Top Banner
Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland [email protected] NRI Diploma in Economic Policy Analysis Policy for REDD ______________________________________ _____
30

Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland [email protected] NRI Diploma in Economic.

Jan 03, 2016

Download

Documents

Stewart Moore
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air?

Colin HuntVisiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland

[email protected]

NRI Diploma in Economic Policy Analysis Policy for REDD ___________________________________________

Page 2: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Market failure

Emissions of C at no cost Conservation of C no benefit

Page 3: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

REDD and REDD plus

REDD Reduction in deforestation

and forest degradation

REDD++ Low impact

logging, enrichment planting,

etc.

Page 4: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Global greenhouse gas sources

Energy66%

In-dus-try4%

Agriculture14%

Land use

change &

Forestry

12%

Waste3%

Page 5: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Kyoto 1997l

Page 6: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Bonn, 2005

Page 7: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Coalition of rainforest nations, 2005

Page 8: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Coalition of rainforest nations

Page 9: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Bali 2007

Page 10: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

“If the US is not willing to lead then get out of the way!”

Paula Dobriansky

Kevin Conrad

Page 11: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Copenhagen 2009

Page 12: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Cancun 2010

Page 13: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

PNG’s UNFCCC post-Copenhagen submission

1. Increase GDP per capita more than 3 times by 2030

2. Decrease GHG emissions at least 50% before 2030

2 February 2010

Page 14: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

What about REDD for other land uses in PNG?

Page 15: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

How much carbon in forests?

Ground-truthing

Page 16: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

PNG logging 175,000 ha a year

137 Tonnes C per ha 62 tonnes C per ha

Page 17: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Carbon markets

1 tonne C = 3.67 tonnes of CO2

Page 18: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Markets and ‘mani long win’

Page 19: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Opportunity cost of REDD

Logging companies (profits)

The government (log export tax)

Landowners (royalties and development benefits)

Page 20: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

1. Global (UNFCCC) market for C

Demand for C because of caps

buyers and sellers of C

MRV C $

landowners

Page 21: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

2. Voluntary market for C

Voluntary demand for C offsets

C $

carbon cowboys

MRV? C $

landowners

Page 22: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

“I am a top foreigner in Papua New Guinea, says carbon kingpin”,

Carbon Cowboy

Page 23: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

3. Donor

$

PNG government

MRV C $

landowners

Page 24: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Is a tonne of CO2 a tonne of CO2?

Page 25: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Measurement

Leakage

Permanence

Page 26: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Would the forest have been cleared or logged?

?

Page 27: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

REDD plus in PNG Low impact logging and Logging Code of Practice REDD Plus = CO2 LCP - CO2 LIL

A

Page 28: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

REDD and PNG livelihoods

Page 29: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Donor

$

PNG government

MRV C $

landowners

Page 30: Cash for carbon: hot prospect or hot air? Colin Hunt Visiting Fellow in Economics The University of Queensland c.hunt3@uq.edu.au NRI Diploma in Economic.

Some key wordsREDD and REDD plusGround-truthingMRVCO2 and carbon markets

Voluntary marketDonorLeakage