CAD APPLICATIONS [MAE 577] FINAL PROJECT: Design and Analysis of Pneumatic Welding Fixture By: Sidhant Sharma Date: 12/15/2010
Nov 22, 2014
By: Sidhant Sharma
Date: 12/15/2010
Agenda Introduction Automation Basic Terminologies Product and System Description Problem Description Reasons for choosing the problem Design goals Survey Alternative designs Analysis Problems faced Webpage
Introduction Automation Basic termin0logies
Automation Automation is the use of control systems and information technologies to reduce the need for human work in industry Mechanization on the other hand is the aid of machinery to assist humans with the muscular requirements of work Need for Automationy Higher production rates y Increase in accuracy y Replacing human operators in hard physical, monotonous or dangerous
work y Performing tasks beyond human capabilities of size, weight, speed, endurance, etc. y Economy improvement
Common types of Automation Electrical Hydraulic Pneumatic
fast, reliable, precise but expensive high forces possible but prone to leakage cheap, small but slow in operation and provides low force
Combined systems y Electro-hydraulic y Hydro-pneumatic y Electro-pneumatic
Basic terminologies Welding A fabrication process that joins materials, usually metals or thermoplastics, by causing coalescence. Eg. gas welding, resistance welding, friction welding, laserbeam welding, etc. Fixture A device which locates and secures a workpiece during a machining operation y y y y y
Features of a fixture Location system Clamping system Control system Foolproofing and asymmetry Weight and Handling
Product and system description
Product and System description A Safe (also called strongbox) is a secure lockable box used for securing valuable objects against theft or damage Two models of Defender Plus Safes from Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd. are shown below61 (height) model
26 model
Product and System description contd.. The 61 model is composed of three subassemblies1. 2. 3.
Inner body Door Outer body - Fixture is being designed for making this subassembly (shown in next slide)
1. Inner body being inserted
2. Door assembly
Problem description
Problem description : To design a pneumatic welding fixture for outer body subassembly
Left shell Right shell
Lug
3. Outer body subassembly and operations
Why is the problem worth study??y Design : Designing a fixture involves designing all of its
elements i.e location, clamping, control systemsy Motion Study: Motion study is a necessity as the fixture
involves moving elements that must move precisely so as to maintain tolerancesy Optimization: The problem breaks down into a multi-
optimization problem as we optimize the assembly sequence, process sequence, setup-time, etc.y FEA : We analyze the clamping forces and their effects on
the parts as a preventive measure
Design goalsy To design the location system y To design pneumatic clamps for the clamping system y To carry out mechanical simulation on the fixture, which
will help in fixing the location, design and geometry of clamps y To optimize the setup time on the fixture y To optimize the sequence of assembly of the outer body y To design the control electro-pneumatic circuit for the finalized motion sequence
Survey of pneumatic clamping mechanisms
Pneumatic Clamping Mechanisms
Alternative fixture designs
Design 1
Design 2
Decision making : Final DesignWeightage to factors out of 1Sr no Factors Design 1 Design 2 Selection Design 2 Design 2 Design 1 Design 2 Design 2 Design 2 Design 2 Design 1,2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Pneumatic elements no. Weight of fixture Workpiece securing Ease of welding operation Setup time Spacing for pneumatic wiring Sequence control Design of circuit
0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1
CAD Models
Horizontal toggle clampcad final project simulation videos\horizontal pneumatic toggle clamp mechanism.avi
Hold down clampcad final project simulation videos\vertical pneumatic toggle clamp mechanism simulation.avi
Final fixture assembly
Analysis and Results
Geometric AnalysisLug location system
Right shell location
Motion analysis
Piston rod displacement
Clamping rod displacement
It can be observed that 24 mm of the piston stroke is converted into 11 mm of the clamping rod movement through the toggle mechanism. Thus we can fix the clamping bar 8-10 mm away from the surface to be clamped.
Motion analysis contd..
iston rod displacement
lamping rod path trace
For 24 mm of the piston stroke the clamping point moves 55 mm horizontally and 88 mm vertically. Thus we placed it 40 mm horizontally and 20 mm below the point to be clamped.
Setup time analysis resultsSet ti e(sec) Trial sequence Trial sequence Difference 64 47 17 r cess ti e(sec) 5 98 17
cad final project simulation videos\fixture trial2.avi fixture mech simulation setup time analysis.xlsx
Clamping force and stress analysis
Horizontal clamp force
Left shell
Lug clamp force
Lug
Clamping force and stress analysis contd..
Old design of lug clamping rod
New design with reduced stress by approx. 50 %
Electro pneumatic system equivalent
Fixture mechanical system
Electro pneumatic control circuit
cad final project simulation videos\IMG_0132.MOV
Design-Analysis Optimization flow sequenceDesign of fixture elements Optimum placement using motion simulation Designing the Assembly sequence Designing the Motion sequence Setup time analysis Optimization of motion and assembly sequence Clamping force and stress analysis Design changes in clamping elements to reduce stress Final design of system Design of electro pneumatic control circuit
ChallengesThe main problems faced in the project werey Setting up the event based motion sequence in Solidworks as there was no provision for event based motion simulation in the premium version y High computation times as the simulation was upto 1 minute in certain cases Solution: The event based problem was solved by the use of independent linear motors to control the motion of each pneumatic clamp independently in the required sequence
Website demo
https://sites.google.com/site/sidhantsharmacadapplications/
ReferencesBOOKS [1] Jigs and Fixture Design by Edward Hoffman [2] Design of Jigs and Fixtures by Joshi WEBSITES [1] www.wikipedia.com [2] www.youtube.com [3] http://www.drillspot.comp
Questions??