CIS 465 - WCA Framework 1 Basic Concepts The Work Centered Analysis Framework
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 1
Basic Concepts
The Work Centered Analysis Framework
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 2
Processing Résumés Using Resumix
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 3
Processing Résumés Using Resumix
CUSTOMER
Manager who needs to hire an employee
Applicant who receives responses about a job application
Government agency that receives reports about compliance to equal opportunity guidelines
PRODUCT
List of applicants who fit the criteria
Selected data items about each applicant
Automatically generated rejection letters
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 4
Processing Résumés Using Resumix
BUSINESS PROCESS
Major Steps:
•Define the criteria for selecting applicants
•Receive résumés
•Scan résumés and extract data
•Select applicants meeting criteria and forward their résumés to the hiring manager
•Send out rejection letters
•Track the hiring process
•Store applicant data for future searches
Rationale:
Instead of finding appropriate candidates by searching through paper résumés, extract the information on the résumés and do the search automatically.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 5
Processing Résumés Using Resumix
PARTICIPANTS
Human resources employees
Manager doing the hiring
INFORMATION
Description of job opening
Scanned résumés converted into a database format
List of qualified applicants
TECHNOLOGY
Résumix software
Scanner
Unidentified computers
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 6
DEBATE TOPIC
• The technology is Resumix is designed to convert a resume into a series of fields in a database regardless of what the initial resume looks like. Statements that don’t match these specific fields aren’t recognized. Does the use of this technology imply that a company does not care about the individuality of the applicants?
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 7
INTRODUCTION
• Framework - brief set of ideas about organizing a thought process about a concept.It helps by identifying topics that should be considered and shows how they are related.
• Models - useful representation of reality. The describe or mimic reality without dealing with the details
• They both help us understand complexity
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 8
A Classification of Models
• Iconic Models
• Analog Models
• Mathematical Models
• Mental Models
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 9
Iconic and Analog Models
• Iconic (scale) models - the least abstract model, is a physical replica of a system, usually based on a different scale from the original. Iconic models can scale in two or three dimensions.
• Analog Models - Does not look like the real system, but behaves like it. Usually two-dimensional charts or diagrams. Examples: organizational charts depict structure, authority, and responsibility relationships; maps where different colors represent water or mountains; stock market charts; blueprints of a machine; speedometer; thermometer
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 10
Mathematical Models
• Mathematical (quantitative) models - the complexity of relationships sometimes can not be represented iconically or analogically, or such representations may be cumbersome or time consuming.A more abstract model is built with mathematics.
• Note: recent advances in computer graphics use iconic and analog models to complement mathematical modeling.
• Visual simulation combines the three types of models.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 11
Mental Models
• People often use a behavioral mental model.• A mental model is an unworded description of how
people think about a situation.• The model can use the beliefs, assumptions, relationships,
and flows of work as perceived by an individual. • Mental models are a conceptual, internal representation,
used to generate descriptions of problem structure, and make future predications of future related variables.
• Support for mental models are an important aspect of Executive Information Systems. We will discuss this in depth later.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 12
Examples of Models
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 13
Viewing Businesses as Systems
• A business is a system consisting of many subsystems, some of which are information systems.
• Definition: A system is a set of interacting components that operate together to accomplish a purpose.
• Key ideas: purpose, boundary, environment, inputs, outputs.
• Businesses can be considered as systems consisting of business processes.
• A process’s value added is the amount of value it creates for internal or external customers.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 14
Viewing a firm as a System
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 15
The Value Chain
• The set of processes a firm uses to create value for its customers is called its value chain.
• The value chain contains both primary processes and support processes.
• The value chain is important because the way business processes are organized in a firm should be related to the way the firm creates value for customers.
• Understanding how the value chain is “supposed” to work is the first step in improving business processes.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 16
Primary processes for a hypothetical restaurant
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 17
The Functional Areas of a Business
• Large subsystems of a firm related to specific business disciplines are often called the functional areas of the business.
• Examples: Production, Sales and Marketing, Finance.• Most Businesses are organized around these functional areas.• Sometimes there can be organizational inertia where
organizational members focus on the functional areas instead of the customer.
• Functional areas are important, but they should not be the basis for studying information systems
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 18
Business Processes and Functional Areas
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 19
Functional Areas in a Typical College or University
• Admissions• Records and
Registration• Financial Aid• Bursar• Human Resources• Accounts Payable• Budget, Finance, and
Accounting
• Academic Department• University
Advancement• Student Services• Residence Life• Public Safety• Physical Plant• Student Career
Development
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 20
The Context of Information Systems….
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 21
The System We Are Talking About….
• A work system is a system in which human participants perform a business process using information, technology, and other resources to produce products for internal or external customers.
• The core of a work system is a business process, a related group of steps or activities that uses people, information, and other resources to create value for internal or external customers.
• Work is the application of human and physical resources to generate outputs used by internal and external customers.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 22
Information System vs. Work Systems
Bar code scanners and computers identify the items sold and calculate the bill
Work system supported by the information system: Performing customer checkout
Aspects of the work system not included in the information system: Establishing personal contact with customers, putting the groceries in bags
University registration system permits students to sign up for specific class sections
Work system supported by the information system: Registering for classes
Aspects of the work system not included in the information system: Deciding which classes to take and which sections to sign up for in order to have a good weekly schedule
Word Processing system used for typing and revising chapters
Work system supported by the information system: Writing a book
Aspects of the work system not included in the information system: Deciding what to say in the book and how to say it
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 23
Information System vs. Work Systems
Interactive system top managers use to monitor their organization’s performance
Work system supported by the information system: Keeping track of organizational performance
Aspects of the work system not included in the information system: Talking to people to understand their views about what is happening
System that identifies people by scanning and analyzing voice prints
Work system supported by the information system: Preventing unauthorized access to restricted areas
Aspects of the work system not included in the information system: Human guards, cameras, and other security measures
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 24
WCA framework for thinking about any system in business
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 25
Example: Who is a toy factory’s customer?
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 26
Relationship between data, information, and knowledge
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 27
WCA framework for thinking about any system in business
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 28
Five Perspectives for Understanding a Work System
ARCHITECTURE•What are the components of the system that performs the work and who uses the work product?•How are the components linked?•How do the components operate together?
PERFORMANCE•How well do the components operate individually?•How well does the system operate? (How well is the work performed?)•How well should the system operate?
INFRASTRUCTURE•What technical and human infrastructure does the work rely on? •In what ways does infrastructure present opportunities or obstacles?
CONTEXT•What are the impacts of the organizational and technical context?•In what ways does the context present opportunities or obstacles?
RISKS•What foreseeable things can prevent the work from happening, can make the work inefficient, or can cause defects in the work product?•What are the likely responses to these problems?
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 29
Important Point
• Improvements in a work system are usually related to the links between the architecture and the performance perspectives.
• Customer satisfaction is largely determined by product performance.
• Product performance is determined by a combination of product architecture and the internal work system performance.
• Note: efficiency vs. effectiveness
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 30
From work system architecture to customer satisfaction
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 31
Detailed Discussion of the Five Perspectives:Architecture
Performance
Infrastructure
Context
Risks
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 32
Architecture, Perspective #1
• Architecture is a summary of how a work system operates. It focuses on the components of the system and how those components are linked, and how they operate together to produce outputs.
• It is not merely a technical issue; IT and business professional involved with a system need to understand how it operates.
• It is impossible to build an information system without detailed documentation of information and technology components of the architecture.
• We use successive decomposition for documenting and summarizing
architecture.• Process operation and process characteristics
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 33
Architecture, Perspective #1
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 34
Architecture, Perspective #1
CUSTOMER
Customer’s entire cycle of involvement with the product
Requirements
Acquisition
Use
Maintenance
Retirement
PRODUCT
Components
Information content
Physical Content
Service content
(more in Chapter 6)
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 35
Architecture, Perspective #1
BUSINESS PROCESS
Process operation:
•Processes providing inputs
•Sequence and scheduling of major steps
•Processes receiving the outputs
Process characteristics:
•Degree of structure
•Range of involvement
•Level of integration
•Complexity
•Degree of reliance on machines
•Linkage of planning, execution, and control
•Attention to exceptions, errors, and malfunctions
More to be covered in Chapter 3….
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 36
Architecture, Perspective #1
PARTICIPANTS
Formal and informal organization:
Job responsibility
Organization chart
INFORMATION
Major data files in the database:
Data organization and access
TECHNOLOGY
Major components:
Hardware
Software
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 37
Performance, Perspective #2
• Performance - How well the system operates.
• A complete analysis involves qualitative and quantitative measurements.
• Consider some performance variables….
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 38
Performance, Perspective #2
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 39
Performance, Perspective #2
CUSTOMER
Customer Satisfaction
PRODUCT
Cost
Quality
Responsiveness
Reliability
Conformance to standards and regulations
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 40
Performance, Perspective #2
BUSINESS PROCESS
Rate of output
Consistency
Productivity
Cycle time
Flexibility
Security
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 41
Performance, Perspective #2
PARTICIPANTS
Skills
Involvement
Commitment
Job satisfaction
INFORMATION
Quality
Accessibility
Presentation
Prevention of unauthorized access
TECHNOLOGY
Functional capabilities
Ease of use
Compatibility
Maintainability
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 42
Comparing Vague Descriptions, Measurements, and Interpretations
ACCURACY OF INFORMATIONVague description: The information doesn’t seem very accurate.Measurement: 97.5% of the readings are correct within 5%.Interpretation:This is (or is not) accurate enough, given the way the information will be used.
SKILLS OF PARTICIPATIONVague description: The sales people are very experienced.Measurement: Every salesperson has 5 or more years of experience; 60% have more than 10 years.Interpretation:This system is (or is not) appropriate for such experienced people.
CYCLE TIME OF BUSINESS PROCESSVague description: This business process seems to take a long time.Measurement: The three major steps take an average of 1.3 days each, but the waiting time between the steps is around 5 days.Interpretation:This is (or is not) better than the average for this industry, but we can (or cannot) improve by eliminating some of the waiting time.
QUALITY OF THE WORK SYSTEM OUPUTVague description: We produce top quality frozen food, but our customer’s aren’t enthusiastic.Measurement:65% of our customers rate it average or good even though our factory defect rate is only.003%Interpretation: Our manufacturing process does (or doesn’t) seem O.K., but we do (or don’t) need to improve customer satisfaction.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 43
Infrastructure, Perspective #3
• Infrastructure: Essential Resources shared with other systems.
• Infrastructure failures may partially be beyond the control of people who rely on it (e.g. power outages).
• Evaluation is difficult because the same infrastructure may support some applications excessively and others insufficiently.
• Critical mass, having enough users to attain desired benefits, may be a key infrastructure issue.
• Distinguish between infrastructure and the supporting technology (laptops used in the sales process vs. used for company e-mail).
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 44
Infrastructure, Perspective #3
• Technology can be infrastructure if it is outside the work system, shared between work systems, owned and managed by a central authority, or when details are largely hidden from users.
• Business professionals are often surprised at the amount of effort and expense absorbed by human infrastructure.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 45
Infrastructure, Perspective #3
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 46
Infrastructure, Perspective #3
CUSTOMER
Technical and human infrastructure the customer must have to use the product
PRODUCT
Infrastructure related to information content
Infrastructure related to physical content
Infrastructure related to service content
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 47
Infrastructure, Perspective #3
BUSINESS PROCESS
Infrastructure related to internal operation of the process
Infrastructure related to inputs from other processes
Infrastructure related to transferring the product to other processes
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 48
Infrastructure, Perspective #3
PARTICIPANTS
Shared
human infrastructure
INFORMATION
Shared
information infrastructure
TECHNOLOGY
Shared
technology infrastructure
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 49
Context, Perspective #4.
• The organizational, competitive, and regulatory environment surrounding the system.
• The environment around the system may create incentives and even urgency for change.
• The personal, organizational, and economic parts of the context have direct impact through resource availability.
• Even with enough monetary resources, context factors ranging from historical precedents and budget cycles to internal politics can be stumbling blocks.
• Incentives
• Organizational Culture
• Stakeholders
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 50
Context, Perspective #4
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 51
Context, Perspective #4
CUSTOMER
Issues in the customer’s environment that may affect satisfaction or use
Business and competitive climate
PRODUCT
Substitute products
Ways the customer might bypass this type of product altogether
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 52
Context, Perspective #4
BUSINESS PROCESS
Organizational culture
Concerns of stakeholders
Organizational policies and initiatives
Government regulations and industry standards
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 53
Context, Perspective #4
PARTICIPANTS
Incentives
Other responsibilities and job pressures
INFORMATION
Policies and practices regarding information sharing, privacy, etc.
TECHNOLOGY
Technology policies and practices
Technology that may become available soon
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 54
Risk, Perspective #5
• Risks: Foreseeable Things that can go wrong in terms of:
– accidents and malfunctions
– computer crime
– project failure
(To be considered again in Chapter 13….)
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 55
Risk, Perspective #5
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 56
Risk, Perspective #5
CUSTOMER
Customer dissatisfaction
Interference by other stakeholders
PRODUCT
Inadequate or unreliable products
Fraudulent products
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 57
Risk, Perspective #5
BUSINESS PROCESS
Operator error
Sloppy procedures
Inadequate backup and recovery
Mismatch between process requirements and participant’s abilities
Unauthorized access to computers, programs, data
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 58
Risk, Perspective #5
PARTICIPANTS
Crime by insiders or outsiders
Inattention by participants
Failure to follow procedures
Inadequate training
INFORMATION
Data errors
Fraudulent data
Data theft
TECHNOLOGY
Equipment failure
Software bugs
Inadequate performance
Inability to build common sense into information systems
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 59
Systems Analysis
• Systems Analysis is different for the business professional than from the system builder.
• Technical vs. non-technical.
• Think of what will happen in the future when systems building tools become more effective for non-programmers.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 60
Steps in systems analysis for business professionals
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 61
Defining the Problem
• Identify the purpose of the analysis and scope of the work system.
• Tradeoffs - broad vs. narrow.
• Constraints
• priorities
• system snapshots
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 62
Using the WCA for a “System Snapshot”
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 63
Definitions of Topics in a System Snapshot
CUSTOMER
Product used by: Internal or external customers who use or receive direct benefit from the product
Other stakeholders: People who have a significant stake in the work system or its product even though they do not use the product directly and do not participate directly in the work system
Infrastructure requirements: Infrastructure the customer should have to use the product effectively
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 64
Definitions of Topics in a System Snapshot
PRODUCT
Information content: The aspects of the product that consist of information
Physical content: The aspects of the product that consist of physical things
Service content: The aspects of the product that consist of services performed for specific customers
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 65
Definitions of Topics in a System Snapshot
BUSINESS PROCESS
Major steps: Listing the major steps in this business process
Rationale: The overriding idea or approach that determined the process would be performed using the current approach rather than another
Processes providing inputs: External processes outside the work system that produce inputs of information, physical things, or services needed in order for this business process to operate
Processes receiving the product: The customer’s processes that receive and use the product of this work system
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 66
Definitions of Topics in a System Snapshot
PARTICIPANTS
People who perform the work
Shared human infrastructure
INFORMATION
Created or modified within this system
Received from other work system
TECHNOLOGY
Technology within the system
Shared technology infrastructure
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 67
The 10 Issues in the Work-Centered Analysis Method
Systems analysis step
1. Define the problem
2. Describe the current work system in enough depth
and
3. Design potential improvements
4.Decide what to do
Corresponding issues for thinking about a system
Issue 1: Problem Definition
Issue 2: Improvements from product changesIssue 3: Improvements from process changesIssue 4: Improvements related to work system participantsIssue 5: Improvements from better informationIssue 6: Improvements from better technologyIssue 7: Improvements from shared infrastructureIssue 8: Improvements related to the business contextIssue 9: Improvements from risk reduction
Issue 10: Recommendation
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 68
Common Systems Analysis Pitfalls Related to Elements of the WCA Framework
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 69
Common Pitfalls - WCA Elements
• Customer– ignore customer and the fact that the customer should evaluate the
product.
– Treating managers as customers even though they don’t use the
product directly.
• Product– forget that the purpose is to produce a product or service for a
customer.
– Forget that the product of a work system is often not the product of the organization.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 70
Common Pitfalls - WCA Elements
• Business Process– Define process so narrowly that improvement is of little consequence.– Define process to widely that it is too complex.– Confuse business process measures(consistency and productivity)
with product measures (cost to the customer and quality perceived by customer).
– Think of business process as theory and ignore its support by participants, information, and technology
• Participants– ignore incentives and other pressures– focus on users rather than participants.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 71
Common Pitfalls - WCA Elements
• Information– assume better information generates better results.
– Ignoring the importance of “soft” information not captured by formal systems.
• Technology– assume better technology generates better results.
– Focus on the technology without thinking about whether it makes a difference in the work system.
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 72
Common Pitfalls - Five Perspectives
• Architecture
– over emphasis on architectural details
– confusion related to people’s roles
• Performance
– Tendency to ignore performance
– tendency to exaggerate the scope of work system performance.
• Infrastructure
– Tendency to ignore infrastructure issues
CIS 465 - WCA Framework 73
Common Pitfalls - Five Perspectives
• Context– tendency to ignore incentives, organizational
culture, and non-participant stakeholders when designing systems.
• Risks– tendency to assume system will operate as
planned.