Top Banner
Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions Reading: CS-B Chapter 6 Grossman Chapter 4
36

Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Aug 11, 2021

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Chem 634

Pericyclic Reactions

Reading: CS-B Chapter 6

Grossman Chapter 4

Page 2: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Pericyclic Reactions

Definition: Continuous, concerted reorganization of electrons

Fukui & Hoffmann: Nobel Prize in Chemistry, 1981, “for… their theories, developed independently, concerning the course of chemical

reactions” (Woodward dies in 1979)

cyclic transition

state

no intermediate, single transition state

Bond breaking & bond making occur at the same time.

Can be synchronous (equal extent of breaking & making in TS) or asynchronous (unequal extent of breaking & making in TS).

Page 3: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

5 Types

1.  Electrocyclic

2.  Cycloadditions

3.  Sigmatropic

4.  Chelatropic

5.  Group Transfer

Page 4: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

3 Theories

All 3 theories are correct!

1.  Woodward–Hoffmann: Conservation of Orbital Symmetry •  1st historically •  Uses correlation diagrams

2.  Fukui: Frontier Molecular Orbital Theory •  Easier than Woodward–Hoffmann (usually) •  Based on HOMO/LUMO interactions

3.  Dewar–Zimmerman: Aromatic Transition State •  Easiest to apply for all reaction types, but not intuitive to understand why

it’s valid

Page 5: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

3 Things Matter

1.  Number of electrons involved

2.  Stereospecificity

3.  Conditions: heat (Δ) vs. light (hυ)

Page 6: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Type 1: Electrocyclic Reactions

-  Ring openings and closures -  Exchange π-bond for σ-bond -  Classified by number of electrons

R R

favored by release of ring strain

R R

π-bond (~75 kcal/mol) –> σ-bond (~88 kca/mol)

Page 7: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Diastereoselectivity – Observations

RRΔ

R R(±)4e-

R H H RH

R

R

H

RRhυ

R R4e-

R H H RH

R

H

R

RR

Δ

6e-R R

R HH RR R

HH

RR6e-

R R

(±)

R HH RH R

HR

Case%1:%

Case%2:%

Case%3:%

Case%4:%

Page 8: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

General Phenomenon… Woodward–Hoffmann Rules

Number'of'electrons' Thermal' Photochemical'

4n% Con% Dis%

4n+2% Dis% con%

(n = integer)

6 points for a touchdown –> 6e-, thermal, disrotatory

... But why???

Page 9: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Theory #1: Woodward–Hoffmann Correlation Diagrams

Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1969, 8, 781.

•  Consider all molecular orbitals (MO’s) involved •  Consider symmetry of MO’s in starting material, product, and transition state. •  Orbitals of different symmetry can cross (orthogonal orbitals). •  Orbitals of same symmetry cannot cross (extreme energetic cost). •  We are about orbitals where electrons end up.

Page 10: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Example of W–H Correlation Diagrams

conrotatory TSdisrotatory TS

Page 11: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

σ

σ∗

π

π∗

Example of W–H Correlation Diagrams: Thermal Conditions

conrotatory TSdisrotatory TS

σ-plane of symmetry C2 axis of symmetry

σSM σP

S

S

S

S

A

A

A

A

Ψ1

Ψ2

Ψ3

Ψ4

Page 12: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

σ

σ∗

π

π∗

Example of W–H Correlation Diagrams: Photochemical Conditions

conrotatory TSdisrotatory TS

σ-plane of symmetry C2 axis of symmetry

σSM σP

S

S

S

S

A

A

A

A

Ψ1

Ψ2

Ψ3

Ψ4

C2-SM C2-P

A

A

A

A

S

S

S

S

con pathway disfavored

Page 13: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

W–H Conservation of Orbital Symmetry Shortcut

conrotatory TSdisrotatory TS

σ-plane of symmetry C2 axis of symmetry

Ψ2

(HOMO)

Page 14: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Cycloadditions & Cycloreversions

-  Union of 2 π-systems -  Exchange π-bonds for σ-bonds -  Classified by [m+n], m & n = # of conjugated atoms in each π-system

[4+2]

4 atoms 2 atoms

Diels–Alder Reaction! Note: 6 e-

Great way to make cyclohexenes & cyclohexanes

Page 15: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

diene dienophile

E nonbonding level

HOMO

LUMO

HOMO

LUMO

Fukui: Frontier Molecular Orbital (FMO) Theory The idea: Use FMO’s (HOMO + LUMO)

Which HOMO & LUMO?

E EA – EB

ΔE

ΔE ∝ orbital overlapEA – EB

geometrical/spatial overlap

If closer in energy,then more stability

by forming a covalent bond.

In this case, it doesn’t matter… HOMO/LUMO

gaps are the same.

Page 16: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Types of Diels–Alder Reactions

Normal electron demand = HOMO of diene + LUMO of dienophile

Inverse electron demand = HOMO of dienophile + LUMO of diene

Page 17: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Net Bonding Interaction? The idea: Use FMO’s (HOMO + LUMO)

diene dienophile

E nonbonding level

HOMO

LUMO

HOMO

LUMO

Page 18: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Diastereoselectivity: Endo vs. Exo

[4+2]

Me

MeMe

O

OMe+

Me

MeMe

O

OMe

Me

MeMe

O

OMe+

minorexo

majorendo

(favored)

Me

Me

MeOMe

O Me

Me

Me

OMeO

Page 19: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Why? … Secondary Orbital Interactions Me

MeMe

Me

Me

O

OMe

HOMO LUMOMe

O

OMe

Page 20: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Regioselectivity & Rates: Substituent Effects

Rates depend on HOMO/LUMO gap.

Perturba4on' HOMO' LUMO'

extra%conjuga7on% !% "%

electron9withdrawing%group% "% "%

electron9dona7ng%group% !% !%

Effects apply to both dienes & dienophiles. Effect of substitution is biggest if on C1 of diene.

R1

R2 123

4

bigger effect

Page 21: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Examples

O O

O

O

O

O

+rt, 24 h

100%

+165 °C

12,600 psi17 h 78%

Page 22: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Regioselectivity

Related to polarization of HOMO and/or LUMO

+

major

OMe

H

O OMe O

H vs.

OMe

O

H

minor

Quick prediction: “imaginary intermediate” (push arrows to get maximum effect of substituents)

OMe

H

O OMe O

H more stable

OMeOMe

CH2

O

H H

O

… but remember these reactions are concerted!!!

Page 23: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Lewis Acid Effects One of the first Lewis acid-accelerated organic transformations!

+ O

O

OCH2Cl225 °C

OO

additivenone

AlCl3 (1 equiv)

t1/2

2400 h< 1 min

O

+ OMe

O

CO2Me

HH

endo H

CO2MeH

exo

+additive

noneAlCl3·OEt2 (1 equiv)

endo:exo82 : 1899 : 1

+ OMe

O

OMe

O

OMe

O

+

PhPh

Phadditive

noneAlCl3

1,4 : 1,380 : 2097 : 3

1,4 1,3

Lewis acid increases rate, endo/exo selectivity & regioselectivity!

Yates, Eaton. JACS 1960, 82, 4436

Page 24: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Why???

MO perturbation!

Houk JACS 1973, 95, 4094

OMe

O AlCl3OMe

OAlCl3

more reactive, more like O

Explains rates, but what about selectivity issues???

Page 25: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Why???

Houk JACS 1973, 95, 4094

Lower LUMO = faster rate

Bigger difference in lobe size on C1 vs. C2 = better regioselectivity

Bigger lobe on C=O carbon = bigger 2° orbital interactions =

better endo/exo selectivity

Page 26: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

One More Consideration: S-cis vs. S-trans

vs.

S-cisreactive

S-transnot reactive! + O

O

O

O

O

O

+ O

O

O

O

O

O

Me Me

+ O

O

O

O

O

O

Me

Me

+ O

O

O OO

O

HH

krel

1

4

10–3

103

Me

MeH

Page 27: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

[2+2] Cycloadditions

FMO Analysis: •  No net bonding… “forbidden” •  This geometry is suprafacial on both

π bonds => [2πs + 2πs]

Suprafacial = same face of π-system Antarafacial = opposite faces of π-system

Page 28: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Alternative Transition State Geometry

HH

H HH HH H

Problem: Steric Hindrance!

Solution: Remove steric hindrance!

Page 29: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Sigmatropic Reactions

•  Reorganization of σ and π bonds (migration of a σ-bond)

•  Number of σ and π bonds remains constant

•  Classify by [m,n]-rearrangement or [m,n]-shift (m, n = number of atoms in

fragment)

Page 30: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

[1,3]-Sigmatropic Rearrangement

Does this rearrangement proceed under thermal conditions?

Supra- or antara-facial??

For FMO, break into HOMO and LUMO:

Page 31: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

[1,3]-Sigmatropic Rearrangements

Alkyl Shift?

FMO:

Page 32: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

[3,3]-Sigmatropic Rearrangements

Suprafacial on both components! Highly predictable TS –> “chair-like” (can predict stereochem)

Page 33: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Claisen Rearrangement

Page 34: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Oxy-Cope

Page 35: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Theory #3: Dewar–Zimmerman: Aromatic Transition State

Steps: 1.  Choose basis set of 2p AO’s (or 1s for H atoms) 2.  Assign phases (any phases) 3.  Connect orbitals that interact in the starting material 4.  Connect lobes that begin to interact in the reaction 5.  Count the number of phase inversions 6.  Identify topology

1.  Odd # of phase inversions = Möbius 2.  Even # of phase inversions = Hückel

7.  Assign Transition State as aromatic (thermally allowed) or antiaromatic (photochemically allowed)

System/Topology' Aroma4c' An4aroma4c'

Huckel% (4n+2)%e9% (4n)%e9%

Mobius% (4n)%e9% (4n+2)%e9%

Page 36: Chem 634 Pericyclic Reactions...RR Δ RR (±) 4e-RHHR H R R H RR hυ 4e-RR RHHR H R H R RR Δ 6e-RR RHHR RR HH RR 6e-RR h ... FMO Analysis: • No net bonding… “forbidden” •

Example of D–Z Theory