Top Banner
1 Taylor, Dianna From: Chris Lussier <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, July 28, 2015 2:47 PM To: Sadler, Bill Cc: Hambrook, Lauren; Kellee Fletcher; Bill Maiden; Dana Derrington Subject: AFIN 47-00461 Permit 0303-S3N PPES 2015 1st Half GWMR Attachments: PPES 2015 1st Half GWMR.pdf Please See Attached. Thank You Christopher E. Lussier | Environmental Specialist NAES Corporation Ͳ Plum Point Energy Station 2732 South County Road 623 Osceola AR 72370 Direct 870 563 5072 Cell 901 651 6930 Email [email protected] Rec’d Digitally AFIN:PMT#:S W DOC ID#:M D TO:47-00461 0303-S3N 67908 BS>File By Dianna Taylor at 9:51 am, Jul 29, 2015
177

Chris Lussier Tuesday, July ...

Jan 16, 2022

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

1

Taylor, Dianna

From: Chris Lussier <[email protected]>Sent: Tuesday, July 28, 2015 2:47 PMTo: Sadler, BillCc: Hambrook, Lauren; Kellee Fletcher; Bill Maiden; Dana DerringtonSubject: AFIN 47-00461 Permit 0303-S3N PPES 2015 1st Half GWMRAttachments: PPES 2015 1st Half GWMR.pdf

Please See Attached.

Thank You

Christopher E. Lussier | Environmental SpecialistNAES Corporation Plum Point Energy Station2732 South County Road 623 Osceola AR 72370Direct 870 563 5072Cell 901 651 6930Email [email protected]

Rec’d Digitally

AFIN:_________________________

PMT#:_________________________ SW

DOC ID#:______________________ MD

TO:___________________________

47-00461

0303-S3N

67908

BS>File

By Dianna Taylor at 9:51 am, Jul 29, 2015

Page 2: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Energy People Making Energy Facilities Work – Better Plum Point Energy Station Post Office Box 567 2732 South County Road 623 Osceola, Arkansas 72370 (870) 563-4018 FAX (870) 563-5053

July 28, 2015  Mr. Bill Sadler [email protected]  Re:  Plum Point Energy Station Semi‐Annual Ground Water Monitroing Report   Class 3N Landfill   AFIN: 47‐00461 

Permit Number 0303‐S3N    Dear Mr. Sadler,  Please accept the Semi‐Annual Groundwater Monitoring Report for Plum Point Energy Station.    If you have any questions, please contact me at 870‐563‐5072.   Thank You,   Christopher E. Lussier Environmental Specialist    Cc:  Dana Darrington, FTN 

  Kellee Fletcher, PPSC   NAES, ESS 

  

Page 3: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

FIRST HALF 2015 SEMIANNUAL

GROUNDWATER MONITORING REPORT

PLUM POINT ENERGY STATION CLASS 3N LANDFILL

OSCEOLA, ARKANSAS

PERMIT NO. 0303-S3N AFIN: 47-00461

JULY 28, 2015

Page 4: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

FIRST HALF 2015 SEMIANNUAL

GROUNDWATER MONITORING REPORT

PLUM POINT ENERGY STATION CLASS 3N LANDFILL

OSCEOLA, ARKANSAS

PERMIT NO. 0303-S3N AFIN: 47-00461

Prepared for

NAES Corporation Plum Point Energy Station

2732 South County Road 623 Osceola, AR 72370

Prepared by

FTN Associates, Ltd. 3 Innwood Circle, Suite 220

Little Rock, AR 72211

FTN No. R14590-0840-001

July 28, 2015

Page 5: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 6: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PROFESSIONAL GEOLOGIST’S CERTIFICATION .................................................................. i

1.0 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................... 1-1

2.0 GROUNDWATER MONITORING PROGRAM ........................................................... 2-1

2.1 Current Monitoring Network ............................................................................... 2-1

2.2 Sampling Methodology ........................................................................................ 2-3

2.3 Laboratory Analyses ............................................................................................ 2-3

3.0 WATER LEVEL DATA .................................................................................................. 3-1

3.1 Water Level Measurements and Direction of Groundwater Flow ....................... 3-1

3.2 Hydraulic Gradient and Rate of Groundwater Flow ............................................ 3-3

4.0 GROUNDWATER QUALITY DATA ........................................................................... 4-1

4.1 Review of Field Documentation .......................................................................... 4-1

4.2 Quality Control Data Evaluation ......................................................................... 4-1

4.3 Summary of Groundwater Quality Results .......................................................... 4-2

5.0 STATSTICAL EVALUATION ....................................................................................... 5-1

5.1 Statistical Program Design ................................................................................... 5-1

5.1.1 Detection Monitoring Statistics ............................................................... 5-1

5.1.2 Background Datasets ............................................................................... 5-4

5.1.3 Site-Wide False Positive Rate and Power ................................................ 5-4

5.2 Statistical Results ................................................................................................. 5-6

5.2.1 Outlier Identification ................................................................................ 5-6

5.2.2 Prediction Limits ...................................................................................... 5-6

5.2.3 Mann-Kendall Test/Sen’s Estimate of Slope ........................................... 5-7

6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS .......................................................... 6-1

7.0 BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................ 7-1

Page 7: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

iii

LIST OF APPENDICES

APPENDIX A: Field Sampling Forms APPENDIX B: Laboratory Data Sheets APPENDIX C: Historical Database APPENDIX D: Distributional Plots APPENDIX E: Background Data Used for Statistics APPENDIX F: Statistical Evaluation Results

LIST OF TABLES

Table 2.1 Plum Point Energy Station monitoring well construction data ............................ 2-1 Table 2.2 Plum Point Energy Station detection monitoring constituent list ........................ 2-4 Table 3.1 Water level data and potentiometric surface elevations, April 29, 2015 ............. 3-1 Table 4.1 Detected groundwater quality results, first half 2015 .......................................... 4-4 Table 5.1 Well-parameter pairs tested with prediction intervals. ........................................ 5-2 Table 5.2 Well-parameter pairs tested with Mann-Kendall Test/Sen’s Estimate of Slope .. 5-3 Table 5.3 Test alpha (α*) and power curve criteria, 2015 semiannual reporting periods .... 5-4 Table 5.4 Summary of SSIs identified with prediction limits .............................................. 5-7

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 2.1 Monitoring well network ..................................................................................... 2-2 Figure 3.1 Potentiometric surface map, April 29, 2015 ........................................................ 3-2 Figure 5.1 Power curve for semiannual detection monitoring, 2015 .................................... 5-5

Page 8: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

1-1

1.0 INTRODUCTION

NAES Corporation operates a Class 3N Industrial Solid Waste Landfill (the Landfill) at

the Plum Point Energy Station in Osceola, Arkansas. The Landfill operates under

Permit No. 0303-S3N, which was issued by the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality

(ADEQ) on October 22, 2002, and is utilized for the disposal of coal combustion residuals

(CCRs) and other approved wastes. The CCRs consist of bottom ash, economizer ash, fly ash,

and coal pulverizer rejects.

Groundwater monitoring was initiated in November 2007 and the Landfill began

receiving CCRs in March of 2010. Groundwater detection monitoring is currently conducted on

a semiannual basis in fulfillment of the permit and Arkansas Pollution Control and Ecology

Commission (APCEC) Regulation No. 22 requirements.

This document presents the results of semiannual detection monitoring during the first

half of 2015 and fulfills the requirements of §22.1204 of Regulation No. 22. Section 2.0

describes the facility’s current groundwater monitoring network and sampling approach;

Section 3.0 presents water level data; Section 4.0 presents groundwater quality data, Section 5.0

presents the statistical approach and analyses of the first half 2015 data with a discussion of

results; Section 6.0 includes conclusions and recommendations for the program; and Section 7.0

provides selected references for the report.

Page 9: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

2-1

2.0 GROUNDWATER MONITORING PROGRAM

This section describes the current groundwater detection monitoring program at the

Landfill. Included is a discussion of the monitoring well network, sampling methodology, and

laboratory analyses.

2.1 Current Monitoring Network

Figure 2.1 depicts the current monitoring well network which consists of the twelve wells

shown in Table 2.1. Monitoring wells are constructed of solid 2-inch Schedule 40 PVC casing

and 10- to 15-ft well screens. Well construction details are summarized in Table 2.1. Each

monitoring well is screened in the Mississippi River Valley alluvial aquifer, the uppermost

aquifer in the vicinity of the landfill and the zone of interest for detection monitoring. The

direction of groundwater flow beneath the site is variable and generally dependent on seasonal

fluctuations in the river stage of the Mississippi River. As a result, there is not a true upgradient

well or set of wells at this facility.

Table 2.1. Plum Point Energy Station monitoring well construction data. .

Well Number

Well Installation

Date

Ground Surface Elevation

(ft, NAVD)(a)

Top of Casing Elevation

(ft, NAVD)(a)

Total Depth (ft below top of

casing)(b)

Screen Interval (ft below top of

casing)(b) MW-1 04/09/01 239.6 242.67 33.6 23.6 to 33.6 MW-2 04/09/01 240.4 243.86 30.2 20.2 to 30.2

MW-3R 09/26/07 240.6 243.26 32.8 22.8 to 32.8 MW-4R2 05/04/12 237.6(c) 240.65(c) 32.2 21.8 to 31.8

MW-5 04/11/01 239.4(d) 243.14(d) 32.5 22.5 to 32.5 MW-6 04/12/01 238.9 242.47 28.5 18.5 to 28.5 MW-7 04/10/01 242.2 245.61 31.6 21.6 to 31.6 MW-8 04/11/01 241.8 245.12 32.4 22.4 to 32.4

MW-10R 09/25/07 236.9 240.24 33.4 23.4 to 33.4 MW-11R 09/25/07 238.2 241.79 33.4 23.4 to 33.4 MW-13R 04/07/09 241.7 244.62 35.9 20.9 to 35.9 MW-15 09/25/07 240.6 243.56 33.0 23.0 to 33.0

(a) Based on survey completed July 13, 2011, by Harmon Surveying, Conway, Arkansas, except where noted. (b) Based on well construction diagram. (c) Based on survey report dated June 12, 2012, by Harmon Surveying, Conway, Arkansas. (d) Based on verification survey dated September 28, 2011, by Harmon Surveying, Conway, Arkansas.

Page 10: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

XX

XX

XX

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

XX

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

MW-15

MW-11R

CELL 7

CELL 9

CELL 6

POTENTIAL

ARCHAEOLOGICAL

AREA OF

CONCERN

EX

IS

TIN

G S

TO

RM

WA

TE

R P

ON

D

BORROW

AREA

BORROW

AREA

GRAVEL

ACCESS ROAD

ARKANSAS

HIGHWAY 239

ARKANSAS

HIGHWAY 198

FENCE

CELL 11

CELL 10

CELL 5

CELL 4

CELL 8CELL 2

MW-7

CELL 1

(ACTIVE DISPOSAL AREA)

CELL 3

(UNDER

CONSTRUCTION)

MW-3R

MW-1

MW-2

MW-8

MW-13R

MW-6

MW-5

MW-10R

MW-4R2

R:\PROJECTS\14590-0840-001\CAD\DWG\1H2015\14590-0840-001-FG21.DWG

Figure 2.1. Plum Point Energy Station groundwater monitoring well network

LEGEND

WASTE CELL BOUNDARY

EXISTING INDEX CONTOUR (5-FT)

EXISTING INTERMEDIATE CONTOUR (1-FT)

EXISTING FENCE

EXISTING OVERHEAD ELECTRIC LINE

PAVED ROAD

UNPAVED ROADS

MONITORING WELLS

POWERLINE

MW-11R

2-2

Page 11: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

2-3

2.2 Sampling Methodology

The groundwater monitoring program consists of semiannual water level measurements

at all twelve wells and sampling at the following eight wells: MW-1, MW-2, MW-3R, MW-4R2,

MW-6, MW-8, MW-10R, MW-11R, and MW-13R. Monitoring wells MW-5, MW-7, MW-11R,

and MW-15 are used only for water level measurements per the September 6, 2007 permit

addendum.

FTN provided the first half 2015 groundwater sampling services which were conducted

using low-flow sampling techniques in accordance with US Environmental Protection Agency

(EPA) guidelines (EPA 1996). Each well was sampled using a Geopump™ Peristaltic Series II

Pump and linear low-density natural polyethylene tubing. Field parameters were measured

during purging and sampling using a HACH 2100P portable turbidity meter and a YSI 556

multiprobe system (MPS) fitted with a flow through cell.

2.3 Laboratory Analyses

The sampling parameter list required by the facility's permit is shown in Table 2.2.

Environmental Science Corporation (ESC) of Mt. Juliet, Tennessee, provided laboratory services

for the current monitoring event. Samples were analyzed using recommended methods described

in Test Methods for Evaluating Solid Waste—Physical/Chemical Methods (SW-846) or

equivalent and guidelines established by EPA.

Page 12: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

2-4

Table 2.2. Plum Point Energy Station detection monitoring constituent list.

Detection Monitoring Constituents

Alkalinity Magnesium

Arsenic Manganese

Barium Mercury

Beryllium Nickel

Boron pH*

Cadmium Potassium

Calcium Selenium

Chloride Silver

Chromium Sodium

Cobalt Strontium

Conductance* Sulfate

Copper Temperature*

Fluoride Total Dissolved Solids (TDS)

Iron Turbidity*

Lead Zinc *Denotes field parameter.

Page 13: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

3-1

3.0 WATER LEVEL DATA

This section presents water level data collected during the first half 2015 monitoring

event and discusses groundwater flow direction and rate of groundwater flow.

3.1 Water Level Measurements and Direction of Groundwater Flow

Static water levels were measured in each well prior to sampling activities to determine

the level to maintain during purging, to contour the potentiometric surface, and to determine the

hydraulic gradient. FTN measured water levels on April 29, 2015. Depths to water were

measured to the nearest 0.01 ft from the top of casing and are tabulated in Table 3.1. These

measurements were converted to elevations in feet North American Vertical Datum (ft NAVD)

of 1988 and contoured to construct the potentiometric surface map shown on Figure 3.1. As

shown on the figure, flow was generally southward across much of the site during this

monitoring event. This flow pattern agrees with previously observed variations in flow direction

at this site due to its close proximity to the Mississippi River.

Table 3.1. Water level data and potentiometric surface elevations, April 29, 2015.

Well Number TOC Elevation

(ft NAVD) Depth to Water (ft below TOC)

Potentiometric Surface Elevation (ft NAVD)

MW-1 242.67 17.08 225.59 MW-2 243.86 18.13 225.73

MW-3R 243.26 18.57 224.69 MW-4R2 240.65 16.85 223.81

MW-5 243.14 19.08 224.06 MW-6 242.47 19.60 222.87 MW-7 245.61 19.41 226.20 MW-8 245.12 17.95 227.17

MW-10R 240.24 16.63 223.61 MW-11R 241.79 18.71 223.08 MW-13R 244.62 19.75 224.87 MW-15 243.56 20.70 222.86

Page 14: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

XX

XX

XX

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

XX

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

BORROW

AREA

BORROW

AREA

GRAVEL

ACCESS ROAD

ARKANSAS

HIGHWAY 239

ARKANSAS

HIGHWAY 198

FENCE

POTENTIAL

ARCHAEOLOGICAL

AREA OF

CONCERN

CELL 5

CELL 7

CELL 9

CELL 11

CELL 10CELL 8

CELL 6

CELL 4

CELL 2

MW-15

CELL 1

(ACTIVE DISPOSAL AREA)

MW-10R

MW-1

MW-2

MW-7

MW-8

MW-13R

MW-11R

MW-6

MW-5

MW-4R2

MW-3R

EX

IS

TIN

G S

TO

RM

WA

TE

R P

ON

D

CELL 3

(UNDER

CONSTRUCTION)

2

2

4

.0

0

224.50

225.00

2

2

6

.

0

0

2

2

5

.5

0

2

2

3

.

5

0

2

2

3

.

0

0

2

2

6

.

5

0

R:\PROJECTS\14590-0840-001\DWG\CAD\1H2015\14590-0840-001-FG31.DWG

Figure 3.1. Potentiometric surface map, April 29, 2015.

LEGEND

WASTE CELL BOUNDARY

EXISTING INDEX CONTOUR (5-FT)

EXISTING INTERMEDIATE CONTOUR (1-FT)

EXISTING FENCE

EXISTING OVERHEAD ELECTRIC LINE

PAVED ROAD

UNPAVED ROADS

MONITORING WELLS

POWERLINE

APRIL 2015 POTENTIOMETRIC SURFACE

MW-11R

3-2

Page 15: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

3-3

3.2 Hydraulic Gradient and Rate of Groundwater Flow

The hydraulic gradient across the site from MW-1 to MW-10R during the April 2015

sampling event was calculated at 7.98 x 10-4 ft/ft. The rate of groundwater flow was calculated

using the measured gradient, a hydraulic conductivity of 1.09 x 10-2 cm/sec, and effective

porosity of 27% (GEC 2001). These values were applied to the following equation:

Vx = -K/ne x dh/dl

where: Vx = linear velocity,

K = hydraulic conductivity,

ne = effective porosity, and

dh/dl = hydraulic gradient.

The estimated average linear groundwater velocity is 33 ft/year based on the

measurements from the April 2015 sampling event. This velocity is generally consistent with

seasonal fluctuations observed in past flow rates beneath the regulated unit.

Page 16: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

4-1

4.0 GROUNDWATER QUALITY DATA

This section presents analytical results for detection monitoring during the first half 2015

sampling event and reviews field and laboratory quality assurance (QA) and quality control (QC)

measures. Data quality was evaluated by reviewing the chain-of-custody (COC) documents, field

documentation, laboratory QC results, and conformance of QC sample results.

4.1 Review of Field Documentation

Field sampling forms for the current monitoring period are included in Appendix A.

Based on a review of these records, the following observations were made:

• Criteria for low-flow minimal drawdown purging and sampling were met for all samples collected during the first half 2015 event (i.e., drawdown was less than 0.3 ft during purging and sample collection which conforms with low-flow sampling requirements [EPA 1996]).

• Field-measured turbidity was below 10 NTU for all samples, as required by Regulation No. 22.1103(a).

• The pH and dissolved oxygen (DO) values appeared suspect and inconsistent with previously recorded values for the monitoring well network. The YSI was examined after sampling and it was discovered that the sensors for these parameters needed replacement/factory calibration. As such, the data for pH and DO during this event are considered invalid.

4.2 Quality Control Data Evaluation

The laboratory report provided by ESC detailing the analytical results for the first half

2015 sampling event is included in Appendix B. Based on a review of the data quality

documentation provided by ESC, the overall quality of the data relative to the contaminants of

concern was acceptable and generally met method-specific requirements for precision and

accuracy. Provided below is a summary of the QA/QC results included in the ESC report:

• The laboratory method blank was reported non-detect for all tested parameters.

Page 17: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

4-2

• The laboratory method duplicate was within laboratory criteria for all tested parameters.

• The laboratory control sample (LCS) and LCS duplicate relative percent difference (RPD) and percent recoveries results were within laboratory criteria for all parameters.

• The matrix spike (MS) and MS duplicate samples were within laboratory criteria except for the percent recovery for calcium and alkalinity in the MS sample and the RPD for alkalinity in the MS duplicate sample.

Field QA/QC included the collection of one field duplicate and one equipment rinsate

blank. These samples were collected in conjunction with groundwater sampling activities and

were handled in the same manner as groundwater samples with respect to handling and COC

procedures.

The field duplicate, labeled as MW-20, was taken at monitoring well MW-4R2 during

this sampling event. To verify that results for these two samples showed reasonable precision for

analyzed parameters, the RPD was calculated for detected parameters where the detected level

was at least five times the laboratory practical quantitation limit (PQL) and where neither result

was qualified or suspected of blank contamination. Calculated RPDs were below the quality

control limit of 20%, indicating that sampling methods produced samples with an acceptable

level of reproducibility.

The equipment rinsate blank was taken to assess the effectiveness of field

decontamination procedures. Analytical results for this sample, labeled as MW-21, did not have

any detections above the laboratory PQL. When detections do occur above the PQL in a quality

control blank, groundwater data for the detected parameter(s) are flagged with a “B” in the

historical database. EPA guidance (1986) recommends that detections in quality control blanks

not be used to correct groundwater data.

4.3 Summary of Groundwater Quality Results

Laboratory results detected above the PQL in groundwater samples from the first half

2015 monitoring period are summarized in Table 4.1 along with field-measured turbidity. Water

quality standards promulgated by EPA are included for comparison purposes in Table 4.1, where

Page 18: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

4-3

applicable. Summarized below are well-parameter pairs that exceeded water quality standards

during the current monitoring period:

• The Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) for arsenic (0.01 mg/L) was exceeded

in MW-4R2 and its duplicate MW-20,

• The Secondary Drinking Water Standard (SDWS) for TDS (500 mg/L) was exceeded at MW-3R and MW-8,

• The SDWS for manganese (0.05 mg/L) was exceeded at MW-1, MW-4R2 and in its duplicate MW-20, and in MW-10R; and

• The SDWS for iron (0.3 mg/L) was exceeded at MW-4R2 and its duplicate sample MW-20.

These exceedances appear consistent with previous sampling results. Regional

groundwater in the alluvial aquifer has typically displayed elevated levels of these constituents

and current detected levels are generally consistent with historical data at the facility.

Page 19: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

4-4

Table 4.1. Detected groundwater quality results, first half 2015.

Parameter Chloride Fluoride Sulfate Alkalinity TDS Arsenic Barium Manganese Nickel Selenium Calcium Iron Magnesium Potassium Sodium Strontium Turbidity*

Units mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l NTU

MW-1 1.6 0.28 11 320 360 0.00093 J 0.15 0.055 0.002 0.0051 110 0.099 J 23 1.1 3.9 0.3 3

MW-2 5.4 0.15 98 290 500 0.00096 J 0.19 0.018 0.0011 J 0.0084 130 0.094 J 27 1.4 6.2 0.38 4

MW-3R 3.2 0.21 80 470 580 0.00058 J 0.18 0.037 0.0023 0.0069 170 0.056 J 34 0.81 J 6.1 0.51 1

MW-4R2 1.3 0.3 13 320 350 0.016 0.22 2.5 <0.00035 0.002 92 5 27 1.8 8.3 0.21 10

MW-6 0.72 J 0.1 5.3 93 120 0.0016 J 0.092 0.0013 J 0.0042 0.0024 27 0.037 J 6.9 0.68 J 3.2 0.083 1

MW-8 2.9 0.16 60 490 610 0.00088 J 0.3 0.04 0.0019 J 0.00044 J 180 0.024 J 31 3.6 5.5 0.56 2

MW-10R 3.9 0.31 10 250 290 0.0032 0.16 0.27 <0.00035 <0.00038 74 0.025 J 22 2.6 4.5 0.2 2

MW-13R 5.3 0.094 J 26 280 370 0.0012 J 0.18 0.0005 J 0.0011 J 0.00055 J 89 <0.014 25 1.8 3.5 0.22 1

MW-20 1.3 0.33 13 320 340 0.016 0.21 2.3 <0.00035 0.002 J 92 5.1 27 1.8 8.3 0.2 ---

MW-21 <0.052 <0.0099 <0.077 <2.6 5 J <0.00025 <0.00036 <0.00025 <0.00035 <0.00038 <0.046 0.026 J <0.011 <0.10 0.18 J <0.0017 --- EPA Standard 250(b) 4(a), 2(b) 250(b) --- 500(b) 0.01(a) 2(a) 0.05(b) --- 0.05(b) --- 0.3(b) --- --- --- --- ---

Notes: Bold values indicate detections above EPA water quality standards. J flags indicate value is below the PQL MW-20 is a duplicate of MW-4R2 MW-21 is a field blank (a) EPA Primary Drinking Water Standards - Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) (b) EPA Secondary Drinking Water Standards (SDWSs) *Field-measured parameter

Page 20: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

5-1

5.0 STATSTICAL EVALUATION

5.1 Statistical Program Design

This section outlines the statistical program design for the groundwater detection

monitoring program at the Landfill. This statistical program design is based on EPA's Statistical

Analysis of Groundwater Monitoring Data at RCRA Facilities Unified Guidance (Unified

Guidance), released in March 2009.

5.1.1 Detection Monitoring Statistics

For detection monitoring, well-parameter pairs are tested for compliance using prediction

limits or formal trend tests. As recommended by the Unified Guidance, prediction limits are run

only on well-parameter combinations where the background population is free of statistically

significant trends (increasing or decreasing). If significant trends are present in background, the

assumption of a steady-state condition (required by the test) is not met, resulting in a less

powerful test and prediction limits that are biased high or low. Table 5.1 identifies

well-parameter pairs that have background populations free of statistically significant trends and

are tested for compliance using prediction limits.

When significant trends are indicated in background populations, a formal trend test is

recommended by the Unified Guidance in lieu of a prediction limit test. If a statistically

significant increasing trend is indicated by a formal trend test, it would indicate deteriorating

groundwater quality, as evidenced by rising concentration levels (EPA 2009; email

communication from Dr. Kirk Cameron, Statistical Scientist MacStat Consulting, Ltd., and

Kristina Rayner, Sanitas Technologies, April 5, 2011). Well-parameter pairs tested for

compliance using a formal trend test are summarized in Table 5.2.

Page 21: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

5-2

Table 5.1. Well-parameter pairs tested with prediction intervals.

Parameter Well ID

Alkalinity MW-2,MW-3R,MW-10R

Arsenic MW-1, MW-3R, MW-4R2, MW-6, MW-10R

Barium MW-2, MW-3R, MW-10R

Boron MW-1, MW-3R, MW-4R2, MW-6, MW-10R

Calcium MW-2, MW-3, MW-4R2,MW-10R

Chloride MW-2, MW-3R, MW-10R

Dissolved Solids MW-2, MW-3, MW-4R2,MW-10R

Fluoride MW-1, MW-2, MW-3R, MW-6, MW-10R

Iron MW-2, MW-3R, MW-4R2,MW-6, MW-10R

Lead MW-1, MW-2, MW-4R2,MW-6, MW-10R

Magnesium MW-2, MW-3, MW-4R2,MW-10R

Manganese MW-2, MW-4R2,MW-6, MW-10R

Nickel MW-1, MW-3R, MW-10R

pH MW-1, MW-2, MW-4R2,MW-6

Potassium MW-2, MW-3R, MW-4R2,MW-6, MW-10R

Selenium MW-2, MW-3R, MW-10R

Sodium MW-1, MW-3R, MW-4R2,MW-6, MW-10R

Strontium MW-2, MW-3, MW-4R2,MW-10R

Sulfate MW-2, MW-3, MW-4R2,MW-6, MW-10R

Zinc MW-2, MW-4R2,MW-10R

Page 22: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

5-3

Table 5.2. Well-parameter pairs tested with Mann-Kendall Test/Sen’s Estimate of Slope.

Parameter Well ID

Alkalinity MW-1, MW-4R2, MW-6, MW-8

Arsenic MW-2, MW-8

Barium MW-1, MW-4R2, MW-6, MW-8

Boron MW-2, MW-8

Calcium MW-1, MW-6, MW-8

Chloride MW-1, MW-4R2, MW-6, MW-8

Dissolved Solids MW-1, MW-6, MW-8

Fluoride MW-4R2, MW-8

Iron MW-1, MW-8

Lead MW-3R, MW-8

Magnesium MW-1, MW-6, MW-8

Manganese MW-1, MW-3R, MW-8

Nickel MW-2, MW-4R2, MW-6, MW-8

pH MW-8, MW-10R

Potassium MW-1, MW-8

Selenium MW-1, MW-4R2, MW-6, MW-8

Sodium MW-2, MW-8

Strontium MW-1, MW-6, MW-8

Sulfate MW-1, MW-8

Zinc MW-1, MW-3R, MW-6, MW-8 Note: Monitoring well MW-8 does not currently contain the EPA recommended minimum background size to perform prediction limit testing. At this time, all detected data from MW-8 is evaluated using a formal trend test.

The following metals are not included in Tables 5.1 and 5.2 because they contain a large

percentage of non-detects in their datasets: beryllium, cadmium, chromium, cobalt, copper,

mercury, and silver. Should these parameters be detected, they will be evaluated using either the

double-quantification rule (EPA 2009) or other appropriate test.

If a well-parameter pair has two consecutive statistically significant increases (SSIs) (or a

statistically significant decrease [SSD] in the case of pH) from a prediction limit test or formal

Page 23: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

5-4

trend test, then the data will be further examined by a qualified groundwater scientist. If a

confirmed SSI is declared, the facility will initiate the procedures required by §22.1204(c) of

Regulation No. 22. However, some flexibility is necessary in evaluating confirmed SSIs,

primarily when there is uncertainty that the SSIs are the result of landfilling activities.

5.1.2 Background Datasets

Background datasets were updated during the second half of 2014and are detailed in

Appendix E.

5.1.3 Site-Wide False Positive Rate and Power

The Unified Guidance (EPA 2009) recommends that detection monitoring programs have

adequate statistical power and a site-wide false positive rate (SWFPR [α]) value of α =10% over

a one-year period of testing. As a result, the semiannual SWFPR is fixed at 5%. The magnitude

of the per-test alpha (α*) will vary depending on how many statistical tests are required per

semiannual evaluation. Input criteria to determine the per-test alpha (α*) for intrawell prediction

limit analyses are included in Table 5.3.

Table 5.3. Test alpha (α*) and power curve criteria, 2015 semiannual reporting periods.

Statistical Test Intrawell Prediction Limit

Number of Downgradient Monitoring Wells 7(a) Minimum Background Sample Size (n) 10 Estimated Number of Detected Parameters 17 Re-Sample Strategy 1 of 2(b) Per-Evaluation SWFPR 0.05

(a) Each of the 8 sampled wells is considered "downgradient" at this facility; however, MW-8 does not have sufficient background to run prediction limits and is not considered when constructing the power curve.

(b) The facility's monitoring program currently does not have an approved re-sample strategy. However, SanitasTM software requires a minimum re-sample strategy of “1 of 2” when using Unified Guidance methods.

To gauge statistical power, current EPA guidance recommends the use of the EPA

Reference Power Curve (ERPC) to estimate the ability of any individual test to identify an

exceedance above background SSIs. Any single statistical test should have the ability to detect

Page 24: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

5-5

an exceedance 55% to 60% of the time at three standard deviations (3σ) above background, and

80% to 85% of the time at 4σ above background.

Input criteria used to construct the power curve for the 2015 statistical program are

included in Table 5.3. Figure 5.1 depicts the facility's power curve plotted against the ERPC. The

facility's power curve indicates that any single test will detect exceedances above background

approximately 40% of the time at 3σ and 87% of the time at 4σ. It is anticipated that the

detection rate at 3σ above background will improve following the next scheduled background

update.

Figure 5.1. Power curve for semiannual detection monitoring, 2015

Page 25: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

5-6

5.2 Statistical Results

Detected constituents during the first half 2015 sampling event were evaluated using the

SanitasTM software program. No statistical evaluations were conducted for results detected below

the practical quantitation limit (PQL), per §22.1203(h)(5) of Regulation No. 22. Results detected

below the PQL are flagged with a “J” in Appendix C, which includes the period of record data

from the monitoring program.

Distributional analyses including time-series plots, box-and-whiskers diagrams, and

outlier tests were applied to period of record data on currently detected parameters to identify

apparent trends or excursions from normal ranges. Results from these analyses are included in

Appendix D, and outliers identified in the current dataset are summarized in Section 5.2.1.

Background datasets used for statistical comparisons are summarized in Appendix E. Plots for

prediction limit tests and trend analyses are included in Appendix F.

5.2.1 Outlier Identification

For small data populations (generally containing less than 25 data values), Dixon's outlier

test is applied to period of record data to identify possible outliers. For larger populations

(at least 20 or more data values), the Rosner's test is applied. SanitasTM identified one outlier in

the first half 2015 dataset; manganese at MW-10R was statistically low compared to the period

of record dataset for this well-parameter pair.

5.2.2 Prediction Limits

Detected data for well-parameter combinations identified in Table 5.1 were tested using

intrawell prediction limits to determine if the first half 2015 data are representative of

background data. Statistical analyses are included in Appendix F and results indicated eight SSIs,

which are summarized in Table 5.4. All other analyzed well-parameter combinations were within

estimated prediction limits.

Page 26: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

5-7

Table 5.4. Summary of SSIs identified with prediction limits.

Parameter Well ID Upper Limit Observation

Sulfate MW-2 45.38 mg/L 98 mg/L

Alkalinity MW-3R 462.2 mg/L 470 mg/L

Calcium MW-3R 132 mg/L 170 mg/L

Dissolved Solids MW-3R 502.7 mg/L 580 mg/L

Magnesium MW-3R 32.8 mg/L 34 mg/L

Strontium MW-3R 0.4933 mg/L 0.51 mg/L

Sulfate MW-3R 79.56 mg/L 80 mg/L

Fluoride MW-10R 0.2978 mg/L 0.31 mg/L Note: Red type indicates a confirmed SSI.

Five of the SSIs shown in Table 5.4 are considered confirmed because they were

indicated as SSIs during one or more previous and consecutive sampling events. However, it is

uncertain at this time that these SSIs signify impact from landfilling activities. The current levels

of calcium, dissolved solids, strontium, and sulfate are generally comparable to those measured

historically at monitoring wells MW-7, MW-8, and MW-15 that are located more than 2,000 ft

from the active disposal area, as listed below:

• Calcium was detected at a level of 190 mg/L in MW-8 during May 2014 and at 140 mg/L in MW-15 during November 2010;

• Dissolved Solids was detected at a level of 520 mg/L in MW-7 in November 2010, 650 mg/L at MW-8 in September 2013, and 510 mg/L at MW-15 in May 2010;

• Strontium was detected at a level of 0.43 mg/L in MW-7 during November 2007, 0.74 mg/L in MW-8 during May 2014, and 0.48 mg/L in MW-15 during November 2010; and

• Sulfate was detected at a level of 76 mg/L in MW-8 during March 2013.

5.2.3 Mann-Kendall Test/Sen’s Estimate of Slope

The Mann-Kendall/Sen’s slope estimate trend analysis for temporal trends was applied to

well-parameter pairs where significant trends in background were identified (Table 5.2) and to

Page 27: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

5-8

all detected parameters at MW-8. Period of record data for each well-parameter combination

were analyzed and test plots are included in Appendix F. Results from the analysis did not

indicate any SSIs.

Page 28: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

6-1

6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS

The following recommendations and conclusions are based on a review of data for the

Landfill from the current monitoring period:

1. The direction of groundwater flow across the permitted footprint during the first

half 2015 monitoring period was generally to the south, which agrees with historical variations in the direction of flow across the site due to response to fluctuating water levels in the Mississippi River.

2. Exceedances of SDWSs for TDS, iron, and manganese; and the exceedance of the MCL for arsenic are consistent with the Landfill's historical data. These exceedances are also consistent with regional groundwater quality in the alluvial aquifer.

3. Five confirmed SSIs were indicated based on intrawell prediction intervals: calcium, strontium, sulfate and TDS at MW-3R; and for sulfate at MW-2. It is unclear at this time if these SSIs are the result of disposal activities because the elevated levels that triggered the SSIs are similar to measured levels at monitoring wells located more than 2,000 ft from the active disposal area.

4. The first half 2015 data and statistical analysis results are generally consistent with the facility's previous groundwater analytical results.

Page 29: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

July 28, 2015

7-1

7.0 BIBLIOGRAPHY

Ackerman, D.J. 1989. Hydrology of the Mississippi River Valley alluvial aquifer, south-central

United States; a preliminary assessment of the regional flow system. USGS Water Resources Investigations Report 88-4028, 74 p.

Broom M.E. and Lyford F.P. 1981. Alluvial aquifer of the Cache and St. Francis River Basins, Northeast Arkansas. USGS Open-File Report 81-476, 48 p.

EPA. 1986. RCRA Ground-Water Monitoring Technical Enforcement Guidance Document. National Water Well Association, Dublin, Ohio.

EPA. 1996. Low-Flow (Minimal Drawdown) Ground-Water Sampling Procedures. Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response, April 1996.

EPA. 2009. Statistical Analysis of Groundwater Monitoring Data at RCRA Facilities, Unified Guidance (EPA 530-R-09-007). Office of Resource Conservation and Recovery, Program Implementation and Information Division, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C., March 2009.

FTN. 2011. Second Half 2011 Semiannual Groundwater Monitoring Report, Plum Point Energy Station, February 24, 2011.

GEC, Inc. 2001. Geotechnical and Hydrogeological Investigation, Plum Point Energy Station, July 2001.

Gibbons, Robert D. 1994. Statistical Methods for Groundwater Monitoring. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York.

Gonthier, G.J. 2003. Quality of Groundwater in Pleistocene and Holocene Subunits of the Mississippi River Alluvial Aquifer, 1998. U.S. Geological Survey Water-Resources Investigations Report 03-4202.

Intelligent Decision Technologies, Inc, an NIC Company. 2002. SanitasTM for Groundwater Version 9.2 User’s Guide. Intelligent Decision Technologies, Inc., an NIC Company. Longmont, Colorado.

Kresse, T. and Fazio, J. 2003. Occurrence of Arsenic in Ground Waters of Arkansas and Implications for Source and Release Mechanisms. ADEQ Water Quality Report WQ03-03-01, March 2003.

Welch, H.L., Kingsbury, J.A., Roland, W.T., and Seanor, R.C. 2009. Quality of Shallow Groundwater and Drinking Water in the Mississippi Embayment-Texas Coastal Uplands Aquifer System and the Mississippi River Valley Alluvial Aquifer, South-Central United States, 1994-2004. U.S. Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2009-5091.

Page 30: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

APPENDIX A Field Sampling Forms

Page 31: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 32: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 33: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 34: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 35: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 36: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 37: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 38: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 39: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 40: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 41: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 42: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

APPENDIX B Laboratory Data Sheets

Page 43: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

Chris LussierPlum Point Services Co., LLC2739 SCR 623Osceola, AR 72370

Report Summary

Monday May 11, 2015

Report Number: L762513

Samples Received: 05/01/15

Client Project: 14590-0840-001

Description: NAES Plum Point LF

The analytical results in this report are based upon information suppliedby you, the client, and are for your exclusive use. If you have anyquestions regarding this data package, please do not hesitate to call.

Entire Report Reviewed By: ____________________________________

Mark W. Beasley , ESC Representative

Laboratory Certification NumbersA2LA - 1461-01, AIHA - 100789, AL - 40660, CA - 01157CA, CT - PH-0197,FL - E87487, GA - 923, IN - C-TN-01, KY - 90010, KYUST - 0016,NC - ENV375/DW21704/BIO041, ND - R-140. NJ - TN002, NJ NELAP - TN002,SC - 84004, TN - 2006, VA - 460132, WV - 233, AZ - 0612,MN - 047-999-395, NY - 11742, WI - 998093910, NV - TN000032011-1,TX - T104704245-11-3, OK - 9915, PA - 68-02979, IA Lab #364, EPA - TN002

Accreditation is only applicable to the test methods specified on each scope of accreditation heldby ESC Lab Sciences.

This report may not be reproduced, except in full, without written approval from ESC Lab Sciences.Where applicable, sampling conducted by ESC is performed per guidance providedin laboratory standard operating procedures: 060302, 060303, and 060304.

Page 1 of 20

Page 44: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-01 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : MW-1

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/29/15 12:15

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride 1600 52. 1000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1 Fluoride 280 9.9 100 ug/l 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate 11000 77. 5000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1

Alkalinity 320000 2600 20000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 1

Dissolved Solids 360000 2800 10000 ug/l 2540 C- 05/06/15 1

Arsenic 0.93 0.25 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium 150 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium U 0.16 1.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 0.68 0.54 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper U 0.52 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt 0.35 0.26 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead U 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese 55. 0.25 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel 2.0 0.35 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium 5.1 0.38 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc U 2.6 25. ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury U 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 72. 13. 200 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium 110000 46. 1000 ug/l V 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron 99. 14. 100 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium 23000 11. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium 1100 100 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Sodium 3900 98. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Strontium 300 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 2 of 20

Page 45: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-02 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : MW-3R

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/29/15 14:20

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride 3200 52. 1000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1 Fluoride 210 9.9 100 ug/l 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate 80000 77. 5000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1

Alkalinity 470000 26000 200000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 10

Dissolved Solids 580000 2800 10000 ug/l 2540 C- 05/07/15 1

Arsenic 0.58 0.25 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium 180 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium U 0.16 1.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 0.70 0.54 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper U 0.52 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt U 0.26 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead U 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese 37. 0.25 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel 2.3 0.35 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium 6.9 0.38 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc U 2.6 25. ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury U 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 120 13. 200 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium 170000 46. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron 56. 14. 100 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium 34000 11. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium 810 100 1000 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Sodium 6100 98. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Strontium 510 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 3 of 20

Page 46: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-03 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : MW-6

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/30/15 10:15

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride 720 52. 1000 ug/l J 9056MOD 05/08/15 1 Fluoride 100 9.9 100 ug/l 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate 5300 77. 5000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1

Alkalinity 93000 2600 20000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 1

Dissolved Solids 120000 2800 10000 ug/l 2540 C- 05/09/15 1

Arsenic 1.6 0.25 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium 92. 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium U 0.16 1.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 0.82 0.54 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper U 0.52 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt U 0.26 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead U 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese 1.3 0.25 5.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel 4.2 0.35 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium 2.4 0.38 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc U 2.6 25. ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury U 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 88. 13. 200 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium 27000 46. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron 37. 14. 100 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium 6900 11. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium 680 100 1000 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Sodium 3200 98. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Strontium 83. 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 4 of 20

Page 47: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-04 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : MW-10R

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/30/15 09:20

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride 3900 52. 1000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1 Fluoride 310 9.9 100 ug/l 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate 10000 77. 5000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1

Alkalinity 250000 2600 20000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 1

Dissolved Solids 290000 2800 10000 ug/l 2540 C- 05/09/15 1

Arsenic 3.2 0.25 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium 160 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium U 0.16 1.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 0.75 0.54 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper U 0.52 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt U 0.26 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead U 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese 270 0.25 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel U 0.35 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium U 0.38 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc U 2.6 25. ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury U 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 70. 13. 200 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium 74000 46. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron 25. 14. 100 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium 22000 11. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium 2600 100 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Sodium 4500 98. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Strontium 200 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 5 of 20

Page 48: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-05 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : MW-20

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/29/15 15:50

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride 1300 52. 1000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1 Fluoride 330 9.9 100 ug/l 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate 13000 77. 5000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1

Alkalinity 320000 2600 20000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 1

Dissolved Solids 340000 2800 10000 ug/l 2540 C- 05/07/15 1

Arsenic 16. 0.25 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium 210 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium U 0.16 1.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 0.96 0.54 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper U 0.52 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt 0.38 0.26 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead U 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese 2300 0.25 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel U 0.35 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium 2.0 0.38 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc U 2.6 25. ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury U 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 77. 13. 200 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium 92000 46. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron 5100 14. 100 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium 27000 11. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium 1800 100 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Sodium 8300 98. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Strontium 200 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 6 of 20

Page 49: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-06 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : MW-4R2

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/29/15 15:45

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride 1300 52. 1000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1 Fluoride 300 9.9 100 ug/l 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate 13000 77. 5000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1

Alkalinity 320000 2600 20000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 1

Dissolved Solids 350000 2800 10000 ug/l 2540 C- 05/07/15 1

Arsenic 16. 0.25 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium 220 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium U 0.16 1.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 0.99 0.54 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper U 0.52 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt 0.38 0.26 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead U 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese 2500 0.25 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel U 0.35 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium 2.0 0.38 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc U 2.6 25. ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury U 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 83. 13. 200 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium 92000 46. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron 5000 14. 100 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium 27000 11. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium 1800 100 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Sodium 8300 98. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Strontium 210 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 7 of 20

Page 50: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-07 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : MW-2

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/30/15 11:55

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride 5400 52. 1000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1 Fluoride 150 9.9 100 ug/l 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate 98000 77. 5000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1

Alkalinity 290000 2600 20000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 1

Dissolved Solids 500000 2800 10000 ug/l 2540 C- 05/09/15 1

Arsenic 0.96 0.25 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium 190 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium U 0.16 1.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 1.3 0.54 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper 0.92 0.52 5.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt U 0.26 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead U 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese 18. 0.25 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel 1.1 0.35 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium 8.4 0.38 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc U 2.6 25. ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury U 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 84. 13. 200 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium 130000 46. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron 94. 14. 100 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium 27000 11. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium 1400 100 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Sodium 6200 98. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Strontium 380 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 8 of 20

Page 51: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-08 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : MW-8

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/30/15 11:30

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride 2900 52. 1000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1 Fluoride 160 9.9 100 ug/l 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate 60000 77. 5000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1

Alkalinity 490000 26000 200000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 10

Dissolved Solids 610000 2800 10000 ug/l 2540 C- 05/09/15 1

Arsenic 0.88 0.25 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium 300 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium U 0.16 1.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 1.0 0.54 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper 0.90 0.52 5.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt U 0.26 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead U 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese 40. 0.25 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel 1.9 0.35 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium 0.44 0.38 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc U 2.6 25. ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury U 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 160 13. 200 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium 180000 46. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron 24. 14. 100 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium 31000 11. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium 3600 100 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Sodium 5500 98. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Strontium 560 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 9 of 20

Page 52: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-09 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : MW-13R

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/30/15 10:55

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride 5300 52. 1000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1 Fluoride 94. 9.9 100 ug/l J 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate 26000 77. 5000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1

Alkalinity 280000 2600 20000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 1

Dissolved Solids 370000 2800 10000 ug/l 2540 C- 05/09/15 1

Arsenic 1.2 0.25 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium 180 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium U 0.16 1.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 0.96 0.54 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper U 0.52 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt U 0.26 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead U 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese 0.50 0.25 5.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel 1.1 0.35 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium 0.55 0.38 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc U 2.6 25. ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury U 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 58. 13. 200 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium 89000 46. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron U 14. 100 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium 25000 11. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium 1800 100 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Sodium 3500 98. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Strontium 220 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 10 of 20

Page 53: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-10 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : MW-21

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/30/15 13:30

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride U 52. 1000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1 Fluoride U 9.9 100 ug/l 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate U 77. 5000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 1

Alkalinity U 2600 20000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 1

Dissolved Solids 5000 2800 10000 ug/l JT4 2540 C- 05/09/15 1

Arsenic U 0.25 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium U 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium U 0.16 1.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 0.93 0.54 2.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper 2.7 0.52 5.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt U 0.26 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead U 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese U 0.25 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel U 0.35 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium U 0.38 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc U 2.6 25. ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury U 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 29. 13. 200 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium U 46. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron 26. 14. 100 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium U 11. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium U 100 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Sodium 180 98. 1000 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Strontium U 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 11 of 20

Page 54: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970

REPORT OF ANALYSIS Chris Lussier May 11, 2015 Plum Point Services Co., LLC 2739 SCR 623 Osceola, AR 72370

ESC Sample # : L762513-11 Date Received : May 01, 2015 Description : Plum Point Energy Station LF

Site ID : Sample ID : LEACHATE

Project # : 14590-0840-001 Collected By : Michael Clayton Collection Date : 04/30/15 13:00

Parameter Result MDL RDL Units Qualifier Method Date Dil.

Chloride 130000 5200 100000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 100 Fluoride 1000 9.9 100 ug/l 9056MOD 05/09/15 1 Sulfate 1500000 7700 500000 ug/l 9056MOD 05/08/15 100

Alkalinity 1100000 26000 200000 ug/l 2320 B- 05/11/15 10

Dissolved Solids 4400000 2800 10000 ug/l 2540 C- 05/09/15 1

Arsenic 87. 0.25 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Barium 120 0.36 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Beryllium U 0.12 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cadmium 0.94 0.16 1.0 ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1 Chromium 25. 0.54 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Copper 75. 0.52 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Cobalt 4.6 0.26 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Lead 5.2 0.24 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Manganese 41. 0.25 5.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Nickel 120 0.35 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Selenium 210 0.38 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Silver U 0.31 2.0 ug/l 6020 05/08/15 1 Zinc 11. 2.6 25. ug/l J 6020 05/08/15 1

Mercury 0.27 0.049 0.20 ug/l 7470A 05/04/15 1

Boron 1300 13. 200 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Calcium 12000 46. 1000 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Iron 860 14. 100 ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1 Magnesium 600 11. 1000 ug/l J 6010B 05/07/15 1 Potassium 180000 510 5000 ug/l 6010B 05/08/15 5 Sodium 1200000 490 5000 ug/l 6010B 05/08/15 5 Strontium 550 1.7 10. ug/l 6010B 05/07/15 1

U = ND (Not Detected) RDL = Reported Detection Limit = LOQ = PQL = EQL = TRRP MQL MDL = Minimum Detection Limit = LOD = TRRP SDL Note: The reported analytical results relate only to the sample submitted. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval from ESC. . Reported: 05/11/15 15:29 Printed: 05/11/15 15:29

Page 12 of 20

Page 55: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Attachment AList of Analytes with QC Qualifiers

Sample Work Sample Run Number Group Type Analyte ID Qualifier ________________ ___________ _______ ________________________________________ __________ __________

L762513-01 WG787214 SAMP Arsenic R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Chromium R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Cobalt R3035712 J WG786973 SAMP Boron R3035708 J WG786973 SAMP Calcium R3035708 V WG786973 SAMP Iron R3035708 J

L762513-02 WG787214 SAMP Arsenic R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Chromium R3035712 J WG786973 SAMP Boron R3035708 J WG786973 SAMP Iron R3035708 J WG786973 SAMP Potassium R3035708 J

L762513-03 WG787308 SAMP Chloride R3036101 J WG787214 SAMP Arsenic R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Chromium R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Manganese R3035712 J WG786973 SAMP Boron R3035708 J WG786973 SAMP Iron R3035708 J WG786973 SAMP Potassium R3035708 J

L762513-04 WG787214 SAMP Chromium R3035712 J WG786973 SAMP Boron R3035708 J WG786973 SAMP Iron R3035708 J

L762513-05 WG787214 SAMP Chromium R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Cobalt R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Selenium R3035712 J WG786973 SAMP Boron R3035708 J

L762513-06 WG787214 SAMP Chromium R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Cobalt R3035712 J WG786973 SAMP Boron R3035708 J

L762513-07 WG787214 SAMP Arsenic R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Chromium R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Copper R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Nickel R3035712 J WG786973 SAMP Boron R3035708 J WG786973 SAMP Iron R3035708 J

L762513-08 WG787214 SAMP Arsenic R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Chromium R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Copper R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Nickel R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Selenium R3035712 J WG786973 SAMP Boron R3035708 J WG786973 SAMP Iron R3035708 J

L762513-09 WG787826 SAMP Fluoride R3036095 J WG787214 SAMP Arsenic R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Chromium R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Manganese R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Nickel R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Selenium R3035789 J WG786973 SAMP Boron R3035708 J

L762513-10 WG787214 SAMP Chromium R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Copper R3035712 J WG786973 SAMP Boron R3035708 J WG786973 SAMP Iron R3035708 J WG786973 SAMP Sodium R3035708 J WG787136 SAMP Dissolved Solids R3035952 JT4

L762513-11 WG787214 SAMP Cadmium R3035712 J WG787214 SAMP Zinc R3035712 J WG786973 SAMP Magnesium R3035708 J

Page 13 of 20

Page 56: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Attachment BExplanation of QC Qualifier Codes

Qualifier Meaning __________________ _______________________________________________________________________________

J (EPA) - Estimated value below the lowest calibration point. Confidencecorrelates with concentration.

T4 (ESC) - Additional method/sample information: QNS - Quantity Not Sufficient

V (ESC) - Additional QC Info: The sample concentration is too high toevaluate accurate spike recoveries.

Qualifier Report Information

ESC utilizes sample and result qualifiers as set forth by the EPA Contract Laboratory Program andas required by most certifying bodies including NELAC. In addition to the EPA qualifiers adoptedby ESC, we have implemented ESC qualifiers to provide more information pertaining to our analyticalresults. Each qualifier is designated in the qualifier explanation as either EPA or ESC.Data qualifiers are intended to provide the ESC client with more detailed information concerningthe potential bias of reported data. Because of the wide range of constituents and variety ofmatrices incorporated by most EPA methods,it is common for some compounds to fall outside ofestablished ranges. These exceptions are evaluated and all reported data is valid and useable"unless qualified as 'R' (Rejected)."

DefinitionsAccuracy - The relationship of the observed value of a known sample to the

true value of a known sample. Represented by percent recovery andrelevant to samples such as: control samples, matrix spike recoveries,surrogate recoveries, etc.

Precision - The agreement between a set of samples or between duplicate samples.Relates to how close together the results are and is represented byRelative Percent Differrence.

Surrogate - Organic compounds that are similar in chemical composition, extraction,and chromotography to analytes of interest. The surrogates are used todetermine the probable response of the group of analytes that are chem-ically related to the surrogate compound. Surrogates are added to thesample and carried through all stages of preparation and analyses.

TIC - Tentatively Identified Compound: Compounds detected in samples that arenot target compounds, internal standards, system monitoring compounds,or surrogates.

Page 14 of 20

Page 57: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970Plum Point Services Co., LLC Chris Lussier 2739 SCR 623 Quality Assurance Report

Level IIOsceola, AR 72370 May 11, 2015

L762513

Laboratory BlankAnalyte Result Units % Rec Limit Batch Date Analyzed

Mercury < .0002 mg/l WG786495 05/04/15 17:13

Dissolved Solids < 10 mg/l WG786646 05/06/15 16:02

Dissolved Solids < 10 mg/l WG786877 05/07/15 13:11

Boron < .2 mg/l WG786973 05/07/15 19:39 Calcium < 1 mg/l WG786973 05/07/15 19:39 Iron < .1 mg/l WG786973 05/07/15 19:39 Magnesium < 1 mg/l WG786973 05/07/15 19:39 Potassium < 1 mg/l WG786973 05/07/15 19:39 Sodium < 1 mg/l WG786973 05/07/15 19:39 Strontium < .01 mg/l WG786973 05/07/15 19:39

Arsenic < .002 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Barium < .005 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Beryllium < .002 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Cadmium < .001 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Chromium < .002 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Cobalt < .002 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Copper < .005 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Lead < .002 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Manganese < .005 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Nickel < .002 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Selenium < .002 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Silver < .002 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42 Zinc < .025 mg/l WG787214 05/08/15 01:42

Dissolved Solids < 10 mg/l WG787136 05/09/15 13:50

Fluoride < .1 mg/l WG787826 05/09/15 09:48

Chloride < 1 mg/l WG787308 05/07/15 21:28 Sulfate < 5 mg/l WG787308 05/07/15 21:28

Alkalinity < 20 mg/l WG788008 05/11/15 06:53

DuplicateAnalyte Units Result Duplicate RPD Limit Ref Samp Batch

Dissolved Solids mg/l 358. 357. 0.280 5 L762513-01 WG786646

Dissolved Solids mg/l 1610 1600 0.936 5 L762390-02 WG786877

Dissolved Solids mg/l 868. 892. 2.73 5 L762617-02 WG787136

Fluoride mg/l 0.190 0.211 12.0 20 L762513-02 WG787826 Fluoride mg/l 1.00 1.03 0.0 20 L762513-11 WG787826

* Performance of this Analyte is outside of established criteria.For additional information, please see Attachment A 'List of Analytes with QC Qualifiers.'

Page 15 of 20

Page 58: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970Plum Point Services Co., LLC Chris Lussier 2739 SCR 623 Quality Assurance Report

Level IIOsceola, AR 72370 May 11, 2015

L762513

DuplicateAnalyte Units Result Duplicate RPD Limit Ref Samp Batch

Chloride mg/l 56.0 61.5 9.00 20 L762478-03 WG787308 Sulfate mg/l 140. 154. 9.00 20 L762478-03 WG787308

Alkalinity mg/l 600. 560. 6.90 20 L761991-01 WG788008 Alkalinity mg/l 940. 940. 0.426 20 L761991-02 WG788008

Laboratory Control SampleAnalyte Units Known Val Result % Rec Limit Batch

Mercury mg/l .003 0.00337 112. 80-120 WG786495

Dissolved Solids mg/l 8800 8620 98.0 85-115 WG786646

Dissolved Solids mg/l 8800 8540 97.0 85-115 WG786877

Boron mg/l 1 0.995 100. 80-120 WG786973 Calcium mg/l 10 10.3 103. 80-120 WG786973 Iron mg/l 1 1.05 105. 80-120 WG786973 Magnesium mg/l 10 10.3 103. 80-120 WG786973 Potassium mg/l 10 10.8 108. 80-120 WG786973 Sodium mg/l 10 9.06 91.0 80-120 WG786973 Strontium mg/l 1 0.962 96.0 80-120 WG786973

Arsenic mg/l .05 0.0496 99.0 80-120 WG787214 Barium mg/l .05 0.0485 97.0 80-120 WG787214 Beryllium mg/l .05 0.0558 112. 80-120 WG787214 Cadmium mg/l .05 0.0517 103. 80-120 WG787214 Chromium mg/l .05 0.0504 101. 80-120 WG787214 Cobalt mg/l .05 0.0527 105. 80-120 WG787214 Copper mg/l .05 0.0532 106. 80-120 WG787214 Lead mg/l .05 0.0487 97.0 80-120 WG787214 Manganese mg/l .05 0.0493 99.0 80-120 WG787214 Nickel mg/l .05 0.0528 106. 80-120 WG787214 Selenium mg/l .05 0.0484 97.0 80-120 WG787214 Silver mg/l .05 0.0504 101. 80-120 WG787214 Zinc mg/l .05 0.0496 99.0 80-120 WG787214

Dissolved Solids mg/l 8800 8630 98.1 85-115 WG787136

Fluoride mg/l 8 7.71 96.0 90-110 WG787826

Chloride mg/l 40 39.0 98.0 90-110 WG787308 Sulfate mg/l 40 40.5 101. 90-110 WG787308

Alkalinity mg/l 100 101. 101. 85-115 WG788008

Laboratory Control Sample DuplicateAnalyte Units Result Ref %Rec Limit RPD Limit Batch

Mercury mg/l 0.00293 0.00337 98.0 80-120 14.0 20 WG786495 * Performance of this Analyte is outside of established criteria.For additional information, please see Attachment A 'List of Analytes with QC Qualifiers.'

Page 16 of 20

Page 59: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970Plum Point Services Co., LLC Chris Lussier 2739 SCR 623 Quality Assurance Report

Level IIOsceola, AR 72370 May 11, 2015

L762513

Laboratory Control Sample DuplicateAnalyte Units Result Ref %Rec Limit RPD Limit Batch

Dissolved Solids mg/l 8590 8620 98.0 85-115 0.349 5 WG786646

Dissolved Solids mg/l 8550 8540 97.0 85-115 0.117 5 WG786877

Boron mg/l 1.00 0.995 100. 80-120 1.00 20 WG786973 Calcium mg/l 10.4 10.3 104. 80-120 1.00 20 WG786973 Iron mg/l 1.06 1.05 106. 80-120 1.00 20 WG786973 Magnesium mg/l 10.4 10.3 104. 80-120 1.00 20 WG786973 Potassium mg/l 10.9 10.8 109. 80-120 1.00 20 WG786973 Sodium mg/l 9.14 9.06 91.0 80-120 1.00 20 WG786973 Strontium mg/l 0.969 0.962 97.0 80-120 1.00 20 WG786973

Arsenic mg/l 0.0509 0.0496 102. 80-120 3.00 20 WG787214 Barium mg/l 0.0502 0.0485 100. 80-120 3.00 20 WG787214 Beryllium mg/l 0.0571 0.0558 114. 80-120 2.00 20 WG787214 Cadmium mg/l 0.0523 0.0517 105. 80-120 1.00 20 WG787214 Chromium mg/l 0.0521 0.0504 104. 80-120 3.00 20 WG787214 Cobalt mg/l 0.0538 0.0527 108. 80-120 2.00 20 WG787214 Copper mg/l 0.0545 0.0532 109. 80-120 2.00 20 WG787214 Lead mg/l 0.0503 0.0487 100. 80-120 3.00 20 WG787214 Manganese mg/l 0.0501 0.0493 100. 80-120 2.00 20 WG787214 Nickel mg/l 0.0522 0.0528 104. 80-120 1.00 20 WG787214 Selenium mg/l 0.0516 0.0484 103. 80-120 6.00 20 WG787214 Silver mg/l 0.0517 0.0504 103. 80-120 3.00 20 WG787214 Zinc mg/l 0.0497 0.0496 99.0 80-120 0.0 20 WG787214

Dissolved Solids mg/l 8540 8630 97.0 85-115 1.05 5 WG787136

Fluoride mg/l 7.82 7.71 98.0 90-110 1.00 20 WG787826

Chloride mg/l 39.0 39.0 98.0 90-110 0.0 20 WG787308 Sulfate mg/l 40.6 40.5 102. 90-110 0.0 20 WG787308

Alkalinity mg/l 101. 101. 101. 85-115 0.0 20 WG788008

Matrix SpikeAnalyte Units MS Res Ref Res TV % Rec Limit Ref Samp Batch

Mercury mg/l 0.00271 0.0000069 .003 90.0 75-125 L762513-01 WG786495

Boron mg/l 1.06 0.0716 1 99.0 75-125 L762513-01 WG786973 Calcium mg/l 118. 111. 10 62.0* 75-125 L762513-01 WG786973 Iron mg/l 1.12 0.0992 1 100. 75-125 L762513-01 WG786973 Magnesium mg/l 32.1 23.0 10 91.0 75-125 L762513-01 WG786973 Potassium mg/l 11.9 1.09 10 110. 75-125 L762513-01 WG786973 Sodium mg/l 12.5 3.86 10 87.0 75-125 L762513-01 WG786973 Strontium mg/l 1.23 0.299 1 93.0 75-125 L762513-01 WG786973

Arsenic mg/l 0.0514 0.000109 .05 100. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Barium mg/l 0.0537 0.000433 .05 110. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214

* Performance of this Analyte is outside of established criteria.For additional information, please see Attachment A 'List of Analytes with QC Qualifiers.'

Page 17 of 20

Page 60: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970Plum Point Services Co., LLC Chris Lussier 2739 SCR 623 Quality Assurance Report

Level IIOsceola, AR 72370 May 11, 2015

L762513

Matrix SpikeAnalyte Units MS Res Ref Res TV % Rec Limit Ref Samp Batch

Beryllium mg/l 0.0605 0.0000036 .05 120. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Cadmium mg/l 0.0535 0.0000092 .05 110. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Chromium mg/l 0.0524 0.000881 .05 100. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Cobalt mg/l 0.0535 0.0000217 .05 110. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Copper mg/l 0.0544 0.000191 .05 110. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Lead mg/l 0.0522 0.000197 .05 100. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Manganese mg/l 0.0495 -0.000099 .05 99.0 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Nickel mg/l 0.0527 -0.000561 .05 100. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Selenium mg/l 0.0510 0.0000040 .05 100. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Silver mg/l 0.0527 0.0000463 .05 100. 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214 Zinc mg/l 0.0496 -0.000736 .05 99.0 75-125 L762797-75 WG787214

Fluoride mg/l 5.13 0.102 5 100. 80-120 L762513-03 WG787826

Alkalinity mg/l 381. 320. 100 61.0* 80-120 L763788-01 WG788008

Matrix Spike DuplicateAnalyte Units MSD Ref %Rec Limit RPD Limit Ref Samp Batch

Mercury mg/l 0.00257 0.00271 85.6 75-125 5.00 20 L762513-01 WG786495

Boron mg/l 1.09 1.06 101. 75-125 2.00 20 L762513-01 WG786973 Calcium mg/l 121. 118. 93.2 75-125 3.00 20 L762513-01 WG786973 Iron mg/l 1.14 1.12 104. 75-125 2.00 20 L762513-01 WG786973 Magnesium mg/l 33.0 32.1 100. 75-125 3.00 20 L762513-01 WG786973 Potassium mg/l 12.1 11.9 110. 75-125 2.00 20 L762513-01 WG786973 Sodium mg/l 12.9 12.5 89.9 75-125 3.00 20 L762513-01 WG786973 Strontium mg/l 1.26 1.23 96.2 75-125 2.00 20 L762513-01 WG786973

Arsenic mg/l 0.0497 0.0514 99.1 75-125 3.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Barium mg/l 0.0477 0.0537 94.5 75-125 12.0 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Beryllium mg/l 0.0567 0.0605 113. 75-125 7.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Cadmium mg/l 0.0515 0.0535 103. 75-125 4.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Chromium mg/l 0.0497 0.0524 97.7 75-125 5.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Cobalt mg/l 0.0508 0.0535 102. 75-125 5.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Copper mg/l 0.0517 0.0544 103. 75-125 5.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Lead mg/l 0.0496 0.0522 98.8 75-125 5.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Manganese mg/l 0.0487 0.0495 97.6 75-125 2.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Nickel mg/l 0.0504 0.0527 102. 75-125 4.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Selenium mg/l 0.0473 0.0510 94.6 75-125 8.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Silver mg/l 0.0494 0.0527 98.8 75-125 6.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214 Zinc mg/l 0.0471 0.0496 95.7 75-125 5.00 20 L762797-75 WG787214

Fluoride mg/l 5.13 5.13 100. 80-120 0.0 20 L762513-03 WG787826

Alkalinity mg/l 384. 381. 64.0* 80-120 0.784 20 L763788-01 WG788008

Post Spike

* Performance of this Analyte is outside of established criteria.For additional information, please see Attachment A 'List of Analytes with QC Qualifiers.'

Page 18 of 20

Page 61: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970Plum Point Services Co., LLC Chris Lussier 2739 SCR 623 Quality Assurance Report

Level IIOsceola, AR 72370 May 11, 2015

L762513

Post Spike

Serial Dilution

Batch number /Run number / Sample number cross reference

WG786495: R3034908: L762513-01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11WG786646: R3035360: L762513-01WG786877: R3035560: L762513-02 05 06WG786973: R3035708 R3035795: L762513-01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 WG787214: R3035712 R3035789: L762513-01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 WG787136: R3035952: L762513-03 04 07 08 09 10 11WG787826: R3036095: L762513-01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11WG787308: R3036101: L762513-01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11WG788008: R3036115: L762513-01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11

* * Calculations are performed prior to rounding of reported values.* Performance of this Analyte is outside of established criteria.For additional information, please see Attachment A 'List of Analytes with QC Qualifiers.'

Page 19 of 20

Page 62: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

12065 Lebanon Rd.Mt. Juliet, TN 37122(615) 758-58581-800-767-5859Fax (615) 758-5859

Tax I.D. 62-0814289

Est. 1970Plum Point Services Co., LLC Chris Lussier 2739 SCR 623 Quality Assurance Report

Level IIOsceola, AR 72370 May 11, 2015

L762513

The data package includes a summary of the analytic results of the qualitycontrol samples required by the SW-846 or CWA methods. The quality controlsamples include a method blank, a laboratory control sample, and the matrixspike/matrix spike duplicate analysis. If a target parameter is outsidethe method limits, every sample that is effected is flagged with theappropriate qualifier in Appendix B of the analytic report.

Method Blank - an aliquot of reagent water carried through theentire analytic process. The method blank results indicate ifany possible contamination exposure during the sample handling,digestion or extraction process, and analysis. Concentrations oftarget analytes above the reporting limit in the method blank arequalified with the "B" qualifier.

Laboratory Control Sample - is a sample of known concentrationthat is carried through the digestion/extraction and analysisprocess. The percent recovery, expressed as a percentage of thetheoretical concentration, has statistical control limitsindicating that the analytic process is "in control". If atarget analyte is outside the control limits for the laboratorycontrol sample or any other control sample, the parameter isflagged with a "J4" qualifier for all effected samples.

Matrix Spike and Matrix Spike Duplicate - is two aliquots of anenvironmental sample that is spiked with known concentrations oftarget analytes. The percent recovery of the target analytesalso has statistical control limits. If any recoveries that areoutside the method control limits, the sample that was selectedfor matrix spike/matrix spike duplicate analysis is flagged witheither a "J5" or a "J6". The relative percent difference (%RPD)between the matrix spike and the matrix spike duplicaterecoveries is all calculated. If the RPD is above the methodlimit, the effected samples are flagged with a "J3" qualifier.

Page 20 of 20

Page 63: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 64: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 65: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...
Page 66: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

APPENDIX C Historical Database

Page 67: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Chlo

ride

(mg/

l)

Fluo

ride

(mg/

l)

Sulfa

te (m

g/l)

Alka

linity

(mg/

l)

Diss

olve

d So

lids

(mg/

l)

Mer

cury

(mg/

l)

Arse

nic

(mg/

l)

Bariu

m (m

g/l)

Bery

llium

(mg/

l)

Boro

n (m

g/l)

MW-1 d11/19/2007 6.6 0.27 30 410 500 <0.0002 0.0014 0.27 <0.0003 <0.1

3/11/2008 9.1 0.24 27 380 500 <0.0002 <0.02 0.25 <0.002 <0.25/13/2008 13 0.34 26 400 560 <0.0002 0.0013 0.24 <0.002 <0.29/24/2008 7.1 0.26 23 440 490 <0.0002 0.002 0.24 <0.002 <0.2

11/20/2008 6 0.25 25 420 480 <0.0002 0.0014 0.23 <0.002 <0.23/24/2009 9.6 0.28 26 430 480 <0.0002 0.0015 0.24 <0.002 <0.25/20/2009 11 0.27 22 440 500 <0.0002 <0.001 0.23 <0.002 <0.28/12/2009 6.2 0.27 26 370 480 <0.0002 0.0017 0.29 <0.002 <0.2

5/5/2010 9.3 0.25 26 330 450 <0.0002 <0.001 0.19 <0.002 <0.211/4/2010 5.4 0.32 30 320 400 <0.0002 0.0015 0.22 <0.002 <0.2

6/7/2011 5.6 0.26 17 340 370 n/a 0.00056 0.19 <0.001 0.074(J)12/13/2011 4(B) 0.35 15 290 350 <0.0002 0.0013 0.16 <0.001 0.069(J)

5/14/2012 2.8 0.32 17 290 380 <0.0002 0.0014 0.16 <0.001 0.08410/9/2012 4.2 0.3 24 310 390 <0.0002 0.0012 0.19 0.00035 0.093/13/2013 1.9 0.37 10 290 330 <0.0002 0.0017 0.17 <0.001 0.063(J)9/11/2013 1.1 0.33 12 330 380 5.4E-05(J,) 0.00043(J) 0.16 <0.001 0.064(J)5/19/2014 2.2 0.29 8 300 320 <0.0002 0.0011 0.12 <0.001 0.072(J)11/4/2014 2.7 0.28 14 320 390 <0.0002 0.0017(J) 0.17 <0.002 0.072(J)4/29/2015 1.6 0.28 11 320 360 <0.0002 <0.002(J) 0.15 <0.002 <0.2(J)

MW-2 d11/19/2007 8.3(R) 0.2(R) 23(R) 360(R) 450(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0095(R) 0.55(R) 0.00076(R) <0.1(R)

3/11/2008 6.6 0.2 22 310 480 <0.0002 <0.02 0.21 <0.002 <0.25/13/2008 5.9 <0.1 20 350 500 <0.0002 0.0019 0.19 <0.002 <0.29/24/2008 7.5 0.2 19 390 460 <0.0002 0.0027 0.18 <0.002 <0.2

11/20/2008 7.4 0.17 18 380 410 <0.0002 0.0019 0.17 <0.002 <0.23/24/2009 7.8 <0.1 20 410 440 <0.0002 0.002 0.18 <0.002 <0.25/20/2009 8.3 0.22 19 390 450 <0.0002 0.0013 0.18 <0.002 <0.2

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 68: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Chlo

ride

(mg/

l)

Fluo

ride

(mg/

l)

Sulfa

te (m

g/l)

Alka

linity

(mg/

l)

Diss

olve

d So

lids

(mg/

l)

Mer

cury

(mg/

l)

Arse

nic

(mg/

l)

Bariu

m (m

g/l)

Bery

llium

(mg/

l)

Boro

n (m

g/l)

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-2 8/12/2009 7.2 0.13 17 320 420 <0.0002 0.0022 0.18 <0.002 <0.2(cont.) 5/5/2010 3.6 0.18 14 280 390 <0.0002 <0.001 0.15 <0.002 <0.2

11/4/2010 8.6 0.14 18 340 410 <0.0002 0.0014 0.18 <0.002 <0.26/1/2011 4.1 0.16 33 290 410 n/a 0.0017 0.16 <0.001 0.072(J)

12/14/2011 9.9(B) 0.21 38 300 420 <0.0002 0.0016 0.18 <0.005 0.084(J)5/14/2012 6 0.18 59 290 460 <0.0002 0.0012 0.16 <0.001 0.0893/13/2013 5.8 0.16 45 290 410 <0.0002 0.0016 0.17 <0.001 0.067(J)9/11/2013 5.3 0.2 70 290 490 <0.0002 0.00033(J) 0.18 <0.001 0.072(J)5/19/2014 5.5 0.16 100 290 490 <0.0002 0.00098(J) 0.16 <0.001 0.067(J)11/4/2014 5.4 0.16 71 270 450 <0.0002 0.00071(J) 0.18 <0.002 0.071(J)4/30/2015 5.4 0.15 98 290 500 <0.0002 <0.002(J) 0.19 <0.002 <0.2(J)

MW-3R d11/19/2007 5.5(R) 0.26(R) 15(R) 370(R) 410(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0037(R) 0.31(R) <0.0003(R) <0.1(R)

3/11/2008 4.8 0.27 16 360 420 <0.0002 <0.02 0.28 <0.002 <0.25/13/2008 3.6 <0.1 5 380 400 <0.0002 0.003 0.29 <0.002 <0.29/24/2008 6.5 0.23 36 380 440 <0.0002 0.0016 0.23 <0.002 <0.2

11/21/2008 10 0.21 55 350 450 <0.0002 <0.001 0.16 <0.002 <0.23/25/2009 9 0.12 35 400 430 <0.0002 0.0015 0.16 <0.002 <0.25/20/2009 8.5 0.24 28 330 370 <0.0002 <0.001 0.12 <0.002 <0.28/13/2009 9.7 0.18 27 270 400 <0.0002 <0.001 0.12 <0.002 <0.2

5/5/2010 9.5 0.21 33 290 440 <0.0002 <0.001 0.12 <0.002 <0.211/5/2010 8.5 0.19 46 340 440 <0.0002 <0.001 0.18 <0.002 <0.2

6/1/2011 7.6 0.2 48 340 460 n/a <0.001 0.13 <0.001 0.098(J)12/13/2011 7.1(B) 0.41 50 330 420 <0.0002 0.0009(J) 0.13 <0.001 0.1(J)

5/14/2012 6.4 0.23 78 370 560 <0.0002 0.001 0.17 <0.001 0.1410/9/2012 7.2 0.22 66 360 510 <0.0002 0.0014 0.19 0.00034 0.133/14/2013 8.1 0.2 69 420 510 <0.0002 0.0013 0.18 <0.001 0.11(J)9/11/2013 4.7 0.23 83 380 580 <0.0002 0.00034(J) 0.18 <0.001 0.1(J)

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 69: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Chlo

ride

(mg/

l)

Fluo

ride

(mg/

l)

Sulfa

te (m

g/l)

Alka

linity

(mg/

l)

Diss

olve

d So

lids

(mg/

l)

Mer

cury

(mg/

l)

Arse

nic

(mg/

l)

Bariu

m (m

g/l)

Bery

llium

(mg/

l)

Boro

n (m

g/l)

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-3R 5/19/2014 4.6 0.2 81 410 530 6.2E-05(J) 0.00095(J) 0.15 <0.001 0.093(J)(cont.) 11/4/2014 5.5 0.2 81 390 560 <0.0002 0.00073(J) 0.18 <0.002 0.1(J)

4/29/2015 3.2 0.21 80 470 580 <0.0002 <0.002(J) 0.18 <0.002 <0.2(J)MW-4R d

11/19/2007 15 0.3 18 380 410 <0.0002 <0.001 0.34 <0.0003 <0.13/11/2008 10 0.24 17 360 440 <0.0002 <0.02 0.31 <0.002 <0.25/13/2008 9.3 0.28 18 380 440 <0.0002 <0.005 0.3 <0.002 <0.29/24/2008 16 0.28 15 440 450 <0.0002 0.0013 0.33 <0.002 <0.2

11/20/2008 17(R) 0.3(R) 18(R) 420(R) 470(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0021(R) 0.34(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)3/24/2009 13(R) 0.31(R) 17(R) 440(R) 410(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0017(R) 0.32(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)5/20/2009 14(R) 0.31(R) 18(R) 430(R) 440(R) <0.0002(R) <0.001(R) 0.32(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)8/13/2009 17(R) 0.32(R) 19(R) 390(R) 480(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0021(R) 0.34(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)

5/5/2010 7.8(R) 0.26(R) 120(R) 380(R) 660(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0024(R) 0.42(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)11/5/2010 5(R) 0.26(R) 150(R) 380(R) 620(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0031(R) 0.14(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)

6/7/2011 9.5(R) 0.27(R) 70(R) 390(R) 520(R) n/a 0.013(R) 0.6(R) <0.001(R) 0.065(JR)12/14/2011 7.2(BR) 0.36(R) 170(R) 400(R) 700(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0044(R) 0.52(R) <0.005(R) 0.07(JR)

MW-4R2 d11/19/2007 15 0.3 18 380 410 <0.0002 <0.001 0.34 <0.0003 <0.1

3/11/2008 10 0.24 17 360 440 <0.0002 <0.02 0.31 <0.002 <0.25/13/2008 9.3 0.28 18 380 440 <0.0002 <0.005 0.3 <0.002 <0.29/24/2008 16 0.28 15 440 450 <0.0002 0.0013 0.33 <0.002 <0.2

11/20/2008 17(R) 0.3(R) 18(R) 420(R) 470(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0021(R) 0.34(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)3/24/2009 13(R) 0.31(R) 17(R) 440(R) 410(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0017(R) 0.32(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)5/20/2009 14(R) 0.31(R) 18(R) 430(R) 440(R) <0.0002(R) <0.001(R) 0.32(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)8/13/2009 17(R) 0.32(R) 19(R) 390(R) 480(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0021(R) 0.34(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)

5/5/2010 7.8(R) 0.26(R) 120(R) 380(R) 660(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0024(R) 0.42(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)11/5/2010 5(R) 0.26(R) 150(R) 380(R) 620(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0031(R) 0.14(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)

6/7/2011 9.5(R) 0.27(R) 70(R) 390(R) 520(R) n/a 0.013(R) 0.6(R) <0.001(R) 0.065(JR)Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 70: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Chlo

ride

(mg/

l)

Fluo

ride

(mg/

l)

Sulfa

te (m

g/l)

Alka

linity

(mg/

l)

Diss

olve

d So

lids

(mg/

l)

Mer

cury

(mg/

l)

Arse

nic

(mg/

l)

Bariu

m (m

g/l)

Bery

llium

(mg/

l)

Boro

n (m

g/l)

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-4R2 12/14/2011 7.2(BR) 0.36(R) 170(R) 400(R) 700(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0044(R) 0.52(R) <0.005(R) 0.07(JR)(cont.) 5/15/2012 8.5 0.29 15 310 380 <0.0002 0.016 0.24 <0.01 0.079

10/10/2012 7.5 0.4 14 340 370 <0.0002 0.023 0.23 0.00037 0.113/13/2013 5.7 0.32 19 330 390 <0.0002 0.021 0.26 <0.001 0.078(J)9/11/2013 3.4 0.36 16 330 390 <0.0002 0.0099 0.22 <0.001 0.087(J)5/20/2014 1.9 0.35 14 320 370 5.7E-05(J) 0.0092 0.19 <0.001 0.094(J)11/6/2014 2.6 0.36 14 310 370 <0.0002 0.019 0.2 <0.002 0.076(J)4/29/2015 1.3 0.3 13 320 350 <0.0002 0.016 0.22 <0.002 <0.2(J)

MW-5 d11/20/2007 13 0.19 16 220 300 <0.0002 <0.001 0.12 <0.0003 <0.1

3/11/2008 6 0.16 12 270 330 <0.0002 <0.02 0.13 <0.002 <0.25/13/2008 6.4 0.12 15 290 370 <0.0002 <0.005 0.16 <0.002 <0.29/24/2008 10 0.15 15 250 300 <0.0002 <0.001 0.13 <0.002 <0.2

11/20/2008 11 0.13 16 240 280 <0.0002 0.0013 0.11 <0.002 <0.23/24/2009 7.5 <0.1 14 340 300 <0.0002 0.0013 0.13 <0.002 <0.25/20/2009 7.8 0.17 13 340 310 <0.0002 <0.001 0.14 <0.002 <0.28/12/2009 11 0.25 16 240 340 <0.0002 0.001 0.13 <0.002 <0.2

5/5/2010 9.6 0.12 17 220 330 <0.0002 <0.001 0.12 <0.002 <0.211/5/2010 7.9 0.12 12 200 270 <0.0002 <0.001 0.45 <0.002 <0.2

MW-6 d11/20/2007 7.7(R) 0.15(R) 9.6(R) 83(R) 150(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0052(R) 0.23(R) 0.0004(R) 0.12(R)

3/11/2008 6.1 0.12 8.8 96 180 <0.0002 <0.02 0.11 <0.002 <0.25/14/2008 8.5 0.13 10 110 200 <0.0002 <0.001 0.12 <0.002 <0.29/24/2008 7.5 0.16 9.9 82 150 <0.0002 <0.001 0.1 <0.002 <0.2

11/20/2008 5.7 0.12 9.8 78 130 <0.0002 0.0016 0.095 <0.002 <0.23/24/2009 4.9 <0.1 9.6 91 120 <0.0002 0.0015 0.096 <0.002 <0.25/20/2009 7.6 0.14 12 110 160 <0.0002 <0.001 0.11 <0.002 <0.28/12/2009 7.4 <0.1 11 75 170 <0.0002 0.0014 0.11 <0.002 <0.2

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 71: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Chlo

ride

(mg/

l)

Fluo

ride

(mg/

l)

Sulfa

te (m

g/l)

Alka

linity

(mg/

l)

Diss

olve

d So

lids

(mg/

l)

Mer

cury

(mg/

l)

Arse

nic

(mg/

l)

Bariu

m (m

g/l)

Bery

llium

(mg/

l)

Boro

n (m

g/l)

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-6 5/5/2010 6.6 0.12 12 73 170 <0.0002 <0.001 0.09 <0.002 <0.2(cont.) 11/5/2010 1.5 0.13 5.9 360 120 <0.0002 0.0013 0.12 <0.002 <0.2

6/6/2011 3.8 0.12 12 72 130 n/a 0.0005 0.089 <0.001 0.12(J)12/13/2011 1.7(B) 0.31 6.4 62 99 <0.0002 0.0023 0.073 <0.005 0.11(J)

5/14/2012 1.2 0.2 5.8 61 110 <0.0002 0.0017 0.067 <0.001 0.1110/9/2012 1.3 0.13 4.9 52 100 <0.0002 0.0022 0.061 0.00039 0.13/13/2013 0.98(J) 0.12 5 72 98 <0.0002 0.0019 0.07 <0.001 0.084(J)9/10/2013 0.72(J) 0.17 4.6(J) 64 110 <0.0002 0.0013 0.066 <0.001 0.08(J)5/20/2014 1 0.14 5.5 73 120 5.3E-05(J) 0.0018 0.073 <0.001 0.1(J)11/6/2014 1.2 0.15 5.2 70 110 <0.0002 0.0014(J) 0.073 <0.002 0.09(J)4/30/2015 <1(J) 0.1 5.3 93 120 <0.0002 <0.002(J) 0.092 <0.002 <0.2(J)

MW-7 d11/19/2007 9.7 0.21 23 390 470 <0.0002 <0.001 0.28 <0.0003 <0.1

3/11/2008 4.6 0.2 18 360 440 <0.0002 <0.02 0.25 <0.002 <0.25/13/2008 4.4 <0.1 20 360 460 <0.0002 <0.001 0.25 <0.002 <0.29/24/2008 7.4 0.22 20 400 460 <0.0002 <0.001 0.27 <0.002 <0.2

11/20/2008 12 0.21 22 410 460 <0.0002 <0.001 0.26 <0.002 <0.23/24/2009 7.6 0.1 20 440 460 <0.0002 <0.001 0.27 <0.002 <0.25/20/2009 7.3 0.13 24 400 420 <0.0002 <0.001 0.24 <0.002 <0.28/12/2009 9.6 0.2 22 360 410 <0.0002 <0.001 0.26 <0.002 <0.2

5/5/2010 8.6 0.19 23 360 480 <0.0002 <0.001 0.24 <0.002 <0.211/4/2010 17 0.19 31 70 520 <0.0002 <0.001 0.075 <0.002 <0.2

MW-8 d3/11/2008 6.5(R) 0.17(R) 27(R) 410(R) 480(R) <0.0002(R) <0.02(R) 0.48(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)5/14/2008 4.9(R) <0.1(R) 53(R) 390(R) 500(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0049(R) 0.5(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)9/24/2008 10(R) 0.19(R) 50(R) 470(R) 570(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0072(R) 0.56(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)

11/21/2008 15(R) 0.14(R) 54(R) 460(R) 570(R) 0.00052(R) 0.26(R) 8.4(R) 0.049(R) 1.4(R)3/25/2009 9(R) <0.1(R) 45(R) 470(R) 630(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0017(R) 0.42(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 72: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Chlo

ride

(mg/

l)

Fluo

ride

(mg/

l)

Sulfa

te (m

g/l)

Alka

linity

(mg/

l)

Diss

olve

d So

lids

(mg/

l)

Mer

cury

(mg/

l)

Arse

nic

(mg/

l)

Bariu

m (m

g/l)

Bery

llium

(mg/

l)

Boro

n (m

g/l)

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-8 5/20/2009 7.5(R) <0.1(R) 52(R) 480(R) 570(R) <0.0002(R) 0.064(R) 0.42(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)(cont.) 8/12/2009 11(R) 0.16(R) 55(R) 480(R) 610(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0046(R) 0.49(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)

5/6/2010 15(R) 0.15(R) 36(R) 480(R) 640(R) <0.0002(R) <0.001(R) 0.4(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)11/5/2010 6.5(R) 0.16(R) 44(R) 460(R) 570(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0023(R) 0.29(R) <0.002(R) <0.2(R)

6/1/2011 6.4(R) 0.14(R) 48(R) 490(R) 580(R) n/a 0.0018(R) 0.38(R) <0.001(R) 0.15(JR)12/13/2011 7.4(B) 0.28 45 430 520 <0.0002 0.0011 0.28 <0.001 0.14(J)

5/14/2012 5.7 0.2 57 500 300 <0.0002 0.0016 0.38 <0.001 0.193/12/2013 5.2 0.16 76 470 590 <0.0002 0.0014 0.33 <0.001 0.15(J)9/10/2013 3.3 0.2 62 490 650 5E-05(J) 0.00077(J) 0.33 <0.001 0.14(J)5/20/2014 3.1 0.18 74 530 630 <0.0002 0.0012 0.26 <0.001 0.211/6/2014 2.6 0.19 67 470 600 0.00018(J) 0.00074(J) 0.32 <0.002 0.17(J)4/30/2015 2.9 0.16 60 490 610 <0.0002 <0.002(J) 0.3 <0.002 <0.2(J)

MW-10R d11/19/2007 8.5 0.24 18 240 290 <0.0002 0.003 0.24 <0.0003 <0.1

3/11/2008 4.8 0.18 14 260 320 <0.0002 <0.02 0.26 <0.002 <0.25/13/2008 3.7 0.18 12 290 310 <0.0002 0.0029 0.26 <0.002 <0.29/25/2008 5.2 0.23 12 270 280 <0.0002 0.0035 0.22 <0.002 <0.2

11/20/2008 6.4 0.21 15 240 270 <0.0002 0.0054 0.21 <0.002 <0.23/24/2009 5.6 0.13 14 360 340 <0.0002 0.0025 0.26 <0.002 <0.25/21/2009 6 0.11 19 370 330 <0.0002 0.0022 0.3 <0.002 <0.28/12/2009 6.7 0.2 15 270 320 <0.0002 0.0031 0.24 <0.002 <0.2

5/6/2010 6.2 0.19 14 240 300 <0.0002 0.0023 0.2 <0.002 <0.211/4/2010 6.6 0.2 12 240 290 <0.0002(R) 0.0039 <0.005 <0.002 <0.2

6/7/2011 4.9(R) 0.17(R) 11(R) 240(R) 280(R) n/a 0.048(R) 0.38(R) <0.001(R) 0.074(JR)12/13/2011 11(BR) 0.24(R) 14(R) 240(R) 280(R) <0.0002(R) 0.0071(R) 0.22(R) <0.001(R) 0.08(JR)

5/15/2012 7 0.21 14 250 300 <0.0002 0.0041 0.19 <0.001 0.08210/9/2012 7.6 0.22 15 240 300 <0.0002 0.012 0.23 0.00034 0.0863/13/2013 3.5 0.16 10 250 280 <0.0002 0.0077 0.26 <0.001 0.065(J)

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 73: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Chlo

ride

(mg/

l)

Fluo

ride

(mg/

l)

Sulfa

te (m

g/l)

Alka

linity

(mg/

l)

Diss

olve

d So

lids

(mg/

l)

Mer

cury

(mg/

l)

Arse

nic

(mg/

l)

Bariu

m (m

g/l)

Bery

llium

(mg/

l)

Boro

n (m

g/l)

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-10R 9/10/2013 7.2 0.21 14 260 340 <0.0002 0.0025 0.22 <0.001 0.07(J)(cont.) 5/20/2014 4.2 0.1 12 260 300 5E-05(J) 0.0032 0.15 <0.001 0.088(J)

11/6/2014 6.9 0.21 16 280 340 <0.0002 0.0049 0.27 <0.002 0.07(J)4/30/2015 3.9 0.31 10 250 290 <0.0002 0.0032 0.16 <0.002 <0.2(J)

MW-11R d11/19/2007 6.3 0.16 9.1 200 250 <0.0002 <0.001 0.16 <0.0003 <0.1

3/11/2008 7.8 0.14 8.1 200 290 <0.0002 <0.02 0.17 <0.002 <0.25/14/2008 8.9 0.13 11 260 320 <0.0002 <0.001 0.19 <0.002 <0.29/25/2008 6.9 0.13 8.8 230 260 <0.0002 <0.001 0.16 <0.002 <0.2

11/21/2008 5.7 0.11 11 220 250 <0.0002 <0.001 0.15 <0.002 <0.23/24/2009 6.9 <0.1 10 260 260 <0.0002 0.0015 0.17 <0.002 <0.25/20/2009 8.8 <0.1 11 270 290 <0.0002 <0.001 0.18 <0.002 <0.28/12/2009 8.5 <0.1 12 210 270 <0.0002 <0.001 0.17 <0.002 <0.2

5/5/2010 2.5 0.13 18 170 260 <0.0002 <0.001 0.13 <0.002 <0.211/4/2010 1.6 0.14 21 170 230 <0.0002 <0.001 0.13 <0.002 <0.2

MW-13 d3/12/2008 11 0.27 <5 520 570 <0.0002 0.038 0.55 <0.002 <0.25/14/2008 11 0.38 <5 540 530 <0.0002 0.053 1.2 0.0044 0.269/25/2008 14 0.26 <5 560 570 <0.0002 0.027 0.54 <0.002 <0.2

11/21/2008 13 0.37 <5 520 550 0.00022 0.037 0.55 <0.002 0.233/25/2009 12 0.15 <5 590 620 <0.0002 0.037 0.58 <0.002 <0.2

MW-13R d5/20/2009 4.4 <0.1 19 330 320 <0.0002 <0.001 0.17 <0.002 <0.28/12/2009 17 <0.1 22 280 370 <0.0002 <0.001 0.19 <0.002 <0.2

5/6/2010 9.5 0.11 19 280 380 <0.0002 <0.001 0.17 <0.002 <0.211/4/2010 26 0.11 29 260 370 <0.0002 0.0011 0.2 <0.002 <0.2

6/6/2011 23 0.09 30 280 400 n/a 0.00044 0.19 <0.001 0.076(J)12/13/2011 17(B) 0.13 26 280 370 <0.0002 0.0013 0.19 <0.001 0.064(J)

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 74: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Chlo

ride

(mg/

l)

Fluo

ride

(mg/

l)

Sulfa

te (m

g/l)

Alka

linity

(mg/

l)

Diss

olve

d So

lids

(mg/

l)

Mer

cury

(mg/

l)

Arse

nic

(mg/

l)

Bariu

m (m

g/l)

Bery

llium

(mg/

l)

Boro

n (m

g/l)

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-13R 5/14/2012 9.8 0.093 24 270 370 <0.0002 0.0019 0.16 <0.001 0.082(cont.) 10/9/2012 3.9 0.1 17 260 320 <0.0002 0.0012 0.19 0.00039 0.083

3/12/2013 4.1 0.094(J) 36 290 370 <0.0002 0.0014 0.19 <0.001 0.053(J)9/10/2013 3.7 0.13 21 260 360 <0.0002 0.0012 0.16 <0.001 0.076(J)5/20/2014 4.8 0.1 29 280 350 <0.0002 0.001 0.14 <0.001 0.081(J)11/6/2014 2.6 0.12 22 250 300 <0.0002 0.0012(J) 0.17 <0.002 0.068(J)4/30/2015 5.3 <0.1(J) 26 280 370 <0.0002 <0.002(J) 0.18 <0.002 <0.2(J)

MW-15 u11/19/2007 8 0.24 15 350 420 <0.0002 <0.001 0.25 <0.0003 <0.1

3/11/2008 7.4 0.21 16 320 420 <0.0002 <0.02 0.24 <0.002 <0.25/14/2008 7.4 <0.1 20 340 390 <0.0002 <0.001 0.25 <0.002 <0.29/25/2008 8.5 0.23 16 370 430 <0.0002 <0.001 0.24 <0.002 <0.2

11/21/2008 11 0.31 16 380 440 <0.0002 <0.001 0.21 <0.002 <0.23/25/2009 11 0.14 19 370 430 <0.0002 <0.001 0.23 <0.002 <0.25/21/2009 12 0.23 20 380 410 <0.0002 <0.001 0.24 <0.002 <0.28/12/2009 12 0.21 18 340 450 <0.0002 <0.001 0.23 <0.002 <0.2

5/6/2010 14 0.2 18 350 510 <0.0002 <0.001 0.22 <0.002 <0.211/4/2010 23 0.22 33 350 500 <0.0002 <0.001 0.3 <0.002 <0.2

LEACHATE d6/7/2011 8.9 0.46 300 87 320 n/a 0.0057 0.05 <0.001 0.16(J)

12/14/2011 78(B) 0.76 780 910 2300 <0.0002 0.048 0.056 <0.001 0.435/15/2012 110 0.82 920 1000 3200 0.00033 0.096 0.13 <0.001 0.95

10/10/2012 130 0.86 930 1200 3600 0.00065 0.098 0.21 0.00047 1.23/14/2013 110 0.38 1200 220 2200 <0.0002 0.035 0.04 <0.001 1.39/11/2013 120 0.6 1100 420 2600 6.9E-05(J) 0.03 0.039 <0.001 1.65/20/2014 68 0.7 790 590 2200 0.00046 0.047 0.11 0.00019(J) 1.111/6/2014 130 0.65 760 1100 3000 0.00019(J) 0.057 0.15 0.00018(J) 1.14/30/2015 130 1 1500 1100 4400 0.00027 0.087 0.12 <0.002 1.3

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 75: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

MW-1 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/4/2010

6/7/201112/13/2011

5/14/201210/9/20123/13/20139/11/20135/19/201411/4/20144/29/2015

MW-2 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/2009

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

Cadm

ium

(mg/

l)

Calc

ium

(mg/

l)

Chro

miu

m (m

g/l)

Coba

lt (m

g/l)

Copp

er (m

g/l)

Iron

(mg/

l)

Lead

(mg/

l)

Mag

nesi

um (m

g/l)

Man

gane

se (m

g/l)

Nic

kel (

mg/

l)

<0.004 130 <0.007 <0.007 <0.006 3.1 <0.001 30 0.85 <0.01<0.005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 2.2 <0.005 32 0.75 <0.02

<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 1.1 <0.005 31 0.59 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 1.7 <0.005 32 0.68 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 2.2 <0.005 31 0.68 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 1.6 <0.005 31 0.58 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 1.4 0.012 31 0.56 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.98 <0.005 28 0.42 <0.02<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.38 <0.005 25 0.27 <0.02<0.0005 130 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.89 <0.025 29 0.023 <0.02<0.0005 95 0.00058(J) 0.0007 <0.002 0.47 <0.001 23 0.64 0.007<0.0005 90 <0.002 0.00091(J) <0.002 0.14 <0.001 21 0.28 0.0059<0.0005 95 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002(B) 0.17 <0.001 23 0.16 0.007<0.0005 100(B) 0.00056 0.0035 0.00092 0.69(B) 0.00061 24(B) 0.76 0.011<0.0005 91 0.00054(J) 0.00096(J) 0.00079(J) 0.3 0.00054(J) 20 0.3 0.0063<0.0005 100 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002 <0.1 0.00086(J) 23 0.0083 0.0033

0.00017(J) 96 <0.002 <0.001 0.00097(J) <0.1 <0.001 21 0.0057 0.0029<0.001 110 <0.002 0.00032(J) 0.00088(J) 0.023(J) <0.002 23 0.11 0.0038<0.001 110(V) <0.002(J) <0.002(J) <0.005 <0.1(J) <0.002 23 0.055 0.002

<0.004(R) 120(R) 0.02(R) 0.013(R) 0.014(R) 18(R) 0.012(R) 28(R) 0.79(R) 0.043(R)<0.005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.12 <0.005 25 0.012 <0.02

<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.11 <0.005 25 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 25 0.093 <0.02<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 24 0.14 <0.02<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.15 <0.005 26 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 100 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.19 0.0065 24 <0.01 <0.02

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 76: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-2 8/12/2009(cont.) 5/5/2010

11/4/20106/1/2011

12/14/20115/14/20123/13/20139/11/20135/19/201411/4/20144/30/2015

MW-3R d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/21/20083/25/20095/20/20098/13/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

6/1/201112/13/2011

5/14/201210/9/20123/14/20139/11/2013

Cadm

ium

(mg/

l)

Calc

ium

(mg/

l)

Chro

miu

m (m

g/l)

Coba

lt (m

g/l)

Copp

er (m

g/l)

Iron

(mg/

l)

Lead

(mg/

l)

Mag

nesi

um (m

g/l)

Man

gane

se (m

g/l)

Nic

kel (

mg/

l)

<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.18 <0.005 23 0.02 <0.02<0.0005 91 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 20 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 100 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.025 24 0.27 <0.02<0.0005 95 0.0012(J) <0.001 <0.002 0.98 0.00085 21 0.064 0.0045<0.0005 100 <0.002 <0.001 0.00088(J) <0.1 0.00031(J) 24 0.011 0.0033<0.0005 110 <0.002 <0.001 0.00071(B) 0.1 <0.001 25 0.023 0.0048<0.0005 100 0.00071(J) <0.001 0.0011(J) 0.092(J) 0.0005(J) 23 0.029 0.0042<0.0005 110 <0.002 <0.001 0.0016(J) <0.1 0.0017 25 0.0017(J) 0.0025

0.00021(J) 120 <0.002 0.00027(J) 0.0008(J) 0.037(J) <0.001 26 0.006 0.0026<0.001 110 <0.002 <0.002 0.00067(J) 0.019(J) <0.002 25 0.0066 0.0012(J)<0.001 130 <0.002(J) <0.002 <0.005(J) <0.1(J) <0.002 27 0.018 <0.002(J)

<0.004(R) 97(R) <0.007(R) <0.007(R) <0.006(R) 16(R) 0.0028(R) 27(R) 2.3(R) <0.01(R)<0.005 98 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 12 <0.005 28 2.6 <0.02

<0.0005 100 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 12 <0.005 29 2.6 <0.02<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.75 <0.005 26 1.2 <0.02<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 24 0.4 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.17 0.0074 26 0.096 <0.02<0.0005 90 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.15 0.011 20 0.087 <0.02<0.0005 93 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.22 <0.005 21 0.062 <0.02<0.0005 96 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 22 0.049 <0.02<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.025 24 0.095 <0.02<0.0005 110 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002 0.053 <0.001 25 0.066 0.0064<0.0005 110 <0.002 <0.001 0.00069(J) 0.056(J) 0.00026(J) 25 0.067 0.0067<0.0005 140 <0.002 <0.001 0.0012(B) 0.14 <0.001 31 0.18 0.011<0.0005 130(B) 0.0012 0.0026 0.001 1.4(B) 0.00064 30(B) 0.96 0.019

0.00033(J) 130 0.00062(J) 0.00056(J) 0.0011(J) 0.26 0.00036(J) 29 0.16 0.0098<0.0005 150 <0.002 <0.001 0.0012(J) <0.1 0.00039(J) 32 0.025 0.0053

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 77: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-3R 5/19/2014(cont.) 11/4/2014

4/29/2015MW-4R d

11/19/20073/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/13/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

6/7/201112/14/2011

MW-4R2 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/13/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

6/7/2011

Cadm

ium

(mg/

l)

Calc

ium

(mg/

l)

Chro

miu

m (m

g/l)

Coba

lt (m

g/l)

Copp

er (m

g/l)

Iron

(mg/

l)

Lead

(mg/

l)

Mag

nesi

um (m

g/l)

Man

gane

se (m

g/l)

Nic

kel (

mg/

l)

0.00024(J) 150 <0.002 0.0003(J) <0.002 <0.1 0.00034(J) 33 0.032 0.0052<0.001 160 <0.002 <0.002 0.00061(J) <0.1 <0.002 32 0.035 0.0042<0.001 170 <0.002(J) <0.002 <0.005 <0.1(J) <0.002 34 0.037 0.0023

<0.004 110 <0.007 <0.007 <0.006 0.24 <0.001 29 0.77 <0.01<0.005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 29 0.74 <0.02

<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 29 0.62 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 30 1.1 <0.02

<0.0005(R) 110(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) <0.1(R) <0.005(R) 31(R) 1.1(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 110(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) 0.1(R) <0.005(R) 29(R) 0.96(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 110(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) <0.1(R) 0.012(R) 29(R) 1(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 120(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) <0.1(R) <0.005(R) 30(R) 1(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 140(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) <0.1(R) <0.005(R) 36(R) 1.5(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 120(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) <0.1(R) <0.025(R) 26(R) 0.12(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 120(R) 0.00055(JR) 0.023(R) 0.00059(R) 2.9(R) <0.001(R) 32(R) 7.1(R) 0.004(R)0.00016(JR) 160(R) <0.002(R) 0.0024(R) 0.00068(JR) 0.065(JR) 0.00044(JR) 40(R) 2.4(R) 0.0046(R)

<0.004 110 <0.007 <0.007 <0.006 0.24 <0.001 29 0.77 <0.01<0.005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 29 0.74 <0.02

<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 29 0.62 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 30 1.1 <0.02

<0.0005(R) 110(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) <0.1(R) <0.005(R) 31(R) 1.1(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 110(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) 0.1(R) <0.005(R) 29(R) 0.96(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 110(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) <0.1(R) 0.012(R) 29(R) 1(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 120(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) <0.1(R) <0.005(R) 30(R) 1(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 140(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) <0.1(R) <0.005(R) 36(R) 1.5(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 120(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) <0.1(R) <0.025(R) 26(R) 0.12(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 120(R) 0.00055(JR) 0.023(R) 0.00059(R) 2.9(R) <0.001(R) 32(R) 7.1(R) 0.004(R)

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 78: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-4R2 12/14/2011(cont.) 5/15/2012

10/10/20123/13/20139/11/20135/20/201411/6/20144/29/2015

MW-5 d11/20/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

MW-6 d11/20/2007

3/11/20085/14/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

Cadm

ium

(mg/

l)

Calc

ium

(mg/

l)

Chro

miu

m (m

g/l)

Coba

lt (m

g/l)

Copp

er (m

g/l)

Iron

(mg/

l)

Lead

(mg/

l)

Mag

nesi

um (m

g/l)

Man

gane

se (m

g/l)

Nic

kel (

mg/

l)

0.00016(JR) 160(R) <0.002(R) 0.0024(R) 0.00068(JR) 0.065(JR) 0.00044(JR) 40(R) 2.4(R) 0.0046(R)<0.005 86 <0.02 <0.01 <0.02(B) 4.7 <0.01 31 3 <0.01

<0.0005 84(B) 0.0016 0.0011 0.00097 6.1(B) 0.00081 31(B) 3.3 0.0041<0.0005 85 0.00096(J) 0.00029(J) 0.00095(J) 3.8 <0.001 28 2.7 0.0028<0.0005 91 <0.002 <0.001 0.0012(J) 2.3 0.00067(J) 29 2.5 0.0024

0.00023(J) 90 <0.002 0.00044(J) 0.00065(J) 1.7 <0.001 28 1.4 0.0018<0.001 93 <0.002 0.00046(J) <0.005 5 <0.002 29 3 0.0007(J)<0.001 92 <0.002(J) <0.002(J) <0.005 5 <0.002 27 2.5 <0.002

<0.004 65 <0.007 <0.007 <0.006 1.4 0.0012 25 0.092 <0.01<0.005 72 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.23 <0.005 28 0.022 <0.02

<0.0005 78 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.41 <0.005 28 0.048 <0.02<0.0005 67 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.22 <0.005 26 0.013 <0.02<0.0005 60 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.2 <0.005 24 0.015 <0.02<0.0005 73 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.19 <0.005 28 0.018 <0.02<0.0005 74 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.2 <0.005 27 0.023 <0.02<0.0005 68 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.16 <0.005 26 0.01 <0.02<0.0005 58 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.16 <0.005 23 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 140 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.14 <0.025 38 1.7 <0.02

<0.004(R) 30(R) <0.007(R) 0.0091(R) 0.0074(R) 9.4(R) 0.0099(R) 8.9(R) 0.43(R) 0.021(R)<0.005 28 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.11 <0.005 7.9 <0.01 <0.02

<0.0005 34 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 9.4 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 28 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 7.5 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 24 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 6.8 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 26 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.18 <0.005 7 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 31 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 8.3 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 29 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 7.7 <0.01 <0.02

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 79: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-6 5/5/2010(cont.) 11/5/2010

6/6/201112/13/2011

5/14/201210/9/20123/13/20139/10/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

MW-7 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/4/2010

MW-8 d3/11/20085/14/20089/24/2008

11/21/20083/25/2009

Cadm

ium

(mg/

l)

Calc

ium

(mg/

l)

Chro

miu

m (m

g/l)

Coba

lt (m

g/l)

Copp

er (m

g/l)

Iron

(mg/

l)

Lead

(mg/

l)

Mag

nesi

um (m

g/l)

Man

gane

se (m

g/l)

Nic

kel (

mg/

l)

<0.0005 25 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 6.9 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 55 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.025 21 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 23 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002 0.12 <0.001 6.4 0.011 0.004<0.0005 18 <0.002 0.0004(J) 0.00095(J) 0.5 0.00088(J) 4.9 0.028 0.0052<0.0005 17 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002(B) 0.1 <0.001 4.5 0.0057 0.0037<0.0005 21(B) 0.00076 0.00074 0.00096 0.38(B) 0.0006 6.6(B) 0.053 0.0055<0.0005 17 <0.002 <0.001 0.00082(J) 0.32 0.00079(J) 4.9 0.032 0.0054<0.0005 19 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002 0.017(J) 0.0029 5 0.0026 0.0030.0002(J) 20 <0.002 <0.001 0.00078(J) 0.058(J) <0.001 5.8 0.007 0.0043

<0.001 22 <0.002 <0.002 0.00067(J) 0.04(J) <0.002 5.1 0.012 0.004<0.001 27 <0.002(J) <0.002 <0.005 <0.1(J) <0.002 6.9 <0.005(J) 0.0042

<0.004 130 <0.007 <0.007 <0.006 0.55 <0.001 28 0.16 <0.01<0.005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 27 0.14 <0.02

<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 27 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.11 <0.005 29 0.023 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 28 0.045 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 0.0079 29 0.19 <0.02<0.0005 100 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 0.01 25 0.15 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 0.0063 27 0.048 <0.02<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 26 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 20 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 5.3 <0.01 <0.02

<0.005(R) 140(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) 9.6(R) 0.0072(R) 29(R) 3.3(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 130(R) 0.014(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) 11(R) <0.005(R) 28(R) 3(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 160(R) 0.015(R) 0.014(R) <0.02(R) 18(R) 0.016(R) 34(R) 1.6(R) 0.027(R)

0.023(R) 770(R) 0.74(R) 0.45(R) 0.72(R) 810(R) 0.79(R) 290(R) 17(R) 1(R)<0.0005(R) 140(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) 2.9(R) 0.0054(R) 29(R) 0.75(R) <0.02(R)

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 80: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-8 5/20/2009(cont.) 8/12/2009

5/6/201011/5/2010

6/1/201112/13/2011

5/14/20123/12/20139/10/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

MW-10R d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/25/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/21/20098/12/2009

5/6/201011/4/2010

6/7/201112/13/2011

5/15/201210/9/20123/13/2013

Cadm

ium

(mg/

l)

Calc

ium

(mg/

l)

Chro

miu

m (m

g/l)

Coba

lt (m

g/l)

Copp

er (m

g/l)

Iron

(mg/

l)

Lead

(mg/

l)

Mag

nesi

um (m

g/l)

Man

gane

se (m

g/l)

Nic

kel (

mg/

l)

0.062(R) 150(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) 3.5(R) 0.013(R) 31(R) 0.65(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 170(R) 0.014(R) 0.011(R) <0.02(R) 11(R) 0.017(R) 35(R) 0.86(R) 0.034(R)<0.0005(R) 160(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) 1(R) <0.005(R) 34(R) 0.63(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 140(R) <0.01(R) <0.01(R) <0.02(R) 5.4(R) <0.025(R) 28(R) 0.012(R) <0.02(R)<0.0005(R) 160(R) 0.0049(R) 0.0036(R) 0.0014(JR) 2.7(R) 0.0027(R) 34(R) 0.51(R) 0.012(R)

<0.0005 140 <0.002 0.00035(J) 0.0008(J) 0.21 0.00038(J) 28 0.16 0.0074<0.0005 180 <0.002 <0.001 0.00061(B) 0.33 <0.001 35 0.33 0.0094<0.0005 170 0.00072(J) <0.001 0.0016(J) 0.3 0.00066(J) 31 0.096 0.0083<0.0005 180 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002 0.031(J) 0.00031(J) 33 0.14 0.0082

0.00017(J) 190 <0.002 0.0003(J) 0.00094(J) <0.1 <0.001 38 0.016 0.0039<0.001 180 0.00055(J) <0.002 0.00076(J) <0.1 <0.002 31 0.069 0.0025<0.001 180 <0.002(J) <0.002 <0.005(J) <0.1(J) <0.002 31 0.04 <0.002(J)

<0.004 64 <0.007 <0.007 <0.006 1.3 <0.001 21 1 <0.01<0.005 73 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 1.2 <0.005 24 1.2 <0.02

<0.0005 72 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 1.3 <0.005 23 1.1 <0.02<0.0005 66 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.9 <0.005 21 1.3 <0.02<0.0005 62 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 1 <0.005 20 1.2 <0.02<0.0005 78 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 1.3 <0.005 25 1.2 <0.02<0.0005 84 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 1.5 0.0054 27 1.3 <0.02<0.0005 72 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.86 <0.005 22 1.3 <0.02<0.0005 65 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.48 <0.005 21 0.96 <0.02<0.0005 <0.5 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.82 <0.005 <0.1 <0.01 <0.02

<0.0005(R) 62(R) <0.002(R) <0.001(R) <0.002(R) 12(R) <0.001(R) 20(R) 1.7(R) <0.001(R)<0.0005(R) 66(R) 0.0008(JR) 0.0011(R) 0.0014(JR) 2.1(R) 0.0012(R) 21(R) 1.3(R) 0.0028(R)

<0.0005 71 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002(B) 0.54 <0.001 21 1.4 0.0027<0.0005 70(B) 0.00078 0.00079 <0.002 1.9(B) 0.00034 22(B) 1.5 0.0027<0.0005 67 <0.002 0.00066(J) <0.002 1.2 <0.001 22 1.3 0.0022

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 81: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-10R 9/10/2013(cont.) 5/20/2014

11/6/20144/30/2015

MW-11R d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/14/20089/25/2008

11/21/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/4/2010

MW-13 d3/12/20085/14/20089/25/2008

11/21/20083/25/2009

MW-13R d5/20/20098/12/2009

5/6/201011/4/2010

6/6/201112/13/2011

Cadm

ium

(mg/

l)

Calc

ium

(mg/

l)

Chro

miu

m (m

g/l)

Coba

lt (m

g/l)

Copp

er (m

g/l)

Iron

(mg/

l)

Lead

(mg/

l)

Mag

nesi

um (m

g/l)

Man

gane

se (m

g/l)

Nic

kel (

mg/

l)

<0.0005 72 <0.002 <0.001 0.001(J) 0.26 <0.001 24 1.3 0.00180.00017(J) 73 <0.002 0.00045(J) 0.00056(J) 0.038(J) <0.001 24 0.47 0.0021

<0.001 87 <0.002 0.0013(J) 0.00054(J) 0.5 <0.002 24 1.8 0.0014(J)<0.001 74 <0.002(J) <0.002 <0.005 <0.1(J) <0.002 22 0.27 <0.002

<0.004 61 <0.007 <0.007 <0.006 0.6 <0.001 16 0.013 <0.01<0.005 64 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.19 <0.005 17 <0.01 <0.02

<0.0005 76 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 20 0.021 <0.02<0.0005 64 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 17 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 61 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 16 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 68 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 18 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 71 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 0.009 18 0.011 <0.02<0.0005 66 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 17 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 52 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 14 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 55 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 14 <0.01 <0.02

<0.005 140 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 37 <0.005 39 2.5 <0.020.00087 170 0.088 0.033 0.067 97 0.056 58 3 0.076<0.0005 140 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 28 <0.005 39 1.7 <0.02<0.0005 140 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 34 0.0054 39 1.6 <0.02<0.0005 150 0.015 <0.01 <0.02 36 0.012 42 1.3 <0.02

<0.0005 79 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.22 <0.005 23 0.12 <0.02<0.0005 85 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.1 <0.005 26 0.16 <0.02<0.0005 83 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 25 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 64 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.025 20 1.3 <0.02<0.0005 82 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002 0.26 <0.001 26 0.082 0.0023<0.0005 89 <0.002 0.0003(J) <0.002 0.2 0.00035(J) 26 0.056 0.0048

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 82: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-13R 5/14/2012(cont.) 10/9/2012

3/12/20139/10/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

MW-15 u11/19/2007

3/11/20085/14/20089/25/2008

11/21/20083/25/20095/21/20098/12/2009

5/6/201011/4/2010

LEACHATE d6/7/2011

12/14/20115/15/2012

10/10/20123/14/20139/11/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

Cadm

ium

(mg/

l)

Calc

ium

(mg/

l)

Chro

miu

m (m

g/l)

Coba

lt (m

g/l)

Copp

er (m

g/l)

Iron

(mg/

l)

Lead

(mg/

l)

Mag

nesi

um (m

g/l)

Man

gane

se (m

g/l)

Nic

kel (

mg/

l)

<0.0005 86 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002(B) 0.066 <0.001 28 0.026 0.005<0.0005 78(B) 0.0013 0.00075 0.00093 0.46(B) 0.0011 23(B) 0.052 0.0064<0.0005 89 0.00056(J) 0.00046(J) 0.00097(J) 0.41 0.00097(J) 25 0.13 0.0072<0.0005 78 <0.002 <0.001 <0.002 <0.1 <0.001 26 0.0019(J) 0.0019

0.00019(J) 92 <0.002 <0.001 0.00053(J) <0.1 <0.001 26 0.001(J) 0.0025<0.001 83 0.00066(J) <0.002 <0.005 <0.1 <0.002 24 0.012 0.0018(J)<0.001 89 <0.002(J) <0.002 <0.005 <0.1 <0.002 25 <0.005(J) <0.002(J)

<0.004 110 <0.007 <0.007 <0.006 0.032 <0.001 28 0.27 <0.01<0.005 99 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 28 0.53 <0.02

<0.0005 100 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 28 0.58 <0.020.0011 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 30 <0.01 <0.02

<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 27 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 100 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 0.1 <0.005 28 0.16 <0.02<0.0005 100 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 0.0091 28 0.17 <0.02<0.0005 110 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 29 0.019 <0.02<0.0005 120 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.005 29 <0.01 <0.02<0.0005 140 <0.01 <0.01 <0.02 <0.1 <0.025 30 0.015 <0.02

<0.0005 23 0.016 <0.001 0.0021 0.12 <0.001 0.4 0.0039 <0.0010.00034(J) 15 0.088 0.0047 0.072 0.31 0.00076(J) 0.44 0.031 0.016

<0.0005 21 0.0045 0.0068 0.12(B) 1.7 0.0029 3.3 0.14 0.0860.0011 22(B) 0.012 0.0072 0.14 2.8(B) 0.0087 2.3(B) 0.22 0.13

0.00074 7.6 <0.002 0.0013 0.019 0.048(J) <0.001 0.64 0.028 0.0630.00059 7.8 <0.002 <0.001 0.0084 0.056(J) 0.00049(J) 0.25 0.059 0.0590.0021 20 0.0095 0.0035 0.11 3.4 0.012 1.5 0.19 0.0720.0021 16 0.0076 0.0038 0.077 2.3 0.012 0.67(J) 0.17 0.15

<0.001(J) 12 0.025 0.0046 0.075 0.86 0.0052 <1(J) 0.041 0.12Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 83: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

MW-1 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/4/2010

6/7/201112/13/2011

5/14/201210/9/20123/13/20139/11/20135/19/201411/4/20144/29/2015

MW-2 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/2009

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

Pota

ssiu

m (m

g/l)

Sele

nium

(mg/

l)

Silv

er (m

g/l)

Sodi

um (m

g/l)

Stro

ntiu

m (m

g/l)

Zinc

(mg/

l)

pH (s

u)

Cond

uctiv

ity

(um

hos/

cm)

Turb

idity

(NTU

)

Tem

pera

ture

(C)

2.2 0.035 <0.007 6.3 0.46 0.014 6.91 848 14 17.91.8 0.051 <0.01 5.2 0.36 <0.03 6.81 811 0 17.11.8 <0.02 <0.01 5.8 0.39 <0.03 6.94 816 0 16.82.3 0.038 <0.01 6.4 0.38 <0.03 6.93 707 1.53 18.32.6 <0.02 <0.01 6.8 0.37 <0.03 6.78 859 0 14.21.7 0.022 <0.01 5.6 0.35 <0.03 6.86 820 2.12 17.51.3 <0.02 <0.01 6.4 0.37 <0.03 6.94 793 1.97 18.71.8 <0.02 <0.01 18 0.46 <0.03 6.88 740 2.22 20.81.3 0.037 <0.01 5 0.32 <0.03 6.88 674 1.43 20.8

0.57 <0.02 <0.01 5.2 0.38 <0.03 6.92 681 0 14.11.4 0.003 <0.001 4.6 0.29 <0.01 6.9 n/a 11 n/a1.2 0.0052 0.00044(J) 4.2 0.27 0.0033(J) 7 564 16.4 16.40.8 0.0034 <0.001 4.8 0.29 0.0026 6.8 629 8 n/a1.4 0.004 <0.001 11(B) 0.29 0.0046 6.3 529 8 18.9

0.91 0.035 <0.001 4.7 0.28 0.0033(J) 7 542 1 14.91.2 0.0048 <0.001 4.3 0.33 <0.01 7.1 n/a 8 n/a1.3 0.0023 <0.001 4.1 0.29 0.0033(J) 7 n/a 1.2 n/a1.1 0.0025 <0.002 4.4 0.32 <0.025 6.8 649 1.2 18.051.1 0.0051 <0.002 3.9 0.3 <0.025 n/a 651 3 17.2

5.7(R) 0.012(R) <0.007(R) 5.9(R) 0.56(R) 0.071(R) 6.8(R) 743(R) 46(R) 17.2(R)1.9 0.054 <0.01 14 0.57 <0.03 6.65 751 4 17.11.7 <0.02 <0.01 15 0.68 <0.03 6.86 772 0.06 16.32.5 0.031 <0.01 9.8 0.73 <0.03 6.87 633 4.81 18.92.7 0.036 <0.01 7.6 0.63 <0.03 6.68 770 1.28 14.81.7 0.049 <0.01 11 0.45 <0.03 6.7 755 4.88 18.11.2 <0.02 <0.01 15 0.5 <0.03 6.91 714 4.91 18.7

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 84: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-2 8/12/2009(cont.) 5/5/2010

11/4/20106/1/2011

12/14/20115/14/20123/13/20139/11/20135/19/201411/4/20144/30/2015

MW-3R d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/21/20083/25/20095/20/20098/13/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

6/1/201112/13/2011

5/14/201210/9/20123/14/20139/11/2013

Pota

ssiu

m (m

g/l)

Sele

nium

(mg/

l)

Silv

er (m

g/l)

Sodi

um (m

g/l)

Stro

ntiu

m (m

g/l)

Zinc

(mg/

l)

pH (s

u)

Cond

uctiv

ity

(um

hos/

cm)

Turb

idity

(NTU

)

Tem

pera

ture

(C)

2.3 <0.02 <0.01 10 0.46 0.23 6.77 671 2.99 21.91.4 0.031 <0.01 8.6 0.34 <0.03 6.82 608 4.72 20.11.2 <0.02 <0.01 5.7 0.35 <0.03 6.75 702 3.14 14.31.5 0.0015 <0.001 8.3 0.35 0.0034 6.8 n/a 11 n/a1.6 0.0042 <0.001 7.3 0.34 0.0027(J) 6.7 636 0 16.71.2 0.003 <0.001 7.1 0.37 <0.01 6.5 715 7 n/a1.3 0.031 <0.001 7.1 0.35 <0.01 6.6 631 0 15.41.5 0.0036 <0.001 6.8 0.39 <0.01 6.8 n/a 0 n/a1.5 0.0066 <0.001 7 0.42 0.0046(J) 6.6 n/a 0.6 n/a1.6 0.0014(J) <0.002 6.5 0.37 <0.025 6.5 687 3.4 18.421.4 0.0084 <0.002 6.2 0.38 <0.025 n/a 763 4 18.3

3.5(R) <0.002(R) <0.007(R) 6.4(R) 0.4(R) 0.028(R) 7.01(R) 721(R) 37(R) 17.7(R)2.5 0.029 <0.01 5.8 0.33 <0.03 6.89 712 3.81 17.32.6 <0.02 <0.01 8.1 0.37 <0.03 7 712 4.83 17.92.4 <0.02 <0.01 13 0.39 0.04 6.87 602 4.6 23.41.5 <0.02 <0.01 9.6 0.37 <0.03 6.72 772 0 14.8

0.68 0.039 <0.01 6.4 0.41 <0.03 6.73 744 3.27 17.6<0.5 <0.02 <0.01 6.1 0.3 <0.03 6.78 575 4.38 20.80.69 <0.02 <0.01 5.5 0.33 <0.03 6.72 610 4.28 19.10.54 0.034 <0.01 4.9 0.32 <0.03 6.66 609 4.93 21.41.4 <0.02 <0.01 8.5 0.45 <0.03 6.72 728 2.47 13.5

0.54 0.00054 <0.001 5.3 0.37 <0.01 6.9 n/a 10 n/a0.82 0.00099(J) 0.0015 5.1 0.37 0.0028(J) 6.64 662 0 17.50.5 <0.001 <0.001 5.7 0.46 <0.01 6.4 869 9 n/a

0.96 <0.001 <0.001 22(B) 0.44 0.0054 5.9 671 1 19.30.56 0.03 <0.001 8.7 0.43 0.0038(J) 6.5 764 0 14

1 0.0071 <0.001 6.3 0.52 <0.01 6.7 n/a 1 n/aNotes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 85: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-3R 5/19/2014(cont.) 11/4/2014

4/29/2015MW-4R d

11/19/20073/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/13/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

6/7/201112/14/2011

MW-4R2 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/13/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

6/7/2011

Pota

ssiu

m (m

g/l)

Sele

nium

(mg/

l)

Silv

er (m

g/l)

Sodi

um (m

g/l)

Stro

ntiu

m (m

g/l)

Zinc

(mg/

l)

pH (s

u)

Cond

uctiv

ity

(um

hos/

cm)

Turb

idity

(NTU

)

Tem

pera

ture

(C)

1 0.004 <0.001 6.3 0.5 <0.01 6.5 n/a 0 n/a0.71(J) 0.0022 <0.002 5.8 0.51 <0.025 6.5 856 1.6 19.58<1(J) 0.0069 <0.002 6.1 0.51 <0.025 n/a 975 1 20.8

2.7 0.0084 <0.007 7.1 0.47 0.013 7.39 741 5.4 17.72.5 0.027 <0.01 6.4 0.35 <0.03 7.3 728 3.83 17.92.5 <0.02 <0.01 7.6 0.37 <0.03 7.41 712 0 17.82.8 <0.02 <0.01 7.6 0.41 <0.03 7.37 644 4.88 23.9

3.2(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 7.9(R) 0.4(R) <0.03(R) 7.17(R) 833(R) 4.87(R) 13.9(R)2.3(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 7.3(R) 0.38(R) <0.03(R) 7.25(R) 748(R) 4.65(R) 18.7(R)2.3(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 8.4(R) 0.37(R) <0.03(R) 7.36(R) 735(R) 3.99(R) 20.5(R)2.4(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 8(R) 0.42(R) 0.095(R) 7.19(R) 774(R) 0.51(R) 18.4(R)2.5(R) 0.035(R) <0.01(R) 8.8(R) 0.47(R) <0.03(R) 7.08(R) 888(R) 3.96(R) 21.2(R)

0.59(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 6.4(R) 0.43(R) <0.03(R) 7.11(R) 953(R) 4.42(R) 14.7(R)2.4(R) 0.001(R) <0.001(R) 8.5(R) 0.41(R) 0.0075(R) 6.9(R) n/a 15(R) n/a2.8(R) 0.0068(R) <0.001(R) 11(R) 0.51(R) 0.0031(JR) 7(R) 961(R) 0(R) 16.9(R)

2.7 0.0084 <0.007 7.1 0.47 0.013 7.39 741 5.4 17.72.5 0.027 <0.01 6.4 0.35 <0.03 7.3 728 3.83 17.92.5 <0.02 <0.01 7.6 0.37 <0.03 7.41 712 0 17.82.8 <0.02 <0.01 7.6 0.41 <0.03 7.37 644 4.88 23.9

3.2(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 7.9(R) 0.4(R) <0.03(R) 7.17(R) 833(R) 4.87(R) 13.9(R)2.3(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 7.3(R) 0.38(R) <0.03(R) 7.25(R) 748(R) 4.65(R) 18.7(R)2.3(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 8.4(R) 0.37(R) <0.03(R) 7.36(R) 735(R) 3.99(R) 20.5(R)2.4(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 8(R) 0.42(R) 0.095(R) 7.19(R) 774(R) 0.51(R) 18.4(R)2.5(R) 0.035(R) <0.01(R) 8.8(R) 0.47(R) <0.03(R) 7.08(R) 888(R) 3.96(R) 21.2(R)

0.59(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 6.4(R) 0.43(R) <0.03(R) 7.11(R) 953(R) 4.42(R) 14.7(R)2.4(R) 0.001(R) <0.001(R) 8.5(R) 0.41(R) 0.0075(R) 6.9(R) n/a 15(R) n/a

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 86: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-4R2 12/14/2011(cont.) 5/15/2012

10/10/20123/13/20139/11/20135/20/201411/6/20144/29/2015

MW-5 d11/20/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

MW-6 d11/20/2007

3/11/20085/14/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

Pota

ssiu

m (m

g/l)

Sele

nium

(mg/

l)

Silv

er (m

g/l)

Sodi

um (m

g/l)

Stro

ntiu

m (m

g/l)

Zinc

(mg/

l)

pH (s

u)

Cond

uctiv

ity

(um

hos/

cm)

Turb

idity

(NTU

)

Tem

pera

ture

(C)

2.8(R) 0.0068(R) <0.001(R) 11(R) 0.51(R) 0.0031(JR) 7(R) 961(R) 0(R) 16.9(R)2.6 <0.01 <0.01 6.1 0.2 <0.1 6.7 668 7 n/a3.3 <0.001 <0.001 7(B) 0.19 0.0037 6.5 531 9 16.92.1 0.0052 <0.001 13 0.2 <0.01 6.8 616 9 17.11.7 0.0028 <0.001 8.2 0.24 <0.01 7.2 n/a 0 n/a1.8 0.0038 <0.001 12 0.26 0.0036(J) 6.9 n/a 5.4 n/a1.8 0.00062(J) <0.002 6.6 0.22 <0.025 7 521 5.3 15.731.8 0.002 <0.002 8.3 0.21 <0.025 n/a 643 10 18.6

1.2 0.002 <0.007 3.5 0.2 0.019 6.93 504 12 17.41.3 0.028 <0.01 2.8 0.19 <0.03 7.03 541 3.68 16.61.8 <0.02 <0.01 4.4 0.22 <0.03 7.13 561 2.14 17.51.6 <0.02 <0.01 4.6 0.2 <0.03 6.93 398 4.97 24.81.7 <0.02 <0.01 4.3 0.18 <0.03 6.83 531 4.25 14.21.2 <0.02 0.013 4 0.19 <0.03 7.08 552 5 181 <0.02 <0.01 4.9 0.2 <0.03 7.15 534 4.58 23.61 <0.02 <0.01 4.4 0.2 <0.03 6.89 515 3.82 19.91 0.026 <0.01 4 0.16 <0.03 6.81 460 4.65 20

2.5 <0.02 <0.01 11 0.53 <0.03 6.7 472 4 14.6

1.7(R) 0.0025(R) <0.007(R) 3.3(R) 0.12(R) 0.042(R) 6.26(R) 209(R) 27(R) 17.8(R)0.55 0.025 <0.01 3 0.097 <0.03 6.24 221 3.87 16.30.71 <0.02 <0.01 4 0.13 <0.03 6.1 254 0 18

1 <0.02 <0.01 4 0.1 <0.03 6.42 179 3.83 22.81.3 <0.02 <0.01 3.9 0.086 <0.03 6.26 213 3.26 15.4

0.52 <0.02 <0.01 3.3 0.097 <0.03 6.39 202 3.96 18.3<0.5 <0.02 <0.01 4.2 0.11 <0.03 6.38 242 0.81 19.20.68 <0.02 <0.01 3.9 0.11 <0.03 6.21 219 1.2 21.7

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 87: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-6 5/5/2010(cont.) 11/5/2010

6/6/201112/13/2011

5/14/201210/9/20123/13/20139/10/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

MW-7 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/4/2010

MW-8 d3/11/20085/14/20089/24/2008

11/21/20083/25/2009

Pota

ssiu

m (m

g/l)

Sele

nium

(mg/

l)

Silv

er (m

g/l)

Sodi

um (m

g/l)

Stro

ntiu

m (m

g/l)

Zinc

(mg/

l)

pH (s

u)

Cond

uctiv

ity

(um

hos/

cm)

Turb

idity

(NTU

)

Tem

pera

ture

(C)

0.53 <0.02 <0.01 3.8 0.093 <0.03 6.3 198 2.8 20.90.76 <0.02 <0.01 4.7 0.16 <0.03 6.3 163 3.03 15.70.54 <0.001 <0.001 3 0.078 0.0078 6 n/a 7 n/a0.68 <0.001 <0.001 2.8 0.063 0.0043(J) 6.2 160 11 18.60.35 <0.001 <0.001 3.2 0.062 <0.01 6 155 6 n/a0.61 0.00044 <0.001 8.3(B) 0.056 0.003 5.3 133 9 19.7

0.46(J) 0.0043 <0.001 3.1 0.06 0.0041(J) 6.3 157 5 13.10.65 0.0042 <0.001 3.4 0.073 <0.01 6.2 n/a 4 n/a0.56 0.0046 <0.001 3.2 0.072 0.0032(J) 6.2 n/a 1.4 n/a

0.46(J) 0.002 <0.002 3.2 0.076 <0.025 6.1 155 2.1 17.63<1(J) 0.0024 <0.002 3.2 0.083 <0.025 n/a 225 1 17.2

1.6 0.0096 <0.007 5.9 0.43 0.015 7.06 795 5.1 17.61.5 0.03 <0.01 4.9 0.31 <0.03 6.93 713 2.64 16.41.5 <0.02 <0.01 6.2 0.34 <0.03 7.05 706 0 16.91.9 <0.02 <0.01 6.7 0.38 <0.03 7.04 640 3.3 23.42.3 <0.02 <0.01 7 0.37 <0.03 6.91 835 0 14.71.4 <0.02 <0.01 5.6 0.35 <0.03 6.97 793 3.69 18.91.3 <0.02 <0.01 6.1 0.28 0.062 7.09 656 4 191.4 <0.02 <0.01 6.3 0.36 <0.03 6.9 729 3.36 221.2 0.033 0.061 6 0.32 <0.03 6.92 721 2.17 20.8

<0.5 <0.02 <0.01 3.3 0.072 <0.03 6.93 893 4.84 14.7

5.6(R) 0.05(R) <0.01(R) 6.8(R) 0.64(R) 0.12(R) 6.96(R) 811(R) 239(R) 17.3(R)6.6(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 6.9(R) 0.63(R) 0.072(R) 6.8(R) 741(R) 476(R) 18.2(R)6.8(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 9.4(R) 0.78(R) 0.1(R) 7.01(R) 722(R) 1000(R) 23.1(R)140(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 15(R) 3.2(R) 3.9(R) 6.91(R) 971(R) 1000(R) 13.2(R)4.3(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 6.7(R) 0.61(R) 0.042(R) 6.92(R) 858(R) 13.89(R) 17.2(R)

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 88: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-8 5/20/2009(cont.) 8/12/2009

5/6/201011/5/2010

6/1/201112/13/2011

5/14/20123/12/20139/10/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

MW-10R d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/25/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/21/20098/12/2009

5/6/201011/4/2010

6/7/201112/13/2011

5/15/201210/9/20123/13/2013

Pota

ssiu

m (m

g/l)

Sele

nium

(mg/

l)

Silv

er (m

g/l)

Sodi

um (m

g/l)

Stro

ntiu

m (m

g/l)

Zinc

(mg/

l)

pH (s

u)

Cond

uctiv

ity

(um

hos/

cm)

Turb

idity

(NTU

)

Tem

pera

ture

(C)

4.2(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 6.1(R) 0.54(R) <0.03(R) 6.91(R) 852(R) 48.11(R) 23.8(R)5.4(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 6.5(R) 0.72(R) 0.048(R) 6.68(R) 864(R) 279(R) 28.3(R)3.3(R) 0.038(R) <0.01(R) 5(R) 0.56(R) <0.03(R) 6.82(R) 912(R) 44.99(R) 24.7(R)1.1(R) <0.02(R) <0.01(R) 7.7(R) 0.46(R) <0.03(R) 6.84(R) 943(R) 34.4(R) 15.43.8(R) <0.001(R) 0.01(R) 5.5(R) 0.61(R) 0.013(R) 7(R) n/a 30(R) n/a

3.5 0.00058(J) <0.001 6.8 0.55 0.0059(J) 6.9 817 5 17.63.6 0.0011 <0.001 7.5 0.72 0.007 6.5 1036 8 n/a3.8 0.0037 <0.001 7.9 0.65 0.0054(J) 7 900 2 17.73.7 0.004 <0.001 7 0.64 0.0048(J) 6.8 n/a 0 n/a3.8 0.0043 <0.001 8 0.74 0.0037(J) 6.8 n/a 0.8 n/a3.5 0.00054(J) <0.002 6.5 0.63 0.0027(J) 6.7 815 2.2 17.613.6 <0.002(J) <0.002 5.5 0.56 <0.025 n/a 1024 2 19.7

2.6 0.0025 <0.007 6.6 0.26 0.012 7.24 499 8.2 17.32.4 <0.02 <0.01 4.9 0.24 <0.03 7.08 534 4.01 17.62.6 <0.02 <0.01 5.8 0.24 <0.03 7.18 512 2.6 18.12.7 <0.02 <0.01 6.4 0.23 0.039 7.26 409 4.31 18.43.1 <0.02 <0.01 6.5 0.22 <0.03 7.15 502 2.24 13.72.4 <0.02 <0.01 5.3 0.27 <0.03 7.05 573 4.6 20.62.1 <0.02 <0.01 6.1 0.27 <0.03 7.07 612 4.23 19.12.2 <0.02 <0.01 6.3 0.26 <0.03 7 512 3.8 22.42.1 <0.02 <0.01 6.2 0.22 <0.03 7.05 480 0.99 22.4

<0.5 <0.02 <0.01 <0.5 <0.01 <0.03 7.12 484(R) 1.62 14.92.2(R) <0.001(R) <0.001(R) 5.7(R) 0.2(R) 0.016(R) 7(R) n/a 70(R) n/a2.4(R) <0.001(R) <0.001(R) 5.6(R) 0.21(R) 0.0065(JR) 7(R) 486(R) 30(R) 18.4

2 <0.001 <0.001 6.9 0.24 <0.01 6.8 535 5 n/a2.2 <0.001 <0.001 7(B) 0.24 0.0026 6.4 445 9 182.4 <0.001 <0.001 4.8 0.2 <0.01 7 470 4 15.2

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 89: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-10R 9/10/2013(cont.) 5/20/2014

11/6/20144/30/2015

MW-11R d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/14/20089/25/2008

11/21/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/4/2010

MW-13 d3/12/20085/14/20089/25/2008

11/21/20083/25/2009

MW-13R d5/20/20098/12/2009

5/6/201011/4/2010

6/6/201112/13/2011

Pota

ssiu

m (m

g/l)

Sele

nium

(mg/

l)

Silv

er (m

g/l)

Sodi

um (m

g/l)

Stro

ntiu

m (m

g/l)

Zinc

(mg/

l)

pH (s

u)

Cond

uctiv

ity

(um

hos/

cm)

Turb

idity

(NTU

)

Tem

pera

ture

(C)

2.3 <0.001 <0.001 5.6 0.23 <0.01 7.1 n/a 0 n/a2.5 <0.001 <0.001 5.7 0.22 <0.01 6.9 n/a 4.2 n/a2.5 0.00073(J) <0.002 6.3 0.28 0.0028(J) 6.7 481 6.3 16.812.6 <0.002 <0.002 4.5 0.2 <0.025 n/a 521 2 17.1

<1 0.003 <0.007 2.6 0.22 0.013 6.69 425 6.7 18.10.96 0.024 <0.01 2.1 0.2 <0.03 6.57 453 4.34 171.2 <0.02 <0.01 3.1 0.25 <0.03 6.7 484 0 18.11.4 <0.02 <0.01 3.3 0.2 <0.03 6.74 372 4 21.81.8 <0.02 <0.01 3.7 0.19 <0.03 6.6 488 2.99 141.1 <0.02 <0.01 3.1 0.21 <0.03 6.63 473 3.35 18.6

<0.5 <0.02 <0.01 4 0.21 <0.03 6.81 483 2.28 20.91.1 <0.02 <0.01 3.5 0.22 <0.03 6.53 449 3.93 21.10.7 <0.02 <0.01 2.9 0.15 <0.03 6.72 360 1.28 20.6

0.88 <0.02 <0.01 2.8 0.16 <0.03 6.65 376 2.14 16.2

6.7 0.043 <0.01 7.8 0.82 <0.03 6.91 1019 1000 15.219 <0.02 <0.01 9.3 1 0.26 6.7 954 802 17.36.8 <0.02 <0.01 9.2 0.9 <0.03 6.94 839 71 258.8 <0.02 <0.01 9.5 0.91 0.03 6.83 1071 82 15.38.2 <0.02 <0.01 8.7 0.93 0.042 6.81 1017 51 15.9

1 <0.02 <0.01 4.3 0.21 <0.03 7.18 522 4.23 23.33.4 <0.02 <0.01 5.6 0.25 <0.03 6.87 613 3.65 21.92 <0.02 0.025 4 0.22 <0.03 6.96 581 4.4 21.1

2.2 <0.02 <0.01 6.3 0.25 <0.03 6.85 621 1.83 17.22 0.0046 <0.001 4.5 0.24 0.0092 6.6 n/a 9 n/a

1.8 0.0024 <0.001 4.1 0.24 0.0037(J) 6.8 595 9 17.4Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 90: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-13R 5/14/2012(cont.) 10/9/2012

3/12/20139/10/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

MW-15 u11/19/2007

3/11/20085/14/20089/25/2008

11/21/20083/25/20095/21/20098/12/2009

5/6/201011/4/2010

LEACHATE d6/7/2011

12/14/20115/15/2012

10/10/20123/14/20139/11/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

Pota

ssiu

m (m

g/l)

Sele

nium

(mg/

l)

Silv

er (m

g/l)

Sodi

um (m

g/l)

Stro

ntiu

m (m

g/l)

Zinc

(mg/

l)

pH (s

u)

Cond

uctiv

ity

(um

hos/

cm)

Turb

idity

(NTU

)

Tem

pera

ture

(C)

1.8 0.0045 <0.001 4.3 0.25 <0.01 6.5 629 8 n/a1.3 0.0036 <0.001 4(B) 0.21 0.004 6.4 450 8 18.61.8 <0.001 <0.001 3.8 0.24 0.0035(J) 7.2 560 1 15.21.6 0.0027 <0.001 3.8 0.22 <0.01 6.8 n/a 0 n/a1.6 0.001 <0.001 6.2 0.25 0.0029(J) 6.9 n/a 1.2 n/a1.5 0.0039 <0.002 3.9 0.22 <0.025 6.8 447 0.4 171.8 <0.002(J) <0.002 3.5 0.22 <0.025 n/a 597 1 17.4

<1 0.0023 <0.007 3.8 0.36 0.016 6.95 711 0.92 16.90.74 0.028 <0.1 3 0.27 <0.03 6.8 673 0.51 16.70.8 <0.02 <0.01 5.5 0.27 <0.03 6.7 652 0 18.31.2 <0.02 <0.01 4.8 0.32 <0.03 7.03 598 0.84 211.1 <0.02 <0.01 5.3 0.34 <0.03 6.92 381 2.5 14.6

0.55 <0.02 <0.01 3.6 0.29 <0.03 6.92 698 2.28 17.20.5 <0.02 <0.01 4.5 0.28 <0.03 6.95 703 1.73 18.3

0.69 <0.02 <0.01 5.6 0.31 <0.03 6.83 717 0.67 19.7<0.5 0.025 <0.01 5.9 0.32 <0.03 6.85 733 0.52 21.31.2 <0.02 <0.01 7.8 0.48 <0.03 6.94 846 0 16.7

12 0.0036 <0.001 70 0.4 <0.01 n/a n/a n/a n/a96 0.056 <0.001 710 0.43 0.0039(J) 12.31 5540 7 12.7

140 0.11 <0.001 1000 0.89 0.0075 9.4 674 90 n/a200 0.13 0.00042 960(B) 0.91 0.019 11.42 5980 20 18.6120 0.13 <0.001 640 0.47 <0.01 n/a n/a n/a n/a110 0.097 <0.001 720 0.46 0.0065(J) 11.4 n/a 2 n/a100 0.051 <0.001 650 0.67 0.027 11.6 n/a n/a n/a160 0.089 <0.002 990 0.7 0.019(J) 11.9 4443 7.3 20.9180 0.21 <0.002 1200 0.55 <0.025(J) n/a n/a n/a n/a

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 91: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

MW-1 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/4/2010

6/7/201112/13/2011

5/14/201210/9/20123/13/20139/11/20135/19/201411/4/20144/29/2015

MW-2 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/2009

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

TOC

[Tot

al

Org

anic

Car

bon]

(m

g/l)

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a0.841.5

0.860.98n/an/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/a

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 92: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-2 8/12/2009(cont.) 5/5/2010

11/4/20106/1/2011

12/14/20115/14/20123/13/20139/11/20135/19/201411/4/20144/30/2015

MW-3R d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/21/20083/25/20095/20/20098/13/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

6/1/201112/13/2011

5/14/201210/9/20123/14/20139/11/2013

TOC

[Tot

al

Org

anic

Car

bon]

(m

g/l)

n/an/an/a9.21.11.1n/an/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a161.72.21.1n/an/a

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 93: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-3R 5/19/2014(cont.) 11/4/2014

4/29/2015MW-4R d

11/19/20073/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/13/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

6/7/201112/14/2011

MW-4R2 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/13/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

6/7/2011

TOC

[Tot

al

Org

anic

Car

bon]

(m

g/l)

n/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a

1.1(R)1.2(R)

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a

1.1(R)Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 94: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-4R2 12/14/2011(cont.) 5/15/2012

10/10/20123/13/20139/11/20135/20/201411/6/20144/29/2015

MW-5 d11/20/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/5/2010

MW-6 d11/20/2007

3/11/20085/14/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

TOC

[Tot

al

Org

anic

Car

bon]

(m

g/l)

1.2(R)3

1.6n/an/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 95: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-6 5/5/2010(cont.) 11/5/2010

6/6/201112/13/2011

5/14/201210/9/20123/13/20139/10/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

MW-7 d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/24/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/4/2010

MW-8 d3/11/20085/14/20089/24/2008

11/21/20083/25/2009

TOC

[Tot

al

Org

anic

Car

bon]

(m

g/l)

n/an/a1.81.21

1.1n/an/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/a

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 96: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-8 5/20/2009(cont.) 8/12/2009

5/6/201011/5/2010

6/1/201112/13/2011

5/14/20123/12/20139/10/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

MW-10R d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/13/20089/25/2008

11/20/20083/24/20095/21/20098/12/2009

5/6/201011/4/2010

6/7/201112/13/2011

5/15/201210/9/20123/13/2013

TOC

[Tot

al

Org

anic

Car

bon]

(m

g/l)

n/an/an/an/a

23(R)1.51.1n/an/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a

1.6(R)1.4(R)0.990.96n/a

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 97: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-10R 9/10/2013(cont.) 5/20/2014

11/6/20144/30/2015

MW-11R d11/19/2007

3/11/20085/14/20089/25/2008

11/21/20083/24/20095/20/20098/12/2009

5/5/201011/4/2010

MW-13 d3/12/20085/14/20089/25/2008

11/21/20083/25/2009

MW-13R d5/20/20098/12/2009

5/6/201011/4/2010

6/6/201112/13/2011

TOC

[Tot

al

Org

anic

Car

bon]

(m

g/l)

n/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/a1.41.4

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 98: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Plum Point Energy Station Historical Database Permit No. 0303-S3N

MW-13R 5/14/2012(cont.) 10/9/2012

3/12/20139/10/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

MW-15 u11/19/2007

3/11/20085/14/20089/25/2008

11/21/20083/25/20095/21/20098/12/2009

5/6/201011/4/2010

LEACHATE d6/7/2011

12/14/20115/15/2012

10/10/20123/14/20139/11/20135/20/201411/6/20144/30/2015

TOC

[Tot

al

Org

anic

Car

bon]

(m

g/l)

2.91

n/an/an/an/an/a

n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a

3.3174075n/an/an/an/an/a

Notes:R-flagged data are rejected and not used in statistical analysis.J-flagged data indicate detections below the laboratory PQL.B-flagged data indicate that parameter was detected above the PQL in one or more quality control samples.

Page 99: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

APPENDIX D Distributional Plots

Page 100: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Time Series Plots

Page 101: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

120

240

360

480

600

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Alkalinity Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

0

0.006

0.012

0.018

0.024

0.03

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Arsenic Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Page 102: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.08

0.16

0.24

0.32

0.4

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Barium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

0

40

80

120

160

200

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Calcium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Page 103: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

6

12

18

24

30

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Chloride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

0

140

280

420

560

700

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Dissolved Solids Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Page 104: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Fluoride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

0

4

8

12

16

20

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Iron Analysis Run 7/2/2015 7:15 AM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Page 105: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

8

16

24

32

40

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Magnesium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

0

0.8

1.6

2.4

3.2

4

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Manganese Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Page 106: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.004

0.008

0.012

0.016

0.02

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Nickel Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

0

0.8

1.6

2.4

3.2

4

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Potassium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Page 107: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.012

0.024

0.036

0.048

0.06

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Selenium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

0

6

12

18

24

30

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Sodium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Page 108: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.16

0.32

0.48

0.64

0.8

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Strontium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

0

20

40

60

80

100

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-1

MW-2

MW-3R

MW-4R2

MW-6

MW-8

MW-10R

MW-13R

Time Series

Constituent: Sulfate Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:05 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Page 109: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Box and Whiskers Plots

Page 110: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

120

240

360

480

600

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Alkalinity Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17

______+

MW-3R

n=18

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______+

MW-6

n=18

______+

MW-8

n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17

______+

MW-13R

n=13

______+

0

0.006

0.012

0.018

0.024

0.03

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Arsenic Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19 21%nds

______+

MW-2

n=17 17%nds

______+

MW-3R

n=18 44%nds

______+

MW-4R2

n=11 27%nds

______+

MW-6

n=18 33%nds

______+

MW-8

n=7 14%nds

______+

MW-10R

n=17 5%nds

______+

MW-13R

n=13 30%nds

______+

Page 111: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.08

0.16

0.24

0.32

0.4

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Barium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17

______+

MW-3R

n=18

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______+

MW-6

n=18

______+

MW-8

n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17 5%nds

______+

MW-13R

n=13

______+

0

40

80

120

160

200

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Calcium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17

______+

MW-3R

n=18

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______+

MW-6

n=18

______+

MW-8

n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17 5%nds

______+

MW-13R

n=13

______+

Page 112: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

6

12

18

24

30

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Chloride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17

______+

MW-3R

n=18

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______+

MW-6

n=18 5%nds

______+

MW-8

n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17

______+

MW-13R

n=13

______

+

0

140

280

420

560

700

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Dissolved Solids Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17

______+

MW-3R

n=18

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______+

MW-6

n=18

______+

MW-8

n=7

______

+

MW-10R

n=17

______+

MW-13R

n=13

______+

Page 113: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Fluoride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17 11%nds

______+

MW-3R

n=18 5%nds

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______+

MW-6

n=18 11%nds

______+

MW-8

n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17

______+

MW-13R

n=13 23%nds

______+

0

4

8

12

16

20

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Iron Analysis Run 7/2/2015 7:17 AM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19 15%nds

______+

MW-2

n=17 41%nds

______+MW

-3R

n=18 38%nds

______+

MW-4R2

n=11 27%nds

______+

MW-6

n=18 44%nds

______+MW

-8n=7 42%

nds

______+MW

-10R

n=17 5%nds

______+

MW-13R

n=13 46%nds

______+

Page 114: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

8

16

24

32

40

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Magnesium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17

______+

MW-3R

n=18

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______+

MW-6

n=18

______+

MW-8

n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17 5%nds

______+

MW-13R

n=13

______+

0

0.8

1.6

2.4

3.2

4

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Manganese Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17 23%nds

______+MW

-3R

n=18

______

+

MW-4R2

n=11

______

+

MW-6

n=18 55%nds

______+MW

-8n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17 5%nds

______+

MW-13R

n=13 15%nds

______+

Page 115: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.004

0.008

0.012

0.016

0.02

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Nickel Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19 52%nds

______

+

MW-2

n=17 58%nds

______

+

MW-3R

n=18 50%nds

______

+

MW-4R2

n=11 54%nds

______+

MW-6

n=18 50%nds

______+

MW-8

n=7 14%nds

______

+

MW-10R

n=17 64%nds

______

+

MW-13R

n=13 38%nds

______+

0

0.8

1.6

2.4

3.2

4

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Potassium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17

______+

MW-3R

n=18 11%nds

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______

+

MW-6

n=18 11%nds

______+

MW-8

n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17 5%nds

______+

MW-13R

n=13

______+

Page 116: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.012

0.024

0.036

0.048

0.06

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Selenium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19 26%nds

______

+

MW-2

n=17 23%nds

______

+

MW-3R

n=18 44%nds

______+

MW-4R2

n=11 36%nds

______+

MW-6

n=18 61%nds

______+

MW-8

n=7 14%nds

______+

MW-10R

n=17 88%nds

______

+

MW-13R

n=13 46%nds

______+

0

6

12

18

24

30

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Sodium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17

______+

MW-3R

n=18

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______+

MW-6

n=18

______+

MW-8

n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17 5%nds

______+

MW-13R

n=13

______+

Page 117: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.16

0.32

0.48

0.64

0.8

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Strontium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17

______

+

MW-3R

n=18

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______+

MW-6

n=18

______+

MW-8

n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17 5%nds

______+

MW-13R

n=13

______+

0

20

40

60

80

100

Box & Whiskers Plot

Constituent: Sulfate Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

MW-1

n=19

______+

MW-2

n=17

______

+

MW-3R

n=18

______+

MW-4R2

n=11

______+

MW-6

n=18

______+

MW-8

n=7

______+

MW-10R

n=17

______+

MW-13R

n=13

______+

Page 118: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Outliers

Page 119: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.4

0.8

1.2

1.6

2

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

Dixon's Outlier TestMW-10R

Constituent: Manganese Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:08 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 17

Statistical outliers aredrawn as solid.Testing for 3 low outliers.Mean = 1.094.Std. Dev. = 0.453.0.47: c = 0.5699tabl = 0.49.Alpha = 0.05.

Normality test used:Shapiro Wilk@alpha = 0.1Calculated = 0.9099Critical = 0.895 The distribution, afterremoval of outliers, wasfound to be normally dis-tributed.

Page 120: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

APPENDIX F Statistical Evaluation Results

Page 121: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

E-1

BACKGROUND DATA

Outliers and Rejected Data in Background The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Unified Guidance (the Guidance)

recommends that background be screened for potential outliers. However, it also advises that

outliers not be removed unless a source of error or reason for the discrepancy can be identified.

As advised in the Guidance, select removal of extreme outliers without knowledge of error may

be warranted to improve environmental protection, but removal of all outliers can mask real and

legitimate changes in background. Currently, there are no outliers excluded from background.

Data that are marked in the database as rejected (R) are identified in Table E1. These data

were excluded because evidence indicates that analytical data may not be representative of

groundwater quality, per Reg.22.1103(a).

Table E1. Data marked as rejected (flagged with an R) in the historical database.

Well ID Date Parameters Reason for Exclusion MW-2 11/19/2007 All data Recorded turbidity was 46 NTUs

MW-3R 11/19/2007 All data Recorded turbidity was 37 NTUs

MW-4R 11/20/2008 All data Well was damaged by construction equipment in September 2008. Data collected after damage to the well is suspect.

MW-4R 3/24/2009 All data Well was damaged by construction equipment in September 2008. Data collected after damage to the well is suspect.

MW-4R 5/20/2009 All data Well was damaged by construction equipment in September 2008. Data collected after damage to the well is suspect.

MW-4R 8/13/2009 All data Well was damaged by construction equipment in September 2008. Data collected after damage to the well is suspect.

MW-4R 5/5/2010 All data Well was damaged by construction equipment in September 2008. Data collected after damage to the well is suspect.

MW-4R 11/5/2010 All data Well was damaged by construction equipment in September 2008. Data collected after damage to the well is suspect.

MW-4R 6/7/2011 All data Well was damaged by construction equipment in September 2008. Data collected after damage to the well is suspect.

Page 122: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

E-2

Table E1. Data marked as rejected (flagged with an R) in the historical database (continued).

Well ID Date Parameters Reason for Exclusion

MW-4R 12/14/2011 All data Well was damaged by construction equipment in September 2008. Data collected after damage to the well is suspect.

MW-6 11/20/2007 All data Recorded turbidity was 27 NTUs MW-8 3/11/2008 All data Recorded turbidity was 239 NTUs MW-8 5/14/2008 All data Recorded turbidity was 476 NTUs MW-8 9/24/2008 All data Recorded turbidity was 1,000 NTUs MW-8 11/21/2008 All data Recorded turbidity was 1,000 NTUs MW-8 3/25/2009 All data Recorded turbidity was 13.89 NTUs MW-8 5/20/2009 All data Recorded turbidity was 48.11 NTUs MW-8 8/12/2009 All data Recorded turbidity was 279 NTUs MW-8 5/6/2010 All data Recorded turbidity was 44.99 NTUs MW-8 11/5/2010 All data Recorded turbidity was 34.4 NTUs MW-8 6/1/2011 All data Recorded turbidity was 30 NTUs

MW-10R 6/7/2011 All data Recorded turbidity was 70 NTUs MW-10R 12/13/2011 All data Recorded turbidity was 30 NTUs

Background Data Evaluation and Update EPA guidance recommends updating baseline parameters (background data) to include

more recent observations because some long-term fluctuation in background levels may be

possible even though a given well has not been impacted by the Landfill.

Background populations are updated when at least four compliance data values have been

collected. Prior to updating, existing background and compliance populations for each

well˗˗parameter pair were tested with the intrawell Mann-Whitney (Wilcoxon Rank Sum) test,

which evaluates whether the mean of the existing background population is statistically different

than the mean of the compliance data. When comparing four compliance data values to

background data, the background data are updated if the test finds no significant difference at the

95% confidence level (α = 0.05). For compliance populations of five or more data values, the

background data are updated if the test finds no significant difference at the 99% confidence

level (α = 0.01).

Updated background populations are tested for trends and outliers. Outliers were

screened using Dixon's or Rosner's outlier tests. Although extreme outliers exist in background

for some well-parameter pairs, none are excluded from statistical analysis at this time because of

Page 123: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

E-3

the small number of data currently available for background comparisons. Outliers will be re-

evaluated each time background is updated. The Sen's Slope/Mann Kendall trend analyses was

run on updated background populations to determine the presence of statistically significant

increasing or decreasing trends. The presence of linear trends in background data determines

which type of test to use in detection monitoring.

Background for MW-1, MW-2, MW-3R, MW-6, MW-10R, and MW-13R was updated,

where possible, to include data through May 2014 except where noted below. Background for

monitoring well MW-4R2 includes data through November 2014. As of the first half of 2015

monitoring period, monitoring well MW-8 does not contain the EPA recommended minimum

background size to perform prediction limit testing and data from this well are evaluated using a

formal trend test.

Background for the following well-parameter pairs includes historical data through

December 2011:

• pH and sulfate at MW-2.

• Calcium, magnesium, strontium, sulfate, TDS and pH at MW-3.

Page 124: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

APPENDIX E Background Data Used for Statistics

Page 125: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Prediction Limits

Page 126: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.08

0.16

0.24

0.32

0.4

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-1 background

MW-1 compliance

Limit = 0.3841

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Fluoride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:19 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.2924, Std. Dev.=0.0393, n=17. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9311, critical = 0.851. Kappa = 2.336 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.004

0.008

0.012

0.016

0.02

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-1 background

MW-1 compliance

Limit = 0.011

Prediction LimitIntrawell Non-parametric

Constituent: Nickel Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:19 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Non-parametric test used in lieu of parametric prediction limit because censored data exceeded 50%. Limit is highest of 17 background values. 58.82% NDs. Well-constituent pair annual alpha = 0.005984 (1 of 2). Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence.

Within Limit

Page 127: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

4

8

12

16

20

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-1 background

MW-1 compliance

Limit = 18

Prediction LimitIntrawell Non-parametric

Constituent: Sodium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:19 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Non-parametric test used in lieu of parametric prediction limit because the Shapiro Wilk normality test showed the data to be non-normal at the 0.01 alpha level. Limit is highest of 17 background values. Well-constituent pair annual alpha = 0.005984 (1 of 2). Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence.

Within Limit

0

100

200

300

400

500

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 436.9

Limit = 219.1

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Alkalinity Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:21 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=328, Std. Dev.=45.07, n=15. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8474, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limits

Page 128: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.044

0.088

0.132

0.176

0.22

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 0.2105

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Barium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:21 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.1753, Std. Dev.=0.01457, n=15. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9023, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

28

56

84

112

140

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 131.3

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Calcium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:50 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=107.1, Std. Dev.=9.091, n=15. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9018, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.668 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.05132). Report alpha = 0.0004115.

Within Limit

Page 129: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

2.2

4.4

6.6

8.8

11

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 10.75

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Chloride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:21 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=6.633, Std. Dev.=1.704, n=15. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9846, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

120

240

360

480

600

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 529.1

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Dissolved Solids Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:21 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=442.7, Std. Dev.=35.75, n=15. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9126, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 130: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.06

0.12

0.18

0.24

0.3

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 0.2854

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Fluoride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:21 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.1607, Std. Dev.=0.05161, n=15, 13.33% NDs. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8421, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

5.8

11.6

17.4

23.2

29

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 28.08

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Magnesium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:21 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=24, Std. Dev.=1.69, n=15. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8656, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 131: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.06

0.12

0.18

0.24

0.3

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 0.2758

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Manganese Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:21 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on cube root transformation) (after Kaplan-Meier Adjustment): Mean=0.2824, Std. Dev.=0.1525, n=15, 26.67% NDs. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8637, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.6

1.2

1.8

2.4

3

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 2.829

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Potassium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:21 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=1.68, Std. Dev.=0.4754, n=15. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8625, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 132: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.012

0.024

0.036

0.048

0.06

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 0.05723

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Selenium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:21 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (after Kaplan-Meier Adjustment): Mean=0.01411, Std. Dev.=0.01785, n=15, 26.67% NDs. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8437, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.16

0.32

0.48

0.64

0.8

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 0.7808

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Strontium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:21 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.462, Std. Dev.=0.1319, n=15. Seasonality was not detected with 95% confidence. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8506, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 133: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

20

40

60

80

100

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-2 background

MW-2 compliance

Limit = 45.38

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Sulfate Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:54 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary (based on square root transformation): Mean=4.601, Std. Dev.=0.7165, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8077, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.98 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.05132). Report alpha = 0.0004115.

Exceeds Limit

0

100

200

300

400

500

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 462.2

Limit = 251.5

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Alkalinity Analysis Run 6/13/2015 10:02 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=356.9, Std. Dev.=40.45, n=16. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.962, critical = 0.844. Kappa = 2.604 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.05132). Report alpha = 0.0004115.

Exceeds Limits

Page 134: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.06

0.12

0.18

0.24

0.3

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 0.2992

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Barium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:31 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.1744, Std. Dev.=0.05278, n=16. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.86, critical = 0.844. Kappa = 2.364 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

40

80

120

160

200

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 132

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Calcium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:59 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=104.3, Std. Dev.=9.318, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9038, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.98 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.05132). Report alpha = 0.0004115.

Exceeds Limit

Page 135: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

2.4

4.8

7.2

9.6

12

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 11.96

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Chloride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:31 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=7.238, Std. Dev.=1.997, n=16. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9429, critical = 0.844. Kappa = 2.364 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

120

240

360

480

600

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 502.7

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Dissolved Solids Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:59 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=424.5, Std. Dev.=26.22, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9376, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.98 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.05132). Report alpha = 0.0004115.

Exceeds Limit

Page 136: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 0.3856

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Fluoride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:32 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.2119, Std. Dev.=0.0735, n=16, 6.25% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8521, critical = 0.844. Kappa = 2.364 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

8

16

24

32

40

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 32.8

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Magnesium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:59 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=24.55, Std. Dev.=2.77, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9686, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.98 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.05132). Report alpha = 0.0004115.

Exceeds Limit

Page 137: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.004

0.008

0.012

0.016

0.02

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 0.019

Prediction LimitIntrawell Non-parametric

Constituent: Nickel Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:32 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Non-parametric test used in lieu of parametric prediction limit because censored data exceeded 50%. Limit is highest of 16 background values. 56.25% NDs. Well-constituent pair annual alpha = 0.006536 (1 of 2).

Within Limit

0

0.012

0.024

0.036

0.048

0.06

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 0.05169

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Selenium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:32 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on square root transformation) (after Kaplan-Meier Adjustment): Mean=0.07745, Std. Dev.=0.06342, n=16, 50% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8915, critical = 0.844. Kappa = 2.364 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 138: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

6

12

18

24

30

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 22

Prediction LimitIntrawell Non-parametric

Constituent: Sodium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:32 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Non-parametric test used in lieu of parametric prediction limit because the Shapiro Wilk normality test showed the data to be non-normal at the 0.01 alpha level. Limit is highest of 16 background values. Well-constituent pair annual alpha = 0.006536 (1 of 2).

Within Limit

0

0.12

0.24

0.36

0.48

0.6

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 0.4933

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Strontium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:59 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.3645, Std. Dev.=0.04321, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9491, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.98 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.05132). Report alpha = 0.0004115.

Exceeds Limit

Page 139: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

18

36

54

72

90

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

MW-3R background

MW-3R compliance

Limit = 79.56

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Sulfate Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:59 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=34.45, Std. Dev.=15.14, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9562, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.98 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.05132). Report alpha = 0.0004115.

Exceeds Limit

0

0.008

0.016

0.024

0.032

0.04

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-4R2 background

MW-4R2 compliance

Limit = 0.03386

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Arsenic Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:37 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (after Kaplan-Meier Adjustment): Mean=0.01098, Std. Dev.=0.008268, n=10, 30% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9191, critical = 0.781. Kappa = 2.768 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 140: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

28

56

84

112

140

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-4R2 background

MW-4R2 compliance

Limit = 134.4

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Calcium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:37 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=97.9, Std. Dev.=13.18, n=10. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.855, critical = 0.781. Kappa = 2.768 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

100

200

300

400

500

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-4R2 background

MW-4R2 compliance

Limit = 489

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Dissolved Solids Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:37 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=401, Std. Dev.=31.78, n=10. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8444, critical = 0.781. Kappa = 2.768 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 141: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

1.8

3.6

5.4

7.2

9

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-4R2 background

MW-4R2 compliance

Limit = 8.525

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Iron Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:37 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (after Kaplan-Meier Adjustment): Mean=2.414, Std. Dev.=2.208, n=10, 30% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8696, critical = 0.781. Kappa = 2.768 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

6.6

13.2

19.8

26.4

33

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-4R2 background

MW-4R2 compliance

Limit = 32.23

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Magnesium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:37 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=29.3, Std. Dev.=1.059, n=10. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.846, critical = 0.781. Kappa = 2.768 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 142: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

1

2

3

4

5

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-4R2 background

MW-4R2 compliance

Limit = 4.907

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Manganese Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:37 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=1.913, Std. Dev.=1.082, n=10. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8542, critical = 0.781. Kappa = 2.768 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.8

1.6

2.4

3.2

4

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-4R2 background

MW-4R2 compliance

Limit = 3.814

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Potassium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:37 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=2.38, Std. Dev.=0.5181, n=10. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9328, critical = 0.781. Kappa = 2.768 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 143: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

3.2

6.4

9.6

12.8

16

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-4R2 background

MW-4R2 compliance

Limit = 15.29

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Sodium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:37 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary (based on square root transformation): Mean=2.833, Std. Dev.=0.3894, n=10. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.792, critical = 0.781. Kappa = 2.768 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.12

0.24

0.36

0.48

0.6

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-4R2 background

MW-4R2 compliance

Limit = 0.5698

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Strontium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:37 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.291, Std. Dev.=0.1007, n=10. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8767, critical = 0.781. Kappa = 2.768 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 144: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

4.4

8.8

13.2

17.6

22

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

MW-4R2 background

MW-4R2 compliance

Limit = 21.22

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Sulfate Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:37 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=16, Std. Dev.=1.886, n=10. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8868, critical = 0.781. Kappa = 2.768 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.08

0.16

0.24

0.32

0.4

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-6 background

MW-6 compliance

Limit = 0.2982

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Fluoride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:39 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on square root transformation): Mean=0.3641, Std. Dev.=0.077, n=16, 12.5% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8608, critical = 0.844. Kappa = 2.364 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 145: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

1.8

3.6

5.4

7.2

9

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-6 background

MW-6 compliance

Limit = 8.3

Prediction LimitIntrawell Non-parametric

Constituent: Sodium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:39 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Non-parametric test used in lieu of parametric prediction limit because the Shapiro Wilk normality test showed the data to be non-normal at the 0.01 alpha level. Limit is highest of 16 background values. Well-constituent pair annual alpha = 0.006536 (1 of 2).

Within Limit

0

4

8

12

16

20

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

MW-6 background

MW-6 compliance

Limit = 14.94

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Sulfate Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:39 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=8.325, Std. Dev.=2.8, n=16. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8736, critical = 0.844. Kappa = 2.364 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 146: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

80

160

240

320

400

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 370

Limit = 240

Prediction LimitIntrawell Non-parametric

Constituent: Alkalinity Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Non-parametric test used in lieu of parametric prediction limit because the Shapiro Wilk normality test showed the data to be non-normal at the 0.01 alpha level. Limits are highest and lowest of 15 background values. Well-constituent pair annual alpha = 0.0153 (1 of 2).

Within Limits

0

0.004

0.008

0.012

0.016

0.02

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 0.01419

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Arsenic Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on natural log transformation): Mean=-5.544, Std. Dev.=0.5334, n=15, 6.667% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8686, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 147: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.08

0.16

0.24

0.32

0.4

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 0.3215

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Barium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on square transformation): Mean=0.0512, Std. Dev.=0.0216, n=15, 6.667% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9482, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

18

36

54

72

90

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 86.42

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Calcium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on cube transformation): Mean=335287, Std. Dev.=128355, n=15, 6.667% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9006, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 148: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

2

4

6

8

10

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 9.441

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Chloride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=5.947, Std. Dev.=1.446, n=15. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9719, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

72

144

216

288

360

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 357

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Dissolved Solids Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=304.7, Std. Dev.=21.67, n=15. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9479, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 149: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.08

0.16

0.24

0.32

0.4

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 0.2978

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Fluoride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 10:06 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.1847, Std. Dev.=0.0424, n=15. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9028, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.668 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.05132). Report alpha = 0.0004115.

Exceeds Limit

0

6

12

18

24

30

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 27.83

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Magnesium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on cube transformation): Mean=11062, Std. Dev.=4346, n=15, 6.667% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9114, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 150: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.4

0.8

1.2

1.6

2

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 1.682

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Manganese Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on square transformation): Mean=1.356, Std. Dev.=0.6099, n=15, 6.667% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.89, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.8

1.6

2.4

3.2

4

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 3.228

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Potassium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on square transformation): Mean=5.454, Std. Dev.=2.055, n=15, 6.667% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9075, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 151: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

1.6

3.2

4.8

6.4

8

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 7.979

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Sodium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on square transformation): Mean=34.09, Std. Dev.=12.24, n=15, 6.667% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8821, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.06

0.12

0.18

0.24

0.3

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 0.2922

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Strontium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Background Data Summary (based on cube transformation): Mean=0.01294, Std. Dev.=0.00497, n=15, 6.667% NDs. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9034, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 152: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

4

8

12

16

20

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/7/12 11/2/13 4/30/15

MW-10R background

MW-10R compliance

Limit = 19.63

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Sulfate Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:40 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=14, Std. Dev.=2.33, n=15. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9144, critical = 0.835. Kappa = 2.417 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.046

0.092

0.138

0.184

0.23

5/20/09 7/28/10 10/5/11 12/12/12 2/19/14 4/30/15

MW-13R background

MW-13R compliance

Limit = 0.2267

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Barium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:42 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.1773, Std. Dev.=0.01849, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8715, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.671 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 153: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

22

44

66

88

110

5/20/09 7/28/10 10/5/11 12/12/12 2/19/14 4/30/15

MW-13R background

MW-13R compliance

Limit = 102.8

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Calcium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:42 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=82.27, Std. Dev.=7.669, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9013, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.671 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

80

160

240

320

400

5/20/09 7/28/10 10/5/11 12/12/12 2/19/14 4/30/15

MW-13R background

MW-13R compliance

Limit = 332.6

Limit = 229.7

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Alkalinity Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:42 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary (based on square root transformation): Mean=16.7, Std. Dev.=0.5769, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.7924, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.671 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limits

Page 154: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

8

16

24

32

40

5/20/09 7/28/10 10/5/11 12/12/12 2/19/14 4/30/15

MW-13R background

MW-13R compliance

Limit = 33.19

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Chloride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:42 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=11.2, Std. Dev.=8.231, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.842, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.671 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

100

200

300

400

500

5/20/09 7/28/10 10/5/11 12/12/12 2/19/14 4/30/15

MW-13R background

MW-13R compliance

Limit = 425.9

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Dissolved Solids Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:42 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=361.8, Std. Dev.=24.01, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8659, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.671 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 155: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

8

16

24

32

40

5/20/09 7/28/10 10/5/11 12/12/12 2/19/14 4/30/15

MW-13R background

MW-13R compliance

Limit = 30.69

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Magnesium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:42 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=24.91, Std. Dev.=2.166, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8638, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.671 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.8

1.6

2.4

3.2

4

5/20/09 7/28/10 10/5/11 12/12/12 2/19/14 4/30/15

MW-13R background

MW-13R compliance

Limit = 3.494

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Potassium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:42 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=1.864, Std. Dev.=0.6104, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8602, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.671 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 156: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

1.6

3.2

4.8

6.4

8

5/20/09 7/28/10 10/5/11 12/12/12 2/19/14 4/30/15

MW-13R background

MW-13R compliance

Limit = 7.317

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Sodium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:42 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary (based on square root transformation): Mean=2.142, Std. Dev.=0.2109, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8004, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.671 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

0

0.056

0.112

0.168

0.224

0.28

5/20/09 7/28/10 10/5/11 12/12/12 2/19/14 4/30/15

MW-13R background

MW-13R compliance

Limit = 0.2782

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Strontium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:42 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=0.2345, Std. Dev.=0.01635, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.8171, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.671 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 157: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

10

20

30

40

50

5/20/09 7/28/10 10/5/11 12/12/12 2/19/14 4/30/15

MW-13R background

MW-13R compliance

Limit = 40.31

Prediction LimitIntrawell Parametric

Constituent: Sulfate Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:42 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

Background Data Summary: Mean=24.73, Std. Dev.=5.833, n=11. Normality test: Shapiro Wilk @alpha = 0.01, calculated = 0.9492, critical = 0.792. Kappa = 2.671 (c=16, w=8, 1 of 2, event alpha = 0.1). Report alpha = 0.0008228.

Within Limit

Page 158: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

Trend Tests

Page 159: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

100

200

300

400

500

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-1

Constituent: Alkalinity Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:53 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 19

Slope = -18.19units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -87critical = -58

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

0.06

0.12

0.18

0.24

0.3

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-1

Constituent: Barium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:53 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 19

Slope = -0.01622units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -124critical = -58

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 160: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

4

8

12

16

20

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-1

Constituent: Chloride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:53 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 19

Slope = -1.069units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -115critical = -58

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

120

240

360

480

600

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-1

Constituent: Dissolved Solids Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:53 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 19

Slope = -24.73units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -119critical = -58

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 161: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

8

16

24

32

40

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-1

Constituent: Magnesium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:53 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 19

Slope = -1.472units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -109critical = -58

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

-0.07

0.124

0.318

0.512

0.706

0.9

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-1

Constituent: Manganese Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:53 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 19

Slope = -0.1074units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -104critical = -58

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 162: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.6

1.2

1.8

2.4

3

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-1

Constituent: Potassium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:53 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 19

Slope = -0.1338units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -92critical = -58

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

0.012

0.024

0.036

0.048

0.06

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-1

Constituent: Selenium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:53 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 19

Slope = -0.001874units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -90critical = -58

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Page 163: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-1

Constituent: Strontium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:53 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 19

Slope = -0.016units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -83critical = -58

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

8

16

24

32

40

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-1

Constituent: Sulfate Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:53 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 19

Slope = -2.552units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -105critical = -58

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 164: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

4

8

12

16

20

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-2

Constituent: Sodium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:54 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 17

Slope = -0.7435units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -94critical = -49

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

-0.2

0.44

1.08

1.72

2.36

3

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-3R

Constituent: Manganese Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:56 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 18

Slope = -0.04833units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -78critical = -53

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 165: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

100

200

300

400

500

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-4R2

Constituent: Alkalinity Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:54 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 11

Slope = -8.615units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -31critical = -27

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

0.08

0.16

0.24

0.32

0.4

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-4R2

Constituent: Barium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:54 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 11

Slope = -0.01652units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -40critical = -27

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 166: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

4

8

12

16

20

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-4R2

Constituent: Chloride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:54 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 11

Slope = -1.994units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -47critical = -27

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

0.08

0.16

0.24

0.32

0.4

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-4R2

Constituent: Fluoride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:54 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 11

Slope = 0.008952units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = 24critical = 27

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 167: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.006

0.012

0.018

0.024

0.03

11/19/07 5/15/09 11/10/10 5/6/12 11/1/13 4/29/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-4R2

Constituent: Selenium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:54 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 11

Slope = -0.001213units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -32critical = -27

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

0

80

160

240

320

400

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-6

Constituent: Alkalinity Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:57 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 18

Slope = -3.713units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -62critical = -53

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 168: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.04

0.08

0.12

0.16

0.2

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-6

Constituent: Barium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:57 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 18

Slope = -0.006714units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -76critical = -53

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

12

24

36

48

60

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-6

Constituent: Calcium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:57 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 18

Slope = -1.544units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -61critical = -53

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 169: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

40

80

120

160

200

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-6

Constituent: Dissolved Solids Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:57 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 18

Slope = -8.745units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -76critical = -53

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

6

12

18

24

30

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-6

Constituent: Magnesium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:57 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 18

Slope = -0.4406units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -67critical = -53

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 170: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.004

0.008

0.012

0.016

0.02

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-6

Constituent: Nickel Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:57 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 18

Slope = -0.000947units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -84critical = -53

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

0

0.006

0.012

0.018

0.024

0.03

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-6

Constituent: Selenium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:57 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 18

Slope = -0.001278units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -76critical = -53

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Hollow symbols indicate censored values.

Page 171: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.04

0.08

0.12

0.16

0.2

3/11/08 8/14/09 1/17/11 6/21/12 11/24/13 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-6

Constituent: Strontium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 8:57 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 18

Slope = -0.005439units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -65critical = -53

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

120

240

360

480

600

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Alkalinity Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 7

Slope = 13.79units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = 5critical = 15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 172: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.08

0.16

0.24

0.32

0.4

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Barium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 7

Slope = -0.008649units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -6critical = -15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

40

80

120

160

200

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Calcium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 7

Slope = 4.959units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = 9critical = 15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 173: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

1.6

3.2

4.8

6.4

8

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Chloride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 7

Slope = -1.289units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -19critical = -15

Decreasing trendsignificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

140

280

420

560

700

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Dissolved Solids Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 7

Slope = 27.57units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = 9critical = 15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 174: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

0.06

0.12

0.18

0.24

0.3

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Fluoride Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 7

Slope = -0.02116units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -11critical = -15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

8

16

24

32

40

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Magnesium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 7

Slope = 0units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = 2critical = 15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 175: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

-0.0008

0.0794

0.1595

0.2397

0.3198

0.4

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Manganese Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 7

Slope = -0.05912units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -13critical = -15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

0.8

1.6

2.4

3.2

4

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Potassium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 7

Slope = 0units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = 2critical = 15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 176: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

1.6

3.2

4.8

6.4

8

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Sodium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 7

Slope = -0.3845units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -5critical = -15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

0

0.16

0.32

0.48

0.64

0.8

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Strontium Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

l

n = 7

Slope = -0.01209units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = -3critical = -15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).

Page 177: Chris Lussier <Chris.Lussier@PPENERGY.net> Tuesday, July ...

0

16

32

48

64

80

12/13/11 8/15/12 4/19/13 12/22/13 8/26/14 4/30/15

Sen's Slope EstimatorMW-8

Constituent: Sulfate Analysis Run 6/13/2015 9:00 PM

Plum Point Energy Station Client: NAES Corporation Data: Plum Point Energy Station

Sanitas™ v.9.5.16 For the statistical analyses of ground water by FTN Associates only. UG

mg/

ln = 7

Slope = 4.029units per year.

Mann-Kendallstatistic = 5critical = 15

Trend not sig-nificant at 95%confidence level(α = 0.025 pertail).