Top Banner
Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers Miniworkshop "Supersymmetry, Supergravity, Superstrings" March 19-21 2007 Aula 131 - Dipartimento di Fisica - Largo B.Pontecorvo,3 - Pisa
31

Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Mar 21, 2018

Download

Documents

lamcong
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO

Scalar gravitational wavesfrom Scalar-Tensor Gravity:production and response of

interferometers Miniworkshop

"Supersymmetry, Supergravity, Superstrings"March 19-21 2007

Aula 131 - Dipartimento di Fisica - Largo B.Pontecorvo,3 - Pisa

Page 2: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Introduction1) Mechanism of production of SGW from Scalar-

Tensor Gravity2) Massless case: invariance of the signal in three

different gauges3) Massless case: the frequency-dependent angular

pattern4) The small massive caseGeneralized previous results analyzed in the low-

frequencies approximation

Page 3: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Mechanism of production of SGWfrom Scalar-Tensor Gravity

Most general action for STG in literature

Page 4: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Considering the transformation

previous action reads

BD-like theory

Page 5: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Field equations

Klein-Gordon

Page 6: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Linearized theory in vacuum

Minkowski background + minimum for W

We assume

Page 7: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

obteining

with

Page 8: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Effective BD

The massless case

Most simple case:

Gauge transforms (Lorenz condition)

Page 9: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Solutions are plan waves

Purely scalar wave: line element

TT gauge extended to scalar waves

Page 10: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

The response of aninterferometer

Literature: low-frequencies approximation

Method of “bouncing photon” : the variationof space-time due to the scalar field iscomputed in all the travel of the photon

Page 11: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Computation of the variation of proper timein presence of the SGW

In the Fourier domain

Page 12: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

The “Shibata, Nakao and Nakamura” gaugefor SGW

Purely scalar wave: line element

Reanalyzed

Page 13: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Same results of the TT gauge

In the Fourier domain

Used a time transform

Page 14: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

The local Lorentz gauge for SGW:three different effects

The motion of test masses

The travel of photons in curved spacetime

Page 15: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

The shifting of time

Gauge invariance recovered

In the Fourier domain

Page 16: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Angular pattern for SGW

Page 17: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Line element in u direction

variation of proper timein presence of the SGW inu direction

Page 18: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Response function in u direction

Same analysis: responsefunction in v direction

Page 19: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Total frequency-dependent responsefunction

Agrees with

Low frequencies

Page 20: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers
Page 21: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers
Page 22: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers
Page 23: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

The small massive case

Treating scalars like classical waves

Frequencies have to fall in

Interval for the mass

Known for string-dilaton gravity

Page 24: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Parameterization of the field with the phase-velocityPresence of the mass: third component ofRiemann

Previous analysis in the local Lorentz gaugegeneralized with the aid of Fourier theorems,two effects

The motion of test masses

Page 25: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

The travel of photons in curved spacetime

Total frequency-dependent longitudinalresponse function

Page 26: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers
Page 27: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers
Page 28: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers
Page 29: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers
Page 30: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

ConclusionsRealistic possibility to detect SGW indifferent gauges

Realistic possibility to detect a longitudinalcomponentThe investigation of scalar components ofGW could be a tool to discriminateamong several theories of gravity

Page 31: Christian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves · PDF fileChristian Corda INFN-VIRGO Scalar gravitational waves from Scalar-Tensor Gravity: production and response of interferometers

Next papersCorda C. The “Shibata, Nakao and Nakamuragauge for SGW” submitted to GRG gr-qc0610157Corda C. “The importance of the magneticcomponents of gravitational waves in theresponse function of interferometersgr-qc 0702080 accepted for IJMPD

Capozziello S.,Corda C. and de Laurentis MF“On the correct frame for theories: Jordan frameversus Einstein frame”