8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
1/38
1
Pengobatan komplementer danalternatif (Complementary and
Alternative Medicine)
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
2/38
2
Sasaran belajar
Mampu mendefinisikan pengobatan
komplementer dan alternatif
(PKA)/{complementary and alternativemedicine (CAM)} dalam hubungannya
dengan pengobatan konvensional
Mampu mereview penemuan danpenelitian mutakhir tentang PKA/CAM
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
3/38
3
Sasaran belajar
Mampu berkomunikasi dan menasihatkan
pasien tentang PKA/CAM baik evidence-based research maupun patient values
and preferences.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
4/38
4
Definisi PKA/CAM Setiap tindakan baik yang tidak diajarkan di fakultas
kedokteran maupun tidak tersedia di rumah sakit(Interventions neither taught in medical school, norgenerally available in hospital) (1)
Pengobatan yang berada diluar model biomedisBarat tentang penyakit, diagnosis dan pengobatan(healing therapies that typically fall outside theWestern biomedical model of disease, diagnosis,
and treatment) (2)
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
5/38
5
Definisi PKA/CAM
The World Health Organisation : "all
forms of health care which usually lie
outside the official health sector (3)
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
6/38
6
Apakah pengobatankomplementer berbeda dengan
pengobatan alternatif ? Ya (4)
PK digunakan bersama pengobatan
konvensional. Misal aromatherapy untukmengurangi rasa tidak enak pasien setelah operasi
PA digunakan untuk menggantikan pengobatan
konvensional, misal diet khusus unuk pengobatankanker dan bukan pembedahan radiasi atau
kemoterapi
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
7/38
7
Apakah kedokteran integrasi(integrative medicine)?
Integrative medicine combines treatments
from conventional medicine and CAM forwhich there is some high-quality evidence
of safety and effectiveness.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
8/38
8
Lima tipe mayor dari PKA (4) Whole Medical Systems,traditional Chinese
medicine, homeopathy, naturopathy, botanical,acupuncture, moxibustion and Ayurveda
Mind-body interventions, meditation, prayer,mental healing, art, music, or dance.
Biologically-based treatments substancesfound in nature, herbs, foods, and vitamins. Some
examples dietary supplements, herbal products,unproven therapies (shark cartilage to treatcancer),lifestyle (exercise,relaxation).
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
9/38
9
Tipe mayor dari PAK Manipulative and body-based methods
manipulation and/or movement of one ormore parts of the body, chiropractic orosteopathic, and massage.
Energy therapies two types: i) Biofieldtherapiesqi gong, Reiki, and TherapeuticTouch, ii) Bioelectromagnetic-based
therapies, pulsed fields, magnetic fields, oralternating-current or direct-current fields.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
10/38
10
Jenis PKA di masyarakatAcupuncture Imagery
Aromatherapy Magnets
Biofeedback Massage
Chiropractic Prayer
Diets ReflexologyExercise Relaxation
Folk remedies Self-help/support groups
Herbal/botanical therapy Spiritual healing (by others)
Homeopathy Vitamins
Hypnosis Yoga
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
11/38
11
Siapa pengguna PKA?
1997, 47% penduduk US menggunakan PAK(5)
2002, 75%of U.S. adults reported use of
CAM in lifetime and 62%in past 12 months(when prayer included) (6)
Survei Sosial Ekonomi Nasional tahun 2001,
31,7% menggunakan obat tradisional, dan
9,8% pengobatan tradisional (7)
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
12/38
12
Mengapa masayarakatmenggunakan PKA ?
WHO 80% masyarakat menggunakan PKA
Desire for health and wellness
Prevention Cancer- recent estimate 83% (8)
Pain : -Musculoskeletal pain
Back and neck pain
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
13/38
13
Why do people use CAM?
Desire for health and wellness (1)
Prevention
Cancer- recent estimate 83% (2)
Pain
Musculoskeletal pain
Back and neck pain
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
14/38
14
What do CAM users want?
Empowerment in medical interactions
Chance to share their own views about healthand healing
Health provider who will spend time with them
Someone who will answer their questions
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
15/38
15
Evidence-based Medicine (EBM)and CAM
EBM aims to integrate
best research evidence clinical expertise
patient values
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
16/38
16
EBM and CAM
While some scientific evidence exists
regarding some CAM therapies, for most
there are key questionsthat are yet to be
answered through well-designed scientific
studiesquestions such as whether they are
safe and whether they workfor the diseasesor medical conditions for which they are used.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
17/38
17
Where does this leave us?
CAM interventions generally
are low cost
are low risk
are free of serious side effects
AND
are widely used.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
18/38
18
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
19/38
19
CAM: evidence and research
Glucosamine/Chondroitin Arthritis
Echinacea for the Prevention and
Treatment of Colds
St John's wort) in major depressive disorder
Acupuncture for Osteoarthritis
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
20/38
20
Glucosamine/Chondroitin Arthritis
Intervention Trial (GAIT) Study Results(9)
Supplement combination of glucosamine
plus chondroitin sulfate did not provide
significant relief from osteoarthritis painamong all participants.
However, a smaller study participants with
moderate-to-severe pain showed significantrelief with the combined supplements.
CAM: evidence and research
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
21/38
21
CAM: evidence and research Echinacea for the Prevention and Treatment of
Colds in Adults: Research Results and
Implications for Future Studies (10)
437 healthy adult volunteers were assigned at random
to receive one of the three E. angustifoliapreparationsor a placebo. They received in two phases: a
"prophylaxis" and a treatment phase. The prophylaxis
phase lasted 7 days. On the 7 day, the already treated
subjects were exposed to a nasal spray containing avirus that induces signs and symptoms of a cold in
about 2 days.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
22/38
22
CAM: evidence and research Volunteers were isolated for 5 days, tested them,
appearance and severity of cold signs and
symptoms
None of the three preparations of E. angustifoliaat
the 900 mg per day dose had significant effects onthe severity or duration of symptoms among those
who developed colds. However, critics of this study
believe the dose of E. angustifoliaused was too
low.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
23/38
23
CAM: evidence and research Effect of Hypericum perforatum (St John's wort) in
major depressive disorder: a randomized controlledtrial. (11)
OBJECTIVE: To test the efficacy and safety of awell-characterized H perforatum extract (LI-160) in
major depressive disorder.
DESIGN AND SETTING: Double-blind,randomized, placebo-controlled trial conducted in12 academic and community psychiatric researchclinics in the United States.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
24/38
24
CAM: evidence and research PARTICIPANTS: Adult outpatients (n = 340)
recruited with major depression and a baselinetotal score on the Hamilton Depression Scale(HAM-D) of at least 20.
CONCLUSION: This study fails support theefficacy of H perforatum in moderately severemajor depression. The result may be due to lowassay sensitivity of the trial, but the completeabsence of trends suggestive of efficacy for H
perforatum is noteworthy (perlu diperhatikan).
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
25/38
25
CAM: evidence and research
Acupuncture for peripheral joint osteoarthritis Asystematic review and meta-analysis (12)
Objective. To evaluate the evidence for the
effectiveness of acupuncture in peripheral joint
osteoarthritis (OA). Methods. Systematic searches were conducted on
Medline, Embase, AMED, Cochrane Library,
CINAHL, British Nursing Index, PsychINFO and
CAMPAIN
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
26/38
26
CAM: evidence and research
Results. Thirty-one possibly relevant studies wereidentified and 18 RCTs were included.
Conclusions. Sham (pura-pura)-controlled RCTs
suggest effects of acupuncture for pain control in
patients with peripheral joint OA. Considering itsfavourable safety profile acupuncture seems an
option worthy of consideration particularly for knee
OA.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
27/38
27
What about communication?
Between 40 and 70% of CAM users do notdisc losetheir use to their physician.
WHY?
Patients usually say that they do not report
because they are not asked.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
28/38
28
Why does this matter?
The substantial overlap between use ofprescription medications and herbal
supplements raises concerns about unintended
interactions.
Patient use of CAM is often a clue to values
and preferencesthat need to be
acknowledged.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
29/38
29
How can we communicate?
1. Always ask!What else are you doing for yourhealth?
2. Be open and nonjudgmental.
3. Consider patient preferences and values.
4. Be honestabout your lack of knowledge
5. Sadar adanya efek samping & kontraindikasi
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
30/38
30
Efek samping/kontraindikasi (13)
Echinacea : autoimmune rseponse, tidak bolehdiberikan AIDS, TBC, multiple sclerosis
St Johns wort : efek samping fotosensitif akibat
komponen hipericin
Ginkgo biloba ; efek inhibitor on platelet-activatingfactor, avoid pasien bleeding disorders,
thrombocytopenia, bilateral subdural hematoma
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
31/38
31
Daftar Pustaka
1. Eisenberg DM, Kessler RC, Foster C.
Unconventional medicine in the United States :
prevalence, cost and patterns of use. N Engl J
Med 1993;328:246-52.
2. Drivdahl CE, Miser WF: The use of alternative
healthcare by a family practice population. J
Am Board Fam Prac1998, 11:193-9.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
32/38
32
Daftar Pustaka
3. Gureje O, Von Korff M, Gregory SE, Richard G.
Persistent pain well-being. A World Health
Organization study in primary care. JAMA1998,280:147-51.
4. National Center for Complementary and Alternative
Medicine (NCCAM). What Is CAM? Available at :
http://nccam.nih.gov/health/whatiscam/. AccessedNovember 22, 2007.
http://nccam.nih.gov/health/whatiscam/http://nccam.nih.gov/health/whatiscam/8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
33/38
33
Daftar Pustaka
5. Eisenberg DM, Davies RF, Ettnier SL. Trends in
alternative medicine uses in the United States
1990-97. JAMA 1998;280:1569-75.6. Barnes P, Powell-Griner E, McFann K, Nahin R.
CDC Advance Data Report #343. Complementary
and Alternative Medicine Use Among Adults:
United States, 2002.Atlanta, 2004.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
34/38
34
Daftar Pustaka
7. Departemen Kesehatan R.I. Wajib Daftar bagiPengobatan Tradisional. Available at :http://www.depkes.go.id/index.php?option=news&task=viewarticle&sid=434. Accessed
November,22,20078. National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). The Use ofComplementary and Alternative Medicine in the
United States. Available at :http://nccam.nih.gov/health/whatiscam/.
Accessed November 22, 2007
http://www.depkes.go.id/index.php?option=news&task=viewarticle&sid=434http://www.depkes.go.id/index.php?option=news&task=viewarticle&sid=434http://nccam.nih.gov/health/whatiscam/http://nccam.nih.gov/health/whatiscam/http://www.depkes.go.id/index.php?option=news&task=viewarticle&sid=434http://www.depkes.go.id/index.php?option=news&task=viewarticle&sid=4348/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
35/38
35
Daftar Pustaka
9. Clegg DO, Reda DJ , Harris CL, Klein MA, O'DellJR, Hooper MM. Glucosamine, chondroitin sulfate,
and the two in combination for painful knee
osteoarthritis. N Engl J Med 2006;354:795-808.
10. Turner RB, Bauer R, Woelkart K, Hulsey TC,Gangemi JD. An evaluation of Echinacea
angustifolia in experimental rhinovirus infections.
N Engl J Med 2005; 353: 341-8.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
36/38
36
Daftar Pustaka
11. Hypericum Depression Trial Study Group.Effect of Hypericum perforatum (St John's wort)
in major depressive disorder: a randomized
controlled trial. JAMA 2002;10:1807-14.
12. Kwon YD, Pittler MH, Ernst E. Acupuncture forperipheral joint osteoarthritis : a systematic
review and meta-analysis. Rheumatology
2006;45:13317.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
37/38
37
Daftar Pustaka
13. Silverstein DD, Spiegel AD. Are physicians
aware of the risks of alternative medicine? J Com
Health 2001; 26 :159-74.
8/11/2019 CAM PAK 11-6-2014 Prof Adi Hidayat
38/38
38