! M.?)


5/32

Y

Levels of GovernmentLevels of Government

!! Z.&.$/0Z.&.$/0!! D0#)-/#. /'#2%$)#8 F)#2)" "/$$%F 0)-)#< ?$/"#.& =8 #2. (%".&.$/0 0/FA%$ ?$./#.$ )".& =8 #2.


6/32

]

Other Governmental EntitiesOther Governmental Entities

!! Z.&.$/0 /"& 3#/#. 0/F -/8 /00%F #2. ($./#)%" %>Z.&.$/0 /"& 3#/#. 0/F -/8 /00%F #2. ($./#)%" %>

JJ)"&.@."&."#)"&.@."&."#KK."#)#).< #% /&&$. 1./0#2 O/&,)


7/32

_

LawsLaws!! +/(2 =$/"(2 %> ?%,.$"-."# )< )",%0,.& F)#2 #2. 0.?/0 @$%(. ?%,.$"-."#A

!! M/F< #/I. -/"8 >%$-< /"& #2. #.$- 2/< ,/$8)"? &.>)")#)%" (%"&'(# %$ /(#)%" @$.%$-/008 $.(%?")`.& /%$(.& =8 / (%"#$%00)"? /'#2%$)#8A

!! Z%$ %'$ @'$@%


8/32

a

!! !"##$!"##$ !"# ! %"&%&'#( )!*' &"!"# ! %"&%&'#( )!*' &" '+!+,+#'-'+!+,+#'-

!! ./#0 !"# 12+"&(,3#( 40 #)#3+#( &55131!)' !2( ,2(#"6&./#0 !"# 12+"&(,3#( 40 #)#3+#( &55131!)' !2( ,2(#"6&

7!20 )!0#"' &5 "#81#* !2( (#4!+#-7!20 )!0#"' &5 "#81#* !2( (#4!+#-

!! 9&'+ 5!)) 40 +/# *!0'1(# !2( !"# 2&+ 8&+#( ,%&2-9&'+ 5!)) 40 +/# *!0'1(# !2( !"# 2&+ 8&+#( ,%&2-

!! : 41)) 4#3&7#' )!* ;! '+!+,+#< 15 1+ 1' %!''#( 40 ! 7!=&"1+0: 41)) 4#3&7#' )!* ;! '+!+,+#< 15 1+ 1' %!''#( 40 ! 7!=&"1+08&+# &5 +/# )#61')!+,"#-8&+# &5 +/# )#61')!+,"#-

!! &'(')'*&'(')'*>>#2!3+#( &2)0 40 +/# )#61')!+18# 4"!23/ &5 '+!+# &"#2!3+#( &2)0 40 +/# )#61')!+18# 4"!23/ &5 '+!+# &"

5#(#"!) 6&8#"27#2+5#(#"!) 6&8#"27#2+

!! ?+!+,+#' !"# #2!3+#( 40?+!+,+#' !"# #2!3+#( 40 #)#3+#(#)#3+#(4&(1#'-4&(1#'-!! ./#"# 1' 6#2#"!))0 '&7# 12+#2+ &5 %#"7!2#23#-./#"# 1' 6#2#"!))0 '&7# 12+#2+ &5 %#"7!2#23#-

!! ./#0 7!0 %"&81(# +/# !,+/&"1+0 5&" 2&2./#0 7!0 %"&81(# +/# !,+/&"1+0 5&" 2&2@@#)#3+#(#)#3+#(

"#6,)!+&"0 4&(1#'A!6#231#' +& #2!3+ "#6,)!+1&2'-"#6,)!+&"0 4&(1#'A!6#231#' +& #2!3+ "#6,)!+1&2'-

Bills & StatutesBills & Statutes


9/32

b

Regulations & Executive OrdersRegulations & Executive Orders

!! !"#$%&'()*+,!"#$%&'()*+, %>#." (/00.& /&-)") /'#2%$)#8AP.?'0/#%$8 @%F.$ )< 0)-)#.& #% #2. %$ :'=0)( E%--."#e@@%$#'")#8 >%$ :'=0)( E%--."#

!! :'=0)( 2./$)"?< Q F$)##." (%--."#%$(. /"& .>>.(# %> 0/F%> /?."().< /"& 2/,. #2. >%$(. /"& .>>.(# %> 0/F


10/32

65

4'&'$'"4'&'$'"

! D>.(# #2. .T#."# %> $.?'0/#)%" /< F.00 /< )# #2. E0./" U)$ U(# U-."&-."#< %> 6bb5A


13/32

6B

How do environmental lawsHow do environmental lawswork?work?

A few examplesA few examples


14/32

6L

Require action byRequire action by someonesomeone

! +T.('#),. /?."().#.$ ;.(.-=.$ B69

6b_59 ?%,.$"-."#! +/(2 3#/#. %$ )[email protected]."#/#)%"9

-/)"#."/"(.9 /"& .">%$(.-."# %>


15/32

6Y

!

4"' +'&*3&23+ 5)2 6)%%$'&*' %"1"%+ (*"*1(2)*7"*'&% 7"3(&

!! E0./" U)$ U(#E0./" U)$ U(# XXG/#)%"/0 U-=)."# U)$ j'/0)#8 3#/"&/$&/(. F/#.$ ['/0)#8 ($)#.$)/3'$>/(. F/#.$ ['/0)#8 ($)#.$)/

! !"#$%&'" '8" 3(+08&2#" )2 "7(++()* )5 +6"0(5(06)%%$'&*'+ ') '8" "*1(2)*7"*'9

!! P.


16/32

!! !":$(2" $+" )5 +6"0(5(0 '"08*)%)#;!":$(2" $+" )5 +6"0(5(0 '"08*)%)#;

!!N.%$-/"(. 3#/"&/$&< OG3:3R

+-)%%&9 ,%0/#)0.0./& )" @/)"#9 @.


17/32

6_

!!!":$(2" 0"2'&(* =)2> 62&0'(0"+!":$(2" 0"2'&(* =)2> 62&0'(0"+

!!!"%$ 0./I


18/32


19/32

6b

Some Governmental Agencies that propose andSome Governmental Agencies that propose and

adopt regulations and enforce lawsadopt regulations and enforce laws

!! Z.&.$/0Z.&.$/0

!!+",)$%"-."#/0 :$%#.(#)%" U?."(8 O+:UR+",)$%"-."#/0 :$%#.(#)%" U?."(8 O+:UR

!!DA3A :'=0)( 1./0#2 3.$,)(.DA3A :'=0)( 1./0#2 3.$,)(.

!! 3#/#. OGWR3#/#. OGWR

!!;.@/$#-."# %> +",)$%"-."#/0 :$%#.(#)%" OGW;+:R;.@/$#-."# %> +",)$%"-."#/0 :$%#.(#)%" OGW;+:R

!!;.@/$#-."# %> 1./0#2 Q 3.")%$ 3.$,)(.< OGW;133R;.@/$#-."# %> 1./0#2 Q 3.")%$ 3.$,)(.< OGW;133R

!! M%(/0M%(/0

!!1./0#2 &.@/$#-."#


20/32


21/32

46

Civil EnforcementCivil Enforcement

!! M.,.0 %> @$%%> $.[')$.&M.,.0 %> @$%%> $.[')$.&

!! @@B2"6)*3"2&*0" )5 "1(3"*0"B2"6)*3"2&*0" )5 "1(3"*0"AA

!! C8@.< %> U(#)%" U(#)%" ,)%0/#)%"G%#)(. %> ,)%0/#)%"

!! G%#)(. %> @."/0#8 /3'@.$)%$ (%'$# -/8 ?$/"# )"c'"(#),. $.0).>

!! V%


22/32

44

Criminal EnforcementCriminal Enforcement

!! P.[')$.< @$%%>P.[')$.< @$%%>JJ=.8%"& / $./%$ (%00.(#)"? .,)&."(.A

!! :%#."#)/008 -%$. %$ ,)%0/#%$O)-@$)%$>.)#'$. %> @$%@.$#8 .#(ARAO)-@$)%$>.)#'$. %> @$%@.$#8 .#(ARA

!! S2.$. /@@0)(/=0.9 ($)-)"/0 @."/0#).< /$. ).& F)#2)"S2.$. /@@0)(/=0.9 ($)-)"/0 @."/0#).< /$. ).& F)#2)"

#2. 0.?)


23/32

3%-.3%-.JJG%"G%"XX.",)$%"-."#/0.",)$%"-."#/0KK/$./< %> 0/F/$./< %> 0/F

#2/# -/8 =. '$/'&R


24/32

Civil Enforcement byCivil Enforcement by CitizensCitizens!!:$),/#. @$%..< -/8 =. $.(%,.$.&A

!!e$?/")`/#)%"< -/8 >)0. #2.)0. #2.


25/32

4Y

Civil Enforcement byCivil Enforcement by CitizensCitizens contd.contd.

!!C%$# M/F2/< =.." )"c'$.& =8 #2. F$%"?>'0 /(# %>/"%#2.$ -/8 > -/8 $.(.),. (%-@."> -/8 $.(.),. (%-@."> -/8 $.(.),. @'")#),.@'")#),.&/-/?.


26/32

4]

Toxic tortsToxic torts make the moviesmake the movies

+$)"+$)" N$%(I%,)(2N$%(I%,)(2O4555RO4555R

!! 1.T/,/0."# (2$%-)'- (%"#/-)"/#)%" %> ?$%'"&F/#.$ =81.T/,/0."# (2$%-)'- (%"#/-)"/#)%" %> ?$%'"&F/#.$ =8

:/()>)( 7/< /"& +0.(#$)(A:/()>)( 7/< /"& +0.(#$)(A

!! ;/-/?.


27/32

4_

Toxic tortsToxic torts make the moviesmake the movies

U E),)0 U(#)%" O6bbaRU E),)0 U(#)%" O6bbaR!!UUJJ0.'I.-)/ (0').&A a >/-)0).< >)0.& @'=0)( (%--'")#8 F.00< )" S%='$"9(%"#/-)"/#)%" %> @'=0)( (%--'")#8 F.00< )" S%='$"9V/


28/32

Major Issues with Toxic TortMajor Issues with Toxic TortLitigationLitigation!! E/' )00".


29/32

4b

DaubertDaubert DecisionDecision

!! :0/(.& #2. c'&?. /< #2. ?/#.I..@.$ >%$ .T@.$# #. #2. -.#2%& ')( (%--'")#8A

;/'=.$#;/'=.$#,A V.$$.00 ;%F :2/$-/(.'#)(/0


30/32

B5

Accepted criteria for evaluating causationAccepted criteria for evaluating causation

based on epidemiological evidencebased on epidemiological evidence

!! 4'2"*#'8 )5 &++)0(&'()*4'2"*#'8 )5 &++)0(&'()*

!! C)+"C)+"DD2"+6)*+" 2"%&'()*+8(6+2"+6)*+" 2"%&'()*+8(6+

!! E)*+(+'"*0; )5 5(*3(*#+ &02)++ +'$3("+E)*+(+'"*0; )5 5(*3(*#+ &02)++ +'$3("+!! F()%)#(0&% 6%&$+(?(%('; G)2 "/6"2(7"*'&% "1(3"*0"HF()%)#(0&% 6%&$+(?(%('; G)2 "/6"2(7"*'&% "1(3"*0"H

!! I"76)2&% 0)#"*0;I"76)2&% 0)#"*0;

!! E)*'2)% )5 0)*5)$*3(*# &*3 ?(&+E)*'2)% )5 0)*5)$*3(*# &*3 ?(&+

E)7?(*"+ J(%% 02('"2(&, K949 4$2#")* L"*"2&% &*3 (*3(1(3$&%E)7?(*"+ J(%% 02('"2(&, K949 4$2#")* L"*"2&% &*3 (*3(1(3$&%&$'8)2+ (*0%$3(*#&$'8)2+ (*0%$3(*#


31/32


32/32

AcronymsAcronymsD3ED3E XXD3 E%&.D3 E%&. XXe>>)()/0 $.(%$& %> /00 >.&.$/0 0/F>)()/0 $.(%$& %> /00 >.&.$/0 0/F Z.&.$/0 P.?'0/#)%" Z.&.$/0 P.?'0/#)%"< XX(%&)>)(/#)%" %> /00 $'0.)(/#)%" %> /00 $'0.

Class 3-Law Fall

Documents