Top Banner
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 "I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ h h rz ~ Q) C/) ~ ~ Q) 00 0.. ~ >< .,0 ~ -- 0 ~ ~ ~ C/) 0 ~~ C/)-- .~ 0 ..d C/) ~ ~ Q) .9 E ~~ Q) ..d ~ ~ u ~ h ~ ~uc""-:>," '>"'o.uu~ C~._IU_- '" C I.,C 0 >~ U IU ~ ~ ~ Q 0 0 ~ u -0 .-~ U ~ 0 ~ ~ u 8.0: Q -; U.D ~ C :.= '" ~ co >..0 U IU U > ~ IU U ~ .D ~ ~ C -.: ~ ~ .-C N Y ~ ~ U ~ >< ~ co a ~.. ~ 0. 0 C U o.~ "'g..s~""':o""u""~~"'" CO"""'IUCOCO...C~ o.IUO d",~""C.-"'ou..o. .- 0~.-cd_~ 81U'rlQ ~ "'.D u 0 u 0 IU ~ 0 u 0.0 IU ~ ~ ~ .in.- co ..Co.O ...:E ~ C u 0.> g.~ u ~ 0 0. 0. co ; ~.. >. '" C ~ ~u IU u u u ...C IU = ~ ~ .-.2'"3 0 ~ is.9u.-UIU~C'''.~'''''~'''''''' .D~~:"~,,,_u""".'-" '" -~-u"""u"'_._'" 0 "" v.. '" IU U 0.1U IU 1U0_IUIUUC-.DCOU 0"'" 0. ~ -;E~""olUucu - ... u :.. ~ U ~ -.-~ ~:-= C """U~.D _v...",-:.. U .-0 ~ >..~ ...u C ~ ~ .; o.t~..~oJ"=> IU~ ~O U a ~ ~ .:::: 0 ~ .~ :-a :-=.~ >. ~ ~ u C >< u O.D IU.. C a ~= .. IU '" -" C IU"""" u .~ ..,. '" u '" '" IU IU- d'- t~ CO"" "," "'" 8 g,~~:-= IUU dlU"'O- v "":" 0 .-0. >. u '"'"' u IU u '" ~ 0. u >< u 0 -~ u = ~ ~ '" ~ ~ u is co -; -; ~ ~ ..~ .~ :>" IU U"'-IUU""U-IUC~~~~ U ..IU "'.D C .0:"'" 0. 4J 0 ~ 0 c~..- u.-o ~'" d"" IU -0:- >. 8 _0 "'.- d a 0: IU '" U >. ~ C ~ u -'" IU 0. a.- 8 .-d a ~'i ua-g>...iSu-gUlUu CO c 0 0:; ~ ~"t:c ..E ~ 'U IU ~ d ~ .D '" ~ ~ , ~ u co .in IU.~ ~ d ~ ~ ~.D >. d u is IU d ~ E .5 .~ ~ 0 ~.o:.s = au g ~ .~ 0 ..-"' u - 8 -U IU ""'" ~ .- u.~ .=:.. d IU C .-~ 0. 0 '" d U u -~ ",'- ..0 U co u '" .-.0: ~ ~ =.- u ~ .-u ..co.D:E ~ uo.""OU"""IU~~lUd ~ ~ ~ u ...~ > IU IU -u -.-~ IU c .- L.. ~ U.D u ~ ~ ~ ~ IU ~.~ ~ r- '" ~ ~ ~:.. ~ d.- .r 'u -IU ..0- .-co ~ 0) '" -8 '" v G ~ § ~~.§ '3 ~ ~ 5 5 1 c ~ ~ § ~ ou"'-~ ~ o c .- O .u v 0 :.. = ..~ O .~ .0 0 '" -u ~ 4J ~.. '" '" .- ~ is ..u 0 0. U 0. '" .0 .~ u t ~ '"0 ~ U o IU .=..e 8 u.~ 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ -..u u~uo~"" o~- .( 0. c:E ~ 0' IU U f-- .:...E IU 0. ..~ "" 0 0 ~ "- ~ ~ ~ ~ C"') . ('f'", "- ~ ~ ~ ~ . V"\ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .s:.qJ-a-a-a~ In I qJ~-o .~ -s ~ ~ ~ qJ O ~ 'E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~w ~oo~ ~ ~ In .~.5 ~ 0 e- ...In 0 :.2 .s:. U -0 qJ Po In '... ~ .s:.wu...~o ""': 0 qJ,... ~",,"""... ",.s:.w ?~~~O>' "'u-w~ qJ ~ o..in ~ .OJ:.:3 0 -I: .~ '8 bQ qJ t: ,~t:: w e w ,~ r.)/; ...~ e ~ 0 In ...~ ,... -qJ. wln-o. ..."'~-"'In ~ '" e ...0 "':3 u >."'u,~ ~ t) D.'" .0 ~ 0 qJ 0 e WIn"E..:U§ :Q0-~9qJ .s:. e e qJ 0. bQ In '... w-o bQqJ ';:';:3 :3:3In~~ :3- 0 ~ 0 In... ~ U 0 .0 .0 qJ '" >. '" 0 0 ~ ~ "'0 .s:.bu .~w,~?-o ",~-""""o."'~"':Q»'qJ 0 'u ~ '" ~ bQ -0 ~-o >. -W;.:= 0. W ... t: > ~ e ~ -~u.o ~ ","" bQU:3 bQoo..o u>. e ~ a :3 ~ '" >< ~ ~ qJ I 'in.s: o.'-"'.' e ~.s:..s:.~ w... ~... -W W '" ~ qJ 0 ~..."-'" '" qJ ... - qJ .s:. o~ ;.:= "'qJuwo""."""qJ o ~.?~ ~;'G~~o.no ""o.s:.o.~>o.o.qJ~""" """w -a """"'0~:3 w qJ ~ ~ qJ 0 ...w.o .c, w w .~...~o~ In ... o...~~ U ~ ~ In ~ ... e e '... -0 '... t) > ~.s:. .~.£ ~ -I: ~ .~ qJ ~ 0 w .s:..D I-. -'c t ~ -a w O.in ...t ~ qJ .~ 0- o-o~8u"'..EoqJw~e .0 ,'" ~ e 0. ~ ~ '... ~.5 qJ.'" ~ ...0 1n.D'" > qJ e w"" o "9 ~ ; £.OJ:. 0-1: '" ...'" 0.- 0 ~w"'w 8~qJ~:O=-o°"'Ow=.s:. 0 u ~ ~ ~ -8 ~ ~ ~ 0 .~ qJ ~ 'c, 0 :3 ~ '" 0 ~ ~ u ~ ,~ :3 ~ .c, 0 '" >..2 -0 ? ~ '" > 0 ...o e u ~ ;.Co ~ >. 0 ~ -a w 0. >..9 ~ 0 ~ ~ In .9 < Ol-.w.", ~ e ~'" 0 o.qJ:= 0:3 0. '" a s:. ~ '" .~ - ."'."'-L.~"'.~U qJ>~~r-?"'U~ .s:.~~:':: ",.~qJO w',,' ~u-ou f.I) f.I) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - f.I) ~ ~ >- - s f.I) z - ~ ~ 0 ::r: f.I) z ::r: 0 ~ E ~ ~ ~ ,. c :;) ~ ~ Q. 0 :I: ~ ~ .2, ~ '"' .L '8 0 'i' '" 0 .., ..; 6 Z .". ~ 1 ~ ~ ;s ~ "5- ~ ! .~ oS f ~ .. 'C
10

Bioethics as Politics

Mar 07, 2023

Download

Documents

Alexis Lyras
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Bioethics as Politics

~~~~~0"I

~~~

~~hhrz~

Q)

C/)

~~Q)

00 0..

~

><

.,0 ~--0

~~

~

C/)

0

~~C/)--

.~

0..d

C/)

~

~Q

) .9

E

~~

Q)

..d~

~u~h~

~uc""-:>

," '>

"'o.uu~C

~._IU

_- '"

C

I.,C

0 >

~

UIU

~

~

~

Q

0

0 ~

u

-0 .-~

U

~

0 ~

~

u

8.0: Q

-;

U.D

~

C

:.=

'" ~

co

>..0

U

IU

U

>

~

IU

U

~.D

~

~

C

-.:

~

~

.-CN

Y

~

~

U

~>

<~

co a

~..

~

0. 0

C

Uo.~

"'g..s~

""':o""u""~~

"'"C

O"""'IU

CO

CO

...C~

o.IU

Od",~

""C.-"'ou..o.

.-

0~.-cd_~

81U

'rlQ~

"'.D

u

0 u

0 IU

~

0u

0.0 IU

~

~

~

.in.-

co ..C

o.O

...:E

~

C

u 0.>

g.~

u

~

0 0.

0.co

; ~

.. >

. '"

C

~

~u

IU

uu

u ...C

IU

=

~

~

.-.2'"3 0

~is.9u.-U

IU~

C'''.~

'''''~''''''''

.D~

~:"~

,,,_u""".'-"'"

-~-u"""u"'_._'"

0 ""

v.. '"

IU

U

0.1U

IU1U

0_IUIU

UC

-.DC

OU

0"'"

0.~

-;E

~""olU

ucu -

...u

:.. ~

U

~

-.-~

~

:-=

C"""U

~.D

_v...",-:..

U .-0

~

>..~

...u

C

~

~

.;o.t~

..~oJ"=

>

IU~

~

O

Ua

~

~

.:::: 0

~

.~ :-a :-=

.~

>.

~

~

uC

>

< u

O.D

IU

.. C

a

~=

..

IU

'" -"

C

IU""""

u .~

..,.

'" u

'" '"

IU IU

-d'-

t~

CO

"" "," "'"

8g,~

~:-=

IUU

dlU

"'O-

v "":"

0 .-0.

>.

u '"'"'

u IU

u

'" ~

0. u

><

u 0

-~

u =

~

~

'" ~

~

u

is co -;

-; ~

~

..~

.~

:>

" IU

U"'-IU

U""U

-IUC

~~

~~

U

..IU

"'.D

C

.0:"'" 0.

4J 0

~

0 c~

..- u.-o

~'"

d""IU

-0:- >

.8

_0"'.-

da

0: IU

'"

U

>.

~

C

~

u-'"

IU

0. a.-

8 .-d

a~

'i ua-g>

...iSu-gU

lUu

CO

c0

0:; ~

~

"t:c..E

~

'U IU

~

d ~

.D

'" ~

~

, ~

u

co.in

IU.~

~

d

~

~

~.D

>

. d

u is

IU

d~

E

.5

.~

~

0 ~

.o:.s =

au g

~

.~

0..-"'

u -8

-U

IU

""'" ~

.-

u.~

.=:..

d IU

C

.-~

0.0

'"d

U

u -~

",'-

..0 U

co

u '"

.-.0: ~

~

=

.- u

~

.-u ..co.D

:E

~uo.""O

U"""IU

~~

lUd

~

~~

u

...~

>

IU

IU

-u -.-~

IUc

.-L..

~

U.D

u

~

~

~

~

IU

~.~

~

r- '"

~

~

~:..

~

d.- .r

'u-IU

..0-.-co

~

0) '"

-8 '"

vG

~

§

~~

.§ '3 ~

~

5

5 1 c ~

~

§

~ou"'-~

~

o

c.-

O.u

v0

:.. =

..~O

.~

.0 0

'" -u

~

4J ~..

'" '"

.-~

is

..u 0

0. U

0.

'" .0

.~

u t

~

'"0 ~

Uo

IU

.=..e

8 u.~

8

~

~

~

~

-..u u~

uo~""

o~-

.( 0. c:E

~

0' IU

U f-- .:...E

IU

0. ..~

""00~"-~~~~C

"').

('f'",

"-~~~~.V

"\~~~~~

.s:.qJ-a-a-a~

In I

qJ~-o

.~

-s ~

~

~

qJ

O~

'E

~

~

~

~

~~

~w

~

oo~~

~

In

.~.5

~

0 e-

...In

0 :.2

.s:. U

-0

qJ P

o In

'... ~

.s:.wu...~

o ""':

0 qJ,...

~",,"""...

",.s:.w?~

~~

O>

' "'u-w

~

qJ ~

o..in

~

.OJ:.:3

0 -I:

.~'8

bQ

qJ t:

,~t::

w

e w

,~

r.)/;

...~e

~

0 In

...~,...

-qJ.w

ln-o. ..."'~

-"'In~

'"

e...0

"':3 u

>."'u,~

~

t)

D.'"

.0 ~

0

qJ 0

e

WIn"E

..:U§

:Q0-~

9qJ.s:.

ee

qJ 0.

bQ

In '...

w-o

bQqJ

';:';:3 :3:3In~

~:3-

0 ~

0

In... ~

U

0 .0

.0qJ

'" >

. '"

0 0

~

~

"'0 .s:.bu

.~w

,~?-o

",~-""""o."'~

"':Q»'qJ

0 'u

~

'" ~

bQ

-0 ~

-o>

. -W

;.:=

0. W...

t: >

~

e

~-~

u.o ~

",""

bQU

:3 bQ

oo..o u>

.e

~

a :3

~

'" >

<

~

~

qJ I

'in.s: o.'-"'.'

e~

.s:..s:.~w

... ~

... -W

W

'"

~

qJ0

~..."-'"

'" qJ

...-qJ

.s:. o~

;.:=

"'qJuwo""."""qJ

o ~

.?~

~;'G

~~

o.no

""o.s:.o.~>

o.o.qJ~"""

"""w

-a """"'0~

:3w

qJ

~

~

qJ 0

...w.o

.c, w

w

.~...~

o~

In...o...~

~U

~

~

In

~

...

ee

'... -0

'... t)

>

~.s:.

.~.£

~

-I: ~

.~

qJ

~

0 w

.s:..D

I-.

-'c

t ~

-a

w

O.in

...t ~

qJ

.~

0-

o-o~8u"'..E

oqJw~

e.0,'"

~

e 0.

~

~

'... ~

.5 qJ.'"

~

...0 1n.D

'" >

qJ

ew

""o

"9 ~

;

£.OJ:.

0-1:

'" ...'"

0.- 0

~w

"'w

8~qJ~

:O=

-o°"'Ow

=.s:.

0 u

~

~

~

-8 ~

~

~

0

.~qJ

~

'c, 0

:3 ~

'"

0 ~

~

u

~

,~

:3 ~

.c,

0 '"

>..2

-0 ?

~

'">

0

...oe

u ~

;.C

o ~

>

. 0

~-a

w

0. >

..9 ~

0

~

~

In .9

<O

l-.w.",

~e

~'"

0 o.qJ:=

0:3

0. '"

a s:.

~

'" .~

-

."'."'-L.~"'.~

U

qJ>~

~r-?"'U

~.s:.~

~:'::

",.~qJO

w',,'

~u-ou

f.I)f.I)~~~~~-f.I)

~~>--sf.I)

z-~~0::r:f.I)

z::r:0~

E~~~,.c:;)~~Q

.0

:I:~~.2,

~'"'.L'80'i''"0..,..;6Z.".

~1~~;s~"5-~!.~oS

f~..'C

Page 2: Bioethics as Politics

~

~

~

c r;

,~>

-"" d

t '"

"'~ d

~

~

~

"'~ bO

~

-0 ~

~

t

..s g. -s

~

;.:: ';:' ~

~..s

~

~..d

-g ~

~

,~

g -s

~.s

~

~

~

~

0.>

-~

""."'.- -S

"""'."'S""~

.OV

~

~-o~

dr-'~

",O

~:::;.e§~

~

.s~~

~~

~~

:s~

82,~..;~

5~'§~

~r;

~

>-';:'

&

'c ]

~

~

8 ~

'0

8 ~

'o ~

~

,g

'in ~

S

~

~

'" ~

oS0'

~.o

~

: '"

='

"QJ"':-""""

'" o.:.c

-0 8

'-=.-=

t"';

='

v S

~

-o0

do"" I-.

~

~

.0 ~

-0

~

:-a §

~

~ v

-: ",.2.

u >

e.o -s

~

~

dN

~

bO

~

~

'0 .E

~

(:j

g ~

'0

';:' -s

~

~

~

';;; ~

.?;- 8

g ~

d

oS

8 ~

~

~~

~o

...d~bO

o...dr;bO~

V~

.u~id~

"';°E.5-;

~

~ 1

; ~

.;

] ..s

~

~

E

~

&g

~

~

.£ ~

§

.-=

~

~

g ~

~

~

..g

t~

O

""-o~

,.,- ~

"""'O

~d""'o,J~

~d-.'"

>

..d"" v:-:=

v

d v

-0 v

~

t..d ~

:.E

~ =

= 0 "'"" :-:=

~

.~""-o,,,~

U!..d

..dot""v~"'o~

"'" ~

~~

Ov~

-o~

~

"3 =

=

-s s

~0

.~

~

"3 ..d

t: .:::.c

bO

~.s

0 -s

~

t d

u~

t

.d.dO

.'" '"

.""0"".,E""

...Udd

~",,"'

~

~

~"Q

J -§

~

r; ~

~

",..d

d V

.2

,S

.s .0

§ .,..0

V

~

.in ~

"'""

S

~

~

< z~

'"

'" ~

V

0 S

0

0"' S

'" ~

~

c."" -g ""';:'

~

d ~

d=,O

~

0"':-""

'" "'d

""."""'~O

"'v~V

>-""~

Vo.~

VV

O

~

.~

O~

~ ~

;

~

~

~

&:a

; :

§ g oS

t1 ~ .E

5 S

~

.§ ,§ ~

,~

~

~

"';0

"""'><

~d

-o""OO

dd O

V""~

"""~""~

""""v",",, ::;;' "3.3

V ~

';

S

; ~

d

~U~

8 -g::!.

S ~

~

d ~

~

=

' t"'; -0 ..d ~

g

gU

"'.>

"'""-bOO

~

~--

~~

~d""v""d.~

""Ud""

bO'"

:;: §

0 ~

V

~.o

-o.~

~

~

'" >

- ~

0 =

' ~

t:

0 V

1;- ~:E

~

~

,~

~-o

~

tJ '"

'" -0

--V

,- '...

>-.~

d.o

d..d =

' ""..d

--'" 0

~

U

~

8 ~

~

e

~.s..d

-s oS

==

"'; ~

~

'...

~

U

8 ~

"" V

0

.~

;:: ~

~

0

~

g.~.f

~

S

8 t

t .~

~

..;

.0 g:g

=

~

~

~

; ~

~

§

; ~

f;J i

~

~~

"'..d

V

d ~

.E

o d

>

U

V

~

='

~

so""::C

I-. --'" 0

'0 0

d~

' ]

-::a ~

g :J.

~

~

~

i ]

'~

~

~

'f ..s ~

!.,go

5 ~

~

~

~

~

:.s .s

~

(:: ""V

""-""'S."""~

""""'~>

~-""d;gr;u

~o~

~V

~Z

"Q

J u"o V

-fo

V ~

~

0.

0 0.

d '-=

0. -;

~

""o'u

""..d ~

"'2.s.{g '...

~

S-~

dvU

U,~

.O"""""'oo.~

o

~~

""."'SV

O.o'O

~d

~

>-

~.s

E

S

§ ~

:a ~

..&:J.';:'

'0 '0

r~

~

~

~

E

§ =

' ~

..d

'0 ~

~

~

~

~o.~

bO",O

"""'>..V

~=

' ""-~

.c-~v"""

t 0.

~Z

S

V

'Q

:i:'=

~

d ~

V

d

...~

~

d "'"

~

V

~

~

'" ~

d

~

0. ~

d

Z

U

"">

dd"" ""U

vVd"">

-""'.o-V~

~

~

§

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

i ~

.,g,.s ~

5 e..s

E

~::;

.~ -.:s ~.s

§ E

8 ~

~

.~ :.=

.> -0

5 ~

~

0 ~ -fo ~

V

S

~

8 ~

~

~

g

~

'" §.§.~

~

bO

'~ bO

g:J.'OoS

"":a~~

='§~

§~~

::="'vs---g"""Q

J~~

;§;'O00.

d""O~

O

u d

o""dd

V

~"O

~~

0.

"'>-v

'T'

""'" ~

V

"'vO

~..d-

--o.""~"""

""v~~

v~"O

""'ov='~

""vbOv..d

'Q:i""=

'so o"O

8 -s ..s ~..s

~;

S

~

~ 1-- ..8 ..s '0

~

~

].s s..s

8 V

S '0

~

E

~

..s::b~--;--;

~~

-:"'O~

S&

~eon"E

~S

~

~~

-:"bo~Q

)'e:'6.~~

~~

~'O

Q)S

§ .'£jO

~

i] tong

1 ~

~

E

.£ ~

~.:

~ ~

~

..§ ~

5 ~

~

l

~

~

~

~

~ ~

.R

.s ~

,] §..§

U

Q)

.-=

.~

0 ...U

Q

) Q

) I::

~

~

0 0.

Q)

>-

11).0 00

~

Q)

I:: Q

)"'" I::

0. Q

) Q

)~

..cQ)

oJ:: ~

II)

0. bD

.;=

~..!,

Q)

~

=

~

II) U

I::

~

0. """

~Q

) ll:j

5 ~

~

~

0

~

~

bD

~

"E

0 ..c

~'""

~~

I::-~

.'" .E

~-~

~

~~

Q)Q

) I::~

'V"""~

'" U

"'-~~

-=

-

I=; ~

.5

~

0 '0 .2

t ...S

§ --; .~

-; ~

~

~

0 II):C

~

9 ~

~

~

.~ S

~

:I go ~

,=- ~

:g .~ .-=

~

2~

~

~

~

..s ~

~

i .§' ~

~

~

.'f: .~

E

>- ~

"E

~

~

E

1)..5 ~

g 0. bD

:g Q ~

'0

Q).~

~

~

0. ~

0.

~

e ~

§ §

S .g

~

'e:'.~ ~

~

.~ ~

~

~

~

§ .~ l

~ '0

jg i:§ ~

]

l ~

~

~~

~ ~...~

~

5.=

-.~

9 .:S.oJ.r:;

oJ Q

) II) ~

~

oJ:: ;: ...Q

).r:; Q

) ...II) ~

I:: ~

~

-"';00 ~

~

~

~

~"'3

~

oJ::~--;""O

~~

"'bDI\)8~

u~~

~~

Q

)bD~

~O

~

>--ggoJ::Q

)~Q

)'Qjoo£

0 0

...0' bD

8. ...~

::;; ~:a

~ -e.~

.=

oJ:: ~ ~

.:c S

=

..."""'8

= =

.~

II) ~ :I: ~

~

U

<

";I~

~

'e:' U

~ --;.£

S

~:E

~

'--: ~II) § ,g 't

-g ~

~ ~

S

~

~

,9 e ~

.g.g ~

~

~

-g >

. =

g on ~

]~

~

0 ~

~

'~

'O

~

~..c

-0 S

U

'2 -0 II) ...~..c

Q)

0""" ~

=

=

~

...~

...~

.~

~

~

=

0.~

~

.:S

:E:;

~

~

§ '"'b 5. r~ ~

~

I\) ';

~:.a ~

..s 5. ~

..s ~ o

~

~

~

~ ~

~

=0=

~

8 .3 '-=

§,~.;,f

~"'bD

O~

U"'Q

)"'" ...~

.~,

~

II) -Q

) Q

)0~

II)...0 -bD

~~

'v.u...I

~

-; ~

Q

) ...II) 0. ..."-

=

=

~ ~

Q

) 0 ~

0

U

:I: I:: ...II)

~

U =

II) S

-; Q

) >

=.c:

Q) "

~~

;.§

.g ~

~

§:g

.~.:s

~

~ ~

~

5.£

e ~

; ~

.; %

bb""g.S

~

~ =

:§ o~ ~

§

~..s

'0 ~

5 ~

r ~

~

c.;:=:, ~

.r:; ~

U .-=

.~

Q) Q

) ~

0 ~

~

=

=

0 e

t: ~

os =

~

S

Q

) ~

0. ~

0 U

~

=

Q ~

~

-S

...ci::

'e:' ~ -g

e -E ~

~~

E

~ ~

.3

0><

~ t

~

,9:I: S

~

~

9 .~

~

~

~

:E

Q ~

~

~

~ ~

o '&

8. ~.~

~

~

v; ~

~

~

~ ~

.~

S

0. u Q

) I\) ~

~

~

.~

u ~

-I:: ~

~

Q

) Q) II) ~

Q

) 'Qj ;...

...=

Q) 0. 0

~ ro.::.>

U EQ

) ~

~

=

-0 ~

>

<

Q) ~

~

~

..c ~

Q

) ~

U

...~

~

I

S

~

~

=

-g 0.

0 ~

~

.c: ~

Q

)..c \0

~0

~

~

0. oJ::

Q)..c

H

=

I': ...~

=

~

...11);00

Q)

=

>-

II) 0

Q) -~

Q

) ...~

...II)

...~

t"- oJ::

,~

Q)=

II)"'-Q)X

..II),",O~

Q

) =

1::0 ~

bD",II)II),",-"'~

..~.c:

oQ

)o0-=

0

Q) =

~

=

Q

) , >

- -U

u ...Q

) Q) 0

>

.~...

~

~

~

-~

0 U

II)

oJ:: ~ 11)"" >

-~

~

0 e

~

~

II) Q} ~

0

=

0 ~

bD

-0

~..s

S .~

-;00 ~

>

- ~ ~

.c: vU

~

~ ~

+

.;; ...~

~ -..c

~ N

Q

) II) I:: ~ ~

...Q

) '" ~

=

Q

) ~

Q)

~

t"- Q

) I:: -=

U

~

...Q)

cu... ~

Q

)~

~

Q

) ~"'Q

)"" ~

" >- S

~

..s .~

~ .Q

3..s a ~

~

0. ~

~ t"- ~

g

~

9 :.a Q

) ~

t ,~

.c: ~

C

~

1::0

~'""

...=

r:; =

>-

~

~...

..c U

0

-=§

~

0\ .Q

)..c bD

--=

~

~

~

~ -bD

~

~

u ~

.>..cQ

) ~.....c.5 ~

0

~

'Qj ~ ~

Q

) ~.£

oJ:: --= -

...~

~

=

-9 ~

~

;00 ~

:: ~

.-=

.~ --; Q

~-:

~

Q)

~

-->;:

'v '" I::

oJ -"'.c: 'v ~

0

~

...0 ~

]

g.!!i ~

1 ~

~

'~

~

~

~

~

~]

,~

~

§ i ~

~

~]

~

~ ~

~

~

~

..8 ~ 1

.~]

§ ~

~

~

~

,g

1Q :=

~

~ ~

.s

I:: O;.=

: ~ ~

~o

:.a .~ ~

'~

.c: ~

U

S

~ -E

~:3

~ -0

~ ~

~

~

.0 ~

~

.~

'r:; ~

§ .00>

- ~ -;

00-- S

."'>-Q

)-'" =

~..c-'"

~~

""""'~"'-=

I-o""j;J~",

~

o"'~

..c=

~

0. ~

Q >

. 0 >

-0

s..s ~

~

U

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

" I::

~

~"-=

U

~

~

~

~

~

~

"2 u

--;:. =

~

~

:

~

=

~~

~

=

~

~

'v

P

-Q)

bD

;: -Q

) ",

Q)

~

.~

=

~

~

.c: -,'"

~

...'" Q

) s

Q)

S~

Q

) 0 :; Q

II) ~:2:

~ooo~

~ ..s ~

~

'Q

j ~ -s

s:-g"2 ~

~

:o~ ~

s ~

Q 9.::.

g. ,s ;;.:=

g

~..s

~

8 ~

~

..s Q

)0

S-:-::=

~

~.

V").J.O

~~

I':",Q)=

=~

... >

~

",Q)Q

)"'~~

""""V_~

"'Q

) S

~

o'~.s

~

~

Q);£ ~

t"- ~

~

;

~ ~

~

~ ,9

0 ~

8 ~

8

Q)..s

~

:; ~

.2 e

t: .g

~

=

.3 Q

) .g '0 ~

'Q

j 0 S

~ ~

~

..s ~

~

--; .c: ~

~ ~

..s 8

'i r:::- .s."E

..s ~

~

'f!,]

5 ~

~

g. ~

...~

g. ~

9

.f:] g

.~

0 ~

t:

';;..c .=

- <

e e

0 ~

g

~

~

5 Q

) 0 ~

~

~

>

-,~

~ ~

Q

) ~ ~

~

Q

) Q) e ~

:.c ;00 ~

~

~

Q).'F

. § ~

8. S

'9

~

~

~

~

S

So

~..s

=

~

~ -a.:I:

9 ~

..s .r:; t

-g :I: S

~

=

9

0. =

~

..s ~

.r:; ~

~

'r:;

'" ~

.:'

I c=

'" >

-c=

~

-c=

c=

Q

) Q

) Q

)

...cU

Q)

bI)~Q

)=~

0

bI) '" Q

) .>

;.=

,-",c=C

=..cQ

)Q)",

:>

8 ~

..c :3

...0. '...

0' Q

)cU

~~

~

c=

u...--Q

),"oom'd

Q)":

8 0

';j r;:;

.~-..c

o"'L~

cU:J:

...0-~"'"'C

Uf-'

0"'-+-"'...8...

~

"'~c=

"~

o-.",..c=

cU

~ ~

~

:r.'6""""""C=

'"u

Q)"'o~

oo>-

-~0.""...8u",

b Q

)Q)'Q

::~Q

)Q)~

<

~:c-S

~~

-SgQ

)~~

1.."

cU

cU'"

Q)

'"Q

.. ~

'Q

::.S

8 ~

~

'c ~

~

~

~~

cU

~

Q)

cU0

~

Q)

c=

~

~

o.,~~

'"

bI) 0 ,"

><

-,~

c=

... Q

)Z

""- O

Q)"'Q

)cU

~-0

u8t..c~'t:~

~

~

cU

Q)

:3 '0

~

Q)

"2~

V

I Q

) 0

'" u

'""'-:s

"'c=U

~-Q

),..,0

~

~;'=

"""C=

~~

Q)

~

...0. 0

cU.;j

..c=:J:

~

0 ~

:

f-' ~

u"""ocU

c=0

~

,1:;"~

§ ,~

0.

:3 ~

Z

..c= ~

.m

0

:Q

...<

...cU

."'..c=

0 >

cU

Q)",uu",.:e..c=

~

OcU

Q)

C=

c='"

~

:.E"'~

~o"...""

<

u Q

) '...

c=§

>-

'... ..c=

'""i'

...Q)

Q)

~-S

""'O~

-S8

...Q)0,:3

bI)~

oo...~

O'~

~~

0.~

..~C

=~

C=

:3~

""

Q) Q

) cU .~

'".C=

~'"

uQ

) Q

) c=

Q

) ...u~

ocU

t

c=

5 c=

'... ...~

..c=0...

°t g'Q

'" 0.

U

"~

~

0 c=

Q

) 0

><

Q

) ~

."'..c=

...Q

)...cUC

=

o.

\00 r-..0...,

Page 3: Bioethics as Politics

~

~

~

._~

~"'O

~

"'O"'O

I

0 ~

-..c=

'"

t) .~

~

0

..c=

~

c=

~

..c=..c...o~

uoo~

"'~~

C=

~e

"'...~

~..c=

",~-",

.~"'e.=

e""-

...,,'J

'" ,~

'""'0-0:=

~

-~u

""""'e

c=c=

~

~

u 0'--'

'" .~

...0

~

~0

0~

... 00...

~

"':>

~

u6i>"'~

c=°O

~>

<

~"'e",'r:.~

r::-'"

...000\0 ...~

...",~

c=~

cIS~

0 "'0

cIS

...:'"'0 .r:.

=.

~

oe~

-..a..c=

0

..c. ...

0 ~

>

-..c=

c=

cIS

g ..c=

~

...", .~

..c=

~

gN

.=

~

00

"'3 ~

cIS

~

... ~

:>

E

.0 ~

"'O

'"I.:

o...c=.~

~

u

0'\ :.::

...~

""" ..,.

~

...>-

u~

'"

~

c=

~

I'-.. ~

c=

-S

cIS

cIS

-"'0 '"

cIS

~

c=

",t:: ~

o c=

->-

~~

~

.~

~

-; ~

cIS

~

~

e

u '0

~..c

~

~

~

bE

! cIS

cIS

'0"'0 00

~

...~

0 "'0"""

~..c=

0

E:

."':I:~~

C=

0 ~

~~

"'>"'

e~

~

0..:=

.~

U

~

00

c=

.~

.in O

..c=

.,-,

"':>

'" c=

cIS

'J

~

00 ...cIS

U

.8

~

~

C'

~

:>

~

~

t) .~

~

..c ~

'S

: "'0

.oJ ",...

U

...","'O~

."'C

=U

-..c="'cIS

-<

s: cIS

s: cIS

cIS

"'0

~

~

...~

c=

~

~

~

d' -g r;f%

:: ~

~

'fi

-; -;

:u ~

~

:D

:J ~

~

cIS

0 0

e .~

... ~

.O

..c=

~"'O

.r:."'O

0 ~

~

~

~

~

~

c=

~

U

..c=

c=

[ ~

;;;' "'>

-~~

~.~

~"'e

~"~

~~

~e

UOu

..cu

U

~

--'-' ~

.-

..."'0 -~

'"

0.""" :>

'"

'J0

...

~~

"'O

cIS

>-

~

~'"

0 ~

"""'" c=

~

U0.

e...

e~

..c=

0

O..c=

.., ~

~

U

~

0.

...~

U

c=~

~o.~

cIS

- ...U

.r:.cIS""-

~

U

0.'" >

<

~

~..c=

'" cIS

c=

... cIS

U

~

~

0 ~

t::

~~

..c=

...""".9 0

~

~

~

~

...0~

.~

o.e

cIS c=

..c ...c=

0

U

"'0 cIS

c= ...'"

~..c=

~:s

O~

c=~

~

~

~O

c=

",

e~

"'O

~

..c=...

~"'u~

~",>

-

..c=

'J.'" .00...

'". -cIS

U0

~

0"'0 cIS

..0.

-=

c=e

0 I-..c=

e'"

~

c=

,~

~

V)

~

~

0. 0'\

c=

...d ~

.~

'O

>

oo..c=

~

~

c=

~

~..c

c=

~

I'f") ~

0

~

U

0 c=

"'O

~

0~

~

cIS

:'~~

I'-..>-",'p-~

"'o.2."'e

Q~

- c=

"",,"" o~

C=

t::"'u ~

~

~

rJ' ~

~

>

- ~

-;

e b

~

cIS '0

"'0 ~

e-;

~

§~~

e-5~~

.go.~.E

:S

~;...~

.~..,

0 -00

c=

0 "

c="'O

:>

~

... "0

_..0...

o."O..c=

~

'~'"

~

ue

~

:>.0

N

~

~"'O

c=

"'S

c=

...; ~

"O

"'0 -.~

... cd

~

-~

...N0

0 ...0.

"'0 'J

~

~

-~

cIS

..."' ..c=

~

~

~3"'00~

~..d~

~~

-;~0.~

c='O

~e

"""""oo"""..c=

~cIS

."'~.E

e:g>

in

~.~

~

~

~

~

...'U

~

§'

~~

.2...8.2

g ~

.S

~

3 ~

8

e ~

.=

~

II);:0.~:EE~~.~.~~,II)E':s~...;:~~

""","",-"" >

. "'

'" >

.~

I Q

) >

-'Q)

Q)

_."'O~

OQ

) ."'~

""=o

u~~

""..Q8

~..Q

u

~..Q

C

C~

-~L..

...Q)

~

","", ~

~..Q

8"'."'..Q)

"""'U""~

- 0"'""'

tIt) Q

~

~

c ~

Q

) 0

8 Q

).~

c ~

~

u

~

~

~

..~

-fo ~

;:=

~

0 8

~

.+3

0 tit)

U

'"~

.::."i

.::- 8 ~

~

~

<

..t=

Q) "'""'

0~

~

.S

~

--;~

-'"

~

0 Q

~

Q

) ..-c

.-S

'"

Q)

Q..Q

~

~

~

-g

c '"

Q)

~

t .bb

CQ

)~~

,p~""

~"""'uQ

) c"'~

~

oQ

)"" ~

~

-Q

) ~

""§~

~g.~

~

c~~

~~

8~

8ce~8

°E.

.+3

f-- .m

0

.~

0 ~

~

0

-=

8 ~

>

. ~

'" ~

U

.",..Q

coo

~tIt)u'S

.00.0co

~Q

)8.::1.~

~

Q

) '" .-Q

) C

C

Iu

-..Q

~

~..Q

) ~

:..a.+3

~

>

.m

0 ~

~

Q

) :~.£

""..Q

u0.

'" ~

~

Q

)8

C

Q) ~

8

~

~

C

~

~

r -cn .£

~

8 .=

C

Q

)0

~

~

C

00

Q)

'"'0

08

'" tit) -..N

'"

Q) "'""'

0. ~

'"'"

>

~

0 ~

.. 0

o..m

~

~

;:=

Q) ~

'"

0 ~

~

~

0.

u8

Q).m

~

Q

) ~

u

...m

""Gj~

O~

tIt)..Q

'oJ8~0~

~0-S

§5~~

'tI u

-S

S

.~

~

Q)

0 ..C

0.

-S

C

.+3

..0 ~

~

~

Q)""

~..Q

Q

) ~

"'""'

0 Q

).'" 0

~

~

Q)

0 -g

8 ~

~

~

~

'"

~

't .g,

~

~

>.

~

~

-5 ::c

""o.c~-;..Q

9.a~

;:=8

~-g::::o.o.~

~'"

~->

~

~Q

) ~

o","",o..~

Q

).C

>.

Q).'"

~

u ~

..~

~

~

u

>.

0 ..Q

)~

..o -C

...~

..,

-..'" 0

-~

-0. '"

;>

~

~.""

;>

Q)

~

~

Q)

I'"

~

~

C

0. ~

~

"'",u~u"

~;>

""~~

o~o

C -;:0=

: >

. >

. -0 ~

"'""' C

Q

) tit) '"

~

~

~

.-.9

0 ~

~

"+

3u0"Q

. '"

~..o

C

~

0..9 ~

t

.!: ~

U~

~

=

~

Q

)-Q

) 'C

~

..~

~

>-.

Q) '"

Q) "'""' ~

~

~

'" 0

U"""

'" ~

~

",

u.. ~

.. "'

u8

~

~ ~

'"

~

~

t::=

0 ~

~

-;

~

.8-08

.+3

"'""' .C

~

~

~

~

Q)

Q)

u.£ 0.

u ;>

~

0.-

Q) --8

~

~

.] .0

~

'" 0.

8 0

tit) 0

'" '"

Q)

0.8

>

=;

8 0.

..'" ~

Q

) 8

Q) .m

Z

.S

§.a

~

~

Q)

.+3

-0 Q

) C

-~

..~

~

Q

) u ~

.m

..Q

~

"'8"'""'

tIt) C

~

~

~

Q

).::I. 0

=

C0

.~

..=

~

Q)

~

Q) ~

'"

~::c

-!, u

~

~

~0...Q

.2 ~

~

.~

~

0 ~

~

~

~

~

""Gj'+

3 u

Q) ~

~

.'" ~

0..Q

Q

) Q

) ~

~'"

8 ;

~

Q).~

~

~

;

g ~

~

8 >

.~~

8.~

8

"' t;-;"'""'

""'C

Q)-"'""'

~~

Q

) =

'"

tit) 0

~

~

Q)

Q)

C

0 ~

~

.. ~

0

Q~

~

c"'~~

~"'

o",o

Q)u

~8","'~

0 ~

""Q)-!.

~."""'8~

't.+3.'"

C..Q

~

~

C

~

C

-Q)

C

>.""

..Q)

~.c

08'-5

.~

=

-; ~

0

~

~

~

t e

~

~

-S

~

~0

C

~

~

0 Q

) -~

0. Q

) .,;

Q)

Q)

~Q

) ~

~

~-"'""'O

Q

~~

",tit) ","",..0

Q)

;>

'" ~

0

'" 0

Q)

'" ;>

~

~

.~

~

~ ::§]

~]

~

~ ~

§ .§ .~

..s .§ 1

~s ~

~I'

~~

-fo ~

] ~

~

]

~

] g

~

.~ ~

f..E

I: §

q) S

~

::2

0. ~

~

.>

[~

~

.\3 ~

'0

e. g:J.

q) §

g ~

5

~

.~

~

0 ~

e

: -s

§ ~

-o

,., ~

.r; e

u ~

~

~

.s

8 I:

q).~

..r::..=

d q)

U

q) ~

..r:. 1:0

.:- ......~

U

q) ...cu...

..~ ---

..0::2

'~

°..r:. 8

-q)::2 bO

>

...C

U

o..r: C

U

"'... I:;

U

I: """

-.~

~

~..r:

CU

U

...

~

~:.g.~

:~]

8.] ~

~

'§ '0 ..g ~

~

.§..E

8 i ~

]

.~.~

1.

~

..s e .c s

i ~

-E

rtJ; ~

~ .~

5

~~

"' l:do.l:;"'."'~

'" I:

"",q)CU

dl:;'"

~~

...I

."'... C

U

ObO

UI:

><

~

I:

~.s

0 I:;

>-

0 ~

~

q)

>-

::2 -s .o..r:

bo I:;

0 .~

~

~

~

::2 ~

I:

~

0 S

,~

.r;

...~

~

I:~

bo

8 ~

...U

~

I:

'" 0

::2 '8 ~

0

q) q)

...t: 8

~

.r;..o q)

bo .c..r:.

0 U

~

C

U U

C

U ...C

U

...~

::2 -§

~

t §

~

~

U

q) 0.

~

~

g. ~

~

;;;

~

~

~

~'v;

S

~

."'~

~

0 '0

.g §

..0 :E

r:;;-

8 s]

~

..8"(; u

::2.§ U

I:;

-S

:::;. -S

e ~

C

U ..r:. ~

~

5

§ ~

t:

~

5:;JJ 13 ;::;-

g '0';

t: 0

'V;"(;

0 ';;\

q) I:

""

~

~

~"bb

8 '~

'O

u ~

~

'0

8 0

.g,~

0 §

'"'oJ"(; t

S

~

'"'oJ :3 ~

';;\

'C

...t:",,"" .0

~

t: --S

.9

§-"

",..r: t:

~

'" -0..=

>

- t:

'" ~

S

U

~

t:

CU

~ .=

~

-:3

t: C

U ~

~

q)

q) ~

,~

'...

~

0"' ~

~

I:

d..r:"E

t: ...0

:..=

'- t:

0q)

~

q) C

U..r:.

0 U

:3 ""

t: ..c

~

eo'" 0

U

...0

S

t: '"

0. t:

0 1:;...

0 ."'...

cu !::;'.'"

u ---bo.-

'" t:

0 q)

~

cu t:

S

t: q)

cu

t: ",.9

~

~

cu'~

~

8 §

.~

~

:a 5:

~

~

~

~

e 'E

~

§

~

~'c

'~

-; .9

~.g

~

0 -g

-¥ .~

.~

~

-g

.., .~

0.

; ~

~

q)

q) q)

cu"5 0

-0. >

- 0

q) q)

q) _0

'= ::t::0

~

~

t ~

.~:3

~:3

==

:==

>-..s

0:3-"

dCU

>"'-

dOU

O

t:..r:."'---o. ...'"

-"-t:---"""0 0"""q)~

1...:::J 0

§ ~

~

!: ~

0:-9 -g

E

a N

~

cu t ~

.co0 ~

s

~

« ""

cu 0 .r; ~

~

S .c

-S

q) ~

9:.~

~~

q)'"

-q) ,.

q) ~

'" cu 0

...'"' "'..0"'"

;>

q);>

It:"" "'

cu ..r:

~

-~,~

'":t

S

~

~

'" e- ~

-=

.. ;L

~

.9 ~

~

'v; 0

e g ~

..o cu ~

~..r:.9

; o:-a -&

'i ~

'" E

'" ~

S

~

C~

0

cu... '"

'" u~

- """...

~:3

'" cu

.00:3 cu t...

...0-:3~

"""1:; cu q)...:..=

.i; '"

bo 0. t: q) .r; 00 0

q) e- q) ;> cu '8 ...~

~

'"

0 cu ~

...cu "'.9-

~ q)

cu 0 ~

8..r:. U

cu

E

-g.~

~ 'R

~

:a ~

~

~

] §:5

~

~

~

..s -t ~

1]

.s .; '"';; §

~ ~

-5 ]

,s g ~

;

§ S

~

~

~

~5

cu""5 ~

S

0

g. c=

.r; t:

cu U

c=

C

~

~

e ':

g ~

~

8

~

..s.!i. '"

~

0. ~

bo -g

S

8 8

<

-S

U

Q.

'd ~

6

:3 ~

'"

~

.3 .~

""

cu ~

:..=

S

.~

cu q) <

.=

q) cu

bo t:

q)I

q)"" ...""

~

'" u"'"

q) q)

0"'<

'r; t:

...~

t: ~

'C

~

~

~

'"

cu.E

!oJ' ..0 -S

:-u

q)..r: ~

..r: cu..r:

:9 t:

~

~.a..c

-d.a cu

~

a.i ~

-S

...'C

:3

~

cu :3

0 <

-, ~

0

~

cu q)

cu '"

~

---q) 0

U

~...

'0 U

<

.=.c

cu ~

q)

cu t:

0 .~

:3

...I:~

:;:

~~

~

~

8

S

.~,~

~

g;

5 :J.

'0 ~

~

~

§

-:0"' go:o

e §

-a. '0

5 ~

>

- ~

---~

[~

-5 'C

:

~

~

-g g

g:t

~

1:;::2.'" U

q)

-.to ...

r:3

~

..."' ;>

.~

00 .=

'V;

q) I:;

q) cu

...'" S

;>

cu

cu cu'"

0 ~

U

~

~:J."E

g

~

-s ~

.~

'"

:: ~

g

~

g...8 ~

.\3 ~

;;. ;

~

; ~

§

~

§ S

~

}; ~

:-9 ~

~

~

U

~

~

~

.~

5 i S

":~ .~

': -s 1

.E]

E a 1

£. ~:§

t:] -0. ci ~

'§. § ~

-5 ~

5 ~

..s "" .!i. ~

2 ~

-; ~

~

E.'C

~

~

"(; ~

I-F

t

~

8 ...q)

.r; ~

t:

:3 ~

'"

~

0 q)

~~

cu

..r:..=

>

?: ...q)

~

5 ~

-S

>

'"

t: ~

'" ...~

, ~

~

'- -'"

.cu ."'."'q)."'-;>

- -1

-"'" '"'~

~

S

~

cu..r: ::2

U

"CU

~

d cu

~

q) t:

0 ~

U

~

r~

...>

.~

...cu cu

~

~

~

..« .~

t

U

q) ~

.~

0

t: 0

~

:..=

q) U

U

-cu

I:; U

...0

q) ...v

cu ""..0

cu -U

0.

..0 '"

I e

S

~

t: ..r:

...~

cu U

~

.§.[.SO

~

~

j

s..s ..s

~S

~

.g

t .&

~

.g

e §

~.~

~

'0

~:&

-g

}; ~

:s g

.~

cu §

i ~

,~

5 ]

b =

Q. -S

~.!i.

~ ~

~

.~

8 .5

~ ~

.~

-S

q) ~ ~

-d' .r; :..=

.5"(; §

2 ~

cu -g

S ,~

~

S

.~ ~

.cCU

.§ ~

~

~

:..=

.:

I ...0.

to' ~

..r:.

q) :3

q) U

q)

...'... ~

0

...50 q)

,=

bo 0

-cu ~

~

=

=

~

S:..=

.~

.5

-g ~

0:3 ~

~

~

a.!:l.

~

.~

~

..0 ~

t

t::-=

1 -E

~

.s""

t' ~

.c

<

s:..=

S

g ~

q)

cu q)

q) 0

.r; ~

0

0 q)

t: 0

cu t:..o

0 q)

:3 o..r:

0 d

0:3 ..r:..'"

0 q) ..0

..r:. d

'"..r: ~

~

U

:3 S

0. bo ~ ~

cu ~

~

U -0

0 ...U

~

.r; 0. t:

I:; o..~

... >

... ...0

cu '" I:; ~

000...,

0\0

Page 4: Bioethics as Politics

11uco0.""

00

-0

?i 0

~

-sIIJ

~

~

~~

..B

.~~ 0.

~

.,g;J

~'"

0 E

..., co

~

-S~

5

'" ~

...~0

>;

~ ~

V)

Z

""-0-~

~=

Q

bO

0IIJ

=-0

Z

=Z

~

co

'" C

O..c

~

E

co=

.~

0'"

'" u

'0 :.E

~

-0 ~

~~~;:~'t1~0~~0:;?~~

..c=

bI) .,; '" ~

v

0...>-

~c=

~C

=~

..c=

~

.~

~..c=

.-~

0

~

~ ..d

",""">..c=

._~~

~

.E~

O"'~

.D..c=

o--;..:'

c=.-c=

", ,~

o~",...~

~~

~I

~O

~C

="""=

~~

.

~~

...~

~~

O=

,~-bI)

,~

...0

~

0 0

~

c=~

'"

u ...c=

~

-U..d..d.~

b ~

~

u~

u

u ~

v ~

0.

'" ~

0'"~=

' ~

~

'"

0...'"

~

-~

~

~

'"...c=

=

' 0

><

~

'" ..c=

-~

~

00 "'..c=

~

~

U

.~

~

~

""".-0'" ~

~"'.-O

~",.~

...v"'~O

e'" "O

~C

=.D

...e~..c=

~

c='"

0 ~

..d ~

=

~

.~

~

=

a ~

'" ~

bI)~

'" ~

-~

=

' =

~~

,-~

-~~

"'o =

~""""'~

--"'~u

0...>

"""..c=",~

~..du~

~~

~

~

...=

u

~

",...~bI)

O._""""~

"'~c=

'm

...bI)

0. ",..d

=

v >

- ~

~

~o~

=,=

'~t,...",

o.-=

0.

~

'" ...~

0

...~

--;.E

u~

~

0"'.'"

='"0

~

'"' c=

...",...>

~.D

"'o

...v .-~

~

-"'..c=

"" u

:-a e

=..g

v'" t-",900"-g

=' ~

~

,- ..."""

~

c= '"

c= ~

\.Q~

..c= ~

~

~

0 -E

5~"'r;.~

8.s..g'5~5

~..d

~;.=

: ~

e

~

=.D

.- ~

-E

E

~

e ~

...=

' ..:-

~

.-~

I~

=

~

~

~.a>

0~

=~

.D~

~~

v...~tie"""8~

=e6:J.

~...v~

-..:- >

-~bI)O

...~

=

.D

0. ~

~

~

...u ~

'm

=~

~

0~

u..c=

~

v

'" =

,.- ~

~

"'.;:""O"'U

.-U~

0 ~

...'"

'... ~

'" '"

'... ...~...~

~~

o=

~~

-E..c=

~~

~

~

v-,., ~

~

~

bI)

...u~

'"

=

='

-..d ~

0.-0

v=

'"

.-0"'" ...u"""

;,=:~

u..c=o-~

o:.E

~..g

u '"

c=

'" ...~

o.~

0

0c=

~",.-

"'~"""O

~

.-~

~

=

=

>

,- ~

...=

..c=..d

~~

~'-O

o~

-0"'...

~~

~...,...

~e~

""~~

.- """~

v ~

v-0

", v...v~

...-~

'"

~

~

0 ~

..d =

,~

-~

~--;oO

'~~

f--~ti!:::!.~

I I

"""""'4)"'..~.£

.~"-;

-:3.- :3

O..t:.!:!

4) U

~

-4) 0

'" S

t:

..t:.tj~

0

t:.- t:

>.

'" t:

~

uo.~

0

~

0.&J:3

0 e

10. ~

~

~

.~

t: ~

0

~~

""""".""""""'.4)

-i!J

>'o!:!

e"""'>.£

4)~..t:

~

~

u-o.o.-t: bO

u""

0~

>

'" t:e~

-4)-S~

~

"1j.- ...4)

~e

..t:~

""",...t:

o U

X

0.~0~

4):3_0:3 t::3

~

4)U

.&J.tj

0. U

~e

'" ~

e:3"'

e~

U

'" ~

~

0 -t:

>

~

><

0-<

"1j

t: 0

0 0

~.~

0"1j

~0

~

""""'.-U_-

-0

~.~

",,""0"':3 ~

~

~

~

~

~':::0."1j0

t

""""'" ~

>

- 0

O!:.

"'0O

!:! O

.S

0 lot: t:;>

0

~0.0.

~

'" Q

.""","1j"i

~~

-S~

", ~

><

...

e~

.- ~

.&

J ~

e.tj

'" ~

...t""t: ~

""

~~

:1.-

~.-

:3 0.

~

~

.~

'"-'"

-.&J

~

~

-0. t:

~

"'~

-"">..t:.&

J><

00

~

~

~

g .0

~

~

~

~

~

~

.tj

:I: 0

e.~

rn

.~

--S

0.~

~

"'"1j

>U

~

e.;;

r:; t:0

t:~

>.

U'"

0~

:3

'" ~

~

>

<

0 :3'"

E~

"'.-

e~

e~

et:

~

~

~

Uo...~

~

o..t:..t:U

bO>

.~

00

~._""""~

"'"1j 0.0

~

-S

~:=

: t:"2"1j.:I;e.~

e

~'"

t:"1j .~

t:.=

~

'S

~

r:;

-<

~t:"'..t:0.~

~~

C'

""",'"

~:3

t '"

", ""

~

t:~U

bO

0 .-4)

~e"-;

0 -""

0 e

:2 t:

t:;: :3eO

~

U~

~

~

t: 0

~

~

>'""bbO

e..t::-2e.'c:-s ~

-s

O"i:t:U

"">

~~

bO..t:t:

-~.-

-bO

t: ~

t:

e~

CQ

"1j

'" ~

t:

~

"'.- .=

~

'"

~

.t: ~

~

.:a ~

.S

eo.>

~.-

~~

:3""

e'O

9~

~e=

~

U:3

0 0

~

~ -'..-

,.~

'S

O 0 =

t:

~

-0.0. t ~

~

e ~

~

0 0 -s

~..t:

t:"1j"1j"1j '8

~uU

'"

~

~

0 ~

~

'0

.~

e 0

0 ~

-t: ~

>

. ~

'i1

..t: ;>

:3

bO ~

-S"1j

0. ~

"1j .-~

bbt:..tbO~

u t:

~-S

t: .9

~

= ..t:

~.s

~

0 ~

'. -

~.~0~~,...'".~~~.~"-~~~~C

',...'".~'"c3

is~~u~~is

6 6

ci.6 "'-;q).,..!.

>-bD

'C

=-'=

6

q) ~

~

~

.~

Q..~

g

~

6 0R

~

~

.S

,~~

'C

6

-g O§

~-S

Q

. ~

C

~

'O

f" q) 0

q) u'"

q) ..6

0~

q)N

~§~

": .-oQ

.Q.d~

~~

~

-'=q)

:c g.~

d'M

0

Q.

q).~

6 0

<I::

~

-,=-,=

~

0

,~~

~

:-:=

~

x

~ ..c

-o';j q)

q) bl)

q) ~

u

:>>

- >

~

~

~

q)

-eo No

-0 ~

u

~

-'=

~o'~

~

~

q)

...~

-""q)

N""

-P

o~

~

,=

>

- ~

~

~

0

='

Q..=

'2

0 U

-0

~

.~

~

q)_..Q~

dq)NO

-a~~

"" '~

"'~""'=

'~

..;" 'q)-o

'" ~

-'=

~

u ~

bl)

q) ~

~

q)

q) 0

0

~~

~q)~

q)"":'=c~

-o""~~

~

='>

..."'"~

0

~

~

" ~

~

0

q) ;

0 ...q)

""';j ~

~

~

~

~

.~

~

-;

~

~

-; 'q)

§ 5

>

~.9..Q

bD

Q.

q) .;

'" q)

~

'" '=

6

q) -0

~

t -0

~

§ ~

~

§

'q) ~

~

] ~

'0

.~

~

-g 6

'C

; -;

'~"3

'" ~

';j

-S

-S

~

Q

~..9

'" 0

~

'" '0

..0

~"""~

Q.:I:I

~""oooo""uq)q)"""'u

~

t -d

..U

...q) ~

'"

--0 .-q)

~ oq)

~~

::

'q) '0

~.=

~

.~

-a 6

~

~

q) .9:-.2..

-'=

=~

-"~

q)'-"'-""~U

"'...

';j ..Q

0

'" ~

~

Q

. q)

='

-0 ~

bD

~

~

a 8

~

~

.~

-a ~

bD

'O

0' ~

a

0 'c.=

~

g

bO

0 -0

q) £

~

'" o';j

-; '60

t- 0

Q..~

b

~~

';j ~

.u;

-'=

.a '0

.9 ~

~

"":'=

6

'" '"

~

~

", 'C

'(!

'0 'q) I--

~

~

~

~

§ 8.';j

'O"'E

.~

g

~

~

'C

§

.~

a. 6

>

~.

.~

8 =

' ~

~

';j

Q.

'0 0

'O'C

d

~

q) ~

U""-q)-,=

",q)O'..~

=,O

O

6q)~~

"""q)q)::E

0

-; 6.~

~

~

q)..e

'0 ~

q)

~

bD ~

>

~

~

~

..

='

~

0 ~

,-

->

-0 '"

'" -'=

=

' ~

q)

'" 0

'" t;

~

'" ~

b

~

';j 6

q) -~

0"-

~

-'=

't;- ~

U

0

~

~

O""

U

'" ~

~.=

~

u-o'=

~~

"""" ~

~-o

~0

q) ~

0

q) d

~.-

q) ~

~

... 0

0 ""

q) -0

='

~

, ~

~

~

=

' q)

~

q) ~

~"'2

§q) e-'o

-; -;

'0 '0

E

-tj ..::::

~

'q) --g

§ -S

'q)

~

~

ti

..Q

'" U

...s

..>

~

bD

'... q)

0 .-~

=

' d"""

~

.."" d

.-U

O

0-"" ~

""oq) ~

:d 6

~

~:I

d =

; :

6 >

- -£

-0 .~

~

6

~

U

'C.5

q)bl)

q) q)

q) ~

'"

0 ~

~

=

' 0

~

0 ::

q).- ~

:Q's

~

~

-;; -S

~

:"§ ~

q)

~

~

6 ~

~

'0

U

~

~

~

u ~

",..."",,"""""~

~q)

:>

" ._q)~

'"

~

~

~

='

-'0 -'"

,=:'

Q}

-U

q) ...~

q)

0 '"

~

q).-~

c

~

-; ~

~

U

~

~

~

-S

6

='

-S

'" ~

>

'"

~

-£ -0

~

~

::!... E

,=

~

'2

-d' 5

-e. '0

~

8 0

-; 9

~~

'§ ~

q) ~

..QN

-o >

Q

.~~

" ~

U

"" ~

~

~

q) >

-~

,=

~

~

~

8

';j q)

8 ~

-a ~

'C

~

~

I-.

'... ~

-'=

~

~

bD.=

-N

~

q)

U

-q) -0"3

0 Q

} -'=

d

a -0

""-I--

~

~

[ ~

6

t: ,~

gf'

~

q) 0'-

~

.~

~

~

~

~

~..Q

6 .-r---

'" ~

..c -Q

. "..

,~

~

'" q)'-

q) cIS

=

'

.-U

'Of"

.-Q.

0 '",

0 ~

>

~

cIS

u

C

~

-0.

...:"":-OU

~U

UboC

chC-O

U-o

u""-o~...:'u~

1: ~

5 ~

~

-S

.5

§ -S

-0

'0 ~

~

~

:09...

; ~

~

~

~

5

~

~

~

..c=u-:>

..c=

~

...'" ~

'

..c=

.;=

~

bl)

SS

5

"'..c=.~

~~

...~~

u ""t:~

"'S~

""'-~bl)

c=

0 "",~

-c...c=

0

u u""

0 ~

c=

~

u

u ...'"

-0 bl)""~

-g

-0 ~

~

~

S

S

-0

-0 ~

~

~

~

.~

~

c=

o.~

..c!'

~~u--.~ 0

0'"

u"'- bl)

u ou

.~

~

~

,. >

- ~

.-'"

£ ~

...u.o..c=

u

-u..c=.-

~

~~

'"'-~u"'~

'"'~

=

.- bl)

..c",u~

..c=o,,::c=

~

~c=

~

...~c=

o '-;::>

~'-~

~"':.E

~bl)

=

0 1-.":

0.- ~

"t ~

0"

~

u 0

bl)'" ..c=

~

:>

'c

'-..c=

~

~

~

'" :>

0- -S

:>0- ~

c=

'"

~

g ~

.-~

.~

.~

0

c=

"- c=

bl)

u ""..c=

-0

.':0"- '"

u c=

... ...!:'

S

~..c=

~

u

>-.~

0 0

'C

a u

><

0'-

c=

>

0 u

u bl)..c=

~

u

='5

u ~

~

,~

E

~

c=

~

'-..

~

'5 ~

:i.

~

e ~

'0

.s ~

~

~

~~

..c=bl)u"'U

c.o<.l:>

;"':~

""o..c=

",Uu

0 -0

::: 'C

..c=

,~

~

S

":: .-::=

~

-0

8 :=

c=

~ '"

~

~

'0 c=

~e

c=

~

u I

c=

0 o.~

-0

~

-0 ~

-bl)

0 c=

'cU

0

~

0 ~

~

:I ..c=

.t

u u

~

8 '0

c=.:.o

.; ..,;

.~

":: ~

..c=

>-~

>

'"

~c=

""- ""O

...c=

o.~,"",,-O

~U

""""~-;~

"2°

"u ~

0...;;;;

c=

.-c. ~

S

U

."i >

- c=

U

u

~

~

u..c=0

'"-""

0 ~

'"

c. 0

u ~

c.

u u

,-"" ...

'0 .g

'5 ~

~

~

~:::

~

~

~

'0 '0

~

-S

S

--a. ~

:c

~

~

~

~

~

~

.~

~~

--a.~2

~~

.SO

I--. §~

s-o~

s'~~

-;;~:;;

g..c~.]

<

QJ

0 0

~.~

u

~

c=

'" "::

0 ~

;

't;- 8

0 -S

u

c=

u ~

u

~uU

o"";=

-"'U'"'U

'" .__fol::O

:>

~

oC

="""c.

""'-""U'--

0 ~

U

""0

,- C

='"

t 0

u..c=

~

-; S

&

~

,-

c=

c=

u 0

"'~

0 ...'0

-0 .9

g:=

'0 c=

~

,~

t

c=

~

~

S.£'

0 ~

-g

~

g .E

~

~

§ 'cU

u.~

~

~

0

"-08

,- -g

~

S

c=

..~

u .~

.-~

bl)'-':'

o>~

u

c=~

~

-o u..c=

:>o-t;

=

c=-

"- "::

'" u

~

c=

0 '0

..c=

C

~

0 c=

'cU

""~

.':o ~

~

u

.,- 00

:i. g

~

-S

Z

~

:>

c..g ~

'0

1:: ]

~

~

~

~

-; :

~

=

-5 ~

~

~-

", O

C

=

"""L.O~

c=

bl)

0 "'8

~

:.E

,~

'"; ~

~

~

'"

~

~

,- =

0

~

r- U

0

0 -

1:1 c=

~

~

'0""

>

~

Ofol::

~

u 8"0

o.~

u S

S

..,; u

~",.o

'61>.-

~

~

~

0 ~

S

...S

u'o

~

u c=

...c.

>-

\0-S

c=

u

0 .-0

.-":: =

-g

0 >

- c=

-0

c=

.c=

0 g

~

~

0

.;.- ~

<

;

U

QJ

u~

"'=

U

~

o<~

0"::

~

c=

""

~~

1::rJ!"_~S

~>

<c=

c."'~-S

8~u-9""~

~~

>-""

",'>

t" c.'2

'0 u

~

S

~

0 U

~

..c=

' ~

~

"'"-u

c=

~

5 ~

"- ,~

"... '.'J

,- u

U

QJ

0 -0

S

0 ~

'0

[ 0"

u ~

~

'0"0 0.0

~

rJ' S

~

-S

-S

~

g

~

~

S

8 S

u

-;..:a ~

:I~

Z

~

>

~

.c:: c=

-~

~

-0

c=

.-~

~

~

~

~

-0 0"'2

5 >

.-u

~

u .5

~

~

S

~

-0 e

; ';;;

..s ~

=

-5

's 'cU

~

.8

~

S

.5 <

~

'0

..c=..c=

~.-

,_C=

o ""

'"'~

c=U

""-""U

.,""L.

,~

U

z '"

0 c=

"3 ~

c=

0

...U

L. ~

S

0

-; '-..c=

~

.~

'-..c=..c=

ubl)~>

-"'u",...~uu

r-~uu

~""u~

:>

L. ..c=

,-

...u u

~

U

QJ

'" u..c=

Q

J Q

J 0

0 ~

ct;

r oc.~

...",._~

o ~

", oo~

-

0..."" ~~~

Page 5: Bioethics as Politics

u >

.~

'" "'-

d ~

~

U

I ~

~

c=

~

~,~

- ~

~

,~

~

~

~

~

0 ,~

~

~

c=

~

~

~

'"

0 ~

~

U

c=

-u ,~

- ~

""..0

~

~.c=

" ~

c=

0

'" ..c=

.~

0 ~

,9

-g .r:.

.g ,9'.c=

§

~

0 S

~

';.c=

~

g

~

~

'=

0 ~

~

~

~

g

~

'c .,g .a

: Q

().d ,5

,5 ~

~

~

b1>

,E~

.C

I!..o '" >

0

9: ~

'c ~

~

"9

Q()

~

~

~

u >

<'"

~

~~

""-L."C

=""~

.c=

...~

-"""~-~

!=;

u ~

'"

~

Q()

~

r- -,~

'c

0 ~

,~

0

0 u

~

'~~

u

~

'r:. ~

c=

"""' ~

~

.d ~

~

u"'"

0 ~

.d.c=

c=

0 ~

~

2

;~

,~

~

~

~

~

~

u

Q()

-~

"'.c=

'" ~

~

~

-0

s.~

J,g

g §:.2

..0 ~

~

,~

~

..s

'~'O

8.'~

:i. ~

~

fj,~

;]

~

~~

~

u

u ~

~

~

~

,=

..0 0."""'"

Q

'~'"

t 0

~

~

~~

u

0~

,~

0

0.0

~

~

~

°.c=

~

.~

~

~0

0...'r:.

>

c=

0."'" ~

~

~

Q

() U

cn -~

0. ~

'"

-'"

~

~

~

,~

~

~

~

0 ..0

0' '>

0

Q

,~

~

~

~

~

0 v

'" ~

0 ~

~

,~

.c=

S

~

Q

t

~

,~

~

e"'" ~

u.c=

,~

0 ~

~

'0

~

0. ~

.c=

,~

.~

~,~

0

:>

e Q

>

. ~

0

Q

~

'r:. c=

-..::::

0 0

~

~Q

~~

~oo~

'r:.~,~

~Q

:Eu'~

'~"2~

~""=

oo",0

~

~

-~

~

Q

",.g ~

Q

.g ~

~

~

~

~

"O

U

0. I:Q

~

.~

Q

() ~

'" 0

u~

~~

.c=

~

~

U

~

U

0 Q

c=

c=

0

~

c=;>

Q

'"

I::~

~

:>

c=

~

U

u;.:=

~..c~

0

><

~

~

~

~

..~

,~

~

~

~

c=>

..;>

0

~,~

O

'~

0. ~

'"

~

~

~

o..c=

--~

.!:;' 0

°:..a

~

'c ~

~

~

0

~

c=

~

0. ~

'<

'J ~,~

'<

'J"Q.

~

0 Q

()0

,5 ~

..o ~

'c

,""~

~

;>",

~Q

""~

~~

~Q

Q

~

~

co~~

~

0

Q()

~

,~o.

~'~

>

. ...~

~

~

>

,~

~

~

-Q

~

>

;>~

~

..o 'c

~

~

Q

~

~

e"Q.

e"'3 ~

0

'c 0

~

0 e"'Q

) 0

~

~

~f-"

..0co ~

>

.'~

0 .c=~

d

., u,~

U

~

~

'"

~

~..o.c=

0

-,~

~~

-,~

",.~

(j ,g

-fo..s ":S

'c £

'iU '0

-g t

'm

t t

g, ~

] "'~

~,~

§

>.

~

~

~

~

!=;

>,~

c=",~

t

o~~

.c=co",O

~Q

Q~

'm=

~

o;':=-~

S

,9

': ~

~

~

~

>

. ~

~

~

o.,~

e..o,~

,9

'<'J '0

~

~

~.c=

~

,~

'" co

~

~

o.,~

~

~

~

~,~

u

~.~

U

~

O

',~

~

'" c=

0 =

~

0.

~

~,~

t

t..o ~

~

.c=

~

~

co ~

U

~

~

'"

~

c=

,~"',~

..d ~

""-""""""-Q

()o

'~~

~

Q

"".c='"

:>

~

~

-..0 Q

"O

Q

~

>

x... ~

"0

~

--; >

. '...

~

co .(

;>e~

"'~~

,...Q~

"" e'~

-"u"" ~

-"",-,~

(3 'iU

~

~

3

g '"

,~

~

e ~

:i. ';

§ ~

'g

-g :

'<'J Q

g

g; ~

Q ~

~

~

-~

~

0 ~

'm

~

~

Q

() ~

Q

-~

Q

co co

t: ~

~

~

~

0

~

~

~~

""Q

()~"'~

""~'~

C=

~-~

UO

->

~»<

"'~

~

!;:j ~

~

~

Jf'~

..o ~

0

~

r£ U

~

U

-d"O

Q

~

b

~

0 ~

~

ci'.a

t0

~,~

,~

U

~

>.

~

~:=

~

~

E

:5 0 ~

~

,~

0 '"

~

~

~

0. ,9

~~

"'8~

~.2c=

;~..80:'§.0

.c=~

~~

s2..s0~~

t~'O

.0 fj

~

cu 0

Q

e U

~

~

'"

c=

~,~

~

'"

o..s.g0

1:) ~

~

'/1 Q

()~

c=

>

d o~

~

~

Q

..~

~

:-=

s

~

'" '"

~

ffi ~

tn

,~

'r:. 3

~

~

0 'c

~

g 0

~

~

'=

0 Q

~

~

S

Q

cn ~

c=

~

~

U

~.c=

~

c=

~

~

0.

-~

~

,~

,~

'" ~

~

0

U

~

>.

2 ~

I: rl ~

80

'0 jg;' ~

80

'0 -it.go

5 ~

1

] ~

~

~

,~

§

~

~

] ~

"'~

",~Q

()~

""'~'~

~"'U

""-"'O

oo.~"""

~

~..s

c= ~

.c=

'c

.2 :

~

U

6'b ~

'r:.

c=

~.=

,~

u,~

~

c=

~

;>

co v

0 f-

~

d ~

,5

~

~

~

co ~

~

~

~

..o ~

~

U

,~

; §

§ ~

":S

~

..s '0

~,~

,~,~

[..s..s..s

..s ..s

'0 ~

'0

~

>-

O.d

tIi v"o

=

.!. =

>

- v

~

~0

V

V

~

,!" =

v

~'"

rJ!' v v

~

v =

~

~

"O

~

>-

v ...:-

O~

v

b/)(U

uv.d=

v "".d..c"'

", ""~

""""'O~

="O

~-

..c""

~(U

~~

v"'~>

o .d=

~",.~

""",(U",

00 (U

o.d~~

""j;J(U"o",

o-._v

""80 ""'-""zj

0\ ~

~

=

u

"Ov

~

=u=

,(U=

"'C

v",'" ""'3.-(U

~"'~

~=

0\ ..i

~

~

~

~

g -5

:i, ~

~

~

~

1

~

's 0

~

's ~

:E

~

s>

n l 'S

[

~

.d .s

U

~

§ ~

s

.g ~

.s ~

~

~

.~

-3 8

~

v =

~

~

..s.~

§ ~

~

~

~

8

~

.E..s

; 'ih

~

~

.~

~

~

-5 '0

~

~

g ~

~

;] §

'" ~

~

'"

u.- ~

S

(U

'"'

0:=

v v

~

;>.-

~

(U -I

.d 0

...='

=

='...

u0

::e I.;.zj

(U

~

0 u

~

=

~

~

c. 0

~

5 =

v

S

>-

~

§ =

.9-

c 0

"'"g:.a v

~

<

~

I-i0

.d~...u'"'u

.d"'.--Oo=

o",.->",v",

.-""V

o~""""",=

Uo(U

'"'~

~

§.~

8 8.

>-.=

- ~

,~

~.'?;;-];

S

~

=

=o..s

g ~

~

~

:::..s g

"E

~

S

~

~

g ~

5.d

~..E

,E

~

..."""' V

u>

~b/).-~

";::'" "'~

-=,!-to'-~

o .d",o

!-t"""""'(Uo

t ~

=

' >

-.d.s..s.zj 0

='

~

~

.s .~

..c .~

::r:.2

0 ~

0'

~

C

~

~

-; >

-.0 u

~

~.~

g

I -,

v .;;;

~

-fa].~

5 ~

'C

£

5: ~

..s c9; ~

'i

t ~

.s:;;;

0 :

.a ~

§:a

.0 ~

.R

5

Jg ~

] v

~

.g <

.::

~

~

15.2.s g.E

-3

t .g

~

~

~

~;g

§..s ~

~

:a

] :]

~

:e .~

~

: .§

~

~

~

~..;

~]

8 -1:i

g-t''"

.::. =

' b/)

0 .~

..s

>

~

E::

...~"o

5 ,~

~

~

~

.0..:'=

=

~

=

...(U

=

u v

='

(U

>-

00~

...

.(U

o._""'" "-~

0..~(U

,,,~;>

;>

.d ~

v

v=c...

~=

'

~

~

0 ~

-;.s

~.~

~

g

~0=

~

S..c..s

~

~

£ ~

.~

.~

~

~

"O

IJJ' t

§ ~

.:

(U

~

~

~

~

~

'0 :

z cv""o~

-'" ?--

vo~

=

~

0 (U

._",=,"",

"0 ~

v "'0"'0.d

=~

:--=

~

~

~

;>

~

~

~

~

u.d

u ~

.~

0 ~

=

..c ~

~

=

' (U

:'==

=

~

~

:--=

~0

'" 0

~

~

v::>

(U

~~

vuo..

="'~

~

=

""O

(U

"""'O=

(U

.-v"O

=

"O-~

",~

0 ...=

' b/).;;:;

.>

.zj .0

0 '"

-.~

~

,- -5

S

~

.v.zj '"

-5 ~

"o v

0 ~

v'"

:'.- ~

o.~

0

u ~

;;;' ..g

c9; -g

S

~

~

.s ~

.ih

-; c.

~

'0 ~

.; =

-?

~

Q

="~

~

;.zj

._,..s

'0 ~

5

~

=

s>n

g -fa

~.E

o ~

u ~

v.~

O

.d 0...

0 ~

~

v

0 >

- U

v

==

=

' v

~

~

.~.::.

~

c c

e ~

=

' '"

'" =

' =

' v

b/)

::2 u..s,~

u

u ~

0..

""bb"""" ~

~

...]

'" ~

v

8 tIi

<

c =

,.- ~

(U

~

.o b/)

v 8

='

~

0 ti..s

~f-'

u ~

C

~

..I: -;

0 ~

-;>

,2:!

~

~'"

~

v 6b

~

v ~

e

; 0

tIi..s v

zj"O

~

b/) 0

C

v ,-

~

~.-

,- 0

u... ~

~

~

b/)

~

.-tIi C

""bb"O

~..I:

'" ,-

b/) 0

C

v u

='

v ~

.c.-

C

0.. ,-

"0

~

"0 v"o

.zj ~

=

' v

'c ~

... c

>

rJ!' c

(U

c ,=

- u

~..:

...b/) 0

~

c ~

,~

'"

~

(U..s

0"0 c-

0 ",

u_",c -~

~

g.- ...cu~

.- .,.b/),-

oo_,

u.....c

>'-""vv~

~-~

'" v

~

-~o(U

V'-i:E

~"'o~

=>

<

(U"""""'O

,-- ~

~

~

~

c ~

~

:E.

c b/)

='

~

"0 ~

=

' 0

0.- v

v -;

...0.. ~

C

>

- ~

~

~

v

;>..1:

~

~

0

i:=

t 's

,S

; 5

'~

'0 .g

'g ~

g]

~

~

'0 8:::

C~

"8.f:' E

t

~

.g -[

~

1 't

~

~

s ~

; ~

~I

~ rJ!'

~1=

v

~

'" "'~

:.=

=

>-

~

c ci.

>-

~

-~

v 0

~

0 ~

'Q

j"..I: 0..

'" v:C

~

"O

~.d

>-

~

~

v 0

~

~..g

~

§ 8

"v ~

-:.

0.. ~

r-::]

~'~

-g

5 ~

g

[ ~

';--

-s ~

~

'0

,.g :§1J ~

~

£ §

~

--5 ~

i'~

~

~

~

~

>-

C

.zj 5

~

.a ~

;

-; ~

~

'-0

c9; s>

n ~

>

v v..s

e C

.d ~

e

"""'V

v ~

~

.d

='

C

'c ~

..c g

Q

--0 0

='

~

,- v,...

-='

0 ~

>

- Q

~

V

..Q

(- 0

,- v

0-

~

~

t'~

5 ~

.5 ~

~

] ;

~

~

~]

~

~

-; .E

E

',~

~

:E

~

-5 -.8

~

==

~

"O

~

Q

.~

oh ~

::§..s

~ .'?;;-

~

z ~

v ~

~~

tco...,~"O

o~v(

~._~

>"O

.d.~>

-C~

"'5c~~

c",~

eov

~

",-=""",

"O'-~

-c=",-'"

0 "'",v~

""-cooO""-~

'-""

0 "":1

~

~

e 0'

C

's ~

=

S

'c

'~.s

(U

>-

~

"0 "tIi

C

8 0

(U..s

~,~

~

~

.zj

e o..,~

~

~

::]

5"'2 ~

~

a

"I'

~o

8 ~

.g

~

0 .;;

"3 <

~

""..2:! ~

§"3

~

.9 -;

: ~

C

;

~

'0 ,§

~

...:'.5 2

(- ~

,~

~

S

~

5 ~

~

~

o~U

"'.dOv"O

"'" "'0

,- .-,_.d_-"'u",,-

._U",b/)"O

,-

='

e:i, e

.~

~

8 ~

.d

~

'a 8

~

~

~

0 -=

Q

v

go,s '0

";; .E

.:i?:

s ,

~

~

g. ~

-g

~

~

~

r::::-,~

,- '0

~

0 ~

"O

(- '"

=

,~

(U

0.. v

'v; c9;

~

~

v"O"'C

0

;>

C

.~

~

t -=

v

"'"0 ,~

v

"0 "0

.-") t

~V

_~O

-.dC

~'-~

~""'~

~V

"'.d~O

~>

-O...o,-

O~

""""'=""""'=

,"'.~u

>-

~

~

~:s

~

<;

~

0 ;>

~

...v ~

~

C

0

u ~

'"

>

~

0 =

' 0

~

.~

0 0..

0..

""".dC=

~I""""""

0 bO

U

0 ~

5

o:s 0

§ ~

N~:s

=

.~

~

05

0 c=

.-.'.. U

",-..

u"".-.,

'v '"

U -.

.~

""' ::

""GJ'-"""'c.

..o~O

=~

O

.dGJ"'~

:S';::

GJ

5.d G

J""" u..E

"1:3 ---

'" ~

U

1:>

-5 G

Jo c=

:: ~

oG

J"3C=

-.8P",

5 ~

~

o-5.~

~

G

J d ~

0"

~

9 ~

N

t::~-oo"'~

'a",,~'"

c=

~

c= .9-'~

c=

bO

'-' -~

GJ

c. bo

U

c=

'-' c=

.-.~

~

GJ

c=

GJ

GJ

'" ~

'"

~

"",..o""" ~

-,,,--..."

:s G

J G

J ~

~

~

.-. ~

.-.'..

"""...c.~""G

J:: U

~

.d-~

""

'"'.-. '"

~U

~

.d G

J"" G

J ",--",,""

GJ

~

~

>",-""I;')c.G

Jo-~0

'" bO

'C

I ~

c.

"A""

U",

C=

GJ-'

-.~'U

""C=

<

.-~

~

~

'.. ~

.d c=

G

J ~

.d c.""

~.

~

I '-'

.d

~

t ~

"' c..do"""""'c.

0 0

U

GJ A

c=

~

c."" '"

.';: c.

'" 5

~

'-,.S

~

~.d

~

>.

GJ

:>

GJ

~~

..0

c=

'C

';:.d ~

0

~.d

0 c=

c

~

0 -;

f-o G

J U

Uc=

O

>G

J""=~

~;:=

G

JN

0" ---'"

c.~"""'-'-5-

><

GJ

~

~~

~~

""",5~5.~

GJ~

~

c.'" """'

'-' .d

'3 .-.G

J c=

GJ ~

GJ

00

c=

L. ~

A

U

bo d

=

A

~

c=

GJ

'-"" G

J G

J .-5

C-'C

0

U

0 ~

d

=""

'-'.~

c.

GJ

c=

d.d 0:::'..0

~

~

-;I,.)

-0 bO

uU

-~

-0

~

0 U

G

J'C

'V

c=

.~

0'..

0 ->

'"

~.~

:>

U

~

~

'" ~

.~

G

J.d.d ...G

J G

J ~

~

GJG

J ~

O~

""O

""~-.d""",

~

GJ"'c.~

C=

8"" c=

t

"'~::

-~

c.~

0~

GJ

GJ

c=--."'~

I

~

~G

J c=

U

0

.-.'v ~

.d 0

>.

-.~

"" ~

~

=

-5

~

5 ~

~

~

":..-

'S

~

GJ

~

0~

'" c=

""

~

~.-.

U=

~

c=

c.=

-=

~

'" +

-'U

0

=

~

~

-.->.

""' G

Jg.~

c=

~

0

~

~

~

-=

-; -5

""", '"""~

°c=-C

=C

=-5

.-.:>...d

5.-. c.

GJ ~

c=

_.d "'-U

"".-

<

U

c= .~

-5

=

c=

GJ ~

..g c=

'II

=

GJ >

~

o.d

.:=

~

~

~

55~'O

~50~

~~

~

N...,

rf'\""rf'\

Page 6: Bioethics as Politics

", ~

u

""""b()u""b()""O'b()~

"'UA

U""""""(Q

'" O

'~"'C

:'" b()~

'".-~

0

(Q

O..Q

.-0

c: A

U

c:

'" U

c:

'" S

..Q

u A

...(Q

~

(Q

U

U

c:

.-"" c:

""o.t:AA

",""

O"' ~

.-.S.,..Q

.",S""""""".~

-cb()..Q~

"!:: u~

..QO

",~

.-~.S

""c:~

...~~

-tcU-o..c:...

~C

U

~~

""

cU

""'~u"""'u

A-O

~

'" 9- A

0Q

.9 cU

c: "' 0.S-b():C

-0 cU

;g ~

U.£

--.>-

S

c: cU

0\ (Q

'" E

:: ~

00

'"'""""

u...o

u- "'..Q

-""".-O--."'uu

cUuU

- --

~

~~

"':E

cU

o..-""" """~

cU

"'uA",u..Q

.-:JO

...~...",..o

So

~~

~

.9 ~

~

~

U

U

.~

~

0..

~

u :J

0 u

~

(Q

8, ...~

~

U

U

0'

c: §'

~

~

U

~

0 N

A

~

",""~o

o U

US

~uo..c:~

~"'C

:A

u ~

O:'=

:"'~U

-o ">

-,,,c:0 ",-u

~

~

~

b() '" u

b() S

c:

~

A

0 0.. ~

-; cU

~

A

u

c: .a ~

'" '"

-0.. ~

-0

,- c:

0 c:

~~

~

~

'6

'0 -:S

,S

~

8 ~

§

~

-.e ~

,5.!l:.

'0 ~

] -:S

::: ~

-g ~

G

~

8

~

~

a ,~

-:S

~.g

~

j '0.

~

c- '"

c: u

c: ,-

u u

0 A

'"

>

S

U

U

U

cU 0

(Q ,-

-; 0

...>-

0 ~

~

cU

0

~

0..~

cU"'O

~

gs.~

~...,~

'(!. c:..o~

-:S""""~

U"'cn"u

b()",.~09...

""~(Q

-<

~

0-:J -0

U""

c: C

:'" u

u u

...",:J u"'-

0 cU

u'"

u "'..Q

-~

',::

.....ocU

.~

S

~

~

'" Q

0

:J ~

~

'~

S ~

~

: ~

~

A

0

~

S

> .~

cUu

_0~

c: '"

£ :-g 1:: u

t"-o

...~

cU

u -0

b() ,- 0

0 .-0"'"

u:J Q

u

-0 cU

:J

:J '"

0 '...

0\~

~

o.t: u

cU

QUA

~

"'-

:Jo~

!-! ~

~(.'>

O

~--.

8,C:

0~

;g C

:-o ~

5

~:J

<

c: 0..~

0\""

oo A

'"

uO:J

_0IJ0..'" .b()cU

~o..

"'-'" -~

cUO

'o.. 0

"'>

0 .5

'0- 1--

.'fI ~

.~

-:s g;!i:

~

g ~

§

~

-t' ~

,S

S

~

.~

S

~

~

;:g ;

~

-:s 5

§ ~

S

~

~

&

. ~

-;:-

'" ~

~

~

c:

A

"":J '"

0 0

'" 0""

cU A

c:

r- ~

J >

<

U

--" U

c:

.-u ~

c:

u u

t:: 0

~

0 -0

cU ~

;g

~

u :>

u

?. c:

u cU

u

.~

0 >

. (!).in

>

5'~

'(!. 0

u ~

0~

!:

cU

c: ~

~

~

'" "-

'- ..Q

p

~...

c: ...u

~

cU

...cU

U

'... ~

'"

>-:.=

:. u

~

u ..Q

-=

0..

'" ~

:J

...

:3 ~

~

:g ~

g..o

:d ~

.<::.,g

-:s i

'0 j

§ -£

~

.g '0

i3"2.!l:. ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

'0

~

-fo §

..g 0

~

~

~

~ ~

d'

u b() ~

cU

~

~

c: cU

~

~ ~

~

u

0 ~

i3 ~

..Q

...~

0

c: '~

cU

~

§ ~

8 ~

.g ~

..2 ~

;

~

~

.~ .E

~

:g ,S

'5 .s £ -5 ~

,so:.a

~ ~

~

~

~

~

'g.g ~

~

,so ~

~

u '"

~c:cU

... ""."'uC

:u~

00.."'.- ",0...

>

uc:u U

O!:jU

~O

U

cU

~E

~

~

00 ;g

~

u cn

~

~

.>Uo

...'0 -;

-5 cU

~

,=,!i,..:=

':..Q

~

-5

~

~

~

§ -5

':' ~

>

<

~

c: S

u

~,~

~

~

o

...:J'- ...u

u .;

cU

u ~

u

u cU

""

0 u...

'" >

o.t:.~.-

"";':: cU

0

~

cU

cn c:

,- ...u

~

:J 0

c: u

cU

5 ~

..Q.~

'"

'0 c:

a u

~

-; ,-

--.2

~

~

-s ~

~

a.c

S

~,~

~

0

~:.§

'" S

~

O

""',!i,:g u

0 ';

-0 u

~

~

c: u

0 £..0

..0 cn" 8

"' ~

0

0 ~

8

c: '"

cU..Q

c:

u c:

b()C:

cU ~

cU

'(!. t... ~

0"'-;

oA

~

"' u

c:-<

~

~

~

~ -;

'... '"

cU.'"

U

,u u

cU 0

c: 0

u cU

~

U

U

U

~o>

,...""

u c:

0 ~

..Q

.9..:''"

:-;: ~

=

.~

>- '"

...A

a ..0

~

.-.in >

u ~

u ,~

0.. u..!::

>-

>- ...0

b() ~ ",

~

.~

+0 .5

g t

'rl S

.~

:9

E-:

~

~,.g

t ~

§

.~

~

] -fo..o

-§ 8

~

~]

s'O

,g- ~

~

~

,S

~

~

~

<-'

f-' ~

~

~

'"

cU ~

~

...0

'" b() >

-':' =

-~

c:

'... A

'"

0.. 0

..o:.=:

0"" ~

u

~

...g J'

-5 3

uQ

-:S

~

~

:.:;. '0

~

~

~

-5 ~

~

~

§ §.2.

~

';;; ,S

~

.~

~

.!l:. ~

::g §

§ j

~

E

~

~

-; --g

.~

~-5

~

"'0 (Q

UA

""l::ucU

"'uuUU

""U>

- ~

=

""",u uo..~

->

.~

~

~

=

~

~

:J 0

~

U

c: ~

'"

~

..Q

9 -g

'" cU

U

0

'... =

~

...,~

cU

~

~..o

'rl c:

0'"

~

,~

'" ~

0..

...cU

0 -0

U

0 ~

~

t

>- ~

S

~

cU

U

c: u

=..0

>-

...~

'0 ~

c:

~

~

~

~

~

~

E'~

-0

cU '0

~

'0. ,a ';:-6]

~;a-

~

s ~

"2

-0 8

c: ~

£

-5 E

8

,~

,t1 cn" ;

~,~

~

~

.~

~

~

1:1'<>

0

U

b() S

c: c:

~

0.. b()

c: ~

0

U

=

0 b() 0

A

,9 51) '"

c: b()

U

'" 0..

...'" ::g

~

'"2

.:.~.~

~

-5 ,s

~

@.sE

,5,S..o~

-£ a ~

"2 -9,~

§ ,~

~

-£ ~

.0 ~

E .~

--g -; ~

,~ .g

,so i3 ~:2

'c: o'" Q

~

~,..."'...

cUc:'"

...~o"""

>

u...cUb()'-

uA"'>

cUu~

w

.

~

~

~

-5 ~

~

~

..( ~

c:

cU

~

~

~

~

0.. E

.g

,~

-; 0

-0 ~

0

~

'~..Q

c:

~~

~

..Q

~

-0

A

-5 <

..:':.a

~::3

~

c: cU

cU

cU

0

U...

(Q

"'~

0..0 ~

~

=

>

",..Q

U

..Q

U

(Q

c: U

c:...

>

u cU

'"~

0

~

0 S

~

S

S

-5 -.e ~

0

~

cU ~

c: =

..0 £

-.e ,S

~

~ -5 1-- -5 -£

0 ~

0 8

,S

~

£ -5 :.a

~

~

'0 £

~

£ '0

,~

~

.9 ,6

~:;J

9!; ~

~

.. ~

.2

~

~

~

~

-£ ;

§ ;:;-

~

~;

"E

'0 '0

.~

~

§ 6

""Q)"""'U

o.", °E

o",o.~

O--O

Q)

~U

""""'..Q

=

,~Q

)""'" 'U

~

-5 ~

tJ] 00'"

i ~

E

~

.~

S

'g ~

.~

t

g 'c

] .~

'0

t ~

~

] ci..§

~

~

~

~

.Ei

S

~

~

~>

~

0.

Q)

~

Q

~

""0 ~

~

U

...Q

) ~

~

..~

~

0.

~0

~...

='

Q)

~

Q)

'I)

Q)

~

'" ..0:0=

0

U

~

~

Q)

~

0 Q

) Q

) Q

) ~

0

~

9- --;

..0 >

- ~

0

Q)

,~::c.!.

~

~~

...Q)r---:'

~~

0~""'~

..Q0.~

=

'",,""~E

""~

'U>

oQ

) ~

U

::C"'o'"

~

0' ~

5..s

[;;; ,~

0..;

0 .~

~

;

~

..E'"

0 ~

..Q

~

~

?;- =

?;- 0

..s ~

.~

~

~

9

~

~0

~

E

~

-~

--; t

~

~

~

~

~

.~

Q)

on E

0 '0

0 >

~

~

~

.g ~

~

.E.

~

,=.E

. 8

~'o

-Ti

'8~

~

..g;.~

~

~

~

~

~

Q) "8

'>

g t

~

..s::a ~

'=

,=

..0 ;

iJ ~

~

~

~

~

='

~

",';: ~

~

~

~

Q.. .=

- ~

,§:; E

'0

o..s -0

?;- bD

[~

'0 ~

5

g =

' E

~

'd

E:.2

~

~

~

~

-0 8

~

e j

~

~

~

~

~

1;;::; ~

5]]

§ ~

~

..s ~'g

§ ~

.to ~

~

..g ~

~

§ 1

~]

t:S ~

~

~

g

~

fg' ~

i]@

J, ~

s"'g -d ~

"'g ~

~

;g"'g

S '0

;::: 'R

§ 't

~

; Q

) ~

.-= ~

~

~

g ~

8

::: 8.

~

E

U

e..s ~

f..;;

.g '0

~

8 ~ o

~

~'~

..8 ~

O~

§ ~

~

~

[

; ~

'E

~ ~

..s 8 .gu

'R

; --;';;

~

~

g 5

~

e e

~~

-'"

-=

0.- '"

'... ~

?;-

u 0. ...Q

) ~

~

~

-E

Q

) '... ~

~

§

-5 :g R

'~

.~

~

e .9

~

e. g

"E

~

'0 -£ ,5

~ ~

~

.9 ~

.]:;

S

S

~

g ~

~

~

~ ~

ri

: e

;J ?;-.;:

~

~

~

-0 ~

~

.; ~

0

g ~

~

~

""O

~

: -g

; ~

Q

)..Q ~

-~

'" 0'"

~

--; 0.-=

=

' ~Q

, ;..:: ~

0

='

Q)'o

~

~ u

>

u 0

~.S

U

E

i 8

'" 'ti' '"

t d""5b'~

'"5 ~

'"

Q)

E -g

t ..0

'=

~ ~

d

~ -g "E

~

'0. ~

~

g ~

~

~

.~

E

.~

~

~

g;'~

~

~

; ~

.g .~

i ;

~

-g ..g §

g..S

~

g ~

~

~

S..2

e i'~

-g .5 ~

~O: ~

.S

~

~

] ~

~

;

~.~

:E

8'§ ~

~

~

1;; ~

~

§'~

~

~I:@

§ ~

~

.3 ~

~

~Q

)O,...~

~~

..Q

""-"""~

,...>~

oE

""O

.""""'..Q

..."", ~

~

0 g..s~

E~

-oQ)~

-:-§~%

0.~;8E

-a~~

~~

:~~

9]~E

'" ~

~o~

;';;;~~

~

~

-;: 0

~

bD 0;:' ';:

~

~

~

~

~

0 Q

) U

='

..'... -0 ,~

~

~

..Q

"" >

- ~

'" Q

) ~

~

§.~.~

1:m

~

~

~

~

~

~o~ ;31]

i ~

1

~ 1

~ 1

~

1 ~

~

~

~

~

~

.~

E

~ 1

~ ~

~

:~

j

1...Q

»<"",..Q

-O=

""'~~

'" =

' L-..'"

-OQ

)O

0"'- ,U

Q)",

Q)o."'~

~"'=

""""""' z

~

Q)

'""" ~

~

bD

~

~

-0

r- o..s

~

E..Q

~

'0.

~

...~

~

'" 0

0 '0.

><

>

<

0 ~

~

b""

'" ~

E--

-.-Q)

='

U

Q)

0\ -0

Q)

Q)

Q)

.'5 ...'"

~

~

~

Q)

0. E

Q

) Q

) Q

) '"

.".."" ~

;;: .0."E

iJ

~

0. 0\

Q)

g t:..s

E

~

~

~

E

~

.,;' bD

.9..s ~

'"

~

Q)

Q)

0 Q

) t

.9 g,

~

u >

- ~

0 :::0

E

~

.~

::=:: -Q

) '=

s

Q)""

~,,~

~

'=

~

8 0

5 .S

0.

'" ~

~

0

~

~

;g '=

s

~

~

Q)

8:.2 t:

u~

0

u lr)

"'..Q

Q)

~

-Q)

-~

~

~

Q)""

~

-0 -~

... Q

) 0""'"

0=

'z

~

u ~

-o

l"--=

...~

=""'

o"'-o

...0'" U

'" bD

Q)":

~

~

u ~

Q

) ~

u... 0 ..."'-

...o~

"'" '"

Q)

'"z'"

-..~

Q)

'", ...""".'"

~

~

~

-g '"

0..J. i

-.2 bD

~

Q

)..'!j E

~

Eo

5 -::"

1 ..s

.9 ..g;

~

§.~

5'~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~.~

bD

.S

~

E

~

~-O

\O'"

-O-U

""""" U

=,,~

=

,~u~

Q)

~=

,U"'",~

Q)~

Q)

I~

Q)""'"

.~

:.~

~

0\ Q

) ~

,=-

Q)

; g..E

~

~

c-e 'E

--;

~

~

.~

0 Q

) ~

'8 ~

0

--; ~

;::=

S

~

~

~

~

?;-'o J:1 ~

~

~

Q)

~

~

~

...Q)

.~

U

bD ~

0

--; Q

) S

~

..d'~"'C

. '=

.9 0.

E

>

>-

~

~

~'2

bD""

;.g Q

) U1]

~

~

~

~ ~

,~

8. ~

~

~

S ,~

~

8 S

~

~.~

~

:~

.~~

~

g.2: ~

~

:g ~

.~ ~

.~

~

~,]

g ~

:go='

~U

Q)~

t..Q-o

o.bD..Q

~O

Q)O

""'..Q

,="'"

='

Q)..Q

Q)""""""

"'~~

Q) '-=

;..:: ~

~

...~

0. 0

.~

...U

0 ~

0

0 ~

0.

..o,~

~

~

0 .~

~

U

~

~

0. ~

.,.,~""''-t-~

Page 7: Bioethics as Politics

'0 v

; I:","E

0..=

.~

c""'=

' o..!. ~

~

~

.~

~

-8

~

§ ~

:r: u

v '"

S..t:

bO t:

...; 0

~

~

~ ~

~

,",""

"'. "",=

,O~

""t:vO

UV

t:"'V

bO-t:

S

v ~

'C

o...t:'~

~

>.

:3 t:

~

~

0 'M

-.d

t: :3

~I;;...~

U"'U

... ""..c~

"'~

~

>--

0:3'" V

I;; :3V

t:O""'=

'o. -~

o."",=,V

~"",=

,_U~

"'.2

>

0 ~

-~..t:

V

S

~~

I;;

S'"

V

V

t: V

t:

""' ~

0

U

v..c -;

0.'=

V

V

"".2 ...t:

:3 ...0

0 ~

--a.

~

>-.~

~

~

.0

~

~

t: t:

~.o

V.~

~

~

8

~

:;:0

""""Q)

>...t:

~..t:

V

t: ~

~

t:

S

"" 0

~N

~

""""'>""U

>bO

~

",~""~

O-""V

:3 ...

~

0 oS

:.=

.:=

~

:3 I;;

~

V

~

U

'" >

- ~

:a '"

'iU

~,",""'=

'",V""~

-"'O

bOl;;""",-.~

"",..c

..t: >

-'"'1;;~

"""~

...~

t:~

""Qjo

~...~

v~

~

o :.=

g

~~

..t:'u..t: ...;'o.~

~

>-""'=

' >

-~

~

~'"'

~-O

~I;;t:..c""t:~

OV

CO

bO~

-="""t:bO

t .;;

~

'" g,

0 v""'=

' ~

v.g,.~

t:

0'; 5

5 ~

~

~

'"' ~

"""',-,~';;>

v-;~

OV

O"",,

~I;;I;;.~

~

:.=

~

~

S

-5

~'~

"§..c tf

t ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

.~

""'=

'

~~

I;;"'V""""'V

V"'~

""""'='--"'O

va-

=;!

:3 S

bO

g .~

:a

.;; ~

..t: <

.I:: I;; b()

t: 0.

S

...U

8 ...co

~z

co"",=,"",=

, S

Ot:

V

~

>-

~.=

0

~

0 ~

.=

t: ~

V

g

~

V

v.=-..t:

V

-~.o

U

~

'iU

~

t: t:...

t: ...I;;

:;J >

~:I

,~"'~

&t:""~

..5U"'~

~""'=

'~~

""."'bOQ

, <

.1:: ~

..t: 0.

0 0

~..t:

~

",:.e >

- -5 0..=

'60

~

~

S.=

'" v"'"

~

~

~

S

t: U

~

t:

~

-..t: ~

.;;

~

U

"'OO

bO~

"'t:ot:

~~

~

s~""..t:~

~

~

~

~.=

t:

'O.~

§.;;;

~.2

~

cO 0

~

~

:.=

.2 ~

.E

.

'"' ~

o"".=~

",~';n>

-'iUo~

'=S

s~£~

""~~

~

V

-t:e

V

V

:3 ~

'"

t: V

t:

0 V

co

t: v

0-5

~

~

r" ~

..t: --.~

t:

~

0 '"'

'"' k~

V

0

'" '"'

v_""u O

bOl;;",...~

,t:V

""V:=

'"'~'iU

~

0 ~

:.g~

§ £.;;.=

'i~

~

=

0-5 t.:E

,'", .

..t:..c ...~

!:;:: '"

t: U

~

u""'=

' ~

~

~

'" .~

0

t:U>

.

~

"" v

t:...t: 0.

-",.0 0.

I:: v.~

~

N

t

~

-8 '0

~

oS

0 ~

;

v S

.~

~

0

>

~-=

'" "'""'=

' 0

ci. t:

0"" 0.""

~..t:

-5 v

~

t: ~

'"

v v

&.

z 0

c:- r,

.;; u..t:

'" ~

..c ~

S

0

0 ~

..t: 5

...;;:

o.QO

~O

'~O

~vov~

O

"" O

""~V

""'='

(:) §'

.; ,,~

o ~

.$ >

-'C

U

-5 -a.

~

~

.$'~

0 ~

.~

5"o:a ;

'"' '"

0. 'iU

~

0

.:?:;- ~..c

~

-; v

bO

:3 t:

.; ~

.g, ~

~

""'='

~z

>-

~..t:

v N

v

'" >

. ~

v

'" t:

0 v>

""'""'='

~

~

'C

:3 '"

~Z

v..t:""""'=

't:>"'I-.""":3""U

""

"" ~

v~~

..t:

0"" v

0 v

v ~

U

v

0 v

v 0

..."'-

""~~

>o

",'iU~

vv..t:u~~

...;'~

s.~~

o~""'

ov

"",=,

t:'-!""v oo'V

'" """'~

'iU""'=

'oCL"':.=

:a""-S~

..cst:..t:-5~~

~v",~

",-5

r,; t: 2

~ u

~ =

~

'iU

:3 bO

9' t:

=

'E

~

§ .~

~

I;;t:VU

CO

..t:

~..t:=

t:'v ,v

d",--' ""'"

v >

""'=

'U

I;; 'V

bO~

~~

~~

..c~:3~

..t:v~

t::3 o",t:~

~t:t:..t::3

v:3~0..t:

t:-0~",

:3~I;;

CO

O...o.l;;

§ ~

~

~

=;:5

~ .§>

;:;; g s ~

~

'5 ~

~

E

] .~

~

-s ~

'0 ~

E ~

.~

:5 ~

~

~

s ], e

; @

~~

~

:9

~

] 1'>

~

~

.~

:5

's .g

u ~

~

"2 ~

bB

.g c

8. d

oS -g

; ~

'g

9 ~

.a &

3 ~

-5 '2

~.a

~

g ~

0

~'"

>

r-.. e

'" :.c

oS..o

~

',;; &

3'S

~

8. ~

e

..;' =

' u

...0. ~

~

d

S

'"'"' =

' ~

'x

~

u co ~

0

'Q'j 'Q

'j § ~

:

0. § S

'0 c

0 l=

J >< ~

~

=' 0. u

g e

~

~

S

~

u u ~

0

"'" ~

u

~

g .~

.:q ~

8. i ~

~

§:.s

E'§

..; §

~ .~

-g ~

~

.§ ~

~ ..go ~

J!]] g

] ~

~

..§ ~

.~ ~

-S

~.S

O

.~]

~

~

',;; -5 .S

~

~

~

~

1 .g

8..E

.S

'0 -:S

.9

~

~

g ~

~

.2

~

~.~

-5.S

'~

~]

~

-g .S

O-'

u >

-u

g ~

'"

0"\ u

ou~

~

u

u -t:

c 9.~

~

..d co

g ~

~

'u 01) >

co

~

~

co co -t:

.~~

C

coco~

...~

co u

...co...uu u~

", ~

uo~

'- u-c~

uc""'"0

~

~.8:S

~

'Q

'j ~

'5 §

'Q'j

~:5

~"2

-S

~

~

~

~

~]

-S

~

~

j .;;

:2. ~

i]

~

>-. oS

-g

e 8.

~..o

='

co ~

.9

-=

o..c ~

~

~

'9 .~

-5

'" iii

c""QJ

0 -t:

&

~

'" ~

'"

c ..~

""3

>-.

c ~

c

='

co~"

'"' '"'"'

",'" co

","CO

o,v C

'-C""u-t:

""u"' ~

co ",

'- ,'-0"""-'

0 0

co 0.

~

~

>

~

.-~

~

'" 0.

.-!:: o.~

~

~

>

-. ~..00

-t: ~

~

u"bb -;

.~:.=

~

C

~

b.

co =

'0

~

'"'"' -~

u-t:~uS

",,""-"'~

uo- c-t:C

O,-",C

",-'--o""",-,~

~

u .S

o.k;-

~

~

u ~

u

~

...0"":' 'Q

'j u

..o'~ .$

~

C

-t: ~

C

co

c:.=

.m

.:' u

~

~

-.;: ~

~

~

-:S

-Q)

~

U-'-"'O

uO

-C

=,"0"".-0'"

",CO

co""'U-

~

C

-~

='

~

'>.

'" -:S

~

.~

C

0

'0 co

S

u .2.

Z

u ~

.;: c:2

~

'" ~

co 0.

[ ~

"'.>

u

co -:S

co

:J C

]

~

'"'"'~ ~

"L: '0

;:; >

..d

.-0 S

...co';:

.S

...S

.9 ~

~

0

-t: .;:.-

u 8.'c:.e

0 u

lot..,'-

,,"" u

-u C

co

u co

J N

~

'"

=..d

'" co

0. u

~

S

C

0 ~

~

-=

.~

~

=

,.S

~

co U>

...u -u

C

co ~

..d'- '"

...u '-'"

'v co

u >

-. 'v

U

co co'-

0 u

...~

8..d

o.~

C

'Q'j

to=

'2 5

.~

co.~

0

-o.'c 0.

"'..0 0.

S

u '0

u co

'" S

C

~

'"

~

0. ...co

20

""='occo

='

'U

._co ..."'cu

~

CO

-t:._uco co-t:...

~

~

.g.~

~

['0 ~

'R

~

'5 §

~ ~

~

~

.~

~ ~

.8 g

]] ~

.§ ~

.~

~

~

~'g ~

~

§ 8

] ~

~

~

~ ~

-' -:S

~

>

0

~

-t: S

u

<.1:=

~..!: -t:

~

~

51) ~

0.

',;; :

~

'" oS

>

<.;:

u 0.""8

.-u C

&

3 co

co iii

2; ~

.;:

co C

~

.~

~

=

' ~

.0

0 co~

~ 0.

0. ~

9 §

'0 ~

[.~

§""8

co ~

~

~

~

co

; Q

. ~

0 co

~

-:s g

~

;~

~ ~

.~

~

§ -a

~ ~

~

f -E

. -;- ~

~

-!:: ~

~

~

] .~

~

~

~

'a -:s ~

~

; ~

~

§

~

~

~S

] £

'5<

.'3"" -~

S~

u-t:u-"'o.;:co=,'-~

'" =

'uu~~

o~

""u""u'a"'OC

O'l)

',;;~

~

.g

c'x ~

=

; ~

-:s .£ ~

§ ~:§

.~ -:S

"i.g ~

-S

~

.~

~

-S

~

-d -g

8. ~

g ~

~

~

~

.i:5 ~

-:S ~

~

S

.., C

u 0

0 0

=' co'"

.-~

~

~

2 co

C

0 'a

0 u

u 0. 0 oS

0 '"

co C

' 0

&3 co u

>-.

9 8

~..d

~ ~

5

.9 ~

~

~

~

0 ~

.~

!!1 ~

~

.s.g -;

~

~"2

~

'5 0~

~

.~

~

~

~

g

-5 S

~

.~

'Q

'j "E~

C

u

-u 'v

c.:;;' !j

c"" 0.

...0 0

u 0.

0 >

-. r:;

co ~

",

"" ...

:S.;

co ~

'"

0 u

t -5

co '"

~'"

0 -t:

a:: ~

S

=

' ~

.$ 0.

-t: ~

u

'"'"' C

'bo

o'u ;:

~

~~

>

-. -~.~

3

t S

...=

,'- 0

C

>-.

C

U..d

"';':: .~

'"

co =

' =

' .~

C

~

C

>

0

~

~

;: 0

C

=

u

~

£ ",

~

co..co',;;coo ..oc'"

u"'~occoo~

uuo.'ct::u"'-§

; ~

~

~

~

g

~

~.a

g ',;;

lot ~

~

~

~

~

'c ~

9

0 .9..8

~'f

~

' ~

~

.rj

~

~:=

E.2

~

u ';=

:g ~

.-

0 "'--

0 couu~

u..." -U

'"'"""""._CO

-""u"U'-"'~

~

=-t:'"

~

..g ci.

~

'g S

'0

u ~

'Q

'j ...~

.~.~

-5

~

~

'0 ~

§

0 ~

t

~

§ ~

.S

...co

~

~

.g ~

.~

-0

C

~

~

.5

~ 0"

0. 00( ~.; -;

o..g ~

~

=

.~ ~

.u co C

.5 '" ~;.g

~

~

C co 8. ~

-5 ""3 .~

-= ~

0

§ ~

~ ~

e

S.-0

00( u co u

...00

., 0

0 S

~

9

'" ~

0

~

0 ...u

~

'" .~ .;=

.~ ~

0 f-I

-~

C 'm

0. u",0

.r,CQ

) ""-O

~O

Ou

",...uo."""~

'--""""'..."'u -0

coo.'"co

N

co C

S

.S

:I:

co ~

u

c..o 0

~

co =

' co

'" 0.

<

0 -:S

-:S

.~

~

~

co ~

-t:

~

-:S

u..o co

.~

'"'0--'" ~

CD

'~

V"""

~v"'O

"'C:

=-=

c: t:c:

"'O~

>.£",,=

,V..c""":""'pO

V

",'p

0.'" 0

V0

00.",0 ..sv

"' ~

'""",,~

O\~

'~N

",v"'g"'",v

0 "'0.

0\ .~

V

'"

~

V

'Qj

~.-.£

>..c

'" .-"".or:;

~

~

..c ..c:..c

~

0. V

c:

8 u

c: V

c:

'" ""

c: -'o..c:

'"'"

c: 0

-0 c:

'- '"

c: c:

o'~

0

0.'- -

0c:

-~

"'.- :>

-'"

",'._-",;>c:o.-o..g

~..c

'P..c..s

~

8 0.

0 'Q

jC

D0

~

'" V

U

0.

V

.-c:..c:..cc:

a"'O8

V

"'8c: t:

c: -v-'.

o"""

UV""... ='..c.

,.v '"

U

0 ~

V

V

'"

'" -;;

CD

0.

0"""

~=

-=

.-~

..c -0

'" "

V

'" V

-~-"""",o.

",:o=u~

..c:"'c:oc: V

"" '"

0 8 v'"

c: 0"" o.o..c

8 .s

E..c

'" '"

..c ~

0

8 0

b'P

:>c:"'..c:

'" 0.;>

b V

c: 0

~

U

'" "'-0

","""" 0

'"-0

0'"

0=

' .-V

u'"

0 c: ~

.A

c: '"

",.- -V

w

,~

O

VU

-O",v

..c"'..cn O

:;t:: >'"

0 'p'~

-;

~

0. ~

~

gun", 0. V

'p 'Q

j.~

..s ~

.~ :§ -5 ;;

~ ~

i:2 ~ S

~

t ":5

I,J "'~

~~

~

-cIi.-O

r-~C

D~

~

..c",>-°o

~~

~g~

Q)"'O

~

V

a o..a

~

~

",,'p._'~

c: U

~

'b'o

,~

..c ~

U

~

=

' 0.

.~

~

~

0. ->

E

.S

c:-,

""v~-o",

c:v'" --U

_'-0

>.-

~

U

0 '"

0. c:

CD

~

'" t

'~

~

>

U

CD

'p

0. "'"'0

V

'" ~

..c "'0.'"

"'.S

"""V~

c:c:V",

U ~

","""

c: U

U ~

c: 0

'" V

E

'""'C

Dv..c"'C

: ~

c:..9~C

D..cC

DC

:oo"'u"'~

U

'-",-c:-o V

~"'O

"""'" v

::_-c:~v

0. 0.

8 e

rJ .a

~.~

~

c:

~

'" 0

'""'v

0.""" """"'-"'>

-8

V..c

8 0.

--V

c: 0.

'" 0

..c~

V

",.!:!..s

;:-;...s ~

'0

t: e-

8 ~

~

._"'..c: c._'"

"'c:vO

ov-V

'"

:>

0\ C

D.a'-

u c:

'" C

D'"

>

.-V

;>

0\ c=

=

' '"

U

0 0

.-

Eo~

§.9v ",0.d'.S

8

V

>

c"'O

",.k;- V

'"

0 '"

='

V

'"~

.c:

.~

~

V

.~.-

'" '"

~

'p.£ '"

c:.£

"'::CD

U8

>-~

~0=

'~0.~

00....~

.a8

u ,.

:>.-

c: 0

",.- 0

r~

c: .--0

u ;>

U

--"'.-vU"'V

\..;--- """,c:-

oc:

v---v"""v'" .-u

.-"'=

,o ~

,"" """c:"'=

'='"

CD

""".a",~

"'0.-_0.","'0.

r--

\C!-4rf"\

Page 8: Bioethics as Politics

..cvv ~

""..c""O~

QO

""~Q

O..o

8 a

.~

QO

~

.Q

.s..e c:

~~

c:~

."".Q::

~8

-=

'" 8

u ~

~

~

..a c:

"">.

"':;, v

""'0"'0;..

o ~~

", ~

o v

~

., v

v I:;

0. -;>

- ~

"'>

"""""'0

0. >

~

C:

o'"O

"" 0.'"

I:; 0

"' 0

8

0 U

"'" v

., 0

~

U

'"O

k"0

0 c:

~~

-c:

...'" ~

'"""""M

,-=

.z; ~

~

-s

U ~

>

- ~

~

0.'";;""

~-

C:~

:I"E"o~

'"

0.

~

ut..e ~

~~

'O~

c:~a~

~

c: o::S

w,

>

V

0 ...:;

...~

.0

v ~

~

v

~

c: '8

>

0~

v

QO

... .~

~

:;;

:;.9 0.

~

c: '~

...

6: o.v~

t;c:vo~o.v~

c:~~

"""'.~0

"""""o

V'"

Ov"'V

-u

:; ...

.0 ~

~

~

~

~

0

'" -:'

0 U

.3

..,j ...I:;vo"'

~<

>t.~

~...",

-<

v >

..QO

v .c:

=...~

...Z

"'O

~~

C:>

"'.""~O

""~'"

~

v""'~~

~V

C:""O

~

~~

v~

'"'~oV

I:;

;>..0

0.., ~

'"'~

;>

~~

v~

"'v ~

o.~~

c:~V

o'"

-,...:;:; 0

QO

~..o

>

~

I:; v

=u

5 ~

o '"

~

~8

~

'" 8

g=

v-~

~

~

c:

...~

~

U

tj.~

:; 8

~

1:; oc:--"

~-o.ov

~

~

8.;:j.o.9- ~

~

b

8 ~

U

Q

OO~

g;

'i ~

g

0. g

,g ..g>

c:o

.' ...8-"3 ~

;

Q)

U'"

v-0

"""'"~

U

~

'

~"'C

:"'~""o.o.~

_OU

V~

-...~

v_v ~

...~

.a c: ~

~

~

.;g

~

'";; 0

~

'" I:;

v c:

...~

U

= ..a

' s

c: Q

O 0

o.~

" v

U

8

'" 0'"

"'C:"'>

<

o z

~

g .;:j ~

O~ 'ti'

~

0 0.

v to."'.P

--c..I:;UV

..o°8v...=

v-

~

0~,~

8","'~~

~vo-S

~U

"' u

V"~

I:;'"'~

'"~

c:

o""""Ul:;o""""v~

~.Q

Z

.-=.s

.~"C

:"" ~

U

0

~

>

v c:

...

~

0. v

--g b

~

g -s

v 8

~.t

~

~

'0~

c::C

.~

v ~

'"

c: -s

c: -;:::

~

~

~

c:~

._-~

VQ

.1 v"'-"'~

ov

~

v '"

;g ~

v

'v; a

tv:; .-

"""'.QC

:-VC

:~.""'"

~~

...8.,;g

...0 .~

.~

:.a

><

.-=

=

5

'>

~

o.o ",~

~~

uv~.""""

o"'~

-;>

v

v ~

""'V:;v

""~O

.Q"'.Q

OC

:""0

..0 ,~

0.

'=

:; 0.

..6 i.S

u

'i 'i

08u

.S

~

~

t .~

.~

..d' ~

~

"E

--;.S

Gs=

"C"U

=

",..s=ou=

",uu""" 'u

~0

0 ~

-0

:>

.." c..

0"

>

0... ..bO

"""~

-U'"

",u;>"""":3

:3"'=U

E

~

~..s=

"3 -5

.a "C

~

u..Q

~

:g ~

~

~

t

0- ti

~

0~

8""uu

uut~

c..u"""""~~

u"'8~

"C

..s=

"'

=

I: "C

"C

...=

u

"' 0

~

..s=:3

u~

~

U

8

§ ~

0

~

.E

>-u

~

~

~

0 u

~

1:: ~

bO

~'

~

c.. :3

'"U:3

Z

~

U

=..c

;~

'" '--

'" g

~

~

~

=

uC

o u

"'>-~

..s=

>

<~

"""'=""'~

~

=

uo>>

<

U

u ~

-:..

'" U

~

=...

0 ~

U

~

~

=

"C

'a

~

U

0 u

t.-. =

U

0

O..s=

...~

U

c.. bO

u

U

'"' ~

-:..

:>

-0 '"

U

V)

~

>

U

E--.~

cn

:3 U

U

=

'"

0 ~

~

<

u,...;>

'" ~

-s I

U

~

"';0 .U

U

'"

U

~

~..c-

U

U~

..c

o.~

bO =

: =

"0

'" ..s=

~

'"

0:- ~

8

~

~

-5 <

.~

..c

~0

=,...

>

=

u... V

) ~

=

U

0..o"t

u.. cn

U0

-

""~I"""":>

o, ou=

-

u=

0

U.0;

uO

"""';>

"..s=

"'..cu, =

",o~

=

", ~

I'- U

.C",

c.. =

""':3~

00 0

0 -=

~

~

"C

c..

08

0c

08

'"8

~

="""

~,

U~

'" 0

~

"'8

u ""O

uO~

..s=

~

o ~

",..c"O

=

0

=

~~

-=~

~

.E

0 c..8

0 >

--""r")"""'U

.CO

\o ..s=

~

- ""u~

o~=

bO

=...

~

;I", V

).S

.9;.S

~

~

~

E--.£

~

g:: ~

.~

-; ~

>

U

~

~

8

2'"'

=

ci. ~

~

b..c

U

"C

c..'" ,...

...U

""..s=

"C..c

'" ~

s=

~

0 c..'S

~

Uo

:3 =

;I""

=

8 ~

-=

e.o ~

5 ~

>

- ~

=

=

i: '"

~..c""

"'0 .~

~"""'~

>-8=

~~

~~

Uu

..~

~

",.a ~

~

~

'0

~

2 >

< ~

~

-=

..c ~

0 ~

8

§ ~

~

-Sd

""0\~""~

~8""~

~~

:3 u~

="C

'" o:.=

~

8 j § .~

.~ i]

~ ~o

i ,~

~ j ~~

.~ ~ ~ 1 ~

~ 'it "8 ~ ~

Co

'" =

'v

0 "C

'-'

=

U

;>

~

~

bO

U

;>""

~

c.. 0

U

~

g =

U

~

s

~

.E

~

08~

c=

=

..c ~

~

=

<

=

8 U

~

~

~

~

o.a

§ ~

=

U

>

- ~

... ~

"C

c=

-;;; d

oo'O~

""'c=~

b""'a~°'O

~~

>~

~~

o=~

T

"'~""

8°u=

=

"C~

0~

8:3°""-~""O

u~

>

- roo U

-.~

~

:3 0

U

'" -U

88

~

~

~

=

'" =

~

O

c U

~

8bO

u t.£

~

8 =

~

""

=

U

~

~

.0

o.'"'8

..s=ou

==

u.~uo;':=

-"""""'~0

8-""-

-8

=8

U

:3 0

:3..c'~

'"

=

S

~

~

-=

U

U

~..E

~

~:3

bO

""8"'.'"

=

U

L.. '"

'(;- =

c=

""

U

"C

c...U

=

=

=

U

~

t

; 0

0 -S

roo

~

~

-.9 =

'"

0 ~

~

U

"'q)

~

u=~

0'~~

""~u~

u ~

",-S8~

u§ ~

~~

..s=~

§

S

~

8 ~

.~

g

U..c

~

8 0

; ~

8 '"

~

U

~

'" ~

U

~

..s=

U~

""

~

~

U

e- -S

0

-=

8 c

=

~

~

~

:>

~

~

c0

~:3

U

'"t ..s=

"C

~

=

..s=

=

"C

U

;>

~'

0 >

- 0

Co

..s=

0 U

0= ~

.S

~

'a ~

--;

~

:3 U

~

>

"3

=

u u..s=

~

:3

bO

u... ...:3

8=

0

~

--0 U

~

...'"

'"

..s=

..s=U

-"C""

>""00-

U""~

"'~

~O

""UU

1:", E

-- =

8

=

u.S

0 u

~

U

=

~

bO ~

~

=

~

1::..c'a

~

c..

~~

..c8&

~ffi~

~

-SO

8§-S;~

~[~

g~J:

"" '"

"' '"

..c c:: us:

~

U

"""'" U

.U

0

U

>.

"""""'.2c::a~"".-"""'c::

..c::.c.~u;':=

C::"""".c'"

.~8C

::c::.~u~

.~~

~C

::.- t..c::~

..o.9~

""~

~~

§og~~

~

~S

~

'"'Oa~

§5...Ej5~

~a

'" 0.

<

c:: S ~

-~

-s U

.~

--d

'" ~

0

a t::

b

~

,.g..B

~

§ -S

~

~

~

s- ~

~

~

.~

-S

.J?.g

5a~

§

.§ ~

8

10. -'"

c:: ou

a",.-

>.0

o",a

oI:s

'"""'uc::oc::-"'u.- o"'O

bD

~

>.

~

t ~

a

~..c::

u ~

,.,;".c

C:' ~

.~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

8 ~

~

~

e. ~

~

s

e ~

~

.5

~a.s

.~

:§ ~

.J?

~

~

.=

~

'"'0 ~

~

&

.-.."

c:3...!-l ~

~

~

~

~

0

...~

",.- u

~

u 0.

~

~

u :

~

~

'iU ~

~

.E:

8 ~

;

-.2 i ~

-g

.£.~

~

~

~

-S..s

:E' ~

~

~

8

~

'"'0 j.g .8

~

~a~

-g -s ~.g ["1I:s

~

<o~

~

_C::"""'.-U

>.'"

:o~

..c:::3 ":S

U

~

5

.0.. ~

~

~

~

~

-s

~.~

:-=

g..21. :3 -bD

t

0

..c::~>

:9o.a

.-:3~"'.-

~c::..oo.~

.Sc::..;juc::

~

~~

u.,g~

~~

~[~

.E~

~~

80~"E

° ~

o~

a

~

~

-0 ~

"E

80

a --;

...:.. b Y

0.

-; ~

~

Od ~

.E

u U

0

.-u I

, -'"

~

~~

~~

a"".~

""",u~~

~§C

::"3~~

~a.;:.~

o~

ouuc::..C

::o

uo.~~

", .~

"'ou""'" U

~~

'">

00-~

C

::-C::,",C

::o U

""" u

...c u._~

"' '-""

a""-""~

C::""U

:3"" '"'

a""",

._~'"'-

~-

""""""'uo o

aI;.)

§ ~

u

.9 ~

~

.:g

u c::

.~

\0 ~

0.2;,s

~

U.;:.

"';.:=

~

~

'" ~

~

~

g

&.

~

~

-s g..0

g:: ""3

~

~

'"'0 8

~

~

~

'"'0 ...

0 c::-u-

O

U

u.c or-'

~u

0.:3~

"'c::~

0

~

>

.-0 0

c::..o U

~

~

bh..c:: '"

u C

' >

. U

a.-

~

."'bD.-a~

o.~~

°.c.-C::

c:: .oC

::..c:: :.=

'"

Q

~.s

5 .~

.E

: ~

~

-s

'i ~

~

~

§

~

r 8;.

§ 2

-§ ~

§

.-C::U

~o.""-.~

c::o. -~

c::",~"'u

..c::o.c::'"~

ao.c"'

a""~

0c::

a-c::

c::u u

~~

",.-o

0. u

c:: c::...:3.c~

c::ou

'0;: -~

"'ii.'" ~

u

0 0.

u ~

>

. 0

c:: ~a

u C

' ~

~

,-.-

c:: ~

-U

~o.>

<u""o>

u~.cU

a~

;>

au

I;; .~

""

au~

u.c.;: ~

~~

~..c::~

c:: -S

c::,9c::~

"",

'":3 c::C

:: u

._~

:3""~

~

; 0

0 :3

~

'ti' ~

.~

~

Ua~

-g

~

~

~

~..=

'"

-'"'0 0

~

>~

"""'>

'~~

..c::..2I...c::~

""~"".cbD

og8:3 uU

..21.Q

:E

. ~

5 ~

d'

""..0 0

:3 u

c:: >.

bD ~

U

.-c::.,g ~

0

~

~:3.,g

u..c:: 0

~

~

~ ~

~

:"9 c:: bD

:3;,s >

. ~

.:g '"

u """'ii

'" t

-S.~

~

;

~

~

~

:3 ~

~

.,g ~

~

-'"

~

..c:: "'2 ~

0

~

a ~

~

a..d'~

~

~~

:lbDS

~

~

u"" s-§

o~

~~

u

1-- bD

~

9.~

~

0

--g .c ~

:3

~

<

i;' ,.,;" ~

u.,g 0

~

~""o'"""~

C::""'

a:3C

::~

u~>

<,""u""=

"'~

.=

~

1-- ~

:3

0. ~

~

0

~

0 u

0 '"

<

~

0.

~

C:""

c: ~

'"

c: I

°..c: q)

>.

~~

'"6i>~

~~

0 ~

::§~:o~

O'C

q) ~

bO

~ ~

~

~

~

", ",~

~~

O

~~

~~

"'3 ,,=

0

0 S

0.

~

..c: =

~

:'2 c:

Uc:

~

U

""q)-"'~'t:'"

...I: ~

I:

~

-a 0..""'"

I: .,r

.0 °..c:

q) U

... 0

~

c: ~

~

~~

UU

U

'"

Sq)

0. ~

~

~

'O

'" 0.

q) '"

.--q)

0 q)

'" '"

..c: q)

:s ~

..c~

"""

~

q) c:

~

:s...~

u 0.

I: """'"

'"OS

e I:

,9-"'; ~

~

0

0q)..c:

'" ~

'v

...0 q)

"":S

~

U'2

.c q)

0 I:

I: 0

I:..c: ...

oo~~

e~~

q)

e~

o""~'"

';:' c:

0 .zj

'"

V)

e--""

o~

.'" "'",u~

q)u

'v.;:. "'

q) ...

r"" ...o

~

:So~

S

:S

~..c

S

I-' 0

~

"':s 0

0::J

""'uq»...c:q)u ~

O

"'~0

~[-S

l:t-S>

. ~

~Q

..~§

~

~'"

~s

'o::! q)..c:q)bO

.;:'~

"'

~

", c:

U~o

-~

q) ~

:s.

~

.;; ~

q)

q)1:>..c:~

ObO

..c

Q

"'~o"""'..ol:

>.

0q)00

~

", ~

~

-~""'

e~

I: ~

q)1: I:

---0

~-5bO

q)=~

O

i.1-a.§~

" >

. ~

~

><

~

'(J .c:s.'"

0~

0

=

q)Sq) I::

q) 0

~

~ '"

:I: ~

... ~

0'"

0. U '...

~

~~

.~

~

~

..s .~

~

~

5 ..§~ §

eo ~~

~

o~."'~

I:~

o"'e

Uc-""us

~q)U

",~

~

~_I:

'" ,=

1:~

-u"'...,vo .'-u-.

0-s

g.E

t g

1 e

§ .~

~

~

"'2..'b'

'"E

s 0

~

5 ~

§

';:' I:

~.g

g ~

:s q)

0 --U

~

-~

~

q)

bOl:..c:

...bOq)

0"=...O

"""""q)~

q)q)..c:Z...~

: .~

0:'2..c

q) 0.

'"q)

~

0"""""'1: :s

>

5 ~

>

~

I:

.J' '...

-S

~

'"

~00e~

~08~

"'1:'rl5..c:

U

~

bO..c

q)..c: ~

q)

.-'"

""'q)~~

;':=l:tO

~I:~

..o1:-S

~

.~ ~

g

S

E;

~ ~

a

8~

0\1-4-"~

Page 9: Bioethics as Politics

~~~~~><~,.j

~0~~0~t::

~ ~

!Ij U

~ ~

u ~

§ ~0~~0(~u~~.~~

...'" Q

,I'" Q

,I""" Q

,I ,...

"" Q

,I~--

~"""

s= ""

-~

s=Q

,I ~... ...Q,I..d..c

~

~

0. s=

t: ~

>

...~

~

~

c

~

Q,I =

Q

,I Q,I.-

s= ~

~

~

.-~

,--s

s= ~

~...

= -S

'" 5

g Q

,I 0. 0 o..~

.~

'0+04;:=

0"Q

0 E

~

'"

0 ~

.~.~

~

.~

Q

,I .~

~

...~

~ ~

~

Q

,I t ~

~

~

'" ~

~

.E

::=

~

~

.~ .~

~

.>

~

.~.8

0 ~.g

; ~

~

,~~

.~

~

-; ~

] 8. s

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

8. Z

~

~

-5 ~

i

§'e. ~

~

.5

i:f::g ~

§

.,., .-:.~

O\

s= ~

~

0.S

=

u ~

!9"'...~

.-5

s= =

>

~

u~

0 0

Q,I 0

~0

("ooQ,l,..;gQ

,l 00

.':'.~~

.-o.~~

Q

"'~005.-~

~

S=

""OS

=5~

~u

0 r'">

~S

=~

"'~"'U

.~

~

:-~~

~.,

~'~

u.':""~"'

ObO

Q,I

>-o

-Q,l~

"'~-,

"'._"""~'...

~

~o

~

u -s=

...Q

,I'"'Q,I-Q

,l-'"

,:. Q

,I s= .

~~

0

0:=

~

~

~

...s=

~

-h .~

~

-=

~

~

'0+

04 ~.-

0 :=

u

~

~

5 s=

-~

-~

"'..d...,v

.':'S=

"""'o~"'-

"'0 'v

Q,lO

;>"'~

,v~Q

,lbO

.-'"~

O~

.S.9

'0+04"'... -S

0. ~

~

5

., ":' g ~

s=

0. ":' ~

...Q,I '"

-=

;>

'" '"t:

5 ~

~

~

5

~

...'" 0"""'

Ou"',v-",~

'"'.- s=

.- "'~

Q,I>

---'" '"

'v~

0\

Q,I

~

0 =

0

...u ~

u

~

Q,I

=

.-'" '0+

04 Q,I ~

bO

s=

U

~

cn -~

-S

5

s=~

O\-dU

U..d..c~

~

Q,lo-S

", ",Q

,I ~

Q,lo~

--~Q

,I.':'~~

...Q

,I._~!-o

,..; ~

..9

-; Q

. ~

Q

,I... '0

\..j '"

~

~

~

~

-S

==

",'~

.~

~

5 ~

>

- s=

:9 ~

~

Q

,I>

'" 0

...~

"'>

--;,"'Q,lI..o"'~

~

~.-s=

-s=

~

.-S=

Q,lbO

"'Q,lO

Q,lQ

,l>

0...=~

~

..c Q

,I U o

~

0 ~:;;

~..cQ

,l s= 0

0 =

>

- ~

~.9

~.£

c'=

Q,I..s -0 ~

~

':::.E

0. ...0.

"'... ...0

0 '"

s=

U

0 =

... -=

..d

~

s=

;>

'v 0.

0 s=

..J <

I:: =

~

'"

~

a:! 0

~

~'~

'cn ~

~

~

'"

~

co ~

cn"

~.~

co'"

'" ~

9..c

5 =

~

~

-<

_..cU.~

~

bO'"

~~

",~u""-;Q

,I u=

Q,I~

g~-;-o,~

...Q,I~

"""~u

Z

Q,I

Q,I~

-S

~

Q,I

~

Q,I ~

5

==

~

-=

~

.:

'0+04 s=

~

co

~.5

'" Q

,I Q

,I...

.,g S

=..e

~

5 g

S

~

Q,I

~

5'" -..c

bO'"

>

'"' .-0.

'v 0

-Q,I

0 r-'

U

~

d ...Q

,I .'v

~

'"

g ..:,~

~

~>

-~Q

,I ~

~5'O

.~~

~Q

,I S

=~

"'7'="'Q

,I~~

~~

..:-'O~

t:;.e-."'..d

~

,=

""Qj..d

~

~

Q,I.-

~

'" ...~

... 0

~

=..d

0 s=

~

~

Q,I -s=

'"

~

0 Q

,I",~

o Q

,I~~

'"'

~S

=u~

._"'s=~

'"

...bO'0+

04 0'"

Q,I

Q,I~

::t:...'0+04o.

U

~

s= '0

>

S;:=

-S

.9

...0;:=

>-

5 .a

~

~

~

c 8'=

0

h '0+

040

~

"'00

5 s=

=

'"

>-

><

~

._~

'-"'.- ~

..c"'5~

Q,I;:=

-",-

..."'=O

"'._~Q

,I~

~

; ~o

§ ~

.~

~

g.

Q

"; ~

~

~

0

~

oJ ~

~

~

~

-g

~

~

-8 ~

..s 5

~

U

~.~

~

-;

-0- ...=

...Q

,I~=

-.-U~

~U

o-~

..c",o Q

,I"'~-;..d"""'"

'5 0.

~

.~

5 ~

~

s=

~

5 ...0

~

"'8 ~

~

":'

'" c:: ,g

5 8

~

5 G

5

J; ~

..e

.=

,~

...:J. ~

0

>-

~

Q,I 5

5 5.~

.- ~

5

5 ...°..c

Q,I s=

,~

Q,I =

Q

,I 0..- Q

,I..d ~

""3 Q

,I Q,I .~

,~

~

..c 5

~=

=

~

g. Q

,I ~

":' g!jJ/

~'O

0.

~

~

=

-S

~..s

5 13

~..d

~

5 ~

~

5

,~

.~

-S

"0 ~

...~

-;

.§ b'

0 ~

0.

~

<I::

Q,I ~

s=

~

-S

~

'::

Q,I o.!:.

~

~

.~

'0+04 ~

~

-S

.; t:

U

~

0. g..e

0'"

;.'=

: Q

~

~

0

~

£ ~

<

I:: ~

Q

~:J.

~

.~

13 ~

..e ~

::: ~

-S

Q

.~

u

~

S

.~

..;- V

).~

E

~

z O

._'-,~

"'...~

Q,lbO

Q,lO

"'~-.':'_S

='0+

04oQ,lQ

,lQ,l",>

-""";>s=

...Q,I~

'"-.0.

~

~

~

>-

0.£

-S

0 ~

~

s=

U

~

0

0 Q

,I .~

U

8 .~

~

0

~

...Q,I

s= .~

0Q

,I~

~

Q,I

~0'0+

04 ..c

~>

<

~._~

...", u5s=

t3Q,155~

Q,I...Q

,lS=

5

@

~~

-t~5Q

o~~

S~

~~

~;Q

~~

~~

58~~

..s",~~

-g~~

~~

~~

-;:::.

~

~

==

~

;g 0

~

~

§ -S

Q

,I Q,I -S

~

,5

'0+04 ~

.9.~

0..>

~

8..~

~

bO

': .S

~

a:!.Q

'0+

04~

~

s=

Q

,I Q,I ~

.- c

~

Q,I

0 ~

~

s=

~

'"

0 s=

~

>

< --Q

,I bO

>-

...s=

s=

~

s=

=

...~

0~

.S

.~.9:9

~

~:09;:=

~

:09 ~

~

~

...~

~

~

s=

R

R

Q

,I 13 ~

0~

2

~::3..s

~:=

0

~

s=~

o""""'~"'~

"'0

.S=

bO

...'"'o~~

>-.':'.:=

~

oQ,l

",~"""'O

Q,I

~

S=

=

""0 ~

'0+04~

Q

,I.S=

~

bO

~'~

~

.~

...;:==

=~

; o.s=

._,U...

~.~

"""50 .s=

,v=

..c'-S=

Q,I':'U

~~

~

Q,lO

Q,l"';>

"'5O

Q,l2Q

,1~",

~:.E

~

u;;;:-

Q,I "Q

."Q.

~

0 c,;

Q,I..c

~

..:,.~

~

5 ~

~

>

0.

0. 5

0 ~

t:

0.':' ~

>

- 5

~

~

Q,I"'~

"'OO

~

V)s=

==

s=.:,~

-o 5~

~Q

,I~5

>-"'O

U~

..cU..c'"""

0.:.EUo

~

0\ ...~

~

8

.9.~

~

Q,I

0 '"5

.-8 ~

s=

0

~

~

~::t:

'0+04.~

Q

,I ...'"

'"5 0

0... ;>

,..; 0 ...'"

...;>

U

0. 0. 0

0 '0+

04 r-'

~

U

...~

~

Q,I 0

s= -0

0 ,- ...0.

"0=(Ud'0~...(U~u

~t'5:I:'i......5-0;:38'(U,oJ"E

.,;.-~~

(U

.-"0~ b

(U .-

~~...

S-S

.a ~u

C:3

..

(U

e

..e~

0

e u

~

...r..ES

=

-~..a 0

~u(U

(U~

bI)~e ~(U

>

-U

I ...,..

--I ...~

..~

""

;, ~

>

-~

-, ~

,~

oo ~

. 'a

r: -S

"E

..=

'lJ.

~

\3 ~

~

0

1.."...~

-:J

"" .~

o'~

q; v

0 0

..g '"

'" ~

'~

~

~

'(;- 2

~

; ~

1:) 1:;

U.E 1

~

5.:9 ~

">

<0

=0U

'7

~

~

~

~'~

~

-~

~

rf")~

,..""-0

' ~

o

~

~"

~

=

00 '-'

"':t -"'

:-;: ~

...v

:.=

0 '0

.] ~

-<

rf")'~

~

~.

.-0 .,;

,~~

~

~

.. ~

.~

~~

"' a

~U

i""\) ~

o~

~

~

Q.,

'~.

\3 ~

=

..

u ~

'-.It

v\O-

0 0

ot.-.~

",,~

,~~

'C

:'~

~

~

,so ~

8,~

~

~

j 1

~

~

~

~

~

~

] ~

~

~

~

,~

~..0

'" ~

'~

~

~

~.J::

v c-

~..

~

~

-:: ,g

~

~

\II V~

.~

~

~

~

]. ~

.( ~

t;

i ~

~

~

.J Q

,ff

~

~

~

,~

c3 ~

0 -,

u ~

0

~

"" ~

v

.Q

~

--v o.

..t.-. .~

~

.J:: ~

~

'" .!..

'8 ::C

~

'E

~

~

-S

~

~

~

.J:::-;:

~

.E

~

'" ~

~

~

u

"0- 'a

~

~

~

j "]

.J Q

., .~

!--

a ~

~

~

!:

~'~

d

'a ~

~

'(;-

~

~

~

~z

~

'~

~

Q.,

9 0

,..; ~

~

=

0

0 -"0-

13 ~

~

.2

~

~

~

'~~

~

.E

. ~

.\II ~

N

0 ~

\II 0 ~

\II

0 \II

,- ~

~

'" ~

=

'(;- v

~

-;~

Q

~

0

'a ~

.g 0

~

'~-g:-

~

\II ~

-S

~

_\II

~

~

=

.~ .~

Q

~

~

u,~

.,;.,; '~

u...N

'(;-~O

~

\II ~

~

~

~~

>

<'"'"'~

:J=.

o~

6:<J

=

'lJ r;;. =

t;

.::i. c3 ~

,- ~

~

~

~

~

~

,-'~

~

...0>

< Q

>

~

\0 ~

E

oo;; 0

..? ~

..,- g~

'"""

~~

.b ~

~

~

";:!""" ~

'a~'"

~

.'(;-g

~ ~

""§

Uu~

~

= 0

.'lJa

~

~

~

£ S

~

~

,5 ~

.5 ..s ~

~

~

~ ~

Uo ~

.~\11'-'

0..'-~

"o

0 ~

..v-""'."

~

",".-~

-<

"'. ~

'~

-=0

:t,~

~

0 ~

<

'(;-

~

0 '"

~

><

'"

~

'" v

.-.~

'" v",""'"

~

~,-

,-'-=-

='

0,-

>~

~

. -,"'"

u .~

~

0

~

~

_ 0"

> ,--.

00

=

~

,-~

va=

' '"

e ~

-<

--~

~

~

0

v 'f<

=

=

~

~

'2 j

'2"'§ ]

a ~

..£ -:S

...j'~

.~

,~

,~

&

~

1 ~

~

~

0

] Q

~

"o- ]

7-

~

1 ~

§

'~£

~

~

;g ~

~

=

~

~

~

] .~

a :.;

~

N

~ ~

~

§ ~

§

~

~.,..;

~..s

a '~

bO

'" ~

'0 ~

to ~

'C

:' .,; 0

.~

_\II >

""""' =

1:) ~ 'lJ ~

~

g.,~

~

~"I

~0>

< a

~.§

:a j

~

~

~

~

0 ~

.s ~

~

~o~

..g j

~

e. ob ""5 ~

~

a ~

'J:: ,sa

~~

0

"",",=,--.~

"'~~

"o ~

Q.O

" .J::v'~

o-~

.\0

~

-0 u

t ~

...'~

~

~

0

e ~

'"

'i- ~

U

U

; N

'U

~

~

00; u

Z

~

~

~

~

"30~

'" .c:

~

"':" ~

v U

='

v ~

'"

=

v -Q

. ~

.I

.'" =

'~~

oo '"""=

~

~...jz~

~~

a~'~

t ,;~

u""C~

~

Q.v.:!l~

~~

rf") r"~

~

~

~

~

~.~

~

..s a

-d r-:

=

~

5 ~

~

~

~

~

~

.:d

~

<:3

~

.g -3

~

~

; ~

~

~

~

~

a' ",'-

ovt.-. 0

.'- ~

~o._v

~vu",.~

~

v

~

0 ~

=o

~

jo~-s

",:~~

~::§~

'(;-~~

~':5r-:o

'~-i:f~

~a~

~~

i~~

~

] =

~

. ~

~

.,..;

~

.~

c. ~

:;,

~

~o~

S

~

oS

'~

~

~

Q

~

~

j g::

~

~

~

~

<

:g ~

~

~

~

u .J::

,~

\0 0

>-

a \3

~

0 ,..

..=

v ~

~

'"

=

~

~ .c

~

-0'"

d ~

-<

.£.

rf")1~

0

r!. ~

-;

~

'~

e ~

~

~

~

0

,~

,.; ~

.~

~

:,

~

v5 ..~

:,

§ a

~

.~

-<

~~

O""

'" ~

.J::~~

~I

'- x

=-

~'"'

..~

~~

~~

.J::~.5

'p 9

cj 'i

~

",,~

~

~

-<

g ~

-S

~

~.5

0 ~

~

oS

~ c:; ;

.~ ~

~

~

..;' 2

~

a u

oS u

5"0-g.

'0 t:

~

>-

~

=

I: ~

~

v

=

~

:J 'C

'=

-;

~-<

-<

-<

~

~

~

~

~

~

U

Q

~

~

~

~

~

:t .£.

""'N""0Nrt'\

Page 10: Bioethics as Politics

I-u

E""

'" '

~

..r <

U

bQ

~u

~

u ~

,..,

u ~

~

.-.E

~

~o

=

~

;a 'c

~o=

~

.,;'"

<U

"".&

J <

U

-'" 0

~

°e

..~e

-, -'"

u~

.. .'"

=

~...~

(X

) -<

U

~

U

~~

.-~

~

0 ~

~

u

-s. ~

~

't;-

=

<U

-'

..u "'-

'" <

U

.,; =

~

=

u

US;0

0 '",

0 '"

-~..

~

0 bQ

.~

~

b

0 -5

~

ci. .Q

u:'9

~..

>

~.;:

~.-

~

~

.,; u

...~

.~'2

~...

=

~

u a

~

.&Je

-c; u::r:

'~;::J

~~

o~

~

~

...0 ..~

~

~

~

=

~

e °

~ 0"

<U

:s

~

.S

u~

.- =

.~.~

<

U

Z

-',.., U

\I

<U

$!J

t~

'u"'-.c. -r')

0... 3'"

~~

~~

.s=

~

°l-o-i ~

"".;,::'c

.u- ~

=

""O

\~

-~""-.&

J

~

~~

u-gr,...J <

U

>-['-

~

bQ

'a ~

S

a.~

..<

U~

. '"

~N

~

=

.~...

<U

~

'" 't;-~

~

~

=

p.. -'0

~

~.5

u

~ ~

.~ ~

j ~o

~

:§ ~

~ 1

~ ~

~ ~

~ ~

~

~

>

0<

U

r').. ...U

-..u

.~

~

;J -C

:.- .-U

N

-""

"'1~

.- 0

=

.=

Q

e ~

~

.5

0.; .-.c.

<U

~...,

0 ;::J

~

u ~

ci.

~

...~

0 ~

(X

) e-

u .c

e

13 ~

~

0 50 ~

0.

§Zo"".Q

=

N

~

'0 ~

<

U~

I:o",u~

~.-

.~~

<

U

~u

~

ti '"

~

=

t bQ

:c ~

bB

0.;

0 't;-'o

101 l:'

><

Q;;

§ 0

~

<

.5 ~

.E

E

N

~

'in ;::J

t...t;

0 ~

u

'" <

U

:t;,. ~

I: 'u

$ ~

b

'0 <

U0

.Q

..~

~

~

0 '0

~

0 =

Q

. ~

>

e

--~

~

u ~

...u

~

~

<U

0 ..-u

cn~

~

O!!)"3

~...

'" o.~

~

-c; ",;;;,=

=

I: '"'>

< §

~

~

8 §

~

~

~

~~

~

r')

~

:'ii ...;

00 ~

. ~

~

~

O-C

:- bQ

-c:~o...~

II) .-:.

.~

8 ~

~

u

~

%

'a .5

~

~

~

u ;

~

0\ ~

~

0

z ~

~

,..,

~

':: .,;.£

~

00u

<

'" o.;"'.N

=

.'-"""'u~

;a.

a~fii

(X)~

~

.:.; <

U

0.; ~

~

~

~

\I~~

ur')

<U

-(X

) =

~

['-

="'

~

~

0. ~

...['-.-

~=

O\

o r

0\ u-

'"" ~

.'0\::=

~-.c.-"'r,u.-

::r:..'t;- .'-<

0.,..,.- 0\

0 .:-a

.::=

~.

e'"

~ .-o.~

~ 0

.~

0\ ,

~ <U

~ ~

U .c.

~ ~""

0 ~

u ...~

~

->-~

~

~~

'oC

0. §..Y

;O\

bo ~

::=-5

~~

..&Ju~

!!) u~

"'.&

J->N

~>

="'

acn

=

Q

~

~

..Y;"i:

0 .~

0

"2 .L

u.- .-;

.0

'" 0

<U

0\

II

-=

!:>

<U

.. ""'.-

..r b

U

Q

;.:3 : 0\

.a ~

;::J

0 ~

P

::3

--:

'oC

~

N

U

U

.-:-:=

...0

<U

~

~

~

~

~

~~

~

\Z

j r-"

NN""