This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1. Emotional Biases of Investors By M.Yasodhai
2. Can Binjing be the next Warren Buffet?? Lets see
3. Mr.Binjing: A highly ambitious man 45 yr IT professional,
survived by his wife and 2 boys Recently, he was rewarded bonus and
modest hike in his salary . Since then he bought a 5 bed room flat
,a sudden jump from a 2 bedroom flat with a huge EMI per month
which leaves no room for saving. His two children will enter into
college in 4 years time,he assumes by that time he will get a
salary hike and a similiar bonus too. ..is he emotionally
biased
4. Examples of lack of self control: Enrollment in Gym and
never turning up Obese people fail to cut back on food consumption
Smokers continue to smoke even though aware of long term health
risks When ample of things to be done ,but still wasting time in FB
,whatsapp etc People may know they need to save for retirement, but
they have difficulty sacrificing present consumption because of a
lack of self control on current spending From Behavioral Finance
jargon he has be diagnosed with . Self control Bias : He has a
strong desire to consume today, which can be counterproductive to
attain his long term financial goal.
5. Despite a net worth measured in $$$billions, Warren Buffett
earns a base salary of $100,000 a year at Berkshire Hathaway. It's
a salary that has not changed in 25 years. A man of simple tastes,
Buffett easily supports his modest standard of living with this
salary. He lives in the same five- bedroom house in Omaha that he
bought in 1958 for $31,500. .this is Mr.Buffett
6. Emotions in advertisements.
7. Other habits of Binjing.. His favorite pastime is stock
investment, calls himself as a long term investor like Mr.Buffett .
he watches his portfolio of stocks daily and keeps readujsting
according to the latest hot recommendation available on TV ,but
then At times, his positions shows below his cost price but still
waits for his shares to breakeven ,even if he knows that some of
the companies which he holds is experiencing permanent difficulties
,he assures himself that miracle happens everyday and some day
those companies will be hale and healthy. Now What.
8. ....he has been diagnosed with Loss aversion Bias: The pain
of loss is far greater than the enjoyment of a gain. Holding loss
positon longer than justified by fundamental analysis and selling
winner too quickly . makes investors unduly conservative eg:
holding 30 to 40% in bonds where the time horizon is deacades
Sitting on huge losses and not admitting making mistake on stock
selection ,but if dont sell a mistake ,you are potentially giving
up a gain that could be earned by reinvesting smartly. Regret
Aversion (Herding Behaviour): to avoid regretting latter they buy
the popular opinion and tell themselves they are not to blame if
others are wrong too.
9. What Buffett has to say. He says ..Investors dont need
extraordinary intelligence, but they do need to be able to watch
their holdings halve in value without becoming panic-stricken, if
the holdings has sound fundamental analysis. When stock markets
crashed on Black Monday in 1987, Berkshires share price suffered
its biggest-ever one-day fall, plunging 18 per cent and denting
Buffetts fortune by an estimated $347 million. Buffett shrugs off
these paper losses; in his 1987 annual letter, he did not even
refer to Black Monday. This approach has served him well, with
Berkshires share price soaring from $2,675 in 1987 to last
Decembers all-time high of $229,000.
10. Any other biases?? His friend who works for a Bio tech firm
sometime back told him about his firms breakthrough in a new
technology which is in a development stage and very much confident
of its success Binjing assumes his friend must have vast knowledge
of his company since he is a long term employee and buys the shares
of this firm without a second thought. Also , Binjing believe he
has a superior ability to beat the market most of the time . Yet
again, Binjing has been possessing . Over confidence bias: He
thinks his friend knows everything about the current situation of
that Bio tech company and he fallaciously equate the quantity with
quality of information .He is underestimating risks involved and
overestimate expected returns. Beleiving they can pick stocks that
will deliver superior future performance without any supporting
evidence .
11. This is Warren Buffett Buffett adamantly restricts himself
to his "circle of competence" - businesses he can understand and
analyze. As Hagstrom writes, investment success is not a matter of
how much you know but rather how realistically you define what you
don't know. Buffett considers this deep understanding of the
operating business to be a prerequisite for a viable forecast of
future business performance. After all, if you don't understand the
business, how can you project performance? Buffett's business
tenets each support the goal of producing a robust projection.
First, analyze the business, not the market or the economy or
investor sentiment. Next, look for a consistent operating history.
Finally, use that data to ascertain whether the business has
favorable long-term prospects.
12. what can be done Perform post-investment analysis on both
successful and unsuccessful investment. Was the investment bought
at a particular advantageous time based on fundamentals or was a
luck during market upswing. Errors made during time to sell or was
the market going through a correction. During unprofitable
decisions, look for common mistakes which the person was unaware of
making
13. OMG!!! Binjing possess Endowment bias too.. He inherited
large number of securities when his Uncle died 5 years back Now the
company crossed its high speed of growth and in declining phase and
some gossips about the management involvement in fraudulent
activities so the share prices now only represent 8 times its cost
price and 2 years back shares touched its life time high ( i.e
almost 20 times the cost price ) . He is still reluctant to sell
his shares because he fear that the position will increase in value
someday and may regret having sold it.
14. Endowment Bias: Where people value an asset more when they
hold rights to it than they do not. Binjing must know the purpose
of the holding the inherited security ,was that on the basis of
fundamental analysis or being emotional with the security. When
financial goal are in jeopardy ,emotional attachment must be
moderated. Buffett contends that the key to overcoming emotions is
being able to retain your belief in the real fundamentals of the
business, and don't get too concerned about the stock market. More
than anything, investors' own emotions can be their worst
enemy.
15. One fine day he realizes, that he is no where near to his
LT goal and the only thing which he has common with Buffett is his
recently bought 5 bed room home . So what is hindering him from
becoming the next Warren Buffet : Self control Bias Loss Aversion
Bias Regret Aversion Bias Overconfidence Bias Endowment Bias
16. So how can we help Mr.Binjing . Its difficult to make him
the next Buffett but we can definetly save him from going bankrupt
(if this situations continues) ,by educating him on his emotional
biases. The more we are aware of the emotions we posses towards the
investment/finances ,we can limit the poor investment choices to
manifold. We must ask him to define his long term and short term
goals in quantitative terms rather that qualitatively and it has to
reconcile with his risk tolerance . In term of investment time
horizon he has three stages ,first stage is 4 years where his both
sons will be entering college and his second stage is till his
retirement .Third stage is retirement period. He need to decide
what is the retirement amount he wants in his retirement portfolio
to have in 15 years time and it depends on the how much he would
save during his working period.
17. Failing to plan is planning to failplan before its too
late