175 The Korean Journal of Pathology 2008; 42: 175-80 True malignant mixed tumor (carcinosarcoma) of the salivary gland is an extremely rare tumor. By definition, it is a heterologous neoplasm that’s composed of both malignant epithe- lial and mesenchymal components. We report here on a case of an 83 year old female patient with a parotid gland mass. Histologic examination showed a biphasic pattern of growth with both a poorly differentiated epithelial component and a sarcomatous spindle cell background. The immunohistochemical and ultrastructural findings support the diagnosis of a small cell neuroendocrine epithelial tumor and an undifferentiated malignant mesenchymal features. The histologic and ultrastructural features along with the immunohistochemical findings are presented. We also review the literature and we discuss the different opinions on the exact histogenesis of the true malignant mixed tumor of the salivary gland. To the best of our knowl- edge, this histological pattern has not been previously reported in the English medical literature. Key Words : Carcinosarcoma; Parotid gland; Carcinoma, small cell; Immunohistochemistry; Microscopy, electron Hun-Soo Kim∙Hyang Jung Cho Yeun-Tai Chung 1 ∙Soon-Ah Park 2 Hae-Joong Cho 3 ∙Jin-Man Kim 4 175 Carcinosarcoma (True Malignant Mixed Tumor) of the Parotid Gland - A Report of a Case with Small Cell Carcinoma as the Carcinoma Component - 175 175 Corresponding Author Jin-Man Kim Cancer Research Institute and Department of Pathology, Chungnam National University School of Medicine, 6 Munwha-1-dong, Jung-gu, Daejeon 301-131, Korea Tel: 042-580-8237 Fax: 042-581-5233 E-mail: [email protected]*This paper was supported by Wonkwang University in 2006. Departments of Pathology, 1 Anatomy, 2 Nuclear Medicine, and 3 Obstetrics and Gynecology, Wonkwang University School of Medicine, Iksan; 4 Cancer Research Institute and Department of Pathology, Chungnam National University School of Medicine, Daejon, Korea Received : September 12, 2007 Accepted : March 18, 2008 Malignant mixed tumor of the salivary gland refers to three different entities, carcinoma ex pleomorphic adenoma (which is most common), metastasizing mixed tumor and carcinosarco- ma. 1 Carcinoma ex pleomorphic adenoma represents malignant transformation of a pre-existing pleomorphic adenoma, usually in the setting of an untreated, long-standing benign pleomor- phic adenoma or in a tumor with multiple local recurrences. Malignant mixed tumor (carcinosarcoma) is a biphasic neo- plasm that comprises of both malignant epithelial and mes- enchymal elements. 9 More than 99% of these tumor arise from pleomorphic adenomas, with only 0.2% being primary carci- nosarcoma or true malignant mixed tumors. 2 To date, there are only about 60 reported cases in the medical literature, most of which are case reports and reviews. The most common type of epithelial component of the salivary gland carcinosarcomas is squamous cell carcinoma or adenocarcinoma and the common type of mesenchymal component is chondrosarcoma, fib- rosacroma, leiomyosarcoma, osteosarcoma, and rarely liposarco- ma, in the order of frequency. We report here on a case of a true malignant mixed tumor (carcinosarcoma) of the parotid gland that contained an unusu- al epithelial component, that is, small cell carcinoma, and we present the results of the immunohistochemical and ultrastruc- tural studies. CASE REPORT An 83-year-old female patient presented with a mass in the right inferior auricular area, and she’d had this mass for one and
6
Embed
Carcinosarcoma (True Malignant Mixed Tumor) of the Parotid Glandkoreanjpathol.org/upload/journal/2008/2008_0175.pdf · 2008-12-29 · Carcinosarcoma (True Malignant Mixed Tumor) of
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
175
The Korean Journal of Pathology2008; 42: 175-80
True malignant mixed tumor (carcinosarcoma) of the salivary gland is an extremely raretumor. By definition, it is a heterologous neoplasm that’s composed of both malignant epithe-lial and mesenchymal components. We report here on a case of an 83 year old female patientwith a parotid gland mass. Histologic examination showed a biphasic pattern of growth withboth a poorly differentiated epithelial component and a sarcomatous spindle cell background.The immunohistochemical and ultrastructural findings support the diagnosis of a small cellneuroendocrine epithelial tumor and an undifferentiated malignant mesenchymal features.The histologic and ultrastructural features along with the immunohistochemical findings arepresented. We also review the literature and we discuss the different opinions on the exacthistogenesis of the true malignant mixed tumor of the salivary gland. To the best of our knowl-edge, this histological pattern has not been previously reported in the English medical literature.
Key Words : Carcinosarcoma; Parotid gland; Carcinoma, small cell; Immunohistochemistry;Microscopy, electron
Carcinosarcoma (True Malignant Mixed Tumor) of the Parotid Gland
- A Report of a Case with Small Cell Carcinoma as the Carcinoma Component -
175 175
Corresponding AuthorJin-Man KimCancer Research Institute and Department of Pathology, Chungnam National University School ofMedicine, 6 Munwha-1-dong, Jung-gu, Daejeon301-131, KoreaTel: 042-580-8237Fax: 042-581-5233E-mail: [email protected]
*This paper was supported by Wonkwang Universityin 2006.
Departments of Pathology, 1Anatomy,2Nuclear Medicine, and 3Obstetrics andGynecology, Wonkwang UniversitySchool of Medicine, Iksan; 4CancerResearch Institute and Department ofPathology, Chungnam National University School of Medicine, Daejon,Korea
Received : September 12, 2007Accepted : March 18, 2008
Malignant mixed tumor of the salivary gland refers to threedifferent entities, carcinoma ex pleomorphic adenoma (which ismost common), metastasizing mixed tumor and carcinosarco-ma.1 Carcinoma ex pleomorphic adenoma represents malignanttransformation of a pre-existing pleomorphic adenoma, usuallyin the setting of an untreated, long-standing benign pleomor-phic adenoma or in a tumor with multiple local recurrences.
Malignant mixed tumor (carcinosarcoma) is a biphasic neo-plasm that comprises of both malignant epithelial and mes-enchymal elements.9 More than 99% of these tumor arise frompleomorphic adenomas, with only 0.2% being primary carci-nosarcoma or true malignant mixed tumors.2 To date, there areonly about 60 reported cases in the medical literature, most ofwhich are case reports and reviews. The most common type ofepithelial component of the salivary gland carcinosarcomas is
squamous cell carcinoma or adenocarcinoma and the commontype of mesenchymal component is chondrosarcoma, fib-rosacroma, leiomyosarcoma, osteosarcoma, and rarely liposarco-ma, in the order of frequency.
We report here on a case of a true malignant mixed tumor(carcinosarcoma) of the parotid gland that contained an unusu-al epithelial component, that is, small cell carcinoma, and wepresent the results of the immunohistochemical and ultrastruc-tural studies.
CASE REPORT
An 83-year-old female patient presented with a mass in theright inferior auricular area, and she’d had this mass for one and
176 Hun-Soo Kim∙Hyang Jung Cho∙Yeun-Tai Chung, et al.
a half year. She was admitted to the ENT department after shenoticed a sudden increase in size of the mass along with localtenderness. She had no specific past medical history, except forhypertension, or any signs of facial weakness. A preoperativeCT scan of the neck showed an irregular marginated soft tissuemass in the right superficial lobe of the parotid gland and themass measured 4.3×3.7 cm, without any significant lympha-
denopathy in the neck (Fig. 1). Fine needle aspiration was ini-tially performed. The cytologic specimen showed scattered hyper-chromatic small round cells with molding and crushing arti-fact. The initial cytologic diagnosis was consistent with smallcell carcinoma. The patient then, underwent right total paroti-dectomy and right radical neck dissection with full preserva-tion of the facial nerve.
Fig. 1. CT scan showing a tumor of the right superficial parotidgland with heterogeneous density (black and white arrows).
Fig. 2. Gross examination of the parotid gland showing an ill-defin-ed, lobulated and fleshy soft tissue mass with focal areas of hem-orrhage.
Fig. 3. Histology of the tumor showing dual components-small cellcarcinoma and sarcomatous spindle cells.
Fig. 4. Diffuse cytoplasmic staining for synaptophysin in the car-cinomatous component.
Carcinosarcoma (True Malignant Mixed Tumor) of the Parotid Gland 177
Pathologic findings
The specimen received from the operating room was a total-ly resected parotid gland. A relatively ill-defined, solid massthat measured 5×2.5×2.2 cm was present on sectioning. Itwas lobulated, fish-fleshy and whitish-tan colored with focalareas of hemorrhage (Fig. 2). The specimen was fixed in 10%buffered formalin, embedded in paraffin and the routine hema-toxylin-eosin sections were obtained. Microscopically, the tumorwas mainly composed of two components. The epithelial com-ponent showed clusters of closely packed primitive small roundto elongated cells that were arranged in a cord-like pattern.These cells had scanty cytoplasm with ill-defined cell borders.The nuclei were hyperchromatic with inconspicuous nucleoli(Fig. 3).
The morphological and immunohistochemical findings ofthe epithelial component were consistent with small cell carci-noma. On the other hand, the stromal component was highlycellular and it consisted of oval to elongated spindle cells thatwere arranged in a fascicular pattern of growth. These cells weregenerally monotonous with moderate nuclear atypia. Mitoticfigures were frequent on both the epithelial and stromal com-ponents. There were no areas morphologically consistent withpleomorphic adenoma.
Immunohistochemistry and ultrastructural findings
The immunohistochemical profiles are summarized in Table1. The carcinomatous areas were reactive for cytokeratin, EMA,synaptophysin (Fig. 4), chromogranin, and CD56, indicatingtheir neuroendocrine nature. However, the sarcomatous area wasreactive for only vimentin and it was negative for desmin, smoothmuscle actin and S-100 protein.
Ultrastructural studies were preformed by using the remain-
Antibodies Source and dilutionCarci-noma
Sarcoma
Cytokeratin Dako Carpinteria, + -CA, USA, 1:70
EMA Dako, 1:100 + -
Synaptophysin Zymed, San Francisco, + -CA, USA, 1:100
*Plus sign indicates positive; minus sign, negative.
Table 1. Immunohistochemical profiles of different tumor com-ponents
A B
Fig. 5. Electron microscopic analysis of the carcinomatous component showing numerous cytoplasmic neurosecretory granules (arrows)(original magnification ×15,000) (A). Detail of cytoplasmic thin filamentous material suggesting vimentin (arrows) in the sarcomatous spin-dle cells (original magnification ×20,000) (B).
ing tissue that was fixed in formalin. Although the specimenwas in poor condition for electron microscopic examination, itwas adequate enough to demonstrate neurosecretory granulesin the cytoplasm of the epithelial cells (Fig. 5A). The spindlecells showed numerous well oriented, thin filamentous materi-als that were suggestive of vimentin (Fig. 5B).
These histologic, immunohistochemical and ultrastructuralfindings were consistent with true malignant mixed tumor (car-cinosarcoma) with small cell carcinoma for the carcinomatouscomponent, and an unspecified sarcomatous component. Theradical neck dissection specimens showed no evidence of lymphnode metastasis.
DISCUSSION
Carcinosarcoma of the salivary gland is an extremely rare, agg-ressive neoplasm. Because of its rareness, the molecular changes,clonality, and the origin of this tumor are still controversial.3 In1951 Kirklin et al. first described mixed carcinoma and sarco-ma of the parotid gland,4 and the sarcomatous component wasthought to be the stroma of the tumor. The term true malignantmixed tumor (carcinosarcoma) was first used by King et al.5 in1967. An association of a clinical history of pleomorphic ade-noma and the histologic evidence of coexisting or preexistingpleomorphic adenoma has been documented.7 There is also asubset of salivary gland carcinosarcomas that arise de novo.8 Thetumorigenesis of carcinosarcoma has been debated and the argu-ments can be divided into two antithetical hypotheses. Onehypothesis is called the ‘‘convergence hypothesis’’ and it suggests
the existence of a multiclonal tumor in which two or more mes-enchymal and epithelial stem cells originate. The other, calledthe ‘‘divergence hypothesis’’, is a monoclonal hypothesis in whicha totipotent stem cell in the tumor undergoes divergent differ-entiation.13 LOH analysis suggests that the carcinosarcoma is ofa monoclonal origin and the myoepithelial cell is the most likelycandidate for the common stem cell.3 But the precursor cell isnot always of a myoepithelial origin.8,11 Alvares-Canas and Rodil-la proposed the origin was the ductal luminal epithelial cells,10
but primitive pleuripotent cells have been thought to be the cellof origin by other authors.11
Gnepp1 summarized 43 published cases of carcinosarcoma ofthe salivary glands. Twenty-seven tumors were from parotidglands, 8 were from submandibular glands, 5 were from thepalate,7 two were from unspecified major salivary glands andone was from the tongue. Six tumors had microscopic evidenceof having arisen in a benign mixed tumor. The histology of thecarcinomatous component in that previous study1 consisted ofsalivary duct carcinoma as the most common (19 cases), andthen adenocarcinoma (6 cases), poorly differentiated carcinoma(5 cases), undifferentiated carcinoma (4 cases), squamous cellcarcinoma (3 cases), and epidermoid carcinoma (1 case). Focalareas of mixed differentiation were also present in 5 cases. Therehave been about 20 cases that were either not included in Gnepp’sarticle or they were reported afterward (Table 2). Epithelial-myoe-pithelial carcinoma and myoepithelial carcinoma have also beendescribed as epithelial components.2,17 The modes of metastasesare both hematogenous and lymphatic. Hematogenous metas-tases are more common to the lung, bone, and liver. Cervical andhilar lymph node metastases are also common.7,9 The initial clin-
178 Hun-Soo Kim∙Hyang Jung Cho∙Yeun-Tai Chung, et al.
Source, year Age/Sex Type of carcinoma Type of sarcoma Location
Stephen, 19867 12 cases review Included in Gnepp’s articleGarner, 198915 57/F Adenocarcinoma Chondrosarcoma, osteosarcoma Parotid gland
Table 2. True malignant mixed tumors (carcinosarcomas) of the salivary glands: a review of the literature
ical manifestations include slow growth of the tumors over sever-al years, followed by sudden rapid growth; these carcinosarcomasare most often associated with benign mixed tumor.10 Althoughour case showed no evidence of residue benign pleomorphic ade-noma, the previous slow growing parotid mass that had beenfor over a year and a half could be the clinical evidence indicat-ing that this true malignant mixed tumor (carcinosarcoma) mayhave arisen in a preexisting pleomorphic adenoma. On the otherhand, some patients exhibit rapid growth without a previouslong-standing mass; these tumors are probably not associatedwith a previous benign mixed tumor.9,11 Fine needle aspiration(FNA) studies can be used for preoperative evaluation, but therare incidence, the great diversity of tumor cell types, the het-erogenic cytologic details and the few reports that are availablefor describing the cytologic details can limit making an accu-rate diagnosis.17 Yet the dual populations of both spindle cell andepithelial cell components can be well observed.12
The differential diagnosis of carcinosarcoma includes the sar-comatoid variant of salivary duct carcinoma, in which the epithe-lial component bears a striking resemblance to ductal carcino-ma of the breast. The immunohistochemical reactivity for cytok-eratin in the sarcomatous regions can be helpful, but not always,for making the diagnosis of sarcomatoid salivary duct carcino-ma.15 Synovial sarcoma will show immunohistochemical pro-files similar to carcinosarcoma. Tightly interlacing fascicles ofuniform spindle cells and gland-like structures are more char-acteristic of synovial sarcoma than carcinosarcoma, and the lat-ter is more pleomorphic, with less integrated carcinomatous andsarcomatous tissues.1 Collision tumors or metastatic disease shouldalways be excluded when making a diagnosis of malignant mix-ed tumor.8 In summary, we report here on a case of true malig-nant mixed tumor (carcinosarcoma) of the parotid gland, whichwas uncertain as to whether it was primary or secondary, and thetumor had features of small cell carcinoma as the carcinomacomponent. The patient did not receive any kind of adjuvantchemo or radiation therapy. She is currently free of disease withno evidence of recurrence or metastasis after 3 months of closefollow-up.
REFERENCES
1. Gnepp DR. Malignant mixed tumors of the salivary glands: a review.
Pathol Ann 1993; 28: 279-328.
2. Owaki S, Kitano H, Hanada M, et al. Carcinosarcoma of the sub-
mandibular gland: an autopsy case. Auris Nasus Larynx 2003; 30: