Top Banner
September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Los Angeles Department of Water Los Angeles Department of Water & Power & Power CH2M HILL and Air Sciences CH2M HILL and Air Sciences Bishop, September 28-29 2005 Bishop, September 28-29 2005
27

CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

Dec 27, 2015

Download

Documents

Shon Gallagher
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05Owens Lake Dust Mitigation ProjectOwens Lake Dust Mitigation Project

Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05Owens Lake Dust Mitigation ProjectOwens Lake Dust Mitigation Project

Los Angeles Department of Water & PowerLos Angeles Department of Water & PowerCH2M HILL and Air SciencesCH2M HILL and Air SciencesLos Angeles Department of Water & PowerLos Angeles Department of Water & PowerCH2M HILL and Air SciencesCH2M HILL and Air Sciences

Bishop, September 28-29 2005Bishop, September 28-29 2005

Bishop, September 28-29 2005Bishop, September 28-29 2005

Page 2: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Goal of Analysis

• To examine spatial and temporal trends in the District sand mass collections, in light of construction activities on the lake bed

Page 3: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Data

• Data provided by District,– Jan 2000-July 2005

• Data summarized by year & month

• CSC locations categorized by location and/or control status

Page 4: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Factors Considered

• Meteorology

• Dust Control Measures (DCMs)

• Construction activities

Page 5: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Meteorology

• Windspeed

• Precipitation

• Temperature & Relative humidity

Page 6: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Page 7: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Page 8: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Page 9: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Page 10: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Meteorology: Results

• Wind speed in ’00-’05 similar to long term trend

• Wind speed similar during all construction phases

• Precipitation variable by year• Temperature and relative humidity

similar to long term trend

Page 11: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Base

Map

Page 12: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Construction Periods

• Pre-construction 1/00-10/00• NSS construction 11/00-12/01• Managed Vegetation 1/02-8/02• Phase 2 shallow flood 9/02-4/03• Interim (no activity) 5/03-8/03• Phase 3 construction 9/03-9/04• Phase 4 shallow flood 10/04-7/05

Page 13: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Analysis of Sand Mass Trends

• Two levels of Analysis:1. Trends by CSC category

2. Trends by individual CSCs

Page 14: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Sand Mass Trends by Category

• High throughout entire period – Shallow Flood Phase 4 and 5– Keeler Dunes

• High initially, decrease with DCMs– NSS Zone 2– Managed Vegetation– Shallow flood Phase 2

Page 15: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Page 16: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Page 17: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Sand Mass Trends by Category

• High initially, construction increase– NSS Zone 1

• Low initially, construction increase– 2002-2004 SCA

Page 18: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Page 19: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Page 20: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Results by CSC Group

• Analysis indicates increased sand mass over time due to construction activities

• However, trends in sand mass are unique on a CSC by CSC basis

Page 21: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Construction Evidence by CSC

• Distance to construction activity

• Timing of construction activity

• Wind speed and precipitation

Page 22: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Results

Map

Page 23: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Page 24: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Results: By individual CSCs

Evidence Category # Cells %

• Unlikely, low sand mass 16 12• Unlikely, high sand mass 39 28• Inconclusive 29 21• Possible evidence 10 7• Strong evidence 44 32

Total 138

Page 25: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Results: ’02-’04 SCA Cells only

Evidence Category # Cells%

• Inconclusive 5 15

• Possible evidence 7 20

• Strong evidence 21 65

Total 33

Page 26: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences

Sand mass affected by:

• Meteorology: No

• DCM: Yes

• Construction: Yes

Page 27: CH2M HILL & Air Sciences September 2005 Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin CSCs, ‘00-’05 Owens Lake Dust Mitigation Project Sand Mass Trends at Great Basin.

September 2005 CH2M HILL & Air Sciences