STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER, Governor Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive, Suite 260 Sacramento, California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay SeJVice TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 www.chiro.ca.gov NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING January 21, 2010 9:00a.m. State Capitol Assembly Room 126 Sacramento, CA 95814 AGENDA 1. OPEN SESSION- Call to Order & Establishment of a Quorum Frederick Lerner, D. C. Chair Hugh Lubkin, D.C., Vice Chair Francesco Columbu, D.C., Secretary Jeffrey Steinhardt, D.C. Richard Tyler, D.C. 2. Chair's Report 3. Election of Officers for 2010 A. Chair B. Vice Chair C. Secretary 4. Approval of Minutes November 19, 2009 Board Meeting 5. Public Comment 6. Board Member Training on the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act and other relevant laws 7. 2010 Board Meeting Schedule 8. Interim Executive Officer's Report A. Administration B. Budget C. Licensing D. Enforcement 9. Ratification of Approved License Applications 10. Ratification of Approved Continuing Education Providers 11. Ratification of Denied License Applications in Which the Applicants Did Not Request a Hearing 12. Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement to Restore a Cancelled License ·---·--- ---
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay SeJVice TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING
January 21 2010 900am
State Capitol Assembly Room 126
Sacramento CA 95814 AGENDA
1 OPEN SESSION- Call to Order amp Establishment of a Quorum Frederick Lerner D C Chair Hugh Lubkin DC Vice Chair Francesco Columbu DC Secretary Jeffrey Steinhardt DC Richard Tyler DC
2 Chairs Report
3 Election of Officers for 2010 A Chair B Vice Chair C Secretary
4 Approval of Minutes November 19 2009 Board Meeting
5 Public Comment
6 Board Member Training on the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act and other relevant laws
7 2010 Board Meeting Schedule
8 Interim Executive Officers Report A Administration B Budget C Licensing D Enforcement
9 Ratification of Approved License Applications
10 Ratification of Approved Continuing Education Providers
11 Ratification of Denied License Applications in Which the Applicants Did Not Request a Hearing
12 Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement to Restore a Cancelled License
-~-----middotmiddotmiddot---------- ~-middot middot---middot-----shy
BCE Board Meeting Agenda January 21 2010 Page 2
13 Enforcement Committee Meeting Update- Board may take action on any item on the attached agenda for the Enforcement Committee
14 Search for Executive Officer
15 Rulemaking Calendar
16 Proposed Regulations Update A Manipulation Under Anesthesia B Continuing Education C Recognition of Chiropractic Specialties D Fingerprint Submissions
17 Public Comment
18 Future Agenda Items
19 Hearings Re Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License A Mario Alvarado B Dennis Nguyen C Salim A Chowdhry
20 Closed Session
A Pursuant to California Government Code Section 11126(e) 1) Catherine Hayes v Board of Chiropractic Examiners
Sacramento County Superior Court Case No 34-2008-0000647 middot2) David Hinchee v Board of Chiropractic Examiners Cathy Hayes
Sacramento County Superior Court Case No 07AS03721 3) Board of Chiropractic Examiners v Carole M Arbuckle
Sacramento County Superior Court Case No 03AS00948 B Deliberation on Disciplinary Matters and Possible Action on Disciplinary Decisions
Pursuant to California Government Code Section 11126(c)(3)
21 OPEN SESSION Announcements Regarding Closed Session
22 Adjournment
Meetings ofthe Board of Chiropractic Examiners are open to the public except when specifically noticed otherwise in accordance with the Open Meeting Act Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Board may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call 916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site at wwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mail marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 250 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWNchirocagov
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMIN PUBLIC SESSION MIN
November 19 2009 Holiday Inn San Diego
4875 N Harbor San Diego CA
Board Members Present Frederick Lerner DC Chair Hugh Lubkin DC Vice Chair Francesco Columbu DC Secretary Jeffrey Steinhardt DC Richard Tyler DC
Staff Present Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer LaVonne Powell Senior Linda Shaw Staff - 0
Dixie Van Allen u Lavella Matthews Tammi Pitta Staff Valerie James Office
were present except Dr Steinhardt who came at 1014 am
Chairs Report Dr Lerner gave the
Approval of Minutes September 24 2009 Board Meeting
Discussion Dr Lerner Mr Puleo and Ms Powell discussed that there were items from the last meeting regarding public comments on the regulations that were discussed but not responded to The comments were minor technical changes however will still need to be addressed The minutes were tabled to be discussed later in the meeting with the regulations
middot----shy
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Public Comment None
Board Member training on the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act and other relevant laws Ms Powell stated there is nothing she needed to discuss
Dr Lubkin asked for clarification if there has been a change on the members versus three members
Ms Powell provided clarification and stated the reconnmendaltiol) members
Interim Executive Officers Report Mr Puleo gave the Interim Executive Officers Repo Licensing and Enforcement
Dr Lubkin Mr Puleo and Dr Lerner uu the categories for complaints and the possibility of breaking within its subsections
Ratification of Approved
MOTION DR LICENSE APPLICATIONS SECOND DR uu-
VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Bolt~rd applications incorporated herein
Ratification Education Providers
MOTION DR PROVIDER SECOND DR uuLuJJyen1ou SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Board ratified the attached list of approved continuing education providers incorporated herein (Attachment B)
Discussion Dr Lubkin asked for a brief description on the course being offered
2
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Dr Lerner clarified this is solely the provider being approved
Ratification of Denied License Applications in Which the Applicants Did Not Request a Hearing None
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement to Restore a
MOTION DR LUBKIN MOVED TO RATIFY THE RECOMMEN[Jfl REQUIREMENT TO RESTORE A CANCELLED LICENSE SECOND DR STEINHARDT SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Board ratified the attached list of applications in year requirement to restore a cancelled license
the two
Discussion Dr Lubkin asked for clarification on why the license was
Ms Powell clarified that these will not be due to lack of renewal
Government Relations Committee Mebull~tin Dr Lubkin provided an update from the mtir
out for another 15 day comment period
Ms Powell ing if MUA was taught in chiropractic school in 1922 raised in the letters we have already responded to The final middot is not a new comment and use previous comments to
MOTION TO ACCEPT STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE THREE COMMENTS COMMENTS PREVIOUSLY RESPONDED TO SECOND DR D THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
3
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE THE FINAL LANGUAGE WITHOUT CHANGES AND SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
B Continuing Education Dr Lerner provided an update stating over 6 hours was changes were made to the language
and several
Dr Lerner Ms Powell and Mr Puleo discussed be addressed Those comments pertained to section sentence in question will read and
neE~OElO to however the
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO BACK TO AND IN SECTION 359 OFF SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
the continuing education providers and are not included in the regulation
15 day comment period
on why the IACN was removed
Ms Powell respo
Dr Lerner went over responses to the comments
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS AS THEY ARE AND INCLUDE RECOGNITION FOR THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE WORKERS COMPENSATION LAW SECOND DR TYLER SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
4
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Discussion None
Public Comment Dr Becker provided public comment on the suggested response
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ADOPT THIS LANGUAGE FOR SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
RULE MAKING AND
Legal Representation for Board Dr Lerner Mr Puleo Ms Powell Dr Lubkin Dr that has already been completed regarding legal General We will check with the working group at help our research
the research Attorney will
Search for Executive Officer Dr Lerner provided an update and uu
on options outside
MOTION DR LERN THE SEARCH COMMITTEE THE TASK TO COME THE ACTUAL CONTRACT THAT IS BEING BID ON SECOND DR COLUM VOTE 5-0 MOTION
bull Services with the previous item Search for Executive Officer
of Legal Services within Department of Managed Healthcare icaltion on the legalities of prepaid health programs
questions from Dr Lerner and Dr Lubkin
Mr Sumner stated that Mr Stiger was interested in putting some educational information on the boards website from the Department of Managed Healthcare and would be willing to work with Mr Puleo to make that happen
Mr Sumner and Ms Powell responded to public questions from Christine Shultz CCA
5
-----------------middotmiddot---middot------shy
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
ExemptionReciprocity for Chiropractors Traveling with Sports Teams Dr Lerner stated the Medical Board uses AB138 for this purpose however we would have to amend our Initiative Act this couldnt be done through regulation so we are stuck with the way it is If someone comes here from out of state to treat a sports team they will need to have a California license to do so This varies from state to state
Acceptable Advertising Dr Lubkin stated this item has been deferred to the next Enforceme
Proposed Board Meeting Schedule for 2010 Dr Lerner announced the proposed board meeting schedule fo changed from the 20th to the 13th and the July meeting locati Orange County
May meeting date was from San Diego to
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ACEPT THE SCHEDULE SECOND DR COLUMBU SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Public Comment Dr Charles Davis provided public rnrTimlltgtni
Future Agenda Items None
Hearings re Petitio License Administrative Law nd Deputy Attorney General Tom Rinaldi appeared on behalf of th on the following hearings
Closed Following went into closed session for deliberation and determinations of Petitioners
Adjournment Dr Lerner adjourned ic meeting at 348 pm
6
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment A
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved September 1 2009- October 31
Name (First Middle Last)
Jon Lawrence Chang Hung Yang Jae Jaime Casey Dongjoo Jennifer Eloise Wendy Megan Joseph Joanna Sara Thanh-Huyen
Michael Khalid Charissa Ytis Mireya Bret David Colman Cesar Augusto
Turkowski Tseng Wills Yoon Silver Wells Chaney Galvan Hernandez Jenkins Leung Mavila
7
9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 1082009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009
31392 31393 31394 31395 31396 31397 31398 31399 31400 31401 31402 31403 31404 31405 31406 31407 31408 31409 31410 31411 31412 31413 31414 31415 31416 31417
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Hiromichi Jagjit Brett Bill Andrew Brandey Loren Kenneth Bethany David
~ Anthony Ann Clark John Ryan Diane James Young Thong Daniel Christopher Ronald Eric Nima Yu-Fu
Samuel
Singh Earl Chuwen Nathan Patricia Cecil Stuart Grace Shawn Ariel Marie Michael Anthony Montana Kristy Eric Ki Huu Phillip Robert
Nakano Sihota Underwood Wang Hassen Dollens Marshall Johns Genovea Kleinberg Silva Eissler
De Mey Lonsbury Sidhu Stubblefield Woolfenden
10122009 31418 10122009 31419 10122009 31420 10122009 31421 10152009 31422 10152009 31423 10152009 31424 101 31425 101 31426
31427
31435 31436 31437 31438 31439 31440 31441 31442
10302009 31443 10302009 31444 10302009 31445 10302009 31446 10302009 31447 10302009 31448 10302009 31449 10302009 31450 10302009 31451 10302009 31452
8
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
BCE Board Meeting Agenda January 21 2010 Page 2
13 Enforcement Committee Meeting Update- Board may take action on any item on the attached agenda for the Enforcement Committee
14 Search for Executive Officer
15 Rulemaking Calendar
16 Proposed Regulations Update A Manipulation Under Anesthesia B Continuing Education C Recognition of Chiropractic Specialties D Fingerprint Submissions
17 Public Comment
18 Future Agenda Items
19 Hearings Re Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License A Mario Alvarado B Dennis Nguyen C Salim A Chowdhry
20 Closed Session
A Pursuant to California Government Code Section 11126(e) 1) Catherine Hayes v Board of Chiropractic Examiners
Sacramento County Superior Court Case No 34-2008-0000647 middot2) David Hinchee v Board of Chiropractic Examiners Cathy Hayes
Sacramento County Superior Court Case No 07AS03721 3) Board of Chiropractic Examiners v Carole M Arbuckle
Sacramento County Superior Court Case No 03AS00948 B Deliberation on Disciplinary Matters and Possible Action on Disciplinary Decisions
Pursuant to California Government Code Section 11126(c)(3)
21 OPEN SESSION Announcements Regarding Closed Session
22 Adjournment
Meetings ofthe Board of Chiropractic Examiners are open to the public except when specifically noticed otherwise in accordance with the Open Meeting Act Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Board may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call 916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site at wwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mail marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 250 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWNchirocagov
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMIN PUBLIC SESSION MIN
November 19 2009 Holiday Inn San Diego
4875 N Harbor San Diego CA
Board Members Present Frederick Lerner DC Chair Hugh Lubkin DC Vice Chair Francesco Columbu DC Secretary Jeffrey Steinhardt DC Richard Tyler DC
Staff Present Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer LaVonne Powell Senior Linda Shaw Staff - 0
Dixie Van Allen u Lavella Matthews Tammi Pitta Staff Valerie James Office
were present except Dr Steinhardt who came at 1014 am
Chairs Report Dr Lerner gave the
Approval of Minutes September 24 2009 Board Meeting
Discussion Dr Lerner Mr Puleo and Ms Powell discussed that there were items from the last meeting regarding public comments on the regulations that were discussed but not responded to The comments were minor technical changes however will still need to be addressed The minutes were tabled to be discussed later in the meeting with the regulations
middot----shy
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Public Comment None
Board Member training on the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act and other relevant laws Ms Powell stated there is nothing she needed to discuss
Dr Lubkin asked for clarification if there has been a change on the members versus three members
Ms Powell provided clarification and stated the reconnmendaltiol) members
Interim Executive Officers Report Mr Puleo gave the Interim Executive Officers Repo Licensing and Enforcement
Dr Lubkin Mr Puleo and Dr Lerner uu the categories for complaints and the possibility of breaking within its subsections
Ratification of Approved
MOTION DR LICENSE APPLICATIONS SECOND DR uu-
VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Bolt~rd applications incorporated herein
Ratification Education Providers
MOTION DR PROVIDER SECOND DR uuLuJJyen1ou SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Board ratified the attached list of approved continuing education providers incorporated herein (Attachment B)
Discussion Dr Lubkin asked for a brief description on the course being offered
2
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Dr Lerner clarified this is solely the provider being approved
Ratification of Denied License Applications in Which the Applicants Did Not Request a Hearing None
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement to Restore a
MOTION DR LUBKIN MOVED TO RATIFY THE RECOMMEN[Jfl REQUIREMENT TO RESTORE A CANCELLED LICENSE SECOND DR STEINHARDT SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Board ratified the attached list of applications in year requirement to restore a cancelled license
the two
Discussion Dr Lubkin asked for clarification on why the license was
Ms Powell clarified that these will not be due to lack of renewal
Government Relations Committee Mebull~tin Dr Lubkin provided an update from the mtir
out for another 15 day comment period
Ms Powell ing if MUA was taught in chiropractic school in 1922 raised in the letters we have already responded to The final middot is not a new comment and use previous comments to
MOTION TO ACCEPT STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE THREE COMMENTS COMMENTS PREVIOUSLY RESPONDED TO SECOND DR D THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
3
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE THE FINAL LANGUAGE WITHOUT CHANGES AND SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
B Continuing Education Dr Lerner provided an update stating over 6 hours was changes were made to the language
and several
Dr Lerner Ms Powell and Mr Puleo discussed be addressed Those comments pertained to section sentence in question will read and
neE~OElO to however the
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO BACK TO AND IN SECTION 359 OFF SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
the continuing education providers and are not included in the regulation
15 day comment period
on why the IACN was removed
Ms Powell respo
Dr Lerner went over responses to the comments
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS AS THEY ARE AND INCLUDE RECOGNITION FOR THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE WORKERS COMPENSATION LAW SECOND DR TYLER SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
4
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Discussion None
Public Comment Dr Becker provided public comment on the suggested response
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ADOPT THIS LANGUAGE FOR SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
RULE MAKING AND
Legal Representation for Board Dr Lerner Mr Puleo Ms Powell Dr Lubkin Dr that has already been completed regarding legal General We will check with the working group at help our research
the research Attorney will
Search for Executive Officer Dr Lerner provided an update and uu
on options outside
MOTION DR LERN THE SEARCH COMMITTEE THE TASK TO COME THE ACTUAL CONTRACT THAT IS BEING BID ON SECOND DR COLUM VOTE 5-0 MOTION
bull Services with the previous item Search for Executive Officer
of Legal Services within Department of Managed Healthcare icaltion on the legalities of prepaid health programs
questions from Dr Lerner and Dr Lubkin
Mr Sumner stated that Mr Stiger was interested in putting some educational information on the boards website from the Department of Managed Healthcare and would be willing to work with Mr Puleo to make that happen
Mr Sumner and Ms Powell responded to public questions from Christine Shultz CCA
5
-----------------middotmiddot---middot------shy
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
ExemptionReciprocity for Chiropractors Traveling with Sports Teams Dr Lerner stated the Medical Board uses AB138 for this purpose however we would have to amend our Initiative Act this couldnt be done through regulation so we are stuck with the way it is If someone comes here from out of state to treat a sports team they will need to have a California license to do so This varies from state to state
Acceptable Advertising Dr Lubkin stated this item has been deferred to the next Enforceme
Proposed Board Meeting Schedule for 2010 Dr Lerner announced the proposed board meeting schedule fo changed from the 20th to the 13th and the July meeting locati Orange County
May meeting date was from San Diego to
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ACEPT THE SCHEDULE SECOND DR COLUMBU SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Public Comment Dr Charles Davis provided public rnrTimlltgtni
Future Agenda Items None
Hearings re Petitio License Administrative Law nd Deputy Attorney General Tom Rinaldi appeared on behalf of th on the following hearings
Closed Following went into closed session for deliberation and determinations of Petitioners
Adjournment Dr Lerner adjourned ic meeting at 348 pm
6
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment A
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved September 1 2009- October 31
Name (First Middle Last)
Jon Lawrence Chang Hung Yang Jae Jaime Casey Dongjoo Jennifer Eloise Wendy Megan Joseph Joanna Sara Thanh-Huyen
Michael Khalid Charissa Ytis Mireya Bret David Colman Cesar Augusto
Turkowski Tseng Wills Yoon Silver Wells Chaney Galvan Hernandez Jenkins Leung Mavila
7
9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 1082009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009
31392 31393 31394 31395 31396 31397 31398 31399 31400 31401 31402 31403 31404 31405 31406 31407 31408 31409 31410 31411 31412 31413 31414 31415 31416 31417
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Hiromichi Jagjit Brett Bill Andrew Brandey Loren Kenneth Bethany David
~ Anthony Ann Clark John Ryan Diane James Young Thong Daniel Christopher Ronald Eric Nima Yu-Fu
Samuel
Singh Earl Chuwen Nathan Patricia Cecil Stuart Grace Shawn Ariel Marie Michael Anthony Montana Kristy Eric Ki Huu Phillip Robert
Nakano Sihota Underwood Wang Hassen Dollens Marshall Johns Genovea Kleinberg Silva Eissler
De Mey Lonsbury Sidhu Stubblefield Woolfenden
10122009 31418 10122009 31419 10122009 31420 10122009 31421 10152009 31422 10152009 31423 10152009 31424 101 31425 101 31426
31427
31435 31436 31437 31438 31439 31440 31441 31442
10302009 31443 10302009 31444 10302009 31445 10302009 31446 10302009 31447 10302009 31448 10302009 31449 10302009 31450 10302009 31451 10302009 31452
8
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWNchirocagov
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMIN PUBLIC SESSION MIN
November 19 2009 Holiday Inn San Diego
4875 N Harbor San Diego CA
Board Members Present Frederick Lerner DC Chair Hugh Lubkin DC Vice Chair Francesco Columbu DC Secretary Jeffrey Steinhardt DC Richard Tyler DC
Staff Present Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer LaVonne Powell Senior Linda Shaw Staff - 0
Dixie Van Allen u Lavella Matthews Tammi Pitta Staff Valerie James Office
were present except Dr Steinhardt who came at 1014 am
Chairs Report Dr Lerner gave the
Approval of Minutes September 24 2009 Board Meeting
Discussion Dr Lerner Mr Puleo and Ms Powell discussed that there were items from the last meeting regarding public comments on the regulations that were discussed but not responded to The comments were minor technical changes however will still need to be addressed The minutes were tabled to be discussed later in the meeting with the regulations
middot----shy
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Public Comment None
Board Member training on the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act and other relevant laws Ms Powell stated there is nothing she needed to discuss
Dr Lubkin asked for clarification if there has been a change on the members versus three members
Ms Powell provided clarification and stated the reconnmendaltiol) members
Interim Executive Officers Report Mr Puleo gave the Interim Executive Officers Repo Licensing and Enforcement
Dr Lubkin Mr Puleo and Dr Lerner uu the categories for complaints and the possibility of breaking within its subsections
Ratification of Approved
MOTION DR LICENSE APPLICATIONS SECOND DR uu-
VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Bolt~rd applications incorporated herein
Ratification Education Providers
MOTION DR PROVIDER SECOND DR uuLuJJyen1ou SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Board ratified the attached list of approved continuing education providers incorporated herein (Attachment B)
Discussion Dr Lubkin asked for a brief description on the course being offered
2
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Dr Lerner clarified this is solely the provider being approved
Ratification of Denied License Applications in Which the Applicants Did Not Request a Hearing None
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement to Restore a
MOTION DR LUBKIN MOVED TO RATIFY THE RECOMMEN[Jfl REQUIREMENT TO RESTORE A CANCELLED LICENSE SECOND DR STEINHARDT SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Board ratified the attached list of applications in year requirement to restore a cancelled license
the two
Discussion Dr Lubkin asked for clarification on why the license was
Ms Powell clarified that these will not be due to lack of renewal
Government Relations Committee Mebull~tin Dr Lubkin provided an update from the mtir
out for another 15 day comment period
Ms Powell ing if MUA was taught in chiropractic school in 1922 raised in the letters we have already responded to The final middot is not a new comment and use previous comments to
MOTION TO ACCEPT STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE THREE COMMENTS COMMENTS PREVIOUSLY RESPONDED TO SECOND DR D THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
3
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE THE FINAL LANGUAGE WITHOUT CHANGES AND SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
B Continuing Education Dr Lerner provided an update stating over 6 hours was changes were made to the language
and several
Dr Lerner Ms Powell and Mr Puleo discussed be addressed Those comments pertained to section sentence in question will read and
neE~OElO to however the
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO BACK TO AND IN SECTION 359 OFF SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
the continuing education providers and are not included in the regulation
15 day comment period
on why the IACN was removed
Ms Powell respo
Dr Lerner went over responses to the comments
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS AS THEY ARE AND INCLUDE RECOGNITION FOR THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE WORKERS COMPENSATION LAW SECOND DR TYLER SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
4
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Discussion None
Public Comment Dr Becker provided public comment on the suggested response
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ADOPT THIS LANGUAGE FOR SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
RULE MAKING AND
Legal Representation for Board Dr Lerner Mr Puleo Ms Powell Dr Lubkin Dr that has already been completed regarding legal General We will check with the working group at help our research
the research Attorney will
Search for Executive Officer Dr Lerner provided an update and uu
on options outside
MOTION DR LERN THE SEARCH COMMITTEE THE TASK TO COME THE ACTUAL CONTRACT THAT IS BEING BID ON SECOND DR COLUM VOTE 5-0 MOTION
bull Services with the previous item Search for Executive Officer
of Legal Services within Department of Managed Healthcare icaltion on the legalities of prepaid health programs
questions from Dr Lerner and Dr Lubkin
Mr Sumner stated that Mr Stiger was interested in putting some educational information on the boards website from the Department of Managed Healthcare and would be willing to work with Mr Puleo to make that happen
Mr Sumner and Ms Powell responded to public questions from Christine Shultz CCA
5
-----------------middotmiddot---middot------shy
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
ExemptionReciprocity for Chiropractors Traveling with Sports Teams Dr Lerner stated the Medical Board uses AB138 for this purpose however we would have to amend our Initiative Act this couldnt be done through regulation so we are stuck with the way it is If someone comes here from out of state to treat a sports team they will need to have a California license to do so This varies from state to state
Acceptable Advertising Dr Lubkin stated this item has been deferred to the next Enforceme
Proposed Board Meeting Schedule for 2010 Dr Lerner announced the proposed board meeting schedule fo changed from the 20th to the 13th and the July meeting locati Orange County
May meeting date was from San Diego to
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ACEPT THE SCHEDULE SECOND DR COLUMBU SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Public Comment Dr Charles Davis provided public rnrTimlltgtni
Future Agenda Items None
Hearings re Petitio License Administrative Law nd Deputy Attorney General Tom Rinaldi appeared on behalf of th on the following hearings
Closed Following went into closed session for deliberation and determinations of Petitioners
Adjournment Dr Lerner adjourned ic meeting at 348 pm
6
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment A
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved September 1 2009- October 31
Name (First Middle Last)
Jon Lawrence Chang Hung Yang Jae Jaime Casey Dongjoo Jennifer Eloise Wendy Megan Joseph Joanna Sara Thanh-Huyen
Michael Khalid Charissa Ytis Mireya Bret David Colman Cesar Augusto
Turkowski Tseng Wills Yoon Silver Wells Chaney Galvan Hernandez Jenkins Leung Mavila
7
9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 1082009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009
31392 31393 31394 31395 31396 31397 31398 31399 31400 31401 31402 31403 31404 31405 31406 31407 31408 31409 31410 31411 31412 31413 31414 31415 31416 31417
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Hiromichi Jagjit Brett Bill Andrew Brandey Loren Kenneth Bethany David
~ Anthony Ann Clark John Ryan Diane James Young Thong Daniel Christopher Ronald Eric Nima Yu-Fu
Samuel
Singh Earl Chuwen Nathan Patricia Cecil Stuart Grace Shawn Ariel Marie Michael Anthony Montana Kristy Eric Ki Huu Phillip Robert
Nakano Sihota Underwood Wang Hassen Dollens Marshall Johns Genovea Kleinberg Silva Eissler
De Mey Lonsbury Sidhu Stubblefield Woolfenden
10122009 31418 10122009 31419 10122009 31420 10122009 31421 10152009 31422 10152009 31423 10152009 31424 101 31425 101 31426
31427
31435 31436 31437 31438 31439 31440 31441 31442
10302009 31443 10302009 31444 10302009 31445 10302009 31446 10302009 31447 10302009 31448 10302009 31449 10302009 31450 10302009 31451 10302009 31452
8
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Public Comment None
Board Member training on the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act and other relevant laws Ms Powell stated there is nothing she needed to discuss
Dr Lubkin asked for clarification if there has been a change on the members versus three members
Ms Powell provided clarification and stated the reconnmendaltiol) members
Interim Executive Officers Report Mr Puleo gave the Interim Executive Officers Repo Licensing and Enforcement
Dr Lubkin Mr Puleo and Dr Lerner uu the categories for complaints and the possibility of breaking within its subsections
Ratification of Approved
MOTION DR LICENSE APPLICATIONS SECOND DR uu-
VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Bolt~rd applications incorporated herein
Ratification Education Providers
MOTION DR PROVIDER SECOND DR uuLuJJyen1ou SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Board ratified the attached list of approved continuing education providers incorporated herein (Attachment B)
Discussion Dr Lubkin asked for a brief description on the course being offered
2
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Dr Lerner clarified this is solely the provider being approved
Ratification of Denied License Applications in Which the Applicants Did Not Request a Hearing None
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement to Restore a
MOTION DR LUBKIN MOVED TO RATIFY THE RECOMMEN[Jfl REQUIREMENT TO RESTORE A CANCELLED LICENSE SECOND DR STEINHARDT SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Board ratified the attached list of applications in year requirement to restore a cancelled license
the two
Discussion Dr Lubkin asked for clarification on why the license was
Ms Powell clarified that these will not be due to lack of renewal
Government Relations Committee Mebull~tin Dr Lubkin provided an update from the mtir
out for another 15 day comment period
Ms Powell ing if MUA was taught in chiropractic school in 1922 raised in the letters we have already responded to The final middot is not a new comment and use previous comments to
MOTION TO ACCEPT STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE THREE COMMENTS COMMENTS PREVIOUSLY RESPONDED TO SECOND DR D THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
3
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE THE FINAL LANGUAGE WITHOUT CHANGES AND SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
B Continuing Education Dr Lerner provided an update stating over 6 hours was changes were made to the language
and several
Dr Lerner Ms Powell and Mr Puleo discussed be addressed Those comments pertained to section sentence in question will read and
neE~OElO to however the
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO BACK TO AND IN SECTION 359 OFF SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
the continuing education providers and are not included in the regulation
15 day comment period
on why the IACN was removed
Ms Powell respo
Dr Lerner went over responses to the comments
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS AS THEY ARE AND INCLUDE RECOGNITION FOR THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE WORKERS COMPENSATION LAW SECOND DR TYLER SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
4
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Discussion None
Public Comment Dr Becker provided public comment on the suggested response
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ADOPT THIS LANGUAGE FOR SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
RULE MAKING AND
Legal Representation for Board Dr Lerner Mr Puleo Ms Powell Dr Lubkin Dr that has already been completed regarding legal General We will check with the working group at help our research
the research Attorney will
Search for Executive Officer Dr Lerner provided an update and uu
on options outside
MOTION DR LERN THE SEARCH COMMITTEE THE TASK TO COME THE ACTUAL CONTRACT THAT IS BEING BID ON SECOND DR COLUM VOTE 5-0 MOTION
bull Services with the previous item Search for Executive Officer
of Legal Services within Department of Managed Healthcare icaltion on the legalities of prepaid health programs
questions from Dr Lerner and Dr Lubkin
Mr Sumner stated that Mr Stiger was interested in putting some educational information on the boards website from the Department of Managed Healthcare and would be willing to work with Mr Puleo to make that happen
Mr Sumner and Ms Powell responded to public questions from Christine Shultz CCA
5
-----------------middotmiddot---middot------shy
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
ExemptionReciprocity for Chiropractors Traveling with Sports Teams Dr Lerner stated the Medical Board uses AB138 for this purpose however we would have to amend our Initiative Act this couldnt be done through regulation so we are stuck with the way it is If someone comes here from out of state to treat a sports team they will need to have a California license to do so This varies from state to state
Acceptable Advertising Dr Lubkin stated this item has been deferred to the next Enforceme
Proposed Board Meeting Schedule for 2010 Dr Lerner announced the proposed board meeting schedule fo changed from the 20th to the 13th and the July meeting locati Orange County
May meeting date was from San Diego to
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ACEPT THE SCHEDULE SECOND DR COLUMBU SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Public Comment Dr Charles Davis provided public rnrTimlltgtni
Future Agenda Items None
Hearings re Petitio License Administrative Law nd Deputy Attorney General Tom Rinaldi appeared on behalf of th on the following hearings
Closed Following went into closed session for deliberation and determinations of Petitioners
Adjournment Dr Lerner adjourned ic meeting at 348 pm
6
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment A
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved September 1 2009- October 31
Name (First Middle Last)
Jon Lawrence Chang Hung Yang Jae Jaime Casey Dongjoo Jennifer Eloise Wendy Megan Joseph Joanna Sara Thanh-Huyen
Michael Khalid Charissa Ytis Mireya Bret David Colman Cesar Augusto
Turkowski Tseng Wills Yoon Silver Wells Chaney Galvan Hernandez Jenkins Leung Mavila
7
9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 1082009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009
31392 31393 31394 31395 31396 31397 31398 31399 31400 31401 31402 31403 31404 31405 31406 31407 31408 31409 31410 31411 31412 31413 31414 31415 31416 31417
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Hiromichi Jagjit Brett Bill Andrew Brandey Loren Kenneth Bethany David
~ Anthony Ann Clark John Ryan Diane James Young Thong Daniel Christopher Ronald Eric Nima Yu-Fu
Samuel
Singh Earl Chuwen Nathan Patricia Cecil Stuart Grace Shawn Ariel Marie Michael Anthony Montana Kristy Eric Ki Huu Phillip Robert
Nakano Sihota Underwood Wang Hassen Dollens Marshall Johns Genovea Kleinberg Silva Eissler
De Mey Lonsbury Sidhu Stubblefield Woolfenden
10122009 31418 10122009 31419 10122009 31420 10122009 31421 10152009 31422 10152009 31423 10152009 31424 101 31425 101 31426
31427
31435 31436 31437 31438 31439 31440 31441 31442
10302009 31443 10302009 31444 10302009 31445 10302009 31446 10302009 31447 10302009 31448 10302009 31449 10302009 31450 10302009 31451 10302009 31452
8
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Dr Lerner clarified this is solely the provider being approved
Ratification of Denied License Applications in Which the Applicants Did Not Request a Hearing None
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement to Restore a
MOTION DR LUBKIN MOVED TO RATIFY THE RECOMMEN[Jfl REQUIREMENT TO RESTORE A CANCELLED LICENSE SECOND DR STEINHARDT SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED The Board ratified the attached list of applications in year requirement to restore a cancelled license
the two
Discussion Dr Lubkin asked for clarification on why the license was
Ms Powell clarified that these will not be due to lack of renewal
Government Relations Committee Mebull~tin Dr Lubkin provided an update from the mtir
out for another 15 day comment period
Ms Powell ing if MUA was taught in chiropractic school in 1922 raised in the letters we have already responded to The final middot is not a new comment and use previous comments to
MOTION TO ACCEPT STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE THREE COMMENTS COMMENTS PREVIOUSLY RESPONDED TO SECOND DR D THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
3
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE THE FINAL LANGUAGE WITHOUT CHANGES AND SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
B Continuing Education Dr Lerner provided an update stating over 6 hours was changes were made to the language
and several
Dr Lerner Ms Powell and Mr Puleo discussed be addressed Those comments pertained to section sentence in question will read and
neE~OElO to however the
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO BACK TO AND IN SECTION 359 OFF SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
the continuing education providers and are not included in the regulation
15 day comment period
on why the IACN was removed
Ms Powell respo
Dr Lerner went over responses to the comments
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS AS THEY ARE AND INCLUDE RECOGNITION FOR THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE WORKERS COMPENSATION LAW SECOND DR TYLER SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
4
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Discussion None
Public Comment Dr Becker provided public comment on the suggested response
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ADOPT THIS LANGUAGE FOR SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
RULE MAKING AND
Legal Representation for Board Dr Lerner Mr Puleo Ms Powell Dr Lubkin Dr that has already been completed regarding legal General We will check with the working group at help our research
the research Attorney will
Search for Executive Officer Dr Lerner provided an update and uu
on options outside
MOTION DR LERN THE SEARCH COMMITTEE THE TASK TO COME THE ACTUAL CONTRACT THAT IS BEING BID ON SECOND DR COLUM VOTE 5-0 MOTION
bull Services with the previous item Search for Executive Officer
of Legal Services within Department of Managed Healthcare icaltion on the legalities of prepaid health programs
questions from Dr Lerner and Dr Lubkin
Mr Sumner stated that Mr Stiger was interested in putting some educational information on the boards website from the Department of Managed Healthcare and would be willing to work with Mr Puleo to make that happen
Mr Sumner and Ms Powell responded to public questions from Christine Shultz CCA
5
-----------------middotmiddot---middot------shy
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
ExemptionReciprocity for Chiropractors Traveling with Sports Teams Dr Lerner stated the Medical Board uses AB138 for this purpose however we would have to amend our Initiative Act this couldnt be done through regulation so we are stuck with the way it is If someone comes here from out of state to treat a sports team they will need to have a California license to do so This varies from state to state
Acceptable Advertising Dr Lubkin stated this item has been deferred to the next Enforceme
Proposed Board Meeting Schedule for 2010 Dr Lerner announced the proposed board meeting schedule fo changed from the 20th to the 13th and the July meeting locati Orange County
May meeting date was from San Diego to
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ACEPT THE SCHEDULE SECOND DR COLUMBU SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Public Comment Dr Charles Davis provided public rnrTimlltgtni
Future Agenda Items None
Hearings re Petitio License Administrative Law nd Deputy Attorney General Tom Rinaldi appeared on behalf of th on the following hearings
Closed Following went into closed session for deliberation and determinations of Petitioners
Adjournment Dr Lerner adjourned ic meeting at 348 pm
6
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment A
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved September 1 2009- October 31
Name (First Middle Last)
Jon Lawrence Chang Hung Yang Jae Jaime Casey Dongjoo Jennifer Eloise Wendy Megan Joseph Joanna Sara Thanh-Huyen
Michael Khalid Charissa Ytis Mireya Bret David Colman Cesar Augusto
Turkowski Tseng Wills Yoon Silver Wells Chaney Galvan Hernandez Jenkins Leung Mavila
7
9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 1082009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009
31392 31393 31394 31395 31396 31397 31398 31399 31400 31401 31402 31403 31404 31405 31406 31407 31408 31409 31410 31411 31412 31413 31414 31415 31416 31417
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Hiromichi Jagjit Brett Bill Andrew Brandey Loren Kenneth Bethany David
~ Anthony Ann Clark John Ryan Diane James Young Thong Daniel Christopher Ronald Eric Nima Yu-Fu
Samuel
Singh Earl Chuwen Nathan Patricia Cecil Stuart Grace Shawn Ariel Marie Michael Anthony Montana Kristy Eric Ki Huu Phillip Robert
Nakano Sihota Underwood Wang Hassen Dollens Marshall Johns Genovea Kleinberg Silva Eissler
De Mey Lonsbury Sidhu Stubblefield Woolfenden
10122009 31418 10122009 31419 10122009 31420 10122009 31421 10152009 31422 10152009 31423 10152009 31424 101 31425 101 31426
31427
31435 31436 31437 31438 31439 31440 31441 31442
10302009 31443 10302009 31444 10302009 31445 10302009 31446 10302009 31447 10302009 31448 10302009 31449 10302009 31450 10302009 31451 10302009 31452
8
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE THE FINAL LANGUAGE WITHOUT CHANGES AND SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Discussion None
Public Comment None
B Continuing Education Dr Lerner provided an update stating over 6 hours was changes were made to the language
and several
Dr Lerner Ms Powell and Mr Puleo discussed be addressed Those comments pertained to section sentence in question will read and
neE~OElO to however the
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO BACK TO AND IN SECTION 359 OFF SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
the continuing education providers and are not included in the regulation
15 day comment period
on why the IACN was removed
Ms Powell respo
Dr Lerner went over responses to the comments
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO APPROVE STAFFS RECOMMENDATIONS AS THEY ARE AND INCLUDE RECOGNITION FOR THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE WORKERS COMPENSATION LAW SECOND DR TYLER SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
4
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Discussion None
Public Comment Dr Becker provided public comment on the suggested response
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ADOPT THIS LANGUAGE FOR SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
RULE MAKING AND
Legal Representation for Board Dr Lerner Mr Puleo Ms Powell Dr Lubkin Dr that has already been completed regarding legal General We will check with the working group at help our research
the research Attorney will
Search for Executive Officer Dr Lerner provided an update and uu
on options outside
MOTION DR LERN THE SEARCH COMMITTEE THE TASK TO COME THE ACTUAL CONTRACT THAT IS BEING BID ON SECOND DR COLUM VOTE 5-0 MOTION
bull Services with the previous item Search for Executive Officer
of Legal Services within Department of Managed Healthcare icaltion on the legalities of prepaid health programs
questions from Dr Lerner and Dr Lubkin
Mr Sumner stated that Mr Stiger was interested in putting some educational information on the boards website from the Department of Managed Healthcare and would be willing to work with Mr Puleo to make that happen
Mr Sumner and Ms Powell responded to public questions from Christine Shultz CCA
5
-----------------middotmiddot---middot------shy
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
ExemptionReciprocity for Chiropractors Traveling with Sports Teams Dr Lerner stated the Medical Board uses AB138 for this purpose however we would have to amend our Initiative Act this couldnt be done through regulation so we are stuck with the way it is If someone comes here from out of state to treat a sports team they will need to have a California license to do so This varies from state to state
Acceptable Advertising Dr Lubkin stated this item has been deferred to the next Enforceme
Proposed Board Meeting Schedule for 2010 Dr Lerner announced the proposed board meeting schedule fo changed from the 20th to the 13th and the July meeting locati Orange County
May meeting date was from San Diego to
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ACEPT THE SCHEDULE SECOND DR COLUMBU SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Public Comment Dr Charles Davis provided public rnrTimlltgtni
Future Agenda Items None
Hearings re Petitio License Administrative Law nd Deputy Attorney General Tom Rinaldi appeared on behalf of th on the following hearings
Closed Following went into closed session for deliberation and determinations of Petitioners
Adjournment Dr Lerner adjourned ic meeting at 348 pm
6
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment A
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved September 1 2009- October 31
Name (First Middle Last)
Jon Lawrence Chang Hung Yang Jae Jaime Casey Dongjoo Jennifer Eloise Wendy Megan Joseph Joanna Sara Thanh-Huyen
Michael Khalid Charissa Ytis Mireya Bret David Colman Cesar Augusto
Turkowski Tseng Wills Yoon Silver Wells Chaney Galvan Hernandez Jenkins Leung Mavila
7
9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 1082009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009
31392 31393 31394 31395 31396 31397 31398 31399 31400 31401 31402 31403 31404 31405 31406 31407 31408 31409 31410 31411 31412 31413 31414 31415 31416 31417
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Hiromichi Jagjit Brett Bill Andrew Brandey Loren Kenneth Bethany David
~ Anthony Ann Clark John Ryan Diane James Young Thong Daniel Christopher Ronald Eric Nima Yu-Fu
Samuel
Singh Earl Chuwen Nathan Patricia Cecil Stuart Grace Shawn Ariel Marie Michael Anthony Montana Kristy Eric Ki Huu Phillip Robert
Nakano Sihota Underwood Wang Hassen Dollens Marshall Johns Genovea Kleinberg Silva Eissler
De Mey Lonsbury Sidhu Stubblefield Woolfenden
10122009 31418 10122009 31419 10122009 31420 10122009 31421 10152009 31422 10152009 31423 10152009 31424 101 31425 101 31426
31427
31435 31436 31437 31438 31439 31440 31441 31442
10302009 31443 10302009 31444 10302009 31445 10302009 31446 10302009 31447 10302009 31448 10302009 31449 10302009 31450 10302009 31451 10302009 31452
8
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Discussion None
Public Comment Dr Becker provided public comment on the suggested response
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ADOPT THIS LANGUAGE FOR SEND IT OFF TO OAL SECOND DR LUSKIN SECONDED THE MOTION VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
RULE MAKING AND
Legal Representation for Board Dr Lerner Mr Puleo Ms Powell Dr Lubkin Dr that has already been completed regarding legal General We will check with the working group at help our research
the research Attorney will
Search for Executive Officer Dr Lerner provided an update and uu
on options outside
MOTION DR LERN THE SEARCH COMMITTEE THE TASK TO COME THE ACTUAL CONTRACT THAT IS BEING BID ON SECOND DR COLUM VOTE 5-0 MOTION
bull Services with the previous item Search for Executive Officer
of Legal Services within Department of Managed Healthcare icaltion on the legalities of prepaid health programs
questions from Dr Lerner and Dr Lubkin
Mr Sumner stated that Mr Stiger was interested in putting some educational information on the boards website from the Department of Managed Healthcare and would be willing to work with Mr Puleo to make that happen
Mr Sumner and Ms Powell responded to public questions from Christine Shultz CCA
5
-----------------middotmiddot---middot------shy
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
ExemptionReciprocity for Chiropractors Traveling with Sports Teams Dr Lerner stated the Medical Board uses AB138 for this purpose however we would have to amend our Initiative Act this couldnt be done through regulation so we are stuck with the way it is If someone comes here from out of state to treat a sports team they will need to have a California license to do so This varies from state to state
Acceptable Advertising Dr Lubkin stated this item has been deferred to the next Enforceme
Proposed Board Meeting Schedule for 2010 Dr Lerner announced the proposed board meeting schedule fo changed from the 20th to the 13th and the July meeting locati Orange County
May meeting date was from San Diego to
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ACEPT THE SCHEDULE SECOND DR COLUMBU SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Public Comment Dr Charles Davis provided public rnrTimlltgtni
Future Agenda Items None
Hearings re Petitio License Administrative Law nd Deputy Attorney General Tom Rinaldi appeared on behalf of th on the following hearings
Closed Following went into closed session for deliberation and determinations of Petitioners
Adjournment Dr Lerner adjourned ic meeting at 348 pm
6
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment A
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved September 1 2009- October 31
Name (First Middle Last)
Jon Lawrence Chang Hung Yang Jae Jaime Casey Dongjoo Jennifer Eloise Wendy Megan Joseph Joanna Sara Thanh-Huyen
Michael Khalid Charissa Ytis Mireya Bret David Colman Cesar Augusto
Turkowski Tseng Wills Yoon Silver Wells Chaney Galvan Hernandez Jenkins Leung Mavila
7
9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 1082009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009
31392 31393 31394 31395 31396 31397 31398 31399 31400 31401 31402 31403 31404 31405 31406 31407 31408 31409 31410 31411 31412 31413 31414 31415 31416 31417
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Hiromichi Jagjit Brett Bill Andrew Brandey Loren Kenneth Bethany David
~ Anthony Ann Clark John Ryan Diane James Young Thong Daniel Christopher Ronald Eric Nima Yu-Fu
Samuel
Singh Earl Chuwen Nathan Patricia Cecil Stuart Grace Shawn Ariel Marie Michael Anthony Montana Kristy Eric Ki Huu Phillip Robert
Nakano Sihota Underwood Wang Hassen Dollens Marshall Johns Genovea Kleinberg Silva Eissler
De Mey Lonsbury Sidhu Stubblefield Woolfenden
10122009 31418 10122009 31419 10122009 31420 10122009 31421 10152009 31422 10152009 31423 10152009 31424 101 31425 101 31426
31427
31435 31436 31437 31438 31439 31440 31441 31442
10302009 31443 10302009 31444 10302009 31445 10302009 31446 10302009 31447 10302009 31448 10302009 31449 10302009 31450 10302009 31451 10302009 31452
8
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
ExemptionReciprocity for Chiropractors Traveling with Sports Teams Dr Lerner stated the Medical Board uses AB138 for this purpose however we would have to amend our Initiative Act this couldnt be done through regulation so we are stuck with the way it is If someone comes here from out of state to treat a sports team they will need to have a California license to do so This varies from state to state
Acceptable Advertising Dr Lubkin stated this item has been deferred to the next Enforceme
Proposed Board Meeting Schedule for 2010 Dr Lerner announced the proposed board meeting schedule fo changed from the 20th to the 13th and the July meeting locati Orange County
May meeting date was from San Diego to
MOTION DR LERNER MOVED TO ACEPT THE SCHEDULE SECOND DR COLUMBU SECONDED THE VOTE 5-0 MOTION CARRIED
Public Comment Dr Charles Davis provided public rnrTimlltgtni
Future Agenda Items None
Hearings re Petitio License Administrative Law nd Deputy Attorney General Tom Rinaldi appeared on behalf of th on the following hearings
Closed Following went into closed session for deliberation and determinations of Petitioners
Adjournment Dr Lerner adjourned ic meeting at 348 pm
6
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment A
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved September 1 2009- October 31
Name (First Middle Last)
Jon Lawrence Chang Hung Yang Jae Jaime Casey Dongjoo Jennifer Eloise Wendy Megan Joseph Joanna Sara Thanh-Huyen
Michael Khalid Charissa Ytis Mireya Bret David Colman Cesar Augusto
Turkowski Tseng Wills Yoon Silver Wells Chaney Galvan Hernandez Jenkins Leung Mavila
7
9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 1082009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009
31392 31393 31394 31395 31396 31397 31398 31399 31400 31401 31402 31403 31404 31405 31406 31407 31408 31409 31410 31411 31412 31413 31414 31415 31416 31417
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Hiromichi Jagjit Brett Bill Andrew Brandey Loren Kenneth Bethany David
~ Anthony Ann Clark John Ryan Diane James Young Thong Daniel Christopher Ronald Eric Nima Yu-Fu
Samuel
Singh Earl Chuwen Nathan Patricia Cecil Stuart Grace Shawn Ariel Marie Michael Anthony Montana Kristy Eric Ki Huu Phillip Robert
Nakano Sihota Underwood Wang Hassen Dollens Marshall Johns Genovea Kleinberg Silva Eissler
De Mey Lonsbury Sidhu Stubblefield Woolfenden
10122009 31418 10122009 31419 10122009 31420 10122009 31421 10152009 31422 10152009 31423 10152009 31424 101 31425 101 31426
31427
31435 31436 31437 31438 31439 31440 31441 31442
10302009 31443 10302009 31444 10302009 31445 10302009 31446 10302009 31447 10302009 31448 10302009 31449 10302009 31450 10302009 31451 10302009 31452
8
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment A
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved September 1 2009- October 31
Name (First Middle Last)
Jon Lawrence Chang Hung Yang Jae Jaime Casey Dongjoo Jennifer Eloise Wendy Megan Joseph Joanna Sara Thanh-Huyen
Michael Khalid Charissa Ytis Mireya Bret David Colman Cesar Augusto
Turkowski Tseng Wills Yoon Silver Wells Chaney Galvan Hernandez Jenkins Leung Mavila
7
9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 9172009 1082009 1082009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009 1052009
31392 31393 31394 31395 31396 31397 31398 31399 31400 31401 31402 31403 31404 31405 31406 31407 31408 31409 31410 31411 31412 31413 31414 31415 31416 31417
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Hiromichi Jagjit Brett Bill Andrew Brandey Loren Kenneth Bethany David
~ Anthony Ann Clark John Ryan Diane James Young Thong Daniel Christopher Ronald Eric Nima Yu-Fu
Samuel
Singh Earl Chuwen Nathan Patricia Cecil Stuart Grace Shawn Ariel Marie Michael Anthony Montana Kristy Eric Ki Huu Phillip Robert
Nakano Sihota Underwood Wang Hassen Dollens Marshall Johns Genovea Kleinberg Silva Eissler
De Mey Lonsbury Sidhu Stubblefield Woolfenden
10122009 31418 10122009 31419 10122009 31420 10122009 31421 10152009 31422 10152009 31423 10152009 31424 101 31425 101 31426
31427
31435 31436 31437 31438 31439 31440 31441 31442
10302009 31443 10302009 31444 10302009 31445 10302009 31446 10302009 31447 10302009 31448 10302009 31449 10302009 31450 10302009 31451 10302009 31452
8
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Hiromichi Jagjit Brett Bill Andrew Brandey Loren Kenneth Bethany David
~ Anthony Ann Clark John Ryan Diane James Young Thong Daniel Christopher Ronald Eric Nima Yu-Fu
Samuel
Singh Earl Chuwen Nathan Patricia Cecil Stuart Grace Shawn Ariel Marie Michael Anthony Montana Kristy Eric Ki Huu Phillip Robert
Nakano Sihota Underwood Wang Hassen Dollens Marshall Johns Genovea Kleinberg Silva Eissler
De Mey Lonsbury Sidhu Stubblefield Woolfenden
10122009 31418 10122009 31419 10122009 31420 10122009 31421 10152009 31422 10152009 31423 10152009 31424 101 31425 101 31426
31427
31435 31436 31437 31438 31439 31440 31441 31442
10302009 31443 10302009 31444 10302009 31445 10302009 31446 10302009 31447 10302009 31448 10302009 31449 10302009 31450 10302009 31451 10302009 31452
8
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment B
Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing
Continuing Education Providers
bull M Kirk Meier
9
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
BCE Public Meeting Minutes November 19 2009
Attachment C
Recommendation to Waive Two Year on Restoration of a Cancelled
Name (Last First Ml)
Alcantara Junjoe 08312009
Hedayat Nick 02282009
Mauldin 12312008
04302009
10
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
Classification
Special Investigator (Northern California)
Associate Governmental
Program Analyst (Compliance Unit)
Recruitment and Selection of Vacant Positions January 13 2010
Date Advertised
101509
Application Review
Completed
Interviews Conducted
In Process
Background Checks
Formal Offer Start Date
120909 Completed Completed Yes 11310
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
State middot -ard of Chiropractic Examiners
Current November 2009
FY 200910
I
Sandra Walker Compliance Manager
620-11 0-4800-006
I
Compliance Unit
Lavella Matthews Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-002
Vacant Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-005
Beckie Rust Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-004
Christina Villanueva Assoc Gov Program Analyst
620-11 0-5393-xxx
Christina Bell Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-004
Julianne Vernon Management Services Technician
620-11 0-5278-001
BOARD MEMBERS (7)
Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
620-110-8862-001
Keith Powell Field Investigations Manager
620-110-8549-001
Field Operations North
Maria Martinez Special investigator 620-110-8563-001
Vacant Special investigator 620-11 0-8563-003
Field Operations South
Janitzia Downey Special Investigator 620-11 0-8563-004
Lilia Jones Special Investigator 602-110-8563-005
Linda Shaw LicensingCE Manager
620-11 0-4800-008
I PolicylAdmin
Dixie Van Allen Assoc Gov Program Analyst I
620-11 0-5393-xxx
AdminLicensing
Marlene Valencia Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-008
Tammi Pitto Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-007
Ray Delaney Office Technician (T)
620-110-1139-001
Valerie James Office Technician (T)
620-11 0-1139-008
LicensingContinuing Education
Genie Mitsuhara Staff Services Analyst
620-110-5157-wigt I
Interim Executive Officer ~~~~~ rl) ltiiv
Rev 11509
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
0152- Board of Chiropractic Examiners Analysis of Fund Condition (Dollars in Thousands)
2010-11 Governors Budget
ACTUAL CY BY 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
BEGINNING BALANCE $ 4935 $ 4150 $ 2706
Prior Year-Adjustment $ 1 $ - $ Adjusted Beginning Balance $ 4936 $ 4150 $ 2706
REVENUES AND TRANSFERS Revenues
125600 Other regulatory fees $ 164 $ 120 $ 120
125700 Other regulatory licenses and permits $ - $ - $
125800 Renewal fees $ 1985 $ 2045 $ 2045
125900 Delinquent fees $ 39 $ 30 $ 30
141200 Sales of documents $ - $ - $
142500 Miscellaneous services to the pvblic $ - $ - $
150300 Income from surplus money investments $ 120 $ 27 $ 14
150500 Interest Income From lnterfund Loans $ - $ - $ 160400 Sale of fixed assets $ - $ - $ 161000 Escheat of unclaimed checks and warrants $ - $ - $ 161400 Miscellaneous revenues $ 5 $ 6 $ 6
161900 Other Revene- Cost Recoveries $ 82 $ 82 $ 82
164600 Fines and Forfeitures $ 7 $ 7 $ 7
Totals Revenues $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Transfers to Other Funds $ - $ - $
Totals Revenues and Transfers $ 2402 $ 2317 $ 2304
Totals Resources $ 7338 $ 6467 $ 5009
EXPENDITURES Disbursements
0840 State Controller (State Operations) $ 1 $ 1 $ 2
8500 Program Expenditures (State Operations) $ 3187 $ 3760 $ 3627
9900 Statewide Gen Admin Expenditures (Pro Rata) (State Operations) 8880 Financial Information System for California (State Operations) middot $ 2
Total Disbursements $ 3188 $ 3761 $ 3631
FUND BALANCE Reserve for economic uncertainties $ 4150 $ 2706 $ 1378
Months in Reserve 132 89 45
NOTES A ASSUMES WORKLOAD AND REVENUE PROJECTIONS ARE REALIZED B EXPENDITURE GROWTH PROJECTED AT 2 BEGINNING FY 2010-11
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS BUDGET REPORT
FY 2009-10 EXPENDITURE PROJECTION CALSTARS REPORT AS OF 113009
ACTUAL PRIOR YEAR CURRENT YEAR UNENCUMBERED
EXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES BUDGET EXPEIWITURES PROJECTIONS BAlANCE
I
11212010
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
LICENSE TYPE
CHIROPRACTOR
SATELLITES
CORPORATIONS
REFERRALS
TOTALS
APPLICATION TYPE INITIAL RECIPROCAL RESTORATION CORPORATION
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS LICENSE STATISTICAL DATA
FY 200708- FY 200809 COMPARISON
TOTAL LICENSES 112009 TOTAL LICENSES 112010
13807 13841
2533 3231
1350 1334
18 19
17708 18425
APPIICATIONS RECEIVED AND PROCESSED
NOVEMBER 1 2009- DECEMBER 312009
RECEIVED APPROVED DENIED 40 38 3 0 2 3
41 38 0 19 18 3
NET VARIANCE
+34
+698
-16
+1
+717
WITHDRAWN PENDING 0 144 0 14 0 17 0 12
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
Compliance Unit Statistics
Fiscal Year 0506 0607 0708 0809 091 0
Complaints Received 764 702 644 655 285 Pending 760 863 824 410 250
Closed with Insufficient Evidence 118 132 107 206 96 Closed with No Violation 98 61 78 223 77 Closed with Merit 319 202 321 275 85 Letter of Admonishment na na na na 4 Citations and Fines Issued (Total Fine Amount) 36 34 28 41 ($19200) 44($16050)
Accusations Filed 45 41 13 64 39 Pending 142 92 73 105 115
Revoked 16 27 8 10 8 Revocation Stayed Probation 16 23 10 4 7 Revocation Stayed Suspension and Probation 15 15 10 7 2 Suspension 0 1 0 0 0 Suspension and Probation 0 0 0 2 0 Voluntary Surrender of License 8 4 2 2 4 DismissedWithdrawn 0 3 3 5 7
Statement of Issues Filed 5 11 7 3 2 Denied 1 1 0 ~ 1 0 Probationary License 6 9 7 4 1 Withdrawn at Applicants Request 0 2 1 0 1 Granted 8 3 0 0 0
Petition for Reconsideration Filed Granted
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
Denied 0 1 0 1 0
Petition for Reinstatement of License Filed 9 10 bull 15 13 3 Granted 1 5 12 4 1 Denied 9 4 6 11 4
Petition for Earllpound Termination of Probation Filed 2 5 6 6 7 Granted 1 4 1 6 14 Denied 1 0 1 2 4
Petition for Modification of Probation Filed 1 0 0 0 0 Granted 1 0 0 0 0 Denied 0 0 0 0 0
Petition b)l Board to Revoke Probation Filed 2 2 0 11 39 Revoked 0 0 0 3 16
Probation Cases Active 188 174 159 140 118
bull FY 0910 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 middotRevised January 4 2010
---- middot--- ---shy-~-----~
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
FISCAL YEAR 2010 IiiACT 10 July 1 2009- December 31 2009 IIACT 15
Total Number of Complaints Opened - 285 OCCR 302A middot Total Number of Violations- 404
(A complaint may contain multiple violations) DCCR 303
liiCCR 304
140 IICCR 308
IICCR311
OCCR 312
IICCR316 120
iiCCR 317
DCCR 318
lilCCR 319
iiCCR 355 100
iiCCR 360
lil CCR 3675 c omiddot
IICCR 3677 ~ 0 liiBP 801 gt 80
DBP 810C
tn OBP 1051 2
middot---middot~middot----middot DBP 1054ltC 0 OHS 123110 - 60
0 E 1 z
40
20
0
ACT 10 ACT 15 CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR CCR BP 801 BP 810 BP BP HS 302A 303 304 308 311 312 316 317 318 319 355 middot 360 3675 3677 1051 1054 123110
Violation
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
i I
Violation CodesDescriptions
The Chiropractic Initiative Act of California (ACT)
10- Rules of Professional Conduct 15- Noncompliance With and Violations of Act
California Code of Regulations (CCR)
302(a)- Scope of Practice 303 - Filing of Addresses 304 - Discipline by Another State 308 - Display of License 311 - Advertisements 312 -Illegal Practice 316- Responsibility for Conduct 6n Premises 317- Unprofessional Conduct 318 - Chiropractic Patient RecordsAccountable Billing 319- Free or Discount Services 355 - Renewal and Restoration 360- Continuing Education Audits 3675- Application Review of Refusal to Approve (corporations) 3677- Name of Corporation
Business and Professions Code (BPI
801 -Professional Reporting Requirements (malpractice settlements) 810 -Insurance Fraud 1051 -Apply for a Corporation with the Board 1054 - Name of Chiropractic Corporation
Health and Safety Code (HS)
12311 0 - Patient Access to Health Records
Revised August 2008
~~--~~---------------------
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
FISCAL YEAR 2010 July 1 2009- December 31 2009
Total Number of Complaints Opened Alleging Violation of CCR 317- 123 (A complaint may contain multiple violations)
0 - Gl c E l z
Iii (a)
II (b)
D(c)
D(d)
liiii (e)
iii (f)
Iii (g)
D(h)
Ill (i)
Iii G)
D(k)
Iii (I)
bull(m)
lil(n)
Iii (o)
bull(p)
Iii (q)
D (r) _
D(s)
D (t)
D(u)
Iii (v)
lil (w)
D(x)
w (~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ m m oo ro ~ (~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ oo m ~l M M w Violation CCR 317- Unprofessional Conduct
I
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
I
Violation CodesDescriptions
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 317- Unprofessional Conduct
(a) Gross Negligence (b) Repeated Negligent Acts (c) Incompetence (d) Excessive Treatment (e) Conduct Endangering Public (f) Administering to Oneself DrugsAlcohol (g) Conviction of a Crime Related to Chiropractic Duties (h) Conviction of a Crime Involving Moral TurpitudePhysi al Violenceetc (i) Conviction of a Crime Involving Drugs or Alcohol U) Dispensing NarcoticsDangerous Drugsetc (k) Moral TurpitudeCorruptionetc (I) False Representation (m) Violation of the ACTRegulations (n) False Statement Given in Connection with an Application for Licensure (o) Impersonating an Applicant I
(p) Illegal Advertising related to Violations of Section 17500 BP (q) FraudMisrepresentation (r) Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Records (s) EmploymenUUse of Cappers or Steerers (t) OfferReceive Compensation for Referral (u) Participate in an Illegal Referral Service (v) Waiving Deductible or Co-Pay bull (w) Fail to Refer Patient to PhysicianSurgeonetc (x) Offer or Substitution of Spinal Manipulation for Vaccin1ltion
i
I I
I I i
Revised January 2010
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Member~])~
From Robert Puleo ~-~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Doctors of Chiropractic for Licensure
This is to request that the Board ratify the attached list of individuals as Doctors of Chiropractic at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
I
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
Approval By Ratification of Formerly Approved License Applications November 1 2009- December 31 2009
Name (First Middle Last)
Oscar Alejandro Jane Holybee Michelle Lee Brian Christopher Michael Cody Mark Gabriel Nikki Latoya Minh Phillip Brian Hoc Duy Hoang Gail Duane Jennifer Anne Massoud Jennifer Jean Beau Jonathan Igor Jennifer Eileen Jeremy Sean Andrea Baiotto Ashley Ann David Thompson James Oliver Connie Loraine Julie Elizabeth Christopher Ray Danny Basil Matthew Carl Tracey Suzanne John Erik Knute Neal Michael Richard Walter Andrew Robert Kristen Michelle
Castro Baxley Anderson Cripe DAuria Tenenbaum Thornton Vo Yoo Tiel Le Kelley Murphy Abedinzadeh Pedley Pierce Sklovskiy Olthafer Dorris Dorris Miller-DeBoer Main McElroy Evans Lynch-Sasson Adams Bachoua Kamerzell Reeb Vang Anderson Damian Dinubilo Mukai Adriano
Date Issued DC
1152009 31453 1152009 31454 1152009 31455 1152009 31456 1152009 31457 1152009 31458 1152009 31459 1152009 31460 11162009 31461 11192009 31462 11302009 31463 11302009 31464 11302009 31465 11302009 31466 11302009 31467 11302009 31468 11302009 31469 11302009 31470 1232009 31471 1232009 31472 1232009 31473 1232009 31474 1232009 31475 1232009 31476 1232009 31477 1232009 31478 12102009 31479 12102009 31480 12102009 31481 12102009 31482 12172009 31483 12172009 31484 12172009 31485 12172009 31486 12172009 31487
Page1of2
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
Daniel Ross Cockrell 12172009 31488 Lucas C McCully 12172009 31489 Joel Wilstead 12212009 31490 Julie Quan 12212009 31491 Laura Catherine Scheiner 12312009 31492
Page 2 of2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To
From Robert Puleo Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Formerly Approved Continuing Education Providers
This confirms that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners did not approve any Continuing Education Providers during this reporting period
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Board Members ~
~_~ From Robert Puleo )
Interim Executive Officer
Subject Ratification of Denied License Applications of Doctors of Chiropractic
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Board) denies licensure to applicants who do not meet all statutory and regulatory requirements for a chiropractic license in California An applicant has 60shydays after the denial is issued to appeal the decision If the applicant does not submit an appeal to the Board the denial is upheld
Between November 1 2009 and December 31 2009 staff reviewed and confirmed that applicants met all statutory and regulatory requirements for licensure No denials of licensure were issued for this timeframe there is no ratification necessary
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER GOVERNOR
MEMORANDUM
Date January 12 2010
To Bobullnl Mombo ) gt
From Robert Puleo ~~ Interim Executive Officer
Subject Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License- Chiropractic Initiative Act Section 1 O(c)
This is to recommend that the Board waive the two year restoration requirement of a cancelled license for the individuals named on the attached list at the January 21 2010 public meeting
Staff reviewed and confirmed that the applicants met all other regulatory requirements for restoration including sufficient continuing education hours
If you have any questions or concerns please contact me at your earliest opportunity
middot---------- ------shy
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
Recommendation to Waive Two Year Requirement on Restoration of a Cancelled License
Name Last First Ml)
Dolan R Michael
Himes Robert
Howse Cheerie
Myung Ray
Stevens Don
License No
13766
25702
16417
29079
18206
Cancellation Date
05312009
10312009
12312008
09202009
12312008
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE
January 14 2010 1000 am
2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 100 Sacramento CA 95833
AGENDA
1 CALL TO ORDER
2 Approval of Minutes September 1 0 2009
3 Legal and Ethical Advertising Protecting the public through ethical accurate and truthful advertising
4 Developing a Proactive Monitoring System for Board Enforcement and Complaint Tracking Assuring compliance with Bureau of State Audits recommendations and maximizing public protection
5 SB 1441 -Uniform Standards Regarding Substance-Abusing Healing Arts Licensees
6 PUBLIC COMMENT
7 FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
8 ADJOURNMENT
ENFORCEMENT COMMITTEE Hugh Lubkin DC Chair Francesco Columbu DC
The Board of Chiropractic Examiners paramount responsibility is to protect California consumers from the fraudulent negligent or incompetent practice of chiropractic care
A quorum of the Board may be present at the Committee meeting However Board members who are not on the committee may observe but may not participate or vote Public comments will be taken on agenda items at the time the specific item is raised The Committee may take action on any item listed on the agenda unless listed as informational only All times are approximate and subject to change Agenda items may be taken out of order to accommodate speakers and to maintain a quorum The meeting may be cancelled without notice For verification of the meeting call (916) 263-5355 or access the Boards Web Site atwwwchirocagov
The meeting facilities are accessible to individuals with physical disabilities A person who needs a disability-related accommodation or modification in order to participate in the meeting may make a request by contacting Marlene Valencia at (916) 263-5355 ext 5363 or e-mai marlenevalenciachirocagov or send a written request to the Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento CA 95833 Providing your request at least five 5) business days before the meeting will help to ensure availability of the requested accommodation
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
--STATEOF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW Susan Lapsley Director
300 Capitol Mall Suite 1250 Sacramenta CA 95814 916) 323-6225 FAX 916) 323-6826 staffoalca gov
c~middot rrov - ~ Pil 1
)cshyr_bull UJ
November 3 2009
Chief Counsels Regulation Coordinators
Re 2010 Rulemalcing Calendar and Legislative Reporting Requirements
We would like to talce this opportunity to remind you that Government Code section 110176 requires every state agency responsible for implementing a statute that requires interpretation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act to prepare by January 30 a rulemaking calendar for that year The rulemalcing calendar must be (1) prepared in accordance with the format specified by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) (2) approved by the head of the department or if the rulemalcing agency is an entity other than a department by the officer board commission or other entity which has been delegated the authority to adopt amend or repeal regulations and (3) published in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) (Gov Code sect 110176)
We are enclosing two forms for providing the infonnation required by Government Code section 110176 Schedule A is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted during 2009 Schedule B is for proposed regulations implementing statutes enacted prior to 2009 The forms can also be downloaded from our website at wwwoalcagov
Also please be aware that Government Code sections 110175 and 11 0176(b) contain other requirements for state agencies to submit certain information to the Legislature when implementing new programs or statutes
Each year OAL compiles all of the individual agency rulemalcing calendars into one calendar for publication distribution and posting on our website The Rulemalcing Calendar will be reproduced for publication exactly as received so it is important to send us a final document Please remember to fill in your agency name in the top heading on the form To aid us in publication we request that you submit your Rulemaking Calendar on a diskette CD or viaeshymail to mfongoalcagov
Please submit your completed Rulemaking Calendar to OAL on or before February 12 2010
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
2010 Rulemaking Calendar 2 November 3 2009
If you have any questions please contact me at (916) 324-7952 or by e-mail at mfongoalcagov You may also contact our Reference Attorney at (916) 323-6815 or at staffaal ca gov
Thank you for your attention to these matters
Sincerely yours
Melvin Fang Legal Analyst
Attaclnnents
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TTTDD (800) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 WWINchirocagov
Continuing Education
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER Governor
Board of Chiropractic Examiners 2525 Natomas Park Drive Suite 260 Sacramento California 95833-2931 Telephone (916) 263-5355 FAX (916) 263-5369 CA Relay Service TiffDD (BOO) 735-2929 Consumer Complaint Hotline (866) 543-1311 wwwchirocagov
Fingerprint Submissions
Hand out will be given at the Board Meeting
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
---------- -----------------
Hearings Re
Petition for Reinstatement of Revoked License
A Mario Alvarado
B Dennis Nguyen
C Salim A Chowdhry
- page 1
- page 2
- page 3
- page 4
- page 5
- page 6
- page 7
- page 8
- page 9
- page 10
- page 11
- page 12
- page 13
- page 14
- page 15
- page 16
- page 17
- page 18
- page 19
- page 20
- page 21
- page 22
- page 23
- page 24
- page 25
- page 26
- page 27
- page 28
- page 29
- page 30
- page 31
- page 32
- page 33
- page 34
- page 35
-
Related Documents
