Amity Business School Amity Business School MBA(M&S) Class of 2010, Semester II Channel Management Power, Conflicts and Control Prof. P K Bansal
Amity Business School
Amity Business School
MBA(M&S) Class of 2010, Semester IIChannel Management
Power, Conflicts and Control
Prof. P K Bansal
Amity Business School
Multi-Channel Marketing System
Channel Options
Direct Marketing
Sales ForceIntermediaryMarketing Channel
Amity Business School
Channel
Management
1
Use of
Power Bases
2
Resolving
Channel
Conflicts
3
Channel
Control
Amity Business School1 POWER BASES
Referent Power
Expert Power
Legitimate Power
Competition Power
Coercive Power
Amity Business School
Referent Power• Driven from the position the company holds in
the industry.• It comes from instant recognition and respect
associated. (Nestle, Vijay Sahu)
Expert Power• Specialised knowledge on developing
business, available with a channel member, which adds constant value to the channel operation to perform well. (HUL)
Amity Business School
Legitimate Power• Legal power to enforce agreement or contract
signed with the company as regards to distribution / sales / credit etc. (HUL, Brooke Bond) `
Support Power• Company can provide additional support to
channel partners to increase volumes viz. promotions, distribution costs and awards etc.
Competition Power• Ability to generate rivalry among channel
partners to compete in contests and targets etc.
Amity Business School
Reward Power• Provide incentives to the channel partners to perform
additional tasks at specific points of time.• It is only for a specific duration and task.
Coercive Power• Power of a threat to the defaulting channel partner e.g.,
take away some support, discount, appoint more distributors or persuade to extend credit to important customers.
• Used by companies having established distributors with very high dependence on the principal to stay in business.
Amity Business School
USE OF CHANNEL POWER• Power is part of any channel network as the ability to
influence the actions of other channel members.
• All players are dependent on each other.
• The extent of dependence of one on other decides appropriate power base.
• The influence is necessary to the overall batter performance of the system in delivering customer service objectives.
Amity Business School
• Power is the instrument of influence to make the other member willing to act in situations they normally would not have acted in that manner.
• Exercising power is not exploitation or force or pressure, but value adding in context of channel management.
• Dependence of channel members on each other is based on the benefits they can drive.
• Channel members consider themselves important and powerful if the company is dependent on them but this perception of power has no value if company can find alternatives.
Amity Business School
Dependence is determined by:
1. How important is the business of the principal to the channel member.
2. How good the channel member is as a channel partner.
3. How good the company products / New product launches are perceived.
4. Channel partner working in the best interest and working parameters of the principal.
Amity Business School
DEPENDENCE CONTEXTS• Not only the Channel principal, but channel partner can also have
advantage over the principal / other members by having referent and expert power over his own customers which is equally valuable to the company. This power is called, Countervailing power.
• This dependence in channel relationships is very critical in reducing confrontation and improves co-operation for good performance of the channel.
• The interdependence can be deadening for the ancillaries solely dependent on the principals with the declining business.
• Distributors therefore shy away from being exclusive for any single company unless it is a company like HUL, P&G, Nestle, L&T or Maruti.
Amity Business School
2CONFLICT
GOAL
Understanding
of objectives of
Channel members
is different
DOMAIN
Channel members
Understand
Responsibilities
differently
PERCEPTION
Understanding of
Market Place is
different. Actions
do not match
Amity Business School
What is Channel Conflict?
• Channel conflict is a situation of discord or disagreement between channel members from the same marketing channel system.
• Conflict always has negative connotations and is driven more by feelings than fact.
• It is initially latent and does not effect the working of the channel members.
• It is not possible to detect till it reaches a level of disruption.
Amity Business School
2
PERCEIVED
3
FELT
1
LATENT
4
MANIFEST
Conflict
Stages
Amity Business School
Sources of Channel Conflict
• Unclear Role Definition.• Appointment of New Channel Partner.• Target Fixing Exercise• Extension of Credit• Multiple Distributors• Dealers/Distributors sell competing products.• Allocation of Resources by the parent company• Opposing Behaviour/ Direct Competition with
trade partners
Amity Business School
Managing Conflict
• Understanding the nature of conflict and its impact.
• Tracing the source of the conflict.
• Understand the impact of the conflict.
• Strategy and Plan of action for resolution.
Amity Business School
Conflict Resolution
• Joint membership of trade associations• Distributor councils/ unions used as a medium of
coercive power• Mediation through trade associations• Sharing of information between channel partners• Use of third party for mediation• Clear rules of conduct to help build relationship• Use of incentives and rewards based on
performance as part of conflict resolution
Amity Business School
Styles of Conflict Resolution
Avoidance• Used by weak channel partners where
relationship is not of much importance. The problem is postponed only.
Aggression• Used by the dominant member using coercive
methods.
Amity Business School
Accommodation• A situation of complete surrender. One party
helps other without being worried about its own goals. Situation can also lead to exploitation.
Compromise• Finding mid way solution. Can only work with
small and not so serious conflicts.
Collaboration• Win-Win situation. Information sharing approach.
Amity Business SchoolMinimising Channel Conflict
Value added by Channel
Significant Insignificant
Cooperate•Look for WIN-Win•Seek Compromise•Look to sell New Products through New Channels
Forward Integrate•Identify New Value Proposition•Act Fast / Independently•Fill Gaps in Channel Coverage
Channel Controls Customer
Market P
ow
er
Lead•Define appropriate approaches for the Channel•Make Initial Investment
Compete•Internet Link to Customers•Shift volume to new Channel by Promotion
Supplier Controls Customers
Amity Business School
3
CHANNEL
CONTROL
PROTECTION
Interest of all
Channel Members
are protected
OBJECTIVES
Actions of all
are in line with
overall objectives
DELIVERY
Channel Flows
streamlined to
service end
customers
Amity Business School
Maintaining Cordial Relationship• Cordial relationship require similar goals for channel
members regarding the various aspects of relationship to achieve effectiveness and efficiency in the process of delivering service of outputs required by end users.
• Convergence is essential in terms of individual goals of all the channel members with a collaborative process by:
1) Frequent and Effective Communication of Information.2) Proper Grievance handling system.3) Proper distribution of roles, resources and power.
Amity Business School
Significance ofIndividual Goals
High Low
Integration byNegotiation
Compromiseby Sacrifice
Long Run Natu
re of
Relatio
nsh
ip
Forcing byDomination
Withdrawalby avoidance
Transactional
Channel Relationship Maintenance Strategies
Amity Business School
References :
• Sales and Distribution Management; P K Agarwal & Manoj Kumar; Pragati Prakashan
• Sales and Distribution Management; Krishna K Havaldar & Vasant M Cavale; Tata McGraw-Hill Pub. Co. Ltd.