Top Banner
Journal of the National Association of Journal of the National Association of Administrative Law Judiciary Administrative Law Judiciary Volume 38 Issue 2 Article 1 12-15-2018 Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States Carrie Townsend Ingram Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.pepperdine.edu/naalj Part of the Administrative Law Commons, Constitutional Law Commons, Courts Commons, and the Supreme Court of the United States Commons Recommended Citation Recommended Citation Carrie Townsend Ingram, Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States, 38 J. Nat’l Ass’n Admin. L. Judiciary 1 (2018) Available at: https://digitalcommons.pepperdine.edu/naalj/vol38/iss2/1 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Caruso School of Law at Pepperdine Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of the National Association of Administrative Law Judiciary by an authorized editor of Pepperdine Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected].
32

Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

Apr 08, 2022

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

Journal of the National Association of Journal of the National Association of

Administrative Law Judiciary Administrative Law Judiciary

Volume 38 Issue 2 Article 1

12-15-2018

Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

Carrie Townsend Ingram

Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.pepperdine.edu/naalj

Part of the Administrative Law Commons, Constitutional Law Commons, Courts Commons, and the

Supreme Court of the United States Commons

Recommended Citation Recommended Citation Carrie Townsend Ingram, Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States, 38 J. Nat’l Ass’n Admin. L. Judiciary 1 (2018) Available at: https://digitalcommons.pepperdine.edu/naalj/vol38/iss2/1

This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Caruso School of Law at Pepperdine Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of the National Association of Administrative Law Judiciary by an authorized editor of Pepperdine Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected].

Page 2: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��

���������� ��� ��������������� ������������������������������� � �� !���"�� �#$�����%&'()*+�,*%-)#+'�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�.�/$� 0123456�789:;<62=�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�.�>$� ?12�0@4426A�BA;A2�5C�0123456�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�D�� ##$�����-&'�-&)''�E-/-'E�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�F�/$� G2:;H;42$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�F�����������������������I$�����-JK�&LMNOPQ�OR�,KSTUTPKVM�ENTWXTPX�OR�)KYLKU�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�F�����������������������.$�����,KSTUTPKVM�%ZPPKWN�ENTWXTPX�OR�)KYLKU�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�[�����������������������D$�����,KSTUTPKVM�)ZSK�%O\]TPKX�NO�%JKYPOW�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$��>$� _6=<;6;�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�I�����������������������I$�����#WXLTWTVM�&LMNOPQ�OR�aLYLWb�aPKTN�cKLbJ�NO�ENTNK�/bKWdLKM�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�I�����������������������.$�����#WXLTWTVM�%ZPPKWN�ENTWXTPX�OR�)KYLKU�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�I.�����������������������D$�����#WXLTWTVM�)ZSK�%O\]TPKX�NO�%JKYPOW�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�Ie�%$� f4<g56;�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�IF�����������������������I$�����/PLhOWTVM�&LMNOPQ�OR�,KRKPKWdK�NO�ENTNK�/bKWdLKM�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�IF�����������������������.$�����iKbLMSTNLYK�%JTWbK�LW�/PLhOWT�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�Ij�����������������������D$�����kZXLdLTPQ�#WNKP]PKNTNLOW�OR�iKbLMSTNLYK�%JTWbK�LW�/PLhOWT�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�I[�����������������������e$�����/PLhOWTVM�)ZSK�%O\]TPKX�NO�%JKYPOW�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�.I�� ###$��-&'�lm-m)'�*l�%&'()*+�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�..�/$� 0123456�;6=�B29;4;A<56�5C�n5H24o�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�..�>$� p2oo56o�C45q�A12�BA;A2o��$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�.r�����������������������I$�����%JTWbK�ULNJ�sZP]OMK�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�.r�����������������������.$�����ENPOWb�lOZWXTNLOW�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�.[�����������������������D$�����#bWOPTWdK�LM�+ON�>SLMM�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�.�� #($��%*+%imE#*+�$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$�D��� �����������

Page 3: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ����� ����������� ������������������������������������ ��������������� ������ ������ !"#$�%&'()�*+�� (,-��./0123�456789:-�;<=�-=7<>?9=,-4�>@�7,-�A�B��BCD8-E-�'5C87�9:�FGHI�<:4�9=�:57<>?@�7,-�E5=7�9:J?C-:79<?�6<=-�9:�<4E9:9=78<79K-�?<;�F��(,-�456789:-L�<?=5�M:5;:�<=��./0123�4-J-8-:6-L�65:=94-8=�7,-�NC4969<8@O=�85?-�9:�9:7-8D8-79:P�<�=7<7C7-�;,96,�<:�<4E9:9=78<79K-�<P-:6@�<4E9:9=7-8=�Q��(,-�'5C87�4-7-8E9:-4�7,<7�7,-�J98=7�RC-=795:�75�65:=94-8�9=�;,-7,-8�'5:P8-==O�9:7-:7�5:�7,-�9==C-�9=�6?-<8�S���J�7,-�9:7-:7�5J�'5:P8-==�9=�6?-<8�<:4�C:<E>9PC5C=L�7,-�NC4969<8@�<:4�7,-�<4E9:9=78<79K-�<P-:6@�EC=7�P9K-�-JJ-67�75�'5:P8-==O�9:7-:7�I���JL�,5;-K-8L�7,-�=7<7C7-�9=�<E>9PC5C=�58�9=�=9?-:7�5:�7,-�9==C-L�7,-�NC4969<8@�9=�75�4-7-8E9:-�9J�7,-�<P-:6@O=�9:7-8D8-7<795:�5J�7,-�=7<7C7-�9=�<�D-8E9==9>?-�65:=78C6795:�5J�7,-�=7<7C7-�T��U�65C87�=,5C?4�:57�9ED5=-�97=�5;:�65:=78C6795:�5:�7,-�=7<7C7-�V�� WX���./0123� YZ[\]3/�� (,-��./0123�456789:-�-=7<>?9=,-4�<�7;5_=7-D�<:<?@=9=�7,<7�,<=�>--:�;94-?@�C79?9-4�;,-:�<:<?@9:P�7,-�<DD85D89<7-�9:7-8D8-7<795:�5J�<�=7<7C7-�7,<7�<:�<4E9:9=78<79K-�<P-:6@�9=�6,<8P-4�;97,�-:J5869:P�a��U:�<449795:<?�=7-D�;<=�<44-4�75�7,-�<:<?@=9=�>@�bXcX�0X�d/\��21ZX�9:�QeeF�H��(,9=�<449795:<?�=7-D�9=�65EE5:?@�6<??-4��./0123�B7-D��������������������������������������������������f�g5:��'<889-�(5;:=-:4��:P8<E�;<=�<;<84-4�7,-�QeFH�*UUhi�j-??5;=,9D�J85E�7,-�*UUhi�j-??5;=,9D�'5EE977--�<:4�D8-=-:7-4�,-8�D<D-8�<7�7,-�QeFH�*UUhi�U::C<?�'5:J-8-:6-��(,9=�<8796?-�9=�><=-4�5:�,-8�D<D-8��k�'<889-�(5;:=-:4��:P8<EL�i�%�L�9=�<:�U4E9:9=78<79K-�h<;�iC4P-�9:�7,-�B7<7-�5J��:49<:<�;,5�,<=�4-496<7-4�,-8�6<8--8�75�DC>?96�=-8K96-��(,-�<C7,58�;5C?4�?9M-�75�7,<:M�,-8�,C=><:4L�%C=7<:L�6,9?48-:L�h9<E�<:4�l<49L�<:4�D<8-:7=�J58�7,-98�D<79-:6-�<=�=,-�;857-�7,9=�<8796?-L�<:4�75�%<;:�m9?=5:�J58�D85K949:P�C:;<K-89:P�=CDD587�4C89:P�,-8�6<8--8��F�',-K85:�A�B�U�L��:6��K��*<7��)-=��%-J��'5C:69?L��:6�L�IVa�A�B��HSa�nFGHIo��Q�p��<7�HIQ��S�pX�I�pX�<7�HIQqIS��T�pX�<7�HIS��V�pX�a�pX�<7�HIQqIS��H�A�B��K��l-<4�'58D�L�TSS�A�B��QFH�nQeeFo����

Page 4: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� ������ !��"#$%�&�'()�*&+*�,-#./01�(�2���34��5)��3'6�+77��7�5+*��8&�3�9�3:��))�(�'�:+*�(�+;*&��5*6�*��*&��+:�346�*��<+=���;'�)�4+��653:�*&��2��4���2�'+8�+3(�*&+*�*&��+:�346�53*��7��*+*5�3�8+)�7��<;':+*�(�53�*&���>��45)���2�*&+*�+;*&��5*6 ?@��A2�9�3:��))�&+)�3�*�(�'�:+*�(�+;*&��5*6�*��*&��+:�346�*��<+=���;'�)�4+��653:�*&��2��4���2�'+8B�*&��4�;�*)�)&�;'(�*&�3�+77'6�(�2���34���)*+C'5)&�(�53�DEF%G0/#�.H�DIFJK�$1%�,0 ??�� LH��M-#�,N//#1K�DK$K#�0J�,-#./01��� O&��4;���3*�4�3*��P��)6��2�*&��,-#./01�(�4*�53���2*�3��P��'��=)�*&��2+4*)�);���;3(53:�*&��4+)��+3(�*&����+)�353:�2���*&��9�;�*Q)�(�45)5�3 ��,-#./01�53P�'P�(�(522��53:�53*��7��*+*5�3)��2�*&��*��<�R)*+*5�3+�6�)�;�4�BS�8&54&�8+)�+(�7*�(�C6��;'��*&��;:&�*&��T3P5��3<�3*+'�U��*�4*5�3�V:�346�53���)7�3)��*��*&��9'�+3�V5��V4*�V<�3(<�3*)��2�?!WW ?X��O&�)��+<�3(<�3*)�8����+�R'�3:*&6B�(�*+5'�(B�*�4&354+'B�4�<7'�>B�+3(�4�<7��&�3)5P����)7�3)��*��+�<+Y���)�45+'�5));� S?Z��O&��9�;�*�&;<C'6���4�:35[�(�*&+*�R\Y];(:�)�+���3�*��>7��*)�53�*&��25�'( S?��O&��Y;(545+�6�5)�3�*�+�7�'5*54+'�C�+34&��2�:�P��3<�3*�*&+*�5)�(5��4*'6�+44�;3*+C'��*��*&��7��7'��+3(�5)�3�*���)7�3)5C'��2�����)�'P53:�*&��)*�;::'��C�*8��3�4�<7�*53:�P5�8)��2�7;C'54�53*���)* ?_��O&�)����)7�3)5C5'5*5�)�+���P�)*�(�C6�*&��9�3)*5*;*5�3�*��*&���>�4;*5P��+3(�'�:5)'+*5P��C�+34&�)��2�*&��:�P��3<�3* ?��a&�3�9�3:��))�5)�53+(P��*�3*'6�)5'�3*��3�*&��5));������������������������������������������������������!�D##�O&�<+)�a �b���5''�c�d�5)*53�T �e54=<+3B�,-#./01fg�h0G$F1B�i!�jTk �l �m �iZZB�iZ�nX@@?o�n4�53�(�*&��*��<�,-#./01�p*�7�����o �?@�"#$%q�_ZZ�r p �+*�XXsXW ��??�t%H�+*�XZi �D##�p=5(<����P �p852*�c�9� B�ZXZ�r p �?ZB�?@�n?! o�nRa��4�3)5(���*&+*�*&���;'53:)B�53*��7��*+*5�3)B�+3(��7535�3)��2�*&��V(<535)*�+*���;3(���*&5)�V4*B�8&5'��3�*�4�3*��''53:�;7�3�*&��4�;�*)�C6���+)�3��2�*&�5��+;*&��5*6B�(��4�3)*5*;*��+�C�(6��2��>7��5�34��+3(�532��<�(�Y;(:<�3*�*��8&54&�4�;�*)�+3(�'5*5:+3*)�<+6�7��7��'6���)��*�2���:;5(+34� ��O&��8�5:&*��2�);4&�+�Y;(:<�3*�53�+�7+�*54;'+��4+)��85''�(�7�3(�;7�3�*&��*&���;:&3�))��P5(�3*�53�5*)�4�3)5(��+*5�3B�*&��P+'5(5*6��2�5*)���+)�353:B�5*)�4�3)5)*�346�85*&��+�'5���+3(�'+*���7��3�;34�<�3*)B�+3(�+''�*&�)��2+4*��)�8&54&�:5P��5*�7�8���*��7��);+(�B�52�'+4=53:�7�8���*��4�3*��' So �?X�b���5''�c�e54=<+3B�gNu/$�3�*��!B�+*�i_! �?Z�t%H�+*�ii �?�t%H�+*�i_ �?_�t%H�+*�i �?�t%H�n45*53:�O�33 �v+''�6�V;*& �P �e5''B�ZW�r p �?_ZB�?!_�n?!Wioo �

Page 5: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ����� ����������� ������������������������������������ ��������������� �������� ���!�"##$�# "% &��' ��&&( ��!�) �* &!#% +�)$��' �", �-$�-'"*, +�.��'�"+/���&� *��,��' �&�"�(� 0��' �1!(*��/(&��+ � */�� ��'"������&�� - &&"*$�2!*��' �3(+�-�"*$��!�+ 2 *��!�"��", �-$4&�* "&!�")# ���� *5* �"��!��!2��' �&�"�(� 678�9(&��- �:��!����;-"#�"0�.'!�.*!� ��' �+�&& ������<=>?0��&�"�-'"/5�!��2!*��' �@A=BCDE�+!-�*�� 67F��9(&��- �;-"#�"�.*!� ��'"���' �<=>?�/"3!*��$�!5���!��-!##"5& &��' �@A=BCDE�+!-�*�� 67G��;5 -�2�-"##$0�"�$�"/)�,(��$�# 2��)$�1!�,* &&��!�", �-� &��&��!���!�) �* &!#% +�)$�3(+, &6HI��J' �/"3!*��$�'!#+&��'"���' �# ,�&#"��% ���&�*(-��!�&��!�", �-� &�"* ��!�) �* &!#% +��!��)$�", �-� &0�)(����&� "+�)$�3(+, &0�.'�-'��&�-!/5# � #$�-!��*"*$��!��' ���� ���!2�@A=BCDE6H7��J' �+�&& ���&�"� &��'"���' �2# K�)�#��$�,�% ���!�"+/���&�*"��% �", �-� &�.�##�- "& �.��'��' �2�*&��3(+�-�"#�* &!#(��!��!2��' �&�"�(� 6HH�L(*��,�9(&��- �M!*&(-'4&�-!�2�*/"��!��5 *�!+0��' �/ +�"�."&�* 5!*���,�!��.' �' *��' �@A=BCDE�+!-�*�� �.!(#+�) -!/ �!)&!# � 6HN��O� �$ "*�"2� *�'�&�"55!���/ ��0�9(&��- �M!*&(-'�.*!� ��' �/"3!*��$�!5���!�����PQP�RESTUTVT=W�REXY�BY�R>EXV�"�+�# 2���!�+!()���'"���' �1!(*��.�##�#�Z #$�-!�&�+ *��'�&��&&( 0�.' ��"55*!5*�"� 6H[��\��PQP�RESTUTVT=0��' �1!(*��-!�&�+ *&�"�&�"�(� �"+/���&� * +�)$��' �]6;6�"� ���"�+�J*"+ /"*Z�O22�- 6H_��J' �5 ����!� *0�;:;�\�&���(� 0�-"##&�!���' �-!(*���������������������������������������������������78�R?Y�"��F_a 6�7F�]6;6�%6�b "+�1!*560�_NN�]6;6�H7F0�HNG�cHII7d�c;-"#�"0�960�+�&& ����,d6�7G�R?Y�"��H[I6�HI�R?Y�H7�R?Y�"��H[N6�HH�R?Y�"��H[86�HN�P==�e��"�J!� �) *,0�fCVghiS�PVhC=g=�@DVCT�jDgUE==�Pk=hTUX>l�Dm�n=?=C>l�Qo=EXp� qDr=CW� e:J4s� ]t6� u:L\O� cb"*6� 780� HI78d0�'��5&vww...6�5*6!*,wHI78wINw78w_HIN7IN_w�*(/5&x&(5* / x-!(*�x�!/�� x&Z 5��-"#x!2x2 + *"#x", �-$x5!. *y�z/�#$�t"{ #!��|�z*�-�!&� *0�fA=�}DB=CEg=ET�}DCSVXA� ~>ETS� TD� �E?DW� e6�6� J\bz;0� :5*6� 70� HI780�'��5&vww...6�$��/ &6-!/wHI78wI[wI7w&(�+"$x* %� .w�' x,!% *�/ ��x,!*&(-'x."��&x�!x(�+!6'�/#y�\#$"�;!/��0�}DCSVXA�US�CUoAT�>�DVT�@A=BCDE�?=m=C=EX=W��:;�6�O;J0� b"*6� H_0� HI780� '��5&vww...6."&'��,�!�5!&�6-!/w� .&w%!#!Z'x-!�&5�*"-$w.5wHI78wINwH_w,!*&(-'x�&x*�,'�x")!(�x-' %*!�x+ 2 * �- w�(�/�� */�6)"F-)8"2[-8_6�H[�;:;�\�&�60�\�-6�%6�\"�-(0�7NF�;6�1�6�7N[F0�7N_F�cHI7Fd�c96�M!*&(-'d6�H_�R?Y�"��7N_NaI6�

Page 6: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� �������� !� �"#$%&'()*+��,-.�/�01�2�-�3.4.12�!�.5� �����6.��-.���7��� !��!475.5��-���83-.�-.1�"#$%&'(�5-�09!�1.:�7 �75���;0.5�7� �3.�:�<�9.�4.�=�1�� ��-.1�!�<)>*?��,-.�/�01��-�9!5��-���.4. �0 !.1�"#$%&'(2�7=���5���0�.@5�:.� 7 A�75�B9.�12� ��!.=.1. B.�����-.��A. B<@5�7 �.1C1.���7� �75��CC1�C17��.)*D��E ��-75�B�5.2��-.�:�F�17�<��C7 7� �=�0 !��-����-.�5���0�.�3�5�0 �:�7A0�05�� !�-�!���B9.�1�:.� 7 A)*G��,-.�!755. �2�!.974.1.!��<�H05�7B.�I�.C-. �J1.<.12KL�5���.5��-����-.�5���0�.�7 �;0.5�7� �75��:�7A0�05�� !��-���:�1.��-� �� .�7 �.1C1.���7� �B�09!��.�:�!.�3-. ��-.��.1:7 �9�A<�75�1.�!�7 �-�1:� <�37�-��-.�. �71.��B��C�55.!��<�/� A1.55)KM��,-.�F05�7B.5�7 ��-.�!755. ���CC9<��-.�"#$%&'(�!�B�17 .�� !�A74.�!.=.1. B.�����-.��A. B<@5�7 �.1C1.���7� )K*�� EE)��,NO�,NPOO�I,Q,OI��RS��T$UVWV&$���M)��,-.�N75��1<��=�X.9�3�1.@5�I�� !�1!��=�P.47.3��� Q�MGY?�B�5.�=1�:��-.�I0C1.:.�/�01���=�X.9�3�1.�5��1�.!��-.�B-�7 ��=�.4. �5��-���9.!�����-.�B011. ��5�� !�1!�=�1��!:7 75�1��74.��A. B<�7 �.1C1.���7� ��=�5���0�.5��-.��A. B<�. =�1B.5)KK��E �"'(($UU�%S�T$UVWV&$�RZ&[&V\]�(_a]&Z$a2��-.�B�01��:�!.�7�5�!.B757� �� ��-.�B�5.�� !�F05�7=7.!�7�5�!.B757� ��<�=7 !7 A��-���7��3�5�B� 575�. ��37�-��-.��!:7 75�1��74.��A. B<@5�7 �.1C1.���7� )KY�,-.�B�01��C1�47!.!���!75B9�7:.1��-����-.��!:7 75�1��74.��A. B<�7 �.1C1.���7� �3�5� ���B� �1�997 A�� ��-.�F0!7B7�1<2��0���-.��A. B<�7 �.1C1.���7� �3�5�. �7�9.!����5�:.�3.7A-��0 9.55��-.�7 �.1C1.���7� �3�5�B9.�19<�31� A)Kb��E ��������������������������������������������������*+�_S����MKbD)�*?�_S��*D�_S�*G�_S��KL�_S����MK+L�cJ1.<.12�H)2�!755. �7 A2�F�7 .!��<�d7 5�01A2�H)2�� !�I���:�<�12�H)2�� !�F�7 .!�7 �C�1���<�e�A� 2�H)f)�KM�_S����MK+*)�K*�_S����MK+Yg+b)�KK�/� .99�4)�X.9)�Q71B1�=��E !05)2�E B)2�bb�Q)*!�+K?�cX.9)�MGY?f)�KY�_S����+Yb)�Kb�_S�

Page 7: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ����� ����������� ������������������������������������ ��������������� ��������� �!"#�$%&&'((�)*+,-.*/#0�.11#.0#)�*2�3456%&768'�9:�;<%&=%(8>?@��A"#�BC10#/#�DEC0!�EF�G#-.H.0#�.I.*2�JC+!*F*#)�.2�*2!#010#!.!*E2�EF�.�+!.!C!#�KL�-#.2*2I�E2�!"#�*2!#010#!.!*E2�EF�!"#�.)/*2*+!0.!*M#�.I#2,L>?���N2�;<%&=%(8 �!"#�,EC0!�H.+�,E/FE0!.K-#�H*!"�*!+�*2!#010#!.!*E2�EF�.�+#,!*E2�EF�!"#�OE!E0*+!�P0E!#,!*E2�Q,!�K#,.C+#�!"#�B!.!#�N2+C0.2,#�DE//*++*E2#0 �H"E+#�EFF*,#�H.+�.,!*M#-L�*2ME-M#)�*2�1.++*2I�!"#�.,! �*2!#010#!#)�!"#�+#,!*E2�EF�!"#�+!.!C!#�,E2+*+!#2!�H*!"�!"#�,EC0!R+�*2!#010#!.!*E2>?S���A"#�$%&&'((�)*+,-.*/#0�)*+.11#.0#)�F0E/�JC)*,*.-�)#,*+*E2+�FE0�.�F#H�L#.0+�C2!*-�*!�0#+C0F.,#)�*2����T>?���N2�!"#�/#.2!*/# �!"#�+!.2).0)�EF�0#M*#H�FE0�*2!#010#!.!*E2�EF�+!.!C!#+�.)/*2*+!#0#)�KL�.�IEM#02/#2!�.I#2,L�H.+�K#*2I�)#M#-E1#)>��N!�+!.0!#)�2E!�H*!"�.�,.+#�*2ME-M*2I�.2�.)/*2*+!0.!*M#�.I#2,L�*2!#010#!.!*E2 �KC!�H*!"�.�,.+#�*2ME-M*2I�!"#�+!.2).0)�EF�0#M*#H�FE0�!"#�*2!#010#!.!*E2�EF�.2L�+!.!C!#>TU��N2���SV �!"#�+!.2).0)�EF�0#M*#H�FE0�W,E2+!0C,!*E2�.2)�!"#�.11-*,.!*E2�EF�-.H�!E�!"#�F.,!+X�H.+�FEC2)�!E�K#�.�1-#2.0L�0#M*#H�*2�Y:Z:�8[�\%&5�8'�3']%[<�9:�_'((�a6(�$%:T��A"#�G#-.H.0#�JC)*,*.0L�,E2!*2C#)�!E�C+#�.�1-#2.0L�+!.2).0)�EF�0#M*#H�FE0�*2!#010#!.!*E2�EF�+!.!C!#+�.2)�#b!#2)#)�!"#�1-#2.0L�+!.2).0)�!E�+!.!C!#+�!".!�.)/*2*+!0.!*M#�.I#2,*#+�#2FE0,#>��N2���S� �!"#�,EC0!�)#,*)#)�3'7�$45('�$%[&5c�$%[&d6(�9:�e$�f'9:�g %d645':hi��A"*+�,.+#�)*)�2E!�*2ME-M#�.2�.)/*2*+!0.!*M#�.I#2,L �KC!�!"#�,EC0!�-*j#2#)�!"#�.,!*E2+�EF�!"#�k#H�D.+!-#�DEC2!L�DEC2,*-�!E�!".!�EF�.2�.)/*2*+!0.!*M#�.I#2,L>T?��OC,"�-*j#�.)/*2*+!0.!*M#�.I#2,*#+ �!"#�k#H�D.+!-#�DEC2!L�DEC2,*-�H.+�)#-#I.!#)�-#I*+-.!*M#�.C!"E0*!L�EM#0�lE2*2I>TT��A"#�k#H�D.+!-#�DEC2!L�DEC2,*-�/.)#�.�lE2*2I�0#IC-.!*E2�!".!�H.+�.)M#0+#�!E�mD�G#M#-E1/#2!R+�*2!#0#+!>TV��A"#�lE2*2I�E0)*2.2,#�H.+�,".--#2I#)�*2�,EC0!�.2)�C-!*/.!#-L�)#,*)#)�KL�!"#��������������������������������������������������?@�k.!*E2H*)#�OC!>�N2+>�DE>�M>�n0E2IE-) �?�S�Q>o)�@U@ �@U��pG#->����Tq>�?��Z8:�?S�Z8:�?��r>�B"E0#�k.!>�s.+�M>�G#->�PCK>�B#0M>�DE//R2 �@?��Q>o)��U ��V�pG#-����Tq>�TU�r>N>�)C�PE2!�)#�k#/EC0+�M>�B"#--�t*-�DE> �T�S�Q>o)���US ����?�pG#->���SVq>�T��Z8:�To�k#H�D.+!-#�D!L>�DEC2,*-�M>�mD�G#M>�Q++E,> �V@��Q>o)��o���pG#->���S�q>�T?�Z8:�.!��o�V>�TT�Z8:�TV�Z8:�.!��o��>�

Page 8: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� ������ ! �"#��$�#%�& '()(� *+,��-#��(�.#/0/1�� 1�'($0#/2�$3 �4#��$�%#�/5�$3($�6$3 �7$(/5(�5�%#��� 80 )�07�)3 $3 ��$3 �(4$0#/�07�0/�4#!�'0(/4 �)0$3�(��'04(9' �7$($�$ 7*:+;��<3 �4#��$�40$ 5�$#�=>?>�@A�BCDE�@F�GFHCAIJ�(/5�3 '5�$3($�$3 � �07�(��' /(�K�7$(/5(�5�#%�� 80 )�%#��0/$ ��� $($0#/�#%�7$($�$ 7*+L��M30' �$307�4(7 �5# 7�/#$�50� 4$'K�0/8#'8 �(/�(5!0/07$�($08 �(1 /4K2�9 4(�7 �$3 �N )�"(7$' �"#�/$K�"#�/40'�)(7�'0O / 5�$#�(/�(5!0/07$�($08 �(1 /4K2�$307�4(7 �)(7�(/�0!�#�$(/$�5 8 '#�! /$�%#��(5!0/07$�($08 �'()�0/�& '()(� *�P/�QRRS2�$3 ����� ! �"#��$�#%�& '()(� �)(7��� 7 /$ 5�)0$3�(�%(4$��($$ �/�$3($�!(5 �0$�4#/705 ��0$7��#' �%#��0/$ ��� $($0#/�#%�7$($�$ 7�$3($�(/�(5!0/07$�($08 �(1 /4K�(5!0/07$ �7*+R��P/�TECUEV�W>�XCDJAHFI�YZZ[\IJ�]@>2�$3 �4#��$�3 '5�$3($�)3 /�� 80 )0/1�(�5 4070#/�#%�(/�(5!0/07$�($08 �(1 /4K2�$3 �4#��$7�� 80 )�07��' /(�K�)3 /�$3 �077� �0/8#'8 7�4#/7$��4$0#/�#%�7$($�$#�K�'()�(/5�$3 �(��'04($0#/�#%�$3($�'()�$#��/507��$ 5�%(4$7*_��<3 �7$(/5(�5� 7$(9'073 5�9K�TECUEV�)(7�4' (�2��/$0'�QRR+�)3 /2�#/4 �(1(0/2�$3 �XCDDFUU�5074'(0! ��!($ �0('0. 5�0/�=[JEFID�TaCIF�G[E\CD[U�b[J�XC>�W>�cFU[d[IF�BAeU\f�TFIW\fF�XCHHgD>_Q��h/'K�$307�$0! 2�$3 �5074'(0! ��)(7�/#�'#/1 ��i�7$�(�5074'(0! �2�9�$�0/7$ (5�0$�3(5�$�(/7%#�! 5�0/$#�(�/ )�7$(/5(�5�#%�� 80 )�$3($�4#!90/ 5�TECUEV�(/5�XCDDFUU*_S��<3 �� 7�'$�)(7�(�/ )�7$(/5(�5�#%�� 80 )�$3($�$3($�$3 �4#��$�3(7��' /(�K�� 80 )�#%�(/�(5!0/07$�($08 �(1 /4K7�5 4070#/*��<3 �4#��$�07�/#$�9#�/5�9K�$3 �(1 /4K7�4#/4'�70#/2�9�$�$3 �4#��$�5# 7�108 �7�97$(/$0('�) 013$�$#�$3 �(1 /4K7�0/$ ��� $($0#/�#%�(�7$($�$ �$3 �(1 /4K� /%#�4 72��/' 77�$3 �0/$ ��� $($0#/�07�4' (�'K� ��#/ #�7*_j��<3 �(�� ''($ �4#��$7�9 1(/��$0'0.0/1�$3 �=[JEFID�TaCIF�7$(/5(�5�(/5�$3 �i�5040(�K�1(8 �5 % � /4 ��������������������������������������������������+,�?@>�+;�?@>�($�QS;,*�+L�?@>�+R��$#'$.�8*�"#/7�! ��k%%(0�7�l5*2�,Q,�k*S5�QS_�m& '*�QRRSn*�_�?@>�($�QS;*�_Q�o*��3#� �N($*�p(7�8*�& '*�q�9*�� �8*�"#!!/2�,j;�k*S5�Q2�Q_�m& '*�QRR+n*�_S�?@>�TFF�"#// ''�8*�& '*�k0�4�(%$�P/5�7*2�P/4*2�__�k*S5�,j;2�,+_�m& '*���� �*�"$*�QR+;n*�_j�=>�TaCIF�G[E>�b[Jr�,j;�k*S5�($�Q_>�

Page 9: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ����� ����������� ������������������������������������ ��������������� ���������� !"!#�$��!%&��'&"(!&#�!"�(�#&#�!"%�)%!"'�!"�&$*$&���!�"#��+��,&�#���-�&#��,&��'&"(.�/�#�(,�$'&��/!�,�&"+�$(!"'012��30��4&)�/�$&5#�6-$$&"��7��"��$���+�8&%!&/��� 9:;<=>�?@ABC�DE�F=9@GH:@<B�$&(�'"!I&���,&�(�"+-#!�"��,���,���J&&"�($&��&��J.��,&�K@GABCL�MNOCB�#��"��$���+�$&%!&/�J&(�-#&�!��,���($&��&���/��!"(�"#!#�&"��#��"��$�#�+�$�#���-��$.�(�"#�$-(�!�"011��P�(�-$��(�""���,�%&����$-&�*)&"�$.�$&%!&/��"������,&�#� &��! &�'!%&��&+&$&"(&�����"��'&"(.�!"�&$*$&���!�"��+���#���-�&�!��&"+�$(&#01Q��P#���$&#-)�R��,&�(�-$���%&$$-)&���,&�K@GABCL�MNOCB�#��"��$���+�$&%!&/�+�$�#���-��$.�(�"#�$-(�!�"01S��T,&�(�-$��&#��J)!#,&���,����,&�U-�!(!�$.�/!))�-#&���*)&"�$.�$&%!&/�+�$�#���-�&�(�"#�$-(�!�"��"���**)!(��!�"����-"�!#*-�&��+�(�#01V��T,&�(�-$�#�/&$&�"�������&+&$�����'&"(.�!"�&$*$&���!�"��+���#���-�&�!���� !"!#�&$#R�J-�� �.�'!%&�!���-&�/&!',�01W��T,���/&!',�R�,�/&%&$R���&#�"��� &�"��,����,&��'&"(.5#�#���-��$.�!"�&$*$&���!�"�!#�(�$$&(�� &$&).�J&(�-#&�!��!#�$��!�"�)��$�"���()&�$).�&$$�"&�-#0QX��T,&��**&))��&�(�-$�#�#,�-)��"���*$�%!�&���,!',&$�)&%&)��+��&+&$&"(&�����,&��� !"!#�$��!%&��'&"(.5#�)&'�)�(�"()-#!�"��,�"�!����&#�����,&��$!�)�(�-$�#5�)&'�)�(�"()-#!�"#0QY��T,&�U-�!(!�)�!"�&$*$&���!�"� �.� ��(,��,&��� !"!#�$��!%&��'&"(.5#�!"�&$*$&���!�"R�J-���,&�(�-$�#�#,�-)��"���(�"+-#&��,&�(�$$&(��#��"��$���+�$&%!&/�J&(�-#&�J��,�!"�&$*$&���"���**).��,&�#���-�&��,&�#� &0Q3��Z"�&&���"��� !"!#�$��!%&��'&"(.�!#��� & J&$��+��,&�&[&(-�!%&�J$�"(,��+�'�%&$" &"�R��"��#���-��$.�(�"#�$-(�!�"�!#��,&�U-�!(!�)�J$�"(,5#�-)�! ��&�$&#*�"#!J!)!�.0Q\���������������������������������������������������12�MBB�6,&#�*&�]&��!)#0�6�$*0�%0�4&)0�_-J0�7&$%0�6� 5"R�SX1�P03��YX1WR�YXS1SQ�a4&)0�7-*&$0�6�0�YWWSbc�d�,"#�"�%0�e!))!� #R�S3V�P03��YYV1R�YYVS�a4&)0�7-*&$0�6�0�YWWVb0�11�_-J0�e��&$�7-**).�6�0�%0�4!_�#f-�)&R�S\1�P03��\SVR�\V3�a4&)0�YWW3b0�1Q�ghE�1S�ghE����\V3iV\0�1V�ghE����\VYc�7��)�I�j' �0�6�0�%0�6�"#- &$�P++�!$#�k�ER�QYQ�P03��Y3X1R�Y3XV�a4&)0�YWW3b0�1W�F=9@GH:@<BR�S\1�P03�����\V30�QX�ghE����\V\0�QY�ghE����\VY0�Q3�MBB�=hE����\V\0�Q\�l0�7,�$&�m��0�n�#�%0�4&)0�_-J0�7&$%0�6� 5"R�Q\S�P03��YXR�Y1�a4&)0�YWW2b0�

Page 10: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� ������ �!"�#$��%�&'�'!��()*!�+��,�)!#�-��.�-/.#/01)/.$�2�#���0�.#'#)#��'0-�'1�034�!�1)&'#/�0�/0#�!*!�#'#/�0567��8�!�'1�034�!�1)&'#/�0�/0#�!*!�#'#/�0"�3�)!#.�-�9�!�#��'-+/0/.#!'#/ ��'1�034:.�!�1)&'#/�0�3�0.#!)3#/�0"�)0&�..�#$��3�0.#!)3#/�0�/.�3&�'!&4��!!�0��).56;��<$��!�1)&'#/�0�+).#�2��.�)0-�'0-�3�0./.#�0#��/#$�#$��1� �!0/01�.#'#)#�=66��8�!�.#'#)#��/0#�!*!�#'#/�0"�#$��3�)!#�-��.�0�#�-�9�!�#��'1�034�/0#�!*!�#'#/�056>����?5��%�&'�'!�:.�@)&��,�+*'!�-�#��,$� !�0��� <$��'-+/0/.#!'#/ ��'1�034�/0�ABCDEF�GHIJK�'!1)�-�#$'#�%�&'�'!��.$�)&-�'-�*#�LMJNKOPQR�.#'0-'!-��9�!� /��S6T��<$��()*!�+��,�)!#��9�%�&'�'!��!�U�3#�-�#$��'-+/0/.#!'#/ ��'1�034:.�'!1)+�0#56V��W0�-�/01�.�"�#$��3�)!#�!�3�10/X�-�#$'#�#$��LMJNKOP�-�3/./�0��'.�2'.�-��0�#$��Y5(5�()*!�+��,�)!#:.�$/.#�!4��9�-�9�!�03��#��'-+/0/.#!'#/ ��'1�034�/0#�!*!�#'#/�0��9�.#'#)#�.�#$��'1�034��09�!3�->Z��[��.)3$�$/.#�!4��9�-�9�!�03���\/.#�-�/0�%�&'�'!�5>]��W0�9'3#"�#$��/..)���9�'-+/0/.#!'#/ ��'1�034�/0#�!*!�#'#/�0��9�.#'#)#�.�#$��'1�034�'-+/0/.#�!�-�-/-�0�#�9)&&4�-� �&�*�)0#/&�]VV5>��<$��.#'0-'!-��9�!� /����'.�)03&�'!�)0#/&�_EAHRBHDJ�3&�'!&4�'--!�..�-�/#�/0�]VVV5>?�a�3�+*'!/.�0��9�#$��LMJNKOP�-�3#!/0��/.�+�!��&/b�&4�9�)0-�/0�%�&'�'!���/#$�/0#�!*!�#'#/�0��9�!�1)&'#/�0.�3!�'#�-�24�'0�'1�0345>7����������������������������������������������������67�_EAHRBHDJc�>?;�a5-�'#�?Td�e'..'&&�� 5��'2�!�f&�35�,�S"�7?;�a5-�]Z76"�]Z;Z�g%�&5�()*�!5�,#5�]VT]h5�6;�_EAHRBHDJc�>?;�a5-�'#�?T?�05Vd�['#/�0�/-��i)#5�W0.5�,�5� 5�j!�01�&-"�?]T�a5-�6Z6"�6ZV�g%�&5�]V>7hd�%�&5�k-5��9�[)!./01� 5�8!'03/."�[�5�6V"�.&/*��*5�'#�];�057Z�g%�&5�Z]Th5�66�lJJ�%/ 5��9�8'+/&4�(�! 5� 5�(5m5"�]Z�a5?-�6"�?�g%�&5�8'+5�,#5�Z];h5�6>�noS�6T�_EAHRBHDJ"�>?;�a5-�'#�?T?5�6V�noS�>Z�noS�>]�lJJ�(#�&#X�i1+#5�,�5� 5�,�0.)+�!�a99'/!.�k-S"�6]6�a5-�]Z;"�]Z;�g%�&5�]VVhd�f5W5�-)�m�0#�-��[�+�)!.� 5�($�&&�p/&�,�5"�7VT�a5-�]]ZT"�]]ZT�g%�&5�]VT;h5��>�lIODIq"�6]6�a5-�'#�]ZT5�>?�_EAHRBHDJ"�>?;�a5-�'#�?TrT?5�>7�lJJ�,$� !�0�Y5(5a5"�W035� 5�['#5�@�.5�%�95�,�)03/&"�W035"�76>�Y5(5�T?>"�T7r7?�g]VT7hd�_EAHRBHDJ"�>?;�a5-�'#�?T?�05Vd�['#/�0�/-��i)#5�W0.5�,�5� 5�j!�01�&-"�?]T�a5-�6Z6"�6ZV�g%�&5�]V>7hd�%�&5�k-5��9�[)!./01� 5�8!'03/."�[�5�6V"�.&/*��*5�'#�];�057Z�g%�&5�Z]Th5�

Page 11: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ���������� ������������������������������������������������ ������� !"!#$�!"!%�&'()�)&*%+*#+��,�#!"(! �+�!)�%�&�-(##�#�&'*&��,�./0123456789��:'!�;!<* *#!�=>+(?(*#@�+!,!#)�&��&'!�*A!%?@B)�(%&!#C#!&*&(�%��,�(&)�#!A><*&(�%)$�>%<!))�&'!�(%&!#C#!&*&(�%�()�?<!*#<@�!##�%!�>)78D��E'(<!�&'()�)&*%+*#+��,�#!"(! �()�*F(%�&��G/0123456�)&!C�& �$�(&�()�<*?F(%A�& ���&'!#�?�%)(+!#*&(�%)788��H(#)&$�&'!�)&*%+*#+�+�!)�%�&�#!I>(#!�&'!�=>+(?(*#@�&��?�%)(+!#�G/01234�)&!C�J!#�$� '!#!�&'!�<!A()<*&>#!�'*)�+!<!A*&!+�&'!�*A!%?@�*>&'�#(&@�&��-*F!�#!A><*&(�%)�&'*&�*#!�C#�-><A*&!+�?�%)()&!%&� (&'�&'!�<!A()<*&>#!B)�+!<!A*&(�%78K��L!?�%+$�&'!�)&*%+*#+�+�!)�%�&�#!I>(#!�&'!�=>+(?(*#@�&��?�%)(+!#�G/01234�)&!C��%!M� '(?'�%!?!))(&*&!)�#!A><*&�#@�*-N(A>(&@78O��:'!�)&*%+*#+��,�#!"(! �,�#�(%&!#C#!&*&(�%��,�*A!%?@�#!A><*&(�%)�'*)�%�&�N!!%�<(&(A*&!+�(%�&'!�;!<* *#!�*CC!<<*&!�?�>#&)�&��C#�"(+!�,>#&'!#�+!,(%(&(�%7KP���� QR��S4TUV4V���W7��X%+(*%*B)��()&�#@��,�Y("(%A�Y#!*&�E!(A'&�&��L&*&!�ZA!%?(!)�� X%+(*%*B)�?'*%A!�(%�[PWK�&��(&)�)&*%+*#+��,�#!"(! �,�#�*A!%?@�(%&!#C#!&*&(�%��,�)&*&>&!)�*%+�#!A><*&(�%)KW�+!-�%)&#*&!)�&'!�(-C�#&*%?!��,�<��F(%A�*&�X%+(*%*B)�'()&�#@��%�&'()�())>!7K[�X%+(*%*B)�'()&�#@�)&!-)�N*?F�&��WO9[� '!%�&'!�L>C#!-!�.�>#&��,�X%+(*%*�+!?(+!+�Q\VU2�1R�]0U4_027K�Q\VU2�(%"�<"!+�#!A><*&(�%�?�%)&#>?&(�%��������������������������������������������������89�a00�G/01234M�bD8�c7L7�*&�Kb[dbe�fUgV6hiV\0M�89�Z7[+�*&�K�%7Oe�j234_3\T$�WK�Z7[+�*&�DPOe�k2V4lU6$�m�7�DO$�)<(C��C7�*&�W9�%7bP7�8D�a00�G/01234M�bD8�c7L7�*&�Kb[nbe�fUgV6hiV\0$�89�Z7[+�*&�K�%7Oe�j234_3\T$�WK�Z7[+�*&�DPOe�k2V4lU6$�m�7�DO$�)<(C��C7�*&�W9�%7bP7�88�G/01234M�bD8�c7L7�*&�Kb[dbe�c7L7�"7�o!*+�.�#C7$�9 �c7L7�[WK$�[[Dd[8�p[PPWq7�8K�a00�r0VT$�9 �c7L7�*&�[[Dd[87�8O�a00�G/01234M�bD8�c7L7�*&�Kb[nbe�fUgV6hiV\0$�89�Z7[+�*&�K�%7Oe�j234_3\T$�WK�Z7[+�*&�DPOe�k2V4lU6$�m�7�DO$�)<(C��C7�*&�W9�%7bP7�KP�a00�fUgV6hiV\0$�89�Z7[+�*&�K�%7Oe�j234_3\T$�WK�Z7[+�*&�DPOe�k2V4lU6$�m�7�DO$�)<(C��C7�*&�W9�%7bP7�KW�X%�X%+(*%*$�*A!%?@�#!A><*&(�%)�*#!�?�--�%<@�?*<<!+�*+-(%()&#*&("!�#><!)7��a00�Xm;7�.s;t�u�bn[[�p[PWDq7��H�#�?�%)()&!%?@�(%�&'()�*#&(?<!$�#><!)� (<<�N!�#!,!##!+�&��*)�#!A><*&(�%)7�K[�a00�mXvL.s�X%+>)7�Y#C7�"7�m7�X%+7�v>N7�L!#"7�.�7$�WPP�m7t7+�[b$�[bW�pX%+7�[PWKq7�K�L&*&!�0w�20\R�x<*(#�"7�Y!&&(%A!#M�WP9�m7t7[+�WDW�pX%+7�WO9[q7�

Page 12: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� ����������� !�" #��$#%�&%��" �&������'�( �&�"'�!)'%�� !'�*'*+,-��.��")�"�!�*'/�")'�!#0%"�! "'��"#�")'�$�1#0*�*"����%��#$�%'2 '3�'*"�4� *)'�� ��")'�56--�7+8+�80�%'1'�9#0%"�!�*'/�:;<=>?�@A�B>CDE;=>�F;GH+,I��J)'�.�� ����*"����%��#$�%'2 '3�%'K0 %'��")�"�")'�%'&0��" #��$ %*"�4'���#�"'�� ��!#1�� ��!'�3 ")�")'�*"�"0"#%(�%'K0 %'1'�"*�$#%��%#10�&�" �&�%'&0��" #�*+,L��8'!#��/� $�")'�%'&0��" #��3�*�0��14 &0#0*/�")'�M0� ! �%(�*)#0����#"�!#�* �'%�")'���1 � *"%�" 2'��&'�!(� �"'%�%'"�" #�+,N��.$��")'�%'&0��" #��3�*��14 &0#0*/�O")'���1 � *"%�" 2'� �"'%�%'"�" #��#$�P")'�%'&0��" #�Q�3 ���)�2'�10!)�3' &)"�0��'**� "� *���� ��(�'%%#�'#0*�#%� �!#�* *"'�"�3 ")�")'�P%'&0��" #�Q� "*'�$+R,,��J)'�:=SDT�*"����%�U*����� !�" #��!#�" �0'������3�*�'V����'�� ��WXXX+,6�.��YZ[�B\>>=�];A�@A�TD__DE/�")'�.�� ����'��%"1'�"�#$�a�4#%� �"'%�%'"'��*"�"0"'*�")�"�")'�.�� ����8"�"'�b") !*�9#11 ** #��3'%'�!)�%&'��3 ")�'�$#%! �&+6X��J)'�.�� ����80�%'1'�9#0%"�$#0���")�"�")'����%#�% �"'��&'�!(�"#� �"'%�%'"�")�"�*"�"0"'�3�*�")'�8"�"'�b") !*�9#11 ** #�/��#"�")'�'��%"1'�"�#$�a�4#%+65�J)'�*�'! $ !�*"����%��'*"�4� *)'��3�*c�OP�Q�� �"'%�%'"�" #��#$���*"�"0"'�4(������1 � *"%�" 2'��&'�!(�!)�%&'��3 ")�")'��0"(�#$�'�$#%! �&�")'�*"�"0"'� *�'�" "�'��"#�&%'�"�3' &)"/�0��'**�") *� �"'%�%'"�" #��3#0���4'� �!#�* *"'�"�3 ")�")'�*"�"0"'� "*'�$+R6W�7��0�" ��") *��# �"/�")'�M0� ! �%(�)���#��(��$$#%�'��&%'�"�3' &)"�"#�����&'�!(U*�#3��%'&0��" #�� �"'%�%'"�" #�+6d���YZ[�B\>>=�4'!�1'�")'�!�*'�")�"�*04*'K0'�"��'! * #�*�! "'��"#�$#%�")'�*"����%��#$�%'2 '3�!#�!'%� �&��&'�!(� �"'%�%'"�" #��#$�*"�"0"'*�����%'&0��" #�*�'�$#%!'��4(�")�"��&'�!(+6-����������������������������������������������������,-�efA��"�5L5gL,+�,I�efA��"�5L,+�,L�efA��,N�efA��,,�efA��,6�aJh�8"''��9#+�2+�i% $$ �/�NdX�j+b+W��5WI5/�5WIN�k.��+�WXXXl+�6X�efA�65�efA�6W�efA�6d�efA�k! " �&�"#�.��+�'�U"�#$�8"�"'�m'2'�0'�2+�n0�o1�" !�J%��*�+�9#+/�L-,�j+b+W��55IL/�55IN�k.��+�566Il�$#%�M0*" $ !�" #�p�)#3'2'%/�:q=HCS\DG� �2#�2'��%'&0��" #�� �"'%�%'"�" #�/��#"���*"�"0"'� �"'%�%'"�" #�l+�6-�.��+�r�!#)#��s�J#4�!!#�9#11U��2+�a'4�1#$$�b�"'%*+/�WN�j+b+d��,XW/�,XL�k.��+�9"+�r��+�WX5Ilp�9#11U%�#$�.��+�'�U"�#$�.�*+�2+�t0"1��/�6,�j+b+d��6,/�5X-�k.��+�9"+�r��+�WX5,lp�WII�u#%% */�aa9�2+�.��+�r�!#)#��s�J#4�!!#�9#11U�/�6d�

Page 13: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ���������� ������������������������������������������������ ����������� !"# #$%�&'(() *�+*# !#(!�,-�.)/")0��� 123�4566789�%*# !#(!�,-�()/")0�#::)#()!�*,�;)�:'*�*,�#�<#=*�" ��>?@�AB�� �CDE4FG�DHIJ95KLM7�NKOJP�QR�COK5S6KH�DHILMHM�EJT7LU�46KQLU6�FORV�*<)�� !"# #�+':()W)�&,'(*X�" �#�' # "W,'%�!)Y"%", �0("**) �;Z�['%*"Y)�+=#'\<*)(X�#!!()%%)!�*<)�"%%')�,-�%*#*'*,(Z�" *)(:()*#*", �,-�#�%*#*'*)�) -,(Y)!�;Z�# �#!W" "%*(#*"/)�#\) YZ�A]��<)�Y,'(*�<)=!�*<#*�_')%*", %�,-�=#0�#()�()/")0)!�I6�HOQO�# !�:(,/"!)� ,�!)-)() Y)�*,�*<)�#!W" "%*(#*"/)�#\) YZ$%�" *)(:()*#*", ��� *)()%*" \=Z�) ,'\<X�*,�%'::,(*�"*%�%*# !#(!�,-�()/")0X�*<)�Y,'(*�Y"*)%�*,�MKTJKa�QR�MIL9OHbc�# !�# �� !"# #�+':()W)�&,'(*�Y#%)�!)Y"!)!�" �?AAA�A@� <)�� !"# #�+':()W)�&,'(*�!"!� ,*�d'%*�%*,:�#*�)%*#;="%<" \�*<"%�%*# !#(!�,-�()/")0e�"*�0) *�, �*,�:, *"-"Y#*)�#;,'*�%):#(#*", �,-�:,0)(%f�� +):#(#*", g,-g:,0)(%�:(" Y":=)%�!,� ,*�Y, *)W:=#*)�#�h*")g\,)%g*,g*<)g#\) YZh�%*# !#(!�-,(�()/")0" \�#!W" "%*(#*"/)�!)Y"%", %�, �_')%*", %�,-�=#0��� �!"%Y<#(\" \�,'(�Y, %*"*'*", #=�!'*ZX�0)�:(, ,' Y)�*<)�%*#*'*,(Z�" *)(:()*#*", �*<#*�"%�;)%*�# !�!,� ,*�#Y_'")%Y)�" �*<)�" *)(:()*#*", %�,-�,*<)(%��i)Y"!" \�*<)�%Y,:)�,-�*<)�&,WW"%%", $%�#'*<,("*Z�' !)(�*<)�i+�&�+*#*'*)�-#==%�%_'#()=Z�0"*<" �,'(�" %*"*'*", #=�Y<#(\)��&(#-*" \�,'(�+*#*)$%�'*"="*Z�=#0�"%�-,(�*<)�=)\"%=#*'()e�"W:=)W) *" \�"*�"%�-,(�*<)�)j)Y'*"/)�#Y*" \�*<(,'\<�*<)�&,WW"%%", e�# !�" *)(:()*" \�"*�"%�-,(�*<)�Y,'(*%�AA��������������������������������������������������k�l�m!�??nAX�??Bm�o� !��&*��p::���>?@qe�l*r=)(�/��� !��i):$*�,-�.)/) ')X�nm�k�l�m!��B>X��BB�o� !��&*��p::���>?Bq��AB�k�s+&t�� !'%��u(:��/��k��� !��s';��+)(/��&,�X�?>>�k�l�m!��mnX��n?�o� !���>?@q��A]�DIR�#*��mA��Av�w#(;'(Z�/��w#!"%, X�B�x�+��?mvX�?v]�o?@>mq�A@�CDE4FGV�?>>�k�l��m!�#*��n?�oyz)�()/")0�_')%*", %�,-�=#0�!)� ,/,X�� !��{)==�)=��&,��/��� !��x*"=��.)\'=#*,(Z�&,WW| X�v?B�k�l��!�mB?X�mBn�o� !��?AAAq�oY"*#*", �,W"**)!qX�# !�#YY,(!�*<)�#!W" "%*(#*"/)�*(";' #=�;)=,0� ,�!)-)() Y)��,�!,�,*<)(0"%)�0,'=!�#;!"Y#*)�,'(�!'*Z�*,�%#Z�0<#*�*<)�=#0�"%�}�oY"*" \�MKTJKaX�B�x�+��#*�?v]qq���AA�DIR�

Page 14: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� ���� ����� !"#�$ �%�& #�"�'�"�&���#���%#(&$("$� '�"�)*�+�,-.�/0112��%#(34*%��$5677��89:/;<� &4=�($$"�%%�%�%#(#!#�%�(&$�>(?�%�& �>�&#* &� '�#���%#(&$("$� '�"�)*�+�' "�"�@!4(#* &%�#�(#�A4(*"��%#(34*%��$�*&�6BCD5676�����"�(% &*&@�3��*&$�#�*%�$"(%#*����(&@��*&�#���%#(&$("$� '�"�)*�+�("��!&�4�("E�3!#�#�*%�%�*'#�>*"" "%�F!%#*����� >(%�(&$�F!%#*���G "%!��H%�� &��"&%567D�I�'�+�> &#�%�('#�"�89:/;<E�#���J&$*(&(�K!L"�>��M !"#�$��*$�$�NOPQRPQ0S�TU�9VWU�X1YZ0�O[�8R0U�\1]UE�+�*���(4% �($$"�%%�$�#���%#(&$("$� '�"�)*�+�' "�(@�&�=�%#(#!# "=�*&#�"L"�#(#* &567�����>(_ "*#=� L*&* &� '�#���� !"#�*&�NOPQRPQ0S���4$�#�(#�#���%#(&$("$�!%�$�*&�89:/;<�+(%�& #�$*''�"�&#�#�(&�#���,-.�/0112�%#(&$("$567��� a(#��"�#�(&��''��#*&@�(�%�(���(&@��*&�89:/;<E�+��(LL4*�$�(�%L��*'*�E�� &#" 44*&@�L "#* &� '�#���%(>��%#(&$("$�+��"��*#��# $(=5�A #��*&�89:/;<�(&$���"�E�+��& #��#�(#�+�� "$*&("*4=�"�)*�+�4�@(4�b!�%#* &%�($$"�%%�$�3=�(&�(@�&�=�$��& ) 5�c89:/;<d�677�ef5�$�(#�D6g5�J&�89:/;<E�#�(#�+(%� !"�L"*>("=�' �!%5�9WU�h��$*$�& #�� &#*&!�� !"�$*%�!%%* &� '�#���%#(&$("$� '�"�)*�+�# �($$"�%%�(&�(@�&�=H%�*&#�"L"�#(#* &� '�#���"�4�)(&#�%#(#!#��3��(!%��#��"��+(%�& �&��$i�+��' !&$�#���(@�&�=H%�*&#�"L"�#(#* &�� &#"("=�# �#���%#(#!#��*#%�4'�(&$E�#�!%E�&���%%("*4=�!&"�(% &(34�567C�� J&�#���$*%%�&#*&@� L*&* &E�F!%#*���K4(!@�#�"�+" #��#�(#�#���,-.�/0112�%#(&$("$��($�3��&�j4(*$�# �"�%#�' "�@ $�*&�89:/;<5k67l�F!%#*���K4(!@�#�"�"(*%�$�%*@&*'*�(&#�� &��"&%�+*#��%�L("(#* &� '�L +�"%�' "��������������������������������������������������677�,-.�/0112E�m7�e5f5D$�(#�6DCm5�676�89:/;<E�677�e5f5$�(#�D6i�]11�K#(#��1n�P12U�A4(*"�)5�G�##*&@�"d�67C�e5f5D$�6l6E�6lo�pJ&$5�6BCDq5�67D�/11�r*��*@(&�)5�fsIE�6C�K5�M#5�DlBBE�Dm6D�pD76Cq�p�� >(%E�F5E�� &�!""*&@qi�G!#*�""�tuA"*t!�4(�)5�v=&��E�o �w5$�66DE�66B�p67#��M*"5�D76lq�pG "%!��E�F5E�� &�!""*&@q5�67�r "*("*#=�)5�J&$5�x�LH#� '�e(#5�a�%E�66�e5f5�$�l6E�l6B�pJ&$5�D76Bq5�67�9WU�67C�9W5�67l�9WU�(#�lDC�pK4(!@�#�"E�F5E�$*%%�&#*&@q5�

Page 15: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ���������� ������������������������������������������������ ������� �!""#$%!�$&'�&(��� �)*+�,-../�0�!'1!213456��782�� 29&2 :�"2&;$1$'<�1 ( 2 '% ��&�!< '%=�0�!�8�&2=�$'� 2"2 �!�$&'�$0�$'�1$2 %��%&'(#$%��>$����� �?81$%$!2=@0�AB18�=��&�!%��!0��� �($'!#�!'1�8#�$9!� �!8��&2$�=@�$'�"2&'&8'%$'<�C'1$!'!�#!>3D45E�F 0"$� �G80�$% �H#!8<�� 2@0�%&'% 2'0:��� �%&82�0�%&'�$'8 ��&�"2&;$1 �!�1 �'&;&�0�!'1!21�&(�2 ;$ >��&�!< '%=�0�!�8� �!'1�2 <8#!�$&'�$'� 2"2 �!�$&':�I8��<$; �<2 !��> $<����&���!��$'� 2"2 �!�$&'�8'# 00�$��$0�%# !2#=� 22&' &80345J��K3��C'1$!'!@0�L8# �M&9"!2 1��&�M� ;2&'��� N�$# �C'1$!'!@0�0�!'1!21�&(�2 ;$ >�9!=�0&8'1�%&9"!2!I# �OP.QRST:��� �1$0�$'%�$&'0�!2 �0$<'$($%!'�3445�OP.QRST�H� "�U 2&:�(&8'1�$'�V.WX:�2 Y8$2 0�M&'<2 00��&�1 # <!� ��� �!< '%=�!8��&2$�=��&�9!Z �2 <8#!�$&'0���!��!2 �"2&98#<!� 1�%&'0$0� '��>$���08%��!8��&2$�=3444�C'1$!'!�1& 0�'&��2 Y8$2 ���!��!'�!< '%=@0�$'� 2"2 �!�$&'�&(�!�0�!�8� �I �"2&98#<!� 1���2&8<��!�2 <8#!�$&':�I8��!'�!< '%=�$0�'&��" 29$�� 1��&�"2&98#<!� �!�2 <8#!�$&'�8'# 00�$��$0�!8��&2$[ 1�8'1 2��� �0�!�8� 344\���OP.QRST�2 Y8$2 0��� �?81$%$!2=��&�%&'0$1 2�>� �� 2�M&'<2 00@�$'� '��&'��� �$008 �$0�%# !2344K��C(�M&'<2 00@�$'� '��$0�%# !2:��� �%&82��!'1��� �!19$'$0�2!�$; �!< '%=�!2 �2 Y8$2 1��&�!1&"��M&'<2 00@��������������������������������������������������456�]X�_A� 0 �2$;!#�0�!'1!210�&(�2 ;$ >a�B&'#=��� �I 0�@�;03�B2 !0&'!I# �>$##�1&@a�!2 �'&��&'#=�$22 %&'%$#!I# �I8��"2&% 1�(2&9�; 2=�1$(( 2 '��;$0$&'0�&(��� �2&# �&(��� �?81$%$!2=�>$��$'�&82�%&'0�$�8�$&'!#�0%� 9 3�bCcHMd�2 <!210��� �?81$%$!2=�!0�!�;$�!#:�%&e Y8!#�I2!'%��>$��$'�&82��2$"!2�$� �0=0� 9�&(�<&; 2'9 '��>$���8#�$9!� �2 0"&'0$I$#$�=�(&2�$'� 2"2 �$'<��� �#!>3�&1!=@0�1 %$0$&':��&> ; 2:��2 !�0��� �?81$%$!2=�!0�!�I$��"#!= 2�>$���!�#$9$� 1�2&# �;$0efe;$0��� �&�� 2��>&�I2!'%� 03�&�I �082 :�?81$%$!#�9&1 0�=��!0�$�0�"#!% 3�g8��> �0�&8#1�'&��%&'(80 �9&1 0�=�>$���!I1$%!�$&'3�d82�?&I�$0��&�$'� 2"2 ���� �#!>�(8##=�!'1�(!$��(8##=a�'&�9&2 :�'&�# 003�&1!=@0�0�!'1!21�1& 0�98%��# 003�C��$0�!�0�!'1!21�>� 2 �?81$%$!#�2 ;$ >�$0�"# '!2=�$'��� &2=:�1 ( 2 '�$!#�$'�'!9 :�!'1�!�28II 20�!9"�$'�(!%�3�N �1&�'&��<$; �0$9$#!2�1 ( 2 '% ��&�&�� 2�!%�&20�>�&�>$ #1� h %8�$; �"&> 23�7&2� h!9"# :�> �!((&21�[ 2&�1 ( 2 '% ��&�"2&0 %8�$'<�!��&2' =0:�>�&� h 2%$0 �!'� 00 '�$!#�!0" %��&(��� �H�!� @0� h %8�$; �"&> 2i3jDk3�45E�]X3�_Y8&�$'<�2&8 �;3�l!2Z 2m�\n\�b3o3\1�E55:�E5K�_4JpJkk3�45J�l&2$!2$�=�;3�C'13�F "@��&(�b!�3�L 0:�44K�b3o3�K1�p4q:�p4J�_C'13�\54Jk3�445�]X3r�M� ;2&'�s3H3t3:�C'%3�;3�b!�3�L 03�F (3�M&8'%$#:�C'%3:�qp6�s3H3�EK6:�Eq\eqK�_4JEqk3�444�s3H3�;3�l !1�M&2"3:�nKK�s3H3�\4E:�!��\\pu\6�_\554k3�44\�,..�CbF3�MdFo�v�qe\\�_\54pk3�44K�OP.QRST:�qp6�s3H3�!��Eq\uqK3�

Page 16: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� ��������� !!"�#�$�%�%�&'()�*�+%,��&'�*�$�)�$�%-.�/(��0�1')�%$-���*�)%��,��)�/(2%��'�* !!3�#1��+��2%�/(%/���*�(�%-.�/('(*4��+��&'()��5�22��'��&'�*�$�)��+��%$-���*�)%��,��%/��&06*�����)7)��%��'�* !!8��9+�)���*�%�$�*���&��'��.��5����:;<=>?@�%�$�#�$�%�%6*�*�%�$%)$ !!A��:;<=>?@�7�)-��*��+��B($�&�%)0��'�$���)-�����1�.'�+��+��*�%�(��6*�2%�/(%/��%�$�C'�/)�**�'�%2��������%)��&2�%) !!D��#�$�%�%�*�-720�2''E*�%��5+��+�)��+��)�/(2%��'�*6�2%�/(%/����*�21��*�(�%-.�/('(*4�5��+'(��&'�*�$�)��/��+��%$-���*�)%��,��%/��&06*������� !!F��#1�C'�/)�**6���������*��'��&2�%)4�:;<=>?@�)�G(�)�*��+��B($�&�%)0��'�$�1�)��'��+��%/��&06*�����)7)��%��'��*'�2'�/�%*�����*�%�)�%*'�%.2��%�$�7�)-�**�.2������)7)��%��'��'1��+��*�%�(�� !HI��#��#�$�%�%4��+��B($�&�%)0��*��'�/�,��/)�%��5��/+���'��+��%/��&0�����)7)��%��'�4�(�2�**��+������)7)��%��'���*�72%��20��))'��'(*�')���&'�*�*�����5��+��+��*�%�(���')�)�/(2%��'����*�21 !H!��J+�2���+�*��*�%�$%)$*�-%0�*'(�$�*�-�2%)4��+��$�*���&��'�*�%)���-7')�%�� ��9+��1�$�)%2�B($�&�%)0�'�20�&'�*�$�)*�5+��+�)��+��%/��&06*�����)7)��%��'���*�)�%*'�%.2��%�$�7�)-�**�.2� !HH��#1�����*4�&'()�*�%)��)�G(�)�$��'�%$'7���+��%/��&06*�����)7)��%��'� !HK��#��#�$�%�%4�&'()�*�/�,��/)�%��5��/+���'��+��%/��&06*�����)7)��%��'��.(��)�-%���%.2���'�%$'7����*�'5������)7)��%��'� !H"�� :L��M>NO?@P��! �Q)�R'�%6*�S�*�')0�'1�T�1�)��&���'�U�%���Q/��&��*�� #��!F3A4��+��U(7)�-��C'()��'1�Q)�R'�%�$�&�$�$�V?;P@@P@�=L�:?>WL�:?XXNYYN?@�?Z�M>NO?@P !H3��9+��&'()��5%*�&'�*�$�)��/�%�*�%�(����������������������������������������������������!!"�[\L�!!3�U�%���<]�><L�_2%�)�, ������/�)a�!I3�b c H$�!8!4�!8D�d#�$ �!F3He �!!8�[\L�!!A�f<<�N\Lg�:;<=>?@4�"8A�h U �%��D"Hi"K �!!D�[\L�!!F�VPN>4�!I3�b c H$�%��!8D �!HI�[\L�!H!�[\L�!HH�f<<�N\ �%��D"Hi"K �!HK�[\L�!H"�f<<�VPN>4�!I3�b c H$�%��!8D �!H3�_'+%��%��, �C')7 �C'--6�4�K!K�j H$�KAF�dQ)�R �!F3Ae �

Page 17: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ���������� ������������������������������������������������ ������� �� !� "#$!$%�& �$'(� )(!*+�, %�(#-.,(&("��.�(!/.&*(0123��4�(�%� �5�(�, %� �#(&(�&($!%� �(#(!��./� �%(*�$.!�$!���(�6&$7.! �%� �(�*.!%�$�5�$.!0128��6%� �&(%59�:���(�*.5&�� ! 9+7("���(�9 !)5 )(�./���(�*.!%�$�5�$.!012;��4�(�*.5&��"(�(&#$!("��� ����(&(�,(&(��,.�-9 5%$<9(�$!�(&-&(� �$.!%�./���(�9 !)5 )(� !"���(&(/.&(���(�9 !)5 )(�, %� #<$)5.5%012=��>!���(�/.&�+?/$'(�+( &%�./�$�%�(@$%�(!*(:���(�%(*�$.!�./���(�6&$7.! �*.!%�$�5�$.!�$!�A5(%�$.!�� "�!.��<((!�*� 99(!)("01BC��6%� �&(%59�:���(�*.5&��/.5!"��� ��DE5F!$/.&#� *A5$(%*(!*(�./�#( !$!):�$/�$��$%�!.��# !$/(%�9+�(&&.!(.5%:�,$99�!.��<(�"$%�5&<("�0�0�0�0G1B1��4�(� )(!*+H%�$!�(&-&(� �$.!�./���(�%� �5�(� !"�*.!%�$�5�$.!�, %�59�$# �(9+�5-�(9"01B2���4�(�*.5&�%�*.!�$!5("��.� --9+���(�&59(�(%� <9$%�("�$!�IJKLMMLM� !"�($��(&�) '(�,($)����.� !� "#$!$%�& �$'(� )(!*+H%�9.!)?%� !"$!)�$!�(&-&(� �$.!%�./�%� �5�(%�.&�/.5!"��� ����(�$!�(&-&(� �$.!�, %�# !$/(%�9+�(&&.!(.5%01BB�>!�1=;B:���(� --(99 �(�*.5&��, %�*� &)("�,$���$!�(&-&(�$!)� �&()59 �$.!�-&.#59) �("�<+� !� "#$!$%�& �$'(� )(!*+01BN��4�(�*.5&��5�$9$7("�-.&�$.!%�./���(�&59(�(%� <9$%�("�$!�IJKLMMLM1BO� !"�*9( &9+�(%� <9$%�("���(� --&.-&$ �(�%� !" &"�./�&('$(,01B3��P$&%�:���(�*.5&��#5%��"(�(&#$!(�$/���(�&()59 �$.!�$%� #<$)5.5%01B8��>/�$��$%:���(�*.5&��#5%��9..Q� ����(�$!�(!��./���(� )(!*+��� ��-&.#59) �("���(�&()59 �$.!01B;��4�(�&(%-.!%$<$9$�+�/.&�$!�(&-&(�$!)��������������������������������������������������123�RST� ��B;C0�128�RST�12;�RST� ��B;CU;20�12=�RST� ��B;10�1BC�RST�1B1�RST� ��B;20�1B2�RST�1BB�VWW�>!"5%0�X.##H!�'0�Y &<.&�>!%0�X.0:�NN=�Z02"�1:�N�[6&$70�1=3;\�[5-�.9"$!)���(� "#$!$%�& �$'(� )(!*+H%�9.!)?%� !"$!)�$!�(&-&(� �$.!�./���(�%� �5�(\]�.9"(&�'0�_(-H��./�('(!5(:�a� �(�b"0�./�4 @�6--( 9%:�O==�Z02"�213:�22C�[6&$70�1=8=\�[&('(&%$!)���(� "#$!$%�& �$'(� )(!*+H%�$!�(&-&(� �$.!�./���(�%� �5�(�<(* 5%(�$��, %�# !$/(%�9+�(&&.!(.5%\0�1BN�c &9 &�'0�a� �(:�333�Z02"�OCN:�O1C�[6&$70�X�0�6--0�1=;B\0�1BO�RST� ��O1CU11�[��(�*.5&��/.5!"��� ����(�&()59 �$.!�, %� #<$)5.5%:� !"�"(/(&(!*(�$%�)$'(!��.� !� )(!*+H%�9.!)?%� !"$!)�$!�(&-&(� �$.!�./�$�%�&()59 �$.!%\0�1B3�RST�1B8�RST�1B;�RST� ��O1C0�

Page 18: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� ����������� �!"�" #�$��%!&��$�%'�� $(�" ����)%�*��* �+�,%-%�"(./01��2* �-!�"���* &� 3� &, ,��* �45678878�"�$ ��!�" #�$��%!&���&,�* $,��*���, 9 " &- �%��#%: &��!��&��# &-(;��$!&#<���&,%&#�%&� "=" ���%!&�!9�%���!)&�" #�$��%!&�./>?�@&�A??>B��* �C�=" ' �D!�"��!9�E"%F!&�B�%&�GHIJ587�K7LMH�N5O�PO�GHIJ587�QMRSL�5T�K7LMH�UMVOB/>/���%$%F ,�N6MPH58�9!"�������!"(�%&� "=" ���%!&.��W -��� ��* �-�� �%&:!$: ,�������!"(�%&� "=" ���%!&B��* �-!�"��* $,��*������&,�",�!9�" :% )�)���XM�85P5./>A��2* �-!�"��9!�&,��*����* ������� ����%��� ��!�Y ��'Y%#�!����&,��* &�-%� ,��!��* �� -!&,��� =� ���Y$%�* ,�%&�N6MPH58��!�-!'=$ � �%����&�$(�%�./>0��Z"!'�A??>��!�A?/[B�-�� ��-%� ,��!�GHIJ587�K7LMH��&,�N6MPH58�)* &�%&� "=" �%&#������� ���&,�" #�$��%!&���*����&��# &-(�%��-*�"# ,�)%�*� &9!"-%&#./>>��A.�\ #%�$��%: �D*�&# �%&�E"%F!&��� 2* ��*%"� &�( �"���" �]�!9��* �E"%F!&��+�,%-%�"(�="!:%,%&#�, 9 " &- ��!��,'%&%��"��%: ��# &-% ��)����!�#*���!�Y � &, ,�Y(��* �E"%F!&��$ #%�$���" �%&�A?/./>_��&�a�&��"(�/[B�A?/B���Y%$$�)���%&�"!,�- ,�%&�!��* �E"%F!&��b!�� �!9�c =" � &���%: ���*���%&� &, ,��!�'�] ��$$�d� ��%!&��!9�$�)�%&� "=" � ,�Y(��* �+�,%-%�"(B�)%�*�&!��������������������������������������������������/01�eXO����_//.�/>?�eXO�f" 9 " &-%&#�@&,��.�D!'';&�:.�b�"Y!"�@&�.�D!.B�>>1�g.A,�/B�>�fE"%F.�/1hii.�/>/�E"%F.�j�� "�D!.�:.�E"%F.�k =;��!9�j�� "�c �OB�1/�g.0,�11?B�11>B�11[�fE"%F.�A??>i.�/>A�eXO����11>.�/>0�eXO����11[.�/>>�lMM�g%'��D�(.�:.�g%'��D�(.�\�)�m&9;��n "%��C(��.�D!�&� $B�//1�g.0,�/?A[B�/?0/�fE"%F.�A??_i�f-%�%&#��!�GHIJ587�K7LMH��&,�N6MPH58�%&�9%&,%&#��*���op)q �, 9 "��!��&��# &-(;��" ��!&�Y$ �%&� "=" ���%!&��!9�%���!)&�" #�$��%!&�.ris�C� �"&��:.�E"%F.�k =;��!9�c : &� B�/0/�g.0,�/?h0B�/?hh�fE"%F.�D�.�E==.�A??hi�f-%�%&#��!�GHIJ587�K7LMH��&,�N6MPH58��!�9%&,��*����* ������� �)���-$ �"��&,��* " 9!" ��* " �)���&!�& ,��!�, 9 "��!��* ��# &-(�%&� "=" ���%!&is�C).�C�&,�t�u"�: $B�@&-.�:.�D &�.�E"%F.�j�� "�D!&� ":��%!&�k%��.B�A/A�g.0,�/B�1�fE"%F.�D�.�E==.�A??i�f-%�%&#��!�GHIJ587�K7LMH��&,�N6MPH58�%&�9%&,%&#��*���op)q ��--!",�#" ���) %#*���!��&��# &-(;��%&� "=" ���%!&�!9��* ������� ��%��%�� &�"��� ,��!��,'%&%�� ".ris�j�, �:.�E"%F.�C��� �c �.�C(�.B�01?�g.0,�[11B�?0�fE"%F.�A?/[i�f-%�%&#��!�GHIJ587�K7LMH��&,�N6MPH58�%&�9%&,%&#��*����* �$�&#��# �!9��* ������� �%��-$ �"��&,��* " 9!" �, 9 " &- ��!��* ��# &-(�%&� "=" ���%!&�%��&!��)�""�&� ,i.�/>_�lMM�b.W.�AA0B�Z%9�(�2*%",�\ #.B�C -!&,�c #.�C ��%!&�fE"%F.�A?/i�f &�-� ,i.�

Page 19: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ���������� ������������������������������������������������ ��������� �!"��#$�%�&'!'(# %#')��%*�!"'�(+,-.��/((�!#'%0012�'#�%33�% ���%(�'��#4��5'00�6%(�6 '##�!�#$��!(7 ��#4%#�#4��87�'"'% 1��'��!$#�7(��9:;<=>?�64�!�'!#� 3 �#'!*�(#%#7#�(�$ � �*70%#'$!(�#4%#�%�&'!'(# %#')��%*�!"'�(�6� ��"4% *���6'#4��!�$ "'!*+,-@��A4��5'00�6%(�)� 1�3$0'#'"%0�%!��%0#4$7*4�'#�3%((��2�'#��'��($�3 '&% '01�%0$!*�3% #1�0'!�(�'!�5$#4�#4��4$7(��%!��#4��(�!%#�2�6'#4�B�3750'"%!(��%)$ '!*�#4��5'00�%!��C�&$" %#(�$33$('!*�#4��5'00+,-D��A4��5'00�6%(�('*!���'!#$�0%6�51�E 'F$!%G(�H$)� !$ �$!�E3 '0�,,2�IJ,D2�%!��5�"%&������"#')��E7*7(#�K2�IJ,D+,-L��A4��5'00�%&�!����E 'F$!%�B�)'(���M#%#7#�(�(�"#'$!�,INL,JO/P�%!��'!"07����#4���$00$6'!*�0%!*7%*�Q�� R!�%�3 $"���'!*�5 $7*4#�51�$ �%*%'!(#�#4�� �*70%#���3% #12�#4��"$7 #�(4%00���"'���%00�S7�(#'$!(�$��0%62�'!"07�'!*�#4��'!#� 3 �#%#'$!�$��%�"$!(#'#7#'$!%0�$ �(#%#7#$ 1�3 $)'('$!�$ �%� 70��%�$3#���51�%!�%*�!"12�6'#4$7#����� �!"��#$�%!1�3 �)'$7(���#� &'!%#'$!�#4%#�&%1�4%)��5��!�&%���$!�#4��S7�(#'$!�51�#4��%*�!"1+��T$#6'#4(#%!�'!*�%!1�$#4� �0%62�#4'(�(75(�"#'$!�%330'�(�'!�%!1�%"#'$!��$ �87�'"'%0� �)'�6�$��%!1�%*�!"1�%"#'$!�#4%#�'(�%7#4$ 'F���51�0%6+,UJ��K+�V7�'"'% 1�R!#� 3 �#%#'$!�$��W�*'(0%#')��X4%!*��'!�E 'F$!%�� M'Y��%1(�%�#� �E 'F$!%�B�)'(���M#%#7#�(�(�"#'$!�,INL,J�6%(�%&�!���2�#4��M73 �&��X$7 #�$��E 'F$!%2�'!�Z[\<;=�<]�_;\>�a;\�Z>\�bcd;=�9>]2�-IK�e+K��K-D�OE 'F+�IJ,DPf�'((7���'#(��' (#���"'('$!�7#'0'F'!*�#4��!�6�(#%!�% ���$7!��'!�#4��(#%#7#�+,U,��A4��"%(��4%���$7 �$3'!'$!(Q�#4��$3'!'$!�$��#4��"$7 #�O4� �'!%�#� �&%8$ '#1�$3'!'$!P2,UI��������������������������������������������������,-.�gh]�,-@�gh]�,-D�Z;;�i'00�M#%#7(�R!S7' 1��$ �j+�i+�IIKD2�IJ,D�E 'F+�M�((+�W%6(2�4##3(Qkk%33(+%F0�*+*$)ki'00M#%#7(ki'00l)� )'�6k@JJ,UPm�j$7(��$��B�3 �(�!#%#')�(�n�&5� (�B$(#� 2�IJ,D�E 'F+�M�((+�W%6(2�4##3(Qkk666+%F0�*+*$)kn�&5� B$(#� k�o5$�1pj+�,-L�EBRq+�B/r+�MAEA+�ETT+�s�,INL,JO/P�OIJ,IP+�,UJ�gh]�,U,�Z;;�M'0)� �)+�e7�50$�C�0�M$0�t%#� �X$+2�-IK�e+K��K-D�OE 'F+�IJ,DP+�,UI�gh]�%#�KU,u.,�OW$3�F2�V+2�8$'!���51�i 7#'!�02�r'"��X+V+m�A'&&� 2�H$70�2�VV+P+�

Page 20: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� �������� � ���!��!"## �$� ����#%���&�& ''(�%� ����#%�)*+�,('��� � ��-./012���'(!��&��� � ���!��!"## �$� ����#%���&�& ''(�% �$� ����#%�)*+�, !3��� � ��-./014���&������ � ���!��!"## �$� ��%5(���#% �,�& ''(�%'�)*6(,��&(#��� � ��-.7011��85(�!�'(� �9�,9(&� �%(#�#(%�% ����:���'%�%"%(�%5�%�����&; � '%#�% 9(��$(�!<�=�'�!5�#$(&�= %5�(�:�#! �$701>��?�(! : !�,,</�%5(�!�"#%�=�'�&(%(#; � �$�%5(�;(�� �$��:�%5(�%(#;�*,($�,,<��9� ,�@,(7-01A���85(�;�B�# %<��� � ���,��3(&��%�%5(�'%�%"%(�%��&(%(#; �(�=5(%5(#�%5(�%(#;�*,($�,,<��9� ,�@,(-�=�'��;@ $"�"'701C��D��: �& �$�%5�%� %�=�'��;@ $"�"'/�%5(�;�B�# %<��� � ���,��3(&�%��'(!��&�#<�%��,'��:�'%�%"%�#<�!��'%#"!% ���%�� ''"(� %'�&(! ' ��701E��85(�'�(! : !�'(!��&�#<�%��,�%5�%�=�'��# ;�# ,<�"'(&�=�'�:�"�&� ����!�����(F�,� �(&� ����@��3�!��"%5�#(&�@<�G"'% !(�?!�, �70>H��*I!!�#& �$�%��%5�%�!����/� :���'%�%"%(�"'('�=�#&'��#��5#�'('�%5�%�5�9(��,#(�&<�#(!( 9(&�7�7�7�"� :�#;�!��'%#"!% ���@<�7�7�7���#('���' @,(��&; � '%#�% 9(��$(�!</�%5(<��#(�%��@(�"�&(#'%��&��!!�#& �$�%��%5�%�!��'%#"!% ��7-0>0��85 '�,��$"�$(�'�"�&'�9(#<�' ; ,�#�%��%5(�#",(�('%�@, '5(&� ��JKLMNNMNO0>P�5�=(9(#/�%5(#(� '����! %�% ���%��JKLMNNMN��#���<��%5(#�I# Q����!�'(�,�=�('%�@, '5(&����%5(��#(; '(��:�%5(�JKLMNNMN�'%��&�#&70>2��D�'%(�&/�%5(�;�B�# %<��� � ���! %('�%��%=��!�'('�:#�;�%5(�R7?7�?"�#(;(�S�"#%�%5�%����,<�%5 '�!�������&�$ 9(�$#(�%�=( $5%�%��%5(�,��$'%��& �$� �%(#�#(%�% ��'��:�'%�%"%('�@<�����$(�!<�!5�#$(&�= %5� %'�(�:�#!(;(�%70>4��85(�#(!(�%��;(�&;(�%'�%��I# Q����T(9 '(&�?%�%"%('�'(!% ���0PUE0H�=(#(�@# (:,<��&&#(''(&�@<�%5(�;�B�# %<��� � ��70>1���������������������������������������������������012�VWX��%�2>0Y>>�)+�,('/�S7G7O�B� �(&�@<�6(,��&(#/�G7/�!��!"## �$� ����#%���&�& ''(�% �$� ����#%.7�014�VWX��%�2>>Y>E�)+�, !3/�G7O�B� �(&�@<�6(,��&(#/�G7/�!��!"## �$� ����#%���&�& ''(�% �$� ����#%.7�011�VWX��%�2>EYAH�)6(,��&(#/�G7/�!��!"## �$� ����#% �,�& ''(�%'.7�01>�VWX��%�2147�01A�VWX��%�2107�01C�VWX��%�2117�01E�VWX�0>H�VWX�0>0�VWX�0>P�+�5������97�S�#�7�S�;;Z�/�202�67P&�2AE/�2CP�)I# Q7�0E1A.7�0>2�[\]_/�4P2�672&��%�2117�0>4�VWX��0>1�VWX��%�21>7�

Page 21: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ���������� ������������������������������������������������ ��������� !"#$%&'�(#)*+�&�!&�!,&�#)-��&���! �*+ �*&�+%+�*#&�!,,#.�&���")+%/%!$'�&#�-%0��+�(�$�*/��&#�!*�!-�*/'�%*&�$1$�&!&%#*�#(�!�2&!&)&�3�%&�+%+�*#&�1$#�%4%&�&���,�-%2,!&)$��($# �!+#1&%*-�!*�!-�*/'52�%*&�$1$�&!&%#*�#(�&���,!*-)!-��%*�6)�2&%#*7899��:�$�3�&���,�-%2,!&)$��!+#1&�+�&���!-�*/'52�%*&�$1$�&!&%#*�#(�;,�-!,,'�!0!%,!4,�<�!*+�!2�!�$�2),&3�&��� !"#$%&'�#1%*%#*�),&% !&�,'�)1��,+�&���!-�*/'52�%*&�$1$�&!&%#*�#(�&���2&!&)&�789=�����>!,�2�#1%*%#*�+�&�$ %*�+�&�!&�&���&�$ �;,�-!,,'�!0!%,!4,�<�.!2�*#&�! 4%-)#)2�!*+�(#)*+�&�!&�&��� !"#$%&'�#1%*%#*�;26)%*&2�&#�(%*+�2&!&)&#$'�! 4%-)%&'7<89?��@%0�*�&���1,!%*�,!*-)!-��#(�&���2&!&)&�3�*#�()$&��$�!*!,'2%2�#(�&���2&!&)&��.!2�*�/�22!$'789A��B*�!++$�22%*-�&���! �*+�+�,!*-)!-��%*�C$%D#*!�E�0%2�+�F&!&)&�2�2�/&%#*�8GHA8I3�&���>!,�2�#1%*%#*�(%*+2�&�!&�&��� !"#$%&'�#1%*%#*52�%*&�$1$�&!&%#*�#(�&���*�.�2&!&)&�� %22�2�&����*&%$��1#%*&�#(�&���! �*+ �*&278=I��J)2&%/��>!,�2�!2�!2K2�&���$��&#$%/!,�6)�2&%#*L��;B(�%&�%2�#4"�/&%#*!4,��&#�/�+��&���1#.�$�&#�%*&�$1$�&�2&!&)&�2�#$�$),�2�&#�!*�!-�*/'3�%2*5&�%&��0�*� #$��#4"�/&%#*!4,��&#�/�+��&#�!*�!-�*/'�7�7�7�&���0�$'�1#.�$�&#�1!22�2&!&)&�2�4'�%*(�$$%*-3�($# �,�-%2,!&%0��2%,�*/�3�!*�%*&�*&�&#��*!/&�1$��M%2&%*-�!-�*/'�$�-),!&%#*2N<8=8��B*�!*2.�$%*-��%2�#.*�6)�2&%#*3�J)2&%/��>!,�2�+�&�$ %*�2�&�!&�&��� !"#$%&'�#1%*%#*��!2�/# 4%*�+�;+�(�$�*/��!*+�+�,�-!&%#*�.%&��!�0�*-�!*/�7<8=G��O%K��&���>!,�2�#1%*%#*3�&���>#,%/K�#1%*%#*�(%*+2�&���&�$ �;,�-!,,'�!0!%,!4,�<�&#�4��)*! 4%-)#)278=P��C�/#*/�$*�%2�$!%2�+�%*�&���>#,%/K�#1%*%#*�.%&��&��� !"#$%&'�#1%*%#*52�)2��#(�#*,'�#*��#(�&�$���/!*#*2�!0!%,!4,��(#$�2&!&)&#$'�/#*2&$)/&%#*78=Q������(%$2&�/!*#*�%2�&�!&�!�&�M&)!,,'�1�$ %22%4,��%*&�$1$�&!&%#*�&�!&�()$&��$2�$!&��$�&�!*�#42&$)/&2�&�!&�2&!&)&�52�1)$1#2��2�#),+�4��(!0#$�+78=R������2�/#*+�/!**#*�%2�%*&�*+�+�&#�1$�0�*&�*#&�#*,'�&���+%2$�-!$+�#(�!�1$#0%2%#*3�4)&�!,2#�!*��������������������������������������������������899�STU�89=�STU�89?�STU�!&�P9G�V>!,�23�J73�/#*/)$$%*-�%*�1!$&�!*+�+%22�*&%*-�%*�1!$&W7�89A�STU��8=I�STU�!&�P9P7�8=8�STU�8=G�STU�8=P�STU�!&�P99�V>#,%/K3�J7�/#*/)$$%*-�%*�1!$&�!*+�+%22�*&%*-�%*�1!$&W7�8=Q�STU�!&�P9=7�8=R�STU�

Page 22: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� �������� ���!��"���#!�����$��%���� "���&�%%'()*��+#���#��$�,!�"���%��#��"����#!���%���&��$�- "��./��#��0!1"���/'())��+#��2"&�,3�" ���"��4-�%��"�%�#"5�6!���#���#��$�,!�"��%#"-&$�&"7�,!&&/��8���$'()9��:%�!���8!0 &�;��#��,"-��� "%�%�!�4-�%��"��"6�5#��#����#��,"-���%#"-&$�7�<��5��7#���"��#��!7��,/;��6���%�&"�7=���0��-&��5!%�6"���#��>���,�"���"�$����0����&�7!&�!<!�&!.�&��/�./��!���7�!�1�&&/�%!�$5�,#'()?��@.<�"-%&/;�!�,"-���%#"-&$��"��7�<��5��7#���"��#!��0��#"$"&"7/;�.-��"���#��%,!&��"6�!.%-�$��/;�#"5�6!��$"�%��#�� ��"��,"�%��-,��"��,!�"���8���$A(9B��+#��2"&�,3�" ���"��!�!&/C�%��#�����0�-%��7��#��6��%���5"�,!�"�%'(9(��D��!&%"�!$$��%%�%��#��!0��$0���%��"�:��C"�!�E�<�%�$�F�!�-��%�%�,��"��(G=?(B�!�$�6��$%��#!���"�$�6����,��"��5��7#��%#"-&$�.��7�<����"�!��!7��,/H%������ ���!��"��"6�!�%�!�-��'(9G��I�<����#��!0��$0���%��"�:��C"�!�E�<�%�$�F�!�-��%�%�,��"��(G=?(B;�J-%��,��2"&�,3��%�"6��#��" ���"���#!���#���#��$�,!�"��"6�,"�%��-,��"��0-%��/��&$��"��#��6��%���5"'(9K�+#��L�&!�$���" ���"��,"�,-�%�5��#��#��2!&�%�" ���"�H%�<��5�"6��#�����0�M&�7!&&/�!<!�&!.&�N�!%�-�!0.�7-"-%'(9O��:%%-0��7;�#"5�<��;��#!���#�����0��%�!0.�7-"-%;��#��L�&!�$���" ���"��,"�,-�%�5��#��#��2"&�,3�" ���"��"��%�!�-�"�/�,"�%��-,��"�'(9P��+#��L�&!�$���" ���"���#���,!&&%�6"���#��&�7�%&!�-����"���5������#��%�!�-����6��#��0!1"���/�" ���"���%���,"���,��"���#��&�7�%&!�-��H%�0�!���7�"6��#�����0�M&�7!&&/�!<!�&!.&�'N(9*��O'�:��C"�!H%�E-&��Q"0 !��$��"�RSTUVWX���������������������������������������������������()*�YZ[�())�YZ[�()9�YZ[�()?�YZ[�(9B�YZ[�(9(�YZ[�!��K*9\*?'�(9G�YZ[�(9K�YZ[�!��K*9'�(9O�YZ[�!��K*?�]L�&!�$��;�J'�,"�,-����7�����#�� !���!&�$�%%���%'�(9P�YZ[�(9*�YZ[�!��K)B'�

Page 23: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ����������� ������������������������������������ ��������������� ���������� !"#$%�&'(!)!% *��%+�',!-!"�(�./01234�5��$�!$,� 6 �,!$7�%),+�#8�9#$7 �++:;<=��>,�� �,�%$�,�%,?�,���+,%$(% (�!$�� !"#$%�!+�%�@*+,� *:���8,� �� !"#$%A+�B#C� $# �+!7$�(�,���D!--�,�%,�%@�$(�(�� !"#$%�E�C!+�(�F,%,',�+�+�),!#$�;GHI;J?�!,�+��@�(�%+�!8�,�� ��5#'-(�D��+#@��@%&# �)�%$7�+�!$�,���5%*�,�%,�,���&'(!)!% *� '-�(�#$�)%+�+�!$C#-C!$7�%7�$)*�!$,� 6 �,%,!#$�#8�!,+�+,%,',�+:��K�+6!,��,�%,?�,���@%&# !,*�#6!$!#$�!$�LMN102�(!(�$#,�',!-!"��� !"#$%�E�C!+�(�F,%,',�+�+�),!#$�;GHI;J�%+�#$��@!7�,��O6�),?�7!C�$�,���)-�% �-%$7'%7��#8�,���+,%,',�:;<<��P$+,�%(?�,���@%&# !,*�#6!$!#$�',!-!"�(�)%$#$+�#8�+,%,',# *�)#$+, '),!#$�%$(�)!,�(�,#�%�D##Q�)#%',�# �(�D*�R'+,!)��F)%-!%�,#�&'+,!8*�,���6#+!,!#$�#8�6 #C!(!$7�(�8� �$)��,#�%$�%7�$)*A+�-#$7H+,%$(!$7�!$,� 6 �,%,!#$�#8�%�+,%,',�:;<I���� PPP:���ST�UV�VET�>U�.WXYZ[\�� ]��./01234�_4�L0a_2_bM34�3c�d3e02f��� ����6#-!)*� �%+#$�,#�&'+,!8*�,���8!$(!$7�!$�./01234��!$7�(�#$�,���)#$)�6,�#8�+�6% %,!#$�#8�6#5� +:;IJ������,��# *�5%+�,�%,�,���6#-!,!)%-�D %$)��+�#8�7#C� $@�$,�% �� �+6#$+!D-��,#�%�)#$+,!,'�$)*:;I;����%,�)#$+,!,'�$)*�!$8-'�$)�+�6� +#$%-�6#-!)*� �%+#$+�8# �+,%,',# *�)�%$7�:;IG���7�$)!�+?�!$�)% *!$7�#',�%�+,%,',���$%),�(�D*�9#$7 �++?�)#$+!(� �,��� %@!8!)%,!#$+�#8�,���+,%,',��%,�%�(��6� �-�C�-:;Ig��P8�,���)#$+,!,'�$)*�(#�+�$#,�-!Q��,���+,%,',��# �,��� %@!8!)%,!#$+�#8�,���+,%,',�?�,���6�#6-��)%$��-�),�$�5�-�%(� +�,#�,��+��,5#�6#-!,!)%-�D %$)��+�,#�)�%$7��,���%7�$(%:;Ih����!+�!+�$#,�, '��#8�,���8�(� %-�&'(!)!% *:;Ii������&'(!)!% *�(#�+�$#,��%C��%�)#$+,!,'�$)*�%$(��%+�%�(',*�,#� �+6�),�,���-�7!,!@%,��6#-!)*�)�#!)�+�#8�,���6#-!,!)%-�D %$)��+��������������������������������������������������;<=�T%,#$�C:�� !":�S�%-,��9% ��9#+,�9#$,%!$@�$,�F*+:?�=I�j:g(�;Jhh?�;Jh<�k� !":�9,:��66:�GJJgl:�;<<�L00�LMN102?�hGg�j:g(�%,�gihmiin�� !":�E�C:�F,%,�o�;GmI;J�kGJ;<l:�;<I�LMN102?�hGg�j:g(�%,�gihmip:�;IJ�9��C #$�V:F:�:?�P$):�C:�q%,:�E�+:�K�8:�9#'$)!-?�P$):?�hp=�V:F:�<g=?�<phmpp�k;I<hl:�;I;�r�%,�<pi:�;IG�r�;Ig�r�;Ih�r�;Ii�r�

Page 24: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� ��������� !"# "$%&'(��)*�+ �,*�-, +.�*�/ � !.�#0+$�1 �2 �-$-#3$ .�/*-,*�$* �405-,-3!6�02$-#3$ 26�5 $ !#-" +%&'7��8 ��! �39926-"��:;<=>?@�5 � ! ", �$��$* �3� ",6.�$* �,�0!$�#0+$��-!+$�5 $ !#-" �$*3$�$* �+$3$0$ �-+�3#1-�0�0+.�-"��$* !�/�!5+.�$* �+$3$0$ �*3+�#�! �$*3"��" �# 3"-"�%&'A��B�405� �,�025�1 �$ #9$ 5�$��923, �3"�-"$ !9! $3$-�"��"�3�+$3$0$ �$*3$�-+�13+ 5�09�"�9 !+�"32�9�2-,6�9! � ! ", +.�10$�:;<=>?@�2-#-$+�$*3$�9�/ !�/-$*-"�$* �405-,-3!6%&''��C"+$ 35.�:;<=>?@�! D0-! +�$*3$�3�405� �5 $ !#-" �-��$* �3� ",6E+�-"$ !9! $3$-�"�-+�13+ 5��"�3�9 !#-++-12 �,�"+$!0,$-�"����$* �+$3$0$ %FGG��C��$* �-"$ !9! $3$-�"�-+�! 3+�"312 .�$* �,�0!$�*3+�3�50$6�$��! +9 ,$�3� ",6�-"$ !9! $3$-�"�3"5�2 3� �$* �9�2-,6�#3H-"��-"�$* �*3"5+����$* �9�2-$-,32�1!3",* +�$*3$�*3� �3�,�"+$-$0 ",6%FG&���I*-2 �$* �5�,$!-" ����+ 93!3$-�"����9�/ !+�#-�*$�*3� � +$312-+* 5�:;<=>?@.�-$�#-�*$�$���1 �-$+�02$-#3$ �5 #-+ %��C"�FG&J.�K0+$-, �L,32-3�-++0 5�$* ��9-"-�"����$* �M�0!$�-"�NOP;OQR@�=S�TUV%FGF��)* �M�0!$�0$-2-W 5�:;<=>?@.�10$�! ,��"-W 5�$*3$�XY Z� "�0"5 !�$*-+�5 � ! "$-32�+$3"53!5�%�%�%�3� ",- +�#0+$��9 !3$ �/-$*-"�$* �1�0"5+����! 3+�"312 �-"$ !9! $3$-�"%[FG\��C"�39926-"��:;<=>?@.�$* �M�0!$���0"5�$*3$�$* �$ !#�X399!�9!-3$ [�$��1 �3#1-�0�0+�3"5�$0!" 5�$��/* $* !�$* �3� ",6�#35 �3�! 3+�"312 �-"$ !9! $3$-�"����$* �$ !#%FG]��)* �M�0!$�02$-#3$ 26���0"5�$*3$�$* �3� ",6�X+$!36 5��3!�1 6�"5[�-$+�1�0"5+�3"5.�$* ! ��! .�$* �-"$ !9! $3$-�"�/3+�"�$�! 3+�"312 %FGJ��C"�5�-"��+�.�$* �M�0!$�0$-2-W 5�:;<=>?@.�10$�32+��90$�2-#-$+��"�$* �3� ",6%��)* �M�0!$�#35 �-$�,2 3!�$*3$�:;<=>?@�5-5�"�$�+$3"5���!�$* �9! #-+ �$*3$�3�X$- ��� +�$��$* �3� ",6.[FG(�3+�$* �L09! # �M�0!$����C"5-3"3�+0�� +$+.�1 ,30+ �$* �M�0!$E+�! +9�"+-1-2-$6.�0"5 !�$* ��������������������������������������������������&'(�_S�3$�A((%�&'7�_S�3$�A]F%�&'A�_S�3$�A]\%�&''�_S��FGG�_S�FG&�_S�3$�A((%�FGF�-,*-�3"��%�abB.�&\J�L%�M$%�F(''.�F(''�cFG&Jd%��FG\�_S�3$�F7G7�c,-$-"��$��e$-2%�B-!�f �023$�!6�g!�09��%�abB.�J7\�e%L%�\GF.�\F&�cFG&]dd�c-"$ !"32�D0�$3$-�"�#3!H+��#-$$ 5dd%�FG]�NOP;OQR@�=S�TUV.�&\J�L%�M$%�3$�F7G7%�FGJ�_S�3$�F7GA%�FG(�h<<�iCbLMj�C"50+%�g!9%��%�i%�C"5%�b01%�L !�%�M�%.�&GG�i%a%\5�F\].�F]&�cC"5%�FG&Ad%�

Page 25: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ���������� ������������������������������������������������ ��������� !�"#�� $%&%�'"(�"#�$") &�*�& +,'& -�'���"�- � &!'( �). �. &��. �%/ (0�1��'(� &$& �%�'"(�)%��& %�"(%23 4567���8,��'0 �9."!%��)&"� �%�0"!$ 33'(/�0"(0,&&'(/�"$'('"(�'(�:;<=;>?@�AB�CDE456F��G(�'�*�8,��'0 �9."!%��&%'� ��0"(0 &(��)'�.�). �. &�H=IAJK@��%L ���. �M,-'0'%&�1��& �$"(�'2'3'�' ��"#�'(� &$& �'(/��. �3%)�%(-�/'N ��'���"��. � O 0,�'N 456P��8,��'0 �9."!%��("� ���.%���. �M,-'0'%&��'��0.%&/ -�)'�.��. �& �$"(�'2'3'���"#� O &0'�'(/�'(- $ (- (��3 /%3�M,-/! (��). (�'(� &$& �'(/���%�,� �*�%(-�H=IAJK@�& +,'& ���. �M,-'0'%&���"�Q%2%(-"(�).%���. ��2 3' N �'��R�. �2 ���& %-'(/�"#�%(�%!2'/,",����%�,� 1S�'(�#%N"&�"#�%(�%/ (0�1��0"(��&,0�'"(45T6��9.'��)%��("��M,���%2",��/'N'(/�$") &�2%0L��"��. �M,-'0'%&�*�2 0%,� �. �%3�"�&%'� -�%�0"(0 &(�)'�.�U"(/& ���- 3 /%�'(/�'���3 /'�3%�'N �& �$"(�'2'3'�' ���"�%(� O 0,�'N �2&%(0.�%/ (0�45TT��G#��. �U",&��$ &!'���H=IAJK@��"�0"(�'(, *�'��!,���2 �)'33'(/��"�$ &!'��%(� (�'���"�. &��.%(�U"(/& ����"� O &0'� �3 /'�3%�'N �$") &�*�'(�-'& 0��N'"3%�'"(�"#��. �V('� -�W�%� ��U"(��'�,�'"(45T5��9. �2'// &�0"(0 &(�#"&�8,��'0 �9."!%��)%���.%���. �%/ (0��Q# 3���,##'0' (�3�� !2"3- ( -�4�4�4��"�!%L ��. �2'-�#"&�- # & (0 ��.%��'��-'-�. & S5TX�%(-��.%���. �M,-'0'%&��Q� !Y -Z��"�2 ���&%�'(/�#,&�. &�%(-�#,&�. &�#&"!��. �U"(��'�,�'"(�)'�.",���"�!,0.�%��$%,�'(/��"�%�L�).�4S5T[��9"�8,��'0 �9."!%�*�'��)",3-�2 �$&,- (��#"&��. �U",&���"�0"(�'- &��. �U"(��'�,�'"(�2 #"& �/'N'(/�- # & (0 ��"�%(��"�. &�%/ (0��'(� &$& �%�'"(�"#���%�,� �45T\�8,��'0 �]"&�,0.�&%'� -��'!'3%&�0"(0 &(��'(�56T�). (�. �)%��"(��. �V4W4�U",&��"#�_$$ %3�*�9 (�.�U'&0,'�45T��G(�ab;IJJIcdeJ;caIf?�AB�gh@<=*�8,��'0 �]"&�,0.�)&"� ��. �"$'('"(�"#��. �0",&�*�2,��%3�"�)&"� �%�0"(0,&&'(/�"$'('"(45T7��9. �0%� �'(N"3N -�%(�%-!'('��&%�'N �%/ (0��'(� &$& �'(/�%���%�,� �"( �)%��'(�566\�%(-�%�-'## & (��)%��'(�566745TF���������������������������������������������������567�:;<=;>?@�AB�CDE*�TX\�W4�U�4�%��576PiT54�56F�jkB�%��57T5�l9."!%�*�84*�0"(0,&&'(/m4�56P�jkB�%��57T5iTX4�5T6�jkB�%��57T54�5TT�jkB�%��57TX4�5T5�jkB�%��57T5�l0'�'(/��"�V4W4�UnoW94*�%&�4�G4*�p�Tm4�5TX�jkB�%��57TX4�5T[�jkB�5T\�jkB�%��57T[4�5T�qII�],�' && rst&'r, 3%�N4�u�(0.*�FX[�v4X-�TT[5*�TT[54�5T7�jkB�%��TT[X*�TT[P4�5TF�jkB�%��TT[[4�

Page 26: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� �������� !�"#$#"�%� �!&�'"#"�($�")*�+,���"�-"!���. #/( ��+"/%(&"���"�&�%�(�"�'%&�%0+ 1(�(&�%!*���"�%1"!/,�0%*"�%�#"%&�!%+)"� !�"#$#"�%� �!��2���"�&�%�(�"3456��-�"�$#�+)"0� !��� &�/%&"��%$$"!"*�'�"!���"�%1"!/,�&�(1������%$$),���"�4778� !�"#$#"�%� �!�#"�#�%/� 9"),�($�!�$"#&�!&�'����%*�#") "*:������" #�*"�# 0"!�:��!���"�477;� !�"#$#"�%� �!3447��-�"��$ ! �!��2���"�/�(#���")*���%��%!�%*0 ! &�#%� 9"�%1"!/,�/%!!���$#�0()1%�"�%*0 ! &�#%� 9"�#()"&�%!*�%$$),���"0�#"�#�%/� 9"),3445��<� !1�&��#% &"&�$��"!� %)�9 �)%� �!&��2�*("�$#�/"&&444�%!*�"=(%)�$#��"/� �!344>�?(&� /"�@�#&(/�A&�/�!/(## !1��$ ! �!�*"%)��) ��)"�' �����"�#"�#�%/� 9"�%$$) /%� �!��2���"� !�"#$#"�%� �!��2���"�&�%�(�"�%!*�0�#"�' �����"�/�!/"#!&�2�#�&"$%#%� �!��2�$�'"#&���%��BCDEFGH��%*�/#"%�"*� !��� &�& �(%� �!344I��?(&� /"�@�#&(/��/%))&��� &���"�J")"$�%!�� !���"�#��0K�%!*�/�!& *"#&�'�"��"#� �� &�� 0"����J2%/"���"�+"�"0���3K44;��L)���(1��!���&$"/ 2 /%)),�&�%�"*:���"�+"�"0������%���%&�+""!�/#"%�"*� &���"�"M"/(� 9"�+#%!/����#�(1��%*0 ! &�#%� 9"�%1"!/ "&3��-�"�9 �)%� �!&�'"#"�0�#"�"1#"1 �(&� !�NOPQDFFDRSTFQRODUV���%!���",�'"#"� !�WQXCQYVH�EZ�[\]344��<"&$ �"���%�:���"�/�!/"#!&�#% &"*�'"#"�& 0 )%#������"�/�!/"#!&�#% &"*�+,�?(&� /"�-��0%&3448��?(&� /"�@�#&(/��'%&�/�!/"#!"*���%��BCDEFGH��%*�%))�'"*�%*0 ! &�#%� 9"�%1"!/ "&�����9"#�%_"�$�'"#&�&$"/ 2 /%)),�9"&�"*������"�(* / %)�%!*�)"1 &)%� 9"�+#%!/�"&��2�1�9"#!0"!�344a��?(&� /"�@�#&(/��%#�2()),�"M$)% !&�� &�/�!/"#!&�' �����"�"M"/(� 9"�+#%!/��%/� !1� !�%�(* / %)�/%$%/ �,b���������������������������������������������������456�cdZ�447�cdZ�%��55I3�445�cdZ�%��55Ia3�444�cdZ�%��55I�e2 !* !1���%����"#"�'%&�!��!�� /"��2���"� !�"#$#"�%� �!��2���"�)%'���%����"�%1"!/,�&�(1������%$$),f3�44>�cdZ�eJghi2���"�%1"!/,�'"#"�2#""����/�%!1"���"�)%'�#"�#�%/� 9"),�+%&"*��!�&� 2� !1�$�) � /%)�' !*&:� ��/�()*�(&"���%��$�'"#����$(! &��$�) � /%)),�* &2%9�#"*�1#�($&��#� !* 9 *(%)&�2�#�/�!*(/����",�/%!�!��)�!1"#�%)�"#3Kf3�44I�cdZ�%��55I6�e@�#&(/�:�?3:�/�!/(## !1f3�44;�cdZ�44�jDD�QdZ�%��55IIk�l /� 1%!�93�mnL:�5>;�o3�.�3�466:�487Ip7�e475;f3��448�@(� "##"qr�# q(")%�93�s,!/�:�a>I�t3>*�55I4:�55I6p;a�e57���. #3�475fk�l /� 1%!�93�mnL:�5>;�o3�.�3�%��4854p5I3�44a�NOPQDFFDRSTFQRODUV:�a>I�t3>*�%��55;7p;53�

Page 27: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ���������� ������������������������������������������������ �������� !�"� !#$""%� &!'(�$) !#� &�*�+,�# �-!+"$#!-� &!�* $ � !*.�/!$'�'0�$'-��**�!-�$�)�'$"�-!+�*�,'(�$'�!1!+� �2!�$0!'+%�3$*�4!#/� !-� ,�5$'-�-�-6� !""��*� ,�#!2!#*!�,�#�-!+�*�,'�"�7!�*,/!�*,# �,)�*�4!#�+,�# �,)�$44!$"*8�9)� &$ �-,!*'. �:�$"�)%�$*�$'��'+,'* � � �,'$"�#!2�*�,'�,)�$�;�-�+�$"�-!+"$#$ �,'�,)� &!�"$3�<%�$�4,"� �+$"�<#$'+&(�9�+,')!**�9�<!0�'� ,�3,'-!#�3&! &!#�3!.2!�),#0, !'�3&$ �/�0& 8==>�� ?&�*�"$'0�$0!�*$%*�� �$""8��@&!'� &!�$-/�'�* #$ �2!�$0!'+%��*�4#,2�-!-�3� &�*,�/�+&�4,3!#(� &!�+,'*!:�!'+!*�$#!�2�,"$ �,'*�,)�-�!�4#,+!**�$'-�!:�$"�4#, !+ �,'8=AB��?&!�+&!+7*�$'-�<$"$'+!*� &$ � &!�;�-�+�$#%�4#,2�-!�,'� &!�!1!+� �2!�!'*�#!� &$ � &,*!�2�,"$ �,'*�$#!�"�/� !-8=AC��?&!�;�-�+�$#%��*�-!*�0'!-� ,�",,7�$ �$�"$3�3� &�$�-�))!#!' �4!#*4!+ �2!�$'-� #$'*)!##�'0� &$ �4,3!#� ,� &!�!1!+� �2!�+,/!*�$ �$�+,* 8��?&$ �+,* �&$*�<!!'�3!""�-,+�/!' !-� &#,�0&,� �&�* ,#%�3� &�$'�!1!+� �2!��' !#4#! �'0�"$3*� &$ �$#!��'+"!$#�$'-��*�'0� &!/� ,� &!�#�$-2$' $0!� ,�!14",� �� *�+� �D!'*8=A=�?&!�+,'+!#'�3� &� &!�!1!+� �2!�4#,+�#�'0�"!0�*"$ �2!�4,3!#*��*�!:�$""%�+,'+!#'�'0� ,�E�* �+!�F,#*�+&8=AA��G@&!'� &!�4,"� �+$"�<#$'+&!*�-�*$0#!!�3� &�$�;�-�+�$"��' !#4#! $ �,'�,)�!1�* �'0�"$3(� &!�H,'* � � �,'�4#!*+#�<!*� &!�$44#,4#�$ !�#!/!-�$"�4#,+!**8��9 .*�+$""!-�"!0�*"$ �,'8I=AJ��@&�"!�/$'%�<!"�!2!� &$ � &!�"!0�*"$ �2!�4#,+!**��*�"$<,#�,�*(�E�* �+!�F,#*�+&�<!"�!2!*� &$ � &�*��*� &!�4�#4,*!�,)� &!�+,'* � � �,'$"�-!*�0'(� &!�#!$*,'�),#� &#!!�<#$'+&!*�,)�0,2!#'/!' (�$'-� &!�#!$*,'�3&%�$""� &#!!�<#$'+&!*�&$2!��'�:�!�#!*4,'*�<�"� �!*8=AK�� LM��NOPPQRP�STQU�VWO�XVYVOP��C8��H&$'0!�3� &�Z�#4,*!����������������������������������������������������==>�[\M�$ �CCKB8�=AB�[\M�$ �CCKC8�=AC�[\M�=A=�[\M�=AA�[\M�=AJ�[\M�=AK�[\M�

Page 28: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� ������� !"�!#��"$%�&��'�(!�)�*%%�#���)�%%�#+*#�#+���!%&�,�!'#*!#�-'�,+*!.�/��0+*!.�'�-!�#+���1�,2#-���3 -!.�,+*!.�'�-!�*.�!4*/��0+*!.�'�-!�%�.-'%*#� '�3 -!.�,+*!.�'�#��#+��'#*#2#�/��0+*!.�'�#��#+��'#*#2#���5#�!�3 -!.�!�)�,*'��%*)�-!#� $ �#-!.�#+�'��'#*#2#�'/��0+*!.�'�#��'#*#2#��*!4�,*'��%*)�"�*!�"�%4-!.�#+��*.�!4*�* �2!4�#+�'��,+*!.�'/��6+��,- ,%��-'�)�%%�)� !�3&�#+��%�!.7%-��4�.��� !"�!#��"$%�&��/��8#�-'�*%'��)�%%�(!�)!�#+*#�#����5#�!�,+*!.��92'#� �:2- �'�$��$%��#��+�%4�#+�- �'�*#�*!4�)*-#�5� �-#�#��2!5�%4/�;%%�#+ ���'#*#�'�+*���+*4�,+*!.��#��-#'�'#*!4* 4��5� ��-�)�5� �-!#� $ �#-!.�'#*#2#�'�*!4� �.2%*#-�!'�#+*#�*!�*.�!,&�-'�,+* .�4�)-#+��!5� ,-!./<=>��6+��,+*!.��-!�?�%*)* ��)*'�,%�*!�*!4�4�5-!�4/<=@��A�"��"-.+#�%-(��-#B�'�"��"-.+#�!�#B�32#�*#�%�*'#�#+� ��-'�%-##%��,�!52'-�!�*3�2#�-#/<=C��8#�-'��� &�,%�* �#+*#�#+�� ��-�)�-'�$%�!* &B�*!4�#+��924-,-* &�4��'�!�#�.-���4�5� �!,��#��*.�!,&�-!#� $ �#*#-�!'��5�#+��'#*#2#�'�-#��!5� ,�'/<=D��E!�#+���#+� �+*!4B�#+��,+*!.��-!�8!4-*!*�*!4�; -F�!*�)-%%� �:2- ��"� ��4�5-!-#-�!/��G� ��1*"$%�B�-!�8!4-*!*B�HIJKLM�*$$�* �4�#��,+*!.��#+��'#*!4* 4��'#*3%-'+�4�-!�NOP�KQRRS/<TU��V�)��� B�HIJKLMWX�%*,(��5� �5� �!,��#��NOP�KQRRSB�*%%�)�4�#+��,�2 #�-!�YZ[\][\Q�#��,�!,%24��#+*#�HIJKLM�+*4�!�#�,+*!.�4�#+��'#*!4* 4��5� ��-�)/<T_��6+��,+*!.��-!�; -F�!*�+*'�,%�* �'#*#2#� &�%*!.2*.�B�32#�%*,('�,%* -#&�-!�*$$%-,*#-�!/<T<��6+���� &�5- '#�4�,-'-�!�-''2�4�*5#� �#+��,+*!.��-!�'#*#2#� &�%*!.2*.�� �'2%#�4�-!�5�2 �'�$* *#���$-!-�!'/<T=��6+��,�2 #�'��"�4�2!'2 ��+�)�#��+*!4%��#+-'�!�)�'#*#2#��#+*#�#�%4�#+��,�2 #�#+*#�-#�,�2%4�!�#�4�5� �#��*.�!,&�-!#� $ �#*#-�!'��5�*�'#*#2#�/<TT��6+��$��$%��-!�3�#+�8!4-*!*�*!4�; -F�!*�)-%%�3��5� ,�4�#��)*-#�#��'���+�)�#+-'�2!5�%4'�*'�"� ��4�5-!-#-�!�-'�$ ��-4�4�3&�#+��%�.-'%*#2 ��� �#+��924-,-* &/���������������������������������������������������<=>�KRR�23/�a*#� �A2$$%&�0�/��/�?-*':2*%�B�@=b�;/<4�=@CB�=C<�c?�%/�_DD<d/�<=@�KRR�\ef�<=C�KRR�\ef�<=D�Ief�*#�=C</�<TU�g8A0E�8!42'/�� $/��/�g/�8!4/�23/�A� �/�0�/B�_UU�g/h/=4�<=TB�<T_�c8!4/�<U_Cd/�<T_�Iefi�j� -* -#&��/�8!4/�?�$k#��5�g*#/�l�'B�__=�g/h/�=4�>_TB�>_Dm<U�c8!4/�<U_Dd/�<T<�KRR�;l8n/�lho/�A6;6/�;gg/�p�_<mD_U�c<U_<dq�A-%�� ��/�2�3%��?�%�A�%�a*#� �0�/B�T<=�/=4�=TCB�=bTmb>�c; -F/�<U_Cd/�<T=�K\SrR[B�T<=�/=4�*#�=b_B�=>_B�=>>B�=>D/�<TT�KRR�\ef�*#�bbTmb>/�

Page 29: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ���������� ������������������������������������������������ ���������� ! �!"#$�%��&'"$(�)*++�,��-�('�.',/*-�$�)��(��$�*(�*/�,�.�//0$1�('�%02��0�.�0,3� ��45�(���&'"$(�.0,�)'$2�)*(�*,�(���6'",-/�'5�789:;<=>�*(�#$'606+1�/�'"+- ��45�.�0,3�?��')�@�$?�*/�,�.�//0$1�*(�,��-/�('�6��%0-��)*(��#"$#'/� ������&'"$(�%*3�(�.',/*-�$�+''2*,3�0(�(���*//"�/�(�0(��0@��0$'/��*,�4,-*0,0�0,-�A$*B',0�('�-�(�$%*,��*5�*(�)0,(/�('��0@��(���+')�$�.'"$(/�*,�5+"C?�+*2��(��1�0$��*,�4,-*0,0 DEF��G,�(���'(��$��0,-?�(���&'"$(�.0,�#"++�5$'%�H�+0)0$�I/��C#�$*�,.��('��,/"$��(�0(�(���'"(.'%��*/�.+�0,�0,-�0--$�//�/�0++�$�+�@0,(�/(0,-0$-/ ��D ��!($',3�J'",-0(*',�� K0@*,3�0�/($',3�5'",-0(*',�*,�0�.0/��*/�2�1�('�#$'@*-*,3�,�.�//0$1�-*$�.(*',�0,-�-�5*,*(*', ��4,-*0,0�0,-�H�+0)0$��6'(���0-�.0/�/�(�0(�%0-��/(0(�%�,(/�(�0(�/�'"+-�,'(��0@��6��,�.',/($"�-�('�6��(���$"+��6"(��,-�-�"#�6�.'%*,3�(���$"+� DEL������/($',3�5'",-0(*',�)0/�,'(�/�( ��4,�4,-*0,0?�MNO�PQ99R�.$�0(�-�0,�*,0-@�$(�,(�$"+��',�0�/�(�'5�50.(/�(�0(�)�$��,'(�+'3*.0++1�(*�-�('�(���$"+� DES������50.(/�*,@'+@�-�0,�0-%*,*/($0(*@��03�,.1�*,(�$#$�(*,3�0�/(0("(��(�0(�0�-*55�$�,(�0-%*,*/($0(*@��03�,.1�)0/�.�0$3�-�)*(���,5'$.*,3 DET��U"(�(���$"+��(�0(��0/�6��,�$�#�0(�-+1�.*(�-�*/�(�0(�(���V"-*.*0$1�)'"+-�3*@��3$�0(�)�*3�(�('�0,�0-%*,*/($0(*@��03�,.1I/�*,(�$#$�(0(*',�'5�*(/�/(0("(�/ DEW��4,�H�+0)0$�?�(���.'"$(�0((�%#(�-�('�V"/(*51�*(/�-�.*/*',�61�*//"*,3�0�-*/.+0*%�$�0/�0,�05(�$(�'"3�( DFX����*/�-*/.+0*%�$�(��,�/��%�-�('��������������������������������������������������DEF�P99�&'%#0,1�@ �Y�@ �U- �'5�(���4,- �H�#I(�'5�Z'$25'$.��H�@ ?�[[\�] \-�[D[E?�[D[T�_4,- �&( �A## �DX[T�_.*(*,3�('�abcP7d�0,-�5*,-*,3�(���/(0,-0$-�'5�$�@*�)�('�6��e9�=<:<�)*(��,'�-�5�$�,.��('�(���0-%*,*/($0(*@��($*6",0+f�&'%%g$�'5�4,- �H�#g(�'5�4,/ �@ �!.�"%02�$?�[[T�] \-�[[?�DX�_4,- �&( �A## �DX[T�_.*(*,3�('�h�i�!(��+�&' �@ �j$*55*,?�S\X�] D-�[DF[?�[DFS�_4,- �DXXX�0,-�5*,-*,3�(�0(�*5�0�/(0("(��*/�0%6*3"'"/?�-�5�$�,.��/�'"+-�6��055'$-�-�('�(���0-%*,*/($0(*@��03�,.1I/�*,(�$#$�(0(*',?�/'�+',3�0/�*(�*/�,'(�*,.',/*/(�,(�)*(��(���/(0("(��*(/�+5 �DEL�P99�&',,�++�@ �H�+ �A*$.$05(�4,-"/ ?�4,. ?�FF�A D-�L\S?�LEF�_H�+ �!"#�$ �&( �[WESf�MNO�PQ99R?�S\X�] D-�0(�[DFS ���DES�MNO�PQ99R?�S\X�] D-�0(�[DFS �DET�bek�DEW�4,- �A+.'�'+�l��'60..'�&'%%I,�@ �h�60%'55�,(�$/ ?�DS�] \-�TXD?�TXL�_4,- �&( �A## �DX[Ff�&'%%I$�'5�4,- �H�#I(�'5�4,/ �@ �m"(%0,?�WT�] \-�WT?�[XE�_4,- �&( �A## �DX[Tf�DFF�n'$$*/?�hh&�@ �4,- �A+.'�'+�l��'60..'�&'%%I,?�W\�] \-�[[EW?�[[F\�_4,- �&( �A## �DX[Tf�(B+�$�@ �4,- �H�#I(�'5�Y�@�,"�?�E\�] \-�DFX?�DFF�_4,- �&( �A## �DX[F �DFX�7<==9RR?�FF�A D-�0(�LEF �

Page 30: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� ������� !"�#$�! �"�%�&'#!'��()#* )"(+�(",�)-�)'"�.�/�"*"�0-��)�-��1"( & �"�-2"���(#$3�456789:�;759�<"! ��"�=>::8??�& ����",�#$� �* $$"��)' )�& ��$-)�(-3#! (@ABC���D��)'"�E@.@�.�/�"*"�0-��)�(--F�� )�'-&�#)�&#((� ,,�"���#���"���"( )",�)-�=G8H9>:� $,��"/ � )#-$�-��/-&"��%�#)�&#((�<"�#*/-�) $)�)-��"*"*<"��)'"��$!( �#)+�)' )�*#3')�(--*���-*� �! �"�)' )�,-"��$-)�/�-2#,"�)'"�/�-/"���-�$, )#-$@��I$�;J;�K:67L7M78%�N��)#!"�O-���!'��"!-3$#P",�)'"�#*/-�) $!"�-��' 2#$3�)'"��#3')��")�-��� !)��)-� ,,�"���)'"�!-$!"�$��'"�� #�"��#$�QM7L8998RST9LRM8?5UABA��V'#���)�-$3��-�$, )#-$�#��)'"�F"+�)-�/�-2#,#$3�!( �#)+� $,�,#�"!)#-$��-��)'"���)��"@��W#)'-�)�#)%�!-$���#-$�&#((� �#�"%� $,���)��"�! �"��&#((�" �#(+�<"� <("�)-�,#�)#$3�#�'�#)�"(��)-� 2-#,�#)�� //(#! )#-$@��X@��I3$-� $!"�#��Y-)�Z(#���� I3$-�#$3�/�"!","$)� $,�!�" )#$3�$"&���("��&#)'-�)��"!-3$#P#$3�-�� ,,�"��#$3�)'"�-(,�! $�(" ,�)-�,#� �� +@��I)��"* #$���$!(" ��&' )�&#((�' //"$�#$�I$,# $ �<"! ��"�[K\;=]�-2"�(--F",�)'"�!���"$)��) $, �,�-���"2#"&�#$�I$,# $ @ABX��V'#��-2"��#3')�(",�)-�!-$���#-$� $,��$!( �#)+�)-�)'"�(-&"��!-��)�@AB��I)�#�� (�-��$!(" ��#��)'#��& ��#$)"$)#-$ (�-��$-)%�<�)�)'"�� !)�)' )�#)�' //"$",�,-"��$-)�3-��$$-)#!",@��I$�D�#P-$ %�)'"�* _-�#)+�-/#$#-$�#$�;L?H89%�)--%��""*",�)-��F#�)� �-�$,�)'"�� !)�)' )�)'"�_�,#!# �+�' ,�/�"2#-��(+�3#2"$�,"�"�"$!"�)-� 3"$!+�#$)"�/�") )#-$�-���) )�)"�%��$("���!(" �(+�"��-$"-��%� $,�$-&�)'"�("3#�( )��"�/�"2"$)",�)'"�_�,#!# �+���-*�,-#$3��-@ABB��V'"�!-��)�,#,�)'#��<+���#$3�! $-$��-��!-$�)��!)#-$�)' )�&"�"��#*#( ��)-�)'"��) $, �,��-�$,�#$�T>G5::5:� $,�<+�!#)#$3�)-�E@.@�.�/�"*"�0-��)�! �"��)' )� (�-���",��������������������������������������������������ABC�a�<@�W )"��.�//(+�0-@�2@�1#a �b� ("%�cXB�D@A,�Xcd%�XdAedX�f1"(@�CggAh@�ABA�;88�.D.�I$�)@%�I$!@�2@�I $!�%�CXd�.@�0)@�CXd%�CXBd�fAiCdh�fN@�O-���!'hj�O�)#"��"PkZ�#P�"( �2@�l+$!'%�dX�m@X,�CCA%�CCgeBd�fCi)'�0#�@�AiCnh@�ABX�YIa.0o�I$,��@�O�/@�2@�Y@�I$,@�a�<@�."�2@�0-@%�Cii�Y@p@X,�AX%�AC�fI$,@�AiCdh@��AB�;88�0-*/ $+�2@�q"2@�Z,@�o��)'"�I$,@�1"/r)�-��W-�F�-�!"�1"2@%�CCX�Y@p@X,�CAC%�CACd�fI$,@�0)@�D//@�AiCdh�f!#)#$3�)-�[K\;=]� $,��#$,#$3�)'"��) $, �,�-���"2#"&�)-�<"�s8�:>H>�&#)'�$-�,"�"�"$!"�)-�)'"� ,*#$#�)� )#2"�)�#<�$ (hj�0-**t��-��I$,@�1"/t)�-��I$�@�2@�.!'�* F"�%�CCd�Y@p@X,�CC%�Ai�fI$,@�0)@�D//@�AiCdh�f!#)#$3�)-�lVu�.)""(�0-@�2@�O�#��#$%�cXi�Y@p@A,�CABC%�CABc�fI$,@�Aiiih� $,��#$,#$3�)' )�#�� ��) )�)"�#�� *<#3�-��%�,"�"�"$!"��'-�(,�<"� ��-�,",�)-�)'"� ,*#$#�)� )#2"� 3"$!+r��#$)"�/�") )#-$%��-�(-$3� ��#)�#��$-)�#$!-$�#�)"$)�&#)'�)'"��) )�)"�#)�"(�h@�ABB�.#(2"��2@�a�"<(-�1"(�.-(�W )"��0-@%�AX�a@X,�Xd%�XBeBn�fD�#P@�AiCdh@�

Page 31: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ������ ���������� ������������������������������������������������ ���������� �!"!#$%&��'( ��)*+,�-./012�*!�3!4*�!�5���*6�4*4�!"��7"�(!!"�* ,4#�37!"8*!7�19:;<=>?@�,A*6�,! ,�B*))�!"���448,66���,�C�)*4�(!4,8)D*!7�*66(,6�8�*6,4�ED�F(6�* ,�G"86( ���!4�F(6�* ,�H�"I�6#$%J���3!� ,8��*!�*!6��! ,65�19:;<=>���6�*!C*�,4��4I*!*6�8��*C,��7,! *,6��"��8()D�E,)*,C,��������K�*,L7",6L�"L��,L�7,! D#M$%N��H�*6��*,� �!�E,�6�8,� �,4��"��7,! *,6�E,)*,C*!7�*��*6�"+��"�C*")��,�E�6* � "! ,O�6�"P�4(,�O8" ,66��!4�,Q(�)�O8"�, �*"!#��3��*6��*7�)D�(!)*+,)D��������*6�B�6���,�*!�,!��"P���,�R"(8��B�,!�*��(!�!*I"(6)D�*66(,4�*�6�4, *6*"!�*!�19:;<=>#$%S��TA, (�*C,�E8�! ��,IO)"D,,6�!,,4��"�E,�I*!4P()�"P�4(,�O8" ,665�,Q(�)�O8"�, �*"!��!4�"��,8� "!6�*�(�*"!�8*7��6�*!�,C,8D�4, *6*"!�I�4,#��3P��4I*!*6�8��*C,��7,! *,6� "!�*!(,��"�7*C,���,�U(4* *�8D�8,�6"!6��"�4*6�8(6����,�,A, (�*C,5�19:;<=>�B*))�E,�6)"B)D�,8"4,4�"8�"(�8*7���"C,88(),4#�� 3V#��RWXRYZ[3WX�� \,)�B�8,5�3!4*�!���!4�]8*"!����C,��))���+,!�4*PP,8,!��O���6��"�4,�,8I*!,��"B��"�*!�,8O8,��6���(�,6��!4�8,7()��*"!6�������4I*!*6�8��*C,��7,! *,6��8,� ��87,4�B*���,!P"8 *!7#��T� ��I,��"4���6� "I,�B*��� ��)),!7,6��!4�"E6�� ),6_6"I,�7""45�6"I,�E�4#��X"B������F(6�* ,�G"86( ��*6�"!���,�Z#[#�[(O8,I,�R"(8�5�19:;<=>�B*))�E,��448,66,4#���6,4�(O"!��*I� ),�8)D�6���*!7�*!�0a0�.>@bcbdb:������19:;<=>�I�D�E,��!�*66(,��"�E,��448,66,4��!"��,8�4�D5�*��*6� ),�8��������*6�*6�"!�F(6�* ,�G"86( �e6�I*!4#��3��*6�)*+,)D�"!�F(6�* ,�H�"I�6e�I*!4��6�B,))#��f"B�19:;<=>�I*7��� ��!7,�"8�E,�)*I*�,45�B�,��,8�*��B*))�E,�"C,88(),4�"8�B�,��,8�*��B*))�6��D���,�6�I,5�*6���Q(,6�*"!�P"8��!"��,8�4�D#��H�,��"O,5���"(7�5�*6��������,�P,4,8�)�7"C,8!I,!�� �!�)""+��"���,�6���,6�P"8�7(*4�! ,5�O())*!7�P8"I���,�7""4��!4�),�8!*!7�P8"I���,�E�4#��3!�,8O8,���*"!�"P�6���(�,6�������7,! *,6��8,� ��87,4�B*���,!P"8 *!7�6�"()4�E,�6"I,��*!7�������))"B6���,�U(4* *�)5��������������������������������������������������$%&�.gh����i%%#�$%J�'* �*7�!�C#�Tj]5�ki%�[#�R�#����$Jk$lkmn�odbc:<<:pqr<cpd:st5�Nim�u#i4����kkmSl%N#�$%N�0::�-./0125�kvv�X#T#i4����$mk#�$%S�0::�R�,C8"!�Z#[#]#5�3! #�C#�X��#�w,6#�\,P#�R"(! *)5�3! #5�m&J�Z#[#�NiJ5�NiS�xkSNmy�xH�,8,�B�6�!"�4*66,!�*!7�"8� "! (88*!7�"O*!*"!�*!�R�,C8"!5��"B,C,85�F(6�* ,�'�86��))5�F(6�* ,�w,�!Q(*6���!4�F(6�* ,�WeR"!!"8�4*4�!"����+,�O�8��*!���,�4, *6*"!y#�

Page 32: Chevron Deference in the States: Lessons from Three States

� ��������������������� ������� ���������������������������� ���� ���������� �������� !"��#$%�&�'!(&# !"��)*#$�+�(� ,�-,*.�!$�+#*/,$01�*��,'$!2!$'� +�!*�*�(3,$(!)!&! !�(1�.$,-!$'� +�!*�&!/! (1�3*,"!%!$'��+��.(�,$��#�+�, +�*1�+,$,*!$'� +�!*�%� 0��$%�*� +��4,$( ! � !,$�#$%�(�*"!$'� +!(�'*�# �%�/,�*#�0� ,�3*, �� �#$%�+,$,*�! (��,$( ! ��$�05���