This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
EN BANCG.R. No. 142840 May 7, 2001ANTONIO BENGSON III, petitioner,v.HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ELECTORAL TRIBUNAL andTEODORO C. CRUZ, repon!ent.KAPUNAN, J.:T"e #iti$en"ip o% repon!ent Teo!oro C. Cr&$ i at i&e in t"i#ae, in vie' o% t"e #ontit&tiona( re)&ire*ent t"at +no peron"a(( e a Me*er o% t"e -o&e o% Repreentative &n(e "e i anat&ra(orn #iti$en.+1
Repon!ent Cr&$ 'a a nat&ra(orn #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine. -e
'a orn in San C(e*ente, Tar(a#, on Apri( 27, 10, o% i(ipinoparent. T"e %&n!a*enta( (a' t"en app(i#a(e 'a t"e 13Contit&tion.2
On Nove*er , 18, "o'ever, repon!ent Cr&$ en(ite! in t"e5nite! State Marine Corp an! 'it"o&t t"e #onent o% t"eRep&(i# o% t"e /"i(ippine, too6 an oat" o% a((eian#e to t"e5nite! State. A a Cone)&en#e, "e (ot "i i(ipino #iti$en"ip%or &n!er Co**on'ea(t" A#t No. 3, e#tion 149, a i(ipino#iti$en *ay (oe "i #iti$en"ip y, a*on ot"er, +ren!erinervi#e to or a##eptin #o**iion in t"e ar*e! %or#e o% a%orein #o&ntry.+ Sai! proviion o% (a' rea!:
SECTION 1. How citizenship may be lost. – A i(ipino #iti$en *ayoe "i #iti$en"ip in any o% t"e %o((o'in 'ay an!;or event:
< < <
49 By ren!erin ervi#e to, or a##eptin #o**iion in, t"ear*e! o% a %orein #o&ntry: Provided, T"at t"e ren!erin o%ervi#e to, or t"e a##eptan#e o% &#" #o**iion in, t"e ar*e!%or#e o% a %orein #o&ntry, an! t"e ta6in o% an oat" o% a((eian#en#i!ent t"ereto, 'it" t"e #onent o% t"e Rep&(i# o% t"e/"i(ippine, "a(( not !ivet a i(ipino o% "i /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip i% eit"er o% t"e %o((o'in #ir#&*tan#e i preent:
a9 T"e Rep&(i# o% t"e /"i(ippine "a a !e%enive an!;oro=enive pa#t o% a((ian#e 'it" ai! %orein #o&ntry> or
ti*e o% ren!erin ai! ervi#e, or a##eptan#e o% ai! #o**iion,an! ta6in t"e oat" o% a((eian#e in#i!ent t"ereto, tate t"at "e!oe o on(y in #onne#tion 'it" "i ervi#e to ai! %orein#o&ntry> And provided, fnally, T"at any i(ipino #iti$en '"o iren!erin ervi#e to, or i #o**iione! in, t"e ar*e! %or#e o% a%orein #o&ntry &n!er any o% t"e #ir#&*tan#e *entione! inpararap" a9 or 9, "a(( not e Rep&(i# o% t"e /"i(ippine!&rin t"e perio! o% "i ervi#e to, or #o**iion in, t"e ar*e!%or#e o% ai! #o&ntry. 5pon "i !i#"are %ro* t"e ervi#e o% t"eai! %orein #o&ntry, "e "a(( e a&to*ati#a((y entit(e! to t"e %&((en?oy*ent o% "i #ivi( an! po(iti#a((y entit(e! to t"e %&(( en?oy*ento% "i #ivi( po(iti#a( ri"t a a i(ipino #iti$en < < <.
@"atever !o&t t"at re*aine! rear!in "i (o o% /"i(ippine#iti$en"ip 'a erae! y "i nat&ra(i$ation a a 5.S. #iti$en on
&ne , 10, in #onne#tion 'it" "i ervi#e in t"e 5.S. MarineCorp.
On Mar#" 17, 14, repon!ent Cr&$ rea#)&ire! "i /"i(ippine#iti$en"ip t"ro&" repatriation &n!er Rep&(i# A#t No. 230. 3 -eran %or an! 'a e(e#te! a t"e Repreentative o% t"e Se#on!itri#t o% /anainan in t"e May 11, 18 e(e#tion. -e 'on y a#onvin#in *arin o% 2,71 vote over petitioner AntonioBenon III, '"o 'a t"en r&nnin %or ree(e#tion.1âwphi1.nêt
S&e)&ent(y, petitioner (e! a #ae %or Qo !arranto Ad"atelam 'it" repon!ent -o&e o% Repreentative E(e#tora(Tri&na( -RET9 #(ai*in t"at repon!ent Cr&$ 'a not )&a(ie!to e#o*e a *e*er o% t"e -o&e o% Repreentative in#e "e inot a nat&ra(orn #iti$en a re)&ire! &n!er Arti#(e DI, e#tion o% t"e Contit&tion.4
On Mar#" 2, 2000, t"e -RET ren!ere! it !e#iion !i*iin petition %or #o warranto an! !e#(arin Cr&$ t"e !&(y e(e#te!Repreentative o% t"e Se#on! itri#t o% /anainan in t"e May18 e(e#tion. T"e -RET (i6e'ie !enie! petitioner *otion %re#oni!eration o% t"e !e#iion in it reo(&tion !ate! Apri( 27,2000.
T"e i&e no' e%ore & i '"et"er repon!ent Cr&$, a nat&ra
orn i(ipino '"o e#a*e an A*eri#an #iti$en, #an ti(( e#oni!ere! a nat&ra(orn i(ipino &pon "i rea#)&iition o%/"i(ippine #iti$en"ip.
/etitioner aert t"at repon!ent Cr&$ *ay no (oner e#oni!ere! a nat&ra(orn i(ipino in#e "e (ot " i /"i(ippine#iti$en"ip '"en "e 'ore a((eian#e to t"e 5nite! State in1, an! "a! to rea#)&ire t"e a*e y repatriation. -e initt"at Arti#(e #iti$en are t"oe '"o are %ro* irt" 'it" o&t "avito per%or* any a#t to a#)&ire or per%e#t &#" #iti$en"ip.
Repon!ent on t"e ot"er "an! #onten! t"at "e rea#)&ire! "itat& a nat&ra(orn #iti$en '"en "e 'a repatriate! in#e tp"rae +%ro* irt"+ in Arti#(e ID, Se#tion 2 re%er to t"e innate,in"erent an! inorn #"ara#teriti# o% ein a nat&ra(orn #iti$
T"e petition i 'it"o&t *erit.
T"e 187 Contit&tion en&*erate '"o are i(ipino #iti$en a%o((o':
19 T"oe '"o are #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine at t"e ti*e o% t"ea!option o% t"i Contit&tion>
29 T"oe '"oe %at"er or *ot"er are #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippin
49 T"oe '"o are nat&ra(i$e! in a##or!an#e 'it" (a'.8
T"ere are t'o 'ay o% a#)&irin #iti$en"ip: 19 y irt", an!
y nat&ra(i$ation. T"ee 'ay o% a#)&irin #iti$en"ip #orrepoto t"e t'o 6in! o% #iti$en: t"e nat&ra(orn #iti$en, an! t"enat&ra(i$e! #iti$en. A peron '"o at t"e ti*e o% "i irt" i a#iti$en o% a parti#&(ar #o&ntry, i a nat&ra(orn #iti$en t"ereo%.
A !ene! in t"e a*e Contit&tion, nat&ra(orn #iti$en +aret"oe #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine %ro* irt" 'it"o&t "avin toper%or* any a#t to a#)&ire or per%e#t "i /"i(ippine #ite$en"ip
On t"e ot"er "an!, nat&ra(i$e! #iti$en are t"oe '"o "avee#o*e i(ipino #iti$en t"ro&" nat&ra(i$ation, enera((y &n!eCo**on'ea(t" A#t No. 473, ot"er'ie 6no'n a t"e Revie!Nat&ra(i$ation Fa', '"i#" repea(e! t"e %or*er Nat&ra(i$ation FA#t No. 2279, an! y Rep&(i# A#t No. 30. 11 To e nat&ra(i$ean app(i#ant "a to prove t"at "e poee a(( t"e)&a(i#ation12 an! none o% t"e !i)&a(i#ation13 provi!e! y (
to e#o*e a i(ipino #iti$en. T"e !e#iion rantin /"i(ippine#iti$en"ip e#o*e e<e#&tory on(y a%ter t'o 29 year %ro* itpro*&(ation '"en t"e #o&rt i atie! t"at !&rin t"entervenin perio!, t"e app(i#ant "a 19 not (e%t t"e /"i(ippine>29 "a !e!i#ate! "i*e(% to a (a'%&( #a((in or pro%eion> 39 "anot een #onvi#te! o% any o=ene or vio(ation o% Govern*entpro*&(ate! r&(e> or 49 #o**itte! any a#t pre?&!i#ia( to t"enteret o% t"e nation or #ontrary to any Govern*ent anno&n#e!po(i#ie.14
*o!e y '"i#" /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip *ay e rea#)&ire! y a%or*er #iti$en: 19 y nat&ra(i$ation, 29 y repatriation, an! 39y !ire#t a#t o% Conre.1
Nat&ra(i$ation i *o!e %or ot" a#)&iition an! rea#)&iition o%/"i(ippine #iti$en"ip. A a *o!e o% initia((y a#)&irin /"i(ippine#iti$en"ip, nat&ra(i$ation i overne! y Co**on'ea(t" A#t No.473, a a*en!e!. On t"e ot"er "an!, nat&ra(i$ation a a *o!e%or rea#)&irin /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip i overne! yCo**on'ea(t" A#t No. 3.1 5n!er t"i (a', a %or*er i(ipino#iti$en '"o 'i"e to rea#)&ire /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip *&tpoe #ertain )&a(i#ation17 an! none o% t"e !i)&a(i#ation*entione! in Se#tion 4 o% C.A. 473.18
Repatriation, on t"e ot"er "an!, *ay e "a! &n!er vario&
tat&te y t"oe '"o (ot t"eir #iti$en"ip !&e to: 19 !eertiono% t"e ar*e! %or#e>1 ervi#e in t"e ar*e! %or#e o% t"e a((ie!%or#e in @or(! @ar II>20 39 ervi#e in t"e Ar*e! or#e o% t"e5nite! State at any ot"er ti*e,21 49 *arriae o% a i(ipino'o*an to an a(ien>22 an! 9 po(iti#a( e#ono*i# ne#eity.23
<<<. /arent"eti#a((y, &n!er t"ee tat&te re%errin to RA No. an! 230H, t"e peron !eirin to rea#)&ire /"i(ippine
#iti$en"ip 'o&(! not even e re)&ire! to (e a petition in #o&rt,an! a(( t"at "e "a! to !o 'a to ta6e an oat" o% a((eian#e to t"eRep&(i# o% t"e /"i(ippine an! to reiter t"at %a#t 'it" t"e #ivi(reitry in t"e p(a#e o% "i rei!en#e or '"ere "e "a! (at rei!e!n t"e /"i(ippine. Ita(i# in t"e oriina(.2
Moreover, repatriation re&(t in t"e re#overy o% t"e oriina(nationa(ity.2 T"i *ean t"at a nat&ra(i$e! i(ipino '"o (ot "i#iti$en"ip 'i(( e retore! to "i prior tat& a a nat&ra(i$e!i(ipino #iti$en. On t"e ot"er "an!, i% "e 'a oriina((y a nat&ra(orn #iti$en e%ore "e (ot "i /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip, "e 'i(( eretore! to "i %or*er tat& a a nat&ra(orn i(ipino.
n repon!ent Cr&$ #ae, "e (ot "i i(ipino #iti$en"ip '"en "eren!ere! ervi#e in t"e Ar*e! or#e o% t"e 5nite! State.-o'ever, "e &e)&ent(y rea#)&ire! /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip &n!er
R.A. No. 230, '"i#" provi!e:
Se#tion 1. Any peron '"o "a! (ot "i /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip yren!erin ervi#e to, or a##eptin #o**iion in, t"e Ar*e!or#e o% t"e 5nite! State, or a%ter eparation %ro* t"e Ar*e!or#e o% t"e 5nite! State, a#)&ire! 5nite! State #iti$en"ip,*ay rea#)&ire /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip y ta6in an oat" o%a((eian#e to t"e Rep&(i# o% t"e /"i(ippine an! reiterin t"ea*e 'it" Fo#a( Civi( Reitry in t"e p(a#e '"ere "e rei!e orat rei!e! in t"e /"i(ippine. T"e ai! oat" o% a((eian#e "a((#ontain a ren&n#iation o% any ot"er #iti$en"ip.
-avin t"& ta6en t"e re)&ire! oat" o% a((eian#e to t"e Rep&(i#an! "avin reitere! t"e a*e in t"e Civi( Reitry o%Maantare*, /anainan in a##or!an#e 'it" t"e a%ore#ite!
proviion, repon!ent Cr&$ i !ee*e! to "ave re#overe! "i
oriina( tat& a a nat&ra(orn #iti$en, a tat& '"i#" "ea#)&ire! at irt" a t"e on o% a i(ipino %at"er.27 It ear tret"at t"e a#t o% repatriation a((o' "i* to recover, or retrn t
/etitioner #ontention t"at repon!ent Cr&$ i no (oner anat&ra(orn #iti$en in#e "e "a! to per%or* an a#t to reain "#iti$en"ip i &ntena(e. A #orre#t(y e<p(aine! y t"e -RET in!e#iion, t"e ter* +nat&ra(orn #iti$en+ 'a rt !ene! inArti#(e III, Se#tion 4 o% t"e 173 Contit&tion a %o((o':
Se#. 4. A nat&ra(orn #iti$en i one '"o i a #iti$en o% t"e/"i(ippine %ro* irt" 'it"o&t "avin to per%or* any a#t to
a#)&ire or per%e#t "i /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip.
T'o re)&iite *&t #on#&r %or a peron to e #oni!ere! a &19 a peron *&t e a i(ipino #iti$en irt" an! 29 "e !oe no"ave to per%or* any a#t to otain or per%e#t "i /"i(ippine#iti$en"ip.
5n!er t"e 173 Contit&tion !enition, t"ere 'ere t'o #ateoo% i(ipino #iti$en '"i#" 'ere not #oni!ere! nat&ra(orn: 19t"oe '"o 'ere nat&ra(i$e! an! 29 t"oe orn e%ore an&ary 173,38 o% i(ipino *ot"er '"o, &pon rea#"in t"e ae o%*a?ority, e(e#te! /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip. T"oe +nat&ra(i$e!#iti$en+ 'ere not #oni!ere! nat&ra(orn ovio&(y e#a&et"ey 'ere not i(ipino at irt" an! "a! to per%or* an a#t toa#)&ire /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip. T"oe orn o% i(ipino *ot"ere%ore t"e e=e#tive(y o% t"e 173 Contit&tion 'ere (i6e'ie n#oni!ere! nat&ra(orn e#a&e t"ey a(o "a! to per%or* an to per%e#t t"eir /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip.
T"e preent Contit&tion, "o'ever, no' #oni!er t"oe orn oi(ipino *ot"er e%ore t"e e=e#tivity o% t"e 173 Contit&tionan! '"o e(e#te! /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip &pon rea#"in t"e *a?oae a nat&ra(orn. A%ter !enin '"o re nat&ra(orn #iti$enSe#tion 2 o% Arti#(e ID a!! a enten#e: +T"oe '"o e(e#t/"i(ippine #iti$en"ip in a##or!an#e 'it" pararap" 39, Se#tio"ereo% "a(( e !ee*e! nat&ra(orn #iti$en.+ Cone)&ent(y, onat&ra(i$e! i(ipino are #oni!ere! not nat&ra(orn #iti$en. Iapparent %ro* t"e en&*eration o% '"o are #iti$en &n!er t"epreent Contit&tion t"at t"ere are on(y t'o #(ae o% #iti$en19 t"oe '"o are nat&ra(orn an! 29 t"oe '"o are nat&ra(i$in a##or!an#e 'it" (a'. A #iti$en '"o i not a nat&ra(i$e! i(ipi
i.e., !i! not "ave to &n!ero t"e pro#e o% nat&ra(i$ation tootain /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip, ne#eari(y i nat&ra(orn i(ipinoNote'ort"y i t"e aen#e in ai! en&*eration o% a eparate#ateory %or peron '"o, a%ter (oin /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip,&e)&ent(y rea#)&ire it. T"e reaon t"ere%or i #(ear: a to peron, t"ey 'o&(! eit"er e nat&ra(orn or nat&ra(i$e!!epen!in on t"e reaon %or t"e (o o% t"eir #iti$en"ip an! t*o!e pre#rie! y t"e app(i#a(e (a' %or t"e rea#)&iitiont"ereo%. A repon!ent Cr&$ 'a not re)&ire! y (a' to ot"ro&" nat&ra(i$ation pro#ee!in in or!er to rea#)&ire "i#iti$en"ip, "e i per%or#e a nat&ra(orn i(ipino. A &#", "epoee! a(( t"e ne#eary )&a(i#ation to e e(e#te! a*e*er o% t"e -o&e o% Repreentative.
A na( point. T"e -RET "a een e*po'ere! y t"e Contit&ti
to e t"e +o(e ?&!e+ o% a(( #ontet re(atin to t"e e(e#tion,ret&rn, an! )&a(i#ation o% t"e *e*er o% t"e -o&e.2 T"eCo&rt ?&ri!i#tion over t"e -RET i *ere(y to #"e#6 +'"et"er not t"ere "a een a rave a&e o% !i#retion a*o&ntin to (aor e<#e o% ?&ri!i#tion+ on t"e part o% t"e (atter.30 In t"e aet"ereo%, t"ere i no o##aion %or t"e Co&rt to e<er#ie it#orre#tive po'er an! ann&( t"e !e#iion o% t"e -RET nor to&tit&te t"e Co&rt ?&!e*ent %or t"at o% t"e (atter %or t"ei*p(e reaon t"at it i not t"e o#e o% a petition %or #ertiorariin)&ire into t"e #orre#tne o% t"e aai(e! !e#iion. 31 T"ere i&#" "o'in o% rave a&e o% !i#retion in t"i #ae.
2UAN . FRIVALDO, petitioner,v.CO++ISSION ON ELECTIONS, and RAUL R. LEE, repon!ent..R. No. -5611 2ne 3, -004RAUL R. LEE, petitioner,v.CO++ISSION ON ELECTIONS and 2UAN .FRIVALDO, repon!ent.PANANIBAN, J.: p
T"e &(ti*ate )&etion poe! e%ore t"i Co&rt in t"ee t'in #ae: @"o "o&(! e !e#(are! t"e ri"t%&( overnor o% Soroon
i9 &an G. riva(!o, '"o &n)&etiona(y otaine! t"e "i"etn&*er o% vote in t"ree &##eive e(e#tion &t '"o 'a t'i#e!e#(are! y t"i Co&rt to e !i)&a(ie! to "o(! &#" o#e !&e to"i a(ien #iti$en"ip, an! '"o no' #(ai* to "ave rea&*e! "iot /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip t"r& repatriation>
ii9 Ra&( R. Fee, '"o 'a t"e e#on! p(a#er in t"e #anva, &t'"o #(ai* t"at t"e vote #at in %avor o% riva(!o "o&(! e#oni!ere! voi!> t"at t"e e(e#torate "o&(! e !ee*e! to "avententiona((y t"ro'n a'ay t"eir a((ot> an! t"at le$ally , "ee#&re! t"e *ot n&*er o% valid vote> or
iii9 T"e in#&*ent Di#eGovernor, O#ar G. eri, '"o ovio&(y'a not vote! !ire#t(y to t"e poition o% overnor, &t '"oa##or!in to prevai(in ?&ripr&!en#e "o&(! ta6e over t"e ai!pot ina*&#" a, y t"e ine(iii(ity o% riva(!o, a +per*anent
On Mar#" 20, 1, private repon!ent &an G. riva(!o (e! "iCerti#ate o% Can!i!a#y %or t"e o#e o% Governor o% Soroon int"e May 8, 1 e(e#tion. On Mar#" 23, 1, petitioner Ra&( R.Fee, anot"er #an!i!ate, (e! a petition 7 'it" t"e Co*e(e#!o#6ete! a S/A No. 028 prayin t"at riva(!o +e !i)&a(ie!%ro* ee6in or "o(!in any p&(i# o#e or poition y reaon o%not yet ein a #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine+, an! t"at "i Certi#ateo% Can!i!a#y e #an#e(e!. On May 1, 1, t"e Se#on! iviiono% t"e Co*e(e# pro*&(ate! a Reo(&tion 1rantin t"e petition'it" t"e %o((o'in !ipoition 4:
@-EREORE, t"i iviion reo(ve to GRANT t"e petition an!!e#(are t"at repon!ent i ISK5AFIIE to r&n %or t"e O#e o%
Governor o% Soroon on t"e ro&n! t"at "e i NOT a #iti$en o%t"e /"i(ippine. A##or!in(y, repon!ent #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y #an#e(e!.
T"e Motion %or Re#oni!eration (e! y riva(!o re*aine!&na#te! &pon &nti( a%ter t"e May 8, 1 e(e#tion. So, "i#an!i!a#y #ontin&e! an! "e 'a vote! %or !&rin t"e e(e#tion"e(! on ai! !ate. On May 11, 1, t"e Co*e(e# en
On &ne , 1, Fee (e! in ai! S/A No. 028, a&pp(e*enta(9 petition 0 prayin %or "i pro#(a*ation a t"e !e(e#te! Governor o% Soroon.
In an or!er -/ !ate! &ne 21, 1, &t pro*&(ate! a##or!int"e petition +on(y on &ne 2, 1,+ t"e Co*e(e# enbanc !ire#te! +t"e /rovin#ia( Boar! o% Canvaer o% Soroonre#onvene %or t"e p&rpoe o% pro#(ai*in #an!i!ate Ra&( Fee at"e 'innin &ernatoria( #an!i!ate in t"e provin#e o% Sorooon &ne 2, 1 . . .+ A##or!in(y, at 8:30 in t"e evenin o% &30, 1, Fee 'a pro#(ai*e! overnor o% Soroon.
On &(y , 1, riva(!o (e! 'it" t"e Co*e(e# a ne'petition, -- !o#6ete! a S/C No. 317, prayin %or t"eann&(*ent o% t"e &ne 30, 1 pro#(a*ation o% Fee an! %or "io'n pro#(a*ation. -e a((ee! t"at on &ne 30, 1, at 2:00 int"e a%ternoon, "e too6 "i oat" o% a((eian#e a a #iti$en o% t"e/"i(ippine a%ter +"i petition %or repatriation &n!er /.. 72 '"e (e! 'it" t"e Spe#ia( Co**ittee on Nat&ra(i$ation inSepte*er 14 "a! een rante!+. A &#", '"en +t"e ai!or!er !ate! &ne 21, 19 o% t"e Co*e(e#9 . . . 'a re(eae!
an! re#eive! y riva(!o on &ne 30, 1 at :30 o#(o#6 in t"evenin, t"ere 'a no *ore (ea( i*pe!i*ent to t"e pro#(a*ao% riva(!o9 a overnor . . .+ In t"e a(ternative, "e averre! t"ap&r&ant to t"e t'o #ae o% abo vs. "omelec, - t"e Di#eGovernor not Fee "o&(! o##&py ai! poition o% overnor.
/REMISES CONSIERE, t"e Co**iion irt iviion9,t"ere%ore RESOFDES to GRANT t"e /etition.
Conitent 'it" t"e !e#iion o% t"e S&pre*e Co&rt, t"epro#(a*ation o% Ra&( R. Fee a Governor o% Soroon i "ereyor!ere! ann&((e!, ein #ontrary to (a', "e not "avin arneret"e "i"et n&*er o% vote to 'arrant "i pro#(a*ation.
5pon t"e na(ity o% t"e ann&(*ent o% t"e pro#(a*ation o% Ra&(Fee, t"e /rovin#ia( Boar! o% Canvaer i !ire#te! to i**e!iare#onvene an!, on t"e ai o% t"e #o*p(ete! #anva, pro#(aipetitioner &an G. riva(!o a t"e !&(y e(e#te! Governor o%Soroon "avin arnere! t"e "i"et n&*er o% vote, an! ""avin rea#)&ire! "i i(ipino #iti$en"ip y repatriation on &n30, 1 &n!er t"e proviion o% /rei!entia( e#ree No. 72 a
t"&, )&a(ie! to "o(! t"e o#e o% Governor o% Soroon.
On e#e*er 2, 1, Fee (e! a *otion %or re#oni!eration'"i#" 'a !enie! y t"e Co*e(e# en banc in itReo(&tion -7 pro*&(ate! on er&ary 23, 1. On er&ary 1, t"e preent petition 'a (e!. A#tin on t"e prayer %or ate*porary retrainin or!er, t"i Co&rt i&e! on er&ary 27,1 a Reo(&tion '"i#" inter alia !ire#te! t"e partie +to*aintain t"e stats #o prevai(in prior to t"e (in o% t"ipetition.+
/etitioner Fee +poition on t"e *atter at "an! *ay rieLy e#ap&(i$e! in t"e %o((o'in propoition+ -1:
-irst T"e initiatory petition e(o' 'a o %ar in&#ient in %or*an! &tan#e to 'arrant t"e e<er#ie y t"e COMEFEC o% it&ri!i#tion 'it" t"e re&(t t"at, in e=e#t, t"e COMEFEC a#te!'it"o&t ?&ri!i#tion in ta6in #oni$an#e o% an! !e#i!in ai!petition>
2econd 33 T"e ?&!i#ia((y !e#(are! !i)&a(i#ation o% repon!ent'a a #ontin&in #on!ition an! ren!ere! "i* ine(ii(e to r&n %or,
to e e(e#te! to an! to "o(! t"e O#e o% Governor>
hird 33 T"e a((ee! repatriation o% repon!ent 'a neit"er va(i!nor i t"e e=e#t t"ereo% retroa#tive a to #&re "i ine(iii(ity an!)&a(i%y "i* to "o(! t"e O#e o% Governor> an!
T"i i a petition to ann&( t"ree Reo(&tion o% t"e repon!entCo*e(e#, t"e rt t'o o% '"i#" are a(o at i&e in G.R. No.1237, a %o((o':
1. Reo(&tion
-4
o% t"e Se#on! iviion, pro*&(ate! on May 1,1, !i)&a(i%yin riva(!o %ro* r&nnin %or overnor o%Soroon in t"e May 8, 1 e(e#tion +on t"e ro&n! t"at "e inot a #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine+>
2. Reo(&tion -6 o% t"e Co*e(e# en banc, pro*&(ate! on May 11,1> an!
3. Reo(&tion -3 o% t"e Co*e(e# en banc, pro*&(ate! a(o on May11, 1 &pen!in t"e pro#(a*ation o%, a*on ot"er, riva(!o.
he -acts and the sse
T"e %a#t o% t"i #ae are eentia((y t"e a*e a t"oe in G.R.No. 1237. -o'ever, riva(!o aai( t"e aove*entione!reo(&tion on a !i=erent ro&n!: t"at &n!er Se#tion 78 o% t"e
O*ni& E(e#tion Co!e, '"i#" i repro!&#e! "erein&n!er:Se#. 78. Petition to deny de corse or to cancel a certifcate o6candidacy . A verie! petition ee6in to !eny !&e #o&re or to#an#e( a #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y *ay e (e! y any perone<#(&ive(y on t"e ro&n! t"at any *ateria( repreentation#ontaine! t"erein a re)&ire! &n!er Se#tion 74 "ereo% i %a(e.T"e petition *ay e (e! at any ti*e not (ater t"an t'entyve!ay %ro* t"e ti*e o% t"e (in o% t"e #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#yan! shall be decided, a%ter noti#e an! "earin, not later than
f6teen days be6ore the election. E*p"ai &pp(ie!.9
t"e Co*e(e# "a! no ?&ri!i#tion to i&e ai! Reo(&tion e#a&et"ey 'ere not ren!ere! +'it"in t"e perio! a((o'e! y (a'+ i.e.,+not (ater t"an %teen !ay e%ore t"e e(e#tion.+
Ot"er'ie tate!, riva(!o #onten! t"at t"e %ai(&re o% t"eCo*e(e# to a#t on t"e petition %or !i)&a(i#ation 'it"in t"eperio! o% %teen !ay prior to t"e e(e#tion a provi!e! y (a' i a&ri!i#tiona( !e%e#t '"i#" ren!er t"e ai! Reo(&tion n&(( an!voi!.
By Reo(&tion on Mar#" 12, 1, t"e Co&rt #ono(i!ate! G.R.No. 1202 an! 1237 in#e t"ey are inti*ate(y re(ate! in t"eir%a#t&a( environ*ent an! are i!enti#a( in t"e &(ti*ate )&etionraie!, viz ., '"o "o&(! o##&py t"e poition o% overnor o% t"eprovin#e o% Soroon.
On Mar#" 1, 1, t"e Co&rt "ear! ora( ar&*ent %ro* t"epartie an! re)&ire! t"e* t"erea%ter to (e i*&(taneo&(y t"eirrepe#tive *e*oran!a.
1. @a t"e repatriation o% riva(!o va(i! an! (ea(J I% o, !i! iteaona(y #&re "i (a#6 o% #iti$en"ip a to )&a(i%y "i* to epro#(ai*e! an! to "o(! t"e O#e o% GovernorJ I% not, *ay it iven retroa#tive e=e#tJ I% o, %ro* '"enJ
2. I riva(!o +?&!i#ia((y !e#(are!+ !i)&a(i#ation %or (a#6 o%i(ipino #iti$en"ip a #ontin&in ar to "i e(iii(ity to r&n %or, e(e#te! to or "o(! t"e overnor"ip o% SoroonJ
3. i! t"e repon!ent Co*e(e# "ave ?&ri!i#tion over t"e
initiatory petition in S/C No. 317 #oni!erin t"at ai! petiti not +a prepro#(a*ation #ae, an e(e#tion protet or a #owarranto #ae+J
4. @a t"e pro#(a*ation o% Fee, a r&nner&p in t"e e(e#tion, vaan! (ea( in (i"t o% e<itin ?&ripr&!en#eJ
. i! t"e repon!ent Co**iion on E(e#tion e<#ee! it ?&ri!i#tion in pro*&(atin t"e aai(e! Reo(&tion, a(( o% '"iprevente! riva(!o %ro* a&*in t"e overnor"ip o% Soroo#oni!erin t"at t"ey 'ere not ren!ere! 'it"in t"e perio!re%erre! to in Se#tion 78 o% t"e O*ni& E(e#tion Co!e, viz ., +n(ater t"an %teen !ay e%ore t"e e(e#tion+J
he -irst sse: -rivaldo7s %epatriation
T"e va(i!ity an! e=e#tivity o% riva(!o repatriation i t"e lismota, t"e t"re"o(! (ea( i&e in t"i #ae. A(( t"e ot"er *atteraie! are e#on!ary to t"i.
Se#. 3. Qalifcations. a9 An e(e#tive (o#a( o#ia( *&t e #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine> a reitere! voter in t"e aranay,*&ni#ipa(ity, #ity, or provin#e or, in t"e #ae o% a *e*er o% t"an&nian pan(a(a'ian, an&nian pan(&no!, oran&nian ayan, t"e !itri#t '"ere "e inten! to e e(e#te!rei!ent t"erein %or at (eat one 19 year i**e!iate(y pre#e!int"e !ay o% t"e e(e#tion> an! a(e to rea! an! 'rite i(ipino or aot"er (o#a( (an&ae or !ia(e#t.
9 Can!i!ate %or t"e poition o% overnor, vi#e overnor or*e*er o% t"e an&nian pan(a(a'ian, or *ayor, vi#e *ayor *e*er o% t"e an&nian pan(&no! o% "i"(y &rani$e!#itie *&t e at (eat t'entyt"ree 239 year o% ae on e(e#ti!ay.
<<< <<< <<<
Ina*&#" a riva(!o "a! een !e#(are! y t"i Co&rt / a a n#iti$en, it i t"ere%ore in#&*ent &pon "i* to "o' t"at "e "area#)&ire! #iti$en"ip> in ne, t"at "e poee t"e)&a(i#ation pre#rie! &n!er t"e ai! tat&te R.A. 7109.
5n!er /"i(ippine (a', - #iti$en"ip *ay e rea#)&ire! y !ire#a#t o% Conre, y nat&ra(i$ation or y repatriation. riva(!o t
t"i Co&rt in G.R. No. 1044 an! !&rin t"e ora( ar&*ent t"i #ae t"at "e trie! to re&*e "i #iti$en"ip y direct act o"on$ress, &t t"at t"e i(( a((o'in "i* to !o o +%ai(e! to*ateria(i$e, not'it"tan!in t"e en!ore*ent o% evera(*e*er o% t"e -o&e o% Repreentative+ !&e, a##or!in to "to t"e +*ane&ver o% "i po(iti#a( riva(.+ In t"e a*e #ae, "iatte*pt at natralization 'a re?e#te! y t"i Co&rt e#a&e o ?&ri!i#tiona(, &tantia( an! pro#e!&ra( !e%e#t.
epite "i (a#6 o% /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip, riva(!o 'aover'"e(*in(y e(e#te! overnor y t"e e(e#torate o% Soroo'it" a *arin o% 27,000 vote in t"e 188 e(e#tion, 7,000 in12, an! 20,000 in 1 over t"e a*e opponent Ra&( Fee. T'i#e, "e 'a ?&!i#ia((y !e#(are! a noni(ipino an! t"& t'i#e!i)&a(ie! %ro* "o(!in an! !i#"arin "i pop&(ar *an!ate
No', "e #o*e to & a t"ir! ti*e, 'it" a %re" vote %ro* t"e
T"i *e*oran!&* !ate! Mar#" 27, 187 7 #annot y any tret#"o% (ea( "er*ene&ti# e #ontr&e! a a (a' an#tionin ora&t"ori$in a repea( o% /.. No. 72. Fa' are repea(e! on(y y&e)&ent one 1 an! a repea( *ay e e<pre or i*p(ie!. It iovio& t"at no e9press repeal 'a *a!e e#a&e t"en /rei!entA)&ino in "er *e*oran!&* ae! on t"e #opy %&rni"e! & yFee !i! not #ateori#a((y an!;or i*p(ie!(y tate t"at /.. 72'a ein repea(e! or 'a ein ren!ere! 'it"o&t any (ea(e=e#t. In %a#t, "e !i! not even *ention it pe#i#a((y y itn&*er or te<t. On t"e ot"er "an!, it i a ai# r&(e o% tat&tory#ontr&#tion t"at repeals by implication are not %avore!. An*p(ie! repea( 'i(( not e a((o'e! +&n(e it i #onvin#in(y an!&na*i&o&(y !e*ontrate! t"at t"e t'o (a' are #(ear(yrep&nant an! patent(y in#onitent t"at t"ey #annot #oe<it+. 4
T"e *e*oran!&* o% t"en /rei!ent A)&ino #annot even erear!e! a a (ei(ative ena#t*ent, %or not everyprono&n#e*ent o% t"e C"ie% E<e#&tive even &n!er t"e Tranitory/roviion o% t"e 187 Contit&tion #an nor "o&(! e rear!e! aan e<er#ie o% "er (a'*a6in po'er. At et, it #o&(! e treate!a an e<e#&tive po(i#y a!!ree! to t"e Spe#ia( Co**ittee to "a(tt"e a##eptan#e an! pro#ein o% app(i#ation %or repatriationpen!in '"atever +?&!*ent t"e rt Conre &n!er t"e 187
Contit&tion+ *i"t *a6e. In ot"er 'or!, t"e %or*er /rei!ent!i! not repea( /.. 72 &t (e%t it to t"e rt Conre on#e#reate! to !ea( 'it" t"e *atter. I% "e "a! inten!e! to repea(&#" (a', "e "o&(! "ave &ne)&ivo#a((y ai! o intea! o%re%errin t"e *atter to Conre. T"e %a#t i "e #are%&((y#o&#"e! "er prei!entia( i&an#e in ter* t"at #(ear(y in!i#ate!t"e intention o% +t"e preent overn*ent, in t"e e<er#ie o%pr&!en#e an! o&n! !i#retion+ to (eave t"e *atter o% repea( tot"e ne' Conre. Any ot"er interpretation o% t"e ai!/rei!entia( Me*oran!&*, &#" a i no' ein pro=ere! to t"eCo&rt y Fee, 'o&(! viit &n*itiate! vio(en#e not on(y &pontat&tory #ontr&#tion &t on #o**on ene a 'e((.
Co**ittee on Nat&ra(i$ation 'a inten!e! o(e(y %or t"e perointeret o% repon!ent,+ 6 t"e So(i#itor Genera( e<p(aine! !&rit"e ora( ar&*ent on Mar#" 1, 1 t"at &#" a((eation ii*p(y ae(e a t"ere 'ere *any ot"er '"o app(ie! an! '#oni!ere! %or repatriation, a (it o% '"o* 'a &*itte! y "to t"i Co&rt, t"ro&" a Mani%etation 3 (e! on Apri( 3, 1.
On t"e ai o% t"e partie &*iion, 'e are #onvin#e! t"at"e pre&*ption o% re&(arity in t"e per%or*an#e o% o#ia( !&tan! t"e pre&*ption o% (ea(ity in t"e repatriation o% riva(!o"ave not een &##e%&((y re&tte! y Fee. T"e *ere %a#t t"at"e pro#ee!in 'ere pee!e! &p i y ite(% not a ro&n! to#on#(&!e t"at &#" pro#ee!in 'ere ne#eari(y tainte!. A%tea((, t"e re)&ire*ent o% repatriation &n!er /.. No. 72 are not!i#&(t to #o*p(y 'it", nor are t"ey te!io& an! #&*ero*e
%a#t, /..72 0 ite(% re)&ire very (itt(e o% an app(i#ant, an! even t"e r&an! re&(ation to i*p(e*ent t"e ai! !e#ree 'ere (e%t to t"eSpe#ia( Co**ittee to pro*&(ate. T"i i not &n&&a( in#e,&n(i6e in nat&ra(i$ation '"ere an a(ien #ovet a frst3timeentryinto /"i(ippine po(iti#a( (i%e, in repatriation t"e app(i#ant i a%or*er nat&ra(orn i(ipino '"o i *ere(y ee6in to rea#)&ireprevio& #iti$en"ip. In t"e #ae o% riva(!o, "e 'a &n!o&te!nat&ra(orn #iti$en '"o open(y an! %ait"%&((y erve! "i #o&ntan! "i provin#e prior to "i nat&ra(i$ation in t"e 5nite! Statea nat&ra(i$ation "e init 'a *a!e ne#eary on(y to e#apeiron #(&t#"e o% a !i#tator"ip "e a"orre! an! #o&(! not in#on#ien#e e*ra#e an! '"o, a%ter t"e %a(( o% t"e !i#tator ant"e reeta(i"*ent o% !e*o#rati# pa#e, 'ate! no ti*e inret&rnin to "i #o&ntry o% irt" to o=er on#e *ore "i ta(ent a
ervi#e to "i peop(e.So too, t"e %a#t t"at ten ot"er peron, a #ertie! to y t"eSo(i#itor Genera(, 'ere rante! repatriation ar&e #onvin#inan! #on#(&ive(y aaint t"e e<iten#e o% %avoriti* ve"e*entpoite! y Ra&( Fee. At any rate, any #ontet on t"e (ea(ity o%riva(!o repatriation "o&(! "ave een p&r&e! e%ore t"eCo**ittee ite(%, an!, %ai(in t"ere, in t"e O#e o% t"e /rei!ep&r&ant to t"e !o#trine o% e<"a&tion o% a!*initrativere*e!ie.
hird, Fee %&rt"er #onten! t"at a&*in t"e aai(e!repatriation to e va(i!, nevert"e(e it #o&(! on(y e e=e#tiveat 2:00 p.*. o% &ne 30, 1 '"erea t"e #iti$en"ip )&a(i#apre#rie! y t"e Fo#a( Govern*ent Co!e +*&t e<it on t"e !o% "i e(e#tion, i% not '"en t"e #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y i (e!,
#itin o&r !e#iion in G.R. 1044 5/ '"i#" "e(! t"at +ot" t"eFo#a( Govern*ent Co!e an! t"e Contit&tion re)&ire t"at on(y/"i(ippine #iti$en can rn and be elected to pblic o:ce.+Ovio&(y, "o'ever, t"i 'a a *ere obiter a t"e on(y i&e iai! #ae 'a '"et"er riva(!o nat&ra(i$ation 'a va(i! or noan! NOT t"e e=e#tive !ate t"ereo%. Sin#e t"e Co&rt "e(! "inat&ra(i$ation to e inva(i!, t"en t"e i&e o% '"en an apirantp&(i# o#e "o&(! e a #iti$en 'a NOT reo(ve! at a(( y t"eCo&rt. @"i#" )&etion 'e "a(( no' !ire#t(y r&(e on.
a rei!ent t"erein %or at (eat one 19 year i**e!iate(ypre#e!in t"e !ay o% t"e e(e#tion>
a(e to rea! an! 'rite i(ipino or any ot"er (o#a( (an&ae or!ia(e#t.
In a!!ition, +#an!i!ate %or t"e poition o% overnor . . . *&t eat (eat t'entyt"ree 239 year o% ae on e(e#tion !ay.
ro* t"e aove, it 'i(( e note! t"at t"e (a' !oe not pe#i%y anyparti#&(ar !ate or ti*e '"en t"e #an!i!ate *&t poe#iti$en"ip, &n(i6e t"at %or rei!en#e '"i#" *&t #onit o% ateat one year7s residency immediately precedin$ t"e !ay o%
e(e#tion9 an! ae at (eat t'enty t"ree year o% ae on electionday 9.
/"i(ippine #iti$en"ip i an in!ipena(e re)&ire*ent %or "o(!inan e(e#tive p&(i# o#e, 5- an! t"e p&rpoe o% t"e #iti$en"ip)&a(i#ation i none ot"er t"an to en&re t"at no a(ien, i.e., noperon o'in a((eian#e to anot"er nation, "a(( overn o&rpeop(e an! o&r #o&ntry or a &nit o% territory t"ereo%. No', ano#ia( ein to overn or to !i#"are "i %&n#tion on(y &pon"i pro#(a*ation and on t"e !ay t"e (a' *an!ate "i ter* o%o#e to ein. Sin#e riva(!o rea&*e! "i #iti$en"ip on &ne30, 1 t"e very !ay 5 t"e ter* o% o#e o% overnor an!ot"er e(e#tive o#ia(9 ean "e 'a t"ere%ore a(rea!y)&a(ie! to e pro#(ai*e!, to "o(! &#" o#e an! to !i#"aret"e %&n#tion an! reponii(itie t"ereo% a o% ai! !ate. In "ort,at t"at ti*e, "e 'a a(rea!y )&a(ie! to overn "i nativeSoroon. T"i i t"e (iera( interpretation t"at "o&(! ive pirit,i%e an! *eanin to o&r (a' on )&a(i#ation #onitent 'it" t"ep&rpoe %or '"i#" &#" (a' 'a ena#te!. So too, even %ro*a literal a !itin&i"e! %ro* liberal9 #ontr&#tion, it "o&(! enote! t"at Se#tion 3 o% t"e Fo#a( Govern*ent Co!e pea6 o%+Qalifcations+ o% +EFECTIDE OICIAFS+, not o6 candidates. @"yt"en "o&(! &#" )&a(i#ation e re)&ire! at t"e ti*e o% e(e#tionor at t"e ti*e o% t"e (in o% t"e #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#ie, aFee initJ Fitera((y, &#" )&a(i#ation &n(e ot"er'iee<pre(y #on!itione!, a in t"e #ae o% ae an! rei!en#e "o&(! t"& e poee! '"en t"e +e(e#tive or e(e#te!H o#ia(+ein to overn, i.e., at t"e ti*e "e i pro#(ai*e! and at t"etart o% "i ter* in t"i #ae, on &ne 30, 1. /arap"raint"i Co&rt r&(in in ;as#ez vs. &iap and i 2en$ &iap <2ons, 55 i% t"e p&rpoe o% t"e #iti$en"ip re)&ire*ent i to en&re
t"at o&r peop(e an! #o&ntry !o not en! &p ein overne! ya(ien,i.e., peron o'in a((eian#e to anot"er nation, t"at ai*or p&rpoe 'o&(! not be thwarted bt instead achieved y#ontr&in t"e #iti$en"ip )&a(i#ation a app(yin to t"e ti*e o%pro#(a*ation o% t"e e(e#te! o#ia( an! at t"e tart o% "i ter*.
B&t per"ap t"e *ore !i#&(t o?e#tion 'a t"e one raie! !&rint"e ora( ar&*ent 57 to t"e e=e#t t"at t"e #iti$en"ip )&a(i#ation"o&(! e poee! at t"e ti*e t"e #an!i!ate or %or t"at *attert"e e(e#te! o#ia(9 reitere! a a voter. A%ter a((, Se#tion 3,apart %ro* re)&irin t"e o#ia( to e a #iti$en, a(o pe#ie aanot"er ite* o% )&a(i#ation, t"at "e e a +reitere! voter+. An!,&n!er t"e (a' 51 a +voter+ *&t e a #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine. Sot"ere%ore, riva(!o #o&(! not "ave een a voter *&#" (ea validly reitere! one i% "e 'a not a #iti$en at t"e ti*e o%
&#" reitration.
T"e an'er to t"i pro(e* aain (ie in !i#ernin t"e p&rpoe o% t"e re)&ire*ent. I% t"e (a' inten!e! t"ecitizenship )&a(i#ation toe poee! prior to e(e#tion #onitent 'it" t"e re)&ire*ent o%ein a reitere! voter, t"en it 'o&(! not "ave *a!e #iti$en"ipa SE/ARATE )&a(i#ation. T"e (a' a"or a re!&n!an#y. Itt"ere%ore tan! to reaon t"at t"e (a' inten!e! CITIENS-I/ toe a )&a(i#ation !itin#t %ro* ein a DOTER, even i% ein avoter pre&*e ein a #iti$en rt. It a(o tan! to reaon t"att"e voter re)&ire*ent 'a in#(&!e! a anot"er )&a(i#ationai!e %ro* +#iti$en"ip+9, not to reiterate t"e nee! %or nationa(ity&t to re)&ire t"at t"e o#ia( e reitere! a a voter IN T-EAREA OR TERRITORP "e ee6 to overn, i.e., t"e (a' tate: +areitere! voter in t"e aranay, *&ni#ipa(ity, #ity, or provin#e . . '"ere "e inten! to e e(e#te!.+ It "o&(! e e*p"ai$e! t"at
t"e Fo#a( Govern*ent Co!e re)&ire an e(e#tive o#ia( to ea re$istered voter . It !oe not re)&ire "i* to vote actally . -ereitration not t"e a#t&a( votin i t"e #ore o% t"i+)&a(i#ation+. In ot"er 'or!, t"e (a' p&rpoe in t"i e#on!re)&ire*ent i to en&re t"at t"e prope#tive o#ia( i a#t&a((reitere! in t"e area "e ee6 to overn and not anywhereelse.
Be%ore t"i Co&rt, riva(!o "a repeate!(y e*p"ai$e! an! F"a not !ip&te! t"at "e +'a an! i a reitere! voter o%Soroon, an! "i reitration a a voter "a een &taine! ava(i! y ?&!i#ia( !e#(aration . . . In %a#t, "e #at "i vote in "ipre#in#t on May 8, 1.+ 54
So too, !&rin t"e ora( ar&*ent, "i #o&ne( tea!%at(y*aintaine! t"at +Mr. riva(!o "a a('ay een a reitere! voto% Soroon. -e "a vote! in 187, 188, 12, t"en "e vote!aain in 1. In %a#t, "i e(iii(ity a a voter 'a )&etione!,&t t"e #o&rt !i*ie! sic9 "i e(iii(ity a a voter an! "e 'a((o'e! to vote a in %a#t, "e vote! in a(( t"e previo& e(e#tionin#(&!in on May 8, 1.+ 56
It i t"& #(ear t"at riva(!o i a re$istered voter in the
province '"ere "e inten!e! to e e(e#te!.
T"ere i yet anot"er reaon '"y t"e pri*e i&eo% citizenship "o&(! e re#6one! %ro* t"e !ate o% pro#(a*ationot ne#eari(y t"e !ate o% e(e#tion or !ate o% (in o% t"e#erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y. Se#tion 23 o% t"e O*ni& E(e#tionCo!e 53 ive any voter, pre&*a(y in#(&!in t"e !e%eate!#an!i!ate, t"e opport&nity to )&etion t"e EFIGIBIFITP or t"e!i(oya(ty9 o% a #an!i!ate. T"i i t"e on(y proviion o% t"e Co!t"at a&t"ori$e a re*e!y on "o' to #ontet e%ore t"e Co*e(ean in#&*ent ine(iii(ity ariin %ro* %ai(&re to *eet t"e)&a(i#ation en&*erate! &n!er Se#. 3 o% t"e Fo#a( Govern*Co!e. S&#" re*e!y o% Qo !arranto #an e avai(e! o% +'it"in !ay a%ter pro#(a*ation+ o% t"e 'innin #an!i!ate. -en#e, iti only at sch time t"at t"e i&e o% ine(iii(ity *ay e ta6en#oni$an#e o% y t"e Co**iion. An! in#e, at t"e very *o*o% Fee pro#(a*ation 8:30 p.*., &ne 30, 19, &an G. riva'a a(rea!y an! in!&ita(y a #iti$en, "avin ta6en "i oat" o%a((eian#e ear(ier in t"e a%ternoon o% t"e a*e !ay, t"en "e"o&(! "ave een t"e #an!i!ate pro#(ai*e! a "e &n)&etionaarnere! t"e "i"et n&*er o% vote in t"e i**e!iate(y
pre#e!in e(e#tion an! &#" oat" "a! a(rea!y #&re! "i previ+?&!i#ia((y!e#(are!+ a(ienae. -en#e, at &#" ti*e, "e 'a no(oner ine(ii(e.
B&t to re*ove a(( !o&t on t"i i*portant i&e, 'e a(o "o(!t"at t"e repatriation o% riva(!o RETROACTE to t"e !ate o% t"(in o% "i app(i#ation on A&&t 17, 14.
It i tr&e t"at &n!er t"e Civi( Co!e o% t"e /"i(ippine, 50 +(9a'"a(( "ave no retroa#tive e=e#t, &n(e t"e #ontrary i provi!eB&t t"ere are ett(e! e<#eption 7/ to t"i enera( r&(e, &#" a'"en t"e tat&te i C5RATIDE or REMEIAF in nat&re or '"en CREATES NE@ RIG-TS.
A##or!in to To(entino, 7- #&rative tat&te are t"oe '"i#"&n!erta6e to #&re error an! irre&(aritie, t"erey va(i!atin ?&!i#ia( or a!*initrative pro#ee!in, a#t o% p&(i# o#er, oprivate !ee! an! #ontra#t which otherwise wold not prodctheir intended conse#ences by reason o6 some stattory
disability or 6ailre to comply with some technical re#iremen T"ey operate on #on!ition a(rea!y e<itin, an! are ne#earretroa#tive in operation. Apa(o, 7 on t"e ot"er "an!, ay t"a#&rative tat&te are+"ea(in a#t . . . #&rin !e%e#t an! a!!in to t"e *ean o%en%or#in e<itin o(iation . . . an!9 are inten!e! to &pp(y!e%e#t, ari!e &perL&itie in e<itin (a', an! #&r #ertainevi(. . . . By t"eir very nat&re, #&rative tat&te areretroa#tive . . . an!9 rea#" a#6 to pat event to #orre#t erroor irre&(aritie an! to ren!er va(i! an! e=e#tive atte*pte! a#'"i#" 'o&(! e ot"er'ie ine=e#tive %or t"e p&rpoe t"e partiinten!e!.+
By t"eir very nat&re, #&rative tat&te are retroa#tive, B/ v.CA, SCRA 3429, in#e t"ey are inten!e! to &pp(y !e%e#t,ari!e &perL&itie in e<itin (a' e( Cati((o v. Se#&ritiean! E<#"ane Co**iion, /"i(. 119 an! #&r #ertain evi(Santo v. &ata, 14 SCRA 10419.
n t"i #ae, /.. No. 72 'a ena#te! to #&re t"e !e%e#t in t"ee<itin nat&ra(i$ation (a', pe#i#a((y C.A. No. 3 '"erein*arrie! i(ipino 'o*en are a((o'e! to repatriate on(y &pon t"e!eat" o% t"eir "&an!, an! nat&ra(orn i(ipino '"o (ot t"eir
/rei!entia( e#ree No. 72 provi!e! a re*e!y %or t"ea%ore*entione! (ea( aerration an! t"& it proviion are#oni!ere! eentia((y re*e!ia( an! #&rative.
n (i"t o% t"e %oreoin, an! pre#in!in %ro* t"e 'or!in o% t"eprea*(e, it i &nar&a(e t"at t"e (ei(ative intent 'a pre#ie(yto ive t"e tat&te retroa#tive operation. +A9 retrope#tiveoperation i iven to a tat&te or a*en!*ent '"ere t"e intentt"at it "o&(! o operate #(ear(y appear %ro* a #oni!eration o%t"e a#t a a '"o(e, or %ro* t"e ter* t"ereo%.+ 71 It i ovio& tot"e Co&rt t"at t"e tat&te 'a *eant to +rea#" a#6+ to t"oe
peron, event an! trana#tion not ot"er'ie #overe! yprevai(in (a' an! ?&ripr&!en#e. An! ina*&#" a it "a een"e(! t"at #iti$en"ip i a po(iti#a( an! #ivi( ri"t e)&a((y a*portant a t"e %ree!o* o% pee#", (ierty o% ao!e, t"e ri"taaint &nreaona(e ear#"e an! ei$&re an! ot"er&arantee en"rine! in t"e Bi(( o% Ri"t, t"ere%ore t"eei(ative intent to ive retrope#tive operation to /.. 72 *&te iven t"e %&((et e=e#t poi(e. +I9t "a een ai! t"at aremedial statte mst be so constred as to ma=e it e>ect theevident prpose 6or which it was enacted, o t"at i% the reason o6the statte e9tends to past transactions, a 'e(( a to t"oe in t"e%&t&re, t"en it 'i(( e o app(ie! a(t"o&" t"e tat&te !oe not inter* o !ire#t, &n(e to !o o 'o&(! i*pair o*e vete! ri"t orvio(ate o*e #ontit&tiona( &aranty.+ 74 T"i i a(( t"e *ore tr&eo% /.. 72, '"i#" !i! not pe#i%y any retri#tion on or !e(i*it or)&a(i%y t"e ri"t o% repatriation rante! t"erein.
At t"i point, a va(i! )&etion *ay e raie!: -o' #an t"eretroa#tivity o% /.. 72 enet riva(!o #oni!erin t"at ai! ('a ena#te! on &ne , 17, '"i(e riva(!o (ot "i i(ipino#iti$en"ip *&#" (ater, on an&ary 20, 183, an! app(ie! %orrepatriation even (ater, on A&&t 17, 14J
@"i(e it i tr&e t"at t"e (a' 'a a(rea!y in e=e#t at t"e ti*e t"riva(!o e#a*e an A*eri#an #iti$en, nevert"e(e, it i not ont"e (a' ite(% /.. 729 '"i#" i to e iven retroa#tive e=e#t, even t"e repatriation rante! &n!er ai! (a' to riva(!o on &n30, 1 i to e !ee*e! to "ave retroa#te! to t"e !ate o% "iapp(i#ation t"ere%or, A&&t 17, 14. T"e reaon %or t"i ii*p(y t"at i%, a in t"i #ae, it 'a t"e intent o% t"e (ei(ative
a&t"ority t"at t"e (a' "o&(! app(y to past event i.e.,it&ation an! trana#tion e9istin$ even be6ore the law came
into bein$ in or!er to enet t"e reatet n&*er o% %or*eri(ipino poi(e t"erey ena(in t"e* to en?oy an! e<er#ie#ontit&tiona((y &arantee! ri"t o% #iti$en"ip, an! &#"(ei(ative intention i to e iven t"e %&((et e=e#t an!e<preion, t"en there is all the more reason to have the lawapply in a retroactive or retrospective manner to sitations,events and transactions sbse#ent to the passa$e o6 sch la T"at i, t"e repatriation rante! to riva(!o on &ne 30, 1 #an! "o&(! e *a!e to ta6e e=e#t a o% !ate o% "i app(i#ationear(ier *entione!, t"ere i not"in in t"e (a' t"at 'o&(! ar t"or 'o&(! "o' a #ontrary intention on t"e part o% t"e (ei(ativa&t"ority> an! t"ere i no "o'in t"at !a*ae or pre?&!i#e toanyone, or anyt"in &n?&t or in?&rio& 'o&(! re&(t %ro* ivin
retroa#tivity to "i repatriation. Neit"er "a Fee "o'n t"at t"e'i(( re&(t t"e i*pair*ent o% any #ontra#t&a( o(iation,!it&ran#e o% any vete! ri"t or rea#" o% o*e #ontit&tion&aranty.
Bein a %or*er i(ipino '"o "a erve! t"e peop(e repeate!(y,riva(!o !eerve a (iera( interpretation o% /"i(ippine (a' an!'"atever !e%e#t t"ere 'ere in "i nationa(ity "o&(! no' e!ee*e! *oote! y "i repatriation.
Anot"er ar&*ent %or retroa#tivity to t"e !ate o% (in i t"at i'o&(! prevent pre?&!i#e to app(i#ant. I% /.. 72 'ere not to iven retroa#tive e=e#t, an! t"e Spe#ia( Co**ittee !e#i!e noto a#t, i.e., to !e(ay t"e pro#ein o% app(i#ation %or any&tantia( (ent" o% ti*e, t"en t"e %or*er i(ipino '"o *ay tate(e, a riva(!o "avin a(rea!y reno&n#e! "i A*eri#a#iti$en"ip 'a, *ay e pre?&!i#e! %or #a&e o&ti!e t"eir#ontro(. T"i "o&(! not e. In #ae o% !o&t in t"e interpretatioor app(i#ation o% (a', it i to e pre&*e! t"at t"e (a'*a6ino!y inten!e! ri"t an! ?&ti#e to prevai(. 76
An! a e<perien#e 'i(( "o', t"e Spe#ia( Co**ittee 'a a(e pro#e, a#t &pon an! rant app(i#ation %or repatriation 'it"inre(ative(y "ort pan o% ti*e a%ter t"e a*e 'ere (e!. 73 T"e t"at &#" interrena 'ere re(ative(y inini#ant *ini*i$e t"e(i6e(i"oo! o% pre?&!i#e to t"e overn*ent a a re&(t o% ivinretroa#tivity to repatriation. Bei!e, to t"e *in! o% t"e Co&rt,!ire#t pre?&!i#e to t"e overn*ent i poi(e on(y '"ere aperon repatriation "a t"e e=e#t o% 'ipin o&t a (iai(ity o% "to t"e overn*ent ariin in #onne#tion 'it" or a a re&(t o% "ein an a(ien, an! a##r&in on(y !&rin t"e interren&*
et'een app(i#ation an! approva(, a it&ation t"at i not preein t"e intant #ae.
An! it i &t ri"t an! ?&t t"at t"e *an!ate o% t"e peop(e,a(rea!y t'i#e %r&trate!, "o&(! no' prevai(. 5n!er t"e#ir#&*tan#e, t"ere i not"in &n?&t or ini)&ito& in treatinriva(!o repatriation a "avin e#o*e e=e#tive a o% t"e !ao% "i app(i#ation, i.e., on A&&t 17, 14. T"i ein o, a(()&etion ao&t "i poeion o% t"e nationa(ity )&a(i#ation '"et"er at t"e !ate o% pro#(a*ation &ne 30, 19 or t"e !ato% e(e#tion May 8, 19 or !ate o% (in "i #erti#ate o%#an!i!a#y Mar#" 20, 19 'o&(! e#o*e *oot.
Bae! on t"e %oreoin, any )&etion rear!in riva(!o tata a reitere! voter 'o&(! a(o e !ee*e! ett(e!. Ina*&#""e i #oni!ere! a "avin een repatriate! i.e., "i i(ipino
#iti$en"ip retore! a o% A&&t 17, 14, "i previo&reitration a a voter i (i6e'ie !ee*e! va(i!ate! a o% ai!!ate.
t i not !ip&te! t"at on an&ary 20, 183 riva(!o e#a*e anA*eri#an. @o&(! t"e retroa#tivity o% "i repatriation note=e#tive(y ive "i* !&a( #iti$en"ip, '"i#" &n!er Se#. 40 o% t"eFo#a( Govern*ent Co!e 'o&(! !i)&a(i%y "i* +%ro* r&nnin %orany e(e#tive (o#a( poitionJ+ 70 @e an'er t"i )&etion in t"eneative, a t"ere i #oent reaon to "o(! t"at riva(!o 'area((y STATEFESS at t"e ti*e "e too6 ai! oat" o% a((eian#e an!even e%ore t"at, '"en "e ran %or overnor in 188. In "iCo**ent, riva(!o 'rote t"at "e +"a! (on reno&n#e! an! "a!
on aan!one! "i A*eri#an #iti$en"ip (on e%ore May 8,1. At et, riva(!o 'a tate(e in t"e interi* '"en "eaan!one! an! reno&n#e! "i 5S #iti$en"ip &t e%ore "e 'arepatriate! to "i i(ipino #iti$en"ip.+ 1/
On t"i point, 'e )&ote %ro* t"e aai(e! Reo(&tion !ate!e#e*er 1, 1: 1-
By t"e (a' o% t"e 5nite! State, petitioner riva(!o (ot "iA*eri#an #iti$en"ip '"en "e too6 "i oat" o% a((eian#e to t"e/"i(ippine Govern*ent '"en "e ran %or Governor in 188, in12, an! in 1. Every #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y #ontain anoat" o% a((eian#e to t"e /"i(ippine Govern*ent.+
T"ee %a#t&a( n!in t"at riva(!o "a (ot "i %orein nationa(ityon e%ore t"e e(e#tion o% 1 "ave not een e=e#tive(yre&tte! y Fee. &rt"er*ore, it i ai# t"at &#" n!in o% t"eCo**iion are #on#(&ive &pon t"i Co&rt, aent any "o'ino% #apri#io&ne or aritrarine ora&e. 1
he 2econd sse: s ac= o6 "itizenshipa "ontinin$ ?is#alifcation@
Fee #onten! t"at t"e May 1, 1 Reo(&tion 15 o% t"e Co*e(e#Se#on! iviion in S/A No. 028 a ar*e! in toto yCo*e(e# 8n /anc in it Reo(&tion o% May 11, 1 +e#a*e na(an! e<e#&tory a%ter ve 9 !ay or on May 17, 1, noretrainin or!er "avin een i&e! y t"i -onora(eCo&rt. 17 -en#e, e%ore Fee +'a pro#(ai*e! a t"e e(e#te!overnor on &ne 30, 1, t"ere 'a a(rea!y a na( an!
e<e#&tory ?&!*ent !i)&a(i%yin+ riva(!o. Fee a!! t"at t"iCo&rt t'o r&(in '"i#" riva(!o no' #on#e!e 'ere (ea((y+#orre#t+9 !e#(arin riva(!o an a(ien "ave a(o e#o*e na( an!e<e#&tory 'ay e%ore t"e 1 e(e#tion, an! t"ee +?&!i#ia(prono&n#e*ent o% "i po(iti#a( tat& a an A*eri#an #iti$enao(&te(y an! %or a(( ti*e !i)&a(ie! "i*9 %ro* r&nnin %or, an!"o(!in any p&(i# o#e in t"e /"i(ippine.+
@e !o not aree.
t "o&(! e note! t"at o&r rt r&(in in G.R. No. 8713!i)&a(i%yin riva(!o 'a ren!ere! in #onne#tion 'it" t"e 188e(e#tion '"i(e t"at in G.R. No. 1044 'a in #onne#tion 'it" t"e12 e(e#tion. T"at "e 'a !i)&a(ie! %or &#" e(e#tion i na(an! #an no (oner e #"ane!. In t"e 'or! o% t"e repon!entCo**iion Se#on! iviion9 in it aai(e! Reo(&tion: 11
T"e re#or! "o' t"at t"e -onora(e S&pre*e Co&rt "a! !e#i!e!t"at riva(!o 'a not a i(ipino #iti$en an! t"& !i)&a(ie! %or t"ep&rpoe o% t"e 188 an! 12 e(e#tion. -o'ever, t"ere i nore#or! o% any +na( ?&!*ent+ o% t"e !i)&a(i#ation o% riva(!o aa #an!i!ate %or t"e May 8, 1 e(e#tion. @"at t"e Co**iionai! in it Or!er o% &ne 21, 1 implemented on ne )4,155+9, !ire#tin t"e pro#(a*ation o% Ra&( R. Fee, 'a t"at riva(!o'a not a i(ipino #iti$en +havin$ been declared by the 2preme"ort in its Brder dated Carch (+, 155+, not a citizen o6 thePhilippines.+ T"i !e#(aration o% t"e S&pre*e Co&rt, "o'ever, 'an #onne#tion 'it" t"e 12 e(e#tion.
n!ee!, !e#iion !e#(arin t"e a#)&iition or !enia( o% #iti$en"ip#annot overn a peron %&t&re tat& 'it" na(ity. T"i i
e#a&e a peron *ay &e)&ent(y rea#)&ire, or %or t"at *atter
(oe, "i #iti$en"ip &n!er any o% t"e *o!e re#oni$e! y (a't"e p&rpoe. -en#e, in ee vs. "ommissioner o6
mmi$ration, 14 'e "e(!:
Everyti*e t"e #iti$en"ip o% a peron i *ateria( or in!ipenain a ?&!i#ia( or a!*initrative #ae, '"atever t"e #orrepon!in#o&rt or a!*initrative a&t"ority !e#i!e t"erein a to &#"#iti$en"ip i enera((y not #oni!ere! res Ddicata, "en#e it "ato e t"re"e! o&t aain an! aain, a t"e o##aion !e*an!.
he hird sse: "omelec7s risdictionBver he Petition in 2P" 'o. 5+3)1*
Fee a(o aver t"at repon!ent Co*e(e# "a! no ?&ri!i#tion toentertain t"e petition in S/C No. 317 e#a&e t"e on(y+poi(e type o% pro#ee!in t"at *ay e entertaine! y t"eCo*e(e# are a prepro#(a*ation #ae, an e(e#tion protet ora #o warranto #ae+. Aain, Fee re*in! & t"at "e 'apro#(ai*e! on &ne 30, 1 &t t"at riva(!o (e! S/C No. 317 )&etionin "i Fee9 pro#(a*ation on(y on &(y , 1 +eyon! t"e !ay re(e*entary perio!.+ -en#e, a##or!in to"i*, riva(!o +re#o&re 'a to (e eit"er an e(e#tion protet oa #o warranto a#tion.+
T"i ar&*ent i not *eritorio&. T"e Contit&tion 16 "a ivet"e Co*e(e# a*p(e po'er to +e<er#ie e<#(&ive oriina( ?&ri!i#tion over a(( #ontet re(atin to t"e e(e#tion, ret&rn a)&a(i#ation o% a(( e(e#tive . . . provin#ia( . . . o#ia(.+ Intea!!'e((in at (ent" on t"e vario& petition t"at Co*e(e#, in t"ee<er#ie o% it #ontit&tiona( preroative, *ay entertain, &to ay t"at t"i Co&rt "a invaria(y re#oni$e! t"e Co**iioa&t"ority to "ear an! !e#i!e petition %or ann&(*ent o%pro#(a*ation o% '"i#" S/C No. 317 ovio&(y ione. 13 T"&, in Centan$ vs."BC88", 10 'e r&(e!:
T"e petitioner ar&e t"at a%ter pro#(a*ation an! a&*ption o#e, a prepro#(a*ation #ontrovery i no (oner via(e. In!e'e are a'are o% #ae "o(!in t"at prepro#(a*ation#ontroverie *ay no (oner e entertaine! y t"e COMEFECa%ter t"e 'innin #an!i!ate "a een pro#(ai*e!. citin$ Ga((av. Ri*an!o, 187 SCRA 43> Sa(va#ion v. COMEFEC, 170 SCR13> Cai*iro v. COMEFEC, 171 SCRA 48.9 T"i r&(e, "o'evei pre*ie! on an a&*ption t"at t"e pro#(a*ation i nopro#(a*ation at a(( an! t"e pro#(ai*e! #an!i!ate a&*ption
o#e #annot !eprive t"e COMEFEC o% t"e po'er to *a6e &#"!e#(aration o% n&((ity. citin$ A&a* v. COMEFEC, 23 SCRA 88Aayani v. COMEFEC, 18 SCRA 484.9
T"e Co&rt "o'ever #a&tione! t"at &#" po'er to ann&( apro#(a*ation *&t +e !one 'it"in ten 109 !ay %o((o'in t"epro#(a*ation.+ Ina*&#" a riva(!o petition 'a (e! on(y 9 !ay a%ter Fee pro#(a*ation, t"ere i no )&etion t"at t"eCo*e(e# #orre#t(y a#)&ire! ?&ri!i#tion over t"e a*e.
T"e r&(e 'o&(! "ave een !i=erent i% t"e e(e#torate %&((y a'are in%a#t an! in (a' o% a #an!i!ate !i)&a(i#ation o a to rin&#" a'arene 'it"in t"e rea(* o% notoriety, 'o&(! nonet"e(e#at t"eir vote in %avor o% t"e ine(ii(e #an!i!ate. In &#" #ae,t"e e(e#torate *ay e ai! to "ave 'aive! t"e va(i!ity an!e#a#y o% t"eir vote y notorio&(y *iapp(yin t"eir %ran#"ieor t"ro'in a'ay t"eir vote, in '"i#" #ae, t"e e(ii(e #an!i!ateotainin t"e ne<t "i"er n&*er o% vote *ay e !ee*e!e(e#te!.
B&t &#" "o(!in i )&a(ie! y t"e ne<t pararap", t"&:
B&t t"i i not t"e it&ation otainin in t"e intant !ip&te. It "a
not een "o'n, an! none 'a a((ee!, t"at petitioner Fao 'anotorio&(y 6no'n a an ine(ii(e #an!i!ate, *&#" (e t"ee(e#torate a "avin 6no'n o% &#" %a#t. On t"e #ontrary,petitioner Fao 'a even a((o'e! y no (e t"an t"e Co*e(e#te(% in it reo(&tion !ate! May 10, 12 to e vote! %or t"eo#e o% t"e #ity /ayor a it reo(&tion !ate! May , 12!enyin !&e #o&re to petitioner Fao #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y"a! not yet e#o*e na( an! &?e#t to t"e na( o&t#o*e o% t"i#ae.
T"e (at)&ote! pararap" in abo, &n%ort&nate(y %or Fee, i t"er&(in appropriate in t"i #ae e#a&e riva(!o 'a in 1 in an!enti#a( it&ation a Fao 'a in 12 '"en t"e Co*e(e##an#e((ation o% "i #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y 'a not yet na( one(e#tion !ay a t"ere 'a in ot" #ae a pen!in *otion %or
re#oni!eration, %or '"i#" reaon Co*e(e# i&e! an o*ni&9reo(&tion !e#(arin t"at riva(!o (i6e Fao in 129 an! evera(ot"er #an ti(( e vote! %or in t"e May 8, 1 e(e#tion, a in%a#t, "e 'a.
&rt"er*ore, t"ere "a een no &#ient evi!en#e preente! to"o' t"at t"e e(e#torate o% Soroon 'a +%&((y a'are in %a#t an!n (a'+ o% riva(!o a((ee! !i)&a(i#ation a to +rin &#"a'arene 'it"in t"e rea(* o% notoriety>+ in ot"er 'or!, t"at t"evoter intentiona((y 'ate! t"eir a((ot 6no'in t"at, in pite o%t"eir votin %or "i*, "e 'a ine(ii(e. I% abo "a any re(evan#eat a((, it i t"at t"e vi#eovernor an! not Fee "o&(! e pro#(ai*e!, in#e in (oin t"e e(e#tion, Fee 'a, toparap"rae abo aain, +ovio&(y not t"e #"oi#e o% t"e peop(e+o% Soroon. T"i i t"e e*p"ati# tea#"in o% abo:
T"e r&(e, t"ere%ore, i: t"e ine(iii(ity o% a #an!i!ate re#eivin*a?ority vote !oe not entit(e t"e e(ii(e #an!i!ate re#eivint"e ne<t "i"et n&*er o% vote to e !e#(are! e(e#te!. A*inority or !e%eate! #an!i!ate #annot e !ee*e! e(e#te! to t"eo#e.
2econd. A 'e "ave ear(ier !e#(are! riva(!o to "ave eaona(yrea#)&ire! "i #iti$en"ip an! ina*&#" a "e otaine! t"e"i"et n&*er o% vote in t"e 1 e(e#tion, "e not Fee "o&(! e pro#(ai*e!. -en#e, Fee pro#(a*ation 'a patent(yerroneo& an! "o&(! no' e #orre#te!.
t"e Co*e(e# Se#on! iviion9 !ate! May 1, 1 an! t"e#onr*atory en banc Reo(&tion o% May 11, 1 !i)&a(i%yin"i* %or 'ant o% #iti$en"ip "o&(! e ann&((e! e#a&e t"ey 'ereren!ere! eyon! t"e %teen 19 !ay perio! pre#rie! y Se#tion78, o% t"e O*ni& E(e#tion Co!e '"i#" rea! a %o((o':
Se#. 78. Petition to deny de corse or to cancel a certifcate o6candidacy . A verie! petition ee6in to !eny !&e #o&re or to#an#e( a #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y *ay e (e! y any perone<#(&ive(y on t"e ro&n! t"at any *ateria( repreentation#ontaine! t"erein a re)&ire! &n!er Se#tion 74 "ereo% i %a(e.T"e petition *ay e (e! at any ti*e not (ater t"an t'entyve!ay %ro* t"e ti*e o% t"e (in o% t"e #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y an!"a(( e !e#i!e! a%ter noti#e an! "earin, not later than f6teendays be6ore the election. E*p"ai &pp(ie!.9
T"i #(ai* i no' *oot an! a#a!e*i# ina*&#" a t"eereo(&tion are !ee*e! &pere!e! y t"e &e)&ent onei&e! y t"e Co**iion irt iviion9 on e#e*er 1, 1ar*e! en banc 45 on er&ary 23, 1> '"i#" ot" &p"e(! "e(e#tion. At any rate, it i ovio& t"at Se#tion 78 i *ere(y!ire#tory a Se#tion o% R.A. No. 4 a&t"ori$e t"e Co**ito try an! !e#i!e petition %or !i)&a(i#ation even a%ter t"ee(e#tion, t"&:
Se#. . 8>ect o6 ?is#alifcation "ase. Any #an!i!ate '"o "aeen !e#(are! y na( ?&!*ent to e !i)&a(ie! "a(( not evote! %or, an! t"e vote #at %or "i* "a(( not e #o&nte!. 6 6oany reason a candidate is not declared by fnal Dd$ment be6o
an election to be dis#alifed and he is voted 6or and receives winnin$ nmber o6 votes in sch election, the "ort or
"ommission shall contine with the trial and hearin$ o6 theaction, in#iry or protest and pon motion o6 the complainant
any intervenor, may drin$ the pendency thereo6 order thesspension o6 the proclamation o6 sch candidate whenever th
evidence o6 his $ilt is stron$. e*p"ai &pp(ie!9
%e6tation o6
Cr . stice ?avide7s ?issent
In "i !ientin opinion, t"e etee*e! Mr. &ti#e -i(ario G.avi!e, r. ar&e t"at /rei!ent A)&ino *e*oran!&* !ate!Mar#" 27, 187 "o&(! e vie'e! a a &penion not a repeaa &re! y Fee9 o% /.. 72. B&t '"et"er it !e#ree a &pen
or a repea( i a p&re(y a#a!e*i# !itin#tion e#a&e t"e ai!i&an#e i not a tat&te t"at #an a*en! or aroate an e<iti(a'. T"e e<iten#e an! &iten#e o% /.. 72 'ere re#oni$e! in rt riva(!o #ae> 47 viz ., +&9n!er CA No. 3 a a*en!e! y CNo. 473 an! P.?. 'o. *(+, /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip *aye rea#)&y . . . repatriation+. -e a(o #onten! t"at y a((o'in riva(!oreiter an! to re*ain a a reitere! voter, t"e Co*e(e# an! e=e#t t"i Co&rt aette! a +*o#6ery+ o% o&r t'o previo& ?&!*ent !e#(arin "i* a non#iti$en. @e !o not ee &#"aettin or *o#6ery. T"e retroa#tivity o% "i repatriation, a!i#&e! ear(ier, (ea((y #&re! '"atever !e%e#t t"ere *ay "aeen in "i reitration a a voter %or t"e p&rpoe o% t"e 1e(e#tion. S&#" retroa#tivity !i! not #"ane "i !i)&a(i#ation188 an! 12, '"i#" 'ere t"e &?e#t o% &#" previo& r&(in
Mr. &ti#e avi!e a(o e(ieve t"at Qo !arranto i not t"e re*e!y to )&etion t"e ine(iii(ity o% a #an!i!ate, #itin t"eCo*e(e# a&t"ority &n!er Se#tion 78 o% t"e O*ni& E(e#tionCo!e a((o'in t"e !enia( o% a #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y on t"ero&n! o% a %a(e *ateria( repreentation t"erein a re)&ire! Se#tion 74. Citin Foon, "e t"en tate "i !iaree*ent 'it"o&r "o(!in t"at Se#tion 78 i *ere(y !ire#tory. @e rea((y "ave)&arre(. O&r point i t"at riva(!o 'a in error in "i #(ai* in GNo. 1202 t"at t"e Co*e(e# Reo(&tion pro*&(ate! on May1 an! May 11, 1 'ere inva(i! e#a&e t"ey 'ere i&e!+not (ater t"an %teen !ay e%ore t"e e(e#tion+ a pre#rie! Se#tion 78. In !i*iin t"e petition in G.R. No. 1202, 'e "t"at t"e Co*e(e# !i! not #o**it rave a&e o% !i#retione#a&e +Se#tion o% R.A. 4 a&t"ori$e t"e Co*e(e# to tryan! !e#i!e !i)&a(i#ation even a%ter t"e e(e#tion.+ In pite
"i !iaree*ent 'it" & on t"i point, i.e., t"at Se#tion 78 +i*ere(y !ire#tory+, 'e note t"at ?&t (i6e &, Mr. &ti#e avi!enonet"e(e vote to +ISMISS G.R. No. 1202+. One ot"erpoint. oon$, a )&ote! in t"e !ient, tea#"e t"at a petition !eny !&e #o&re &n!er Se#tion 78 *&t e fled 'it"in t"e (+3day perio! pre#rie! t"erein. T"e preent #ae "o'ever !ea('it" t"e perio! !&rin '"i#" t"e Co*e(e# *ay decide &#"petition. An! 'e "o(! t"at it *ay e !e#i!e! even a%ter t"ef6tday perio! *entione! in Se#tion 78. -ere, 'e r&(e t"at a!e#iion proml$ated y t"e Co*e(e# even a%ter t"e e(e#tionva(i! &t oon$ "e(! t"at a petition fled eyon! t"e 2!ayperio! i o&t o% ti*e. T"ere i no in#oniten#y nor #onLi#t.
+!i(&te+ o&r "o(!in in t"e rt riva(!o #ae. B&t t"e rt an!even t"e e#on! riva(!o9 !e#iion !i! not !ire#t(y invo(verepatriation a a *o!e o% a#)&irin #iti$en"ip. I% 'e *ay repeat,t"ere i no )&etion t"at riva(!o 'a not a i(ipino %or p&rpoeo% !eter*inin "i )&a(i#ation in t"e 188 an! 12 e(e#tion.T"at i ett(e!. B&t "i &pervenin repatriation "a #"ane! "ipo(iti#a( tat& not in 188 or 12, &t on(y in t"e 1e(e#tion.
O&r (earne! #o((ea&e a(o !ip&te o&r "o(!in t"at riva(!o 'atate(e prior to "i repatriation, ayin t"at +in%or*a(ren&n#iation or aan!on*ent i not a ro&n! to (oe A*eri#an#iti$en"ip+. Sin#e o&r #o&rt are #"are! on(y 'it" t"e !&ty o%
!eter*inin '"o are /"i(ippine nationa(, 'e #annot r&(e on t"eea( )&etion o% '"o are or '"o are not A*eri#an. It i ai# innternationa( (a' t"at a State !eter*ine ONFP t"oe '"o are ito'n #iti$en not '"o are t"e #iti$en o% ot"er #o&ntrie. 41 T"e&e "ere i: t"e Co*e(e# *a!e a n!in o% %a#t t"at riva(!o'a tate(e an! &#" n!in "a not een "o'n y Fee to earitrary or '"i*i#a(. T"&, %o((o'in ett(e! #ae (a', &#"n!in i in!in an! na(.
T"e !ientin opinion a(o &*it t"at Fee '"o (ot y #"a*i#*arin to riva(!o in a(( t"ree previo& e(e#tion, "o&(! e!e#(are! 'inner e#a&e +riva(!o ine(iii(ity %or ein anA*eri#an 'a p&(i#(y 6no'n+. irt, t"ere i ao(&te(y noe*piri#a( evi!en#e %or &#" +p&(i#+ 6no'(e!e. Se#on!, even i%t"ere i, &#" 6no'(e!e #an e tr&e post 6acto on(y o% t"e (at
t'o previo& e(e#tion. T"ir!, even t"e Co*e(e# an! no' t"iCo&rt 'ere;are ti(( !e(ieratin on "i nationa(ity e%ore, !&rinan! a%ter t"e 1 e(e#tion. -o' t"en #an t"ere e &#" +p&(i#+6no'(e!eJ
Mr. &ti#e avi!e &*it t"at Se#tion 3 o% t"e Fo#a(Govern*ent Co!e re%er to t"e )&a(i#ation o% elective(o#a(o#ia(, i.e., #an!i!ate, an! not elected o#ia(, an! t"at t"e#iti$en"ip )&a(i#ation &n!er par. a9 o% t"at e#tionH *&t epoee! y #an!i!ate, not *ere(y at t"e #o**en#e*ent o%t"e ter*, &t y e(e#tion !ay at t"e (atet. @e ee it !i=erent(y.Se#tion 3, par. a9 t"ereo% pea6 o% +e(e#tive (o#a( o#ia(+ '"i(epar. 9 to %9 re%er to +#an!i!ate+. I% t"e )&a(i#ation &n!er par.a9 'ere inten!e! to app(y to +#an!i!ate+ an! not e(e#te!o#ia(, t"e (ei(at&re 'o&(! "ave ai! o, intea! o%!i=erentiatin par. a9 %ro* t"e ret o% t"e pararap". Se#on!(y,% Conre "a! *eant t"at t"e #iti$en"ip )&a(i#ation "o&(! epoee! at e(e#tion !ay or prior t"ereto, it 'o&(! "avepe#i#a((y tate! &#" !etai(, t"e a*e 'ay it !i! in par. 9 to%9 %ar ot"er )&a(i#ation o% #an!i!ate %or overnor, *ayor, et#.
Mr. &ti#e avi!e a(o )&etion t"e ivin o% retroa#tive e=e#t toriva(!o repatriation on t"e ro&n!, a*on ot"er, t"at t"e (a'pe#i#a((y provi!e t"at it i on(y a%ter ta6in t"e oat" o%a((eian#e t"at app(i#ant "a(( e !ee*e! to "ave rea#)&ire!/"i(ippine #iti$en"ip. @e !o not )&etion '"at t"e proviiontate. @e "o(! "o'ever t"at t"e proviion "o&(! e &n!ertoo!t"&: that a6ter ta=in$ the oath o6 alle$iance the applicant is
deemed to have reac#ired Philippine citizenship, whichreac#isition Eor repatriationF is deemed 6or all prposes and
intents to have retroacted to the date o6 his application there6or .
n any event, o&r +o too+ ar&*ent rear!in t"e (itera( *eanino% t"e 'or! +e(e#tive+ in re%eren#e to Se#tion 3 o% t"e Fo#a(A&t"ority Co!e, a 'e(( a rear!in Mr. &ti#e avi!e t"eit"at t"e very 'or!in o% /.. 72 &et nonretroa#tivity, 'erea(rea!y ta6en &p rat"er e<tenive(y ear(ier in t"i e#iion.
Mr. &ti#e avi!e #ap "i paper 'it" a #(arion #a((: +T"i Co&rt*&t e t"e rt to &p"o(! t"e R&(e o% Fa'.+ @e aree 'e *&ta(( %o((o' t"e r&(e o% (a'. B&t t"at i NOT t"e i&e "ere. T"e i&e how "o&(! t"e law e interprete! an! app(ie! in t"i #ae o it#an e %o((o'e!, o it #an r&(eQ
At a(an#e, t"e )&etion rea((y oi( !o'n to a #"oi#e o%p"i(oop"y an! per#eption o% "o' to interpret an! app(y (a're(atin to e(e#tion: (itera( or (iera(> t"e (etter or t"e pirit, t"e
na6e! proviion or it &(ti*ate p&rpoe> (ea( y((oi* or
&tantia( ?&ti#e> in io(ation or in t"e #onte<t o% o#ia(#on!ition> "ar"(y aaint or ent(y in %avor o% t"e voterovio& #"oi#e. In app(yin e(e#tion (a', it 'o&(! e %ar etteerr in %avor o% pop&(ar overeinty t"an to e ri"t in #o*p(e< (itt(e &n!ertoo! (ea(i*. In!ee!, to inLi#t a t"ri#e re?e#te!#an!i!ate &pon t"e e(e#torate o% Soroon 'o&(! #ontit&te&n*itiate! ?&!i#ia( tyranny an! an &na##epta(e aa&(t &pont"i Co&rt #on#ien#e.
8 P B & G 8
In &*, 'e r&(e t"at t"e #iti$en"ip re)&ire*ent in t"e Fo#a(Govern*ent Co!e i to e poee! y an e(e#tive o#ia( at
(atet a o% t"e ti*e "e i pro#(ai*e! and at t"e tart o% t"e teo% o#e to '"i#" "e "a een e(e#te!. @e %&rt"er "o(! /.. No72 to e in %&(( %or#e an! e=e#t &p to t"e preent, not "avineen &pen!e! or repea(e! e<pre(y nor i*p(ie!(y at any ti*an! riva(!o repatriation y virt&e t"ereo% to "ave een proprante! an! t"& va(i! an! e=e#tive. Moreover, y reaon o% t"re*e!ia( or #&rative nat&re o% t"e (a' rantin "i* a ne' ri"re&*e "i po(iti#a( tat& an! t"e (ei(ative intent e"in! it, 'e(( a "i &ni)&e it&ation o% "avin een %or#e! to ive &p "#iti$en"ip an! po(iti#a( apiration a "i *ean o% e#apin arei*e "e a"orre!, "i repatriation i to e iven retroa#tivee=e#t a o% t"e !ate o% "i app(i#ation t"ere%or, !&rin t"epen!en#y o% '"i#" "e 'a tate(e, "e "avin iven &p "i 5.nationa(ity. T"&, in #onte*p(ation o% (a', "e poee! t"e vitre)&ire*ent o% i(ipino #iti$en"ip a o% t"e tart o% t"e ter* o%
o#e o% overnor, an! "o&(! "ave een pro#(ai*e! intea! oFee. &rt"er*ore, in#e "i rea#)&iition o% #iti$en"ip retroa#tto A&&t 17, 14, "i reitration a a voter o% Soroon i!ee*e! to "ave een va(i!ate! a o% ai! !ate a 'e((. T"e%oreoin, o% #o&re, are pre#ie(y #onitent 'it" o&r "o(!int"at (a#6 o% t"e #iti$en"ip re)&ire*ent i not a #ontin&in!iai(ity or !i)&a(i#ation to r&n %or an! "o(! p&(i# o#e. Anon#e aain, 'e e*p"ai$e "erein o&r previo& r&(in re#oni$t"e Co*e(e# a&t"ority an! ?&ri!i#tion to "ear an! !e#i!epetition %or ann&(*ent o% pro#(a*ation.
T"i Co&rt "a ti*e an! aain (iera((y an! e)&ita(y #ontr&et"e e(e#tora( (a' o% o&r #o&ntry to ive %&((et e=e#t to t"e*ani%et 'i(( o% o&r peop(e, 44 %or in #ae o% !o&t, po(iti#a( (a'*&t e interprete! to ive (i%e an! pirit to t"e pop&(ar *an!%ree(y e<pree! t"ro&" t"e a((ot. Ot"er'ie tate!, (ea(ni#etie an! te#"ni#a(itie #annot tan! in t"e 'ay o% t"eoverein 'i((. Conitent(y, 'e "ave "e(!:
. . . F9a' overnin e(e#tion #ontet *&t e (iera((y#ontr&e! to t"e en! t"at t"e 'i(( o% t"e peop(e in t"e #"oi#e op&(i# o#ia( *ay not e !e%eate! y *ere te#"ni#a( o?e#tio#itation o*itte!9. 46
T"e (a' an! t"e #o&rt *&t a##or! riva(!o every poi(eprote#tion, !e%ene an! re%&e, in !e%eren#e to t"e pop&(ar 'iIn!ee!, t"i Co&rt "a repeate!(y tree! t"e i*portan#e o%ivin e=e#t to t"e overein 'i(( in or!er to en&re t"e &rvivo% o&r !e*o#ra#y. In any a#tion invo(vin t"e poii(ity o% arevera( o% t"e pop&(ar e(e#tora( #"oi#e, t"i Co&rt *&t e<ert&t*ot e=ort to reo(ve t"e i&e in a *anner t"at 'o&(! ive
e=e#t to t"e 'i(( o% t"e *a?ority, %or it i *ere(y o&n! p&(i#po(i#y to #a&e e(e#tive o#e to e ((e! y t"oe '"o are t"#"oi#e o% t"e *a?ority. To &##e%&((y #"a((ene a 'innin#an!i!ate )&a(i#ation, t"e petitioner *&t #(ear(y!e*ontrate t"at t"e ine(iii(ity i o patent(y antaoniti# 43 #ontit&tiona( an! (ea( prin#ip(e t"at overri!in &#" ine(iian! t"erey ivin e=e#t to t"e apparent 'i(( o% t"e peop(e, 'o&(ti*ate(y #reate reater pre?&!i#e to t"e very !e*o#rati#intit&tion an! ?&riti# tra!ition t"at o&r Contit&tion an! (a'o $ea(o&(y prote#t an! pro*ote. In t"i &n!erta6in, Fee "a*iera(y %ai(e!.
In riva(!o #ae. it 'o&(! "ave een te#"ni#a((y eay to n! %'it" "i #a&e. T"e Co&rt #o&(! "ave re%&e! to rant retroa#tto t"e e=e#t o% "i repatriation an! "o(! "i* ti(( ine(ii(e !&"i %ai(&re to "o' "i #iti$en"ip at t"e ti*e "e reitere! a
voter e%ore t"e 1 e(e#tion. Or, it #o&(! "ave !ip&te! t"e%a#t&a( n!in o% t"e Co*e(e# t"at "e 'a tate(e at t"e ti*eo% repatriation an! t"& "o(! "i #one)&ent !&a( #iti$en"ip a a!i)&a(i#ation +%ro* r&nnin %or any e(e#tive (o#a( poition.+ B&tt"e rea( een#e o% ?&ti#e !oe not e*anate %ro* )&i(in overpat#"'or6 (ea( te#"ni#a(ity. It pro#ee! %ro* t"e pirit &t#on#io&ne o% t"e !yna*i# ro(e o% (a' a a ri#6 in t"e&(ti*ate !eve(op*ent o% t"e o#ia( e!i#e. T"&, t"e Co&rttr&(e! aaint an! e#"e'e! t"e eay, (ea(iti#, te#"ni#a(an! o*eti*e "ar" ana#"roni* o% t"e (a' in or!er to evo6e&tantia( ?&ti#e in t"e (arer o#ia( #onte<t #onitent 'it"riva(!o &ni)&e it&ation appro<i*atin venerai(ity in/"i(ippine po(iti#a( (i%e. Con#e!e!(y, "e o&"t A*eri#an#iti$en"ip on(y to e#ape t"e #(&t#"e o% t"e !i#tator"ip. At t"itae, 'e #annot erio&(y entertain any !o&t ao&t "i (oya(tyan! !e!i#ation to t"i #o&ntry. At t"e rt opport&nity, "eret&rne! to t"i (an!, an! o&"t to erve "i peop(e on#e *ore.T"e peop(e o% Soroon over'"e(*in(y vote! %or "i* t"reeti*e. -e too6 an oat" o% a((eian#e to t"i Rep&(i# every ti*e"e (e! "i #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y an! !&rin "i %ai(e!nat&ra(i$ation i!. An! (et it not e over(oo6e!, "i !e*ontrate!tena#ity an! "eer !eter*ination to rea&*e "i nationa(ity o%irt" !epite evera( (ea( eta#6 pea6 *ore (o&!(y, in pirit,n %a#t an! in tr&t" t"an any (ea( te#"ni#a(ity, o% "i #on&*inntention an! &rnin !eire to ree*ra#e "i native /"i(ippineeven no' at t"e ripe o(! ae o% 81 year. S&#" (oya(ty to an! (oveo% #o&ntry a 'e(( a noi(ity o% p&rpoe #annot e (ot on t"iCo&rt o% ?&ti#e an! e)&ity. Morta( o% (eer *ett(e 'o&(! "ave
iven &p. A%ter a((, riva(!o 'a a&re! o% a (i%e o% eae an!p(enty a a #iti$en o% t"e *ot po'er%&( #o&ntry in t"e 'or(!. B&t"e opte!, nay, in(e*in!e!(y inite! on ret&rnin to an!ervin on#e *ore "i tr&(in &t e(ove! (an! o% irt". -et"ere%ore !eerve every (iera( interpretation o% t"e (a' '"i#"#an e app(ie! in "i %avor. An! in t"e na( ana(yi, over an!aove riva(!o "i*e(%, t"e in!o*ita(e peop(e o% Soroon *ot#ertain(y !eerve to e overne! y a (ea!er o% t"eirover'"e(*in #"oi#e.
@-EREORE, in #oni!eration o% t"e %oreoin:
19 T"e petition in G.R. No. 1237 i "erey ISMISSE. T"eaai(e! Reo(&tion o% t"e repon!ent Co**iion areAIRME.
29 T"e petition in G.R. No. 1202 i a(o ISMISSE %or ein*oot an! a#a!e*i#. In any event, it "a no *erit.
No #ot.
SO ORERE.
AAS2S 8ADVOCATES AND ADHERENTS OF SOCIAL 2USTICEFOR SCHOOL TEACHERS AND ALLIED *ORKERS9 +E+BER :HECTOR U+ANAN CALILUN,V#.THE HONORABLE SI+EON DATU+ANON, "n !"# o;c"a%ca(ac"t< a# t!e Secretar< o' 2#t"ce,DECISION
=UISU+BIN, J.:
T"i i an oriina( a#tion %or pro"iition &n!er R&(e o% t"e 17Revie! R&(e o% Civi( /ro#e!&re.
/etitioner (e! t"e intant petition aaint repon!ent, t"enSe#retary o% &ti#e Si*eon at&*anon, t"e o#ia( ta6e! to*p(e*ent (a' overnin #iti$en"ip.>-? /etitioner pray t"at a'rit o% pro"iition e i&e! to top repon!ent %ro**p(e*entin Rep&(i# A#t No. 22, entit(e! An Act Ca=in$ the"itizenship o6 Philippine "itizens !ho Ac#ire -orei$n "itizenshipPermanent, Amendin$ 6or the Prpose "ommonwealth Act 'o.), As Amended, and 6or Bther Prposes. /etitioner aver t"atRep. A#t No. 22 i &n#ontit&tiona( a it vio(ate Se#tion ,Arti#(e ID o% t"e 187 Contit&tion t"at tate, &a( a((eian#e o%#iti$en i ini*i#a( to t"e nationa( interet an! "a(( e !ea(t 'it"y (a'.
Rep. A#t No. 22, ine! into (a' y /rei!ent G(oria M. Arroyon A&&t 2, 2003, rea!:
SECTION 1. 2hort itle.T"i A#t "a(( e 6no'n a t"eCiti$en"ip Retention an! Rea#)&iition A#t o% 2003.
SEC. 2. ?eclaration o6 Policy.It i "erey !e#(are! t"e po(i#y ot"e State t"at a(( /"i(ippine #iti$en '"o e#o*e #iti$en o%anot"er #o&ntry "a(( e !ee*e! not to "ave (ot t"eir /"i(ippi#iti$en"ip &n!er t"e #on!ition o% t"i A#t.
SEC. 3. %etention o6 Philippine "itizenship.Any proviion o% (at"e #ontrary not'it"tan!in, nat&ra(orn #iti$en o% t"e/"i(ippine '"o "ave (ot t"eir /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip y reaont"eir nat&ra(i$ation a #iti$en o% a %orein #o&ntry are "erey!ee*e! to "ave rea#)&ire! /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip &pon ta6in %o((o'in oat" o% a((eian#e to t"e Rep&(i#:
9 are in t"e a#tive ervi#e a #o**iione! ornon#o**iione! o#er in t"e ar*e! %or#e o% t"e #o&ntry'"i#" t"ey are nat&ra(i$e! #iti$en.
SEC. . 2eparability "lase. I% any e#tion or proviion o% t"i A#t "e(! &n#ontit&tiona( or inva(i!, any ot"er e#tion or proviionnot a=e#te! t"erey "a(( re*ain va(i! an! e=e#tive.
SEC. 7. %epealin$ "lase. A(( (a', !e#ree, or!er, r&(e an!re&(ation in#onitent 'it" t"e proviion o% t"i A#t are "ereyrepea(e! or *o!ie! a##or!in(y.
Rep. Fo#in &n!er#ore! t"at t"e *ea&re !oe not ee6 toa!!re t"e #ontit&tiona( in?&n#tion on !&a( a((eian#e ani*i#a( to p&(i# interet. He #a"d t!at t!e (ro(o#ed %a@
a"# to 'ac"%"tate t!e reac"#"t"on o' P!"%"(("ne
c"t")en#!"( &< #(eed< ean#. Ho@ever, !e #a"d t!at "n one
#en#e, "t addre##e# t!e (ro&%e o' da% c"t")en#!"( &<
re"r"n$ t!e ta"n$ o' an oat!. He e(%a"ned t!at t!e
(ro&%e o' da% c"t")en#!"( "# tran#'erred 'ro t!e
P!"%"(("ne# to t!e 'ore"$n contr< &eca#e t!e %ate#t oat!
t!at @"%% &e taen &< t!e 'orer F"%"("no "# one o'
a%%e$"ance to t!e P!"%"(("ne# and not to t!e Un"ted State#,
a# t!e ca#e a< &e. -e a!!e! t"at t"i i a *atter '"i#" t"e
/"i(ippine overn*ent 'i(( "ave no #on#ern an! #o*peten#eover.
Rep. i(ana(en a6e! '"y t"i 'i(( no (oner e t"e #o&ntryW#on#ern, '"en !&a( a((eian#e i invo(ve!.
Rep. Fo#in #(arie! t"at t"i 'a pre#ie(y "i o?e#tion to t"eoriina( verion o% t"e i((, '"i#" !i! not re)&ire an oat" o%a((eian#e. S"nce t!e ea#re no@ re"re# t!"# oat!, t!
(ro&%e o' da% a%%e$"ance "# tran#'erred 'ro
t!e P!"%"(("ne# to t!e 'ore"$n contr< concerned, "ee<p(aine!.
< < < <
Rep. i(ana(en a6e! '"et"er in t"e parti#&(ar #ae, t"e per!i! not !eno&n#e "i %orein #iti$en"ip an! t"ere%ore ti(( o'ea((eian#e to t"e %orein overn*ent, an! at t"e a*e ti*e, o"i a((eian#e to t"e /"i(ippine overn*ent, &#" t"at t"ere ino' a #ae o% !&a( #iti$en"ip an! !&a( a((eian#e.
Rep. Fo#in #(arie! t"at &< #@ear"n$ to t!e #(ree
at!or"t< o' t!e Re(&%"c, t!e (er#on "(%"c"t%< renonc
!"# 'ore"$n c"t")en#!"(. -o'ever, "e ai! t"at t"i i not a*atter t"at "e 'i"e to a!!re in Conre e#a&e "e i no*e*er o% a %orein par(ia*ent &t a Me*er o% t"e -o&e.
< < < <
Rep. Fo#in rep(ie! t"at it i i*perative t"at t"oe '"o "ave !a((eian#e #ontrary to nationa( interet "o&(! e !ea(t 'it" y(a'. -o'ever, "e ai! t"at t"e !&a( a((eian#e pro(e* i nota!!ree! in t"e i((. -e t"en #ite! t"e e#(aration o% /o(i#y ini(( '"i#" tate t"at It i "erey !e#(are! t"e po(i#y o% t"e Stt"at a(( #iti$en '"o e#o*e #iti$en o% anot"er #o&ntry "a(( !ee*e! not to "ave (ot t"eir /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip &n!er t"e#on!ition o% t"i A#t. -e tree! t"at @!at t!e &"%% doe# "#
/etitioner (i6e'ie a!van#e t"e propoition t"at a(t"o&"Conre "a not yet pae! any (a' on t"e *atter o%!&a( a((eian#e, &#" aen#e o% a (a' "o&(! not e ?&ti#ation'"y t"i Co&rt #o&(! not r&(e on t"e i&e. -e %&rt"er #onten!t"at '"i(e it i tr&e t"at t"ere i no ena(in (a' yet on !&a(a((eian#e, t"e S&pre*e Co&rt, t"ro&"Cercado v. Canzano,>4? a(rea!y "a! !ra'n &p t"e &i!e(ine on "o' to !itin&i" !&a(a((eian#e %ro* !&a( #iti$en"ip.>6?
or it part, t"e OSG #o&nter t"at p&r&ant to Se#tion ,Arti#(e ID o% t"e 187 Contit&tion, !&a( a((eian#e "a(( e !ea(t'it" y (a'. T"&, &nti( a (a' on !&a( a((eian#e i ena#te! yConre, t"e S&pre*e Co&rt i 'it"o&t any ?&ri!i#tion to
entertain i&e rear!in !&a( a((eian#e.>3?
To ein 'it", Se#tion , Arti#(e ID o% t"e Contit&tion i a!e#(aration o% a po(i#y an! it i not a e(%e<e#&tin proviion. T"eei(at&re ti(( "a to ena#t t"e (a' on !&a( a((eian#e. InSe#tion 2 an! 3 o% Rep. A#t No. 22, t"e %ra*er 'ere not#on#erne! 'it" !&a( #iti$en"ip per se, &t 'it" t"e tat& o%nat&ra(i$e! #iti$en '"o *aintain t"eir a((eian#e to t"eir#o&ntrie o% oriin even a%ter t"eir nat&ra(i$ation.>0? Conre 'aiven a *an!ate to !ra%t a (a' t"at 'o&(! et pe#i# para*etero% '"at rea((y #ontit&te !&a( a((eian#e.>-/? 5nti( t"i i !one, it'o&(! e pre*at&re %or t"e ?&!i#ia( !epart*ent, in#(&!in t"iCo&rt, to r&(e on i&e pertainin to !&a( a((eian#e.
Neit"er #an 'e &#rie to t"e propoition o% petitioner t"at a
a' i not nee!e! in#e t"e #ae o% Cercado "a! a(rea!y et t"e&i!e(ine %or !eter*inin !&a( a((eian#e. /etitioner*irea! Cercado. T"at #ae !i! not et t"e para*eter o% '"at#ontit&te !&a( a((eian#e &t *ere(y *a!e a !itin#tionet'een !&a( a((eian#e an! !&a( #iti$en"ip.
Moreover, in 8strada v. 2andi$anbayan,>--? 'e ai! t"at t"e #o&rt*&t a&*e t"at t"e (ei(at&re i ever #on#io& o% t"e or!eran! e!e o% it p(enary po'er, an! pae! (a' 'it" %&((6no'(e!e o% t"e %a#t an! %or t"e p&rpoe o% pro*otin '"at iri"t an! a!van#in t"e 'e(%are o% t"e *a?ority. -en#e, in!eter*inin '"et"er t"e a#t o% t"e (ei(at&re are in t&ne 'it"t"e %&n!a*enta( (a', 'e *&t pro#ee! 'it" ?&!i#ia( retraint an!a#t 'it" #a&tion an! %orearan#e.>-? T"e !o#trine o% eparationo% po'er !e*an! no (e. @e #annot arroate t"e !&ty o%ettin t"e para*eter o% '"at #ontit&te !&a( a((eian#e '"en
t"e Contit&tion ite(% "a #(ear(y !e(eate! t"e !&ty o%!eter*inin '"at a#t #ontit&te !&a( a((eian#e %or t&!y an!ei(ation y Conre.
*HEREFORE, t"e petition i "erey DIS+ISSED %or (a#6 o%*erit.
EN BANCLOIDA NICOLASLE*IS, REORIO B. +ACABENTA,ALE2ANDRO A. ESCLA+ADO, AR+ANDO B. HEREDIA,REUBEN S. SEURITAN, ERIC LACHICA FURBEGRE,TERESITA A. CRUZ, 2OSEFINA OPENA DISTERHOFT,+ERCEDES V. OPENA, CORNELIO R. NATIVIDAD, EVELGN D.NATIVIDAD,V#. CO++ISSION ON ELECTIONS,A$#t 7, //4
D E C I S I O NARCIA, J.
In t"i petition %or #ertiorari an! *an!a*&, petitioner,re%errin to t"e*e(ve a +da%#+ or !&a( #iti$en, pray t"at t"eyan! ot"er '"o retaine! or rea#)&ire! /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip&n!er Rep&(i# A#t R.A.9 No. 22, t"e "itizenship %etention and%e3Ac#isition Act o6 (44), e a((o'e! to avai( t"e*e(ve o% t"e*e#"ani* provi!e! &n!er t"eBverseas Absentee ;otin$ Act o6
(44)1H R.A. 189 an! t"at t"e Co**iion on E(e#tionCOMEFEC9 a##or!in(y e or!ere! to a((o' t"e* to vote an!reiter a aentee voter &n!er t"e aei o% R.A. 18.
T"e %a#t:
/etitioner are &##e%&( app(i#ant %or re#onition o%/"i(ippine #iti$en"ip &n!er R.A. 22 '"i#" a##or! to &#"
app(i#ant t"e ri"t o% &=rae, a*on ot"er. Fon e%ore t"eMay 2004 nationa( an! (o#a( e(e#tion, petitioner o&"treitration an! #erti#ation a +overea aentee voter+ on(ye a!vie! y t"e /"i(ippine E*ay in t"e 5nite! State t"aper a COMEFEC (etter to t"e epart*ent o% orein A=air !atSepte*er 23, 20032H, t"ey "ave yet no ri"t to vote in &#"e(e#tion o'in to t"eir (a#6 o% t"e oneyear rei!en#ere)&ire*ent pre#rie! y t"e Contit&tion. T"e a*e (etter,"o'ever, &re! t"e !i=erent /"i(ippine pot aroa! not to!i#ontin&e t"eir #a*pain %or voterW reitration, a t"erei!en#e retri#tion a!verte! to 'o&(! #onte<t&a((y a=e#t *e#ertain in!ivi!&a( '"o 'o&(! (i6e(y e e(ii(e to vote in %&t&ree(e#tion.
/ro!!e! %or #(ari#ation y petitioner Foi!a Ni#o(aFe'in t"e (i"t o% t"e r&(in in Cacalintal vs. "BC88" 3H on t"erei!en#y re)&ire*ent, t"e COMEFEC 'rote in repone:
A(t"o&" R.A. 22 en?oy t"e pre&*ption o%#ontit&tiona(ity V, it i t"e Co**iion poition t"at t"oe '"ave avai(e! o% t"e (a' #annot e<er#ie t"e ri"t o% &=rae &n!er t"e OADF %or t"e reaon t"at t"e OADF 'a not ena#te! t"e*. -en#e, a i(ipino '"o "ave *ere(y rea#)&ire! t"eir#iti$en"ip on 18 Septe*er 2003 at t"e ear(iet, an! a (a' a ?&ripr&!en#e no' tan!, t"ey are #oni!ere! re&(ar voter '"ave to *eet t"e re)&ire*ent o% rei!en#y, a*on ot"er &nSe#tion 1, Arti#(e o% t"e Contit&tion. 4H
a#e! 'it" t"e prope#t o% not ein a(e to vote in t"e M2004 e(e#tion o'in to t"e COMEFEC re%&a( to in#(&!e t"e*t"e Nationa( Reitry o% Aentee Doter, petitioner Ni#o(aFe'i et al., H (e! on Apri( 1, 2004 t"i petition %or #ertiorari a*an!a*&.
A (itt(e over a 'ee6 e%ore t"e May 10, 2004 e(e#tion, oon Apri( 30, 2004, t"e COMEFEC (e! a "omment ,H t"ereinprayin %or t"e !enia( o% t"e petition. A *ay e e<pe#te!,petitioner 'ere not a(e to reiter (et a(one vote in ai!e(e#tion.
On May 20, 2004, t"e O#e o% t"e So(i#itor Genera( O(e! a Cani6estation Ein ie o6 "ommentF, t"erein tatin t"ata(( )&a(ie! overea i(ipino, in#(&!in !&a( #iti$en '"o #arto e<er#ie t"e ri"t o% &=rae, *ay !o o , oervin, "o'e
T"e "o(!in o% t"e 2004 e(e#tion "a!, a t"e OSG poino&t, in!ee! ren!ere! t"e petition *oot an! a#a!e*i#, &t inon(y a petitionerW parti#ipation in &#" po(iti#a( e<er#ie i#on#erne!. T"e roa!er an! tran#en!enta( i&e ten!ere! or&&*e! in t"e petition, i.e., t"e propriety o% a((o'in !&a(parti#ipate an! vote a aentee voter in %&t&re e(e#tion,"o'ever, re*ain &nreo(ve!.
Oervin t"e petitionerW an! t"e COMEFECW repe#tiv%or*&(ation o% t"e i&e, t"e a*e *ay e re!&#e! into t"e)&etion o% '"et"er or not petitioner an! ot"er '"o *i"t "*ean'"i(e retaine! an!;or rea#)&ire! /"i(ippine #iti$en"ipp&r&ant to R.A. 22 *ay vote a aentee voter &n!er R.A.18.
T"e Co&rt reo(ve t"e poer in t"e ar*ative,an! t"erey a##or! *erit to t"e petition.
In esse, t"i #ae i a(( ao&t &=rae. A )&i#6 (oo6 at t"overnin proviion on t"e ri"t o% &=rae i, t"ere%ore,in!i#ate!.
@e tart o= 'it" Se#tion 1 an! 2 o% Arti#(e D o% t"eContit&tion, repe#tive(y rea!in a %o((o':
SECTION 1. S&=rae *ay e e<er#ie! y a(( #iti$en ot"e /"i(ippine not ot"er'ie !i)&a(ie! y (a', '"o are at (eei"teen year o% ae, an! '"o "a(( "ave rei!e! int"e/"i(ippine %or at (eat one year an! in t"e p(a#e '"erein t"
propoe to vote %or at (eat i< *ont" i**e!iate(y pre#e!in t"ee(e#tion. <<<.
SEC 2. T"e Conre "a(( provi!e V a yte* %oraentee votin y )&a(ie! i(ipino aroa!.
In a n&t"e((, t"e a%ore)&ote! Se#tion 1 pre#rie rei!en#yre)&ire*ent a a enera( e(iii(ity %a#tor %or t"e ri"t to vote. Ont"e ot"er "an!, Se#tion 2 a&t"ori$e Conre to !evie a yte*'"erein an aentee *ay vote, i*p(yin t"at a nonrei!ent*ay, a an e<#eption to t"e rei!en#y pre#ription in t"epre#e!in e#tion, e a((o'e! to vote.
In repone to it aove *an!ate, Conre ena#te! R.A.18 t"e OADF8H i!enti%yin in it Se#tion 4 '"o #an vote &n!ert an! in t"e %o((o'in e#tion '"o #annot, a %o((o':
Se#tion 4. "overa$e. A(( #iti$en o%t"e /"i(ippine aroa!, '"o are not ot"er'ie !i)&a(ie! y (a',at (eat ei"teen 189 year o% ae on t"e !ay o% e(e#tion, *ayvote %or prei!ent, vi#eprei!ent, enator an! party(itrepreentative.
#9 T"oe '"o "ave V eenH #onvi#te! in a na(&!*ent y a #o&rt or tri&na( o% an o=ene p&ni"a(e y*prion*ent o% not (e t"an one 19 year, in#(&!in t"oe '"o"ave V een %o&n! &i(ty o% i(oya(ty a !ene! &n!er Arti#(e137 o% t"e Revie! /ena( Co!e, V.>
!9 An i**irant or a per*anent rei!ent '"o ire#oni$e! a &#" in t"e "ot #o&ntry, &n(e "e;"e e<e#&te,&pon reitration, an a!avit prepare! %or t"e p&rpoe y t"eCo**iion !e#(arin t"at "e;"e "a(( re&*e a#t&a( p"yi#a(
per*anent rei!en#e in t"e /"i(ippine not (ater t"an t"ree 39year %ro* approva( o% "i;"er reitration &n!er t"i A#t. S&#"a!avit "a(( a(o tate t"at "e;"e "a not app(ie! %or#iti$en"ip in anot"er #o&ntry. ai(&re to ret&rn "a(( e t"e #a&e%or t"e re*ova( o% t"e na*e o% t"e i**irant or per*anentrei!ent %ro* t"e Nationa( Reitry o% Aentee Doter an!"i;"er per*anent !i)&a(i#ation to vote in absentia
e9 Any #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine aroa! previo&(y!e#(are! inane or in#o*petent y #o*petent a&t"ority V.@or! in ra#6et a!!e!.9
Nota(y, Se#tion (it t"oe '"o #annot avai( t"e*e(ve o% t"e aentee votin *e#"ani*. -o'ever, Se#tion !9 o% t"een&*eration repe#tin i(ipino i**irant an! per*anentrei!ent in anot"er #o&ntry open an e<#eption an! )&a(ie t"e!i)&a(i#ation r&(e. Se#tion !9 'o&(!, "o'ever, %a#e a#ontit&tiona( #"a((ene on t"e ro&n! t"at, a narrate!n Cacalintal, it
V vio(ate Se#tion 1, Arti#(e D o% t"e 187 Contit&tion'"i#" re)&ire t"at t"e voter *&t e a rei!ent int"e /"i(ippine %or at (eat one year an! in t"e p(a#e '"ere "epropoe to vote %or at (eat i< *ont" i**e!iate(y pre#e!inan e(e#tion. T"e #"a((enerH #ite V "aasi vs. "ort o6Appeals H to &pport "i #(ai* '"ereH t"e Co&rt "e(! t"at areen #ar! "o(!er i**irant to t"e 5SH i !ee*e! to "aveaan!one! "i !o*i#i(e an! rei!en#e in t"e /"i(ippine.
T"e #"a((enerH %&rt"er ar&e t"at Se#tion 1, Arti#(e D o% t"e Contit&tion !oe not a((o' proviiona( reitration or a
pro*ie y a voter to per%or* a #on!ition to e )&a(ie! to vote
in a po(iti#a( e<er#ie> t"at t"e (ei(at&re "o&(! not e a((o'eto #ir#&*vent t"e re)&ire*ent o% t"e Contit&tion on t"e ri"t &=rae y provi!in a #on!ition t"ereon '"i#" in e=e#t a*enor a(ter t"e a%oreai! rei!en#e re)&ire*ent to )&a(i%y a i(ipiaroa! to vote. -e #(ai* t"at t"e ri"t o% &=rae "o&(! norante! to anyone '"o, on t"e !ate o% t"e e(e#tion, !oe notpoe t"e )&a(i#ation provi!e! %or y Se#tion 1, Arti#(e D ot"e Contit&tion.10H @or! in ra#6et a!!e!.9
A *ay e re#a((e!, t"e Co&rt &p"e(! t"e #ontit&tiona(itySe#tion !9 o% R.A. 18 *ain(y on t"e trent" o% t"e %o((o'inpre*ie:
A na((y approve! into (a', Se#tion !9 o% R.A. No. 1pe#i#a((y !i)&a(ie an immi$rant or permanent resident 'i re#oni$e! a &#" in t"e "ot #o&ntry e#a&e i**iratioor per*anent rei!en#e in anot"er #o&ntry i*p(ie ren&n#iatioo% one rei!en#e in "i #o&ntry o% oriin. -o'ever, a*eSe#tion a((o' an i**irant an! per*anent rei!ent aroa! treiter a voter %or a (on a "e;"e e<e#&te an a!avit to"o' t"at "e;"e "a not aan!one! "i !o*i#i(e in p&r&an#et"e #ontit&tiona( intent e<pree! in Se#tion 1 an! 2 o% Arti#t"at all #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine not ot"er'ie !i)&a(ie! (a' *&t e entit(e! to e<er#ie t"e ri"t o% &=rae an!, t"aConre *&t eta(i" a yte* %or aentee votin> %orot"er'ie, i% a#t&a(, p"yi#a( rei!en#e in t"e /"i(ippine ire)&ire!, t"ere i no ene %or t"e %ra*er o% t"e Contit&tion *an!ate Conre to eta(i" a yte* %or aentee votin.
Contrary to t"e #(ai* o% t"e #"a((enerH, t"e e<e#&tiont"e a!avit ite(% i not t"e ena(in or en%ran#"iin a#t. T"ea!avit re)&ire! in Se#tion !9 i not on(y proo% o% t"e intento% t"e i**irant or per*anent rei!ent to o a#6 an! re&*rei!en#y in t"e /"i(ippine, &t *ore ini#ant(y, it erve ae<p(i#it e<preion t"at "e "a! not in %a#t aan!one! "i !o*io% oriin. T"&, it i not #orre#t to ay t"at t"e e<e#&tion o% t"a!avit &n!er Se#tion !9 vio(ate t"e Contit&tion t"atpro#rie proviiona( reitration or a pro*ie y a voter toper%or* a #on!ition to e )&a(ie! to vote in a po(iti#a(e<er#ie. 11H
29 T"oe ee6in e(e#tive p&(i# o#e in t"e/"i(ippine "a(( *eet t"e )&a(i#ation %or "o(!in &#" p&(i#o#e a re)&ire! y t"e Contit&tion an! e<itin (a' an!, att"e ti*e o% t"e (in o% t"e #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y, *a6e aperona( an! 'orn ren&n#iation o% any an! a(( %orein #iti$en"ipV>
39 <<< <<< <<<.
49 <<< <<< <<<>
9 T"at ri"t to vote or e e(e#te! or appointe! to anyp&(i# o#e in t"e /"i(ippine #annot e e<er#ie! y, ore<ten!e! to, t"oe '"o:
a9 are #an!i!ate %or or are o##&pyin any p&(i#o#e in t"e #o&ntry o% '"i#" t"ey are nat&ra(i$e! #iti$en>an!;or
9 are in a#tive ervi#e a #o**iione! or non#o**iione! o#er in t"e ar*e! %or#e o% t"e #o&ntry '"i#"t"ey are nat&ra(i$e! #iti$en.
A%ter '"at appear to e a &##e%&( app(i#ation %or
re#onition o% /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip &n!er R.A. 18, petitionerno' invo6e t"eir ri"t to enDoy I political ri$hts,pe#i#a((y t"eri"t o% &=rae, p&r&ant to Se#tion t"ereo%.
Oppoin t"e petitionerW i!, "o'ever, repon!entCOMEFEC invite attention to t"e a*e Se#tion 19 provi!int"at !&a( #an en?oy t"eir ri"t to vote, a an a!?&n#t topo(iti#a( ri"t, on(y i% t"ey *eet t"e re)&ire*ent o% Se#tion 1,Arti#(e D o% t"e Contit&tion, R.A. 18 an! ot"er e<itina'. Capita(i$in on '"at at rt (&" i t"e #(a"in proviiono% t"e a%ore#ite! proviion o% t"e Contit&tion, '"i#", to repeat,re)&ire rei!en#y in t"e /"i(ippine %or a #ertain perio!, an! R.A.18 '"i#" rant a i(ipino nonrei!ent aentee votin ri"t,12H COMEFEC ar&e:
4. X?GA2J CG2 -%2 82A/2H H8% ?BC"8K
%82?8'"8 ' H8 PHPP'82
4.01. T"e in#(&ion o% &#" a!!itiona( an! pe#i# re)&ire*entn RA 22 i (oi#a(. T"e X!&a(,W &pon reno&n#e*ent o% t"eiri(ipino #iti$en"ip an! a#)&iition o% %orein #iti$en"ip, "avepra#ti#a((y an! (ea((y aan!one! t"eir !o*i#i(e an! evere! t"eirea( tie to t"e "o*e(an! a a #one)&en#e. -avin&e)&ent(y a#)&ire! a e#on! #iti$en"ip i.e., i(ipino9 t"en,X!&a(W *&t, %or p&rpoe o% votin, rt o% a((, !e#iive(y an!!enite(y eta(i" t"eir !o*i#i(e t"ro&" poitive a#t> 13H
T"e Co&rt !iaree.
A *ay e note!, t"ere i no proviion in t"e !&a(#iti$en"ip (a' R.A. 22 re)&irin +!&a(+ to a#t&a((y eta(i"rei!en#e an! p"yi#a((y tay in t"e /"i(ippine rt e%ore t"ey
#an e<er#ie t"eir ri"t to vote. On t"e #ontrary, R.A. 22, in*p(i#it a#6no'(e!*ent t"at !&a( are *ot (i6e(y nonrei!ent, rant &n!er it Se#tion 19 t"e a*e ri"t o% &=raea t"at rante! an aentee voter &n!er R.A. 18. It #annot eovere*p"ai$e! t"at R.A. 18 ai*, in een#e, to en%ran#"iea *&#" a poi(e a(( overea i(ipino '"o, ave %or t"erei!en#y re)&ire*ent e<a#te! o% an or!inary voter &n!eror!inary #on!ition, are )&a(ie! to vote. T"&, 'rote t"e Co&rtn CacalintalL
It i #(ear %ro* t"ee !i#&ion o% t"e V Contit&tiona(Co**iion t"at itH inten!e! to en%ran#"ie a *&#" apoi(e all i(ipino #iti$en aroa! '"o "ave not aan!one! t"eir!o*i#i(e o% oriin. T"e Co**iion even inten!e! to e<ten! toyo&n i(ipino '"o rea#" votin ae aroa! '"oe parentW
!o*i#i(e o% oriin i in t"e /"i(ippine, an! #oni!er t"e*)&a(ie! a voter %or t"e rt ti*e.
It i in p&r&an#e o% t"at intention t"at t"e Co**iionprovi!e! %or Se#tion 2 Arti#(e DH i**e!iate(y a%ter t"e rei!enre)&ire*ent o% Se#tion 1. By t"e !o#trine o% ne#earyi*p(i#ation in tat&tory #ontr&#tion, V, t"e tratei# (o#ation Se#tion 2 in!i#ate t"at the "onstittional "ommission provide6or an e9ception to the actal residency re#irement o6 2ectio1 'it" repe#t to )&a(ie! i(ipino aroa!. T"e a*eCo**iion "a in e=e#t !e#(are! t"at )&a(ie! i(ipino '"o not in t"e /"i(ippine *ay e a((o'e! to vote even t"o&" t"ey!o not ati%y t"e rei!en#y re)&ire*ent in Se#tion 1, Arti#(e D
t"e Contit&tion.
T"at Se#tion 2 o% Arti#(e D o% t"e Contit&tion i ane<#eption to t"e rei!en#y re)&ire*ent %o&n! in Se#tion 1 o% ta*e Arti#(e 'a in %a#t t"e &?e#t o% !eate '"en Senate Bi(No. 2104, '"i#" e#a*e R.A. No. 18, 'a !e(ierate! &pon t"e Senate Loor, t"&:
2enator Arroyo. Mr. /rei!ent, t"i i(( "o&(! e (oo6einto in re(ation to t"e #ontit&tiona( proviion. I t"in6 t"eponor an! I 'o&(! aree t"at t"e Contit&tion i &pre*e in tat&te t"at 'e *ay ena#t.
Fet *e rea! Se#tion 1, Arti#(e D, o% t"e Contit&tion V.
No', Mr. /rei!ent, t"e Contit&tion ay, '"o "a(( "
rei!e! in t"e /"i(ippine. T"ey are per*anenti**irant. T"ey "ave #"ane! rei!en#e o t"ey are arre!&n!er t"e Contit&tion. T"i i '"y I a6e! '"et"er t"i#o**ittee a*en!*ent '"i#" in %a#t !oe not a(ter t"e oriinate<t o% t"e i(( 'i(( "ave any e=e#t on t"iJ
2enator An$ara. Goo! )&etion, Mr. /rei!ent. An! t""a een a6e! in vario& %ora. T"i i in #o*p(ian#e 'it" t"eContit&tion. One, t"e interpretation "ere o% rei!en#e iynony*o& 'it" !o*i#i(e.
A t"e ent(e*an an! I 6no', Mr. /rei!ent, !o*i#i(et"e intent to ret&rn to one "o*e. And the fact that a Filip
may have been physically absent from the Philippines a
may be physically a resident of the United States, for
example, but has a clear intent to return to thePhilippines, will mae him !uali"ed as a resident of the
Philippines under this law.
T"i i #onitent, Mr. /rei!ent, 'it" t"e #ontit&tiona*an!ate t"at 'e t"at Conre *&t provi!e a %ran#"ie tooverea i(ipino.
#f we read the $onstitution and the su%ra&e
principle literally as demandin& physical presence, then
there is no way we can provide for o%shore votin& to ou
o%shore ababayan, Mr. /rei!ent.
2enator Arroyo. Mr. /rei!ent, '"en t"e Contit&tionay, in Se#tion 2 o% Arti#(e D, it rea!: T"e Conre "a((provi!e a yte* %or e#&rin t"e e#re#y an! an#tity o% t"e
a((ot a 'e(( a a yte* %or aentee votin y )&a(ie!i(ipino aroa!.
'he ey to this whole exercise, (r. President, is
)!uali"ed.* #n other words, anythin& that we may do o
say in &rantin& our compatriots abroad must be anchor
on the proposition that they are !uali"ed. Absent the
!uali"cation, they cannot vote. And )residents* i#9 is!uali"cation.
Foo6 at '"at t"e Contit&tion ay In t"e p(a#e '"et"ey propoe to vote %or at (eat i< *ont" i**e!iate(ypre#e!in t"e e(e#tion.
I (ive in Ma6ati. My nei"or i /atero V. @e areeparate! on(y y a #ree6. B&t one '"o vote in Ma6ati #annotvote in /atero &n(e "e rei!e in /atero %or i< *ont". T"at "o' retri#tive o&r Contit&tion i. V.
A I "ave ai!, i% a voter in Ma6ati 'o&(! 'ant to vote in/atero, ye, "e *ay !o o. B&t "e *&t !o o, *a6e t"e tran%eri< *ont" e%ore t"e e(e#tion, ot"er'ie, "e i not )&a(ie! tovote.
<<< <<< <<<
2enator An$ara. It i a oo! point to raie, Mr.
/rei!ent. B&t it i a point a(rea!y 'e((!eate! even in t"e#ontit&tiona( #o**iion o% 18. And the reason Section +
of Article was placed immediately after the six-
monthone-year residency re!uirement is to demonstrate
unmistaably that Section + which authori/es absentee
votin& is an exception to the six-monthone-year
residency re!uirement . T"at i t"e rt prin#ip(e, Mr./rei!ent, t"at one *&t re*e*er.
T"e e#on! reaon, Mr. /rei!ent, i t"at &n!er o&r&ripr&!en#e V rei!en#y "a een interprete! aynony*o& 'it" !o*i#i(e.
Bt t!e t!"rd ore (ract"ca% rea#on, "#, "'
@e 'o%%o@ t!e "nter(retat"on o' t!e $ent%ean, t!en "t
"# %e$a%%< and con#t"tt"ona%%< "(o##"&%e to $"ve a
'ranc!"#e to vote to over#ea# F"%"("no# @!o do not(!<#"ca%%< %"ve "n t!e contr<, @!"c! "# "te r"d"c%o#
&eca#e t!at "# eact%< t!e @!o%e (o"nt o' t!"# eerc"#e
: to en'ranc!"#e t!e and e(o@er t!e to
vote. 14H E*p"ai an! 'or! in ra#6et a!!e!> #itationo*itte!9
Fet it e over(oo6e!, no (e t"an t"e COMEFEC ite(%a!*it t"at t"e "itizenship %etention and %e3Ac#isitionAct e<pan!e! t"e #overae o% overea aenteevotin. A##or!in to t"e po(( o!y:
1.0 @it" t"e paae o% RA 22 t"e #ope o% overeaaentee votin "a een #one)&ent(y e<pan!e! o a ton#(&!e i(ipino '"o are a(o #iti$en o% ot"er #o&ntrie, &?e#t,
"o'ever, to t"e tri#t prere)&iite in!i#ate! in t"e pertinentproviion o% RA 22> 1H
It i very (i6e(y t"at a #oni!era(e n&*er o% t"onmarried children below ei$hteen 189 years o6 a$e "a!ver et %oot in t"e /"i(ippine. No' t"en, i% t"e ne<t enerato% +!&a(+ *ay nonet"e(e avai( t"e*e(ve t"e ri"t to enDoy6ll civil and political ri$hts &n!er Se#tion o% t"e A#t, t"en t"i neit"er no r"y*e nor reaon '"y t"e petitioner an! ot"erpreent !ay +!&a(,+ provi!e! t"ey *eet t"e re)&ire*ent &nSe#tion 1, Arti#(e D o% t"e Contit&tion in re(ation to R.A. 18,!enie! t"e ri"t o% &=rae a an overea aentee voter.Conre #o&(! not "ave p(a&i(y inten!e! &#" a&r!it&ation.
*HEREFORE, t"e intant petition
i RANTED. A##or!in(y, t"e Co&rt r&(e an! o "o(! t"att"oe '"o retain or rea#)&ire /"i(ippine #iti$en"ip&n!er Re(&%"c Act No. 01, t"e "itizenship %etention and%e3Ac#isition Act o6 (44), *ay e<er#ie t"e ri"t to vote &n!t"e yte* o% aentee votin in Re(&%"c Act No. 0-30,t"eBverseas Absentee ;otin$ Act o6 (44).
SO ORDERED.
EN BANC
>.R. No. -4-757. +arc! 5, //7?
+ARIA 2EANETTE C. TECSON and FELIJ B. DESIDERIO,
2R., petitioners, vs. T!e CO++ISSION ON ELECTIONS,
RONALD ALLAN KELLG POE 8a..a. FERNANDO POE, 2R.9
and VICTORINO J. FORNIER, respondents.
>.R. No. -4-457. +arc! 5, //7?
ZOILO ANTONIO VELEZ, petitioner , vs. RONALD ALLAN
KELLEG POE, a..a. FERNANDO POE, 2R., respondent .
>. R. No. -4-37. +arc! 5, //7?
VICTORINO J. FORNIER, petitioner , vs. HON. CO++ISSI
ON ELECTIONS and RONALD ALLAN KELLEG POE, ALSO
KNO*N AS FERNANDO POE 2R., respondents.
D E C I S I O N
VITU, J.
C"t")en#!"( "# a trea#red r"$!t con'erred on t!o#e @!o
t!e #tate &e%"eve# are de#erv"n$ o' t!e (r"v"%e$e. It "# a
Be%ore t"e Co&rt are t"ree #ono(i!ate! #ae, a(( o% '"i#" raiin(e )&etion o% pro%o&n! i*portan#e to t"e nation. T"e i&o% #iti$en"ip i ro&"t &p to #"a((ene t"e )&a(i#ation o% aprei!entia( #an!i!ate to "o(! t"e "i"et o#e o% t"e (an!. Opeop(e are 'aitin %or t"e ?&!*ent o% t"e Co&rt 'it" ate!reat". I ernan!o /oe, r., t"e "ero o% i(ver #reen, an! no'one o% t"e *ain #onten!er %or t"e prei!en#y, a nat&ra(orni(ipino or i "e notJ
T"e *o*ent o% intrope#tion ta6e & %a#e to %a#e 'it" Spanian! A*eri#an #o(onia( root an! re*in! & o% t"e ri#" "erita#ivi( (a' an! #o**on (a' tra!ition, t"e %&ion re&(tin in a"yri! o% (a' an! ?&ripr&!en#e t"at #o&(! e no (e t"an!itin#t(y i(ipino.
Antecedent Ca#e Sett"n$#
On 31 e#e*er 2003, repon!ent Rona(! A((an Ye((y /oe, a(o6no'n a ernan!o /oe, r. "ereina%ter +/+9, (e! "i #erti#ao% #an!i!a#y %or t"e poition o% /rei!ent o% t"e Rep&(i# o%t"e /"i(ippine &n!er t"e Yoa(iyon n Na6a6aian /i(ipinoYN/9 /arty, in t"e %ort"#o*in nationa( e(e#tion. In "i#erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y, /, repreentin "i*e(% to e a nat&orn #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine, tate! "i na*e to e +ernan!
r.,+ or +Rona(! A((an+ /oe, "i !ate o% irt" to e 20 A&&t13 an! "i p(a#e o% irt" to e Mani(a.
Di#torino Z. ornier, petitioner in G.R. No. 11824, entit(e!+Di#torino Z. ornier, /etitioner, ver& -on. Co**iion onE(e#tion an! Rona(! A((an Ye((ey /oe, a(o 6no'n a ernan!o/oe, r., Repon!ent,+ initiate!, on 0 an&ary 2004, a petition!o#6ete! S/A No. 04003 e%ore t"e Co**iion on E(e#tion+COMEFEC+9 to !i)&a(i%y / an! to !eny !&e #o&re or to #an#e("i #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y &pon t"e t"ei t"at / *a!e a*ateria( *irepreentation in "i #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y y#(ai*in to e a nat&ra(orn i(ipino #iti$en '"en in tr&t",a##or!in to ornier, "i parent 'ere %oreiner> "i *ot"er,
Beie Ye((ey /oe, 'a an A*eri#an, an! "i %at"er, A((an /oe, 'aa Spani" nationa(, ein t"e on o% Foren$o /o&, a Spani"&?e#t. Grantin, petitioner aeverate!, t"at A((an . /oe 'a ai(ipino #iti$en, "e #o&(! not "ave tran*itte! "i i(ipino#iti$en"ip to /, t"e (atter ein an i((eiti*ate #"i(! o% an a(ien*ot"er. /etitioner ae! t"e a((eation o% t"e i((eiti*ate irt" o%repon!ent on t'o aertion frst , A((an . /oe #ontra#te! aprior *arriae to a #ertain /a&(ita Go*e$ e%ore "i *arriae toBeie Ye((ey an!, second, even i% no &#" prior *arriae "a!e<ite!, A((an . /oe, *arrie! Beie Ye((y on(y a year a%ter t"eirt" o% repon!ent.
n t"e "earin e%ore t"e T"ir! iviion o% t"e COMEFEC on 1an&ary 2004, petitioner, in &pport o% "i #(ai*, preente!evera( !o#&*entary e<"iit 19 a #opy o% t"e #erti#ate o% irt"
o% /, 29 a #ertie! p"oto#opy o% an a!avit e<e#&te! in Spani"y /a&(ita /oe y Go*e$ attetin to "er "avin (e! a #ae %oria*y an! #on#&inae aaint t"e %at"er o% repon!ent, A((an. /oe, a%ter !i#overin "i ia*o& re(ation"ip 'it" BeieYe((ey, 39 an En(i" tran(ation o% t"e a!avit a%oreai!, 49 a#ertie! p"oto#opy o% t"e #erti#ate o% irt" o% A((an . /oe, 9 a#erti#ation i&e! y t"e ire#tor o% t"e Re#or! Manae*entan! Ar#"ive O#e, attetin to t"e %a#t t"at t"ere 'a no re#or!n t"e Nationa( Ar#"ive t"at a Foren$o /oe or Foren$o /o& rei!e!or entere! t"e /"i(ippine e%ore 107, an! 9 a #erti#ation %ro*t"e O#erInC"are o% t"e Ar#"ive iviion o% t"e Nationa(Ar#"ive to t"e e=e#t t"at no avai(a(e in%or*ation #o&(! e%o&n! in t"e (e o% t"e Nationa( Ar#"ive rear!in t"e irt" o%A((an . /oe.
On "i part, repon!ent, preente! t'entyt'o !o#&*entarypie#e o% evi!en#e, t"e *ore ini#ant one ein a9 a#erti#ation i&e! y Etre((a M. o*ino o% t"e Ar#"iveiviion o% t"e Nationa( Ar#"ive t"at t"ere appeare! to e noavai(a(e in%or*ation rear!in t"e irt" o% A((an . /oe in t"ereitry o% irt" %or San Car(o, /anainan, 9 a #erti#ation&e! y t"e O#erInC"are o% t"e Ar#"ive iviion o% t"eNationa( Ar#"ive t"at no avai(a(e in%or*ation ao&t t"e*arriae o% A((an . /oe an! /a&(ita Go*e$ #o&(! e %o&n!, #9 a#erti#ate o% irt" o% Rona(! A((an /oe, !9 Oriina( Certi#ate o%Tit(e No. /2247 o% t"e Reitry o% ee! %or t"e /rovin#e o%/anainan, in t"e na*e o% Foren$o /o&, e9 #opie o% Ta<e#(aration No. 20844, No. 2043, No. 23477 an! No. 23478 int"e na*e o% Foren$o /o&, %9 a #opy o% t"e #erti#ate o% !eat" o%Foren$o /o&, 9 a #opy o% t"e p&rporte! *arriae #ontra#tet'een ernan!o /o& an! Beie Ye((ey, an! "9 a #erti#ation
&e! y t"e City Civi( Reitrar o% San Car(o City, /anainan,tatin t"at t"e re#or! o% irt" in t"e ai! o#e !&rin t"eperio! o% %ro* 100 &nti( May 14 'ere tota((y !etroye! !&rin@or(! @ar II.
On 23 an&ary 2004, t"e COMEFEC !i*ie! S/A No. 04003 %ora#6 o% *erit. T"ree !ay (ater, or on 2 an&ary 2004, ornier(e! "i *otion %or re#oni!eration. T"e *otion 'a !enie!on 0 er&ary 2004 y t"e COMEFEC en banc. On 10 er&ary2004, petitioner aai(e! t"e !e#iion o% t"e COMEFEC e%ore t"iCo&rt #on%or*a(y 'it" R&(e 4, in re(ation to R&(e , o% t"eRevie! R&(e o% Civi( /ro#e!&re. T"e petition, !o#6ete! G. R. No.11824, (i6e'ie praye! %or a te*porary retrainin or!er, a 'rito% pre(i*inary in?&n#tion or any ot"er reo(&tion t"at 'o&(! tayt"e na(ity an!;or e<e#&tion o% t"e COMEFEC reo(&tion.
T"e ot"er petition, (ater #ono(i!ate! 'it" G. R. No. 11824,'o&(! in#(&!e G. R. No. 11434, entit(e! +Maria eanette C. Te#on, an! e(i< B. ei!erio, r., v. T"e Co**iion onE(e#tion, Rona(! A((an Ye((ey /oe a.=.a. Xernan!o /oe, r.W9, aDi#torino Z. ornier,+ an! t"e ot"er, !o#6ete! G. R. No. 1134entit(e! +oi(o Antonio G. De(e$, v. Rona(! A((an Ye((ey/oe, a.=.a. ernan!o /oe, r.,+ ot" #"a((enin t"e ?&ri!i#tion t"e COMEFEC an! aertin t"at, &n!er Arti#(e DII, Se#tion 4,pararap" 7, o% t"e 187 Contit&tion, on(y t"e S&pre*e Co&rt"a! oriina( an! e<#(&ive ?&ri!i#tion to reo(ve t"e ai# i&on t"e #ae.
2r"#d"ct"on o' t!e Cort
In . R. No. -4-37
In ee6in t"e !i)&a(i#ation o% t"e #an!i!a#y o% / an! to "t"e COMEFEC !eny !&e #o&re to or #an#e( /W #erti#ate o%#an!i!a#y %or a((ee! *irepreentation o% a *ateria( %a#t i.e.
t"at / 'a a nat&ra(orn #iti$en9 e%ore t"e COMEFEC,petitioner ornier invo6e! Se#tion 78 o% t"e O*ni& E(e#tionCo!e
Se#tion 78. Petition to deny de corse to or cancel a certifc
o6 candidacy. A verie! petition ee6in to !eny !&e #o&reto #an#e( a #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y *ay e (e! y any perone<#(&ive(y on t"e ro&n! t"at any *ateria( repreentation#ontaine! t"erein a re)&ire! &n!er Se#tion 74 "ereo% i %a(e
an! in re(ation to Arti#(e o% t"e O*ni& E(e#tion Co!e '"i#'o&(! a&t"ori$e +any interete! party+ to (e a verie! petitio!eny or #an#e( t"e #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y o% any n&ian#e#an!i!ate.
e#iion o% t"e COMEFEC on !i)&a(i#ation #ae *ay erevie'e! y t"e S&pre*e Co&rt per R&(e 4 2H in an a#tion%or certiorari &n!er R&(e 3H o% t"e Revie! R&(e o% Civi(/ro#e!&re. Se#tion 7, Arti#(e IZ, o% t"e 187 Contit&tion a(orea!
+Ea#" Co**iion "a(( !e#i!e y a *a?ority vote o% a(( itMe*er any #ae or *atter ro&"t e%ore it 'it"in i<ty !ay%ro* t"e !ate o% it &*iion %or !e#iion or reo(&tion. A #aor *atter i !ee*e! &*itte! %or !e#iion or reo(&tion &pon(in o% t"e (at p(ea!in, rie%, or *e*oran!&*, re)&ire! y tr&(e o% t"e Co**iion or y t"e Co**iion ite(%. 5n(eot"er'ie provi!e! y t"i Contit&tion or y (a', any !e#iionor!er, or r&(in o% ea#" Co**iion *ay e ro&"t to t"eS&pre*e Co&rt on #ertiorari y t"e arieve! party 'it"in t"ir!ay %ro* re#eipt o% a #opy t"ereo%.+
A!!itiona((y, Se#tion 1, Arti#(e DIII, o% t"e a*e Contit&tionprovi!e t"at ?&!i#ia( po'er i vete! in one S&pre*e Co&rt anin &#" (o'er #o&rt a *ay e eta(i"e! y (a' '"i#" po'ein#(&!e t"e !&ty o% t"e #o&rt o% ?&ti#e to ett(e a#t&a(#ontroverie invo(vin ri"t '"i#" are (ea((y !e*an!a(e anen%or#ea(e, an! to !eter*ine '"et"er or not t"ere "a een rave a&e o% !i#retion a*o&ntin to (a#6 or e<#e o% ?&ri!i#tion on t"e part o% any ran#" or intr&*enta(ity o% t"eGovern*ent.
t i &#ient(y #(ear t"at t"e petition ro&"t &p in G. R. No.11824 'a apt(y e(evate! to, an! #o&(! 'e(( e ta6en#oni$an#e o% y, t"i Co&rt. A #ontrary vie' #o&(! e a ro!enia( to o&r peop(e o% t"eir %&n!a*enta( ri"t to e %&((yn%or*e!, an! to *a6e a proper #"oi#e, on '"o #o&(! or "o&(!e e(e#te! to o##&py t"e "i"et overn*ent pot in t"e (an!.
In . R. No. -4-757 and . R. No. -4-457
/etitioner Te#on, et a(., in G. R. No. 11434, an! De(e$, in G. R.No. 1134, invo6e t"e proviion o% Arti#(e DII, Se#tion 4,pararap" 7, o% t"e 187 Contit&tion in aai(in t"e ?&ri!i#tiono% t"e COMEFEC '"en it too6 #oni$an#e o% S/A No. 04003 an!
n &rin t"e S&pre*e Co&rt to intea! ta6e on t"e petition t"ey!ire#t(y intit&te! e%ore it. T"e Contit&tiona( proviion #ite!rea!:
+T"e S&pre*e Co&rt, ittin en banc, "a(( e t"e o(e ?&!e o% a((#ontet re(atin to t"e e(e#tion, ret&rn, an! )&a(i#ation o% t"e/rei!ent or Di#e/rei!ent, an! *ay pro*&(ate it r&(e %or t"ep&rpoe.+
T"e proviion i an innovation o% t"e 187 Contit&tion. T"eo*iion in t"e 13 an! t"e 173 Contit&tion to !einate anytri&na( to e t"e o(e ?&!e o% prei!entia( an! vi#eprei!entia(#ontet, "a #ontraine! t"i Co&rt to !e#(are, in Fopez vs.%o9as,4H a not ein9 ?&ti#ia(e #ontroverie or !ip&tenvo(vin #ontet on t"e e(e#tion, ret&rn an! )&a(i#ation o%t"e /rei!ent or Di#e/rei!ent. T"e #ontit&tiona( (apepro*pte! Conre, on 21 &ne 17, to ena#t Rep&(i# A#t No.173, OAn Act "onstittin$ an ndependent Presidential 8lectoralribnal to ry, Hear and ?ecide Protests "ontestin$ the 8lectiono6 the President38lect and the ;ice3President38lect o6 thePhilippines and Providin$ 6or the Canner o6 Hearin$ the2ame.O Rep&(i# A#t 173 !einate! t"e C"ie% &ti#e an! t"eAo#iate &ti#e o% t"e S&pre*e Co&rt to e t"e *e*er o% t"etri&na(. A(t"o&" t"e &e)&ent a!option o% t"e par(ia*entary%or* o% overn*ent &n!er t"e 173 Contit&tion *i"t "ave*p(i#it(y a=e#te! Rep&(i# A#t No. 173, t"e tat&tory et&p,nonet"e(e, 'o&(! no' e !ee*e! revive! &n!er t"e preentSe#tion 4, pararap" 7, o% t"e 187 Contit&tion.
Or!inary &ae 'o&(! #"ara#teri$e a +#ontet+ in re%eren#e to apote(e#tion scenario. E(e#tion #ontet #onit o% eit"er an
e(e#tion protet or a #o warranto '"i#", a(t"o&" t'o !itin#tre*e!ie, 'o&(! "ave one o?e#tive in vie', i.e., to !i(o!e t"e'innin #an!i!ate %ro* o#e. A per&a( o% t"e p"raeo(oy inR&(e 12, R&(e 13, an! R&(e 14 o% t"e O%les o6 the Presidential8lectoral ribnal,+ pro*&(ate! y t"e S&pre*e Co&rt enbanc on 18 Apri( 12, 'o&(! &pport t"i pre*ie
R&(e 12. risdiction. T"e Tri&na( "a(( e t"e o(e ?&!e o% a((#ontet re(atin to t"e e(e#tion, ret&rn, an! )&a(i#ation o% t"e/rei!ent or Di#e/rei!ent o% t"e /"i(ippine.
R&(e 13. How nitiated. An e(e#tion #ontet i initiate! y t"e(in o% an e(e#tion protet or a petition %or )&o 'arranto aaintt"e /rei!ent or Di#e/rei!ent. An e(e#tion protet "a(( notn#(&!e a petition %or #o warranto. A petition %or #o
warranto "a(( not in#(&!e an e(e#tion protet.
R&(e 14. 8lection Protest. On(y t"e reitere! candidate %or/rei!ent or %or Di#e/rei!ent o% t"e /"i(ippine '"o re#eive! t"ee#on! or t"ir! "i"et n&*er o% vote *ay #ontet t"e e(e#tiono% t"e /rei!ent or t"e Di#e/rei!ent, a t"e #ae *ay e, y(in a verie! petition 'it" t"e C(er6 o% t"e /rei!entia( E(e#tora(Tri&na( 'it"in t"irty 309 !ay a%ter t"e pro#(a*ation o% t"e'inner.
T"e r&(e #ateori#a((y pea6 o% t"e ?&ri!i#tion o% t"e tri&na(over #ontet re(atin to t"e e(e#tion, ret&rn an! )&a(i#ation o% t"e +/rei!ent+ or +Di#e/rei!ent+, o% t"e /"i(ippine, an! not o%+#an!i!ate+ %or /rei!ent or Di#e/rei!ent. A #owarranto pro#ee!in i enera((y !ene! a ein an a#tionaaint a peron '"o &&rp, intr&!e into, or &n(a'%&((y "o(! or
e<er#ie a p&(i# o#e.H
In &#" #onte<t, t"e e(e#tion #ontet
#an on(y #onte*p(ate a pote(e#tion scenario. In R&(e 14, on(reitere! #an!i!ate '"o 'o&(! "ave re#eive! eit"er t"e e#oor t"ir! "i"et n&*er o% vote #o&(! (e an e(e#tionprotet. T"i r&(e aain pre&ppoe a pote(e#tion scenario.
It i %air to #on#(&!e t"at t"e ?&ri!i#tion o% t"e S&pre*e Co&rt,!ene! y Se#tion 4, pararap" 7, o% t"e 187 Contit&tion,'o&(! not in#(&!e #ae !ire#t(y ro&"t e%ore it, )&etionin)&a(i#ation o% a #an!i!ate %or t"e prei!en#y or vi#eprei!ee%ore t"e e(e#tion are "e(!.
A##or!in(y, G. R. No. 11434, entit(e! +Maria eanette C. Te#et a(., v. Co**iion on E(e#tion et a(.,+ an! G. R. No. 113
entit(e! +oi(o Antonio De(e$ v. Rona(! A((an Ye((ey/oe a.=.a. ernan!o /oe, r.+ 'o&(! "ave to e !i*ie! %or 'ao% ?&ri!i#tion.
T!e C"t")en#!"( I##e
No', to t"e ai# i&e> it "o&(! e "e(p%&( to rt ive a rie%"itori#a( a#6ro&n! on t"e #on#ept o% #iti$en"ip.
/er"ap, t"e ear(iet &n!ertan!in o% #iti$en"ip 'a t"at ivy Aritot(e, '"o, o*eti*e in 384 to 322 B.C., !e#rie! t"e+#iti$en+ to re%er to a *an '"o "are! in t"e a!*initration o% ?&ti#e an! in t"e "o(!in o% an o#e.H Aritot(e a' itini#an#e i% on(y to !eter*ine t"e #ontit&en#y o% t"e +State'"i#" "e !e#rie! a ein #o*poe! o% &#" peron '"o'o&(! e a!e)&ate in n&*er to a#"ieve a e(%&#ient
e<iten#e.7H T"e #on#ept re' to in#(&!e one '"o 'o&(! ot"overn an! e overne!, %or '"i#" )&a(i#ation (i6e a&tono* ?&!*ent an! (oya(ty #o&(! e e<pe#te!. Citi$en"ip 'a ee!ea( 'it" ri"t an! entit(e*ent, on t"e one "an!, an! 'it"#on#o*itant o(iation, on t"e ot"er.8H In it i!ea( ettin, a#iti$en 'a a#tive in p&(i# (i%e an! %&n!a*enta((y 'i((in to&*it "i private interet to t"e enera( interet o% o#iety.
T"e #on#ept o% #iti$en"ip "a! &n!erone #"ane over t"e#ent&rie. In t"e 18t" #ent&ry, t"e #on#ept 'a (i*ite!, y an(are, to civil citizenship, '"i#" eta(i"e! t"e ri"t ne#ea%or in!ivi!&a( %ree!o*, &#" a ri"t to property, perona( (ian! ?&ti#e.H It *eanin e<pan!e! !&rin t"e 1t" #ent&ry toin#(&!e political citizenship, '"i#" en#o*pae! t"e ri"t toparti#ipate in t"e e<er#ie o% po(iti#a( po'er.10H T"e 20t" #ent&
a' t"e ne<t tae o% t"e !eve(op*ent o% social citizenship,'"i#" (ai! e*p"ai on t"e ri"t o% t"e #iti$en to e#ono*i# 'eein an! o#ia( e#&rity.11H T"e i!ea o% #iti$en"ip "a aine!e<preion in t"e *o!ern 'e(%are tate a it o !eve(ope!in @etern E&rope. An onoin an! na( tae o% !eve(op*en6eepin 'it" t"e rapi!(y "rin6in (oa( vi((ae, *i"t 'e(( et"e internationalization o6 citizenship.12H
T!e Loca% Sett"n$ 'ro S(an"#!
T"e# to t!e Pre#ent
T"ere 'a no &#" ter* a +/"i(ippine #iti$en+ !&rin t"eSpani" rei*e &t +&?e#t o% Spain+ or +Spani" &?e#t.+
#"&r#" re#or!, t"e native 'ere #a((e! 7indios7, !enotin a (o'rear! %or t"e in"aitant o% t"e ar#"ipe(ao. Spani" (a' on
#iti$en"ip e#a*e "i"(y #o!ie! !&rin t"e 1t" #ent&ry &tt"eir "eer n&*er *a!e it !i#&(t to point to one#o*pre"enive (a'. Not a(( o% t"ee #iti$en"ip (a' o% Spain"o'ever, 'ere *a!e to app(y to t"e /"i(ippine I(an! e<#ept t"oe e<p(i#it(y e<ten!e! y Roya( e#ree. 14H
T"e year 188 'a anot"er t&rnin point in /"i(ippine"itory. A(rea!y in t"e tate o% !e#(ine a a &perpo'er, Spain'a %or#e! to o #e!e "er o(e #o(ony in t"e Eat to an &p#o*in'or(! po'er, t"e 5nite! State. An a##epte! prin#ip(e o%nternationa( (a' !i#tate! t"at a #"ane in overeinty, '"i(ere&(tin in an aroation o% a(( po(iti#a( (a' t"en in %or#e, 'o&(!"ave no e=e#t on #ivi( (a', '"i#" 'o&(! re*ain virt&a((y inta#t.
T"e Treaty o% /ari 'a entere! into on 10 e#e*er 188et'een Spain an! t"e 5nite! State.21H 5n!er Arti#(e IZ o% t"etreaty, t"e #ivi( ri"t an! po(iti#a( tat& o% t"e native in"aitanto% t"e territorie #e!e! to t"e 5nite! State 'o&(! e !eter*ine!y it Conre
+Spani" &?e#t, native o% t"e /enin&(a, rei!in in t"eterritory over '"i#" Spain y t"e preent treaty re(in)&i"e or#e!e "er overeinty *ay re*ain in &#" territory or *ayre*ove t"ere%ro*, retainin in eit"er event a(( t"eir ri"t o%property, in#(&!in t"e ri"t to e(( or !ipoe o% &#" property oro% it pro#ee!> an! t"ey "a(( a(o "ave t"e ri"t to #arry on t"eirn!&try, #o**er#e, an! pro%eion, ein &?e#t in repe#tt"ereo% to &#" (a' a are app(i#a(e to %oreiner. In #ae t"eyre*ain in t"e territory t"ey *ay preerve t"eir a((eian#e to t"eCro'n o% Spain y *a6in, e%ore a #o&rt o% re#or!, 'it"in a year%ro* t"e !ate o% t"e e<#"ane o% rati#ation o% t"i treaty, a!e#(aration o% t"eir !e#iion to preerve &#" a((eian#e> in!e%a&(t o% '"i#" !e#(aration t"ey "a(( e "e(! to "ave reno&n#e!t an! to "ave a!opte! t"e nationa(ity o% t"e territory in '"i#"
t"ey rei!e.
T"&
+T"e #ivi( ri"t an! po(iti#a( tat& o% t"e native in"aitant o%t"e territorie "erey #e!e! to t"e 5nite! State "a(( e!eter*ine! y t"e Conre.+22H
5pon t"e rati#ation o% t"e treaty, an! pen!in (ei(ation y t"e5nite! State Conre on t"e &?e#t, t"e native in"aitant o%t"e /"i(ippine #eae! to e Spani" &?e#t. A(t"o&" t"ey !i!not e#o*e A*eri#an #iti$en, t"ey, "o'ever, a(o #eae! to e+a(ien+ &n!er A*eri#an (a' an! 'ere t"& i&e! paport!e#riin t"e* to e #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine entit(e! to t"eprote#tion o% t"e 5nite! State.
T"e ter* +#iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine I(an!+ appeare! %or t"e ti*e in t"e /"i(ippine Bi(( o% 102, a(o #o**on(y re%erre! to at"e /"i(ippine Orani# A#t o% 102, t"e rt #o*pre"enive(ei(ation o% t"e Conre o% t"e 5nite! State on t"e /"i(ippi
+.... that all inhabitants o6 the Philippine slands continin$ toreside therein, who were 2panish sbDects on the 11th day o6
April, 1051, and then resided in said slands, and their childrenborn sbse#ent thereto, shall be deemed and held to be
citi/ens of the Philippine #slands an! a &#" entit(e! to t"prote#tion o% t"e 5nite! State, e<#ept &#" a "a(( "ave e(e#to preerve t"eir a((eian#e to t"e Cro'n o% Spain in a##or!an#
5n!er t"e orani# a#t, a #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine 'a one ''a an in"aitant o% t"e /"i(ippine, an! a Spani" &?e#t on 11t" !ay o% Apri( 18. T"e ter* in"aitant 'a ta6en toin#(&!e 19 a nativeorn in"aitant, 29 an in"aitant '"o 'anative o% /enin&(ar Spain, an! 39 an in"aitant '"o otaine!Spani" paper on or e%ore 11 Apri( 18.24H
Controvery aroe on to t"e tat& o% #"i(!ren orn in t"e/"i(ippine %ro* 11 Apri( 18 to 01 &(y 102, !&rin '"i#"perio! no #iti$en"ip (a' 'a e<tant in t"e /"i(ippine. @ei"'a iven to t"e vie', arti#&(ate! in ?&ripr&!entia( 'ritin at
ti*e, t"at t"e #o**on (a' prin#ip(e o% Ds soli, ot"er'ie a(o6no'n a t"e prin#ip(e o% territoria(ity, operative in t"e 5nite!State an! En(an!, overne! t"oe orn in t"e /"i(ippineAr#"ipe(ao 'it"in t"at perio!.2H More ao&t t"i (ater.
In 23 Mar#" 112, t"e Conre o% t"e 5nite! State *a!e t"e%o((o'in a*en!*ent to t"e /"i(ippine Bi(( o% 102
5n!er t"e one Fa', a nativeorn in"aitant o% t"e /"i(ippine'a !ee*e! to e a #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine a o% 11 Apri( 18% "e 'a 19 a &?e#t o% Spain on 11 Apri( 18, 29 rei!in in t"e/"i(ippine on ai! !ate, an!, 39 in#e t"at !ate, not a #iti$en o%o*e ot"er #o&ntry.
@"i(e t"ere 'a, at one rie% ti*e, !iverent vie' on '"et"er ornot Ds soli 'a a *o!e o% a#)&irin #iti$en"ip, t"e 13Contit&tion ro&"t to an en! to any &#" (in6 'it" #o**on (a',y a!optin, on#e an! %or a((, Ds san$inis or (oo! re(ation"ipa ein t"e ai o% i(ipino #iti$en"ip
Se#tion 1, Arti#(e III, 13 Contit&tion. T"e %o((o'in are
#iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine
19 T"oe '"o are #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine I(an! at t"e ti*eo% t"e a!option o% t"i Contit&tion
29 T"oe orn in t"e /"i(ippine I(an! o% %orein parent'"o, e%ore t"e a!option o% t"i Contit&tion, "a! een e(e#te! top&(i# o#e in t"e /"i(ippine I(an!.
859 T!o#e @!o#e 'at!er# are c"t")en# o' t!e P!"%"(("ne#.
+No peron *ay e e(e#te! /rei!ent &n(e "e i a natural-
born citi/en of the Philippines, a reitere! voter, a(e to ran! 'rite, at (eat %orty year o% ae on t"e !ay o% t"e e(e#tion
an! a rei!ent o% t"e /"i(ippine %or at (eat ten yeari**e!iate(y pre#e!in &#" e(e#tion.+
T"e ter* +nat&ra(orn #iti$en,+ i !ene! to in#(&!e +t"oe 'are #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine %ro* irt" 'it"o&t "avin toper%or* any a#t to a#)&ire or per%e#t t"eir /"i(ippine#iti$en"ip.+27H
T"e !ate, *ont" an! year o% irt" o% / appeare! to e 20A&&t 13 !&rin t"e rei*e o% t"e 13 Contit&tion. T"roit "itory, %o&r *o!e o% a#)&irin #iti$en"ip nat&ra(i$ationsoli, res Ddicata an! Ds san$inis28H "a! een in vo&e. Ont'o, i.e., Ds soli an! Ds san$inis, #o&(! )&a(i%y a peron to a nat&ra(orn #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine. s soli, per %oa vs."ollector o6 "stoms2H 1129, !i! not (at (on. @it" t"ea!option o% t"e 13 Contit&tion an! t"e revera( o% %oa in
"hon$ vs. 2ecretary o6 abor 30H 1479, Ds san$inis or (oo!re(ation"ip 'o&(! no' e#o*e t"e pri*ary ai o% #iti$en"iy irt".
o#&*entary evi!en#e a!!&#e! y petitioner 'o&(! ten! toin!i#ate t"at t"e ear(iet eta(i"e! !ire#t a#en!ant o% / '"i paterna( ran!%at"er Foren$o /o&, *arrie! to Marta Reye,%at"er o% A((an . /oe. @"i(e t"e re#or! o% irt" o% Foren$o /o¬ een preente! in evi!en#e, "i !eat" #erti#ate, "o'evei!entie! "i* to e a i(ipino, a rei!ent o% San Car(o,/anainan, an! 84 year o(! at t"e ti*e o% "i !eat" on 11Septe*er 14. T"e #erti#ate o% irt" o% t"e %at"er o% /, A. /oe, "o'e! t"at "e 'a orn on 17 May 11 to an Epao%at"er, Foren$o /o&, an! a *eti$a Epao( *ot"er, MartaReye. Intro!&#e! y petitioner 'a an &n#ertie! #opy o% a
&ppoe! #erti#ate o% t"e a((ee! *arriae o% A((an . /oe an!/a&(ita Go*e$ on 0 &(y 13. T"e *arriae #erti#ate o% A((. /oe an! Beie Ye((ey reLe#te! t"e !ate o% t"eir *arriae toon 1 Septe*er 140. In t"e a*e #erti#ate, A((an . /oe 'tate! to e t'entyve year o(!, &n*arrie!, an! a i(ipino#iti$en, an! Beie Ye((ey to e t'entyt'o year o(!, &n*arriean! an A*eri#an #iti$en. T"e irt" #erti#ate o% /, 'o&(!!i#(oe t"at "e 'a orn on 20 A&&t 13 to A((an . /oe, ai(ipino, t'enty%o&r year o(!, *arrie! to Beie Ye((y, anA*eri#an #iti$en, t'entyone year o(! an! *arrie!.
Coni!erin t"e reervation *a!e y t"e partie on t"e vera#o% o*e o% t"e entrie on t"e irt" #erti#ate o% repon!ent ant"e *arriae #erti#ate o% "i parent, t"e on(y #on#(&ion t"#o&(! e !ra'n 'it" o*e !eree o% #ertainty %ro* t"e!o#&*ent 'o&(! e t"at
N8ntries in o:cial records. Entrie in o#ia( re#or! *a!e in t"eper%or*an#e o% "i !&ty y a p&(i# o#er o% t"e /"i(ippine, ory a peron in t"e per%or*an#e o% a !&ty pe#ia((y en?oine! ya', are prima 6acie evi!en#e o% t"e %a#t t"erein tate!.
T"e tr&t'ort"ine o% p&(i# !o#&*ent an! t"e va(&e iven tot"e entrie *a!e t"erein #o&(! e ro&n!e! on 19 t"e ene o%o#ia( !&ty in t"e preparation o% t"e tate*ent *a!e, 29 t"epena(ty '"i#" i &&a((y a<e! to a rea#" o% t"at !&ty, 39 t"ero&tine an! !iinterete! oriin o% *ot &#" tate*ent, an! 49t"e p&(i#ity o% re#or! '"i#" *a6e *ore (i6e(y t"e prior e<po&reo% &#" error a *i"t "ave o##&rre!. 31H
T"e !eat" #erti#ate o% Foren$o /o& 'o&(! in!i#ate t"at "e !ie!on 11 Septe*er 14, at t"e ae o% 84 year, in San Car(o,/anainan. It #o&(! t"& e a&*e! t"at Foren$o /o& 'a orno*eti*e in t"e year 1870 '"en t"e /"i(ippine 'a ti(( a #o(onyo% Spain. /etitioner 'o&(! ar&e t"at Foren$o /o& 'a not in t"e/"i(ippine !&rin t"e #r&#ia( perio! o% %ro* 188 to 102#oni!erin t"at t"ere 'a no e<itin re#or! ao&t &#" %a#t int"e Re#or! Manae*ent an! Ar#"ive O#e. /etitioner,"o'ever, (i6e'ie %ai(e! to "o' t"at Foren$o /o& 'a at anyot"er p(a#e !&rin t"e a*e perio!. In "i !eat" #erti#ate, t"erei!en#e o% Foren$o /o& 'a tate! to e San Car(o,/anainan. In t"e aen#e o% any evi!en#e to t"e #ontrary, it
"o&(! e o&n! to #on#(&!e, or at (eat to pre&*e, t"at t"ep(a#e o% rei!en#e o% a peron at t"e ti*e o% "i !eat" 'a a(o"i rei!en#e e%ore !eat". It 'o&(! e e<tre*e(y !o&t%&( i% t"eRe#or! Manae*ent an! Ar#"ive O#e 'o&(! "ave "a!#o*p(ete re#or! o% a(( rei!ent o% t"e /"i(ippine %ro* 188 to102.
Proo' o' Patern"t< and F"%"at"on
Under C"v"% La@.
/etitioner &*it, in any #ae, t"at in eta(i"in (iationre(ation"ip or #ivi( tat& o% t"e #"i(! to t"e %at"er or *ot"erH9or paternity re(ation"ip or #ivi( tat& o% t"e %at"er to t"e #"i(!9o% an i((eiti*ate #"i(!, / evi!ent(y ein an i((eiti*ate ona##or!in to petitioner, t"e *an!atory r&(e &n!er #ivi( (a' *&t
e &e!.
5n!er t"e Civi( Co!e o% Spain, '"i#" 'a in %or#e in t"e/"i(ippine %ro* 08 e#e*er 188 &p &nti( t"e !ay prior to 3A&&t 10 '"en t"e Civi( Co!e o% t"e /"i(ippine too6 e=e#ta#6no'(e!*ent 'a re)&ire! to eta(i" (iation orpaternity. A#6no'(e!*ent 'a eit"er ?&!i#ia( #o*p&(ory9 ovo(&ntary. &!i#ia( or #o*p&(ory a#6no'(e!*ent 'a poion(y i% !one !&rin t"e (i%eti*e o% t"e p&tative parent> vo(&ntaa#6no'(e!*ent #o&(! on(y e "a! in a re#or! o% irt", a 'i((, p&(i# !o#&*ent.32H Co*p(e*entary to t"e ne' #o!e 'a A#t 373 or t"e Civi( Reitry Fa' e<prein in Se#tion t"ereo%,t"at
In #ae o% an i((eiti*ate #"i(!, t"e irt" #erti#ate "a((
e si&ned and sworn to 0ointly y t"e parent o% t"e in%ant on(y y t"e *ot"er i% t"e %at"er re%&e. In t"e (atter #ae, it not e per*ii(e to tate or revea( in t"e !o#&*ent t"e na*t"e %at"er '"o re%&e to a#6no'(e!e t"e #"i(!, or to ivet"erein any in%or*ation y '"i#" &#" %at"er #o&(! e i!entie
In or!er t"at t"e irt" #erti#ate #o&(! t"en e &ti(i$e! to provvo(&ntary a#6no'(e!*ent o% (iation or paternity, t"e #erti#'a re)&ire! to e ine! or 'orn to y t"e %at"er. T"e %ai(&r&#" re)&ire*ent ren!ere! t"e a*e &e(e a ein ana&t"oritative !o#&*ent o% re#onition.33H In Cendoza vs. Cella34H t"e Co&rt r&(e!
+Sin#e Ro!o(%o 'a orn in 13, a%ter t"e reitry (a' 'aena#te!, t"e )&etion "ere rea((y i '"et"er or not "i irt"
#erti#ate E<"iit 19, '"i#" i *ere(y a #ertie! #opy o% t"ereitry re#or!, *ay e re(ie! &pon a &#ient proo% o% "i"avin een vo(&ntari(y re#oni$e!. No &#" re(ian#e, in o&r ?&!*ent, *ay e p(a#e! &pon it. @"i(e it #ontain t"e na*eot" parent, t"ere i no "o'in t"at t"ey ine! t"e oriina(a(one 'ore to it #ontent a re)&ire! in Se#tion o% A#t No.373. or a(( t"at *i"t "ave "appene!, it 'a not even t"ey eit"er o% t"e* '"o %&rni"e! t"e !ata to e entere! in t"e #ivreiter. /etitioner ay t"at in any event t"e irt" #erti#ate in t"e nat&re o% a p&(i# !o#&*ent '"erein vo(&ntary re#onito% a nat&ra( #"i(! *ay a(o e *a!e, a##or!in to t"e a*eArti#(e 131. Tr&e eno&", &t in &#" a #ae, t"ere *&t e a#(ear tate*ent in t"e !o#&*ent t"at t"e parent re#oni$e t"#"i(! a "i or "er o'n.+
In t"e irt" #erti#ate o% repon!ent /, preente! y ot"
partie, no'"ere in t"e !o#&*ent 'a t"e inat&re o% A((an ./oe %o&n!. T"ere ein no 'i(( apparent(y e<e#&te!, or at (ea"o'n to "ave een e<e#&te!, y !e#e!ent A((an . /oe, t"e oot"er proo% o% vo(&ntary re#onition re*aine! to e +o*e ot"p&(i# !o#&*ent.+ In PareDa vs. PareDa,3H t"i Co&rt !ene! '#o&(! #ontit&te &#" a !o#&*ent a proo% o% vo(&ntarya#6no'(e!*ent:
+5n!er t"e Spani" Civi( Co!e t"ere are t'o #(ae o% p&(i#!o#&*ent, t"oe executed by private individuals which
must be authenticated by notaries, an! t"oe i&e! y#o*petent p&(i# o#ia( y reaon o% t"eir o#e. T"e p&(i#!o#&*ent pointe! o&t in Arti#(e 131 a one o% t"e *ean y'"i#" re#onition *ay e *a!e e(on to t"e rt #(a.+
Fet & (eave it at t"at %or t"e *o*ent. T"e 10 Civi( Co!e #ateori$e! t"e a#6no'(e!*ent orre#onition o% i((eiti*ate #"i(!ren into vo(&ntary, (ea( or#o*p&(ory. Do(&ntary re#onition 'a re)&ire! to ee<pree!(y *a!e in a re#or! o% irt", a 'i((, a tate*ent e%o#o&rt o% re#or! or in any a&t"enti# 'ritin. Fea(a#6no'(e!*ent too6 p(a#e in %avor o% %&(( (oo! rot"er an!iter o% an i((eiti*ate #"i(! '"o 'a re#oni$e! or ?&!i#ia((y!e#(are! a nat&ra(. Co*p&(ory a#6no'(e!*ent #o&(! e!e*an!e! enera((y in #ae '"en t"e #"i(! "a! in "i %avor aevi!en#e to prove (iation. 5n(i6e an a#tion to #(ai* (eiti*a#'"i#" 'o&(! (at !&rin t"e (i%eti*e o% t"e #"i(!, an! *i"t pae<#eptiona((y to t"e "eir o% t"e #"i(!, an a#tion to #(ai*a#6no'(e!*ent, "o'ever, #o&(! on(y e ro&"t !&rin t"e(i%eti*e o% t"e pre&*e! parent.
Amics "riae R&en . Ba(ane !ene!, !&rin t"e ora( ar&*ent,+a&t"enti# 'ritin,+ o a to e an a&t"enti# 'ritin %or p&rpoeo% vo(&ntary re#onition, i*p(y a ein a en&ine or in!&ita(e'ritin o% t"e %at"er. T"e ter* 'o&(! in#(&!e a p&(i# intr&*entone !&(y a#6no'(e!e! e%ore a notary p&(i# or ot"er#o*petent o#ia(9 or a private 'ritin a!*itte! y t"e %at"er toe "i.
19 T"e re#or! o% irt" appearin in t"e #ivi( reiter or a na(&!*ent> or
29 An a!*iion o% (eiti*ate (iation in a p&(i# !o#&*ent ora private "an!'ritten intr&*ent an! ine! y t"e parent#on#erne!.
In t"e aen#e o% t"e %oreoin evi!en#e, t"e (eiti*ate (iation"a(( e prove! y:
19 T"e open an! #ontin&o& poeion o% t"e tat& o% aeiti*ate #"i(!> or
29 Any ot"er *ean a((o'e! y t"e R&(e o% Co&rt an! pe#ia(a'.
Art. 173. T"e a#tion to #(ai* (eiti*a#y *ay e ro&"t yt"e #"i(! !&rin "i or "er (i%eti*e an! "a(( e tran*itte! to t"e"eir "o&(! t"e #"i(! !ie !&rin *inority or in a tate o%nanity. In t"ee #ae, t"e "eir "a(( "ave a perio! o% veyear 'it"in '"i#" to intit&te t"e a#tion.
T"e a#tion a(rea!y #o**en#e! y t"e #"i(! "a(( &rvivenot'it"tan!in t"e !eat" o% eit"er or ot" o% t"e partie.
< < < < < < < < <.
Art. 17. I((eiti*ate #"i(!ren *ay eta(i" t"eir i((eiti*ate(iation in t"e a*e 'ay an! on t"e a*e, evi!en#e a (eiti*ate#"i(!ren.
T"e a#tion *&t e ro&"t 'it"in t"e a*e perio! pe#ie! inArti#(e 173, e<#ept '"en t"e a#tion i ae! on t"e e#on!pararap" o% Arti#(e 172, in '"i#" #ae t"e a#tion *ay e ro&"t!&rin t"e (i%eti*e o% t"e a((ee! parent.
+Art. 2. T"i Co!e "a(( "ave retroa#tive e=e#t ino%ar a it!oe not pre?&!i#e or i*pair vete! or a#)&ire! ri"t ina##or!an#e 'it" t"e Civi( Co!e or ot"er (a'.
T"&, in D!a. !e SyK&ia v. Co&rt o% Appea(,3H t"e Co&rt "ar&(e!:
+@e "o(! t"at '"et"er oe 'a a vo(&ntari(y re#oni$e! nat&ra(#"i(! "o&(! e !e#i!e! &n!er Arti#(e 278 o% t"e Civi( Co!e o% t"e/"i(ippine. Arti#(e 220 o% t"at Co!e provi!e t"at t"e vo(&ntaryre#onition o% a nat&ra( #"i(! "a(( ta6e p(a#e a##or!in to t"iCo!e, even i% t"e #"i(! 'a orn e%ore t"e e=e#tivity o% t"i o!yo% (a' or e%ore A&&t 30, 10. -en#e, Arti#(e 278 *ay eiven retroa#tive e=e#t.+
t "o&(! e apparent t"at t"e ro'in tren! to (iera(i$e t"ea#6no'(e!*ent or re#onition o% i((eiti*ate #"i(!ren i anatte*pt to rea6 a'ay %ro* t"e tra!itiona( i!ea o% 6eepin 'e((apart (eiti*ate an! non(eiti*ate re(ation"ip 'it"in t"e%a*i(y in %avor o% t"e reater interet an! 'e(%are o% t"e#"i(!. T"e proviion are inten!e! to *ere(y overn t"e privatean! perona( a=air o% t"e %a*i(y. T"ere i (itt(e, i% any, ton!i#ate t"at t"e (eiti*ate or i((eiti*ate #ivi( tat& o% t"en!ivi!&a( 'o&(! a(o a=e#t "i po(iti#a( ri"t or, in enera(, "i
re(ation"ip to t"e State. @"i(e, in!ee!, proviion on
+#iti$en"ip+ #o&(! e %o&n! in t"e Civi( Co!e, &#" proviion*&t e ta6en in t"e #onte<t o% private re(ation, t"e !o*ain o#ivi( (a'> parti#&(ar(y
+Civi( Fa' i t"at ran#" o% (a' '"i#" "a %or it !o&(e p&rpot"e orani$ation o% t"e %a*i(y an! t"e re&(ation o% property. "a t"& eenH !ene! a t"e *a o% pre#ept '"i#" !eter*an! re&(ate t"e re(ation o% aitan#e, a&t"ority an! oe!iena*on *e*er o% a %a*i(y, an! t"oe '"i#" e<it a*on*e*er o% a o#iety %or t"e prote#tion o% private interet.+3
In aez de /arnevo vs. -ster ,38H t"e Co&rt "a "e(!:
+In a##or!an#e 'it" Arti#(e o% t"e Civi( Co!e o% Spain, < < < t(a' re(atin to %a*i(y ri"t an! !&tie, or to t"e tat&,#on!ition an! (ea( #apa#ity o% peron, overn Spaniar!a(t"o&" t"ey rei!e in a %orein #o&ntry> t"at, in #one)&en#ea(( )&etion o% a #ivi( nat&re, &#" a t"oe !ea(in 'it" t"eva(i!ity or n&((ity o% t"e *atri*onia( on!, t"e !o*i#i(e o% t"e"&an! an! 'i%e, t"eir &pport, a et'een t"e*, t"e eparao% t"eir propertie, t"e r&(e overnin property, *arita(a&t"ority, !iviion o% #on?&a( property, t"e #(ai#ation o% t"eproperty, (ea( #a&e %or !ivor#e, t"e e<tent o% t"e (atter, t"ea&t"ority to !e#ree it, an!, in enera(, t"e #ivi( e=e#t o% *arrian! !ivor#e &pon t"e peron an! propertie o% t"e po&e, a)&etion t"at are overne! e<#(&ive(y y t"e nationa( (a' o% "&an! an! 'i%e.+
T"e re(evan#e o% +#iti$en"ip+ or +nationa(ity+ to Civi( Fa' i ee<e*p(ie! in Arti#(e 1 o% t"e Civi( Co!e, tatin t"at
+Fa' re(atin to %a*i(y ri"t an! !&tie, or to t"e tat&,#on!ition an! (ea( #apa#ity o% peron are in!in &pon citi/
of the Philippines, even t"o&" (ivin aroa!+
t"at e<p(ain t"e nee! to in#orporate in t"e #o!e a reiteration t"e Contit&tiona( proviion on #iti$en"ip. Si*i(ar(y, #iti$eni ini#ant in #ivi( re(ation"ip %o&n! in !i=erent part o% t"eCivi( Co!e,3H &#" a on &##eiona( ri"t an! %a*i(y re(ation40H In a!option, %or intan#e, an a!opte! #"i(! 'o&(! e#oni!ere! t"e #"i(! o% "i a!optive parent an! a##or!e! t"ea*e ri"t a t"eir (eiti*ate #"i(! &t &#" (ea( #tione<ten!e! on(y to !ene "i ri"t &n!er #ivi( (a' 41H an! not "ipo(iti#a( tat&.
Civi( (a' proviion point to an ovio& ia aainti((eiti*a#y. T"i !i#ri*inatory attit&!e *ay e tra#e! to t"eSpani" %a*i(y an! property (a', '"i#", '"i(e !eninproprietary an! &##eiona( ri"t o% *e*er o% t"e %a*i(y,provi!e! !itin#tion in t"e ri"t o% (eiti*ate an! i((eiti*ate#"i(!ren. In t"e *onar#"ia( et&p o% o(! Spain, t"e !itri&tioan! in"eritan#e o% tit(e an! 'ea(t" 'ere tri#t(y a##or!in to(oo!(ine an! t"e #on#ern to 6eep t"ee (oo!(ine&n#onta*inate! y %orein (oo! 'a para*o&nt.
o% anot"er peron re(ate! to "i* y irt" or *arriae, *ay ere#eive! in evi!en#e '"ere it o##&rre! e%ore t"e #ontrovery,an! t"e re(ation"ip et'een t"e t'o peron i "o'n yevi!en#e ot"er t"an &#" a#t or !e#(aration. T"e 'or! [pe!ireeWn#(&!e re(ation"ip, %a*i(y enea(oy, irt", *arriae, !eat",t"e !ate '"en an! t"e p(a#e '"ere t"ee %a#t o##&rre!, an!t"e na*e o% t"e re(ative. It e*ra#e a(o %a#t o% %a*i(y"itory inti*ate(y #onne#te! 'it" pe!iree.
or t"e aove r&(e to app(y, it 'o&(! e ne#eary t"at a9 t"e!e#(arant i a(rea!y !ea! or &na(e to teti%y, 9 t"e pe!iree o%a peron *&t e at i&e, #9 t"e !e#(arant *&t e a re(ative o%t"e peron '"oe pe!iree i in )&etion, !9 !e#(aration *&t e
*a!e e%ore t"e #ontrovery "a o##&rre!, an! e9 t"ere(ation"ip et'een t"e !e#(arant an! t"e peron '"oepe!iree i in )&etion *&t e "o'n y evi!en#e ot"er t"an&#" a#t or !e#(aration.
T"&, t"e !&(y notari$e! !e#(aration *a!e y R&y Ye((eyMana"a, iter o% Beie Ye((ey /oe &*itte! a E<"iit 20e%ore t"e COMEFEC, *i"t e a##epte! to prove t"e a#t o%A((an . /oe, re#oni$in "i o'n paterna( re(ation"ip 'it" /,i.e, (ivin toet"er 'it" Beie Ye((ey an! "i #"i(!ren in#(&!inrepon!ent /9 in one "o&e, an! a one %a*i(y
3. ernan!o an! Beie /oe "a! a on y t"e na*e o% Rona(!A((an /oe, *ore pop&(ar(y 6no'n in t"e /"i(ippine a [ernan!o/oe, r.,W or [/W.
4. Rona(! A((an /oe [/W 'a orn on A&&t 20, 13 at St.F&6e -opita(, Ma!a(ena Street, Mani(a.
< < < < < < < < <
7. ernan!o /oe Sr., an! *y iter Beie, *et an! e#a*eenae! '"i(e t"ey 'ere t&!ent at t"e 5niverity o% t"e/"i(ippine in 13. I 'a a(o intro!&#e! to ernan!o /oe, Sr., y
18. I a* e<e#&tin t"i e#(aration to attet to t"e %a#t t"at *ynep"e', Rona(! A((an /oe i a nat&ra( orn i(ipino, an! t"at "e it"e (eiti*ate #"i(! o% ernan!o /oe, Sr.
one in City o% Sto#6ton, Ca(i%ornia, 5.S.A., t"i 12t" !ay o%an&ary 2004.
R&y Ye((ey Mana"a
e#(arant
DNA Te#t"n$
n #ae proo% o% (iation or paternity 'o&(! e &n(i6e(y toati%a#tori(y eta(i" or 'o&(! e !i#&(t to otain, NA tetin,'"i#" e<a*ine eneti# #o!e otaine! %ro* o!y #e(( o% t"e
((eiti*ate #"i(! an! any p"yi#a( rei!&e o% t"e (on !ea! parent
#o&(! e reorte! to. A poitive *at#" 'o&(! #(ear &p (iationpaternity. In iDin$ vs. "ort o6 Appeals,42H t"i Co&rt "aa#6no'(e!e! t"e tron 'ei"t o% NA tetin
+/arentae 'i(( ti(( e reo(ve! &in #onventiona( *et"o!&n(e 'e a!opt t"e *o!ern an! #ienti# 'ayavai(a(e. ort&nate(y, 'e "ave no' t"e %a#i(ity an! e<pertie&in NA tet %or i!enti#ation an! parentae tetin. T"e5niverity o% t"e /"i(ippine Nat&ra( S#ien#e Reear#" Intit&te5/NSRI9 NA Ana(yi Faoratory "a no' t"e #apai(ity to#on!&#t NA typin &in "ort tan!e* repeat STR9ana(yi. T"e ana(yi i ae! on t"e %a#t t"at t"e NA o% a#"i(!;peron "a t'o 29 #opie, one #opy %ro* t"e *ot"er an!
t"e ot"er %ro* t"e %at"er. T"e NA %ro* t"e *ot"er, t"e a((e%at"er an! t"e #"i(! are ana(y$e! to eta(i" parentae. O%#o&re, ein a nove( #ienti# te#"ni)&e, t"e &e o% NA tet evi!en#e i ti(( open to #"a((ene. Event&a((y, a t"e appropr#ae #o*e, #o&rt "o&(! not "eitate to r&(e on t"e a!*iio% NA evi!en#e. or it 'a ai!, t"at #o&rt "o&(! app(y t"ere&(t o% #ien#e '"en #o*petent(y otaine! in ai! o% it&atiopreente!, in#e to re?e#t ai! re&(t i to !eny prore.+
Pet"t"oner# Ar$ent For
2r"#(rdent"a% Conc%#"vene##
/etitioner 'o&(! "ave it t"at even i% A((an . /oe 'ere a i(ipino#iti$en, "e #o&(! not "ave tran*itte! "i #iti$en"ip torepon!ent /, t"e (atter ein an i((eiti*ate #"i(!. A##or!into petitioner, prior to "i *arriae to Beie Ye((ey, A((an . /oeon &(y , 13, #ontra#te! *arriae 'it" a #ertain /a&(itaGo*e$, *a6in "i &e)&ent *arriae to Beie Ye((eyia*o& an! repon!ent / an i((eiti*ate #"i(!. T"e vera#o% t"e &ppoe! #erti#ate o% *arriae et'een A((an . /oe an/a&(ita Go*e$ #o&(! e *ot !o&t%&( at et. B&t t"e!o#&*entary evi!en#e intro!&#e! y no (e t"an repon!ent"i*e(%, #onitin o% a irt" #erti#ate o% repon!ent an! a*arriae #erti#ate o% "i parent "o'e! t"at / 'a orn o20 A&&t 13 to a i(ipino %at"er an! an A*eri#an *ot"er ''ere *arrie! to ea#" ot"er a year (ater, or on 1 Septe*er140. Birt" to &n*arrie! parent 'o&(! *a6e / an i((eiti*a#"i(!. /etitioner #onten!e! t"at a an i((eiti*ate #"i(!, / o%o((o'e! t"e #iti$en"ip o% "i *ot"er, Beie Ye((ey, an A*eri#iti$en, ain "i tan! on t"e r&(in o% t"i Co&rt in Corano v
;ivo,43H #itin "hion$bian vs. de eon44H an! 2erra vs. %epbli
On t"e aove #ore, t"e !i)&iition *a!e y amicscriae oa)&in G. Berna, S, i *ot #onvin#in> "e tate
+@e *&t ana(y$e t"ee #ae an! a6 '"at t"e lis mota 'a ea#" o% t"e*. I% t"e prono&n#e*ent o% t"e Co&rt on Dssan$inis 'a on t"e lis mota, t"e prono&n#e*ent 'o&(! e a!e#iion #ontit&tin !o#trine &n!er t"e r&(e o% stare decisis. i% t"e prono&n#e*ent 'a irre(evant to t"e lis mota, t"eprono&n#e*ent 'o&(! not e a !e#iion &t a *ere obiterdictm '"i#" !i! not eta(i" !o#trine. I t"ere%ore invite t"eCo&rt to (oo6 #(oe(y into t"ee #ae.
irt, Corano vs. ;ivo. T"e #ae 'a not ao&t an i((eiti*ate#"i(! o% a i(ipino %at"er. It 'a ao&t a tepon o% a i(ipino, atepon '"o 'a t"e #"i(! o% a C"inee *ot"er an! a C"inee%at"er. T"e i&e 'a '"et"er t"e tepon %o((o'e! t"enat&ra(i$ation o% t"e tep%at"er. Not"in ao&t Ds
Se#on!, "hion$bian vs. de eon. T"i #ae 'a not ao&t t"ei((eiti*ate on o% a i(ipino %at"er. It 'a ao&t a (eiti*ate oo% a %at"er '"o "a! e#o*e i(ipino y e(e#tion to p&(i# o#ee%ore t"e 13 Contit&tion p&r&ant to Arti#(e ID, Se#tion 12o% t"e 13 Contit&tion. No one 'a i((eiti*ate "ere.
T"ir!, 2erra vs. %epblic. T"e #ae 'a not ao&t t"ei((eiti*ate on o% a i(ipino %at"er. Serra 'a an i((eiti*ate #o% a C"inee %at"er an! a i(ipino *ot"er. T"e i&e 'a '"et
one '"o 'a a(rea!y a i(ipino e#a&e o% "i *ot"er '"o ti((
nee!e! to e nat&ra(i$e!. T"ere i not"in t"ere ao&tnvi!io& Ds san$inis.
ina((y, Paa vs. "han.4H T"i i a *ore #o*p(i#ate! #ae. T"e#ae 'a ao&t t"e #iti$en"ip o% K&intin C"an '"o 'a t"e ono% Feon#io C"an. K&intin C"an #(ai*e! t"at "i %at"er, Feon#io,'a t"e i((eiti*ate on o% a C"inee %at"er an! a i(ipino*ot"er. K&intin t"ere%ore ar&e! t"at "e ot "i #iti$en"ip %ro*Feon#io, "i %at"er. B&t t"e S&pre*e Co&rt ai! t"at t"ere 'a nova(i! proo% t"at Feon#io 'a in %a#t t"e on o% a i(ipina*ot"er. T"e Co&rt t"ere%ore #on#(&!e! t"at Feon#io 'a noti(ipino. I% Feon#io 'a not i(ipino, neit"er 'a "i onK&intin. K&intin t"ere%ore 'a not on(y not a nat&ra(orn i(ipino
&t 'a not even a i(ipino.
T"e Co&rt "o&(! "ave toppe! t"ere. B&t intea! it %o((o'e!'it" an obiter dictm. T"e Co&rt ai! obiter t"at even i% Feon#io,K&intin %at"er, 'ere i(ipino, K&intin 'o&(! not e i(ipinoe#a&e K&intin 'a i((eiti*ate. T"i tate*ent ao&t K&intin,ae! on a #ontrary to %a#t a&*ption, 'a ao(&te(y&nne#eary %or t"e #ae. < < < It 'a obiter dictm, p&re an!i*p(e, i*p(y repeatin t"e oiter !i#t&* in Corano vs. ;ivo.
< < < < < < < < <
+Ai!e %ro* t"e %a#t t"at &#" a prono&n#e*ent 'o&(! "ave note<t&a( %o&n!ation in t"e Contit&tion, it 'o&(! a(o vio(ate t"ee)&a( prote#tion #(a&e o% t"e Contit&tion not on#e &tt'i#e. irt, it 'o&(! *a6e an i((eiti*ate !itin#tion et'een aeiti*ate #"i(! an! an i((eiti*ate #"i(!, an! e#on!, it 'o&(!*a6e an i((eiti*ate !itin#tion et'een t"e i((eiti*ate #"i(! o% ai(ipino %at"er an! t"e i((eiti*ate #"i(! o% a i(ipino *ot"er.
T"e !o#trine on #ontit&tiona((y a((o'a(e !itin#tion 'aeta(i"e! (on ao y /eop(e v. Cayat.47H I 'o&(! rant t"att"e !itin#tion et'een (eiti*ate #"i(!ren an! i((eiti*ate#"i(!ren ret on rea( !i=eren#e. < < < B&t rea( !i=eren#e a(one!o not ?&ti%y invi!io& !itin#tion. Rea( !i=eren#e *ay ?&ti%y!itin#tion %or one p&rpoe &t not %or anot"er p&rpoe.
< < < @"at i t"e re(evan#e o% (eiti*a#y or i((eiti*a#y toe(e#tive p&(i# ervi#eJ @"at poi(e tate interet #an t"ere e%or !i)&a(i%yin an i((eiti*ate #"i(! %ro* e#o*in a p&(i#o#er. It 'a not t"e %a&(t o% t"e #"i(! t"at "i parent "a! i((i#it
iaion. @"y !eprive t"e #"i(! o% t"e %&((ne o% po(iti#a( ri"t %orno %a&(t o% "i o'nJ To !i)&a(i%y an i((eiti*ate #"i(! %ro*"o(!in an i*portant p&(i# o#e i to p&ni" "i* %or t"en!i#retion o% "i parent. T"ere i neit"er ?&ti#e nor rationa(ityn t"at. An! i% t"ere i neit"er ?&ti#e nor rationa(ity in t"e!itin#tion, t"en t"e !itin#tion tranree t"e e)&a( prote#tion#(a&e an! *&t e reproate!.
T"e ot"er amici criae, Mr. &ti#e Di#ente Men!o$a a %or*er*e*er o% t"i Co&rt9, /ro%eor R&en Ba(ane an! ean MartinMaa((ona, at otto*, "ave e<pree! i*i(ar vie'. T"e t"ei o% petitioner, &n%ort&nate(y "inin o(e(y on p&re obiterdicta, "o&(! in!ee! %ai(.
@"ere ?&ripr&!en#e rear!e! an i((eiti*ate #"i(! a ta6in a%tert"e #iti$en"ip o% it *ot"er, it !i! o %or t"e enet t"e #"i(!. It
'a to en&re a i(ipino nationa(ity %or t"e i((eiti*ate #"i(! o% ana(ien %at"er in (ine 'it" t"e a&*ption t"at t"e *ot"er "a!#&to!y, 'o&(! e<er#ie parenta( a&t"ority an! "a! t"e !&ty to&pport "er i((eiti*ate #"i(!. It 'a to "e(p t"e #"i(!, not topre?&!i#e or !i#ri*inate aaint "i*.
T"e %a#t o% t"e *atter per"ap t"e *ot ini#ant#oni!eration i t"at t"e 13 Contit&tion, t"e %&n!a*enta( (a'prevai(in on t"e !ay, *ont" an! year o% irt" o% repon!ent /,#an never e *ore e<p(i#it t"an it i. /rovi!in neit"er #on!itionnor !itin#tion, t"e Contit&tion tate t"at a*on t"e #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine are t"oe '"oe %at"er are #iti$en o% t"e/"i(ippine. T"ere &tter(y i no #oent ?&ti#ation to pre#rie#on!ition or !itin#tion '"ere t"ere #(ear(y are none provi!e!.
In S :
19 T"e Co&rt, in t"e e<er#ie o% it po'er o% ?&!i#ia(revie', poee ?&ri!i#tion over t"e petition in G. R. No.11824, (e! &n!er R&(e 4, in re(ation to R&(e , o% t"e ReviR&(e o% Civi( /ro#e!&re. G.R. No. 11824 aai( t"e reo(&tiot"e COMEFEC %or a((ee! rave a&e o% !i#retion in !i*iin%or (a#6 o% *erit, t"e petition in S/A No. 04003 '"i#" "a pray%or t"e !i)&a(i#ation o% repon!ent / %ro* r&nnin %or t"epoition o% /rei!ent in t"e 10t" May 2004 nationa( e(e#tion ont"e #ontention t"at / "a #o**itte! *ateria( repreentation"i #erti#ate o% #an!i!a#y y repreentin "i*e(% to e anat&ra(orn #iti$en o% t"e /"i(ippine.
pre*at&rity, t"e petition in G. R. No. 11434 an! No. 1134ot" "avin een !ire#t(y e(evate! to t"i Co&rt in t"e (atterW#apa#ity a t"e on(y tri&na( to reo(ve a prei!entia( an! vi#eprei!entia( e(e#tion #ontet &n!er t"e Contit&tion. Evi!ent(yt"e pri*ary ?&ri!i#tion o% t"e Co&rt #an !ire#t(y e invo6e! ona%ter, not e%ore, t"e e(e#tion are "e(!.
39 In a#ertainin, in G.R. No. 11824, '"et"er ravea&e o% !i#retion "a een #o**itte! y t"e COMEFEC, it ine#eary to ta6e on t"e *atter o% '"et"er or not repon!ent i a nat&ra(orn #iti$en, '"i#", in t&rn, !epen!e! on '"et"er not t"e %at"er o% repon!ent, A((an . /oe, 'o&(! "ave "i*e(%een a i(ipino #iti$en an!, in t"e ar*ative, '"et"er or not t"a((ee! i((eiti*a#y o% repon!ent prevent "i* %ro* ta6in a%t"e i(ipino #iti$en"ip o% "i p&tative %at"er. Any #on#(&ion o
t"e i(ipino #iti$en"ip o% Foren$o /o& #o&(! on(y e !ra'n %ro*t"e pre&*ption t"at "avin !ie! in 14 at 84 year o(!, Fore'o&(! "ave een orn o*eti*e in t"e year 1870, '"en t"e/"i(ippine 'a &n!er Spani" r&(e, an! t"at San Car(o,/anainan, "i p(a#e o% rei!en#e &pon "i !eat" in 14, in taen#e o% any ot"er evi!en#e, #o&(! "ave 'e(( een "i p(a#erei!en#e e%ore !eat", &#" t"at Foren$o /o& 'o&(! "aveenete! %ro* t"e en masse i(ipini$ation t"at t"e /"i(ippinBi(( "a! e=e#te! in 102. T"at #iti$en"ip o% Foren$o /o&9, i%a#)&ire!, 'o&(! t"erey e<ten! to "i on, A((an . /oe, %at"er repon!ent /. T"e 13 Contit&tion, !&rin '"i#" rei*erepon!ent / "a een rt (i"t, #on%er #iti$en"ip to a((peron '"oe %at"er are i(ipino #iti$en rear!(e o% '"et"&#" #"i(!ren are (eiti*ate or i((eiti*ate.
49 B&t '"i(e t"e tota(ity o% t"e evi!en#e *ay not eta#on#(&ive(y t"at repon!ent / i a nat&ra(orn #iti$en o% t"e/"i(ippine, t"e evi!en#e on "an! ti(( 'o&(! prepon!erate in "%avor eno&" to "o(! t"at "e #annot e "e(! &i(ty o% "avin*a!e a *ateria( *irepreentation in "i #erti#ate o% #an!i!ain vio(ation o% Se#tion 78, in re(ation to Se#tion 74, o% t"eO*ni& E(e#tion Co!e. /etitioner "a &tter(y %ai(e! to&tantiate "i #ae e%ore t"e Co&rt, not'it"tan!in t"e a*opport&nity iven to t"e partie to preent t"eir poition an!evi!en#e, an! to prove '"et"er or not t"ere "a een *ateria*irepreentation, '"i#", a o r&(e! in %omaldez3Carcos vs"BC88",48H *&t not on(y e *ateria(, &t a(o !e(ierate an'i((%&(.
*HEREFORE, t"e Co&rt RESOFDES to ISMISS
1. G. R. No. 11434, entit(e! +Maria eanette C. Te#on an! eB. ei!erio, r., /etitioner, verss Co**iion on E(e#tion,Rona(! A((an Ye((ey /oe a.=.a. +ernan!o /oe, r.,9 an! Di#torinornier, Repon!ent,+ an! G. R. No. 1134, entit(e! +oi(oAntonio De(e$, /etitioner, verss Rona(! A((an Ye((ey/oe, a.=.a. ernan!o /oe, r., Repon!ent,+ %or 'ant o% ?&ri!i#t
2. G. R. No. 11824, entit(e! Di#torino Z. ornier,/etitioner, verss -on. Co**iion on E(e#tion an! Rona(! AYe((ey /oe, a(o 6no'n a ernan!o /oe, r., %or %ai(&re to "o'rave a&e o% !i#retion on t"e part o% repon!ent Co**iioon E(e#tion in !i*iin t"e petition in S/A No. 04003.