By Ms Darawati Hussain, Chairman of Malaysian Venture Capital & Private Equity Association July 2011 WORKSHOP ON FINANCING FOR ASEAN MSME IN THE 21 ST CENTURY
Apr 01, 2015
By
Ms Darawati Hussain, Chairman of Malaysian Venture Capital & Private Equity Association
July 2011
WORKSHOP ON FINANCING FOR ASEAN MSME IN THE 21ST CENTURY
CONTENTS
2
Page
Introduction to MVCA 3
Private Equity as an Alternative Asset Class 9
Insights into PE Investing 15
The Malaysian Challenge 22
INTRODUCTION TO MVCA
OUR MISSION & OBJECTIVES To promote, develop and maintain the venture capital industry in
Malaysia as a source of equity financing for business enterprises principally for the start-up and/or development of small and medium sized enterprises.
To promote cooperation among members, encourage joint efforts and business undertakings as well as to provide a regular forum for the exchange of views amongst members and also foreign industry players and regulators.
To represent, express and give effect to the views and opinions of persons or companies engaged in the venture capital industry, including making representations to all governmental or public authorities or bodies.
To develop and encourage the highest standard of professional ethics in the venture capital industry.
4
To promote private sector’s participation in the VC/PE industry and thus, expanding the fundraising opportunities for the Fund Managers.
To develop and expand the VC/PE industry in Malaysia by increasing the number of VC/PE firms and VC/PE Funds as a supporting engine to innovation.
To develop the skills and experience of the local VC/PE companies by providing a larger funding platform and thereby, encouraging the companies to invest regionally and globally.
To increase the number of VC/PE professionals and introduce more structured human capital development programmes in Malaysia for talent development and succession for the VC/PE industry.
To support Government-backed programmes to produce quality entrepreneurs and technopreneurs
To support Government initiatives to promote Malaysia as the hub of Islamic VC/PE which will be an integral part of the strategy to turn Malaysia as the hub for global Islamic finance.
OUR TARGETS
5
INDUSTRY OVERVIEW
INDUSTRY PARTICIPANTS 2010 2009 % Change No of Registered VC Funds or Companies 58 59 -1.69% No. of Registered VCMCs 55 55 0.00% No. of Investee Companies 389 445 -12.58% SHAREHOLDING STRUCTURE 100% Local Ownership 102 104 -1.92%Joint Ventures 9 9 0.00%100% Foreign Ownership 2 1 100.00%
VENTURE CAPITAL INVESTMENTS As at Dec 2010 As at Dec 2009 % Change
Total Committed Funds Under Management RM 5.9 billion RM 5.3 billion 11.45%
Total Investment RM 3.4 billion RM2.6 billion 31.05%
Investment in Investee Companies RM 453 million RM 597 million -24.12%
Divestments RM 89 million RM 43 million 106.98%
Source: Securities Commission
6
Source: Securities Commission
INDUSTRY OVERVIEW
7
Source: Securities Commission
Number of Islamic Venture Capital Firm: 2
The number of venture capital professionals currently stands at 160 people. This number is based on professionals with at least 4 years experience in the venture capital industry.
28 venture companies were divested in 2010 compared to 21 in 2009. However, only 1 VC-backed company was listed on ACE Market of Bursa Malaysia in 2010.
INDUSTRY OVERVIEW
8
PRIVATE EQUITY AS AN ALTERNATIVE ASSET CLASS
Non-traditional/Alternative assets include:• Real estate• Private equity• Venture capital• Hedge funds• Commodities• Others, e.g. wines, antiques, art
Common features of alternative assets:• Less liquid than traditional assets• Caters to institutional or high net
worth individuals• Has mid-to-long term investment
horizons (3 years or more)
WHAT ARE ALTERNATIVE ASSETS? Traditional asset classes available to investors include equities and bonds
Alternative assets simply describes NON TRADITIONAL asset classes
Asset Classes
As
se
t C
las
se
s
Pu
bli
cP
riv
ate
Equities
Derivatives
Real Estate
Debt Securities
Cash
Fixed Income
Private Equity &Venture Capital
Others
Commodities
10
HOW A PRIVATE EQUITY & VENTURE CAPITAL FUND WORKS
INVESTORS(e.g. GLCs)
PE/VC MANAGEMENT TEAM
(e.g. CIMB PE & VC)
PE/VC FUND CO(e.g. CIMB PE
Fund 2)
100% Preference Shares
PORTFOLIO COMPANY 3
x% equity
z% equity
PORTFOLIO COMPANY 2
PORTFOLIO COMPANY 1
y% equity
11
PRIVATE EQUITY IN A BUSINESS LIFECYCLE
Expansion Stage
Early Stage/Start up
Seed Stage
Sales Growth
Late Stage IPO/MBO/MBI/LBO
Distressed situation
Mezzanine
Own funds
Angel Investors
Venture Capital
Own funds
Angel Investors
Expansion Stage
Early Stage/Start up
Late Stage IPO/MBO/MBI/LBO
Turnaround
Private Equity
PEVC
Time
Seed - For initial concept for R&D of a product
Early - For product development and initial marketing; the company may be in the process of being organised or may have been in business for a short time, but has not yet sold its product commercially
Expansion - For growth and expansion of a company that has built up a short track record; used for increasing production capacity, market/product development and/or additional working capital
Growth/Mezzanine - Financing to help a company go public/trade sale
Late Stage - Financing in form of loan/equity to enable MBOs or MBIs of an existing product/business
Turnaround - Financing to re-establish a business which has encountered some performance difficulties
12
20 Year US PE & VC Performance Benchmark
0
5
10
15
20
25
Ear
ly/S
eed
VC
Bal
ance
d V
C
Late
r S
tage
VC
All
Ven
ture
Cap
ital
Sm
all B
uyou
ts
Med
ium
Buy
outs
Larg
e B
uyou
ts
Meg
a B
uyot
us
All
Buy
outs
Gen
eral
ist
All
Priv
ate
Equ
ity
S&
P 5
00
NA
SD
AQ
Private Equity and Venture Capital Annual Returns
*Source: Thomson Reuters, through
31/3/2008
13
IRR
13
PRIVATE EQUITY AND VENTURE CAPITAL-BACKED COMPANIES
Company
Company
CompanyCompany
In the United States, Europe and Australia...
Closer to Home...
14
INSIGHTS INTO PE INVESTING
16
Extremely In-depth Investment ProcessDeal
Sourcing
PreliminaryDeal
Assessment
In-depthStrategic
Due Diligence
Accounting, Tax and
Due Diligence
Legal Documentation
Growth potential
Attractivenessof industry
Strength ofmanagement
Competition
Financials
Indicative valuation
Detailed Financial Evaluation
Tax Compliance
Contingent Liabilities
Material Contracts andAgreements
Licenses
Deal structuring
SharePurchaseAgreement / subscription agreement
Shareholders’Agreement
Others – Put/Call Option agreement etc.
Network
Monitoring / Business Plan Implementation
16
5-year businessplan and projections
Product and pricingstrategy
Marketing strategy
R&D strategy
Customers
Suppliers
Competitive strength
HighQuality DealsOnly
Business process improvement
Active participation at Board and Management level
Preferential Rights
100 25 12 5 3Numberof deals:
T = 0 T + 2 wks T + 16 wks 3 – 5 yrsTime: T + 6 wks T + 12 wks
16
INVESTMENT CRITERIA
Right Fit – Willingness to admit and work with a PE/VC Investor
Opportunities for value enhancement
Attractive margins
Relatively low cost position
Strong product or service branding
High or increasing market share
Integrity of management
Proven business model
Strong industry fundamentals
17
Common Risks Encountered by the Fund ManagerType of Risk Selected Examples
Business Risk
• Misrepresentation by the entrepreneur• Risk of misalignment of interest of the entrepreneur with passive investors• Lack of management performance• Lack of management focus• Risk of misalignment of management interest with passive investors• Product development risk (including achievement of commercial break-
even)• Technology risk• Financial risk• Operational risk (not related to management)
Liquidity Risk• Illiquid investment in private companies• No readily available secondary market
Country Risk• Change in regulation or government policy• Foreign-exchange risk
Market Risk• Interest rate risk• Global economic cotangent effect
Private equity investments aim to achieve alpha returns, by combining thorough pre-investment due diligence
with subsequent proactive participation in the business.
18
Monthly basis• Monthly performance report (including
management, operational, financial and industry performance).
Regular basis
• Review all aspects of the business and implementation of post-acquisition initiatives.
• On-site visits to ensure company’s operations and performance are in line with expectations or projections.
• Attend board and management meetings.
Quarterly basis• Report to a risk oversight committee (including
business model, competition & current position, exit strategy, risk & risk mitigation initiatives).
Post-Investment: Proactive Monitoring Initiatives
To ensure:
Alignment of Interest
Focused Efforts towardsGoals
Optimal Performance
Operational Efficiency
Corporate Governance
Transparency
1919
Post-Investment: Role at BOD and EXCO Preferential and veto rights over key decisions items such as: Replacing CEO, CFO and members of senior management Alteration to the terms of employment conditions Changes to pre-agreed business plans: including new business focus,
marketing & strategy Capital expenditure above agreed figure Property/equipment leases above set value Annual CAPEX Operating budgets Issuance & repayment of debt Dividend policy Entering or accepting contracts above pre-agreed quantum Right to conduct special audit as and when necessary
2020
2121
Pre-acquisition Post-acquisition
CAGR: >22%
CAGR: >30%
Revenue
Net Profit
Careful selection of new stores increases revenue
Business performance improvements via implementation of action plans
Operational efficiency contributed to higher net margins
• Improvements in organizational structure to ensure efficient decision making process
• Improvements in procurement procedures to obtain best prices
Case Study 1: Post Acquisition Initiatives for a F&B chain
THE MALAYSIAN CHALLENGE
WHERE WE AREGNI Per Capita 2009 US$ Thousand GDP Growth
M&A as % of GDP
Sources: Economy Watch, IMF, Bloomberg, World Bank, Malaysia Productivity Corporation
Productivity Levels, 2009 US$ Thousand Per Worker
High Income
Economies
23
GDP BY SECTOR Source: Bank Negara Malaysia
24
POPULATION BY COUNTRYSource: World Bank
25
Current Income
$7000
~$15,500
~$17,500 Average Annual
Growth of 6.5%
Middle and Lower Income
Economies
High Income Economies
2010 2020
Per Capita Income
USD
THE NEED TO GROW
26
FUNDING LANDSCAPE IN MALAYSIA
BANKING INSTITUTION’S SME LOAN APPROVAL RATE; %
FINANCING OUTSTANDING AS END-MAY 2009 (RM BILLION)
Source: Bank Negara Malaysia
27
INNOVATION MODEL
Technology Technology
Market (to be
Identified)
Market (to be
Identified)
Science (Basic
Research)
Science (Basic
Research)
Market IdentifiedMarket
Identified
Technology Grants
Technology Grants
Risk CapitalRisk CapitalMalaysia’s Strategic
Positioning and Market
Niche
Aggressively pursue market driven innovation and capture short- to-medium term opportunities for value creation
Aggressively pursue market driven innovation and capture short- to-medium term opportunities for value creation
Continue to actively support and facilitate technology driven innovation for medium to long term benefits
Continue to actively support and facilitate technology driven innovation for medium to long term benefits
Technology Technology
Science Grants
Science Grants
Risk Capital Risk Capital
10 – 15 years
3 – 5 years
3 – 5 years
Market Driven
Innovation
Technology Driven
Innovation
Source: Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation
28
(Pn) Darawati HussainChairman
(Pn) Ariza NorhalimSecretariat
Malaysian Venture Capital & Private Equity Association26-3, Medan Setia 2, Plaza Damansara, Bukit Damansara
50490 Kuala LumpurTel: 03-2096 2094Fax: 03-2095 8992
Email: [email protected]
OUR CONTACTS
29