Civil Rights: Equal Protection of the Law
Jan 29, 2016
Civil Rights: Equal Protection of the Law
Missouri Compromise It prohibited slavery in the former Louisiana
Territory north of the parallel 36°30' north except within the boundaries of the proposed state of Missouri
The Dred Scott Case 1857 Supreme Court decision that blacks, whether
free or slave could not be citizens Court ruled Missouri Compromise ban against
slavery was unconstitutional Felt it was a matter of state law
Emancipation Proclamation Who is famous for this? Freed slaves in the Confederate States
Amendments 13th Amendment- “neither slavery nor
involuntary servitude” could exist anywhere in the US, except for punishment for a crime
14th Amendment- promised all black Americans not only citizenship but “equal protection of the laws”
15th Amendment- right that all citizens to vote cannot be denied “on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude”
Civil War Amendments Video
The Civil Rights Act of 1866 Offered blacks the same rights as
American citizens “To inherit, purchase, lease, sell, hold, and
convey real and personal property” “Punishable discrimination”
What’s discrimination? Little effect- repealed, declared unconstitutional, or never enforced
Limits on the 14th Amendment Most unsympathetic Supreme Court Rulings
made early civil rights laws ineffective Clause in 14th Amendment that prevents
discrimination by state governments States that “no State shall make or enforce any
law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the US”
Slaughterhouse Cases Supreme Court ruling that upheld a Louisiana
law that granted a monopoly to one butcher Other butchers claimed this violated their rights
to equal protection under the 14th Amendment
The Court’s decision narrowed the protections of the 14th Amendment Allowed state governments to continue limiting
civil rights Legislators especially in the South began
passing discriminatory laws Literacy tests Poll taxes
Once blacks lost voting rights others could discriminate against them Employers, state and local governments HOW?
Segregation? Jim Crow Laws
Increased segregation Made it lawful State laws required that blacks and whites be
separate but equal Schools Hospital wards or different hospitals Burial in separate cemeteries What other areas of segregation can you
think of?
What is Jim Crow
The Civil Rights Act of 1875 1883 in front of the Supreme Court
5 cases Involved incidents in the north and south Tried to eliminate segregation
Court ruled that on all cases unconstitutional 14th Amendment said the court prohibited
discrimination only be state governments Railroads and theaters were private industries
and Congress had no authority to limit discrimination
Plessey VS Ferguson (1896) Challenged Louisiana “Jim Crow” law that
required blacks and whites to ride in separate coaches on trains
Supreme Court ruled 8-1, establishing separate but equal Claims that under state law, segregation was
legal as long as public facilities were equal Was it really equal? Why?
Separate but equal will last for nearly 60 years
The NAACP (1909) The National Association of the Advancement
of Colored People Founded to secure the social and political
rights of blacks Goals
Public awareness Exert pressure on Congress Initiate legal action in the courts
Earliest target was schools
Sweatt VS Painter 1950 Herman Sweatt Law school in Texas Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the two law
schools were far from equal World War II brought some advances in Civil
Rights 1941- President Roosevelt issued Executive Order
8802, forbidding racial discrimination in defense industries
1948- President Truman issued Executive Order 9981, ending segregation throughout the military
Public School Desegregation Brown VS Board of Education (1954)
Linda Carol Brown White school seven blocks from her house Had to travel 20 blocks to attend school Father sued for violation of 14th Amendment
Thurgood Marshall- counsel for NAACP Became first black Supreme Court Justice
Supreme Court voted to support Brown and overturn Plessey VS Ferguson Rejected separate but equal doctrine
Plessey Vs Ferguson and Brown Vs Board of Education
1955-Court ordered all public schools to move toward “full compliance” and “end segregation” with full speed
Some schools obeyed the court order and others refused especially in the South
Desegregation was strong, emotional, and sometimes violent in the South
Little Rock, Arkansas- 1957- President Eisenhower deploys National Guard to help students enroll in school
Integration?
Martin Luther King? Formed the Southern Christian Leadership
Conference (SCLC) Civil Disobedience?
What tactics did they use? Ghandism?
Political Pressure Securing the Vote The Civil Rights Act of 1957
Civil Rights Commission Civil Rights Division within the Justice Department
Federal officers could go after those who refuse citizen’s right to vote
Civil Right Act of 1960 Court-appointed federal agents to assist blacks in
the voting process Federal crime to use violence in preventing school
integration
Parts of the act’s major sections: Outlaws discrimination in public
accommodations such as motels, restaurants, theaters, and sports arenas
Can take back federal funds in schools that practice discrimination
Prohibits job discrimination Expands the power of the Civil Rights
Commission
Video of Civil Rights Act of 1964
The Voting Rights Act of 1965 Federal examiners to make sure blacks can
vote Strict penalties on those who interfere with
voters Restrictive Covenants? Open Housing Act
Prohibits discrimination in the sale or rental of most housings
The Rights of Other Minorities Hispanics
Trace their heritage to Spanish-speaking nations 15% of popular (as of 2008) Want to seek an end to discrimination in housing
and employment In large areas of minority voters
Ballots printed in their native language and English
Important issue for Hispanics and other groups What is bilingual education?
Has become a big issue Problems? Cultural separateness English only?
Dual citizenship? Like blacks, have suffered discrimination
Legal Social Why?
Bureau of Indian Affairs American Indian Movement
1960’s Part of the civil rights movement
As a result of the movement Regaining of valuable mineral and water
rights Hunting and fishing rights Land taken illegally was returned Millions given as compensation for past wrong
doings Self-Determination Act of 1975
Native Americans under own rule Education, health, welfare, and housing
Ageism? Employment Act of 1967
Protects employees between 40 and 65 from being discriminated against in hiring and promotion
Exception is those jobs that show age is related to doing the job well
Age Discrimination Act of 1975 Authorizes the feds to withhold federal
funding from any program that discriminates unreasonably because of age
Rehabilitation Act of 1973 Public facilities must be made accessible by
those with physical disabilities The Education for All Handicapped
Children Act of 1975 Federal money to aid in giving children the
right to “free and appropriate public education” Must provide individualized programs Mainstreaming?
IDEA Full coverage of all disabilities (physical and
learning)
Individuals must be judged on basis of abilities or conduct
Looking at how the effects of a law influence fundamental rights
Suspect Classification? Japanese American Relocation
Eventually got reparations
What is it? Was intended to compensate for past
negative policies that had limited people’s opportunities
Executive Order 11246 Lyndon Johnson, 1965 Required contractors and unions to hire
minorities Two years later affirmative action of women
Affirmative Action
Job discrimination High school diploma or general education
tests In hiring and pay
WHY?
Reverse discrimination? Allan Bakke
Supreme Court Justices Whites must always be questioned Giving preference to those who have been
discriminated against is different
Last hired first fired Must provide proof for discrimination Employers must prove hiring processes
aren’t discriminatory People can win cash damages if found
victim of discrimination
•The Right to Vote–100 years after the constitution
•Women couldn’t vote or hold office•Before 1920
–Only 16 states and territories,mainly in the west extended full voting rights to women
•Why?•Jeanette Rankin
–First women in Congress–From Montana, 1916
Suffragists? Wanted full voting rights as well as social
and economic reforms What tactics did they use? Women’s Rights Convention in 1848
Declaration of Sentiments
Susan B. Anthony (1872 Presidential election) Arrested with fifteen other women for “illegal
voting” (Federal Offense) Quotes Declaration of Independence
“how can the consent of the governed be given if the right to vote is denied”
Court didn’t think 14th nor 15th Amendments applied to women, black or white
Not till 1920 did the suffragists’ efforts succeed 19th Amendment?
Women’s Rights Video
During most of the nation’s history, social and economic discrimination against women was accepted and legal Why do you think this is?
Supreme Court upholds in the late 1800’s that legal classifications based on sex Myra Colby Bradwell
Not until 1970 did the Supreme Court rule that law based on classification by sex violated “equal protection” clause in 14th Amendment
1974 Florida law
Granted widows but not widowers a yearly $500 tax exemption
1977 Greater social security benefits
Due to lower average salaries and the years in which women worked outside the home
In the Navy, more time is awarded to female officers to acquire a promotion Why?
1981 Punishes males but not females for statutory
rape Why? Is this fair?
All male military draft Why are females not included?
During 1800’s women and children worked 16 hour days 1900’s laws passed to limit the number hours
women and children could work Amount of weight they could lift Restrictions on night work (bars and
restaurants) Laws had intention of helping harsh
working conditions Become excuses to deny women jobs,
overtime pay, and equality in the work place
Equal Pay Act of 1963 Forbids using different pay scales for men and
women who do equal work All though effective, excluded millions of
women and permitted wage differences Why?
Title VII (part of Civil Rights Act of 1964) Prohibits sex discrimination in employment
Forbids rejection of women for having kids Rejected height and weight restrictions Maternity leave
What is comparable worth? Women have traditionally held low-
paying jobs Women with four years of college are paid less
then men without high school diplomas Librarians VS Gardeners
Is that right?
Until the mid 1970’s sex discrimination in schools was common Boys couldn’t take Home Economics Girls couldn’t take shop classes Boys only team sports Girls teams poorly equipped, ignored, and
sometimes non-existent Classroom
Differences between male and female teachers with same qualifications
Title IX of the act All schools receiving federal funds must give
male and female students equal opportunities in instruction and extracurricular activities
Academic classes are open to any sex Equal athletic opportunities
Treatment of women’s athletics equally Prohibits sex discrimination in educational
employment Federal funding can be taken away if any one
program is discriminated against About Title IX
Once was hard for women to: Get credit cards Buy houses Get credit on their own
Equal Credit Opportunity Prevents banks, retail stores, savings and loan
associations, etc. from denying credit on account of sex
Prohibits creditors from asking questions regarding sex or marital status
Credit it to be given based on the borrower’s income and credit rating