Business Models Serdar Temiz, [email protected] ME2603 Entrepreneurship 6.0 credits Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Sep 13, 2014
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Business Models
Serdar Temiz, [email protected]
ME2603 Entrepreneurship 6.0 credits
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
About me• Master in ICT Entrepreneurship • SSES Alumni• Previously Software Developer/ Project
Manager• PhD Candidate at Indek KTH• Business/ Project developer/adviser for
private companies• www.Opensweden.net
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
This presentation
• Not about a specific business idea• About business processes• About business model innovation
• It is pretty long
• Feel free to fall asleep, interrupt or leave
• I hope you know all this already.
• If not, I really think it can give you a lot
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Why should I listen to you?• Do not listen me!
IT IS YOUR RESPONSIBILITY TO QUESTION ALL ASSUMPTIONS. MINE, YOURS, EXPERTS.
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Recap: What is Entepreneurship?
The process of coordinating resources to exploit or take advantage of opportunities that exists in the market or are created by innovation in an attempt to create value. (Brown, 1994)
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Some Questions
• Who is your customer?• What is Innovation• Why it matters
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Invention vs InnovationBusiness Plan vs Business Model
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
There are many inventions, but far fewerinnovations.An invention is a novel ideaInnovation is the commercialization of thatnovel idea
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
FORTUNE 500
• “Two thirds of the original 1955 list was gone within three decades” William Shanklin*
• The rate at which large American companies left the Fortune 500 increased four times between 1970 and 1990 a change of almost 50% from the 1999 Fortune 500 to the 2009 Fortune 500
John Micklethwait & Adrian* Wooldridge,
• *(cited in Dane Stangler and Sam Arbesman WHAT DOES FORTUNE 500 TURNOVER MEAN
)
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Turnover Rate in Fortuna 500
• Dane Stangler and Sam Arbesman WHAT DOES FORTUNE 500 TURNOVER MEAN
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Types of Innovation
1. Technology innovation2. Process innovation3. Product & service innovation4. Business Model innovation
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Process innovation
• Implementation of a new or significantly improved production or delivery method
• Ford Car Production• Dell Computers
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Product & service innovation
• Customer Support & Communication via FB– airbaltic
• Facebook itself
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Why business models matter?Joan Magretta
• Who is the customer and what does the customer value?
• How do we make money from the business?• How can we deliver value to the customer at an
appropriate cost?• Writing a new story• A better way than existing alternatives• Making the number add up• Tweaking on the fly based on feedback
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Business Model WarfareLangdon Morris
• Business mortality is high• Technology innovation by itself has rarely
been sufficient to ensure the future.• Similar products and services• Advantages resulting from a successful
business models are fleeting. Models need to be continuously reviewed and updated when necessary
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Operating Margin Growth in Excess of Competitive Peers
[Source: IBM, CEOs are expanding the innovation horizon: important implications for CIOs]
Compound annual growth rate over five years
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Benefits Cited by Business Model Innovators% of responders
Source: IBM, Global CEDO Study 2006
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
How Business Models Emerge (1 of 3)
– The value chain is the string of activities that moves a product from the raw material stage, through manufacturing and distribution, and ultimately to the end user.
• Primary activities are directly concerned with the creation or delivery of a product or service.
• Support activities help to improve the effectiveness or efficiency of primary activities
Raw Material
Value ChainPrimary & Secondary Activities +
Margin
Product / Service
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
How Business Models Emerge (2 of 3)
The Value Chain (again)
"Competitive Advan tage: Creating andSustaining superior Performance" (1985).
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
How Business Models Emerge (3 of 3)
• The Value Chain (continued)– Entrepreneurs look at the value chain of a product or a
service to pinpoint where the value chain can be made more effective or to spot where additional “value” can be added.• This type of analysis may focus on (1) a single primary activity of
the value chain (such as marketing and sales), (2) the interface between one stage of the value chain and another (such as the interface between operations and outgoing logistics), or (3) one of the support activities (such as human resource management).
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Business Models GenerationAlexander Osterwalder
• “A business model describes the rationale of how anorganization creates, delivers,and captures value.”
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
A business Model is..
• The business model is a strategic plan to be implemented through organizational structures, processes, and systems in order to need customer needs.
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Simple Business Model
Value Proposition
Revenue Model
Production Model
Delivery Model
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Simple Business ModelVa
lue
Prop
ositi
on
10Re
venu
e M
odel
10
Prod
uctio
n M
odel
10
Del
iver
y M
odel
10
HOW MANY OPTIONS DO WE HAVE?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Forces affecting the business model• Customer needs• Competition• Technological change• Social change• Legal environment
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Pivoting
• Changing important part of business model• - can be simple: chancing pricing• -can be complex: target customer, user needs
change, feature set changes, new distribution channel
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Basic Business Model Map
Product/Service Ecosytem
Customer EcoSystem
Finance
Value
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
• Who is customer• How do you reach customer• What is your value proposition /USP• How to you communicate customer• What are your resources• What is your enviromental costs/benefits• What are your key activities• What are your key partners• How do you make money?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
There are different type of Business Model Maps
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
• Henry Chesbrough & Richard Rosenbloom
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
intacam's Business Model MapperTM
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013Mark Johnson
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Business Model Canvas
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
The 9 building blocks for Business Model Canvas
1. Customer Segments2. Value proposition3. Channels4. Customer Relationships5. Revenue Streams6. Key Resource7. Key Activities8. Key Partnerships9. Cost Structure
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
1. Customer Segment
• For whom are we creating value? • Who are our most important customers?• Customer Segments– Mass Market– Niche market– Segmented - related customer segments: frequent
flier program, bank customers with big assets– Diversified: Unrelated customer segments: Amazon– Multi sided: free newspaper-readers and advertisers
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Find a Customer-I
• Why?• Who is your customer? Grave, School, hospital, apotek, free newspaper• Can everyone be your customer?• "people who want to buy a flat," • "anyone needs job" • “Everyone who goes to university”
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Find a Customer-II
• Find a customer for solving a pain• Use the Customer Profile• Describe who is making purchasing decision? IT ? Operations Group? Management?• Make sure they are happy• Market is important but -do not only think market• Billion dollar market does not start in few minutes
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Q’s for Customer
IDENTIFIABLE – what distinguishes them?MEASURABLE – how many belong to your target segment?REACHABLE – how to reach, communicate with each segmentWILLING– do they want it?ABLE– they want but can they afford it?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Q’s for Customer - Macro Level
• Population size• Population character• Disposable income levels• Educational background• Primary languages• Infrastructure• Regulations• Political affiliation• And so on…
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Keep In Mind -Paradox
• Customer is important but you can not give all they want
• Learn to stay No,• Learn to focus• Learn to ”change and adopt”• They may not know what they want: buying
process is mysterious
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
2.Value Proposition
• a bundle that meets that meets a customer's needs or solve his/her problem.
• benefits can be tangible and intangible• Reason why customers pick one business or
another.• can be – innovative, new disruptive offer– similar to existing offers but just added feature or
attribute in some sort of way
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Q’s to answer – Value Proposition
• What pain do we solve for customer?• What do we deliver for customer?• What value do we develop for customer• Which need of customer do we satisfy?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Some Elements that may add to value
• newness• customization• getting job done• support• price
• design• status/ brand• Accessibility• risk deduction• usability
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
2. Value Proposition - Q’s to answer –
• What pain do we solve for customer?• What do we deliver for customer?• What value do we develop for customer• Which need of customer do we satisfy?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
3. Channels
• Awareness of products and services, Evaluation of value proposition, Purchase, Delivery, After sales
• Direct: Brick and mortal stores, websales, sales force
• Indirect: wholesales partner stores,
Value Proposition
Customer Segment
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
3. Channels- Qs
• Through which Channels do our Customer Segments want to be reached?
• How are we reaching them now? • How are our Channels integrated? • Which ones work best? • Which ones are most cost-efficient?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
4. Customer Relations
• Customer acquisition
• Customer retention
• Boosting sales (upselling)
Value Proposition
Customer Segment
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Example Customer Services
Can you give some example companies?• (Dedicated)Personal assistance• Self Service• Community• Co-creation• Automated
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
4. Customer Relationships
• What type of relationship does each of our Customer Segments expect us to establish and maintain with them?
• Which ones have we established? • How costly are they? • How are they integrated with the rest of
our business model?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
5. Revenue Streams
• For what value are our customers really willing to pay?
• One time/ recurring?• For what do they currently pay? • How are they currently paying? • How would they prefer to pay? • How much does each Revenue Stream
contribute to overall revenues?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
5.Revenue Streams
•ChannelsValue Proposition
Customer Segment
• Asset sale• Usage fee: use more, pay more• Subscription: monthly, yearly• Leasing/Lending/Renting• Licensing: patents, license fee• Brokerage fees• Advertising
Fixed pricing
Dynamic pricing
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
5.Revenue Streams
Fixed pricingDynamic
pricing
• List price • Product feature
dependent• Customer segment
dependent• Volume dependent
• Yield management : hotels, airlines
• Real-time-market :supply and demand
• Auctions Price • Negotiation
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
6. Key Resources
Value Proposit
ion
physical financial
intellectual human
Key resources can be owned or leased by the company or acquired from key partners.
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
6. Key Resources
• What Key Resources do our Value Propositions require?
• Our Distribution Channels? • Customer Relationships? • Revenue Streams?• What physical resources, intellectual,
human, financial resources do we have?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
7. Key Activities
• What Key Activities do our Value Propositions require?
• Our Distribution Channels? • Customer Relationships? • Revenue streams?• Production- Microsoft• Problem Solving: Mc Kinsey• Network/Platform: Facebook, ebay, Visa
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
8. Key Partnerships
Why Partnership?– reduce cost, – Reduction of risk and uncertainty: Blu Ray Tech.– Acquisition of particular resources and activities: Nokia
Windows, HTC phones• Strategic alliances between non-competitors• Coopetition: strategic partnerships between
competitors• Joint ventures to develop new businesses• Buyer-supplier relationships to assure reliable supplies
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
8. Key Partnerships -II
• Who are our Key Partners? • Who are our Key suppliers? • Which Key Resources are we acquiring from
partners? • Which Key Activities do partners perform?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
9. Cost Structure-I
• Business model Cost Structures:
cost
-driv
en minimizing costs wherever possible
valu
e-dr
iven Premium
Value Propositions and a high degree of personalized service
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
9. Cost Structure-II• Cost Structure Characteristics:
• minimizing costs wherever possibleFixed costs
• Premium Value Propositions and a high degree of personalized serviceVariable costs
• average cost per unit to fall as output risesThe same Distribution
Economies of scale
• Channels for different products and servicesmay support multiple products.
Economy of Scope
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
9. Cost Structure
• What are the most important costs inherent in our business model?
• Which Key Resources are most expensive?• Which Key Activities are most expensive?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
In Total
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Problems with this canvas?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Spotify Business Model
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Business Model Canvas – Spotify- September 2013
Key Partners Key Activities Value Propositions
• .
Customer Relationships
Customer Segments
Key Resources Channels
Cost Structure Revenue Streams
Serdar Temiz Stockholm-Sweden
Listeners• Legal music for free or minimum payment
• Be social when you listen• Music based on mood
• Automated service• self service (FAQ)• Community forum• Customer Service
• Awareness at social media • Mobile application• Desktop application• Spotify.com
Advertisers
• self service : on learning how ads are located in the spotify etc.
• personal assistance: to put ad, advertisers should get in touch directly
• Targeted advertisement-• commercials between
songs: make listeners sure to listen
• Awareness with social media partners (fb, msn)
• Customer center representative
• Keep technology up and running
• Adding more music, label, artists to Spotify offering
• Launching Spotify in different countries
• Music,• Server,• Brand• Employees
• Labels, • aggregators (e.g merlin
network )• Facebook
• License fee• Salaries• Technology cost
• Subscription of unlimited and premium customers,• Advertisement revenue
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
• Are we done?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Business Model Canvas – Spotify- September 2013
Key Partners Key Activities Value Propositions
• .
Customer Relationships
Customer Segments
Key Resources Channels
Cost Structure Revenue Streams
Serdar Temiz Stockholm-Sweden
Listeners• Legal music for free or minimum payment
• Be social when you listen• Music based on mood
• Automated service• self service (FAQ)• Community forum• Customer Service
• Awareness at social media • Mobile application• Desktop application• Spotify.com
Advertisers
• self service : on learning how ads are located in the spotify etc.
• personal assistance: to put ad, advertisers should get in touch directly
• Targeted advertisement-• commercials between
songs: make listeners sure to listen
• Awareness with social media partners (fb, msn)
• Customer center representative
• Keep technology up and running
• Adding more music, label, artists to Spotify offering
• Launching Spotify in different countries
• Music,• Server,• Brand• Employees
• Labels, • aggregators (e.g merlin
network )• Facebook
• License fee• Salaries• Technology cost
• Subscription of unlimited and premium customers,• Advertisement revenue
Developers
• developer.spotify.com/• physical meetups
Can add music to their code
????
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Business Model Canvas – Spotify- September 2013
Key Partners
• Labels, • aggregators (e.g
merlin network )• Facebook
Key Activities
• Keep technology up and running
• Adding more music, label, artists to Spotify offering
• Launching Spotify in different countries (currently only in Sweden, Norway, Finland, the UK, France, Spain, the Netherlands and the US )
Value Propositions
• Legal music for free or minimum payment
• Be social when you listen• Music based on mood
• Targeted advertisement-
• commercials between songs: make listeners sure to listen
• Can add music to their code.
Customer Relationships
• Automated service
• self service (FAQ)• Community forum• Customer Service
• self service : on learning how ads are located in the spotify etc.
• personal assistance: to put ad, advertisers should get in touch directly
Customer Segments
Listeners
Advertisers
Developers
Key Resources
• Music,• Server,• Brand• Employees
Channels• Awareness at social media • Mobile application• Desktop application• Spotify.com• Awareness with social
media partners (fb, msn)• Customer center
representative• developer.spotify.com/• physical meetups
Cost Structure• License fee• Salaries• Technology cost
Revenue Streams• Subscription of unlimited and premium customers,• Advertisement revenue
StartupAcademy.se Stockholm-Sweden
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Facebook’s Canvas?
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
iTune’s Canvas
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Twitter’s Canvass
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Serdar Temiz [email protected] 2013
Thank youSerdar [email protected]