Capturing the Lived Experience - WHO’s International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health Melissa Selb ICF Research Branch Coordinator
Capturing the Lived Experience -WHO’s International Classification of
Functioning, Disability and Health
Melissa SelbICF Research Branch Coordinator
This talk will…
• briefly introduce the ICF
• show real-life examples of ICF application
• informed you about the role of the ICF in the ICD-11 revision process
• give you insight into future developments related to the ICF
2
ICF Research Branch
Jerome Bickenbach
Judith HollenwegerAlarcos Cieza
Gerold Stucki
Cooperation partner within the WHO Family of International Classifications (WHO-FIC)
Collaborating Centre in Germany (at DIMDI)
Melissa Selb
3
Bio-psycho-social model of functioning and disability
Grandma Smith is living with rheumatoid arthritis
Def.: Rheumatoid arthritis:
“Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic, systematic inflammatory disorder that may affect many tissues and organs, but principally attacks the joints producing an inflammatory synovitis that often progresses to destruction of the articular cartilage and ankylosis of the joints.”
The lived experience
Grandma Smith is living with rheumatoid arthritis
However:What are Grandma Smith’s problems and needs in relation to her experience living with rheumatoid arthritis ?
The lived experience
(ICD: M05)
Bio-psycho-social model of functioning and disability
Inflammatory polyarthropathies(M05-M14) M05 Seropositive rheumatoid arthritisExcludes: rheumatic fever ( I00 )
rheumatoid arthritis (of): · juvenile ( M08.- ) · spine ( M45 ) M05.0 Felty's syndrome
Rheumatoid arthritis with splenoadenomegalyand
leukopeniaM05.1+ Rheumatoid lung disease ( J99.0* ) M05.2 Rheumatoid vasculitisM05.3+ Rheumatoid arthritis with involvement of other organs and systems
Rheumatoid: · carditis ( I52.8* ) · endocarditis ( I39.-* ) · myocarditis ( I41.8* ) · myopathy ( G73.7* ) · pericarditis ( I32.8* ) · polyneuropathy ( G63.6* )
M05.8 Other seropositive rheumatoid arthritisM05.9 Seropositive rheumatoid arthritis, unspecified
Diagnosis is not enough…
Same health condition, Different experiences
6
Functioning and disability is reflected in terms of…
Body Structures
Activities
Participation
Joints
Manipulating objects
Taking care of others
Body FunctionsMobility and stability of joints
…in interaction with the environment
Pain medicationHealth servicesSupport and relationships
Bio-psycho-social model of functioning and disability
Multi-dimensional approach to describe human functioning and disability and is a framework to organize information on the lived experience of a person with health condition.
Health condition
Environmental factors Personal factors
Body functions/ Body structures
Activities Participation
Bio-psycho-social model of functioning and disability
8
Body functions and structures
Activities & ParticipationFunctioning
Bio-psycho-social model of functioning and disability
ImpairedBody functions and structures
LimitedActivities
& RestrictedParticipation
Disability
Bio-psycho-social model of functioning and disability
ICF moves away from seeing disability as soley a consequence of disease
Disability = Consequences of disease
Health condition
Medical model
Health condition
Environmental factors Personal factors
Body functions/ Body structures
Activities Participation
Bio-Psycho-Social model of the ICF
to a result of the dynamic interaction between components of health
Bio-psycho-social model of functioning and disability
11
ImpairedBody functions and structures
LimitedActivities
& RestrictedParticipation
Person‘sexperience of disability in
relation to thebody
Person‘sexperience of disability in
relation to theenvironment
Bio-psycho-social model of functioning and disability
Medication
Joint pain
Health condition
Environmental factors
Personal factors
Body functions/ Body structures Activities Participation
There is a dynamic interaction between the entities: Changes in one entity have the potential to modify one or more of the other entities.
Rheumatoid arthritis, ICD M05
Buttoning coat; Taking care of granddaughter
Bio-psycho-social model of functioning and disability
13
Health condition
Environmental factors Personal factors
Body functions/ Body structures
Activities Participation
493 384
253
310
0
1424 ICF categories are grouped into the components
No personal actors yet!
classified within ICD
Body functions
Body structures
Activites & participation
Environmental factors
The structure and codes of the ICF
14
Health condition
Environmental factors Personal factors
Body functions/ Body structures
Activities Participation
1685 categories
• Derived from the ICF• Designed to describe the characteristics of the developing
child and influence of his/her environment.
ICF - Children and Youth Version
Children &YouthVersion
261 categories more than the ICF
15
• Same organisation and structure as the ICF
• Includes all the codes of the ICF
• Modified descriptions
• New codes
• Modified inclusion and exclusion criteria
• Expanded rating scale (qualifiers) to indicate that impairments may take form of delays or lags in emergence of functions, activities/participation
Children &YouthVersion
WHO, 2007
ICF - Children and Youth Version
Kostanjsek N. Use of The International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) as a conceptual framework and common language for disability statistics and health information systems. BMC Public Health. 2011; 11(Suppl 4): S3.
16
Assigned new contentb1470 Psychomotor controlb1471 Quality of psychomotor functionsb1472 Organization of psychomotor functions
b1473 Manual dominanceDevelopment and preference in hand use.b1474 Lateral dominanceDevelopment and preference of eye, and limb use.
Examples differences ICF and ICF-CY
Modified and expanded descriptionsb147 Psychomotor functionsSpecific mental functions of control over both motor and psychologicalevents at the body level.
Modified and expanded descriptionsb147 Psychomotor functionsMental functions that regulate the speed of behaviour or response timethat involves both motor and psychological components, such as indisruption of control producing psychomotor retardation (moving andspeaking slowly; decrease in gesturing and spontaneity) or psychomotorexcitement (excessive behavioural and cognitive activity, usuallynonproductive and often in response to inner tension as in toe-tapping,hand-wringing, agitation, or restlessness.)
17
Modified inclusion and exclusion criteriab147 Psychomotor functionsInclusions: functions of psychomotor control, such as psychomotorretardation, excitement and agitation, posturing, catatonia, negativism,ambitendency, echopraxia and echolalia; quality of psychomotor functionExclusions: consciousness functions (b110); orientation functions (b114);intellectual functions (b117); energy and drive functions (b130); attentionfunctions (b140); mental functions of language (b167); mental functionsof sequencing complex movements (b176)
Examples differences ICF and ICF-CY
Expanding qualifiers Added “During childhood and adolescence, impairments may also take the form of delays or lags in the emergence of body functions during development”.
Modified inclusion and exclusion criteriab147 Psychomotor functionsInclusions: manual and lateral dominance functions of psychomotor control, suchas in psychomotor delay, excitement and agitation, posturing, stereotypes, motor perseveration, catatonia, negativism, ambitendency, echopraxia and echolalia; quality of psychomotor function.Exclusions: consciousness functions (b110); orientation functions (b114); intellectual functions (b117); energy and drive functions (b130); attention functions (b140); basic cognitive functions (b163); mental functions of language (b167); clumsiness (b760)
18
Merger ICF and ICF-CY
WHO plans to merge the ICF and ICF-CY further enhancing the ICF’s relevance for the population at ALL ages
No date set yet
19
The different health professionals speak their own language in relation to
Functioning
Actual situation ….
Development of ICF Core Sets
Ψ diagnosisΨ Interventions
Ψdocumentation
__________
__________
__________
Physician‘ diagnosis Physician Interventions
Physician documentation
____________
____________
____________
Nurses‘ diagnosisNursing Interventions
Nursing documentation
___________
___________
___________
OT diagnosis OT Interventions
OTdocumentation
____________
____________
____________
PT diagnosisPT Interventions
PTdocumentation
____________
____________
____________
Patient
Development of ICF Core Sets
Actual situation ….
Ψ diagnosisΨ Interventions
Ψdocumentation
__________
__________
__________
Physician‘ diagnosis Physician Interventions
Physician documentation
____________
____________
____________
Nurses‘ diagnosisNursing Interventions
Nursing documentation
___________
___________
___________
OT diagnosis OT Interventions
OTdocumentation
____________
____________
____________
PT diagnosisPT Interventions
PTdocumentation
____________
____________
____________
Patient
Development of ICF Core Sets
Aim and vision….
ICF__________
__________
__________
ICD-10
Health Condition(disease, trauma)
Environmental Factors
Personal Factors
ActivitiesBody FunctionsBody Structures Participation
Introduction to the ICF
493310
384
253
Over 1400 ICF categories
Development of ICF Core Sets
Development of ICF Core SetsICF Research Branch in cooperation with the
WHO-FIC Collaborating Centre in Germany (at DIMDI) Swiss Paraplegic Research
Ludwig-Maximilians-University
WHOClassifications, Terminology and Standards Team
Partner-Organizations
Development of ICF Core Sets
Development of ICF Core Sets
Development of ICF Core Sets
s110s120s130s430s510s710… b110b114b117b130b152b144b730...d110d240d410d415d520d630d920…e110e115e120e125e130e150…
s110s430s710b110b130b152b730d240d410d415d920e110e120e130
Health condition-, setting- and situation-specific, Minimal Generic Set
ComprehensiveICF Core Sets
Brief ICF Core Sets
Over 1400 categories
28
Health sector
• Settings in which a comprehensive multidisciplinary description and assessment of functioning is necessary (e.g. rehabilitation)
Comprehensive ICF Core Set for a specific health condition or setting or situation
Brief ICF Core Set for a specific health condition or setting or situation
• Settings in which a brief description and assessment of functioning issufficient (e.g. primary care)
• clinical & epidemiological studies / research
• reporting of disability and other variables of functioning; population studies
Development of ICF Core Sets
b152 Emotional functionsb265 Touch functionb270 Sensory functions related to temperature and other stimulib280 Sensation of painb710 Mobility of joint functionsb715 Stability of joint functionsb730 Muscle power functionsb760 Control of voluntary movement functionsb810 Protective functions of the skinb740 Muscle endurance functionsb780 Sensations related to muscles and movement functionsb820 Repair functions of the skinb860 Function of nails
ComprehensiveICF Core Set
Hand conditions (Excerpt) – Body Functions
Brief ICF Core Set
Development of ICF Core Sets
d230 Carrying out daily routine d430 Lifting and carrying objects d440 Fine hand use d445 Hand and arm use d5 Self-care d6 Domestic life d7 Interpersonal interactions and relationships d840 - d859 Work and employmentd170 Writingd360 Using communication devices and techniquesd4400 Picking upd4401 Graspingd4403 Releasingd4408 Fine hand use, other specified
Development of ICF Core Sets
Hand conditions (Excerpt) – Activities and Participation
Brief ICF Core Set
ComprehensiveICF Core Set
Acute inflammatory arthritis Ankylosing spondylitis Low back pain Obstructive pulmonary diseases Osteoarthritis Osteoporosis Rheumatoid arthritis Chronic widespread pain Breast cancer Head and neck cancer Depression Bipolar disorders Chronic ischemic heart disease Diabetes Obesity Stroke Hand conditions Multiple sclerosis Traumatic brain injury
Available ICF Core Sets
Development of ICF Core Sets
Spinal cord injury in post-acuteand long-term care
Sleep disorders Inflammatory bowel diseases Hearing Loss Vertigo Children/youth with Cerebral Palsy Cardiopulmonary, muskuloskeletal
and neurological conditions in acute and post-acute setting including for geriatrics
Vocational rehabilitation
Current developmentsLower limb amputees, Autism spectrum, Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), Schizophrenia
Where to find existing ICF Core Sets
33
Generic Set and Disability Set
ICF Generic Set (N=7) Mobility d450 Walking
d455 Moving around Pain and Discomfort b280 Sensation of pain Sleep and Energy b130 Energy and drive functions Affect b152 Emotional functions
d230 Carrying out daily routine d850 Remunerative employment
Disability Set - the Generic Set to be added (N=15) Mobility b455 Exercise tolerance functions
b710 Mobility of joint functions b730 Muscle power functions d470 Using transportation
Self Care d510 Washing oneself d540 Dressing d570 Looking after one’s health
Interpersonal Activities d710 Basic interpersonal interactions d920 Recreation and leisure
Sleep and Energy b134 Sleep functions
b640 Sexual functions d770 Intimate relationships d240 Handling stress and other psychological demands d640 Doing housework d660 Assisting others
Should always be used when applying other ICF Core Sets !
Environmental Factors – can be added to Disability Set (N=10) e110 Products or substances for personal consumption e120 Products and technology for personal indoor and outdoor mobility and transportation e135 Products and technology for employment e150 Design, construction and building products and technology of buildings for public use e155 Design, construction and building products and technology of buildings for private use e225 Climate e310 Immediate family e320 Friends e450 Individual attitudes of health professionals e580 Health services, systems and policies
Environmental Factors for Disability Set
Real-life application of the ICF
Melissa SelbICF Research Branch Coordinator
VIRK Vocational Rehabilitation Fund
The ICF domains
Smári PálssonMargrét Theoodórsdóttir
Main features in the work of ability assessment
Re-assessmentSpecial AssessmentBasic Assessment
ICF in Finland - HUS
Outpatient Clinic for Spinal Cord Injury, Helsinki University Central Hospital (HUS)
• Started in August 2013
• Assessment Sheets similar to Rehab Basel concept based on a modified version of the Brief ICF Core Set for Spinal Cord Injury
• Useful for patient discussion and inter-professional work
• Positive resonance from patient and health professional
• Takes 20-30 min. (1st outpatient visit)
• Plan to put in electronic records format
44
ICF in Finland - HUS
45
ICF in Finland - HUS
46
Assessing functioning status and working capability
VAT Valmennuksen arvioinnin tuki
Tool for describing (defining) the goals and effects of work counselling or assessing working capacity
C: Tuomas Leinonen
Aims of VAT
• Describe the strengths and disabilities of the customersfunctioning status / working capability in a familiar working environment
• Facilitate the decision-making of multidisciplinary teams
• Provide support for feedback discussions between customers and rehabilitation staff
• Helps to optimize rehabilitation interventions
• Provide evidence on the impact of rehabilitation
C: Tuomas Leinonen
More information on the VAT system, and its practical applications can be acquired from:
Tuomas [email protected]
+35850 5210 964http://www.kumppaniksi.fi/load/VATinfoE.pdf
ICF in the ICD-11 Revision processFunctioning properties are part of the ICD content model used as the framework for the 11th revision of the ICD. Functioning properties is a set of ICF categories that describe functioning associated with ICD disease entities.
Diagnosis + Functioning a broader and more meaningful picture of the health of persons and populations can be used for a range of decision-making purposes
ICD-11 Revision
52
ICD-11 Beta Browser
http://apps.who.int/classifications/icd11/browse/f/en
53
Functioning Topic Advisory Group (fTAG)
Purpose: To support WHO in the linking of ICD and ICF in the context of the development of ICD-11.
Tasks:
•Populate functioning properties (FP)
•Identify mirror coding i.e. the conceptual and terminological overlaps between disease entities in the ICD-11 with the ICF
•Develop use cases for ICD-ICF joint use
•Exploring possible structural and content revisions to the Z-codes
54
ICD-11 Revision
55
Publications
Assessing the impact of musculoskeletal health conditions using the ICF.
Kostanjsek N, Escorpizo R, Boonen A, Walsh N, Üstün TB, Stucki G. Disability and Rehabilitation. 2011; 33(13–14): 1281–1297.
Assessing the impact of health conditions using the ICF.
Kostanjsek N, Rubinelli S, Escorpizo R, Cieza A, Kennedy C, Selb M, Stucki G, Üstün TB. Disability and Rehabilitation. 2011; 33(15-16): 1475-1482.
56
Publications
57
Rehab.-relevant Health Conditions
58
Guidance Document
59
Thank you for your attention!
QUESTIONS?