1 CHAPTER – I INTRODUCTION 1.1 PROBLEM AND IMPORTANCE OF STUDY The topic which we have selected for our project study is of wide relevancein the Indian context now and ever. Though divisions based on economic status, colour, creed etc were found in many places all over the world, Caste System is unique to India. Though we don’t wish to delve into the details of Caste system here, the point that we shouldn’t miss is about the bondage or fetters that are lashed upon the people by birth, under this system. The Scheduled Castes are placed at the lower rungs of social and economic ladder. They had been at this disadvantageous position for centuries. While framing our Constitution after independence, B.R.Ambedkar, who himself was the member of the community, laid enough provisions for the upliftment and development of Scheduled Castes. They had been provided with reservation in jobs, educational institutions and even in promotions of jobs. Successive governments have implemented various schemes and programmes for their upliftment. The most unfortunate thing is that there had been mixed responses regarding the success of these shemes.Though they have succeeded in uplifting the members of the community, there is a strong
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1
CHAPTER – I
INTRODUCTION
1.1 PROBLEM AND IMPORTANCE OF STUDY
The topic which we have selected for our project study is of
wide relevancein the Indian context now and ever. Though divisions based
on economic status, colour, creed etc were found in many places all over the
world, Caste System is unique to India. Though we don’t wish to delve into
the details of Caste system here, the point that we shouldn’t miss is about the
bondage or fetters that are lashed upon the people by birth, under this
system.
The Scheduled Castes are placed at the lower rungs of social
and economic ladder. They had been at this disadvantageous position for
centuries. While framing our Constitution after independence,
B.R.Ambedkar, who himself was the member of the community, laid
enough provisions for the upliftment and development of Scheduled Castes.
They had been provided with reservation in jobs, educational institutions and
even in promotions of jobs. Successive governments have implemented
various schemes and programmes for their upliftment.
The most unfortunate thing is that there had been mixed
responses regarding the success of these shemes.Though they have
succeeded in uplifting the members of the community, there is a strong
2
accusation that the benefits of these schemes are cornered by a particular
section within the community, who are continuously availing these
benefits.And there has emerged a “creamy layer” within the community.
The major question remains that why the majority members of
this community still remain deprived of the benefits of development. Many
of the Scheduled Castes still remain as illiterates, unknowing of the schemes
for their upliftment.Their living standards are below what we call as a decent
standard of living. Most of them don’t have any assets like land, gold etc
except a house to live.
The study regarding the educational attainment and living
standards of Scheduled Castes has got relevance on two aspects- the
“obligation aspect” or commitment aspect and the “rights aspect”. As with
regard to the obligation side all the people of the country have got the
obligation to ensure equality on all scales and no injustice is done to any
community. We people have got the responsibility to ensure that no people
are denied their basic human rights. Further as with regards to the rights
aspect, we people have the right to inquire into the issues of welfare of
Scheduled Castes as it is the taxpayer’s money that has been used to finance
the developmental schemes for Scheduled Castes. The so called “General
category” had to sacrifice many opportunities in the fields of education,
employment etc for the benefit of Scheduled Castes. So they have the right
to know about the improvements in living conditions of Scheduled Castes.
The scheme of reservation for scheduled castes in educational
institutions ,jobs etc have attracted much controversy on the ground that it
3
just promotes inefficiency by neglecting merit. Though we are pretty sure
about the faults of present reservation system, we can’t just ignore the fact
that majority among the scheduled castes are non recipients of the benefits
of the welfare schemes for their amelioration. Through this study we try to
show that there are many among the Scheduled Castes who need a big push
inorder to bring up their living standards. We shouldn’t expect them to play
the same as others because the playing field is not yet leveled.
1.2 REVIEW OF LITERATURE.
Even though caste system is a unique feature of India, many
studies and research have been done regarding the conditions of Scheduled
Castes and the problems faced by them. In this section we are reviewing the
existing literature on the Scheduled Caste.
According to Dumont there is a definite relationship between caste
and occupation, eventually contributed to the stability of caste system which
is a major hazard in the way of social mobility.
K.C.Alexander opines that education can promote acquisition of
new skills among Scheduled Caste.Saradhamani in her study found that
Scheduled Caste people are forced to do low status jobs mainly because they
are polluting caste.
Vijay Nayak and Shailaja Prasad in their article observed that
consumption and expenditure distribution of Scheduled caste people is very
low and there exist wide differences in levels of education and occupational
status of Scheduled Caste households.
4
Isaac cited in his work and said about the education of Scheduled
Caste that no new Ambedkars appeared in city among the young, but a mass
of self-engrossed people who are quickly and easily satisfied with the small
gains they can win for themselves.
Putwardhan had found a wide gulf between the educated and
uneducated harijan and he also tried to find a relationship between the
education and social mobility.
Vinay Kripal and Raj.K.Gupta cited in their article thet social
problems in Scheduled Caste students are caused by inferiority complex ,
problems with English and their introverted nature etc.
Victor.S.Dsuza when dealing with the problems of Scheduled
Caste people in Punjab came to the conclusion that the educational gap
between the Scheduled Caste and the rest of the society is very wide and
improvement is very slow.He also came to the conclusion that there exist
educational inequalities among Scheduled Caste.
Krishnakumar opined that proper education to Scheduled Caste
students can only uplift these people.Pimpley,Nayar,Dubeg,Valnikar,Chitins
and Yadav in their studies on difference between educational level of
Scheduled Caste both at the school and college level,found that at college
level most of the students are aware of the scholarship facilities, reservation
etc in the educational institutions.
5
Malik found that greater percentage of educated respondants is
aware of more important facilities such as educational facilities like
provision of grants, while less educated people are comparatively less aware
of the facilities.
Beteille,Sharma,Nijhawan.N.K observed that the occupational
mobility directly influence the standard of living, education, social mobility
and social status.
From the review of literature it is understood that most of the
studies are concentrating on the social aspects of Scheduled Castes.Even the
studies which are concentrating on the economic impacts are mostly general
in nature.A few studies available on socio-economic status of the Scheduled
Castes are done at micro level.Hence, we have selected the present study
which is micro in nature.
OBJECTIVES OF STUDY
The main objectives of the study are the following:
• To examine the income and standard of living of Scheduled Castes.
• To understand the educational status of Scheduled castes.
• To get an idea of the housing conditions of Scheduled Castes.
METHODOLOGY AND SOURCE OF DATA.
6
The present study is based on primary data as well as secondary data.
Chembukkavu Division of Thrissur Corporation in Thrissur District.There
are many total number of Scheduled Caste households in Chembukkavu
division.Out of this 50 households are taken randomly. The sample
households of this Chembukkavu division are visited and detailed
information are collected through a well settled questionaire .
Besides this primary data, we have
collected secondary data from the various secondary data sources.
CONCEPTS AND DEFINITIONS.
Scheduled Caste: Scheduled Caste means such castes, races or tribes part or
group within such castes, races or tribes as are deemed under Article 341 of
the Indian Constitution to be Scheduled Caste for the purpose of the
Constitution of India.
Household: A house hold is a group of persons normally living together and
taking food from a common kitchen. Here in the study a house hold was to
consist of its normal members only.
Standard of living: The financial health of a population, as measured by
percapita income and consumption of goods and services by individuals or
households.
Educational attainment: the highest level of education completed in terms
of the highest degree or the highest level of schooling completed.
7
PLAN OF STUDY.
The study is divided into six chapters. The first chapter
dealswithintroduction including problem, objective and methodology. The
second chapter deals with the profile of Scheduled Castes. It comprises a
general view of the caste system, status of Scheduled Castes in India,their
status and conditions in Kerala. The third chapter deals with status and
living conditions of Scheduled Castes in Thrissur District. The fourth
chapter provides an outline of the general characteristics of sample
households. The fifth chapter mainly consist of the analysis of the primary
data collected from the sample survey and presenting it in tables and charts.
The sixth chapter highlights the findings and conclusion of the project.
8
CHAPTER II
PROFILE OF SCHEDULED CASTES. The Scheduled castes are not a homogeneous group but consists
of morethan 400 major caste groups having varying numerical strength. Due
to occupational differentiation , some castes are predominantly rural while
others are exclusively urban based. Agricultural labourers, cobblers,weavers
and artisans tend to concentrate in rural areas. The spatial distribution of
the Scheduled caste population is such that they can be described as
"dispersed minority”. The Scheduled castes have been notified by the
President of India under articles 341 of the constitution of India.
Accordingly from 1951 Census onwards information on
Scheduledcastes were collected and made available in Census reports. From
1961 Census onwards-special tables on Scheduled Castes were
published in Census reports. From 1981 Census onwards Primary Census
abstract for Scheduled Castes were prepared separately from that of General
Population.
CASTE SYSTEM: A GENERAL VIEW.
Surjit Sinha defined caste system as a hierarchy of endogamous
groups organized in a characteristic hierarchy division of labour where in the
9
functions of caste specialization and hierarchy were originally
linked.Moreover a fairly close correlation existed between caste hierarchy
and the distribution of land holding and power. Caste may be defined
as a small and named group of persons characterized by
endogamy,hereditary membership and specific style of life which
sometimes includes the persuit by tradition of a particular occupation and is
usually associated with a more or less distinct ritual status in a hierarchical
system.
The origin of the caste system are shrouded in a pre-historic past.
A social organization based on differential access to resources, exchange of
service, sharing of produce and a hierarchy of status among a host of
corporate groups got gradually institutionalized.
The saga of the oppression of Scheduled castes in India is as
long as the history of this subcontinent itself. Right from the Indus Valley
Civilisation, we find the presence of this class in Indian society in one
form or the other.Caste has been one of the primary unit of stratification
in India.6 The institution of caste is regarded as a distinguishing feature
of social organization of the Indian people under Hinduism. Caste
system is based on the fundamental social principal of hierarchy. The
caste system determines the hierarchical social status of various groups
in the Indian society. The traditional Indian society remained
structurally stratified into different unequal strata of caste / occupational
groups comprising the socially and economically privileged section of the
higher castes or the Savarnas on the one side lid the Avarnas consisting of
10
the mostdisadvantaged group of the lowest castes, and the intermediate
castes with relative deprivation or affluence on the other.
The caste system was developed to meet the
requirement of the Hindu society in good faith and was based not on birth
but on type of work, but gradually it gave way to division in the Hindu
Society leading to castes and sub-castes based on birth. Thus
untouchability was the out come of degenerated caste system.
Untouchability is not simply a reflection of caste
phenomenon, but of underlying socio economic factors of semi
feudal relation.Further the social oppression of the untouchables had
religious sanction. Thus the untouchables have been the victims of brutal
exploitation and have suffered the stigma of untouchability, social isolation,
residential segregation,economicdeprivation, political subjugation and
cultural degradation.Theybecame illiterate, landless, and with no
hope of progress. Lack of wealth, education and power made the
untouchables vulnerable to oppression. Coming to the other point ie.
the economic condition;these became worse and kept on worsening due
to the nature of tasks entrusted to Sudras, which apart from being menial
were not remunerative enough to keep them going. This led them to take
loans and loan sharks, ultimately, took not only them, but their families
also in bondage. This made them slaves forever and hence they were left
behind in the struggle of life.
STATUS OF SCHEDULED CASTES IN INDIA SINCE
INDEPENDENCE.
11
Independent India offered to the untouchables (now
officially called Scheduled castes) the promise to a life of dignity
through a number of protective measures written into the Constitution.
The Constitution of independent India does not recognize the concept of
caste. Untouchability has been prohibited and various castes have the right
to function freely. The constitution forbids legal recognition of hierarchal
ordering of, and patronization among caste groups. Two schedules of the
constitution (under Article 341 and 342) have specifically listed the
needy caste groups for giving special considerations.
The constitution prohibits discrimination against any citizen on
grounds of religion, race, class, place of birth or any other factor. The
President enjoys the power to appoint a special officer to investigate
matters related to safeguards provided for Scheduled castes and
Scheduled tribes in the constitution and accordingly commissioner
for the weaker sections of the Nation is appointed.
Substantial funds were allocated in the National Five
Year Plans for ameliorating the conditions of scheduled castes.
Constitutional guarantees, planned development of the country which
aimed at a rapid economic growth, agrarian reforms, adult franchise
and elections at all levels had a profound impact on the life of the
untouchables. The five decades since independence witnessed a
perceptible improvement in their lives and socio-economic status.
However the benefits of the overall development and growths have not
percolated down to the concerned groups as much as expected. This weaker
12
sections are still the victims of growing economic inequalities. They have
not even been assured of the basic amenities of life such as food, shelter,
education and medical care and they continue to be exploited
economically and are discriminated socially.
There is a growing sense of deprivation and consciousness
of the rights among Scheduled Castes nowadays. This has been derived
from the deeply felt grievances that have been lived with them for a long
time. The awakening lies in the fact that people no longer feel that they
have to repress their aspirations as much as they did formerly.Thus
protest movements among the Scheduled Castes have been launched by
dalits channeled towards raising their social status.
By embracing other religions apart from Hinduism they put
in all the efforts to regain their lost identity or status.Thus,the major
problem to be solved for the Scheduled castes in India is to regain the
fuller human self identity. The main motive or purpose behind the various
efforts including the change of religion from Hinduism to other religion
by the Scheduled castes has been to gain their lost identity or to establish a
new one. The general feeling that the caste consciousness is vanishing
in modem India may be there but there is a prevalence of caste system
hegemony through physical discrimination, subordination, hostility and